Yes, absolutely correct. Now might we if we choose option one kick the can down the road and we have to then look at every other staff member that's the difference between option one and option three next year that is facts that is but meaning that means a loss of programs or that means a loss of things that is not what that is at the present moment in time and that is not what we are talking to you about currently and what next year looks like because we as a community have talked about and have done everything we can to express our programs are the most important and our staff agrees with this. Our programs are the most important. So right now our programs are the things that we are shielding the most. It is staff we are looking at currently and might we have to look at doing different things for class sizes and all of that.
>> Okay. Thank you. That's all she had. >> Other board questions potentially. I think my just main question is I in my research and you both coming is that I found that there seems to be a very big push for funding the pension deficit by the governor and by other legislators and it kind of seems like a push in a poll of if there's if that's your choice to fund the pensions or education and I guess my direct question would be is what would you choose to support. >> So, we have a big uh unfunded pension liability problem state >> $35 billion >> ish these days and you know the state essentially has have a mortgage payment plan on those liabilities where we pay I think approximately $3.2 two billion dollars a year and over the next 25 years about we're going to pay off that that liability.
Maybe your assumption is correct, but you'll never know until you have a conversation." And that's one of the things and that all of you can attest to um with the board here that I have said a gazillion times is that so many things can be addressed just by a simple one-on-one conversation. And um so just just to respond real briefly to what you just said and thank you for that is number one um you do have to be willing to talk. You do have to be willing to have a conversation. If you have a disagreement with somebody that you know you feel like you know this is bothering me. Don't let it fester. Have a conversation. Get it out the way. If you feel like like you and one other person can't have a conversation together, the superintendent can meet with the two people and have the conversation or be there to mediate the conversation when it takes place.
Also, I was able to talk with the uh superintendent of the Miami district. Um he they talked on stage about the flood that they went through recently and some of the things that were done. The volunteers who showed up to help uh the Pendergas school district that had some furniture that they could uh were able to ship to Miami to help them with their schools. And it was just overall a really um positive experience. uh really connecting with other people in our state who were um board members, but also superintendent and administrators and nonprofits and community faith members and just across the board. It was a really good experience. So, I wanted to share that. >> Thank you, Miss Humphre. On that note, if there's anybody out there that's in one of those cold weather states that's experiencing the storms, plenty of homes for sale here in Gilbert and we would love you to come to Gilbert Public Schools.
Yes, I still do not understand the risk that means we are creating more of a problem for ourselves next year other than the reality that we may have to cut folks. And so if your question is we either cut them now or next year, I choose next year. I choose next year. And the reason I choose next year is because who knows what next year will bring us come November when we vote and we have opportunity to look at different things. Who knows what next year will bring us? So why do we look at the staff who agreed to no raise last year, who are still showing up every day, who have moved all of our schools up to A's and are consistently doing the work and say if we don't have to right now, I just choose to because it feels safer. Right now the world is unsafe.
>> Um on top of that $3.2 billion a year, we have these fiscal guard rails which limit the amount of money that we're allowed to spend in the state budget. And one of those guardrails, the volatility cap, um has uh it's it's a guardrail and all the guard rails make like perfect sense. I I support that all in principle. Um but the the volatility cap in particular um was meant so that um if you have a volatile stream of revenue, you're not in a good year with the floods of cash. You don't spend all that money, put in a bad year under short, you don't want to have a cut program. So if you spend the average, you know, in the good years, you take the excess above the average, put it in a rainy day fund, and the bad years can pull from that rainy day fund.
Um the other part of that though that I want to say is that once the conversation takes place and Okay. Yes. Okay. I understand. Okay. Thank you. Feel better now. Don't keep bringing it up again. whatever the issue was because then that just restarts the whole fire again. So that's something that has to not occur. Um once you've said, "Okay, I accept this. Yes, I understand. Okay, I understand." You may still not agree, but you've had a conversation. You come to a consensus of either, you know, you don't agree, but you're okay with it, we're cool, or maybe we're not cool, but we can work together. Whatever way it is, just don't keep bringing it back up. That's something that has um happened a lot and we want to make sure that that that goes away. And then um don't expect others to have the same feelings about um something being an issue because sometimes like you were saying, we may say something and or somebody says something and you take it one way that intent and but they didn't mean it that way and so they don't understand why you're mad.
So, there you go. Uh, Legislative Representative Dr. Blake Robinson. >> Nothing to report. >> Thank you, Dr. Robinson. Uh, item number 10, meeting dates. Dr. McCordon. >> Thank you, Mr. President. Governing board members, February 10th, we have a board work study and brief board business meeting. And on February 24th, we have a regular board business meeting. >> So, is there no policy meeting in February? >> There is not. >> Okay. Thank you. All right. Brings us to adjournment. Is there a motion to adjurnn? >> I move to adjurnn. >> Thank you, Miss Humphre. Is there a second? >> Second. >> Thank you, Miss Murray. All those in favor of adjournment say I. I. >> I.
There is no guarantee for so many things. So why not choose people? And I will always choose hope. And if you get mad at me community in a year from now, again, I still don't understand why you're angry at me. I didn't vote no on this override. I haven't campaigned against it. And I will always choose community always because I'm a part of this world and I see my neighbors and I see their kids and I love watching them grow. I love all of the new things that happen. And I choose to be a member of this community. And maybe over the course of the next year as the world continues to change and people start reaching out for community because we need it, then we find it and we somehow come together next year and we don't have to do any of this. I I can't there is no five alarm fire at the present moment in time when we have the opportunity to do that.
But the way they set the limit on that spending was arbitrarily low. So we've only been able to spend about 70% uh of that income, not not the average of that income. And as a result of that, um we've on top of this $3.2 billion a year payment, we've put in like10 billion over the last seven or eight years into the pension funds. And that's a really good thing. Um because you know in 2016 I think our liabilities were funded at like 35%. Now it's like around 60%. That's like huge progress. Know it's in the right direction. It's really great for state >> and it frees up hundreds of millions of dollars in budget. That's part of it because we're not paying that >> that 3.2 billion would be 4.2 billion if we haven't made those extra payments. Um but no, you're right. There is there is a balance to like you know I think this year we're supposed to have like $2 billion of extra money you know do we spend it now on things like uh updating the ECS formula and and increasing that base amount or you know do we continue to like pay off these pensions?
Um and then it gets all blown up and we have to talk it out again. so that clarity can be had and you can move on because you do have to work together as a governance team. >> Can I just rephrase? You said make it go away. Instead of making it go away, can we address it and resolve it and move on? >> Resolve it and move on. I like that better. Thank you. >> Resolve it and keep going. >> Yes. Yes. And that's what you have to do. So, thank you for bringing that up. And um hopefully now we'll move on and we won't have to come back to that one again. Any other ones up there? >> I just have a suggestion to strike out uh number five. It seems out of place. It doesn't seem like a protocol. I mean, we calendar study sessions every December, right?
I I it does not make sense. It does not compute. Why would I blow up what is working well when we don't have to? Doesn't make sense. Um, President Wade, you mentioned in the beginning you you continue to yell and lecture our our community members, yet you expect them to support us. And that's part of the problem. But uh with option one and two, literally it's like we're using a credit card and calling it a plan. And that's not that's not a plan. And it might feel easier now, but guarantees that there's going to be pain later. So we can um I I move to call the vote. >> I I I can motion, but Mr. Glover has his up. I just wish to express uh especially with 20 years of finance this would be savings not a credit card. This is savings not a credit card.
I I think there should be a balance to it. I think we should be able to use some of that money to do things um like sending more money to towns. Um and you know we also have a spending cap issue like which limits the amount of increases spending every year can't increase by more than a inflationary amount. Um in order to do things like reform the ECS formula send send the monies to town. We have to adjust that as well. Um I I think that makes a ton of sense. Uh I think that when we're making spending that is just going to towns that's a different kind of spending starting programs. I mentioned earlier I think like all the answers might be said to towns it's effectively a property tax cut. So we should look at things that I don't think our constituents that well.
>> Um because everything else is what the board's going to be doing, what the superintendent is going to be doing, the what the president's going to be doing. Uh so it just seems out of place to me. It seemed to just kind of be weird stuck right there in the middle. Um I I would like to keep it maybe in another place ju just for future reference. Um, I know Superintendent Ortega like is probably redundant, but there was a point where I've been here on this DAS and we didn't have any study sessions for like for a while. And so that's I >> that's why it's there to just to remind the board and to remind the superintendent um, hey, the study sessions need to be scheduled because they they weren't being scheduled. we were not having these conversations. Um there were like three of them or something like that and that's why that was put on there.
It won't cost more than what we have that is a very different aspect. Now to be clear from a finance perspective it does not feel great to blow up your savings which is why we went for an override. It's why we did it. >> A point of order. >> No. Yeah. You need a second right? Because I'm not done. I have another comment to make. She would need a second. Correct. >> Yes. Okay.
Um I would also say I don't think it's just between pensions and education. It's between pensions and everything. It's between pensions and are we going to fund new meals. It's between pensions and are we going to fund are we going to put money towards people's healthcare? We want to put money towards nonprofits who for years government has pushed off so many of what jobs the government used to do onto those nonprofits and then people expect the charity is going to be the only thing that um funds those nonprofits which is unrealistic you know considering most people are are struggling to get by and we often hear from our nonprofit providers like in for instance in the in the realm of homelessness a lot of those folks that are providing services to the actual homeless are either bar you know barely hanging on or already living in their cars homeless themselves.
>> So just leave it here. >> Any other comments on this? >> I I think we should put it in in maybe where the calendar is at. There's a calendar on here, right? >> Um I thought I saw one here. >> Yeah, there's I was looking. Maybe where the calendar's at might be great. Uh but you're right because it doesn't fit into this discussion here does not >> the meeting dates. Yeah, we have a calendar back here. >> Oh, there's a calendar. Yes. >> So maybe >> but he would just every year and you wouldn't know like he wouldn't know what to put on here until the calendar is developed for that year. Maybe just making a notation at the bottom or something or >> an aster or something. >> Oh, of the actual calendar. Oh, I see. Yes. Okay, understood. >> Yeah. >> So, strike it out of number five.
Hearing none, may I go? Okay. Thank you. Can you please pull up uh slide eight, please? That has the carry forward after reduction. Uh so everyone can see what we're talking about because I feel like I just I I'm I'm gobsmacked sometimes at some of the comments. Um especially like that we're using a credit card. We are not allowed to go in into the negative balance as we'd be in receiverhip. That's it's an absurd it's an absurd comment. uh for someone that's an elected official to make. So if you look at slide six, the line that says carry forward after reduction with option one, we are still carrying forward 15.25 million. Option two, 15.75 and 17.15 million. I don't see doom. I don't see this the you know that chicken little the sky is falling in in those scenarios. Again, I don't like the idea of option two, 45 sta, 45.5 staff, 63 staff.
Um, so I think that it's not everything Paul said is accurate and also it's not just between pensions and education because I I don't want people to walk away with the perception that we're pitting, you know, those pensions against whether or not we want to fund education appropriately because that that's not entirely true and and the fiscal programs are important. We we have reached the point where it is very difficult to explain to people why we wouldn't put more money towards our schools or towards valuable programs that benefit people in our state when we seem to be so flush with cash and we're trying to plead up for decades of mismanagement by both parties in terms of not paying the pension debt appropriately. Um, I mean, if you didn't pay your mortgage after two months, they'd take your house. So, um, it's it's very frustrating.