2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 107
They also found fundamental issues that could have been addressed during the design and planning stage. So all of this >> I I think that um the department's challenge and partly I'm speculating I think they also told us some of this that uh they there was not one contractor or one manufacturer that could provide all of the installation of AC. So they distributed the work through many different contractors using many different types of equipment. And because of that lack of any kind of standardization, so to speak, there was some challenges with who was installing, how it was installed, and the equipment that was installed. The other big challenge is many of the classrooms weren't cool. They went the the parameters for the AC, it was something like 75 to 78° or something like that. And teachers may not have been aware of that. and they're trying to run the AC to cool their classrooms well below that that that parameter of 75 or 78 degrees or whatever it was.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 108
Uh and to your point, Senator, I know you called it the AC thing, but the response was by one of the consultants is this is heat abatement. It's not AC. So, it's to reduce the heat in the classrooms, >> you know. And then we also report in our report about challenges where the department decided they were going to seal jealousy windows in the portable classrooms so that they could keep the cool air inside better. But you know that also created a very hot environment when the AC wasn't on like in the evenings or after school. So it became a very hot classroom. We also have an MK Think study commissioned or paid for by the Department of Education where they comment about the air quality when you close up these these uh portable classrooms where the carbon monoxide level or carbon dioxide level, excuse me, gets to the point where it could impair learning, impair cognitive thinking.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 109
So there are a lot of challenges in what the department did and I would suggest it's because there was a rush a rush to spend $100 million within this very short amount of time and maybe even more than hund00 million. >> Thank you. >> So I think at the end of the day we have very few of these units that continue to work in the way that you'd expect them to work. Many of them are dying. You know the warranties or the lifespan of not only units but also the PV panels but maybe more importantly the batteries that were installed. they're reaching the end of that lifespan life cycle or lifespan and I think some now are getting plugged into the wall into the grid and you know you I don't know we report about it too but there's also another law that the legislature enacted that same year that requires the department to be net energy zero by a certain time very quick very very soon if not now um very challenging when you're sticking in AC into the wall without taking out a bunch of other kind of electrical loads that that likely are present isn't in classrooms.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 110
>> Anyway, thank you. >> So, so the numbers you quote in the audit, those are best guesstimates then because you couldn't get >> Yes. >> on concrete data. So, that 108 whatever that's >> 103 that's that's the best that you could come up with >> based upon looking at files and things. There's other numbers that we that got we report some of them. They get tossed out but we're not confident. >> Got it. Got it. Thank you. So chair um before >> uh with the new website um it looks like it requires a login. How did you get the login? >> Oh well we requested and they gave us a login. It was first to a website that was not active and then they gave us another login to the active site. But I'm not sure we haven't logged in since we issued the report.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 111
So I'm not sure it's still the active site. >> Okay. And then at at the time when you did log in, it was outdated data information. >> It's inconsistent data. Some schools seem to be current and other schools seem not to be current in terms of their inventory. And I think we know that because we feel like there's some schools that got sent or or AC through cool classrooms initiative and we don't see those classrooms identified in the website that you're referring to senator where the schools are required or supposed to report their inventory. So according to your report uh you can't quantify or prioritize where these AC's were put in what districts in what schools. >> I think we did a good job. I think we did our best and that's that chart um in our report to identify you know where where the where the department put the air conditioning.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 112
So we identify, you know, by by island schools on each island where we saw contracts relating to AC under what we think is the initiative funding. Is that what you're asking me, Senator? Yes, >> that is. Thank you, >> Chair. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Superintendent. >> Granted, you were not here in 2016. Uh but you know, I'm sure there's people on your staff that were here. Um and I understand that um you know you took over in 2022 so but still this issue um remains as a concern. I am pleased that you did respond who did send a response in um to this audit and you didn't address many of the issues. However, uh the main one of the documents and the contracts and the number of schools that have air conditioning, but you did say that the department had already initiated proactive measures to enhance procedures for the school directed air conditioning.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 113
Oh, Gren, I wish I would want to know what was initiated um prior to them concluding their audit, which is what you stated in your honor. >> Thank you, Senator. Um joining me, Deputy Superintendent of Operations, Jesse Suki. Um Senator for for um to your question one of the proactive measures was uh the department the state office did um from the uh school initiated ACS um in institute a process where now schools would work with the office of facilities and operations um to request uh uh AC's whether they're going to put ACs or not and I think that was that was in response to uh department facilities and operations being able to really assess and get a better handle on where our AC's are um and uh what what else needed to be done to get based on analysis. But deputy Suki if you want to add anything else.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 114
>> Well, let me ask this first. Is there still a school directed AC program? >> There's a it's been modified. >> It's been Yes. And what it's called is it called that? >> It's still the same thing though. Yes. >> And how long has you have this modified program? >> Is it two years? The memo memo went out in January 2025 to all complex superintendent and principles and then the follow-up guidance was um sent around uh is dated November 5th. >> 2025. >> Yeah. >> So one year >> November >> January no what one you said in January 2005 you sent the memoir. Oh, January 29, 2025, there were a memo about the procedural changes and talking about what the SDAC new program would be and then the guidance after that that really went into detail about what needs to be done and the process.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 115
Yeah, it's November. >> So, very very recent. >> Um, so you never provided the list of schools that participate in the school AC program. According to the auditor, he never got that list. So, so are you attempting to get that list or are you >> We have a list. We have a list. >> Was that list given to the auditor? >> I I don't think we did we send it over. We didn't send it over, but if >> when did you when did you finally compile this list? >> I I I started five months ago, but I asked for it and we we have a list. U it shows all the u it shows where the money was spent. It shows um what schools it was at. Um all of the money that was under act the the um hund00 million act 47. Um it's it's accounted for in in our um fiscal management system.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 116
So we know where the money was spent and what for and we have a list of schools. >> So you came on just about the time that this letter was written for the audit. >> September. Yeah. >> Yeah. So the the letter is dated August 1st. Um how many how many architects remind me that you folks have in your me facility? We talked about this in the >> engineer. Yes, we talked about that right in the >> uh 24 positions share architects and engineers. Um >> okay, because we asked this question in field >> we asked this this question in resumes. >> Yes, sorry I I took notes after you asked. So 34 architects and engineer A&E 24 engineers 10 are architects. >> Okay. Well, thank you for taking notes and and looking at because I'm concerned on page nine and I've said this before.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 117
Yeah, I sound like a broken record. I'm concerned about the number of consultants we hire, the number of of um apps we rely on or department relies on. And on this page there were seven design consultants for the 25.3 million which I think the auditor did mention. And under this Miller Kelly architects architects we have architects but we had to hire these architects and they're not the only one. We also hired Pacific architects. Um and then it's 5.3 million but on the bottom it says DOE would end up shelving much of MK tank multi-prong conceptual framework for cooling classrooms as bids for installation expensive solar AC system classroom consumed its 100 million budget 25 million I mean 5.3 million just down and yet we have all these architects and then why why do we have architects if we're going to hire all It was a hundred million and this this is just me like reviewing all of the materials and trying to figure out the same question.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 118
Uh a hundred million in a very short period of time. >> That's what the question is. >> But the contractors help deploy the money because it's a lot to do in a short period of time. I so >> still do that to to this day that we brought that up in WHAM. You still hire architects. We have all the contracts that we went through in WHAM. all the architects, all the engineering firms, and yet you still have them on staff. And I understand that some of them are doing um what um overseeing work, right? They oversee the projects, right? Project management work. But then you hire a consultant to do project management. And then so the architects and engineers that license oversee the overseer. >> And I've brought this up before and it's like here in writing all of this money being spent. And I I have a hard time understanding that >> we we are trying and looking at we are looking at it's one of the um deliverables we have for our strategic plan to look at how um we handle our contractors and to sort of reduce our reliance on them.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 119
But having at least some contractors helps us deploy CIP some contractors. Yes. But it seems like that's the standard because so for some reason after you hire state workers be it architects engineers I I think they are afraid to maybe do the work because they don't want to they don't want to get audited they I don't know what it is so it's easier to hire a consultant and you're not the only one DOT does it all the time at the airports we even had engineering from these companies would sit at the desk on the seventh floor of DOT And if you walked in, you wouldn't know who was the who was the consultant and who was the the worker. And they since stopped that because we kept harping on it. But these are the kinds of things that goes on in state government. So it's either or.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 120
You either hire all these cons uh architects and engineers and they do the drawings and they do this stuff or you hire out. And there are going to be times when you're going to need some outside help, but it shouldn't be the norm. Or we don't need them. Hire project managers and hire them all out. Contract them all out. Right. I mean, it's we've got to look at that. So, I hope you folks will >> I don't want to have to do an audit on that, but I'd like for you folks to to look at that. >> Yes. >> Okay. I have other questions, but I will go ahead questions. >> Yeah. Uh, with regards to the Castle High School, um, you folks put in an AC, solar AC in the classroom that was sitting under the banyan tree, the monkey pod tree, and now the department is because it doesn't, the sunlight doesn't hit the solar panels because of the monkey pod tree.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 121
Uh, now the department is actually having to pay to cut the trees so that the sun can hit the AC. So, how much is that costing the departments? that kind of maintenance. So, you see how mistakes have consequences and now this is an ongoing issue that the department is going to have to continue to use funds, taxpayer funds to pay for this maintenance. It's like you guys are forcing this thing to work and you're putting it in places that basic common sense says it's a cooled classroom. It's under a monkey pod tree where your DOE architect even said and I quote, "This is a very rushed project." A very rushed project. So >> we senator um Oh, I understand your point. um how uh that particular portable was selected for um for the solar AC in in the Kuya classroom project. Uh um I I I'm sorry but I'm not able to share why why that happened and what else why that particular classroom was selected during that time.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 122
>> Terry, are you able to comment? >> Oh, sorry. >> Oh, me? Yeah, Jesse. >> Jessie. Jessie. >> Sorry. You're Terry. >> Thank you. >> No, I I I was I was just going to say that um I agree with what you just said in the auditor. It was a rush project because the money lapsing was a very short period of time and a lot all at once. >> But isn't that the being the norm? You folks get all this money for CIP in a short period of time. You can't spend it all and that's why we have such a encumbered funds that are sitting there. You cannot build 12 schools. You only built what? Three schools. I mean it's like it it's a norm. So >> I think chair um we appreciate the support from the legislature and we've shifted from uh the process to lump sum buckets for defer maintenance in in those different areas.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 123
We do >> and so and so that that actually provides us with the flexibility to prioritize projects that need to be done. So we appreciate the the legislature supporting that. >> Yeah, that that that has helped a lot. And we do have, you know, the the schools, uh, you know, they're either in design, uh, you know, waiting for construction money or, um, you know, we're asking for design money to get them moving. Uh, but, you know, they're not just city, >> and we Sorry, Glenn. >> More troubling than even that for me is the fact that documentations are missing, contracts are missing. You guys don't know. you guys don't have the don't don't know know how much money was spent. I mean how can you guys manage a hundred million dollars of the taxpayers and not have the documentation to me that is 101. >> So I I I'm very troubled by that because again it seems to be a pattern.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 124
Um >> so so that was concerning to hear that and read that. Uh I did you look at and see that we have tracked all of the expenses for this uh 100 million. We spent about 98 million and about uh so when you were out I asked them if they had the information if they know how many classrooms they said they did all of this but they haven't submitted the report to you a report to you. So um >> was not employed at the time we did this >> right. No, but just recently >> they asked many times. Okay. And we got no thumbnail that the deputy superintendent is representing. He has. We did not get. >> Yes. No, but I'm saying they said they have it now. So hopefully you'll get it. So can you guys send that? >> Move on. And I want to clarify.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 125
I didn't say the money would lapse. I said it was rushed probably because there was an initiative by the government. >> Somebody said it would lapse >> or superintendent said the rush would because the funds would lapse. That's right. I said I wasn't implying but they would lapse it was because there was a initiative to meet 100,000 classrooms by the end. >> Well yeah it was a great political statement >> right but not laps >> and there was a laps in concern as well. So it's both of those things. >> So so for your so I don't you know it's great that you found all those documents. I I don't know did you always have it all all the time or not? I you know they just it was uh not easy to retrieve because they were in these boxes but >> you couldn't find the box.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 126
So the boxes were missing. >> They have them. It's need to be needs to be retrieved >> or did they just not want you to give it >> storage? >> So so I guess so so how okay so so moving forward I hope we don't have boxes. I hope it's you know so hopefully digital at this point. If I may on that point, yes. U one of the changes that they've made at OFO is to digitize all of their documents and keep them, you know, files, digital files. >> Okay. So, and I assume the the login that he logged into and there was couldn't get any info. I I assume that's updated as well because I think what we really need to understand is are you guys actually and we had this conversation wh are you guys actually using that software to truly track projects now?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above