All righty. >> All right. >> Great. >> I think that work that works. >> So, we Okay, great. So, we're going to continue to um March 2nd. >> Yeah. Do I hear a motion to continue? See, I just want to get the uh do I hear hear a motion to continue notice of intent 61 Waverly Street, map 15, parcel 12, the Gutierrez Company, D file number 95-106 to March 2nd at 7:05 p.m. So move >> second. >> Roll call vote. Acro I >> Croach I >> Atinson I >> Molton I >> W J W J W J W J W J W J W J W J W J W J's I motion passes so we'll we'll see you on the second at 7 o'clock. >> All right, thank you very much. >> Another productive meeting, >> Mr. Gorman and uh Mr. Carter, thank you for being here.
I thought both candidates are strong. I can see why they got to the the the final round. Um, I agree with what I heard at the other public comment that um, I think the second candidate um, seemed to me like a better fit for Greenfield. I think um again both seem very capable and probably good at their jobs, but but something about the way that the second candidate um spoke and uh carried herself and also maybe the fact that she in Chikap and understands some of the Western Mass um challenges um made me really feel like she was the stronger candidate for us as a community. Um, I I also liked the way she talked about um centering on the student and um and some of the other things she said about the way that she would collaborate with the community um both for the city as well as the community I thought spoke well of her also.
Uh appreciate your input >> very much. Yeah. Okay. Next on the agenda, we have review of minutes from January 12th, 2026. >> Who sent this over >> to the commission? Just give me one second to get that up. >> Sure. Thank you. >> Good night. Thanks for coming. I think I have the I think I have Jean's comment version up. I had a couple of minor comments. I'm trying to find them here. At least I thought I did. I Okay. Um, again, I don't have numbers on my lines here, so I'm on page four. Um, on mine it's the um it's the last line before it says no motion was made or no vote was taken. Says Mr. Hackinson suggested containing Mr. Jordan. Not not sure what that meant. I don't think that's what I said but including maybe trying to find there it is.
Thanks. >> Thank you. >> Any other folks online or any other folks in person? Public comment going once. If you would like to make one, you can come off mute and say your name. Public comment going twice. I want to give as much opportunity as possible. >> Yeah. >> All right. Public comment going three times. And we are done with public with the second public comment of the evening. Uh thank you member Childs for for bringing that motion forward and thank you member Deny for seconding it to put it on the table. Um with that uh I would love for us to transition now to the deliberation. Um I would I would like to make a motion to suspend Robert's rules of order to enable enable us to have uh just more of a discussion. >> Seconded. >> Okay.
>> What was that? >> I I did say to include his wetland scientist. >> Is that what it should have been? >> Oh, yeah. No, in I think it was to uh include Mr. Jordan in the correspondence we were sending out. >> Yeah. Right. >> Yeah. >> But not containing him. Yeah. >> Okay. I had a couple more quick ones and um I didn't catch that. Next page, Becca. um in the discussion about Warren Woods uh on line five of that first paragraph. Is that where we are? >> I believe so. >> Okay. Mr. Hackinson added that the hunter had been allowed to go back into the woods to retrieve the deer in the next few days afterward. The hunter was still searching. Wasn't the next few days. It was just the day after. or the following day, but it wasn't multiple days. >> I just say next day, the hunter was still searching.
Any discussion? All right. All in favor? >> I. Any opposed? >> Any abstensions? Okay. Passes unanimously. So, we are in open discussion. Um, for now, I would love to hear, let me cancel it. I would love to um go around and hear from members, you know, what you thought some of the strengths of each candidate were. What were the things that really stood out to you about each candidate? um and to get a sense of if you if you have a leaning right now to get a sense of where folks are are at in terms of which candidate they would rather uh that they plan to support. Um we can do this popcorn style. Does anyone want to share their thoughts? >> I'll go. >> All right. So, Mayor Dorger, then member Childs. >> Um well, I'm so thank you for the so grateful for people chiming in.
>> The next paragraph down, um, again, this is minor. Third line, it says AI, except it's a believe it should be a capital I. >> Yeah, I was going to do that, but I didn't. Um, and going down about five lines after that, it says, "Mr. Crouch, no, it was before that. However, the hunter did not have a firearm when searching for the deer in the few days afterwards." Just put the day afterward because it was singular. And that's it. That's all I have. to the commission. I'll scroll back up because we uh passed over Jean's corrections, which I think this is page three. Um removing some language on on this line here and uh correcting it so that it uh reads uh Mr. Crouch stated that the channel that the commission observed on January 10th did did have water in it despite not getting any rain between then and now.
I thought that was wonderful. But my um I would support the second candidate. Um I agreed with some of the things that our citizens said. I thought she was very focused on the children. She also spoke about special needs and about the elementary schools which we hadn't really heard of. Um, and I also wanted to share I got a I I got a phone call a week from Saturday, which I didn't call anybody and say, from Joe Cmerford, who strongly recommended Carol. Um, and I asked her if I could call people and she said yes, I could. And I thought, well, if I called everyone, that would be an a what do you call a violation of open meeting law. So that's the first time that I said that. she um and her wife knew her personally and spoke about her work ethic, dedication, and her interest in being here and many other glowing things that I can't remember all of which so I don't want to paraphrase um a quote, you know, incorrectly.
>> Yeah, I think my main comment was that it had water in it, but I didn't we didn't have sea flow in it that day, but it did have water puddled in it in places. >> Should Skinner Katrone be hyphen? >> Uh, it's not. She does not hyphen Nate that name. >> Okay. So, first name Skinner. >> No, >> this yours is mine. It's yours. >> Yeah. >> I think that was all the comments. >> There was one other place I deleted some stuff. >> Was it further down? 247. Oh, there it is. Instead of very detailed discussions will be had, uh, change to there will be very detailed discussions. >> Yeah, I don't you don't typically end a sentence with the word had >> unless you said not past the voice. I've been had >> was never my >> eliminated passive voice. That's good.
So, I'm for the second candidate, but I thought they were both wonderful and very qualified. I was on the initial worked wonderfully. It was great working with Ian and Stacy. >> Thank you. Got member Charles next and then >> Okay, >> then member Deny. >> For the first one, the ones that stood out the most was I really liked the way she talked about how she collaborated with other city departments in building a budget. Um, I really liked the stress she put on finding the pain points of whatever she was doing to figure out how to fix and especially the growth mindset uh part that she talked about at the end. For the second one, what I really liked best about her interview is how specific she was in answering questions. Her examples were very real, not theoretical, and of course the student focus. I would be comfortable with either of these women as superintendent.
>> And that's the end of the minutes. >> That's where it's at. >> Oh, that's fine. >> That's the end of the minutes. Unless you want to go through the page of documents. >> No. >> Yeah. I don't I don't look through those. I'll make a motion to accept the minutes of January 12th, 2026 as amended. >> Second. >> Roll call vote. >> Acriman I. >> Crow I. >> Crouch I. >> At Hackinson I. >> Molton I. >> Wans I. Motion passes. meeting minutes are accepted from January uh January 12th, 2026. All right. So, we got uh member prerogatives. Any prerogatives from the commission? >> Just clarificate. Our next meeting is next Monday and it's regularly scheduled. Uh correct. >> That is correct. >> Okay. >> Right. And that's virtual. >> Yes. The next meeting is virtual. >> Yeah. Yeah. Anyone from the audience like to make a comment?
They struck me as very knowledgeable, experienced, educated, good people. And I think we are incredibly lucky that our choices between awesome and awesome. >> Okay. Thank you, member Deniv. And then member one, >> I think that they were both eminently qualified and we would be in good hands with either of them. I am team Carol though because she did her homework. She knew about Greenfield. She knew about our particular struggles. She came prepared to discuss us and what we needed. Um she's watched city council meetings. She knew a little bit about us. Uh, I also talked to MASC and they put a little bug in my ear about Carol. So, I was excited to hear from her. I feel like she will really click with the town and the citizens. Um, and I really appreciate that she always centered the students first and talked about concrete ways that we could improve their outcomes, which is the point of our us being here.
>> I did not see any hands raised. >> All right. Do I hear >> to adjourn? >> Second. >> Roll call vote. >> Aman I. >> Crow I. >> Crouch. I >> Atinson I. >> Molton. I >> W's eye.
Um, I also think Sharon would be great. Um, I just think that Carol has a certain Western Massachusetts quality that I think really will endear her to us. And I hope that I hope that we choose her, frankly. >> Okay, I have member Webb and then member Goodwin. >> Um, so I wrote down some things that I really liked about the first candidate and one thing that um, she did say was setting up budget boundaries um, to support the climate if we want it. Um and also just having like listening sessions, being consistent with budgets. Uh not having um answers prior to asking people for opinions. Um these are just some of the notes I jotted down. Um how she took a chance and she walked in as a superintendent during COVID. Um, and then the things that stood out for me for the second person, Carol, was um just how she took the chance on the yonder pouches and, you know, she wasn't sure if she was going to have good feedback or not.
I know it sounds like a weird thing, but as a parent, I'm not a huge Yonder Pouch supporter. Um, but my child doesn't have a cell phone. Um, she's just a stable leader. I agree with member Deniv saying she did her homework on us. um she comes from a place that has 15 schools. So she comes from a district rather than a regional school. So that for me was also something and her longevity when I look at her resume in the same district and working her way up the ladder which I know is something um we do value or I value as a person. >> Thank you. member Goodwin, then member Nitton. >> When I walked in here tonight, I could have gone either way. I've spent hours reading about two amazing educators, looking at what they've done, where they've been. And I had one concern, and it came from my love for literacy.
Um, because I was really hoping we would have somebody who, you know, had promoted literacywide. But then I looked at team Carol as a licensed she is a licensed superintendent and a licensed special educator which means she has literacy because that is what you do. She also has um her undergrad degree because they're both very strong science people. Her undergrad degree is in English language arts. So, as an educator for 40 some odd years, she impressed me off the charts. She knows what she's talking about. It to walk into um postcoid and say we're putting all your cell phones away was as she said a career breaker. She could have lost her job. She stood behind the teachers. She listened to them and that she could have lost her job. She made a choice to stand for the teachers and the children because she believed it was the right thing to do.
So, hands down, I am team Carol. >> Member Diamond. >> Uh it it sounds like uh there's a great deal of agreement in the room. Um I I I agree that we are blessed to have interviewed two highly qualified candidates. Um, looking at both of their records of accomplishment, there's a lot of things to admire about these candidates. Um, the impression that I get is that um, Sharon Kunwir uh, has been working in a district with a rather high achieving school, the EOSmith school, um, with a very good record of, uh, sending students to higher ed. And um this is a candidate who would be likely to bring um a higher level of rigor to our schools. Um and and has a great deal of other advantages that she would bring. Um, however, when I think about who's the best fit for Greenfield, I'm also just drawn to Carol Cruiser because um because she did her homework, because um she seems to care about Greenfield and understand what a city like Greenfield is like.
Um because of her accomplishments um in if you if you look at the numbers uh what she was able to accomplish in decreasing suspensions for students with disabilities, the numbers are really impressive. 2014 it was 24.5% and in 2021 it was 12.8%. It was roughly half. Um and and then I agree that the the Yonder Pouch move and these other specific examples of um policy decisions that were courageous um they demonstrate uh a bold leader who is also um capable of finding consensus. I think that this is the candidate we need. >> Okay. And I'll take a moment to also share um some of my thoughts. Uh coming into this um interview, I I was also in like a I don't think we can lose. You know, I think that either of these candidates would do an admirable job and are are perfectly qualified for the role.
Um and so it was a matter of thinking who is the best fit for our district, for our community, for the folks who are around us. And um you know towards the end of these interviews I also was finding myself drawn towards Carol Cruiser um primarily because of the way that she not only discussed but also demonstrated just like a very clear and open way of communicating. I did feel like this was someone who would tell me not what I wanted to hear but what I needed to hear. Um and that I think is is something that we need. I also really appreciated the focus on creating lasting systems and structures. I imagine that some of the some of the structures that she's been creating in Chapi will live even if she's not there and that that really matters to me. um someone who is interested in building something that they might not see the fruits of even.