That's why you have the meetings. This is one of the reasons why I've specifically asked for the board of regents border regions, the board of education to be here in these meetings. And I hope they all got to watch the hearing on f Friday we had last Friday because I don't recall ever that the board took up any of the audits. I don't believe the board even asked for the auditor to come and explain to them about the audits, you know. Well, you did. >> That's not true. >> Okay. You can I'll let you come up and you can you can make it um you can respond. >> Yeah. What you want me to respond to? >> Well, okay. Have you folks met with the auditor on the audits? >> We personally didn't meet with the audit, but the heat abatement audit was on the board agenda as well.
Aiden, what were the leading scores looking like for each team? >> Oh, yes. The Tigers and Patriots both played a very great game on the charity strike as we saw Reed Abbott take home 15 of his own points, followed by Gibson Grezer, Mr. clutch himself with 13, Rafe Gerber with 11, Bennett Stler with four, and Andy Bumgardner with two in the victory. As the on the Jay County side, Samuel Wiggins and Nicholas Snow both pair for 15 points. Brody Collins with eight, Paul Dirkson with two, and Tyler Wson with one. Both teams playing a very high percentage game from the field. As we saw, both teams shoot 100%. Just kidding. That's just our stat sheet. >> Yeah, both leading scorers, as we mentioned, the leading scores for the Tigers, both three-point shooters. Three-point shooting was very strong in the first part of that game. Second half kind of died down a little bit.
And then what the board usually does is they hear a report on the um results of the audit and the recommendations of the auditor >> and then what the department's going to do. >> Okay. And then generally what we do is on a time certain basis whether it's 3 months or 6 months or whatever the case may be put it on the agenda again and say okay this was what has been the progress on the driver ed one that one I take responsibility for because on that audit and as you well know senator this is an issue that's been around for 60 years >> this is a issue that uh 25 years ago that there was a recommendation that there be rules and it really came to light in 2022 when a resolution was introduced by representative Hashimoto calling for that audit. >> But as I read the the findings of the audit, a lot of it concerned the department of transportation because the department of transportation is responsible for certification of driver instructors and so on.
And then overtime, we just saw the poise of the Tigers take over as they were able to have stifling defense that stopped Jount's postgame and was able to pull out the four-point win. >> Yeah, just going to piggyback on what you said a little bit. The Tigers actually shot nine went made, excuse me, nine threes on the game as J County made seven. Both you don't usually see in JV games as 28 of the 45 points for the Tigers were off three-point shots. >> Excuse me, 27. >> As we wrap this up, we will not have a live broadcast of the varsity game. But if you ever head over to Burn Witness and Witness Media, they will be covering the live action of the Patriots and the Tigers here in the Tiger Den. From me, Jonah Geel, this is Aiden Graves and the rest of our crew.
Now this takes place on the school campuses. I get >> it's a 50/50. I mean the DOE had their responsibility in terms >> I get that I get that and so that one yeah again I take responsibility why we didn't put it on the agenda but the board is in receipt of audits right both internal and external >> and then the board makes a decision whether or not it rises to the level that it should be on the board agenda because as you all know many agenda many audits if you look at the conclusion they tend to be sort of benign conclusions right they're not um you know things look okay whatever you know So, so that's a >> but if we're spending money for these audits or for these studies or these reports and I think it deserve the public deserves to know instead of get put it on a shelf deserve to know what was the outcome.
What did we spend $50,000 on it? >> Well, the audit for >> the auditor puts these reports. >> No, I know that >> on on So, it is publicly available. >> No, but you folks aren't discussing it. there are a lot of issues on the the driver's ed um and you know and not to have the auditor actually come in and present and explain why the why they >> well let me senator let me let me u put it in a certain context yeah because um I think one of the things that's been interesting for me after serving here for 30 years and then getting on the board >> I think there are three fundamental fact differences between the boards and by the way as you know there are 15 executive departments In the state, not everyone has a board. >> In fact, a minority has a board >> and only two have independent boards >> that have the ability to hire the leadership.
Okay. So, you have the 15 executive departments. Okay. So, then when it comes to the board of education, part of the challenge I find compared to here was that board meets 11 times a year. That's the equivalent of the legislature meeting two weeks. Your first two weeks in the legislature is the equivalent of the board meeting over the course of the year. And so I don't know how much the legislature would accomplish in two weeks relative to what the board can accomplish in a year meeting 11 times. Second difference is the staff challenges. Each of these senators have two year round staff. That's the equivalent of the board of education. I had 18 staff. When I came on the board, there were three staff including one support staff. So two professional staff. So there's that staff kind of challenges as well. We don't have an SMA.
We don't have an LRP. We don't have the kind of capacity much less year round analyst like the money companies have. So that's a challenge as well. And then third is the sunshine law. You know uh the sunshine law I can understand the rationale for but it's creative. It's a big challenge. I am so used to you are as well in this building. If I want to know how you're going to vote on a bill, I just go up and ask you. I can't do that. I can't go up to a board member, say, "Hey, what do you think about this on an item that's going to be on the agenda that violates sunshine law?" When I was here chairing the committee, I could say, "Oh, I'm going to defer this bill until next Wednesday. Work on it, come back." The board simply cannot do that.
I have to we have to defer for a month. Right? So, we have all these challenges. Now, look, >> it may seem as excuses. Yeah. But I'm saying sitting where I sit now relative to where I was before um I see more. And then part of it is personal, you know. Um I've never served on a board. Maybe you have. I've never served on a board before the 2,000 employees in a budget over $2.2 billion. I never have. I served on a number of boards included in the past where the budgets were so small that we could go over the postage line item. We could go over the printing line item in a budget of 2.2 billion. We don't unpack that budget page by page looking at hundreds of worksheets. In fact, even the subject matter committees in the legislature does not do that. The health committee doesn't walk through the $700 million DO budget.
>> Well, they should. >> That's not my call. >> Well, that's not your call. So, I'm just saying we have our challenges here. I mean, you know, I have to I don't I only do this committee. I said ways that means the entire state. I don't just have DOE. You have only DOE. I don't have We don't have DOE. Okay. I mean, you have just the education plan. So, if you're comparing, I'm just going to compare. And yes, you meet once a month, but you folks have the ability to meet more than once a month. Nothing stops you from calling other meetings. >> Oh, no. No doubt. No doubt. But okay, let me give you a sense of that. Yeah. We have three standing committees as you well know. Okay. Finance and human resources and um what you call student achievement committee safar business. But this is a volunteer board.
>> Understand? >> And we have three board members that work full-time as well. >> And so, and we know that and we ask them in the in the confirmation. >> By the way, I'm not asking for your understanding or forgiveness. >> I'm just saying there's such has to be some awareness >> the challenges. So, okay, >> I want you to know that I am very much aware and we very much appreciate the the volunteeress of people serving, but we ask at the confirmation hearing, do you have the time? Are you willing to serve? You know how much you have to put in. I tell them, you got to raise up roll up your sleeves. It's not one one meeting a month. And they all and they all agree. So, I'm just saying, you know, we do go through those steps. So, I appreciate what you're saying.
Look, I could show you my calendar. I can tell you in the last six months of last year, I attended 25 all day meetings, summits, conferences, whatever, cafeteria managers meetings, whatever. >> I can show you the same as well. >> Okay. >> As a volunteer, >> I I participated in well over two and a half dozen conference calls, Zoom calls, and whatnot that lasted at least two hours. That's in the last six months. That's not counting the six community meetings that the board does. That's not common board meeting. >> So what are you what are you saying? You don't want >> I'm saying that I'm saying that as a volunteer board, right? >> That if the expectation that it's a full-time position, that is very challenging. And I think in I think all boards and commissions, the 50some boards and commissions in the state, if that was a requirement that you put in that kind of time um as it is, it's very challenging to find people that will serve on these board.
>> Well, nobody said that. I asked about the audits, two audits of whether you guys >> No, no, you didn't just ask about two. >> I did. I asked about two audits. you were inferring that why doesn't the board have a hearing I have put on the agenda every single audit that comes before the board because you just mentioned it's tax dollars should be transparent >> well I not you didn't just mention the two >> okay well I I introduced measures that we have to hear every single one that we spend money on if we're going to spend the taxpayers dollars on these studies they have a right to know what what came about and what the board or whoever asked for it or whoever was about resulted. Okay. So, I'm not saying they have to come 24/7, but to have the auditor come and present.
I just asked that question whether or not you folks were aware because there were some very >> You have had the officer come to the meeting. >> So, we didn't have him come for the abatement. We applied >> and you didn't even have the one on the driver's license. And I only raised that because not like you said, not every audit will rise to that level. But in that situation, there were some very scathing things in it regarding the performance of the department and of DOT. >> And as I mentioned earlier, >> I personally take full responsibility for not scheduling >> the um the I mean what they >> driveration. Yes. Yes. So um you know >> and the whole point of this is just that as as the board of education and you folks are the ones that overseeing DOE that I think you guys need to be aware doesn't necessarily mean that every one of the members are going to be here but they can watch the video but aware and then take that into consideration as they are deliberating or as they have the board in front of them that would raise some questions and when those questions aren't raised then it makes me wonder why not or are they even aware that this is going on?
Right. >> Point is well taken, Senator. The way I look at it though, it's a partnership. I just think whenever we have a challenge in our community, education certainly is a challenge. And um if you're going to resolve it, it's going to take actually more than a legislature, more than the board of education, more than the executive branch. It's going to take all the various stakeholders in our community, the business community, the philanthropic community, teachers, students, and so on and so forth. We should all be at the table. when I look at >> which is what we're trying to do here. >> Well, that's one venue, right? Anformational briefing is one venue, but there are other venues as well. You know, like I said, the board has sponsored six community meetings. That's another venue. >> The school community councils which exist in schools >> and I'm sure you all attend your school community in your district.
That's another venue to get a sense of what's the issues facing that >> but they don't necessarily have oversight like you folks do. members. You have >> this is my point. My point is that there are many ways to get information. There are many ways to develop partnerships. There are many ways to collaborate on issues that concern all of us. >> Yes. But so I don't think >> but we're talking about the budget. We're talking about uh statutory um bills and so forth on how we govern. So that there therein lies a difference. Okay. So yes it is. I mean, we have that we have that responsibility uh and you have a responsibility of oversight. And so, if the legislature have concerns and concerns about the budget, you folks got to be concerned because at the end of the day, we make those decisions, right, on how much money, how much budget, how many board members is going to be on the board of education.
I mean, all of those kinds of decisions are being made here. So I think we are, you know, a little bit um the information that you gain here is very different from all the other um community type meetings that we have. You know, I go to the neighborhood boards as well. >> My comments in no way, shape or fashion tries to diminish the importance and the relevance of the information that process gets. I think I'm fairly aware that >> it should be. >> Yeah. So, but again, you are concerned in your particular case in front of the education committee today, rightfully so, is concerned about this particular topic. I can tell you obviously there are other members of the legislature. They might be concerned about chronic absenteeism. They might be concerned about student achievement. They might be concerned about graduation. They might be concerned about the achievement gap particularly with Pacific Islander and Native Hawaiian students.
I might be concerned about the ka puning program that exists in 19 schools. I might be concerned about the learning centers that exist in 29 campuses across the state. Everybody has concerns. Everybody has priorities, right? >> And the board in my opinion serving for the last two years. >> Uh the board concerned about every just like business you all are concerned about the high cost of living. Hawaii is number one in the country in high cost of living. You all are concerned about the lack of affordable housing. You all are concerned about the climate change and the opioid epidemic and all the issues facing the legislature. But it's very very difficult for an individual legislator such as yourself to do something about everything. >> Mhm. >> So you focus tend to prioritize and does that mean to the extent that you don't care about the other issues?
I >> I don't think so. >> No. And I and as the chair of the committee and as committee members, yeah, we are focusing on education and that is our responsibility that >> but as a state senator, you care about the state. >> Exactly. Exactly. But again, I think you missed the the sense of here. It's not just topic. It's the structural. It's the the basics on whether or not the department is able to deal with what's in front of them. when there are audits and there are evidence but well let me can I please finish okay I will let you yeah the um and there's evidence brought up about the recordkeeping about having information about these things and this is what I'm raising about how are we going to deal with these issues how are they going to deal with it and not just this one project but overall if there are evidence going across that's weaving through everything that these are the the shortcomings that they're having.