CorpusRecord 102185

Regular Board Meeting - 01.13.2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Othello School District
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Adams County, WA
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,829 words · about 50 min
Collected
2026-06-13

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001thank you like to welcome all of our guests is there any translation needs okay at this time I will accept an approval of the agenda all motion to approve the agenda I'll second all in favor I I agenda motion approves 5 Zer now we will move on to our recognition portion of the night yeah we uh you know typically we we make an effort to recognize our students and our staff for the excellent work that they do every day in our schools it's always nice to he from our principes and our directors when they call those folks out but it's nice to let the community know and to let all of you know that January is Schoolboard appreciation month and um today is an unusual day in the sense that it's our new Governor's transition

002so he hasn't put out a proc I don't think school board recognition was the first thing on his agenda but I'm sure that it's coming um but we wanted to uh take a few moments to recognize all of you for your effort and um there's a a certificate for you that I want to pass down and absent the governor's Proclamation maybe we could just personalize it a little bit and I would just share a word of appreciation about each of you if that's okay with the board all right well I'll start with aaro and and one of the things I've I've come to know about director pruneda is uh certainly his love for our community and for our students and he always has a Keen Eye looking out for our teachers how is this going

003to impact our teachers and I know that that uh having a students and a spouse in our system uh he brings a to the work and I've always appreciated that uh I know what director pruna I'm always going to know where he stands and I've always appreciated that about him so I appreciate his work in in the last year on the board uh president prow who I know I think has been on the board since our covid experience and has certainly gone uh the Rounds Around some unusual circumstances in Schoolboard and I what I appreciate about director prow is uh the steadiness to take this new leadership opportunity and to help guide the board into the next consideration of the alal school district beyond Behind the Strategic plan thinking about new considerations perhaps for facilities

004and things that are coming our way and and again keeping a key eye Keen eye out for the the the best moves for our teachers and for our kids so thank you for to director prow for that Ken who I see on Zoom certainly is the veteran of the group and has been on board for quite some time and um when I meet with Ken individually when he was board president and he would come in and meet with me what I I always knew the meeting was going to be brief for me and for him and it was never going to be emotional Ken is a very steady presence um he's very calming and keeps um keeps me grounded when things get tough and is shares messages in a way that are I think are

005are neutral and to provide calm for for the team and I think that's a really good um a good uh component of our team and so I really have appreciated Ken's steady leadership uh director vinsky um I know that he graduated in 1991 because he's said it almost every meeting and I graduated with him just one year earlier and what I have appreciated about Chris's presence on the board is not only being mindful of the opportunities and experiences we're creating for our kids but he's particularly mindful of the makeup of our community uh the egg based sort of economy and the kinds of folks that live and work in the oala school district and I've always appreciated Chris looking back back toward tradition but also pushing us to pursue new experiences for our kids and

006staff and I think that's a a difficult balance to maintain and that all people don't have and so I've appreciated that about him director Gerber who I got to spend some time with this weekend at the legislative conference and we're going to share that a little bit with you um I've known uh director Gerber since he was a student I didn't know he was uh maybe he wasn't like this as a student but a guy takes more notes than perhaps any board member that I've been around um and what I appreci appreciate about that and I've shared this with our principles over and over this board that we currently have doesn't forget things when we say we're going to do something they expect us to get it done and uh one of those reasons is

007one Aaron has a great memory but he also takes great notes and so I apprec appreciate his attention to detail and the level of accountability it provides for me um and for the for the staff who know that when we say something to this board um that we're giving them our word and they're going to hold us to that so I want to recog recogniz all of you for all of your work if your families were here I'd recognize them because I know it's difficult to show up to the meetings and to to take time away from your family now for our student board members we're not recognizing you today uh we'll do that at a different time but I don't know miles if you wanted to add anything to the conversation maybe put you

008on the spot about your experience as a student rep with with board members uh yeah sure um all the board members especially when we had our lead conference trip I think I had a great experience with each and every one of you guys en again I like Ang thoughtfulness and wittiness too dor binski I enjoy I I also like to focus on the the a kind of system and I see it a lot in our schools especially in high school we see a lot of people who are moving towards CTE route so I see that you know his efforts are they're good for us they're good for the kids Lindsay love talking to you old time she's just a great person out that be around honestly I thank you guys all you guys have made

009very time always fun always something to do never moment well again I want to I do want to close by um sharing with the community and with our staff our deep appreciation for signing up for a a position that doesn't come with certainly a lot of compensation it comes with a lot of phone calls um a lot of folks who want to bend your ear about particular issues and I appreciate you taking on that on in the interest of serving our kids so thank you and and happy Schoolboard recognition M thank you thank you thank you that was a nice surprise yeah oh Round of Applause thank you um appreciate everyone showing up tonight when you're not required to be here that's very nice so thank you um thank you superintendent brez for all the

010nice words you said about us we are going to move into our student representative reports and we would like to welcome our two new student reps we've got Isabelle Sanchez and Liliana bastino did I say that correct okay great and of course always our shining star miles um so yeah we'll turn the time over to you guys majority well okay High School's been pretty dry I'd say we're kind of just in the the big battle Sports so everyone's kind of out and about right now one thing that is a concern though is a lot of people are starting to hear about our Dohs transition not necessarily scared but they're just looking more the logistical side um classroom sizes teachers how's it going to look because the different like if they don't the same kind of

011classes they do that we do it's whole the work is different so I think people are just looking for tal Clarity I'm assuming you know looking at this right now we'll talk something about that with this uh Levy stuff here and ultimate I just wanted to introduce our two people Isabelle she is I have her an avid FBLA leadership uh cheer she's everywhere with me and I she think she's going to be a great fit for this position same with Liliana these guys are both SCH to they do their work all the time on top of doing all their other extra creers Liliana is a great voice and um she's good connecting with her running start students as well I think this G to be a good good section of kids obviously we do Mission

012and Katie I'm excited to see what we do us three do you girls want to add anything um I'm just very excited to have this opportunity to beud this is definitely an opportunity I've been looking forward to it's not it's something very new to me I'm not ership stuff but I feel like this is a great way for me to show what I have and show others that I'm able to take on a leadership well thank you we're so excited to have both of our new student reps on the board so thank you for being here director prow if I could address miles for just one moment and the other students I know that the when we're staying away from the word transition about Dohs and a lot of us in the system are having

013trouble with that because we know it is a transition and we're talking about it as an integration how do we bring those students and and those teachers over to OS in a way that feels good for for everyone at the next board meeting on the 27th we'll have a report that we're going to provide about that work uh we've been working pretty closely with uh principal Tovar and his team uh principal aeson and we have an outside consultant Dr Chuck Selena from Gonzaga University who's gone through this process in the Sunnyside School District several years ago and so he's really pushing on us to think about how we're doing it so that we do it in the in the best interest of everyone so I hope you bring your questions uh next time on the

01427th and listen to that presentation and then you know challenge us to make sure that we we do it right by the students who are at dos and the kids that are currently at OS so we'll provide that update in two weeks thank you um moving on to board member discussions do we have a legislative report director uh yes just briefly so the legislative the 105 day legislative session started today um new governor new attorney general new all sorts of positions are new now um so we get into that like Pete said we attended a legislative conference over the weekend and we're going to talk a lot more about that in the superintendent informational items um we have a preschool site visit coming up on Tuesday January 21st um I let director binsky know that

015I would not be here so he's going to run that meeting at the preschool and is there anything else anyone would like to discuss no okay we will move on to re approvals I will accept a motion to approve approvals a motion to approve the required approvals I'll second all in favor I any opposed just really quick do I need to say any opposed yeah it's it's always good to provide Clarity for the community and those watching if they're not able to see or or if that audio really provide and it provides a record for our minutes as well okay yep making sure um moving on to required approvals early accounts payable warrants two I'll make motion I'll make a motion to approve early accounts pable warrants to all in favor I any oppos and

016I will abstain moving on to number three required approvals early accounts payable warrants three I'll make a motion to approve are they Council pable Wars three all in favor I I any opposed I'll just sustain from that okay motion passes um and now we will move on to our superintendent informational items yeah two items uh this evening uh one on Levy Logistics that Amy sarez and I are going to talk through a little bit and I'll give you uh some background on why we're doing that what might might seem like a little bit early and director Gerber and I wanted to have a conversation with the board about what we learned at the legislative conference and so I think he's going to jump into some of the components you have a few resources in front

017of you about what the um the entities uh wda who represents School District directors Wasa who represents School administrators and wasbo who uh represents School business officers have come together around these three big ideas and they're calling them The Big Three and so director Gerber if you want to jump right in and then I'll I'll tag along as needed yeah so we had this conference over the weekend uh like you said I was co-sponsored between the three organizations and they talked a lot about how this is kind of the first time that all three organizations have come together and aligned themselves on these priorities to have a better chance at actually making progress with the legislator so that's really exciting for everyone um like Dr prz said they we heard the big three they said

018that a lot they said that over and over at this conference um because that's what they're trying to get across now you do have handouts one for each of the big three um so the big three that they're focusing on with legislators this time around the first one is MOG funding so that's Material supplies and operating costs the second is spe special education funding and the third is transportation funding now they went they went really went out of their way to explain to everyone why they chose these three things um the first big point they made about this was that these are all things that are supposed to be covered by the government that are what's in the Constitution that they're supposed to fully fund these things and that schools feel like they're not funding

019them so that's why they chose that's part of why they chose these three they also chose these three because they felt like these things would benefit every school district in the state instead of choosing one or two things that only benefits half the districts or some people don't have this problem some people don't have that problem they chose three broad things that everyone will benefit from and even if you don't have like a big problem with one of these three in your districts that extra money for those things will allow you to move money around and use it outward so those are two of the biggest reasons they focused on these three that they feel that the government isn't doing their job in covering them and that these three things would affect positively affect every

020school district in the states so I just wanted to draw your attention to the three handouts we'll talk about mck first um that's kind of the one that I think affects our district the most directly um now everyone's already familiar with what MSO means um but the this first group of the green bullet points um talks about everything that MSO funds insurance and utilities are kind of the big ones that everyone that everyone knows about is talked about the most often but there are quite a few other things that are covered through MSO technology funds curriculum and textbooks any these supplies Library materials instructional professional development for staff facilities maintenance security and Central office supports and of course MSO has been um an issue for a while now and they did approved some funding for

021that last year but kind of like it says here didn't the legislator add funding for MSO last year yes however the increase provided was $21 per student whereas actual expenses are underfunded by nearly $500 per student so they were kind of worried the legislators would be like oh we I thought we already took care of this but they only did you know drop in the bucket on that that's why it's a major Focus for us again this year did you have anything you want to add to MSO that was an excellent summary um MSO I think a couple important points to re-emphasize that director Gerber shared MSO is the one that's going to impact us the most um it's it's the one that we can calculate and say yeah that's really going to make a

022difference for um our operations for us locally uh we've had particular increases in insurance and utilities that have been especially around insurance that has been rather dramatic but just like you're experiencing in your business or personal life certainly the cost of um of everything has gone up uh they made a point and and this is maybe more common for those of you who work in in Private Industry these were used to be called non-employee related costs nerks they went away from that term so this really isn't about additional salaries or compensation for staff it really is about can we keep the doors open and can we um provide the services we have been providing when inflation has dramatically impacted a number of items any questions or comments on the MOG portion of this what's what's

023the longterm do they have a long-term goal on how they're GNA get more funding or are they waiting for the federal funding to come through and then do I think if you if you ask them their position they would say there's enough money uh you're just spending it on other things and your your first Duty first Duty in the state of Washington is to pay for public education and you're not meeting that Duty so what all these other projects you have going on that cost money they're pulling away from the money that public Ed deserves so their strategy is really to say spend at the level you were spending so when you look at it as a percentage of overall budget there's about a 10% drop in how much um revenue's been pushed out to

024schools so even though the actual number might have gone up right they're investing this many more billion um as a percentage of overall Revenue it's less so they're they're just saying do what the Constitution says which is it's your Paramount duty pay for public schools and then these other projects you have going might have to give some of those up that's their strategy so they're really doing uh making an effort to calculate those costs specifically and asking school districts to help tell that story because another thing we heard pretty clearly over and over was how do we begin to Advocate with our representativ so that they know here's the issue no fell when we talk to to Joe Schmick we shouldn't be talking about Transportation we're probably only going to talk about MSO that way

025when he goes over there and votes he knows how we feel about it they kind of they made a big push to get everyone on the same page about the big three so that they weren't getting legislators weren't getting distracted with other educational things that while important aren't going to make as big of a difference for as many people so with um like P said m is the one that's going to impact us the most they did also talk a lot about both transportation and special education and as I said before when we get more money for those things there's more money to move around so that still impacts Us in special education they talked a lot about what's called a a multiplier so the state funds us according to how many students we have

026and but if there are a special education students then they get a multiplier so instead of getting 100% of what a general education student gets they get like 1.12 um percent of what they get so it's extra funding for us and something that they're um they're putting a big emphasis on is recalculating those multipliers saying that those multipliers don't actually give enough money for what it takes um in these in these special education classes and for that funding so um that's their big thing with special education funding is to raise those multipliers so that more schools are getting more funds per special education students and then that would make a big difference for those schools I think one local experience for those of you on the board who have heard us talk about co- teing

027and wondering how are we adding Co co- teers when we're talking about reductions in in other areas this is one of the ways you can do that when additional funding comes in specifically for special education students the more that you can include them in general education courses the higher the funding so if a kid is in so I'm speaking to the student reps now if you're taking an algebra class and there's a student who has some special struggles in math and we put some of them in that alge class that class size might be a little bit smaller and you might have two teachers in there to make sure that the special education students have a general education experience to provide for those two teachers the state gives us some extra money what's the criteria

028of a special education student yeah so in the state of Washington you would either qualify for an IEP an individualized education plan or a 504 so there's a series of Assessments that students go through to determine whether or not they qualify for special education and that's a really good question Miles because one of the concerns about people around this l legislation is hey we get extra money if if kids qualify let's qualify a bunch more kids I don't believe educators are they don't get into the business to do that but it will help them provide opportunities for students that maybe otherwise we couldn't um so the the multiplier thing is is a big factor that I know Amy Suarez and her team and and Heidi Wagner calculate to help us think about how do we

029maximize our resources uh the other thing that Aaron and I heard about and we reached out to Amy over the weekend about something called Safety Net funding so in special education if you have a particular student with really high needs that comes at a dramatic expense um once you cross a certain threshold I I believe the number we heard was $40,000 in additional expense that you could qualify for these safety net funds that are available across the state there's only a certain pot that's available and we just haven't qualified in the in the past but that was a new learn learning for me and for and for director Gerber and and talking about that there are also safety net funds in transportation that we haven't been able to access but it's important for a lot

030of school districts in Washington any questions or comments on the special ed um special education funding portion of this um the next one is transportation um similarly to how in the special education funding it was changing the formula they're kind of trying to do that with Transportation as well there's a form for determining how much um transportation funding a district requires and it has to do with with number of students um and something they haven't taken into account is you know a bus that carries 20 students versus 40 students cost the same for the district and Fuel and maintenance and everything so that it's called the student transportation allocation reporting system which they call the Stars formula they're trying to kind of revamp that and make it better reflective of of what the actual cost

031is we heard some some crazy stuff about Transportation expenses around the state we were talking to someone from Federal Way was it yes said that there they're having to send they're having to send multiple Ubers out every day to pick up students AC like way outside their district and it's just costing them insane amounts of money um yeah so we felt a little better about that one for our districts um but as with all of these when we get more money for funding from state of these then that does help us yeah and I think the the comment about the big three and that they're going to impact all school districts this was one that Aaron and I sat back and said well that really isn't that important to us but in our small group

032the story that we shared if you look at the three uh first screen bullet points there uh particularly around homeless students under the federal mckin vento act so if you live in a in a dense urban area and you start school in Federal Way and then you know in in the first trimester you move to Tacoma but you're homeless the school district is obligated to pick you up in Tacoma and bring you to Federal Way they were required to do that and so what happens is uh it's hard to find bus drivers all across the state of Washington but particularly in urban areas so they don't have bus drivers but they're required by law to do this so they're looking at rid share services like uber they're looking at um other sort of public transportation

033which creates its own other problems because you have this bus that's dedicated to get people to and from work and you fill up with a 100 students going to high school it sort of changes the vibe on the bus so in understanding the big three and their level of importance in each district for some this was a top top issue and as it relates to safety net the state does currently doesn't send you any extra funding until you hit that threshold so $40,000 for Uber rides that's a lot of uber rides you're probably never going to get there and it's not across the district that you you spend an extra 40,000 it's for each individual student so definitely some formula problems there that that we learned about that the state needs to figure out and

034all three entities like director Gerber shared are pushing on these three items on these three um key funding issues so we'll uh it started today the session started today and they'll be sending out updates and and director Gerber was up shaking hands with people that are going to be communicating that out to board members across the district so or across the state I know you'll be hearing more about these things given the the tone from wda which was basically no money so don't come looking for it was this conference did it have a little bit of a different tune or like do you think there's a probability that these could get that we could actually get some funding so the probability is much higher now that the three groups are kind of together on this

035rather than each group asking for their own separate thing and not getting anywhere with someone so they kind of they just me talked about like how many lobbyists all three groups together have we had two there were Senators right we had two senators come and speak to us at the conference about these things and they said you don't worry we know about the big three like it's been communicated to us we've heard rep say I know about the big three like and um so yeah I think they're going to make they're definitely going to make some uh difference it was a little Bleaker at wasda I feel like they were just talking about the deficit and they definitely did here as well but they said you know because of that deficit that's why we came

036together and focused on these uh more basic things we're not asking for crazy things that on on the outskirts but just these basic things that the state should be covering anyway so yeah I think they have a better chance um now at getting some of these things through than they would have we we also got challenged at a couple points not not the two of us but the folks in the room who were um they challenged uh the presenters not to use the word deficit because they actually said there's more Revenue available it's just things cost more which has created a deficit but it's not that we aren't um that taxes aren't pouring in it's just that the costs have accelerated so much the two numbers that they used um one was was uh the

037pro projected shortfall over the next four years was between we heard between 13 and 17 billion so where do you where do you find three or four billion every year in that size of budget and then what we heard from Senator Wellman who really is the PowerHouse around public Ed in Washington she said uh I think re doll and Insley have asked for just over two billion dollar 2.5 to be invested into public aded the number she used was 1.1 billion is what she expects will be pumped into the system to help address some of these big three issues so there'll be some money there and the other thing we heard over and over was um concern about making sure that as the funds come in that there are guard rails around them so that

038they can only be used for these particular activities and not um not bargained outside of their intended use so you know we'll see if if folks can come together around it but really it was a my the first time they've done the conference this way where they had presentations and folks who are working in Olympia and also opportunities for us to go in small breakout rooms so they were 60-minute sessions with about 350 of us there there were student reps as well so maybe next year when we go we'll be able to take some student reps with us um and we heard from the student reps at the end and I think they asked a really nice question to kind of bring all this together they had 14 student reps and they asked them several

039questions and the last one was hey what are you missing out on in your schooling experience because funy SC short or things have been cut and so to hear individual stories from kids who said I can't get it to the skill center anymore because they canceled the bus um my my sister went to school here and they offered um French English Spanish and German and and American Sign Language I either have to take Spanish or sign language like they the really specific stories that kids are experiencing in our schools because we've had to cut back in in certain areas so at the end they really brought it around and and circled back to the students it was time well spent I think the of 137 billion it's the state saying hey for the last couple

040of years this is this is how much it's cost to run the state of Washington and this is how much revenue came in right so you're supposed to balance the budget 100 billion comes in a 100 billion goes out well they know that costs have been have escalated and so now they say well we need 105 billion this year but we only we know only 104 billion 100 billion is coming in so we're four to five short right so is that a deficit or do you just need to cut back and not do some of the things you've been doing that's what they're wrestling with and in washing what's different in the at the state level than at the national level what we heard was it has to be a balanced budget they can't just

041walk away the numbers have to line up so some things are going to go they I think they shared uh um Governor Ferguson who's the first new governor in 12 years he's walking in on day one and they're saying to him hey congratulations Governor what would you like to cut and or what taxes would you like to raise and nobody wants to be that Governor so it'll be an interesting 105 days to see where they go so I just encourage you to read through these they're um they're very they're great handouts just very assist to one page things about kind of their goals and they're good for sharing with other people and for getting legislator's attention so yeah all right thank you director Gerber for that and for the board for your your thoughtful questions

042we're going to move on to the next portion and you have a PowerPoint in front of you a presentation um says board Workshop Levy but what prompted this conversation is we're we have our friends in Moses Lake and in ephra who are running levies um and I think the voting date is is February 12th maybe it's coming up and uh so those are uh big moments for both those school districts but particularly for our friends and colleagues in Moses Lake and so we're paying attention to uh the efforts that they're putting into communicating um what the levy does and and and for you those of you who are new to the board there are really some specific requirements about um how much you can advocate for levies in your role as board members and in

043these kinds of meetings we're a year out from really jumping into that work but we thought it was important and it was timely as you're hearing maybe from friends and family who live in Moses Lake and and in EA or other school districts around us um how levies work and what it's really all about and what the impact is here in ell so Amy put together a series of slides and she and I maybe are going to partner on this I think she's certainly going to take the lead and uh we hope you have some questions about how Levy work in othell and and what you all need to think about because your role will be when do we run a levy how long do we run the levy for how many years and how

044much do we ask for those are the really the responsibilities that the board takes on okay so uh what we're gonna discuss today is why do we have levies what are the levy limits um what is an epml Levy it's for educational programs and operations uh we're going to go into our Levy history what the levy uh pays for um and then what the tax rates are we're also going to have a levy planning calendar like U Pete said we're not going to go for Levy until next February but we're trying to get the ball rolling now you guys inform so why do we need a levy so the state gives us C amount of money for example for a teacher and then the average um teacher pay is a certain amount well there's a

045gap in there that's what a levy covers the levy covers a gap the funding um we get plus the levy is what we have to balance every year so we need we need our L let me share this with the student reps because it ties to the conversation we just had the state of Washington sends us this much money we need this this much to run schools in oel so we ask our local taxpayers your moms and dads your aunts and uncles your neighbors say hey we need a little bit of extra money to run our schools and then we only vote here in our community and if enough people vote Yes 50 50% plus one and we get some extra funding uh from from the community and Amy will talk a little bit about

046if we throw some more money so remember when I said the state sends us this much and we kick in this much if we kick in that piece the state will send us even a little bit more they'll say hey thanks for doing that here's that's called Levy Equalization and we'll talk a little bit about that in a few minutes with the money coming from our communities is that tax it's a it's a it's a tax yeah and so we'll we'll talk about those rates and kind of where they've been historically in O and then if I'm not mistaken the bonds andies are different correct the bond bonds are for building levies are for learning okay um and Miles um if you were to ask your Mom hey can I see the tax St for

047house on there on that tax statement you will see how much actually goes to the to the schools it'll show Bond and it'll show the one other important difference about bonds and levies Amy's exactly right in Washington to passive pass a levy what did I say it takes how much 50% plus one right you just got to get over the simple majority for for passing a bond it's 60% so there'll be some communities where the levy will pass hey that's we we just know we have a levy so we can keep our schools open and then you have to ask a little bit more for a bond and so the threshold is a little bit higher there is legislation floating around to bring that down a little bit um the last number we heard was

048to bring it down to 55% to see if that might help communities pass bonds they have not passed at a very high level in Washington the last few years okay the next slide is some uh items that we pay with our Levy um examples are U certificated and classified Staffing our sub ca for professional development for our employees technology preschool curriculum Athletics and extracurricular activities after school programs safety maintenance and insurance and I have a couple of examples just so that you guys know so for example uh substitute costs that's a really good one because the state gives us a whole 23 24 the U the state allocated $123,000 for substitute cost what we actually paid from basic Ed was $1.1 Million so that's why we need the levy because we can't say oh the

049teacher didn't show up we're not going to put a substitute in there and when we have longterm Subs do they get the same pay as if they every single day or do they get bumped up to like an actual teacher uh after 20 20 days on the 21st day they get paid first year teacher one other thing about the sub costs that we learned this weekend so the state these formulas that director Gerber talked about I believe the um the actual allocation for certificated is four four um days yes yeah so each teacher gets 12 sick days or days they could be absent plus some personal days and the state only provides for four of those so that Gap those eight extra days we have to figure that out locally and they don't give give

050anything for the classified staff for the Paras the food service for anything that's all another another example since we're talking about the MOG um in the 23 24 school year uh we got allocated $6.3 million for our MOG and we um spent $1.8 million more than what we were allocated so that comes from the ly and Leah there is one other important item around uh around levies and and the most significant expense in any school district is salaries and what the state did when the McClary legislation passed is they used to uh so in othell school district they would take all the teachers and say well you're a first year teacher and and you're a 10th year teacher and you're a 20th year teacher you need this much money and that's what they would send

051to the district well when they changed the funding formula they just came up with this average and so the average that the state allocates is $78,000 now if you have teachers who are brand new who are making 60,000 good for the district right you have some extra money that you can hang on to if you have teachers at the far end that are making 105,000 State isn't sending you enough money and so in oel the state allocation is just over 78,000 but the average uh expense for teacher is just over a 100,000 we have to make up that Gap and what some school districts are doing in really large systems if I'm a 20-year teacher and I apply for a job in Federal Way and a first year teacher applies for the same job in

052Federal Way some are being forced to hire the first year teacher because they're not as expensive and that's what the the state out the model is flawed by the state they're not compensating districts to fund their staff at levels that are sustainable so the levy limits um these changed in 2018 with the McClary act um as you can see here we're either going to do uh the the limit is the lesser of 250 per thousand of the assess value or we're going to be able to um Levy $2,500 per student in our district that $2,500 has increased every year with inflation the 2024 rate was 3,149 so um if we were to use our assessed value in our district we would be able to Levy up to$ 14.3 million that's the maximum the minimum would

053have been um 5,759 5,759 and that's doing 250 which is your um assess value times the Adams County assess value of 2.3 billion divided by a th so those are the max the minimum and the maximum that was that was our 2024 Levy lid and in one of these other slides you'll see where we actually work and what we heard at the conference was there are some school districts who are pushing to have that Levy lid increased so they're saying hey in our community we can we can do $4 per thousand and people will vote Yes um the push back on that was well now you're going to create this system in Washington where you have a bunch of halves at the top and then a bunch of have knots at the bottom and so

054they're they're trying to get districts to stay together but there are some communities who are saying I'm willing to pay a little more tax why are you limiting me to 250 and you'll see where othell is at in relation to that 250 and again the responsibility of the board is to determine what's the threshold that the district needs to do business but also that our community will vote for and approve okay so more information about levies um generally there a replacement Levy So currently our our community is playing is paying a levy so when we go out for another Levy it's to replace that Levy it's not a new tax it's replacing the taxes already in there um we usually go for a Lev one to four years the past several years we've done three

055years before that we were doing two but in the past three times I think we've been doing threeyear levies um like Pete said it requires a 50% plus one to approve it we can only go for um our election two times a year so if we go in February for our election and it it fails we can go again in April or November and if that one fails we can't go again till the following year so that means it would affect two school years half of one and the beginning half of the of the next one and how you'll hear School Board directors or student reps who are in school districts where they had a double Levy failure that's what Amy is describing you don't want to be in that situation double Le Levy failure

056is very hard to recover from and it's what has occurred in Moses Lake um we already said it's funded by our local property taxes like I said it come you get a tax statement every year and it states on there I think I don't really pay attention to mine but I see it online that it breaks it down how much we get from the state and how much we get from the local school um also when we're getting ready to do our Levy we there's a form that I have to complete and we send it to Opi and they have to approve it so there's a form on OSI I go in there we complete it and then we have to go for approval for that okay the it on the very bottom I should

057have done it in big letters is we must pass a levy in order to get the local um effort assistance money if we don't pass the levy we don't get the state funding for it so and we'll show you the breakdown here in a little bit so in this Slide the um this is the 23 revenues and the reason that I put this slide in here is so that you um can see that 9% of our revenues for 23 24 were from Levy and the Leah so what happens if we don't pass the levy we don't have 9% of our revenues 9% of $81 million budget miles 7,000 7, 49,000 so this is our um historical information you goes back to 2013 you could see in 2013 the blue is the levy and the green

058is our bond so in that year in 2013 our taxpayers were paying $440 per thousand of their assess value and then you can see it's gone down down down down if you go into TW um 2024 which is um this past year you can see that our rate went down to A123 for our Levy when we ran for the levy we were projecting it was going to be a150 but because the assess values in Adams County went way up which was out of our control we're down to A123 we are pro or OPI is projecting that our um assess values in 2025 and 2026 will be a do five and 99 the assessed value what is that so they all the properties in Adams County so they can to add the value of my house

059the value of your house the value of Chris's Farm all the properties they add them all together and they come this this amount of how much Adams county is worth that for m so the way they determine that is they get that 2.3 billion they divide that by a thousand and that um and that's how they come with their rights so in the next slide um what's in Black was a from a presentation we did in 2022 when we were going for our lobby I updated those numbers they are in red to the actual so you can see that in 2024 well the in the first um column you'll see what our Levy rates are so the 2.8 million the 3, 50,000 and the 3.3 million those don't change that is the authority that is

060what we're getting each year from property tax okay so then you divide that by the thousand and then that gives you our rate so you can see that in 2024 we were predicting that we were going to be uh a150 actually for all three years that's why we were increasing the levy rate but now with the property values the way they are um it's A123 a1599 so because our rates went down not at the1 50 the state does not give us the full amount of the Liam money okay so they're going to say what's A123 divided by a150 and whatever percentage that is the 82% that's how much of the allocation of the of the leam money that we get so you can see that next year we're going to get even less leam money

061and then the year after that as well so in the totals you can see that when we submitted our Levy proposal we were expecting that our Levy Lea was going to be 24.8 million right now we're projecting that it will be $19.8 million for a difference of5 million quick question so when we went to the community and asked for the levy we told them it was going to be 150 that's what we thought it was going to be yes based on those property values at that time at time okay and we'll go into that in the next couple of slides can you go back one slide so this this slide here if you think about the green portion that's um that would be like your mortgage right you you you're paying it on this house

062or property that you bought and when does our mortgage end on that Bond December 2027 yeah so in coming up that whole green ch junk is going to go away and when you think about levies and bonds that's the kinds of conversation and strategic thinking that we'll need the community to help us with and and the board to say all right what's what's next what's the next need in oel because what if this graph was designed in a way that really works for communities it would just be flat that way you don't feel this heavy new burden and you don't get this dramatic drop when schools need the funding and then it goes back up because this is this is hard story to go out and tell you know going back right now it's 11

063years right how do we look back that far but I think it's important for the board to start thinking about that Bond coming off the books here in just a couple years yeah the bond was uh we use it to um REM remodel all our schools back in 2009 and uh yes yes the left over I think there was so what actually happened with wajas and and Greg maybe can help with some of the historical part of this so the costs got accelerated right and inflation went up this just recently the opposite happened when when it was 0708 in the crash construction C costs went down dramatically and so we that was really almost extra money that was left over from the remodel they were able to build that school so it was just really

064really good timing for the community and and when you go to a business owner it was an easy sell hey if we do this project we're going to get a a $20 million school back then um and the state's going to pay for it so we we we'll have some some more sessions around State match and bond preparation and all those things in in the next year or two but I I think it's important for us to start thinking about that okay Amy I need you to D this down for me because every time we've done Levy information I always am like uh but really I'm like what how so okay if we passed a bond for a150 per thousand doll when the when you're when your assessed value increases so let's say my house

065was worth $100,000 and then it went up to being $110,000 wouldn't I still pay 50 per thousand dollar I think the Bond was set up an amortization Bond I'm talking about the levy sorry Levy okay so so in the black it says a150 and then it says actual A123 why are they charging less I don't understand that and you said it's because my assessed value went up yeah so that it doesn't um take as many dollars to come up with a 22.8 million because that 2.8 million stays the same yeah we left a fixed rate a fixed amount so the fixed amount wasn't a150 the fixed amount was 2.825 okay y That's what I'm not getting I'm like why would we get less why would I pay less than a150 if that's what I agreed

066to I didn't realize the fixed amount was the end goal and the and the part where we get less is the state is now saying hey you agreed to pay a150 and you're not you're paying what Amy just said was 82% of a150 so the extra match we were going to send you that Miles brought up we're only going to send you 82% of that and so that's where these negative numbers start to pop up there has has to be sorry there has to be a set amount when we request a levy yeah so we're thinking about those structures and and do we fix the levy rate the cost per thousand or do we fix the amount and being strategic about thinking about that right how much what's the right way to do that so

067when we start to talk about bonds and levies that's absolutely something we need to address because then it becomes more predictable if we had fixed the the the amount at a150 we wouldn't we wouldn't be having the shortfalls right correct we have a lot more money okay y thank you little more clear okay so this this table shows what the assess value was for Adams County in it was 1.7 billion when we did the tables for the levy at that time we we um did them at an 8% per year growth and then if you look in the next slide or in a couple of slides you'll see that it actually went up uh in 2023 the growth was 23% so the increase from 2021 to 2024 was huge and that's why it's making such

068a big difference in our rates one other thing I want to point out on this particular slide I know that I've talked to a number of board members and community members who say hey look at that school in Quincy look what they built in Quincy right you guys maybe have been to that school do you see Quincy on that chart where are they at what's their assess value almost eight billion dollar they they have more assessed value than Moses Lake and when you have that high of an assessed value because of the data centers that they have there the people really paying the tax are the companies that own those data centers and so as a local person in Quincy you don't have to kick in as much in to if you um once you

069tax this assess value your rate goes way down and you're going to get a really nice school at a really good bargain because of those data centers there so you know I I get that a lot from folks who say why can't we do what they've done in Quincy well that's one of the factors they assessed value they're an outlier in the state and maybe in the country um very unusual as Quincy has fewer students than we do and certainly probably not even a third of the students that are in Moses Lake schools on the same line I was just noticing Pasco Pasco has an assess value of 15 billion but their Community pays a168 for epnl so they're getting more revenues in that way more than we are one of the things that I

070wanted to point out is um I contacted the Adams County today and they said that the 2025 values should be in by the end of this month what I wanted to point out in this slide was um when we're trying to figure out what is the growth for Adams County are we going to want are we going to use a 20year growth are we going to use a 10e or are we going to use a fiveyear so when we start looking at the levy those are the kind of things that we're going to have to say you know do we predict um Adams County growth is going to be 8% every year or 10% or is it going to be 2023 and it's going to be 35% those are unknowns to us that affects us

071because we're we're budgeting at 8% growth and then it comes in at 35% and then it brings our revenues down is that growth in students or or housing property value property value assess value okay and the next slide is just goes back to 2004 of how um what the property values were and I think if you take out the anomaly of 2023 when perhaps there were just maybe there were changes in in assessor processes or Personnel but uh that's certainly a dramatic difference and uh made it difficult for school districts to predict where we were going to end up so when I was working on the budget this year I have to predict in the four-year budget what we're going to get in uh Leah money in 25 and 26 and the way I do

072that is based on a tool that OSI provides and they have their own growth for Adam County and until we know for sure what Adam County did those are the tools that we use to predict what our revenues are going to be and that's in our next in the next slide um OPI U post this tool they updated it on November in November and they're predicting our assess value to be 2.9 billion with a 26.1 increase now I have this tool I will follow up in the end of January to see if the if the values are posted and that's going to give us a better idea what this year's going to look like because that value will determine the Leah in 2425 school year as well okay so the percentage that they're estimating this

0732611 per increase for 25 is that the same percentages from the slide before so the slide before those are actuals um so like in 2024 we inreased property value by 5.8% and they're saying that in 2025 it's going to go up 2611 so we're having another huge like we did in 2023 this is yeah that that is OSI tool so then I thought okay I wonder if they're using the same growth what's their rhyme and reason and I went in and looked at other districts and they're all different so my assumption would be is that they have somebody who's really looking into what the growth would be but we'll see we'll I'll um keep you guys updated the end of January the next slide is just um history of when we have um gone for

074Levy and the pass and failed we um this goes back to 1992 and we have only failed a once and that was in um in 2000 the interesting thing is I was here but uh it failed by we only had 48.5 and if you remember we needed 50 and then they went ahead and went in April again and then they passed it by 75% which is almost the highest we've ever gotten okay so the next couple of slides is um just when we're going to start planning for our February 2026 Levy um I think in July and August when I'm done with the budget we'll have another get together another budget workshop and say hey we need to figure out I need to know for our budget what do we going to do and we'll

075have another um sit down and try to figure out are we going to do the $150 or those are decisions that we were going to have to make this coming summer and then um by December we have to file with the auditor we have to do our resolution in October and then election day I believe is going to be February 10th second Tuesday of February have any more questions um no but I I know that East Valley is running a levy because when we were at their basketball game uh before the game started they did the Pledge and then somebody read like a little script in English and in Spanish saying we're running a levy here's the things that it pays for our sports program tonight wouldn't be possible without our Levy money like please

076Community please vote Yes and then they also had a pamphlet that they handed out that I mean I thought it was the um the brochure for the game I don't know what it's called can't program the program thank you and it was actually a brochure about their Levy and all the things that it pays for so that like stuck out in my mind of well this is a district that's like ready to go and every person they come in contact with knows that they're running a levy and what it that what it pays for because I think sometimes people get confused you know new tax more money you know you're mismanaging funds blah blah blah but it's a replacement tax that is actually really really really beneficial to students so anyway I thought that was

077really great and hopefully we can follow in their footsteps and be really great with our messaging to our community about how important this is so thank you for all of your hardworking yeah that's something that we can start doing now like with our post like thank you community for like um one of the things that I had written down I didn't say um the Athletics and extracurricular what what it cost was .6 million and that's all I I have a sister in Moses Lake and she has to drive her she had to drive her daughter's volleyball team you know as many people she could fit in her Suburban to every away game so it's just I mean little things that you take for granted that oh the bus is going to take the girls and

078bring them home and all of the things like it's we got to show up our community and and really make this work no I I agree on the communication part of it if we can get the word out even some banners posted saying that I yeah it was just Moses and and that yeah the whole Moses just flooded with vote vote and then so that people we get the word out we get the maybe like when Lindsay Sai Valley things like that I mean uh when I first started voting I didn't know I had teacher friends that said if it's a levy just vote Yes it's for the teach so I always just voted yes but I never knew what I was voting for I just relied on my teacher friends to tell me to

079to vote on it but if we you know get the ball rolling and really publicize maybe we got to do a community forum and we have you explain it we we we can explain it better to the to the public uh and answer questions or something I think whatever we can do to get people on board I I agree but uh somehow getting the message out yeah and that this was really our uh attempt to let you know what our neighbors are dealing with let you know what's coming your way and to to begin to backwards plan what you just described how do we begin to communicate and share with folks and one other important session for the board will be what are your limitations as a board member how can you Advocate where can

080you Advocate what can you say in in what format so we'll get some training on that as well and uh you know hopefully we historically the community has supported levies and we're going to make sure that they show up again for our kids and for our teachers so thank you for uh your careful attention to both those presentations and uh turn it back over to director prow great thank you again Amy for all of your hard work um and thank you to Aon and to Pete for your presentation on the things that you learned when you were on the wests side and also for this lovey information um we will move on to our policy review there are some policies that are being retired and some proced that are getting updated so please review those

081before we take those to vote next meeting do did we have any public comment no public comment this evening okay great we will move on to upcoming events January 20th there is no school I'll take a woooo from our student reps just kiding and January 21st is our preschool site visit that will be led by director binsky and then January 27th is another regularly scheduled board meeting does anyone have anything that they need to add to the upcoming events calendar we did all get invited to the career day at McFarland I'm trying to remember what day it's I don't remember what day is I'm it's this month yeah I have here January 30th yeah 8 a.m. to 10:30 got anything back from Ms with the I forgot what the prr was but with the parents

082and students about kind of the behavior issues and Stu I know schaer and coun talk us about the sessions that they run to guess com that the Middle School hosts several parent nights I get invitations all the time for different things whether they're talking you know trying to educate parents on social media practices and all sorts of different they have a whole Myriad of Standards based grading and a ton of things that they meet with their parents and and try and educate them on different things um okay we will move on to board self assessment of the meeting great uh meeting very informative uh especially the levy thank you Amy again for putting all that together and uh thank you for the shout out for the for us board people uh shout out to the

083shout out want to go a conferences we hear all sorts of horror stories from around the state and we we're seeing lots of financial stuff pop around all around the state and uh one of the big reasons we're not as bad as we as it could have been is because of Amy and her team so we're thankful for them Ken still on okay um thankful that we've got a full board tonight even though we've got Ken on Zoom we still have a full board and all of our new student reps so thank you guys for attending tonight anything else okay we will move on to an executive session the board will go into recess for 60 minutes to discuss the sale or lease of land potential litigation and the performance of a Public Employee no

084action will be taken following the executive session thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.