>> Do you have a number, I guess, between the auditor and department of education as to the level of unmet need both on Oahu and on the neighbor islands? >> We we do. Um I believe we do have that number, Senator. Um Jack Well, if that can be provided, >> we can provide it to >> to the committee chair. I think you know the goal would be to really see how we can assist the development and you know respond to whatever unmet need there is. But it's it's hard to know how how how much is needed and so that's kind of why I wanted to get a a ballpark just you know to get a sense of what it might take to address that unmet need. Thank you. manager, when we were looking at the audit because that was one of the the concurrent resolutions request without the weight list, there was no way for us to determine or understand, you know, what that demand was.
So, I'm not sure what the department has implemented since then, but hopefully they've implemented some tool that would allow them to calculate the demand. One more comment before I before I get off my podium here. Um and unfortunately the DOT directors left but it allows driver education could be um can be obtained or completed through online courses which the director needs to certify those courses or that curriculum. Online is different than virtual when the teacher is right there in the room and you're watching on video. So the opportunity for students on neighbor islands for instance or other places to be able to complete driver education there are other opportunities. It's just right now we're talking in-person instruction and uh or or virtual and not online courses which the statute of the rules certainly allow. >> Let me ask you may I >> um Senator Fukunal uh thank you for that question.
Um the website that we have we have stood up for a driver's education. Um so if students uh want to apply for a driver's ed program going into that website they will select the school that they want to apply to put the application in and so it's through that site now that we're able to calculate uh the need and and yeah right so thank you >> um superintendent what is the cost to deliver this driver's ed program >> I we don't have that we okay to bring Terosima. >> Good afternoon, chair and members of the committee. Terry Shiima. So um we receive from the insurance commission's fund 2,200 uh oh I mean 2,200,000 a year and of that um 1,500 is used for projected school programs like 52% of it is for instructor fees um administrator time for the coordinators um it's also for um maintenance things like uh vehicle gas maintenance repairs and equipment.
Uh some you know you have >> the question is what does it cost the DOE to deliver the program? Not what's in your budget, not how much money you get. What is the cost to deliver this program so far? >> So currently it's about two 2.9 to 2.7 million a year. >> Okay. So the amount of money that's provided to you is enough to cover the delivery of this program. >> Yes. >> Okay. The delivery of the program such that it doesn't necessarily means you've been delivering it the way it should be delivered. Yes. >> So is there an an anticipated amount? What what is going to cost to be able to deliver the program the way it was intended >> to be a statewide program consistency across the board and so forth? What is that? I I think Senator, we we um what we'll do is we'll take a look at um how many students have signed up.
We we can take a look at also expanding the program. So, uh we we need some time to do a further analysis then we can get that to the committee. >> Okay. My concern is that this program has been going on for 60 years and 60 years we have no data. We we I mean according to we don't know the weight list and these are stuff that you should know because the next question is who determined the costs? Who determines the cost that we're charging the participants? >> I think that cost has been set over time. I think there's something else in it that we need to reevaluate. >> So, you've never re-evaluated the cost? >> To my knowledge? No. >> Why not? >> So, it's determined by the board of education and it's been $10 and the fees that's collected goes back into the general fund.
>> Yeah. It's middle school, right? $10. It was not 60 years ago. $10. Nothing stayed the same. 60 years ago what it is today. Not saying that we should be charging, you know, whatever it cost us to deliver the program, but the fact that one, you haven't even reviewed it to see. I mean, we review bus fairs, you you review school lunches, you review everything, but for some reason this tend I mean it seems like again what the auditor pointed out is that is it's not been taken seriously the program. I I I don't know how else to >> we'll do a re analysis, Senator. We'll do a reassessment of the charges. chair, how much how much how many students are we serving right now? >> Um I have that. Um so um when well we're still in this school year. So last school year uh we serviced 3,637 students.
Well, they enrolled and of that 2,975 students pass um the course. Do you know how many were how many wanted to take the program and couldn't for whatever reason? >> I know. And that's where the audit was helpful. We are now um looking to track that. >> You guys never thought about tracking that before. >> Well, are we starting to track though? Because we must have the weight list now, right? >> Yes, we do. >> And we we don't have some preliminary data. >> Uh I do have some preliminary data. Um so and these could be duplicate counts because a student is able to um request more than one site to um be on the list. So for uh Kawaii um for Kawaii we have there and it's it fluctuates because when it's an ongoing list so as they um open up seats for upcoming courses they could be taken off but more people add you know constantly.
So right now we have 37 for Kauaii, 95 for Maui, uh 200 for Hawaii Island, and Oahu is um fairly large. We have uh 633, but a large portion of this is because we have 171 at one of our large high schools and we're taking steps to um um partner with another instructor from another school to do the virtual part of the program. So, we're trying to bring that number down >> because part of it is it's the hard part. I'm sure you can do the in-classroom instruction fairly easily. It's it's it's behind the wheel instruction that I'm sure is a little bit more complicated. So, it's kind of like a bipation of how you got to figure this all out, right? >> Yes. So, by bringing by partnering with another school to do it virtually, then we could free up that other um instructor's time to do the behind the wheel.
Just so go ahead. >> If I can redirect uh to page 21 or if we still want to stay on the data at the appropriate time. Okay. Page 21 please of the state auditor's um report. Uh it is stated in there that a deputy superintendent who is over um this program has mentioned to have limited understanding of the program. Uh, is that deputy intendant still with us or previous deputy superintendent? >> Hi, deputy superintendent. Um, so in your in the state auditor's report, it was mentioned that you had said you had limited understanding of the program. Uh, if you have limited understanding of the program, why are you overseeing it? >> Correct. I I don't directly oversee the program, but I do oversee the office and the um conversations in the um audit here or in the audit meetings were very helpful um to grow my understanding of the details of the program.
>> Who directly oversees it? >> The assistant superintendent for the office of curriculum and instructional design. >> Who is that? >> The Terry Ushiima. >> Okay. But you're over her, right? Correct. Okay. So ultimately you oversee her who oversees the program. Okay. So it brings me to my next point where you had mentioned you had just learned that in the state auditors report that you had just learned this is a two department program. That seems pretty basic. Um did you not have understanding that this was DOE in collaboration with DOT? I did know that it was a I didn't know the details of the responsibilities of each program and that is something that the um auditor helped clarify in the audit report. There was confusion about um who was responsible for what under each department and I think that was a big finding of the auditor's report.
>> You had also mentioned that you were lacking guidance. Um who were you expecting to give you guidance being that you are the overseer? No, we were um that was referring to guidance for the driver education program um which um was one of the recommendations in the report and so we now have clear curriculum and clear um protocols for implementation. Yeah. So this is very concerning um that a deputy superintendent that's supposed to be overseeing this program has limited understanding not even knowing the basics of this is a two department program. Uh so how are we expecting to move forward if you still have the same people that are in these position overseeing these programs that are not taking initiative and being proactive in getting to know these programs. Uh and how are we going to have confidence that these are the people that are going to be helping to promote our programs?
uh make sure that there's all the checks and balances in these programs. I mean, where can we really start getting some accountability because the state auditor according to his statement is sick and tired of auditing the state the department of education. Okay. So, uh this is where we are finding oursel um not sick of it. I'm I'm not sick not sick of it. Frustrated. Frustrated. >> Um yes. Uh because because I this is where we've got to get to the root of really what this is. And time and time again the arrows are always pointing to leadership. It's always pointed to the deputy superintendent, the superintendent. So where can we start getting some hardcore accountability where people are just knowing the basics that this program is a two departmental program. I mean that sounds pretty basic. >> Thank you, Senator. Um ultimately the accountability rests with me.
Uh I I am the one that's accountable for it. Um we are we have reviewed the audit. Um we've made the um addressed the recommendations. I think uh there is definitely additional more articulation going on within the within the section uh to be sure that everyone is well aware of what the requirements are, what the driver's education program is uh and our um our um the importance of us working together with the department of transportation who has been very helpful in helping to secure the necessary certifications for employees. So is it is it not uh uh does the deputy superintendent just not take a proactive approach in learning the programs that are under her purview? >> They they are very proactive in um >> well it seems like they're not because it says here that they have limited understanding of the program >> and I and I think >> so that doesn't sound proactive.
It sounds very apathetic. they um I think in any situation um even even for me I I'll to admit uh you know I think coming into a department it's not an excuse uh but there are many programs in the department and you know it's a continuous learning even for me as a superintendent um I learn every day something new um it is my responsibility though saying that to u be able to oversee the department and the the breadth of what we have to do and the importance of it you know it is very every program is important as >> yeah these deputy positions although superintendent with all due respect this is not a learning on the job type of task >> you don't come in and then learn you learn you master it and then you come in and so maybe these deputy superintendent are just not equipped for the job >> okay if if I may senator um uh the selection of the deputy superintendent um go through a very rigorous selection and the ultimate decision is is line on who uh seats in that very important seat.
Uh the deputy superintendent that we have or we're fortunate to have working in the department right now um are very adept uh very knowledgeable in their area. Uh you know and and we'll continue to all of us to work together um to ensure that we're delivering quality programs for our students. >> Well, maybe they're too in-depth. They don't know the real ground level things. um we're finding that they're so educated maybe they're too educated to help us with very basic things that our school needs. So I'll say that. Thank you. Chair >> follow up. Is it always going to take an audit before folks understand what your responsibilities and roles are going to be? Is that is it always going to take an >> Senator? No. >> That's what appears because you know what? Yeah. You can say now that the audit made you aware, but the the reszo was introduced back in 2022.
When the a when the reszo was introduced already, you should have been looking into your program. If if you had no idea, which you should have an idea, that's why you and you have hundreds of people working for you. You have a whole slew of administrative people working for you. You know, I have during the year I have two people and during session I have two. I have four people. Four people. And I can I know more about some of your programs than you do. How is that possible? Right? I'm just saying. How is that possible? And you're asking for more people and money for more more leadership people. That worries me. I'm sorry. It it does. It worries me because in 2022 when this was introduced, I don't know how come you folks didn't say what's going on with our driver's license. You got to wait for an audit to come out to know what your responsibilities are to understand the program.
>> We I mean 60 years this program on the books. even coming to the legislature, you know, and yet I don't know. I don't understand. I I'm sorry. I I just don't understand how that's can slip you folks and not understand what the I mean, it's not like this is a a tiny little program, you know, in some school in the rural area. No, it's not. We we'll be definitely more vig vigilant in >> Is there a reason why in 2022 when the audit when the resolution was introduced that you folks didn't then say and be more aware so by the time the audit came in you could answer his questions. >> We'll be we'll be much more aware Senator of uh different resolutions that come in from the legislature. >> No, it's not >> and continue to take them seriously. folks are supposed to know your programs and if you don't when we bring this stuff up and then we have to go to a resolution but even then then that should even light the fire at that point right I mean it's not like you know I mean come on this is your program >> yes we we have started taking some steps um as we work with the auditor's office even before the final report but I understand yes we >> provide support back to him you guys didn't even respond >> even after your meeting even when you didn't know how to you didn't understand what your limited understanding.
You guys didn't even bother to write a report or or give a response. It's like thumbing your nose. Well, it definitely wasn't that. And and and we'll do better to um in the future to be more um be more responsive. >> Okay. Follow up. >> Yeah. No, I I think I think at the end of the day, this this was a good, you know, audit. I think it gave a lot of information and I understand as the person that was pushing this you guys were in a really tough position that you know the DOT was kind of micromanaging the DOE and so I think at least we have a breakthrough now and hopefully they're not micromanaging the department so I think there was some really good takeaways from this at the end of the day all we want are are you know to increase drivers education to increase enrollment I I think I think there was probably a lot of helpful things I think when we introduced this audit we didn't know that there was structural issues that you really needed to work on and so I at least now, you know, and and we can we can move forward.
So hopefully you can get those last two recommendations completed. Yes. >> Um and but but I think I have to say we we are in a far better place than we were back in 2022. We're not quite there, but I think we're in a much better place. So thank you, chair. >> Thank you. >> We are going to move to the next audit, the heat abatement audit. And let me just say part of my frustration um superintendent is that we're going to see a thread running through everything today with this next next audit. We're going to see a thread as to the DOE and the failures of of the information. And when we get to Medicaid, the same thing we're going to see that. So that's why it's just building. So when you say we're going to do better, it just worries me because it's the theme that's running through this whole thing.
I think it's >> Senator, may I ask a comment? Yes. About what you guys were talking about? I think it's important and and necessary that any state department, any program be accountable for state resources and state money. Absolutely. By the way, I never said I was tired of the deal. >> I was being dramatic, >> but I think it's very important and our job is to provide recommendations. Our suggestions is how to make them accountable, how to address the issues that we identified, meaningful recommendations. uh and the department is I guess trying to address those recommendations. I got to say both both for transportation and education the key is they need to have policies and procedures documented processes so that the people who are on the ground doing the work they know how management expects them to do that task to do that work we would call them controls in my office senator called them checks and balances you need that they need to have document processes >> I'm going to interrupt right now because you know what as instructors as educators of our students they have to do that in the classroom they have to do that with the students, they know that already.