CorpusRecord 101998

Northshore School District Special Meeting January, 31st 2025: Superintendent Search

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Northshore School District
Date
2025-02-01
Location
Snohomish County, WA
Material
Transcript
Extent
3,225 words · about 18 min
Collected
2026-06-13

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Hayes can hear us best if we use our microphone and I'm going to be occasionally pausing to make sure if she has a questions or input or what have you um and we will take care of that but we are now recording um director Hayes I'm going to go ahead and start the meeting um and we'll I will like I said cue you when it's when we are pausing to get some input otherwise let me know if you need to chat but I'm going to go ahead and call the special meeting to order um thank you all this is a special meeting on behalf of the school board to begin um the conversations around the superintendent search process as superintendent Tully has announced his retirement um the school board is here to start a process

002so our attendees are we have our recording secretary Peggy King we have um Schoolboard me members jacqulyn mordi and Elizabeth soac um School Board member Sandy Hayes is participating virtually um from Washington DC she's at a wasda meeting representing not only norshore but Washington State very well so she is joining us on the phone um I am Amy cast I currently serve as president of the board and we will go ahead and start this meeting so this meeting is very straightforward we have time on the agenda to discuss um a couple topics around the superintendent search um and then there is a place on our agenda for an action item um in order to solidify board action around it so there are at least two things that we need to discuss and decide which way

003to move forward with today um first of all is whether or not our board would like to hire a superintendent search firm some districts do some districts don't it can cost um when we've done it in the past the range has been about $3 to $50,000 so that it's something for the board to keep in mind so that's something for us to discuss um and also two um action would be um we would want to take action and talk about whether or not we would want to seek an interim superintendent or if we'd want to seek a permanent superintendent so pros and cons to both we can talk about that a little bit and then once we've had our discussion I'll ask for a motion and we'll combine those two thoughts and someone can make

004a motion and we'll go forward with that does that sound good okay great so first of all yes director C yes um are I feel like we might be jumping a step um that we are going to do a search as opposed to just appointing someone oh thank you for that clarification so um let's also consider that as well that um and director Tran is joining us so we are doing great so um we'll amend the minutes to for director trans participation here so also um also here we're going to talk about whether or not we're going to an uh appoint someone whether if we're not going to appoint someone and do a superintendent search whether or not we're going to do um a search using um staff within Northshore or hire a search firm

005and then the third aspect of this whether or not we want to look for an interim superintendent or whether or not we'd want to go and um search for a permanent superintendent so those are the three aspects um in order to kind of help the discussion and um provide some information um Deputy superintendent SL applicable here head of HR um jolen Bergie took our last request for a proposal from 2 years ago when we did utilize a search firm and kind of updated it with dates that might apply for this search right now so that would give the board kind of a comparison to consider it wasn't meant to say oh this is something we're definitely going to do but I think it's easier to talk about something when you have an example in front

006of you so those are the so appoint versus I'm taking notes director Hayes so thank you for that appoint versus um search so um I think we just open it up for a discussion and if anyone has any questions any thoughts they want to dive in on um let's just open up I do have one question that I think is relevant to whether we consider an interim and um as and well a few points but I didn't think to look up when we actually made a final decision on the last permanent um so the last permanent search we started so so you're talking about the 2022 process or the 2016 process the two sorry the 2022 so we we started if I remember correctly from the the the old RFP we started that in October

007of 22 had appointed superintendent tal as the inum I'm just wondering how long that process took to name the final permanent it had to have been at least you know into March it went into March okay I did look up the 2016 process which the timing here is very similar so that um started with an early February initiation and um search by the board for a firm the actual superintendent search process started in April the first I I think almost April 1st I have it pulled up here actually April 4th of 2016 um and it concluded in early June okay with the idea that the um the contract was signed I think it was June 15th with the idea that again it it made it before July 1st okay so where my my thoughts were

008going with that is that we when when superintendent Reed um resigned we were first she had first to go through her own interview process so it was a little bit later and it was so when we finally had that decision we decided to to appoint an an interim or search for an interim I think this time we have sufficient time um and without I think starting in October and then coming up to the holidays and having to go through that in the first of the year uh complicated the length of time that that that process took um but this time around I think I think we have a good amount of time to do a permanent search without first going to an interim okay okay so it so that thank you thank you I don't

009need to remark on that any any other thoughts I'm not terribly familiar with this process having not done it before um so I know that superintendent T was interim and so the purpose last time was to search for an interim person and then make a decision on whether or not they would continue or or was the idea to have an interim person and then search for a permanent person or what's the benefit of interim benefit of interim the reason why the board at that time decided to do interim was because um superintendent Reed had made her announcement well into the spring and um in the prior instances of a superintendent search there had been a robust round of community engagement and the board felt there wouldn't be time um in order to get that done

010um especially with the permanent right placing um so there was a shorter amount of of um Community engagement done for an interim the idea being then we would have the full year for a more robust um director Hayes do you have any other Reflections about that process you'd like to add yeah um well the other part of the story was that everybody and their brother was looking for a superintendent at that same time and so not we were well behind many of the other districts in the process so it was going to be challenging to find a high quality candidate um as opposed to this year which were much earlier and there's very few districts in this St that are searching that are our size that are searching for a superintendent good point historically do

011when we use a search firm are they looking more locally or do they cast The Net wide and what does that look like that's a really good question so the last several times and part if um the sample that we were given in section two part of the criteria was asking the search firm to look Nationwide so the last several times we have um we have done that we have put that in as a criteria it's something we can we can talk about now as well once we um got through kind of these big questions if we do decide as a board to go forward with a superintendent search I figured we'd pull up the example see if there's any tweaks we'd want to do in that criteria what are the pros and cons for

012using a search firm versus going out on our own and some of the other options I mean director mg if you want to dive in I have I have some opinions um well first it's a whole heck of a lot of work um to do this search and we want someone who is or a group of people who are familiar with superintendents plugged into districts across the country um and we were look we had looked last time at a number of uh recruiting firms who do exactly that I mean this is what they focus on and so they they have staff who routinely you know have been involved in superintendent searches know who's at what district across the the the country and so they have all of that in place rather than I think the

013alternative would be having our staff here uh do that work which I think would be a huge burden on on them uh and take away from what they're doing here so that was that was my thinging and and they probably have access to more like advertising or sort of head hunting kind of strategies than we would have time or ability to is that kind of well and it's I think helpful to point out that for um it's not uncommon for senior level cabinet positions for search firms to be used also so it's not just superintendent again it's it's a pretty complicated vetting process and and again having the contacts and are admin hello I I'll just add um two things one it it kind of already sounds like we're leaning that direction but I I

014just wanted to to quot uh David kogan put a vow on it that we do a search as opposed to appointing um it sets the uh superintendent up for Success if they've had to earn the role instead of just receiving it and you get Buy in from the community um the the advantage of a search firm is they have the skill set that we don't have plus it puts a wall between us and potential candidates and I've had enough times where I've ended up in some uncomfortable situations that being able to defer them to the search firm was very handy so I that's a good point I just hearing the pros and cons here I see a lot of Pros for the search firms so I agree we should go with the search firm it

015sounds like we also need to choose between appointing versus searching um I think appointing is like Sandy said you've earned it and met the criteria in a public way and been you know had sort of had the community has sort of had access to you and been exposed to you in the vein of I'm trying to be superintendent versus us just appointing someone because um that would be easier in some ways but again they wouldn't have gone through the process to demonstrate that they have the skill set to do the job necessarily okay that's that's just my opinion any cons for appointing versus searching right now the the only other factor I think to consider is the fee so so when we did an interim and then a permanent placement that was two fees right

016which is relevant given our financial situation so appointing one of the pros is you don't have to pay fee or take on extra staff time so that's the trade-off do we know the fee off the top our head from um in the request for proposal the range is about $30 to $50,000 okay and that includes all the um Community engagement we asked for and pulling reports screening candidates helping run interview processes things like that what does the community engagement look like well that yeah go ahead director mcgerty just goingon to say we um it it was pretty pretty extensive the last time we did I was and I was really proud of the community too I mean we had um surveys and you know put it out to the community what do they want to

017do they were included in the interview process I mean or the in terms of the forums that were held for the yeah so there was setting criteria for qualities we would like in a superintendent there was both um surveys that were translated into our top eight languages I believe um to get some information that way as well as some inperson Town Halls as well and then um once that was coated into the actual job posting the search firm took that um screened applications we saw the list of the um of everyone who had applied but of course the search firm had an idea of who should be the semi-finalists the semi-finalists were kept confidential in order to not impact their current employment I think maybe six or seven semi-finalists if I remember correctly which we

018interviewed in who we interviewed in person um but it was kept very confidential and then once a group of finalists was announced we chose in North sure to have that be a public process some some districts choose not to um but then at that point Su uh director mordi helped organize um part of that vetting of the finalist was was almost a focus group so when room 208 upstairs it was some students it was some staff members community members um and it was kind of a a panel situation where one at a time of course um the finalists were brought in and ask some questions and then we got feedback from the room and then also there was a public town hall with Q&A that we got feedback as well okay so it sounds like

019at least three touch points for the community to provide input through the surveys the interviews and then the public town hall right right okay that's great what is the reasoning behind choosing to have the process for the finalists be private versus public there's some thoughts that you can get more applicants if it's private so they don't if they don't perhaps feel comfortable letting their current School Board know that they're applying you might get more applicants if it's 100% confidential um what we've been told there have been some distri actually districts our size have done it this way and that panel focus group I I explained um they were asked to sign perhaps non-disclosure agreements but something pretty similar um and so that was the community input into the final selection um but the names you

020know when when our finalists are announced and other districts going through this as well usually there it's a press release of who the finalists are with some bio biographic information about them their districts definitely know they're a finalist okay um just just to be clear the the semi finalist candidates those are completely confidential when we interview them only after we select from them the finalists who then necessarily need to come here and interact with the community and be interviewed uh face to face they they necessarily have made it public and director Hayes do you have any other thoughts to add to that question um well I didn't really hear the question could you repeat the question yeah it was what are the benefits of having the finalist process be private versus public oh yeah you're

021you're going to lose people who don't that they're currently sitting superintendents in districts that are not uh interested in their districts knowing that they're looking for another job um and I think we are an attractive enough of a district that we can get a a superintendent that has experience interested but if they're going to have to let their Community know and then they anyway it just makes things very awkward for them we have what we and I think president C said all this that we usually um have the top two or three finalists are announced to the community so it's not like we're keeping anything from them um and I will just cycle back again I'm just confirming that it's sounds like we are deciding we're going to do a search as opposed to a

022point but I didn't I don't know if I missed that we Haven inclusive we haven't gotten to the point of making a motion yet director Hayes so we're just exploring we're exploring options yeah okay I was seeing it in my because I I don't have the agenda in front of me I was seeing it as three different topics so I didn't because if we're going to point then having the conversation about the search firm is not a most eff use of our time we only have one action item on the agenda okay so anyway that that's I'm just clarifying um and then the other thing about the search firm there was talk about the process we used and yes we started in October but we hadn't really done Community engagement just on the the future

023of the district and what they were looking for in many years when superintendent re left um but that was only two and a half years ago that we did this plus we did a whole essentially another round with budget cuts so I'm wondering if we need to do as deep of a dive with focus groups and surveys about what they're looking for and maybe just have it be more truncated here's here's who we've got and what do you think I feel like in in the vein of the way this community likes to be told about things and likes to have input we should at least have something that people have the opportunity to say what they're interested in or where what where their priorities lie or or even say what were the strengths that superintendent

024Tully had that they would like to see continue on into the next superintendent um because that's also helpful information um so yeah like is it important that your superintendent have a lot of experience with financial stability of your of large corporations or whatever um but at least something I think because if we just say here's your choices um but you know again along the along the way though there there could be options how many Town Halls we host for Gathering input into the criteria you know things I think there would be some variables to think about yeah as accessible as we can make collecting the input would be wonderful too so people people who can't attend town halls or people who prefer to answer surveys or yeah couple different mediums would be nice yep and

025and still maintain our sanity I think that's important as well um because the more indepth we go with the community the more we're going to have to be involved and I love meetings so much but at some point I might get burned out with meetings um it is a lot of meetings a lot of meetings um but I want to have them be useful meetings and you know if we're you know sort of hitting the same nail with the hammer over and over and over again it can feel repetitive um so I think I agree with what director TR said is having a couple different options available to people but maybe less number of them overall perhaps yeah and that's something that would be again it it sounds like we would be considering a search

026firm that's that's something you discuss as you're interviewing search firms how their approach and what they've seen be successful do we make a separate motion for the search firm or are we bundling all three of the topics together in we we any I will entertain a motion we can move on to action items at any time we can B we can bundle uh I would bundle the three of them together okay since that matches our agenda all right so I think who we're using our method of searching I think we discussed that what's what are the other two can you so um we discussed interim or permanent interim or per and search firm or not so a so appointing or searching and if we're searching internal staff or firm and um interim position to post

027or a permanent position to post I I move that we start a search process uh to find a search firm who look for a permanent superintendent second that okay so now it's been moved we can keep doing discussion if we like or we can go ahead and call for a Voice vote just just I know we want to keep this short I'm just curious though yes yes Absolut we have experts here still um who is going to be our quote unquote interim we're not appointing we're not doing interims but you know who is going to fulfill the role of the superintendent while we're searching so the idea is this is why we have some lovely support in the room um our human resources department is ready to post the request for proposal Monday morning so

028we would kick this off if if the if the motion passes we would kick this off right away and we would get the position filled ideally um by early June we're going to have to talk about the June 1st date maybe we'll get some input um but then that way there would be some overlap and because superintendent Tully's last day is June 30th so the idea being the position would be filled before superintendent T's last day ah that clarifies things yeah absolutely okay so um so then we can call for the vote and then see if there's any last questions how's that s sound so the motion's on the table I'm going to call for a roll call vote so we're going to start with director hay since she's virtual um yay or nay director

029Hayes yay yay yay yay yay and yay thank you so much so we have this sample from um executive direct Deputy superintendent and executive director Bergie um there's just one besides correcting my email address in here and things like that there's just one so if we look here um and we can do this while you're home again we have until Monday morning so I would just point out um in the scope of work section and and it's highlighted yellow what's been edited um beginning with this number one is where the details kind of are so if you want to take a look at that um I'm around all weekend um we can we can pull together some ideas the only other thing I was going to talk to Deputy superintendent Bergie about the first line

030on this is that the um the process list is going from April 4th to May 16th which might be too tight so and again based on what we did in 2016 maybe we'll just bump it up to May 30th or something and then we'll get input from search firms would be my only suggestion at this point might there be a chance of starting it a little bit earlier as opposed to well there I think there are some State requirements in terms of how long this is posted for with the feedback two it has to be posted at least two weeks there's some feedback processes I think that's pretty well stipulated since we're governmental entity um so I think it's as it's as accelerated as it can be but good question I yeah good question all

031right so okay any input anything else director Hayes she might have she might have no good you're good all right this call will be recorded okay well there you go call is no longer being recorded okay so anything else before we adjourn for the evening I think we'll we'll have time to discuss it further as the process goes along right just to loop back to the um involvement of the community we we have set a precedent and I think they will definitely expect to be as involved as they have been in the past um but as we've said it may not need to go as indepth since it's only been two and a half years yeah so we and again it's great to have input from search firms when you're talking about that yeah what's

032the selection for the panel like for the community panel oh yeah you ran that last time director mcgerty we don't have to talk about it now no we don't I'd have to go back and look at my notes yeah okay okay we can do that all right I'm going to go ahead and adjourn the special meeting thank you everyone so much enjoy the school dance tonight director soac

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.