This does not happen overnight. It is a result of long-term decisions, inadequate forecasting, and a failure to correct course early. Yet tonight, instead of seeing a comprehensive recovery strategy, we are being asked to accept a number. $10 million. Again, you still haven't settled with the teachers. As if the size of the cut alone proves seriousness, it doesn't. What proves seriousness is transparency. What proves leadership is accountability. And what proves respect for the community is allowing stakeholders, that's the employees, the parents, and the public to see and understand exactly what is being proposed before it is approved. Our members are not expendable. Our students are not bargaining chips. And our community deserves more than a vote based on uncertainty and after the fact explanations. I urge this board to reject any proposal that authorizes sweeping reductions without a full disclosed public reviewed and clearly justified plan.
So they still have to apply for them for all of their wetlands. Any um >> That's a river, right? >> Yeah. But they have to do riverfront restoration. There's going to be a lot of remediation. They need a dewatering plan. Um they there's a lot of information about the discharge and the storm water that they have to review. So it there's nothing that the 40B process does to wave conservation requirements. >> So they will have to adhere to all the riverfront. So provisional to them passing. When do they start going to construction? >> 10 to 60 main will be a long time because of the site remediation that has to be done on site. So there's going to be a lot of soil work that has to take place before they'll break ground. So you'll see a lot of activity there before you start seeing any construction because they have to get those contaminated soils out and everything that goes out and comes in has to be tested and brought to specific places.
And we did ask them to look into that on how they could um support some regional uh programming. And um we talked about the cost of school lunches, school breakfasts and um so we brought a lot of our concerns. Thank you again to Dr. Solen for putting together. I think there were four items um there that we're concerned about here in Cheshure. and hopefully they will bring those up to some of their committees that they sit on and um discuss because a lot of times there's a a big voice up there of the t of the cities and I think towns like Cheshire and other towns in the state need to have that kind of a voice that we too are concerned about the fiscal climate and um to make sure that our kids are getting the appropriate education that um they need around staffing, around having lunch, around transportation and lots of things.
Slow this down. Bring the details forward and do this the right way because responsible governance is not about how fast you can pass a motion. Is about how well you can protect the future of this district. Now, I'd like to start with another disclaimer. Unless otherwise stated, none of my comments at this podium is intended to be a personal attack. My remarks are not made or excuse me, my remarks are made strictly in my professional capacity in service of the members I represent and are grounded in verifiable facts and at the current state of the district. Any concerns raised relate solely to conduct, governance, and accountability, not individuals, unless otherwise stated. I would be happy to address any concerns personally if anyone feels offended in any way. Now I would like to speak in opposition to the unprovisional conduct, legal violations, hypocrisy and fabrications that were presented from this das during the last board meeting by a trustee.
So that you'll probably be a few years before you see construction. 61 Waverly. If they get through conservation commission, you could see them pull a building permit within a year, assuming that all of their funding goes well and they get through conservation non-issue. >> So the tenants at 1060 probably won't kick out for a while. >> I'm not sure because they could if they get through conservation, they could start that ground work within a year, but that groundwork is going to take a long time to remediate unless he's got an astronomical team and they move at lightning speeds. You never know. >> So, I just know there's been a lot happening with that. OB Jasmine is at all those meetings. I pop in when I can, which is a small fraction of the meetings. >> They've had a lot of work. They've had a lot on their shoulders, the ZBA.
So, um, as I said, it was a lively discussion and, um, I know that those legislators come every year and we appreciate their, um, their visiting us and hopefully some of our message got through. >> Thank you. Any other comments? No. Um, any additional committee? I know Miss Fitzgerald, you said you had some planning and zoning um information. >> Do you mean park and wreck? >> Park. I apologize. >> Oh, yeah. >> Definitely not planning. [laughter] >> Um no, just that I am going to be I don't know that there is an official liaison, but I'd like to be the official liaison for the uh park and recre commission. I was a commissioner for just under a year. Um and I do think it's important to stay connected. I think there's some stuff to think about, you know, with the fields at the schools and the fields of the town and how do we all work together to make sure there's enough capacity um uh you know for all the youth athletics that are happening at the town and so I think that it would be uh beneficial if I remain as liaison and so I intend to do so.
law 9010 of the Apple Valley Unified School District Board of Trustees policies says the governing board recognizes the responsibility of board members in their role as community leader community leaders to participate in public discourse on matters of civic or community interest. However, to ensure communication of a consistent unified message regarding district issues, board members are expected to respect the authority of the board to choose its representatives to communicate its position and to abide by established protocols. It further goes on to state, "When speaking for the board, a spokesperson shall exercise restraint and tact, communicate in a manner that promotes public confidence in the board's leadership." Board members are reminded that when speaking publicly, their statements may be perceived as reflecting the views of the board as a whole and they have a responsibility to clearly identify when a viewpoint is personal rather than the representative of the board of the district.
>> They appreciate your support. Certainly. >> Yeah. Just warming a seat really, you know. >> But, um, but anyway, uh, so I just wanted to have an update on that. And then ongoing and new projects. So, this is where I thought um uh you can bring up um >> Can I ask one more question on that that's totally unrelated? Um it's the water issue. Does that come into play ever? >> So, you mean >> the fact that we don't have enough water for our town and now we're adding even we're doubling? So the way that >> this is a very simple very simple nondescriptive answer for a very >> very difficult question. So please excuse my my nuance with my lack of terminology. This this takes a lot more explaining than I have the ability to do. But essentially we get our water from the MWR and we have a certain amount that we've already paid for.
I don't know if anything needs to be done officially for that. I am going to go to the meetings. Um just wanted to put that out there. >> Carol, can we add that as part of the liaison? committee. >> Yeah, that that's a great idea though. We'll come back to it for sure. Thank you, Miss Fitzgerald. >> Yes. Um [clears throat] I I think we do have to change bylaws. >> We could change the bylaw. >> Yeah, >> let us know. Go. >> Um, Miss Colin, is there any ACES uh update? The um right now ACES is um looking for a new um leader um Mr. Doctor Deain >> Denny um is retiring at the end. So, um we have we are working with uh CAPS no >> CAB >> to um get a an idea of who we want um to fill that role and uh we'll be starting to interview I believe at the end of February.
Board members are also expected to conduct themselves in a respectful, courteous, and professional manner and to model appropriate behavior for the students and the community. A trustee failed to follow that policy. That is hypocrisy. Early in the meeting, two members of the public were denied the opportunity to complete their comments because it exceeded the allotted time by a minimal amount. It was stated, "We have rules and we're going to follow these rules." Yet, moments later, when another board member raised a point of order regarding a violation of the same rules, the response was, "I'm going to anyway." That again is hypocrisy. It was also claimed that both bargaining unit presidents routinely call this trustee to to negotiate. That statement is a fabrication. Bargaining unit members negotiate with the district, not individual board members. Any negotiations of substantive discussions conducted by an individual board member outside a properly noticed public meeting would constitution would be a constitute a violation of the board uh Brown Act.
There is more water available if you pay for it. So it's not that we have no more water. is that we've paid up to a certain amount and we haven't reached that threshold yet. We are getting closer of course with these developments. We haven't reached it yet, but there is more water available if we so choose to enter into that agreement. Again, there's a lot that's a very simple explanation. So, that was pretty good. >> Thank you. >> It might it might I'm sure there are some people watching that's like that's really oversimplified. It is. What's the implication to the town if we have to get into an MW agreement >> that I don't know the details of >> it short-term or is it a long-term agreement? >> Likely you'd want a long-term agreement unless you have something else in mind. I don't I mean we do have some areas in town that are marked for potential aquafers, but they're not designated at this time.
We have a meeting of the whole next week to discuss that. Um we have updates on um ASUS at Chase which is their school in Waterberry. They are doing um an immense amount of uh work there. Um refurbishing buildings and um they have clo and they in New Haven, North Haven, they have closed a couple buildings um and again are consolidating some of the services there but you know looking to enlarge their um footprint uh in the state. So, thank you. I think that's it. I I know Dr. Sen mentioned about CF and their anniversary as well. I don't know if you have any info, Miss Fitzgerald, on the anniversary for CF celebrations and so forth. have the same info that John has. So, I'll end up [laughter] >> Yeah, I mean that'll definitely be part of my uh my update, but the uh the concert, the 30th anniversary concert will be held the 27th at 6:30 in the Thorp Auditorium.
Furthermore, we can substantiate with phone records demonstrating that neither bargain unit president has ever called them for negotiations. These actions undermine public trust, violate board policy, and er confidence in the leadership of the district. Accountability must apply to everyone, especially those trusted with government authority. Earlier in the evening, a member of the crowd, clearly emotional giving the current state of the district, momentarily stepped out of line. They shouted a coward. To which the response was, "Oh, I'm a coward. I'll remember that during negotiations." Later, however, it was stated, "Some of you like to throw insults at us. That's fine. You know, we can take it." Yet moments later, after making that claim, they became clearly visible, offended when I merely recited applicable law regarding bad faith conduct. That contradiction speaks for itself. Additionally, this trustee publicly singled out me and my bargaining unit for statements made by someone else, an individual they could not clearly articulate or identify as a teacher, an employee, excuse me, or even a community supporter.
So you you have other you you would want to explore some options depending on what the financial situation looks like. I mean, this topic was raised I mean I kind of raised it up last month with >> Yeah. in December with the concerns about the water usage >> because it kept coming up in emails. >> Yeah. >> One that just came out this week and it's like okay, >> you know, at least it raises the concern to to ask are we okay >> and will we be okay if there's run on the water? >> Right. That's something we've we've discussed. A water study is we would like to get a quote for what it would be, but I don't know that we'd have the funds to follow through with such study as much as we might like. >> Is it something we can put on some of the larger developments as part of their approval that they have to do like a water study?
We are uh really excited to bring a a great show. We have uh musicians and performers from across the district who will be there that evening. Uh you know to to entertain our community is the uh as I said the 30th anniversary if people were so moved to uh make a donation. Um the suggestion was 30 for 30. Uh that's not a ticket price that it's $30 a ticket. there is no fee to attend the concert. Um, but we'll also have, you know, just some information about the uh CEF and the great work that they've done in our community over the last 30 years. Uh, during the show, MCED by me and um Jane Lukeart, who's been a member of the board for a very long time, past president as well. So, should be a fun night. >> Is this in addition to their their game, their quiz?
Despite that lack of verification, they proceeded to make untrue statements about both me and my bargaining unit. That conduct is not only inappropriate, it is reasonably viewed as bad faith conduct and intimidation. Bargaining units are not responsible for policing or holding individual members of the public accountable for their speech. That responsibility rests with you, the elected officials, who are bound by your oath of office to act fairly, lawfully, and without retaliation. Based on all the facts stated above, the governing board of the California School Employees Association, chapter 828, including all voting members present on January 21st, 2026, unanimously admonishes this trustee and formally calls for their resignation. Should they refuse to resign, we demand that the remaining trustees take swift and appropriate action in response to their conduct at the December 11th board meeting. Lastly, we continue to stand in solidarity with President Sabers and the Apple Valley Unified School Teachers Association in sincere hope for dignity, community, authenticity, and service.
>> We can run that by council. The issue with that is that here's the problem is if you haven't done it all along and all of a sudden you do it for one developer now you're doing something that's not normal and you could be picking on them and that could be a case for court and they could say you know they're putting unfair regulations on me unfair unreasonable restrictions unreasonable requests that are making my project uneconomical. So I'd have to ask council about that one because it really depends on what you're asking. Obviously there has to be a point at which you have to start doing things. So what's that threshold >> and is it something that you you I don't know it's all developers over x amount of units have to do this and then it's fair for everyone >> right and that would be some like if we put that in I don't know design guidelines or put it in the site plan regulations then it's very fair as long as we put it in our regulations but as of right now we don't have anything it would just be conditional and that's where you get that's where that risk comes in >> is it in our purview to ask for there being some conservation mitigation to collect rainwater to use for some >> you can make a request but to be able to condition it if they can prove that that would make the project unfeasible I don't think we could condition it that way >> you could create a bylaw >> exactly >> so we absolutely have jurisdiction to create zoning >> to create you yes you'd have to do it through zoning >> add that to this wonderful to-do list and if you build research on it >> I think it's something that keeps coming up in our town.
Oh yeah, the quiz. Uh that's a >> that's non-negotiable. Trivia night coming up. That's >> compete. >> We are going to be at Cheshure Academy this year in March. I can't remember the date. Um people ask me why Cheshure Academy. They allow alcohol on campus. Um and some people have better memories for trivia when they >> have alcohol. I would stop short of inebriated. >> Can I just add it was a very nice location to have. >> Yeah. Can I have it? >> Yeah. >> Um, if I could just say one more thing about the Cheshire Education Foundation. I I'm also going to be less on for that. I was a board member for I don't remember now, a year, two years, I don't know, time flies when you're having fun. But um it's it's such a tremendous work that they do, the scholarships that they offer um to students, but also want to make sure that teachers here watching wherever are um aware of the the many grant opportunities that that exist.
President JC Scott, thank you so much. [applause] Apple Valley Unified Teachers Association. Avooda Karen Sabers. [applause] Good evening, Superintendent Nelson, board members, cabinet, audience, President Scott. Tonight's going to be a little different. Normally I write a speech. I did not. What I want to address tonight is the 16page paper that was sent out to all staff. basically saying that we were not telling the truth when we stood up at this podium and spoke. So, I'm going to go through each one and I don't have a script. I'm just going to talk. First, we made a claim. When trying to negotiate counseling case loads or compensation, the district offers ultimatums, not negotiations. There has been no positive leadership, no negotiation, and no good faith effort to even have a conversation. Second claim that we made, I think we have a couple of different ideas of what negotiation looks like.
You know, whether we can buy more water, that's all handy and dandy. Like if I travel somewhere and the water source is limited and I have to bring water, that's nice. I could afford to do that. That's not ideal. It's not sustainable. >> So if we as a community care about it, it keeps coming up. Technically, the jurisdiction over water lies, I believe, with the select board. >> I believe it does. But jurisdiction over the zoning lies with us relative to certain requirements. So that would be the most sustainable thing for us to do as a community. Just like we've been talking for years about a tree bylaw >> and the water keeps coming up and bursting pipes and all this. That's that's the power really of and I believe this was somewhat addressed in the comprehensive plan as a concern um as something that we should be thinking about and could be part of the implementation committee's discussions but it doesn't prevent us as the planning board to start drafting a zoning bylaw that addresses it.