>> Yeah. >> That's how we get grouped in. Why we got grouped in that way, I have no idea, but that's how we get grouped into it. So anyway, >> but anyway, >> regardless regardless >> of any any of those things, >> 40B has been around since 1969. >> Yep. >> Housing is still a crisis in this state. >> Y >> or affordable housing. And it hasn't done what it was supposed to do or what it needs to do. >> And I mean, that's the bottom line. Doesn't matter who you're tied into or anything else. >> It should be tweaked. >> But go ahead, Michael. So So What are you all going to do about it? >> I mean, we have the same discussion like, >> well, I don't know. I've been asking to have our attorneys be a little more proactive, and that hasn't been the case.
Um >> I'm sorry. Can we stay on this item for a moment? >> Yes. >> Just fact that we passed the motion doesn't mean we have to move on. Do we want to do anything to deal It's okay. I just want Do we want to do anything to deal with the two we didn't pass because right now they're not on the books? >> Um, so do we want to make a motion about when we're going to address those or what that looks like? >> I think we need to make sure that we say when we're going to address them because there's there's another question on the mental health one. um because of age aging out. Um some of the things that are referred to in here once a student has turned 18, there's nothing compulsory about getting them those services. >> How's February 20th sound?
Yes, Sam 1451 color. Again, um to Commissioner Bell's point, uh you need an R4 zone that's dedic that's designed to accommodate 502s, which is what this is proposing. So, 85 limit, and I recommend keeping 300 foot rule for building with. Um there is another board of matter of business that I've been meaning to bring to the planning commission. Since I happen to be here tonight, I thought I would do it now. Um this is going to sound like the most pedantic thing in the world. Architectural standards for fences. I have a very small overlap behind my garage with a commercial property on Packard and they have built uh it's a chainling fence and apparently in the 60s there used to be a little gate there so you could get to it. Um and they took a bunch of just junk and it's um you know the gates that fold open for chain link fences.
So, um, you know, I've I've written to the governor. I've written to our state legislators. Um, you know, housing is a huge issue in across the state. >> And did she did our governor get back to you? She did not because she's running for reelection. I'm surprised she didn't. >> So, you know, I mean I I uh >> No, I mean I mean do you feel like do you feel like having the conversation that you're having is is productive? >> I think part of it is >> Michael >> Oh, sorry. Go ahead. >> Go ahead. No, it's just like Well, first off, I just wanted to back up when you're like, "What are you going to do about it?" I just needed you to clarify what do you mean do about what specifically? Right. I think that's >> if we're are we so I just want to get clarification on that before we start talking about solutions because I'm not sure what that it is.
18th. How's that sound? >> Great. Thank you. >> All right. So, do we need a motion to table the discussion of those two pulled items until February 18th? >> Okay. >> Cool. >> Okay. >> Yeah. >> Okay. >> Yeah. That seems like a pretty easy question of whether we can change that verbiage or not. and the other one will have some time to email back and forth and discuss what exactly you'd like to see to feel good about the mental health one. >> Absolutely. >> Okay. That was my fault, too. I didn't allow for adequate discussion. So, >> all right. U moving along again. This is um Superintendent Greg. Um >> essentially this one uh we've been talking about well we had a request essentially from Maragold Margold's expanding their afterchool program and you know we've been kind of infringing on that encroaching on that a little bit and so we've done a a search of suitable locations that we had in this area.
They just stapled them to a utility pole to fill in that gap at weird angles. Um, and I had the zoning coordinator come out to my house to look at it. Um, I can show you some pictures. Um, and there are no architectural standards for Texas in the city. So, there I would ask that you consider um updating the architectural standards just to say that fences can't be made out of junk and they need to be orderly or something like that. That's all. >> Thank you. Is there anyone else present who'd like to address us at this time? Manager Kelly, do we have remote participants who'd like to address us? Seeing none, I'll close the last public comment of this meeting. Is there Oh, Commissioner Dish, I went to look for, but can you tell me again what your comment about uh Mr. Hilton was at the beginning?
>> Yeah. So you can define what you're talking about >> and then we can kind of go from there. >> You know that's a very good question. Um, and I think probably the the best it is how do we move from the stuckness that we just keep, you know, the community seems to be in. Um, you know, >> well, it's it's a it's an emotional topic right now and everybody is upset because there isn't anything we can do about it. >> We've been having this discussion since I've been here. >> Well, well, I would I would say that we did do right. We did what we thought would help us, right? We did our first housing production plan and we moved we moved the needle forward a little bit. We did our second housing production plan. It didn't quite move the needle partly because of some of the things that happened to us because of two projects, but I would say it's because not everyone in town supported pushing for affordable housing units in every project, >> right?
We found the Carmichael building in BCOE has worked with us to say, you know, this could work out for them and for us. And so it and our facility people have gone out and checked it out and given it the the stamp of approval to give it a shot. So we're going to give this thing a shot on February 4th um and see how it works out. Make sure that our sound is working properly. Make sure our video is working properly at it properly at a special meeting. Um, and we're kind of got our fingers crossed that it seems like it's going to be okay and we're going to give this thing a shot and we'll know shortly thereafter. It's a very very nice facility. I think most of all, not all of you have been there and it's a uh, you know, it's got uh, easy easy access, lots of parking.
I have his comments up now. >> I thought that he asked us to have the timeline reflect that Ann Arbor had passed an open housing ordinance. >> Okay. Yes. I will um look again at the edits that uh Planner Bennett uh proposed and see if those are included. >> I'm not sure. >> Sure. Okay. Thank you. Any uh Yes. Commissioner Norton, I was going to ask any other commission proposed business. Commissioner Norton, >> not proposed business, but I forgot something that I might have conveyed during the reports back from subcommittees. >> Oh, sure. >> I'm on the um storm the swag storm water advisory group. >> Yes, >> we had a meeting. It turns out the city of Van Arbor has the ability to do more fine-tuned modeling and um flood control, flood plane mapping what the FEMA guidelines promote. Planner Bennett and I were both at this meeting and at the end of the meeting we were urging them strongly to start moving expeditiously toward developing that data in a way that we could update our zoning code provision so that we would have better information to act on.
I mean, we have projects where it's only 10%. And the other thing I think to your point, Michael, is going back to the state and saying, how do we adjust one, what our SHI is because it's not realistic necessarily for Ashland and for this area and the costs of what it is for housing in this area and try to work with our surrounding communities and other people to try to push back. We're never going to get the 10% removed. I mean, from what I'm hearing, they're looking to increase. They're looking to increase that, right? Um I think it's continuing to have the conversation and try to reach out to other people who are having the same struggle that we are because the other thing is Framingham, who has all this housing, has empty units, >> right? They have vac I was in a meeting last week and they showed um a listing of the units that they have and even though some of them are affordable, they have vacant units because they're not affordable enough for the people who live in in Framingham >> area.
It should be pretty cool. So, that's it. I mean, it's just informationational. I'm just giving you the heads up on a trial run coming up next meeting and we'll give you plenty of notice and we'll be talking to our community about that as well.
So there is some movement in that direction. So hopefully they'll be proceeding with that. I thought I would just convey that to you. That group is actively meeting and they're working to update the the storm water management plan and and do some better analysis for us. >> Great. Thank you. Any other commissioners? Seeing none, I will entertain a motion to adjurnn. Moved by Commissioner [laughter] Dish, seconded by Commissioner Mills. All those in favor say I. >> Any oppose? We are adjourned. >> Thank you. before.
Right. >> Well, you know, I just I just think it's, you know, if if you as an individual community are going to reach out to the state, it's probably not going to have an impact. But if you do band together as communities and you actually leverage >> Yep. >> It's almost like efficiencies of scale, you you'd have the, you know, probably have a little more of a voice. I think >> he's talking about strengthen numbers. >> Well, we could have teamed up with Falmouth or Manchester by the Sea or worked with some of those attorneys and we chose not to. >> Well, that's looking back looking forward. >> I think it's a regional. I think what what Yolanda and I think what Michael pending at is like approaching this problem regionally, you know what I'm saying? Instead of town by town, it that's what may yield the best results.
Any questions for Greg? >> Is there any cost associated with it? >> The the the only cost I think that the building itself, no. If they if they have to have any janitorial or custodial or setup costs with their IT people, then that would be something that we would pay for. >> Thank you. Any public comment? Okay. So, as Greg mentioned, this isformational only. Um, so we don't need to take any action um regarding this tonight. Um, let's see. Um, items from the floor. Are there any um items from the floor? Seeing none, we'll move on um uh to um let's see board member request to agendaize item. At this time there um were no requests um by board members. So um we're at this time in the evening where we could move towards adjournment. Is um there a motion to adjourn this meeting? [laughter] >> I missed who >> second.
And like we see sort of like the unevenness, you know, like the said, they've got empty units in Framingham >> because, you know, they built all this stuff and it's too expensive. Nobody can can use it. And that's a direct result of, you know, basing, you know, basing what's affordable on Boston prices, right? So I I think the the answer to your question, Michael, has to do it's it's multipronged, right? It's that there's a there are some policy solutions regionally that we have to take a look at. Um you have to kind of band together and come up with some creative solutions. I think during the conversation that we're having around this housing housing production plan can be very helpful for us to sort of determine what those other avenues could be. And then during this process, we should operationalize uh some of that organization so that we can band together as a community, try to figure out at band together as a region and try to figure out and get some housing solutions that make sense for our region >> and for our the people out our way and not people in downtown Boston.
>> Was that Greg who? Okay. [laughter] Who who that was? Was you? Oh, okay. I thought that was Greg. I'm sorry. I really did. Okay. U >> move to adjourn. [laughter] >> All right. Uh let's call for a vote. All those in favor of adjourning. >> I. Those opposed. Okay. Adjourn. [snorts]
>> The other idea is reach out to Goldson. They're writing our housing production plan. They do this with other people. What other communities have they worked with that are facing similar issues that we're facing that we can say okay how can we work together to do something about this right there >> did they ever mention that during you know you guys spent a lot of time and and effort multiple meetings did that conversation ever come up >> I offered last night to do an analysis because people were saying look you know this these this data doesn't this the way it's analyzed doesn't include include or isn't really who we are. It's because we're in this huge group of towns. I think it was 130, but um it was either Anyways, it was up there. It was over 100. And so what they said was, you know, for a cost, we could um have them look at a smaller target area >> and give data, similar data for that.
But for what reason? You know, it would be interesting to learn and know some of the things that we know that we really don't fit that 130 town model. However, do we really want to spend money at that? I I don't think so. But >> so is there any action uh related to this that we need to move forward with? I think the action that we that's taken has already been done, you know, unless you start taking a step backwards and, you know, rehash what what's already been done or what's already been said. >> Oh, yeah. I was just thinking on that and I don't think that's going to be productive. >> The whole housing production plan, we're still on track to basically complete this in Marchish. And the plan is to then present that to the select board and the planning board. And then it we get sent to the state for certification and and it's important that we do it because it it does provide us >> it's a tool.
It is a tool right in the tool. It's a tool, but once again, it's a tool, but it's it's kind of like a technicality because we don't have to follow any of the I mean, it's it's it's maybe an important conversation to have. And if we really had some control, it might give us some suggestions on how we could move h our housing production in a affordable way. But, you know, it it's uh >> well, you have to make you have to make progress towards the goal in order to utilize that tool. >> Right. Right. you know, you have to it's it's half a percent or 1%, >> right? You have to you have to show that you're making >> you can use any strategy to get there. So, if something changes in the next five years that it's a better approach, we could >> One of the things that was talked about last night, which I thought was really interesting is we were talking about inclusionary zoning, which we've talked about for eons.
Um, and one of the things that she was talking about is that there's ways to structure inclusionary zoning that doesn't necessarily um when we worked with MAPC, we were basically told that if if there was inclusionary zoning and we said just say for our sake of argument 10% townwide for affordable housing that there had to be a give up. like we had to make concessions to developers whether it's a density bonus >> or something like a parking >> reduction >> like there needed to be an incentive and the requirement and last night when we were talking it didn't sound like that needed to be the case. It sounded like we could incentivize in certain ways that may not be density. Maybe we figure out a different way to incentivize. >> Well, I think one of the things that she said was that Ashlin is the market is not so strong here in terms of a developer profit margin that it doesn't put us in a strong position to negotiate incentives, right, with developers >> and requirements.