Reader
Browse passages, annotate evidence, and export with full provenance for citation.
>> Should we first ask for anything else? Yeah, you're well. >> I'm sorry. I'm messing the process up and I apologize. >> Okay. I don't >> How about we see if there's any questions on anything else and then we can make a motion to pass everything except that one if we want to. I'm jumping ahead. I apologize. >> Okay. >> U meander, what um >> are you referring to a section in the mental health policy? >> No, I am on 5145.13. Uh it is titled uh response to immigration enforcement. >> Oh, gotcha. Okay. And the very last paragraph uh opens with a sentence. Superintendent or design may report to the board in a timely manner any request for information or access to school site. >> Okay. >> And I would rather that be a will than a may because I would like to know if that's happening in our community.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
[gasps] And so I think I actually I really you know that I'm not super fond of PUDS generally, but I like I actually think conditions make it make it even more difficult to understand what is allowed on the property next door because it looks on the map like it is TC1. Just for what it's worth, that's my two cents. So, um I I for those reasons, I actually don't know even if we tabled this that my vote's going to change. I'm just going to be real clear, but I and so I'm not going to propose tableabling, but I'm Yeah, that's my two cents. >> Commissioner Nord, >> I I appreciate the observations and the analysis that's going on here and I am honestly really struggling with this. I can see both sides. Well, but I'm I keep coming back to there's a project that's being proposed that staff is telling us doesn't comply with the site design requirements.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
The presentation last night at the community center was videotaped by by WACA. Um, and like Claudia said, there's going to be there's a survey and an exercise. So, you you know, I would suggest people watch Goldton's presentation because it's really good. It gives more information about what the housing production plan is and talks about a lot of the acronyms that we talk about a lot which is um SHI subsidized housing inventory and we talk about the 10% and that's really what's driving a housing production plan is really the state's mandate that towns work towards 10% affordable housing. And so until you have 10% you are subject to 40b. And one of the things that they were sharing with us last night was that, you know, we have three large 40B projects in the pipeline. And when assuming those are permitted, um, which you don't always assume, but assuming they're permitted and built within a certain amount of time, they will count towards our our subsidized housing inventory and get us over that 10%.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Uh and and the motion is to pull it. >> Well, we don't have a motion yet. Um right now we're just asking um clarification questions regarding the updated policies. Okay. and then we'll have an opportunity for the public to comment and then we'll open it up for >> there's there's also it's interesting because there is also I mean there's some areas that already say shall the superintendent or designate shall develop procedures for addressing any immigration related requests but the very next paragraph I'm and I'm on I wish they had number page I I'm on the first page kind of at the bottom of the first page the next paragraph says superintendent of designate may may provide training to staff regarding immigration issues which again it's like it seems [clears throat] like we probably should be doing that um and especially in lie of uh you know the training the the at CSBA I attended a pre-conference um and it was the new legal um it was what's coming out in the legal things and I think this this policy changes in part due to that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
We should not approve it. I don't know what would what would work that would pencil in for the developer that would also survive um would pass site plan review. And if we can't be sure that there's a a project that could be built here that would be financially feasible that would satisfy site plan, then where's the necessity to do the resoning to TC1? So, you're not supposed to think about a resoning in the context of a specific project. But if there's no project here that doesn't work, where's the necessity to reszone this to CC1? And if it's necessary to do it here, then why isn't it necessary to do it everywhere in the city that's along a corridor? So, I'm having a really hard time disconnecting the feasibility of this project as design with the need to do the resoning. And if it's not possible to do the project as design, we can't get it through the site plan, then where's the necessity for the reasoning?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> I don't even think we need all three of them to get us over the 10%. But between that and having a an active housing production plan, we will be able to um save ourselves from having to accept 40D projects. >> Put us in safe harbor. >> It'll will be in safe harbor. So, it's it's a good exercise. Like Claudia said, you don't we don't have to implement everything that's in the housing production plan. It's really strategies that you want to look at and say, "Okay, does this make sense?" And it all has to tie back to the comp plan because if it doesn't tie back to the comp plan, we're not going to we're not going to >> if anything tied back to the comp plan, a lot of things would be different. Unfortunately, the comp plan is great in the in theory. >> Oh, absolutely.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
There are some very important um issues discussed about uh making sure that the staff at sites were well trained to understand that not all warrants uh are the same, that it has to be a judicial warrant. And so it seems to me that th those are not things that that AR may provide training that seems like it should be should should provide training um to the applicable staff. So yeah, I I support pulling this. >> Wait, we're not um >> I know I get it. >> Okay, just >> um I also >> because there is a moment here where we can all discuss it, too. So, we can all do that. >> I was at one of the trainings at CSBA and and I inquired about this um actually just today kind of late in the game, but by March first that we have to have a comprehensive safety plan um to address this specifically, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, I still am kind of falling down on the side. I this is a problem enough shoehorning to try and get TC1 to work here um for a project that isn't going to that we're being told and I agree with doesn't pass the site design requirements. I don't see the logic. And maybe if it were tabled and they could do a quick redesign, that would solve that problem. But it sounds like that would take longer than that would be a long and involved process. >> Yeah, that would be another staff review. >> Yeah. So at a minimum, >> so I'm kind of back I understand that the tremendous need to approve projects. I understand that we're not supposed to stop new development and that while we're trying to update the comprehensive land use plan, but that doesn't mean um that we should disregard what the whole purpose of the how the system is supposed to work and the fact that we are proceeding with making the changes that are needing to facilitate the kind of growth and development we want to see.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> As is the housing production plan in theory. Unfortunately, we do not have the power to do what we what people in this community want to do around housing. >> And it isn't that people don't want to have affordable housing. It's just that they want some control over it. >> So, I I missed the meeting last night. I do look forward to going and watching the video. Um, I would ask that it gets put in Michael's newsletter, the connection, you know, the the link to the video, the link to the survey, um, who they should go to if they have questions. So, housing production plan, if it's in place and we're moving things forward, we can be in what's called safe harbor. And even if we get to that 10%, unless we stop building here in town, right, as long as our numbers of houses keep going up and we still have some open space for single family homes and we still have some other projects that are in the books that have no affordable housing, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And we do have a a comprehensive school plan, safety plan, but I don't know that it addresses this specifically. So I think there's more to be coming uh regarding this. >> So I can answer a couple things. First of all, the the training we do train last year we did and this year we're starting the process continuing that with training piece. So that um and that is not an ed code uh notation on the end of that paragraph. So if you wish >> to to push that to um shall instead of may. >> Well, hold on. We're not going to be making these decisions right now. If you want to make a substantive change on something, we're going to make a motion that's going to say, "I move to approve all these minus this one and this one and this one, and those get pulled." I don't we 9:15 at night.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I think I just convinced myself I'm still falling down on the sounds like um this is a problematic proposal. >> All right, I think we're ready to vote. Let's do a a roll call vote, please. >> Um, if I could just add that our uh our current comprehensive plan is only 16 years old. I meant to say that earlier. >> Oh, I did I say 24? >> I can't vote. [snorts] >> Or did I say 19? >> I [laughter] thought I said 19. >> It's not quite that bad. >> Uh, okay. I was off by three years. >> So, on the first motion as presented, >> oh, I'm sorry. you will have to um the first motion everyone is for the site plan uh dated November 19th. Okay. >> And uh the development agreement contingent upon administrative land transfer. >> I also wanted to just mention that uh since you are in even number this evening that if it is split evenly that is a denial recommendation and would be forwarded with the vote count to city council as such.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, it's one of those things that we need to make sure once we get to our 10%, our goal then is to stay at that 10%. As well as andor have things in our housing production plan that helps us stay at that 10%. Because if you drop below the 10% and you aren't doing things to go back to your 10%, that's when you're open to 40bs. And the other part is to to Claudia's point, we were in safe harbor as a community. We were in safe harbor with our housing production plan that we passed in 2020. Unfortunately, two, and we all know this story, maybe not everyone in town. There's two projects that were going to keep us in safe harbor. One didn't go through because they were in a lawsuit, and one didn't go through because the developer felt financially it wasn't the right thing for him.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
We're We cannot start making these decisions right now. I'm sorry. So, >> that makes sense. >> Are there any other questions regarding board policies? >> You you said of any board policies because I'm I'm about to jump into Right. The ones that we are >> Yes. Um, thank you, Mr. Superintendent. Um on the board policy on mental health, um I I have so many notations on verifying the actual availability of what we say we're going to make known to our families as far as um uh resources. not only to our families but to our school personnel that are doing referrals and things because um I've worked in this area enough to know that even though it says those services are available or shall be available, if you make the phone call, you're not going to get services because they will tell you there's no services available.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Uh, Commissioner Norton, >> this is for the site plan >> for the site plan and development agree >> development. Um, no. >> Commissioner Adams, >> no. >> Commissioner Weatherbe, >> no. >> Commissioner Mills, >> no. >> Council member Dish, >> no. >> Uh, Commissioner Hammershmid, >> no. >> Commissioner Abrams, >> no. >> And Commissioner W, >> no. >> That fails. and will be uh recommended uh for denial to city council. On your second motion as presented to approve the petition to transit corridor district and accept conditions um fully stated earlier in the evening. Commissioner Norton, >> no. >> Commissioner Adams, >> this is resoning, correct? >> Yes. The reasonzoning petition. >> Yes. Commissioner Weatherbe, >> no. >> Commissioner Mills, >> no. >> Uh, Council Member Dish, >> yes. >> Uh, Commissioner Hammernet, >> no. >> Uh, Commissioner Abrams, >> yes. >> And Commissioner W, >> yes.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, with those two projects not going forward, we fell out of Safe Harbor, and that's how we got the 40B. So, I know people are like, "Oh, well, as a as a community, we keep wanting the housing. We keep wanting the housing." We've done what we can to not get the housing and to not have to have 40bs. And we I know there are people who've been like, "Well, we need to complain to the state and all the the state wants more housing. The state all the housing reports are showing that we don't have enough housing and we don't have enough affordable housing in the state." So, >> and then that's and that's and that's another topic of discussion. Oh, yeah. what what is affordable and that was part of the discussion last night that I thought was very interesting because uh the speaker uh that who presented it uh was talking about the percentages um your average income for two people and I and I'll use this because this is what I remember and I was going to take the sheet and didn't take it with me um if you were spending more than 30% of your >> total salary towards towards housing costs.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
There's no mental health personnel handling those situ. It's just a crapshoot. Excuse me. But um I want to see verification if we're going to pass this policy on mental health that the services that we're saying should be provided and should be available to our families and our students because some of them go through site personnel in order to get served that they're actually going to be available. Is there a question? >> Pull it. >> Okay. [laughter] Okay. >> If if you're gonna >> That's okay. >> Go through the process and verify that those things are actually available, then we have to pull it. You can't do that tonight at 9:15 either. >> Okay. >> So, >> okay. Were there any other questions in regarding Okay. Any public comment? I think Tom, you had a motion. Let's go ahead and move into um motions at this time.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Okay. So since that is a split vote that uh fails and will be uh recommended to city council as a denial. >> Thank you everyone and thank you all uh so much for coming and sharing your thoughts with us and um being joyful uh objectors. Really appreciated it. That takes us to agenda item 11A. Other business there is none. And now we are at agenda item number 12.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
It was okay. It it you know you it's livable but right now in Ashland it was over 70% >> of the base salary Yeah. going to housing which is >> so one of the issues that Ashland has is one our income is high >> but two our SHI at 80% is tied to Boston income >> right >> and I had this discussion with someone the other day is if we could if we could be tied not to Metro Boston for our SHI and we could have a lower SHI it then our cost could potentially go lower because we then wouldn't, you know, we wouldn't need people with as much money and and our and our cost, our affordable housing cost could potentially be lower if we were tied to Worcester or Framingham or and not Metro Boston. >> And that that grouping get tied in with the insurance companies.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Sorry. Um, I move to adopt all the board policies listed except uh 5141.5 mental health and 5145.13 response to immigration enforcement. >> Thank you. >> Okay. Do we have a second? >> I have a second. >> Okay, >> we all second. >> We have lots of seconds. Who seconded first? >> Draw straws. >> Okay, Tisha. Tisha one. >> Yeah. >> Okay. So, uh we have a motion um by member Lando and a second by member Hayes um to adopt the new board policies uh with the exception of mental health. Which number was that? Uh 5141.5 and also the immigration which was I lost it. 5145.13. >> Okay. >> Yes. >> 5145.13. So, let's go ahead um and vote. Uh let's do this all together again. All those in favor signify by saying I. >> I. >> Those opposed. >> Okay, this passes. >> Okay, moving along.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
This is a second opportunity for individuals to speak up to three minutes on any issue. We'll first hear from those of you present. Some of you are leaving. Then remote participants to [snorts] speak remotely uh press star 9 if on phone or raise or use the raise hand feature if on Zoom. For phone access, dial and enter meeting ID 977-66341226. Uh, city staff will identify callers by the last three digits of their phone number. Uh, and by their name if on Zoom, you'll hear an announcement when it's your turn to speak. Please, uh, let's see. Uh, please ensure that you're in a quiet area and mute any background noise. For all participants, whether remote or in person, please state your name and address at the beginning of your comments. Is there anyone present who would like to address us at this time? Hi, Sam. >> Hi.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above