2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 127
So >> because it's no sense to have the database and then you you don't use it, right? Because I think this is a good example of why you'd want to track it. So at least if you get audited or somebody makes an inquiry, you can easily well we could even follow along, right? So we don't have to call you and you send us a spreadsheet every time. We could just go on and see where our project's at, right? >> Yeah. I I don't know the status of the outward facing but I know that internally they do use um the the uh CPT to log in these projects as as part of the school directed air conditioning project workflow and it's tracked that way through the process. I I get the air condition, but I'm talking about this. This is just an example of your greater CIP projects that we are very very concerned about, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 128
Because it's really hard for us to track, right? People on the ground tell us one thing, we go up the chain and it's a whole different story. And so, you know, I think if if we follow the this air conditioning audit, they're they're telling you all the systematic things that you should be changing. And I think it it applies to a lot of other areas in the DOE for with with in terms of facilities. And so I think we're just trying to understand moving forward what have you guys corrected but I I don't know like you're not giving us a good understanding of okay this is the things that we've implemented since then right is the you're not giving us that the the online system is working so okay we don't know if the tracking is actually working you know are you are you empowering other people to to to do you know things at the school level like the people that could have caught right are you empowering them to say stop stop the project because we don't think that's in a good location just like the transformer at W Luke Elementary.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 129
I don't know why people somebody didn't catch that before but you know you put in the wrong location and now year two years later we still waiting right and so I I think those are the systematic things that we need to understand that you've actually corrected because of this audit right and that's the purpose of an audit we just we trying to get better but you got to pitch to us >> what is it that we've done to to get better >> so one of the so I keep pointing to this but this this is the guidance and one of the important things about the guidance and I think part of what you're saying is people who have to implement this like principles and casses they have to know about Right. And so HOFU has been going out and training on this which came out in November.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 130
>> But that's just for air condition, right? >> But it's for other projects too. >> It's all project. >> Yeah. Yeah. We have we have um larger projects in here too. Yeah. And so for the ACs, if it's a window AC, not a split system um it doesn't trigger um certain things. The money's there, then it goes through this kind of fasttrack. But if it's not, then it goes into our um larger project. So, so is there a system if they feel like they need something at their school, can they log it somewhere so at least it goes up the chain? Because I think that's why a lot of the the the principles were trained. Okay, you there's nowhere to input it for the DOE. So, go ask your legislator, right? And then you got you got upset because we're putting in too many line items.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 131
So, now we're giving you a pot. But everyone needs to understand what is the process. And if so, if we don't know what the process is, I would like to see what my principles are asking for. So, at least you got to be sharing what that information is, right? So we don't have that data though. There is no input of you can request a project because there's that need at the school. >> Well, what they can what there's a way to track in this process that we have these projects. But I think what we're talking about now is funding, right? So if there's no funding, then >> well, but but we got to understand what the need is, right? Because part of it is I don't know how you calculate your RNN backlogs, you know, because what data are you using and how old is that data, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 132
And so so part of it is if you're not transparent with the data, it's hard for us somebody to verify like the auditor is saying, right? >> Yeah. We can we are working on providing a list of projects that are priorities. >> Yeah. This is a single >> I can page 38. A new website and old problem. The school directed AC program project tracking website called CPT which stands for CIP project tracker was intended to enable DOE to track projects including schools air conditioning inventory. Yet when they visited the site in April of 2024 it appeared to be inactive and during a April 24th meeting DOE officials confirmed to us that the site was dead describing it as rendering of a site and said said it should be taken down. However, a few weeks after the meeting with DOA officials, the site was populated with large collection of data that appeared to have been uploaded over a short period of time, including attachments as such, but suddenly the present information appeared to be of little value.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 133
So, it is this project has this project been tracker been taken down or has you folks fixed it or what have you done with it? I can say and internally with the way we track projects we also use CPT that is working. Um >> so this is updated and working >> as far as the web the public facing side I would have to ask it is version two is up and >> when did that get up and running? >> When did that get >> what? No it's not working. >> No it's not the CPT2. >> Yeah 2.0 2.0 which requires a login. >> Okay. >> Our access was not to the public. It was to the DOE. That's why it required it was to the DOE's internal access. >> So this 2.0 website that's in your report. >> Pretty certain it was to the DOE internal access.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 134
It's not a public facing >> but it's still not but it still has >> I just clarified that it wasn't a public facing database. That's why we required access login access from the >> but they did say the site was dead right. >> Yes. >> To be taken that. So is this site similar to design build jobs tracker? resign bill job tracker that >> I used to try to track my CIPs in my district which I brought up to Audrey about this and I was told that the system is also not active or working or >> Yeah, I'm not I I'm not familiar with that one. That's different. They say >> it's on your website. They somebody directed me to this. We looked it up. We went on as you can see this was a Monaloa um project and that one had no update and this one is Khali Wenna last updated 5212025 I went on um on that date or right after that date and all it has on here was the amount $150,153 and it has Kevin Mory is the contact and there's nothing else fill in and I brought it up.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 135
I brought it up to Audrey. I brought it up to Jenine. I think that what they saying, "Oh, that we don't we don't update this." I'm like, "Then what the hell is it doing?" >> Yeah, that could be one of our that's one of our legacy systems possibly. I I will look into that. >> We can't. No. Okay. Thank you for looking into it. But the problem is you have all these systems. Nobody's paying attention to it. Nobody's updating it. It's we can't get information. I asked for information. You give me two different sets. In 2023, you gave me a whole set. I asked for the same update. I gave a whole different set. It It's not even consistent. I don't know. I don't know what you folks how you keeping track of your own projects if you cannot even give it to us and we ask for it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 136
>> We we're we're working on that request for that for the projects for you. Uh I I this book came up a year almost a year ago and still nothing nothing and I don't know Kevin my I don't is he supposed to update this? There's no meeting scope. There's no um start date. There's no preliminary design received. There's no final design. There's no permit submitted. Nothing. It's all blank. It's all blank. Every single except for the amount and the name of the person. >> Sure. Same thing for Mona Law project. Same thing. >> My apologies for that. If u give us an opportunity to get together and we can come back and present to you and share um a system that uh is up and running. >> Superintendent, how many times do I have to bring it up with your staff before we get I have to come to a hearing, bring this up and and and embarrass people before we're going to get any kind of update or fixing or answers.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 137
I I don't like to do this and I don't know where the board of education is if they're not reviewing some of these kind of things. And that's why I wanted the board to be here because my question goes back to the board. What are you folks doing as far as following up? >> Yeah, >> that's their one and only role. I have how many other roles? This is not my one and only ro committee I I I chair, but yes, I sit on all these other committees. chair. Um it again it falls to me to be sure that these things are up and running. If you give us an opportunity to regroup and we can come back and share back with the committee um an update. >> Yeah. Because you know my issue with with Khalena the bridge you folks went in and asked for it and said all the health and safety and then you folks went and lapsed it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 138
>> Yeah. And did not let anybody know about the lapsing and then you got because you folks said you didn't know that the city owned it. Come on. after 3 years of the project, you didn't know that the city owned it. That again, that it just boggles my mind. >> I I think the bottom line is, you know, just just from this audit and I I told you this in person, superintendent, but I I think the committee just needs a clear strategy of where we're going with facilities, right? I think I think you know their conditioning thing that was before your time fine but I think moving forward it's still not perfect right I I think we I've expressed my own frustrations you know the chair is not the only person who has issues with CIP projects in our district and we only ask because at the end of the day the people that you know we care about you they're concerned about it right I think I'm trying to get a transformer installed and it's just like an act of Congress to get everything moving right and and so I think that's that is is very difficult but I think what we need to understand it that there's hope that there's there's we're moving in a direction that we understand what the strategy parts are that all the all the small pieces that are going to we're going to see something that's much more successful.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 139
We're not going to have something like the the 100 million we can't account for. But I think I think we haven't heard that yet. I think that that's why it worries me. I think the board when I I told you in wh members what their strategy is, they don't know what the strategy is. I think every single member of that board needs to understand what is the strategy in facilities. We have to all be going in the same direction. And I so I hope you folks can articulate that very very clearly. >> Thank you Senator and that would be incumbent on me to ensure that that is in strategy is in place so that um I'm able to share with the board what that is. So that that's on me. So I'll take responsibility for that and we'll we'll do better. >> If we can go to page 15 of the report.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 140
Um, it says here at the bottom, oh, let me see. A media report at the time, which was based on DOE procurement documents, found that the highest per classroom bid came in at $360,770, which was to install a solar AC in one portable classroom at Eva Beach Elementary. $360,770 for one one solar AC system. Where are these numbers coming from? >> Page 15. >> Was it 15 or five? >> 15. >> Sorry. You know, you're asking me. >> Yeah. Well, I was actually asking intending it for DOE because you you were >> I'm not sure the question about where are they coming from is what you're asking because we report we got it out of a media article the $360,770 for that one class. >> We don't know where they got >> So, I'm asking where that number came from. >> I think it came from I don't think they >> Yeah, I don't know where the media got that from, but we can we can see if we can >> Okay, let me just move on to my next >> chair.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 141
we can move on. Um, for the classrooms that were enclosed with plexiglass, what is your solution to remedy that because uh there's a large number of classrooms in my district that are sweltering in their classrooms with no AC and now no ventilations because the jealousies have been plexiglassed. >> Um, Senator, if you can let me know what schools they'll be high school. >> Okay, we we'll take a look at that. Um the schools that I do know of, uh plexiglass was installed inside of the classroom, but uh they were installed with those um those clips that can rotate. So those plexiglass the glasses could be removed, but if it's uh if it's permanent, then uh we will definitely take a look at high school. >> Yeah, it's permanent. It cannot be removed and so it's making it uncomfortable for the students and also for the teacher.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 142
It's very hot conditions. Anything else? >> Uh, yes, sorry. Uh, page 25, uh, the DOE repair log registered nearly 1,800 requests for air conditioning maintenance from 2018 to 2024. With the 10,00 AC initiative, how are we logging in a repair log of 1,800 requests? Is this just multiple repairs on one AC? it it does cost money to maintain AC's. Um if it's a school initi initiated AC then um they maintain it. If it's the PV AC's that was um done with the act 47 money then and then then we'll go and maintain it when they put a request in and and we'll we'll maintain it that way. We have a tracking system for repair maintenance. Yeah. >> Okay. If you could share that with us. I mean again I think we could avoid a lot of these re really difficult moments with just transparency, clarity, but then also response time is very important.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 143
Like I think we could have gotten through half halfway through with the driver's license um briefing had you had just responded in a quicker amount of time to the state auditor and then also giving us the information that we need as well. So thank you. Thank you. check. Can you give us a report on what is it going to cost as these batteries um die out as these systems, the ones that were put in under the $und00 million and those all age out? What What are we going to do? What's the plan? How are you going to keep the these classrooms cool? >> We're actually looking at that issue now as they sort of come of age. Right now, we we're maintaining them. Um you probably have about a couple years more where we have to make tough decisions about them. Um >> well, you're not going to wait till the the couple years come.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 144
I mean, we want >> Yeah. Yeah. >> We want to know what the plan is, right? And what the cost is. One of the things that I hope that DOE and the board will do is as we add programs and as we add personnel and positions and so forth, what is the overall impact to the state budget? And I don't think we we look at that. We look at in a vacuum, you know, early education, early child care, all of that put together, charter schools, what is the impact? Because already DOE education takes up one-third of the budget. As we continue to add on programs, it's going to take up more and more and and then sustaining that and then like now I don't think it's in the budget on how to sustain the hund00 million or air conditioning or whatever it is we put in or didn't put in, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 145
and what happens when they get old and we have to recycle them now. So that inherent cost is going to be very impactful. So I hope you folks are looking at that and as you come forward as you ask for your your budget and CIPs that you folks are mindful and you present it to us as to these are costs that's down the road that we can't kick the can down the road continuously. So just to just to summarize basically putting things in context and and just the two audits you know in the driver's education report you know there was a lack of leadership allowed at the lower level specialists to hijack the program in the heat abatement staff departures and rush planning led to chaos DOE couldn't count the money in the heat abatement DOE couldn't count the student demand in driver's education the auditor describes the heat abatement project as a $und00 million disaster and the driver education program as structurally incomplete.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 146
So, has a single DOE administrator, contractor, or decision maker been disciplined at all, held financially liable for any of these failures? And if the answer is no, which I suspect it is, how can you assure this body that the next hund00 million appropriation won't suffer the same fate? a lot a lot of the leaderships not here from or people who worked on the heat abatement but also I would have asked could you give us a few years to spend the money instead of just one so we could plan it out >> understand but I'm just saying that the structure of the DOE that's in place >> whether the ch bodies change but there are some bodies that are here you know long time I've been here a long time and so you know it's not just because that special individual something is not right with the structure and the oversight >> systemically.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above