Ashlin is up by one point. 3736 and obviously the outcome of this match is going to be the outcome of a >> This is some intense wrestling going on. >> This is this is very intense. >> Two rival high schools with a one-point differential in the team score. Coming down to these heavyweights and these are not your old oldfashioned heavyweights of two fat kids rolling around. This is uh these are two very strong, large, powerful kids. >> Raamine is a senior. He's got five varsity wins this year. >> Just under a minute to go here in the first period. Ashlands have had one- nothing. >> Now, I must express to you a little bit of my concern. It looks like Braden's second wind there. Um, >> oh, he did a good job getting wrist control. Then he shucked the wrist and he went for a double leg, but it just didn't happen.
>> So I guess just in terms of sort of trying to create a concise understanding for now, right? I mean this is just a conversation. Is that a number that we need to be saying, look, if we're level funded because there is no override. This is the dollar value that we need to come up with and that might because we obviously as a school committee haven't had the discussion about where we're cutting that might be something in the order of 31 people. >> But is that really what we're talking >> we would but we would not be level funded, right? We don't know that even if the override does not pass, we have 2 and a.5% increase in our levy, >> which is $1 million, right? That's 1 million that has to be spread across, >> right? So it >> but we also used $2.3 million in the last year of Right.
>> Um, so I mean I I'm not opposed to having discussions and I mean I think that's important. Mhm. >> Um, but I'm more inclined to say to have a special meeting next week once we have a little more clarity, more answers to questions, and then we can have a more fruitful discussion. >> Okay. >> But I'm not opposed to >> we could have some discussion tonight. I don't absolutely what the the what the current proposal kind of looks like. Yeah. If we want to do that. >> So, can are you is it okay, By? Um, so with that, I I'm a little leery about some of the questions. I feel like [clears throat] some of the stuff that was asked and some of the things we're we're asking administrators to come back with are building decisions. I think that we need to be really careful about what our oversight is and what we work with at our level versus trying to get into dictating you know what positions are needed how many kids are in certain areas.
And so how well the we're able to take care of the families and the parents and sometimes the single moms that are trying to get going um has a huge effect on on on what they can do for their families. uh and security um and also to second language learner families uh learning to navigate using their language to navigate the complexities of the school system and getting a little capital with being able to support their child at school. So they do a lot with that as well. So they're >> I think I think Cara I think Rick said he was up um over the year 750 learners. So just over a thousand, >> right? >> Quite large. >> Yeah. and he built it back up from the ground since co. So, um, so these are the sort of the big things that are that will be presented in the workshop.
All those in favor, please signify by saying I. >> I. >> Those opposed. All right, this passes. Thank you. >> Thank you. All right, moving along um to business. Uh this is also a discussion action item. Uh we have a presentation uh tonight um by Shereice. >> Hi, good evening board. >> All right, so before you for your approval is the 202425 independent financial audit. Um I know this seems a little bit late in the year to still be talking about 2425. Uh but the deadline was in December. Um, so we received our audit and are now presenting. Um, as a school district, we're required to contract with an external audit firm each year. Our 2024-25 audit was completed by a local firm, Horton, McNei, and SERN, or HMNS. And this was our sixth year working with their team. As a part of the annual audit, HMNS visited our district office during the summer for the first round of testing.
So we wouldn't want evergreens to go up and then have to be trimmed as soon as they reach a substantial height. But and finally we like to thank the planning staff Jill and others for the hard work on this and for identifying pertinent tactical constraints. Thank you for your time and we really appreciate it. >> Thank you. Thank you for your comments. Hi, my name is D. Lampir. I live at 1307y Place. Thank you for allowing uh me and my neighbors to come and talk to you about this project. I sent an email. I'm not going to go back over that cuz I know it's easier to read than for me to talk about, but um my husband and I and our two daughters have lived on Ericoy for almost 20 years. So, we've been there for quite a while. We were there before the stadium bridge construction happened.
Um any discussion or um >> do you just want to put legislative delegate? >> Sure. We can add and alternate with or with alternate. >> Yes. >> Okay. Um something we haven't touched on in the conversation yet. Um or I'm sorry, Miss P. We haven't touched on in policy. Um there was a personnel committee. It's not a committee that's been active in my experience in tenure with the board. I think I saw you shake your head. I think it's you're not familiar with it either. >> Um the board before you, they added. >> Okay. >> But all >> um the consensus I think >> that I saw was was right to dissolve it, but I'll just open for conversation on potentially dissolving the personnel committee. >> Yeah, just to support that decision, um the research that I did has has was pretty clear that u most districts have moved away from having that because there was a a problem with um roles.
He What he did get though, somehow got behind Hopington and uh that's three points. >> Yeah, the Hopington wrestler does look like he's he's got 10 to 15 pounds on on me. So, it's going to be exhausting for me to try to move that weight around. But that's 10 to 15 Hopington pounds, which are soft pounds. >> For the Hopton listeners out there, uh, >> George apologizes. I do not. >> No. All right. Looks like we're going to get to the end of the first period here with Ashlin up 4 nothing. Can wrestlers at this >> weight class carry this intensity, Brett, for another four minutes? I mean, this is um >> Yeah, these kids have a lot of This is grueling. >> This is a lot of muscle, a lot of weight they're moving around. And I'm not just talking about themselves, of course, but their opponent.
So I Right. >> I don't know. And that's why I'm saying I don't have a number. I need I mean if you said listen if Michael says Jim go back what we could let's assume override fails here's a secondary budget I need you to prepare at X that's what I need right that's the information I need to say it's X then I can have a better understanding of how much we're using for revolving how much and how deeply are reductions so can I just follow >> Yep sorry just go ahead >> so if if we use that right to Y's point we're not talking about low fund. We're talking about 2.5 >> that becomes the $2.27 billion figure >> kind of potential cut of just under 25. >> Correct. >> Based on what you got, it's >> still going to happen. Correct. >> Okay. >> I mean, I think that's just >> feel like we got really deep into the weeds of possibilities and a lot of options, which is helpful to understand.
I do think the discussion should be you know what is forward what what's student facing um you know in this proposed essentially we are pre-cutting right the budget to make it a little bit more palatable for the board of finance and the town and that in and of itself is something I struggle with because I do feel like the administrators and the administration team has worked really hard to come up with the budget that we need and while I do agree with the work that the finance committee has done that it is um a good approach and a good exercise to see well like okay if we already know that's high you know where are the areas that we're going to have to look at I think the finance committee has done a ton of work with Casey and Deb to you know really look at ways that we can make it as Caroline has said you know kind of a status quo year in terms of making sure we leave space for what we need for the students but also So giving the the new superintendent that's coming in the opportunity to evaluate and see what we need and then really fight for programs that we might need to introduce next year.
Um, sort of the bigger ticket items. We'll get down to kind of nitty-gritty when we get down to um, and you know, DHS West is the main staffing driver. There are some scant positions across the district that are needed. Um, but the big number, the big FTE numbers is coming from the last phase in of the of the high school campus. Um, I'll go to the next slide for a sec. Hello. And and talk a little bit about this. So, you know, we're we're spending a lot of time talking about some of our historical issues that we've had here with especially in the last couple of years, the audits turning up surpluses. um you know and and looking at current numbers that we have now and you know getting a sense of where we landed last year and you know in some cases we've had you know head scratchers.
Then they come to our school sites during September and finally return to complete the financial review in October. During these visits, the auditors look at the dollars we've spent, the funding we received, and also our compliance with local, state, and federal guidelines. Um, the testing completed during these visits takes a lot of coordination amongst Chico Unified staff to gather requested documentation and provide it to the auditors in a timely manner. Uh so I want to take this opportunity to thank everyone in Chico Unifi that helped out with that process. Since it's a large document, I wanted to uh move forward. We usually tend to focus on the findings portion which starts on page 101 of the audit of the attachment. Um as a part of the 2024 2525 review, we had four audit findings. Two were compliance only with no fiscal impact and two had a fiscal impact to our financial statement.
And um since that construction, uh my side of the street, which is the west side, has flooded several times each summer. Um my across the street neighbor, I think, flooded two of her cars trying to just get into her driveway. Um and I am the closest to the storm drains, so I'm always the person out there with my rake and like digging out the storm drains and trying. But really, it's kind of futile because the water level is above the drains. So, [snorts] you really have to just kind of wait for the water to drop below before the real pull um can start happening. And this flooding has happened way more since the stadium bridge has been built and that water is all flowing down to our street. So, it makes me anxious about hearing about um impervious structures like multi-story parking garages that are going to um you know not going to absorb the same amount of rainwater that's coming.
The board is not responsible for personnel. And so it's it's very easy for lines to get blurred with like what the intention of that committee is versus what they're actually doing. Um so from the research I did that committee doesn't exist in many places any longer. um just because there's you know that conflict of what the B board's responsibility is and what the superintendent's responsibility is >> and I would just you know just to echo that and to and obviously I think to give perspective but if there are issues that are relevant to your role as a member of the board of education that are personnel issues that we encounter that I believe need to be brought to you then we will bring them to you because it fits your role it keeps you clean being in a situation where you could either walk into an ethical dilemma or create a situation.
They're moving moving a 200 something pound guy around for six minutes. Oh, now look how quick Brain Me was there with that that sit out. That's that move's called a sit out there and it was it was good. He didn't ultimately get his escape, but it was a well executed sit out. >> Me now will I think go out of bounds trying to get himself off the mat. Oh no, he's got he's got Huckington's leg. He wants TO STAY IN. OH >> YEAH. YEAH. Once >> I mean the referee had to blow it up there. They got too far out. But Braden was very close to getting an escape. >> One thing that's been impressing me, George, is the decisiveness of these Ashlin wrestlers. They're disciplined and they know what they're going to do before they do it. See, like right there, Brad was actually so fast that he um he didn't wait for the whistle.
But I think in terms of the conversation tonight and talking about an override, we probably I'll speak for myself. I don't want to speak for anybody else. It's helpful to me to really think, okay, if this is the way we're framing it, >> then we are probably talking about cutting 25 positions because we're talking about two and a half% increase and therefore we've got to account for reductions to 2.2 2.3 million. >> Is that am I kind of just >> plus dipping into the one-time funds >> plus an additional whatever it might be, >> right? Which I know is hard to add to the distillation, but >> Right. Which to summarize that we would have a painful first year that we could fill in using the one times funds that pain would only grow and we would not be able to >> augment much of that in year two.
So I I do think that's valuable. Um but I do worry that some of the things we're asking for comebacks on are things that won't even really be decided until the new super comes in anyway. And if you remember from last year and the year before, things that we thought were going to happen in January ended up we ended up having very different conversations in April based on, you know, initiatives, ways that they found money once the once the ad hoc committee for start times came about. We found that the buses could be cut and that wasn't a conversation that we had until April. So, um I don't know where I I struggle with where the line is with what we need to ask them to come back with. And some of those questions I feel like are really can't be decided by us and need to be decided at the administration level with the superintendent.
It's hard for me to get out in front of uh the city of Danberry and have a big ask while we're turning over turning up surpluses. And it's something that we're taking very seriously on how to mitigate that through a deeper analysis of the vacancies that we've had and the realities of our ability to fill them. And you know, it it's it's it's it is that's one of our biggest challenges right now. So, how are we taking how are we using conservative estimates for the benefits? So, if we know we can't fill so many positions historically, even though those positions may change, how do we hedge that against our projection for benefits? And, you know, it's scary because we haven't done it we haven't operated this way before. So, we're we're we're really doing due diligence on on kind of breaking those those down um and really putting something together that we think will be um responsible and maybe a little bit slower moving over time that we can get our hands on while we continue to work on this our ability to with the vacancies.
The first compliance only finding dealt with internal controls in our associated student body or ASB funds. During the 2024-25 school year, uh, a lot of Chico Unified staff participated in a training um that was held by California Fiscal Crisis and Management Assistance Team or FICMAT um that focused on ASB best practices. Uh, we're confident that this will help our secondary school sites to make the necessary changes and ensure compliance going forward. The second complianceonly finding was due to a change in requirements under the expanded learning opportunity program and has already been addressed with a change in process which was enacted by our afterchool program in October of 2025. In regards to the two audit findings that had fiscal impacts, the first was due to an early enrollment student in one of our transitional kindergarten classes in early 2024 25 which resulted in a decrease of revenue of approximately 51,000.
And so I would encourage that if this is um a plan that you're going to approve that you do a very um like governed by code storm water review and um a study of the impervious structures that are being proposed and how that's going to contribute to what we know is already a known flooding issue in that area. And um my other concerns were some of the ones that um Jill was mentioning earlier uh related to um the planning commission staff cautions [clears throat] against exceeding your design maximum building width under the TC1. But also, I question if um reszoning this lot to TC1 uh really makes sense based on the fact that it's R3 and R4 designed um or zoned areas currently. And from my reading of how TC1 evolved, it was for uh areas where there isn't a lot of development or residential, like there aren't people living there.