001e e e good evening it is 6: PM and I'd like to call to order the regular meeting of the Board of Trustees for the School District 5 of lexingon Richland counties do I have a motion to approve the agenda SC I'd like to make a motion to approve the agenda I have a second any discussion all in favor any opposed that motion carries six zero do I have a motion to enter executive session Scully I move that we enter executive session to consider the following selected employment items exhibit a for Action selected employment items exhibit B information only contractual matter regarding professional development services Exhibit C contractual matter regarding the purchase of property do I have a second SLE we will now enter executive session oh I'm sorry I got ahead of myself all
002those in favor all opposed the motion carries six of we will now enter executive session until 7 p.m. [Music] for [Music] e [Music] for [Music] for [Music] for [Music] for [Music] for [Music] for [Music] e e [Music] for [Music] for [Music] e e e good evening it is 7 pm. so I'd like to go ahead and call our December 9th board meeting to order so great to see so many of you with us this evening at this time we'll have the invocation and the Pledge of Allegiance by Mr Mike saterfield thank you uh before we say our prayer I wanted to say one or two things uh uh I think it's important that we recognize and acknowledge that our community is made up of many cultures and religions uh during this time of year those
003of the Jewish faith celebrate Hanukkah those of Hindu Faith celebrate the birth of Krishna and Mira Buddhists celebrate peace and Good Will and many of our African-American uh brothers and sisters celebrate K Quanza though those of us of the Christian faith celebrate the birth of Christ Our Lord and Savior while the majority of our community is Christian it would be shortsighted not to recognize and celebrate our diversity let us pray dear Lord prior to each meeting we come to you and ask for guidance and wisdom we often ask you to intervene in the lives of those who are hurting or maybe going through life's difficulties we profess your name and give thanks but often times we abandon you in all that you have taught us my prayer tonight is that each member on our board
004and all those listening who profess your name be reminded of Mark 1230 31 you shall love your lord your God with all your heart soul mind and strength and you shall love your neighbor as yourself there is no commandment greater than these Lord teach each of us the importance of love and forgiveness so that we may demonstrate to others that when we do pray we do so without boundaries or conditions please keep our District 5 families safe during the holiday season amen would you please stand and join me in the pledge I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for at this time we'll call forth Miss Taylor for school board Spotlight thank you
005madam chair members of the board Dr Ross good evening do uh do you want to move to the front now to recognize for spotlights I have three very special young ladies to introduce to you tonight first um we have with us Lily re black ly re come on Lily Reid is a senior at Spring Hill High School but competes on the chapen high school girls golf team and has done so for six years yes so this year Year Lily Reed won the individual portion of the girls golf 5A division 2 state championship that put her in two record books actually she's the very first 5A division 2 individual champion and she's the very first individual girls golf champion in chapen high school history as well so yes uh she's also a very good student she
006has committed to play golf at William and Mary College in the fall so um I know she'll do great there I um my daughter is a golfer as well so I've had the privilege to see Lily Reed play and I can um I can honestly say that she represents her school our District her family very well she plays with great Sports Wanship is that what we'll say sportsmanship in class and and we're just so proud of you congratulations we'll do a picture here [Applause] next we have with us tonight Lillian Reeves Lillian come on up Lillian is a senior at hermo High School uh last school year Lillian participated in and won the magnet schools of America National poster competition this was a like I said said a national competition with the winners selected by
007online voting the criteria were that the poster had to reflect at least one of the magnet school pillars so we we brought Willam you can hold it if you want um this this is her winning poster and she shared with us that in the poster she emphasized the pillar of diversity Mr saterfield was just speaking about our diversity in our district and that she wanted to show the different cultures and races of our um District learning together so um lilan we are so proud of you congratulations you have a special gift we're so glad you're here to share it with us so I'll hold this and you can do just shake your hands and I'll bring it back to picture [Applause] and then last but not least tonight we've got some students from the Futures
008Future Farmers of America chapter here at the center and I would like to introduce Bruce uh I am so sorry not Bruce Brooke Brooke alorn for a special presentation good evening my name is Brook alorn and I'm the president at the Lexington britland 5 FFA chapter here at the center for advanced technical studies tonight we're presenting Schoolboard members as well as executive staff with poetas that were grown by the agriculture program here at the Kate Center in August we start with root cuting and our first year act students are involved in every step of the process from planting pinching and fertilizing to the final product in November students learned how to hand tie bows and how to give Point SAS and wrap them that give a florish quality presentation students gain the skills of being
009able to to see a product go from a root cutting to a marketable retail product while all at the same time learning plant science and Greenhouse management none of this would be possible without the support of our school board as well as our district and the amazing facilities that they provided us with all the money that we earn from our annual quenia sale goes back into our chapter and helps fun things such as our trip to National Convention camps and competitions we want to thank you again for your amazing support of our program and help build building the future generation of our culture thank you [Applause] your [Applause] at this time I'll turn it over to Dr Ross for the superintendent report thank you madam chair members of the board in our community it is
010a honor as we get ready for the holiday season to rec our students and all of the amazing work that they're doing uh this year uh would like to uh talk about some exciting opportunities we have uh for School District 5 uh as you heard we had our our first um ever division one a state champion in uh in golf and now we have the first opportunity to have division one and division 2 football champions as you know the 5A division has uh been separated into um into two different uh 5A uh region or classification has been separated into two divisions and so uh for the first time hermo and Dutch Fork high schools are playing for State football championships um hero will play this Saturday December 14th versus Northwestern that'll be at 6:00 these
011games will be held at at South Carolina State uh University and uh Dutch FK will play Somerville at 2 pm. and that's right that's Friday during the school day so there's been a lot of discussion about uh R El what do we do with that school day uh I wanted to uh just make it very public and very clear the options that we have um I know e-learning comes to everybody's mind we can just do a e-learning day uh but I I would ask that um we pay attention to the e-learning days District handbook issued by the state uh Department of Education uh e-learning is for weather uh related absences uh and you won't hold those on the date of the actual event uh so that leaves us with three options uh we can either
012uh run school as normal uh close school uh or run a half day uh please be reminded of the state law regarding attendance uh we have uh and and again I'll be honest with you I was e-learning came to mind as well but I was quickly reminded of our um responsibility to the e-learning district handbook and so by law we are supposed to have 180 days of instruction uh so if you cancel school for a football game or any other event you must do a makeup day uh if you using half day for any event you must swap it with one of your half day days you get three half days uh and so um we chose to utilize the half day half day of instruction would this be may I think 20 in May
013uh so um this will give opportunity for a lot of our faculty and staff who are involved in the in the programming uh to uh be available to uh participate and go watch so uh we put that information out today about noon uh but I wanted to make everybody aware of the limitations um that are surrounded uh with with e-learning and uh why we chose to do the half day uh so with that we're try to make every decision as a system answering three critical questions why do we do this work how do we accomplish that why and what are our outcomes our vision is that we love and grow our students our mission is that we're focus on academic social emotional growth and development and then our outcomes are driven by our Strate IC
014plan with those objectives that every student feels loved in our schools and every student has demonstrated academic growth in our schools the state of South Carolina Department of Education has a strategic plan that says that by 2030 at least 75% of our students will be at or above grade level and so we have Target this year as the growing season and within the growing season uh we are using our data uh to help us drive the decision making uh for instance with our focus on graduation rate uh we track this weekly uh celebrating uh last week a a dramatic up take in the amount of students who are um moving towards graduation so I want to celebrate that celebrate those gains with our high schools and our high school staff as we identify not just
015the numbers but the names behind those numbers and the stories behind those names as we look at our March towards uh 75% proficiency uh that we know while we've made a lot of progress over the years we still have progress to go and so we're focusing in on all of our measures we don't want to ever leave a measure out but specifically highlighting uh the need for uh Improvement in and growth in English language arts uh currently we're serving over 61 different languages in School District 5 and we want to make sure that each as we talk about diversity each of these languages are served um and uh that we are meeting their needs in terms of academic Readiness one of the things that I wanted to to remind the board of is act4 that
016was passed this year um a number of policies that we will take up uh tonight um are affected uh by this law uh Act 4 14 14 is the read to succeed amendments uh if we look at our third grade SC ready results uh be reminded that those student scoring does not meet in this year are required to be retained unless good cause exemption is met the reading portfolio has been removed from good cause exemption so if this was in place last year there would be 16, 238 uh third graders back in the third grade additional third graders retained what does that look like for School District 5 if this was in place last year that would be an extra 266 third graders that we would have had to retain well it is in place
017now and this is our big Focus I want to thank academics and uh student services everyone who's pulled around of supporting our students uh so that we can meet the needs um that they have uh but this is a big issue for us this year it's a huge f focus and we're going to continue to talk about this throughout the school year this is the driver behind our administrative priorities whether classroom supports teacher retention and Recruitment and ensuring a safe and productive learning environment for all of our students so as we look forward to supporting our teachers uh as we meet these needs these challenges that we have uh their students our future is different from our past and so we are looking at ways to be innovative inative creative to meet those needs one
018of the innovations that bring that we have come into the district is through our referendum uh so as we move forward uh moving uh to meet the needs of our students Futures uh it brings us to the next steps of how do we Finance uh the referendum how do we manage the projects and the resoning uh tonight you will see uh as we bring forth a discussion we have Mr Hower here with our bond attorney as we talk about the financing of the bonds in the first Bond resolution uh you will see in exhibit R of the packet our solicitation uh for our construction management uh group we thought was important instead of as these construction management firms typically work off of percentages um 2% or 1% of $240 million will start to into uh
019the the budget um and so what we would like to do is isolate those projects of most critical need as we issue these out in solicitation what are the projects we absolutely need to have construction management on and those uh rehab projects that we can manage within house we will do those within house so the first um uh project that you will see in our solicitation uh is all those projects that are around the um resoning related items that's the building of the new Dutch Fork Elementary School the wings at chapen elementary school and Lake Murray Elementary School as well as the U re the movement of three programs into the rich Lakes education center the five program the adult a program and the academy for Success uh we want to make sure that we're
020using uh the The public's trust uh in the best way forward and um managing these construction management projects into chunks would be U into the areas that we need them the most would be the best utilization of that uh we talk about a a Citizens advisory review team extra layer and Partnership of uh of just transparency as we move through this project and what are we talking with the citizens advisory review team about it's really going through our bond referendum dashboard uh before you can get to construction there is procurement design construction documents EMB bidding permitting construction occupancy and closeout and so we will look forward to our dashboard in the new year as we move with our citizens advisory review team uh expanding our existing advisory uh to uh talk more about the items
021that we have within the referendum and then last resoning so as we move through these projects uh again uh we are looking at a ways to protect the budget uh to move through so that we can deliver everything that we have U within our project list uh resoning is our goal to address the capacity issues that we see in the chapen area and so we also will do this by the restructuring of the district uh we will move from this current structure which will be in place for one more school year which is next year this will allow us to make sure that programs people uh and uh equipment certifications all of this is in place as we move from this structure to this structure uh the structure now uh moves to a five Middle
022School uh system you can see the feeders into the different schools uh so that um we can better maximize the academic and programmatic needs of our of our students so we will um enact this uh July 1 of 2026 uh but it takes and we've learned from other districts that it takes that time of planning uh to make sure that you have the right staff the right programs the right people uh equipment and and everything in place when we make this move uh this corresponds to a change in the Elementary um zones as well as the the shifts that we will have there so we are messaging that out and I want to thank our uh our planning team and our operations team for the hundreds of thousands of parcels that they went through in
023order to make this happen along with rerunning all of our bus routes um over uh 200 something bus routes to to um get uh the zones uh in place so in the timeline as we look out to be in place by August 26 uh we will notify we will start to involve our uh faculty uh and staff in the um in the process on May of uh in May of 2025 uh you will start hearing in January how that process works but uh we will um wanted to just kind of lay out why that red dot is over May 2025 and uh we use the summer of 25 and the summer of 26 to make sure that we have the certifications in place necessary to operate full of 2026 uh at this time uh January
024also brings forth a uh update in our cell phone policy we have uh already uh made the uh the passage of that uh that cell phone policy policy uh but I bring forth our uh chief of student services planning Dr Mike Harris uh to talk about the update in the uh cell phone uh actions Dr Harris uh thank you so much uh Dr Ross uh Madam chair members of the board again uh superintendent Ross Community uh we um earlier in the top of the summer 2024 State Department came forward with provisor 1.13 anti-bullying and school safety that basically indicated to districts across South Carolina that we were to um enact a policy that would prohibit access to personal electronic communication devices for students during the instruction of day uh we be jumped on that pretty
025early we began that October 28th of this year uh this Board District Five board in fact approve uh the policy that we currently have policy jcj prohibition of personal electronic devices during the school day now with that uh that is was in preparation as that provider for a law that is to be uh come forward the top of the year January 1 of 2025 this policy basically talks about personal electronic devices as well as accessories and it uh indicates that this the time frame is from Bell to what we consider a referred to as Bell to Bell essentially from the morning Char to Bell until the afternoon dismissal which concludes instructional Daye now this this policy does not include any prohibitions on U school buses field trips or during athletic events or athletic um yeah
026athletic events now students are quite frankly are to store away and silence their devices and or accessories during the instructional instructional day uh this talks about uh through during the classroom as well as an exchange of classes or change of classes if you will and uh and during the lunch periods now with most policies there are some some exemptions or some exclusions if you will and this policy does include the fact that if a student does have an IEP or medical uh plan or 50 or4 plan uh that they certain that is written already written into those plans they certainly have uh means and access to uh those devices as appropriate uh and finally of course in the event that there were students or are students that are pretty admin about um not adhering to
027the policy and the current rule that's in place uh then there certainly they will be subject to the discipline that's found in the student code of conduct I want to say at this point right now uh our schools have done an outstanding job of making certain that they begin to roll us out and apply this uh in our schools um I feel very very comfortable and we had lots of conversations and continue to have conversations quite frankly in prior to the January Top of the year January when the law is enacted so I did want to give a major shout out to our schools K through 12 for doing a super job of making certain that students parents and all are duly aware of what this policy says tonight is really about an opportunity of
028reminding or sharing with you um in this last board meeting prior to the turn of the year that this is um moving forward or has moved forward um the horse is out of the gate if you will we are implementing this as as we speak and we're in good shape as it point at this point right now to meet uh the July I mean January one uh law that's coming forward in 2025 so just want to share that with you all to remind that of you remind our community uh that this is uh moving forward and um one indicator that it is working reasonably well is that we we meet with our student advisory uh I would often times ask them how's it going with the know use of cell phones and I get this
029often times and then I kind of get grunt so that is an indication that things are moving well and at least in the right direction so I did want to mention that to them and shout out to our student advisory for that reason but that basically concludes what I wanted to say to you on tonight and again just by way reminder of the um policy that has already been approved and moving forward the prohibition of personal electronic devices thank you Dr Harris do we have any questions Mr Bay yes sir there was word that there were going to be um potential grants you know provided did we apply for any of those and have they been awarded absolutely thank you for that question um last year and just by way of History last year the
030district received a grant from the safe schools Grant of about $130,000 or so for um school safety and what we Ed that money for was kind of SE that's kind of where we started at some of the first use of um redoing some of the best debuts that are in some of the schools that's kind of where some of that started unbeknownst us we did not know whether or not that was going to continue or not but in fact it did and we received another allocation uh this year after application and about twice as much so with that we have already begun talking with our schools uh on a number of of instances going to talk about uh pouches cell phone pouches as well as storage devices uh that we will have highly encouraged by
031the state to to write into the Grant and we follow suit and I think that had a lot to do with the amount of funds that we did receive uh under that safe school so yes long way to answer your question yes there are funds available and yes we do have uh or nearing opportunity to uh order uh pouches as well as cell phone storage units for our secondary schools and the other question was I've had Parents ask um our principles able to set a more restrictive policy than the district such as pouches or storage boxes again secondary schools are will be receiving those and they are actually working with us right now in terms of just how many we want to kind of do a hybrid of that some of them will have more
032pouches than storage units and vice versa but both are available to our schools and they're actively uh involved with that absolutely thank you do we have Mr SFI yeah I just wanted to share with um at the school board convention meeting this weekend there was a presentation by Rock Hill schools which they implemented at the beginning of the year I'm you're well I'm sure you're well well aware of that they said you know two weeks of a few bumps and bruises and then everything went very well so you have to endure that especially since this has become such a habit for many of our students and one of the things that we noted that was I thought was a pretty neat idea and I'm all about stealing ideas from other folks f um they put
033little small decorative signs that students could see and parents could see they weren't big warnings but they were just reminders sort of G reminder that you know this is a a no cell phone zone or you know schools whatever the however you want to word it but I thought that was a pretty neat idea and uh but they said that they are exceedingly happy uh teachers are happy kids seem to be more engaged and um but I just wanted to share that with with you yeah thank you so much any other questions all right thank you Dr Harris thank you Dr Harris and um last I want to talk about the annual budget timeline um as and I think it's um as Dr haris kind of constantly remind of the change in the cell phone
034policy I'm going to constantly remind about the uh the Esser Cliff uh that um exists for the last three years we have really benefited from over uh $23.3 million of funds that have come through the three series of the elementary and secondary school emergency relief funding U that on average is about $7.7 million per year but the current amount of eser funds that we have are now zero so that means that moving forward a lot of those things and services that we enjoyed uh that were within those different series of now fall back on to the general fund a reminder of what goes in our general fund budget uh of that budget 64% of it comes from the state of South Carolina the state department uh the uh 35% comes from our our local taxes
035and we have about 1% in Grant now how do we use that about 88% of 88 cents of every dollar goes to salaries and benefits about 7 cents for utility ilities and purchase Services supplies and materials is 4 cents from every dollar and equipment is 1 cent from every dollar so as we prepare for uh the annual budget uh I want us to focus on board policy DB um and our goal is to finance the educational programs and priorities for the system uh as an educated others my focus is what are our educational programs and priorities and I think we as a board and as a district need to establish those the administration um showed our priorities our priorities are uh a an environment for learning you hear the students talk about it matters having
036an environment where they can do amazing work uh to have uh teacher retention Recruitment and and and also um to have classroom supports we like to know what the board's priorities are uh so planing of this process goes all the way down to the citizens um uh in in our school district uh but also within that policy I want to uh make the board aware that during the month of February of each year the principles and department heads they put their request in uh so what we don't want to do is get to May where that first budget is due to the board and uh they don't know what the will of the board is or what the priorities of the board are so if we are making a request for ABC but the board
037wants to fund XYZ we have disconnect so again because our board policy says that our budget looks at our um our uh educational programs and priorities uh we would like to uh hear a little bit about with the board's policy and uh with the board's priorities are I want to show just I'm not going to read all of this but what goes into the the budget uh we have different tasks and a lot of sequencing of those tasks um and we take all of those tasks and those sequences and we we put it on this calendar and uh this calendar is just for the budget uh and each person has a role uh within it um but I want you to focus on the top part uh the executive staff the principal directors or ptso
038groups and advisor groups they all have a role in it but if we just look at the first two levels the Board of Trustees and the superintendent uh you can see that uh you get your accountability report in October which really starts to give you what some of our uh instructional needs are throughout the district uh in December you have our audit which we'll have today and move on the calendar uh but we're asking in January um because so many of our tasks uh happen um after January as a district uh that uh the the board conduct a workshop to talk about those priorities and if uh we have those in January then the department heads and the principles can align their requests by board policy to the priorities established by the board so uh
039that is um uh goes into baked into uh our our request uh it would also help us uh as uh we look at any budget amendments that would come in January we would be aligned with those earlier so um we're we're we're asking that of of this body uh last of the superintendent report on your table uh is our hiring event uh the hiring season used to be in February and March and um it's not officially concluded like a national Signing Day until May the 10th I believe uh May the 10th is ntion is Signing Day in the state but we begin January 11th and uh with the teacher shortage and and uh we are we are U moving early and earlier in this phase so if mark your calendars if you know anyone interested
040um voted the number one best place to teach in the state of South Carolina so excellent branding and we're excited about U this work uh and as we look forward to the hiring season uh so that Madam chair members of the board that concludes the superintendent's report and I stand for questions thank you Dr Ross um do we have any questions Miss hudle um Dr Ross um very early on you showed the jump in the projected graduation rate and I was just wonder if you could elaborate on that and why it jumped so much in one month I guess it was a month or a quarter I know we got a report from n today if you can talk about that um I can tell you that we are focusing mainly on finding the students
041that that you know have trans has transitioned from one place to another and being able to identify where they are and that's been one piece of that that's helped to increase um plus continuing to follow along where the students are in terms of their coursework but the big thing right now is really being able to locate those students who are on our that in our graduation rate group that we're no longer in our schools but we're accountable for finding out where they are and so being able to to find some of those students and a huge shout out I tell you to Dutch folk high school they were a big part of that jump as one time so uh those graduation teams are are now as we moving through the the year or moving like
042like you like M mcal said finding those students and um we look forward to some bigger jumps in the future Mr and this might be a question for you do we know on the um the third graders that were below the 266 do we know how many of those were in the reading intervention do we have data on that of the 266 students that were that would have been in that does not meet I don't have the exact number for the does not meet last year was divided into a does not meet one and a does not meet two category all of the does not meet one category students were in intervention but I don't have the data on the does not meet to because those were not students we were specifically responsible for the
043intervention piece of until this year with the law but I can tell you this year we're looking at map scores anything below a 186 and we're intervening with that currently so um I don't have exact numbers for that thank you and then one more on the um construction management firm do we know will the same firm be responsible for each group of the 80 million um their pay is it based off of each 80 million dispersion or is it the full 240 so very good what what we we did not want to do is make it off a percentage of the 240 um if if we look at kind of and I'm looking at M Tucker if I'm an error here but we look at um our current management project is at herl high school
044um rough numbers about they have about $800,000 over a $37 million project so just rough numbers that's about two something percent 2% of 240 brings you about $5 million that starts to eat into the project real really quick so what we try to do is look at the projects that we really need that help on and those projects that we can kind of manage and house more like the maintenance projects um we wouldn't double double that fee and we could we can get some scale there so we will know our final numbers once the projects are finally bid if there are some uh construction management companies that don't charge percentages but have flat rates that may you know help out in the selection process as well uh but just knowing the industry uh we do
045need that we see the the huge benefit of having construction management uh but uh we don't want to just at scale say you're getting a percentage of 240 when we can do some things in the house any other questions all right thank you Dr Ross all right that boovs us down to the approval of the minutes from the November 18th board meeting meeting do I have a motion Mr Scully yeah I make a motion that the board approve the minutes of the November 18 2024 board meeting but remove the attachments attachment numbers one and two in their entirety from the minutes s yeah I second that Mr do you want to elaborate um I don't think so at this point Missle um okay so those were my attachments right she asked for clarification on which
046attachments you were referencing attachment numbers one and attachment number two in their entirety okay um so the irony of this motion is that the stamp that goes on attachments references South Carolina code section 30-4 D90 A4 um that code section says all public bodies shall keep written minutes of all public meetings such minutes shall include but need not be limited to and the item number four on there is any other information that any member of the public body request be included or reflected in the minutes so my concern with this motion is that it's a motion to in my opinion violate the law because the law says any member of any public body can request items to be included in the minutes we are a public body I am a member of that body um
047I think this would be breaking the law I think it would be an intentional violation of Law and honestly an attempt of of to have a public body also breach my freedom of speech um I also think anyone who votes for this would be acting outside of their official duties as a trustee because we took oath um of office to to follow the law um I have some notes and we'll see if you guys try to do this again that um on this that I would like to be added to the minutes go ahead Mr scy okay so it's not a violation of the law you have the right to request it to be added and you have we are simply going to make a take a vote on whether or not to grant that
048to be allowed and published in the minutes um I do have a couple there's a a variety of concerns with publishing these one being uh with the content of the attachments there have been at least two lawsuits filed related to publishing some of the comments and in the attachments because of that there is every reason to believe that the district would also be placing itself in legal Jeopardy should it also publish the same information um the other aspect is or and other of many is that they're not Germaine to the meeting um in there you the comments that you made they regarding the the officer's election and they don't pertain you don't identify any ways that [Music] um any contact con consistent with being an officer of the board uh what that is and how
049anybody identified in your your notes has is unable to execute the duties of being an officer so it's just not germine to the to the discussion um but there's a lot of there's a legal question here and the district should not publish this publish information that could place it in in legal Jeopardy it would be insane for us to do that and we're not going to place the district in in legal harm Mr saterfield uh yes Mr Scully are you asking to remove all eight pages yes yeah okay yeah I agree with Mr Scully on several well for several reasons um a lot of this is just uh Miss Huddle's opinion I mean that's basically it's cutting and pasting from Facebook it's like that's that's what I dealt with with adolescence when I was a
050principal um you you're I mean point of order you said you were not going to allow this I did say that okay um the point being is that if each of us every time there the situation regardless of what it was we all wanted just to interject with our personal opinions and we got 10 pages is that correct that's what board policy calls for I want you to imagine what kind of additions to minutes we would have um again I go back to the fact that much of this or 99% of this is Miss Huddle's personal opinions on stuff her incident report was not an official incident report it's something she made up on her own she put incident reports so it would look like as it was something official the police report was something
051called a citizen complaint anybody can call Richland County and complain and they write it down it doesn't mean anything there are no charges no the investigation I talked to the officer that took the complaint Mr safield okay I'm Sor is there a question any well no the point being is um this is completely inappropriate and uh this should not be included it does not like Mr U Scully said it does not include any board business or anything that was discussed nothing on the agenda it was something that Miss huddle just brought up on her own I don't know why she wants to include it unless you just upset and angry but I'm done Miss huddle um I think it's really interesting that three weeks have gone by and a newspaper reporter with The State newspaper
052decides today to write a story about this and he writes the board will take up approval of those minutes when it meets tonight it sure looks like there's some people who are taking direction from The State newspaper or vice versa it's very curious um you guys are are making up board policy you're making up the state law as you go along um I have an amendment to motion I move to amend the motion to keep the sheriff's report filed against board member Mike saterfield for his conduct towards another board member during the board member me meeting um in the minutes of the 11282 24 meeting I second that um can I make one more comment and this is not about Miss Huddle's notes or anything like that well and it's not about me though uh
053one of the of the things that she writes in there is that Mr Scully is not should not be a board member board policy which Miss hudle oftentimes refers to uh board policy and board member conduct says board members will accept the will of the majority of the vote in all cases and support the resulting policy or decision Mr Scully was voted as Vice chair we should accept that whether we disag agree with it or agree with it it is board policy I get to speak to my motion um I made those comments before the vote um and in my personal opinion you and Mr Scully should recuse yourselves from this vote because it is about you and your conduct okay so when this conversation started I rolled over to Dr Ross because Mrs huddle
054started um reading policy and law and to be quite Frank I don't know sort of where this Falls um I'm not even sure if I can make an amendment or what the um PR protocol is here I believe under Robert's Rules we have to vote on the amendment but before we vote on the original motion you can make another amendment I wanted to make an amendment to table this um to give me an opportunity or to give us an opportunity to get legal advice based on the policies that Mrs huddle is trying to present right now I will second that motion Mr we don't have a lawyer here but I I I wonder what the law is regarding approval of minutes so what you're doing is tabling the approval of the minutes I understand which
055I don't know we can uh pause for a review if if you have that um we don't have an petarian but we do have the Robert's r book so report that no pressure Miss Taylor and my apologies for the delay I just want to make sure we get it right okay Dr Ross Madam chair it says if the assembly does not wish to carry out the reading and approval of the minutes at the regular time it may by majority vote without debate dispense with the reading of the minutes and then it can be taken up without debate any later time during the meeting while no business is pending ask a question so I I guess I'm I'm want clarification on your your Amendment Miss Snipes the board has the ability the authority to approve or
056not approve the minutes so if we don't improve the minutes that's fully within our ability and our Authority so there's nothing wrong with doing that so I don't understand why we would need like to me it's not a legal question we if we don't approve the minutes we simply don't approve the minutes so that's that's up to us Mr hering and if the minutes are not approved what happens then does it say Miss Taylor I'm sorry I know we are required by um our our board policy to keep minutes of of all the of all of the meetings so we would be then going against that I I think I think we're asking clarification that we could um if we move into another meeting could we do that could we that's the clarification um I
057guess it wouldn't be tbling but it would be def verification on the attachments and whether or not we can pull them out by law have attachments ever not been approved I mean I'm sure that's happened in the past M M white do you remember attachments not being approved in the minutes no sir not since I've been the board secretary but maybe in the past I'd have to go back and research okay it does say also the only proper way to object to the approval of the secretary's draft of the minutes is to offer a correction to it so that otherwise they would have to be approved it really doesn't speak as to whether it can be tabled to another meeting I see so with that we're going to have to take up your Amendment we're
058GNA have to take up your Amendment as a vote I'm going to withdraw my Amendment since we can't find something to support that that would be okay so the next takes us back to Mrs Huddle's amendment that I now need her to repeat I need I might not get it exactly the same um I moveed to amend the motion to keep the police report filed against board member Mike saterfield for his conduct toward another board member during the board meeting in the minutes of the 11282 24 meeting and he seconded it she um amended her motion to keep the incident reports that she filed in the minutes yes Mr saterfield yes I'm certainly would be against that but um Miss H knows that that police report is a citizen's complaint and it's one-sided they didn't
059talk to me they don't talk to any Witnesses they just take the report when somebody calls in and makes a complaint Miss Snipes oh yes ma'am um again I'm going read the state law South Carolina law code 30-4 D90 provides and this is a quote all public bodies shall keep written minutes of their public meetings period such minutes shall include but need not be limited to number four any other information that any member of the public body requests to be included or reflected in the minutes that's what I did by law I get a right to do that so do you if you disagree with the account of what happened put your own account in there although it's too late you could have done that but you know you guys vote for this you are
060voting in my opinion to disobey the law and do it and that is outside your official duties and what you agreed to when you took your oath of office all right I'm going to call the question all of those in favor of Mrs Huddle's Amendment all oppose and I'm choosing to abstain but the um motion fails then that takes us back to the original Amendment original motion which is Kevin can you please repeat it um I move that we approve the minutes but remove the attachments numbers one and two in their entirety from the minutes and it was already seconded all those in favor of Mr scully's motion all opposed and I'm also abstaining with the motion passes that moves us to public participation um I would like to remind you that the board welcomes
061and encourages public participation re respectfully ask that you adhere to the procedures provided in board policy bedh public participation at meetings your comments should be limited to 3 minutes and must remain on either the topic noted on your signin form or a listed agenda item questions asked during public participation will be handled in accordance with policy BH Mrs Taylor thank you madam chair Carrie lanfer is here to speak about the emotional well-being of her child at Oak Point Elementary School so before I dive in to what really brings me here um I'm going to read something that's going to sound pretty familiar the mission of School District 5 of Lexington Richland counties is to prepare all students to be College and Career ready by providing a challenging curriculum in a safe secure diverse and Equitable
062learning environment focused on academic social and emotional growth and development tonight I will harp on the safe and secure part of this District's Mission and how crucial that is to the emotional growth and development of the students with a focus on one student in particular my son Lincoln Lamer I never imagined I'd be standing here before you begging for help but here I am please hear me now even if this only helps save one child from the unfortunate situation that my child through no fault of his own is currently in then this is a situation worth fighting for what situation I'm sure you're wondering that would be Miss Amy Gail's first grade class at oako elementary school a school previously loved by my child a school my child previously thrived in a school that supposedly
063cares about the whole child and regularly claims that they are the best school ever I used to believe both of those things until Christian English was assigned assigned principal this year and my son was assigned to the class roster of Miss Amy Gil ma'am I just ask that you please not call out names Okay but well then I will omit any any names so am I allowed to continue um in what school or in what world is the best school ever a school where children six years old are so rled with anxiety and stress that they are in tears vomiting soiling themselves losing sleep developing behavioral issues and unhealthy eating habits to cope under a teacher's instruction Oak Point is certainly not that in my child's eyes principal was presented medical documents earlier today that
064included an anxiety diagnosis stemming specifically from his teachers's classroom environment however the principal denied our request yet again to move my son Lincoln to another class because we refused him to refus to put him back in his original teachers class first on a trial and error basis to see if there's Improvement even though they are aware as an administration of Behavioral issues we are not talking about behavioral issues from my child we are talking about Behavioral issu isues from one of their own a teacher my husband and I are not unreasonable people and only want what's best for our child and if this were an isolated incident we would be willing to try but after speaking firstand with other parents we know that it is not other students this year have been moved due to
065similar issues but they want to use my child as the guinea pig for their attent at behavioral reform I cut you off so I was going just going to let you finish yes ma'am since I only have three minutes to ask um I'm G to ask why doesn't my child matter why are other students more important than Lincoln and able to be accommodated please help me help my son and if it's okay with the board I have an email printed out that was sent to Michael Giuliano um that better explains to you all what Lincoln has been going through daily with school thank you for your time please give it to Miss Taylor and she'll get it to us thank you David Jenkins is here to speak about what parents expect of the board uh
066good evening my name is David Jenkins and I'm a parent and a proud supporter of public education in this District my daughter graduated from iro high and my son is a junior there and um there's so many things that this Board needs to be working on and needs to be focusing on things that you should be concerned with like bullying gun violence uh attracting and keeping good teachers kids who struggle to learn because they are hungry uh and are our kids adequately prepared for uh being critical thinkers and citizens in our society the board serves to to support students and Educators in learning meetings should focus on tasks in front of the board at hand and facing the district and it is inappropriate for board members to air out grievances at these meetings thank you
067Kim Murphy is here to speak about over taxing citizens well I'm I I'm shocked um I briefly reviewed the annual comprehensive financial report which was just completed uh for the last school year ending June 30th um and will be presented tonight um it showed again that citizens were over taxed the year-end fund balance funds remaining at the end of the year after all the bills related to operating our schools education was $7.4 Million the excess tax dollars collected from us was $7.4 million more than it needed to be the current millage charged last year to generate tax revenue was 266 Mills that excess $7.4 million is equivalent to 23 Mills our millage rate should have been Ms but this is a trend and this 7.4 million is then added to last year's excess of $3.9
068million Over The Last 5 Years the district over collected $22 million that equates to more than 70 Mills charged to taxpayers one of the problems is that the funds collected are supposed to go to operating our schools but they're not it is being used for construction such as at Piney Woods and um IRL high school it's build to us to uh cover operating and education but it's not used for that in fact the um that $22 million is a net number much more was over collected the excess $22 million is what is left over after money was transferred out of the operating account into construction it's disingenuous to take our money from education per the operational budget then use it for something else it's disingenuous to change a mil charge a milit rate that the
069district knows is more than what is needed the fund balance is now um more than $63 million the district says it needs to have the funds in fund balance to cover monthly operating cost during the first part of the year to um prior to tax dollars coming in being collected but there are other options such as taxpayer anticipation notes or Tans which we have used in the past that can be used that would allow taxpayers to keep their money in their account with opportunity of earning interest instead of in the district's account earning interest or spend on things not related to operating our schools this District also says that the fund balance needs to be large so it can get better interest rates when borrowing but the fund balance does not need to be that
070excess amount um interest income was over budgeted or excuse me under budgeted by $2.6 million I don't understand how that can happen but that is part of the that brings us to the end of public participation and that moves us into our action agenda do we have any motions um or matters discussed in executive session Mr St yeah I'm move that we approve selected employment items as identified in exhibit a have a second Mr saterfield discussion all those in favor opposed the motion carries 6 to Z um I move that we approve the board approved professional devel vment Services as identified in Exhibit C have a second Mr SFI all those in favor any opposed motion passes 6 to zero we'll now move to First reading approval of propos proposed revisions to board policy ikg
071secondary education I'll ask our chief of academics Mina MCO uh to come forward uh for a presentation first reading good evening Madam chair board Dr Ross um this policy revision takes it is the beginning of taking out the extended diploma studies it will be phased out but the current um nth graders this year will be the last year that will be able to work towards that the state has a program um for this same type of diploma that we're going to move towards utilizing the state program versus a district program that we currently have do I have a motion before discussion I move that we approve the first reading of proposed revision to board policy I kg secondary education exhibit d a second Mr Haring do we have any discussion or any questions for Miss
072masto all those in favor opposed the motion passes 60 thank you thank you moves this on down to our favorite favorite topic the 2526 school calendar thank you madam chair members of the board um we discussed the calendar at the last meeting so um I just wanted to refresh your memory and based on the results of the online survey that we took um it is the administration's recommendation that the board approve draft a for the 2526 academic calendar I am happy to take any questions if you have them need a motion yes we do God help me I move that we approve the proposed 2025 2026 school calendar has presented an exhibit e do I have a second Mr SF any discussion or questions for Mrs Taylor all right all those in favor all opposed
073no motion passes 6 to zero thank you Miss Taylor that moves us to the renewal of the district by Foundation of educational Excellence memoranda of understanding and agreement uh coming to the Lector is the director of the foundation miss Lynn Collins uh to um share some of the things that the district file Foundation is do doing as we engage in our mou good evening Madam chair Dr Ross and board members again my name is Lyn Collins I'm the current executive director of The District 5 Foundation as always is a pleasure to speak with you all on behalf of the foundation we are truly grateful for the partnership we've experienced over the years as you may know each year the foundation provides funds for snack packs emergencies teacher grants and student grants so that students and
074staff have what they need to not only be successful in school but to be very Innovative while they're doing so we are fully funded 100% through donations and other fundraising efforts and I just wanted to take a special moment to give a huge shout out to a special group of students at chapen high school who I just found out today are going to be donating a hundred I sorry $1,000 um to The District 5 Foundation um from their own fundraising efforts and I would also like to give a huge shout out to homes that I found out at the end of last week is donating $10,000 to the foundation so thank you for the community support out there um we hope that everyone will visit our Facebook page and participate in our holiday fundraising that's
075going on right now and we look forward to many more years of supporting the students and the staff of District 5 and I'm open to any questions if anyone has any I think we need a motion um approximately what percentage can you tell us more about the snackpack program like how much money does the foundation do and I know there's other organizations that participate as well so like what percentage the foundation does versus so Foundation funds one weekend a month um so our Community Partners are responsible for funding uh the other three weeks of every month so last count it was about that number changes because we have some some students go off snackpack and some students come on depending on their home financial situations but between 34,000 a weekend is what it's costing uh
076to fund the snackpack program Mr saterfield yeah um can you tell me what are some of the activities I know that in years past we did dinner on the dam and we had the competition with all the elementary schools cuz I led Seven Oaks in an effort cuz I really wanted to win that prize um had the if you had the most number of students that were there to walk across the dam do you all have anything like that planned those are fun activities that the uh I think the folks look forward to yes that was an amazing event I I was working at Nursery Road at the time and so that was a very fun event for all the students to partake in um we the last couple years we've been trying to give
077more thought to fundraisers and activities that students and schools as a whole can participate in so this spring we are having a we don't want to say cornhole tournament but it's more of a family FunFest day um with a cornhole tournament involved it'll be at Dutch Fork High School I can't remember the date right off the top of my head um but it is before Spring Break um and so we will have food vendors um activities for the kids and opportunities for again it's in the process of planning so don't you know write this down as as gospel um but we will have opportunities for schools to form their own teams have a little spirited competition going on between the schools with the cornhole and other activities this event was originally planned spring of 2020
078and we all remember what happened during the Spring of 2020 so that um we're trying to revive what was planned uh for that year of covid so some other things we're doing we've got some uh Zach spe has been a wonderful Community partner for us this year we did a uh districtwide spirit night uh a month or so ago where we had participation from the Valentine store and the chapen store because they're owned by the same people um they're interested in doing some more fundraising nights some Spirit nights to um just have the kids come and just celebrate they're also interested in helping us do a almost like a stuffff the bus to raise fun to raise items for snack pack and also give coupons back to the to the uh Community when they make
079donations so we're getting a lot more involvement from our Community Partners um rather than just having the one big Gala every year um that has not been as successful over the last couple years as we would have liked so we're trying to come up with other more community- based fund type activities so right now we're running the Pampered Chef in case anybody wants to do any holiday shopping so can I can I add one more thing Miss knes um I'm a huge advocate of pickle ball that's one of my favorite activities and I know that the kids love it and we have all those new courts over in Melvin Park and we had the school Park Agreement to that we kind of work together and share facilities so um as popular as I know it
080is especially with young kids uh if that's something that you would like to consider I will be I will volun my time to help you get that organized and uh I I mean the kids love it and I really enjoy watching the kids out there so um just let me know you can yes we would be more than happy to uh to take you up on that offer yes coming up in more things so our students can really take part in it because our students do a lot of fundraising for us last year we had donations from oako elementary hermo elementary Pineywoods Elementary so the students are really engaged in fundraising to help support each other which is great so we want to be able to give back to them with some fun activities for
081them to take part in any other questions I make a motion that we approve the renewal renewal of District 5 Foundation of educational exellence Incorporated memorandum of understanding and agreement as identified in exhibit F the second SFI all those in favor opposed motion carries 6 thank for your support thank you that moves us to the last item on the action agenda approval of CTE Advanced animation course at Spring Hill High School Dr Ross thank you madam chair at this time I ask our chief of academics M MC come forward uh to present the advanced animation course at Spring oh high good evening again you're going to get to see me several times tonight so I apologize for that but anyway um we do have uh a an advanced framework that we've presented to you for
082the animation honors designation uh this right now is at Spring Hill High School Dr Charity Simmons is with me she's our coordinator for CTE and has done a lot of work to get this to get the framework completed and ready for your approval I know there were some questions earlier that I was able to answer and and send out um to you for those but I stand to answer any other questions that you may have for this Mr B so generally speaking as elective programs um I think the amount that we had unrolled you know you sent that out are there other ways that we can offer different electives such as like training to be EMTs where there's a shortage in our area with all the medical complexes that may be more beneficial to our
083our student body and you know securing a job so we do have um EMT we have that as a training right now um our Mo high school has that as part of their program so different Pathways at different high schools um this particular pathway is the game and interactive media design pathway right now Springhill High School is the only one that this fits under but as far as the EMT we have firefighting we have lots of we have law enforcements we have lots of other communitybased helper type situations we have that already included in in our curriculum thank you Mrs sculling yeah I move that we approve the approval of CTE advance animation course at Spring Hill High School as ex identified in exhibit G and a second Mr Harry all those in favor and
084the motion carries six of thank you that moves us to the discussion agenda um starting with our fiscal year 2024 annual comprehensive Financial report thank you madam chair reporting to the lect is our CFO Miss Heather Tucker with our visitors from um to present our annual comprehensive financial report hi good evening Madame chair Dr Ross board members um just wanted to welcome tonight we have um Josh Garvin and Luke vicory here from Manley Garvin to present our um annual comprehensive financial report but I would be remiss to say a thank you right now to the finance team um Connie Frick and lean London are here representing our finance team what I have learned in my sixish months here in the district is that school district finances are incredibly complicated um ours is even more so
085working in two counties getting revenue from two different places and there's a lot of complexity to it and in a district our size it's the sheer volume and so I just wanted to thank our finance department for their work and their um effort on an everyday basis to make sure that our financials are good clean and that they are accurate it it's as often as possible and everything is um is presented in a way that is correct and so obviously we're human um so just wanted to thank them for their work and at this point I'll turn it over to um luk vicory and Josh Garbin from Manley Garbin thank you thank you heather um all right uh thank you superintendent board for the opportunity uh to work with you guys this year as Heather
086mentioned we are presenting your annual uh comprehensive financial report as of June 30th 2024 uh you have three documents in front of you or you should have uh one is uh the actual annual financial report it should be a bound copy and then you should have what we call our sasma 14 report and a very small uh report that I call our board summary report and I will stick to our board summary report but we'll certainly take questions once I I get through the board summary report uh but what we're pleased to present tonight um and uh our uh uh in the annual financial report is that we have issued unmodified opinion over your financial statements as of June 30th 2024 that's found on page 12 of the the act for uh the unmodified opinion
087you say Luke what does that mean that is that is a clean opinion that is the highest opinion that we can give your financial statements uh as your external Auditors uh that means that you can pick these finances up and know that you can make decisions on these financial statements um that does not mean that uh every every penny is is is accurate there's certainly materiality that's built into these financial statements and we'll talk about that a little bit as we get into some other documents um but uh these Financial stat can you can pick these up and uh know that these Financial STS can be used to make decisions uh again these Financial STS as of June 30th 2024 so they're a bit dated just with the herit nature of an audit uh so
088I don't want to spend too much time on the numbers and getting into the weeds but I will try to summarize some of the numbers for you uh so again we issued our opinion on December the 2nd 2024 and you'll see your general front balance increased by about $7.4 million uh there's a general fund Trend analysis that we'll look at subsequent to this um but your debt service fund increased by about half a million dollars your capital projects increased by about 8.2 uh million and your food service fund uh increased by about 1.9 million uh the other two opinions is as as a we come in uh we we issue three opinions the first we just talked about as a clean opinion over your financial statements those are the numbers the second opinion is found
089on page 132 of the act for uh that is your op our opinion over your internal control so over as a school district we're required to come in uh and test your internal controls more heavily than you would say a for-profit entity uh and so we we test your internal controls much uh uh more M much more uh uh invasively um and if we found any material IAL weaknesses or significant deficiencies in internal controls so big things that were a Miss in your internal controls we would put those findings in that report that said there are non we issued a clean opinion over your internal controls uh the third opinion uh is over the single audit that is p on page 134 uh because the school district spends more than $750,000 of federal funds we're
090required to come in and test the internal controls over those programs uh and if they were in if the money was spent in compliance with the federal government so in this uh in this single audit we required to test the idea cluster uh and the Child Nutrition so two programs that we went and and tested the internal controls over those two programs uh and the uh if the compliance with federal regulations and spending those monies and again we issued an unmodified or a clean opinion over those um those are uh the three opinions uh so the clean opinion and all three of those uh I will move over to the uh uh the next page you can see the the budget to actual again sticking to the summary page uh and so you can see
091that our revenues uh were a bit more above what we budgeted and this is the final budget about $7 million and our expenditures are about $600,000 less in your general fund than what we budgeted uh so your net change in fundaments for the general fund was about $7.4 million uh going to the next page of again the board summary packet uh you can see the the the increase uh uh and and fluctuations of your fund balance throughout the last five years uh and so this year the the uh School District ended um uh the year with 2.75 months of unassigned fund balance um during the for the year into June 3D 2024 uh that means um that if you take your total expenses in the general fund divide them by 12 and look at uh
092what was unassigned we could operate for 2.75 uh months on hand as of year end uh now that number uh is within the gfoa recommendations the gfoa which is the government financial officers associations recommends two to six months uh for a school district uh for a government to to to maintain on hand so 2.75 you were within that uh that recommendation um that said uh I will note that the next uh report uh it's the report to the Board of Trustees this is a draft of this report um and I will certainly get the updated issued copy as to as to you as soon as I can uh but this report is uh essentially our communication of the audit process to the board um so a lot of the accounting fiascos that have occurred over
093the last uh couple decades um have primarily occurred for uh or are being couraged by Auditors lack of communication with the board so they were issues during the uh audit and they were not communicating with the board uh and so this report uh gives us one opportunity to say hey there are issues that may not arise to the level of the the financial report but we still want to make you aware of those that said there are none that are in there um this report is also a plain English version of the audit as much as it as one can be um it talks about materiality again I mentioned that earlier um you know we we don't audit every penny of the the district there's certainly materiality there is here in these uh in these
094financial statements if we were auditing every penny we would be with the finance team year round and you would be getting calls and uh saying hey please get these people out of my office um while we enjoy enjoy working with them I'm sure they don't enjoy working with us that much um so material materiality inherently in these numbers there's also estimates you know um a lot of the buildings or Vehicles we we estimate that those will last over a certain period of time but that's just an estimate you know a vehicle um it could last 15 years it could last two um for a variety of reasons so there's estimates that are certainly built into these financial statements so again this report if you're going to understand the audit process and what we have done
095as far as a risk assessment uh you know this is this report is where I would start um but uh that again is that is the financial statements as of the June 30th 2024 um our firm uh is uh we're we're a local firm out of Greenwood South Carolina um we specialize in audits of governments and not for-profits uh and I I can tell you that working with your team you have one of the uh better teams that I've ever worked with as far as a finance team um and I don't say that lightly um they are are uh extremely responsive to all my questions uh the audit process as Heather mentioned uh is tough I mean you guys are complex and we spend a lot of time auditing these books um but any question
096I have anything that we need to work through uh you this team over here will always uh be extremely responsive um if if other teams were responsive and as knowledgeable my job would be a lot easier um I really appreciate the team that you guys have and working with them through all my questions and concerns as we've gone through the audit process um but that said is there any questions about the annual financial report that I can answer this time thank you do we have Miss hle um yes um so on the liabilities there's a Arbitrage rebate liability of $1,747 th000 and I asked about this before the meeting and we were sent um a um attachment calculating that and I think it um we have till 2027 so this is a liability for a
097future payment correct correct miss hudle this is a liability and correct me if I'm wrong this is related to the bonds that were taken out for her high school and so this would be the liability if we do not spend those funds in a timely manner and so this was a calculated liability but we haven't told that date in 2027 to pay down those funds without incurring this liability this is one of those estimates okay so um two questions one is correct me if I'm wrong but Arbitrage the reason we would have this liability would be to the IRS correct and it would be because we earned more money on the funds that we received from taxpayers than the interest that we would pay on those bonds and since they're taxfree bonds that's why Arbitrage
098exists correct okay um second question is some of this incurred no matter what in other words because this period has gone along since 2022 and the interest that we have earned has been greater than what we paid even if we pay all this money by 2027 aren't we still going to owe some of this I not 100% sure about this but my understanding is that we have certain deadlines to meet and as we as we meet those deadlines paying this down that liability decreases and so I can get you a specific answer on those deadlines in the time period and what what if any we will owe based on what we've incurred already so I can get you a specific answer okay um may I ask one more question okay um and looking at the
099um the worksheet that we received it looks like these Bonds were issued at a premium so if you issue $10 million in bonds you can actually issue them at a premium and sell $1 million in bonds um and you can pay a higher interest rate on those bonds so the net is is a lower interest rate and investors get that um if these bonds and this may be a question for the the auditor if these bonds had been issued at par then the liability would not be as great correct the the liabil are you are you referring to the Arbitrage liability yes yes ma'am um my gut tells me that is correct but I don't want to give you a professional opinion without seeing some numbers officially uh if that sufficient but I it's it's
100not surprising that to to we've gone many years without seeing Arbitrage the reason being is that interest rates have been so suppressed so as interest rates come up and you're earning more money on on the dollars that are sitting there it's not surprising to see those arage liabilities pop up but to kind of big back off Luke's response uh we're not bond attorneys and we're not experts inations Miss Heiser speak please come so I am not the tax lawyer that that does the tax support work for the bonds that that I help y'all issue um and y'all do have a rebate um advisory firm that that works with the staff on ongoing basis the um when we sell your general obligation Bond they are sold at a public sale and and um the biders come
101from all over the country large Banks small Banks whatever um it's the marketplace that determines whether or not you get a premium um we generally would not in a notice of sale uh uh have as a condition of the sale um no premium and because the marketplace is going to give you a better allend interest rate um if the premium process is available technically premium is what we call prepaid interest um you do not issue additional debt using a $10 million bond issue if you get a million of Premium you were still only issuing $10 million of debt you would be repaying $1 million but you have then received that million dollars in upfront Monies so just to be clear it's not really something that the school district determines um whether or not you want
102a premium I mean to be fair the school district could issue bonds not at a premium I mean the investors know that if the going rate is 3% and there's a a premium it it averages out I mean they get that I guess my question was in my reading of it and I'm not hearing anybody tell different is that part part of the reason that there's this Arbitrage I get it interest rates have been high compared to when the debt was issued but part of the reason is that that five the these were mly I think 5% and they were at a premium whereas if we had it had paid 4% with an a premium and I'm just throwing out round numbers there might not be as much Arbitrage yeah I'd be glad to come
103back give you a detailed answer of is Jay yeah this is Jay GL your financial advisor is is uh can can you all hear me because I can I can think I can help address this I mean we didn't know you were there so you came in pretty hot we can hear you sorry again Jay Glover from pfm We're the district's financial adviser on debt related matters and uh I I think we're talking about the 2022 Geo bonds is that correct that have the arbitrate liability um so those Bonds were actually non-callable bonds because they only had a maturity of uh less than 10 years so the fact that they were issued at a premium does not impact the Arbitrage yield on those bonds whether they were issued at par a discount or a premium
104that Arbitrage yield would be essentially the same I think when premium bonds will impact your Arbitrage yield as if the bonds are callable um just to get into the weeds a little bit and and the reason this has a positive liability which is not a bad thing is the Arbitrage yield on these bonds was 2.18% uh and since we issued those fixed rate bonds obviously those proceeds as they were being spent were invested at rates as rates increased well above that so uh that's why you've accured this liability um I I don't think any penalty is due until the fiveyear mark on these bonds and I'm assuming the district is setting aside those funds uh to make that liability payment um but it's it's while it sounds like a bad thing it means you're maximizing
105your interest earnings and getting the maximum amount of proceeds available for projects but you will likely have to rebate anything earned above that 2.18% because like most districts you know you don't need a spin down exception which requires you to spend the proceeds within two years to keep positive Arbitrage so sorry if I came in kind of there but I did want to address that question because you're on point if the bonds are callable it will impact your Arbitrage yield but the fact that these were non-callable the premium and discount are par nature does not impact the Arbitrage yield Mrs huddle um so Mr Glover unless interest rates tank s severely between now and 2027 we are probably going to owe a good portion of this yeah so unless again yeah short-term rates go below
106that 2.18% and thus you're acre negative Arbitrage to offset the positive Arbitrage you're going to have to rebate that liability back to the IRS and again you know I I I would I think the district is probably setting those funds aside in an account to make that payment but you're not required to do that until I think the fifth anniversary of the issuance of the bonds okay and the callable is the the feature that makes it subject to Arbitrage no and and I'm sorry this is a lot yeah so if if if bonds are callable they're actually priced to that call date which would drive that Arbitrage yield down if they're premium bonds which I think is what you were getting at so you're on point that if premium callable bonds are issued that would
107drive the Arbitrage yield down and limit how much investment earnings you could earn up to that Arbitrage yield but since these bonds are non-callable their price to their maturity date so that is not impacting the Arbitrage yield so for instance if we did a 20-year Bond deal at a premium that would drive your Arbitrage yeld down versus doing a 20-year Bond at par but for a 10year bond or less it's non-callable it does not impact that if I could Jay in a little bit we're going to be talking about the first issuance of the um the referendum debt when we get to that point I might ask you to come back and talk about the advis possibility of having a condition of sale be um uh par only and no premium bonds if you'd be
108thinking about that yeah we we can we can discuss that as part because that will be relevant to a 20-year Bond deal that will have a 10-year call provision on it so happy to revisit that at that time think Mr Scully yeah just to kind of bring this back for the Public's benefit in the execution of the bonds did the district act in any way that was uncommon or detrimental to our interest yeah you got an interest rate of a little over 2% which is excellent the fact that you're able to invest the bond proceeds at a higher interest rate is simply the fact that in the last three years interest rates have gone up six years ago you might have gotten an interest rate of one and a half% that you paid on the
109bonds but your investment rate would have been like 0.25 % and as Mr Glover said it is um I think an absolute truism that paying rebate is not a bad thing as long as you have not spent the money that you need to rebate back to the IRS which is why the you have the rebate analyst working from the beginning which is why you set aside the funds and so the the the payment uh just means that um the school district has maximized and earned every pen Penny it could earn in interest on unspent bond proceeds and um you're able to keep part of it and above that certain point you have to send it back to the federal government thank you do we have any other questions all right thank you and I just
110want to thank Manley Garvin for all of their work on this like like Luke said they were very responsive to our questions and helping us um finish this in a timely manner so I just want to really thank them for their work on this as well so thank you Miss Tucker thank you and your team too for the support that you provided them I think you are sticking around for the next item which is the discussion of resolution authorizing the issuance of not to exceed 80 million of debt approved by the referendum yes so as you've seen we have Jake lover here as well as Franny um to speak about this but we have attached for your consideration the resolution authorizing the issuance of our general obligation bonds not to exceed $80 million this is
111essentially the first iteration of our referendum Bond debt and so just wanted to bring this resolution to you um to to discuss and to ask or answer any questions that you may have all right do we have any questions Miss hudle so going back to our other discussion is part of the reason that we have Arbitrage that we're we had the money basically sitting in the bank and not spending it so I guess a question I have is um is it a good thing to borrow $80 million that right now that you can't spend for I mean do how much I guess what's the budget when are we going to spend this $80 million is maybe a better way to put it so we are working through that there are as Dr Ross has mentioned
112we want to move as quickly but as smartly as possible as we move forward on these obviously the longer we wait the more construction cost are going to go up and so we're being mindful of that but working um we have a great team Dave myself um Alan and we've been working in fact we have a a conference room over in facilities where we have a timeline of all the projects what they cost you know when the A&E goes out how long is that process going to take and so we're trying to lay all of that out so we have a very clear visual of not only the timeline but the cost of each project and then breaking down those costs into the A&E then the conr construction and the close out so all of
113those steps and so we were trying to be very mindful of doing that in a quick but efficient manner and so we wanted to essentially issue this first iteration of this 80 million to get that started because we realized we're going to incur quite a few costs UPF front as far as the architectur engineering and getting some of these things going and so we need those funds available um and so that's why we we chunked it in those three I guess $80 million and we have time to issue those or we have time to spin that down without any penalties essentially and so there are a number of things we call sort of conventional wisdom things that we see in in in the work I do and the work Jay does very often um an
114issue where we'll we'll look at what will we spend over the next three years um and and so the um uh that's that's one thing that we look at I would note that this resolution authorizes not exceeding $80 million the um actual sale of the bonds I think is scheduled for March and if uh the the team Dr Ross and and the team here at the school district said you know we're probably not going to need but $60 million to get this up and running then then that that number could could be um could be decreased the uh I think as you shared the financing plans with the public um it appeared that you were going to do three equal um issues of $80 million honestly uh you know the second issue you may need
115$100 million and then a smaller amount to finish up um Jay will um will be the one to make sure that as this these bonds are issued and structured the whole uh um uh 240 million that you stay within the millage um limit that you projected to the public so there there are a lot of moving pieces about um how much to issue and exactly when but we take our cues from the um from your uh senior Administration and would not certainly want to don't want to overissue but you also don't want to you know issue and incur um expenses and and then have to issue again if if say they need Less in March and say they only issue 20 million does that affect the contract for the construction management firm if they're based
116off of 80 million uh so right now if you can talk a little bit about the look back opportunities we have here I think one of the things that we're trying to do is move forward with time so we have a lot of solicitations going through so we can get to bidding so that we can get the actual um prices uh but uh now what we're using is fund balance assignment to pay for everything so we're not even spending Bond proceeds we're spending fund balance assignment uh so I think we wrote in this a a 60-day look back that could help uh give us some optionality on using uh Bond proceeds to pay for construction management exactly there is language I think it's paragraph 18 that we call a reimbursement language um it is the
117official Declaration of intent by this board that um expenditure that are made prior to the issuance of the bonds um will be reimbursed to the fund from which those bonds from which those funds came um to the extent that you're using um general fund monies that and you want to get that you want to have those funds reimbursed as quickly as possible because there are no IRS limits and there are no Arbitrage issues with respect to your cash and and so using cash to get things going but having the um the bond proceeds available to to repay on what you have expended is is a strategy that we would recommend you consider because cash is King you you can um have um earn whatever you can in the elip or wherever y'all's funds are are
118um um invested without fear of positive Arbitrage rebate liability and things like that I'll just um Mr bam on the construction management uh contract right now that is just the construction of Dutch Fork ume the new Dutch Fork Elementary School the two wings at lmes and CES and there's one more the renovations in the new elementary school okay the renovations in the new elementary school so there's just three projects that are in that current contract um so it's not based on a percentage of the $80 million it's based on a percentage of those three projects um so we limited that the first um solicitation for construction management firms to just those so just want to clear that up thank you do we have any other questions Mr SAR when would you actually pay the construction
119management company does that happen upfront or is that after the fact so the construction management company would get paid uh basic based on Milestones throughout the project so there would be be paid percentage well their their total percentage but then as certain Milestones of the projects are reached then they essentially would have a pay application for a certain percentage as that as that moves along Dave did I miss anything okay it's monthly so it's monthly based on those percentages so any any other questions all right thank you thank y'all thank you thank you J youall have a pleasant holiday season and we'll see yall back here I think on January the 13th you too thank you thank y'all all right we have been asked as to group um discussion agenda items 19 through 22 together
120I'm Dr Ross i' like you elaborate uh thank you madam chair um as uh act 114 has impacted uh our operations and our instructional programs uh with the revision to read to succeed it has now impacted a lot of policies so we're asking if we can take all of these up in one discussion even though they're different policies so with that I'll um turn the mic over to the floor to our chief of academics Miss Tina mcco good evening um just like Dr Ross said policy um ihaa which is the ELA instructional policy ihca the summer school policy ik ke which is promotion retention and then IBB the state program assessments all are wrapped around the read to succeeded requirements um I I can read through those for you or I could just stand for
121questions which is best for you do we have any questions I think everybody want questions Miss huddle um so a lot of this is because of the new reading program right um kind of related to this it's kind of tangential but I'd heard that um some of the colleges weren't teaching it yet has that changed you know and then and it kind of goes to recruiting like that if people are graduating from college and they're not learning letters how do we deal with that so I will tell you we partner closely with University of South Carolina and um I'll use Beth white as one of their professors that works directly with our schools and she's actually taking letters herself and incorporating that into her coursework that she does with her um with with her students
122um within the schools so I do know that USC is um utilizing the science of reading which is what what you're referencing I believe okay and then the the other question I had is on the the the students the third grade students that may be held back um how much information is shared with their parents and how do their parents know and is it repetitive you know just I just don't want parents you know I'm sure you guys are doing it so I'm just curious what y'all are doing sure so um by law January of a child's third grade year you have to have parent conferences with those students who are showing that they're at risk and we utilize our map data um the cut score now with the with the new does not meet
123is 186 for map so anyone who would be around a 190 or below because that's a little bit above the cut score but still in that kind of iffy range we'll have meetings with in January that's third grade but we do the same thing whenever we see students who are at risk in second grade we have intervention that starts in kindergarten first grade and parents are part of that process throughout in fact they're not served an intervention without parents being aware of that and there's there's forms and letters that go home with that so there's constant communication to parents about where their students are are and and what's going on in terms of remediation or what needs are there so there's constant communication about that but like I said the law requires starting January of
124the third grade year you have very detailed um parent conference there's a form that goes home parents sign it um starting this coming year part of that is actually a plan that parents are part of creating where you act where you outline what that supplemental instruction's going to look like that's something that we've done a little um maybe not as formally as what now this the law requires but we've always done that but now there's a formal plan that has to be put in place for those students thank you Mrs SFI and then yeah I had one question I was looking at both policies and I noticed I was looking at the wording maybe you can clarify for me if I am below RA reading level in first and second grade is summer reading Camp
125mandatory so starting so this year you will not be but next year first grade will be said 26 27 first grade will be added and then the following year second grade will be or first second grade's added first and then first grade's added excuse me I said it backwards so second grade's added first and then first grade is added so there will be a mandatory and that will be based on the interim assessments that um we give which currently is map now how about third grade because I noticed it was handled a little differently and third grade is the retention year right so third grade there is there's still the requirement if you're in the does not meet category you're required to either meet a good cause exemption um which there are four things that
126are listed there it has to do with your English um ESL e your ml students let me say it the right way now your ml students whether they have an IEP um whether they are um it just went away from me I need to look it up but there's four there's four of them and and I can find them if you need me to say them but there's four of those there's actually another thing that doesn't show up in these policies that is in the law that allows for one SL tweak to the good cause exemption so this is this is what would help a child let's say I took map in March and I made a 190 on map the cut score is 186 but then I went into the SC ready and I
127may does not meet that would say that I have to go to summer reading Camp I'd have to be retained if I didn't meet it at the end of of summer reading Camp as a teacher the teacher can actually write up a proposal to her principal his or her principal and say that child should not be retained because of the map score and the principal can then say okay I see that that's approved it would then go to Dr Ross as a superintendent he would then have to approve that there's there's actually you can actually look at their IEP you can look at their esol status and you can look at um whether or not I'm going to pull that because I tell y my brain just went totally away and I've got it sitting
128right here so there's no need for me not to pull it so you've got two years of reading intervention and prior retention that was the one that was going away from me so if those things were in place those are all good cause exemptions anyway right the only thing that's not a good cause exemption is a prior map score that's above the 186 cut score so that's an addition to a way that a child would not be retained if they and excuse me for all the questions I'm just I was just curious about this because this is really going to impact schools it's going to be one of the biggest things that impact elementary schools especially um will there be an evaluation after reading Camp yes and so at the the end of reading Camp
129all the students will take map this year it's map um and they have to make a 186 or they have to make a 187 or higher because the 186 is the cut score you know the I think it's going to be great for those schools that have consistent students first second and third but for those schools where we have a lot of turnover if you have a large number of third graders that move in that's going to be present quite a challenge for those for those schools especially I mean you have not had the opportunity to have them in first and second and now you get them in third wherever they are and um it's going to be challenging it's going to be challenging Mr Harry I have three questions but I think they'll be
130quick um I pointed this out to Dr Ross in the proposed policy you still have the inclusion of the laps which I think are not really allowed as a good cause exemption um can you tell me where that is because that the lap should not be in there it's on it's on page eight um on which one on uh on exhibit oh sorry K it still references a um lapse as a good cause exemption so that certainly would need to be removed okay I'm going to that now to find it that should not be on there it's under the bulleted list on page eight and I may be wrong I just I wanted to point that out which bullet list on the top of page eight all who demonstrates it's the the next to last
131one demonstrates Mastery of state standards and reading equal to at least above the lowest achievement level on the state reading assessment through a reading portfolio you're exactly right that should come off thank you the second question I told you these are easy ones um I'm aware that some other districts after SE ready will readminister map and the state flowchart a timeline doesn't say when that has to be done so can we retain that as an option to try to taret get some of those students who may have improved their map score retesting a map or whatever one of the other three um alternative assessments to try to catch maybe a few of those kids who really don't need to go to summer school we can if we do that we only test map four times
132a year that's what that's what we're allowed to test so if we test them like the end of May then that's it if they don't make it then summer reading Camp's not an option for them oh got it so that's where we have to be a little bit careful with that understood but we now can use previous map scores so you can use fall winter or spring if they if they performed better on that we can use that so you can use fall we can there are definitely teachers in our state right now that don't understand that I have heard that twice in the I actually just emailed the state department today to get clarifi ification on it so I have it in writing great I'll make sure to share that and the flowchart also
133includes an appeal option which I notic we did have in the per previous policy but we have removed that option is that I would like to understand why that is so it does say um the appeal process we do have that in third grade you can the parent has an appeal process that is the only grade level that there's an actual parent appeal process for retention but that's all struck through in the policy not for third grade um it's somewhere in here and I'll have to find it's actually on the same page that I was referencing the laps it's the appeal for retention determination but it does have it somewhere for third grade it may not be there but it is um I may have to come back to you and find it but it's
134a it I've read it so I know it's supposed to have been in there somewhere okay um okay that's about the tutoring but yes you're right the third grade parent does have the right to repeal now if it's not here then I have read it somewhere and it's not showing up for discussion anyway I can even point it out we can I can go back and if I find it I'll bring it back next time but if not it'll be added next time how about that thank you Miss huddle um one question I I'm curious about is in your opinion should we're we're having to do this basically because the state says we have to do that um and it all makes sense right we want kids to be able to read and statistically if
135they don't read by third grade it's very hard but the question question I have is and I realize there are limited resources but would we be better off focusing we have to do this but would we should we also focus more on like kindergarten in first grade and in other words is it easier if a child is is going to be left behind because they can't read is it better for the child for that to happen earlier than third grade and so that's part one and then part two if so we as a district is there something we should do about that Dr rosson I just had this conversation today actually um I'm not a huge proponent of retention but I do believe the earlier we retain a child the better um so uh I
136do believe what and we've talked to schools about this that we we really need to look at kindergarten first graders that if they are behind excessively behind in reading that we should be looking at whether that's the better place for retention for them which then also leads into um the good cause exemption in third grade because they would have already had one year of retention and should have at that point had some two years of intervention but that that's one of the good cause exemptions is the retention with two years of intervention so I do believe that that is something that we need to look at and probably focus a little more on um what I don't want to happen is is one of the good cause exemptions says that they've had an IEP for
1372 years with reading goals and I don't want us to jump directly from the child struggling in first grade let's go ahead and put them on an IEP because that gives them two years of reading goals so that's what I don't want to happen but I do believe that that the earlier we intervene the better and sometimes retention may be one of those intervention strategies that we need to use har just would advocate for robust investment into interventionists and other strategies to mitigate this in the first grade and in the second grade absolutely yes all right do we have any more questions all right thank you Miss MCO are you up here for the next still get to stay moving right on to proposed revisions to board policy I KF graduation requirements okay this is
138a fairly easy one um the only change to this is a a definition um that is added about making sure that it's not just that the the um that they pass the course with 120 hours of um coursework but that they actually Master the content within the course um so it's a a pretty simp simple change to the um policy but one that was um recommended by school boards Association that we felt was was something that was necessary any questions all right guess we decided to let you off the hook on our last one for the night thank you m m thank you that brings us um to item number 24 under discussion agenda which is a January 2025 board workshop and um okay apparently I'm leading that conversation I do think um that it
139would be important for us to meet in the beginning of the new year just to establish um mainly our board goals and priorities for the year and I'd like us to try to do that ahead of um the district work on budget and some and sort of those things and obviously we'll be open to hearing from you all on things that you may think are important for us to cover in the workshop as well miss huddle um one question I have is um usually when it's phrased as a workshop it means there's no votes taken and I don't know how you can collectively agree on anything without votes being taken so I would just suggest if we're going to be setting priorities that we make a a voting meeting so that we're agreeing what what
140it is it is that okay I think you would just have to establish an action agenda after the workshop okay yes uh Workshop would be more of planning and then you would have to go into an a publicly um we would have to for you and meet the requirements of notifying the public of action after that Workshop okay just making note does anyone else have thoughts regarding the workshop Mr safield yeah i' like to say that the last Workshop we had I found extremely helpful uh especially for new board members coming in um not only did we get a chance in a very relaxed environment to talk about you know what sort of example we want to set for the public um some little basic procedures and things that we we want to follow they
141weren't really policies but they were things that help us all work together and um not that we all need to agree on everything obviously that's why you have seven members but the idea was to uh just familiarize the new board members with some of the operations and how things go and get chance to do a little team building and I would really highly suggest that I think that would be very helpful for our school board thank you okay I'm just making notes um it's my understanding I think what we'll do is circulate some dates to the board following the meeting um it's my hope that this will be a this will be attended by all seven of us so that we can get on the same page and in terms of what we want to
142try to accomplish in the upcoming year anybody else thoughts suggestions questions all right well I'll get with Miss White um on some potential dates and we'll get those out as soon as possible so that everybody can get that on their calendar right if all hearts and minds are oh Mr saterfield I'd like to make a motion we adjourn got to get a second all in favor opposed and that motion carries 60 y'all have a good night