And because of that, I think that's where the board of education comes in to say, well, are there shortcomings? Are there areas that is lacking that we need so that we can get to not just the CIP, but all the other issues that's out there regarding uh our public schools. So I think regardless of whose priorities are who, whose responsibility it is to do what, the discussions that we have, the community that we bring in, the fact of the matter is is you're the chair of the board of education. We are the Senate. We do what we do. Only you can do what you can do, which is hold him accountable. So this is why it's so important for the board of education members to be here because we cannot hold him accountable. We can bring him and we can bring the superintendent. We can bring the deputy superintendent here and we can have an info briefing.
But at the end of the day, the fate lies with you guys. And so that's why we are asking for you folks and the board of regents to be here because the buck stops with you. You are the one that hires and fires. You are the one that looks at the strategic plan. You are the only one that in my opinion can hold the department accountable in the sense of what's happening with our schools. You guys don't get the calls from the parents. We get the calls. You guys are not the ones that have to go to the neighborhood board meetings and answer for why the chronic absenteeism, why the buses are cancelled, why people are why students are graduating with third and fourth grade reading level. We have to do it. And so when we ask you to bring you here, when we ask you to come here, it's not because we're trying to publicly humiliate anybody.
It's because we want answers. We want execution. We don't want excuses. We don't want you to tell us how many days you spent in the calendar year going to this conference and that conference. At the end of the day, we want what you say to be reflected in real results. In real time results, not you'll get back to us. Now, we got to look at the data, but that's what we hear every single time. Meanwhile, kids are graduating not even ready to go into the workforce or into career pathways. So, we have to hold you guys accountable. So, when we want you here, it's because yeah, we do believe it's your responsibility, Roy, to be in the room, if not you, another member. And at the end of the day, if a board member is not able to be present to hear what's happening in the room or for at the least watch the recordings, then maybe it's time to resign.
Maybe it's time to look for new board members because Hawaii is in a place where education is failing and we are going to feel that in real time in future time when these students start to go out to the workforce. And so this is why I want to bring it back to why we are asking you to be here. Roy, I greatly appreciate you coming in person. Thank you very much. But to be honest, you signed up for this. I signed up for this. Nobody feels sorry for me when I have to leave here at midnight. Nobody feels sorry for me when I have to drive in traffic waking up at four o'clock in the morning. So, I'm sorry, but you're not going to get any kind of pity party on this side. What we want is results. >> And if we have to do this every single time, then we're going to do it every single time.
And if you have to be here every time, I believe that that's the passion and that's the genuiness that you want to serve our students and our education system. So, I just want to make very clear here that everybody here is making a commitment and they're making a sacrifice. But what you're not going to get from this committee is sympathy. What you're not going to get what you're not going to get from this committee is a I feel so bad. You're not going to get that here. >> Thank you, Senator. You know, I I'm not um asking for the sympathy. I I am though when you say that our education system is failing, I don't believe that's a correct statement. I do believe that we have areas to improve in 100%. We have areas that we need to improve in and we have areas that we're doing well.
Um I think when folks say that our education system as a as a whole is failing, I really believe that um we have folks in the schools and the complex in the state that are working extremely hard, extremely hard despite many different challenges. And um to say that our system is failing when we're looking at our scores, our positive trajectory over the last 20 years, that we're improving on the pandemic recovery. We're leading the we're leading the country in reading and mathematics. We still have improvements 100%. I tell you, we're always looking for continuous improvement. But I don't believe that our system is failing. We have areas to improve in most definitely, but not failing. >> You guys are failing. And if you can't acknowledge that, then you're in denial. Talk to any parent in my district. Talk to any educator that's teaching in the schools that are working overtime, having to pay for supplies out of their own pocket.
You go talk to them. Don't talk to your deputy superintendent. Don't talk to the casses. Talk to the people that are on the ground. And right now, DOE has unspent CIP funds of $2.7 billion. Not only you have obligated CIP funds according to our records of $1 billion. Now you can't even come to us and give us a basic breakdown of how many construction contracts is that, how many design contracts is that? How much purchase orders is that? Are you even factoring out factoring in the increases, the escalation costs, the construction management, the change orders? So if we can't even trust you to bring the basic data here so we can help you to help our kids and you're just telling me which to me is a little insulting if I might add when you parade that the education is leading in the nation. So I'm forced to believe that maybe it's just my district that's failing.
Maybe you guys are failing why I and you're not admitting that. So I don't know what districts are really thriving but according to my community you guys are failing. And as I shared, Senator and I we met together, right, about your the Nanakuli NYI complex area, um I shared with you the different things that are going on and the hard work that the teachers and the school leaders are doing to help move the schools forward. How we're working with community members to help move the school forward. Um that is all happening. When when you say that um we're failing though as an entire system throughout the state, we definitely have areas we need to improve in. I started out today when we talked about CIP that we definitely have areas we need to work on and we recognize that. We are committed to moving forward to ensure that our system does better for our students and for our families and communities.
We do. Um but we I don't believe when we talk about as a system everyone is working extremely hard extremely we are not fa we I don't believe that we are failing we have areas to improve in most definitely but as a public education system in Hawaii um over the last several years we have made gains >> okay well when you are only able to complete 23 CIP projects in one year I'm sorry but that's a failure >> we have areas to improve improving most definitely. >> We don't have time for you guys to improve. We need execution and we need it now. We need it today. When you folks say that you have 800 contracts accumulating 592 million and that yet our records show that you have 1 billion in obligated CIP funds and then the audacity to come back and ask us for more money for more CIP funds when you can't even do the work that you said that you were going to do.
Now you have to re-evaluate the CIP list. Okay. Well, what's priority? Okay. What's a health risk? What's a safety hazard? We already told you what it was when we asked for the CIP request. So again, you folks are making this way more complicated. And who is suffering at the end of the day? Our teachers, our principles, our admin, and especially our students. So we have audits that are justifying our frustration here today. We have parents that continually berade my office with complaint after complaint. So, we have our sources that are very factual that tell us that this system, again, I'm going to continue to use this word over and over again, failing. But the only person that seems to it not be failing is you and your administration. So, you're not taking in our consideration when we tell you the areas that you're failing in.
All you do is continue to bring us maybe another column or maybe another spreadsheet or maybe another report. Maybe another executed project will be good. Maybe [clears throat] more teachers in the classroom that are licensed. Maybe getting kids to our our schools by not cancelling buses. Maybe that. Thank you, chair. Let me just This is written June 13, 2025. DE called for 12 new speeds and a decade ago. It's built two. And I don't know if this is a whose article is a it's a is it a civil beat article? I don't know. It might have been been a civil beat article. Um but I think that makes a point. Um you have to remember DOE takes up onethird of the state budget. Onethird annually. So again, you know, where's the efficiency? Where are areas that we can streamline? We cannot sustain that kind of funding as we go forward as the federal government cuts back.
How are we going to fund some of these things that's required of us? So we really have to start looking at streamlining on being more effective and being accountable. We have to hold people accountable because in the private sector when you don't when you don't you don't accomplish what you're supposed to fire you. But not in not in government. We don't. And so we are trying our best uh to be able to take care especially our students in our public schools because they are our future and if we're not going to be able to deliver the kind of education and when you say failing I've been to conferences where our country is far behind other countries and I and I think I shared that I shared that art point with you on how we're behind China and we're behind behind all these other countries. We're running far behind.
So when you say you're leading the nation, our nation is far behind everybody else. So I think we have to take that also into consideration on where we're at on the spectrum. And and it's troubling. And you're right, there are many areas in which you can improve on. But if you are the the parent of a child that has failed, then you are failing, right? If they are failing, then you have somewhere somebody's failed that child. So it's relative when when I'm sure um senator talks about failing. So but we do we do know that there are many many hardworking um people in our public schools state at our university in in our in our agencies. Yes. Many uh and we have those that maybe are not doing what they're supposed to be doing. And that's where we need to really look at and be accountable.
And the audits show us, if you read the audit, it shows us that there are a lot of incompetence going on. And and it's sad to point that out. And I know I'm probably gonna get headlines about me saying some of this stuff, but how do we get how do we get change? How do we get people to take these things seriously and and let's do something about it? Not just tell me, oh, this is the way we've been doing all these years. This is according to the books. Forget the books. Let's make changes if we need changes. We cannot do the same thing over and over again. and expect to have a different result. >> Right. >> 100% Senator and and we are committed to improvement as I shared earlier when we started that um we recognize the areas of deficiency that we're work that need to be improved.
Uh and as the leadership in facilities has started in the last couple of years, we are we have did the assessment, the analysis and we are moving forward and we're putting the systems in place. And so I I share that when we start and we're committed to continuing to do that. >> Superintendent, I hear you and I've been hearing you, but it doesn't match up to what's happening. And especially when I see stuff going on in my schools, in my district, and we're warning you and telling you this is not a good decision that it's like ignored. Oh, well, you know, they deserve a chance. A chance what? To continue to fail. A chance what? So that the students at that point in time is is going to be at a detriment. No. I mean, we there's got to be some hard decisions that's got to be made.
It's not like the same before, you know, we're just going to go along to get along. That's not going to happen. >> And >> let me ask you this. Do you think it's okay that seniors in high school graduate with a fourth grade reading level? >> I don't believe, Senator, that um is not okay. >> It's not okay. >> So, that's what's happening and it's happening on your watch. It happened last year. It's happening the year before. It'll probably happen this year and many years to come. So, this is why the pressure is on because the longer that you folks stay talking, meeting, discussing, finding things to be very inconvenient, kids are graduating with that fourth grade reading level. I I really want that to hit because >> the detriment it's not acceptable but it's happening and it's happening on your watch and I told you this and I told you the people that are in position that are allowing this to happen >> certificate >> but I told you the people that are in position that are allowing this to happen and it's happening on your watch and the more you continue to allow these people to be in that position it's on you now and we will continue to put the pressure on you because you're talking that we're leading we're not leading in anything.
Maybe in illiteracy, but we're definitely not leading the nation in anything. So when I say that and you acknowledge it's unacceptable for kids to gra a a 12th grader in high school is graduating with a fourth grade reading level. Okay, that should really start to have you trigger changes in your department. people in the position reach out to you that are allowing this to happen. >> Let's talk about what what you just alleged. >> We have talked about this. We have talked about this, Keith. And until the people that are in the position that are tolerating this and allowing this to happen, >> it will be this way every single time, Keith. And I don't want it to be. All you need to do is start making some real decisions to have real results that can reflect our schools in real time. I just got a call from a parent whose kids is special need that the teacher did not show up and then another parent who also is in special needs that they switched the teachers.
You can't do that with children that have special needs. You can't disrupt the environment. So again, this is all happening on your watch. >> Senator, I I will take a look into that. Definitely. Um, and each situation is unique and and different. I'm not sure what the circumstances are related around the the two examples that you just gave, but let's meet. I we can find I can find out about those two specific examples. >> Okay. But what are you going to do about it? >> I don't need to meet with you. Just tell me what you're going to do about it. >> I wouldn't know what to do about it unless I know the specifics of the situation. >> I just told you the specifics. You don't need to meet with me. I told it. It's on the record. Everybody heard it in this room watching.
Everybody heard it. What are you going to do about it? That's the only thing I need you to do. You don't have to tell me. Just do it. >> I need to know what's who's a student. I need to know what the situation was and I definitely will address it. I need that information though. If not, I wouldn't know where to start. >> Yeah. But superintendent, I'm sorry I have to chime in. Yes, I've been I've been dealing with you from June and you know the specifics. You knew everything. We've met and met and met and we weren't able to solve it. you weren't able to make the decision and we finally came to a point and I'm talking about Kayi. You finally came to a point in December that you know we're letting the fourth grade but you folks put obstacle against obstacle and obstacle about cancelling a 9-year program.
So I'm just saying just because we meet with you and you look into it but you don't make the decision you don't pull the trigger. >> Senator that respectfully that program has been uh re-implemented >> re-implemented not in the original form it was in. It's only for the fourth grade. After all the damage was done and after the whole area got all back with weeds and so forth and everything that was done for nine years and the Cass who approved it all nine years, all of a sudden they want to cancel the program and they canceled it without any kind of of reason why. And then when they gave me the reason, it was a false reason because there was no such policy. And the Cass had their nerve to tell me there was a policy when that policy wasn't even relevant. What? They think I'm not going to look into the policy?