2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 27
That's what we found in a nutshell. So the director did not certify any curriculum and the director by by the rules he is supposed to convene a a committee task force curriculum task force to review the curriculum and provide him recommendations. He eventually is supposed to certify that curriculum which is a fundamental part of the entire program. without that certified curriculum, hard to issue certificates of completion of curriculum or program without the curriculum being first certified. So anyway, I want to talk a little real quickly about what we found the highway safety specialist, the relatively low-level employee, what she did, how she expanded, greatly expanded her authority under the statute, DOT's authority. She approved curriculum. The director did not certify curriculum. He did not delegate that responsibility down to the highway safety specialists. She just took it on herself to decide what curriculum was appropriate.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 28
Right? She sub substituted her decision as to what she thought was appropriate. And we would question whether that's whether that's really appropriate. She certified master trainers. Master trainers are the train the trainer people. The law or the rules do not provide for certification of master trainers. Department of Transportation's sole responsibility with respect to master trainers is to certify the curriculum that they must pass successfully to be a master trainer. She certified it. She certified three people, three that had relationships or she had relationships to them. The first one that she certified was based upon this training course that they went to. She and the person who she eventually certified went to this training course. I think it's in Western Washington University. And the PowerPoint presentation really is is very enlightening. It says specifically this is not that course. This course is not to train or to to to help people become trainers of other instructors.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 29
Yet it was based on this course that she certified those instruct that person to be a master trainer. And the thing about certifying or limiting who would become a master trainer is because those people eventually would train people that wanted to be driver education instructors at a cost. Not free, not part of the Department of Transportation's program where they would provide this for free. They would be private citizens, private individuals who would be able to to charge people who wanted to become an instructor. And it's just not DOE instructors. It's also private driving school instructors. These requirements apply to tri private driving school instructors just as well as DOE driving driver education instructors. Uh, another comment and this is about the lack of any kind of oversight by the Department of Transportation as to what this person was doing. This person was using allowing the master trainers to use the Department of Transportation seal and the state of Hawaii seal on their on their information that they were pushing out advertising for for classes for other instructors to take.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 30
You can't use the state of Hawaii seal to represent that you're part of the state or part of the department. Frankly, it's illegal. But that was allowed. That was being done. and without any kind of oversight, push back, any comment by anybody. It likely was approved by the highway safety specialist, but that's my speculation. But that's based upon her relationship with the three master trainers that she had selected. Um, this is where we get back to the DOE law. The DOE is responsible for training their own master trainers, train the trainers. but by limiting the number of people or the people that she decided that she certified. Again, certification is not part of the requirements under the rule. But by her taking on that responsibility, she excluded the Department of Education instructors, 11 who had been previously training Department of Education instructors, she certified none of them to be master trainers.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 31
Zero. So that required the department of education to send people who wanted to be driver education instructors under the department of education to one of the three master trainers. So we saw in 2024, fiscal year 2024, four DOE employees went to private instruction with these master trainers at a cost of about $1,900 each, which the department paid, Department of Education paid. So she also interfered with how the department of education was providing driver education. She dictated to them how they would provide courses during the pandemic. She limited online or virtual courses, not online, virtual courses to 14 people. She never changed that once the pandemic stopped. She limited in-person instruction to 10 people. She told the Department of Education how to provide instruction. The Department of Transportation has no authority under the rules under the statute to dictate how that instruction is provided. In fact, all the Department of Transportation, its rules has is the instructor has these responsibilities.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 32
He or she is supposed to be able to decide how they provide instruction so that they can issue the certificate. She also, this may be out of order of my slides, but she also decided that if an instructor was sick and could not complete the course, another certified instructor could not then step in and substitute to complete the course. The students who were under the the instructor who could not finish the course for whatever reason, sick or otherwise, they had to start again from step one, square one. She decided that people who she decided when when instructors their certificates were not renewed timely even though the course that they taught was done when the certificate was in place that those students that certificate that they had received from the instructor it was invalid. So she made up some rules on her own that greatly affected the department of education's instruction and the students that they provided instruction to.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 33
She required instructors to attend different kinds of classes uh to maintain their their um their certificate or their license. Not required by rules, not thing things that are outside of the rules. And those classes were taught by one of the master trainers, one of the three people that she selected. And again, it's not free. It's they had to pay. She suspended driver education instructors in a way that was not fair, not equal, not across the board. It was very arbitrary. Some people she she suspended for different things. They were late in renewing their their certificate. They didn't do certain things. In any event, it was not a fair process. She processed driver education applications or certificates for renewal untimely. We have a number of examples where this is a letter A dil dated April 6 telling an instructor that their certificate for May 2020 through May 2021 was now approved a year earlier.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 34
Here's another letter, same date approving a renewal for another period of time the next year and a third letter same date for the future year. So clearly she was doing things very differently for different people. For other instructors, if you were late and you didn't renew on time, your certificate was suspended. Uh she directed county licensing departments not to honor student completion certificates. If a instructor had been had been um suspended even though the course had been completed by the student, the certificate was signed by the instructor while the instructor was still licensed. She directly contacted the DMVs, department of motor vehicles on the different counties and instructed the vehicle examiners not to accept the statement or the certificate of completion for those students. There were times when she suspended or refused to honor allow the DMVs to honor certificates where the certificate didn't include the students middle name.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 35
There were many instances where some of her decisions and her authority well outside of the legal authority but some of her decisions and authority very arbitrary very questionable. Um anyway so these are the things that we identified where she greatly exceeded her authority. We detailed it and a lot more in our report itself. uh we added um a lot of recommendations certify the con the curriculum develop some consistent clear documented policies and procedures so that people would know how to run this program and specifically just relating to licensing or certification of driver education instructors. So the department of educa department of transportation really has to understand what its roles and responsibilities are how limited they are. It's really akin to DCCA and and PVL and them licensing other professionals. You present the application, you give the required documents, you walk away with your license unless there's an issue that comes up later that you're investigated.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 36
Uh anyway, here's our file. Here's our report again and this is our website. Happy to answer any questions. I'm sorry that I did the speed dating speed. >> I have a question because I read the audit and what also troubled me is about this um DOT court monitored project paid members of a nonprofit volleyball club around $200,000 a year and a and half of questionable work. And this is this is the same person that you talked about that was controlling this whole program that also had this other program was doing also in conjunction with DOT. Is that correct? >> That's correct. Can you just give a brief >> that's on page 46 and 47 members if you have not th >> this review of the department of transportation's driver education program it was a very messy we weren't messy but understanding how things were were being done it was unbelievable you know we would get a lot of different responses from the same person uh at different times when we talked to her.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 37
So it was even under hard for us to understand what she was doing or what she was describing things moved. Um so what we ended up trying to understand is what other responsibilities did she have and this was one of them the court monitoring program. And as we learned about this, and in fact during one of the interviews, she jokingly or otherwise told somebody in my office that was talking to her at the end of the interview, well, if your daughter's interested, give me a call. So, it's another one of these things where it's I think it's who you knew. And I think a lot of these people that were involved in the court monitoring were people that had some affiliation with her volleyball club or volleyball more generally. Some of them are high school students. Can you explain the what this court monitoring is and how it's related to DOT?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 38
>> I think it's through a federal grant. I'm not sure. You'd have to ask DOT, but it's where the Department of Transportation and specifically this particular program is I'm not sure the value in court monitoring, but it relates to how courts are are sentencing or the f or the what they're doing with people who are um found to be have driven under the influence. I think it's alcohol uh and how courts are dealing with that. I don't know the and I think she told us the value she felt is the judge would see somebody sitting there and would not be lenient with the defendant. I'm not sure the judge even knew that this high school kid that's sitting there is somehow monitoring whatever sentence that he he imposed on somebody that had been, you know, convicted or or had fled to some drunk driving. >> Not a high school student.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 39
>> I don't know if there's any. it's supposed to be a student at all, but certainly it raised questions about not only that there are high school students and you know court does not operate on the weekends and after school hours. It's during the school day. We didn't go into that too far, Senator, because it was outside of the driver education program. It was just part of her other responsibilities that really raised some big flags about what's going on. and it tied to many of the affiliations that she has with the or had had or has with her volley her own volleyball club and just volleyball in the state more generally. So, one of the people or maybe all three of the people who were the people she designated to be the master trainers, there's some affiliation with her and maybe it's a volleyball affiliation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 40
Uh, one of the people that she designated seems to have a personal relationship with her. Their address is the same address. They co-own a house together. She denied it being her her boyfriend or any other kind of personal relationship, but there's a lot of connection there. And certainly the fact that they co-own a residence together suggests that there's some monetary interest, so to speak, uh when she selects people for different roles and she forces or mandates that instructors go for different kinds of training through these these three designated master trainers. So this person is still with according to this she left the department >> department of transportation can provide more information about this but um she went as far as we know uh or we did talk to her when she had moved from the department of transportation to the department of human services. So we had some challenges in getting her to come back to talk to us but those got resolved through the director.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 41
But um as far as I understand she's still there. I don't have any information to suggest that she's no longer at DHS. Uh but certainly even the leaving the Department of Transportation and like I said the department can talk about that probably in more detail but I don't think I think she gave notice after her last day kind of thing. It was very odd. Uh she was a very challenging person to talk with and I'm sure the department was challenged in having her on staff and supervising her but I think the point is they didn't supervise her. Any other questions for the auditor? He'll still be around because he has another auditor. So, can why don't we start with DOT then? I know Ed might have to leave and uh is really not involved in the other next audits. So, come here and start um you want to comment if >> Yeah.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 42
So, so following up on the audit, I appreciate Les going coming through and his staff coming through to get us the information on this. We followed up with all of his recommendations. So, all of the recommendations are done. um we've completed all those pieces especially getting rid of the employee that was there >> is that you you agree that >> I don't know >> done all the recommendations >> I don't know we have not we have not done any assessment in a couple years three years or so we'll go back and we'll review the implementation of the audit recommendations but right now we don't know um and the only reason why we know a little about DOE is just because I was looking around to see if they had done anything to address some of the recommendations >> so perhaps you you to save some time you and um provide the committee with a list and what exactly that that you folks done to satisfy >> recommendations.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 43
>> Yes, definitely >> good members questions. Senator. >> So, so Ed, I guess I guess how do we prevent this from happening? Because I I think you know as the person that introduced the reso originally, you were aware of what what was going on and then the I think just the frustration with your department's response is why we had to do this reszo and I don't think it should have been taken to this far although we learned a lot, right? But I think how do we prevent this kind of thing from happening? Because the symptoms were all there, right? I think the DOA was so frustrated. I was so frustrated and so we had to do the reszo. So why did it have to get to that? Why didn't couldn't you guys be more proactive and really understand that there was a lack of oversight of this individual?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 44
Right. >> Since since we started that conversation, we took a lot of action on that employee, limiting her scope as much as possible and resetting the program. It was in such a disarray. It took a while to to reset the program. So it's not that nothing got done during that time frame. We had to reset everything that was that was being done during that time, especially the relationships with the DOE. So part of it was making sure that we reset with DOE, make sure that their their instructors were certified and made sure that we started resetting the master the master trainers throughout the state. Right now we don't have one. The whole goal for this year is to make sure we have at least two per island throughout the state. So part of the discussion is bringing in that class to Hawaii to make sure we get those master trainers going.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 45
But bottom line, we had an employee that wasn't being managed. We put management rails around that employee, then started resetting the whole program and everything she had she had worked on. We're taking action on that employee and then she left. But before she left, she was on sick leave for a long periods of time. That made it more challenging to take those corrective actions. >> So So to your question on on how we make sure this doesn't happen again, uh we've already reset what the requirements are for D for the driver's education program from the DOT's perspective. We have it in our we have reset the the priorities and reset up our our committee to ensure that those curricula for drivers education trainers is already set as well. >> So, so I guess what is the system now? So, who's overseeing you know I don't think you know you probably have someone under you overseeing but I guess it would be helpful for us to understand what is that hierarchy now.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 46
How is that changed? The program is run out of our highway safety office and our highway safety administrator and and her direct assign is directly involved in the program. The person that runs the program is two levels below, but they're directly involved throughout and they report up to the deputy on this to ensure that we we and our relationship with DOE reset how many or how we can get more people trained in the state. >> Right. >> So, who was who was her supervisor to begin with? So, under the the um highway safety office, we have a highway safety. We have a highway safe um >> safety officer. >> Yeah. An officer and below that was the was our driver's ed specialist. Yeah. >> Okay. So, that person is that person still in that >> the supervisor was brand new that we brought in to take care of this person.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above