CorpusRecord 10186

Prince William County School Board Work Session - January 15, 2025 - Capital Improvement Program

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Prince William County Public Schools
Date
2025-01-16
Location
Prince William County, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,967 words · about 84 min
Collected
2026-06-01

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001William County School Board to order we have an approval of the agenda a motion in order for the approval of the meeting agenda Mr Blake I move that pursuant to Prince William I move that the Prince William County School Board approve the meeting agenda as recommended do you have a second Mr chairman yeah Mr araport I second any discussion all in favor please raise your hand okay any opposed uh unanimous for moving forward moving on to our proposed CIP I'd like to turn over Dr McDade Dr McDade Dr mcdade's not ready all right good evening uh Dr Latif um as you know the capital Improvement program rcip is our management tool for planning the projects needed to house our students can you hear me our annual review of the CIP enables the division to address

002CH changing enrollment patterns and utilize our facilities in ways consistent with sound educational practice and so our CIP provides essentially a blueprint for new constru ruction for renovations and specific projects in response to our student body our CIP is also reflective of the vision mission and values and commitments in our uh pwcs 2025 strategic plan and specifically there are two commitments in our strategic plan that we believe underg guard The Continuous Improvement uh program every year the first one being commitment number two positive climate and culture where we lay the foundation for welcoming environments conducive to learning and building up responsible and sustainable able facilities the second one being commitment for organizational coherence um that's where we ensure that our uh strategic priorities are driving our investments towards addressing growth funding renovation projects to existing

003facilities and focusing on advancing sustainability goals so I do have members of my um team from the chief operating office beginning with our chief operating officer Mr Vernon Bach is here as well as Chief Financial Officer uh Mr Shaquille Yousef they work collaboratively and hand inand with the development of the capital Improvement plan and so they'll be presenting our proposed Capital Improvement program for fiscal year 26 uh uh 2030 and we also have members of their team here as well um that'll be sharing uh basically our um content experts will be here to share any additional information as a component of the presentation so I'm going to hand it over now to Mr Bach and Mr Yousef thank you Dr McDade and good evening uh uh chairman Latif uh board members uh and Dr McDade

004um a few things I'd like to highlight before we jump into the presentation and and we do have several members here uh from our teams uh to support this has truly been a collaborative effort uh and it's been very exciting collaborative effort that started about three months ago and there's a lot of people that supported this effort that are not in the room with us today so I think uh the collaboration a between uh the chief operating officers uh department and Facilities with our counterparts and budget has been very exciting and even more formalized through this process um this is the first time that our CIP will contain uh the full cadry of the facilities condition uh assessment so each score each school has been assigned a facilities condition index score and and just a

005reminder that uh that was accomplished we entered into a partner ship with Mosley Architects to evaluate our buildings and those uh facilities condition assessments really did look at a deep dive into the infrastructure of the building and the bones and the Mechanicals of the building and provide a rating score uh for that also information that we used uh at that we had at our fingertips and again this is a very data Rich process is through our Energy Management sustainability team investment grade audit information on our uh HVAC uh systems um also contained um within the uh evaluation was an educational space evaluation and uh our our spaces up to part of current educational standards and finally we uh part uh utilized our all of our energy management and sustainability measures in uh providing to you

006what we have uh here in our CIP so um I'm going to turn it over to Shaquille to add additional information and then we'll kick off the presentation good evening Dr Latif uh board members and Dr McDade I think this collaborative effort has allowed us to meticulously develop and base our CIP on facility on the facility condition assessment priority uh that gives us a lot of assurance that we're looking at things objectively uh we have also Incorporated the external Consultants to provide valuable input into our uh cost Tes and as this flows into how we look at our uh bond insurance and our F funding sources we've done our best to optimize the use of bond F funding at the same time balancing it with other resources including cash uh at this time I would

007just like to acknowledge the budget and finance team that is here in addition to uh I think ver you will recognize yours um uh Joe mondoro who's our director of budget Kathleen Addison who's our assistant director of budget uh Dave beavers who's our budget and planning supervisor and Ed Ross who manages our debt service and from our facilities team at the table with us we have Scott Hy one of our administrative coordinators in our facilities planning department and we have Jessica wymer supervisor of energy management and sustainability and back with us we have Vance s s Meers supervisor of construction Matt cage uh supervisor of planning and CIP and uh Assam Al Jaber who's our acting director of facilities so with that I'm going to turn it over to uh Mr Hy thank you Mr

008boach uh good evening Dr Latif members of the board and Dr McDade tonight we're going to go over the student enrollment Trends first and then move into the approved and proposed Capital Improvement programs with new construction additions renovation and maintenance and then lastly we'll talk about the impacts it does have on our budget so first we want to talk about what is happening with population in Prince wom County we are seeing declining birth rates and this data is from the Virginia Department of Health we receive their data and we geocode where these births are happening inside Prince County schools and we're seeing that roughly this past year 5,761 births from September to or October 1st to September 30th occurred in the county so with that being said we're seeing a big drop in births and

009you can see that declining Trend um in birth rates along with that we have domestic migration international migration and just the natural cause of births and deaths domestic migration is still impacting we're losing roughly 4,000 people in Prince County and international migration has decreased over the last couple years to since the pandemic this past year our K through2 enrollment was 8 88651 and we were roughly only 75 percentage point off of our projection the new industry standard is roughly 2 to 3% so we were well within that with our new projection model which we were very proud of next we have our population pyramid as you can see it goes from kindergarten at the very bottom to 12th grade at the very top the 12th grade cohort is extremely large in comparison to the new

010kindergarten cohort this year roughly A600 student Delta in the 12th grade to the kindergarten cohort which is going to make a drop in our projection next year based off these students matriculating through uh first second and third grade so that is something we're seeing where declining enrollment is going to be happening based off these lower birth rates and what we're seeing with the population in Prince County next another component of generating new students is new housing construction Trends this year we reconstructed our model from a top down approach which means we would take roughly how many units we thought we would build in the county and then divy them out within the county to a bottom up approach this is letting our developments generate their own build rates so if they have receed their site

011development permit they would have build rates established if they had been building within the last last couple years and we would take an average of those three years to determine exactly what those build rates could be with single family detached single family attached and multif family homes if they had not had an established build rate we would take a countywide average build rate to determine what the build rate could be you can see in years three and four in the out years we see a big increase in projected new residential development this is where we start building in in our rezoning submitted applications these are the ones farther out in the process but we do have more of them in que this is a lot of the area of the noville area of where the

012rural Crescent is starting to go away and they're starting to build more and more of that of new residential development next is our historical and projected enrollment over the next couple years we are seeing a decrease of roughly 1,200 students from 2024 to 2025 overall we're seeing a decrease of 3,776 over the 5year period and you do see a slight increase in the fifth year and that slight increase is from birth rates we currently only have four years of actual birth rates that we have plotted on of actual birth that we can track the fifth year is a projection because those students are not all born yet so we use our County demographer and we use his uh model to project exactly how many bursts that could occur in that fifth year and his average

013is slightly higher than what we're actually seeing in Prince County next we break it down by school level with Elementary Middle School we have five years of projection data at high school we have seven years of projection at high school we have seven years of projection data because these are students that are already within our system and we're able to continue to progress these students through again at the elementary school level in year five we are seeing a slight uptick in enrollment based off the birth rates that are a little bit higher from the county demographers model at the middle school level we are seeing declining enrollment over the next 5year period next is our other category this includes Independence non-traditional School Pace West prek programs within our County last year we were seeing a

014big uprise in this other enrollment and this year we teamed up with the different departments to help them with their projections and use birth rates at the preschool level and now we're seeing more stabilizing enrollment in the other categories next we're going to start getting into our proposed and approved Capital Improvements for this coming year our new constructions we do not have any changes but we do have Aquin Elementary School Woodbridge area school pic Shores number two and the 14th high school for additions we have Pennington Traditional School Washington Reed preschool Center the noville school and we're looking to propose marstellar middle school and Dale City Elementary School for forthcoming Renovations we're looking at brinville Transportation Center pic Transportation Center Graham Park vaugh Elementary School fredland Middle School Woodbridge Middle School brinville high school and

015adding Dale City Elementary School now we'll get into detail of the projects one by one first we have the acaan replacement school this is going to add an additional program capacity of approximately 226 seats for a total capacity of 719 as this is a replacement school you're not going to see the full effect of a 719 just the additional classrooms what are being added at that school the schedule opening date is December 2025 so with that being said opening midyear the students after the holiday break would look to move into the aquan replacement school as a midyear change the overcrowding relief is only intended for aquan elementary school at this time we do see that it would have some additional capacity but it will be adding additional programs like early childhood special educ ation other

016autism programs where these students have been going to other schools because the school could just not accommodate these in boundary students next is the Woodbridge area elementary school the anticipated opening program capacity is approximately 632 the school has been delayed until the 26 27 school year and schools within the Cardinal and neapco Mills District Northern Route 1 areas are intended to receive the overcrowding relief from the opening of the Woodbridge area school again with these schools in this area some of the schools that have been overcrowded will now be able to gain their Early Childhood special education programs some additional autism programs for these in boundary students and be able to house those in boundary students at their schools with the opening of the school we are seeing ample space at in both the Cardinal

017and the the absco Mills Area and it should be good for the future years to come we did add a doomsday scenario to our model this year and that's if all residential development was built out within the county and with Belmont area they do have a small area plan in that area which could generate a lot of potential residential development and if that were to built out it would then start filling up those additional seats that we are seeing in that area next we have pic Shores number two last year the capacity increased from 750 to 1,50 seats we are seeing that that was a good move in the CIP last year as pic Shores Community is continued to be built out we are seeing in our 5-year Outlook that it would be that area

018would be close to 90% of capacity utilization and if they continue to build out which we do suspect that they will they would be at approximately 95% of capacity utilization for this region the school is scheduled to open in the 2728 school year and this is intended to help the schools within the Cherry Hill region of the with the elementary schools with overcrowding relief next we have our 14th High School an overview and consideration the approved capacity last year was 1,400 seats the scheduled opening is still the 2930 school year the schools intended to receive the overcrowding relief are colan Forest Park and freedom and it may include a robotics aquatic drone lab school-based Clinic we do have a community engagement session starting in February and the public will be able to give feedback of

019what possible specially programs they would like to see in the 14th high school so some considerations that we're looking at transer rates are contributing to overcrowding at many schools in the area Osborne Park is a prime example where their residing population roughly has 1,400 students and we see roughly 33% of a net transfer rate transfer in so there's 33 more students transferring into Osborne Park than are transferring out so we could consider with specialty programs of maybe possibly putting like another biotech program or other specialty program which could accomodate these students on the Eastern side of the county and keep them in that area instead of them all moving to the biotech program or the nursing program at Osborne Park so that could be another possible solution approximately 625 students transfer from the east side

020of the county to osbor park as we look at the projections for the 14th high school we anticipate with the opening of the 14th High School seven schools to be impacted by redistricting they are highlighted in the red box with colan Hilton Forest Park Woodbridge Garfield freedom and pomac the number of seats available in the 2930 school year is approximately 2,262 seats with the opening of the 14th high school so we are seeing that we'll have ample space within our high schools with the opening of the 14th high school next we're going to migrate into our capacity enh hand enhancements our first one is the Pennington Traditional School currently the addition is approved for an eight classroom Edition we are looking to boost that to a 10 classroom Edition and it will include four general

021education spaces as well as six specially rooms Music Arts science labs and other needs for the school there is a delayed opening for Pennington because with it being located within the city of Manasses permitting was a little bit different than in Prince County and the timeline is a little bit longer process for us to get the proper permits to build this addition so it will be delayed one year additionally we have Washington Reed preschool Center there is no current change to Washington Reed we have a 15 classroom Edition slated as well as a renovation this is scheduled to open in the 2728 school year and with the renovation we're looking at a full kitchen remodeling HVAC replacement Ada improvements and add parking to accommodate the staff for this 15 classroom Edition next we have the

022noville school and marstellar middle school currently the noville school is slated for a 30 classroom Edition 20 for elementary school and 10 for Middle School the 30 classroom Edition would eliminate a majority of the green space at the noville school and we are currently working with County the county to review the sewer capacity to see if it could accommodate this 30 classroom addition and then we started looking at other possible scenarios for the noville school we see that in the Linton Hall region there are a lot of schools that are underutilized in that region so we were trying to think of other Solutions if the 30 classroom Edition would not work so we're possibly proposing to reduce the size of the noville Edition to a 10 classroom Edition and consider building it at Middle School

023specs but in intended to use for the elementary portion of the school so if we do see that the Middle School numbers are higher and it might be needed we could then move the middle school students into that addition as well that is still scheduled to open in the 2728 school year with reducing the addition size at the noville school from 30 to 10 classrooms we are looking to build a 10 classroom Edition at marstellar middle school this Edition would open one year later than the noville school edition and that would open in the 2829 school year during the time the noville school and Marcel editions are being constructed we would look at redistricting to keep the noville school's boundary coincident we would still keep it a K through 8 coincident boundary but we would

024look to move students from the noville school into the Linton Hall region and look at moving students into the addition in space in marstellar middle school and possibly look at Gainesville as well as we see them as well declining in enrollment over the projected 5-year period our next capacity enhancement and renovation is Dale City Elementary School according to our FCI it did indicate that Dale city was one of our schools that needed was in the highest need of a renovation I believe it was number eight on our scale Dale City currently utilizes five portable classrooms for various purposes including art L's programs math and reading support ICT Robotics and small group instruction we are seeing this in a lot of the smaller capacity schools that they do not have the necessary resource space to accommodate

025a lot of these small group instructions and various other programs they have in the school so we're looking to add a potential eight classroom addition at Dale City Elementary School in addition to the renovation with new mechanical electrical and plumbing systems Ada improvements and parking improvements this is going to eliminate the needs for portable classrooms at the school and is scheduled to open outside the CIP window in 20 3132 school year I am now going to pass it over to Miss Jessica wymer thank you so much Scott good evening Dr Latif members of the school board and Dr McD before we continue with project specifics we wanted to share pwcs proactive approach to high performance buildings and how it connects with the capital Improvement program so there is a related Virginia code that we follow

026specifically called the high performance building Act and the ACT originally specified requirements for state and local government buildings only and although it did not initially include School divisions pwcs was already moving toward more SU sustainable design and construction so back in June 2020 the school board passed the sustainability initiative and Then followed by the subsequent policy and regulation for sustainability so with the updated requirements that were effective July of 2024 the act now references School divisions so we did anticipate these changes and proactively addressed compliance by incorporating key measures into our sustainable design principles for high performance bus buildings for both new construction and major Renovations which was originally published in 2022 and so even before that we had been designing for lead certification standards even before the ax update so just to highlight some

027of the sustainability aspects of our new construction that do align with this code we design for Ev ready charging capacity and pre-wiring we ensure our systems are measured through energy metering and we incorporate on sight renewable energy when and where possible specifically with solar or photovoltaic or as we call it PV arrays and solar PV will be essential as we look into the future and we'll talk about it a little bit later in the presentation but by expanding our use of solar in both new and existing infrastructure we are preparing for some inevitable increases in Regional energy demands and costs so pertaining to the codes requirements we are working to better understand uh the impacts to the school division so by leveraging uh collaborations with both internal and external resources and stakeholders we should be

028able to accomplish that and considering all of these factors we are affirming our commitment to both sustainability and high performance buildings which as Dr McDade noted earlier is outlined in commitment to of the Strategic plan um so this commitment supports our school buildings being good models for both Environ mental and fiscal stewardship and that is evident throughout our Capital Improvement program so at this time I'd like to turn it over to Mr David beavers who will walk us through the next portion of the presentation super thank you Jessica uh good evening chairman Latif members of the school board and Dr McDade uh my name is Dave beavers I'm with the budget department and we're going to talk about my favorite subject money um as our CFO has noted everything costs money uh here's where we

029see how the rubber hits the road um this table shows us the changes from last year's CIP to this year's proposed CIP in the category of new facilities and additions uh we have several significant cost estimate changes that are detailed here to reflect input from our professional estimating firm Downey and Scott so we've relied on those external Consultants note that the here the project total changes uh differ from the CIP amounts shown in the table because the CIP amount changes from year to year as the funding progresses through time uh numbers will drop out of the CIP time frame as we spend that money so those aren't shown in the CIP amounts after that we see significant cost increases for Pennington traditionals addition of 20.3 million and Washington Reeds pre Edition at 13.9 million we

030have new projects at Mar Stell middle school and Dale City Elementary School is discussed by Mr Hy uh please note that Dale City's uh facility condition index of 21.8 one is the eighth most significant in the division uh so we're correctly targeting those facilities with the greatest levels of repair needs for renovation also note that acaan elementary school's prek Center which we had previously proposed is being deferred uh and that'll decrease the overall CIP P cost by 14.3 million as far as project timing changes go we see Woodbridge area elementary school moved from 2026 moved to 2026 and Pennington Traditional School moved to 2027 this table Compares last year's CIP for renovations to this year's proposed CIP we've Incorporated cost adjustments at several schools to better address all the needs at those schools we see

031Grand Park Middle School the total renovation cost increases by $2.8 million vaugh Elementary School increases by 25.4 million and Woodbridge Middle School increases by 18.9 million and Ludwig's prek renovation which was proposed previously has been deferred yielding a reduction of 18.5 million in the overall CIP costs here we see the changes from last year's CIP to this year's within the maintenance category uh we see a net increase here of 158 million which is nearly 90.2% highlights here include significant increase in investment in HVAC by nearly 121% or almost $80 million we see a significant increase in core electrical infrastructure maintenance and electronic systems and in fenestration and we see $27.2 million increase in sustainability initiatives such as led upgrades and solar photovoltaic installations I said that right finally thank you uh the overall message here

032is that we're increasing resources to take good care of that which we already own by devoting considerable resources to maintenance projects we're addressing previously deferred maintenance and playing catchup we're rightsizing the CIP to ensure that we're providing Equitable facility care across the division and keeping our students and staff safe comfortable and dry now focusing specifically on HVAC Investments within the proposed CIP the maintenance team did a thorough analysis of where Investments are needed they re reviewed facility condition assessments for specific recommendations on HVAC equipment as well as evaluating work orders that we receive by school they reviewed investment grade audits that were developed by the energy and sustainability team and they identified schools without dehumidification all these data were utilized to develop the prioritized list of HVAC needs significant HVAC Replacements at 14 Schools will

033total 81.87 5 million with an average of about $6 million per school as with other school divisions and facility intensive Industries HVAC costs represent a very significant investment here we're we're detailing the seven schools shown that will receive complete HVAC Replacements within their Renovations so those seven schools that are being renovated will receive brand new HVAC systems we're also doing significant HVAC Replacements or improvements pardon me at the 14 schools that you see detailed on the right that'll moving our Focus to sustainability in support of the school board's sustainability initiative and the Strategic plan improvements are planned to include $15.5 Million worth of LED upgrades and $14.75 Million worth of solar array installations at the shown schools this this table details for us several highlights of the cips that wouldn't be otherwise shown these improvements

034address critical infrastructure that must be maintained to ensure safe and comfortable learning environments for our students and teachers uh some of these things are expensive but they're critical and they uh they have to be maintained to to make sure the facilities are working properly and lastly to ensure Equitable access to artificial turf practice fields we will be undertaking the construction of artificial turf practice fields at each of the listed high schools currently there are artificial turf practice fields at several high schools Freedom Patriot Gainesville brentville and colan this project will ensure that Equitable athletic facilities are provided to students across the division the construction priority order was developed to ensure that there was a geographic balance to the availability of artificial turf practice fields now I'll turn it over to Shaquille to share how all

035this fits into the overall Financial picture thank you Mr beas from an overall perspective uh we have increased our CIP over 5 Years From 963 million to over a billion 98,000 um 98 million uh for this year's CIP plan for the next 5 years this is about a $136 million increase and as shown earlier primarily this is mainly in maintenance and artificial track where we have put in Investments and there offsets under construction and renovation and facility uh modifications uh do have a small decrease so overall our next fiveyear plan calls for over a billion dollars worth of investment so in terms of how we funding this uh as I had said in my opening uh remarks that uh most of this is funded by bonds uh we are also putting money through our general

036fund transfers and for the first time time we're showing the available profit funds uh which is approximately $25 million uh and our understanding is that these profit funds while residing at uh the county do have a lot of flexibility in terms of where we can use those funds next slide please in terms of how we going to divide up our bond sales over the next 5 years you can see we've tried to keep this as uniform as possible we are going to have increases in the next 3 years and then it'll start declining um for this 5year CIP uh we are uh we we we are in the process of getting our uh Debt Service estimates but we expect that that to increase uh also finally I just wanted to go quickly over some of

037the uh budget planning timeline for fiscal year 2026 we have preliminary state budget information obviously the governor's bill is now being debated in um in the general assembly and we expect within the next few weeks to get more information as to what is coming from the uh uh final budget the County revenue information that is available is preliminary and we are basing it on the fiveyear plan we anticipate in the next month also to get a better idea of what where the county is going to end with their revenues um today we are talking about the CIP in the work session uh on February 5th the superintendent will submit the FY 26 proposed budget to the school including the CIP we have a public meeting on the 10th of February a public hearing on the

03819th of February and then we go to work session on March 12th 2025 with the school board and with the approval scheduled for March 19th 2025 the School board chairman presents the school board budget to the board of County Supervisors on April 1st and the board of County Supervisors approves on April 22nd 2025 that concludes our presentation and we'll open it up Mr chairman Dr McDade for question thank you Shaquille thank you Dr McDade thank you team questions Mr TR denik um do we know any data about how many kids transfer that are also involved in sports it's just a I'm curious about that number I don't know if it's I know it's a weird question but I'm just wondering like can we get that eventually I don't know if that's an easy thing to

039get or if it's it should be we we didn't run the analysis on that because you know typically when we look at um space utilization um it's based on enrollment and programming things like that but we can we can look and analyze and see of the specifically where you were talking about some of the schools that have high transfer in rates like Osborne Park and see if it's 33 you know to one how many of those students may be athletes just yeah just we can try to figure that out okay and then um I think I've asked this before but I'm not sure I just wanted to make sure I asked it on the record but is there nothing that the city of Manasses can do to help us speed that process up at all

040I'm GNA ask Vince to come to the table and Vince is our supervisor of construction to see I know he's working closely with Manasses uh but Vince good evening everyone um yes and no so I one of our staff members um he is one of my administrative coordinators has a very good relationship with them so I'm having him do kind of behind the scenes work trying to move things along um they have a lot of internal review meetings so that's one one of the big delays so we're working but fingers crossed okay thank you you're welcome um on page 21 The Mention Of unspecified School Renovations is there a list of any of those anywhere are they just kind of like yeah I'm gonna ask uh Mr beavers to speak to that and that's I

041think he's addressed that in or two by twoos so uh I don't think he made mention of it here tonight though so I'm going to ask him to kind of review that with you yes thank you so essentially those were placeholder that was included in the CIP last year to reserve money to show that in the long term we would meet our goal of spending about 2.4% of uh of funds on maintaining our school facilities um it's a benchmark that we like to to make with the additional 150 uh million devoted towards maintenance this year we're going to achieve that goal so we no longer need to show that placeholder in the CIP okay um and then talking about the turf practice fields I love seeing that um my question would be will these practice

042fields be available for public use or will they be fenced in because I know that there are different fields within the ones that already exist some of which are public use fields that people can go on I think they're supposed to rent them but um I guess my question would be have we thought about that in regards to the cost because I know the ones that are for public use or people are using on a regular basis we need to replace sooner than we do that's correct gener we have I think six uh maybe seven I believe we have seven uh tur fields at our middle schools where we've partnered with parks and wck and we will share uh replacement cost for those fields with our parks and Rex Department um currently as it stands

043uh any use of our athletic fields at the high school uh goes through a facility's uh use request and there is a fee associated with that um that is something that I I appreciate you mentioning we will take a look at uh uh the usage of those fields and potentially um take a look at brentville and how that's being leveraged as well currently and give some consideration to that and uh you know how the public may use those or interface with those I just want to be clear I didn't ask for the public to be able to use those fields I know I just want to make sure I'm just saying I'm I'm curious the cost difference and and and the pricing as far as that and if we are making the rest of them

044public use fields or not but I know it's going to come at a cost and we could certainly I could certainly generate some numbers from our facilities use and what we are charging for those fields and come back to the board and share that information with you okay yeah thank you so much Mr Jesse thank you thank you for the presentation uh on the aaan school uh what's the status of the old building so we were uh the Hope initially was that we were going to be able to leverage that as a preschool site and upon further review and and uh conversation with the architect it's not feasible the architect believes actually it would be uh actually cheaper for us to uh build a preschool from the ground up than to try to leverage and

045utilize the old space that would require significant uh improvements uh so uh after the students move into the new site over the winter holiday then we would be the demolition of the old building after that thank you the other question this is sort of strange perhaps the LED lighting tremendous cost when I think of LED lighting home I buy light put it in socket what's the difference here miss wymer you want to chime in absolutely thank you for the question so we show that LEDs compar compared to the fluorescent save us approximately 50% um in energy costs and also they last 5 to 10 years longer another factor that we're showing is that we are starting to have some supply chain issues with fluorescent bulbes and it's becoming Harder To Source them and stock them

046and they're becoming more expensive so we're finding that the right sizing of the cost of LEDs um so that would be the difference so it's really light the light bulbs itself is not rewiring or anything there are some retrofit kits depending on the location so there there are some additional factors when we are changing out the LEDs okay I I'm Sor of you wonder because when I buy light LEDs for my home seem like they don't last nearly as long as they're supposed to and I don't know if I'm supposed to be rewiring and so we're not not doing a math rewiring of the schools for the LED lights no it's generally as as Miss wmer mentioned it's uh sometimes it's the uh the fitting for the lighting that's rewired so we just went through

047that here at the KLC and there's some Replacements ballast a lot of the old fluorescent lights use the ballast so it's replacing those ballasts and retrofitting them uh to accommodate the new LED lighting and and Mr Jesse what we are seeing is longer life out of the LED lighting um that's been our experience thus far yeah and brighter much brighter you know one thing that just because it's I mean we it would be no nice to know and I don't know if we've done this calculation on what we would spend on if we were just replacing the fluorescent lights anyways so the real difference in the spend on the investment is how much more we're spending on the LED but in the long run the savings is what we're really looking for 100% Dr we

048could come back to you with those numbers mean just as a thought Miss Williams thank you um I think the LED just a piggyback on that we started a few years ago and it was like as we did additions we we did The Replacements but I can tell you there's a noticeable difference if you have a split building with fluorescent versus LED the staff and the students tend to prefer the LED CU that was a major hiccup at Ripon a while back is that one hallway was like super bright and and then it was almost like you lost lighting as you went into the older sections um so I just want to clarify for my own brain I apologize for being late because I missed this um when it used fredland renovation I see it's

049now 2028 is is that are we still starting on on the same schedule that we were and it's now being the completion is being uh pushed out or I don't think I don't think Vince if you want to come up to the table Yeah starting the same time okay I just wanted to make sure it's just going to extend further out because I know we're not we're doing it as we're the building is inhabited so I just wanted to make sure I was still understanding that and then um the only other question I have now is not part of the CIP and and it's something that we've asked for historically is could we get an update on which building still do not have science labs or music rooms um because I'm still going to harp

050on that because I know it's still it's important and and of value and I know that we are working towards it so I'm not saying that we're not doing it I just don't remember where we are and if that's something that's on the cons the facility um I can never get the name of that thing right condition assessment I'm G Master it one day if that's included in there if someone could just show me where to find that that's fine too we we certainly have that information Miss Williams and and uh we'll share that with you it was part of the educational space audit that was completed and I will say and and we neglected to mention this tonight as we renovate our elementary schools that's a portion of the renovation is making sure that

051we're including a science lab within that renovation okay I appreciate that because I from just from my own experience a lot of my schools don't have that and so like I have a sixth grader now that's never been in a science lab and so there're like he's at fredland so he's very excited about the renovations going on all everybody is for having labs and and things like that so I appreciate our attention to making sure that those needs are met and I know it's taking a long time but I'd rather take a long time than not do it at all and do it right so I just appreciate um the the continued work on that thank you Mr Jesse just to make sure I'm clear on the acaan elementary school we're not we're going to

052tear down the old building but are we still going to have a a prek uh facility there that's been tabled at this time Mr Jesse because it's been uh deferred at this time we're continuing to study our preschool uh special education enrollment initially we thought we would need it because the uptick but those numbers are are stabilizing so at this time we're continuing to watch we will have we we have in lwig in the hopper uh we also have a couple other sites that we're looking at as potential sites for preschool the the challenge with aaan as well is it is somewhat of a constrained site and uh we want to make sure we have as much Green Space there for the students and I know the principal is very very concerned his Saka field

053is going to still remain correct yes sir okay thank you I have some questions oh sorry I have some questions um let me start with with page three um the data for 2023 we have this data for change up for migration it's 2020 and 2022 but we're now in 2025 so um my question is when do we anticipate the data from 2023 2024 being available is that how much of a lag do we get for data like that it's normally on the site the Nova Regional dashboard it's roughly a year lag so we're hoping within the next couple months that there is is the3 update yes okay yeah cuz I think that it's so Dynamic this area especially has been really Dynamic you know people coming going and it's like are we getting a net

054migration out and you know election the election was recently here and that makes a difference too because we're so tied to the DC uh ecosystem and so we know like we're going to have a big variability and that will affect us I think so okay sometime in the next bit for 202 okay awesome my second question is um on page um uh the question was the or the comment was consider programming to um additional Eastern additional programming to Eastern schools so that we could alleviate the the draw of everybody kind of migrating up to Osborne Park and um do we have like a timeline or a process for that or is there a way for board members to provide input or how are we going to go about doing that and I guess maybe a

055question is more like the timeline in the process it's probably too soon to tell but well I'm happy I'm I I will share uh the first step in that is we really want to engage with the community and we're going to start that in February around the 14th high school and Specialty programming around that so uh you'll hear an update uh in the very near future we anticipate starting that in February and have having several stakeholder sessions to including uh up to and including Business Leaders from the community U looking at Workforce Development data also from the Eastern side of uh Prince William County and uh and then through those engagement sessions uh we'll share that information with the instructional side of the house to potentially consider specialized programming there at the 14th high school

056and we did put a placeholder in here may include Robotics and we know there's been significant interest around Robotics and the Drone lab and both the the air or the land and sea robotics so we put a placeholder in there uh for that but we are looking at uh as as we've designed that we've already started working with the architect at the 14th High School uh making sure that we have available space there for some specialized program to include Labs uh as well okay great because I and I I'm assuming we know which one of our programs are the ones that kids really like and which ones aren't as popular anymore we do too yes ma'am so I'm will the division be providing that input too not just what does the community think but like

057here's some data yeah I think we'll we'll obviously we're working with the instructional side of the house and that's something that we've talked about uh of looking at those programs and how we might be able to balance that across the School Division and I also suppose having conversations with higher education perhaps like what majors are popular and what are kids interested in when they get to college and how can we have programs that are Dynamic and interesting to high schoolers so that they actually engage in high school and things that they're considering studying in college yes okay awesome um I had a question question on page 15 um when I look at the data for enrollment of high school students across the entire County um it looks like um I'm assuming this is an 879

058kind of a light green and then we go to 200 200 2, 22062 sorry can't read numbers um surplus of seats countywide that's and so and I'm reading this that's with the 1400 in addition to that's beyond the 1400 so we add 1400 and then now we'll have 2,262 cor available seats across the county that's correct okay that and that's like the size of our almost our biggest high school that's the equivalent of an entirely new high school of availability our largest high schools are around 2800 students so it's a little bit smaller than that but it's equivalent to a smaller High School yes okay so I guess I mean it's still a ways out but we'll have to see what that data looks like for 2023 2024 maybe even 2025 because we know this

059is like a rolling plan okay I'm just concerned that that's a lot of excess seats um obviously in the East End we we have a great need for seats especially at colan which isn't really East it's Central but uh in the west we're having the opposite problem and it's hard it's hard when you start having like a vacancy of 829 seats to run all the great programs that families want you start having to cut classes cut programs and cut sports teams and things like that because you just can't field you know you don't have enough you don't have enough students to fi it so I'm concerned about this like this data gives me caution so I guess that's just a comment not a question okay um than you uh question or my can I keep

060going yeah anybody okay um I have another question um this is uh oh I didn't put what page facility condition index it was related to what Miss Williams was mentioning um the facility condition index you mentioned Dale city was number eight on the scale which is quite High because we have 100 Schools um but I don't remember maybe this is published do we is this a published document on our website or I don't if I've seen this I don't believe we' published it on our website yet I think I know where you're going with your question though because that was number eight um the actually if you look at the projects that we have for HVAC and that was on page I'm trying to find that page real quick here so if you look on

061page 24 Miss wall yes all of those schools that are getting HVAC Replacements as part of a renovation those schools are our highest schools in our top they are so when you heard that Dale city was eight then you see the other top in in in here okay so and I'm assuming the HVAC is a is a significant contributor to the fact that those schools are high on that list it it would be a very large contributor yes ma'am and we're talking about like humidity issues mold issues yes that kind of stuff okay awesome thank you that's a good clarification on page 19 um the comment was we're preparing for inevitable cost increases such as energy demands energy demands and costs and I was wondering why we were thinking that and is this like because

062of all the construction of data centers that we're doing are we anticipating a high amount of is this a supply and demand problem that we're going to have Miss wall here's why we wanted to put this in there and call us to your attention we we have a pretty good idea of what the new legislation is calling for from the July uh 1st 2024 but we're still trying to understand that to the best of our ability and there could be some cost that we may encourage to meet that new legislation so Jess and the team are really working very closely with folks to try to best understand the full impact of that on us as a School Division okay so this this the estimated increase in cost is related to the new law and the

063demands of the new law and we just don't know what that's we don't know what that might be at this point okay I just wondered if it was yes we're watching energy markets or something um my last question is Page 21 um increases in costs uh okay sorry had I think it's 21 for the M these increase in costs from last year's CIP to this CIP is that market pressure for labor costs materials like why are those costs going up I think all the above some increase in scope as well and some of the renovations and taking a deeper dive and okay and trying to uh as best we can uh promote the instructional programming that we're trying to achieve within the district and and uh making the best use of Education spes okay so

064all the above and all the above because there is a lot of increase in cost actually as I look at this um right that's true okay thank you and my last question is in relation to the tur field you said the priority order is going to be Geographic balanc did we look at conditions of fields also or is it just kind of like we'll just slowly work our way up through the county or it's a good question so here's what we're doing uh we we are going to be engaging with a consultant to come into evaluate all of our turf fields we do have some turf fields that we believe might be getting closer to their life expect expectancy so we're going to have a a thirdparty consultant come in and we we do annual

065G what's called gmax testing that uh measures the rebound of the turf and that's something we measure for uh concussion prevention but they don't come in and actually look at the condition of the turf so we're engaging in a third party to come in to evaluate the turf for us to help us better prioritize I would anticipate next year we're going to be adding some additional turf fields into the CIP for replacement but we'll have a better idea once that third party consultant comes in and then we'll get some some of those fields that are at that life expectancy into the CIP So when you say Turf you're talking about like turf turf are you talking about grass Turf I'm talking I'm talking Turf artificial turf okay yes ma' because like these I think these

066though are all of these grass fields that are going to be upgraded they they are going to be upgraded to artificial t these are grass upgraded to artificial also have turf fields that we need to okay yeah I'm sorry I didn't realize you were referring to the I should have known field sorry I mean both need to be evaluated yeah okay yes and so that was my question is like for instance I know um my community has been very um over many years complaining about their practice field and how poor it is um and the schools tried to improve the grass Turf and they've tried lots of different things that the County's asked them to do but it's still not a very good field and so I wondered if we had if we were taking

067that into consideration I'd like to see it moved up if possible because apparently nobody really uses the field because they don't they hate it they don't want to break their ankles but um I understand you there's lots of stuff that goes into that and you said that gain Battlefield gains Battlefield okay okay we'll take a look at that okay great well that's good to know I know the communities really love the turf field they think they're awesome okay um my never mind I don't I think I'll hold my last question until everybody else gets time to ask more questions thank you for this presentation and for the information Mr Blake okay Miss wall or Miss zapor I guess you have a question thank you um thank you for the presentation I I have just a

068couple of questions um I have learned that when we have more spaces at our schools that are have impervious you know where I'm going with this these nutrient credit things um how are the turf fields going to affect us they'll definitely impact nutrient credits because and we'll have to pay for an offset there because obviously those are impervious surfaces and contribute to phosphate production into the waterways so that is something that will have to be considered in the uh in that project fun I love learning new things all right so to sort of circle back to something Mr denck said um about the will the public have access to these um I have had uh people reach out to me about use of our tracks and I know that that colan and um Forest Park

069are the two that are available are any of these going to have a a track these are these are strictly Turf practice fields all right so just putting their voices out there that um I'm sure they don't all want to come to the midcounty area um but that that is something that I know some people across the county are interested in they take their kids out and strollers they um have some some of their kids are um special needs and they need a a a nice surface to be able to go and do those exercises that's something that um some community members have brought up um and then the other thing I was curious about just with HVAC because uh ever since the pandemic um and I work in a in a classroom that's got

07050 years of dirt and dust in the in the rafters um when we're doing these uh Renovations with HVAC are we it's not the duct work it's just the HVAC system it could when we do a major overall could be both it likely would be is there an opportunity to sort of make sure that we're getting um uh I don't know if these things are effective but when I went to vsba there were people who were trying to sell us the the the lights and things like that is there going to be anything that's making like filtration systems for uh to make the air a little bit more healthy for the people who are inside these buildings all day we we use uh some of the highest grade filters that are out there on our

071HVAC C systems to take out as much particulate matter in the air as we can and that really about is co so I feel like we're in good shape with the filters we're we're using the highest quality that we can in ourf 13s and all that good stuff yeah yeah yeah okay are they MV um are they 13s V they're MV um I think some are 13 and some are still eight yeah well I mean I know the mechanical systems have to be able to to for the filter all right um and then the other thing I just was curious about in um it was on page 15 when we're talking about the 14th high school and we're talking there's the red box with all of the the schools that could be affected Hilton isn't

072they're underc capacity so are we also talking about shifting some kids into Hilton as well so like who do I direct this one to yeah so yeah so when we opened the 14th High School obviously areas where the school is located in the Woodbridge region you have Woodbridge freedom and Garfield who could be directly impacted by by the school but then you have that tertiary effect to backfill some of those other schools and we could see maybe using Hilton for possibly overcrowding with colan or using Woodbridge then to help uh after they their uh enrollment declines based off moving into the new 14th high school for colan students to go to Woodbridge so it's like a trickle down effect it's that domino effect the cascading effect that could occur um and that's why we include

073Hilton because they with regen yeah that um and they've been recently renovated it's beautiful school should go see it right Mr Blake all right thank you that's all my question Mr Blake and then Miss Williams okay um I got a question about page 15 I was the red boxes when when we redistrict for the 14th High School will we be redistricting for will it impact all the high schools or will it just impact the high schools on east side of the county because what is that that boxing mean that we're just going to Red like is it just hitting those schools or are we going to redistrict all the high schools currently the scope what we're looking at is the seven high schools but according to the regulation if the board has an appetite to

074look at redistricting uh countywide that is something that we can definitely look at with opening of the 14th High School Miss Williams thank you um since we're already on this topic um when we say I think you said there's 2,000 what did you say 2, 262 available seats I just want to make sure that the public understands that that seats but we haven't finished our high school capacity uh program capacity so that number may actually change once because I know we're we've all we've done like step one I like to think of it as step one but please reframe it in a proper way if that's possible or more meaningful so whereas like middle and elementary we have our set program capacity we know how we're utilizing how it affects seats in the building but

075um I think we're in the initial stages if I'm correct on the high school capacity so I just want the public to understand that that number is not set in stone it may change with respect to programming capacity um and I also want the public to understand that it it's countywide so it could also change by the time we're looking at that depending on who moves where and things of that nature because I think when you hear that number you're like oh my gosh we shouldn't build but it might just be a pocket over here or it might actually change once we get the program capacity set in stone so to speak and then um I'm going to say uh that for me personally I would love to challenge the board to do a redistricting

076of all the high schools at one time I know nobody likes that idea everybody hates it and I've said it privately I've never said it on the microphone but I think it's time to say it because I I think it's to our benefit as a School Division because part of the reason we're in this situation is when we do a high school it is peace meal by surrounding high schools and our community changes and the needs change and we keep ending up having the same results so to me I think that's the definition of of not being in smart is when you do the same thing and you get the same answer and you're looking for a different answer um but I know that's not my decision it's whatever whoever is sitting in those seats

077at that time but it may be worth looking at um to avoid having to Band-Aid issues because that's something as long as I've been on the board we've done historically but it might not be the right fit when it comes time to do the boundaries for the for the 14th high school so I think it's worth considering um because nobody wins in boundaries someone's people are always upset um there are always people who are happy but there are also always people who are unhappy so if we're going to go down that path I just think it might be something that the division and the board should really think about it's too early to consider that um but I'm happy to take all the hit mail from the people who don't like that idea which is

078why I'm saying it because I think we've just gone too long without saying it and then I'm just going to end um my comments with that again I just appreciate all the hard work that's gone into this every year we continue to do uh I think a better and better job of getting a more accurate picture of how our division is functioning the cons the the conditions of our schools and really getting a more holistic uh view of how everything fits together which I do believe makes us operate better so I just wanted to take time to thank all of the staff and the superintendent um and as well as the public who also provides us with their input because we can't all see everything um but sitting here for 11 years I definitely think

079that we are in much better position and have a much better view of how to move forward every year and that is because of the people who sit in our seats and because of all the staff so thank you m Williams thank you I think you know it's likely that with program capacity there could be some adjustments there I do think we're still going to have uh underutilized seats yeah yeah Mr wil thank you Mr chairman um Mr Bach and team thank you for the presentation uh quick question for clarity where I know we were it was brought to our attention and it's been brought to our attention earlier this year and in previous years long ago um about the sidewalk issue at patomic high school and it was laid out the various fa excuse

080me phases um of what we would be doing and first was you know phase one was the crosswalk and the the the lines and the road um where we where is that in here is that kind of under like an umbrella of things it is we um I are you finished Mr oh yeah no I you're good okay I didn't mean to cut you off you're good uh no uh Mr uh Bill Miller uh through our risk and safety department has been working very closely with the county and with uh pic Senior High School uh and we are accomplishing that in phases and that is reflected in in the CIP what year I guess then would phase two then be I can get clarity on that I know he's continuing to work through it and

081we are committed to addressing it I I don't have that date in front of me right here I don't think but I I think it's more of a because they kind of just started this I don't think we necessarily have a hard and fast date right now to give you but I think the the sentiment is in terms of funding um what needs to be done we're prepared to fund it okay so the funding's there okay okay now to a more pretentious matter um following Miss Williams discussion about cumington Harbor she said rightfully let's wait till we have the CIP meeting where we're expounding on a few things and we can look at some numbers and things looking at the subsidiary data that's in this packet um it's uh palpable palpable excuse me to see

082compared to any other school in projected capacity in the elementary in the entire County again I did a cursory glance a little bit more than cursory but I by all figures and I'm looking at the year before and again albeit there were some challenges and obstacles that we faced in getting acquiring the land and purchasing the land for this building by by the projections here by 2627 the year before pic Shores 2 is supposed to open there's supposed to be 326 kids over capacity that's more than any other elementary school I know we were talking about Hay Market and the nowhere hey Mark is nowhere close um it is overcrowded but um so even if and I'm just doing the math just saying 22 kids per class and do that math that is about approximately

08315 additional total trailers on that property I I I I guess I I I I think it's a flagrant matter and I I I don't I know I made a move last time to have boundaries done I guess in a dramatic fashion but um I don't know I maybe maybe I need to talk to some colleagues and just see if we can ask for a presentation on some type of what are our options because this doesn't sit well with me I I I don't know I I I just think it it's going to ostensibly lead to concerns of people being like the safety concerns of having 15 trailers I know I I know kogan's overcrowded but those are secondary kids so we have K5 primary kids with 15 trailers um in that in that area

084so anyways I'll leave it at that I don't really have any questions at this time but this was I felt the appropriate time to reflect on the data that has been presented to me and just put this out there um because it is um extremely concerning so that's all I have to say thank you thank you Miss wall thank you um Dr I have a couple of additional questions um my my first question is um on page 15 um I know the red boxes the anticipated schools that will be affected but I'm curious maybe we should add I mean I would suggest that we add Osborne Park also to that um because it is also very overcrowded um and it is clearly a school that students from the East do transfer into it um but

085it's just as it looks like it's kind of as overcrowded I mean maybe not as overcrowded as Goan but I would think like I'm curious why it didn't get in the red box but I mean obviously it will be affected by it this is anticipatory right yeah so Osborne Park is a very tricky school they currently only have approximately 1,400 residing students and their capacity of the school their planning capacity is 2400 so they don't actually have enough students to fill that school they rely on the transfers to fill Osborne Park so if we were to move students away from Osborne Park and let's say there is an attractive program at the 14th high school that these Eastern end students would like to go to it would could and if we do redistrict it could

086bring osor Park even farther under capacity at that point in time because those transfers could go elsewhere and then they wouldn't have that residing population to fill the school too okay that makes that elucidates a little bit more um is there so remind me they have the preg governor school there and we we're building that up or standing that up have we already started that is that that's at a different School in the East preo School was it freedom freedom and when will that come on board because I'm assuming preg school is one of the things that draws students to Osborne Park it's it's it open biot it's biotech is the main thing biotech okay I mean it's both but it's both yeah but the prub school did open this year okay um and we

087didn't um we did like a soft open yeah we did a soft a soft launch where we didn't um we weren't hard and fast on the boundaries of you know um who goes to Osborne Park compared to freedom because the announcement came at a time after families had already submitted applications but then moving forward based on you know where your attend your zoned determines whether or not you get to apply to Freedom or osor park so that is going to you know have some kind of impact in terms of relief not significant to Dr latif's point you still have the bio uh program there too but it should it should give some relief but I mean there the amount of students transferring into Osborne Park is significant so it'll take more than the pregu school

088to remedy that so that these numbers are somewhat I mean it depends on how many kids they allow in it's not I guess right how many are accepted into transfer which could be curtailed if necessary I guess is what I'm saying okay and then also um I remember in past years and maybe we'll get it at a later date but I have a couple of schools that have that I'm watching the attendance whether it's dropping or growing and so is that not a thing we get with the CIP do we get that with the budget um like just the fiveyear projection for all of the schools you're talking attendance or enrollment enrollment uh projected enrollment like like on chart 15 oh it's in the back oh okay okay I was just looking for more information

089that's where it is okay great because you know we have Middle School I think like middle schools were doing great ad except that there's a couple of anomalies and one of them is in my district you know and so that can be handled in a different way I think than through a CIP but I was looking for that data so I appreciate that very much thank you Mr Jesse I've been involved with boundaries for 12 years now and worked with uh Mr Dr cat car whatever Matt for a long time uh there's two boundaries issues you have the boundaries that are made by association of the uh geographic area and then you have the specialty programs a when we talk about Domino effects the Domino effects biggest thing is going to be specialy programs because

090you can't the the people at kogan high school up above mcor building and so forth used to be in the aawan district but the problem with that came when those folks wanted to go to kogan and they were going to be jumped over you can't legally you're going to have issues when you have people let's say at Osman Park kogan and then Woodbridge and you're going to try to jump some people from o Osman park over the kogan folks to get down to Woodbridge that's going to be an issue now if there are specialty programs that pull them in that's fine but the boundaries geographically you're going to have issues when you try to jump over another district and uh people don't like that and they took us to court and they won on that

091so that's one thing the one question I do have is it seems like particularly at kogan and some of the Osman Park do we restrict the number of people that can enroll into specie programs yeah we can cap a especially we can cap a program you know cuz I you know to me I I think rationale we need to look at that because we do need to even out some of the stuff but uh and specialy programs are important and I think it's one of the best thing that this County does but is also we have to be realistic uh a thousand people at kogan I don't think a thousand people are there mainly because of the geographic there's a lot du to that because people wanted to go there and they still want to

092go there because it's one of the better performing schools so that's the issue but uh so forth question for acaan elementary school again acaan Elementary last summer last spring summer I think we had some pretty significant issues with the HB back system during the hot weather and I know we got a new schooling coming so we can't put a heck of a lot of money but are we prepared for the potential of the HB not being working well before December of next year we are and and we're uh we're doing everything we can to um make sure that system is is continually um up and running uh Mr Jesse we do have potentially if if we'd have a system failure and we do have this from time to time across the division we'll put spot

093coolers in place uh in classrooms to ensure the temperatures are remaining um at uh manageable levels and then some and the challenge we're facing with some of our older equipment is finding replacement parts and and some of the back orders and backlogs and and getting some of those replacement parts in so those spot coolers do uh help us bridge that Gap sometimes but we are prepared to get through this I you know I I know with is this the fact that we got this old school and we got the spring coming up and we got the next fall coming up and if it's hot and they had issues last year so just hopefully we can get them hey hang on there besides having just be in the room the uh other question and I think

094the anticipation in next month with the turfs or with the tariffs and other potential issues the economic projections are the costs are going to start skywalking and so much of this projected cost more than likely might change significantly so we had some discussion on tariffs and potential tariffs um in terms of how it manifests manifests itself into to some of our Hardware that we use in construction there's still a lot of um speculation there um there is also an existing inventory of things that we have that we could look at uh it's hard because you don't want to go ahead and just start buying things right now uh without understanding what how the federal government is going to forward uh this program of charging ter so it depends on sources of where we get our

095materials and supplies from uh but I do understand that there is an impact at this point we do not know what that impact is Miss Williams thank you I have two questions not to be answered now if you could just give me an update with the Woodbridge Middle School renovation if it's going to have a loading dock and let you know the answer right now it Woodbridge Middle School it are they going if they're going to get a loading dock with the renovations um cuz that's the one thing they don't have we we'll come back to you on that cuz that's what I say you don't have to answer it right now cuz it's kind of like one-offs and then secondly I'm not asking for this I just know that someone has already done this

096somewhere or else it wouldn't be in here the difference between why we would um do a renovation at fredland versus a redo so I'm sure that was already a factor in how we got to this equation but if you could just for my own education sort of fill me in at at a later date um that that's all I'm asking and then third from the pandemic I I I think we learned a lot of lessons about like when we should buy things ahead of time or not in house Supply chains so again you don't have to answer this now but maybe it would be helpful for the board's understanding if we could have a little insight on you know not the nitty-gritty finite details of like how you arrive at that decision but just some

097sort of um what the plan is and if if it's an emergency thing how you would go about reaching out to us and as watching the changes go on the federal government because it's not quite the same issue as the pandemic right like when we had to emergency rushed by laptops but I think it would be helpful information for us as board members when we go to interact with the community just to provide reassurance to say oh this is the basic way that we would come to the board in emergency if we knew that like the uh connectors and the light are going to be under tariffs and we have just so that we can also articulate when people ask us questions and kind of take the weight off you I think that's kind of

098what Mr Jesse was um hinting at as well so we can share the work the the load if you we' be happy to do that I just want to mention Miss Williams we do have Parts departments in our facilities department so we do keep those on hand in in quite a bit of quantity those things that uh are routine things that break and that we have to replace um and uh Shaquille and Supply Services we have uh some items as well that we keep uh a nice stock of but certainly be able to come back to you on the fredland uh question and and the Woodbridge uh loading dock as well thank you I appreciate that cuz I know we have all this construction going on so there's things that we don't order we don't

099use until we get to a certain part and so again like for me I I always like when you get those R it's just helpful if I can say something instead of going hold on let me just go back and bother them while they're in if I have something and then if they need more refinement or there's more information needed then then we can proceed with you but I feel like that's part of our responsibility as well okay thank you we'll do Mr TR denic um excuse my ignorance I did not read through this whole thing and there's a lot of numbers and there's colors is there is there a color guide chart at the beginning that I missed no so like when when there's green yellow red I just assume red means we're in

100the negative simple things like that okay correct with the numbers on the bottom line it that's what it means um is there a column on this that states I know kogan has the specialty program like Mr Jesse stated but is there a column that states this is how many kids from the speci specialy program are within that number like like uh brentville high school for instance says netive 153 by 29 30 do we have a projection of how many kids are going to be in that specialty program so we we can't project how many will be in the specialty program in the out years but we can get disaggregate the data to show for example at kogan of the um 1,000 whatever excess how many of those students are actually in the specialty program can

101we get that be able we should be able to get that I think that would be helpful to possibly dispel the rumor that all of those kids are part of that program they're not we know that for sure so I mean we got you got boundaries that have contributed to I needed that to be said out loud okay um but also can I there is a capacity am I incorrect in saying this there is a capacity to the specialty programs at each school yes correct because there's kids do not get into the program all the time it's not an unlimited number of seats thank you I just wanted to also make that clear because I thought that that was true um and looking at these numbers and the negatives and things like that and and

102all of us talking about um you know what could be solved with redistricting um I know it's not a popular thing to say but knowing what's coming in my district and I've talked about it for a long time now um again we just hit 6,000 homes again like we go down we come back up like you're saying it's not always approved and this is not approved homes but in the pipeline we're at 6,000 um and the only reason we go up and down is because there's conversations being had about space and town homes and you know different models and blah blah blah blah blah but but we have a lot coming into our district and I firmly believe that a redistricting would help solve that problem in the interim that we're going to face and

103I know that possibly that's not till 2930 but if we don't start to initiate that now then it would be what how how many years does it take to do that can I being new here does it take so for redistricting our new policy depending on how many students are affected it could be implemented the very next year depending on when it does start so if we were to start in November it could be implemented the next year obviously we can make grandfather clauses if the board would like on different students being staying at their currently based school or what have you but it could be done within the year or there could be a phased implementation approach too I'm not talking about like school by school I'm saying what if we did a County

104wide registering how long does that take that we would have to look at it's something we have not done in the past it it would be years though per se it it could take years right so in order for it to be done in 2930 oh I'm G to ask Matt I'm gonna have Matt respond that yeah could could I just tag on to hers too could you differentiate when you talk about that as projects that are approved versus unapproved and how that factors into yeah I wasn't asking about that I was just asking how long the process takes yeah so we'll take it in two parts the first part with the residential development I'm Dr Cartage it's great to be back everyone happy new year thanks to my team for getting us to where

105we are today with this conversation so with the feedback that we heard last year from from Mr denck and counterparts related to how the projection model was incorporating future students from new construction there were there were some concerns there and so what we did this year was We redesigned that element to fold in students coming from future construction based on the bottomup approach like Mr Hy mentioned earlier so we're really letting the construction rates at these various communities being built throughout the county guide how quickly they build in our model that's fundamentally different from the way it was done previously where okay there were, 1500 houses built this year so we're going to use, 1500 for the next 10 years in projections and we'll just allocate those 1500 wherever throughout the county so it's a

106more data way to do this now there are some assumptions in there right so we worked with the planning department over at princ County government and we said this is kind of what we think the typical timeline is for a typical development when it's at this stage in the pipeline what do you think does that sound about right to you so we incorporated their feedback and based on where these developments are in the pipeline they might start building next year two years out three years out four years out that's why when we saw the graphic earlier you did see an uptick in how many units are anticipated to be constructed in like the fourth year a lot of those are the ones that Mr Nick mentioned do not have rezoning in place but they could

107by then and they could start yielding students four years from now it's a bit of a bathtub analogy situation the drains open that's our declining birth rates the Taps on that's our new housing construction who wins out is any data scientist guess right now because a lot can change between now and five years from now but what we can say is historically these have been the progression rates that we've observed with data these are the student yield rates that we've observed and if those developments begin building four years from now yielding students at the rates we've observed this is the best practices projection for students right now the other fun question redistricting countywide would that take years and years to do if you wanted to it [Laughter] could it doesn't necessarily have to so with

108Dr mcdade's support we were able to bring in a great consulting firm this last year who worked with each of you to redesign the redistricting process and policy that you will enforce here so with the extended Community engagement opportunities you know this is big we're doing it countywide we would have many Community meetings they would be probably in person they'd probably be virtual combination of the two they would need to be stretch throughout the whole County because this impacts everyone yeah I would say it would probably take at least 6 months to do that at a minimum and then the question is well when do you begin implementing these how do you begin implementing these those are all things through Community engagement Dr mcdade's guidance we could sort through I yeah I mean the part

109of the why I asked is I in in the public am getting a lot of questions because there are people that are dealing with the overcrowding currently you know um Mr wil talks about Covington Harper I have the noville school I have hey Market Elementary I have some that are right on the cusp of it and those parents will come to me in public and say can you just redistrict our school and I think there's this um conception that it's quick and it's easy and it's Snappy and that um certain people will just get to stay where they are because they can see the school from their front yard um it that may not be what turns out from that process um and I wanted to say that and then also can you expound on

110that a little bit yes so you would be taking a snapshot in time and trying to best optimize the attendance areas based on a variety of elements that are out outlined in our new regulation you have the facility optimization you have the demographics and student enrollment you have walkability closeness proximity School neighborhoods that's going to be as good of a process and result as you can have for that moment knowing that all those elements will change moving forward so it's a great optimization at that point in time but things could change I think it was mentioned earlier with Osborne Park the School's attendance area has not enough students in order to really provide that school with the programmatic offerings that it has been accustomed to over the years and so student transfers are augmenting that

111school's enrollment to stay afloat I bring that up because if the board provided great attendance areas for all the high schools if there isn't also an investigation and consideration for the policy or regulation 7212 to which governs High School transfers a lot of your work could be undone through transfers so my team can gladly assist with saying this is the optimal attendance area based on Resident students however when you start allowing students to flow through with intra District transfers that work can be undone thank you Matt I really appreciate it Lisa so stay there um well so so that you this brings up an interesting point though with Osborne Park's territory and it's always been like that I I did graduate from Osborne Park and at that time we didn't have as many schools of

112course and people came from a long distance to go there and it's still the same and um I and being the school board member for there I don't get complaints because people want to be there for those programs right same thing for colan I don't get complaints I get I get I get concerns where people are like my kids's going to be there next year I'm worried because it's very overcrowded and then I hear nothing because people want to be at those schools our our schools are good we have excellent schools here our elementary schools I know Covington Harper is packed I also know there's some great staff there right so our kids are getting a good education everywhere that is really Dr mcdade's trying to make sure that piece works as well so all

113of these are sort of like this um you know this web of puzzle pieces of things that have to sort of fit together and they're not easy conversations right um but uh and and the other thing about Osborne Park is that the people who live in my territory is actually very small compared to probably many other board members so it it makes it um these these these can be very challenging conversations I know that somebody came and talked to us about a veterinary program I've had people at op ask me about a veterinary program but maybe that's not the school to put it in because we need that kind of draw someplace else so I think these are really big they're very important con um considerations and um we want to make sure that every

114school is the school you want to put your kid in that's the bottom line so miss wall I want to commend the bathroom the bathtub analogy I really like that that's awesome very visual you can under I can really understand that and um I know that colan for instance just to add to this conversation since we're on this topic colan has more students in its attendance area than it can accommodate plus it has the only fine and performing arts program in the county which is very popular um so you know things like that I mean make it a lot of water going into the bathtub and then not as many um not as many students not wanting to go um or out transfers I guess but um I think uh what might be beneficial um

115for the board I'm going to propose that maybe we do this at a future board meeting would be a discussion about our specialty programs the numbers how many kids transferring out what the programs are what maybe we could give it a popularity index or something like that like where we have programs that are replicated and what what seems to be our what are our programs that are the most popular um and what would be easy easily replicated in another area based on this the school building themselves because I do know that buildings need to be suited for whatever specialty program it is that might be helpful for um in connection to our understanding of all of our enrollment issues um because it's a very complex problem and and as I alluded to earlier we don't

116even know for sure what our area this this area is traditionally grown the DC area you know the federal government Etc but we don't know what's coming in the next four years for sure we really don't and we don't know the long-term future either um so we it is definitely like like you say we don't know the rate of the water going out we don't know the rate of the water going in um we can make our best projections going forward but that requires a lot of data and a lot of sophisticated analysis and it's and and at the end of the day we could get we could be wrong because I do remember some of our data projecting you know 94,000 students 95,000 students and here we are looking at maybe 87 you know

117in five years and that who could have predicted that that we would have a pandemic and people would get tired in Northern Virginia you know not stop having babies whatever it is um so that might be something worth looking into as a board I think and I'm going to propose that we maybe dive into that I saw maybe four years ago uh before Dr mcdade's time a really cool graphic where there was a program somebody had analyze the specialty to remember this and it had like arrows going in and arrows going out with numbers and might remember somebody working on that yeah yeah that was Scott Hy okay oh yes and it was extremely helpful there was a lot of good data but obviously that's going to need to be updated because things have changed

118so much um but I do like that we have a lot of specialty programs and kids do really like the specialty programs I know that they are a draw and families are happy about being able to get into programs when their kids are really interested in a topic I've heard a lot of positive things from that so I do think we're moving in the right direction to keep them and maybe we improve them thank you okay my turn um couple things to point out for everyone and and if there's anyone in the audience here press there is a number of documents provided to the board this evening and I should have gone over this before one is the annual um comprehensive financial report the board members have the second and I think this is important

119to point out especially after some of the rhetoric in last night's border County supervisor meeting we do have the chair beckard audit from The Prince William County and page six and seven are very important those are the um findings on the audit for the Prince William County schools and I'd like to read them on page six we did not identify any control deficiencies that we believed to be material weaknesses um and that's the seventh year eighth year 10th year in a row we've done that and it's very important for everyone to understand also corrected and uncorrected mistakes uh they were not noted so I think it's very important that everyone know that the Prince William County schools which um is around a$2 billion dollar operating budget um you know all in maybe even a little

120bit more than that continues to operate uh with strong financial um sensibility uh really strong controls um is part of the reason we continue to have a triple a bond rating uh from actually all three rating agencies which is a triple triple which is very rare and I think it's important to know that that the Prince William County schools continues to operate in that way tonight's CIP is another example of what I believe is responsible fiscal management and thoughts the least sexy items today in the CIP that you would see are the HVAC improvements and if you take a look at those there 22 schools that are going to be impacted over the next 5 years and I think that's really good because as we live in these really cold days and we know that

121the really warm days are coming up the HVAC system is really critical to the functioning of the entire school so 22 of these will be either replaced or renovated or significantly improved another less SE sexy item you know these days I guess would be energy and sustainability our continued commitments in that uh will continue to provide long-term savings that I believe are very important for the school division to take those dollars saved and put them into things like HVAC Renovations I think it's also important to note that um most of our maintenance and I think it's a question from Mr use of most of our maintenance and renovation projects are not used uh we're not using bonded money bonded money typically goes to new construction is that correct yes and major Renovations yeah so I

122think it's really important for everyone to know that one of the costliest things for the school division as you take a look at the CIP is our maintenance budget maintenance budget is coming from actual dollars not borrowed monies and so that's really important borrowed monies are monies that we bond out that we pay back over time but the maintenance is really expensive and that comes out of budget that really you know we I'd love to use for expanding programs or you know adding teachers or more curriculum or increased salaries so that does continue to be a big part of the capital Improvement plan and I think that's important for the public to be aware of as well uh I think it's important um you know we have done since Dr mcdade's arrival um I think

123a remarkable job on um working through the CIP and and and and I think it's really important I want to thank her and her team on their more analytical and precise um ways about evaluating our CIP and looking at our enrollment projections their financial impacts and the final impacts on Capital Improvement plan these these efforts that she has put in and and the more efficient they they will allow more efficient use of taxpayer dollars with Maximum Impact I also appreciate the facilities study because we are now addressing the needs of the school division on uh what is needed most what is necessary what's a true need rather than what we used to have which was a completely arbitrary schedule um and I and I think that has gone a long way to I think the

124public should know better use of their taxpayer dollars and I think that also can help correct long-term inequities and again more purposeful with our resources um I think on the boundaries I I think what I would say and I've been through a lot of the these boundary meetings and I think what everyone should remember is that um you know while we say we'd like to redistrict the entire County and and and those are those are good ideas there are ideas but but the only way to do it um you you would really have to uh democracy is an inherently inhuman Endeavor so if M Dr carage comes to us with this great plan for here's how we're going to you know balance our school capacity balance our in in in my primary goal frankly because

125all the studies show that the number one impact on student performance is mixing socioeconomic demographics not race but socioeconomic you mix rich and poor you will have better outcomes in the school for all students all boats rise there's a lot of research to support that so any boundary rebounding should take that into consideration but if you have six months worth of town halls every group and every Community is going to come in here and tell us how this plan that we have will not work for them and they will not tolerate that and that is as I point out an inherently inhuman Endeavor which will then be prone to going back to the problems that have gotten us into this place in the beginning so one should be very careful on how we look and

126talk about this when we do it peace meal by peace meal I will say that since Dr McDade has come since Mr Dr carage has in in our improved policies we are making some improvements we still have a ways to go one should also remember there are real challenges on this enrollment stuff we are losing students um the homes are not coming as quickly and they're not coming with as many kids as they used to be the cost of living is really high and I think this community has to consider that when we're making judicious decisions with their dollars I don't want to be the one closing schools that is the last thing I want to do and I'll be very clear you know Mr Jesse pointed it out whether he intended to point it

127out or not but during the colan redistricting they took neighborhoods that were going to Osborne Park jumped them over Hilton High School and sent them to colan and that is the reason Osborne Park is dramatically under enrolled and we had to create this specialty program which by the way people should note this is not a common thing in school divisions across the country specialty programs you know it's sort of our way of addressing ing school choice maybe keep that school choice crowd happy maybe addressing sort of um you know let let's let's let kids bounce around and move it is a good way to conserve resources meaning not having a computer tech program at every high school it's probably cheaper doing it in two high schools one on each side and moving kids rather than

128hiring staff but that is what we have here we have all inherited a system of specialty programs that I believe really the undermining you know re the real reason they exist is to provide quote school choice and to move people um to maybe schools they'd rather go to not even necessarily on the specialty items so Osborne Park is currently almost I mean half it's you know maybe at least over a third or um a transfer students and and and that is because we screwed up that redistricting um and so we have to be aware of that and everyone in the Eastern part of the county should be very clear that when we come to the redistricting for the 14th high school every single school on the Eastern side of the county in the high school

129will be impacted it has to be and we're going to have to do something about the specialty programs there is no way around it um and I think that's very important I will tell you that since Dr McDade arrived what I also appreciate which I've always had a problem with here is that you know I I think that this specialty idea has a allowed communities to bounce around and move and Tak in the um the fire away from fixing the real problem and the real problem is making sure all of our high schools are operating at the highest levels because I think we have for too long in my opinion this is purely the chair's opinion ignored accountability of those high schools especially the high school accountability and making sure our student performance is where

130it needs to be and me you know I for one um you know while I like the idea of specially programs I like the idea of being able to you know you know these are nice um I have a real problem when we don't focus enough on making sure that our high schools are performing at the best level they have the best principles there they have the best staff there because we know that works and if we're not focusing on that that's a problem Dr McD's strategic plan launching thriving futures has gone a long way to start improving performance and and in that and and and this is all part of the capital Improvement plan right you know we hear about oh let's let's build a better school put more windows in this school more

131important than the windows more important than anything is else is the quality of the teacher and the quality of the principal in that building this school board has spent a lot of time increasing salaries improving recruitment improving retainment Dr McDade has come she's brought more dollars to teachers in the last four years than we have in any other window in the history of the School Division and I think it's really important that we're doing everything we can to address Performance and that is the most important thing so while I recognize you know um capacity issues which are are really concerns to me and I have real concerns about building the new high school how that's going to impact capacity and what impacts that will have long-term and possibly closing schools I think we we need

132to be very aware of this work and this is really important stuff and I think the public should be very aware but for anybody to walk out of this room to think that we can just rebalance the and change the boundaries and that's an easy thing to do um it is a human endeavor prone to continuous mistakes and problems that we're all going to get ourselves into and and I'm not saying we should ignore that but I'm just warning you all as we do this we need to continue to do this so we have some rebounding coming up we have the new new high school the new schools coming we're going to address that but long term we have to think as Miss wall points out you know what are the things we need to

133do um we have to look at specialty programs does it make sense to have one finer performing ARS program in the county or as Dr McDade has put she has investing money not in the CIP and I want to remind the public on improvements in all of our Auditorium I don't know about all the auditoriums but significant number of auditoriums that need the improvements are getting that funding as we speak now to do that work over this next summer and that's a commitment to making sure our theater programs Auditorium programs vocal singing programs are going to be at the highest quality at each other's schools so I want everyone to know that this board I believe you know uh is directly committed to improving performance everywhere in all categories for everyone we may differ on

134how we get there but this is something that I I do believe this board is really focused on our strategic plan focuses on and I'll lead into the fact that we will now start asking the public about our next strategic plan and that's where we need to hear from the public on what their expectations are with what we do with their money and for how long and for where we're going to do that it's really important so we need engagement like we did the first time around even more would be U even more robust would be great I trust that the superintendent and her team will put together another strong strategic plan and I know board members here have a lot of new ideas about what they'd like to see in that but it takes

135a lot of work time and energy I apologize for taken to you know um a lot of time here to speak on this but I think you know I left it to be last cuz I really wanted to make sure that you know the high points you should all know that this audit we continue to have clean audits we continue to be award-winning program on our financials um you see you know there is money in here it looks like we're increasing our borrowing for Bond projects or primarily for the high school right Mr Yousef right Dr McDade most of the money in the upcoming years on the bond baring is for the construction I do want to I wanted to comment on your um just kind of just um not my rambling no you said

136that I didn't uh I just want to uh no I want to comment on the aspect of fiscal integrity and um just put a finer point on something you said around you know the audit and and our management of funds and I think it is important to note that in addition to the clean audits um we do have a fund balance but that fund balance is based on that are needed to cover the cost of our Capital Improvements so we do have current and future construction where we have to have dollars on hand to pay those contracts so because the money may be sitting in our fund balance doesn't mean that it's just unincumbered funds that are sitting there with no purpose so I do want uh Mr youf to speak to that because I

137think that it is important for um the public to know how we are using those dollars and that those dollars are a part of our Capital improve Improvement plan and we have addressed how those funds um are and will be allocated thank you Dr mdate so to put this in context um and and just historically in FY 2024 with each CIP we develop a budget for our our Capital Improvements or construction Fund in fy4 we had a $500 million budget why do we need that much money well when you're building a new high school and you have to go out and ask for beds you have to be able and this is a state law under the Virginia Public procurement act you have to have the budget appropriation and authority to be able to encumber

138those funds so that's why we put all this money the spending of that money can take two years 3 years four years depending on the um length of the project what happened in 2024 into 2025 is we deferred the 14th high school we still had the budget we still retained that budget Authority we do a carryover package at the end of the year that we provide the County Board of Supervisors but prior to that in April of last year when Dr Latif presented the school budget we did bring this up that hey we're deferring the 14th high school and there will be a substantial carryover so let's just just say that the 14th High School is is is going to cost us $200 billion and we had the budget Authority but we did not spend

139it we have to carry it over into the next year and that is what we consider a multi-year project so that is a common practice that every other jurisdiction does we do not take the budget and budget every fiscal year because our contractors and our Builders need to know that we have the authority to do that and not wait every year so I I think it's it's a little bit of um what I consider misinterpretation or misinformation and secondly understanding that there are controls that we have over how we spend we have encumbrance controls in our financial systems internal controls and also all of our contracts undergo a thorough legal review so yes we did have a substantial carryover from 24 to 25 but there is a very very clear reason why that happened and

140those funds are all accounted for um and allocated and our Auditors are well aware of these are the reasons for why we do that correct yes yeah and and and and so you know as I was I started out also you know other items that are here is the presentation that the board received and also important if folks want to take a look at the CIP portal and supporting analysis which has information about enrollment Dr Latif can ask you something before you close out real quick yeah um this meeting is not live I did bring this up last year when we had the same meeting and I'm just wondering if in the future um our work sessions Can Can Be Live since we do allow the public to attend I feel like it's fair to

141also allow them to attend virtually while we're doing it is that a problem or can we do that I I'm not opposed to that we have the capacity to do it we we do um and this has nothing to do with the the statement about it being live but I do just want to note that we record it and we do post it for the public to be able to view the full meeting um and the presentation is available to the public but we do have the capacity to do the live version as well we certainly can look at that yeah I don't have any objection does any board member have any objection to that okay we'll look for I don't have any objection but I just wondered why traditionally it wasn't live I I'm

142here since has been like this I don't memory if memory serves me correctly because we did it in this room I think years ago we just didn't have the capacity to do it live and so that's why we started the recording um I could be wrong but I know we've have much better media and Technology than we had originally that was like 10 years ago so we've upgraded so we can we can upgr you if it makes sense we could do it back in the boardroom I don't think there's any any problem with that if that makes sense as well it just takes away from we're prepared um either way our team's prepared either way um I think that's all I had and and I again I want to thank everyone for all the hard

143work that goes into this I think the public should take a look at this this will be part of our budget um I want to thank everybody who's put in the time and effort on this is there anything else I'm missing here did we cover everything Dr McDade any other comments no I think we've covered everything um that was in the plan today okay uh at this point if there's no objection the meeting will be adjourned [Applause]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.