In this state, in Arizona, we talk a lot about school choice, but I wish we would talk more about choice schools. What does it take to put a wonderful school in the middle of every community that meets the needs of our students? And I see Pioneer as a choice school. They've done great things. They've been um working with kids academically successful. And um I find it very hard to see this community neighborhood school where everyone can attend that we have to vote to close this school. And I just want to salute uh Mr. Ames Singley and all of the staff and the students and the families at Pioneer for the work that they've put in. And my commitment as an individual is to continue to work hard to support our public schools where every student can attend. And I'm sorry that we have to make this decision.
That's going to bring us up to about $3.5 million within reductions. For option three, we have teacher and teacher support an increased number of personnel up to 52 positions and non-teers within admin and support 11.5 positions. One of the questions was asked was in any of these options is it all personnel? Yes, it is. These these options are personnel. We looked at fixed costs. M Rush Camp talked about the increases within that. We know we have to decline from there but we did not change budgets as we felt like we did such a huge budget cut um last year and so we did not uh adjust budget cuts also within these options. We have not cla uh changed the um teacher to student ratio within the classroom and so those have remained and will remain consistent regardless of which of the options that you choose.
>> I have also >> any questions or proposed changes in the minutes? >> None. A motion to approve the minutes for the January 13, 2026 meeting as submitted. >> So moved. >> There a second. >> Seconded. >> I, John Feather, vote in favor. >> I, Brian Forestall, vote in favor. >> I, Ryan Sullivan, vote in favor. >> I, Steuart Seagull, vote in favor. >> Excellent. Those minutes are approved. And thank you very much for submitting those.
So, that really allows us to gauge student learning in a way that is I believe next year when we come to you and talk to you about student learning outcomes, we'll be able to present that to you. Um, so, also I'd mention that pre-K registration is going to be open February 2nd through March 20th and applications will be due by March 20th and that's remember for for students to be included in the lottery. Those aren't the students who we're going through the special education identification process with. Kindergarten registration open will be open on February 9th. Information will be sent to families. You'll see that out in Dartmouth Week. We'll advertise if we haven't already and believe it or not we're going to be welcoming the class of 2039. Um [snorts] at the Across the district I'd also mention access it's testing you know testing season starts as soon as January hits and so access testing is currently taking place for our English language learners and if you remember Dr.
>> What's the likely? >> So I don't think it's unlikely. I mean we're in a short session but I you got to remember we're also I mean to be blunt we're in a campaign cycle right? So there are people who are trying to be great elected including us. I think that, you know, I don't mean to be cynical about it, but the reality is we we know what this year is, right? So, we're looking for I mean, we were asked very specifically in our caucus, what are the affordability measures, ideas that you have that we could put forward that would put more money into people's pockets and and then, you know, that helps with obviously the burden with the the work of taxes as well. Um, I I I can't say, you know, this is guaranteed that this is going to happen, but I can tell you this is what I'm going to push for the hardest that I possibly can because I think that we hear it every year.
Um can we Yeah, I don't know because I I'm I'm reading it and that's how I would take it if I was not here. So, can we put um after board member maybe in parentheses put the superintendent and board members um as individuals or >> uh oneon-one something like u superintendent and board members commit to open dialogue one-on-one, >> but it's more than one-on-one. We're talking about whether you guys are talking to him >> either in the DAS or in one. So yes, >> collectively and or one-on-one with the superintendent. >> Collectively or oneonone? >> Collectively. Yeah. >> Uh superintendent Artega, your thoughts. >> I'm fine. Whatever the board consensus is. >> I'm actually fine the way it reads. I mean to me it's it's the communication that I as an individual have with superintendent Ortega and the communication that us as board members have with him whether again whether it's individual or as a group because it is about that dialogue or the communication with him whether it's individual or as a group I I I think that's that that's the intent of that to cover all those areas right connected to the superintendent um so for me it's fine like that but So if we feel that we need to add more to it and I'm not sure if maybe if we delete this does that make more sense >> I think when it says with one another dialogue with one another that maybe I like the superintendent and the board members committed to open dialogue that's it yeah and not the >> that that sounds good >> like that >> and and just to respond to that well for me I think we have a great communication us board members >> and the uh superintendent, he's always um open for discussion and we text him, call him or what have you, he will call you within the hour sometimes, you know.
and I'm grateful for the graciousness of that community in going along with this hard decision. So, thanks. >> Thank you, Miss Humphre. Other discussion. Okay. Thank you Dr. Martin for the uh explanation and for the uh information. And I want to thank you for uh I was able to attend I believe most of those meetings that you referenced and uh acknowledge the amount of work and care and concern that you and your team has put into making this um making these changes as uh as thoughtful and um as as as common sense as they are. Um I know that every step of this process has been difficult and not what you wanted to do. Uh, but I also appreciate the the foresight and the care that you take to look out for all of Gilbert public schools. And unfortunately, it's decisions like this are not ideal.
We had a summary slide that kind of put it all together um to allow you to look and see of the three options that we looked at, how much would we anticipate taking out of our carry forward and that's the bolded one, the reduction in pay. I did have to include an estimated pay, which is what I did last time, but that can fluctuate depending on the choices that you make in terms of compensation moving forward. Um so an estimated carry forward after the first reduction would be down to about 15.25 25 million about 17 15.75 for option two and option three three would still remain around 17.15 million within that carry forward and I know that's going to be part of that discussion today is where do we want to end on that carry forward and that's really the decision you guys are making and then we can put in place any of the three options that you moved forward with the classroom site fund.
Next item on the agenda is staff updates and administrative matters. We have with us tonight Alex Moronovis who has expressed interest in being appointed as an associate member of the uh zoning board of appeals. Alex was present at our last meeting on January 13th where we had an opportunity to um find out a little bit about him and his background and why he was interested in becoming a an associate member of the ZBA and in accordance with my understanding of the present practice or desires of the select board. they like potential members to attend a couple of meetings to see if it's a if it's a fit for them. And um Alex, as I said, did attend the last meeting. Um we had an opportunity to speak with him. He seems quite enthusiastic. Um, and I think the general impression, and I won't speak for everybody, as I do speak for everybody, um, that the impression was that he would was well qualified to be appointed an associate member of the ZBA.
Tibbet presented this data to you early in the fall and we'll be doing that again. We are pleased that we're going to be hosting student teachers this spring from Bridgewater and Stonehill and they've begun their practicum placements at Dartmouth Middle and Dartmouth High School. We love having student teachers in the district. It is a win-win for us because it allows us to obviously to support the next generation of teachers but it also allows us to take a look at teachers who might be a really great fit for our district. At the high school level Carrie Rower who was an instructional coach from Carnegie visited the high school and she was here on the 21st and 22nd. She's somebody our teachers our math teachers at Dartmouth High School have responded really well to so we've been able to work with Carnegie to make sure that we're providing the math teachers the math department here with the highest quality professional learning and Carrie comes so highly recommended and the feedback that we've gotten regarding the work she's doing with our teachers has been very positive.
I mean, Paul's been here a couple, this is now my sixth time, I think, being here and hearing the same conversation. I remember that first year when two kids came in, it cost $500,000 for a week. Um, I would also point out in terms of special ed, because it is a conversation that we continue to have with our colleagues all year long, especially when you consider the talent cities that end up getting more money because of the types of students that they have that we don't have. They are not taking into account the types of students that we have that they don't have. And so the conversation that I had with one colleague who was very brocher school, I said, "That's great." So, but your charter school is our special education and what are we going to do about that? Because that is what we hear from our towns over and over again how critically important it is to fund special ed and we're legally required to do so.
Um I mean that's my experience, you know, right? And um >> yeah, and I agree actually striking that out. >> Yeah. >> It's just straight to the point. >> Yeah. Open dialogue period. That's it. Yeah. you want to ask? >> No, I'm fine with it. I think I was um kind of read it reading it like a board clerk Ramos had indicated. It's just to me I was thinking collectively and anyways. So, and that's fine striking that out. >> Okay. So, we have consensus on that. >> Thank you. Um are there any of the other bullets? And I'll give you a a couple of minutes to look through those to see if there's anything else. I know number four, uh, our vice president just said that's that one we know is not an issue. >> Yeah. Number five. Are we okay with that? Are we doing good on that one?
Um, and we do realize that they impact many many many people and as Dr. McCord said, that's not something that we ever take lightly. Uh, and so we appreciate and acknowledge your work and uh the care and concern of all of our Pioneer Elementary staff and students and family. Uh, with that, I'll go ahead and call for the vote. Miss Humphre, your emotion is contagious. I'm sorry. >> My apologies. >> All those in favor [clears throat] of the closure of Pioneer Elementary and Gilbert Public Schools, say, "I." >> I.
We'll talk about that again when we get to compensation. But we want to take all the compensation for increases for any classroom siphon eligent poly employee directly out of that bucket instead of the M bucket. I think when we look at the different buckets that we have um M is a huge one and we're trying what we can do to protect M right now to maintain it for as long as possible knowing we have these reductions coming forward and therefore if we can dig into the $15 million carry forward for classroom site fund for increases for people who are eligible we want to put all of the increases in that bucket and not in M. So, uh, I appreciate all of the time, the five of you as you came in and had individual meetings and we were able to answer your questions as you move forward, but I look forward to the, um, discussion that you have and the decisions that you'll make tonight.
Um, Brian Stew. Brian, any any questions for Alex or any concerns? >> no concerns at all. Okay. No concerns here. >> Okay. Thank you. Then the process will be we're going to take a vote and I will send an email uh hopefully I'll be able to do it tomorrow. If not tomorrow, definitely on Thursday morning uh to the select board indicating that we have met with you. Um and we think that you would be a u well appointment to associate member of the ZBA and then the select board Miss Roy's their assistant would be in touch with you to schedule a meeting before the select board when they would have an opportunity to ask you questions and vote to uh whether to appoint you to the board. And after all that talking, I forget. Did we formally vote to make that recommendation? >> No. >> Brian, would you like to make that motion?
Um we have four new educators four educators who have completed new mentor training and we want to continue to do that because again this is giving our teachers an opportunity to be teacher leaders and to mentor others in the field. And then we have teaching alliance teaching learning alliance visiting Dartmouth High School. This is Cynthia Smith. She's providing one-to-one coaching for our lead teachers. If you remember as part of not only our district strategic plan but the high school's school improvement plan also connected to the NEASC report part of what we read and what we're responding to is feedback that Dartmouth High School teachers needed more opportunity for voice and for leadership roles and this is the way we're one way that we're supporting them in developing those kind of opportunities for them and giving them a forum and a struck system and a structure to be able to do that effectively.
So, we should be doing a better job of this without just requiring it to go entirely on the shoulders of the town. Um there has been in this last legislation we were sort of um whispering to ourselves the state department of education is now able to set rates on those out placements. So we are hoping that that will also help bring down some costs because they will be able to say this is extraordinary when you were talking about you know how is it that we can set this like this but then out placement is so outside they've never had the ability to set those rates before so that was part of the bill that we put into place last year and then what I was saying about the seed money the seed money is a good start but I think they're sort of looking for proof in the footing and I would highly recommend that you spend as much time talking to the State Department of Education as possible because if they have something more impressive than this, I don't know what it is.
We are adhering to that. >> Okay, that's that's one I always am going to ask about no matter what. Um just because yeah, >> we got to make sure that that doesn't happen. >> And I think on number six, um >> you can hear I just want to make sure that we keep our community in the loop. >> Yeah. >> That the governance handbook can be viewed on um online for anyone that's watching as well. >> Okay. >> I was just going to move on number six. I think number six is just the superintendent can answer that cuz I don't know if he gets surprises or not. I mean, you know what I'm saying? I mean, I it's individual, man. I I don't know. >> Are they doing well in that? >> So, he would have to. >> Okay. Yeah. Okay. So, we're just taking that one part out and the rest is okay.
>> Any opposed? Okay. 7.02 expansion of Carol Ray Ranch, Harris, and Val Vista Lakes Elementary boundaries for the 2026 2027 school year. Uh, is there a motion for the expansion of these of I'm sorry. Is there a motion for 7.02? >> So moved. >> Thank you, Mr. Briner. Is there a second? >> Second. >> Thank you, Miss Humphre. Uh, Dr. McCord. >> Thank you, Mr. President, governing board members. Um when there is a school closure, um you have to take a look at the existing boundaries and determine uh where those students and what schools those students will go to in uh in other boundaries. And so uh as we've talked about uh Dr. Martin and as we've presented uh with a a a bit of a change um I'll let Dr. Martin explain uh all the routes related to this. >> Thank you Dr. McCord governing board.
So, with that, I will turn it back over to you. >> Do we have questions or comments from the board? anybody would like to go. Go ahead, >> President Wade. Um, I would just like to go through uh my analysis of the options. Um, just to break down what my thoughts are. Um, when we look at all the options, I see option one as the most risky. Um it's the smallest reduction of three million against a known 7 million structural gap. Um that leaves 5.6 5.65 million in unresolved reductions after pay increases and it relies heavily on our carry forward drawdowns. Um, and I know we've discussed utilizing our carry forward. Um, but this would be the biggest impact and it effectively kicks the problem forward. Um, while we have enrollment um that's declining. Um, it's the highest fiscal risk. Um, and pretty much this option is deferral uh not discipline.