Reader
Browse passages, annotate evidence, and export with full provenance for citation.
We brought in a person um a person from DO who's really good. When she came in, she helped us reset the program. >> Okay. now overseeing >> um before that was the person that left in in the interim. So that the position was open and and or being filled and unfilled throughout. There were people who were who were oscillating in that position >> that was supposed to supervise. Yes. >> But who was supervising that person? >> The highway safety um the highway safety administrator. >> And who was that? >> Uh it's Lee Nagano. >> And that's the person. >> She's still there. Yeah. >> Okay. Well, that's that's questionable. if she's still there, how come she didn't monitor this >> knowing that POS knowing that position was filtering and so forth, knowing that all this was going on? I mean, there needs to be accountability.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And if that person is still still there, well, I I'm not sure what kind of performance they have otherwise. But that raises concern because if that can happen on their watch for that long period of time, certainly I don't know what else is falling through the cracks. Yeah, we we've reset the the the requirements and the expectations for this program with her outside of this program. She's she is a high producer. So now we we have rails around it. >> Understand how that how that happens when you have to set rails when that I'm sorry. I'm just >> sure. >> You know, I I would just like to um follow up with that as well. I think we should open that also to the scope of who this individual staff was. Um because these people have been a part of potentially seeing and maybe turning the other way uh while this obvious abuse of power was taking place.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And so um I think that you were able to switch out leadership, but I'm talking about the staff. I'm and I'm not sure if this is in the auditor's report of people that were in the office at the time, but uh this concept of tolerating enabling or just like how I said looking the other way. I mean, this is what continues to create and breed abuse of power not only in this department but further than that. >> Yeah, I totally agree. So, you're asking for us to to send out the the person's name and everything? >> No, no, no. Sorry. So, so just to clarify my comment, not necessarily a question, but anybody that was within her department or her office at the time, these people have been trained on bad behavior and abuse of power. So, it's important that that gets another internal look as well because they've seen this bad behavior and I'm not sure how this individual had left the department.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Maybe she resigned, maybe she retired. Um but I think that it's important to uh the department and the office to know that there are severe consequences when you abuse power. I mean the auditor had said it was illegal to use state logos. Um so I mean we can really take this thing deep if we need to but I think it's important for the office in general to just really see that there are harsh consequences with this. >> Totally agree >> thank you for that. I think uh maybe what would be helpful to you and to this body would be to ask the AG to intervene also and let her set up the investigation so that we do it properly. >> We've already we've already approached our AG with the information to do an investigation. >> When when was that? >> Um I can get the date for you and I can send it to the committee >> recent just recently.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Um I want to say it was last year but I'll send you information. >> I I got to check I got to check on where it's at. Yeah, they'd like to get a report because I don't know that things should stay lang, you know, and they're talking about investigating who got $35,000 and this person have spent and possibly 200 something thousand and a lot of other infractions. I would think that those kinds of things would get investigated as well. Yeah. >> If not more so. >> I'll follow up on the dates and I'll get it to you. >> And it's not that that's important. And it's to make sure that um you know all of us your superintendent I mean superintendent as well as the department heads and and everybody under you and under them know that we have policies in place and we don't want all of us to be under suspicion of protecting someone and not knowing the truth of what really happened.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Agreed. >> Thank you. >> And I think it's also important that there there are checks and balances. There seems to be no checks and balances in the situation. And what what worries me is that we don't know where else in the department until we get another audit that we might find some of this stuff going on. I mean, this program has been going on for 60 years, you know, and only now all of this stuff comes to light. If it wasn't for a resolution, we it might still be going on. I mean, you know, we don't know. And that's what concerns concerns me um as we as we go forward. So, we want to have faith u in our in in our state workers. We want to have confidence that they're doing their job and that you know, but yet we we hear these kinds of incidences and it makes for bad morale.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I think overall >> totally agree. >> Yeah. >> And and overall this is my fault because since 2014 I was running highways and up to this point that's all under my purview. I'll I'll tell you quite frankly that program was very small on my on my focus. So bringing it to light um through to through Senator and and through the audit was a good thing to make sure that we can readress everything to move forward. Thank you for stepping up and taking your responsibility because lot so many times I hear excuses but at the end of the day it stops at you right or absolutely well the director you had you were just highways at the time but you also had somebody above you >> right >> so we took the action after after we started the conversations uh with senator and and and with after um the audit team find came in and we started having the conversations we didn't wait for the audit to be completed to start taking the actions Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Well, certainly appreciate you responding to the auditor's report as well. Um, any any other questions of DT and we move on? Okay. Thank you very much. >> Thank you so much. >> Okay. Just go pave our roads. Okay. >> Yes. >> Thank you. >> Okay. Superintendent, you're up. >> Hello, Chair Kim, Vice Chair Kani, members of the committee. Keith Aayashi, superintendent. Um, first off, I I I also want to thank um thank all of you for the opportunity to respond as well as the uh state auditor for providing um their hard work and their their uh their insights into our driver's education program. >> Let me just make a little comment right here. I just wanted to be known to the public as well. You know, I'm not just picking on DOE or picking on I have had a bill for years now that said that every audit that we pay for and every study that we pay for that should have a public hearing.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
The results should have a public hearing. And so I am doing exactly what I expect others to do, other chairs to do because so often we do these studies, we do these audits and it sit on the shelf or it comes by our desk. We're inundated with all kinds of reports and studies. we don't read it, but it should get heard and the public should know what's going on. So, I just wanted to preface that um that it's not just picking on a certain audit or because I would hear it all if it's up to me. Okay, go ahead. Thank you, >> Chair. Um so, again, thank you very much um the uh state auditor for uh bringing these recommendations to light for us. Out of the 10 recommendations that uh the department received, um eight have been implemented and are done. uh one the the first recommendation uh as far as the HR Hoya administrative rules we've started that process already um and we following the 12 to 18month process to get everything done we anticipate it being completed by January 2027 so that that process has already started um as well as recommendation number 10 which uh deals with reporting to the board of education uh we are um in the process of getting that agenda for the board so I think within the next uh two or three months we should be taking it to the board for uh to provide that the the um in response to the information in response to the auditor's recommendation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Um I don't believe any board member is here in person, but I do believe we might have one on Zoom. Um slow is he on Zoom? But my I guess my question is did the board at any time take up the audits, >> this audit or the next audit? uh for for this audit we are we are agendaizing it with the board. >> No, but I'm saying did the board before you agendaize it because they can take up whatever I mean this was out in the public already. So did the board ever bring this up in the meetings? >> Um no not not to my knowledge yet. >> Bring up the the heat. >> Um did we discuss the heat? >> Captain is here. >> Yeah. Did the board ever take this up? Their state board did have a brief discussion August >> August of for which >> shortly after >> for the driver's license.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
How about that? >> Both of them. And did they take any action or did anything? >> just a discussion. >> What? Yeah. >> Question. Yes. >> Uh sorry. Uh you had mentioned the DOE recommendations. You folks did eight out of the 10. >> Yes. >> Uh which were the ones the >> first and the last one. first int number one and number 10. >> Number 10. >> Oh, yeah. Kr for number one and border ed for number 10. >> Let me ask this while you're doing that. So, superintendent, I looked at your response and I was a little troubled by that um because according to the auditor, uh they originally asked for your response and you gave you didn't give a response. Then you met with the the committee, right? you um what >> I don't know >> sorry about that chair that would be on our end you may continue >> what it is is there something going on with our system >> uh we're good to go chair uh sorry about Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Okay. So going back so um that you provide you you could have provided written comments to the draft report but chose not to and u while you didn't participate according to the report and correct me if I'm wrong that the assistant superintendent office of curriculum instruction design and others uh including resource teacher who works at the high schools um met and they didn't bring up anything that you brought up in in your your letter that you subsequently uh came up with. Um so I'm just concerned that you know and then they called that they followed up and called and then they were told that um we do not intend to provide any written comments to the draft report and that was on a in August >> right >> was that August or April? >> April. >> Yeah. Yeah, you're correct. We did we did not provide any written responses to the audit.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um we we do take the audit very seriously and uh so we did take a look into the recommendations and >> No, but why didn't you guys take it seriously when it came out and provided any comments at the time? >> Oh, we were in the process of after we read the audit the draft report um we started already working on the responses to the recommendations. >> Okay. I'm sorry. I have a hard time. Yes, please. With every audit, we provide a draft to the audit and we ask to meet and talk about the draft >> before you publish it. >> That's correct. We don't we don't share with legislators or anyone else. So, we did that and we did meet with people from the department and we had a good conversation about concerns that they had about the report. We had a typo or some other mistake that we ended up correcting after as a result of that meeting.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And then we waited for the response and when we didn't get it, we followed up to ask, are you going to provide us something in writing? Do you have written comments? And we were told no. And then the superintendent wrote to us three months later. >> Go to >> So we had a good discussion. >> Okay. So why was there no no response? You didn't think it was important. They didn't think it was >> uh No, definitely we take the auditor's report um as very important. Um um my understanding was that we we didn't write a response because we uh were going to address the recommendations in the audit. >> Okay. Now, I'm going to take that an issue because according to your letter that you followed up three months later, three months later, you wrote a you wrote a letter saying you don't agree with anything that you folks didn't have to do rules that you didn't have to do this.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
You you aled and said you didn't agree with that. So, how can you be working on his recommendations when you send a letter saying you disagree with everything? Not everything, but a great deal of what he said. >> Um, so I I am getting Yes, I I know. Yeah. Thank you. >> Who the letter? >> So, um, it it was under my signature. >> I know, but who wrote the letter? >> Obviously, whoever wrote the letter didn't read everything because you subsequently sent another letter saying, "We agree with you." Right. So you went from no response to and then a meeting and no response and then you went to a letter saying you know what we don't agree with this because we didn't have to do this it's not mandatory and then they wrote back and then you came back with another letter say okay we agree with you >> I I I take responsibility for that chair um this was actually the first audit that in in my years time that I started as a superintendent this is the first audit actually that I if I'm not correct that's the first one no it is and so I I take responsibility for any mixup.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
We do at the end of the day. Um I take responsibility. We've addressed the audit. Um it is very important. I think what Mr. K had brought up in terms of providing our students with opportunities. Uh we we we looked at where we are offering driver courses where we're not you know we need to to the best of our ability to expand a number of offerings for our students. Um we we have developed the web page. We're able to assess now uh what the need is. I think that was part of the audit that we weren't able to or we are able to now assess the need. We know where the um uh where there are weight lists at at the different schools. >> Wait, sorry, but you're not being direct in your answer. She's asking you why you didn't respond, why there wasn't an urgency.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Now, I understand that this might have been your first audit, but anybody who's anybody knows that when the auditor is auditing, it's the most important thing, >> right? >> So, so why didn't you respond urgently? >> So, um I take responsibility for that. We did it. It's me. >> Well, you're going to take responsibility cuz you're the guy in the seat. So, whether you do or not, the finger is pointed to you. Why didn't you respond immediately? >> Well, oh, let me just add to that. The people that met, they've been around, they know audits, right? The people that work for you, they know audits. Part of them, part of them were in the meeting. So again, there were no response. So you cannot just say this is your first audit. And and not only that is that how can you write a letter that did saying that you didn't agree with any of it and then turned out that you did?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Somebody were advising you to tell you that the auditor was wrong. And that worries me. to send out a letter that is clearly in error. I mean, I get I get upset with my staff if they send out stuff to me that is in error, you know, because it's my I'm the responsible one to make sure that whatever is going out at the end of the day that it's correct. >> Okay. And being superintendent of education with all you guys degrees, I cannot I I'm sorry. I am just flabbergasted that you could send out a letter that said that they were completely wrong and I think it says that in the letter. Um it it it blows my mind that you can say that they are completely what was the words that you used? I'll find it somewhere in here. But what was the words that they use in the letter?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
You said the gross gross error or anybody I have the letter best you have the letter. Okay. Can you give that to the chair please? >> Okay. to clarify statements of the state office of the auditor. The audit report raises as a pro however however is inaccurate. The legislature has never mandated department establish and administer a motor vehicle driver education and training program. Rather, it's been permissible. This has not changed since the law's inception. The audit report is correct that the legislature first addressed that. However, did not require department to establish a driver's education program. Merely states the department is hereby authorized. Legislature let's see to this day the program remains permissible. Not once during the nearly six decades after act 42 inception has the legislature made any such mandate. Department is unaware of why the legislature did not mandate the program. like the driver education program in general department's interpretation of the statutes that the department has authorized is not required to do that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So and it goes on and you cite things and then and then the next letter you sent out and you agree with them. I mean somebody did some research to say that we didn't mandate that. I mean I'd like to know who did that. That was in reference chair um to uh when state auditor did reference I believe it was uh 302A4 413 >> but the whole gist of this is that you're saying that you're not required to do rules you're not it's not mandated that right I mean that's the gist of your letter >> we we are u working on HR and in the process of that that'll be finished by January 27 27 2027 >> good questions Yes, please. >> Um I can appreciate, you know, on the neighbor islands, you know, the the fact that there's a shortage of uh available um opportunities.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above