CorpusRecord 101006

RHS School Board Meeting 01-14-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Rock Hill Schools
Date
2025-01-15
Location
York County, SC
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,626 words · about 82 min
Collected
2026-06-13

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e [Music] good evening and uh welcome to the first school board meeting of 2025 which is January 4 14 local news media Outlets were notified and writing of the agenda for this meeting on Monday January 13th at this point if you will uh the of Al Al of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you please be seated first up is the approval of the agenda um I'll like to approve this thank you Mr n do I have a second a second I Believe Miss Hutson close any discussion all those in favor James City can't hear anything okay all opposed motion carries I'm going to call that 6 Z since I did not um V

002if you can confirm that you are hearing us cannot hear anything Mr rice can you please come help I may call him from the other phone all right I'm back there we go I apologize for the delay on that uh Mr Burns is now with us so first up is recognition and I am going to welcome up coach gther and uh the Northwestern High School State Football Champions think my [Applause] [Music] [Applause] coming yeah it's so [Applause] good evening TR good evening how's everybody doing um I'm Caleb gther the a director at Northwest High scho school um it's such a great day to be a Northwestern Trojan um and a part of Rock Hill schools um thank you all I'm Caleb gther athletic director at Northwestern High School such a great day to be a

003Northwestern Trojan and a part of rockvill schools um thank you all for having us tonight for this this is such an honor to be here um but it's all about the kids at the end of the day they're the ones that you know performed down there in Orangeburg Matthew fish the Finley pokes and the rest of that Squad did such a great job so I mean extremely proud of our kids our coaching staff um and again thank you all for having us tonight thank [Music] you good evening board I was trying to skip talking but um again just like Mr gther said we're so uh proud of these guys and as I was driving here today um of course I'm proud of what they did on the field but the first meeting when I became

004principal here here when I met with them I told them that I hold them to a higher accountability of leadership on and off the field and they have lived up to that and thanks to our coach um he goes above and beyond I've always been on the opposite side of Northwest hitting beat down and I always wonder what's the ingredients that they're doing to be so successful and when I came here and saw that they paid attention to details on and off the field checking in with academics uh grades attendance and making sure those guys are fit and ready for life um just blew my mind on me so again congratulations guys thank you for having us thank you very much I'm paig wford I'm the head football coach um I'd like to thank Dr

005smalli and and the board for all the support you've given us uh in the course of my career this is my uh 12th year in rockus School District 3 I've enjoyed it I've enjoyed the support that I've got we've got from the board you know they say you can feel excellence and uh you know I think you feel Excellence when you're at Rock Hill School District 3 I think you feel Excellence when you're at Northwestern High School and I think the other teams feel Excellence when they come into District the stadium and especially when they step on our turf I think the guys can tell you that uh you know that we had just new y had new Turf put in which we really appreciate it's the best Turf we played on all year it's

006better than the turf we played on at uh Charlotte Panthers stadium last year and it's better than the turf we played on for the state championship games so I think it says a lot when teams can come in and play on a field uh the quality that we have at District 3 so thank you all very much that for all the support you've given us given us over the years and and uh personally I feel like when you put turf or when you invest like that you're investing in Rock Hill the city of Rock Hill uh because it's our students who benefit uh it's our students who benefit from playing Athletics it's our students who benefit from being a part of a team and uh and having an accountability partner right next to them and

007having coaches that hold them accountable and uh it's just something special about about Northwest and about Rock Hill schools so thank you all very much and uh hopefully we'll be back next year [Applause] have the tallest ones in the back the uh next tallest ones in the front and then we're going to squish in as closely as we can adults on this side please Abraham knew his you get in here somewhere every I'm have everyone take one step that way to the right can you get them all in question you GNA go through these turn right around [Applause] next up is Dutchman Creek uh redesignation of the schools to watch and we have principal M [Applause] here good evening board trustees superintendent small and cabinet I want to thank you for this recognition and give

008you a little bit about schools to watch um it's an initiative born from the national former middle grade reformed and is endorsed by the South Carolina Association of middle level Educators who dispatch a team of highly trained Educators and professionals to evaluate schools based on the following four domains academic Excellence organizational structur processes Developmental responsiveness and social Equity the evalu ation occurs every three years to identify quality practices and to Foster continuous Improvement through a comprehensive list of commendations and recommendations um for student for schools to improve um every classroom is closely observed in every staff member in the building cafeteria staff included custodians included um our interviewed as a part of the Gathering of evidence to support the redesignation each redes ation is tougher by Design and Gator nation is plenty tough to rise

009to the occasion um I would like to acknowledge the following individuals who supported us in person during the evaluation from the district office uh we had Dr smallsy superintendent Dr John Jones Deputy superintendent Dr Jo Holmes executive director of professional learning Dr K dicki associate superintendent of academics and accountability we had Alicia Johnson executive director of secondary education lindsy M executive director of marketing and Communications Helena Miller School Board Andrew Jones director of Safety and Security Dr Juan Rodan HR director and Recruitment and on boarding and William rice District user technology experience manager um our parents came through so I would like to thank chenel wils Brian hollon Walker Wooton alaj lenon Julia CED Lacy Daniel um Joel quanta Judith and Brian Waycaster for coming out and supporting us as well and then we had

010students that were also interviewed uh Jalia Baxter Holland Daniel Virginia Allen Anna quanta um zamina garduna Kia Bennett Isis Robinson Gavin Kennedy BJ Irving Lon Tucker Jackie Lee AJ Barnett and McKenzie fetty and so those students were also part of the interview team where um they gather evidence from them as well but last but not least I definitely want to acknowledge my faculty and staff um it's neat for me to be here to speak on behalf of Dutchman Creek but there's nothing I can do without the amazing teachers and staff at Dutchman Creek Middle School and there are several in the audience if you guys can stand be recognize but I said before and I said it again I am the most proud principal here in Rock Hill schools principal at dman Creek medal school

011again thank you for this recognition [Applause] and can everyone take a step that way so we're all in front of the B [Applause] next up is the South Carolina Alliance for Health and phal education Recreation and dance honor award and we have yes good evening board chair Miller other members of the board Dr schoi and our community tonight I am so honored to recognize Karen Ru she is an exceptional Elementary educator serving PE she recently received the South Carolina Alliance for Health physical education Recreation and dance honor award this is a really prestigious honor it's the highest award given by the Alliance and it's a testament to miss roof's outstanding contributions in her field Miss rof has dedicated 307 years to the Rock Hill schools and she is currently in her 18th year serving India

012Hook Elementary [Applause] School he has undoubtedly shaped the lives of countless students with her passion for health and physical education she also was formerly a professor at winther University for 22 years sharing her expertise in the physical education department and she has been nationally board certified for 20 years when presented with the award the schaer representative shared that the word inspiring is best is a it best describes Karen Ruth it's a sentiment we wholeheartedly Echo her commitment her leadership and her impact with within our schools make her truly deserving of this recognition congratulations to miss rof and thank you for your continued education continued dedication to Excellence and education and for representing Rock Hill school so well [Applause] sorry I'm getting old thank you so much okay next up is Miss Gina Jenkins who is

013going to introduce a new administrator greetings board chair Miller Vice chair Hutchinson Dr schy trustees and the community I am beyond thrilled to present to you our new director of our Workforce Development and adult education program Mr guy Gaither Mr Gaither is a veteran educator whose resume sh shares a couple of key sentiments about who he is as a person and the manner in which he serves those words are Ascend Mastery and harbors of Hope throughout his 20year career he is served as a dean of students a middle school assistant principal in addition to serving as a teacher district testing coordinator and former director of the Tri County adult education program so with that we are excited about the new chapter in our Workforce Development program and the services that our adult adult education program

014will provide Mr gther thank you so much for your service [Applause] next up is recognition of board of Justice uh and signing of South Carolina school board so as chairman Viller comes up I'm going to start uh in this recognition it's important to note any any person that puts their name in the Hat to be a school board member might want to check first what's going on in that head because in our society it is a tough position to be in there's nothing that happens that's good there's nothing that happens that right that's right so for the seven of you to say I want to represent my community and do what's best for the school district I commend you for that as I said before I commend anybody that runs for school board whether you

015make it to this post or not it says a lot about your character if you're running for the right reason to what's best for kids so this is a month to recognize all the Schoolboard members around this nation in the state especially that says I'm going to stand up for what's best for kids and so month every year during this month uh the state sends a poster that you will sign and it has ethics and principles that chairman Miller will talk about but thank you for your willingness to serve and represent our kids at the best of your ability thank you so um as Dr schaly uh explained we are members of the South Carolina School Board Association and they have a um group of ethical principles that uh school board members across the state

016um are pledging to um adhere to in order to improve public education in our community so what we as a board collectively say is we pledge our efforts to inove public education in our community who will Solly try to represent the interests of the entire District when making decisions and to rely on available facts and on our judgment rather than on individuals and special interest groups understand the proper role of the board to set policies governing the district and that and to hire the chief administrative officer to carry out these policies encourage an open Exchange ideas by all board members during the decision- making process seek regular Communications between board and students staff and all segments of the community attend all board meetings to study issues facing the board and to act policies and official

017actions only after full discussion and sou meet meetings work with other board members in a conscientious and courteous manner fitting the public trust placed in the position School Board trustee communicate concerns and public reaction to board Poli IES and school programs the superintendent and other board members in a professional manner support employment of the person's best qualified for staff positions and to ensure a regular and impartial evaluation of all staff avoid conflicts of interest and to positions for personal purpose and gain encourage recognition of the achievements of students and staff and of the involvement of community residents support legislation and funding which will improve the educational opportunity an environment for students and staff they no individual action which would compromise the Integrity of the board or Administration and to respect the confidentiality of information that

018is privileged under the Freedom of Information Act study current educational issues and to participate in training programs such as those offered through the South Carolina School boards Association and last but not least make our District's educational setting the best possible to encourage all students to achieve into law of authority so I hope that we will all together sign this and uh then take a green picture for the uh South Carolina School boards Association so if board members will join me and we get James to uh uh join when he comes back into town um come on on right thank you thank you ready thank you okay next up is citizen participation bedh um encourages um our community to address the board there are a couple of different ways that uh that can happen during our

019business meetings um you can either sign up in advance uh the deadline is the Wednesday the before the meeting um to be placed on the agenda under Communications in which case you are free to address the board on any topic that concerns Rock schools um we also have public participation or citizen participation that is on the agenda but it only pertains to I items that are currently on the agenda for tonight for discussion and we have one person that has signed up to address us the time limit is three minutes and I believe Mr rice will help with the clock Mr Dr Jones so I'm gonna uh welcome up uh Mickey steinber uh who is going to uh address the agend the item of uh uh Financial audit welome on okay um I also have

020two other parents with me that were were all parents of Virtual Academy students um and I was on the parent meeting that we recently had regarding the closure of the Virtual Academy uh my sons will graduate in May however I do have some concerns over the financial audit of the general fund and the 2.8 million transfer from the estra funds to the general fund those are the co monies that were the startup and have uh allowed the virtual school to stay open and I'm not I'm I'm not quite understanding with these audit I mean with this how we can't have the fund the funding to keep it open next year the money itself the essr er3 that is covid money that is what has funded the Virtual Academy the entire time and and yet it

021clearly states in here that the general fund increased by $10.9 million which included 2.8 million from those funds indirect costs and it only takes 2.4 million to run the Virtual Academy and you get $18,000 per child not including the money you get from the state and federal government for kids with IEPs and 504 plans there's no reason why we can't keep this program open with the funds that are delegated or allocated to our kids through the state if you do fund allocations even if you give part of it to the home school part of it to indirect cost and part of it to the Virtual Academy there is enough funds for the 250 students that are there now based on the amount that you get annually per child and especially when you have an excess

022here when you look at your r& right now you have a a you know a surplus of 27 m678 1820 when you look at your revenue and expenditures for 23 24 or 2425 sorry no it is 23 24 you have a surplus of 27.6 million and with with all of that Surplus there there's no reason why the Virtual Academy has to end it has 100% graduation rate it is a vision for the entire State other school districts are looking towards Rock Hill High and the success of this program why would we not want to be on the on the highlight of something instead of getting a failing report card which I have nothing wrong with Rocko High my son had to attend Virtual Academy due to medical issues he broke his neck in 2023 and

023had a very hard time going back to Brick and Mortar had no other issues but there's going to be another David out there there's going and there's G to be another Kyle who severely bullied to the point that he literally shut down this weekend saying I can't go back to school I'm comfortable I'm doing well my son is now an AB student that was formerly a d student in 67th and eighth grade he's in honors geometry there's a disconnect there clearly the virtual program is exceeding it's the money's there and we just need you to help us right same situation my son Elementary School find he was autistic but same situation my son now has been he's in all honors he has a 4 point something GPA he is I I I understand and uh

024but I have to adhere to our policy of three minutes um as we go through this this policy also means that under public participation the board does not respond that's the differentiation between um Communications and citizen participation however as we go through the financial audit I am sure that our CFO can highlight some of these areas um during that agend agenda item so uh we welcome conversation feel free to reach out to any of us um and thank you for being here tonight thank you thank you next up um is consent action agenda and there are three items on there it is the minutes uh from the December 9th specially call business meeting as well as the December 10th business meeting and we also have Personnel recommendations um I would at this point entertain a

025motion um amended to reflect the deletion of employee number five from the consent actions package thank you m Harris do I have a second second miss hson any discussion very none all those in favor all opposed motion carries 7 Z that brings us to the action agenda and um first up is uh a team effort I believe between uh Dr chrisha dicki Dr Katie Barber and Miss Alicia Johnson who are here to uh ask for approval of continuous Improvement turnaround plans Dr Barbara yes good evening board chair Miller other members of the bo Dr schy and community members in summary of our response after the turnaround plan draft was developed each of you had the opportunity to review the turnaround plan draft in a small group meeting following that principal Robert ham had the opportunity

026to present an overview of the school's plan during our December Board of Trustees meeting the draft was resent prior to this board meeting via assembly now I am seeking approval from you for the next phase of the process which is submission to the state for approval and at this time I can answer any questions that you might have if I may recommend that we treat them one first and then we do the second one sure so first of my agenda is Richmond Drive K us Improvement turnaround plan yes so uh if we could start off with questions regarding that one sure if there are any bearing none um I will entertain a motion to approve the Richmond Drive continuous Improvement turn thank you Mr no I have a second you m Daniel any discussion very

027now all those in favor all oppos motion carry 70 so then we're going to go to um rockvill High continuous Improvement around good evening board chair Miller Vice chair hson members of the board Dr schy and community members I'm Alicia Johnson executive director for secondary Ed and I'm here like Katie was to present Ro's continuous Improvement plan draft for a second read on December 5th in small group meetings the board had an opportunity to review the continuous Improvement plan for R high school and then again on December the 10th you were able to hear from Mr Azie all principal from Rocko High School about the continuous inclement from so we are seeking approval for the next pH as well any questions from the board very none I would entertain a motion to approve the continuous

028Improvement turnaround for R high school so I Believe Miss Hutchinson seconded by Dr belon any discussion verying none all those in favor all opposed motion carries 7 Z next up is um policy be board meetings for second read and that is me So based on feedback from uh our board post elction um there was uh a request that we would consider um moving back to two business meetings a month um the purpose of this uh would be um to have an opportunity to um basically do do four things first improve Communications and decision making secondly enhance transparency third Focus discussions uh we now if we if this approved is approved tonight have an opportunity to utilize that second meeting in order to do some more Focus um discussions regarding um big tasks that we have

029in our district and for um a little bit more of a timely followup on action items that we were requested to take action on looking at the feedback um I did see that there were some questions uh regarding um the virtual participation and I thought that I would point out that in our policy manual um the virtual part of uh participating uh in our meetings is actually covered in separate policy and that has been the case since the early 2014 so that is already in policy it just happens to live in a different so um I wrote the policy um we got some feedback and um we go sit down and we can talk about it any comments or questions chair will um chair lady um I do appreciate you're leading us through this particularly

030I speak for me as one of the new four one of one of four new people on here there are a lot of challenges here in front of us a lot of things that we're all kind of drinking out of a water hose fire hose um to get our handle to get a handle on so I I do think this is something that we need to do at least in the near future or the next little while until we can get a handle on some of these big issues so thank you for leading this effort and I'm going to support um yes I agree I second that um I think it would be a good opportunity for us to go to two meetings um and I know that we've kind of talked in spots about

031maybe even establishing committees on some of the things that we need to focus on over the next couple of months especially over the next year definitely so I open the opportunity look for to have more and touch points and even an opportunity for us to work with the staff even more with that do I have a motion to approve since I can't make a motion sorry oh no you're not I also um wanted to agree with what Dr B said and what hon said we have a lot of work to do in our district and when we went back to the one meeting mon things slow down and we have to put our foot on the gas pedal and move forward we have to talk about our enrollment issue we're declining we have to be

032a district that serves all the kids in our community not just some and we need to be better than these schools that these kids are leaving to we are but we have to do we have to take action and do it because the seven of us are the ones who are going to do it so we have to be we cannot be afraid to have hard conversations right now we have one we have three high schools five middle schools these kids that are in these five middle schools go to all three high schools there's no vertical alignment in our schools right now we're very little I don't want to there's very little we have one high school Northwestern High School that if you live in that District you can choose to go to South Point

033High School you can choose to do the Spanish Emer fix and go to Rock High School you want to if you live in the Rock Hill High School District you can choose to go to southp Point High School or you can go to Rock Hill High if you live in South Point's District if you don't do Spanish Immersion you're done South and where do a lot of those families go they go to Y prep and they go to Legion because we're not offering them a choice so we have to bring these kids back it has to be equal across the board equal opportunity um we also need to have two meetings a month so that we can hold our leaders accountable make sure that they're doing the job and that they're doing what's best for

034our kids um I think this is a really big first step and optimistic that this board is not going to shy away from hard work and get done we're fix these problems thank you thank you there no other further questions uh do I have a motion to approve policy be for second and final read thank you Miss Harris do I have a second second thank you Miss Daniel um any discussion further very all those in favor all opposed motion car 70 that concludes our action agenda for the evening um and brings us to communication um like I shared earlier on we do have a policy uh policy D AG that regulates uh public participation at meetings we do have somebody who has together with a group signed up tonight to address the board under Communications

035um the differentiation again is that followup questions clarifications or interaction with board takes place if you placed under the communication J that again the deadline for doing that is Wednesday at noon um the week before a board meeting so with that said um I am going to welcome up Miss Danny Brown and France [Applause] uh chair chairwoman Miller thank you for having us here and also sort of guiding us through the process um we appreciate just your uh helping us understand the order and things like that um so I thank you all um Dr schy Ford and and so many of you who work for our schools thank you for allowing us to speak today um I'm going to share a general statement in a minute um and then I have some other Virtual Academy

036parents here who are going to kind of just fill in some gaps that I've left out um of that general statement I would say what I have to say is a good representation um of how our families are feeling in general and what some of our concerns are um before I talk to you though even more important than us as parents um is a student and so this is my student and you'll forgive me if I'm emotional um this is my son William and he wants to share with you all hello my name is I'm on of me but I'm also here to speak from my friends are not at meeting right now um I been in Rock Hill school since I was 3 years old I have autism and has affected my life most

037good and bad the last time I was in regular school was in fifth grade force and this grade were very hard mainly because kids were bullying me because of my autism and sensory struggles and because I was scared it caused me to get angry and outs and then I always get in trouble which I understand I always want to be respectful and not cause trouble but other students enjoyed trying to make me upset my teachers would try to help me but sometimes the bullying was quiet or hidden and they didn't know what was happening the bullying and worry affected how I did did school on how I did school on assignment I had to leave Class A lot for extra help and times to cool down when Co happened I did not go back to

038face to face I have been in a Virtual Academy ever since it open I originally started because routine is important to me and this was a way for me to go to school constantly and now in a0 days I was in sixth grade that year and I thought I was not going to like it but by the end of the year I realized I loved it and I kept going with it the Virtual Academy has definitely changed my life in Virtual I'm able to focus on my Sport and not get anxious I I don't have to worry about getting bulled or a class being too loud and all of my teachers have time for me when I need extra planing I am a smart student but I some but sometimes I just need a little

039instructions also my mom is able to help me with organization strategies other ways to be successful I have time to learn skills that will help me be independent one day and I can do activities that help me grow like working and volunteering I wouldn't be able to do that if I had to be in regular school the teachers counselor counselor and principles have gone above and beyond to help me become successful I take pride of my work am responsible take honors courses and have a 3.8 GPA I hope I hope to go to to college in two years and I know now that I can be a successful student because of my time in the B Virtual Academy I'm really disappointed virtual clet and I ask you to change your minds [Applause] so it's a

040little hard to follow that but um my name's Danny Brown and I am a William Bueller's mom um two of my children are currently enrolled in Rock Hill schools um William being the oldest he's a remarkable student who's been impacted by autism I've usted him to Rock Hill schools since he was 3 years old unfortunately that trust has been diminished inent recent weeks and I'm here to express my deep concern about the decision to close the Virtual Academy um it's a decision that will affect my child but also disproportionately impact a significant number of students who rely on this program for educational success and well-being particularly we're talking about a group of students who in One Way or Another are the kind of students who essentially fought through the cracks and are held back from

041their full potential in a traditional classroom I do understand that the Virtual Academy was born as a response to covid um to the pandemic but that's not why most of us currently have our students enrolled um we know that virtual learning is not a fit for every student but our eyes have been open and and we see that through the Virtual Academy our students who are unique can be thriving successful healthy kids um learning and what is truly their most least restrictive or truly what is their least restrictive environment the Virtual Academy is is an inclusive and supportive learning environment for students with variety of needs um we're frustrated for so many reasons um but I think a key issue is is how many students in the ver Virtual Academy are students with IEPs um

042we're talking about what we understand to be about 38% of students in the academy are students who rely on IEPs um so almost four out of 10 students in that program um and so for many of these students like my own child the Virtual Academy has provided a Lifeline offering a sensory friendly environment that traditional classrooms simply can't provide outside pressures are eliminated social pressures are eliminated um and our students in a traditional environment can be seen as difficult students and their academic potential is hindered but in this environment they are allowed to actually focus on their academics um in recent meeting we had um District Representatives repeatedly recognized the success of the Virtual Academy and what a wonderful program it was um we heard many times that it's a model program that others in

043the state have looked to um and so you know we as parents want to know why we would dismantle a program that's serving some of our most vulnerable students in our district a lot of them have already faced significant challenges in accessing education that meets them where they are um and so we're talking about students with disabilities with medical needs with mental health struggles even students with Children of their own we all come here with a lot of different reasons but all with a unique story um and we feel like this is an equity issue um I don't pretend to know all the programs of the district or how they're funded but it's tough for us as parents even when we're just sharing with other friends and parents we know that there are students in

044the district who are getting to participate in things like going to winr and taking courses um that's a wonderful program where students can learn language on a college level that's amazing that's a luxury and we feel like for our kids they should be able to access a learning environment that's stable for them that's successful and that gives them the best academic opportunities that they can possibly have we don't feel like that's a luxury we feel like it's essential um this program has a track record of success an excellent graduation rate um and for many of our St students they have significantly decreased their need for accommodations in this environment um in a school setting they require a lot of help um and so we have concerns that if our students go back into the school

045environment um are you prepared for 200 plus students that have significant needs they're coming with IEPs and different needs and they're going to need more significant support than we feel like has been thought about um we've lived just the experience of how this um program has impacted our kids lives and so um we were just really disheartened um at this decision um at what felt like a sudden decision we remember when elementary schools closed a few years ago we all heard about that in the public before the decision was made we knew that it was a possibility and so for us to find out kind of a week before Christmas like as we're just chugging along our students are finishing out their semester for us to find out um was just really disheartening we've also

046just been frustrated don't feel heard many of us have reached out um on to District or board members and and just gotten no response and that's really tough um as parents when we're trying to advocate for our students um unfortunately we can't send our students back to an environment where we know that their chance of academic success um is so diminished and and for a lot of families they feel their children's safety is compromised because again we're just in a lot of cases not talking about typical students I think you're going to find that without this program you're going to have a lot of the impacted families we're going to be forced to end our students time with Rock Hill schools you're going to see us transitioning um to to Charter Schools to online Charter

047Schools obviously to even some of us you know paid private options um we're looking at all kind of other scenarios because we know that a traditional classroom setting has has not been our students best bet um I thank you for your time um I thank you for your commitment to making decisions that support every Learner in our district um even the students who who don't fit the mold like most of ours thank you guys um I just want to talk for just a second about communication and change management um so I have an organizational communications degree I've been in the business world for over 18 years uh I've managed a lot of change and I think especially within education you guys know how important change management is and we saw that even Danny mentioned it

048with other schools closing and different things of that nature um and and this was a this was a failure on on the school district side this was a a serious disappointment and a lack of trust that has happened now um unfortunately because of the way that this came through I had my child come down from a class and say Mom they're going to close the virtual Academy and I said oh my goodness hush you're fine go back to class you're good and the next day I get an email an email that says hey your kids's going back to Brick and Mortar figure it out pretty much okay that's how us parents feel in this we get through the Christmas break and we all get on a call with the district and we feel dismissed we

049get time to share and talk and ask questions and it's hey go to your recent go to your most closed school that you're going to be zoned for ask them questions ask them how it works you're going to be going back to brick and mortar and unfortunately 240 students which is a lot of money for this District which is declining is going to other schools it's not coming back into Rock Hill school districts I have two kids currently in the Virtual Academy I have a uh 10th grader and I have an eighth grader I have a fifth grader right now in Richmond Drive and she's going to Virtual next year and it will not be in the school district unless there's major changes um we want to see change we want to see safety in

050our schools become a priority we want to see our kids be able to go on a daily basis and not be bullied my kids have better mental health working in Virtual focusing on their schools and getting their work done than they do when they're at school and mental health we all know is seriously important it's the biggest challenge that most of our students have in mid High School it is critical absolutely critical for us to figure this out and I know that you guys are capable of doing that I know that Rock Hill School District is capable of doing that just like Danny's story I have a middle schooler who has autism she's a severe ADHD kid walks more than anybody I think um because she's got to move she's got to be moving around

051and she's doing fantastic right we got to figure this out we have to be able to figure out what we can do to make it work there's funding we just have to figure out how we want to use the funding and if we can do that you're going to keep some really great kids in the district that make a difference not only in this District but in this community and that's a big thing that we want to see happen thank you guys [Applause] as you see these aren't you know just numbers this isn't for our families obviously it's not just a a financial decision by the district um this is our kids health it's our kids futures um and the virtual school is not really just an alternative education option to our kids this is

052their school and they love it and they love their teachers and they've made relations ships um so it's not a program to them to them you're closing their school and that's very difficult it's it's an essential service for students who really need it most um so I implore you to just stand by your recognition of the program's success um youselves have said how wonderful it is and so we again just um ask for creative ways um to think about continuing to offer this option for our students um so that we don't have to leave Rock Hill schools we again my son's been here since he was 3 years old um and so I've trusted you guys for a long time um with my kiddo it's hard to drop a three-year-old off uh to school and

053so all that to say we would love for our students to continue with Rockville schools but without this option we don't feel that that's possible for them or in their best interest again we thank you all I know as I spoke before this is my fr we had a complete meltdown this weekend because of losing Virtual Academy he has thrived he has become this child every teacher every teacher in the program will tell you from eth end of eth grade into virtual he was he looked like that like he does now goes into the EOC testing bouncing off the walls communicating with everybody a level two autistic boy finally communicating giving hugs to te teachers who actually talk to him make him feel safe and comfortable we can't lose this program he can't lose that

054program I'm I don't want my child to go back to Dutchman Creek where he was bullied he came home miserable refused to go to school missed look at his record missed days so many days he hasn't missed any he's an AB student in honors Geo geometry I mean he went from D's to A's and B's on his way to AB Honor Roll look how well he does he's up here talking to you begging you to keep this program please help us keep this program there's ways to do it I'm willing to pay for my son to keep this program there are other parents who are willing to pay to keep this program I try not to get emotional but it's hard not to when it's your own child who's thriving and worried about am I

055going to have to go to Northwestern and then be bullied my 21-year-old quit school because he went to Northwestern and South Point he was bullied so bad that we had to deal with legal issues because of things he said because no one would protect him and he quit school and now I'm trying to get him his GED we can't do that he's autistic as well the Rock Hill School District's physical brick and mortar is not made for k kids like them they get left behind they get overlooked and look like he's the problem child oh I got to deal with him he's he's autistic I don't want to deal with him there's many teachers that have done that and I've had them speak to me who overlooked him put him in the back corner in

056his English class in seventh grade and sixth grade but his teachers now they build him up they build him up all of us parents this is what we we need it's not a want it's a need and I appreciate you for allowing me to speak allowing all of us parents to speak today on behalf of our children and the other children in the Virtual Academy thank you we truly appreciate it and especially thank you to the young folks who are out there applicating for themselves that is very brave and I'm very very impressed by both of you okay so with that do we have questions from board members I believe discuss followed by um I just wanted to say William I just really appreciate you coming up here today and sharing your story is being

057your TR and it takes a lot of Courage takes a lot of Courage for us adults to sit up here so I commend you for that um I just want to say as a one of the newer board members um hearing the parents because I am a parent of two children in elementary school um looking at our our numbers I do hope that we have conversations about what we can do uh to assist I have questions so I look forward to our our um conversation a little later on this this evening because I think that we do uh definitely owe you know some answers uh to these families um additionally I think when we talked about going to two board meetings a month it is a good opportunity for us to create committees so that

058we can have these conversations so I appreciate you all uh coming up and sharing your stories and pleasee feel free to reach out to me if and to share anymore if you'd like but again William thank you for your courage for standing up here I know that took a lot so definitely appreciate you thank you Miss Harris thank you um I Echo I shair Hutchinson's remarks William thank you for your bravery and your courage and your voice for standing up for um not going to get emotional um but just for stand because I know it's Tes a lot was your name Kyle I couldn't hear Great Kyle thank you for being here and this is a lot for him alone just to stand up here in front of you he may not speak to you

059but him just standing here that took a lot for him so as a mom of children with special needs i k it I okay um David hayatt he's not here but I want to thank him for his strong testimony that he sent to me and his mom Mickey siner with just sharing their stories and I agree that this is a lifeline and I want to say that as a new board member [Music] um I got it wrong I got it wrong and I hope we have the opportunity to make it right okay so you have my pledge tonight and when we get into further discussion um I hope we take a deeper dive because I do think that we can find a solution I'm hearing that you know there was conversation about we're going to

060restructure well I want to know what restructure looks like but I want to thank you all for your time and I'm sorry I'm a c baby but I'm just I feel your heart and I know the walk that you all had and I won't be able to put my head on a pillow at night without knowing I'm here for all of you so just thank you for your time for your testimony and for your courage and um sharing your story with us Willam and Kyle thank you for being here thank Danny she's she's been thank you m pretty she's been pretty amazing and you guys have been wonderful allowing us to speak our children are important to us Willam and Cal I Echo Vice chairperson Hutchinson and certainly um Miss Harris thank you all both

061for coming um thank you parents for teaching children how to self- Advocate that's a skill that they will need and can use the remainder of their lives how to advocate for themselves not only for this issue but for every issue that they approach in lives parents thank you all so much um I may not have responded to your Tech um well I have gotten some text messages but to your emails the calls to my office and all those things but I do appreciate that um you don't run for public office if you don't want to hear from the public if you don't want to hear from the public do not become a public servant right and so I recognize that that's why our numbers and emails are public but I think you all understand our

062responding to every single email and sometimes they can be numerous um it's just it's just not time efficient and hopefully with some of the new positions in the orc chart that maybe that could help us out with some of that but thank you for making these children's stories real um I heard you very clearly thank you before I'm feeling like I'm getting to know some of the students through some of the testimonies in the email I want to apologize to you as a board of trustee member and I've certainly heard about the roll out and how the roll out could have been done better now certainly I don't know all the details and I'm sure superintendent mosy probably can answer more of those questions that's more of his Lane as opposed to my lane and

063so I'll stay in my Lane but in my Lane I will tell you that like um Miss Harris said I do believe I got that vote wrong now I can't make any promises here today I don't know what that looks like um we certainly are going to start discussions about what our finances look like and what our budget will look like for next year I've spent the whole weekend reading 144 Pages here so I can be informed and more educated and prepared so I got my highlighters and my sticky notes here so I can ask educated questions to try to educate myself on what our finan look like and once we get a handle on that as I think what Miss Harris was saying is then maybe there may be an opportunity to explore some

064of these things not only um not only the virtual school but some of these other things that um that we we are um um voted to to do away with so we we have some time school doesn't start new budget year is not until July 1 but so thank you all for what you've done the last few weeks to make us hear you and I say this in closing that I hope all parents who are listening tonight the seven of us are elected and if we don't want to hear from the public and listen to our constituents then we need not run for office and so I hope that all of our constituents who have issues as they impact our school and our community will be as I won't use the word aggressive in a

065negative way I'm using it in a positive way but I hope they'll take some lessons from you all thank you all so much thank I would be remissed to say that I do not recognize if I did not say that I do not recognize the benefits of a virtual education I teach virtually that is my daytime job um my student one of my children has also participated in virtual education for some of those same reasons um my decision was made based on the information I had at that point in time there more information the rest of the board members have said more information comes out and as things develop I have asked the district early on that we need to be bold we need to get created we need to look at what our students

066so um in my mind at this point this is not closed off forever we do have an enrollment issue in our school district and we need to find what will bring our students back and in my daytime job I can share stories about life students leading go personal education so um thank you just like Dr belon said thank you for being thank you foring now we heard you and we will take once again thank you all very much for coming here and showing up and talking and advocating for your kids we need everybody in this community to do that for their kids this is so important I appreciate everything that y'all said I listen to it um I want to apologize for what happened to your son at Dutchman Creek Middle school is horrible but

067it should never kids should never be run out of a middle school middle school is our opportunity to have a tremendous amount of sea time to prepare our kids to be successful in high school and we have to fix our middle schools we have a real Middle School problem right now and I hate and I it does not surprise me that that happened and I hate I apologize for that kid hit him in the face at the laptop and he defended himself but he was made to be the bad kid does never surpr me at all he's never ever literally ever instigated anything he was that kid that kept his head down all the time you know at most you'd be scolding him for not doing his schoolwork that was about it but he'd never

068ever and he defended himself and they made him look like he was the bad kid when in reality he's not he's a wonderful child thank you for being here and I know that we going to we've heard you we were going to work to fix this and it does it starts with our middle schools and then then we're going to fix our high schools um I also Brandy is not here is she that's somebody that I talk to that um you know Academy I I do have we have there's another parent who we were aware Brandy mcart who I believe was going to be having surgery so she was not able to come and she's she's a family there the student will have one credit I think after this semester and so there's there's a

069lot of nuance I hope to these situations and and I think this this board um is ready to solve some problems and I think that there are things that I'm I'm hoping that we can work to um to keep your kids to be super transparent there's a for us we're in a tough spot um there's a timing issue for us as we you know we've had to plan for all scenarios at this point over the last weeks so we're as we look at other options outside of the district like those enrollment windows are are starting to happen February 4th February 10 so I just I'm not yeah I'm not have meetings a month and that we not be afraid to address yeah complex issues in public so I just wanted you know we're we're we're

070towing a line because we don't want our kids do not have the appropriate spot for next year these kids have one chance at an education and if we sit around and meet once a month and don't do anything we're we're losing our kids so we're not going to do that and I'd like to add on a positive note this is the first time my son he's been in school since three as well that he loves every single teacher in the academy program and this is the first time since the age of three he's been on the honor roll and he was so proud of himself he literally started crying so this is it's not just an opportunity Lifeline this is everything absolutely this whole program is everything I mean he got his first award at

071the end of eighth grade virtual first time he'd never got an award besides in elementary school most kids get Awards in elementary school one way or another but his first award for being the most improved and and now AB student I mean there's a disconnect there b student AB student you know and he's doing amazing all the teachers even one of his teachers is here you know all those teachers will tell you he is completely changed he did a 180 from end of last year to now so I think you know to summarize today we are incredibly thankful to hear from all of you specifically uh our young folks who are here advocating for themselves as you hear from board um we will continue these conversations we understand that there are deadlines that impact you

072that are upcoming as you now know we will have another board meeting uh in just a few weeks um and we you'll get more information from our superintendent as well as staff um but I would be reminiscent to say that you know our budget conversations are ongoing starting now basically we're starting back before Christmas um and one of the things that is a challenge for the school district across the state is that we plan not know what our allocations are going to look like for the state and and that is why it's such a lengthy process but all that said um please reach out we do read all the emails we try to respond as timely as we can um our phone numbers are as well as published um so I guess um the summary

073is stay tuned we heard you thank you thank you I have an account from a parent who couldn't be here can I um certainly Just J ad M while she's passing I you continue I don't want to hold you on how does that work if we want more information kind of a deep dive white paper sort of thing on the Virtual Academy what it cost how many kids are there what's the possibility of keeping it what are the pros and cons the pluses and delas staff recommendation is that something we can get in a timely manner before the next meeting is that something we can get on the agenda is that something we can make a decision about by the end of January so these um people are not held inance while we figure this

074out all of above okay so so request um to the superintendent to get that information from staff um and depending on um exactly what the parameters is you know they should be able to assem that pretty quickly for us and then based on that um our agenda setting meeting would be I gota think probably towards the end of next week um and and then you know we'll get it on the agenda for further discussion so is that something you can do your your staff can do and you willing to do Mr superintendent yeah absolutely okay there probably more variables I me I don't know exactly what you what gives you all that financial and I don't know what I'm asking for either but I I assume you and your staff would know what other the

075pluses and minor some cuz I'm sure there are things we just don't know that maybe even the parents don't know you know and so I don't know what I'm asking for but can you get us enough information that we can make an informed decision if it's on the agenda for the end of the month sure we can get you what yeah what we have for sure and if anyone knows what they need maybe they can chime in and ask but I I think we need to hear them that they need an answer I think I would say one of the questions was for me is the actual cost of the virtu virual Academy and what I would like to see is um the data the expenditures and taking a deeper level data not just a

076blanket this is here I I need to see detailed information so I can make an inform position and I think that in order to make it easier for the superintendent as well as staff um if everybody can just send an email to Dr Schon um that that is probably easier for for him to track as well as staff when they're listening uh with the details or feel free to to send it to me um and I can summarize it and send it in one email either way it doesn't matter but I think that having a writing makes it a little easier than than having braining session well can we can we maybe create a work s couple of work sessions where we can have some conversations about that instead of I mean yes well I'll

077send an email to you Dr but I just think I'm thinking that be an opportunity for all of us to get together um in group sessions and with the m some of the even the teachers so so what I can do is and I'll work on this tomorrow okay is uh see if I can get some small group sessions SS would great and just for clarification um small group session means that the board does not have a quorum which means that we do not make decisions uh but but we meet a small group and that is an opportunity for us to get more information ask um sort of more of an interactive session with staff so I will work on those um I'll get add emails to all involved tomorrow so again we're working on

078it thank you all so much for coming thank [Applause] you so next up is the fiscal year 2023 24 Financial Audits and I'm going to welcome up our CFO Miss Terry Smith and I believe her team is were parts of our team at Le today as well as our financial auditor Mr and good evening it is my pleasure tonight to introduce to you Mr Andrew Coleman he is our auditor with green Finny in Colley and he is here to present to you the results of our financial not for the year ending June 30th of Smith I think you all have uh three items for me that were in your back have a copy of the audit you should have a separate management letter and then you believe have a cop the presentation that we're go

079over here so what we're what we like to do when we're giving our presentations we first like to remind everybody what an audit is what an audit is not and who's responsible for what throughout the audit so in the in the audit there's really only three items that are mine there's three different opinions in there everything else the district is responsible for so the district is responsible to maintain effective internal controls that means having make effective internal controls over your payroll process and your AP process other Financial processes like that um and when looking at internal controls just a reminder regular risk assessment is is important including assessing the risk of fraud unfortunately the reason you know we want to make sure everyone has good internal controls is to help mitigate um any potential fraud

080that could take place um in addition that uh internal controls the district is also responsible for the financial statements that's the accuracy completeness and the balances and all the disclosures that are in the financial statements so what are we responsible for like I mentioned earlier we give an opinion and again we give reasonable assurance that the financial statements are materially correct and again we say reasonable Assurance is because we did not look at every transaction that took place during the year we looked at the material transactions and then samples of others um the other um item to remember our opinion does not address the financial condition of the uh District merely all our opinion says is that the numbers and the disclosures in here are correct also as a reminder the purpose of my audit

081is not to detect fraud we do consider fraud risks in some of our procedures but again our audit is designed modifi opinion all right so looking at your general fun you can see you had a total fund balance of 53.5 million you can see an increase 10.9 million in the current year look at your unassigned fund balance it was 46.1 Million which is 22% of your 24 actual expenditures and 19% of your 25 budget expenditures just as a reminder uh the government Finance Officers Association recommends a minimum of two months now I briefly want to talk you know how has how has fund balance gotten here we all know starting back in uh 20 well whenever it was 21 22 actually might have been 20 when Co started um every school district started receiving Co

082money so fiscal year 24 was is the last year uh that any of our school districts are receiving code money and just as a point of reference in fiscal year 24 uh you all had a little over 21 million that you spent in Co funds so the thing you got to keep in the back of your mind that 21 million has to go somewhere now it's either coming back to your general fund um or it could be spent in some of your other special Revenue funds but main portion of that 21 million is probably coming back to your general fund uh we always like to remind everyone why you want to have a healthy fund balance and for you all it's really the first one and really the last one remember cash flow this is

083what your fund balance was as of June 30th if you would have looked at what your fund balance was at the end of July it would have been lower because you all received the bulk of your funds in December and January through property taxes so obviously your fund balance right now is going to be a good bit higher than it is so you want to make sure that you are maintaining an adequate fund balance to carry you through to when your property taxes come in excuse me all right so looking at your revenues you can see you had 26.5 million um you had 87.4 million in property taxes and 113 million from the state you see this was a 12% or a 22.3 million increase from the prior year a good portion of the increase

084is all related to uh tax revenues you can see had a 13.7 million increase in your uh property taxes you we also had investment earnings increased 1.5 million from the prior year you know investment earnings is not something we've seen except for the past couple of years as interest rates have went higher but I know you've all heard what's happened since then those rates have started to come back down so I would not count on keeping your investment earnings as high as they have been in the past couple of years and when you look at your uh Revenue compared to budget you can see you were 2% over budget and again the bulk of it really being your investment earnings 3.3 million looking at your expenditures you can see had 2133 million for fiscal year

08524 and when you compare that to 23 that was a 28.3 million or a 133% increase from the prior year and again your overall increase was due to increases in salaries and Fringe uh that's health insurance retirement um and I'll talk briefly about why retirement and some of your health insurance U expenses have gone up and when you compare this to budget you can see you were 3.2 million or 1% under budget uh primarily due to Staffing vacancies so in addition to your general fund you have other special Revenue funds which just briefly talk about some of these other ones um and you see you had 35.9 million expended in your special Revenue special projects fund and then you had 19.9 million expended in your eia funds one takeway I want you to uh have

086from all this just remember most of these funds are for very specific purposes they've been given maybe they're a grant or they've been given by the state and they can only be spent on specific items so it's not like any of the funds that come in on these special Revenue funds or your eia funds can be spent on anything most of them have very specific items that you can only use these on uh so looking at your food service fund you had a net decrease of fund balance of 1.3 million and again you can see your fund balance was 4.4 million which is 42% of your 24 actual expenditures remember on your food service funds if you get over a certain amount you have to spend down your uh fund balance otherwise the state starts

087com coming in and tell you to spend uh spend more of your funds uh so there's some a few equipment items that were done and were purchased to bring that fund balance down uh but it's interesting they want you to use the fund balance but if you want to go in and do any major Renovations in a cafeteria they won't let you do your fund balance your food service fund balance for that so they want you to spend it down but they very specific on what you can spend it on so looking at your debt service funding so you had a slight increase of 0.9 million you had a fund balance of 8.8 million and remember everything in your debt service fund is going to be making future Debt Service payments your capital projects fund

088had an increase of1 19 million and the entire fund balance that is left in your capital projects fund is mainly going to be spent on your Sunset Park project which I know you're all aare of so you heard me talk uh earlier about you know your fringe benefits going up and just as a reminder you all participate in the State Pension Plan well since you all participate in the State Pension Plan and the oped plan uh which is reti Insurance what we have to do is record your portion of the state's liability on your books um this does not mean you have you're going to have to write a check to the state simply all this means is when the state started looking at what how big that liability was they increase the rates that

089you all had to pay so the state said hey we have got a big liability out here how we going to how we going to get it down we're going to make the districts pay more so that's what's happened uh fiscal year 24 was supposedly the last year of a 1% increase that you all were paying on every employee for retirement and you can see now um it's up to 18.5 six% is how much you pay uh for each person towards their retirement so in addition to pension you're also in the retiree uh insurance program which is OPB and this also has a l uh a negative net position at the state we have not seen uh rates increased in Prior years however this year it did increase it was historically at 6.25% you said

090they went up a tenth of a percent to 6.35 35% if we were to look and see if they're going to follow what they did with pension we expect that rate to just increase as well and what you all need to remember where that's going to hit you all is in your budget just it's going to mean all of your French benefits for every employee is now going to be higher and there's really nothing you can do about it you have to pay the rate that the state tells you you have to pay um looking at your Capital assets you had you see had 38.8 million slight decrease from the prior year mainly due to depreciation expense um at the end of the fiscal year 24 you see had construction process of 7.2 million looking

091at your long-term debt you can see you had 142. 6 million which is a decrease of 11 million from the prior year just due to making regularly scheduled principal payments looking forward to fiscal year 25 your total debt service payments will be right at million for fiscal year 24 uh the district had to implement uh group Capital asset uh policy essentially what your Finance staff had to do is they had to go back and look at any like any group of uh like items that have been purchased for the past four years and if they were overy your uh capitalization threshold they had to record them do I think this adds value to your financial statements no I only want to mention it because they had to do a lot of work to get this

092number in here and so look so they had to do a lot of work uh for that one this year and looking forward to next year gby 101 on compensated absences will be a new standard we have to implement for next year uh it's just going to be require a little more uh uh work for your Finance staff to get that one implemented as well so looking at compliance so on the financial statements uh we had no significant deficiencies and material weaknesses noted we did did have a finding related to single audit and this was related to the Esser program and the finding was related to procurement so you all were following your your procurement code however some guidance came down the beginning last year uh that if you had local exemptions in your in

093your procurement code if you're purchasing it with federal funds you can no longer use those local exemptions so as a result of that we did have to note that as a finding but this has been corrected going forward and do not expect to see a repeat issue of this also in the separate management letter that you have uh for us we have a just one written comment in there and this is right just reminding you all of the risk related to pupil activity and again anytime funds are collected and go through multiple hands there there's a chance of something going wrong we think the policies and procedures and the monitoring that you all have in place is adequate so it's just a reminder to keep keep up that monitoring uh keep up your procedures uh

094just keep doing what you're doing again remember we did get an unmodified opinion on the financial statements I like say Good Financial condition and the staff were great to work with that thank you as always um do we have any questions or comments from the board I don't know if I have any questions for him I might have some questions for M Smith so I don't know procedure the policy um I I have a question uh I I don't know if can we move to asking questions Char okay um so I noticed uh you mentioned about the $19 million that went to the capital projects fund and you mentioned that it was uh for the purchase of Sunset Park so can you give me the exact number that we are paying for Sunset Park and

095uh and and and maybe this is again new board member here my understanding is that that funding was had already been paid started paying into can you just kind of explain the the funding and and why we put so much why we have so much extra money in capital project funds now so with Sunset Park and on Sunset Park's web page there is a link that will give you updates on that building project just so those that are um in the audience and at our viewing audience will know that any type of progress on there you can go to that site and you will have that information and it will be updated um very periodically now in regards to Sunset Park that is approximately 68 million all of that cost for Sunset Park we are

096not raising any taxes to our taxpayers what she so all of that is earmarked to for Sunset Park there is a small portion that is earmarked for a project that we are currently under way that is a high priority um but the majority of it is Sunset Park is that something that we don't want to say quite yet with the project is that something we need to talk about I I do believe that that is executive session contract but the short answer I think what what Miss Smith is trying to proail is that it's there because we haven't paid the bill yet that's why you see the large amount in the capital fund school is not completed yet uh so the 19 million that was uh moved into that can you kind of just explain

097the the sources of that and how just the various sources that that me sure wasn't just it didn't appear out of nowhere so can you kind of explain how that oops he's me $9 million allocate it to the capital yes great question thank you um so every year we issue short-term bonds okay so that funds comes in usually late September the those funds are set aside for projects that we have designated which the bulk of that was for Sunset Park um and so every year we issue short-term bonds so for several years we have those short-term bonds that we have set aside specifically for Sunset Park we will continue issuing short-term bonds every year in September to pay for those Capital needs that we need to address until at some point we may have a

098bond referendum that we um ask our taxpayers to approve is sorry I'm asking a question for this again this money does it have to be earmarked specifically for capital projects or can that be allocated into other into other places it cannot um and I can refer you and really this is probably um more better suited in small groups so I can go really into more detail for you but if in the audit um on page 22 and page 23 it lists all of our governmental funds so we don't have just the general fund there are multiple funds that we have that we have to manage now our general fund that is for our day-to-day operations everything else that's listed on there special revenues or special Revenue U eia that's the education Improvement act our food

099service Debt Service capital projects those funds there the funds that we receive in are restricted for a specific purpose so we cannot use them for anything except for that so like Capital because I've this question has come up in my prior District when we did a large building program why can we not use some of those funds in the capital projects fund to pay teachers we cannot that is illegal so those funds can only be used for specific things because when you issue those bonds you have to specifically say what is it for and it's if they're for Capital needs legally all you can spend that on its cap so I think one of the things that might be helpful is also that we will get um some continuing ed on that at the conference

100uh that you the school board training that we do in February but I will also make sure that I can send some of the training information that I have I'll send it out to the whole board that will clarify some of it and I can help set up those small groups as well keep asking questions yeah I'm not I'm not necess asking for myself I'm asking for if I'm a a parent that has no knowledge of how to look at this because I I work with budgets in in my own work right so like I'm looking at this and I'm asking the questions so that people understand because if we're talking about budget shortfalls that we have and there's money that's being moved I I I think it's right for the public to understand exactly

101what's happening with our money so that we can be good stewards of the money that we receive so I am asking these questions so that is out in the atmosphere you know so that people can understand so we can make the right decision so I have some other questions but I will pass it over to my colleague to the right thank you madam chair if you don't mind I'll pass it over thank you so that goes back to I think the um and thank you for helping us understand I know we need more time to absorb and a deeper dive but um Vice chair lady Hutcheson I appreciate you seeing the voice of parents because as we earlier had a parent come in and ask okay we see that we have the Surplus but we

102were told that you know you're cutting the Virtual Academy due to a short fall so I think that was a question that was asked if we have this funding could those monies afford to maintain um our Virtual Academy um one of the numbers that were was provided um earlier was 27.7 Million um so we are looking at that number of total governmental funds so that includes money that is restricted also with that number that is just our revenues only not our other sources that are coming in and minus our expenditures so in the accounting world we have other sources other revenues coming in other sources and other financing uses which is um usually are transfers that we are required to do to funds such as for the general fund we will charge indirect cost to

103our federal grants that would be financing source for the general fund but I can go into DET more detail on that at out a small small group on that um now going to the general fund um yes we had an increase of 10 almost $10.9 million for this year um as on one of the slides and I'll actually there was another slide um so that 10.9 million so you know what that number makes up and we had on this one slide talked about um one of these is our interest earnings we only budgeted um so the interest earnings that we earned last year which was very high which we have never had that much interest earnings but we received $4.5 million in interest earnings what we budgeted was a lot less because we did anticipate

104that interest earnings would be decreasing so the budget variance on that was a $3.3 million higher than what we actually budgeted so that will contribute to that 10.9 million also as what Mr Coleman mentioned earlier um why our expenditures was about three million higher um and that is because um we have and this has taken place over many many years um is we have throughout the year we have very we have difficulty filling some of our vacancies so once again we have had unfilled vacancies that we have not been able to find a candidate I'm sure you've um heard conversations from Miss Jenkins in regards to that last year we had $2.9 million that was attributed to position that we were not able to find candidates for okay the other difference of $2.8 million with

105our federal grants we are allowed to charge indirect cost indirect cost are things that these are necessary services that we have to provide in order to operate which an example would be my Department business Services we provide Payroll Services we're paying um vendors for our bills we can then go in charge a percentage and that is dictated by State Department of Education on what that percentage is to all of our federal grants and that is what we did last year we charged indirect grants for eser 3 Program um can I ask the indirect cost rate is that 10% did I that what is that IND direct cost ratey rate so on um it fluctuates every year I think we're at 4.56 around 4 five% and it changes every year and that is a calculation that

106we get from the State Department of Education on June 30th 2024 we did have $ 46.1 million that's unassigned which means that is money that we can use how we choose to use it correct the unassigned fund balance absolutely yes that is what we look at is the unassigned fund balance um there's a portion that is assigned and that was $7 million that is one time use of funds to balance 2425 budget now we do have a board policy for our fund balance and um that board policy states that we have to have a minimum 177% and a maximum 25% if for some reason we get above 25% we will transfer that to our Capital um now with the fund balance there's a lot of communication in regards to fund balance that is just incorrect

107we hear a lot of information coming from the state department or state level um fund balance fluctuates all the time so um June 30th is the one date that fund balance is published but as Mr Andrew was explaining Mr Coleman was explaining earlier that will dip low when we get down to October and November and then it will go back up as we as we get our property tax revenue um there's so to give you an example of could because I track indirect or the unassigned fund balance so at the end of November our fund balance was at 10% fund balance is not a rainy day fund it's not a savings account account it fluctuates so my my followup question is is I recognize that school districts get monies from many different sources federal state

108and local um and so all of at least some of us well four of us here who were just recently in this election we and I'm including Mr Burns in that so I guess to five of us who were recently in this election one of the messages that was out there is the school district is broke we're in the red whether true or not true and and so I agree with Madame Vice chairperson that just as Mr nozel had to call me and have a conversation with me about something here recently that I think he was correct on and and so I I appreciate his doing that I really do um I think Miss Hutchinson is correct just as we are having bold conversations about academics and bold conversations about programming and High School zoning

109and those things we've also got to have the public conversations about our finances because unfortunately what's out in the community is the school district is in the red and we are just we're about to fold financially and we're having to lay people off and all those things and and I'm sure those things are not true but those are the things that were said and that certainly was the C of this most recent campaign so I do appreciate your coming certainly small groups to educate more more on this thing I'm not going to go on I did read 144 pages I have a Highline I mean I as M well I did because I I want to be educated because there's a lot coming at us I do have one more um question so I I

110do thank you Miss Smith for coming and talking to us and like Miss Hutchinson many of the questions that we're going to be asking um I I think we need to ask them publicly and we need as you're explaining it to us you're also explaining it to the community and so and I I appreciate your conversation but it's like M sitting in a legal conference that lay people probably won't understand and so that up here I had something else to go with but anyway I do have one question for you that I that I am interested in knowing and I assume it's probably the the charter school but let me let me get to question you indicated that you did not do an audit of the discreetly um present um presented component which presented component

111do we have is it the Char of school yes sir that is the paletto school so they are we the financial agent of the charter school we are not they are their own we do uh we sponsor them as a charter but we do not hand their finances they have so why would they even be listed in our audit in if we don't handle we don't do we don't have any we don't have finan yeah the way the way all this works at the state every charter school has to be sponsored by someone exactly so you guys are the sponsor so since you're the sponsor it has to show up there so we didn't audit it but they did have their own audit done and we obtained um a copy of the audit from their

112Auditors to include into your financial information and and for Community Information um the P Meda school does have their own governing board that sets their own budget and have the same procedures as this board just with the paleta school itself not for the entire school district and and just one more question about the $119 million 19 actually it was 19 mil8 well 9, 8,142 um do you know off the topic of here I know it was all moved to Capital do you know all the different sources it was coming from and what were the sources what made up this $19 million you're referring to capital projects correct the money the 19 million that was moved into capital projects if I'm reading this correctly so on the accounting side we issue a shortterm general obligation so

113all those 19 million came from that yes yes okay thank you oh we also had sale of property okay for that which was $1.4 Million thank you which property was that that was the land behind Rosewood I believe right yes I believe Mr vaugh off Mount Gall also and mount gallon okay all right thank you I just had a quick question you mentioned the fund balance um you mentioned the policy DB about the uh balance and at the end of November was at 10% so it has to be between 177% 25% at the end of the year June 30 great so it is of our next year's uh budgeted expenditures so for 2324 June 30th budget fund balance what is that percentage to the 25 budgeted expenditures so that cannot be less than 177% what

114is our current unbalance as of the end of November was just in general like on on average what do we typically land at in Rock School District at the end of June at the end of June at the end of June of 2023 2025 I'm just and on average what is our our fund B balance um it it it ranges um and just also to I would have to go pull that information I got lots of numbers in my bra but I can't remember especially those but I just want also to just let you know as our expenditure budget goes up every single year our fund balance total unassigned fund balance also has to go up in order to maintain that percentage is is it a have to because it's required by law or is

115it because it's a nice to um it it's number one is fre I mean because the law says 177% 25% so I'm I'm asking you know what we're as far as how asking great great question and and uh I'll be more than happy to go further into detail especially if we have a work session um which I know we will um for the state in order to not be on a fiscal watch you have to have no less than 10% if your fund balance drops 10% you will be on a f go watch June number that's what's published um GFA says two months of your operating budget okay that's approximately 16.7 million if we are at 16 excuse 16.7% if we are at 16.7% or even at 177% then we do have to issue a

116tan that's a tax anticipation note in order to get us through the month of October and November for our payroll until the property taxes come in so for my comfort zone and my colleagues around the state my comfort zone is 20 to 23% there are multiple reasons on why we could have a just like in January of 2009 we had midyear state cuts from the our state revenue all the districts were cut significantly if you have a healthy fund balance we can write out those six months if we don't we're then having to have another conversation and laying off individuals I don't want to be in that position so there's there's multiple different scenarios on why okay and I I I appreciate the sort of answer to that um I'm asking for a reason because

117again as Dr Belton mentioned we came into this as the newer board members saying that they the the sky is falling and that we don't have money and that we don't have money and if we have a certain percentage of money that's just sitting because people feel comfortable but we're doing things like closing the Virtual Academy or laying off mental health therapists there's we've got to have and I'm saying this publicly and I'm asking you that there has to be some more information that we need to give to the public so they understand how we're allocating this money to our students and our staff because there are things that we need to do it may have to take you out of your comfort zone so that we can get what done in this District so

118um I look forward to having these group conversations not trying to put you on the spot but I'm asking these questions so that we can start the conversations about what we can do to be good stewards of the money that we're getting from this community absolutely and I would be more than happy to be part of those conversations and that is what is key is being part of those conversations so you hear it from The Source okay um chairman Miller do you want me to address the comments that yes I think that that would be helpful um as as there were comments about err funding and I I believe a misconception that that funding was still there available if you could and and do you want um about the were broke pardon the the comments

119that were provided that the public feels is hearing that we do not have cash correct I think I think this is appropriate to address those this thank you Esser so Esser he knew was going to be onetime funds Sr one Sr 2 Sr 3 we had a total of 56 million on Esser this is federal funds and because it was covid related very strict rules on what we can and cannot use for those funds the reporting requirements on eser was through the roof I spent all my time on Esser just because of those reporting requirements um last year alone as Mr Coleman had mentioned which was our last year of those funds because that's we spent everything last year we spent $21.1 million of esther3 funds last fiscal year and if I may interject um

120it is also important to point out that although this was a rather large sum of money it was a very very strange statutorily uh in the sense that the funding was never required or did not require board approval for any school district in the entire country it was spent um by the superintendent in the school district's um discretion and in our school district uh that was our former superintendent uh that held public hearings as well input session from the board however boards did not control the SR funding from day one to now corre wanted to throw that out there correct um which means that we don't have the ability to take SRA funding and place it somewhere else because we know stat to really have that power but chair Miller it's it's what was only

1212.8 million left or no it is completely spent the speaker earlier that was referencing Esser funding in the budget questioning the money and that's what she's finding so all those funds short story it is onetime funds that we received it is not recurring um so a former Administration put a lot of of position into Esther that is former Administration um when you have a lot of FTE that are being paid from one-time funds in order to keep those you will have to absorb those into the general fund and we have absorbed as much as we can um for the current fiscal year we are um for our our our 2425 General fund budget if you will look back at my um presentation from there our revenues well our our budgeted expenditures is$ 239 million and

122our total revenue budget is 223 million we B we balanced the budget last for this current year with a one-time use of funds of 15.8 million dollar that is from fund balance and that is also from Capital um when they talk about we are running out of money that is incorrect um this is looking at budget this is not sustainable to use one-time funds this is one thing we did this for one year and one year only M Smith um thank you for explaining then and I also want to add that when we were working with the budget last time there was a proposed budget that I can't remember the exact number but it gave the teachers a very small raise to table that budget sent it back and we said we want to teachers

123significantly more and we wanted to remove funding from administrative positions that were not in our schools we created the Riff that we just finally improved recently but if the community thought that we were running out of money because we were reducing administrative positions at the same time giving our teachers a significant raise I hope that we can clear that up right now because I will give teachers a raise every single time and cut administrators that are not in our schools so thank you for assigning that absolutely I I think we're some of that was coming um Mr nozel is the fact that you know the mental health people and all those things those positions were cut and so when you when you don't have an understanding of how School Finance works and how some funds

124are restricted and others aren't and it can create that narrative and the lack of information sometimes that vacuum also creates a narrative but but I do have a question for you based on what you just said for clarity for me you said $15.8 million of one-time fund are you saying one-time move from the fund balance yes so onetime use of funds 7.4 million from fund balance so of the 10.9 7.4 is allocated for to to balance the budget and then 8.4 from capital and I guess what I'm just trying to understand the the board approve the one-time use of those funds which means this board could approve to do that again correct if we have the means to do so with onetime funds um you can't do it Rec you know recurring year after year

125because you will then get to a situation where we are not fiscally statable yeah yeah I completely understand what you but I guess just to just to nail down my question the board could approve approved to do that for this upcoming year upcoming year the next 10 years every year okay yes thank you as long as we have it and we don't um violate our fund balance policy we want to be very cautious of how much we use um with the budget process we don't know um allocations from the state is until you last year it was at the end of June that is why we pushed um the board vote until the end of June so hopefully this year we will have a much better legislative session and we know good numbers early on

126and they actually finish the session on time instead of having to extend it um but it really comes down on to what our allocations are from the state and with this new funding formula um I say new it's been um enforc for I think this is the third year um is very difficult school districts cannot project what our allocations are going to be because it is based on a um a proportionate share of all the districts so it's very difficult yes we are declining um district with our students but but there are have been some school districts that have actually been increasing students but they've lost money yeah just my last statement um thank you so much for having this conversation publicly I think it's needed to have um I'll speak for myself and I

127think I speak for most of my colleagues I don't think any of us are financially irresponsible I think all of us want to be mindful of our taxpayers and I and particularly if you own a business here or you own a second property what your taxes are here in loet so I think all of us are physically responsible people but also I think we've got to be responsive to our teachers to our students to our parents to programming to academics and then doing a deep dive um there were some things that we were discussing um you know among some board members this weekend of where some of our expenditures are and so I look forward to having a a more robust conversation with you about our budgeting process and and those things so thank you

128as as Miss Hinson said this conversation so the public can hear it is extremely important so thank you so much for that absolutely can iel and then follow by I mean I don't want to I don't want to beat this one you know at horse but I would like to put Sr phones back out there and discuss that just briefly for a second so that the public is aware what the board walked into when we came in so s funds like you said were a windfall supposed to be one time money that then continue cor to happen right yes and so our understanding is previous administration I understanding is previous administration Ed what they do was one time win fall money some Christmas money that they fell into to pay for and create things that

129were recurring costs that when that one time money went away there was no money left to continue those programs those people can you share with us generally you said positions can you share with us just generally what s funds were used for at that point in time that has put us in this predicament of now that this money is gone away how do we continue things that were put in place without the money to sustain it many districts are in the same position deping on interest great question and and they are and I know even with CMS um I read that they had to riff over 700 positions because of they did the exact same thing and when you get this large of amount of money for covid Relief that is a lot of what

130District's done um yes when it comes to non-recurring revenue I do not like using nonrecurring revenue for recurring expenditures especially to this extent that prior Administration did now um question are recurring that this one time money cannot no longer sustain so actually started with this bus budget year we had to cut a lot of things um tutoring we no longer have funds to pay for tutoring for before during your after school from um eser funds General funds cannot absorb that cost um there could be like Title One or title four who may have some tuto set aside for that um Sumer school we have been able to for the past three Summers um we did not have to charge our students to attend summer school um we had lots of positions we had our mental

131health that was funded through Esser we had um you don't know all just General so that everybody understands decisions weren't made just to me like this money is gone we have to it is were all 11 other the mental health people paid out of Esser money I've heard the number we had 11 in the district I don't know if that's accurate or not but were they all P however many we had were they all paid out of s because some were here before Co right some we had from the general fund and some we had with Esser we we also had our um BMA not our bmas our CMAs that was charged to Esser um I would be more than happy to put that but not all 11 were paid some were paid some were

132already in the general fund some were paid out of s that is correct and I'll be more than happy to put something in a hotline for you if you would like that information obviously you know the Hot Topics that we're getting now Health mental health um Virtual School those types of things and so that's what we're trying to get an understanding of because obviously we came in and with our first or second meeting we had to make decisions about all those things and now that some of us have caught our breath we're stepping back it's budgeting time now we're hearing from the community and I think we have an obligation and the ultimate answer may be no but we have an obligation to at least research it understand it get an understanding so we thank

133you thank you you're welcome Miss Harris yes so um so thank you for all this information and thank you for your presentation I did want to Circle back to indirect cost um I know you said that not all expenditures were subject to indirect cost however there was the 21 22 million in expenditures but 2.8 million in indirect cost at a rate of 4.65% the S rate was higher yeah so with eser that rate was higher okay and on the for the indirects for Sr 3 that was for the entire allocation not just what we spent in 2324 but that one I believe was 18% thank you close um just another quick question what was paid for with Esser are will you be able to put a list of that the teacher pay raises that wasn't

134being was no okay no that was not all which they deserve okay just making sure was not okay and I think that one of the things is I believe that the Esser presentations that the prior administration had to give to the community and the board is still on the website um and um that may be something that we put in a memo and hotline since that is public information to people are interested in go back and looking at the details of it um but I know that it still lives on the in the virtual world um and yes thank you for that point and there may also be some hotline items as as well that are in there there from from back in that day so yes sir just one quick thing you talked about

135uh eser being used for FTE if you could explain what that is and then also a ballpark number of of FTE that were paid through S that might help thank you and I tried to not use acronyms without saying what they are um positions so there was um a about 86 positions that was at to Esser that was charged to Esser and these were new positions and FTE being fulltime employ oh yes thank you yes um so okay well lots of good information coming out and I know that as we start our budget conversations you know we will continue these we look forward to hearing from you Terry as well as your team um as we go through this and I will try to um pass forward any kind of information that I have from

136from old training so we can we will continue to have those conversations not I just want to ask Mr superintendent you indicated 86 FTE were paid out of EST so just in layman's terms there were 86 positions that money is no longer gone District had to make a had to make a decision how do we either absorb it in the general fund or restruct structure in a way through attrition and other ways to to rid ourselves of the expense that came with those 86 position that's a Layman way of saying it right that's 100% correct all right thank you thank you got it well before uh we uh conclude I just want to say thank you to you and your team um as well as course Andrew and his um this document may be a

137slideshow and 4 some pages that we have written or or read over the past couple weeks however uh it has taken a lot of Manpower and a lot of Sweat and Tears In order to accomplish that so um and um so just thank you all again next thank you um okay that brings us to the report of the superintendent okay I just have a brief announcements with school closings and professional development days to start the district will be closed on January 20th and we'll have early dismissal on the 31st of January and then a reminder that we'll engage in e-learning at February 17th that's the weather makeup day for our closure that happened on September 30th so we'll be using e-learning on February 17th reminder the parents our program options window is still open through

138January 31st the lottery for available spaces will be held on February 3rd and more information will be available on our website we are currently still hiring for 25 26 school year so please visit touch hearts.com if you'd like to join our wonderful family and then our next school board meeting will be scheduled is January 28th at 6 pm and once again it'll be streamed as it is today and just to follow up on that obviously that changed tonight based on the the final passing of that policy which means that the deadline for uh signing up on the communications would be new uh next Wednesday because we are now meeting to every two weeks mad chairperson let just ask a quick question of superintendent that was posed to me and I don't know the answer to

139do bus drivers get paid on e-learning days and this good question um yes I'm assuming yeah I think I believe we have B says yes I believe it okay thank you thank you Bob thank you for that okay so uh next up is executive session and we do have two matters uh we have a Personnel matter uh bres contract as well as the superintendent evaluation check at this point uh I will entertain a motion toj the Open Session and ENT executive session for those stated matters thank you Mr no I believe I have a second from Daniel any discussion very enough all those in [Music] favor e e e Ario e e e sorry uh good evening and welcome back to the January 14th board meeting on Rock Hill schools we have been meeting in

140executive session to discuss Personnel matters um and superintendent uh mid checkpoint at this point I will entertain a motion to adjourn the executive session and reconvene the Open session so thank you Miss Hinson second thank you Miss Harris uh any discussion very none all those in favor all opposed motion carries 60 uh do I have any motions coming out of the executive session I have a motion thank you in the matter of teacher resignation case a I move that the board approve the administration's recommendation the report and complaint of breach contract be made to the State Board of Education yes thank you Miss Daniel and we have a second by Mr Noel for the uh removal of um case a um any discussion all those in favor all the poos I'm abing you're abstaining so

141actually okay let's recount this so we have all those in favor that we had James are you voting yeah okay that's five and two uh two abstaining yes okay so so that carries 52 uh with belon Hutchinson 52 52 abstain oh yeah yeah yeah 5 zero thank you sir um Elon and uh staining okay and um do I have any further motions Madam chair I have a motion in the matter of teacher resignation b i the board approve the administration's recommendation as a report complaint of contract State Board of Education thank you Mr noil do I have a second second thank you Miss Harris any discussion verying none all those in favor uh all opposed or any extensions see okay motion carries 5 Z with two extensions that would be belon and umon uh do

142I have any further motions coming out of executive Madam chair teacher res resignation case c i Mo that the board approved the administration's recommendation that a report and complaint of breach of contract be made to the State Board of Education thank you Mr noil do I have a second second thank you Miss Harris any discussion verying none um all those in favor uh all opposed or abstentions okay so that's a six Z with one extion motion carries um um do I have any further motions very none I will at this point entertain a motion to adjourn motion second thank you Miss Daniel uh and second up by Dr bson um uh any discussion on that one very none all those in favor post motion carries 70 SES

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.