Reader
Browse passages, annotate evidence, and export with full provenance for citation.
Um as far as Cheshure Public Schools in general, we do have the President's Day February break which is from the 16th to the 17th. Schools are closed. And that is it. I will entertain a motion to adjourn. Mr. Eckie, >> second Miss Fitzgerald. All those in favor of adjourning unanimous. Thank you everybody.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Some students are in that particular boat. And so, um, these are the numbers, uh, as of right now, uh, at Apple Valley High School and Granite Hills High School. Um, eight and eight. uh five of which at Granite were granted this year, four at Apple. Um but the current numbers um no change from the last although I I couldn't tell. It looked like maybe one student had graduated early. So um that was the numbers for transfers in and and like I mentioned before transfers out mirror that and they mirror for the same reason. people who live in um maybe Apple Valley and whose children are designated to go Apple Valley schools, but they work in neighboring districts, they want their children on the same calendar and to be at their school site. And so that's area districts do these kinds of transfers. Now to intra district transfers.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> I know there's been a request made, but I don't know if there's been a vote made. They did just meet last night. Why don't I Why don't I reach out to Joe, the chair of the select board right now, to see to see where they're at on on theirs. It might be something that we can collaborate on. >> I was thinking more like just tag on. >> Yeah. Yeah. Not >> I mean, given that we're kind of just This wasn't even on our agenda for tonight, right? So, um, let me catch up and see where, um, the select board and Joe is on this and we can, um, >> sign along with them or whatever. >> Yeah, we can kind of, you know, it might mean that, um, if things are happening more quickly over there, it might mean that if they just if they just met last night, then they're probably just with us kind of.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um right now the windows um open for intras and so we receive them in January. We take a look at space available and we respond to those requests. Here are the five criteria we use for intras. Um they're in board policy and administrative regulation. And so in February once the window closes we look at those five categories. For this year, we had uh 11 um who came to Apple Valley High School and three who um moved to Granite Hills High School. And those were mostly again for item five or item four. That's just the most common. Four and five are the uh line share of students who transfer for those first five reasons. So that's the first 11 and three. And then um it does consider it says after priorities 1 through 5 site capacity can be considered essentially to um you know allow students to participate in the program at those schools.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Yeah, I don't think they would have had it drafted yet. Okay, let me let me find out and we can um you can always uh Jasmine can always send out something some kind of notification to see where we are. >> That would be fantastic. Thank you so much for the support. Really appreciate it. And I did also contact uh Michael Herbert and um I missed his office hours. I was working and couldn't get away. But um we're going to talk next week. So I just wanted to have an opportunity to chat with him as well. >> Yeah. Thank you. I'm I'm glad that you you know have that you um thought to come to the meeting tonight. This is sounds like something that must be very frustrating for Hopkington because it sounds like they had all good intentions and somehow something got missed and that that happens.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
We have to remember that just because a student wants a particular elective course that's not the only course they need. They will need the rest of their day. So we have to look and see if you know there might be um room for example student says I really want to participate in the granite hills high school great academy program awesome but they will also need math English science etc. And so especially now with um carefully negotiated class size ratios we look at the rest of that student's schedule to see if we can make um make a fit for them. So, here's an example I gave you last time for someone trying to go down by high school to their a engineering program. And if there's space in every class, the transfer is granted. We actually sit and do this with high school principles because they can look at their schedule right then and there and figure out, you know, we can fit them and so they really try to make we try to grant every transfer.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Um so um so we'll just see you know I'll like I said I'll I'll be in touch with the select board. We'll see where they are they're at and how we can um talk about working together. >> Super. Thank you so much. >> Thank you. >> Is that good with everybody that approach? Okay, great. And then um Okay, so upcoming meetings, as we know, February 12th and then Oh. Oh, meeting minutes review. >> Oh, >> let's take care of that. I didn't have a chance to look at them. Jasmine, do you know what? In line 132, what is a cadile? C O D I C I L. I don't know. Is that a Is that a typo or is that a word? I don't know what it means. >> That's a typo. >> The guidelines had a codicile. Coticile. I line 132. I >> think that's I'll have to go back and listen because I can't even think of what >> what that would be.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
We want people to attend where they want to be. It goes back and forth. This year we were able to grant 10 more to Apple, nine more to Granite. numbers almost always are pretty even because as one leaves, we try to look for another one to match. We lost a freshman at Apple. Let's find a freshman who wants to go to Granite and keep those spaces filled at that time. So, here's the numbers um the requests, the ones that were denied and then the granted. So that apple hive that initial uh number those two numbers that were granted in numbers 1 through five and then those later for program those equal 21 at Granny Hills the three and the nine equal 12 and there are denials and I'll tell you the denials in some cases are like students will write or parents will write medical program well we have that at both high schools that's an inappropriate reason to change high schools given our current policy if that policy is to change um you know we could simply accept back and forth but at the moment or things like um football one word well both schools have a football program in fact granting for that reason throws an automatic CIF issue into play so I just want to you know just a little bit of information uh we all had a chance to attend uh CSBA and um some of the board members were in a session with me on transfers.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> It could be a word that I just don't know the word. But >> I don't think that is a word. >> That sounds kind of sounds kind of legal. Is that >> recalled somebody saying that at the meeting? I would have been like, "Oh, what does that mean?" I'll check on that. Oh, >> it is okay. >> A legal dog. Okay. >> No, >> it sounds it's fancy. All right. >> Oh, >> I don't think that's what we meant. That's very specific. Yeah, go back through and listen to what actually supposed to say. No. >> Okay. Yeah. So, um also it's it says that uh >> which line is this? I'm so sorry. >> Oh, no. Never mind. it. I thought it was a mistake, but it's not. It's okay. >> I was getting >> Is it okay? >> I mean, it's typically to a will, but I'm thinking it's usually a a change to something like a minor change.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Districts do these for all kinds of different reasons. And I was interested in this slide that had to do with intras. And at the third bullet there talking about, you know, we have to employ equitable and non-discriminatory reasons such as capacity, including classroom space, staffing, and studenttoteer ratios. We do take the student names off these when we do them just in case there's some concern that, you know, that's an issue. We do somebody has to look up and see what schedule they're looking for though. So we try to um reidentify them with letters. Then the question becomes but why are you letting those kids in from the outside? Like why those interests that those could be spaces we're using for more interest? And the the answer really is um this is a benefit to staff. Staff really like having their kids at school with them.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, maybe that is the word that they used. >> Okay. You kind of use it the same way you use the term Scribner's error. Maybe like maybe you use it the same way you use the term Scribner's error. Like >> it's kind of like the same thing like you just you were like, "Oh, we just made like a clerical error. It's just a scribers error. Like you just, you know, like a typo. It's a fancy way of saying somebody made a typo. >> Okay. But I don't think I actually have any >> changes. Just a word I didn't know. Does anyone >> I don't have any changes. >> Okay. >> I'll make a motion to approve the January 8th, 2026 minutes as is. >> Is there a second? >> I'll second the motion. >> All right. Espia I >> Paulino I >> and Trisha Kendall I so those are approved anyone have anything else >> I'll make a motion to adjourn >> at 9:29 >> 9:29 p.m.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And so um that's the reason we operate in this manner. But this policy can be changed and we can remove this benefit from staff. Okay, thank you. Are there any questions? I do have a comment. Okay, I know I've already presented some data to you um on this topic of equity across our cl our campuses, our high school, two in particular, Apple Valley High School and Grant Hills High School. I'm just going to add to the information I've already presented. Um 282 Apple Valley Unified School students were denied transfer to the high school of their choice while 82 students from outside Apple Valley were let in. Only 22 of these were staff children. 60 were not. 60 6. Somehow we managed to find space for kids outside our district to come in while denying our own. This practice over time has segregated our student population and disproportionately denied students access to programs and opportunities offered exclusively at another site.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Is there a second? >> I'll second. >> Then a roll call vote. >> Anna Tesmaniski. I >> skipped your eye. >> All the I. >> Angel Kazdian. I >> and Trisha Kendall. I All right. Thank you. >> Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Education code section 35160.5B requires that we honor parent preferences irrespective of where they live in Apple Valley. Our current board policy does not suffice. We must take steps to ensure equitable access in AVUSD. We must improve our random selection process. Covering names just doesn't cut it. We need a public and random selection process. We need to prioritize all students in Apple Valley. To begin, I move that we make board policy 5116.1 an action item in order to consider amending it to include enrollment priorities. Quote, "Every student currently residing in the district's attendance area, shall be given priority over all non-staff inner district transfer requests. I move that we make this an action item. I will second. >> All right.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Is there any discussion? >> Can I ask for some clarity so I don't bring the an item that's unacceptable? Will will we be maintaining the um ability for students who are seniors the way the the way the policy is written borrowed from law is it that if they move during their junior year will they be allowed to remain and then I'm assuming number 13 would stay staff families >> right so what we're looking at is just making sure we're making part of our policy prioritizing the students of Apple Valley as guess as a board we would be discussing details >> respectfully. >> Do you want me to bring a draft? >> Actually, let's respectfully I know that we had a motion and a second that is it is not an action item. So there is no motion or second. It would be something that you would recommend as a future item for us to bring to the board.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> So when I make a motion to add it as an action item, you're saying I cannot do that. There's no need for the motion. It can just be added as an a future item to the board. That's why we have that as part of the um script. >> Okay. Um that's wonderful. And can we do it as soon as possible? I know we have um January is when intra district transfers are being accepted. Could we do it at the next board meeting? >> I just have a comment. I have a comment on this. uh regardless of what we do, we need to know exactly if we have the staffing, if we're willing to move staff to follow the students to where the numbers are. So, if we're going to have a growth that is going to move students from say Granite Hills to Apple Valley High School and we don't have a room or classroom set up to be able to accept that growth numbers and we we don't have the teachers, then these are all things that has to be negotiating.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
If negotiated even with the bargaining unit because you cannot forcibly move a teacher to another school site just because a parent wants their child to go across town. So th there's a whole lot of things that needs to be considered before we even begin this conversation. The bargaining unit needs to be involved in this conversation. The um all of the team the people that have these dealings have to be in the discussion. We cannot make a board decision without considering the bargaining unit. That's where I stand. >> The board policy will take a two read. So even if it comes to the next board meeting, it would be March um for adoption. Um but we certainly can um add it as an agenda item. >> And I just want to make it clear, I'm not asking for staff to move sites. I'm not asking for any of that sort of thing as far as crowding um is concerned.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I'm just asking that we're prioritizing the students of Apple Valley Unified School District before we let interd district transfers in. So I'm talking about already space that's existing with the teachers where they are at the sites, but that we're just prioritizing Apple Valley students for those positions. But what about the students that Mr. Saucer mentioned that say in the middle of their junior year, no cause of their own, but their parents have to relocate to a neighboring town and the student would like to finish with their graduating class. Are we then kicking them out? Because as a parent who recently purchased a Letterman jacket, that would be really awful. First of all, they're not going to graduate with their friends that they've been with for however long. And then I I I think at this point all of these would be uh very speculative. The only thing I've asked is that we prioritize Apple Valley students >> at the expense of who?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
and at at the advantage of the students that we receive federal, state, and local dollars to educate. It's not going to cause a displacement. It's not going to cause staff children not to attend. It's just going to bring to light to the the fact that we need to prioritize the students that we receive federal, state, and local dollars for. Well, we receive that for any student that attends in our district. But we're tasked with the responsibility of educating Apple Valley students and we are. It just may not be their preferred school if there's not room there. >> Um I would like this brought to the board for a vote. That's why I requested it be an action item. >> Okay. Um what's the will of the board? Do you guys want to consider changing our board policy to >> I thought we don't have to vote on this because I did >> we're not voting but we're deciding whether or not we would like to add it to the agenda as an action item.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Okay. So that's exactly what I'm addressing is I [clears throat] called for a vote to add it to the agenda because that has been done in the past. um while it'd be not very um equitable um and perhaps uh discriminatory um I think just adding the agenda item as an action item as suggested by Superintendent Tene Nelson might be a good move at this point. Okay. Um so I'm aware of your opinion. I'm just going to go down the line and make sure that's what everybody would like to do. Rick, would you like that added? >> So, what you're asking, Renee, is to um put this on a future agenda item or a discussion and an action item at a later time. Correct. >> I don't have a problem with with it being added to future agenda or further discussion. There's a lot of issues that were raised by trustee Yokara and but you know we can definitely discuss it in more detail.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above