But the law today, it still in essence mirrors the law that was enacted by the legislature in 1966. It's been now codified or recottified as section 302A413 which is on the screen right here. And it directs the department or actually I take that back. It says the department may authorize or establish a driver education program. It also says that the department for purposes of this section shall do certain things. Those things being that they must set priorities and prerequisites. They must establish and employ the necessary requirements for and employ the necessary instructors and they are going to issue or required to issue a certificate of completion of the course upon successful completion by the students. I got to note that this statute this is the only statute I take it back. There's another statute I'm going to show you in a second but this is the only statute really that defines this program that sets up the structure of this program.
There's no other more detailed provisions in the law about how the Department of Education is supposed to deliver driver education. The department also may implement or adopt administrative rules specifically in 302A413 and it's a really important provision. I'm going to come back and talk about administrative rules in a little bit. The other provision in the statute, the only other provision that relates to driver education in the department of education schools is this provision. And this provision says that the department of education will hold classes, will certify their own instructors. They'll have courses to certify their own instructors. This is an important provision. I'm going to come back and talk about it later on when we talk about the Department of Transportation's administration of their program. But this is something that is important for the department of education and something that the department of education was not able to do when the department of transportation had taken over or when they were administering their program.
So I'll talk about this in a second. So what did we find? We basically found in a nutshell that the department of education did not complete the program structure for for driver education in its schools. the the legislature created some broad general framework and it directed the department of education to complete that framework the structure of the program through administrative rules and the department did not. What we found instead is the department had offered driver education in 35 of its 68 high schools. The 68 high schools includes 21 public charter schools. And of the 35 schools where driver education was offered, three of them were in public charter schools. So in total, 35 out of 68 public high school offered driver education when we performed this audit and that would have probably been around the time frame being late 2024, early 2025. So what we also found is we found the department had not promagated rules as they were required by law to do those necessary details to complete the program.
That's what's missing from this program. It had not established the prerequisites and priorities that the law directed them to do. It had not it had stopped providing training for its own instructors. And like I said earlier, that's at the direction I think of the Department of Transportation. We'll talk about that in a second. The department also didn't have any policies and procedures to guide how driver education was going to be administered in its schools. Uh instead of a program, it was treated just like any other afterchool extracurricular activity. But the legislature determined that it was the state policy that driver education was going to be a department program. there's a very big difference between that policy directive and just any other extracurricular activity after school like robotics or debate. So as a result what we found is we found that there was no uniform manner in which driver education was offered at department of education high schools.
35 schools offered instruction in essence the way that they want to 35 different ways. school principles, the school's driver education coordinators, they really had control over whether the school was going to offer driver education and then how they were going to offer it. And I mean by how that means how they were going to in essence advertise so that students or people who were under the age of 19 could apply. And I forgot something. The law requires driver education to be available to students, sorry, residents of the state of Hawaii who are age 15 and under the age of 19, regardless of whether they attend that particular high school, whether they attend private school, whether they've graduated already, or whether they've just dropped out from school, or maybe they're homeschooled. But the law requires driver education to be available equally to students or residents who are 15 and under 19 between that age period.
So what we found is the schools, the principles, the coordinators, they were deciding how they were going to advertise, my word, advertise that people could apply for driver education, how that application process worked, who got into the courses, how weight lists, if weight lists were maintained at all, what the purpose was, and how those were administered. All of that was decided by the schools and the principles and the driver education coordinators at the school. was not a centralized uniform consistent process as you'd expect with a program that the Department of Education was supposed to create. It's that lack of structure. It really created an opportunity which we'll talk about where it was every man for themselves kind of the wild wild west. And we see examples where there was favoritism where there was unfair treatment for people, students, residents, kids, teenagers who wanted to take driver education.
That opportunity was not available to them because of this lack of structure, lack of policy, lack of what we would call controls where management could ensure that the program was operating the way that they intended and have some supervisory oversight to make sure that it was being operated the way that they intended. What we did see, so what we did is it was very difficult for us to locate driver education information on the school websites. How are is a student or resident supposed to understand what opportunities are available for them? So, we looked at many school websites and we found that there were different approaches to advertising driver education. Some didn't have any information about driver education. We did find a number of schools were using Google forms for the application. Handful of them, not all of them, but the forms were different. Some of them required certain information, others required other information.
One form required students to provide their their permit number. They some some one school required them to indicate where they went to school and it only listed a handful of schools, the schools within that district or near that district. Um other schools required other information on their Google form document, their application. Uh it was different. It wasn't standardized. It wasn't one size or one way. It was done differently. But we also found that some schools like W Pahu as an example, many schools, they didn't use an electronic online system. They required paper forms. Here's an example, and it's from the W Pahu newsletter. You'd have to find the newsletter to be able to find this information. I'm not sure how widely disseminated that newsletter is, but it says that you need to pick up the packet in this room. stop by P36 to pick up an application.
Here's another example. Roosevelt High School students must turn in a hard copy of their application. Another example from Khani. Here's the hard copy application that needs to be filled out and and turned in. This is a good example, too. This is Kyu High School online form, not online form, paper form that we could access through their website. The problem is when we looked at this and we found this in late 2024, uh, Kaiser High School, sorry, Kyua High School had stopped offering driver education in 2022. They had the application fill up, no information about the fact that driver education was no longer offered at the school. It was something that a student might be able to access, fill out, and then turn in, but they're not offering driver education at that school. We did see some schools, sorry. So, what we did find because of this lack of structure is often how you get in is who you know and we have a little text box here which is this slide.
We little we did a little text box about a situation at Radford High School where some Punoho students were allowed to take driver education during the school day. So, that's a four credit course. a little different than the extracurricular afterchool courses that we primar primarily looked at here. We looked at this one and we highlight this one just because by DOE rule only students registered at the school are supposed to be allowed to take four credit courses during the school day at the school. These students initially the allegation was 10. We ended up finding that there were well we ended up talking about the department of education's investigation or department of transportation's investigation. They only identified two students. The students were puno students and there was some relationship to faculty uh at the school. The students had a relationship with faculty at Radford High School.
So actually >> being able to take take the class during the school day. They're not it's school. How long? >> They're not supposed to. So that I think I'm sorry that was my point is that without any kind of structure any kind of oversight these kind of favoritism issues it certainly arose >> school >> don't know no our our scope is very limited some maybe the superintendent can answer that question just kidding uh anyway so this who you know thing we suspect it's probably more than just this incident instant because when we talked to other driver education coordinators, uh how do you select people for for uh the class? One person told us, well, I asked the the teammates of my football of my son's football team whether they're interested. Um so there's other ways that that people would be able to get enrolled in a driver education class that is really not fair.
It's not transparent. It's not equal access to all. So that's the point that we're making here that with a program without that structure every school was doing it their own way and the result of that was inequity was unequal treatment was sometimes favoritism not the way a program really should be should be operated so one school castle they did have a weight list so online something that you fill out not every school maintained a weight list required by DOE rules or or policy to have a weight list at every school so without a weight list the department cannot understand the demand and that was I think one of the senator's concerns about what is the demand for driver education how can the department of education perhaps meet that demand kind of it as aside department of education charges $10 a student to enroll and participate in department of education driver education instruction if you're not able to take that instruction and you have to go to take driver education in a private in the private riv sector, the cost is about $550.
>> So that $10, was that the initial amount in 60 years ago? >> I believe so, but I'm not 100% sure. I don't think the amount has changed. I'm not sure. Maybe maybe the department can answer that question better than I can about how long it's been $10, but the difference between the 10 and the 550, it's significant. Um, but without a weight list, it's very difficult to gauge demand. some weight list maintained by coordinators in their head, not on paper, not some kind of record that somebody could see, not some way that somebody else could determine whether or not they were going down the wait list if there's openings or maybe for future years. One coordinator told us that people sign up when they're freshman, but she takes the seniors. So, in other words, the freshman eventually may get into the class, but they're going to have to wait a few years before they're able to to enroll in the class.
She felt that it was more appropriate, better for for her to service the people that were older and not necessarily the people that were younger. That's not a department policy. That's certainly not in the statute. Without that structure and the rules, she just made that she just made a decision about how she was going to select students to be part of the class. So I wanted to talk quickly about the significance of the program. I keep talking about program program. I know initially the department questioned what a program was. They didn't think they needed to establish a program because the language of the laws may establish and administer a program not mandatory. So the department suggested that that they did not have to create a program. They suggested and we do not say this that they don't have to have a program in every school.
I agree with that. The law doesn't require them to have driver education in every school. and we did not suggest that. So I hope that got clear clarified or cleared up with the department. But there's a significance when the legislature decides as state policy that driver education is going to be a program. That's state policy. It's not an extracurricular activity, you know, like I mentioned drama, robotics where perhaps the principal or the department decides they want to offer this type of instruction. This is state policy. State policy requires consistency, requires structure. So the importance of this is that there needs to be a program. Um started in 1966, continued through uh section 302A 413 today. Um >> can you summarize? >> Surely >> what was the response from the department? >> Okay. And what's important is the rules. That's how you develop the structure. They got the authority to implement rules.
They need to do that. Uh we have a little thing about rules here. You guys probably are familiar with rules. We try to educate the department and other readers of our of our report about what administrative rules are and why they're required by law. Required by law. So one one difference is perhaps it may be discretionary from the department's perspective, but once you do certain things and you affect the rights of people that use your program required by law to have administrative rules. These are recommendations. We included many recommendations in every report. I got to talk to you real quick because I looked real quick yesterday or the day before about what the Department of Education has done. They actually have a new website and this is one of the pages. They actually have other information on that website and one of the things that they've added hopefully across the board consistent through all their programs is they put prerequisites and and priorities for people to enroll in their in their classes at different schools.
One of that is you got to live in the district. So, I was surprised. >> So, you didn't have this website when you were doing >> Oh, no. new. I hope it's in response to the audit. Uh we always want agencies to improve and and to do things better to address the problems that we we've identified. So I was surprised, happily surprised. Uh but at the end of the day, it's not a rule and they still need to put all this stuff in administrative rules. The significance of that is it cannot be changed at the whim of a new administrator or a new superintendent. There's a process. It's transparent. People get a chance to offer public testimony on those rules. So that's the significance of why it needs to be in a rule. This is where our report is in case anyone here maybe people that are watching are interested and uh well that's it.
So anyway, sorry I rushed through the end but thank you for the opportunity to talk about our report. >> So members um you can ask questions of the auditor. You can bring up DOE have questions for the auditors. So less, you know, I think thanks for that great presentation. Um I I think good good overview. I think what you you told us heavily on the DOE side. I don't know if you're going to talk about the DOT side. >> We have the DOT side and a separate >> Okay, we're going to do that after. >> Yeah, that to both. What do you guys prefer? >> Maybe a quick be on the DOT side and then >> Okay. Sorry. Okay. The DOT program is like I mentioned earlier, it is a different separate distinct program from DOE. They have their own responsibilities uh different from what DOE's responsibilities are.
DOE's uh responsibilities its program it started much more recently than DOE's program right it started in I think the year is 19 sorry 1999 is when the legislature established through statute uh the department of education department of transportation's program again it allowed them authorized them to to promagate administrative rules unlike DOE DOT has has adopted administrative rules they did it six years later, but they have administrative rules that provide structure to their program. Um, defines their responsibilities like it's supposed to do, defines the rights of people that use the program. So, DOE, sorry, DOT really has two responsibilities, just two. Certify the driver the curriculum that's going to be used to train people who are called master trainers or train the trainers. people that train the driver instructors, certify the curriculum for the driver education instructors that teach the students and certify the curriculum that will be taught to the students.
That's one of their responsibilities. The other responsibility is to certify driver education instructors. Really, I would call it license the instructors. And I would suggest that second responsibility is somewhat ministerial. The statute or the rules provide what an instructor needs to provide amongst other things. driver abstract, copy of their driver's license, they can't have moving violations within the last year, no drug or alcohol related incidents relating to driving under the influence within the last 5 years, things like that. They need to show proof of that. Once they show proof of that, in my opinion, what the rule says is that the Department of Transportation shall shall issue the driver instructor the certificate or the license. So what we found is the department is doing things very differently. So so in a nutshell what we found is the department of transportation allowed a relatively low-level employee to run rampant you know without adequate supervision to run the program as she wanted to whether authorized by law or not.