Reader
Browse passages, annotate evidence, and export with full provenance for citation.
>> Yeah, because it's February 1st. >> You want to have an outline of the Prop 39 plan on the 4th? >> Yes. Well, what I was going to say was we can tentatively plan for this stuff to be on the fourth, >> but if we get to the point where I'm looking at the agenda and going this cannot be on the fourth, right? >> I just want to make sure that you understand that I'm going to come to you and say, "Let's pick a different night." Y >> because what we have planned for the fourth is big. It's not nothing. So, I just want to I'm not trying to delay. I'm just we we have something going on and I don't know that I'm going to be able to just this isn't going to be a 15minute discussion. It never has been. So, I mean I'm I'm just trying to be real upfront and honest with everybody that >> you know we'll do it quick but we'll have it we will try to get it ready by the fourth just like you're getting it ready by the fourth and if it happens on the 4th boom it happens.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Like I I I I want to like have you all come back and teach folks how to like joyfully oppose things because it was just delightful listening to you as you were just like no no no. But it was happy and you were delighted um to be here and to talk with us and it didn't feel like it's adversarial and um everyone at the table has acknowledged it because uh we sit at this table and we hear from a lot of people um and over the the length of time that we've been working on the comprehensive land use, we've heard from thousands of people and a lot of people um make assumptions about us that are not true. We are your neighbors. I am your neighbor. I I understand what it means to have your neighborhood changed. One of you asked, "Would you like to have 342 new neighbors?" And unfortunately for you, my answer is an enthusiastic yes.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um, you know, and it just kind of goes on from there. >> Okay. Um, >> are any members willing to do that? What? We just need one or two. Um, and >> I'm sorry, Rob. I don't mean to talk. Sure. Go ahead. Happy to, you know, to Joe, happy to, you know, less between us and this particular group on this issue. Um, and if there are any of my other colleagues on select board who are interested in doing the same, you know, we can do that, you know. Um, >> and I I don't have a problem doing that as well. I could be the alternate. Makita could be >> Okay, that would be good. Yeah, because it shouldn't hinge upon >> if you're not available at some point or whatever. Yeah. >> Yeah, I think that makes sense. >> That answer your question, Rob? Yeah, I think that would well, you know, I see Susan wants to uh say something, but I would think it would be agreeable to the committee if we had at least one liaison and an alternative alternate and okay, >> as long as you folks took some action tonight, we'd be I I think, you know, at least I can't speak for everybody, but it seems like a reasonable uh course to take.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Or if we have to delay a few days to do something we have to delay a few days >> but we are required to have a preliminary offer for proper 39 by the 1st. Right. >> Correct. >> So, we'll be able to look at that at least. >> Yes.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I would love to have 342 new neighbors, but my city council members said no. In my neighborhood, they blocked us from increasing uh the residential density in the neighborhood that I live in, which is a R1C. I wanted it to have as much density as possible and I'm still a little angry about that. But I'm glad to be uh in this conversation with you because I think you all see uh what the challenges are. The challenges are uh we're living in a changing environment. We live in a great place. People want to live here and uh because they want to live here, they put demands on us uh which means we have to either make space for them or we have to resist them. and you are in that thin space of this change and uh we're here and we're trying to listen. We're trying to hear what you're saying, what our UDC says, what our staff says, and we're trying to make the best decision.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Yeah. So, you you have you have a way you have a way of contacting Makita and myself. So, if you have some dates that are available that work for for everybody, uh, we could set up >> to the subcommittee, which we did name. Could I ask that you that Susan uh say what she's thinking there? I see Susan's hand is up. >> Yep. I'm sorry. I don't see you behind you. Yep. Right Sue. I'm sorry. >> Hi. That's okay. Um, do you need me to say Susan Brush Jensen? >> Oh, I I forgot to introduce myself. Sorry. Um I guess it it would just be helpful for me to understand the reason you know the change in thinking that you all have like what's the pros and cons from your perspective about that? >> There hasn't been a change. Um there hasn't been a change at all.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Thank Thank you. >> Is that the only thing you're looking for is the offer? That wasn't what I heard. I heard the process. >> Oh, no. It was >> just the offer. >> Oh, yeah. You want that? >> Yeah. >> Sorry. I misunderstood. >> So, I I'm just going to state my preference. I I think it'd be much better to have a special board meeting just for this rather than having it on the 4th. I have no >> that's what I I feel would would be most productive for everyone involved. >> I have no objection to that. So then if that's what we'll do is we will be ready by the fourth but we will madame president and I will talk about what dates are available what we were looking at and we'll figure out if there's an alternate date that we can have with the and doing it at the large conference room and you know things like that and just having it there a little less complicated than trying to have something here and we can do it and we'll get this thing knocked out.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Let me just inform you of what's going to happen and then I'll I'll make my comments. Um whether this passes at this table or not, we are only making a recommendation. So short of us tableabling it and allowing the petitioner to come back, you heard that from Mr. Moore. He's subtly put that into his comments that we could table this and someone at the table would have to take that up as a motion. Um this will proceed to city council and city council uh and uh Commissioner Dish can correct me will have two readings. They'll have a a first reading uh which generally passes um and then they will have a second reading and at each reading they'll have a public hearing. So your opportunities to talk joyfully about your opposition continue and you would have two more chances uh to do that as well as your own advocacy with your direct uh council members.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I mean, I I gave you folks the opportunity to come in front of us and speak uh to do what you needed to do and the door was still open to for dialogue and and to do what needs to get done. I guess I guess I don't understand the difference between the being a liaison to the subcommittee and >> because the board has decided not to have create another subcommittee because then you'd have to go through the open meeting laws and schedule uh and post meetings. Um and and Rob knows that. So I that's >> so it's just simp to simplify it, >> right? that that's that's a great way of uh putting it simplifying the process. >> Okay. >> The other thing too I just want to add if to create a subcommittee um you know we we would probably want to then offer it out to the public to participate and talent >> through the talent bank forms and that as opposed to just having a group come to us and ask us to create a subcommittee.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, if we if we can't do it on the fourth or if it doesn't look right, thinking what you're thinking, then we'll figure out what date we can do it. Okay. >> Sounds good. >> All right. No action taken. >> Thank you. I I I just want to make sure I'm clear on what you guys want when I come when we come back. So, um so I have like the lease from the landlord, you know, confirmation that they're willing to to let us stay. Um like a cost breakdown, right? Site work, soft cost, portable cost, all of that. Any other >> also the um like I think what Tisha was asking about is it possible like some sort of confirmation can you have the portables while also building like is is the feasibility of that. >> Okay. >> Is that what you were kind of originally >> Yes.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Does that all make sense? Okay. I have the privilege of the table to talk to you and you can talk back in this way. Um, so I agree TC1 is not the best uh zoning district, but it is the only one right now because we're updating our 25 year 204 year old plan. Um, which didn't imagine that uh the University of Michigan would be the largest uh state university in Michigan. It didn't imagine that the university would um hire uh 26,000 new employees. It did not imagine that the University of Michigan would uh absorb an entire hospital system. It did not imagine that the university would grow um almost unabated um by 5,000 new students year-over-year. It did not imagine that the university would not build more housing for those students. You all know that it's been since 1964 that the university has built residential um housing in the downtown uh area on this side of town.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, it just seems like having a liaison is just a much simpler um solution, you know, to trying to get to where everybody wants to get to. >> Okay. So, that would still allow us to come to bring a proposal and have the board take action in the future. >> That That's correct. >> Okay. All right. Thank you. I just understand. >> Hey, Rob, are you good with that? Yes, I think that's so you're going to pick a liaison and an alternate tonight. >> Correct. And I think we did. I unless there's anybody else watch. >> We just did Rob. We just said [clears throat] >> and because it's not any kind of official committee from our perspective. You guys are creating this. You're deciding to do this and we have said we will provide a liaison, right? >> And that it's it's just like any other group that forms in Ashland that then looks for a liaison.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Uh >> but board members would wanted to see. >> Okay. I appreciate and support the no action action. >> I I appreciate it as well. Okay. >> So, thank you. >> Well, good. I'm glad we could come to some agreement. All right. Okay. Moving on. >> You guys want to go? >> No, it's long. >> I lost track of where we are. Let's see. Okay. So, moving on to human resources. Um, Mike Allen's going to be presenting tonight on uh resolution 1712-26, elimination of classified staff due to lack of work um or lack of funds. This is discussion action. >> So, um I I think the title is a little um misleading because there's no staff being affected. It's only um positions that we're cleaning up. We bring it in batches um to the board. Um, and most of these positions are just being replaced by a different position.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um it's been a long long time since they've built housing. Our uh comprehensive land use plan that we are operating under did not imagine that environment at all and this is where we find ourselves in this thin space, this in between. So, I'm inclined to uh vote in favor of the resoning uh to deny the site plan because I agree with staff. It does not meet uh the standard and staff has discretion there. And um if the table votes the way that I have counted it, this will fail here at the table, but it will advance uh to city council and you'll have an additional conversation with them. With that, Commissioner Dish. Thank you, Commissioner W. So, um I do want to address a couple of times affordability came up and I do want to talk about that because this is tough. Um and also, um Mr.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
It's not an official committee from our perspect I mean we do not appoint it. It's not listed anywhere. If you guys want to post something, if you want to become a nonprofit, whatever you want to do, that's fine. That's not tied to the select board, >> but Makita has offered to talk to you about it. [snorts and clears throat] >> And when she's not available, I am great. Yeah, I would characterize a little more formal than that, but you know, we all can have our different viewpoints, but certainly wanted to thank Makita and Joe for stepping up for this. We appreciate it. And Makita, I hope you I hope you're feeling better. You sound like I do. So, [laughter] >> I hope you feel better too soon, Rob. >> Yeah, take a hot tide and go to bed. >> Yeah, I would. Except I'm at this meeting.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, um, cleaning up the books, making sure that, you know, I can keep track of, you know, um, data basically saying that, you know, we're full, we're not full, how close were we to full employment, things like that. So, clean it up and then um you know, Jacine doesn't have to budget for positions that we're not using, >> right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Moore has given us an opening to talk about that with him which I will come to in a moment, Mr. Moore. So, you don't have to stand up yet. But um so there are a couple of pathways to affordability and one is to increase supply and the other is to publicly subsidize housing. Ann Arbor is taking both of those pathways. We are increasing supply. the comprehensive land use plan which is what commissioner Norton is referring to when he speaks of the club. We live with it so we call it by its nickname. Um it uh we are doing that. It is we the the comprehensive land use plan envisions greater density in the near campus areas and in downtown just as we're seeing now. It envisions some kind of increase in areas like yours, which that is the least clear, least well articulated part of the plan.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I don't know. You guys have to keep going, though. >> We're going. It's only what? Hour two. That's all. Hour two and a half. It's Yeah. Anyway, well, thanks. I'm I'm gonna stop this filibuster, >> but you've just made a you've kind of discussed it. So, >> I think we're willing to go ahead on that uh that basis. >> Thank you. >> I don't see anybody uh anyone objecting. So, >> no. >> Okay. >> Thanks, Rob.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Any questions from the board? Any public comment? >> Yes. Come on up. >> Questions. Um so, you said being replaced by different positions. So does that mean different instructional PAR positions that are more like full-time based hours or an increase in hours? >> Some Yes. So some of them are going from either six hours to 6.5 hours. We're we're in a transition where we're trying to make most or all um IPS six hours at the elementary site, 6.5 at the secondary site. So, um, as they turn over, we add those hours, change the position, and put in a new position. And then we have to eliminate, >> right? And then between how many? Because I counted I think it's like 21ish or at least 20. My eyes are getting old. >> I count I counted 17.5. >> Um, between how many school sites? Is it all of them or is there just certain number of school sites?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And so I think everyone here is right that your neighborhood is going to change. My neighborhood will change. Um the thanks to you all who voted for the affordable housing mill, we are producing we have a thousand units in the pipeline right now. um some of them rising into the air in Kerry Town of income eligible affordable housing that's open to people that average at 60% of the area median income. Now neither of this addresses what you are talking about which is housing for you or housing for people who were in their 30s um because you are not in the income eligible piece and you are not interested in the form of housing if you could pay for it and many of you wouldn't be able to pay for the high tower housing that is coming in in the So, um, as Commissioner Hammershmmit said, it is true that a three or four story building on this site would feel like it fit the surroundings better, but it definitely wouldn't be cheaper.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above