2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 147
>> Yes. And and and and you know documents and and recordkeeping and so forth the basics somewhere along the line there's a disconnect. So how can we have the confidence and that's I think what what we want to know. We want to move forward but it's hard to have the confidence because the same things happen again and again. So that's something to think about as we go forward, as we go into the session, as we address bills that going to come and some of the bills may be addressing the very things we're talking about because again, the trust is not there. So we got to pass a law, right? And even we passed the law 60 years, the law never wasn't wasn't implemented the way it was intended. Okay. Okay. So with that, we are going to move to the last item on the agenda.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 148
Believe it or not, we still have one more item on the agenda. Uh so the Medicaid reimbursements, as you guys transition here, uh focuses on a critical but often overlooked issue. The Hawaii Department of Education's failure to fully and consistently draw down on available Medicaid reimbursements for services already being provided to eligible students. Medicaid reimbursements is not a discretionary funding. It is federal money owed to the state for qualified health related services delivered in our public schools. These include services such as speech therapy, occupational therapy, physical therapy, behavior health support and nursing services for students with disabilities. I know it sounds like it we're this is a health health uh committee and it's not. It's it's education. So there's been this colliding of of responsibilities and I think sometimes put at the detriment of our schools and our teachers. It's very difficult because that's not what they signed up for.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 149
But they now have these responsibilities. But in the case of the Medicaid reimbursements, you know, year after year, we've been leaving some federal millions of federal dollars possibly on the table. When we compare Hawaii to other states, the contrast is stark. States with similar or smaller student populations routinely draw down two to three times more Medicaid reimbursements per student than Hawaii. Many have invested in proper billing systems, staff training, inter agency coordination, and compliance infrastructure to ensure that they capture the full federal match. And Hawaii has just not kept pace. This is especially troubling because the legislature continues to appropriate state general funds to cover these services. The services are already being delivered. Medicaid reimbursement could directly offsate state costs and reinvest resources back into our schools. So in short, this is not about expanding programs. It's about basic financial stewardship. So today, we hope the department will explain why Hawaii's reimbursement rates lag so far behind other states, what barriers the administrative staffing or system related have prevented full participation, how much federal funding has been foregone over the past several years, and what concrete steps are being taken with timelines to fix this problem.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 150
Because at the time when every dollar public dollar matters, failure to claim available federal funds is really not acceptable. So, our students really deserve a lot more and our school needs the resources and our taxpayers need the accountability. So, with that, Superintendent, I know we've talked about this. So, >> thank you, Chair. Um, joining me is Deputy Superintendent Heidi Armstrong, uh, who will be sharing about the, uh, Medicaid reimbursement. >> Sure. I I'll provide an update on the department's Medicaid reimbursement process. Um, I um am hopeful that I'll outline or to be able to outline clearly the Medicaid claiming pause of which we which we did have to take the compliance steps that are underway and the plan to resume and expand claiming so that you that the department can appropriately access federal funds to offset state costs for required health related services. So the the department um was claiming for um a limited number of services from about 2019 to 2020 um 23 but in November 2023 the Medicaid reimbursement section identified a critical error in the department's electronic record system and this system failed to act accurately report the ratio of nursing services provided to students.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 151
The system defaulted to a one:1 ratio when in actuality um some of the nurses were serving multiple students. But our system was not able to accurately record that and that led to improper claiming at a higher reimbursement rate that than should have been been allowed. So when the Medicaid section caught that, they halted nursing reim reimbursement until the system could be modified because that's what needed to be done. The department continued to seek reimbursement for administrative claiming and worked to restart the direct service claiming and in this case it was nursing. In January 2025, MedQuest, who is our partner um from DHS and they are our state Medicaid provider, halted the Medicaid of Medicaid administrative claiming processing. This was due to compliance concerns regarding provider eligibility and federal guidance that disallows the administrative claiming process unless the direct service claiming um is continued. was also conducted.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 152
So later that year, MedQuest provided the department with a guide to school-based services that outlines the requirements and expectations for direct service and administrative claiming. In May 2025, the department submitted its timestudy implementation plan for Medicaid administrative claiming to MedQuest to meet the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services compliance deadline of June 30, 2026. In November 2025, the department was informed by MedQuest si to submit a quality assurance plan that aligned with the office of the inspector general standards before any claims can be submitted for direct or administrative services. The department has submitted a corrective action plan to MedQuest to address past non-compliance and has engaged a consultant to consult to um conduct a comprehensive risk assessment and gap analysis on gap analysis on all Medicaid reimbursement activities conducted by the department. This report will create the scope of work and implementation roadmap for the department's quality assurance plan as required by MedQuest.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 153
The department is working closely with MedQuest to reser to resume direct service claiming for select nursing services by March of this year. Expanded direct service claiming is projected to resume on or before January 27. Thank you for the opportunity to share the update and the proposed um timeline for our um Medicaid billing re resuming Medicaid billing. >> Um the consultant, when did you hire this consultant? And we we worked with MedQuest and selected the same consultant that they work with. And >> January 8th >> Oh, this year. >> And what cost? >> Uh $24,000 something for the initial garden. And is there a reoccurring cost? >> I'm sorry. >> Is there a reoccurring cost? >> No. >> Michael Stanbury. I'm the administrator for the Medicaid reimbursement section. >> So, Michael, um, in your estimation, why have this been such a so problematic? go for I mean you don't have enough people we didn't get it right the system yes something went wrong with the system but at the same time the corrections I mean enlightened us >> sure um that's a very complicated question thank you um as far as the uh direct service when we stopped uh what we were claiming and we well >> you were only direct servicing nursing right there others you could have done as well but we we haven't done that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 154
>> Yes ma'am. Uh nursing by its very nature is a medical model. It's a a doctor must prescribe the service and a nurse is therefore going to provide the service. So it follows a medical model. The other related services occupational therapy, physical therapy, speech language pathology and um behavioral services. Um the department of education uses an educational model as is required to. So it follows IDA and and provides FAPE to our students. In order to claim for those services, it requires a medical model. Um, so, uh, we recently are, uh, as of November switching to a medical model, but unless we're in a medical model, um, we can't claim for those services. >> But you folks have resisted moving to the medical model. >> And we did initially and we we were having many conversations with MedQuest. Um we did um have different um opinions on on the um school-based claiming model versus the medical model, but we do and other states do have versions of a school-based model that is a bit more friendly to um school-based service billing rather than the strict medical model which follows a um like you would bill in a hospital.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 155
However, after many discussions and many attempts and many plans, um we and wanting to get a move on this, we have um accepted and the to move to a medicallybased model in our school system for Medicaid reimbursement. So when you say medical model, it really is just getting a a therapist or a doctor's approval for a service. So what direct services can you expand for special ed students? I think that's the problem. Sure. Not a medical model, but medically approved for license licensing of of these various services that you could provide to the student. And thank you for that question. Um, none of the services um are whether we bill for Medicaid um or not services do not change for the students. When we say a medical model, it's the way that the providers OTP speech um and our nurses um document their services. Right now we have a process in our IEP and our related service providers have an educational model for keeping um record of their services.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 156
When we move to a medical model, any service um that is provided, we must have a physician's authoriz or a physician diagnosis who is providing that kind of service, right? Not necessarily physician. >> No, we need a physician to give a diagnosis that that service is provided. So, we currently provide service based on need, not based on the um a phys a physician's um diagnosis. >> So, how many special ed students do you have that are eligible to get Medicaid service? >> That number? >> Yes, ma'am. So, um let me preface this by saying they'll have a Medicaid ID, which means at some time in their life they were assigned a Medicaid ID. doesn't mean that today they're still Medicaid eligible, but there's about 4,495 if I had to guess. >> 4,495. >> That's quite a specific. >> Yes, ma'am. Out of about 19 or 20,000 uh students that qualify for special education, about 10,500 or so qualify for related services.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 157
And then that that other sub number, >> how do you how do you work with the students? Because our special ed students do need the services. So my understanding is the teachers, the IEP's teachers, the special ed teachers are the ones who work with the students from kindergarten all the way to high school. So you must have the records in the system. Is that correct? So that you can assess in your medical quest uh I mean your Medicare reimbursement section. What do you do? We we do every student who receives any kind of related service has an IEP and that service is recorded in the IEP and then um the the documentation and recordkeeping of the service is all together there. So when um a service is is offered, it's because there was an IEP team meeting with all of the relevant parties and it was determined that this service would help um um would help assist a child with their education based on assessment results that showed the child has um has a need.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 158
So with the medical model that will still continue but we will need to get a doctor's diagnosis saying the child gets that. Does the med med medical reimbursement team do it or does who does it? >> The parent can give it to the school. >> Okay. or the parent can give authorization with proper documentation for um a designated person at the school to work directly with that child's health care provider to get that information because I think that's a disconnect because you've got 19,000 students that may have um services that they need and somebody should be helping them. And I understand that the the the uh special ed teacher does have the IEP meetings and brings everyone together. What happens to that information so that somebody's assisting the parents to say, you know, you could get these services and putting that together? I would think the med medical reimbursement section should be working with the teachers and the schools to show them what needs to be done and getting that information.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 159
Is any of that being done at all all these years? >> Yes. In order um for us to um claim for the nursing services that were >> services directly >> um we did need parent permission and parents were given information on um um what what we are seeking. We would like to be able to claim reimbursement for these services. um they were given information on how this will impact them or not and they have to sign off. How is that how you're supporting the teachers supporting the families to say these are the kinds of things we can give you because the more you can support them the more reimbursement you can get I understand is 50% of the of the >> our process right now for providing services to children wouldn't change with the Medicaid reimbursement that's a team decision based on assessment data >> monies back definitely we could get more money and that is our goal and to your point.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 160
We do recognize we are leaving money on the table and we um it it's not an excuse, but it's very complex and yes, other states have done it and have been doing it, but um we do have um good partners with MedQuest and they are helping us move forward. >> Did um how much did we pay out for special education um this past year? Let's just say in one year. And how much did you claim of that for direct services? >> We didn't claim for direct services at all last year. No. >> And when did you do 2023? >> 2023. >> Okay. So 2023. How many students and you claim for and how much did you get in reimburse? >> Do you have that? >> No ma'am. I do not. >> We do have that information and we can get it to you as a follow.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 161
>> I think we're looking at what are we leaving on the table. But if you don't have data and you're not claiming that we're leaving everything on the team, >> we do have the data when we were claiming and it was minimal for that particular um subgroup with the transition to the medical model and the training of the staff and the new recordkeeping system that will be required. we will be able to um claim for more direct service um or for more related services other than nursing. Um >> so you're not claiming for any of the other services like assisted technology, behavioral health, speech therapy, none of that. >> No. >> So according to what I have here in 2020 just the direct service for nursing, we got only $830,41. In 2021 for the nursing direct service 1.5 million and then in 2022 it went up 2.5 2023 six million then it dropped in 2024 to 3.8 and then in 2020 2025 I did an administrative claim all those years and that amounted to for five years 7.4 4 million, but nothing was claimed for 2023, 2024, 2025.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 162
>> Correct. Because our current system and and during that time, we've been um um working with vendors to get a system or an add-on that will allow our um claims to be submitted correctly. the platform that we're using statewide currently does not support that and that it it does take time but we also recognize time is of the essence but that we have been working on that at this point it it we um >> when did you recognize that >> in 2023 the our Medicaid section recognized that they and um the the reimbursement they were expecting ing to bring in was actually higher than what they projected. And so that caused a deeper dive. And then it was recognized that when the claims were set differentiating onetoone services versus one to many, a nurse with one to one or a nurse serving one to serving two, three or more children, they were being recorded um the same way.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 163
It didn't differentiate the service. And when the why because our system doesn't have the capacity to do that who is inputting that information >> the the nurses when they provide their service they have a service log and they input it there and we gather the information from the system >> the nurses giving the service somebody from DOE you know >> yes ma'am it' be my section my section coincidentally the skilled nursing contract falls under me also >> your section >> the Medicaid reimbursement section >> so you would know what whether it was faulty or Well, we when we discovered it, it was because we were expecting X dollars back for our reimbursement for direct services and we were getting Y. We're getting more. And so that caused us to go in and look at each individual transaction to see what the difference was. And that's when we figured out that it was all being and we worked with our IT departments to to help figure that out also.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 164
And that's when we figured out that we were submitting every single claim as a onetoone instead of whatever it actually was. And a one to one claim is $68 an hour or back then it was 50 but $68 an hour. So a one to two would be half of that. So instead of claiming for example $34 an hour we were claiming $68 an hour for that same service and that's why we stopped. >> So but you had a third party administrator UMass Medical. >> When did that terminate then? And you're doing it now and No ma'am still with them? >> Uh no ma'am in in June we stopped with UMass because we were of of last year because we were transitioning to a new third party administrator which is PCG. >> So what was happening from when did they start? 2006. >> My goodness, a long time.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 165
I think UMass started 2012. But but >> all of that time wouldn't you have a system in place already? >> Well, the the the hurdle there is that because uh our third party administrator back then, UMass, cannot see our system. They can't see our IEPs. They can't see everything that we submit. They take on faith that we can prove that what we submitted was accurate. They can't see into our ECS system. So the to catch it was on us. They submitted the claims and they said, "Okay, we we expect the DOE is giving the correct information." Turns out we weren't we caught it and when we caught it, we stopped. >> Okay. So when you caught it and simply the way you said it was that you you were claiming all the claims are going in as a one-on-one which some was one and two.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-24 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-23-2026 · passage 166
So why couldn't you just adjust it? >> The well the system didn't allow us to if we were to go in the the issue uh in the simplest terms. So if you have three kids at a school, so they're one to three. If at any time one of those kids goes home or uh if there's two nurses and one of the nurses doesn't show up for work, it's going to change the ratio. So it might go from 1 to three to 1:2 or uh it could be a tube feeding. So at twothirds of the day it's 1:3, but when it's the tube feeding comes in, it's 1:4. And our system can't it can't fluctuate like it can't differentiate. So it just put all of it in as one to one. >> How many students were we talked to? >> Uh back then when in 2023 we had about 500 or so we have 607 today um that are receiving services about a third of those are IEP this question or I made this remark is that you know why couldn't it be done manually then?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above