I say that because I remember overseeing the interview process. It was a very competitive process and I remember her being one of our top candidates. And so I'm here tonight to share with you. She's got eight years of experience in administration and we are recommending to hire her for the principal ship at uh Rancho Gabriella. Will she have tough tough shoes to fill? >> So uh with that I'll I'll stand to the the board's uh decision. Oh, you got to stand up too. I would like to >> I move to approve the appointment of Alicia Ashby as elementary school principal for the 26 27th school year. >> I second. >> Motion carries. Congratulations. [applause] Mr. President, uh, governing board members, uh, the third recommendation we bring to the governing board, I'm excited to announce, uh, Cali Cashette. Uh, she has four years of administrative experience.
So what we've had to do, we've now had to look for other folks to drive buses. We've tried to do things to make that process attractive. We've turned driving a bus into a full-time position where it used to be 2 hours in the morning, 2 hours, we made it into a full-time position. When we did that though, there was some significance financial cost to us. We now had to provide health insurance to them. We also had to provide uh pension benefits from them. Even with that, we know driving a bus is a calling. It's not really a job. So even right now, there's still a shortage of bus drivers. We're not the only one who is experiencing that. It's actually all over the country and even in Canada. So to to answer your question, part of what we're dealing with is that there's just a severe shortage of drivers.
they're doing more in-depth uh activities that require more in the way of resources and and materials. So, um yeah, I think that's historically why you would see um registration fees get higher as the students age. Is >> is that typical in other districts? And do parents want that kind of transparency? Is that why it's, you know, um laid out in this way? Um, I don't know if there's ever actually been the opportunity to survey uh families on the the fee structure to get a sense of why it was uh formulated this way. Um, again, my guess would be uh that um school districts um generally have just looked at it and an eighth grader is going to cost cost more to educate and and therefore the the the fee is going to be higher. Some districts build in uh the like athletic fee and the extracurricular fee in within their registration fee.
Uh, our recommendation is to appoint her as the principal at Surprise Elementary starting uh, the new school year of 2026. And I would like to share also that Cali is a national board certified teacher as well. And she's standing without anybody prompting her. Very good. >> I motion to approve the appointment of uh Cali Cashette as elementary school principal for the 2026 27 school year. >> Second. >> Motion carries. Congratulations >> [applause] >> Mr. President, governing board members, the final uh recommendation uh where we're going to bring to you tonight is for Thompson Ranch's principal ship. Uh that is Ralph Kintana and uh he has four years of experience under his belt. I would also as a veteran myself recognize uh his service in the United States Armies as well as a veteran, numerous years with the army. So, I am proud to uh announce to the board uh and ask for uh an approval for his placement as principal at Thompson.
We don't have enough drivers to go around. And some of our drivers too, they get sick even though we don't have enough to go to begin with. Then you have folks who get sick. Some of them, you may have 20 of them who call in in a given day. Then we have to scramble to make up that route. We're doing everything we can to recruit as many drivers as as we get. But is it's a lengthy process from wanting to become a driver and getting your CDL, going through training, getting that license, going through safety before we can let you drive a bus with our kids on it. And what we find out sometimes is even after we get those folks hired, we get them their CDL, we get them driving, we realize school bus is not the calling for them. They are not suited to drive a bus with 60 kids in the back of it whom you're trying to drive, they don't listen to you.
Uh it's just all in one. Um I'm not necessarily in favor of doing that because you have students that don't necessarily do uh track and and field. Uh so why should they have to to to pay for for that? Um but there are districts that that do that. Uh districts will combine their their tech fee and registration fee into one fee. Um there are ways we can we can we can do this. Um depending on how much the fee structure would change that would determine whether it would be implemented this upcoming year or we'd have to look at it over the the the next year for um the school year after that. So that would be the 20 uh fiscal year 28. Yeah. >> So Katherine, just to go back to your to our conversation here, just run the numbers quick while Miss Sandlin was talking.
>> Motion to approve the appointment of Ralph Kantani as elementary school principal for the 202627 school year. >> Second. >> Yes, >> mine went away. Yes. >> Thank you. Yes. >> Motion carries. Congratulations. [applause] >> Yeah, I see it. It is on. >> Yeah. So, the next item is the amendment to the donation agreement between the Daart Unified School District and Sunset Tortesso LLC. Uh, the reason that I asked for this to be pulled so we can have some discussion is I just I just want a little bit more background on it, honestly. Um, and I apologize for the extra effort, but um, to me it it just looked like that it's we're changing some dates and um, we may be giving the land back to the developer, but I just need clarification. Thank you, Mr. President. Um, yes. So, um, I will have, uh, actually Mary Del Spidel talk about it, but you were right in line.
It takes a kind of person to be able to work the magic necessary to be a bus driver. So to address the question though that the buses being leased are not impacting how we're staffing that a lot of the delays that we have experienced and potentially continue to experience is really derived from our current levels of staffing not leasing versus owning our buses. And to to even address that as it relates to leasing I was going to talk about that in the past what we did we leased the buses and after 5 years we gave them back and then we started over again. The last lease that we did last year the 72 units we actually did lease to own. We didn't and lease to own we paid slightly more over the next five years. And what we we were doing instead of then giving the buses back, we kept we planning to keep those buses for five additional years.
um it would be 1414 for all nine years. Kindergarten, full day, grades 1 through 5, and then grades 6 through 8. Given these numbers right here, we would divide that number by 9. It would be aboutund. It's $157. So, let's round it up to 160 for easy easy numbers, right? Kindergarten through 8th grade would be 160. Would still cover all of that unless you have it set up, Dave, where you take those kindergarten fees, Mr. Sheepard. Sorry. You take those kindergarten fees and you you you mark them towards Oakn Null or does it just go into one big pot? >> Yeah. So, the registration fees go into to our revenue budget on the the revenue side of the house. Uh and in theory, you could tie those into instructional resource materials. Um not necessarily uh if if a Oaknull student pays the fee at Oaknull, doesn't mean that those dollars that they particularly gave are going directly to an Oaknull resource.
So, we signed a agreement roughly 10 11 years ago. Um, we have not developed that land, and by the agreement in 2014, I believe, um, if we had not moved and built a school site on that land, we need to give it back to the developer. And I will let Maryell um, Miss Spidell fill in anything that I missed. >> Yes. Thank you, Dr. Cotto. Yes. Um, President Scavar, that is correct. So, that is one where um, essentially Elliot Homes, they have that land and so obviously now since we don't have as a district any immediate plans to build a school in that community, obviously instead of having that sit as an empty parcel within their already developed um, home and community area, they are looking to exercise that repossession right. So, that has already been stated in that agreement. All this a final amendment does is just really um finalize what those specific um time frames and those dates are in the agreement.
So we actually own those buses after 5 years free and clear. What we found out in doing our analysis is that at the end of 5 years on average our buses only have 22,000 miles on it. It's no reason to rent buses and give them back with 22,000 miles only for the bus company to now turn around and resell those buses or release those buses and make double the amount of money. We're not doing that anymore. We're keeping those buses for 10 years. And by doing that, that was where we got the additional 12 million. So 12 million will be used for another 5 years by extending the useful life from 5 to 10. That's an equivalent savings of 12 million that will be paid for lease and acquisition. >> And just my last question, was the OTAA a part of the whole transportation leasing agreement and so forth as far as just having um conversations what that looked like and they had their buyin, right?
It's going to the resource budget as a as a whole. >> As a whole. So like if we were to do something flat K through eight, that would be that wouldn't screw anything up. Okay. >> Just an idea. Just tossing that out there. >> Just to clarify too so people know, these fees cannot be used for um chairs or staff. It can only be for things like consumables, technology um and things like that. And these fees represent a just a fraction of what those things actually cost the district. Um but just so people know that this cannot be used for um actually for staff. It has to be for consumable type items. >> Yeah. When I was crunching the numbers, I was using the 2526 staffing plan and I was only using full day K through8. Um, I was not considering the blended uh that in the ECE that was getting complicated.
Um which is what the the amendment is for. It's just really finalizing what those agreement dates are. >> Quick question. Were we uh responsible for paying taxes on that land the entire time? >> No. So we have um it was it was in our name. So I'd have to look back and see what specific tax records there were. But um in the meantime, we had also been receiving uh parcel donations as well offsetting that as we owned that land. And so um I'd have to specifically look up any spec, you know, historical tax records. >> All right. Thank you. >> You're welcome. >> Any other questions? >> Quick. Yeah, quick question. Just generally speaking, when we have developer donations of land, do we traditionally pay taxes on on those parcels? >> If it's a land that that we own, I mean, it is in our name.
>> Absolutely. Absolutely. [clears throat] We've never had a a better relationship with our colleagues at OTAA. Yes. We made it a point to extend uh to to extend oursel to make sure that every decision that we make as relates to the work stream they have a say in it >> and in addition to our OTAA um uh Mr. of FME and our transportation department has really tried to move um he mentioned earlier our contracted buses and decrease our level of uh routes that are under contract to then be inhouse and really covered um through our OTAA members. So that's something in partnership with OTAA even amongst the shortage that we're trying to move um just because it not only gives um you know tighter controls and oversight for student um experience and safety um but better communication within uh the transportation department. >> Thank you.
Um, and I wasn't considering any kind of fee waivers either. But, um, yeah, I I was I was I crunched numbers for a while. I did the all grades K through 8 at you know uh 148 and I timed it but 2249 which was the number of the students in that plan and it came up to a difference of 21,000 but then when I you know to do it were kindergarten that rate would just be 148 and then grades 1 through 8 would be 158 just like simplifying it and then that it I don't know I'm just I'm just wondering if the board would understand or want to take a look at simplifying this. >> I guess from my perspective, I'm not necessarily seeing the equity thing because we just went through the the thought process that eighth graders don't need the same things that first graders need, don't need the same things that preschoolers need.
So, we do pay tax, you know, we do have property tax statements that we do receive for the various parcels of land that we do own. >> But this seems to be like provisional donation, like we're, you know, it was donated if we built on it. Am I understanding that correctly? So this specific land had already I mean it had been donated in our name. So we did already have that and recognize that as one of our donated land sites. So once that is really in the the name of the district, it is exercised as one of our properties. Um so essentially we do now have to revert this property back to to the initial homeowners or the developers. >> Got it. Thank you. >> Welcome. >> No further questions. Um, I motion to accept the amendment to the donation agreement between Desaart Unified School District and Sunset Tarteso LLC and authorize the assistant superintendent for business services to sign the agreement and any affiliated documents.
And related to that uh the contract that we are with our third party provider used to be they will guarantee payment for so many routes right and what we trying to do we're trying to be more efficient with how we do transportation they will guarantee payment sometime they didn't even have the drivers to do the work but they were gr guarantee extra amount of payment we negotiated the contract we got attorney involved and say if you were not doing the route we're not going to pay you and those are some of the things that we've done that actually get out of here. So, we're doing everything we can to be more efficient with how we run transportation. We know there's a cost overrun there. So, we're doing everything within our power to make sure that we reduce cost without impacting negatively the experience of our customers or our students.
Um, I'm on board with keeping them flat. I do appreciate anything we can do to our community to provide some relief. Yes. And since we had already gone down, I I certainly didn't think you were coming back to us and saying, "Let's go down again." We're not there yet. But we'll take flat. Um, and if you want my two sons on any of the things on this list, if you lumped the tech fee into the regular registration fee, every one of our students gets tech now. So, kind of if you if I take my board member hat on and I'm only talking to you as a parent, I don't need to see the tech fee separately. If I have to pay it and my student is going to get tech, lump it into the fee. But if you want to be transparent and we did ear mark it differently, I see why it's there.
>> Second Motion carries. Next on the agendum is our agenda is section J, request for fur future agenda items. Not hearing any. Um, next on the agenda, section, executive session. I call for uh an executive section pursuant to ARS 38-431.03 A1 [snorts] >> second. Motion carries. Yep. All right. Next on the agenda item is reconvening of the regular meeting. The governing board administration will return. Um action to discussion continued. action regarding a written summary of the superintendent's uh per the superintendent's mid-year performance evaluation for the 2025 2026 school year. I make a motion that the superintendent is satisfactory progressing towards achievement of the approved goals for the 2025 2026 school year. >> I second. [snorts] I'm going to vote yes. I can't get in. >> Motion carries. >> A motion to adjourn the meeting. >> Second. Motion carries.
>> Thank you. >> Thanks. So, another area where we've had savings was copier and duplication aware. Now, we've been with the same copier company. I came to we came to the board uh last year or since 2016. And what they did is every year when the contract ran up every couple of years, they increased the price. No question asked because we didn't go out and and bid on it. But for the first time last year, we said once the contract was up, we're going to bid it. And initially I had some on my team who say ah no one is probably going to show up to bid on that contract.