There's not a lot of room for um things that come up over the year. Uh there is fluctuation in a lot of budget lines. Some are more volatile than others. Uh things like outplacement subs um you know anything weather related. So, you know, heating and cooling and and uh snow removal and all that. Um, and what we do in terms of budget management is we don't spend a lot of the discretionary money uh until we know we're out of the woods with uh those things that are volatile. Um, and that's just good budget management because, uh, the state law means that you guys are on the hook for the dollars that are over at the end of the year. So, we work very hard to avoid that. And that means we don't spend money on the discretionary lines, like I said, until we know that we're more so in the clear on, you know, the other the other items.
Last year's event was a resounding success, drawing an estimated 1,700 attendees and featuring 65 diverse booths from schools, local community organizations, district partners, and food vendors, even including a Blackhawk helicopter for families to explore and learn from the pilots. While these events are everyone everyone is familiar with the team also supports food pantry individual family needs through support for clothing and the basic needs every child deserves. They should also connect family they also connect families um to other community supports when the need arises daily. They represent our values of dignity, community, authenticity and service. We are so fortunate that we are a district with such an incredible effort to support children. So Congratulations Jackie. was yesterday. It was yesterday. >> Scooch. >> Yeah. Forward. >> Yeah. >> There you go. Ready? Go. >> Got it. Got it. [applause] >> [clears throat] >> Okay, now >> we'll switch that next one.
Remember to take breaks while you're shoveling and please check in on your elderly neighbors. Um, be safe, be good to yourselves, be good to each other, and have a good night. Thank you, Commissioner Ciano, Commissioner Suarez. Thank you, President Bassford. Good evening, everyone. It's so nice to be back with the new team in this new year. Uh, thank you to Jenna um for when you were speaking, I was so appreciative to learn that the students um it was the students idea to have a Chrome beak free Chromebook free day. That along with the students acknowledgement that their attention and focus has increased with the new phone policy. I really think it speaks to the testament of the teaching and learning that's happening in our school in our high school. So, great job to the teachers and great job to the students. Also, thank you to Mr.
Pelum is is a staff full of of of humans who have been there for a really long time. Um, so I also am really thinking about the kids. I don't want you to think I'm not. I am really thinking about the kids. Um, but we have to hold the staff because they're going to be holding the kids >> and thank you >> to know that holding the staff includes you, Mickey >> and and so um it's been it's I know that individuals feel that there are things that could and should have happened differently. Um I am I as a leader I own the timeline and it was not to blindside anyone but also the respect of making sure that we had the opportunity to follow a process and we ran through every possible scenario before we posted information that could have created a whole different set of feelings.
I mean, they could do it without a permit now. >> Yeah. The thing is now that you can't you can you can put two kitchens in your house. You can do this. You you can do it anyway, right? So, um, >> without the in-law, I mean, you can have a second kitchen without without an in-law apartment, you know, it's tough. You can't really you can't really police it, but by law, we put ourselves in a sticky situation where if somebody wants to apply for it, we tell them there's no provision for that. And then they >> Well, there is a provision for it's called an ADU. >> No, but we can't tell them you have to build an ADU. That you cannot you don't have the right to build an in-law. That's illegal. But we don't have the legal means for them to build an in-law.
Now we start by like sometimes a 40% on the discretionary items account because we know we have to do that and there are things that we know we need to buy in July for fall or whatever but um we manage it very tightly. Um so at the end of the day when we went through this this is uh representative I think of where we are. I think further reductions would uh range from risky to reckless um depending on how much and where we're talking about. So it's just my my professional opinion on this. >> Thank you Dr. >> Questions comments. No temp. Uh, thank you, Mr. Superintendent, for putting this together. I appreciate it. Um, I'm so [clears throat] I haven't really heard much outreach from anyone in the public yet. I'm not sure how many people in the public. Did you happen to post this online or anything this afternoon?
>> Yeah, I [clears throat] I should have said >> now who's >> Yeah, that's what she just said. >> So good. >> All right, now our students are welcome to leave. Thank you for staying for the recognition. >> Thanks you guys. Have a good week. Dude, [laughter] I'm Good job. I'm sure she did >> [laughter] >> Okay. >> All right. We're going to move on to board comments. Renee Longshore. Good evening. It feels weird going first. Uh Trusty Tucker always did a wonderful job with covering all of the um you know the holidays and the recognition and amazing. So I'm going to have to get notes from her now. Well, welcome back to our families, our students and staff. I hope you all had a wonderful time of rest and reflection coming into 2026. Every new year is filled with great hope as we have a time to reflect and think forward.
Doctor for sharing the student safety report. I believe that it's worth acknowledging and even celebrating the efforts that the district has implemented to curtail bullying and increase the safety in our schools for all of our students. To Dr. Lucy Danny, thank you for your service on this board. It was great working with you and I wish you all the best in your future endeavors. And lastly, I also want to give a very warm welcome back to Mr. Mark Jingaro. Your absent was your absence was definitely felt and I'm glad to have you back in action. Good night, everyone. Thank you, Commissioner Suarez, Vice President, Mr. Santiago. Thank you, President Bassford. Uh, Mr. Jingaro, welcome back. And happy birthday, Chewy. Good to see both of you guys. Happy birth lady birthday to Commissioner Paris. Um, happy uh, Muslim Heritage Month to everybody who celebrates. To all the board uh, commissioners here, um, you know, board recognition month, thank you for all your service, but to all of the board commissioners out there who do this um, care so much for our kids.
So um I I just want to acknowledge that and acknowledge that the staff includes you Mickey. Thank you, Margaret, for letting me interrupt. >> Jenny, >> you're muted. I'm sorry. >> I really appreciate um those sentiments a lot, Mickey. And I am I'm wondering if there is a plan to communicate this to the community so that people who are not on this call will get one message um so that we can help the staff and help Mickey contain some of the rumors. >> Dr. Z. Um, so Jenny, one of the things in the staff meeting today that we were asked was to create um, one I was asked that I'm and I and agreed that I would send the Pelum staff a bulleted just how did it go today because there's some individuals who admitted that they don't want to watch this school committee, meaning they don't want to hear our discussions.
you could get serious. >> So, so this is also the part I was confused with because to me an ADU and an in-law apartment are used quite interchangeably. So, I thought we followed the state law and created an ADU provision and I personally am confled by why we need this. That's kind of my my instinct. My instinct is the state already told us what this is supposed to look like. Um >> yeah, I'm the same way. That's kind of my thought is just like if somebody comes in and says, "Hey, I want to build an in-law apartment for my >> they would use the ADU." >> Then we just be like, "Okay, here's the qualifications. This is what you have to use to build it." >> So if somebody has an ailing parent, you would like to make them install a second means of egress and a firewall while their mom's going through cancer treatments and they're helping her pay for those.
The recommendation that you're mentioning? >> No. >> Okay. So, generally speaking, I would like the public to have some time to absorb it and to get back to us. I'm not sure that there will be um I'm not convinced that there will be a big reaction. And I say that for this reason. Um just a couple questions. Are we including any layoffs here? Just to be totally clear about it. So, one of the directives from the other day was, you know, to not reduce existing staff. Okay. >> Um, this reduced some of the uh proposed staff >> and increased those that were part of the directive from Tuesday night, the middle school. >> Um, yeah. No, thank you. I appreciate that. I I definitely see a I personally see a big difference between a layoff and a budget reduction that doesn't exist yet. um the average elementary class size with these numbers right here.
I have enjoyed attending many school activities since our return. It has been a joy to watch Granite Hills High School and Apple Valley High School's basketball teams give their all on the court. I even managed to catch a girls basketball game at Phoenix Academy as they matched off against Mariana, and it brought back many fond memories for me. Um, I attended CSBA's 2026 governor's budget proposal breakdown. Um, the ABUSD state of the district presentations. Apple Valley I had a chance to visit the Apple Valley Center for Innovation on Vanguard Steam Night and was excited to see many thankful families at our food pantry as it geared back up with great heart and vigor. Like many of you, I also attended the expenditure reduction meeting held across the district on January 5th. My heart was heavy as we were asked to prioritize 180 positions listed under 15 categories.
Speaking of which, uh, Miss Comboy, thank you so much for acting quickly, for caring so much for our children, and to all of our staff who care so much for our children. Uh, Miss uh, Saunders, congratulations. Um, much much success. I was really happy to hear about the CCMS uh, NJSLA uh, uh, scores particularly for atrisisk students, which is amazing. Um, thank you guys for all you do. Keep up the great work. I think that's it for now. Have a great uh, evening. Thanks. Thank you, Vice President Santiago. I'm going to be a little brief because I've been speaking a lot tonight. I want to thank Matt for the very lovely photos of all the board members. I've you don't know how long I've threaded over that photo that was in the hall. Wasn't the one I picked out, but I I have to thank you.
They it's it's going to cause enough emotion with what's currently happening. So I agreed that I would send them a just you know the presentation and a bulleted um outline of how did it go from my perspective and um you know what the next steps are. I we it was also asked like what can we tell kids um knowing that our children are going to process differently our parents are going to be on the call and they're going to tell their children things differently and what is it going to be and so um I promise to work with them to craft that. Um, so I probably between myself or Mickey, we talked about just keeping it high level and saying it's very early. Um, but we know for sure that we'll have a PEL next year and and and that's what we're working to have.
That's what this bylaw is intended to do. I understand the potential. That potential exists whether this bylaw exists or not. I understand that the policing of it is a concern, but that concern exists whether this bylaw is there or not, but we can't help our residents that our building commissioner who has 30 years of experience going through and reading people. And yes, when they sell it, that's a different story. But in these times, we have to review things as they come before us. And the building commissioner uses their purview to say, "Hey, if it looks like a duck and it walks like a duck and it talks like a duck, it's probably a duck and I think you need to apply for an ADU." But if they go in and they show him all these things, he's like, "Yeah, you know what? I really think this is the right thing to do for you and your family." Usually, you have to trust that some people are just going to do the right thing.
I know we've talked about it sort of in the 18 to 19 range where it's been for a few years. >> Yeah. So the the addition of um five was going to bring it from 19 to 18.7. The addition of four um makes it marginally, you know, off of 18.7. Uh it's like 18.8. >> Okay. And because we're at the expectation is from last year to next year the projected enrollment increase is 225 students. The enrollment projection from [clears throat] this year to next year is 110. The enrollment projection in actual from the end of June last year after we had already made the budget to the beginning of next year is 225. And I think that's relevant because we didn't add teachers in last year's budget. And so that's why we've jumped to 19 plus per class now. And um why the additional elementary classroom teachers are necessary.
I personally did not. I have heard from many of you who felt the weight of this request. Please know the board gave no specific direction for the organization or the conduction of these meetings. After two years of significant deficit spending, we do need to make cuts. But we need to not just look at the 180 positions listed. We need to consider all 427 new positions added from 2020 to 2023. It was our responsibility to inform and then receive input from you. And that is still my hope today. So, I brought spreadsheets for those who are interested on the back table and I have them here to to hand down to any staff who might be interested. [clears throat] Since 2018 and 19, ABUSD increased revenue 57%. And increased spending 63%. Any category that increased more than 57% has contributed to our deficit spending. Spending for supervisors and administrators, both positions and salary, increased 91% on average.
It was the new one is is great and I appreciate you. Um thank you to Miss Convoy. Um, when you do a small act of kindness and you can jump into that, knowing that your fear is just to save that person and she kept at it until she got it done. That's amazing. And I have to commend her and thank her from one first to another. Thank you. Welcome to Miss Saunders. Uh, great to have you. We look forward to great things you're going to do. Um, happy belated birthday to Alan Paris. Happy birthday. I know you didn't but we have to happy birthday to Chewy and um I just want to say happy birthday to Mr. Jinggerro on the 28th I believe right and welcome back to back and we are very grateful that you are back and rise above my friend rise above with that being said I'm going to ask for somebody to make a motion to accept H uh A through one in the agenda and move the item forward motion second motion by uh Mr.
Um, and so we're probably going to work on that too in terms of how do we hold the students, but the individuals, I agree, we're making it individuals to hold the students as a staff. Um, and so for me, that's that's where that is. I hope I answered your question. Yeah, I mean I think it's hard to >> I think it's hard to message one way or the other because what we're messaging is we don't know. Um so but I I think you know just >> the more we can communicate obviously to families and staff I think the better. I I'll work on a message um this evening and Margaret I can send it to you as chair to review and see if you put your stamp on it. Um and just summarizing what we discussed what the perspectives may be and then we can send it out tomorrow morning.
We can't default that everyone will sell it. But we're we're giving we're denying people an opportunity that's a buy right by law and telling them that you have to go out of this complicated, expensive way to do this by not allowing them the in-law bylaw. And it could potentially open us up. I could ask town council of course what the case law is on this, but it would open up us up to a lawsuit. If we denied somebody and said you have to do it this way, we could get in trouble that we don't have any provisions to allow an in-law outside of second means of egress and firewalls that could get us in some serious trouble. Have we had have we turned anybody down and they said I can't afford this because it does it's forcing to have a second form of egress because honestly I think having if somebody's going to have an in-law apartment like where they have their own separate thing there is a door between the two things they probably should have a second form of egress >> right like if you're above a garage >> and you only have one form of egress and you have to go down those stairs it's probably not a great idea >> that's building code so we're not here to you know I'm not going to negate the building code the building code says an in-law apartment only requires these things if you know um >> so it sounds like there's still >> not clarification the main question is like there's there's >> um a not understanding the difference between the two and the need for the two different things is that >> because I don't I don't want I don't want this conversation to go in circles tonight that be a waste of our time >> has somebody come to us and said like no so so for perspective >> I know this has been like about >> this has only been in for May so it hasn't been a year yet.