And a followup for that, what are those like bianual, semiannual? I always confuse the two. Like another check is June or >> Oh, no. No. We get them. They come in. So, you'll see this number go up. It's when we hit the claim, it's a monthly reconciliation process. >> Okay. Okay. So, in in a month, anytime there are claims that surpass that. >> Yes. >> That's right. Other questions for Miss Taylor? Thank you very much for that report. Um, now we're circling back to a report on the 2026 27 budget meetings. Um, and I will sort of give a as brief as I can overview. Um the superintendent presented the budget to us early in the month and um his recommendation was for an 8.83% increase over um the current year's budget. Um the recommendation is for 101,350,757. Um we had three budget two budget workshop meetings Tuesdays and Thursdays and um and then this Tuesday of this week had um both uh responses from um from the from our audience from outside the board and also uh questions and responses from within the board.
She took over a classroom at Vanguard Preparatory. I will never forget the day I called and said, "Will you please come take this class? We need somebody to take care of these kids." I remember with fondness her dad who was um working at the district for a period of time with me um who set up an appointment in HR for me to talk to his girls about being teachers. Christina and Marissa are both now teachers in our district. I said to him that day, you're bringing them in for me to sell something that I have such a passion about. I don't know that I'm gonna convince them to go do anything else. Terry, right? Do you remember that? Yeah. And here they are. Amazing. Both of them. So, I just want to have the board know that um I love when I see these nominations come through for people that um we saw years ago had the commitment and the passion and the ability to go take kids to the next level.
So that's why we go a little bit later. Um, but it works. I mean, as best as we can. I'm not sure that there's a way around that if that's what we're talking about. Does the staff give you a hard time about starting early, Danny, or they understand because of the calendar? So, the staff to the extent that they can have have given input on it, right? Um there was a calendar committee there's input from the unions so survey but never the survey that went out to staff and so we where we can put the stu uh the staff's input in we we do but I think they would rather because if we started any later we'll be here till June 30th and I think they they would rather sacrifice that than be here later in the school year. Anyone else? No. Okay. Roll call.
So, we didn't delve deep into those parts and we we saw what what what Irving had and we said, "Okay, sh run a run a scenario, right?" and said, "Oh, well, there could possibly be savings in this way if they did this." But again, it is all structured on what goes into the agreement, if we use this as the same formulas, those types of things. >> Okay. So then I guess for a followup, I would really like to understand the numbers are the impact on students if we combined more classrooms than just K1. if we went to multi-year classrooms more across the board um before we would send kids out to other schools. >> Sure. Bring this up. >> And then I I I would want to I would want to know, you know, the per pupil charged cost that we pay now to have a kid in the school and then a per pupil cost of what the tuition would be for future, not for tonight, but like I I would need to know that information before I could have an opinion one way or the other.
It's tucked inside the house. So that um one means of egress would be potentially be to run through the house it's associated with. Right? So that would be someone it would be a family member or someone you know well not a stranger you're renting to as they will have full access to your house. You see? So that's why but it could look when Doug goes to permit these things it could look like an ADU. So he needs the two things to be able to permit one way or another. Right? So, say you turned your he always gives the example of like if you turned your basement into an in-law apartment or for a grown child or whatever. Um, it looks like a rentable unit because it has a kitchen and a bathroom and a bedroom. It looks like a little apartment, but the point is that it's actually contained within.
Um that meeting on Tuesday, we have passed along to the full board tonight. Um a um a request we we put in a request on Tuesday and got a nice quick turnaround, I'm happy to say, um for the superintendent to um take that 8.83% increase down to um at least a percentage point down from that um in an attempt to try to be more fiscally responsible before passing along to the town. Um and also we wanted to include in that budget a couple of things differently from what was in the original superintendent's budget recommendation. Um, we felt that it was really important to start adding those uh half team at 8th grade at Dodd and um we knew that that or what we asked Dr. Solen to present to us was what that would do at the expense knowing that it might be at the expense of um a couple of administration administrative positions that were in the budget.
So, Marissa, congratulations. >> [applause] [applause] >> Eileen and Terry, I wasn't sure she had told you. I thought she'd keep it a big secret and just show up. So, I said, "Do I have to call mom and dad?" >> I Yeah, she did. She told me she had. >> Well, good. I remember when we started doing these values, um, Miss Okara said to to me, I want to see more than just staff. I want to see some administrators, too. >> Um, we don't solicit nominations, but this particular administrator received two nominations. Stephanie White >> [applause] >> the two nominations um separately during separate solicitations for nominations. One was from Wendy Watt, a peer, and one was from a teacher, Michael Richardson. from Wendy Watt. Miss White overheard a conversation between Miss Watt and the parent of a basketball player about how great the Sandia boys played against the other team that day.
Uh, Mr. Brunette. Yes. Mr. Kenova? Yes. Mr. Paris? Yes. Mr. Ragsdale? Yes. Mr. Ciano? Yes. To all. No. On EA5. Uh, Miss Suarez? Yes. Vice President Santiago? Yes. President, uh, excuse me, President Bassford? Yes. Motion carries. Okay. Okay, we did P. That would bring you. Yeah. So, the next item of business is uh under D, finance facilities. Looking for a motion to approve F1 to F13. Motion. Motion by Commissioner Breniac, second by Commissioner Suarez. Discussion. Seeing none, roll call, please. Mr. Shiata. Uh, Mr. Bruniac. Yes. Mr. Kenova. Yes. Mr. Paris. Yes. Mr. Ragdel. Yes to all but abstaining on F12 check number 225273. Thank you. Mr. Ciano. Yes to all abstaining on the same check. F1225273. Miss Wararez. Yes. Vice President Santiago. Yes. President Bassford. Yes. Thank you. Vice President Santiago. Uh board member comments. We're going to go in rotation. So uh Commissioner Brunak.
Uh >> sure. Um if Shannon brings up I'll tell you about the the cons I'll just walk you through that first slide with our current enrollment um and the reason why we went with K1 um in terms of a combination. So currently in if you look at our recommended sizes and and even let's just talk about the class sizes in Pelum right you'll notice that there are from second grade to fifth grade we the total number of students is 22 is above 20 students right and so first if we were to combine next year our kindergarteners would be first graders so it would be 12 first graders ers right now what we know from the census and from our inquiry we have five resident kindergarteners coming into Pell next school year. So the class the K1 combined class would be 17 students. Um we we could look at the first grade if we looked at okay what if we combined first and second and again this is the progression this is our current enrollment.
>> So, you you're saying that an in-law apartment cannot be rentable. >> Correct. That's right. It's not meant to be rented. >> So if you're if you are putting your older child, you can't charge them rent for living in the >> Well, that's kind I think kind I mean you could c you could probably charge kid right now. You could charge your kid rent, right? For >> why are you looking for ideas, Scott? Or >> but it's not rentable. You can't put it out there on the market saying, "Hey, I have an apartment for rent." >> Right. So, >> if I may, Madam Chair, in the in So, in the state in the state law, we they use ADU and in-law interchangeably. >> Yeah. >> In the building code, this is where Doug Scott, our building commissioner, runs into issues with the way this ADU bylaw is written.
And so the budget potential budget reductions that um Dr. Solen has presented to us and that we'll be discussing tonight uh take us down to a 7.54% increase rather than an 8.83% increase. And I'm going to read your own words, Dr. Solen, so that I don't misrepresent if that's okay. These reductions go beyond cutting the lowhanging fruit and venture into trimming the limbs. They are very aggressive yet retain classroom level growth and services to the greatest extent possible. Further reductions would need to come from existing staff and or increased revenue if only. Right. This reduction retains four of the six proposed elementary classroom teachers. Remember we have uh we have a growth in our enrollments in elementary schools right now. The reason for building new schools was to have more room. one of the reasons. Um, and so, you know, that that portion bothers me a little bit that we're not uh putting in as many of the proposed uh classroom teachers as we as was in the original budget proposal by the superintendent.
Considering that the Sandia players only practice outside on the blacktop and the boys at the other school had the advantage of indoor practice. The following week, Miss White reached out to the Sandia athletic person and offered to the use of the Phoenix Academy gym two afternoons a week so that Sandia players would have the benefit of indoor practice. This offer was not without sacrifice as the Phoenix students shortened their practice to allow for Sandia to practice. This demonstration of commitment deserves recognition. The Sandia students are grateful for the practice space and ha and it has generally built a spirit of sportsmanship between the two schools during the sporting events. Isn't that amazing? That's Steph. You give her a problem, she finds a solution. Um and then this one is from Mr. um Richardson. Since taking over the role of principal at Phoenix Academy in 2020, Stephanie White has transformed the school culture.
Thank you. President Bassford. Good evening everyone. I want to wish a happy belated birthday to our colleague, Commissioner Paris. Happy belated birthday, sir. Um, prayers up to our former colleague, Dr. Lucy Danny, who resigned recently. I hope all is well with you, and I wish you continued success on your future endeavors. Quick reminder, Saturday, February 7th from 4 to 8:00 p.m. Route 3 westbound over at Chipotle fundraiser for the CJAL team praise. They do wonderful work. Shout out as all always can't give enough shout outs to Bobby and Gabby Mel uh head of praise for everything that you do for our community, for all for so many of our special needs kids. And I want to thank everybody for your time and go God bless America. Have a good night everybody. Thank you, Commissioner Broncia. Commissioner Kenova, um just wanted to say Mr. Jangaro. We're glad to have you and Chewy back with us.
So imagine your kindergarters are your first graders your first graders are your second graders. If we were to combine first and second, we would be at 23 students and we would only have five students sitting in kindergarten by themselves and would take more school choice, right? Um we when you look at the other grade levels, we would be exceeding 30 to 40 students if we combine them. >> I meant if we do we have to keep the spots open for those current choice students or could we try to Okay. >> Right. So, so that's why I go back to in terms of our choice students that we have now are our students. We unless they decide they're going back to their district, they remain with us. So, in our planning, the reason that is why we considered a combination and we had because of our current numbers, we have not considered a combination of other grade levels.
It specifically says you have to have two means of egress and there has to be fire separation between your home and an ADU. So >> is that is that Ashlin's ADU version of it or >> Yes, this is our adopted ADU bylaw that says >> so we >> which is by state law, >> right? >> So state law matches that. >> Yes, absolutely. But the building code says you can also have an inlaw and you don't need two means of egress and you don't need fire separation. But if we don't have that provision in a bylaw because it's not included in this, we can't give use variances. So, if we don't actually have a bylaw that says you're allowed to apply for an in-law, Doug Scott can't give you a permit for one. So, what happens is you end up with a bunch of illegal in-laws because there's no way to legally permit it.
Um it also 1.5 of the 2.5 proposed specialists um is being is in the reduction and it adds the two middle school teachers as I spoke of earlier. It cuts the two administrative positions and the 0.5 teacher of multilingual learners in addition to a special educator at the elementary grades. So, you know, taking the budget request down by roughly one percentage point does some damage. And um that's what we will be discussing tonight. And we may or may not put forth a budget for um for a vote to the full board tonight. Or we may we'll see how it goes. >> Make a comment before we move on. >> Yes. I just want after um Tuesday, you know, I kind of put some thoughts together before we move on to to look at, you know, what the superintendent has in front of us right here.
She arrives daily as early as 5:00 a.m. I can attest to that because when she really needs to send me something, it's at 5:00 a.m. I'm up, but I know she's at school. And she works hard all day to serve the students and staff. She demonstrates authentic care for the Phoenix Academy community by treating students, staff, and parents with dignity and respect. Every year since she has been the principal, I have noticed, Mr. Richardson has noticed the huge improvements in school culture. Thanks to Stephanie and to Ken Davis and the entire administrative team, including the district administrators, for putting this team in place. I'll I don't take credit for that, but um we're thrilled that you're there for making Phoenix Academy one of the best schools in the Apple Valley Unified School District. I'm very glad I chose to stay at Phoenix Academy for 28 years because the reward of writing out some difficult years during the transition from Vista Compana Middle School to Phoenix Academy is now I'm enjoying the completely transformed school culture under the leadership of Stephanie White.
Um happy birthday to Chewy, but also to hear to Mr. Paris. Um the the student ambassador mentioned the uh Chromebook support hours. Is that something we could discuss at tech? Maybe maybe we'll kick it down there and speak about it. Um to to the teacher, Laura, thank you for your quick thinking which saved a child's life yesterday. As scary as that situation was, you acted quickly and became a hero. Um, Miss Danny, I'm wishing you the best in your future endeavors. We'll say more at her next meeting when she uh gets her award. Uh, and that's all ahead. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Co. Kenova, Commissioner Paris. Thank you. Uh, welcome back, Assistant Superintendent Jangaro. Uh, and also my thanks to uh, Miss Laura Conboy for her fast action and saving really saving a student's life. Um, also welcome and congratulations to our new uh, supervisor of special services, Miss Saunders.
So to do that, you would have to roll it up and not accept like if you didn't accept any choice for K1, then you could combine those the next year. And then the next year, if you didn't accept anyone in first and second, then you could roll those. But you would have to roll it up because you can't force a kid that you've already accepted to be choiced in to leave. >> Correct. >> Okay. >> Thank you for that. >> You're welcome. And so the Thank you, Shannon, for sharing that. You could take it. So the next convers the next questions that you have we'll work on those depending on on where we decide to move forward. >> Um I think Jenny I'm happy to pass. I see other hands. >> Okay. Um I see Mickey. John, did did you have your hand up? >> Yeah.
We can't grant you a use variance and you're not going to apply for an ADU because you don't want a second means of egress and you don't want fire separation or you don't need it. So, under the building code, Doug Scott can grant you a building permit for an in-law apartment, but right now our bylaws restrict him from being able to grant that permit. So is every other town in the state creating >> either it has and together or they have two separate. Do the exact same thing when we passed the ADU. We had to amend it to read in the in-law apartment because the exact same situation happened. >> Yeah, I know. I know Doug um has told me over, you know, that that this has been a big discussion between building inspectors >> because they're like now what do we do, right? Our hands are tied.