You know, you have a gap in in funding, what you want to achieve, what you have the money to do. um the Chester Education Foundation exists to be able to fill those gaps and to create, you know, tactile or whatever um opportunities for students to learn. Um so enrichment opportunities. So I want to make sure that teachers and and in light of all that's going on with the budget, I think it's really imperative that they're as aware as possible, take advantage of it, reach out. Um the money is there to do those types of things. So and these are fundraisers. So, yes, let's let's all go and let's all donate so we can help uh fill some gaps for for teachers and schools. >> That's the night life Mr. Coower came here for pretty much. Yeah. >> Awesome. No planning and zoning, right, Mr. White?
And so coming into a room that says first, last final only offer isn't really negotiations. factual response from the district. um they talked about on September 12th we came into negotiations and we worked on um article 11, article 17, article 19 and that um we worked on also we newly introduced a concept of of a cap to the counselor case loads. That is in fact false. I'm going to go through I pulled minutes out of our negotiations. They are shared minutes and so they are factual. It is what is said in negotiations. First of all, I'm going to go back to the two claims and tell you why they are indeed factual. On 4425, we were told We have no direction from the board. End of story. No negotiations. So we gave options because of course then we were doing IBB. We in fact gave 21 options some of which were options like 8% for 2526.
I think it would be it would be good to both see what comes out of the implementation committee um as far as priorities because we can't do everything at once and to look at our checklist or our the task list that I was just talking about. We can definitely add this on, but to see okay, of that list, which ones are pri are priorities, you know, maybe relative to what's on the list, maybe that wouldn't be a priority, but we have to weigh them all and see which one would we one or ones would we want to start working 2026 start working on. So, >> are there any examples in the state of Massachusetts where somebody has created a water conservation mitigation plan? No idea. >> I think that's worthy of research. Like, if you're willing to look into that, let's add it to our to-do.
Natada? >> Okay, great. With that, we're going to move to the minutes in front of us. I will entertain a motion. There are three meeting minutes packets in front of you and we're just going to take them all at once if they're if anybody would like to. >> I read them all.
Offer $10,000 stipen to teachers who sign on and stay for 5 years. Improve longevity at steps 26 28 or 26 to 30. um cola plus 1% until we get up there. We gave many options. They gave five options. Attendance incentive for staff members. Not salary. Is the idea to get us to be number four in the region? Yeah, we'd like to be up there. Supplemental salary schedule comparison. Look at CTE for teachers. Keep up with cola. preserve programs we built and add into the system. No salary negotiations because we were told the board did not give direction. We come in again on 52325. We were told there is no easy way to say this. I have no money to offer towards salary and that was for a three-year budget. We come in again. 8:225 them. What would be helpful? Us something from the district. We have passed out papers, but we haven't been offered anything.
>> Let's put it on the list and let's give it a run for a little while. >> Do some research and see what you can find. >> I don't mean to make it a mounting topic, but concern I have is we run out and have a problem. >> And that's a real concern. >> And then, >> well, any of you have to pay for more water? We're all paying for that. So is there a way to mitigate it? You know, if you have a huge development, I don't know what the the codes apply to a huge development, but do you force like if you have a development over a certain amount, you've got to use ultra low flow everything so that you're minimizing water and go above the what the plumbing code requires. >> I don't know. >> Or you would donate fund or >> right >> put land into an aquifer or something.
I move to approve all three minutes. December 4th, December 18th, and January 8th, 2026. >> Do you want to read the recommended language? Tell me you're new without telling me you're new. [laughter] >> Moved that the Cheshire Board of Education approved the minutes from meetings held on December 4th, 2025, December 18th, 2025, and January 8th, 2026. >> Is there a second? >> I'll second. >> Miss Fitzgerald, are there any additions or corrections that need to be made in all three packets? >> Nope. No, but I have a question on the minutes. I see. Um, is there typically not a ton of like the discussion that's captured in the minutes and that's meant to be like reviewed online? You know what I mean? Because there's just like usually a lot of discussion, but it's not necessarily reflected in all the minutes. I'm just flagging or asking that.
At that point, we were done. We were being drugg along and not offered anything. We were not being negotiated with. We do not negotiate with the board. We negotiate with the district. They bring it to the board. So at that point we had asked if they had thought about impass and were ready to file for impass. They said they were not. We said well we have spent 84 hours 13 sessions with no movement and we are considering impass. Come back to 9:22. That was indeed the first time that they came in with an offer. In fact, they did not hand us the offer. They told us the offer at first and then we were sent a message asking if we could please share our digital copy with them so they could prepare a counter offer. Which is why when you see the offer, theirs was at the bottom because they took our offer, added their offer on to it, they crossed out our count our um counselor case loads, and then after crossing out our counselor case loads, they also put an X through our salary schedule and then handed it back to us with theirs attached at the bottom.
Well, I mean, they they get a water bill, they pay it. >> Yeah. >> Just like the rest of us. >> I mean, just because they consume 160 times the amount I do. >> I mean, their bill will just be 160 times higher. >> How much of that do we make >> on the water bill? Does Tom make any money on that? >> It goes right to MWR, right? >> I believe so. I don't believe that we have any that we collect any. Maybe it's uh you know looking at our planning board task list and one of the things on there is to um uh under the second section um is DPW understand in infrastructure capacity and potential updates to regulations. It's already on our task list >> under DPW. So, so it sounds like the first thing we would want to do is invite DPW, >> Doug Small, say we have Doug Scott and building commissioner and Doug Small is in DPW.
>> Yeah, that's that's general practice. >> Okay. that um minutes more so reflect the actions taken than the discussion but uh obviously it's supplemental to the videos which have everything and they're all available online. >> Okay. Thank you. >> Any other? No. All those in favor of the motion that is on the floor unanimous. Thank you. Uh we do I believe Mr. Secretary, please don't go anywhere because I believe you have some correspondence. >> I think so. >> Yeah. Just real quick, the uh we got an email, excuse me, uh regarding the waiver process uh earlier today and I wanted to clarify. So, we've been going through that process. Uh the first we sent out was the priority legacy waivers and those um we talked about response rate. There were 165 Chapman to Highland legacy priority waiverss uh surveys administered. Um 119 were completed. That that was our best response rate at 72% 45 incomplete.
So you see when we make the claims that we have different ideas of what negotiations is, it is because we do. We wanted to negotiate. We can't negotiate when somebody keeps coming in and telling us we have nothing to offer. It's it's I don't know what you expect. Okay, we go to newly induced introduced concept of a cap to the counselor case loads supposedly September 12th. That was the first time we were supposed to have given that according to this 16-page document that was sent out. That is indeed false. in negotiations. US elementary counselors were worried about their um case loads. Counselors in elementary school don't see all students versus high school counselors. That was them. Then we spoke about um speed pathologist case loads. So we did start the conversation back in May. Fast forward to August 22 when we went in counselor case loads.
Um, and uh, and try to maybe understand more about that to educate oursel, educate our board more about that. Um, February looks a little busy as we already discussed, but maybe it's um >> maybe it's a a thing we should try to get on our agenda for March is to just really try to understand DPW. >> Um, and that would be a good starting point. Um, not that research if someone has an interest can be done in the meantime. If anyone wants to put their name on one of these, like they're interested in water or whatever, um, let me know. We will just fill that in. >> Do you want me to get you contact? >> Understanding like water. Okay. >> Water. Okay. >> I will put you in touch with him. >> Great. Okay. Um, all right. All right. So, the thing I wanted other thing I wanted to look at on there in under this topic is just just so that everyone would understand a little bit about what was going on at uh Zero Cross Street because those emails have been going back and forth since the the first week of January.
Highland to Bar Barnum that Moss Farms group was also in that initial phase. We had 27 surveys administered and 16 completed for a 59% response rate. Um we then sent out last week the second phase. In total we've sent out 534 requests for completion and we had 205 completed for a response rate of 39% earlier today which has made it a little bit more difficult to navigate to ensure that we're doing right because we want to try and follow up with these people. uh which is a little laborious, but um the the we were hoping to have the priority legacy waiver people um notified by the 20th and unfortunately we had to push that back to the 27th of next Monday. Um and you know maybe we'll be able to get to that beforehand. Uh Emily and I are going to try and tackle that tomorrow.
Again, we then proposed caps of 350 cap per counselor at the high school level, 500 at the TK8 level, and 650 at the TK6 level. them. They asked if the goal was to settle um 17 and we said the goal is to include counselors in that article. So then we discussed the idea and we set up a committee that would research counselor case loads and there were four people assigned to that committee. So you can see was not the first time we had ever it was not newly introduced. We had been speaking about counselor case loads. So that is a false statement there. Now we move to Okay, let's go back to the last best final. Although we put on ours last best final that was a formality, it is what we had to do because we could not continue in the process to go move to impass staying with IBB.
Um, and if you can just give a synopsis of the issue there. Absolutely. That would be great. >> So, this this little tiny triangle right here, this is Cross Street. This is zero cross street right here. This entire large parcel in Hopkington is se this one in particular has a solar farm on it. This is 71 Frankland Road in Hopkin. So on this project in Hopkin, a developer had come in and he applied for this project to put in solar panels. Hopington said yes you may. So this property owner, sorry, let me back up. Owns all of this property right here. This is contiguously ownedcledcledcledcledcledcledcledcledcledcl incl.cl.cl.cl.cl.cl.cl.cl.cl.cl.cling including see how this line continues here. He owns this corner in Ashland as well. So all of this is owned contiguously by one property owner. And when they went in to do the application in Hopkin for the solar array, they said, "Okay, we will give you the special permit to put in the solar array if you commit to put the remaining owned land into either open space or conservation restriction in some way restrict this property.
But that the question was, you know, what's what's up with the uh priority legacy waiver people basically. We don't have respon like a definitive answer on that until Monday. >> Tim, >> um yeah. So in following up on the email itself, have you or are you going to send just one blast email saying everyone >> already did? >> You already did. >> Yeah. >> Was that after the email came in? >> Yes. >> Got it. Thank you. Yep. >> So, just a clarification then, if they don't answer it, they will go to the original. >> Yeah. I mean, we're we're trying to reach out to those people to to confirm that. Um but, you know, it's well past the deadline, you know, especially the priority legacy waiver people. The um secondary phase people, their deadline is actually tomorrow. And we've sent reminders, including text messages, um, to people in these groups and still don't have uh, the response rate that we want.
We had to go back to passing the paper and saying last best final in order for PERB to accept. It did not mean that we weren't willing to talk. In fact, there are many messages where we have said we're we're open to conversation. We are willing to have conversation. But we had no choice but to do this because we needed to move it forward. We were not getting anywhere and we needed to help. Um but we've always stated that we were open to communication even then. Now we move to the next. Okay. All right. The claim arling since the 2021 school year through the projected 2025 budget total district revenues have increased by 58% total expenditures have gone down by 54%. On the surface that might sound balanced but when you look closer the distribution of those increases tell a ve very different story. During the same period, Abuda salaries increased by 26%.
So it cannot be built upon. The applicant agreed to that and in their map in the decision it does include this small triangular portion in Ashland and they can do that because it was contiguous ownership. So they're not dictating what Ashlin can do. They're dictating what this owner can do with his owned property. So they were allowed to make that condition on this decision. Now the issue is that when this person applied for their building permit somehow it was missed that only a very small section oh I can't draw on this only a very small section um about this area was put into open space and restricted. So none of the area in Ashland ever got restricted and the rest of the parcel wasn't put into the open space. Now the problem is that the the project is built. So now the building commissioner can't do anything and the planning department can't do anything.
The text message to the group that was the nonpriority legacy waiver people, the other people that were redistricted, that text only went out today and we do have, you know, that we immediately got a better response out of that group, which happens. So, >> I mean, question. >> Yeah. You don't think that um because they they had already made an indication that they wanted to go to a certain school that >> they didn't though. >> Okay. So this is everybody it's automatic >> right they are these are some of these people may have filled out an initial interest form but um many of them did not fill that out either. So, you know, um we don't want to assume and just have everybody really upset when I tell them, "Well, you you missed that boat two months ago." M >> um so we're trying to push it on that like just to get follow-ups but um right now we like I said we have only 39% of the people which does make it harder to to verify things but the priority legacy waiver people are priority for a reason and we will move with those people.
Meanwhile, administrative salaries went up 84%. Factual response from the district. The claim that administrative salaries increased by 84% while VADA teacher salaries increased by only 26% is untrue. Administrative spending figures is due to massive salary raises is not due to massive salary raises for administrators. Instead, it is an expenditure category change caused by the budget recategor recategorization in July 2025. As it is explained more fully below, several groups of the employees such as nurses and psychologists were moved from certificated budget codes to management budget codes. Their salaries are now counted in the administrative bucket, making the category appear to have grown disproportionately even though individual salaries did not change. I have to tell you, I made that claim and when I stood up here because I had gotten word that one of the principles made a comment that I haven't seen that in my paycheck.