So, I don't know why it's falling apart at the upper level when on the lower level, you got to have all of these these reports. You have to have all these policies in place, right? Or the parents are going to be up in arms or you cannot they cannot get go to college. You don't have the SAT scores if you don't have those things in place. So, it's falling apart there. So, I'm preaching to the choir. You're here because we I important. So, >> but for this it would allow the assistant superintendent, deputy superintendent to make sure that things are being done the way that they expect it to be done and they would have a process to be able to evaluate that and we would when we come back for an audit to be able to actually evaluate that process, that program, whatever they have in place.
But thank you. >> More important than that, I think the individuals in these positions should also be evaluated. And that's another thing with with board of education. Are you folks evaluating that? you know, I know you folks made some salary adjustments and stuff. Where's the evaluation and where is your evaluation of the people under you delivering the programs? So, that's important as well. So, okay. Bless. This is on report number 25-09. Auditor, an update on the Department of Education's heat abatement efforts. So for those of you out there, heat abatement, air conditioning of our schools. Okay. >> Can I share my screen again? Do I just not sure what the message I have on this? It do you we need help on this? Okay. I think it's getting >> Hi. Yes. Um, so we're just going to do the same exact thing as earlier, Mr.
Condo. >> Okay. >> Through Zoom. >> Did it not work? >> Is it working? Nope. Hold on. Okay. Mr. condo Ricky is going to go down to help you out with that. >> Why don't you start anyway? >> Okay, I'll start anyway. I don't need the slides. Um my presentation is way shorter, much shorter. And that's because so what we did is is we did a report uh a report about the uh cool classrooms initiative and as well as at the time what was the current air conditioning initiative which was school directed AC. We looked at both of those programs. Neither of those programs are in existence today. The initiative has completed or finished and the school-directed AC program, it's my understanding, has been revised and is no longer the program that schools can use to air condition their classrooms. So this report our our my discussion is much shorter uh just because those are things of the past.
um act 47 in so in in the governor governor Eay's state of the state address in early 2016 he announced that he was going to cool a thousand classrooms by the end of the year and in 2016 the legislature appropriated $und00 million to support that effort. So what we intended is we intended because we had capacity just to do a relatively quick and dirty accounting of that money. How did the department spend the hund00 million? Was there any left? How many classrooms were cooled? How successful was this initiative from the department's perspective? That's what we intended to do. We had done a similar accounting in I think it's 2017 or 2018 about the cost of the Hawaii Super Ferry to the state of Hawaii. And very interesting, at least to me, we discovered and reported that until the year 2028, the state continues to pay millions of dollars on bonds on on geo bonds that the state had issued to support the Hawaii Super Ferry, specifically for the barges and the ramps that they the state had built in the harbors.
So, we wanted to do a very similar kind of report, just a report, not an audit, to account for how the department spent 100 million. Uh, we expected it was going to be easy. We expected the department was just going to be able to provide us accounting records or some kind of spreadsheet that would show where the money went from this specific appropriation. It wasn't part of the department's general general appropriation operating budget. It was specific for air conditioning classrooms. What we found is we couldn't do that. The department couldn't provide us with the accounting of the $und00 million. they couldn't tell us where that money went and whether it was 100 million or they used some money from prior years that made it more than a h 100red million. Uh we were able we were able to get a number of different lists from the department about what classrooms what schools were were airond conditioned but those lists were not consistent.
They were different they had different classrooms different number of classrooms different schools as well as different amounts. So what we thought we were going to do to to try to determine how much was spent, we decided we wanted to go look at um at the contracts themselves, the contracts the department had executed to to facilitate this initiative to put AC in classrooms. So we went actually those documents are maintained in paper form. So we went actually to their office in Kyuki so that we could look at the boxes the contract boxes and unfortunately not all of the contract boxes were there. They were missing a number of contract boxes information in the boxes themselves were missing. For instance, we hoped to find final closeout information to see whether or not contracts had been amended, whether there had been any change orders that would have added to the cost of the project.
We could see the contracts, but we couldn't see any other documents in those in those boxes. But at the end of the day, sorry, now I have a screen. At the end of the day, wrong one. Anyway, um, it oh well. Anyway, at the end of the day, what we were able to calculate was was that uh and and by the way, we put a disclaimer in the report at the very beginning, full page, which we never do about our the lack of confidence that we have in the actual data and we explained how we ended up calculating. This was an audit, we probably wouldn't have been able to complete it. This was just a report. So, we put a big disclaimer which uh is right at the beginning of the report to explain how difficult it was for us to get information about the cool classrooms initiative.
Anyway, we we ended up uh determining that for the 100 million or maybe a little more than 100 million about 25 thou 25 million of that was spent on consultants, design consultants. We also determined that most of the AC that was installed was solar solar AC. In other words, it was not connected to the to the grid. was a separate um contained system. Solar panels directly to an inverter directly to a a split system AC unit. They were not window units. Most of them were were uh split system units that were installed. On average, including the design cost on average was about $120,000 per classroom that was cooled. So, we ended up determining based upon information that we had gathered. And we have a nice graphic in our report with the different schools that we believed were airond conditioned under the initiative with the the amounts of the design consulting costs as well as the construction costs.
And we calculated that they the department had air conditioned 838 classrooms over the state at a cost of about $105 million. That's as best as we could determine and a lot of that from our review of contract files of those boxes that I described as well as other information. We we determined also that there was a lot of maybe it was because it was rushed but there was a lot of design I want to call them errors where um contracts were entered into by the department to air condition classrooms that were already air conditioned that air conditioning was installed or PV panels were installed on um and most of these were installed in in um temporary what I want to call them portable units portable classrooms some of these are very old 60 years old or maybe even long older. Um and the reason for that it was much quicker for the department to install in those in those classrooms because the classroom the structure of the classroom it's a contained unit wooden structure generally so they could easily more easily install the PV panels on the top and install the air conditioning the ventilation in those units not the most most um insulated type of classrooms a lot of leakage so at the end of the day we we identified where where these uh panels were installed um under big banyan trees.
Nobody said anything. We talked to the people at Castle High School and they questioned why the contractor went ahead and installed them. We question we talked to other principles at other schools. They questioned why AC was installed in certain classrooms when other classrooms really needed AC, not the ones that they were installed in. Uh they were installed at Moapu and I saw an article recently the new Moapu Elementary School has been has been built and dedicated. they were installed at Moapu Elementary even though even knowing the school was was destined to be destroyed and rebuilt. Um, so there was a lot of errors in how the department implemented this mandate or this initiative, Governor Eay's initiative uh to get to a thousand classrooms by the end of the the calendar year. Uh, at the end of the day, our challenge was we couldn't see any records.
There was many people in the department that were involved in the initiative who are no longer there. One person who was the primary person, he retired and he passed away. So in addition to the fact that there were no records for us to review to understand what the department did, how the department spent the money, there was no one for us to talk to. And I think that's really the big takeaway from this is the department needs to keep records. The department needs to do better recordkeeping. They need to develop these procedures. we don't have any understanding is the criteria as to how classrooms were selected, how schools were selected for installation of AC units. So I think that's the big takeaway for the committee is the department needs to improve its recordkeeping. It needs, like I said earlier with respect to driver education, they need to develop documented processes, these controls, these checks and balances so that people that are doing the work that that they they they can do it to make sure they achieve the mission or the purpose of of the department or whatever that program is that their supervisors up to the superintendent.
They can make sure the work is being done in a way that they expect it to be done to achieve that purpose or that mission. And then the supervisor can make sure by looking at what they're doing, documentation of that process to make sure the person who's responsible is actually doing it the way that they expect it to do. And of course, when we come in to audit, we can actually audit that process. We can see the records. We can see the documented processes. So to me, that's that's what the department needs to do. 100 million, it's passed. It's gone. But without documentation, we don't know how it was spent. The department needs to be more accountable. I know that we're well at all this. It's okay. It's okay. Okay. And then real quick with cool school directed AC. So the department took a huge pivot before the Okay.
The um Okay, you got to put full screen or do that slide. It's fine. Turn slide. Thank you. Thank you. So this is the graphic I was talking about that that we have in our report. It's nice looking graphic. It tells you a lot of the information per school. uh and island about uh where AC was installed, the cost of design as well as the cost of construction for those schools. Picture of Castle High School where they installed the um the PV panels under this big banyan tree. So the the production from those panels must be very limited just because it's under shade for most of the day. moving to uh school directed AC, the department took a big pivot in moving from um the cool classrooms initiative or just generally how they were air conditioning classrooms under CIP money where it was department controlled.
The department controlled the construction. They executed contracts to install AC. The big pivot was they went to this school directed AC where they put the responsibility to air condition classrooms on the schools themselves. individual schools now had the ability under this different program to air condition their own classrooms. And it was generated or maybe it came about because there were some reports about parents and student uh organizations dropping off air conditioners at schools because students were complaining about how hot their classrooms were. So, it was an opportunity for for schools to be able to to uh install those window units. And they were window units, not they were people weren't like be dropping off the split systems. it was window units and it was an opportunity for them to be able to install those AC without having it be a departmentwide effort. So what happened is the department uh issued or the the assistant superintendent deputy superintendent at that time sorry the assistant superintendent at the time he issued this memo which created this program very little detail to the program it's just this one memo that provides some information about this new program and the concept of this program was that in exchange for um the so what the department really wanted to do which is kind An interesting side story, the department doesn't have or at least when we spoke to them when we started this audit, they didn't have an accurate inventory of classrooms that had AC, which seems really odd to me that these are your buildings, Department of Education.
You can't tell me which classrooms, which schools, and which classrooms in those schools have AC. No, we don't know. And I was told or we were told by the deputy superintendent at that time that and I don't remember his title but somebody else that was also very involved in in this area. Um that the principles school principles kind of dictated their own it was kind of like their own kingdom. If they asked uh they didn't if the department asked the principal sometimes wouldn't respond. And the example that had been raised to us is the department wanted to install PV panels above a parking lot at a school. The department owns the school. The department pays the energy bill, but the principal said no. The principal said no. And we see that all over the place. We see that in some of the DOE um offices where they have the PV panels, which is great.
It provides shade, but it generates energy. But we were told in that school, the principal said no. So that was the big question was what's the inventory? So this program was intended to help the deter to help the department gain that in inventory understand what classrooms at what schools had AC. So in exchange for that what the department was offering these schools that went through this school directed AC program is they were offering the department a free electrical assessment may cost, we were told, up to $10,000. It was really to assess whether or not the school or specifically the buildings where they wanted to install AC, whether the electrical system could handle that additional electrical load. If it can't, there could be serious safety issues, short circuits, maybe even fires, we were told. But that was the the carrot. It was to incentivize schools to participate in this program, report their inventory of AC in exchange for this service that the department was going to pay for for the electrical assessment at the schools.
Uh we had trouble understanding what schools participated in this. the website that we were given. I'm sorry, I'm just talking about the without the PowerPoint at this point, but we were struggling to to understand which schools had participated, what the inventory was, how recently that inventory had been updated. Uh we were given first a dead website and then later on a live website, but even that website, it didn't seem like every school was inputting the the information, the active inventory, the current inventory, and they were inputting it different ways. Again, it gets back to my point about you need to have some control. You need to have some procedure, some process so everyone does it the same way so that you can understand that this is this is you know this school and this school we can compare the apples to the apples and not an apple to the orange.
But anyway, so my long thing here is again this program got scrapped. We were told at the end of our audit that this program was no longer being no longer a current program and the program was being revised to something else where the schools now would lose some of the control over their AC where contractors were now going to be the contracts with contractors to install any kind of AC units or any kind of other work relating to these AC units were now going to be th those contracts were going to be procured and entered into by the department. So, it took some of the control or maybe a lot of the control out of the school and put it back into the department to to deal with contracts to to deal to to relating to ACing classrooms. I'm not saying that's a bad thing given that perhaps that challenge of of procuring of procuring um contractors that process it's not easy and perhaps maybe the expertise is not at the school level.
I'm not sure exactly how things were done at the school level to install window units, but the window units that were installed, by the way, the cost per unit was maybe about $5,000. We reported, and I'm sorry, I don't have the slide right here right now, but it was about $5,000 per unit in contrast or in comparison to the split systems that were done under the school directed, sorry, under the cool classrooms initiative that pencled out to about 120,000 per classroom. So there's a significant difference in in the um in the cost to air conditioning classrooms under the school initiative class school classrooms initiative and the school directed AC AC program. I'm sorry that's all I really wanted to talk about. I just think that we didn't offer recommendations. These are it was just a report but uh at the end of the day the department is really not accountable for that money and they need to be better account more for that that money.
100 million is a lot of money. Where it went, how it was spent, uh the process they went through to ensure that they were spending it reasonably and responsibly. That needs to be documented. And that was my point initially about the cool classrooms initiative. No documentation. They need to document better. >> I have a follow-up question. Page 23, you state from the start, many of the solar AC systems failed or didn't work properly, resulting in a salvage effort with an estimated cost between 3.3 to$6 million. The troubleshooting team dispatched by DOE would later discover that from the start, many of the solar AC systems failed or didn't work properly. They noted that contractor's final inspections found obvious installation issues such as missing insulation, exposed wires, and other issues, but were not able to identify many of the hidden PV and battery problems. The troubleshooting team also found air conditioners that were damaged by geckos or rodents which contractors and contract contract managers considered act of god damages which they were not obligated to repair.