001e e e call uh to order the White County Board of Education special called meeting for Tuesday Thursday January 23rd to order uh if you would please rise and Mr Jason Donald lead us in a pledge I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank you Mr [Music] McDonald so i' like to uh welcome everyone to this special called meeting of White County Board education tonight um Tennessee code annotate and board policy 1400 states that every meeting of the board is open to the public except where law allows a Clos session the agenda for the board meetings are posted on the district website at www.white schools.net at least 3 days prior to
002each meeting each meeting agenda by law includes a ter includes an item reserved for public comment signup sheet is made available prior to the beginning of the regular meeting individuals who have signed up prior to the start of the meeting to speak will be recognized in the order listed on the signup sheet at the point in the agenda designated for public comment board meetings are streamed with the help of warrior media for live or recorded viewing links are provided on the district's website attending and or speaking during tonight's meeting implies consent for comments and appearances to be used so uh tonight is uh a special called meeting as has said and in special called meeting we will only be considering uh and uh having deliberation on the agenda item that is on the uh on
003the uh on the table tonight that was uh presented to you and so there would be no other board action taken other than that that's on the agenda um so tonight's meeting is called as a result of the state legislator's meeting next week to discuss Governor Lee's proposed School voucher program this is a significant proposal being considered by the state that will affect Public Schools those participating in and those providing alternate education paths to Public Schools the taxpayers of Tennessee regardless of whether or not they have students or family members in the system in some capacity with that said as a board we have not deliberated on the subject of vouchers as govern Governor Lee is proposing due diligence at a minimum would suggest that we have deliberation publicly on the subject and that's why
004we're here this also gives us the opportunity to take action in the form of a public statement or resolution on the matter if that's what the board decides to do in all cases we can only take a take board action through this process and tonight's meeting is to give us that opportunity if we choose we'll say that uh before we continue on in our agenda this was uh this was an item that was left off but I do want to uh use this time to allow any board member if there is a potential conflict of interest of anything that we will be discussing tonight please let that be known at this time Mr chairman I you you took the words right out of my mouth I was going to ask that we do that uh
005but I will say that uh my wife is an educator in this system and uh any of the comments that you hear from me tonight uh will be in the betterment for the betterment of the students uh in this school district so uh there is no conflict of interest uh on my part tonight thank you Mr McDonald Mr chairman my husband also works for this school district but again after all the reading and all the discussion these are my opinions and there's no problem with all right thank you Miss officer Mr chairman likewise my wife is an employee at White County High School the comments that I make tonight will be mine or mine alone there is no all right thank you so uh let the uh minutes reflect that Mr MD donnald Miss officer
006and Mr Smith all uh identify that they have uh spouses working with in the board but nothing that we uh be considering tonight on our agenda would constitute a conflict as it's defined so uh so with that said uh we're going to move on to our next agenda item uh our next agenda item which is our only agenda item tonight and that is the 2025 education savings act uh House Bill uh House Bill one I think it's more uh appropriately titled in in the uh in the legisl uh in the bill uh education Freedom Act of 2025 so I'm assuming that you've all read uh the documents that have been provided by our director from tsba and and other sources uh you've had a copy of the house bill number one and so I'm going
007to give our director the opportunity to summarize the information that we received and then we'll go around the table for discussions and questions and after that I will uh entertain any motions that uh may come out of our our discussion um so uh so with that being said uh Mr John bar turn it over to you all right thank you Mr chairman um as the chairman said the uh there's been a special session called of the uh General Assembly to discuss the uh education Freedom Act of 2025 it's otherwise kind of known as the voucher Bill uh and that's coming up soon and so uh many uh school districts across the state have taken uh action and issued resolutions and opposition to this act um and uh we have that has come up maybe a
008time or two in front of this board and uh I express to the chairman that perhaps the because of the nature of the timeliness before our next board meeting that perhaps the board might want to discuss that uh before it goes to special session so uh the chair and set up this uh this meeting this evening um I don't want to speak for our any of our legislators but I do know that it's been very powerful for uh other legislators to have this information such as resolutions from the local school boards that represent so many constituents in each district it's been powerful for them to have that in their hand uh to make their decisions and to stand before uh uh their colleagues in the general assembly and and uh and to be able to
009speak out against vouchers um you have lots of information in your folders there and we I have printed off some for your uh review this evening as well um it is my personal opinion that this is a this is a bad thing for public education across our state um you know it's going to U it's going to uh it's going to reroute funds out of public education into private schools um and I've been very vocal on the subject but I'll be very clear on it as again this evening that um I'm not afraid of competition but I'm afraid of unfair competition and that's what this is if we were playing by the same rules and they had to do the same uh follow the same standards and uh take the our student their students had
010to take the same test and their teachers have be uh accredited the same way that our teachers have and so on and so forth uh I'd be I'd be fine with with this type of proposal but that's not what we're dealing with and for those reasons and and many others that you can that I've alluded to before um I'm against this this legislation but this is not my decision tonight this is something for the school board to entertain uh and so we provide this information for your discussion deliberation and consideration uh and this would be this information should the should the board choose to to issue a resolution against vouchers would be put in the hands of our Representatives uh and shared with others in the general assembly uh as a voice from White County
011Schools okay thank you Mr drer um so board members just uh you know to to reiterate what what was said um this is our opportunity to speak okay and uh it's our opportunity to to discuss this this matter uh openly in public um and so uh we have uh we have uh a perspective from from our director and but I appreciate him understanding his his role and understanding this is this is our our uh this is something that we as a board would be uh would be sharing it would be a board's decision so um I would uh I'd like to just go around the table and uh give everybody the opportunity to uh comment pull out uh pull out maybe some some thoughts and and that you had in the information that was was
012provided um and we can have the discussion so uh if anybody would like to volunte here uh to go first that would be great otherwise I will uh start uh in alphabetical order I'll be happy to jump in um I had a good conversation with representative Cheryl at the prayer breakfast on on Monday shared some of my thoughts with him there one of the things that I've heard numerous times is this is about school choice and and or giving parents a choice I feel like we've always had a choice when it comes to how we want our kids educated it's public schools it's private schools it's home school I don't see how this provides any additional options for to to meet that argument um the second piece is I I would hate to see anything
013take away from funding coming to public education uh by far Tennessee students are are taught through public education and if the money that's looking to be allocated here came to public education uh the changes that others may want to see might actually be come to fruition thank you Mr Smith and also uh represent cherl we appreciate you being here tonight and joining us as well um thank you um anybody who like to go next I'll jump in and kind of echo what uh what Mr Smith said you know we you look at the graphics that we were given uh in our in our in our packet Tennessee has 95 counties only 44 of those Counties have a private school in them uh that leaves what 51 counties that don't have a private school in uh
014public education has always been the Forefront of the educational process in the state of Tennessee um 300 private schools are eligible for this and 44 counties are going to benefit or 100 or 95 counties are going to have to pay for what 44 counties are going to going to benefit from and that's that's not the way that public education and and like like Mr Smith said we've always had school choice we can we can choose where we want to go to school we can choose where we want to live uh we can choose if we want a home school or not um that's never been it's never been about choice this has been about money and I and I'm afraid that that's um going to be the downfall of this um another thing that was
015in your pcket talking about vouchers imp imply that students in rural schools will be better off learning at a private school in another Community than they would be in in our in our hometown in in their Hometown how far from the truth is that this is going to benefit Davidson Hamilton Shelby counties that's going to be three of the biggest counties that are going to benefit from uh the money that's going to be there and it's going to take my tax dollars your tax dollars and every everybody across the state's tax dollars to fund this um I don't understand why we have to force school choice when we already have school choice um I I'm a firm believer in public education I went through it my entire my entire career um and uh some people
016might argue and disagree with me but I think I turned out okay I think I turned out okay everybody in this room is benefit of public education um and we've got people who are working in universities working in universities we've got Master electricians we've got former Educators uh it public education is the most important thing that we can offer our students I don't think we need to take money from our public schools to give to private schools like Mr Smith said if we put the money that's going to be funded to this more of these programs that we have in our Public Schools could be even better than they are now thank you m j thank you Mr McDonald okay I have a question regarding the application process so these students will complete an application
017they have to take a test is that is that correct okay they just have to complete an application all right and if they're chosen for that um voucher is that an every year voucher or is that a one time I don't know that the parents I would think okay I've I've received this voucher I'm a ninth grade student I'll have that 9 through 12 as a parent that might be my thought well then if it's an application every year then my sophomore may not make the cut therefore I go back to public school yeah see I'm not I don't know the answer to that I've not really heard that post I think it remains because there's a limit the first year and then they would see how many more people would need they can they
018can expand the number that they're going to offer in subsequent years so I'm assuming that means that it'll remain with that student and uh and then they'll monitor it to see if they need more that'd be my understanding I don't know that for sure but my understanding is that once they've applied and received it as long as their School of Choice doesn't change that they'll continue to receive that that award then are they responsible to keep that um if they choose that school that that private school that entire year let's say it's not a good fit and come Christmas they ready to go does another student get that I mean could that just be a revolving door yeah that's another issue with this is what is the accounting side of it for the schools for
019the incoming uh institutions and what what personnel will be have to be assigned to exactly handle that that thing it would be outside of ours but uh our school system but that that's a concern as well it's not really addressed it's not addressed in the bill exactly all things that public schools deal with is just not addressed but it's Boucher program and I don't feel like it's real clear for for parents thank you Mr D anything else questions or comments okay thank you okay oh good as officer so as alluded to before we've had school choice and we currently have school choice but the biggest stand out to me is when you look at the map like you said of how many counties have these private schools it's very few are going to be able
020to use these vouchers yes it's tied to money but somehow going to a private school is better you're going to be more academically prepared if you go to a private school completely disagree with that and in the information that we have it shows that that is not true when we're looking at what these test are showing there's a sentence in here and it says that the Issa students test results aren't anything to write home about somehow people are thinking that if you go to a private school you're more educated than if you go to White County High School our Public School System yes we have some downfalls we do but overall it's more of a positive taking this money into those activities that we can do to help the students in a holistic approach we
021can do in the public school system we do not need these private schools out there thank you myself so I've got a question I may have overlooked it I mean because I'm in agreeance about the map and and that all my kids went to public schools and I did everybody in my family has but I didn't see homeschooling did I see did I miss it did anybody see anything about homeschooling in here all it says is private schools no I don't believe that's included in this version of the bill but it was last last time it was and last time I can't speak for everyone but there was a large push back from The Homeschool community at that time in short they didn't want the government in there it's why they went homeschool in the
022first place so I can't speak for all those entities but that was the message I heard that should tell you something that's not included does and that's why I was cuz I thought last time it was in there and nothing is it's all about private schools well and that and that in my opinion speaks again to the Discrimination this discriminatory nature of this bill is now you're saying you have freedom of choice but you're not allowing those homeschool students to choose to take this money and and use it you know they're being excluded from this so right it's limiting their freedom of choice U but it's allowing it for certain select groups you know and then if you've got one in Davidson County that's here and they've got to go all the way over there
023what if what if they can't get them there what if they have to start miss you know what if they start missing because a parent can't get them there you know that's I'm good good I'm good yes than um well I'll share share some comments um and and first of all um for those in the audience uh public uh anyone that's uh watching us on online um we have uh we have some some very good data and and uh information uh packets on the voucher program impact on public education um and so uh I would uh encourage you if you have uh if if you have interest um reach out to central office and I'm sure that uh staff will help provide that information that we're we're looking at tonight uh actually this may be
024also posted on our website for tonight's meeting is that link Ashley to the agenda items is it it is on the okay so this information would be on on our website too so that's another way you could access it to to uh to see what uh the information that we're we're looking at to tonight um so I don't think I need to rehash the fact that state of Tennessee does allow for Alternatives public education um that's that's been mentioned and uh so obviously that's uh that's something in in a in a free uh a free Society such as United States everybody would wants to we appreciate the opportunity freedom of choice and in things in in public and and education the route we choose education uh would fall into that that category as well um
025and appreciate the fact bringing up that uh this this program as it appears um would have uh it wouldn't it would have have impact on on certain certain communities and maybe not others and in situation where white county is today it would not impact us um from the fact that we have competition of private schools uh or other uh educational institutes here in here in County um the thing that uh that for from my standpoint on something that hasn't been been covered and I feel is uh is equally as important that stood out to me is um while yes there is proposal the the scholarships for these vouchers are limited today um and that may not appear to be a big number um but I I can tell you this representative Cheryl you you customed
026to seeing numbers maybe larger than what uh we might ordinarily see but anytime you start taking 7,000 you times that by 20 30 40 and 50 um it becomes to be a a a fairy Parts number would you agree Mr mcel okay um so uh so it may not be a large number today but if more and more uh opportunities for vouchers became available um it could turn into a large number and ultimately what does that impact that impacts the taxpayers of state and um so that's uh from from that standpoint it's you're you're creating creating an opportunity to incur cost for something that I'm not sure what problem you're trying to solve I I'm really not sure what problem you're trying to solve with vouchers um so because again you maybe you know I
027think uh maybe it's Mr drberg stated it um an example um some of my uh sales tax dollars go to uh the repair of uh roads across the State Interstate 840 um but I can't go to the state and say Hey I want my my portion of monies that's going to repair the potholes on 840 to come and repair the potholes in the subdivision the street in the subdivision which I live so um it's you know it's that's pulling money out I can't do that and so just because I might want to choose an alternate Ed uh means of Education doesn't mean that I can pull those monies out unless a bill like this passed um so that is uh and what that does it creates a challenge from the standpoint of in the Tennessee
028state constitution the state is is Constitution uh states that we will educate our our students all students doesn't put any parameters on what type of students we have to make we have to we get to educate smart students like M Mill um and then they had to educate student like me so it there was no you know there's no this constitution puts no barriers on that so um it uh so the state has to educate its children it's mandated to do that and so whether private schools whether home schools whether any other type of of Education opportunity came up the state still has responsibility and last year in in may we sat around this table and we were considering a budget and we were looking at a deficit budget of $2.5 million to provide education
029for our our students here in the county and unfortunately um you can't stop the the the clock of inflation and the impact of inflation and so as our costs will continue to Rise um we're that has to be funded somewhere so I'm not sure how the state has limited resources as well so you know we're we start pulling and then the students the money being tied to the students is that be be pulled away our fixed costs do not change and so we're still we're going to be faced with that ultimately who does that impact well that's going to impact the the the local taxpayers and it's going to impact the state taxpayers it'll probably end up affecting the local taxpayers first um because state has their formula how they're how and how much they're
030going to pay and there'll come a point in time when uh they may turn to the county and say now it's your turn uh that could that could could happen um other states have have tried this in information one of the things that uh that stood out stood out to me was uh the fact that some neighboring states they they tried this with a budget of 65 mli 65 uh million I think it was for uh for a voucher program and this last year their cost was uh $325 million I think that's our our good friends in the state of Arizona um so uh that caused them to put off projects other projects like uh like uh improving their water delivery system because at the end of the day States not like federal government they
031have limited limited resources so it's about where you're appropriating those resources and resour ources that are have the potential to pull away from uh education is that's something we have to do I think we uh um public education which we're we're mandated to do I think that's very risky and it has a a risk to taxpayers taxpayers uh like those of us in this audience uh uh tonight and those taxpayers that are not yet born so it does have impact um from from that that standpoint um the uh I think the the one thing that uh that I think the and this T tsba they have a an info info uh brochure it goes through the uh uh the steps of how does this play out and um and so I'd just like to share
032this example for uh for those those uh in attendance and listening just so you can can understand some of the information we're looking at um it says MMA attends her local public school it cost $941 to provide Emma's education Emma remains enrolled at her local public school and does not use a private school voucher the cost to provide Emma and educa provide Emma and education Remains the Same so the cost to the state and the taxpayers That Remains the Same Alex attends his local public school it cost 9,414 to provide Alex's education Alex's family decides to utilize the new voucher program to partially pay for tuition at a private school the public school the the public cost to provide Alex education Alex and education is now $1,496 of which $7,700 is the voucher and then
033the family would end up funding the remaining 9,414 um with uh and excuse me read that yeah that's really confusing because I think that's part of the hold harm list that they're saying in that first year is that they're going to still award that money to the public school but then that following year it will be gone um and that's one of the caveats in the bill I think they're trying to sell is that the schools are not going to lose money on this deal it's going to be separate and outside on year one on year on year one so the uh so then you go to the one that goes to a private school and said um there's no cost to today there's no cost for somebody going to a public uh for a
034private school it's no cost to the public to provide Tony's education but then the family decides to use the voucher program to offset some of his cost now this student that was in a private school the Public Public uh cost is now uh contributing 17 $7 7,75 to that PRI that students private education uh costs that they're not incurring now so um which that means you took not just in the county that he was in in the private school that he was in then that took money from me you and everybody in this room and and all those other 95 counties across the state took money out of those taxpayers Pockets to pay for this to pay for this young man's private school education which he was already they they already chose to go that
035route OB obviously in this example it was already working for them and it it was not there was there was no uh no uh barrier there to uh to prevent them from getting the education that they freely wanted to pursue so um I I have big concerns on on this uh on this this bill for the items you mentioned plus the cost standpoint uh the cost to to the uh to the state um ultimately to the taxpayers because we're the ones that uh that fund the state it uh could hit us in sales tax they'll have to figure out some way how to pay it pay it but you know you look at sales tax option you look at franchise excise taxes as an option which impacts businesses they'll look if you start running short
036of cash they'll start looking for ways to to to find those funds to to support this maybe able do it this year may be able to do it next year but they'll come a point in time An Inconvenient point in time when they'll be having to make a choice to say do we improve you know our electrical Grid or do we continue with this voucher program that now everybody expects so um I think that's again if if I better understood the problem they were trying to solve maybe it makes sense but it just doesn't to me Miss Miguel I'm sorry I I skipped you before I started started my uh talk how would you would you like to say Yes um actually we talked about this in class uh when the bill first came up
037um and what class was that AP Government there you go um he are our teacher uh asked us what we thought about it and um a lot of the argument was well then the p uh the private school would just raise the cost oh really yeah like would they do that yeah they would would a would a a PR private institution or even public institutions that charge tuition I'm sorry go ahead um uh because they're not going to take people that they don't want they're going to continue having the people they want so they're just raised the cost of of getting in the first place so the vouer won't even have any effect not only that but it says here let's see um that that some some private schools can choose to just not accept
038the voucher at all so it wouldn't affect anything so was do do we do we have that choice now do we get to choose who we can accept absolutely not I think otherwise they would reconsidered back in the day so just to add one thing to what M Mill is saying um for instance our neighboring county has two private schools in it waren county has two private schools I thought it showed th well they may have they have a I was trying to figure have a viral school they have a virtual school so they have Boyd Christian and C Covenant Academy that I know of boy Christian's tuition right now is $5,000 a year do you what do you think boy Christian's s uh tuition is going to be next year if this passes be
039$ 7,75 promise you that uh they're going to raise their price and we're going to pay for it and they may have to to handle the influx of students that they may get actually teachers actually if they I I would dare say that thing that these private schools aren't considering and it's not being considered in this if the demand for your services go up just like if theand for you know uh student enrollment here we would have to do a address that uh and guess what it takes uh it takes funds to do that and on a private school it'll be will take the voucher money and then we'll have to make it up with additional uh tuition costs nobody's brought this up yet there's three other there's three other things that's tied to this
040bill Public Safety flood relief for the people in North Carolina or in Eastern Tennessee why are we having to tie a voucher Bill to helping people who lost everything they had because of a natural disaster that are living intense yep in the freezing weather with snow on the ground the one that sponsored this bill where's he from Cheryl could you speak to the the uh uh the gentleman that uh uh that sponsored the uh Bill Mr uh the uh was it uh Mr Lamberth representative Lambo Lamberth yes sir here there it don't matter yeah just you're find where you're at well it originated from the government's office okay so what what happens on that process is the governor will issue it out to our leaders which William Lambert is is in leadership to pick it
041up in the house and then Johnson the senator from Will Williamson County will pick it up in the Senate side and then they'll bring it and uh either they will carry the legislation theirself or they'll uh uh distribute it out to another member in the house or the Senate to carry it so as of right now my understanding uh Lambert ler Lambert and Le Johnson will carry in the house and the Senate so that's that's but it originated from the governor okay originated from the governor and say uh senator Johnson's from Williamson County and representative Lamberth from Su County Su County okay there you go so um so talk about okay well we appreciate that thank you for for for pro providing us that that information off um okay so let's uh I'm sorry we
042cut M McGill I'm sorry yes you did so miss Miguel y back to you well um to touch on a couple other things we talked about in class was um a student brought up could would they even be using that money for the private schools in the first place and I just so happened to be looking through this packet and that was one of the problems that happened in Ohio uh oh my sorry uh I'm sorry Arizona um because Arizona reported widespread widespread misuse of voucher funds instead of been using off school related items and activities they were used to purchase items and experiences such as ice skating trampolines Disney plus subscriptions and passes to ski resorts instead of the actual School themselves and like we were talking uh you mentioned a second ago um
043a lot of that funding does even go to people want wanting their kids to go to uh private schools in the first place it goes to people who already in private schools and it says over here Florida's voucher uh Voucher Program uh only 69% of the new recipients were they were already enrolled in private schools and only 13% came from public schools with the remaining 18 just being in uh kindergarteners so it doesn't really give the choice of where to go it just cuts down the cost of the people already going I I think that uh I appreciate you you sharing those facts uh tonight bringing those to everyone's attention because um yes that that's that's relevant anytime you uh uh you anytime you give somebody else the opportunity to uh spend funds they could
044have the opportunity to spend on something that that you're you're that wasn't the intent uh in the way this appears the way it was done in in Arizona that uh that was that was allowed to happen um Other M Douglas yes sir um you know they they talk about it being school choice I do feel like our special needs students um may not get that choice you know going through an application process they could be well just skip right over that student I agree and not because no Services have to be provided you know and then that's that's a tough choice there for that that child you know they they may not get that I mean my grandson's considered special ad prek because he's severe ADHD so he gets in third grade and they could
045go right over because of that um all right so let's uh I appreciate appreciate the comments and discussions let's go around the table and see if there's any any other thoughts from you Mr Smith just one more comment and I'll look to Mr Dr marker to correct me but I believe Hamilton Davidson and Shelby already have some type of voucher system in place is that correct that's correct that happened a few years ago and I think the idea all along was to expand that offering um this is this is part of that process that would make it available to the rest of the state what they're currently doing in those Three Counties if this passes will those counties be bound by the new law yeah it's my understanding it would go to all 95 counties
046that's all I have sir okay thank you Mr Smith Miss mcel um I have another question um would the funding of vouchers it it would reduce a lot of the funding that would go to public schools correct if the as of the system we're under nail the Money Follows the student is that correct yes so initially this is money outside of the Tisa funding the way it's written so uh it wouldn't be money that comes from the current Formula uh and then the way I understand the bill there's also a hold harmless in there that first year to make sure that you wouldn't fall below what you already have but in subsequent years um the example I I'll give most often is if you have 20 students in a class here in White County High
047School if five of those students take the voucher and leave I still need the teacher to teach those remaining 15 students but I lost $35,000 to pay that teacher um and you know in White County the re the reality is is our numbers are are down right now um you know our high school all across our district we're down 200 students from uh from about two years ago 200 students at $775 is $1.4 million that were down so every student that leaves is that much more and at and in theory we would have that many students to teach but as I said earlier under my scenario I still have to have that teacher and that teacher has benefits that keep Rising we have utility costs that keep Rising we have deteriorating buildings that keep the
048costs keep Rising so my expenditures continue to rise but my revenues continue to go down with every student that would accept the vouchers yeah that was another uh thing we talked about class that could be a problem that um with with the kids that do leave in the schools to get less funding that would cause a um a wealth a wealth Gap in a way where a lot of the people who wouldn't have enough money even with the vouchers to go to school would be getting an even worse education because you want to have enough to provide for those those activities I I think that is well said and if I could just pile on to that for for just just a moment um the result of what Mr drar said and and M Migel
049what you you alluded to is that if if fixed cost rise or even remain stagnant and your revenues decline well well then that puts you in a in an economic situation or a business situation that you say okay then I've got to make my expenditures match my revenue and so what that would potentially do would mean not me necessarily A I think you you turned a wealth Gap what it would mean is that where you go into a classroom and you want to see modern technology you want to see people to have access to learning the way we typically learn those resources may not be there because there may not be funds to to put them in and so you know in the end of the day who that that decision comes back to the
050board so you know that would be a decision that the board would ultimately have have uh have have S on and so uh it's so yes it the the the revenue for the students it it does matter as Mr drumber said Thank you m off so much like everyone else has said that my concern is that the choice isn't so much the parent but the choice is the private school the voucher does not guarantee a placement in this private school they can say no based on academic performance based upon special needs based upon whatever it is that their choice is and you may not receive the same Services I work with sever high schools and I know the value of wraparound services that aren't necessarily provided at some of the private schools some of the
051things that our Public Schools can do to treat the student holistically and provide for needs maybe outside of the classroom private schools may or may not do that so the way I look at it is this voucher I think people see it as a guarantee I can go to this other school and they're missing that this scholarship isn't guarantee into that other school so it may be kind of like a somewhat false hope for someone that says hey this is a solution it may not be the solution that present the needs of that individual I understand thank you thank you for sharing those comments Mr McDonald I don't know the dror add anything to to anything that Miss officer M Smith or Miss McGill has has already stated I I just would like to stand
052in opposition to this okay thank you Mr M Douglas I don't have anything else to add but I'm opposed to this yes fa other than I just I think I overlooked this the first time so except for a student enrolled in a home school as defined y y or in a church related school so if it's considered like a I don't know or church related schools considered private schools they so if it's a church related school then they're they don't they're not acceptable either so by what this is saying right here so they so P Christian may not may not they they may not qualify not I don't know that would that's a that's a somebody a whole lot higher pay grade than us but I'm against it so um well I I just this
053comment this will be the last comment then we'll we we'll move on but something I I I read um recently um there's a a British physicist and novelist uh CP snow back in 1959 he U he uh had a lecture at Cambridge University um and it's called the two cultures and with that he U was comparing some two cultures and the one of the cultures was the Scientific Revolution um and you know we're familiar with the Industrial Revolution but back in the uh there was another Revolution took place back in the mid-50s and called the scientific uh Revolution and you know that's ultimately where that's came from out of that came from people learning how to split the atoms put people in space and and things of that nature and uh one of the things
054he pointed out in that made the comparison that back during that time um he looked at two country three countries he looked at uh and because during that time they were involved in U allies in in World War I Russia Great Britain and the United States and during that time he noticed that um that of those three countries um Russia put more emphasis in education for scientists and people in in the field field of science than England or the US so they understood what was taking place education that was needed and were preparing their country for the future and when I read that and I thought about what we're talking about tonight I couldn't help but not say this is that um again I go back and ask what problem were we trying to solve
055um what problem are we trying to solve the future is coming and I'm not sure that giving a voucher just paying money out is where State needs to be spending their efforts um if you want to be spending your efforts let's get behind public schools and allow private schools and other entities to come along as well but Public Schools state is responsible for funding Public Schools let's get behind public schools and let's fund what you know the next century is going to need as far as education to see if we really do go and try to put people on Mars what's that going to take and how do we need to be educate our our our students to prepare for that for the future so with that um I will uh I will uh share
056this with you um for your convenience in your packet there was a resolution um of the White County Board uh of education opposing the uh 2025 educational Freedom Act um it was there for your convenience it's not a recommendation um it's there for your convenience but if we chose to take the next step as we I think around this table discussed that we're uh uh we don't think this is a good thing for the state of Tennessee and we certainly don't think it's a good thing going to going to help public education then the way we can support our legislators the ideal way would be through resolution and so this was a draft that was put together just to help us because we don't do this a lot and so um it's not something we
057could do on the fly in a meeting um so we needed something for you to consider there that information is there for you um there may be other action that the board wants to take but this is a time that if we want to take some action then what we would do is somebody would make a motion and somebody would second that motion we'd have have discussion on that we would take take a vote um so this time I'll open the floor if anybody would like to make a motion on anything Mr chairman I I will uh I will say that the resolution that has been drafted is very well written uh it's very well put together and I think it states everything that we've talked about here tonight so uh I would make a
058motion um that we approve this resolution as it is written okay I have motion Mr McDonald have a second second second Mr Smith all right discussion we may have did this backwards we've already had our discussion I think you know not on the resolution not we have discussion on the resolution because that's what that's the motion I don't know who wrote this resolution but Kudos yeah I agree very well put together Miss mcel probably know it she very well could have um smart lady so uh just for public and those in our in our viewing audience viewing and listening audience um I want uh I won't read the entire resolution but I'll try to read some highlights um it's a resolution of White County school board opposing the 2025 educational Freedom Act whereas SW County
059School Board is dedicated to ensuring that all students within the district received highquality Equitable inclusive education fostering the education excellence and preparing students for success in an Ever evolving World White County school board believes public education is the Cornerstone of a healthy democracy and their Public Schools should be fully supported and prioritized in order to provide necessary resources support and opportunity for every students regardless of socioeconomic background geographic location personal circumstance general assembly is currently considering the 2025 Education Act which includes Provisions that would divert public funds from public schools to private institutions through mechanisms such as private school vouchers and unaccountable charter schools and whereas White County school board is deeply concerned that the implementation of the 2025 education Freedom Act would lead to a destabilization of Public public educ ation particularly in Rural
060and underserved communities by redirecting vital funds from our public schools to private schools that are not subject to the same accountability standards as public schools does this sound very much like what we are discussing apologize I said I wasn't going to read it but I believe I will whereas SW KY scoreboard believes that public funds should be invested in strengthening Public Schools improving teacher convers compensation expanding access to educational resources and ensuring that every Public School in Tennessee has the tools it needs to meet the diverse needs of all students and whereas the White County school board believes that local communities should have a central role in determining how their school funds schools are funded and how education decisions are made ensuring that those decisions reflect the specific needs and values of the community and
061whereas the White County school board recognizes school choice is a complex issue and that we are committed to providing quality education options within the framework of a strong well supported Public Schools but opposes the approach proposed by the 2025 education Freedom Act which prioritizes privatization over public investment in education now therefore be it resolved that th County School Board One opposes the 2025 education Freedom Act as currently proposed due to concerns that it will harm public education in Tennessee divert critical resources from our public schools and create further in ities across to Quality education particularly in Rural and underserved communities two it affirms its commitment to advocating for policies that support and strengthen Tennessee's public education system including adequate funding for schools improve teacher support and measures that ensure all students have the right to
062high quality educational opportunities three it calls upon the Tennessee General s assembly to reconsider Provisions in the 2025 education Freedom Act and instead prioritize legislation that supports Public Schools invest in Educators and works to reduce educational discrepancies across the state four it urges lawmakers to engage with Educators parents students and local school boards in the development of policies that best serve the needs of Tennessee's public education system and ensure that every child in our state has access to an excellent education regardless of their background or geographical location and six pledges to continue to advocate for the Improvement expansion of public education in White County and across Tennessee and to stand firm in support of policies that prioritize public investment in schools students and teachers I I think one thing we've left out right there and
063not to be added to this but our teachers do not get the support from the state that they need as far as they and I know I'm preaching to the choir because the the salaries that they make it's it's it's nothing I mean it they those people are those those folks and I know my wife is an educator and and and it's good and we're thankful and we're blessed for the salary that she that she has but you know what those special ed teachers and those those folks that are that are getting beat up every day um by those students that might not know any better um I think we need to invest in in those types of programs instead of sending our money to a to a private educ or to a private school
064um for people who can already afford to go to that private school I have to agree with that I know I talk a lot about Cameron's prek class you know special ed prek at w Park I admire her there's 20 students in her prek class 20 because didn't we need another prek am I not right and we didn't have the funding right well I was funding and the teer teacher that's what I'm saying yes and I I mean I praise her all the time you know um those kids are always running around you know when I take Cam and when I pick him up and I admire her um I mean not just her but all of them but seeing you know that kids in there and when we go do stuff with them man
065they they take on a lot they take on a lot and they're there I mean they're with their children and their grandchild more than we are as parents sometimes you know when they're young and we're working all the time and it's I admire them kudos to the ones that helped raise my children if you're watching thank you Mr power yes comments and this one was one all three of them so in the uh in the resolution uh now therefore it talks about uh uh use the word quality education let me just tell you about quality education going on in in uh in our in our district because uh uh the uh uh uh mayor and City Alderman uh were informed of this personally uh as well as our County Commission um and they were informed
066of this well personally and I appreciate Mr John barer uh going uh attending that with me and and sharing doing presentation for both of those uh those bodies but uh again just as a reminder uh White County Schools uh recognized by the state as a level five School District um all schools received highl grades on the state report card uh White County High School receiving an a we had five uh we had uh level five schools uh White County High School we had level four schools being Bonnie Croft and Woodland Park and this is all based on uh the state's uh measuring uh metrics for uh for academic growth and results in in uh in academic growth and then we have uh four reward schools that's the highest ranking Cate category um and that was
067casel D fin and Northfield so uh our districts ranking rank uh in in uh in top rankings in the in the state out of uh in 16 districts in Upper Cumberland um in uh in third grade fourth and fifth grade uh English Math and Science and in sixth grade and seventh grade is sciences and social studies and so uh I think the results the facts are on our side that white county is providing quality education so we didn't have had any problem putting that in our resolution so uh with that with that said but sorry to digress on that in our discussion but uh we have a motion a second on adopting this uh resolution uh on as uh our position on the 2025 educational Freedom Act any other discussion okay hearing none all those
068in favor signify by say I I opposed motion passes and the resolution uh we will need to be signed by all all board members so thank you for uh for your time and your your discussion deliberation in this um next item our agenda is uh public comment we do we have anybody on public comment we did not have anybody nobody sign up for public comment we do have some visitors in the audience tonight um if there I'm going to assume you came as a group and if so is there uh anybody designated that would like to speak to the board we will allow you five minutes if you would like to speak on any particular subject yes sir I'll speak okay would you mind uh just stand up right there and you'll be fine where
069where you're at um I know this wasn't really a topic for y's meeting tonight but um wait wait can you introduce yourself please yes yes I'm Gracie Clark I play for the high school basketball team for White County um I just wanted to speak today about ke's eligibility um I know it's not we all know that's not agenda but um I feel like as her teammate I've be doing her a disservice uh to not talk about it you know um and I'm speaking for behalf of the team I think we all can do we will do whatever we can to get her eligible now whatever it takes if there's anything we can do and or an explanation as to why she's not eligible now if there's anything we can do I mean we'll do it
070thank you for uh thank you for for sharing that and appreciate your uh uh your concern for your your teammate and and friend um that's that is a subject that's not on our agenda so we wouldn't go in and have deliberation on that or or take that matter up but uh if you uh if you would like to speak to us after the meeting uh we would would entertain and share what we know what we can okay thank you all right thank you Miss CL all right um next item on the agenda is more Sherman's comments um so uh have a reminder that our next board meeting will be February 13th at Finley elementary uh we'll have our work session at 5:00 and our regular board meeting at 6 also as a reminder board members
071please your statement of Interest disclosure is due by January 31st please make Prov make uh sure that you get that filed U because we would not want anybody to incur a u a uh uh a penalty for not doing that can we send out a group text tonight after yes ma'am we'll we'll send out a group text and email for the next uh next seven days okay if that would if that would help remind some of us okay all right with uh with that being said um next item is is adjournment I'll take a motion for motion and second all in favor I all right