2026-01-22 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Tri-Board & Select Board (January 21st, 2026) · passage 113
And we have to craft those things. And just going back to the the number part of the reason I'm com more comfortable with I think you made a good point, Brandy, on we have to be able to provide all that detail. Well, the de the work's been done to that number, right? and that and those people have said that they're comfortable with that number. Uh and I think the other thing that reason I'm comfortable is if you look at the lever I mentioned levers last time, right? You look at all the levers we've been pulling, right? $2.3 million is general stabilization this year. We've been using the revolving funds, all those things. What what the forecasting does, we're not using them either at all or anywhere near the levels we have. It kind of resets those levers that we have been using over the last several years.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Alameda County, CA YouTube / CUSD Board of Education transcript source: youtube Chico Unified School District Board of Education Meeting 1/2… · passage 113
Um, so So yes, facilities has the facilities committee has discussed it, but there hasn't been surveys because I don't think we have like we need to know what we're like, you know, it's like the chicken or the egg, you know, because if you bring it to the community >> and then, you know, so there's not a a solid enough idea yet formed. >> So I'll add a little bit to that. Um, they are informed of what's going on. We have uh sent out parent square posts and we have talked about it individually um and with groups of parents. Have we actually done a survey? No. Um part of that is that we're sort of in an emergency situation. Um we are looking at uh needing to be out of our building. Um we are looking at potentially moving to Prop Prop 39. We're putting that placement in.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 1/21/26 · passage 114
So bear with me, please. The first question I have is a procedural question perhaps for staff, which is that um because a zoning a resoning petition requires an area plan. If we split the two and we say there's not support at the table for the site plan because it doesn't meet the code, how are we how do we understand procedurally approving the reszoning request with a insufficient site plan or no area plan? Um the advice that we got uh yesterday was was and I'm sorry that I wasn't part of that conversation directly. I heard it after the fact. Um but that it's okay for the two to be separated. Um we would obviously have to explain what happened to city council and why they would not match up and be presented together. Um that probably doesn't answer your question, [laughter] but um Yeah, it doesn't like in I don't know really how to frame it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Tri-Board & Select Board (January 21st, 2026) · passage 114
I think you mentioned, you know, 10 years ago talking, you know, Jim Jim in a budget meeting saying, "Oh my god, how how was this sustainable?" And all the factors you said have changed. So, uh, those help to make it more sustainable even though it wasn't sustainable. Uh, but we've reset those levers, right? That's that's kind of the restructuring that Jim has talked about. Um, and that was with that number. So we can we can articulate it because the work's been done to that number. But for me, the part of the reason and I would feel the same way was as you if it wasn't resetting the levers we've been using and that three years from now, should we need it to say, "Hey, we need to get past this year because we think that, you know, uh some projects are going to come on, we're going to have new growth in the following year, we can temporarily pull these levers, right?" Um so to me, that's where that that balance I talked to really sets in for me because I was really concerned at the last meeting about what happens when we pull all the levers.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Alameda County, CA YouTube / CUSD Board of Education transcript source: youtube Chico Unified School District Board of Education Meeting 1/2… · passage 114
So the community knows that we've done that. And then this is another option. Um it's really there's really not a well maybe we want Prop 39. We really don't. Um so that's not it's like that's an emergency. This is also this is less of an emergency. Moving to the portables puts us where we want to be. that I have presented to the staff that what we'd really love to be is at Little Chico Creek because that would be right near um where we're going to be. Well, I know that's not realistic, but you know, that's the kind of thing we're talking about. That would be great, but that's not going to happen. So moving to the site where we want to be that's near the creek that we can begin to work um with Marian Park and on the on the park at the park that they're putting on that side of the the place.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 1/21/26 · passage 115
I don't know whether it's a legal question or just a process question, but like >> hypothetically if the reasonzoning gets approved, you know, for the record it gets paired with this >> wrong site plan. I like it doesn't we haven't done that before as far as I understand. >> Right. I understand what you're saying. It wouldn't be that they're paired. >> [snorts] >> It's it was it was decided that you just have to have one or the other go with the resoning. Um and that the resoning can stand on its own without the approval of the area plan or the site plan. Does that make sense? >> Yeah. I guess if I'm looking at the EDC, it just says that the application has to contain it. It doesn't say that we have to like it. >> It's a little wonky, >> but we aren't approving it as a plan.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Tri-Board & Select Board (January 21st, 2026) · passage 115
we don't have any levers to pull. And that's that's that last page in Jim's thing. It's like we pulled the levers year one. Year two there's there, you know, we have $400,000 to play with, right? We don't we don't have anything to to to that would do that. So for me, as far as numbers, that's that's one of the other reasons I felt comfortable with it. We can articulate. I think that was a good point, Brandy. Uh and also it resets the levers we've been using. But I think the relative to I think we still go with what we talked about and I think we take on the challenge of how how do we how do we measure it? It's it's it's not trivial otherwise we'd already solved it, right? But but I think it's work we need to do and >> and and I would say I mean just to say it's not that simple.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Alameda County, CA YouTube / CUSD Board of Education transcript source: youtube Chico Unified School District Board of Education Meeting 1/2… · passage 115
That's where we it would not be perfect but it would be a better place than where we are. And um you know there are a number of charters that really aren't in perfect facilities. they they're doing, you know, what they can to keep things going. We're the only ones paying $50,000 a month. Um, and if we don't get out of there in a decent amount of time, we're not pay going to be paying it short term because we've shrunk our space, but it will go right back up to $50,000 a month because right now they're giving us a discount for what a commu a a commercial building rent is. So, um, so yeah, um, the community knows what we're doing. They know that we're talking about this. They know what the options are. Um, do we survey, hey, are you going to go to the new new site with portables or, um, squeeze in on a district site?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 1/21/26 · passage 116
We are simply looking at it as part of our Okay, got it. Thank you. [snorts] >> My next question would be for Commissioner Adams. Can you just help what you said about the the specific purpose statement was illuminating for me, but could you help me understand why it is not the law or like what things in the UDC are the law and which things are not the law? >> Well, I recognizing that uh Commissioner Adams is not the city attorney, nor is he the planning commission attorney and is not giving us legal advice. speaking as yourself recovering litigator. Uh I um so the the so I'm interp I'm interpreting it as of course everything in the UDC is the law. Um but it's it's an it's an expression of leg of purpose by virtue of how it's by how it's described in the UDC as a purpose statement.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Tri-Board & Select Board (January 21st, 2026) · passage 116
So like now that you've added it to the base you're going to have an additional growth amount. So where does that go? you know, it's it's not going to be that much, but the amount of energy we'll have to spend to figure that out compared to the impact is going to be very very small. Um, and again, I think like we've been operating under under a certain construct. I think to change it back now, I mean, does that mean we're, you know, we could potentially change it back later? It puts us kind of in limbo. um and uh understand, you know, the challenge uh that that you certainly have. Um gosh, if it was easy, everybody would do it, right? You know, so no, I I just um you know, to be clear, I think that the the 3.5 was is the right number. Um I think that it's going to be very challenging um to explain it to people.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Alameda County, CA YouTube / CUSD Board of Education transcript source: youtube Chico Unified School District Board of Education Meeting 1/2… · passage 116
The answer is they'd prefer to go to the portables. I know that even without doing a formal survey. So again, it just really kind of goes back to um member Olsen's um I think understand I know it's a substitute motion and it's been but really the substitute motion is is in reaction to the first motion and the first motion was made I think because of the amount of uncertainty in all the different budgets, right? And whether or not um it's in the district's best interest to go ahead and earmark I mean officially give this money to Blue Oak uh to do with which what they wish. Um and I'm I'm hearing member Lando Lando's um concern that and Blue Oak's concern that if they don't have this money uh then they can't really plan on it. I get that. But it doesn't the fact that they can't count on it doesn't negate the fact that there are so many things that we don't know right at this time.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 1/21/26 · passage 117
And it doesn't it doesn't prohibit me from doing it. it says you shouldn't probably do this and this is what we intended and that's kind of how it's labeled and that's why I'm interpreting it that way. Um, I'd feel differently if other words were used later on in, you know, tables and other areas of the UDC that said, "Thou shalt not or that type of thing." But I went back and pulled the staff reports associated with the ordinance and feel relatively sound in the conclusion that TC1 is not unlawful to use here, that we have discretion to make a judgment on that. the purpose statement and their council's against it, but then I've got stuff that comes after that that says be creative and flexible in how you interpret this document because it's not meeting our policy needs. So, I don't know how to I think the more recent thing should control and council came along after the fact and said we've got a big problem on our hands and we need to be more aggressive in how we we approve resonings.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Tri-Board & Select Board (January 21st, 2026) · passage 117
It it's you know it's beneficial to some extent to people because it doesn't fall into into our tax levy every year but it doesn't fall away for 23 years. I don't care that it people [laughter] do any >> what happens in 23 years. But um in any case, I I you know and I feel that it's important that people know that there's still an impact. Yes. >> You know, goes to debt exclusion. Just going to a different bucket that is still going to raise your your taxes. So, um it's it's complicated and and uh >> I mean, it's not so complicated it can't be explained to people, but >> it's it just I want to make sure people truly understand it, too. I don't want to walk away thinking that they're only paying on 2.75, right? >> I'm just wondering if we need to, and I know probably not tonight, have a conversation about uh the story of that 750,000 and what it was originally said was going to happen to it versus what's happening now.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Alameda County, CA YouTube / CUSD Board of Education transcript source: youtube Chico Unified School District Board of Education Meeting 1/2… · passage 117
Um, Chico Unified has not officially given the Prop 39 response, which will be February 1. Um, we don't know how Blue Oak whether or not Blue Oak I it does mean something to hear uh that uh King um Consulting feels like you're well positioned. That that that's something that I didn't know. And so I think that's that's helpful to know. Nevertheless, uh we don't know, we won't know officially whether you get Prop 2 funding until, you know, maybe a Aprilish. And so I guess uh member member Lando, is there something else that you would say that I guess to help me better understand kind of urgy and uh like Yeah. >> Well, so excuse me cold. Um if they get Prop 2, the extra million dollars already in the pocket will help them to have been doing planning and make a plan to get on the site as quickly as possible.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 1/21/26 · passage 118
So, that's why I'm taking the position that I'm taking. >> Okay, that helps. Thank you. And again, just for the record, uh, Commissioner Adams is not legal counsel to this commission, nor to the city, and, uh, his legal advice is his own. >> Take it at your own risk? No, I'm kidding. Um, and then my next question maybe starts with staff and then moves to the petitioner, uh, which is, um, was there a conversation or consideration of PUD as opposed to reszoning to TC1? Um the application was for TC1 with conditions. Certainly that was brought up. Um but there wasn't a lengthy discussion of it or anything because it was not what the applicant desired. >> Okay. Is there any guidance or or practice that you you follow as city staff when thinking about weighing the pros and cons of a reasonzoning with conditions versus a PUD?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Tri-Board & Select Board (January 21st, 2026) · passage 118
Just to kind of nip any conversation in the bud, >> oh, I I think we'll have to like repeat what we said at the last at the last meeting. We need to have a conversation about that of >> Yeah, >> it's a change in what was said was going to happen to that 750,000. >> And and I think that's the tension that I I was like, you know, we need to talk about >> not just that it's complicated, it's a change and we need to own that and be transparent about that or else I think we lose credibility. And that's why the vote was, even though you could do it, you know, that's why the vote was, you know, however you decided to do it, whether it was through appropriations or whether through a town meeting vote or, you know, tying it to this. >> Yeah.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Alameda County, CA YouTube / CUSD Board of Education transcript source: youtube Chico Unified School District Board of Education Meeting 1/2… · passage 118
If they don't get Prop 2, then the million dollars still helps them get onto that site more quickly in portables while they look for a longerterm financial solution to build the structure they want to. or they take some kind of a Prop 39 offer, which again, we will hear about that from the families and students of whichever school or schools uh wind up uh suddenly sharing a site on relatively short notice. So either way, I think this just allocating this money gets them to where they need to be and in a position to best serve both their students and ours regardless of the outcome of Prop 2. Thank you. I'll I'll just add with with I think that was well well said. I appreciate the summary. Um without this money, Prop 39 is our only option. So that is what we will do. we you know it doesn't it's enough of a difference to get us over there with portables that it will be too tight and and correct if we get Prop 2 and and I wish we had all of the I wish like we knew what Prop 39 like if we knew what Prop 39 option was and we knew about Prop like it would be so much easier to present all of this to everybody and I would sleep at night.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 1/21/26 · passage 119
>> Um I wouldn't compare them directly. Uh, I mean, if if you or someone asked us to do that, we could certainly do that. I hate to say it, but generally people avoid PUDS because you it costs a lot more because you have to pay into affordable housing or provide units. Um, I don't know that that was the case here and I'm not trying to imply that it was, but um, [laughter] >> we've seen some more creative applications that >> Okay, great. And then maybe to the petitioner I could pose the same question whether or not you considered a PUD and if not why not and and a secondary question would be um could you say something about the reasonzoning petition for the ent for all of the parcels as opposed to just the R4C portion which you plan to redevelop and if there are plans for other portions of the site.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Tri-Board & Select Board (January 21st, 2026) · passage 119
Which is why it should be tied because it is a change in what people thought was going to happen to that. This should absolutely be tied. So, >> I think that's a fair I think. >> It's a fair point. Chantel's Chantel is Hold on one second here. Chantel is absolutely right. And I've some of the people that I have already spoken to about this. The first question was, "Wait a minute, that was public safety building >> issues, you know, and it it was it was attached to that project in some way, shape, and form with respect to the vote that was taken." And um again, transparency is is is a key with respect to that. And I I don't disagree with anything that you said, but I think at some point part of that conversation has to be part of where did this money come from?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-22 Alameda County, CA YouTube / CUSD Board of Education transcript source: youtube Chico Unified School District Board of Education Meeting 1/2… · passage 119
Um, so if we um get Prop 2, while we're waiting for that funding to be available, we can be working on CD site approval. We have the funds to do that work, right? Like all of that's going to cost funds. Working on our architectural plans, working on on all all of those things because that's going to take time. So, this money will give us time to do that. Like we've we've already kind of presented that. And if we don't get Prop 2, then it gets us over there in the portable buildings, which no, of course we don't. That's not what we want, right? We we want to be over there in a nice site that's going to suit our families the best. But without this, it whatever it is, Prop 39. So that is the option because we cannot stay and pay 54 $55,000 a month in rent past, you know, even you know.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above