It seems like you do it every year. You know, you kind of decide every year if you really need it because I don't know, it's a decent amount of money and I understand the caution, but I just can't imagine >> we'll be in a 2004 situation where we're, you know, that board's panicking a little bit. Not panicking, but trying to be cautious. >> What caution? No, I think you're being cautious. Like you're saying, look, these open these open lands. We don't want to be caught. >> I think it was the word choice when you say caution. >> so am I am I hearing just for for sake of summaries, am I hearing that the board would like to see an updated space study that we did in 2022 and then potentially carry the conversation whether or not we should determine a demographic study based on that information that could help drive it.
>> Yep. >> I like how you synthesized that because that was one of our goals. We were kind of One more. Um, so next building and finance will discuss the space study. >> Is that can can I can I get back from the architects timetable for you? But yeah, we we'd aim for February, but we would want to work with them first. >> Okay. >> All right. Thank you. Next, under new business, we have responsible bidder ordinanceformational. I know that has um come to light. We had a speaker a couple months ago and people have asked for more information about that. >> So, yes. So, uh, just to to kick off the conversation, it was, as Dr. Zeter said, it was brought up at our last meeting. Um, the the concept of a responsible bid ordinance. I prepared a memo with, um, some information about what it is, as well as, um, we did, uh, confer with our legal council at HLK with regard to the proposal, uh, which is included in the memo, um, and a draft of one particular, um, example, I guess, which would be from Orland Park Village, who does have, uh, this ordinance.
Um so we wanted to give that we I provided that in advance to both Dr. Zeter and Mr. Casmmer. You have it at your table just for review. Uh but obviously we wanted to give you the information uh in terms of discussion and for the board to provide direction regarding this particular um concept. Go >> ahead. Um, so you know, if I understand like the responsible bidder ordinance, the one thing that it it sort of um encourages our like contractors that we do um aside of like prevailing rate requirements and things like that, it's it's also that they have to participate in um apprentichip programs, you know, Department of um labor bureau of apprentichip and training certified programs and that those programs have to actually graduate apprentices. Um, you know, I think it's like generally a good thing for us to add on to our, you know, policies.
Um, you know, or bid requirements for that. I mean, just last month, our curriculum spotlight was all about kids like trying to go into like CT and stuff like that. And, you know, I think it's good for us to support organizations and contractors that, you know, um, are creating opportunities for our students as they come out of here. Um, you know, I as much as I'm a supporter of prevailing rate, like I would also, you know, be a supporter of something like this because I think it also, you know, protects the district from fly by night contractors and those, you know, that you don't have a long-standing commitment to uh aircraft. >> Yeah. >> Um, to that point, Dave, I I just I know that we have that uh in our bid packages about prior projects and schools and things of that nature. So, I do want to make sure that the board realizes that we put protections into our bid packages for that reason.
Correct, Dave? >> Correct. We have a lot of uh protections for the school district in our bid packages. Um extended from the uh apprentichip program, but all of it that's listed in there and almost everything in that uh memo from last week is is pretty much what we do in school district by state law. uh the rail wage the contractor has to other municipality the school districts uh contracts of the same size within the last three years we see their financials we see uh they submit a lot of things to school district to make sure that we're getting a qualified contractor and that if uh we have a problem with it we have the right to reject it >> and and as you'll see in the memo the ordinance is really designed for municipalities who do not have the same restrictions that school districts do vis school code.
Um and and the one thing that I do want to point out that was in part of the recommen or the the um I guess the feedback from Hler Thurquis, you know, we want to be very cautious and and minimally look into some of of the of the bids. Um I mean, it could reduce significantly the number of bids that we receive for projects, which tends to inflate the cost of projects. Um, so I just want to be cautious with putting things in there that might actually have an inadvertent effect. Even though I think that what the intent is is um I think we all share that that same desire, if you will, but having that in policy might might might be might encumber some of those bids in the future. And even in some cases, I know we were talking about the the was it the fiber optics bid, John, that >> we we might not have any actual certified biders for projects um specific projects if nobody in the industry has people that went through apprenticeships.
Okay, >> so we just have to be cautious at this particularly moving forward and even with the language itself. >> Um there's only four uh six districts in the state of Illinois that adopted it. Four adopted it as it pertains to their villages language. Uh, Manuka and CPS are the only other two districts that have this in their in their uh in their actual policy have this language. >> Now, is it the is it a resolution or >> it would be would actually be a policy that we would have to adopt. I I don't know what policy number it is, but we'd have to amend current policies to >> and I and I do agree with Chris. I think it's a it'll be a good policy resolution to have. Um, it's a good taxpayer protection plan. Um, and I don't know. I That's a good question.
With the fiber optic, but with the other work, it would possibly provide better quality work that could last 20 years, maybe instead of 10 years. >> Um, district 218 did adopt this. >> And and I look into that. It wasn't in that district that I did. So I do I think it's a good policy to look at and to start um discussing more about this. I think it's you know if it helps students to join apprenticeship as well that way they could benefit from that. I think it it's a policy I would support. >> No the only thing though again I'm going to I'm going to kind of go off of what Dr. Noling said and I think we have to be really really cautious um on on what we do here and how we word it. I understand all your points and and it's well taken and and whatever.
Um, but again, I I I just want to make sure that that we don't condense the available contractors out there so much that we potentially get in a situation where either there are no contractors available that meet all these requirements or again we have such a a limited number that we may end up paying more than than we should. I think that if we look back over the history of the contractors who have been here, and yes, we've had some issues with especially the the ball field that's staged. We understand that. Um that's going to happen once in a while. But overall, I would say a large very large percentage of the contractors that we brought in here have done great work for us. Um, and I I don't see Muhammad Al the one statement you made is, well, instead of it lasting 10 years, we get this other contractor, it's going to last 20.
I don't think that's that's reality. Um, you know, maybe it's a a year more or something, but what at what cost? So, I really we need to really think this through and be very cautious um on how we word this and what we require so we don't put the district in a bind to potentially not be able to do some of the work that we need to do. >> Could we could you um Dr. Nelson, you said you'd look into district 218. Could you share with us 218s? So then we look like you said um Mr. territory about that and we're looking at all those considerations >> and then I think Oakan High School has one as well. Can you look into that? I I think I don't know if >> members Dalton >> I just wanted to add one more thought to this um as we try to navigate and and think about this consider this is that we are in the field of education and we want to make sure that uh in from my point of view we should be encouraging our kids when they're going to pursue through a career to go through a path where they're going to get the best resources for the career they're going to do.
And so if they go through a certified program where they're going to be able to learn the trade the right way and not go through and work with my friend's dad's brother um and learn the trade in that way and and you know both routes get you there. But when you go through an established trade program and you're learning the trade the right way, most of the time you will find that tradesmen the cost difference is minimal because they are able to do it efficiently. They know the best practices. And so, um, because we're in education, I want to support our students to be looking at these opportunities to go through, um, a process of actually learning these trades the way to get the best skill set that they can get. Um, and you know, we we want our um, other areas to be educated and we want to promote that.
you know, we promote our teachers to go on to get their masters and their doctorates. Um, education is really important and I do think this is an area that we could show support for education in another area. Um, and that's all. I just I would just like to consider this to learn more about this and think of it in that realm as well. Thank you. So again, synthesizing, I think what I'm hearing is that the board is is interested in looking to see how this might um look moving forward, seeing what other districts might be using some of the similar language and and even if they are, we could look u have some conversations with their leadership to see the pluses and minuses that they've um experienced once they adopted this policy. And I could bring that back again. Um I'll aim for the February building finance if that will work.
Um but if it doesn't um if we don't fit the timeline, I'll certainly be in communication and let you know. We'll bring it down the road. >> Yeah. I'd just like to see mostly how how much it might shrink our our bidder pool. >> Um if if there's not many that can meet, you know, these requirements of being part of a, you know, somebody who could bid on, you know, to a school with a with a bidding ordinance, um you know, then then that would be a real problem. But I I agree with everything else that you said about quality of work and all that. But um if it's something where there's not that many places out there that can meet the requirements, then that has to be something we consider, too. Uh I I would just like to add one more comment just because uh you know this is my industry.
Um you know I I can tell you from you know firsthand knowledge that uh all of the biders who returned a bid for the HVAC um HVAC um project that we're going to discuss or that we already approved all of them would meet this standard. That would not have narrowed that in any way. Um, I do know several months ago, I'm not going to mention the name of the contract because I don't want to get sued for disparaging a contractor publicly, but we had a contractor reply to one of our bids that's well known in our industry for, you know, um, being what we just call a briefca briefcase contractor that like was going to resub the workout somewhere else. Like, fortunately, they were not our low bid. um you know and and it went to the low bidder actually would still meet the um requirement or this language but it would have excluded that bid from that one contractor that that was not low.
Right. So I I do think that like you know there are advantages to stuff like this that it also like gets rid of separates some wheat from the chaff sometimes. Um you know and maybe off of a microphone. I'll tell you who those contractors were and what the the package was. But uh you know >> what's that term again? Briefcase company. Brief >> briefcase contractor. >> Well, that's what we call them. Like somebody who doesn't do any work. >> That's the term brief. >> It's informal. >> Is that a Casmer term or is that a >> No, it's it's some people say that I I've heard a lot in construction, right? Where they're they're out bidding on stuff, but they don't employ any trades people. They don't GC the work. They're just trying to get a low bid and they're going to resub it all out and hope that they're, you know, that they get that margin.
So, >> thank you. >> Um, for one, Dr. Noting for when we um accept a contract accept a contract do the contractor mostly do the contractor do the work or do they norm do they subcontract it to a company >> that would be in the bid correct Dave >> it's a requirement in our bids that they perform one of the major trades so if they're an HVAC contractor that sub the electrical out contractor project they sub out the the roofing part for the supports they don't obviously not a lot of companies have all of that so that's why we made the must do one trade. So it's a big percentage of the project. >> So the primary work has to be done by the company on the bid. But if they have to contract with an electrician to come in and do one portion, >> correct?
>> Okay. >> Or if it's an electrical thing, it's a roof thing. It depends on the project really. But they the bidder has to perform at least one major trade in the package. >> But not not the primary trade. >> Well, I'm just trying to clarify because Bob asked um you know, do they have to perform the primary part of the job and that's not the requirement right that we have the requirement is they have to perform some aspect of it one of the traits correct we usually review a Make sure they're qualified. Make sure they stand by the no mistakes like that. We've had >> Okay. >> We'll come back with information. >> All right. Thank you. All right. Next on our new business is the IHSA cooperative programs. >> Yes. First of all, if I could just begin by thanking the the student athletes who I think all for study maybe studying nutrition or something.
Um as well as the parents who came out. Yes. Thank you. Um just to give a board an update as as you heard in the in the board comment as well as in the education committee report, you know, we were very much disappointed with the uh membership vote um on Proposition 5, which uh has a deep um impact on six programs in district 230. um explaining a brief moment to the board of the bylaw process from the IHSA. The IHSA has an open uh democratic process where they'll take um uh proposals to the bylaw adjustments from any member school in the state of Illinois. Um if they are vetted through a legislative uh procedure process um they will go to the membership for vote. So obviously prop five um went to the legislative process um and frankly um went to the membership vote. Um once it got up uh up and running uh we did reach out to the IHSA and other uh schools to see uh pardon the expression what kind of legs this proposal had.
We were told at the time that it was very uh they they didn't see it happening. They didn't see moving forward. Um so we were relatively surprised when the December vote hit and it was actually on the ballot. Um and got overwhel uh not overwhelming but got uh a decent amount of support. Um throughout that process, District 230 wrote a dear colleague letter to the IHSA in the IHSA board of elective uh of officials. Um which is the good news is we have one uh friendly face on the board which is our very own uh Steve Shans who's the athletic director here um at uh at Samberg High School. Um, and we also, um, wrote a a, um, impassion letter to the IHSA board to minimally delay the implementation of this bylaw until, uh, schools like us could have a a longer runway to make some decisions.
Uh, both were of course denied by the board. Um, and we are where we're at today. Um, as you heard, gymnastics is definitely a program that is impacted by this decision, as well as girls wrestling, boys and girls lacrosse, and boys and girls water polo at Samber, excuse me, Stag and Andrew. um the the other co-ops are currently three school co-ops. Uh but as you know based on enrollment projections, any co-op between any two of our schools would would violate Prop 7. Uh we've also did a lot of work with the IHSA to better define what sports um how sports would be impacted if they are team sports versus individual sports. What I mean by individual sports is uh students uh student athletes can score individually um in in game medals as an individual um and and then team sports are bracketed sports that obviously scores a whole team.