CorpusRecord 101839

School Board Special Meeting - December 14, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / Highline Public Schools
Date
2024-12-19
Location
King County, WA
Material
Transcript
Extent
32,833 words · about 183 min
Collected
2026-06-13

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Well, good morning everybody Do we need to have a quorum for? work session or It's it's just a retreat. Wow. This is very sensitive It's um, if you could text it to find out And let's give it two more minutes. So at 833 and get started at the seminary We don't have the votes. I don't but but it so in good faith And it's so I had said, you know what? Let's just start at 835. All right, so Thank you for everyone being here and this Not so nice weather Saturday morning and to get started with our Special board meeting retreat this morning. So do we call for roll call as well? So roll call please Ariana Director Vann here director Petrini Air president Alvarez here and I am not sure I have not heard

002or have not checked to see have you heard from director hoggles and director Tid home? So hopefully they'll make it in and they are okay And again just as we move in I'm excited to look at what's happening and they hear at the glance and all these things So we're looking forward to but more than anything. I think I just feel a Honored and privileged to be able to work with each one of you all it's been an incredible year of moving through some Uncharted territory the data and all this other stuff that we have Were interrupted doing the thing but the most amazing thinking we all kept going forward because what mattered most was centering our kids And that's what we did So I just want to say thank you to all of you

003and for being here on a Saturday and with that We'll get going. So who do I pass it on to? All right, so Erin you're on Good morning. I hope I hope that works So we are looking at this topic here at a glance should look a little bit familiar and formatting Before I call anything out, I just want to name 2425 does look different just because of the cyber and works around the lesson timber than would so there are two notes very into the stock one knowledge this year and also to that things also change as progressive Data doesn't get released These or if working on a contract waiting for them to Name on this report Those annual report Typical agenda item recognition and other patients as well as partner record For all and

004I just wanted to flag as was mentioned at the last board meeting temple the recognition other Be starting in January. There's a budget at every every That's where you'll see that There are two rows that show work sessions one for this plan work session one for the other types of You'll see labor updates on here as well as have faster Wednesday that Dr. Bannon Alvarez asked that we spend the majority of this time on the actual last column Which is the policy column so you have an accompanying document with that that But before we jump into that policy column, I just wanted to pause Ask if there are any questions about here at a glance outside of the policy column Just check in if there's anything we can answer Nothing for me. Okay So Let's

005go ahead and check out this document the policy doc And I'm gonna start and then I'm gonna go over my colleague nodding so Doing either one On here, you'll see it organized into sort of a lightly shaded grouping as well and then non-shaded The ones that are Shaded those were the five policies identified by director Hago says governance works Action and then underneath are the other policies those are organized by I'm Okay, so it was asked at a planning meeting just kind of go over these at a high level not talk in depth about policy So what you'll see here is you'll see the policy number of the policy name When we think we're gonna be bringing it forward towards to the board and as I said, this is all tentative Anything could happen Something

006happening where we need to elevate a policy that we didn't think we were gonna do Slow down the work Something's changed research conversation about it and then The type of potential those is something to do something that's revised and then you'll see at the very bottom of this We know that we're gonna need to do some work on AI policy slash cyber policies Don't know exactly what that's gonna look like yet. We've got an AI work session I think that that may be part of that conversation And we're just so that's kind of there as a placeholder don't know exactly what the timelines will be or frankly exactly which policies might want to bring forward we have some policies related to the topic that are Older and really need to be looked at you don't

007have really anything on AI So that would be something or might it be? Included in an existing policy. Maybe might it be something maybe and then obviously session starts January 13th and so there are times the legislature passed laws requiring us to have a policy so If there's anything that comes out that's necessary for fall of 25 would be looking at that in the spring that's completely unknown as talked about the other day, but Who knows what they're gonna do? It's a surprise So with that I thought we would just go over these at a high level and then folks Different folks have different ones of these so parent and I don't know if folks are ready to talk about the specific So let's go down start So do you want to mention anything? Yes,

008yeah, it is really sensitive. No ready for hello ready for karaoke, um No, the last time the parent and family engagement policy was updated was about ten years eight to ten years ago, it was Revised at that time to align to the strategic plan at that time and so we have interest in Working with our superintendent family action committee to revise it so that is aligned to our current strategic plan It's a an idea. We will be introducing to our FAC and wanting to make sure they will engage with us on that. So We will bring the topic to them and we'll have some time to work, but we'll likely want to align it to The family engagement update to the board in the spring may mesh In fact was integral and crafting the helping

009craft vision Really cool for the families to see their words and their interests be codified 2020 you're seeing it's introduced. It's in it. It will be introduced on Wednesday. That's about selection adoption of materials The revisions there are mostly just there's some there's a bunch of language in there that's not Not at does not act like our work that doesn't actually accurately like types of materials So they just wanted to clean up the language that it's back happening The next one 3205 that's a massive overhaul to reflect title nine Regulations and we are planning on bringing it forward to you in january for a vote Introduction and vote vote in the second meeting in january. That's our plan I'll be interested to hear your thoughts on that once we get that introduced specifically a massive

010change Sex discrimination sex harassment pregnant parenting students is a new policy and designed sure that we claim to Make sure that we claim to uh pregnant and parenting students what their rights are laws and so it's really a Policy designed to support our students Yeah, oh, yes So did we have anything in place previously? Um, I remember a while while back on I don't know if it was a policy We've not had a policy but we do have a pretty robust teen parent program. I don't know if Remembered us really being supportive things in place Yeah, we have um in the past have had like a pretty significant like years years past like a grads program That we don't have that because of the complications around providing child care for infants and babies But we

011do have a teen parent social worker She's on our social work team and so she does the case management connecting our teen parents to resources and If their neighborhood school isn't you know, the the best fit for them at the time She will help work with corvalli or a connection center counselor and finding alternative programming for them while they're on maternity leave paternity leave And then helping with the transition back to neighborhood school if that's how it plays out But it's um, uh, she plays a case management role Yeah, and i've actually been working closely with her to develop to go through and work on this policy and make it Make it right for highline Um, I anticipate that she'll be at the work set or at the board meeting So you'll get a chance

012to meet her. She is amazing and a delight to work that Cares so much for our students. And when I asked her when we first brought this forward, I said Jennifer You really see a need for this policy said yes, this is going to give me I can hand to a student And have it explain their their rights to them She's she's ecstatic to get a tool that will really help her But no Yeah uh Conduct that one is a question mark. The state has come out with some new rules that right now There are emergency rules. They're going to be codifying them for fall 2025 But I don't know when that's going to happen Uh, and it's unclear yet if we're going to need to change our policy Or if all of the changes

013will live in the procedure I do have a team of folks that are And this is one of the topics that we will be Tackling. So if it needs to Spring Anaphylaxis prevention, that's an update based on changes to state law last year allowing epi pens on campus without prescription interview apocalyptic You know anaphylactic reaction I'm so proud that I can spell the word anaphylaxis now. I'm serious. That's a hard word um So that's it. That's a technical edit. Uh, the new new policy on, uh family medical leaves. It's interesting We have leaves contracts Federal and state law, but again, I kind of would like with pregnant parenting students We have no policy where a staff member could look at and say what types of leaves might I be entitled? If I get sick a

014family member gets sick if I need That um, so this new policy again tell staff members what um, what types of Separate and distinct from those that may live in a contract Those are different those are bargained. Um, I think uh, we're going to talk come back around to six hundred six thousand So, okay, perfect Um nutrition kisa, I think that's also kind of a technical change. It's been a number of years since that policy was looked at And the usda has changed the So lisa johnson's really looking at that to make sure again that our policy reflects actual practice requirements Naming of facilities. That's one of mine um, it's It's a confusing confusingly. Is that a word it has written it's been written in a confusing fashion And there's things in procedure that really

015should be policy. So I really want to just clean that up As we start getting having buildings opening Having parts of buildings named Sports Um philly's master plan also kind of a technical update There's an outdated language and ospi has changed the timeline of when master plan is due So current policy I think says december and it's really So that's again technical change and then we already talked to the last two And then as as uh, erin mentioned at the top those top five policies that are there that are in gray Are policies that director hagos has identified that might be a good governance policies to talk about And so rather than talk about those here There's a conversation to add as you all may be exploring Um as the governance team may be exploring

016governance models There will be policies Looked at as part of that and depending on if you change a governance model it might change what policies include so My thinking that you wouldn't spend a lot of time on those right now, but rather we would start flagging Policies that would relate to governance Um, so that if and when you were to change the governance model or to double down on the one you have We would know like, okay, here's some things that we know we need to look at from the top That's kind of what happened And then obviously 2004 we're actually going to talk about Happy to answer any questions on that or turn it over talk about six out Thousand joe Yeah, well before we get to six thousand I do want to talk

017about real quick high level of the anaphylaxis at least I can say it That response, um, how are we? mirroring that with the narcan usage because it wouldn't it fall under the same thing in regards to something that we are That could be possibly be used to our kids When there is an effect, right? So Is the language going to be the same? I think uh, so it's a It is a very similar concept. We have a standing order for narcan allowing that now from the state of standing order epipens Allowing us to have epipens on campus in our facilities without them being tied to a specific script Yeah, and so it'll it'll enable that so so I think joe yes It the the concept the the mechanism that the state is to get epipens

018for everyone is the same But it lives in a different policy full anaphylaxis anaphylaxis response Policy that will stop that change all of our anaphylaxis So say that word again anaphylaxis Everyone go around and say it. Yeah, everyone just go around and say it and spell it Um Thank you so much for that and in regards to um policy 6000 I Thank you. Jackie for bringing that up this last wednesday. Um, I know there was some Verbiage changes that I know one one director had brought up any other directors Have any other changes that we wanted to talk about with that? All right. Here we go Um, yeah, so i'm not sure um, which director has made the I can't remember which director has made Is it yours? Okay. So the two that I was

019talking about in the policy 6000 Training around using equity lens budgeting. Um, what does that look like? Can we explicitly state what that looks like? Um that will likely be here for updates around um, or overall what uh framework or um, uh, I guess Protocol are we using we're looking at equity lens Um for our budget purposes that was one that I had mentioned at that work session and the other one is priorities Or what does it look like when we're determining board priorities? Although the there are some goals around um, what we should be doing with um, Policy 6000 there isn't any board priorities included in there. So that's another one That I was thinking of and then um Just looking at uh, how do we assess if this is working? How do we

020assess what budget uh using a budget lens or no, sorry using an equity lens for a budget How do we assess how it's working? Um for our district and is uh, and our Are our resources aligned to the needs of our long and short term educational goals for our district? Those are the things that I brought up and I don't think it was captured Um at that work session is things that I brought up in relation to 6000 so just highlighting those again off of memory There may be more but that's where that's where i'm at now Thank you for that. So would it Would you recommend that being part of policy or or could it be part of procedure where we can write it into our procedure? to kind of What would you recommend

021policy policy? Um, so a few things I think with the priorities the board priorities i'm i'm Thinking those may change year to year and i'm not sure we'd want to update the policy each year It could perhaps be a separate document. I will look to my policy procedure friends um For guidance on that, um, but I know it it probably i'm assuming year to year Um, depending on on the priorities of the district for that given Um Do we do? Um annual assessment like do we ever have policies that come up annually that we're supposed to review is that like a practice? Would this be one that we could say annually after we've set priorities for the year or our focus is We should relook at the short thoughts reflected. Is it still relevant? We

022have a few um that are like that and then we also have ones that almost come up organically annually because They're in and budgeting is an annual process so it wouldn't be unheard of to add One thing I will say if we decide to go that direction that's something that would have to occur really really early in the year um right now we're December we're coming back from winter break and we are in budgeting season It it's a year-long process, but january is really the year where we are Starting to do the work On a daily basis as a team so any sort of guidance or Revisions of policy would have to happen early in the fall I think the other part to go with that is Kind of I think about is that goals

023are the kind of like our in many ways our goals that we're trying to achieve over A period of time And I think director patrina your point around having annual would be going back to the priorities The priorities could be ones that in order for us to reach those goals this year. We want this to be our priority So I can see that being done on like an annual basis, but I think jackie's point's really important We'd have to get to that Really early, you know, and I think we'd have to determine Timeline because I would want to see priorities based off of you know the results from the previous year You know as we're kind of in that time frame now where we'd have to probably have them set You know by the end

024of the calendar year december time frame so that we can then use that for the budget cycle Moving forward starting in january of each fiscal year I like that idea of something that's responsive to what we're seeing and that it's something and so I think we had just a Just one piece around um, and I I agree I think there's there's benefit into that recurring cycle of reflection and then planning based on the data and the information that we have Um jackie i'm thinking about your point about how early the process starts and just want to name Um the importance of us being really clear that any planning that would happen like in september Would be for the following academic year like a whole year out and I just think it's really important that we're

025we're clear about that Because as we are kind of doing our backwards mapping from a budgeting perspective That has direct connection with school annual action plan development and the strategies that they are implementing and it's Just the the nature of the cycle of our academic years, it's hard to shift all of that midterm So I just we'll have to be really well, we'll need some communications help I think we move down this pathway just to make sure that all stakeholders are clear that the conversations that we might be having About priorities early in the fall are really To take hold the following academic So just wanted to add explicitly That's a great point and I think the other connection i'll make that you know if the board moves forward to have you know The equity

026lens training using that you know one of the key parts of the equity lens is really considering how a decision is going to impact the potential of the stakeholders and so Um, I think we really have to make sure that that timing part is going to be going to be pretty Quickly that september through december time frame. I think i'll just add that just uh To think about also is that it's going to have to be really well Having all Parts to make sure that that there's grace you know if we're We're also going to be Stakeholders other stuff. They're not always available We're not always available. So just keeping in mind that this is a lot of parts And so that there's things that we're still going to continue to move forward without having

027we can't wait There's no waiting Clear as well Yeah, and I also think the board because I know at the work session last week it also came up around potentially adding another community piece for board input and I would go back and say that I would really encourage us to use the systems that we already have in place because we already have established time frames and timelines for working both with our Superintendent student leadership team the superintendent advisory leadership team our family action committee and our cfac committee which oversees those works So if we move forward with something like that, we could actually use those groups to get this put in place because we already have those regularly scheduled and Help us in our planning So I have brought up the um community parts who

028because it's to me it still feels so disjointed and siloed We've got a group here and there and a group here and it's one directional Presentation and then maybe some questions or maybe a thought exchange and then it comes to us But I don't feel like it's a comprehensive capture of a two-way conversation that comes up in What is expected of us as board directors to as far as was the standard state? To make sure that when we're doing these when we're having these budget conversations and we're having the stakeholder That there is that two-way directional Conversation and feedback and dialogue with all stakeholders involved specifically for budget when we're talking about a 400 close to a 400 million dollar budget Well, actually the last time we had our work session was 405. I think

029million dollars so a little bit more than what we what I what we had saw last year, but Anyways, we're talking about that large of a budget. I think it's it's it's important to have A community advisory committee that there's two-way conversations where we're engaged as board directors, which is what we're called to do So I think that part is missing and I would love to see that incorporated in what we do Yeah, and actually before you took the mic I was just going to add that you know, a lot of times we talk about just that all these silos and then we create Another silo. So why don't we really look at what is already there and look about how can we Make that Whatever is that we're looking for because if not, we'll

030create another Committee and it's just another committee And now we're competing with community members that's sitting on other committees and so I think you know with the family action committee or the cfac really looking at you know, what are we bringing to them? um as For feedback and so are we bringing this to them for feedback and maybe we're not and that's why we're not dialoguing like we want to and you know I don't know just the thought is just that i've been around for a little bit in other spaces and When people are not feeling that they have what they want they create something else and then it becomes another table And then a new member comes in they don't get what they want and they become and then we stop looking I just

031did an assessment of a couple of Tables that i'm at and it was that it's like well so-and-so came in and they didn't feel this so They added one and then so-and-so and it's like but they're all the same thing just in different spaces. So we're So i'm just thinking something to think about There would be and i'd just like to add just as uh, working with Jackie and dr Duran and erin around some of these engagement opportunities. Um, they're not uh, one-way presentations I mean the thought exchange in nature is like gathering a survey type feedback, but We really spend time in small groups and engaging with the student in conversation students or the families in conversation around our budget one first and foremost helping them understand And then engaging in a conversation and

032how we use our funds and I also um, it's an interesting point you make about the the total like the accumulation of the budget and really when you were talking about Stakeholders and feedback. I was thinking about the budget authorities within even my own division and then you can multiply that but everybody else's department and division and And the budget is broken down into multiple parts Where there's budget authorities who have their various ways of engaging with stakeholders around how they make their Budgetary decisions and so I don't want to lose sight that our budget authorities are also stakeholders That includes our principals and schools There are some requirements in alignment to their annual action plan Their requirements particularly those schools who qualify for title one that they have to engage families in the use

033and allocation of those funds and so Might want to consider differentiating really clear like what the board's role versus some of the the budget authorities role and think about our title six native education role that's required to Run by the native family advisory committee. So I think it just want to caution us and in assumptions about what kind of engagement is happening because oftentimes the budget's broken down in multiple budgets and there's Lots of levels of engagement within those specific budget and authorities budget authorities Rambling, sorry And I would also add to kisa's comment that we have been engaging with these groups for years now So there is a knowledge base within these groups that is already there. We have spent You know a few years now training and having these groups become familiar with

034the budget and all of the The different requirements and compliance pieces within this the budget because for a 400 million dollar budget you can imagine how complex it is and difficult and There are so many pieces that are state law or they are compliance pieces that really, I mean we love feedback, but There's not there's a portion of the budget that we don't have a lot of flexibility on And so it's really engaging with the the stakeholders of those Areas of the budget that there is some flexibility And we have done a lot of training on with those stakeholders in the past I can't believe hr person's wanting to talk about fiscal Yeah, I do think there's sometimes you know just distinctions between you know policies that are geared more toward purpose of the organization

035and policies are geared more toward processes of how the organization goes about Um delivering on school I think the governance policies had already been flagged in The gray really get to you know, what are the aims? What are the purposes that we would be directing our resources to? And I think it's good for those policies to carry that weight the This policy carries some important weight I just don't know that it's in those areas and if I could just offer a historic example Of how and why this policy is important and high line I'll start with the you know, the the last number seven talks about internal control And again, my eyes might just start glazing over really we're talking about internal controls going to get more boring Uh, no, it can't get more boring,

036but it also can't get more important You know when you go to a one any of our athletic competitions one person Uh sells the ticket Another person and the ideal takes the ticket that is the most basic form of an internal control In the absence of that the person who sells the ticket could also cancel the ticket It creates the conditions for fiscal mismanagement, which this policy is fundamentally about Preventing and going way back in the history books. Some may wonder Why is it that payroll which is located right in the middle of the hr department? Reports to jackie and not to hr and Again, it's our most fundamental most important Internal control within the district and it wasn't always the case there was a time when the department that Issued the requisitions created the

037hires Also paid the employees and this even predates me, but there was a major issue in high line Uh when some malfeasance occurred because that internal control was not in place So I just offer that to say that This is an important. It's a financial management policy. It's a process policy It talks about things like internal controls efficiency of procedures payment of our vendors of our contractors things like that Um, that's uh, that's I just don't want that process piece to get Overlooked it's not as important perhaps as the goals of the organization But there are other policies that carry that way to that more important more targeted way than the financial management policy 6000 that's pretty good for me. That's awesome. Thank you Thanks steve. Yeah, I think that's a great point I think

038the other part i'll just add is that I think as I I think one of the things that really struck me I was at the wasda conference was Depending on the session that you went to it You have to think about the context of that school district and what's going on Like I attended the peninsula district and they were talking around some of their Changes with the budget in this the context behind that is when the new cfo new superintendent went in when The first thing they found out was that there was like an 11 million dollar deficit And so it's just that context change and so everything after that in their presentation was like here's how we dealt with it These are the controls we set up. These are the check-ins that we set

039up for the community These are the ways that we engage the community Um, so I think it's an important piece for us to consider and I think particularly here in highline Um thinking about you know, we're a good place with our budget grateful for that You know, we've had some great fiscal responsibility here. We did a great job last year on the reductions And so as we think about going back to those priority conversations How do we set those priorities for us to be thinking about what can we do to really invest in what we're already doing? So we just get better with what we're trying to do So the context piece is so important because I think the most difficult thing sometimes is when you Formulate some type of committee or group and you

040try to seek feedback, but then that feedback is not utilized That's one of the big challenges that we face and we don't want to be in those type of situations You know Thank you so much on that. Dr. Duran one of my Recommendation would be you know where you guys are part of all of these groups and jackie You're going to be presenting to us on a monthly basis. Maybe we bring those voices To those the conversation in front of the board or you can speak on that their behalf that that would Allow us some time to have that One v one or the the board versus a conversation Are there any more comments or questions either on policy 6000 or on the euro to glam? Or the policy list. Sorry I don't know If

041so, this is just kind of what came to my mind as I was rereading this again um when we talk about uh Considering equity and student center mindset to eliminate a sickness anybody to reduce systemic measurable inequities achievement What would that mean for what are we taking? I hate to even say what are we taking away from to redistribute resources? and the second question would be like are we able to get like a breakdown of like You know, uh the numbers out there like on ospi that most people know is like how much we're spending for students on our budget, right? 1000 for students, but as we actually have students different needs Do we have a breakdown of like here's how many students and this is really we spend about 10 000 on these students

042and these students it's really more like 30 000 because of their needs and uh different abilities like do we have like a breakdown of Where we're spending those money like how it's different groups so that To see are there inequities or are we already doing a good job in that aspect? Do we have that breakdown? So i'll answer your first your first question around uh Using the equity lens and and what we perhaps are taking away to add in other places Um when we talk about using an equity lens in budgeting, we're really focused on our supplemental budgets so our categorical funds and those funds are distributed based on um kind of a student weighted formula from the state and then we use those those same um allocation methods for our students, um, so Really

043when we talk about the budget there's different layers to it and the first layer is basic education um, so for every student allocated at It's formula based from the state And then we add on different layers of the budget going up from there So we talk about you know, we have our our baseline budget, which is those fundamental Allocations we receive from the state and then we have our categorical funds that are for very specific needs for for students um The second question is are we measuring that I will say when you look on ospi's report card Um, they are uh, I understand they are overwhelmed with lots of information, but they don't break it down so they're just taking our total budget and dividing it by number of students, which is Um kind of

044a false narrative in a way because the way different districts allocate different funds and they may have different central office support So it's it's kind of a misleading number, right? That's what I was saying. I think to better understand Okay, a child's basic education really only costs us if like let's say everyone's doing great We didn't have all these extra supports. We really our budget This per student because we're so efficient and all that but since we have all these added layers Do we have then a breakdown? What is a basic education for students? What is it? servicing Extra things depending on where and we do have a breakdown not necessarily per student but per Categorical funds and then the number of students that are served within those those different areas of the budget that

045report I'd love to kind of see yeah, so that's will be presented in the budget usually on a yearly basis We're presenting those numbers. Um, so I can I mid year We don't usually we'll adjust in january based on our updated enrollment numbers. So i'm happy to share those Um, but that that kind of deep analytical work that we're doing is as we do budget development for the following I just think that that kind of information would be really great to know before we're like revising policies just to see How are we doing? Are we reaching already? Is there other areas that we consider as well or where we revise our our policy And I can i'm happy to share kind of overviews at um the monthly board meetings And you know, I really that's

046going to be a time not only to report back What's where our current state is but where we're going forward with budget development? Um and share some of that context and just as an example of how those numbers get used We're able to so when we talk about how we're not fully funded in special education We're able to look at what we receive from the state what we expend on students and see that there's a gap So that those numbers get used um kind of in a broader context outside of just our budgeting so that other Because it tells part of the story of our budgeting and why we're asking for certain things with the legislature any other questions on the Uh, the question was do you have any questions? Oh, the question is just

047review it and see if you have any questions Yeah, okay, and this is for 2024 2025 school year, right recognizing that you know what we started out with Really changed with the cyber incident because we had to reschedule some stuff and then obviously recognizing that it is tentative So things do change throughout the year the state could come out tomorrow and say hey We're doing this grant on a different timeline. And so you're going to see it in june instead of in december You have no control over that Um, okay, so I was thinking um of a couple of things and you know, not necessarily even for the time Just something to think about as we're developing our annual calendar um looking at or knowing that board directors would um like some say an agenda,

048um in Creating these agendas for our work sessions and for our um, uh retreat time I would love to see discussion healthy discussion amongst board directors on what we would like to see for the upcoming year Before a calendar is developed to determine what we're doing with our time together as a board team um, so that's one area where I think we could have some um, uh What's that called some improvement on is as we're talking about what our year is going to look like as a board team and our work together Um as we're you know There are thoughts that we have and we'd love to see some inclusion on these agenda topics that come up Amongst conversations with the board team. So when we're looking at work sessions and we're looking at um

049Uh retreats having some of that healthy discussion as a board team at a work retreat to say, okay here What are some agenda items that we have and what do we want to see for the coming year? That's one Uh, and then the other thought is I did do that I went to visit white center heights and I went to go visit mount rainier As a school tour and I know that you all do school tours as well I would love to see some sort of combined effort of board and leadership team going out to do these tours and um matching it to either our theme of the year or you know our strategic plan of some sort And seeing that calendared out, you know if it's planned and planned in advance I believe the

050majority of the board should be able to make those events as a as a combined Unified and a unified front. So that's another idea that I had as I was looking at the calendar And then the other two is just uh, you know reviewing some of those What do we call them recognition months or recognition themes? And seeing if there's any other included other recognitions that we would like to include as a board team. I know that September is Attendance awareness fund it would be nice to have a some sort of statement around recognition for attendance. What are they called resolutions proclamations? That's what I was trying to get to so if there are any proclamations or if there's any other recognitions that board directors are interested in seeing Uh now they may not all

051be included but at least some healthy discussion to say What is it that we would like to see that matches our community our our school communities our neighborhoods and things that would Help to highlight some of the good that's happening in our area. So that's the third thought that I have I want to say there were two more But I I forget what they are at the top of the moment So, um, I may just email them out, but those are the three that uh kind of you know Shut at me as I was reviewing this as we were chatting This morning so i'll just say thank you for that director hoggles, but all this calendar is really um was Made because of this all you also This brings in there's things added here that

052must be added because of policies that are coming up or because of um not just policies but um things that we're needing to Um And for us to get info But this was all created based on all uh your suggestions and I love it when you added that You know not everything is added but at least we kind of have a healthy discussion We have these discussions in these meetings and I think a lot of times the the struggle is that If because something didn't get on that you suggest it or that someone suggested that there's a challenge and an issue like You didn't added what I said There's not enough room in the year to add every single suggestion from every single Uh board member, but all of these gets created based on what

053we've mentioned again a lot of things happen this year that put us behind and having the opportunity to really address some of these things because of our data at the beginning, but I will say that um I between joe and I and then um Trying to figure out like okay We have all these many things to add There's always a parking lot's a lot bigger than the time that we have because we could be here till 10 o'clock at night It's still not covered every single thing that everybody wants to go and so we're trying also I mean giving up a saturday all of us signed up for it. I know that our uh, Our cabinet and our superintendent. I know that they're here Uh, but also I mean we could again we could be

054here till midnight None of this I'm not not everything is going to be covered but I can say that truly your voice has been A lot of these have happened because of some of your mesh just to add that we're trying our best nothing on here is Intentional to leave out something. We're not trying to figure out really plug things in a calendar. Yeah Fortunately there's not enough days Thank you for that president alvarez And I just want to echo what what she stated is that a lot of these are sitting in that parking lot And I know that Angelica and I are working with erin because she shows us that parking lot. She goes, okay This is what we got. This is what we got What is our next step and maybe that's something

055that we need to share with you with the board as a whole From the parking lot and go. Okay, so our next retreat is going to be in february Based off of what's happening? um in in in our district These are the things that we're we're gonna we would like to work on and just so you guys can see that and and Let's just start checking those bad boys off one at a time. So maybe that's something that we can work on I I like that a lot. I think um Just sharing because I know that a lot of times it's like we have the parking lot another thing gets added Another thing gets added another thing gets added and we're trying to pick and choose based on what's going to happen and based on

056The need but I think bringing that to the whole board and say, okay, here's the parking lot um What these are some things that we must address and what one or two or three other things that we have time for to add and then they if I believe that is it in regards to our 24 25 year at a glance directors if there are any other concerns, please Emails, let us know. Um, and then we'll move forward with that Appreciate that. Thanks for the presentation All right. Now we're going to talk about our um, washington state improvement framework goals and and policy I know that we had that the work session on november 4th sometime back then Last year, um that we wanted to come back and and speak to so Just you're going to

057take this one to holly I mean unless you wanted joe uh, so 2004 uh, i'm not going to recap the work session because We were all there and It was a month ago So, you know So there you go So current 2004 as you'll all remember is based on no child left behind that whole schema was changed when Every student succeeds act was passed and then washington state created their Continuous school improvement framework. I do have copies. Thank you. Erin and Adriana Of the powerpoint that we used in that work session. So folks want those I can certainly hand those out um and so Our policy is out of date. It includes some stuff that's still valid, but most of it is not um so We had talked about We could I proposed potentially repealing

058the policy Remember that we I looked at the 35 districts in the csesd And about two-thirds of them had the policy none of those policies included goals and I think all but two of those policies uh Were as out of date as ours are um So one option is to repeal because you do not need that policy to adopt wcf goals If you did that, I would suggest that we would repeal policy and adopt wcf goals Uh at the same time I also or you know related time You also have in your folder I had proposed if you want to Still have a policy We could tie the policy to state law and statute and Reiterate what the what the rules say that you should be adopting Some of you know, I don't I don't

059love policies that Tie directly back to wax and rcw's because when those change And we don't change our policy we end up in exactly the same situation that we're in now um, and as I mentioned at the retreat last month, um the essa ever student succeeds act was supposed to be updated in the 2021 school year That did not happen. So it is again something that is on the books potentially for the new administration if they so choose to Um get involved with updating that law. So who knows what it could look like again moving forward um I do want to say And tova and dr. Duran you're going to correct me if i'm wrong. I sat too far away for you to kick me under the table um We have uh, we are in

060the process of developing and updating our annual report for 24 for this year And that is going to include the wcf metrics So joe you had mentioned that Uh in the in the work session Can we make sure that the metrics are added are included along with our strap plan metrics? Yes, those will already be there That is of course separate and distinct from you all adopting goals against those metrics But we did want to make sure that those metrics are included in that So that the public or the community can see all of the ways in which we're measured both strategic plan and wcf goals So I just wanted to name that that's happening direct result of board comment Separate and distinct from policy So with that I think the goal of this hour

061is to really talk have the board talk about his policy and and Do you want it? Do you not want it? I had an opportunity dr. Duran. I had an opportunity to sit down with director hagos um Was that this week? It may have been this week Tuesday not even very long ago. Okay um to talk There's a long time. Okay. Thank you. I don't feel too bad then Um had an opportunity to sit down because director hagos had uh had had mentioned a number of uh changes and edits that she would like to see and I think um, Director hagos, uh also too far away for you to kick me But I think we had a good conversation about governance policies and what it might look like to delay potential governance policy work until

062after you all as I mentioned before after you all have the chance to Have a discussion about what governance model you really want to be looking at. Um I don't think you would want I would not recommend as your policy person that you Craft a policy based on a particular governance model before you've actually decided that that's a governance model you want to work under Because you could end up in a situation where that policy is immediately out of date so I think the other part i'll add to it is that um, I think that last one is just really critical because governance Model and structure could definitely change And you know if the board really decided to shift to a completely new one you could also just choose to Further define the current one

063that you have which is really it was in a conversation with chris recto and the other superintendents across the state for Monthly update and one of the things that chris was talking about is You know, they are going to be really working to think about how they change the accountability system And so I think as we consider any policy change especially related towards gold We need to be thinking about Five ten years out and where we want to go and really thinking about how do we want to have a system of accountability? That really reflects the needs of our students and the growth of our students And I would really want to make sure that we are considering Aspects even mastery based learning because that's a really big thing I think it will be coming

064in the forefront here really quickly Sooner than we thought and we've already had a good start to that But I also just have to really emphasize that growth is such an important tool for us to be considering Because that is the tool and measure that allows us to be able to adjust along the way Rather than waiting for the you know yearly autopsy that we receive, you know from the state on an annual basis Thank you. Dr. Grant, you know holly. Thanks for bringing up the the governance model and I should have prefaced Before we went into to our board policy it is going to be based off of what kind of model we want to go down and I haven't shared this with the directors at all yet, but I would with president alvarez

065I have but You know my goal for 25 Calendar year is to have a couple of directors look at The five or six models that are out there and and and task Them to look at those models and do the research and bring that back to the board and go what is going to work best for us Our governance team is There's six people the five board directors as well as the superintendent So we need to work on it as a team But I am going to ask two directors to work on that on behalf of the board bring it back What did you learn? What's your recommendations and go down that pathway? So I just wanted to throw that out there. So we're all here together It is a team of six, but as

066you know, there's Us as a team here that has a greater input So I just want to throw that out there before we start making changes For us to change it back again to whatever model we go down If you want to volunteer No, I think we still need to go down with our With what we have here and just continue on with what we have because I'm i'm hoping that We can come up with an agreement by the end of the school year and then we can work on it for the 25 26 So would that mean in your mind? Putting a pause on 2004 keeping the current one which is out of date, but it's been out of date for a thousand years So it's another six months Um putting a pause on

067that so that the governance work could happen Maybe i'm gonna ask i'm gonna ask the board. What what are your thoughts on that? um my recommendation in regards to having two board directors and then putting a pause on this or What what is what are your thoughts? So you're saying two board members would work on this instead of all five of us Formulating that um, this is kind of a really important one. I think having all operating and Speaks to all all these different things Can I can I can see I think what I was could look at this at is um Really very similar to when the school board did the street data work Um on a regular basis actually having the board taking through reading different Governance models and having those conversations So

068I think the charge would be potentially having two board members working with You know, um me and the team To do the research and then bring that forward to the board to have the conversations to really dive into it So it'd be almost like work study sessions that we'd have to have with the board collective But we would need a couple board members to actually organize and plan what that looks like and to plan the agendas and how we're going to unpack the policies that were or not the policies but the Governance models that we're considering That is correct Those two board directors would be making the phone the final decision It'd be us as collective but it is very similar to what dr. Duran said. Um, it's just getting the two and cabinet To

069help us figure it out doing the background work Correct But I think it wouldn't be just bringing it to the board for final decision My understanding is is anything like the same model that dr. Duran was saying so when we had street data and we're looking Uh, like let's say we went through chapter one board director brought it Said this is you know, like the summary and then we had our homework Like make sure that you know, you're reading this this and that and then so that we could all bring feedback So it's basically someone just facilitating these conversations. It's not about here's one of feedback and this is what you're going to do is like Basically facilitating that that work session, but we all can we're all doing our homework It's not like we're

070sitting back and we're not doing anything. It's just somebody's Uh tasked with making sure that they're moving the work forward So we're not all just stuck in one policy or in one governance and we're there and we're there. It's like, okay We've had time move on and then collectively in every meeting Everybody's feedback was taken into consideration. So it wasn't just one or two board members. So it's a combination of all It's just somebody has to lead the work I appreciate you guys helping me with the framework. You guys are helping me organize this right now so I think one of the things that would be key for anyone who's Looking at the governance models would be looking at you know It's sort of like what's our current model? What's working? What's not working? What

071do we what kind of things do we want to see different? What's you know, another model a Working not not working not working. But what do we like about this? What's interesting about this? What what concerns us about this? And kind of being able to go through that for any of the models that are looked at And I think that what you would want to do from a policy perspective and i'm obviously happy to partner with folks on that Is like what of our existing policies work under this model? What ones don't you know If you were to go to a policy governance model a lot of the policies that we have disappear Not magically because you'd have to repeal them But if you were to to do a policy governance model with fidelity a

072lot of the kind of really small Technical policies that we have go away because the board is no longer focused on those kinds of details They're really focused up here Uh, and that's that happens to be a model that I know about which is why I can talk a little bit about that one I know director hagos knows more about the student outcomes model than I do But you know, you'd kind of get into that with each of those and I would imagine that as you be going through the governance team You'd be saying okay. Well, wow these These are the kind of policies that we need to update to be really clear on what our model is And here's a bunch that need to go away. There's a bunch that just need to be

073revised Which is really why you know to go back to the beginning when erin was talking Those five that director hagos had flagged potential governance policies are kind of up there but shaded Recognizing those would need to be looked at For governance purposes, but not really looked at right now because that would be So for 2004 like I said Keep it You could revise it you could repeal it In any of those situations, I would suggest that we would also bring forward goals for you to adopt Based on data which have all the data yet So I couldn't bring them forward yet But you know those two things can happen separate from each other Any other thoughts? Yeah, i'm i'm just thinking as i'm Kind of pulled out all my stuff. Um I'm okay with

074with revising it, but I feel like we took out a lot of the key components Um things that people will look to just even just as an example You know citing that we're going to use wissef But then we don't actually say in the policy. What is what is that? What's within you know, we have here on the Uh presentation you guys did about what the those indicators were it was uh using the um The sbas the graduation rate weda regular attendance ninth grade On track and dual credit attainment. So by not even having that just listed here just for like say a parent who's trying to look up What is our policy around our improvement goals for our kids? They see that we don't have like even a link or something that just tells

075them what are those things instead of pushing that are pointing them towards state law, which You know easy to find what those basic education requirements are what the goals So I feel like it's as we take out some of those key components most of this to me when I just look at it as as an overall is just just like Well board directors, we're gonna report on it But then that's pretty vague. What are we reporting on? We don't have those detailed lists um so there's just different things that I feel like some language i'd like to keep that I think just um again Every policy that we create sends a message on what it is that our priority is around that policy and so if we don't continue to help share our Commitment to

076establishing measurements towards reading and mathematics and literacy and science and like Proficiency and things like that um then it kind of It kind of turns into a gray area A bit left up to interpretation. I want us to have like really critical. This is what we're doing. This is what we're And here's where we're getting all that Yeah, so I'd just like to see certain language I think I afforded you the email of different I felt like should still be included And pointing to rcw is I know they update at times but overall it's um, you know when you have a link saying this for You know pointing back to rcw 28a Then then people have a place to go and continue to research on their own Oh, here's what the state law says around

077and always still point to state law and make sure That was just kind of my thought revision is okay But I let's not take out some of the meat So with that I heard um Adding in what the actual wcf metrics are Certainly, um, I think the board would need to have a discussion about some of the other ads that you have um They are also getting a little bit into the governance work and not specific This policy which is focused on performance improvement as required by state law so again in our That you would keep the policy related to that And not necessarily talk about all the all the other rcw blacks Probably i'll just jump in I I think um Not understanding the governance models that are out there or even the one

078that we have is what gets us into some of the things in the weeds um, I think I'm just thinking about How do we best understand because a lot of things get into the governance model? A different models not just the governance models and and we're like mishmashing and putting all these things So until we have a really deep end discussion as to what model we're in It's what we're going to be best able to create. That's why it's like We can sit here and word smithess to death and add all these things and add all these words But if if we don't know what governance model we're going to be using or what we're sticking to it might be So I think again My suggestion is is you know if we're going to be

079digging into or For us to better understand what governance model we're using so we can really then start Uh creating these or revising these policies that's going to admit that governance model because if not, we're just again I think holly said it best earlier as as through in all of this uh is that Some of these models we can sit here and for days and weeks and months create and draft words And then the governance model that we are really going to be under This might just go away So we're putting a lot of time and effort in things that are important But if we don't understand the governance model, this is One thing I was I was thinking too is in our old in our old policy, you know We have other old governance

080models like the washington comprehensive Assessment program no child left behind those those were all specifically named And when those fell away that made this, you know So if we're saying now with sif what if in a few that goes away because we decide to change our model So do we need to have that listed? Unless you're going to then we need to have what those parameters are because people wouldn't be as familiar with that As they would with like the child left behind something that's a state standard I think that goes to dr. Graham's point if I hadn't heard Right i'll talk about that, but if they're talking about changing accountability plan even outside of pssa being Then Because the state could do that on their own authority and doesn't need to deal with the

081federal timeline He could I mean he's got four more years. He could come out The fall and say here's a new accountability model and you're absolutely right Was if could be out the window That's what's hard about this kind of policy It really can change quickly and again, I want to distinguish The ability for the board to adopt goals is not predicated Having this policy or separate things anyway, yeah I I think I would defer to what alvarez Van was saying maybe wait like six minutes see and Maybe put together this through a team Looking at those governance models so that a real That is Sensing the will of the people maybe to kind of table this one for a while um kind of on the dependent on the governance um discussion Uh, and by

082that, I mean multiple discussions over the next six months um the governance team And then at the same time once we have actual data face New goals on to bring that All so that you're still in compliance with that, um, regulatory requirements That would be my recommendation since we're not voting on anything I'm saying i'm sensing the room Okay, then uh, I will I will Continue to work in that direction and we will Collaborate whenever we get that information. Thank you all. It's great time. So We're going to take about 10 minutes or a 15 minute break and we'll be back at 10 o'clock I did He just took My husband doesn't share his either but I share mine All right, everybody welcome back it's it's that time Thank you No, we have time What's

083what's your comment? So I was just thinking as we're talking about Uh, maybe this creation of like the board governance Research team. I mean, that's something i'm definitely interested. I don't know if that's something Well, and I know director hoggles you put a lot of effort into that. So would that be something we could call it? I it's like I i've been personally I guess um Yeah, uh No, I don't No, i'm just joking. Uh, it's more that um I already I have All the information to share along be a big part of i've done the work for the um For six months, I think it took a long time to get to what is it that i'm going to be doing in terms of looking into something um for my uh wasda Capstone project

084and I do appreciate that everyone provided input in some form or fashion Um to help me lead me into you know, what I should be studying doing um with the capstone project, but i've already i've done quite a bit of the Work of studying it I can share it Talk to it. I guess that would be the biggest thing and I am looking for a chance to do that at a retreat or another work session where it provides ample time to do so but um, yeah that's the material and information i'm happy to And we I can do we could do it together. That's Interested. Thank you. All right. Thank you for that So I will be discussing that after I look at the framework and how this would work in the next six months

085and Bring that to the board Moving on up to our next Topic is role of director liaisons. Um currently we have six Committees that we are liaisons to and just wanted to Bring this to the board to make sure that everybody understands what the role is for How we communicate with our community? and all of that fun stuff, so Well, i'm going to go through one by one and and just we're going to be Sharing this at our next board meeting and and appointing or just discussing who's going to be that that next liaison Okay, i'll just read the six Roles are the capital facilities advisor advisory committee. Uh, the next one is capital projects oversight committee W i a a the highland skills foundation the highland forum and this legislative Let's start with cfac

086Um currently they they meet four times a year two hours each time. Um right now Director hoggis is primary and then i'm also secondary on that director hoggis any any Input in regards to what cfac and we know what cfac does but um what your thoughts and on that They're wonderful I mean, they're a great group. They're very they're invested. I mean those conversations you've been you've seen those conversations they look like um, you know, they're rich conversations and dialogue among The folks who do participate in the in the cfac committee Um, i'm always surprised at how much detail they really do dive in and they're thoughtful and considerate So in terms of the group itself, they are absolutely wonderful to work with Or to you know to be a part of in terms of

087sitting as a liaison I think an important piece to add to that is that as we think about the experts or whoever is going to be the liaison for this Is considering that cfac will be you know talking about potential next bond um, including you know, who's going to be um on that list and what that's going to look like because again that goes back to our promise that we have to our community around our bond dollars and how we spend those bond dollars and they're starting to have some of those conversations and some of that even includes, you know the Um discussions around you know, how big of a thing that we want to have at a school I was just reading an article around portland public schools that had identified three high schools

088to be part of the next bond At a cost of just under 500 million dollars. And so they were going to be the most expensive high schools Built in the nation and they were being built for 1700 students and majority of the schools are right about a thousand So it was uh, they they're pulling back on that and so i'm kind of watching and reading that story because it's a Really difficult situation for a new superintendent to come in after a group has made recommendations of the board They made decisions and then come back and say this makes no sense from a fiscal perspective But I think one of the big things with cfac also as a reminder is that they will be bringing for the recommendations to the board around the decisions that they

089think is going to be um, You know best for the next piece and then the board will make the final decision And you know as i've been looking at the list of schools that are remaining on the list, you know We have our comprehensive schools as well as a number of our choice schools that we have to be thinking about so Um, I wish we were going to be able to do it So we just do it all in one more sweep to get all of our schools up to there But this next one's going to be really difficult I think because we're down to a few schools that need to be rebuilt versus the entire district need to be rebuilt I have a question on that liaison role because It came to our attention

090a few months ago that there was some voting that was done apparently and I was not aware And I don't know if anybody else was aware that there was voting done on behalf of the board without The knowledge of the rest of the board. So is that something that is part of that role for the liaison for that committee? Oh, no, never mind. I'm sorry. I'm thinking that um, never mind. I will Okay, so the next one is the capital projects oversight committee um, this typically meets the first tuesday of every Every quarter for about an hour or so I have been on this committee for the last four years and I This is a great committee as well We we look at all of the the dollars the dollars and cents and making sure

091that we are being fiscally responsible In regards to our bond dollars, but making sure that our projects are on time We get down into the granular level which I love But looking at the other things that do pop up the needs like the the boilers those emergency things that go Oh man I sure hope we have something in our stash over here that we can pay for that and just listening to our our facilities people ellie and team just looking at along with alongside you jackie sharing all of that and I think it is so important and this is one of the things that I want to Have be part of the The budget the the monthly budget report outs is it's really sharing with our community that we are On time and for like

09299 percent of the time under budget for our projects. It's showing Our our community where we're sitting at and that's going to help us on our next funds and levies and things like that. So Great committee to be on And I would you know if there's anybody else that would love to be part of that that I would I would much I would love to hand off but I would love to be on it though as well We keep seeing on it director van I think that we can have if we're going to go through each of the liaison roles and then we can have a discussion about what? Being on those folks could look so that way. Okay Next one is wi a Director alvarez you're you're on this one, right? um again, like

093it says it's a no vote either But also there is not like meeting that you go to it's not like dfac or any of those I connect with um Yeah, will But I connect with him when things are um uh to get Any updates or anything if I see something coming up? I'll i'll try to schedule a meeting with him to find out like what's happening to help me understand some of these things um it like when he came over to our board meeting so I would just check in with later and like help me understand the history as I remember this is um, so um I mean, it's uh It's a role. Um that has One of the few roles that doesn't have like a standing meeting Just go under Thank you Next one

094is our highland schools foundation Director patrini you want to I know you and I are on this one I think i've only been able to stay I think in two meetings so far. Um Virtually, which i'd love to have done in person but I think this is sounds like this is more of the fun one where you get to just celebrate all the things that Foundation is able to do and help fill those gaps and help uh fundraise and get more community involvement Um in all the different needs that our students have so that's been really fun to Be a part of um, and of course than all the different uh What are you talking about the events that also are like fundraisers? So those are fun Um, i'm sad. I missed the last winter

095format. I don't know you went to that one. You want to speak to that one, but I think this is this is a fun one Um, but I I know that every board director participates in their own way at the events showing up um I think when I was speaking to fred about when they scheduled their uh their meetings right now, it's It's the same day as our school board meeting so moving forward he's going to flip-flop it so Board directors can participate in that But it is a fun one Next one is our highline forum Director hoggis director patrini. We'd like to share a little bit about the the forum Okay, so Um, it looks like there's a lot more information under the forum here on the paper on the page I didn't know

096we were going to be talking about these in detail and didn't prepare anything. Um, so more so of just uh, it's a Forum that was created by My understanding it was a forum that was created by City leaders and city folk community folk that wanted to have a gathering place to discuss things that affect them and in direct relation to The impact of the port being being a part of port that was my basic understanding of the the group there is a Public comment area so folks can come and just talk with the with the group because again This is a public community. Uh, no, sorry. This is a um, it was it's the public is supposed to have some sort of input Into what is being shared and if they have something to say

097about things related to the port or to the port communities That would be the space to do it and it says here A couple of highlighted points. It's a discussion forum that focuses on areas, you know issue of interest Um and aviation and airport related issues and that pretty much sums up. Um, kind of what that all looks like So that's what I have. Um, just As I feel like this has just sprung on me right now. This is what I have right now There may be more as I as I think through a couple other pieces And maybe just to point out for direction does say no formal votes on this But there is a consensus that is asking it's not not binding. It's just more of a Does anyone have to say anything

098about this? It's not An agreement I believe that's what happened referring to Yes, then thank you for the clarification because my understanding was I mean I was threatened with a opma violation for Attempting to attend the meeting because there was a vote being taken Um, so it sounded to me like there was a vote that was had and Our liaisons voted on behalf of the board talk about in any of these capacities to have more than two board members Would would appear as an opma violation that would be for any in general I think the other part with the forum is that it's um, it's one elected representative from the different communities and high line of read obviously one school board member and then District leadership, so it's a combination So we always have at

099least two people attending those meetings and then based on the topic and we sometimes may have another member from our Team join us in the last forum. They were talking about child care So we had a lito donna from our family engagement team attend to present information around child care including both before and after school care One of the interesting things that I think with this is every time i've gotten to the forum. There's conversations around other jurisdictions predictions of wanting to be added to The forum and that's obviously not our decision. It's run, you know primarily by the port but I think one of the pieces with the forum that I think we're going to have to Pay more attention to especially over this next year is this potential expansion of ctac because you

100know I've had we've had a couple Community members email and ask the just you know, the board and the district do we have an opinion around the expansion? You know and I know talking with ryan caulkins on the port when I saw him at the last Maritime meeting a couple weeks ago, you know He was he's always open for people to have conversations with him and stuff like that But as sometimes our community members want us to make take a position, you know I think it's a challenging place for us to be because you know Sometimes we're in support of the highline forum and the work that they're trying to do But there are going to be times where we will have to take a position if we're chosen especially in relation to the expansion

101of the ctac airport, which is under consideration right now Thank you for the clarification director petrini at the language that was used though was a vote So I just wanted to clarify that but like dr. Duran said with Everything that's coming up with the airport I think it's important if there is a consensus being taken and there's the opinion of the board being asked or the district that everybody on the board is aware that There is a consensus being taken and they're we're giving an opinion and giving the opportunity to All have our thoughts for that Yeah, so I wanted to add, you know, i'm kind of i'm glad that this is a point right now Um, I know that when we were talking about director liaison same here, you know a newer I didn't

102understand what is going on. What are we doing? What are these? Liaison roles and I was asking those same questions that you're asking And so it is good to have those questions or at least an opportunity to see this and talk a little bit more about each one um, I still I don't see any Expansions except for on highline forum where there's a quite a bit of detail other areas still don't have Enough information for me to fully understand what it looks like wiaa and so on and so forth. But um, What I do want to say though is I did my own research because I didn't understand liaison full and in my own research I had found uh, there's the link here that says The www.portseattle.org and it has like operating procedures. I actually

103provided that to the board In emails to the board president to aaron to dr Duran so folks knew what that looked like and to help me understand that better as well So when I did my due diligence to learn, okay, what does this look like to be a highline forum? Liaison and then digging in deeper and deeper and deeper. I did find the operational procedures I said ha this gives me a better idea of what it is that i'm supposed to be doing when I get to the meeting um, and so I shared that and um And so that was a good place to understand kind of what that looks like and I did share it with those who should know Before we even voted Um, so that was out and about for folks to

104see and have an idea of what that role looks like My understanding still it's I think it's good for discussion I think it's good to talk a little bit more about that role. Um when it comes to that area of um, Sometimes having a consensus vote um, and the consensus vote is where my understanding so far is where Uh, you know, there's some sort of consensus taken sometimes it may show up on the agenda And when it shows up on agenda, I don't know it's going to be on the agenda Sometimes it may be right in that in that meeting as conversations are had And there may be an ask for a consensus vote So there may not be an opportunity to share it immediately before a meeting. I wouldn't even know The way that

105the operating procedures share, uh mention it could be at any point in the meeting there may be a consensus request and so, um that consensus request is is uh more of like uh, uh, how do you does it look like so by from my experience You know there was a language They had brought that to the table at the meeting and Is there anybody that's opposed to it supposed to consensus that taken that was kind of the the way that is done And again, these can come up in the as the meeting is unfolding. So don't know will be something to share prior to Um, but if uh, but what I do know is that if I plan on going to any other events here or any other things I do make sure that those

106who are a liaison know before I attend I'll say hey I'm going to go to such-and-such meeting a heads up because of whatever it is that I've read and And so, um, I do give a heads up and it'd be nice to be given that heads up back That way we can have those conversations dialogue before today. Here's what we're going to do because Um, so i'm glad that that that link that I found is included in here Um, you have a chance to go ahead and take a look at it and read it and if there are further conversations I'm happy to share what I know Thank you for that clarification and i'll just add that in the past Uh, it hasn't been a lot of this thing goes back to trust and um

107Let's just be real in this in our current board. There's a lot of lack of and so when people are attending things, um, And let's just name what it is is that um, Previously there was only one uh liaison for each of the um of the Lays on roles or what not there only one per per capital facilities capital projects In the previous it's always been just one person when I came on I thought you know what it'd be nice to have to And at times now I regret that to be honest because it's become Um, even a more challenging because if one decides to show up at a board meeting because they want to Because something is on the agenda now. It doesn't allow for So, uh, we need to rethink about how we

108do this to allow for those Um that want to attend a meeting Uh, and we don't violate an opma and that's what I created unfortunately Thinking it would be cool if one can attend the other one can attend and then we can bring back information But it created another challenge instead of making it a better. I Didn't think of the opma as I was Doing this and I just thought it would be cool. So I I know that there's if we turn our paper around there's um some questions for discussion But I think going and revisiting that it's like how many roles per liaison? How many liaisons per role do we do so we can allow for those that want to come in and do communicate? Hey, I see this is on the agenda And

109let the president know the uh that this is of interest in in that liaison as well those communications Uh to be had so That's just an observation that I had being on the board previously for a couple of years. It's always been one person Thank you, uh director alvarez. I would I wanted to say um Some of these uh meetings that are had are smacked out in the middle of the day We are working people I think every everyone around this board um has a whole variety of commitments and um And so it it just it's mind-boggling i'm like, where do they think we will find the time to attend all these things but um But what I did want to say is that was one of the things that I appreciated even last year

110I think it was c fact where uh doe and I had been Members of c fact even not just this year But last year there had been uh two roles and I I really did like that part of if someone can't attend They've got someone else so there's constant representation of the board I really do appreciate that part and maybe like you said, you know Just some further thinking around what it will look like look like how how we work together and deciding what we're going to do And how it'll play out when we do attend these things But in terms of having a second person, yes, please. Can we keep that like there are like I said these meetings happen Um at all times of the workday. We've got to make sure that we

111attend to our professional careers Just as much as we're attending to our uh elected official role. Yeah. Well Uh, this is a consensus. We'll have to take a vote on it or decide but now it's on joe's court after today uh, but um I strongly recommend for us to really think about all those little nuances as we move forward whether it is having um Two or whether it's having one in a backup or whether it's having you know, it's however we can uh Make it work All of these roles we choose because we all have interest in all of them. I think from what I hear But what is um I think moving forward and also I mean we have to work as a board developing trust among others and Whether it is getting consensus

112or it is getting and how do we best communicate coming back like this is what happened there Uh, we weren't planning and this was taken and a lot of i'm including myself don't bring back You know we attend and then like I went to the forum. Yay. Thank you. Whoo And nothing what was discussed? What what was taken or what consensus was made so how do we now ensure moving forward That we're bringing back what we're learning, right? We all talk about being on the community tons and tons and yet we just say we were at this event or or we went to this, um meeting or to this and uh Don't elaborate on like what happened there that impacted that could impact the rest of district Uh just quickly to to answer that my

113my solution is so I try to include it in my board director reports Like the last one on the agenda was child care and here are some of the things that I knew And so I would love to see a standing space for each of these roles. I don't know what About that and just uh, it would be nice to have each of these like as we attend them Any feedback or any any any discussion or any um topics that were so then it's not all in because when I put in my director Kind of get all okay. Let me try to see if I can get this, you know what this information in versus a standalone We are these liaisons what does it that would be nice if it was Yeah, I I mean

114that's an opportunity We normally have under uh director reports and maybe adding that in in our own director reports for us highlighting Whatever it is that you are the liaison to that's why you will have a report There was no meeting this month There was a meeting this month for the discussion period and not go on 20 minutes about what you know People had for lunch or breakfast or whatnot on that meeting but really getting to the nitty gritty So we can move on because if not our meetings and i've seen them could go on two to three hours For four hours or five hours just because we're talking about Just in details, so just I just wanted to add I like that we have two board members because there are Like she said times

115that you can't have both attend and if you do have both attend and it's something bigger if There's other board directors that want to attend We should we should just be notifying each other like I I notified Dr. Garan and joe about the seatback I what if I do as well to say hey, i'd like to attend this month's meeting And joe just happened to not be there So it made easy for me to go and I didn't have to you know Public communications, which I think is what we're supposed to do if we have more than two And a meeting director But um at other times when I haven't been able to attend meetings due to things I was so grateful for someone else there and I could say hey what happened at that

116meeting did I miss anything? No, great. Well next time i'll i'll get this one. So This is a way we can help each other out because it's a big lift when you're the only one And if you miss then if there was more information We don't have that now um, so I I I like that we have two of us and it it gives There there are some pros and cons against that and one of the cons is the opma, right? The third director wants to come in and listen and be part of that. Um, maybe that's something that we can talk about just not having a primary in the secondary as as a backup and the primary is the main person that usually goes if He or she can't make it then say hey

117i'm going to shoot an email to The board president and the secondary person. Hey, I can't make it to this next meeting Can you please fill in for me if that second person can't do it? Will the board president could say you know what? Anybody out there? Any board director can you guys make to this meeting just so there's representation there, but I like having two Board members, but there are some concerns around that having two board directors at specific meeting kind of also changes the the atmosphere in regards to What people perceive? Um not perceive but just it changes the power dynamics on a lot of things I show up at a lot of meetings where it's usually casual But when joe shows up people starts hushing. I don't know why but it it

118it There's a power dynamic in there that I want to Really have the community even staff be able to speak And and and share that truth so that's what My feelings are about that Well, thank you for bringing that up director van because I actually checked in with a couple other districts and their positions on liaisons And that was one of the main reasons that the majority have won because of the power the positionality He says it's one board member to come in but when two Then it it really changes um I don't want to say the atmosphere but it changes the dynamics in the room because now there's two because we even though you're there And yes, i'm a parent. Yes. I'm a community member But you're there whether you like it or not

119as a powerful board member is what I was told And so when I checked in with other districts that what what their roles are and how many did they have? They said we have one we've uh for that purpose because we've gotten feedback because then they say oh the board is coming so Um, I think we're going we're going down the right path, right? But at the wrong time, let's let's talk about the legislative and then at um Get into the questions. Okay. So next one legislative um Director petrini director tidholm What were your thoughts on this one? This was um year one for you guys and you guys jumped into a really really big one here So well last year was a pretty short session So wasn't a whole lot going on there, but

120really coordinating with different lawmakers This year alone. I've started having conversations with the treasurer's office around some things that they're trying to get done different board directors In the states different legislator senators Just what's going on figuring out what it looks like across the state and even across the united states And what we can do and how we're going to do it to coordinate and Get things done and fully fund education um, just to add to that one of the things that I I appreciate when we look at policy 1220 that um Tells us about how we're supposed to be doing this it's also about you know communicating with our our our communities are Different looking at what the local views and concerns are around the things that we are advocating for or the things

121that they are saying Hey, this is really important. Please speak to that. So by being able to put that together and um Share that with the board is really important as well. So there's all these pieces that come together That was represented Thank you so much. I just wanted to quickly add I'll see 1220 does say that you know conveying local views and concerns the body and participating and Have to also think about Conveying those views two of the few of the two of the three of them come to us Because those are very narrow So I think we need to be really fair around when we're conveying views Whether it's our personal views or the ones that are coming to it. Who are those? Because this is uh, even though you are Districts have

122your own districts within the district. You are representing the whole district Not just a few your district or combination of people that come to you, but I think keeping that in mind as we are moving forward with the legislative it's The views of who are we communicating? Well, I think giving equal representation to all views is important. We obviously Like any organization if you have Uh, you know, they say the squeaky wheel gets the grease, right? And so we don't we don't choose who it is that comes to us at different times and so The important thing is that we are listening to all those voices and those concerns and so not to Place intent on who it is that's coming to us. It's our job just to convey it our job is to To

123repeat what we hear doesn't matter who it came from. I don't ever just I don't ever disclose Race or gender of whoever i'm talking to because it doesn't matter. It's a concern of a person tax They have an equal standard Of the law so that's an equal position if someone brings that to me there are lots of different views from lots of people I take them all into consideration. So Yeah, I don't I don't like intent being placed on who who comes to me because I have a lot of people Are you know don't look like Thank you for that. Oh, go ahead Uh, thank you for that mentioning like we can't control who comes to us, right? Which is also why I try to be really intentional on going to the people even if

124it's just popping up to different events I don't mention every single event that I attend But I go to a lot of different things in the community just to hang out and talk with the kids Even if i'm just at a twenty thousand hour tournament for wrestling if your kids have ever wrestled bless your hearts This was an absolute trap But just sitting there and talking to the kids and the families about what's going on So sometimes we have to go to them and not just wait for the people to come to us because I think it's fair to say that in anything the people that are most upset are going to be the loudest and especially in A community like ours, which is pretty marginalized people don't always feel empowered or know how or

125when to come and address their concerns Um, but then yeah factoring in all the different Perspectives, but also I think it's important to prioritize our families There's a lot of community members that are pretty loud about issues that they have that don't have kids in our district Um, and yeah, just prioritizing our families that actually have children in our district And their perspectives and their experiences because everybody can have their opinion, but who are we here for right? I just um one thing I just want to bring this back and then we'll go down the in regards to the questions. So In regards to the legislative liaison, they are the the spokesperson For the board and the district in regards to what our wishes when we come together and we discuss What are our priorities

126together? So when the five of us sit down and this is our priorities that person shall go back To wasda wasa and share as a whole. This is what the board wishes That's also Inclusive of our district priorities as the district says These are our priorities in addition to our board priorities We have to go back as it as one voice and share that I just want to make that pretty darn clear that this is not one person and their beliefs this is our voice as one so Whoever that next legislative person is going to be if it's the same I just want to make that pretty darn clear that this is an us thing And it's not an eye You can bring your eye and and share your whys around that and that's great

127and that's what we want But this is a collective voice versus the one Okay. Um, thank you. Uh director van. I appreciate those comments um, one of the things a couple things that I wanted to share is Um in terms of legislative work, I can't I don't see the policy listed and maybe it isn't i'm just missing this Missing it, but there's a policy that says something about um Having these discussions throughout the year, right? So there's supposed to be I can't policy 5000 something But i'll have to find the number. I I remember um emailing at some point But um in this policy it does indicate that as we have these um conversations of what's happening on the legislative platform To do that and that would be a good time because you know, as

128you said, I do agree It is every what's happening in those it requires discussion and dialogue and that's what that space meant for and so bringing back those Things that are happening Um out in the legislative world and saying this is what's coming up and this is what we're hearing and this is what's you know Coming down the pipeline and sharing that with the board and having that space to put in The input that we have and as I say we I 100 agree I think with director petrini we means we're bringing back Um the conversations that happen in the community, uh conversations with community family students staff everyone when I say school community I mean everyone because as our role in terms of school board directors We are stewards of our educational system for

129our communities everybody And so um to me that means that we have an opportunity as we bring back our thoughts Based that have been formulated on these Conversations that we're having with different folks that we have an opportunity to dialogue as these legislative um being A time to do so in terms for our students, um, we're hurrying on the platforms Consensus of what i'm interested in being more um discussion in that area and there was um another Um thought that I had around this and oh, that's what I was going to say. Um, the other thought is that opportunities to put in Amendments and all kinds of things And I know that I worked so darn hard to get us to have an opportunity to talk through a possible amendment around the um, native america

130a native american, um curriculum interests and so But because we don't have a space in our annual calendar and it's not already a standing meeting I do appreciate and understand how hard it is to gather everyone without having had some Knowledge that this would be coming up. So we do I think we do know on an annual basis when was that's going to be um Asking the assembly when the general assembly is going to be coming down the pipeline I think we have some general knowledge about that So it would be nice if there is interest in there may not be any interest but if there's interesting folks wanting to advocate for some sort of um Positionality in relation to our needs in high line But also for all students that there is that we

131have that in our annual calendar coming up We have a meeting going to be a part of our meeting so we don't have to Scramble to say here is something so powerfully important to us and we don't have the time to do it. That's a disappointment So I want to see a change in that so having something in our calendar that says we've got time to discuss it because Um was has made it quite clear. It is a board team Interest in terms of what those priorities look like and board team meaning we're advocating on behalf of high line, right? So as a high line school board team, what are some things we'd like to see and how we'd like to Vote when it comes time to do the assembly. Um, so that's one and

132and consider like once that um, I'm I may be losing the words But the general assembly handbook I think is what it's called once that comes through if there's something that we catch That's really going to be important for us and our students or something that we like to advocate based on our Of our value that we have time to make an amendment Without having the opportunity so so those are the big things big asks that I have Thank you director hoggles and I think on that like you mentioned bringing it to the dais the conversations about what's going on But like joe said it's also about the board consensus and just drawing the line between what's happening like In the legislative session and what's happening in terms of like policy? And how we personally

133feel about things or how things went maybe we were happy with them or we were not in the difference between Noting the facts and bringing your feelings and essentially shaming the districts for not agreeing and then also going back to the voice of the community And not just a couple of people that may want certain things that aren't happy with how things went or how they're going Good thing I wanted I wanted to just say really quickly sometimes there will be times where board directors want to speak Like I know I already have requests to speak on behalf of a certain bill, you know Here's a bill coming down the pipeline director hoggles. Do you want to talk about it? And I say I don't say anything I haven't done it just yet because I

134don't know what we how we feel about that as a board team I don't know just yet, but I do know people are asking I know that dr. Duran recently spoke on some of those pilot legislative Priorities a big three that we have so when people are asking us to speak on behalf of things Maybe it's a convert like you just mentioned, you know Like we have the opportunity to do so as an individual As well as to do so on behalf of the district And we got to make sure we clarify when we're doing whichever one it is that we choose to do But that's something I know i've been personally asked to do I was asked to do it last year I didn't step in just yet, but I may be interested in

135it this year What does it look like for us as a board team when we are doing so individually in our individual capacity versus what we're doing? So as a as a representative of our board making sure that folks know As we go to speak on something when there's a bill and we're asking to be making comments Anyone any one of us can make a comment so if I say I would love to comment about this Is this something our board team is in agreement with how would that work? I'm curious that I like what you just brought up Yeah And I went to olympia a number of times last year if I also testified to king county council as well as Local city councils and a lot of the time it's just as a

136member of the community and I don't mention that I'm a highline school board director But if it is something that's specifically in alignment with something that we're advocating for That would be the difference in saying I am a board director for highline school district Because if you are going to testify to something that might not be in alignment with us Whether you say I am here as a representative of highline district or I am just a board member of highline district You are perceived as representing highline school district and I think it's important to draw that line and Keep our name out of it quite frankly if it's not something that we are in alignment with because then it gets really messy So one one quick comment around that is folks are going to know

137whether or not we state or highline school board directors Folks know who we are and I think it's good to be transparent I'm here as an individual and here are some of the roles that I have as well But i'm standing I want to make sure that we clarify when we're doing it as an individual And I also would like to know if I do have an interest to speak on behalf of a comment And it's alignment with our district and it's an alignment with our board But I go and I can do that I can do so if that's something that I haven't interested But I do want to make sure that but you know People are going to know us director tittle no matter if we say who we are or not once

138they see our name They're going to know who we are. I think it's it's it's about communication. It's about communication to the the chair, but also You know the superintendent and just making sure that we are in alignment that we're in the know Um that you're going to be speaking on behalf of yourself or the district Um, that is that is huge and we can just discuss that what would it look like pros and cons And and and just share what it would look like. So for me it is about communication. It could It would work And we already have kind of protocols around Because as elected board members, we also represent our community not just the district or that bridge between the two So we're speaking on behalf of both. So when we have

139a board Consensus that is what you know, we all have to speak to and we've all agreed to we've all sworn for that We also have a duty to make and those local views as well so, um, you know, I know last year I spoke onto a bill that wasn't Chosen as a priority for the district, but I worked the district and said this is what I would like to do They gave me the verbiage of what I should say Of course being elected I have to out myself and say I'm an elected school board member But I am not here speaking on behalf of the board and you state that at the very beginning so that anything said after that Is never conveyed on behalf of their school uh district so there are those

140um those uh Flexibility that we have but is also our duty I also want to note this that maybe this is also a way to kind of help solve some of the things that we're all talking About I notice we've got two different policies here. We have policy 12 20 that pretty much speaks to and it says that they the Representative assumes office in july 1. So that's just note the date And it speaks to the washington state school directors association and kind of sticks with that But then we have a second policy 12 10 that also talks about an even number years in june So these sounds almost like two different positions to me That's a legislative representative That serves that two years so we could still have two Two liaisons, but they're maybe

141over different things one that's over like Helping shape what wasda helps come up with between our board And the second one that takes on and actually is there in olympia advocating on behalf of the things that we've asked that we've all done so Just these sound like almost two different roles to me just because they have two different dates associated with them um, I know we also have Redone our our liaison roles in you know, december january previously and these are stating, you know In this in the summer in even years, so is that something that we want to Amend to say we're doing it whenever we have new people or do we want to say hey starting now? Obviously we've passed 2024 Does does this apply then to in 2026? You know revising this

142or amending that so And just real quick in policy 12 10 It doesn't cite the district. Maybe that should be added but those are the district priorities are a part of that liaison roles Because the first one's more about the positive board Just wanted to cite that They're really good questions and we actually had thought about um, I had spoken to erin Just conveyed to collie, uh around thinking about what do these positions really look like moving forward because they do state those policies we amend the policies to reflect um Because it's hard for let's say you both came on you and you took this out and you took it, you know running and You guys did an amazing job. But how fair is it that here you are starting december and Things don't just

143start in december as we all know for legislative. It's an ongoing and ongoing So thinking about what would that look like moving forward? Could we amend to say? You know, uh Is it a two-year? uh Commitment it is it is it one and is it when does it start? Does it start in june so they can be there from the beginning? Uh and see it through then we have maybe a different voting Uh date for I don't know. I just I think that that's up for discussion and those are things that we've been Struggling, I mean challenged with as well as we've been having discussions about how can we make this better for all? um, so we can move forward in a way that it is also respecting people as they're coming on or Uh

144starting in december. Is that a good time to start? Okay last comment. I know that um I know you probably want to close this. Okay. So uh, just uh, I keep getting um emails, uh from You know different, um agencies about if i'm gonna go to the legislative representative assembly of some kind No legislative assembly, I think is what it's called, uh in january Oh, it's on here. Never mind. So good. It's a part of the agenda. So i'm not creating something new. Yeah Oh great. It's it's there never mind. I probably should so I guess uh, my point is in policy We have that two people will go to those events each year And i'm not sure if we even one person has gone to the event maybe last year I'm not sure who's

145gone But um, that was just my thing is I was going to bring it up but people aren't enough That it's a part of this conversation and already put it on here. So i'll stop talking So there's a lot of um, great discussions here in regards to the legislative I think that is going to be one of our primary well out of all of our Liaison committees, I think that's going to be super duper important that we we hash out. So Some questions on the on the back side That I just wanted to bring up are these liaisons allowed to vote does the board want two-year terms for? Any of the liaison positions one is the the legislative and that is part of our policy And and how do we want to look at the

146the calendar do we want to do school calendar? Do we want to do fiscal calendar or do we just say for one of the liaison committees? Like the legislative that we do the school calendar so it's an alignment or holly's got some Technical stuff that she wants to share. Yes, but so specifically for the legislative liaison um, I hear your point director petrini, but 12 10 and 12 20 i'm 99.9 percent sure are talking about the same Person doing two roles one is wasda and one is um the state legislature because of that last sentence That's mentioned there under 12 20 Monitor proposed school legislation, which is the under the purview of the legislature and not wasda But I wanted to talk about the timing of this one The reason this timeline is written like

147this for the legislative liaison that you would be named in june and take office Or take the position at the first meeting in july For a two-year term is so that you would have taken your seat as liaison on july 1 2024 At which would be the start of the next biennium so you would serve in the 2025 and 2026 sessions um by starting in july in july You get a six-month run up to the January start of the session and then if you do it in even-numbered years You're always starting with a long session the odd number year session followed by a short session even number year session That's why this one is on a different timeline Because I think You both did a great job last year And I think as I said

148in our meeting earlier this week kind of got into our rhythm like at the end of session But it's really hard to start being a liaison in january when the session starts the next week Um, so it is nice to have that That run up to that and so that's I just wanted to name why that one is Timing one and holly and and it's been um challenging because we haven't Uploaded right and and that's what's made it challenge as we move forward so uh I think it's something to do. I mean Unfortunately, we haven't this But I think we can get really clear on um You know, what are the guidance for when you're speaking as a board member versus individual as you said you did that last year Um, the one thing i'll

149just put a personal plug Please let me know whether you're going as an individual at or as a director because I can let our lobbyists know We can provide support Really helpful to if it's virtual. Okay, you did last And and I think anytime we're in a public space I've been told this several times you are always seen as a board director As a parent or as a community member Um, so keeping that in mind that our presence in any space will be seen as either advocating for or in support of right? Um But if we if we're talking about amending anything, I think maybe just the clarification that these are The legislative reps there's still two but maybe they have different functions one's helping with that first run-up starting in that july of You

150know looking at the handbook making sure we're on On schedule to sit down as a board and talk about our priorities that we want to debate at our separate conference Getting that through our general assembly and then that second person kind of taking the baton, right? Like a relay and now they're going to the state helping What we had come up with so it's almost like You're kind of helping each other big push. I think do um, so Um, and I think maybe and I don't know what the purpose was having a july 1 and a june So to me that sounds like whether we match up those dates. Anyway, could still be two positions but each with different functions And is a way to make it feel like Maybe there's not that tug and

151pull right but still that collaborative Spirit of the board having on these different things and that person taking what the board agreed with and going with it So it doesn't it is two dates, but it's to be clear it it's they are elected in june so they can start to like So it's not that there's two starting dates they get it for for this position. It's Elected in june so they can start So it's not too different So what it comes down to is that we have not been following policy. We've been just going through the january through the years, so Um, I hear what you're getting at director petrini and I I like the continuity of having one director Working alongside going through our books or going through all the the wishes that was

152it has and then going to The going down to the hill He or she will have full knowledge. So from the get-go to the very end So just keeping that continuity versus handing the baton off during the the legislative assemblies and conferences you're you're conversing with other directors and other people that You know are influencing your decision or you're communicating back. So That's really hard to hand off to the next person to say here To take off with it and and should definitely still be working together, right two reps together to be you know Because if there was something that that was a priority and all this work around it and the next person is like Oh, I don't I wasn't part of that conversation. I don't understand it They don't advocate as strongly as

153we would want. I think that that constant Between the two i'm i'm saying as in Efforts of maybe one person's like yeah, I have more time I can go down to now speak on to the things that For you know, whereas another person could say hey, I have the ability to Put these other things together. So it's it's more of a working in tandem, but then the baton's more of like, okay I I ran this race now. We're in the same race together still You're you're taking it from here, but we've been working together on this okay, so Sorry, thank you. I had a thought as you were talking Um, but uh, one of the things that I remember seeing in the past is we would have like a whole host of Bills and I

154know that it came from seattle public school and they have a whole tracking thing of what is going on where Um, but I did like seeing that because and it gave me an idea of what highline is advocating for like We don't have a chance to speak with our lobbyists. They don't come to see us as a board team. We don't talk with them I don't know who they are. Um, I don't know what they're doing. So it's nice to know like, okay Here is a list of um bills that we have here are the things that we're lobbying for on behalf of our district Here's what it looks like and um, I recall when I was looking across that list I was like, oh this one looks great. I would love to speak on

155that one um, so that's kind of just something I like to suppose now is when we when we have things that we're speaking for even though We don't have the outside person having done the work and giving it to our district in terms of having a list of um Bills are coming up that we are in agreement with or not in agreement with but my point is though If we had something like that, it would be helpful to know So that way if it aligns with things that we are Interested in we can go and speak on it and it matches what are the interests of our district as well Do you know what I mean? Like that would be helpful to have I know that the league of education puts out some sort of

156thing as well And it's not ours and I don't want to be paying attention to you know I mean it's good to know but I would like to make sure that as i'm thinking through Any kind of legislative support that it does match In one capacity it matches what we're doing here at the district. So that's one thing That I kind of wanted to speak on and then um, the other thought I think it's already been asked I think I should be okay with the second part of the Question it really goes back to um in our annual calendar. Can you please include the wazda's general assembly? Conversation that we have So that we don't miss that I don't want that to be missed again this or missed this year I don't think we've ever

157done that and that was a change I think there was a change from wazda to move it to Uh, just a certain couple of board directors who may be submitting things to ensuring that the entire board team was on Board with um the positions that they're putting forth for the general assembly So I like that change and I just want to make sure it's on our annual calendar so we don't miss it And I think um, it's important to know too that I mean anybody can testify liaison or not anybody can have Conversations around what's going on in olympia? But as I did share in our meeting last week, I personally think that it would be Best if there's only one liaison for the legislative role And I think a part of all that is

158I think especially going into this session coming up here really soon it's going to be so important that we Stay on point and stay focused on the the big three that we've identified know that we have five that we Adopted as a school district, but those big three are going to be really big is already just this week alone um, you know hearing conversations of representative um perquis this week that there's There's a big shortfall in the in the state, you know They've talked about a 10 to 12 billion dollar deficit And so you know with that deficit the question then has to be around revenue Where is revenue going to be coming from? and already starting to hear conversations around, you know potential cuts in other areas, you know, and so We have to

159stay on point and and if we do not there's going to be so many bills that are going to be coming up But we're going to just keep pressing this and we had a really great editorial that came out of the seattle times yesterday emphasizing that at a meeting with the Superintendents here in the king county pierce county which represent the ps esd You know, we have identified the three is the big three and we're going to really advocate for those and And I think as as we start getting a session We you know holly myself and cliff who is our lobbyist, you know, we work really closely and sometimes these things move really quickly Um, so there's not always a timing of it, but we do have the list of bills that will start

160coming forward But I do think this is going to be a year where we're going to have to say We think that's a great idea, but we're not going to support it because it doesn't go back to the big three That's one of my fears, you know from just watching what's been happening this week already is that You know just in one conversation is like hey We have this idea to do this promise so that kids can go to community college Like I think that's a great idea But you've got to go back to funding basic education and we have to make sure that we stay on point with those Um, I just want to say oh, sorry. Go ahead. All right. Excuse me. I'm sorry Just I just wanted to know fully funds education.

161You said funding just a fully part Okay, mine may be long-winded are you sure I can wait if okay, um, so, uh I think that uh, you know as you say, you know, not losing track or staying focused. Um, dr Duran for me I think that um as we went through this year a couple of places where I think we were Not always on board with one another is one of those pieces where We just didn't have legislative conversations on the dais during legislative time. It didn't come up in that dialogue I think may change moving forward if we have those discussions during that time so that way when It is everyone can feel comfortable and happy that the legislative priorities match the entire board team and I say that because um I 100 fully

162fund part. Um, but what I wanted to share is that um, we've had other discussions where we've had Board directors talk about interests in terms of legislative priorities whether it was a literacy time We had our was the thing or other pieces there were other things that came up During our conversations and that wasn't represented at least I didn't see all of I know we can't have I understand The purpose of what we're trying to do is to scale down and really focus on a couple of key points But it just wasn't represented as a whole So I think having that missed opportunity to say here are all the discussions that were had that board team What do you see as far as scaling down to what are our top five top ten? Whatever it

163is that we're deciding that would have been a helpful way that so that we got to a point where everyone feels 100 comfortable with okay. We've got our five legislative priorities. Here we go We have we've had ample discussion dialogue and they match the conversations that have occurred throughout the school year Which is a part of one of our policy asks of us. I think that point and I also 100 back When we do make a decision as a board team that we all back it. That's a priority So this has been the legislative parties have been Approved by a majority of the board and with that ask that our legislative reps will then go out and advocate half of what the board team I do trust our board representatives for legislative rep will both

164go out and make Do the work that We've approved through our board. What is it called our board? Believe that will happen Dr. Durand so around the three priorities Just speaking to others around and in our community about you know hearing Some feedback around not supporting literacy or not supporting. It's not about the not supporting I wanted to get back to the the fully fund Making it very clear that Now we know That this is a statewide effort To get a better understanding is like we keep trying to slice the pie thinner and thinner and thinner and thinner and then And then it takes away. So if we get fully fund amstock special ed in transportation, that's gonna Alleviate some of that pressure and all that funding that's coming from there to let it go

165so we can totally invest in literacy My concern is we keep adding like I said slicing and adding more priorities Let's say they fund that with they they make it a legislative priority without funding Now we're in a worse spot than we were to begin with because now we have a mandate that it's not funded So making it clear that I don't think that there's clarity about how you know, even funding sources work or or how the legislative? Funds These priorities because the more that that we have if we can all stick together too Right now it's three and all the superintendents across the state and even across the nation As I've heard some other from other board directors that if we can get them to fund those three things That will let go money

166so we can really truly invest in literacy and other Important Priorities that we have on our own, but if they can't fully fund it then we're stuck with slicing that pie Unfunded mandates that really take away what we're trying to do So understanding that piece I think it's difficult at times But really being clear about why is it that we're doing what we're doing and everybody's trying to Thank you. Angelica and one thing to note. I know there's a lot of talk Blog posts about literacy and not supporting it But they're not mentioning the fact that we didn't approve also african-american history Which I noted before is really important to me and I voted no on that And although there's been A lot of talk about not voting for literacy being a priority. I think

167we should look at the whole picture um, and not just try to pick at certain things that Support whatever agenda it is people are looking for. Um, and as much as I would love for us to be On that page, you said director hoggles where there is that trust. I just I don't think they were there yet Uh here I think where we need to have some clarification and maybe just Revisit actions have that were taken by the board. We did have our board vote on Uh legislative priorities that we sent to wasda one of those was literacy That was one of the top eight out of the ten that we could have passed When um, it came down to district priorities that were put out Five were passed but only three resided in our

168press release and the other two were completely Left out which was one of my questions But also it didn't even cite that those top three those weren't approved by the board as being top three We never had that discussion said but these of these five that we just passed these are our top three So it wasn't a board decision and that was another thing I I had a beef about which is the reason I I brought that up but being that the district uh The district is supposed to act on behalf of what the board has said So we had said in our priorities of of the eight that we Back in was it september october? Um literacy was one of those ospi put out literacy as one of their top five So there are

169other state agencies that are putting those out wasda put it out as one of their top ones So I was only clarifying to our community to make sure that they know our board did pass literacy as a priority Legislative priority But it didn't make the press release and also two others did not make the press release And I think it's really important if we're going to pass something and we're going to put out Information to our public we need to make sure that all five were cited But also not to make it appear that the board had said but these three are our parties because we did not have that discussion We did not say okay of these five which ones are our top three that was that was a decision made on the district

170without And if that was approved by our board chair that wasn't communicated to us And so that's where that trust breaks down. You know, nothing was communicated to us. Nothing was said Hey, can we put out a press release and say these are our top? What are your thoughts about that that that whole step was missed? so I'm not throwing anyone under the bus. I was clarifying to our constituents. Here's what the board did. Here's what the district did Here's what the press release said and just to clarify Literacy is a board priority. We passed them and there's nothing wrong with stating restating facts There was no opinion that there was no Uh, nothing else in that except just stating facts and timeline Okay, so but I think I think the important point in that

171though is that yes, they were part of the wasda Decisions that the board made correct and then we went to create the district focus areas They were brought that introduction and for two weeks There was a span of time where there was no conversation around those five It didn't come where Okay, but there was no conversation between board directors. No conversation with me. And so when we got to the action point Literacy came up as i'm please don't interrupt me. I'm speaking. Thank you um When it came up at the action point Literacy is brought up, but it was brought up No consultation with me and me being the senior advisor ceo of the organization No one said hey we need to really make sure that we add that one because I think of what

172we told you that We really want to make sure that we focus on these big three knowing that if we can get these funded Then we can use the dollars to choose how we want to implement those funds Because I at this point still do not want the state directing and guiding us with what they think literacy needs to look like We want to have the local control over that knowing that again the context of our district is very different So I really do think it is about a process piece and about how we work to ensure that everyone is on the same page And that no one is surprised when things are brought to the dais so that you know People know what's happening because now the impact you may not have thrown anyone

173under the bus But the way that members of the community have been using that We were all kind of thrown under the bus in that situation because now this belief is out there that we don't support literacy Which is absolutely ridiculous It's one of our priorities is some of the core work that we're trying to do and we're doing really good work on that But we're not able to focus on that good work Because we're not on the same page around what we're trying to accomplish So I think director how goes your piece you brought up earlier around getting ahead of this is going to be so important You know, we make the annual calendar for the board meetings in june And so if we want the law wazda legislator priorities and that whole conversation

174to come up timing with what wazda does that We've got to put it on the calendar so that we're not scrambling because I feel that's where we ended up scrambling and again not having information When we make these decisions Is that thing is what creating the sense that we're not all on the same page and we have to be on the same page moving forward Especially knowing that the session is going to be long But it's going to move fast and we've got to get the additional funding that we're needing that we're going to need for Our students and for our families I totally agree with that with that There was no surprise. I talked to people I sent emails. I also even made a motion on the dais So it it was put in

175I I did ask that we add Literacy as one of our priorities because we had four at the time Or maybe we had five. I don't remember but We were asked is there anything that you guys want to see on here that was my ask and that obviously got voted down That's fine Because that was for the district legislative priorities, but for the board ones Conveying that as we have board directors who have been attacked for not supporting literacy I made the statement our board directors did pass literacy So therefore that covers all of us whether someone voted yes or no for that was a board action. We all stand behind that So that it's just for clarification if people take offense to that then they're not seeking clarification From those who made statements. I'm

176always open to have questions But my comments weren't meant to throw anyone on the bus It was to clarify the actions that were made on behalf of the board and actions made on behalf of the district And just that to make sure to our constituents understood that there are people who have priorities and that's okay I'm stating facts. There's nothing to But those things were done over the dais through conversations through emails So there's there's no surprises I think the point of the surprise is that it was done on the dais rather than a conversation before Um, I think a lot of the important work that is done is done behind the scenes and the conversations that we have So if you're just bringing something to the dais and begging a question It does feel

177like we're being thrown under the bus as opposed to actually intentionally doing the work Like I said, there's a lot of things that I do Behind the scenes that I don't speak about because I don't feel the need Excuse me to um To throw the district under the bus or to search for accolades for the work that i'm doing So if you're only bringing it to the dais and you're not having any conversations I didn't receive a phone call. I don't think anybody else received any phone calls to have a conversation like hey literacy is important to me It was just brought up on the dais and that was a surprise. So it didn't seem Genuine that that was the intention Because it wasn't a conversation that was had Thank you director tenholm. I wanted

178to share. Yeah, I wanted to share a couple of things Um, just kind of centering us back with our policy and I can't state it off the top of my head I'm really sorry. I don't have those numbers, but it is a year-long conversation So even if it didn't come up in that two-week time period our interests should be developed throughout the year So we have a fully packaged legislative priority list That is a consensus amongst the whole board team And I think moving forward that will help if these conversations are had so that we get to that centralized location Now I do read and we get those was the publications and that's how I do know about what's called the top three um, and um You know, I don't necessarily share those with anybody

179because we all should be getting them and if we're not We should be finding people to make sure we get those publications because it does indicate the reasons why we're doing what we're doing Around the top three so that's just my own knowledge because of what i've had access to In terms of um information that came to us through wasta So just that plug as well is um, I believe the verbiage of the top three is pretty coming from those um was the things But I do get what you're saying. It's supposed to still be a representative The statement should be representative of our entire board team But that's why that's why I know about it and how i'm clearly I'm able to back it is because I've read along the year and i've heard

180I've heard about these things and it gave me an opportunity to digest and understand the importance behind that work but a key piece is also again going back to that, uh, our um Our highline policy is that these legislative positions are not just to advocate at the state level or a regional level or whatever It is it really is to also let our community know what our priorities are as a board directing team Or you know a governance team and that space, you know in past one of the things I did mention this by email as well In between that two-week time period when it was an intro and an action I mentioned that um Oh gosh, I forgot what I mentioned. Oh, that's what I mentioned. So I mentioned That in the past we've

181had seven legislative priorities. We've had 10 legislative priorities We've had, you know legislative priorities and then a b b c legislative priorities so we've had room to expand so that everyone's wishes are Our inner consensus is brought together and we fully all can be behind it is because it's been Packaged in a way that there's been room for those things where yes We have our priorities Uh big ones that we're going after and I will 100% stand by those big three But I also want to say this is a space to say to our community Here are the things that we're recognizing and here are the things that we're still going for even if it's just a statement I think it's so very valuable even if it's just a statement because i've seen again Our

182our legislative priorities have been seven to ten long and this time it was capped at five And I just felt like there was room to let our community know that the passion that we have behind our kids educational Programming as well. Not just the money Thank you everybody for sharing this I think there has been some lessons learned this year that we're going to change and and i'm okay with it There are things that we did. Well, there are things that we have opportunities to work on so We as a team will change and and and do better Okay, this is not we're not throwing any anybody under the bus we're just going Oh crap. We missed that one. Let's what are we going to do to change it and prevent that from happening? Okay

183um so as you guys know, uh the We will be identifying director liaisons for the 25th at the january 8th board meeting New year already so depending on the responses to the discussion Discussion questions we we may have to do a board vote in regards to Do we want one or two liaisons per thing going back to our liaison position starting in? july versus the beginning of the year all of that fun stuff, so This is an opportunity for us to have those side conversations with each other and and and talk You know, we're talking earlier We're talking about communication and that's going to be our next part in regards to Our communications with each other with our community with their superintendent with just everybody So I think that's going to help clarify some things

184and um get us to that next point Okay Sorry, I just um, I don't is it a part of our um policy that we vote on these things I'm comfortable that to have it stand as it is We've done this Done we've learned some things and we can change what we do operationally throughout the year But I don't see any reason to change it It's not a policy to vote, but I believe it in regards to even Our legislative it's only supposed to be one person versus having If we if we want to have a primary and a backup that is a different versus having two liaisons to a role So we can identify that yeah, and I would recommend for us to to just to protect ourselves to take things to a vote When

185we can just then later it's like well, I wanted to put this way For the uh legislative reps since we do have two And it is a two-year position You wouldn't be asking a board member to step down in the pillar of their I'm not asking anything. It's going to be a board decision on what that could be who's it could be a primary and a secondary person like a And and one as a primary and then one as a backup but That I am not making any recommendation. I'm just throwing that out there based on what is what has happened This is not a joe decision um, okay, so I was thinking you know, it is a two-year commitment and they've uh, we've already Approved two years at the last meeting to go back

186on that I think it'd be a little bit disrespectful. Um at this time to say, okay, you know, we've done this last year It was a two-year commitment. We've made that two-year commitment now psych. We're doing something different. That would be that would be hurtful Yeah, there's just changes that will need to happen regardless whether we continue to roll because elections will need to happen June for that person to take, uh the role and apply So regardless of whether it's the commitment because we're gonna if we're following we haven't been following the policy And as we follow it to make it um uh I don't want to be easier to to in all fairness to the rep role Uh is that they start so regardless the decision will have to be made not to ask

187anybody to step down or not But if we're going to be following the policy, that means that in june we will um elect the representative for uh, july It says uh, july of an even year next year would be an odd year. So this would be 2026. We're talking about Perhaps this this would extend for at least ted home and I who came in in december of last year two and a half years at this point And you'd have to and you'd have to amend the whole policy to change both both Right, um, not looking at the year, correct, but that's a decision that we as a board make I'm sorry. I just want to say we've already made the decision Um january of last year We made the decision that this would be a

188two real two year position Unless there's going to be a new thing to change that like I said I think that would be hurtful now because people have already invested their time If we're going I actually I do appreciate the correction and making sure that we go By what's stated in policy and making sure that when we do this, it's an even numbered year and it's in june and july As um holly has mentioned that why that's so important to do so So it makes sense in terms of the processes of what happens with legislative standing But as for now what i'm sharing is that we've already made a vote We've already decided we have our liaisons. Well, not about the way that we typically do it we've already decided who our liaison roles were

189are, um, and that's a two-year position and it should stay until the Even numbered year and then we can and that gives us time to process and correct things and then make sure that we do Right by our policies And I think it's important to note too that it was unorthodox that we had two legislative liaisons this year That's not something that we've done before that's not something that other districts do So we did try it and if we decide as a board, um that it didn't work then it's unfortunate that Somebody will no longer be a liaison for that position or for that term the two years Um, but again, it's not something that generally happens. We tried it. Maybe it worked Maybe it didn't and maybe changes need to happen The only thing

190I was just going to add is that regardless whichever way we there's change is going to be happening Yeah, right. So i'm not saying that it's going to happen now or it's going to happen in january or whenever i'm just saying that Noting for us to there's changing And I I really I appreciate it. I think we should be correcting the things that may be causing some trouble here Uh, I just want to indicate in january When we received when we all took on our liaison roles We were given information as to what these rules looked like. I didn't feel like I had enough information for some of them I looked a little further for myself. However, it was indicated that it would be two years For the legislative rep role and no one said

191it was a trial period to see how it worked It was just a this is what we're doing So I still think we need to stand by our word just like we I always say we should be standing by what we do We'll always back what we do once it's done on the dais. We've done it on the dais And I don't see any reason why to change it now And and again, I just wanted to reiterate i'm not making any changes It was my mistake because I was trying to make it uh Where others could participate more not realizing that I was creating more of a challenge than good And so i'm not saying that i'm making any changes now Uh, and it is something that we can look for into into whether but

192what i'm saying is there changes Happening as we align with this. That's all i'm not saying we're changing at all Thank you well, then that concludes our Our role of director liaisons, um, I think this was super duper important Uh director haggis you started off saying that you know back in the day when you first started you were like I don't know what this is i'm going to volunteer for it, but I don't know and that That's what started this conversation is making sure that directors know what? They're stepping into and just you know being um Having the information so All right We're gonna start I don't know if Adriana might grab lunch But uh until she comes back we can move on to our board communication protocols. I think this is super important as

193well Um, I know during our last retreat we did go through it is It's the flow chart that you guys have You guys still had it from the original and I made some updates just adding a couple Um arrows to follow back up, but we ended with our community members to all directors and superintendent This is our current. Thank you everybody For being here. Appreciate you No more fighting about how to decorate the holiday tree. Okay Good conversation to be had right here in regards to what our current state is and what our proposed state is going to be so when a community member emails To all directors and superintendent the board president responds acknowledging the message and or board president responds to the content of the message Or the superintendent responds to the content

194of the message and informs all directors And the board president and superintendent can determine the appropriate next steps are normally from my experience is that the board president will Work alongside the superintendent and going. Okay. What is the what is the question? What is the message and then formulate a response based off of What's what's happening? and then We would cc everybody that was part of that email You guys have any concerns with that any? Which which last part I talked a lot So if a community board our community member emails the board and the superintendent this is the natural process right board president Will work with the superintendent on the response and then communicate back if there are Extinguishing circumstances or if there are side conversations that are happening My recommendation would be that

195specific director reach out to the board president say hey I had this conversation with xyz So they have a little bit of context of what could be happening out there That would be my recommendation on on that when when something like that happens And I know in director petrini's Out-of-office responses that says We'll respond back within three days that gives us really opportunities to really if there are Side conversations that they they reach out right they reach out to the board president and dr Duran and says hey, I had this side conversation Please take this into account And then we can have a better response I just also think that if a community Situation is reaching out About something it's good to inform the board president just because a lot of times community members Had

196to tap in the past email each one individually to see what response they're going to get And then they say well this director's I've seen it Been published in the past with one director So just being aware so if you remember asking you I mean we all I think I said this at our last Communication like we all like to think that we're the only ones in their eyes And they're just reaching us for our own expertise Um, they really want sometimes their answer shopping and sometimes they're genuinely trying to get information so I would inform um Director van if a community member is out or um Is asking you for information or that way it's on his radar So because it might come up again and then if there's various a couple several community

197members different ones reaching out for the same topic to different Board members at least on your But we've had five community members Reach out to individual members just ask them that way we can Their message out or clarify maybe there's something that we can do Because some members are different members are reaching out to us that same member is reaching out to all of us Uh, just so we're all on the same page and communicating Um and letting you know or giving heads up to the president As to what's questions are out thoughts y'all food foods coming so I think Thank you director. Um president alvarez. Just it's the communication part. I don't we Don't know what your what conversations are having on the back side So if we the more that we know the

198better informed and you know, we can do this communicate better. So I agree with that. I think that's uh really important that we Have a good understanding and I think that goes both ways though Oftentimes, I don't know when a community member is sending nothing to say besides I don't and that's not okay Um, and it didn't include anything that I thought about it So yes, um, I believe board president is the spokesperson that takes in the voices of the board team at least an opportunity to say here's what I think of this and um Those two instances are not in here in terms of when will that happen? Is there going to be a can we just say? Hey board President here are some thoughts that I have around this I know it was

199sent to all here's some thoughts so that I am able to share some of my Phone call, but unfortunately phone calls are hard to find these days. I'm not getting anywhere with phone calls And so that's not helpful at all but um But what I do want to say though is two things is one when a response goes out to Whoever has emailed us to all folks I would like to know what that response is and two I want to make sure that it takes into consideration the board's thoughts not an individual's thought Correct And that that's going to go to our next section where it talks about director to director Okay I think if we can this all kind of flows into one if a community member Sends an email and you have personal

200thoughts send the email to the president and the superintendent So they now have that call so we understand so we know what's going on When the response goes back out, it should go back out as all So we know where we all stand. Um, if if it's a Email from a director to the superintendent guess what? He's going to probably add it to The friday packet now he's probably no he's going to based off of what the the process is is You know, it is easier to have it all in one Email versus 15 different emails going back and forth. So it's documented that way so Talk about director to director And we have like also a timeline to respond to each other There's been times i've had texts So we try to to our

201constituents, you know get back to them in a timely manner same with each other To be able to either set up a time to have a phone call Because not everything is best Communicated through email and sometimes feels impersonal. I want to talk to a different board director Can we come up with some kind of timeline? That gives respect to time. I think that The common courtesy, I mean to respond in a timely manner when appropriate But I don't think it would be appropriate to put like stipulations on Like a timeline for us responding. I think that we're not obligated to communicate with each other at all realistically So to have it, I don't know is a requirement. It just doesn't feel appropriate to me those are It is a part of the function of

202a board and board relationships that we do develop with each other and I know that that is Personally important to me that we have relationships with one another and I know that that's how I came in I experience With one another um when I started and so it is a part of what we do and I want to just uh ditto, uh director ted hall. Um director petrini Uh responses to phone calls text messages would be appreciated. It made it incredibly difficult to not be able to have those responded to um And uh breaks down it kind of just erodes our opportunities to maintain good strong relationships so um Some people call it ghosted That is what i've heard and several board directors have been ghosted and it's just an inappropriate and not a way

203to Interact and so when we talk about director director, I agree Maybe not so far as stipulation because again, we are all working adults We are all professionals and we have so many other priorities. I know I do just this morning I was juggling probably six priorities before I got here um, and uh, and then I forgot that we were here and not at the puget sound steel center, so I had to make sure I redirected myself because we do it here now, but uh, so maybe not such Stipulations, but definitely a respect to say a board director has called and they have something they feel like to hear or discuss And if you're unavailable, that's all right, but just making sure that there's that respect is important. Um, and also Maybe even you know,

204um if that's if there are some issues around timing and things like that um You know maybe even regularly scheduling one-on-one check-ins if folks are comfortable doing that so that way it's planned in advance and it's not a Surprise, you know here on a saturday afternoon when i'm tied up someplace with my kid or my family that there's a phone call It would be nice perhaps to have some scheduled one-on-one check-ins Maybe perhaps even with the president the board president with individual board members I remember that's one of the things I appreciated when I was um at the uh in my leadership cohort was a leadership cohort Several members talked about regular scheduled check-ins with board president and individual board members and that was appreciated and I thought wow That makes that communication much more

205easier. Uh, it's not some again not a surprise But something that's made available depending on folks capacity so room to grow But um, I think it's important that we adhere to and find ways to uh look at Functions of the board and board relationships and I agree that you know communications appreciated but not required and I also appreciate having the autonomy to not have to communicate and it comes back to the trust too if I don't feel safe in a conversation then i'm not obligated to engage in that conversation Um, but yeah, it really comes down to the trust and building that relationship But again as I stated earlier, we're just I don't think we're all the way there yet And I also think when we've got and I don't know if we need to

206create a new protocol when we have directors to chair vice chair That comes with added responsibilities So if you guys are having more time and access to the superintendent or to other information It's your job to disseminate that to all board directors to make sure we have that so if we're asking questions that are Not just like hey, what did you have for lunch yesterday? And you're like, I don't want to tell you but if it's like hey So and so is talking to me about this. I know you might have more information about it I think it's really important just to keep to the topic or the issue at hand and put personal issues aside because that's that's what to do and so um, if there's If there's timely things happening and you're getting

207Texts or emails from someone who says I need I need this information. I have other people who are asking and waiting Um, you know as a chair and boy chair that that information is really important. Otherwise, then we are It almost appears as we're acting on our own, which I know we're not supposed to do So to be in constant communication with our chair and board chair is really important. And that's how we have a cohesive Board I just wanted to also add to that that That is important the communication and getting back in a timely manner But the other thing is that there's been times when communication has happened and because it's not the answer That people were looking for all of a sudden. There was no communication and it was stated. There's no

208communication So just making it clear that yes Uh, do we do I have a lot of room to grow? Absolutely. There's no but I think also, um There have been times multiple times when the answer was not what was looked for and then all I would hear is there's no communication No communication I'm getting hungry. So I wanted to go make I wanted to want my food. Sorry. Um, okay, so Um, if there are interpersonal things that are going on We should have an opportunity to work them out And I don't know the best platform to do that but that would be great to have a chance to do it in some form or fashion whether it's um, Uh, I I really don't know. I'm getting a little I want to make sure I go

209warm my food But just a thought I want to put on the table. No, I thank you so much for that Um, and i'm going to be honest with you guys. I am at fault for this as well. Okay, um We do have A regular full-time job out outside of this. So when those emails and phone calls and texts come through And you read it you you forget about it. I do that with my wife and kids. So I apologize um moving forward though It is you know, just the professional courtesy if if it's a simple let me get back to you or whatever and and you forget please patience and Around that because it does happen um I think in regards to our communication with with each other with their superintendent with with our

210community We have A duty to to respond back um Does it need to be instantaneously? No Okay, we we have to do our research. We have to make sure that we Get all of our ducks lined up before we we respond as a as a whole so Um, that is what i'm gonna be shooting for for this year is that You may not get it back Instantaneously, but you will get something back. I mean just like when we have constituents Email us obviously we want to respond and think of what we have at least a week, right? But on here, um, I think for each other Sometimes we even just have a quick email saying received your email. Thank you for working That at least lets them know they were or at least that Lost

211the same thing with a text so quick like i'll get back to you when I can Um, otherwise it can be taken as okay this person We don't want that that's where again as we want to continue to build trust it starts with that Thank you. Um This last one was um in regards to director to superintendent When a director emails the superintendent, um He will be keeping track of all the requests. Um, the superintendent will be responding back to that director and then ceasing the board president Um, so we know what's going on. Um, if the information is relevant to all of the directors The superintendent will be throwing that in in the friday packet. So everybody is in the know Um, if it's to a community member, you know, that'll also be part

212of the friday packet as well Um Any any questions or concerns on that? Quickly add that again the part where oftentimes CC and other people on the team is to ensure that we're keeping track of What's coming in and what's coming out because we do keep a spreadsheet of all the requests to make sure that we're getting them done And done in a timely manner Thank you for that. Dr. Duran questions comments All right So this is a working lunch My goal since it's sunny outside is that I would like to keep on working through this So we can get done sooner and faster and be done and go enjoy the cold sun Back to I don't know if we yes, we can go back Talk about community member to individual director Um after it

213says if if the director does not know the question like if they know the question you can answer it If they don't know it it goes to the superintendent or president We can request a response superintendent or president receives the Request they provide the additional information to the director Would we not have a from the director? Box going back saying okay the director then responds back to the community member that was From our previous work session. I forgot to so the previous one we did discuss that I needed to Draw an arrow from that to to finish that loop. Okay, because I put it on the last one. Yeah I did not send I didn't send Aaron or Adriana the updated to follow up with the arrow So I wanted to get through it all

214before I send them the final revision But point taken I have it here Any other questions comments? I think this go ahead One quick one I just thought about is that when things come to the school board we do respond all so though everyone is getting that response So if there's one that we've missed, um, definitely let us know But when something comes in the school board Um, either all responding or director van is ready our former Our director alvarez has been responding to them, but they are going reply all The other thing I was just gonna add is like before we move on. I'd like to director hoggle so she can come back because I know He'll give her a chance to come back and give people So just uh and in regards to

215our communication expectations, this is an ongoing thing So if we need to check and adjust then we'll we can do that. But just some expectations And it's on the the last page here Directors can respond with information But cannot speak on behalf of the board only the board president can do that um You know directors have a constituent management as part of their jobs So just responding back just say, you know what if a direct if if a community member responds to you say, you know what? I got it. I got your message Let me follow back up with board president or the superintendent so he or she knows what's going on out there It's just you know the professional courtesy That you discussed earlier um what if we have like, um You mean a

216member that reaches out to a board director And it's of someone else's district we wrap that director in as well because if you can't have the Chair and that person straight and yourself right? So, how do you go about? Making sure that director knows about an issue that's happened in their district and the board chair It's not an opium a violation if you're not voting on something. It is just an fyi. So Let's just say I I send out an email to everybody just fyi But if we're not voting and it's just fyi holly, what are your thoughts? It's not an opium a violation if you're not voting and if you're not discussing So if an email is sent to multiple directors What you can't do is respond back. Oh joe. I think that's a

217great idea Let's make sure that we blah blah blah because then you're getting into discussion So it's voting and discussion the violation of the opium a So an email without it doesn't go anywhere It doesn't go anywhere meaning there's not like replies happening back and forth. Just just a simple. Thank you would be sufficient. Yeah Actually That could be a discussion Oh, I guess that's what i was trying to say. Okay. Um, so I took a big bite and I was trying to remember What I was trying to say what i'm trying to say though is um in relation to what you just mentioned director tit home or director, um petrini, um the idea that Like if I if there's a concern that's brought up and a board director says hey I have there's this

218concern that i'm hearing about or there's this concern that I have based off of conversations and um People a board president or board chair goes to meet with someone in that board director's area It is really important that board director is informed and invited or provided an opportunity to say what they would like to see um in terms of what type of communication so like uh, Hold on. It's ringing. I want to make sure it's not my children. Um It is my children. Okay. So, uh Something happens in your area your director area whether or not you know about it You should be informed and or provided an opportunity to to share something thinking around it as the representative of that area So things happen at mount rainier Sometimes I don't know about them and

219other people are acting and sometimes I do but i'm not given the opportunity I remember quite clearly over a year ago. I was like well, here are some things that are happening Let's go sit down and have a conversation with the mount rainier leaders. It's still not happened Um, and this is a year later and yet i'm the representative for the area Those things are unacceptable to me as a director representative of that area If something has happened at a school if i'm asking for it I would like an opportunity to sit down and have a meeting And even if i'm not asking for and i'm not informed or aware someone should let me know i'm the representative of the area So when i'm out and about with the community, I don't want to hear

220from our community people saying director hago Someone did something at the school. Do you know about it? And like well, you know, I I appreciate now that we have these um, Uh pieces of information that's coming from communications. Let us know but but then there may be a meeting and I didn't know about it Or there may be there may be a conversation with people in our area And I did not know about it and was not provided to have a seat at the table. That's unacceptable So as we're talking about communication board directors, especially if it's in your representative area Should be either provided an opportunity to say I would like a meeting and let's have it and not push aside Or provided an opportunity to say I am having a board meeting Would

221you like to come and participate as the representative of the area? So this day it's not happened for my area Thank you any other comments So the communication expectation and director patrina you you did talk about this responses will be made within a week So that gives us some time right to Gather the data or the the correct response To get back to them, but a simple i'll get back to you on that would would be sufficient I will Finish up on the chart Um If there isn't any changes i'll give you guys until the end of the year if if there's any recommend other recommendations Please let me know and then i'll finish the flow charts and get that back to Adriana to print out for us and to have in our binder There

222it is Um at one of our work retreats when we talked about this being a goal We had talked about doing this together is one of the things that we do together And I I did send in quite a bit of thoughts around this and I don't see I see some things included in some other Things not included. I think i'll just send it out to the whole board team so everyone knows those thoughts I send them back in june And i'm trying to read through them and I don't it's it's a lot So I have to can you refresh can you send it back to the top, please? Yes, I will send it back to the top, but there are additional areas of communication. I think we need to look at Like for example

223when someone's asking me for media comments, uh, i've not commented I've always just left it to the board president but there have been times where things that i've said have been taken out of context or Things that i've included have been taken out of context and it's important that I do Clarify some of those things that are taking out of context. So when we have media requests Uh, i've left it to the board president before but my my voice hasn't been included and or my My comments have been misconstrued So I intend to be responding to media, um requests if I if it comes to me But I would like some support with that from our communication department So that's a piece of communication We are this is a part of our role if someone

224asks those questions we respond And again, i've left it to the president before but I think i'll be changing up my practices to make sure I include my voice Because things have been risk misconstrued. Um, so I want to make sure that in terms of our communication flow chart How does how does communication support the board? Our communication department how does it support board members when they have comments or things that they need to relay to make sure it falls within the review of Acceptability, I guess probably the board Can I just see clarification? So are you saying that the right now policy says that the board president is a spokesperson for the board so Nearly every media request will go through the board president Or can you clarify are you saying that you're not

225going to follow that policy now or what are you going to be doing? I'm saying there it is. Uh, no i'm going to still i've always followed that policy and I will continue to follow that follow that policy But just to reiterate that even though the spokesperson is a board president It doesn't mean they they are I believe that it's supposed to be include the voice of the there should be some conversation some dialogue Some hey, this has come up. What do you think? What are your thoughts? It's not just the board president speaks on behalf and as an individual they speak on behalf of the board And so including the board in that response is important. Um, and also the sec that's that's one I will I have no intentions not to follow that

226but what I am saying though is if Sometimes media folks are asking me specifically for my thoughts as an individual board director Which we can do and i've left it to the board president because I trust it that it's going to be A response that includes the voices of all but um, sometimes my words are misconstrued in In blogs or whatever it is and people are taking things out of context that are not accurate And I would like to correct those things because it's inaccurate and it's important that what my thoughts are Conveyed appropriately if it's an individual response to something So my point is in terms of communication support when we're or in terms of communication Um, what does that communication support look like from our communications department for individual board directors before I

227was told, you know, um, Well, i'll just leave it at that. Okay, so I would like clarification on that because I've been board president. So i'm i'm hearing what they're saying. I've never quoted anyone in the media As far as taking things out of context or not letting your voice a lot of the times when the media does Uh call I always make sure check with my vice check with my soup check with communications It's regarding a policy. It's recording something that is happening in the district It has nothing to do with what a board or with what I am even thinking It's about what is currently happening So I like to get like for you to correct it. I like to get uh information as to where I misquoted you as far as Uh

228In the media That I sent out a press because you should have come to me immediately in san jose I've never in my time have quoted any of the board directors as far as stating this is what you said or I've always gone through our communications checked in with my vice check with us, too. I don't respond on my own I Look for what the community's looking at and then make a response But it's nothing has been ever in my time here in the 15 years quoted another I think I think it goes back to what I had discussed earlier Right is is that the context if there is communication especially from the media Is that we we do have our process that they're they're supposed to be reaching out to tova and dr Duran

229and and and asking for that If we're being asked from the media You know, I would recommend is is talking to our comms dr Duran and saying, you know, this is what's being asked. This is what i'm This is what i'm feeling and and just share those thoughts. Um, I think that that is the easiest way to share um And and i'll just add joe that i've had uh in my time here uh multiple Como chiral fox 13 even some at the time some radio stations always wanting to quote like Something happened and it happened to have a latino either student or community and then they look What is your what is your perspective on this and it's like uh, I would always say, you know, um, I have my communications because And I made

230this very clear to someone who wanted to quote me and I told her specifically don't quote me Because what ended up happening is I said something Uh, and they cut the pieces and they said whatever they wanted to say to construe to make their point and so i'm not saying that It's it's just In order to protect myself. I always go through comms and I tell comms like this is what they're asking me Um, this is my thought help me put it together So they can respond so I always I have it on speed dial like if comedian connects with me I will say I have a response prepare contact my head of communications and then I will Yeah president alvarez usually ford's is my my cell number when that happens just like go talk

231to joe I know like um, just another example, you know I I had I think the city town blog that reached out for clarification on something I had said in a meeting So in that I wouldn't need like I cc'd comms to say but like i'm speaking for myself because you're asking me about something Said right so that's well within that Um as another example, maybe to kind of what director haggis is stating and and joe you and I've already had this conversation So if I may use this as an example to learn from Is that uh, you know you and I had a private conversation but then you cited it in a response to media And also in a social media post so just giving that that space to you know Again, we've already

232talked about this. We've worked this out in giving someone a heads up Hey, may I share this because I think that might make statements stronger that you and I had this conversation just because unless I said it, you know publicly Then go ahead and quote it again. That's fine but if it's a private conversation, we don't want to be doing that because that erode trust as well that if i'm having a private conversation with any board director they might use that in a response to media which is again, then unfairly citing a board member without their Okay So, uh president avers I was not I did not indicate I was speaking about you It was this is a general because i've had some things come up over the course of the year the two things

233that I was specifically speaking to Is um one the board president's response out as a spokesperson is a spokesperson on behalf of the board that's my understanding unless i'm wrong someone tell me i'm wrong because uh Being a spokesperson on behalf of the board and not having had any say but here is this now Um crafted uh response it may not reflect the entire board team that's what I mentioned just having an opportunity to be a part of those conversations where If there is going to be something crafted if it's a press release if it's a you know, something that goes out to folks uh that is uh You know a reflective of the entire board team will work at work and send some sort of you know Here's the reflection Board president comments and

234spokesperson ship is to me a reflection of that And so Meaning that it would be helpful and to me quite important that if there is something that's going out on behalf of the board I'm a board member I would like to have my input provided a phone call like you've given other folks or whatever it is or a conversation but also but also hold on so giving other folks meaning our uh Communications not other so that's the other part. So that was the second part So there was an instance where I was asked for um conversation It came the the email came directly to me for my individual input And my request was i'd like to talk with communication to see how I can craft this and that was not given to me So if

235you're having access to talk call communication and say here are my things president if you do have access to communication So that's not that's not available for everybody then so that is something that we need to have a conversation But as board president if I am the spokesperson, yeah Than communications is the one because I don't craft anything on my own Most of the communication that goes out is communication that either requesting clarification on policy What is something that has happened? It is not about what I think it's about facts that have happened. Well, right no facts So I was asked for facts about my my my positionality on things And I had said I would like to talk to board communication My email was a request to have a conversation with board communication so

236my facts can be relayed But that wasn't given it was uh, here's what the board president said and and that was it So i'm just saying in terms of communicate so we're talking about communication in terms of communication and communication access Or or or protocol or however we want to call this Um, if there is an ask for communication support, I would like that to be given that's ultimately what i'm getting what i'm getting to Absolutely, and I think that's something that you'll work with your current board Or your new board president is to how that but for me seeing also the value of making sure that If anything is coming to a board that the board president is aware And if there is a message that the board president is as a spokesperson They

237do have uh with communications because they are the spokesperson To relay back to the board member as far as you know what the communication and that's going to be on joe But what i'm saying is that there's a lot of times that we want to have access to all these other things when You know in reality, I mean we are thinking about staff time we're thinking about you know, what does this entail another They already have planning to do and that's why we have the board president because he should be fielding out all of those Um opportunities and I think I I keep hearing you the hearing use the word access access No one gets denied access As far as I can see Uh, it is the opportunity for us to think about how it

238is it? Is it that it's being denied access or is it that we're also trying to figure out how to um make this in a make it a smoother Process for all of us because imagine if our communication is only answering to us or not only but in addition to us What is their workload? Because many of us get a lot of requests and so for me to be Connecting with their comps like 10 000 times in a week or something because at times when things go down You get a lot of you'll get a lot of uh requests from community, especially right now There's a lot of craziness happening with with many things and so Also being aware of their work, but also it is a process that we have down Uh, and so

239I think joe has i'll just name it better relationship with you all and things might a lot better that's coming uh so I agree staff need we need to be i'm always cognizant of our staff and our staff time My requests only come when I believe it's absolutely necessary and they're very few my requests are very few in terms of asks for help but um but uh I was just mentioning that in terms of our um process Uh what those communications support and communications protocols are going to look like I would like that to be included. I'm making sure that I emphasize that Adding to the conversation, but I think it's been really awesome and um important it's important for us to kind of iron out these um I I have to leave at 115

240because I have a My son has a concert two o'clock. So I know we're working on a board assessment You didn't say that at the beginning I'm so sorry. Well, I did tell you at the end of the last meeting. I said I'll have to leave early And you said we could start earlier and I said 6 a.m. And you I was up. I was ready to go No, thank you very much so in regards to our board self-assessment, that's really Just doing a dipstick of where we're sitting at Q1 of 2024 and q3 of 2024 This is going to This was part of our previous um works or our Work retreat but due to the cyber thing the whole thing got pushed off This was going to help us with our board goals for

241for the the year. Um, and I would really just Wanted us to look at this individually and say, okay What are the things that we need to work on and what should our board goals be for? for the The remainder of this year we have six months left and at the end of this month or at the end of this year We're going to take another self-assessment to do another dipstick check for the 25-26 school year so it's going to be a full calendar school year, right? I want to get us back into a repetition of us Taking this and seeing where we're at and seeing what we can work on So that's what we're going to work on for the board assessment So you're going to miss out on a little bit, but you

242have some homework to do And I expect it to be there tomorrow morning. Okay, um So the board the the communications piece Are are we good with that? I just also wanted to add that you know, uh going back to the media is that it's it's um important for us to really Uh be aware That you know a lot of times they publicize one very one-sided as to they don't publicize all Of what's happening and for us to be aware as they connect with us like what is it that they're communicating out there? Um, that's why I tend to not um Uh talk directly to the media for that purpose Like I said, i've had that happened to me in the past Where um, i'll say one thing and then they cut out a piece

243and then they said well she said this But even seeing some of the blogs now, they're very one-sided to only um Support some of the views and not all and so being aware that that also puts us in a difficult position as a board as a whole Uh and just being aware anything else Yeah I'll send i'll bring you to the top. Um, the I spent a lot of time in the summer Uh kind of thinking through some of these pieces because I promised I would contribute to this work Um, and so i'll send it out to the team. Um, so everyone can see what I put together To support the communication things and then decide if there's if there's an interest in what is in the in that um In that document for communication

244um protocols No, thank you so much in regards to that We did miss the the media part and I was just lumping that in with the community emails So I think just uh clarifying who and what and all that fun stuff would be cool. Thank you Okay, online board self-assessment survey. We might be done by the time Oh, that's the way we're going. Let's go This is um Director hoggis, thank you so much for having us redo this uh get back into the The cadence of doing this I thought when I first came on the board in 2015 ish 16 it it was done a few times and and then we fell off of it because of just we just got busy Um, and once it got was brought back. I was like wow I

245was really really amazed on Where where we were then and where we were at now and this kind of helps us guide And lead us on what we should be working on as a team Okay, but also as a team as as directors, but also with with the district and the superintendent on on getting us to that next level the goal Was to have us do the 24 this was done in q3 and to have us come up with our board Goals for the remainder of this year It's almost q three or it's almost the end of the the school year because it's January next year So I would like for us to take a few minutes to go through this individually take about 10 minutes to look at it And then kind of spitball.

246What do what shall we work on as a board? What should our board goals be to end the year with? and and Make some suggestions out there And then at the end of the school year We'll do another assessment for the full year from next year on what our board goals are going to be Yeah in june june julyish I'm not gonna So take about 10 minutes, please take a look And just also a thank you to the directors and adriana for getting us to this quickly. I know that We were able to flip this within a week, but then the directors I only gave you guys two days to really get the This this in knowing that had a hurry up to wait So thank you so much for everybody participating quickly I would

247like for us to um while you're going through the the assessment Look at two opportunities for us to work on for each director and two things that we did really well and We're going to go around the the tables and just really share what those are We have about three more minutes and we'll start sharing Okay I hope everybody had an opportunity to take a look at the 72 questions that that That we took our assessment on um, i'm going to start with president alvarez Two opportunities and two positives can you speak into that? I know that that you know, it's bad when adriana has to come out um I think I want to name it as One of each and it's the same one so question 44 Regarding having a long-term facilities plan in

248place for construction maintenance I think I want to highlight that because I know that we do have a plan, but we also have a bond coming uh wanting to make sure that we Are aware that it can also be a challenge. We have some schools that are in so bad shape Uh such such bad shape I could add and I want to make sure that it is stays really high on our radar as far as Um, some communities already have their schools built and other communities don't and want to make sure that all our students deserve a safe um learning environment and so I want to name that as a positive and also as the Something to that can be a challenge Forward so on here it shows, you know, one of our highest, uh

249positive but also concerning uh forward um and then uh So you're gonna have to come back to me because I didn't I went through it and I didn't mark Okay, I pass and come back around so director tidlmer passing that Thank you Um, I think something that we've been doing well number 51 regularly monitor the budget and fiscal status of the districts Seems like we're pretty much on the same page in terms of that second one I had 20 pages forgive me find it 40 pages while you I found my So we'll toss it back and forth for a second. Um, the other one where I think I think again, it was the same for both good and um challenge not the highest but um Keeping the community informed about our district's financial status It

250didn't rate high and didn't rate horrible, but I think for both purposes i'm rating it as uh, uh That's an asset And that's something to work on that we can always do better And I think I tie it back to our bond like as long as we're keeping our district, uh our community inform our district's financial status, so As forward we can do better, but I feel like we've been Okay based on our feedback So that was question 47. Thank you And if you guys can clarify what question that is so we can just bounce back and forth. Okay, so i'm done Thank you, are you sure because I did say two of The second one I had that we've been doing well number 64 model cultural racial and ethnic understanding and sensitivity We scored

251really well on that, but I think that's also something that we could improve. I think that a lot going on it's a lot of ugly things that have been said So I think that's something that we can and are going to need to work on um also question 66 Follow I think it's also kind of related to to 64 follow an effective process for responding to questions concerns comments or feedback from citizens Looks like we did not score very well on that And something that we can improve as this uh political climate Continues to escalate Thank you, there's a so just we've only gone through two directors But based off of what we're discussing there a lot of the things that we're discussing today is coming to the to the front So I I like

252where this is going director patrini Hurry up. It's time to go Just messing in the world Um, I thought we told this top five. That's what I wrote last time So I picked up five, but I will I'll pair it down. Um Two things that I pointed out. They were good things. Um, obviously budget. I feel like that's where our we really have uh good communication to our to our constituents, um Real great understanding as it's broken down for us In you know 30 000 foot level and then we can get down down into the weeds and kind of understand a little bit better So I really feel like that's something That I mean there's always room for improvement and everything but I feel like that's a real strong point Um, is there a particular

253question? That is under between I put number 47 number 49 talking about budget That's okay Um, and another one was around number seven and number 30 Which is much like gathering input data and how that directs a lot of our decision making So I know that really mindful about those things. Um understanding the data How it's affecting students and where? You know where can we make improvements so I feel like those are things we really do Um some areas have quite a few and I have a couple that i'm like, oh, this would be a great discussion Um, so if I have to pick two off the top of my head Um, I think one that's a really important one number five around our shared purpose. I kind of put in my own questions I

254was reading this um I know we have our district mission and vision but as a board Do we really have shared purpose, you know, we might each be bringing something different at the table different experiences different Um, you know things that are really important to us and priorities But what is that shared thing that we're like, but we're all doing this Want this thing together? So i'm wondering if that's like a statement that we craft. It's just like um Just something that we can say to remind ourselves But even though we can respect each other's differing Where we're coming from and I think that even spoke to one of the other things that I just saw it talked about one of our standards about um, how do I write it down about um bringing together

255different perspectives and and and valuing that And then can we create a shared purpose why we're all here that we all unite around so Um, that's one of the goals I think that we can come up together. Um, another one would be Probably around student achievement. Um numbers 25 and number 28 um being that I know that we have uh new measurements that we're implementing different ways that we're sharing with uh Parents and schools about how our kids are doing um, but Are we actually reporting that out every month maybe like how our students are doing? I know we don't get reports based on um, you know, um panorama and espert and all those things come in quarters and in different times, but Is there a way that we could continue to report? Actions that

256we're taking to be responsive to things that people are asking like as an example Like we've had people keep asking about like hey when are we going to get algebra in grade? You know, can we address that as a board and say this is why we do or do not, you know Why are we not doing that in some schools? Why do we have these opportunities because I think people have these questions We're not always responsive and really getting that information out there. It's almost like Quiet about it. So that's just like an example where we can continue to maybe each month have a Topic that we just do a little report on, you know, we hear there's concerns about this. We're engaging with our With the district and with different schools about around why

257why or why not are they not engaging in that thing? um, I don't know something that just just really Thank you so much for that in regards to number five I mean that that is one of our lower lowest scoring ones and I think That kind of brings us back to what we're doing now looking at the opportunities to say Okay, what are all of our shared visions this this is what we're looking at right and this is what we need to to come up with and I believe that we should as a board come up with our our own goals and visions like every every school our own vision and mission and stuff like that, so um, I like that I think that uh, well just reading from the um from the data there

258were a couple of things that I wanted to Highlight as far as what um you were saying in terms of the things that are going well I think um collectively from what showed on our um report is standard three um in our collective ratings we What I saw overall was that we believed that we are creating conditions district-wide for student and staff success That's the one I can't remember the number. Um, I just remember it's a part of standard three That was one area where it was the least amount of decline but and highest rating Which I appreciated. I think that it should be One of our top priorities to make sure that the that our staff and students have great conditions for success um, and the other area is um I saw that there

259were some consistent positives in our report about Delegating authority to the superintendent to manage district operations and to implement policies um, and the other one is the I agree with um With dr alvarez in terms of the long-term facilities plan, I believe that's a strength Of ours and it's pretty strong Statement to show that we care about our Facilities for our kids to have safe and and educational environments that match their needs So, uh, those are some of the things that I saw that were positive. Um, and so for the facilities one that's question 44 Um, and then the other uh, the delegation is question 10 on standard one um, and then areas for opportunity um, I saw spaces, uh along standards one One uh two and five but uh, it really is uh, you

260know govern using policies that align with research-based best practices So, you know, I do look for um research whenever we're talking about policy In policy changes or policy adaptation and so that's interesting to me is learning and going back to well What does this match in terms of research best practices? Um, the other one is uh treating all individuals with respect question 18 shut up in our data is one that needs some attention um, and then the other areas have to do with um Using it's still standard one, but it's uh, so i'm cupping standard one into one one big, uh Statement in terms of those areas of opportunities but standard one question 20 21 Using a collaborative process that results in well-informed problem solving and decision making amongst our team um and The question

261so for that those are all the ones for a standard one for center two It's a question 25 fostering a culture of collaboration around the shared purpose Of student of improving student achievement um and uh The last one is one that i've been kind of um ringing for a while now is looking at some way that we can communicate Um performance expectations or sorry communicate district. Um performance to the public I still like the sound of state of state of schools address and that's one that I continue to go through Oh, what question? Yeah, hold on question number. So it's standard for question 57 is communicating performance expectations To our community and that one i've been ringing that bell for a while So that's one that I think that we need to get to In

262some form of passion where it's not just a report or something that's on our on our dashboard But we have engaged our stations with our community as a whole where everyone is invited to a state of school To dialogue with our people about uh, you know championing what's going well and showing how Thank you so much for sharing that director hoggis so my um So I got two pros and this I mean this It looks like a couple other directors have said this is is the fiscal responsibility number 49 through 51. It's it's For us to be where we're at from a financial standpoint. We're sitting good Where we we took steps to get where we need to be But you know like what jackie said as well as dr. Duran going, you know what

263we We're okay right now, but they're still going to look at other opportunities making sure that we're efficient doesn't mean that There may not be cuts, but they're they're gonna keep on looking at opportunities and i'm Thankful for that. So please share that with her The other pros was question 15. This is around collaboration with colleagues across the region I'll tell you that our board has The whole region the whole state it within its touch Um 249 districts we we have the pulse amongst the five of us okay, and and seeing that Also happen at wasda where just you know me standing back and just watching you guys work your magic and just talking to everybody And anybody that was really powerful to see that And I and I like when you guys bring the

264information. Hey, this is what so-and-so does How would it look in our world? um, I really appreciate that so that was one of the the pros and it was one of the higher things that we got scored on here the two opportunities that Were really telling to me was one that director hago's product was question 18. This is treating all board Members staff community with respect This is from joe's experience Um this last few years is that we all have our own individuals wise Sometimes we are passionate about it. Sometimes we're not and and I I know we can do better and that's one of the things that I would like to work on this next year and just ongoing is that we have our own reasons and And I brought this up to you

265Previous director howell that says you know what my friend We've had our differences You you told me you're wise and and it helped me change my look and views of things and And I took it And I and I thanked her for it and and I want us to model that moving forward is like there's a reason why you guys are Sharing what you're sharing. Please tell me your wise you may not like it, but just give me the space to share it And the other one was question 13 around governing using our policies Um Some of our our policies are outdated But not knowing how our governing What our governance model is going to be it kind of puts us to rock in a hard place So we work with what we have but

266also going How does this benefit our kids? So working on those two things this next year is going to help us lead us guide us on on Where we need to be focusing on dr. Viran, you're a part of this too. So I did you have an opportunity? Okay No, he did not he did not participate So this i'm gonna give us, you know, maybe 10 15 minutes really just to go around the table again just based off of what we shared with with each other I mean I'm i'm gonna put this into the scramble and and kind of have it spit back out to us What we should what we should be working on you guys agree or disagree with what we shared with each other? I mean I just want to have this

267to be open thoughts, uh, I was just gonna say I think we have uh, I want to say our board goals go to june ones that we created last week. So we still have board goals One of them had to do with um the communication One of them had to do with was that Uh, you know working towards being all the That's correct. And there was a third goal Oh, it was the community Conversations the community outreach that I thought that was I thought that was all last year That's the reason why we did it for life. So we did it from january till june and then That's when we were gonna do we're gonna do the the board calendar Versus or the the school calendar versus the the fiscal. Okay. So now this is

268space for new So this like kind of what we've discussed right now, okay So this one is going to be through june. We were hoped we were hoping to get this Last quarter so we can finish the remainder of the school year with Thanks for clarifying. Um, I think that you know, just in hearing some of the things that we've shared around the table Um going back to because we didn't necessarily complete or have those conversations around being a board of distinction and it's less about The recognition of this distinction but going through the process I think helps improve our board work and so That to me is still important looking at those Pieces that indicate best practices for school boards and what it looks like and how those best practices translate into improvement for

269the school district Uh, you know, i'm always looking at our students and our staff So I do want to see how it translates to them in particular But um, that is to me is still one that's uncompleted that I feel like we should put some energy into again Less about the certificate of distinction, although it's pretty that's not what i'm interested in I do believe working through that process will help us get to a space that we want to be in as a board team So the board of distinction, what are the criteria does that come out in april? It is basically the same criteria But it's different topics year Year over year. No, it's the it's it's a pretty standard. I mean it does have had years of deviation, but Um, most of the

270time it's just it's criteria you have to meet and standard criteria as far as the same So we could be looking now for year one for next year or the following year or the following um, but I think something that uh is I think crucial as we think about that. Um Is that? um A lot of it we get to do it already Uh, it's how we're doing it. I think the amount of time I think a bit of a nuisance I think for it's a lot of gathering of data And it puts just a lot of time for our staff uh for for our report, uh and Uh, we already see some of that data as we when they're presenting to us and stuff So but because it has to all be actual so

271it it just Um, it is a nice certificate. We've had it before part of that um, but I think it's just really thinking about uh, Are we? a boarder in the district really Because it's about the board but the board is you know supporting the superintendent to For the superintendent district, so I don't know. I I have a lot to I have a lot to say nothing um for me, I think that Ultimately, we want some of the same things I think all of us want our babies to succeed And to be prepared for their future and not just you know Get their diploma to get a diploma um, I think that How's we go about it doesn't always look the same um, so I would very much like For us to build that trust

272and to get on the page Um, I think that like the end goal, right is to get our baby scores up in all of the aspects And some of us might be going this road and some of us going that road But understanding that like it's not how we get there. It's the most important It's just that we get there and sometimes we're gonna have to look at what we're doing and pivot and make adjustments or compromises Um, but yeah just to build that trust so we can actually work on that because it's so counterproductive to just You know the time that's wasted And not making any progress just nobody wins when the family feuds So I would love to see that happen this year I mean aside from the game because obviously the game's

273amazing, but The game is fabulous. We love watching in our household family feud is our top one of our top things to watch Um, it's just to kind of reiterate it was already a goal that we approved We approved it on the dais that we would be working on board of distinction It was a goal that we said we were going to work towards and we haven't done it So i'm just saying I would like to see it get back to it and and to me It's the process of working through it. I think there's already best practices that would help us like the The process of going through it would help with what you're saying Director to home in terms of things that we can do to get there and saying with director alvarez

274and so on and so forth So I think kind of what you're sharing in terms of what you would like to see That process itself would help us to it's a kind of like a guiding light So that we're not kind of well, what framework should we use what protocols should use? It's already established here are some things that we know help schools to be a board teams to be successful in schools You know what I mean? It's already created. It's not something we have to recreate and find out Well, what protocols should we use? You know if you're I don't necessarily I've worked but no i'll just i'll leave that one out But my point is that in terms of having to identify new protocols or find out ways to process this or kind

275of leave it Up into the air is much more concerning to me than saying we already know there's a process out there It's with an association that we are in alignment with and so using that Associations protocols and processes to indicate what does a board distinction look like and it's not something I think we're going to magically do in one year, but it can be it would probably even be a multi-year process I don't know But again, we've already approved it in a dais on one of our agenda items So it's not something we're asking to do again. I'm just saying it hasn't been done and i'd like to see us pursue it Thanks for the clarification on that And being part of a board of distinction doesn't mean it has to be all peachy,

276right? It could be like you said ugly and messy and say, you know what? We've got to this point and share with that 2016 you were part There and during that process there's certain things you So there's a list of things that you do. There's things that you are focusing That year it was 2016 And it was uh Tyrone bernie michael joe and myself And I remember focusing on equity and it being Really messy as we gather data as we uncovered things other data but also It was really telling what direction we were going it was right and it clearly was But it was um, it was a process I remember, um It was a process. All right um and Director patrini, I know I did this was way back when when I did say

277that to bring five So if there are other ones that you guys want to bring forward If you guys can shoot me an email and i'll put those in in a format and i'll work with dr Duran our secretary I love saying that Well, we're working on on looking at what our board goals are going to be and bring that back to the board and And just share all of that. This is some really important things and I appreciate you guys sharing what your thoughts and um, Your whys around that I just wanted to add, you know, I they're going back around. I had originally had also worked number 18 and then I cross it out Measure that because I know it says on here Whatever you pick, you know Can you build a goal

278with something that's specific measurable achievable relevant time-bound? I was like, I don't know how you do that But I sounds like order distinction sounds like it would be a pathway to help us actively be working with ourselves and with each other and saying and I think with that we would build that um the other ones I had also pointed out just as part of this conversation was number 19 and number 21 and they talked about um Trying to achieve mutual trust and commitment with the superintendent using collaborative processes with each other in well-informed problem-solving decision making You know again all of that that takes all of us. There's not one person that can change what's happening in the board This is this is all of us together and um, I remember when we had Was

279it marissa from wasda the very first quarter tree who? Amy amy had talked about You know that they tied student achievement directly to board governance to the weight to function of the board Really did trickle down for our students. And so if we have that in mind, you know you know like Having conversations with each other even if we don't want to but knowing what our shared purpose is At what we're working towards which really should all come around back to the student student achievement Why they're in school why they're here Um, so if we can again, I guess that goes back to the shared purpose Crafting that kind of statement, but we're all here Might really help us Come back together Thank you so much for that Directors any other questions or comments? Okay.

280Well that looks like that concludes our meeting for today For about an hour and 10 minutes. I I do want to give uh, dr Duran an opportunity if there are anything else you would like to share dr d any any upcoming things um, and then also before the Intended I was just thinking um This is something I you keep continuing And I I agree. I think if we're going to be looking, uh at Different, uh board governance models. I mean, I think that we should make it a goal then To have one of our goals is to really look into it We need to really look into it and it is a long process even if we decide that's the route we're going It's not like tomorrow. We change governance. We have to go Training

281there's a lot of things that come into that. I know districts who've done that It's taking sometimes one to two year process in order for them to go through that whole process. So I think um, uh newly elected president van that that should be that I recommend that should be one of our um uh Board goals is to have that is to look into since we said we're gonna do it make it a goal I agree and that's something that i've mentioned before that i'm interested in doing like really looking into All of the different governance models and potentially adopting one Are we working on board goals right now because I wasn't i'm not prepared for This this was a recommendation to throw into the pot for them It's for next time so we don't

282lose it because we've been talking about it and we do a lot of talking at times And then we don't and it's great thought and then later says hey I thought I said this that way It is something that is noted that when we do set our goals that that is something that we've already Have a lot of discussion. So when are we going to be determining what we want for board goals? Well, I was Yeah today. Well, I was thinking on the time Um Yeah, that's what I was going to say is that yeah, I thought that um, I think it's based on a conversation I just say that you know, I think the governance is I mean, that's a big piece. That's uh beginning from the next six months Couple that with the

283legislative and some of the other work we're doing around, you know student outcomes and data monitoring It's a big piece. So I think as you all consider what your goals are Um really think about just the time and commitment that's involved in that um, both from your end and from our end But I do think the governance piece will definitely take a lot exciting about you know when we did the street data book study That was done over numerous meetings and you know, it took us Yeah It took a long time to get through that whole book and we got to be a little bit more fast track on that And I think we'll be able to do that with some support from uh wasta and with our our team being able to support the

284board on that, but I think between that and um getting some of the clarity around some of the The Outcomes that we want to achieve is I think if you are really going to be Looking at the board of distinction the board of distinction specifically talks around, you know Gaps that you want to specifically close and change and I know for me as we've been uh Anxiously waiting for all of our systems to come back online one of the biggest frustration for me after this one is that we still Are not able to get to the data that we want to have because we want to be able to see some cohort data And I think once we have that I think that would really be good Information for the board to see like for

285our students that have been in highline for x amount of time you know, how are they doing because that's a something I really feel like we ultimately have to be accountable for When thinking about students that are here new to our country, you know from second grade, you know They're not going to be efficient on third grade. I've said this before but I want to be able to be clear on what is the outcome that we want to focus on and that's part of the Board criteria for that distinction categories thing about gap that you have identified Um in addition, you know in the conversation we have at seattle times editorial board this week We had a great conversation around our inclusionary work and the things we're really trying to do to support our students

286who receive special education services and Since then i've been you know, really thinking about like how how are we doing in that area? And what are those outcomes? I know our students That receive those services are in the least restricted environment That's one of our goals of our strategic plan right now and that's a significant outcome, you know So there are some things that we're doing that are really Um that I think are really good and I think we as a you know team talk about like What else would we be measuring this area? Can we look at you know, how are students doing? You know with their individual Goals, you know for special education students, I think we would probably see some real bright spots there. So Again, just look forward to the conversations.

287We're going to have to think about how we make a difference for our students Thank you so much. And um, I do apologize. I only read the first little sentence there so We are going to work on our board goals. We have an hour and 10 minutes. So the two things that um Were brought up was our governance model and then also the board of distinction. What else? From what we just shared what else would you guys like to add? and And we can vote on this at the january 8th meeting right now It's just spitballing some things to throw out there to Finish off the year with but I think this is a good opportunity just to throw that as you know some some more things Out there I just thought I thought one

288of those the shared purpose. Maybe we each could craft a one-sentence statement of our why and see if there's any overlaps and then we can kind of like See how we can kind of merge them together to say, you know, this was this was a shared of all board directors So craft craft a shared purpose craft a shared purpose They like give us, you know through three weeks to kind of come up with it Maybe send it all to you and you can kind of just say oh, these were all very similar It's a similar thread That went through all of us that The other one was um student achievement. It's just top of mind every everything we're doing boils down to that so whether that's um Uh better communication about it whether that's more

289um Community engagement for them to share what what they're experiencing. So I know we had our goals last year of um, you know board engagement board member engagement with our community we can still either continue to do that or What would that look like to have all five of us, you know? Be like a panel and be able to ask those questions. Are we able to do that? Just so people feel like there's that you know Whereas when we're up here on the dais, right? They're just speaking to us There's no like and forth would there be an opportunity for us to have more sitting down here on chairs with them engaging conversations all together And have that maybe like quarterly so people could just ask those questions that they keep emailing us and we're

290not Quite getting those answers to I don't know just That is a great question To be honest with you. I may not have the answer Um, and and I would rely on dr. Duran and staff to help me with those specifics Because I may not know but you know, I just director man's sorry to interrupt But I'd just like to add that there's a lot of times we keep getting the same questions Because they're not getting the answers. They won't I know it's been in a couple of instances And that doesn't mean we're not responding and we're not being and we're not listening a lot of times when we don't get then We come with the same. I mean we hear some of the same Questions coming up. They do have responses to some and

291some you know and and I get it there's things that are passionate to me and I want to get those things done, but is It doesn't mean that i'm not getting a response when I don't or I can come here and And ask the same question over and over make the same comment over and over Um either because i'm not understanding or because i'm not Hearing what I want to hear or because changes are not happening that I want because i've talked to um someone who listens pretty much all the time on on Sees it online is viewing it's streaming and This particular person reached out and was saying, you know, I have many of the same questions Uh, and I said, well have you What are the questions until it was drilled down to

292um, and they still said, you know, I know you're you're not Basically, I wasn't giving her the answers that they wanted. So clearly I was not listening So a lot of times is you know, we could we could have these open questions again many moons ago We had community conversations in different parts of the and it was solely the board director And a lot of times another board director and it was just there with the community And it wasn't about come tell me the only the bad or the ugly or only the good it was like having conversations and those were in order for Community to feel that they could speak There was no staff involved whatsoever because this is what's listening. It wasn't for us to respond Some of the things we knew some

293of the things we didn't know and what we didn't know then we grab then we make sure that you know, we Got their contact information so then we can make contact back again, but this way they could speak freely To what was on their mind? And it was it? Staff there so they could answer because this was not a q a is A lot of times we turn it into q a but if it's a truly listening It's not about answering at the moment. It's just truly listening to what you have to say So there's different options. I would say, um, I don't know what the opportunities are now, but I just think something for us to think about that, um We could sit here and go, you know how you know, it's just a

294bounce back. Like you say something I say something And we might not ever come to an agreement or it could be let's listen to what people have to say and then They figure out how to respond but I don't know Those are all Have happened. I think every every season comes with different responses needed. Um You know, like anytime I have a kid who asks me the same question And i'm like, do you really think at the hundredth time i'm going to change my my They do think that yes, they do But really then sometimes when I start probing more beyond than what I think I know about why they're asking that Sometimes something else comes out and then I realize that yes answered a different answer needs to be given If we have community

295members or parents who are asking the same questions Maybe we do have to look at ourselves Are we are we looking at it from our perspectives of what we think that they're asking and they're not getting what they want? so, you know, we're just not going to answer them anymore, but Really? I think people just want to feel like we do care and if if it is that hundredth time that they ask We're giving that I know that's our own personal time and that's individual to every board director what they feel like they can give um, but I feel like that's what our our our calling here is it necessitates so Just having those open dialogues is important individually But as a board to show a unified front like we're here to answer your questions

296We're not just up here to lecture to you, but we want to give you those those answers that you're looking for If you have further questions, i'll meet with you one on one and we can discuss this more So I can better understand where you're coming from, you know Those those kind of responses go so far and pay out huge dividends when people like hey I was heard I was respected and I just wasn't given like a short no or a short answer That was the easiest thing to give so just it just I don't know investing in our community Whoever they are investing in the community. I think it's important. Absolutely. And I just to clarify I don't think as far as I know we don't sit up there and just lecture to our

297community because that's not We're here to do business as far as and not lecture community If someone is disrespecting our staff or students or our community, absolutely I will speak But i'm not here to learn Here to learn as well But we have comments that they can't uh, but if they're going to be disrespecting our students community Uh, we will I will speak And one part um, I love the idea of the purpose of that idea and I think that could come Through some of the work with um the governance model When amy cas was here last, you know, um, you know, i'm very familiar With policy governance, you know And if you go look at some of the elements around policy governance, even when it first starts talking around the board Organization, there's like

298clear almost expectations around what a board does like we'll follow the law And I think you can have a lot of freedom and flexibility in that space to be able to come up with What you would identify as the purpose um of the board that would tie directly to The governance work which I think could tie directly to the outcomes work which could lead to um, okay Thank you patrini for your suggestions. I think that shared vision Uh, well, I don't think it's actually one that we have all said is one of our lowest points um in our own self-assessment Uh is committing to a cleared and shared purpose is one of our lowest points um even lower than that one that's lower than that and that is um our Bottom is using a collaborative

299process that results in well-informed problem solving and decision making that is our bottom Um meaning across the board. We do not feel that this is happening From from reading this data point and one of the things that i'm thinking if we're coming up with goals Is a goal around i've heard of other districts who have these beautiful protocols for agenda setting that includes all board directors And decision making that includes all decisions of each and every single board director to come to a consensus and I would like to see us look for and identify a process for agenda setting and Consensus and decision making however, we want to call it whatever we want to say it is 1.8 is our average for this very low scored Actually the bottom of our um, it's question 21.

300It's the bottom of um the issues that we're having as a board team So in our own self-assessment, this is one that we identify as our lowest point in terms of deviation and um one that I think should be a board agenda, um, or a board goal for 2020 What are we what are we calling it? We're doing a school year 20 or just 25 2025 like wait I can't I can't remember what we're doing with this. Sorry. I lost track here But whatever it is that we're calling it. It should be it definitely needs to be a goal It is the one that's indicated as our lowest um, and then second to that would be the shared goals, so Um real quick on that before you go Can you share what district does that

301process because i'd be curious to look to see what their governance model is I believe amy's um, not the governance model, but I think uh, amy caswell is north shore I believe north shore just off the top of my head just off but but I also there are some others i'll have to Uh consult with my um cohort peers, but there are others. I want to say bethel Um, but again, don't quote me on bethel because I that's just from conversation So i'll have to i'll have to check in with my cohort peers, but um, there are a few of them that have great. Um What do they call them protocols? You know check-ins? Expectations whatever it is that you want to call it. The idea is just that there is uh, everyone's voices to

302the table all Everything is brought together and then we decide as a board team. So there's some consensus around it It's it looks beautiful to me when I saw it So i'll let you know those other districts when I come and learn who they are. Can I offer what you just named? Is the reason why you all need to have the governance model discussion In the governance model that you're currently under you do not live in a consensus model You live in a model where the president and the vice president are the ones who have authority along with the superintendent to do things like set agendas Um, whether it be for the board meeting or for the board retreats or whatever And I know that uh, the historically the president vice president have heard what

303people have said and bring those things to the table As joe mentioned earlier, we have a list of retreat possible items. That's about Three feet long And obviously we can't do three feet worth of work in five hours um, but again That is the governance model question And so if you have as a goal researching Understanding current governance model what's working and what's not? Researching additional governance model. What are the pros and what are the cons what would need to change? That can get you if you land on that type of governance model To a consensus model or to a different distributed leadership model But again under the current model that you are in we are in It is not a consensus model So I would offer say that your board goal should be around

304viewing governance models And then out the outcome of that is landing on a governance model and then making sure that our processes and protocols Match that governance model. So if you land on a consensus based governance model, then absolutely You would look at changing how you do agenda setting how you do retreat agendas, etc, etc but To do it in the reverse is putting the cart before the horse Maybe just a protocol for now. Um Again, it's because it's stated as our lowest it's an I think we should address our lowest issue in some form or fashion for our goals while we're getting to The other pieces that you've that you've mentioned So I still would like to see a goal around it in terms of what we do for this year Rather than wait,

305it's caused enough problem and i'd like to address it um, and then the the just right after that the second, uh Lowest areas have everything to do with student achievement and the work that we do with student achievement like question 32 There's you know checking and reviewing student achievement regularly, and then there's um question 25 fostering a culture of collaboration around Improving student achievement and so the student achievement part pops out a couple of times. There's our second Lois indicated that data point in terms of deviation from the self-assessment report So I don't know off the top of my head What that would look like I know the governance model that i've researched and how that addresses our lowest point um, but uh That's I don't know unless unless you've got some bright ideas around

306that Uh director man, I don't that's the second lois and i'd like to see a goal around that and see what we can do to improve it Well, we we have six months to finish off the year or school year and I would recommend that we build two or three goals using our our smart goals And I think the governance model Is is going to be our driver for a lot of these things It's going to dictate what we do how we do it and and to to to craft all that I'm not saying that we can't reach out to amy and north shore and see what they're currently doing and see if we can Do some quasi and looking into that But I I want to put realistic goals out there that we can

307achieve Before the end of the school year. I don't want to throw everything out there and go Let's try for it and maybe we'll get it. I would start with the smart smarter Achievable goals that we can at least go for and I believe These work well hand in hand in regards to the governance model if we get that That that will help us craft our shared purpose. I still believe director petrini where we can Craft our own shared vision and put that all together and see what what that would come up with it doesn't hurt, right? But then that can also lead us into a board of distinction We went through this entire process from a to z and guess what it was messy, but we got there So I think that all works

308the collaborative process Number 21 that is all going to be dependent on the governance model But there's nothing wrong with us tweaking what we have now. I say let's go see what else is out there and and come back Yeah, I actually just did a poll so I belong to a 51, uh board member across the nation cohort board partners and um just asked like Who sets the agenda? ultimately, you know uh they said uh And i'm getting and now everybody's timing in but ultimately the chair uh vice chair and superintendent uh Final decision days with chair and vice chair uh the stoop, uh is there but ultimately the chair and vice chair are the ones who um Have the final it's coming 51 Thank you for sharing that and asking that question. Um You

309know our the board chair and vice chair meet once a month To discuss the following month's agenda Maybe a proposal Is that once we finish that and just know that not all the bars are written up yet So you you will not get the full Kit and caboodle but know that this is what we could be discussing and we could send that out If we discussed it and say, you know what? This looks good. This is uh, A draft policy or a draft proposal and we kick that to the board that could be something that we could do And so you guys can um, so we all know What is going to be coming up the next month? Thank you. Thank you. Do you have anything? I see you're all packed up and ready to

310go. Um I was gonna say can we do polls during a work meeting to ask for insight from can I call my community people and say Hi guys, this is what we're talking about. Can we get can I do that? Like I don't know if that's because I don't think I can do that And I you know, i'm a little worried because that opens up the door of people being able to because I can just do the same Thing and say hi cohort people. What do you think about this and then bring it to the table? I'm a little worried. Maybe yeah, maybe I should have done that but uh, you also bring in that So this is what you did at your cohort This is a cohort that I did too as well and

311just revisiting some of the questions because those questions came up That's why I went in and you go in there and check You can get if you can get that type of response that quickly from a cohort for information hick. Yeah, that's good information This is Us up to during our meetings, can we go and talk to our constituents can I talk to my people or can I talk to my Friends, this was a cohort of board directors that I because you just went through a cohort. I did too and I just pulled it So can we get clarification holly about policy? Is there a policy that states it? well, we Well, we don't have a governance model. So do we have a policy or? Opm, is there any violation and asking that? We're not

312making a decision on it and it was information that I gathered just like you holly from your cohort This was my cohort that we went through that worried about what i'm worried about then is then can I go and say like can I start using my phone and text my People that I know and say this is the con this is what we're talking about Can you give me some feedback and then bring it back in real time? I thought that's something that we I don't know. I thought that's something we can't do an open show I'm worried about what this opens us up to not the response. It's good. I'm glad to get some clarification I think holly even clarified earlier. I'm just worried about that part. So I I appreciate that. I think

313this is another This is being live fed right now. There's a 10 second delay. So it's very similar To them watching and and offering the suggestions and you know one of the the pros that I did throw out There is that we do have connections across the 249 districts that we have our connections that we could reach out into and say Hey, what do you think? This is what we're thinking. What do you guys do? So I think having that communication Is it's critical. I don't think but I holly i'm gonna rely on you in regards to policy. I know that you're No, you so you You all have already talked about you have opportunities and responsibilities to seek information No, you can't talk to people in board meetings, that's not how it works Um

314You know, is there a policy against this particular action? No, I think you all could have a discussion about what you would like to see in terms of soliciting feedback from whomever You know other than being in the moment. It's really not a lot different talking to someone in the grocery store Having coffee with someone soliciting their input Um, so I think that the something the board could have a discussion I come back to your governance model Going to dictate how you do all of these kinds of things and the current governance model is a strict legislative model That works on majority rule and significant power vested in the chair and vice chair And so if you are honestly going to explore governance models, that's a significant amount of work To truly look at what's

315out there and what are the pros and cons of each and what it might mean to change And if that's a board goal, that's going to be a big board goal A lot of work board goal. We said lots of discussion And out of that can come many of these things But you probably cannot do them in parallel You know, the board of distinction example is a great one It's it's looking at something after the fact And pulling data. It's not a real time You know in the moment. Thank you director patrini. That's okay. I'm taking it personally Yeah There you go Right. So you would you would go through the process and then after the fact you might say actually this was such a vibrant Deep process we want to use this as our

316exemplar process for going through a board of distinction Process, but you wouldn't do them together because we wouldn't have the data yet to reflect on What worked what didn't work what changed why you saw the value of vision? Does that make sense? So I think about 2016 it was all backward At the work that we've done and all of the data that we looked at around equity and disproportionality and such It was a heavy lift Okay um, so right now I have four as far as our board goals and i'm i'll send those i'll say it and then i'll send it out and then on our january 8th meeting Um, we can vote on those board goals one is is um coming up with a governance model being board of distinction craft a shared purpose

317and then student achievement and and collaborative process I need to i'm going to follow back up with the directors that did That proposal and come up with the smart goals looking at what what that all means and so we can just put it in together and then we can vote on those Are we cool with that? We're not voting are we? And we would need to route a bar and everything by wednesday If you want to vote on january 8th, I would recommend that uh, we Do not vote on january 8th that we it comes up for uh, For introduction on january 8th so we can vote on the next one because well We would still need and we would still need the bar now for the intro on the 8th So, um, how about

318more to come i'll get back to you guys atvd. Yeah sounds like a plan Are you guys okay with that more more to come? I'll get that out to you and we can uh, once the sooner than the better, but we'll we'll get this taken care of With that I think since uh more to come with all of this These are good conversations and i'm sure we'll be continuing these um And thank everybody for being here on saturday and with that i'll ask for a motion to adjourn I'll make I will make a motion to adjourn I'll second all in favor Any opposed to adjourn? None, we are adjourned. Thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.