So, I I I'm trying to find where exactly this fits in with the generation who is using chat GPT no matter what. I use it no matter what. Plenty of people are using >> but they don't know the um also the limitation of it and what are some of the new threats, right? I mean right now there's a lot of um different kinds of attacks um um even like there are agents AI agents that can actually intercept different data um so it's all about >> hackers >> yes hackers they're like um human behavior I mean we're vulnerable right we're the weakest link in the cyber security chain in general but I think it's just really being awareness of um also that um there are a lot of hallucinations right with the uh Chad GPU Gemini and so um yes we're changing and technology is evolving but a lot of these tools are offering also some kinds of procedural very lengthy answer I don't know if you have tried recently but if you're asking for ideiation or an answer now Chad is providing this like uh a memo of long answers right this is not helping with really um thinking with AI really like um amplifying our uh creative and cognitive skills.
So how do we teach students really um to use it in a way that will help help them with concepts? >> Let me jump where she's going on this and it's a concern that I raise is that uh we're kind of late to the party, right? um the community, the businesses as AI has been introduced to the community. I mean, it's been there all the time, but it's not been in in the general general public till several years. Um that the university is supposed to be the leader in providing these uh this information safeguards, what's ethical, what's not ethical. uh but some of the professors a majority of professors have not even embraced AI to this day have not embraced AI and so while our students and our our teachers and businesses are out there trying to make sense of all of this there is nobody there until right now that you're starting this and I'm not putting this necessarily on you because you weren't here with the previous administration but you know for a university that says we're R1 and we're getting $700 million worth of research yet somehow the research did not embark on, hey, AI is coming, guys.
Hey, AI, you folks need to be in in front of the ball and not wait five, six years later to say, oh, now we're putting these working groups together. Now, we're going to be out there because again, there it's already out there with good or bad um bad habits already been been um uh adopted and yet the university is lagging behind. Um so let me ask you so how are you uh working with the community college and their AI efforts? So each community I mean um the community college and all of the different campuses have different initiatives and I had conversations to understand where the efforts are and I agree that there should be more coordinated effort to really kind of keep the inventory open and the discussions ongoing. Um but you >> point to a specific a specific program and a specific um community college that you're working with to coordinate this Um I am uh currently um not managing their efforts.
Um things have been highlighted um of what other in you know campuses are doing. We have a representative uh from the community college and our task force. Um but um >> but you said you've done all these listening tours and you've been to all these college. So is there any specific college that is working on AI a specific project? There are many different colleges that are working on many different um like for example there is a the business school is launching a pilot of AI innovation lab um and other uh projects uh but those are campus specific. We bring awareness and opportunity. One of my goal now is to create this like systemwide network, a platform to build this community of practice, coordination, visibility of those projects um so that uh we understand even how we can scale those efforts across different campuses. >> But I'm not managing them.
I'm just trying to really create the platform in the community. Um but if this is if this is an a project for the entire university then if a campus is using state monies for a program we don't want to see one here one there we want to see that it's coming together um so let before I ask um Kahel to come up so what is your you have an office AI office or >> yes it's a newly established office office of academic technology innovation office just you right now. >> Um it's uh we just established the office when I first came in and I have three part-time um employees that are supporting my work um for this semester and they have a very particular campus technology experience and capacity to really uh help me. Um but we haven't formalized a structure or teams yet. >> And the and the budget for your office is how much do I have a budget for that office?
>> I think someone else will answer that question. >> Right now the budget is uh is between two to three million but what Ena is doing and what the positions that she has right now are people that exist at the campus level and have been essentially redeployed. So, we're accounting for them in terms of >> So, where were they before? >> Um, I think one person was uh was within the community college. Uh, >> and we don't need them anymore. So how why would we even have they're they're um splitting their time because uh these are individuals that you know have the expertise or and have the knowledge uh for the work that ENA is doing to try and implement these these systemwide initiatives going forward. So it's more of a redeployment of existing resources versus the establishment of a brand new budget, but we're accounting for that.
>> Yeah, that's good. Um but in business Pacific business you said that uh to launch a fully online degree program. So is that your major major role or is it to coordinate across all the campuses and bringing AI like you explained to us or is it to do the degree or is it both? Um so I am in my office right now is developing as I mentioned an AI online course which is a short introductory course. I am I'm not sure about the rest of the programs that have been brought up at the at the news but that's what I'm um responsible for. >> But you did go to all the campuses and you did a listening tour. >> I did. Yes. >> Okay. And over what period of time was that? from when I started. This is an ongoing effort and as I mentioned, we're really trying to bring visibility um in our AI inventory and experimenting also to create a dashboard and try to add that dashboard within our website.
>> So, what percentage of your time is spent here in Hawaii versus um out of state? >> Um 100%. >> 100% here. >> Yes. >> Sure. >> I based on what I hear. So maybe I u would like to actually offer an explanation. Um I moved in Hawaii in September and during my tenure I had to actually travel due to unforeseen family emergencies. Unfortunately I had to resolve this issue which um required me to travel briefly. Now since the issue has been resolved I'm here. >> Okay. Well that's good to know. But you when you say you're here 100% it it didn't pro it didn't go along to what you know this is a small place. Hawaii is a small place and and people talk a lot. So I just want to >> yeah I just want to be transparent as well and >> and if your program is getting two to3 million um we will definitely start nitpicking.
Um just circling back really quick uh to that position with your uh three part-time staffers. >> Um where is your physical office? Um at the ICT campus at the Korea road >> 2520 in Manol. Yes. >> Not in Bachmann. >> No, not in the back. No, >> we were in the WH web meeting. She said you in Bachman Hall. No, >> no, it's it's in it's in it. >> It Yes. Building. >> Okay. Well, she did say in her office. >> So, she said >> she she said [clears throat] >> the question was posed where is she housed? And >> in my office. I mean I think housed in terms of organizationally >> organizationally she's housed under the president's >> well I think it's physically because I asked the question about >> is she here so well anyway that's water can we call um Cahel >> okay >> thank you >> no no you're not done okay I'll get >> okay [laughter] >> so have you met have you met with him >> yes and you talked about your program.
>> Yes. Briefly. >> Yes. >> Okay. Well, that was what I was getting at and and I was surprised you didn't specifically because the legislature has only appropriated for one AI program with his workforce and she's one. And so, with you not mentioning it, it makes me wonder, you know, where have who have you been talking to? Because we've only had one and we gave a million dollars, which is why we we know this program. And we want I want to know I'm sure the committee wants to know is how are we coordinating this and we don't want to duplicate it and if you're there then why do we need you or vice versa? >> I know this is specifically on workforce >> but again if we're doing a whole AI then we need to incorporate it and and [clears throat] make sure that the funding that we're spending is not going to you know it's not going to be duplicated at some point or Yeah.
So I I mean our project is a AI project. So using AI to improve information access and sharing. >> Isn't that exactly what she said that she's supposed to be doing or is doing? >> Yes. I think her I mean I'm not going to speak for her but ours is pretty specific. Hers is right now across our campuses we have all kinds of AI things happening right now. That's why we want to >> with faculty with academic senates with all kinds of different groups >> and she's the person to bring together the system initiatives. This is probably one initiative under the larger umbrella of all of them >> right >> that has a specific purpose. So her I think hers is more instructional >> and ours is more information access and as a AI tool for our students, faculty and also the community. Well, that worries me when you say, "Oh, hers is more instructional.
Ours is more I mean, shouldn't there be a current?" >> I mean, effort they can use, but when I mean instructional, it's sort of like I mean, I come from Maui College, right? So, faculty are figuring out how to use AI and how to manage AI in their classrooms. I mean, they have been doing that for years. What's coming to head is sort of the collaborative effort to maybe align some of those initiatives across the campuses. So like in the classroom like how do you teach English 100 and how do you manage the use of AI when you're trying to teach somebody to write and they can go into chat GPT and get you know what I mean? So it's those kinds of instructional strategies I think that um we're trying to figure out on a very that's the sort of simplest application of AI but it's one thing that we're managing.
>> So you had submitted an RFP to create the interface. >> Yes. >> Right. and it posted Monday I think. Yes. >> Okay. So, is that also a resource that she will be using or how do how does her role integrate into your role or it doesn't? I mean, how does your role integrate into hers? Yeah, >> I think at some point probably in the um the process that we are in now for the RFP um we posted the RFP then we will get submissions and then we have to review um the submissions to of course select the vendor and that is something that probably [clears throat] um will involve somebody from her office or herself in to help us sort of analyze the submissions to figure out what vendor is the best vendor to move forward with. >> Okay. Because you guys were you guys were planning your system before her.
>> Yes. >> Right. Okay. So, what was your plan if she wasn't here? Like you guys would have probably figured it out, right? >> Yeah. And I I guess our the the our understanding of the million dollars was not for AI application in the instructional areas. Our understanding was that they wanted a tool >> Yeah. that could be used by anybody basically [clears throat] um to access information on education pathways from the high school into the 2-year into the four-year along with all the other um applications that somebody would want to access if they're looking for employment, right? So they can >> Shouldn't that be part of that program? Because there's all these working groups. So how are you your program dovetailing with some of these working groups? this particular tool um >> because it's it's a tool but it's going to be a tool for everybody pretty much.
>> Sure. Right. >> Sure. >> Right. >> So it's an AI tool. >> Mhm. So again, we we need what we're trying to get here and why asking you these questions is not clear in our minds as to what is the funding going for and whether or not there'll be duplicate programs or whether or not we're efficiently using and who exactly is going to be the one to tell us what what's going on and the the fact that uh needs to be the point of the spear and needs to be ahead of the rest of the community so that you can guide the students, guide the teachers, the faculty, the public school administrators and even legislators about AI, >> right? And and how it should be used and what what's ethical and what's not ethical and the fact that, you know, whatever you you write into into chat GPT will stay in the system and they will grab whatever you're saying and they will send it out.
I've argued with chat GPT, by the way, because they gave me wrong information and I said, "Are you sure?" Because, "Oh, you're right." that but you know if you don't correct them then they have the wrong information and that's what information they're going to spit out to somebody else that ask a similar question. Um but again I you know I've learned this through through you know trial and error but these are stuff that a lot of people out there have no clue about and how the university getting ahead of this uh so that you know whether it be night classes for for adults for working adults whether it be you know just other other ways of of um offering some kind of workshops to the general public and or stuff like that. How is a university going to >> Yeah. No, thank you so much.
These are so valid concerns and I have to tell you the world of AI so messy. Everybody right now is trying exactly to figure out how to put the right, you know, governance, how to really coordinate efforts, how to manage AI and teams together. And this is exactly what we're trying to do. >> By the time you do that, it's going to be outdated because it changes so fast. Right. >> It is changing. Yes. But that's why we are trying with smaller efforts right now with this. For example, online uh course that we're launching, right? Um then the task force will have a more concrete recommendation plan. I'm also uh trying to build a community of practice and really um kind of solidify what this campus engagement look like to really hope that we will not have a duplicative uh efforts and that's a big undertake.
Uh one of this um deliverables is as I mentioned is to build a dashboard and really to keep everybody informed but you can't keep them informed just like by survey right there has to be a more coordinated platform. So, those are kinds of pressing issues that keep me at night and there are no no straight answers and I'm trying to be as fast as I can and I really appreciate the opportunity to collaborate with you to keep you informed. >> You know, to hear you say that there are no straight answers is problematic because you are coming in and you're supposed to be the experts, right? The expert. You're supposed to tell us where there are loopholes and where we need to tighten up. And right now with your position and have already started your um interface uh process, I feel like I feel like the university is just trying to make your position work to make it work.
And it's coming with a heavy $3 million budget. And so I I I I'm trying to understand what is the negative impact if we didn't have your position. I think that society would figure it out. I think that we would go on. It could potentially make your program a little bit more difficult because what you were doing was creating an access to the data. The student could come, they can get it, they can get all the information. Now, we're adding on another piece which could potentially make it more complicated. So, creating a dashboard, um I don't know necessarily, >> well, I'm just pointing one of the uh deliverables, right? But um there should be a strategic oversight and as I mentioned coordinated action and um I have been working in the industry I have 10 more than 10 years experience within product and innovation. As I mentioned things are really changing very fast.
Um what we really need to do is keep the conversations and have a shared understanding of how we're moving forward. That starts with having a shared knowledge of AI. >> What's this? I think it starts with you informing us like you can start by giving us a list of these uh working groups, which group groups are doing what, who's on the groups. Uh you can do that by letting us know what your goals and what what your your steps calendar and what the outcomes that you're going to have. I think if you can provide that to us and how it dubtales into the community colleges as well in the community then it'll give us a better understanding of what's going on but without that kind of feedback and communication then you're going to have people questions a lot of questions and even then we're probably going to have some questions so >> thank you I will follow up with information as >> yeah I'm really curious to know how this also impacts our DOE students students who are um learning AI in learning to get on probably by without their parents' knowledge and you know all of these things.