Are we able to consider that? Could you bring possibilities forward? >> I'm not sure what you're asking for because I I honestly don't have an answer for that. >> Okay. So, like a more detailed audit that could actually look at our numbers and give us feedback on >> the the county does do an audit on everything we send through. We it is not just a what we send and they agree. They audit everything we send. They pull certain items, they double check. Um, I will clarify as well that one of the FickMap responses was that the superintendent had signed contracts after the board had approved them at a later date than the board had approved them. I will also tell you that within our county when we contacted them, that was allowable for them because it was after the board had approved it. They didn't care what date I signed it as long as the board um approved it.
Now that FickMad has said that, every contract that comes through is signed with the same day the board has approved it. It seemed disingenuous of me signing my name to something and putting a date that was previous to the day I actually was signing it, which is why when I became superintendent, we called the county and asked the question. So, Fikmat picked things that were very specific and identified them. We have course corrected those. >> Um so no on on more of a detailed internal audit. >> I don't know who the more detailed internal audit is. Last year um there was a request for a um forensic audit. We made contact with people like Fikmat. They don't provide it. Um we can bring back the cost of any of those things to the board. >> Okay. Thank you. I'll look into it a little bit more.
Maybe I can um find something. And my last item is um in an effort to continue looking at equity at our two high schools, Apple Valley High School and Grant Hills High School, I'd like to request data. Um number one for the 2425 total spending for each site including all extracurricular activities and events and a list of certificated classified and management staff for each site with current physician and certification as of today January 22nd 2026 and I can provide this in an email to as a followup. Is there any way I can get that data? Is that the direction of the board? I'm I'm fine pulling it. It's >> um Rick, >> I don't care. >> Anita. >> Yes, >> Maria. >> Okay. >> All right. There being no further >> when you provide that data, you make sure that we all get it. um because we don't want to get half half data that is out there and then we get a print out that comes out and the public gets a hold of the data before we get it.
So it's very important that nothing goes out from this board to the public without us getting a chance to see it first. That is just the way we are supposed to be doing business here. And I've seen it too many times when we come to a board, the superintendent is in charge of every document that you present on this in this district. When I was a teacher, I could not even pass out flyers without getting permission from my school site to be able to put it out. That is why when we go to a school site, they have a a bulletin board that is designated for teachers, bulletin board that is dedicated for classified. So when I come to a school board meeting and a and there are flyers being put on that table that doesn't that has not been approved by the superintendent, that is unacceptable.
We have never done that this in this district and I think we need to cut it off. I have finally come to a point where I think we need to really cut it off. Whatever it is that is going to be presented to us just like the the uh bargaining unit where they have anything to give to us, they arrive here and they hand it to us. We get it before it is passed out to the public because surprise is not one of the things that I do. Well, so when we arrive here and you try to surprise the board, you are not going to get a vote from me. I'm just going to make it very clear. We are a a governing bo body and we speak with one voice and when we disagree, we disagree with be polite about it. And I've seen it just too many times and I have been in this district since 19 19 uh uh 84.
I have never seen a district where a board member will put our flyers out on the table that the board is not aware of it and we need to cut it put it to an end. Whatever it is that we have here, we bring it straight to the board before it goes out to public. That's all I have to say and I will always vote against it anytime somebody does that. Um, I would just like to note that um, presentations that have been given present us with packets. Um, up until just recently, and so I'm guessing maybe even longer, um, it's been going on where we're presented with a packet the day of a board meeting. I understand that this seems to be a point of contention. Um but I am not the only one that was doing that practice of bringing information the day of.
I would also like to point out that uh our um audience has today. I just want to check in. Did you guys receive any packets on our presentations today? No. Okay. Um, so I think we should >> So I know which which packets am I missing or which what is >> what is not working? >> I don't know. Did you guys receive packets in the back for what was presented today? >> Everything is available >> on front of the agenda that's placed at the back. It gives full access to the entire packet. It's been available since Friday. But I believe they don't have is personnel. >> They want to be able to have access at the meeting and that's been brought up. Um, also the idea of me presenting information publicly is uh covered by the Brown Act. So the public having access to information when we have access to information as a board and cabinet that is not a bad thing.
Um, and so I would like to just caution the board to hesitate when you have the feeling that information is not a good thing. Um, because as far as where I stand in in making decisions as a body, the more information the better. >> Let me be clear. What I am saying is you have a right just like every other board member has a right to give information to the public. You have that right. But when you come at a board meeting and we are ready to do the business of the children and then there is a there's a handout that is put out there that we have not even had the opportunity to see as a board. This is a board meeting of the board doing the business of the people. So when the board is supposed to be doing business of the people and suddenly there are handouts in the back there that we don't see we have not seen we have so we didn't prepare for it.
So we have four days or five days to come to a board meeting and then we arrive at the board meeting and then there's a flyer put out there that the pop that the public has access to. We don't get access to it. That is not how we do business. We are not going to be fair enough to answer the questions that you are asking of us. When teachers come to us to talk to us, they bring us the information. We understand that we are here to service them. But we are not here to service our own individual needs for people to see that we are the best and the brightest. That is not what we are. We are one body. We supposed to work together for a common good. The reason we are struggling right now is that we are so fragmented. Everybody is trying to talk talk up something for another person.
And I am refusing to accept the fact that the superintendent who has the right to decide what goes on that table on this campus, this is who we hired as our CEO of this district, does not even see that flyer when she arrives here. That is incorrect. She is supposed to be responsible for this district in every way. So if you have any flyer to put up there, make sure you hand it to the superintendent. Let the superintendent give the permission that it's okay to hand put it over there. Otherwise, it's a no. We have a list of things that we put out there and let it be that way. We must respect the what the office holds holds here. And what the office is holding is a lot of fragmented people having their individual issues and it's it's it's not going to get us anywhere.
So I don't mind staying here till 1:00 in the morning. It's a new day, but I do mind somebody trying to play games by putting flyers out on the table that I haven't seen. Don't surprise me. I have been in this district long enough and I am refusing to accept the fact that any flyer that is put out there has not been seen by the CEO of this district. That's unacceptable. >> Um just for the record, I provided that information. I did not ask questions on it and it available for you to reference um you know considering our upcoming board meeting uh trusty Apara. So I am giving it to you and the and the cabinet and the public ahead of time so that we can be properly informed. It is not the things that you've suggested of me. My work [clears throat] is purely for the good of the district.
>> I have sat in this I've sat here long enough. I have never been disrespectful to anybody. I've never even come after somebody. But there are just some things that I don't I don't like. I don't like when you when somebody goes after even any of the teachers classified a child. I don't like it. I don't like put down. I don't like anybody talking down to anybody in my space. And what I see is a lot of people setting up a shop outside of this. And it's not okay. We have a contract issue that we need to address as a board and we get keep getting sidetracked on side conversations. We need to settle this contract with the teachers. Period. Okay, >> I stop because this is annoying me. >> All right, in the interest of meeting our timeline, there being no further business to come before the board of trustees, it is recommended that the meeting be adjourned, I'll make the motion.
>> I second it. >> Take a roll call vote. Mrs. Longore, >> I. >> Mrs. Tucker, >> I. >> Miss Apara, >> I. >> Mrs. Mr. Buchanan and I and Mr. Raleigh had to leave.
Good afternoon everyone. Calling to order the committee on education. Today's Friday, January 23rd. It is 10:03 p.m. Conference room 229. uh and uh today I would like to also being this is our very first meeting of the year of the committee uh by itself uh introduce my members. Uh to my left is vice chair uh senator Kedani and to her left is senator Fukunaga. To my right is Senator Himoto and Senator Deort. So we're all here all five members of the committee. Uh, so today'sformational briefing is about accountability at the Hawaii Department of Education in light of two recent state auditor reports. One on classroom heat abatement and the other on driver's education program. On heat abatement, the legislature approved 100 million to cool 1,000 public classrooms in 2016. These investments were made because excessive heat directly affects student health, learning, and teacher retention. The auditor's report raises serious concerns about planning, execution, and whether those funds are translating into timely relief for students and educators.
The driver's education audit similarly identifies gaps in access, oversight, and program delivery. Despite continued legislative funding for many students, especially in rural and undeserve underserved areas, driver education is essential and not optional. When programs fall short, students lose opportunities and public dollars are not used as intended. In both cases, the legislature did its part. We provided the funding. The audits call into question whether department has the management systems and accountability measures in place to deliver results consistent with the legislative intent. So, this briefing is not just about reviewing the audits. We expect clear answers on how much funding has been spent, what outcomes have been achieved, where delays occurred, and what corrective corrective actions are underway. So going forward, we expect a written correction corrective action plan, clear timelines, measurable benchmarks, and regular reporting to the legislature. When public funds are appropriated, especially at this scale, we do expect transparency, accountability, and results.
And more importantly, we expect our students to benefit from this. And so for our first audit, we will be taking up audit 25-06, Department of Education and Department of Transportation Administrative Administration of Driver Education Programs. And uh calling on the auditor's office to give us an overview of the audits and then we will have um responders from the appropriate departments come up. >> Okay, Les. >> Good afternoon. Thank you for hosting this briefing. We like these briefings about our reports. My name is Les Condo. I'm the state auditor. Um we issued this report about uh driver education in April of last year, 2025. Uh we started this audit because of concurrent resolution that requested us to audit both the Department of Education and the Department of Transportation's driver education program. Specifically, it asked us to look at uh whether the Department of Transportation was uh Department of Education was providing driver education in its public schools, what what they were doing to address the backlog.
Uh it also asks us to look more broadly at both programs, their procedures, their policies. I think maybe Senator Hashimoto was one of the introducers of this resolution. So, we appreciate the the the ask and we enjoy doing this report. um driver education in department of education and department of transportation those programs they are separate distinct programs they are not one program they each have their own separate distinct program and because of that sorry because of that it's really two separate audits so I'm going to talk first about department of education's driver education program and perhaps maybe we'll take a a second or two and talk to the department of education and I can come back and talk about the department of transportation's program that relates to driver education. Um, so first about the department of education, a little background about DOE and their and their depart and their driver education program.
Driver education in department of education schools. It was created by the legislature in 1966, 60 years ago. And this is the language from the department of from that act uh act 42 in 1966. And it identified the legislature at that time, it identified this problem that these motor vehicle accidents were causing deaths and and injuries. And and just kind of a side note for director sniffing, according to the act that year, there wereund in 1965, the year before the act, 105 people died on our roads and 8,300 people were injured in motor vehicle accidents in 1965. >> Of course not. See, he wasn't even born. >> So, Senator, you were not one of the people driving on the roads. Some of us may have been. No, not really. >> Anyway, sorry. But um the >> I was not the the legislature directed the department to create a driver education and training program in its public high schools after hours on Saturdays and during summer recess.
and and explained the purpose of the program. The legislature did site the grave problems created by high motor vehicle accident and death and death rates and it deemed this program to be a ma matter of urgency uh that the department provide this instruction to uh minors as a solution to protect and preserve health, safety and welfare of the public. Um, in 1999, the legislature made completion of a of a um formal driver education program mandatory to get a driver's license for drivers under the age of 18. So, this will age some of us because some of us, me being one, never took formal driver education class. 1999, that's when it was became a requirement. That started, bill passed in 1999, effective in 2001. In 2020, 2005, sorry, the legislature passed another law that required uh graduated gra uh driver licensing requirements. In other words, there were three steps to becoming a licensed driver in the state of Hawaii starting in 2005.