But otherwise, that's the only thing I really have input on. >> Okay. So, what I'm hearing is nobody really cares. >> I'm just saying. >> Okay. Well, at least thanks for entertaining that. I mean, I don't know. wait till you get the all your kids in the junior high and you have to pay for all that extra stuff and you're still paying the most in fees. I'm trying people. >> So, if there's consensus to uh keep the rates flat, um my recommendation would be for the board to uh approve this next week at the the regular board meeting. Okay, next item we have up is the Oaknull window abatement bid. Mr. Shepard, >> this is actually going to be uh Mr. Martin is going to be our closer tonight. Uh he is going to uh take us home um with the um the abatement bid results for the Oaknull window replacement project.
When we had the bid uh release we required a meeting for the prospective biders to be able to ask questions about what kind of equipment we had any questions they have. We are standing room there about about 15 to 18 companies there attending with interest in bidding and at the end of the day once we did the bidding the company that's been charging us all this money they were the winning bidder and the savings that they provided us with new equipment better services amount to a4 million a year for the next five years same company just because we went out we said we would just not take the prices that you've been giving than us in the past without seeing what the market can provide. And then the last thing I wanted to point to that is the computer devices. Same situation. We have the same company.
Um just a little bit of background here before Mr. Martin reviews uh the the bidding process. Uh, keep in mind this all came about uh last year as we were getting ready to replace the windows at uh at Oaknull and discovered that there uh was asbestous in the sealant that was used around the windows despite the fact that the windows had been I believe replaced in the the 1990s. Um there should have been no reason why asbestous was ever used at that point in time. Regardless, we we discovered it so we we have to uh abate it. Um, so we went through the the bidding process and I'm going to toss it over to Mr. Martin who will give a brief overview and our recommendation. Good evening everybody. So um the uh uh bid uh we had uh conducted by Integrity Environmental Services. They're our consultant on the bid and again it's for the asbestos abatement work at the Oaknull Early Childhood Center and we're scheduling those windows to replace and um that abatement being done in June 2026.
Every time we need to buy computer devices, we just order it from the same company. We decided last year we would not do that. We'll let the marketplace determine what the best price uh going in the marketplace and some of the service that we felt we needed. We did an RFP. We released it. This is the saving that we realize. Additionally, we had better computer than we've had before. And we also received what is called a white glove service, which meant they programmed the computer in MJA by the time we got it. Savings of $1.1 million. Better equipment, better service. So essentially this is a recap of the things that I've talked about earlier which is that we're trying to make sure that we negotiate a better uh better contract with our with our staff member. We're trying to make sure that uh we negotiate better benefits so we can save as much money and we can strategically make sure that we use our taxpayers money well.
So the it supports planned construction activities and ensures continued compliance with all the applicable state and federal asbestos regulations. So we did have to comply with uh those regulations. So the bidding process summary uh we had a mandatory brid bid meeting uh to talk to all the potential like uh contractors. It was well attended. We had 25 uh excuse me 12 qualified abatement contractors. So there's a lot of interest in the project and a lot of competition. Uh at the bid nine contractors submitted bids and the January 15th uh bid deadline. All the bids were publicly open, reviewed for responsiveness, required documentation and acknowledgement of the agenda. So the one agenda we did add to the um uh project was about boarding up the openings uh depending on if the u the window company Auburn windows when they are ready to install the new windows so that if there was any openings they would be totally sealed and weatherproofed.
And this is insurance and risk. I talked about this earlier where the savings that I mentioned earlier came from and transportation leases. I I mentioned that earlier and uh I just wanted to focus on the fact that what we doing right now is RFP which is request for proposal when we needed to buy instead of just saying you've done business with us. You're a legacy vendor. We'll continue to do business with you. We send we do business with whomever it is that can give us the best product as the best price and RF uh uh request for bid and we also use RFQ. If you remember, we having the uh the pack space uh fixed right now in uh OE since the repair that we needed was more standardized. Only a handful of people, architects have the ability to be able to respond and do the work we did we needed.
uh and then the abatement company could work ahead and then the window company would follow them and put windows in as the openings were available and uh to make sure everything was nice and secure uh by the end of the day. So addendum number one was to clarify again the window opening boardup and protection requirements. This addendum was properly acknowledged by all responsive biders considered for the award. Uh the bids were reviewed again for the uh 10% bid bond contractor qualification statement and the acknowledgement of the agenda. So the bid results um the lowest bid uh was by the same company that did the brigate windows. So that was EHC Industries and they came in at $64,850. Unfortunately, they were nonresponsive due to missing the addendum acknowledgement and that board of uh agenda was it's a big uh expense and important to that project. So, them missing that kind of disqualified them as being non-responsive.
So we did an RQ for that where we had the design of what we needed to be done and we just needed to have qualified people provide us pricing a description of the work they needed to do in order to get it done. So those are the process that we've been using to uh to get better pricing. Something I wanted to point out though, what we inherited was that for our drivers at at uh car leases, we had a company I'm not going to name, we actually they were charging us executing us a lot of money for it. And uh when we came aboard, we had a conversation with them. They would never provide us the contract that we signed with them. We had to go back and forth to find it because they knew as soon as we saw that contract, we will be just outdone by what we signed.
Uh the second lowest bid was by Husar abatement and that was in the amount of $66,000. So, just a a slight difference there. And then the other bids, the other seven bids ranged from 70,250 all the way up to 115,500. All the pricing was reviewed against the project scope and the engineers expectations. So they all looked good besides that one uh missing agenda uh contractor evaluation. So the uar abatement so they submitted a complete and responsive bid. They acknowledged the agenda, provided all required bid documentation, and received a positive letter of recommendation from the integrity environmental services. They worked with them in the past, cited uh satisfactory past performance, regulatory compliance, quality of work in similar school districts. So even though they were just the the second highest bid the they had all the same qualifications as the company we used for uh Brierggate. Uh so our recommendation in the the uh finance and operations department uh based on the bid responsiveness completeness past performance the pricing.
So, we fought with them. We're able to get the contract. And what we found out is if we had gone outright and bought those six drivers uh cars instead of leasing them in perpetuity from them, every year we'll be saving over $100,000. Now I just mentioned that the average salary of our educator is 70,000. So that's a 1.5 teachers achieve that we could have saved by just buying our own car. There's no reason to lease six cars and pay the leases in perpetuity and also pay for repairs on top of that too a repair contract. We have mechanics that are employed by the district. They can do the work required. And I talked about the uh taws that we've done over over the last 20 years that we're not doing anymore. So each year we save between uh1 to $200,000 depending on the amount of the issuance.
So we recommend to award the Oaknull Early Childhood Center Abbeestos basement, excuse me, Asbestos Abatement Project to HAR abatement in the amount of the $66,000. And our rationale of course they were the most responsive bidder and second lowest in price. And then that represents, you know, full transparency uh had all the information there and uh great value to the district. And then last but not least, the requested board action is uh to approve the award to Husaro basement for the asbestos baitman services at Oaknull Childhood Center to be reformed in June 2026.
So over the last three years we saved about $600,000. And I mentioned I talked about the computer devices and the savings of 1.5. And so in case folks are wondering, have we used the savings that we've realized over the last couple of years, what we've done is we've shored up the district finances and which was one of the reasons when we went out to do the refinancing on the bond uh that I talked about. We're able to get a lower interest rate, higher subscription rate because the balance sheets look better. uh we uh we use some of the savings to provide instructional support. We are buying more resources that our educators need to be to provide better services to our kids in the classroom. And we've used some of the money to do some of the capital and operational needs that we have as a district, but we know we need more than we'll ever be able to do as far as capital and operational need.
Any questions? >> I have a a question about process. If we have worked with EHC before and they came in really close, does someone pick up the phone and say, "Hey, did you mean to not do this? Did you leave it off or because it's sealed, we're not allowed to do that? >> Well, like after the fact. So, um the company EHC, so in their letter of recommendation, they did have um uh full, you know, recommendation for both companies because they did work with both in the past. And me myself, like I was like, "Oh, great." You know, everything went so well in that really condensed time frame at Brierggate that EHC was the lowest. But then again, they weren't the most responsive. So, and um EHC, the gentleman we work with, his name's Guy, uh he did call him and say, "Hey, you know, like uh this is what happened." They totally understood like, you know, we know we we kind of messed that up.
And what we've also done which I mentioned earlier, we've been able to recruit, retain, and reward our staff by engaging in bargaining where we actually respect our staff member. We pay him well. And then what we've also been doing is trying to increase our fund balance for rainy day because we know there are times when there volatility. We want to be able to have enough money screwed away that we don't have to borrow money at the payday loan rate like I always say. So by doing this we are hoping that by not borrowing money unnecessarily we are doing a better job of of using our taxpayers money. We're making financial decisions that ensure that our money are being spent effectively instead of wastefully. And looking ahead, we plan to continue to uh to do cost control and to be efficient in how we spend money.
And uh there was actually another contractor whose car broke down on the way in and so they weren't be able to weren't able to put their bid in as well because they were going to miss that uh that morning timeline. So So we we did have to disqualify you know like a couple of contractors not just uh not just EHC not well just mark them as not the not responsive. So, so I would when we receive the bids, they are sealed and we we then evaluate them based on what is being opened at the the open the the bid opening which is held in public uh and we tally the the bids at that time. So, uh, in order to to shield ourselves from any challenges that could come about, um, as as technical as something like that is, we could, uh, if if the board were to recommend, uh, the true lowest bidder, um, we could open ourselves to a challenge on on on this uh, simply because someone could come in and say, "Hey, their bid was not the most responsive because they were missing this at the time of the the bid opening." So uh that would be the the the reason for the the recommendation.
And we continue to monitor the economy and to be able to react in case there are things that are beyond our control so we can plan on how we can we can adapt without taking on unnecessary debt. So the the closing summary that I would like to say is we've worked over the last two years to really do a good job of managing district resources resources that have been sent [clears throat] to us who recognize our taxpayers are hardworking. Uh they no one wants to pay property tax but we know we need to do that in order to have an excellent educational experience for our kids. We know one of the key reasons folks buy house in a community is the level of education that children get in there. So we know we recognize the sacrifice that taxpayers make and we've made it a point to make sure that we use those funds well.
>> I am all for certainly following the rules and making sure that we are not doing those challenges. I don't want to pay any more lawyers about I know how much we charge. >> So I have a question. Um they're all working with the same amount of square footage for this for this building. Who fills out this tabulation? because the first one is a dollar a square or $1 a square foot and their price is $79,000. Our bid that we're going with is $2,400 a square foot and they're 66,000. So I don't know how these numbers are. >> So So that one that should have been more clarified. That was going to be a deduction in the pricing for any square foot that wasn't needed to be abated. So looking at that column, so that should have showed deduction of um square footage from the pricing of the bid if they didn't have to do some of the openings.
We use them the same way we would expect them to use it if they were sitting in our seat by making prudent decision uh conservative financial decision making. Investment of the resources in education and also investment to make sure that when the money is not needed is generating yield that we can use for for capital reason for educational resources to make sure that we do right by taxpayer.
So yeah, there's a there's a great range and deduction of possibilities like in that square footage. Yeah. So that that should have been clarified a little bit better on the tabulation sheet. >> Calculator, but something's not making sense. No, we and and and we we actually asked that uh after the the bid opening uh when we were looking at the tabulation sheet and and then we realized that's that's the deduction amount >> um at that point. >> Okay. Just just so I'm really clear, black and white, it's not 2,00 like if we go with usar because that's the responsib $2,400 per square feet. That is up to $2,400 could come off the top of this if they don't have to do that work. >> Correct. Wonderful. All right. Any other questions? >> Thank you for clarifying that we are going to be protective. I am certainly in favor of being protective and so next week when you come back Yeah, let's do that.