2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 189
But the fact that you're not, and the fact that you've had Ali Nolani sitting there for eight years and the president coming up and said he didn't know about it and then we find out that he didn't know about it because they had permits and they had plans and they nixed it. So those kinds of things does not sit well with us. >> Understood. And and I I can say from my perspective, our intention really is to change the narrative around that. >> I hope so. I really hope so with the new president, new leadership. But some of the things that I'm seeing and hearing worries me, you know, like more higher bureaucracy, um things like that. But so I'm trying to bring it up so you folks understand the concerns and hopefully don't go down that road. >> Yeah. because I do want this administration to succeed and I do want to see, you know, meaningful changes.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 190
It doesn't happen overnight. I know that that but we need to be moving in that direction. We seem to be moving in that direction and I hope we continue to move in that direction.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 191
>> Thank Thank you, Chair. Yes. And and you have our commitment to uh to work together. >> Okay. So um the is the is the occupancy rate of rise about the same 70% to 78%. >> Yes, it's at 70% right now. >> It's at 70. Any folks at 70? >> It's a little bit >> 65%. Why do we know why? >> Um [clears throat] there is a number of reasons. I think you know in part it was due to the uh just staffing turnover with the property management team and so there were some um headwinds that we faced. However, we did uh replace the the property manager who started in November and so we believe that led to lower office, >> but we've raised these concerns when you folks were first leasing the building and then building the building, right? We've raised that. I've raised that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 192
>> You had a boy chair that raised it and it went it fell on their ears. So the first two years of operation, we met all of the financial objectives. We're in our third year of operations and yes, we did run into some challenges, but we're addressing that. >> Okay. Yeah. The prediction was it's going to be a white elephant. So I hope that doesn't come come to fruition, but given the track record, I don't know. Okay. Thank you. Next, I don't know what to take next. Okay, why don't we go to Sinclair? >> Okay, >> so higher education committee visited St. Care last year. >> Okay, remember we went to Sinclair. It appeared close to being completed. Yes. >> To be open on August 2025th. >> Yes. >> Is it open? >> No, it is not. Um and >> no, I know that answer right now.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 193
>> Yes, I know. Amazing. >> Um, yes. And anybody that drives up and down University AB, >> I mean, what what happened? Why? Again, you know, the track record is just it's crazy. >> So, yes. Uh, I would say definitely um not proud of the fact that it's not open. Um probably two major reasons is uh Swintton is the contractor um that was also building Halle Halani and uh we the Sinclair project experienced a staffing shortage um uh primarily so that Sernen could redirect its resources [clears throat] to get Hal County built. Um, that's that's one, but also I will say we've uh we've instituted some quality control measures that we are holding our contractor to. Um, and so if they don't pass um we do make them, we do it. And uh it's between those two uh building envelope quality uh issues as well as staffing issues.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 194
That's where we are today. But I'm hopeful that this is the year 2026 year [laughter] >> and I don't know. Yeah. If I got to come before you next year and it's still not open. I don't know. I don't >> What you mean you don't know? >> So we heard earlier about a door about not having planning is holding up that we hear staffing shortage and we hear for the same things from you. So you you see the trend and this is not anything new because this go way back to some of the other projects that I'm not going to bring up at this point. >> So the delay now is what 18 to 24 months delay. >> Yeah, probably close to that. >> 18 to 20 months delay. >> Yeah. >> What's the cost >> for something like that? Um, well, we do have liquidated damages provisions if that's what I think is that what you're getting at or the I mean, you know, it's it it was a library before and it it's definitely serving a different use now.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 195
>> But you knew that when you started. You knew that when you went out to bid, so that's not an excuse. >> Yeah. >> So, how what is the overruns? How much is the overruns? I mean, okay, we gave you folks. [sighs] How much money did we give you folks for for Sinclair? >> You know, 54 million. >> Okay. >> Right. Or 41 million. No, we gave you 41 million. >> 40 million. 40. It was >> We gave you 40 million. Okay. >> So, 40 million. Yeah. >> And so, how much is the actual total cost of this project going to be? >> I want to say, and I apologize. Um, I don't have that particular detail. >> Come on. >> In front. I know. I'm I did not >> You were going to go see. >> Let's see. Let's see. Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 196
Um, >> I'm not going to have any more athletic questions. So, if you got to go recruit and raise money. [laughter] >> 60. Yeah, we want we want to see the money coming in. So, you can go. I do on this video. >> Perfect. >> You can next time you can ask if you can leave. >> We will we try to accommodate >> uh 62.7 million. >> 62.7 million is the total cost. >> Yeah. >> For the project. So we gave you 40 million. So you have 22.7 million overrun. >> Well, we signed a contract for more than 40. We signed the original contract um amount was 56 million56. >> Well, what that what that have to do with anything? [laughter] >> We gave the fact we gave you 40 million. Oh, so you anticipated 56 >> and it went over >> 40 million wasn't enough.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 197
>> Yes, 40 million wasn't enough. >> And so where did that extra money come from? >> Likely paid for it. likely a combination of BIM and tuition increase. >> There we go. >> So the the 16 million over what we gave you and you went ahead and done it and then over that now you have another um >> 6 million $7 million in change >> that you have to >> and that's change orders. So how many change orders? Thank you for raising that. How many change orders? I had it down though. I would have >> I don't have the total number of change orders. >> Okay. So, as of the letter as of a letter from David Lner dated July 26, 2024 change orders of that as of that date number 19 for a total of $82,000 and change. >> So, that was as of 2024.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 198
>> We're in 2026, two years later. How many change orders additional were they? >> I can get back to you on that. I don't have that detail. >> And tell us what those change orders were for. >> Yes, we will give you a detailed breakdown. >> Okay. So again, and you have no date of completion that you can give us. >> December of this year 2026. >> Okay. You guys all that heard I know. I'll see. >> Did you tattoo that in front of you? I will. [laughter] I've got my tattoo gun in the office. >> Okay. My team. [laughter] >> Any other questions on Sinclair before we move on? So, do we have to go visit it again because it changed since the what we saw the last time? >> Um, not there's Yeah, not been a lot of >> Okay. How about Snider Hall?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 199
>> Okay. >> How much did the legislature give you for Snyder Hall? >> 70. I thought it was like 48. 35 and 35 I think. >> 70. >> Okay. That that Yeah. >> Wow. Very generous. Okay. And what's the new cost for Snider? So we um well we combined two projects um where there was a uh our McCarthy Mall um >> what we've been calling it the McCarthy Mall revitalization project. >> Okay. Before you talk about adding in McCarthy, when you came before us and we gave you 70 million, what was that 70 million supposed to be for? >> The Snyder Replacement Building. >> Snider Replacement. Yes. >> Okay. And did that cost go up by itself? >> Yes. >> What did it go up to? >> It went up by an additional 17.7 million. which was effectively what happened was when we bid it out when we bid it out um the uh you know se six uh 68.9 was what the the bid um starting bid came in at we had given you 70 so you had enough >> and that that built four stories it built four stories Um there was the original desire was for it to be five stories.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 200
That was the original scope given what 70 could only afford us four stories. So we um used tuition funding to add another 17.7 to add a fifth floor which we had to make the goal no goal decision at the time that we awarded the fifth floor was a line item I mean an additive that we could add um if that was the desire because we had to make the call at the time because either that elevator is going to four stories or five stories. So, uh that was the >> So, it was supposed to be $87.7 million to get a fivestory building. >> That's what it ended up um costing us. >> Exactly that much. >> Yeah. >> But then you focus >> then you somehow got a sense that you needed to do McCarthy Mall. >> Yeah. So, McCarthy Mall um is widely known um I would say as like it's been widely known the beautifification type of a project but it really is um it it it's it's at its core it's a drainage upgrade project and the entire campus drainage system which is mostly within the McCarthy mall area it's all subsurface um it >> so what was the cost for this.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 201
Okay. So, is McCarthy Mall a building or it's just a mall? >> It's a drainage. It's a sewer. It's a drainage upgrade project. >> So, no building. >> No building. We needed to uh upsize our capacity to withstand a once in a 10-year storm. >> And the toss for that was 16.6 million. >> Okay. And it included Paradise Palms. >> Yes. >> So, could you not have done the drainage, just the drainage without doing the entire >> Yes, we could have. >> At what cost would that have been? >> Um, I don't have it broken down in those two. >> So, why didn't we just do the drainage? >> I mean, we we that was an that was an option. Um the the Paradise Palms area uh if if you're kind of familiar with it, uh there's a there's a big open seating area associated.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 202
It's there's no it's not covered. Um so not a lot of people use it. You're either sitting in the sun or the rain or it's dark. Um there's no lights because there's no it was just open. Uh and so we did see it as a highly underutilized area. So the um desire was to um make improvements to that space so that students could actually use that space for outdoor seating um for studying for gathering uh because that's in its current state. It did not attract that type of um body heat as we would call it. So it was highly underutilized. So because we were kind of already ripping up the mall right in front of it, um that was the time to do the upgrade. >> So what's the total cost of this project? >> So the so the McCarthy Mall was 16.6 which includes Paradise Palms which which comes out to a total of just under 105 million.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 203
So it was 87.7 + 16. >> Correct. >> No cost overruns. >> Uh not not yet. >> Not just yet. I think we had I think we we might have had one small one. >> And when is this supposed to be complete? >> In two years. So 27. >> When did you start? >> 27. um mid summer of of 20 five. >> And is it on a schedule or you right now it's still on schedule? >> Just like just like Sinclair, right? >> Oh, no. I hope it's not just like Sinclair, but yes. Right. Uh it's it's starting off um that way, but hopefully it doesn't. So what was the projected date of completion for Schneider Hall McCarthy Mall? >> Expected completion date is sorry. summer of 2027. >> Okay. So, literally you have a year and a half. >> Yep. >> That date. >> Yes.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 204
>> Don't sound so um enthusiastic about it. [clears throat] >> Well, I already know in my words. >> Yes. >> Well, that's not encouraging. Oh my god. [laughter] Again, why is no one ready? Um members, I don't think I don't hear you guys with so Okay. I know this is this is um Senator Hashimoto's question, but his his question about the means of financing from revenue bonds to go bonds for >> Oh, okay. >> for the housing >> Yes. >> situation. >> Yeah. And also, is student housing going to be run by system or by Monoa? And what's the long-term plan? Oh, I um Okay. I don't know what the long-term plan is. Maybe I think that's still being sorted out. I I don't I don't feel I'm in a position to um I think it's unknown right now >> for the for this uh who is going to be managing student housing.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 205
>> Yeah. Is it going to be a system fall under the system or is it going to fall under um Monoa or I don't know >> it'll be the [laughter] >> so that decision has not been made at this time. There is a recommendation from the board of regions to look into three areas uh that may go from system down to mano. One of them is student housing, the other one is facilities and the third one is auxiliary services. So that uh discussion is starting uh but a decision hasn't been made yet. So that's where we are with that. >> When is the decision going to be made? uh we hope to have a decision by I would hope by the end of this academic year by June and then we need to execute how this is going to is going to run because it also will affect uh the recruitment of who's going to be the next chancellor right uh we need to have an idea of how to position the assets of the campus >> so where would student housing fall in the overall priorities of the university I think probably one of the highest priorities of the university.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 206
>> Okay. When you say one of the highest, how come some of these other ones have leap frog? >> Uh, okay. I was not uh here when these decisions uh were made. Also, student housing sometimes the method of financing is through the rents that the students do pay. Those rents have been stagnant for quite a while. So the reserve accounts in order to upkeep those uh those facilities uh were not kept up in healthy balances and therefore the the student housing fell in some type of disrespect disrepair. Uh and then at that point uh uh VPA jumped in uh uh to see what they can do and then they would use resources from the main campus to try to >> to bring the >> So if the occupancy rate for Kani and occupancy of rise is where it's at continue to stay where it's at and if we have more students students online, less people coming onto the campus.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 207
If enrollment goes down, do are we going to need more student housing to be built? >> I think we going to need uh more student housing or at least maintain the existing inventory we have at Manoa. Uh though we have online students, uh 92% of them are on campus. out of uh the 100% of students at Manoa, 48 are 100% uh uh you know, but I'm hoping you folks are projecting into the future because we build we build you know pharmacy school, we build um housing and then yet and we cannot fill it because or it doesn't come to pass because we our projections are off. >> I I don't want to talk about other campuses. I'll talk for Mano and you and I we were up in DC at NC and CSL and as you saw you know a lot of the community colleges even in other states they have the same issues that we do have.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-29 Honolulu County, HI YouTube / Hawai'i State Senate transcript source: youtube EDU Informational Briefing 01-28-2026 · passage 208
They have a lot of an online population and each state is struggling of what they're going to do with the infrastructure they have put on on these places or on these uh spaces. However, you also heard that the flagship institutions do not have the same issue because the students come there not just for an education but a whole experience which actually attracts them to be >> on campus. >> I don't expect that answers to come today or tomorrow but I'm hoping that you folks are looking at this and that you're going to be able to share what your what the plans or thoughts are as to going forward. [cough] Right? Because as we look at do we invest in redoing polyoi line or do we upgrade the current dorm situation there? Do we look at opening up >> polani to more undergraduate? I mean you know looking at what you already have and how do you utilize it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above