CorpusRecord 102400

Pioneer School Board Meeting December 17th, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Joel Williams
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Mason County, WA
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,604 words · about 59 min
Collected
2026-06-13

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e there that is so waa the our Lo Association they wanted the last two years monthly expenditures so she put all those they want not only these docents but they wanted all theur so each of those next victim that's a lot okay it is six o'clock so we'll go ahead and call this meeting to order if you guys me the flag flag of the United States of America the the mission of the Pioneer School District is to educate each students to the highest levels of academic achievement and prepare students to succeed in life the vision of the Pioneer School District high levels of learning for all every child every day um up first we have any requests to address the board yes don't I don't mind yeah this is the uh yes please speak um

002into the podium into the microphone I tried online oh okay we'll take a look at that thank you yeah sorry no that's okay um uh no words the board recognizes the value of public comment on educational issues and the importance of involving members of the public in its meetings and will allow three minutes per person for public comment um any examples of uncivil comments include comments that are libelous or slanderous unwarranted invasion of privacy obscene or indecent pursuant to the federal con Communications act or any rule of the regulation of the Federal Communications Commission violate School District policy or procedure related to harassment intimidation bullying or discrimination or incite an unlawful act on school premises or violate a lawful School regulation the podium is yours right um so as you guys know I've asked questions

003a couple times about the land yeah selling of the land and I had some concerns that it's not a public um public is not involved in the decision and I have an email August 2024 from the superintendent it says the Board canot sell property without a vote of the public um even if it was purchased by a v repu okay so I did ask and I was told that Schoolboard decision okay I don't personally care whether he sell land or not don't care but I don't think the public should not be informed if that makes sense okay um and I don't know what the plans are hold on one second I just can't hear you sorry I can do that yes thank you I just wanted to make sure I could hear what you were

004saying just have one my minutes no you're good okay so um I noticed on June 11th um of 20124 uh special meeting minutes um said that you guys were going to discuss the land purchase and you took it to an executive session uh because the law allows you to do that if you're concerned that it might affect the price um of the s for the purchase okay so you did that in June uh and then in September was a special session and this is the one I was out for surgery um and then uh it says school property update but there are no special session notes and and I've been working um and you've been working really hard to help me find notes um but I can't find any special session notes on any year

005um I did notice that the RCW says that uh many meeting minutes are required for all regular special and I don't know what that means not smart enough but I couldn't find notes to to get moreart okay so what I found doing this much research and I know nothing so I'm going to par I know nothing okay um there was a a a law excuse me a court case um Attorney General's office where a school district was sued for selling land um and the land was sold uh without the public being given some consideration uh this was way back in the 50s but it's still on case law uh and it was only $20,000 okay so now I found the RCW today I have a copy the RCW says that the board of directors of

006new school district of the state may sell for cash uh at public or private sale and canel by deed uh any interest in land uh and purchase anything um when the board of directors determines uh that it's appropriate but if the value for $7,000 you're required to notify the public and it gives you directions on what that means so um I don't know what it means quite honestly I have a copy of the RCW reading thank you I only have one I'm sorry so I just want to um tell you my concern again is that I heard disuss I guess uh when you identified the land in particular people were against a um and that they had voted a high school down so why are we keeping the land now I don't know um why

007you're keeping it I personally think it's smart I think you don't pay taxes on it that I know of um I think it's an investment I think it's going to get bigger here at this District whether you want or not PUD is planning forward they're putting in new Transformers out here because the land is expected to go up and um so I don't know why but I think that uh there's a lot of smart people in our district that might collectively have an opinion and we should maybe ask them especially if it's a illegal Bo so that's it I appreciate you sharing that yeah thank you is it okay to make a comment we can do com so I will say that we have a facilities committee that had been engaged and we had one

008member from the public we actually had another one attempt to join us I think my friend Melissa but she works during the day but my point in all this is the discussions in all of the properties were going on in that committee and that included the public so I I I don't know if you're saying that we have to have a a formal Vote or something like that again I'm not going to interpret the law I'm gonna give it to you and say hey I think you're required to especially when you look at the court case right and I'm also very important to me to not get sued especially you know what I did for a living that's very important to me and and so it's just like hey let's SM if it requires to

009be notifi then notify if nobody shows up nobody shows up you've done your due diligence that's all I'm asking is hey let's be smart yeah um and not end up uh uh wishing we had later so that's thank thanks I appreciate you sharing and and pointing out your concerns you're okay yeah um oh we all have mics ons the FR there we go are we good okay um do we have any other comments nobody's up there okay uh any changes and or additions to the agenda No not tonight and do I have a motion to approve the regular meeting agenda I move that we approve the regular meeting AG gendra thank you and second I second thank you it has been moved and seconded all in favor say I I I no oppose that motion

010passes up next is approval of the consent agenda do I have a motion to approve the consent agenda as written move to approve the consent agenda thank you do I have a second I second it thank you it has been moved and seconded all in favor say I I I no oppose that motion passes as well that takes up right up to principal reports Dynamic do all right um so we want to uh say yay that we are coming quickly to a nice long break for all of our staff and it's exciting to be able to have that we um they have been powering through our kids have been powering through and we are finally into that week where everything is a little bit of mad joyous chaos but we're here finally and so it's

011a really good thing um and so we have different things going on in each building we're doing dress up days and um we have a holiday fashion show at the middle school that we do and you guys do something of what do you guys do so we have cookie dick um this Friday if you want to come and decorate um cookies with a keny gardener or a fifth grader I'm sure be nice and not too messy for you yes they're very excited because it's tied to our um food drive oh so they're very excited to to have that party and the food drive is going with you as well a food drive going hoping to duct tape one of our teachers to the wall and so actually we'll duct tape it to a table and

012um and see how well that goes that's awfully fun to do for the students so enjoy that yeah um but yes you are very welcome to attend our festivities at both buildings on Friday if you would like to um they kind of just go for an extended amount of time as we wish our kids a wonderful winter Breakaway but just because the year is ending doesn't mean that we aren't think ahead already it's kind of been our nature to plan ahead and make sure that things are going well even if everybody is just thinking about Friday um Amy and I are not we're like okay this starts all up again how are we gonna be ready when kids come back in January and so um I have given all of you the bus contract and

013Matrix of minors and Majors uh this is something that we sent out well it started with um it went to Caleb and Amy and I and Jeff talked about uh holding our students to a certain level of accountability because there's been some pretty naughty behaviors that have been on our buses um and so through the use of our PBIS committees we developed this bus contract we do have uh parents who sit on um the PBIS committee that um meets over here at 7:30 in the morning once a month and so I have four parents who do contribute as well and um we came up with this and then we also came up with the bus Matrix as well the minors and the majors and then that was sent out to every parent and guardian this

014last week for review to look at Vim herent Square and then in January we are going to send out a Google form I was going to send out paper copies but we had a PB meeting again on Tuesday yeah this morning wait when was it yeah this morning this morning at 7:30 in the morning um we had another PBIS meeting and it was brought up by one of our parents that a Google Forum would be a much better idea because they didn't have to want to rely on their child bringing a piece of paper home and so that's fantastic idea love it so a Google form link will be sent out to all family members to have them sign via that Google form link instead and that will happen in January um so I just

015wanted you to be able to look at this um so we've had a lot of input on this before it went out and we have had many parents who have talked to Amy and I about the fact that they feel that at times the bus um writing can be unsafe and so this is really focused on making sure that that students have accountability for their actions and it is very clearly defined What a minor and a major look like just as it is in each of our buildings as well and then the drivers feel incredibly supported um and they feel like there is a cut and dried information as far as like this everyone understands we're on the same page which is really nice did you want to add anything to that at all or

016I did um first thank you to trer PBIS team for C this for us um but when uh when I did uh um talk to the bus drivers I felt their shoulders relaxed they had a plan we have a plan because that's that's one thing that we know when we know hey we can look at this paper and go okay here's what we do next it's not this guessing game sometimes we do after making a thousand decisions and we're like What do we do now and then it doesn't seem consistent so this just being consistent and we're both saying the same thing I just it just felt like the when the drivers were relaxed more things relax just just with the kids as well yes very much so so this is one of the things

017it's only a small component of the PBIS ret that's going to happen in both of our buildings when we come back in January as well we know that that is incredibly important especially after an extended break but January seems like just a naturally a great time with it being a new year for us to refocus on what that reteaching looks like with our sore behaviors and so both our exps have very specific spe ific ways that we go about that reteaching and what that looks like it's not identical to what we did at the beginning of the year but it might be a little bit more abbreviated and the kids all know so it tends to be a little bit more student Le eventually rather than more teacher oriented this is an opportunity for our

018students to really stand up and say what they know and and all of those types of things so we have everything um from you know maybe skits that the kids can enroll plane that they can act out um to some poster making that's can go up in the different areas and things like that but more student generated like I said rather than teacher generated like it is at the beginning of the year um and then last but not least looking at the academic piece is this is a time when we all start to go back through and we look at that grit process and we've talked about this before that um we're looking at what interims look like for ourselves we're done with our winter Benchmark testing um so now we have two data points

019to look at and so we start to look at some of those and um figure out okay and see where the growth is and where we need to continue to put forth a lot more efforts as well yeah that's what JN spers and den fail in our school talking about is those benchmarks what we're going to start talking about next year um January next year yeah and I think they're actually going to be talking at the board I think that they're going to be talking here in January actually so you're going to hear from our achievement specialists in January which nice yeah this is great that's so clear and I'm sure that bus drivers know now that they can say it and it's not them personally yes this is the way it is this is

020what's going to happen yes yeah the other thing I heard from parents too a few of them that that read it that they liked that the driver is going to um contact them first because sometimes when we call we're like well I don't know but this is kind of what they said but now having the driver talk to them and then supporting the drivers uh because we both have spaces in our buildings where they can come get the information and even get support from us when they're talking to families on how to do that so they're not left alone right is this something that goes in with our policies around the boat the um School Bus protocol it could go in as a procedure I think that would be a great addition in that section

021we do get once in a while we will get parents that'll want to see the video because all our bues have cameras and um we don't we invite them to come in they can either go to the co-op um or they can come into the building and look at the tape with the administrator we don't we just don't burn copies and get them out there because we have other children that are in the picture but we also want to make sure that um you know the parents that do request that have the opportunity that we have to reinforce this is why your child's in trouble see them climbing over the seat they're not being safe or whatever the case may be so I don't think I can recall in the two and a half years

022that we've ever looked at a video with a parent and had a mistake it's it just always proves out that oh yeah my kid did that so yeah so I like the U the consequences the infractions meet with some kind of payment that has to be and I think Miss Cook can appreciate that because it's similar to what we had at the shipyard you know you you do something bad you're going to get three days off without pay right so this is a conditioning those people that they have consequences right right can you tell me how these offenses are going to be losted so we both have access to that call Swiss and we log all disciplinary referrals into Swiss um and it's tracked and then we both look at that data throughout the entire

023year that data is given to our teachers to look at on you know specific times throughout the year and so if I was to pull up Amy off of there I could pull up and see every single referral that had been given to her so if I have a student that um I think hey you know I think I remember seen something coming through about the bus because the driers actually out a discipline referral form for us and then that's logged into Swiss so we can go I think I remember seeing that and then we can pull up their name onto Swiss and it will log and it it says in there every single referral that's been written from it that carry over year to year yes it can carry over from year to year

024yes not a clean slate at the beginning no well I shouldn't say that so we we haven't had conversation about fresh start next school year yeah so we always try to make sure that I mean it would it's good teaching and it's good practice for us to give brand new Fresh Starts to students every single year there are always going to be circumstances of which there are very few I have to be honest about that would say no you don't get a new start you know we're talking about putting kids in extreme danger or something to that effect that would cause us to but even then it's in good practice for us to go back through and say okay so maybe this student has learned and so maybe they can go back with these stipulations

025or parameters and so we would not be we would not be able to call ourselves great Educators if we didn't believe that there was hope for students to change from the the the mistake that they make and learn from that because that's what education is about right it's about learning and moving forward we know that kids are going to make mistakes sometimes they make really small ones and sometimes they make really really big ones and E despite what those mistakes look like we have to be able to say we've given students opportunities to go forward you have so can we let's say we have a fighter yeah and and and he he gets warn Leed about fighting he gets a three-day suspension he gets a week suspension he gets a month suspension comes back and

026then it's a month after that comes back next year and he's fighting um can you progress does it do you have to follow that plan or can you go okay you're step for yeah so I with this there's always the administrative discretion that is used always and with a situation like that both Amy and I would look at a person like that and go hey we know that you can change and make a different decision but we're going to put these parameters in this structure because we want to see you be successful we would be remiss to not to just throw a person in if we know they have a certain set ofab habits that they continue to do over and over again if we continue to put that person in that same environment over

027and over again I believe that the definition of that is what Insanity did same thing so we are both and Amy knows more about than I do as far as looking at what looking at boundaries and structure and things like that with her special education background and how to provide those accommodations for students to be successful so she's definitely a person that I would rely on and looking and saying hey I have this kid who continuously is doing these same things I want them to be successful what could we create for them to move forward and to have successful time but ultimately we've always said this too student safety is a number one priority so if we have a student who has repeatedly showed us over and over again that they are able to be

028unsafe then those are the first discussions that we're going to be able to have we have to have that so I have two things um a followup off bricks so is the information that is collated used in the community engagement sessions for you can request that if you would like to so I think it would be good to see that because that also adds to you know the trend that the individual going and I mean if they're in front of the court the court should also know well I was also thinking that if you say to a student you're off the bus for a week yes then they may say well I you know I can't get to school and so then affects their attendance and I will tell you in a majority of times

029that's usually the very first thing a parent will say to us when we remove them well I can't get them to school then right and and I will also tell you nine times out of 10 they find a way to get their kids to school yeah so I'm just like you know what I feel very badly for you but you have to understand that the expectation is that your student is safe on the bus and they have done such and such and such which is an unsafe behavior on the bus and the consequences for that are this we will keep in contact with you via phone every day if we need to schoology if they don't come to school all of those different kinds of things but I'm sorry this is the consequence okay my

030my second question was the acronym PBIS yes all right no that's a great question thank you it is positive behavior and intervention supports is that correct yes I got that right yes yes and it is part of you guys have have you heard the acronym mtss so mtss is kind of like our overarching everything that we do in school PBIS is one of those components or one of those pillars that holds up mtss and mtss is multi-tiered systems of support yes so it's all these different systems that we put in place for students to uh be successful and really what PBIS is is talking about um how are we giv giving kids positive affirmations so it says if you're telling a kid if you're giving them a reprimand one then you need to do at

031least four four or five positives after that one negative in a sense so they're hearing more positives than the negative which is why this year it has been such a push for our staff to send out as many positive informational phone calls emails than we ever have before yeah so that parents are always hearing positives along with any sort of negative comment that comes home as well nice any questions or anything okay thanks you guys appreciate you you okay so we have business operations update yeah just a couple things jolene's not here tonight she's under the weather but um if you look at the first page general fund um laa the one thing I wanted to report on just a couple things if you look down at under expend well if you look up at

032the top first of all the percent of resources by the end of November we've just received about 20 almost 25% of our resources but if you go down to expenditures you'll see that we've expended about 87.7 2% of the expenditures well again the reason is we we've loaded in all of the staff costs for the year all of our contracts for the year so all of the staff pay under incumbrances you can see that you know under regular instruction almost $4.9 million has already been encumbered so we've accounted for all that um till the end of August so that's why you look at that discrepancy on the percent of Revenue versus the percent of expenditures right now at the end of November our ending fund balance was um a little under a million but the

033good news is it pushed us up to 6.5% so we're kind of inching up a little bit and of course we're continuing to watch all expenditures um for the rest of the school year and then um you can look at um capital projects fund there really wasn't uh much movement from last month in there we have a projected ending fund balance of about 33,000 we did make our final payment on the uh District office $181,000 um was a final payment for that building the uh Debt Service fund again not much movement in there um we have an ending fund balance of about 948 again we make our payments out of this um um fund so we have our bond payments on the building um that come out of this and again we have some uh

034some U bonds that we're paying for the Shelton District also uh ASB you can see the ending fund balance is about 8,400 and that's combined middle school and Elementary they started the year with quite a bit of money at the beginning fund balance of 45,000 but it's they spent a few funds too and again ASB remember can only be spent on students so I got a quick question on that so we authorized the elementary school to utilize some of the ASB funds yes how they doing on that I don't think there's been much activity on Elementary ASB that's come across my desk yeah they have the ability to and mostly it's around the yearbook which will happen later in the spring and then the transportation fund uh we are scheduled through depreciation um to be

035looking at purchasing two new buses within the next couple years um they will not probably not be electric just because of capacity but we will make that decision with the co-op when the time comes not that we don't like electric buses but as we continue to grow um those buses have less capacity we then our diesel uh buses by about 10 students so so Transit is switching over primarily to propane to propane yeah yeah and I don't know if that's something that's going to happen with our school buses or not something that we contracted with the bus they you know they have the ability to do it the bus Gage so one of the things that I've talked to Jolene and Lynn both about is in January I think I'll Pro I'll give you access

036to one month of all expenditures which comes out about a 70 page document that has every purchase that we've made so you could look and ones that I've looked at they're anywhere from 60 to 75 Pages depending on the month but you can actually take a look at every single line item and budget code on what was expended for that month we we won't print it out because it's a lot of paper if we make you know six copies times 70 but we'll we'll give at least next month have access to the December and that'll be less because it's a shorter but it'll give you an idea of what elect but it'll give you an idea of what the business office does each month to reconcile all of our expenditures and all the budget codes

037that are you able to take budget questions yeah yeah talk about Shel School District just realizing they have a huge deficit their budget and when you talked about expenses to for our kids they can't change that mid year can they no okay so they can't decide oh my God we're short let's charge more not me here yeah okay any business questions all right we'll move right on to the superintendent report just a couple things you have um a short superintendent report in front of you with some information just a couple things I want to hit on um the last concert of the year tomorrow night grades four and five over at the elementary school 6 o'cl the first two concerts have been packed remember that very first year we did them all on one night

038and it was one illegal because we were so capacity but even breaking it down to K1 then we did 23 uh then we did 23 and now we're doing four five the last couple Wednesdays it's built Full House I mean and so if you get a chance um it takes longer to set up and tear down than it does for the whole concert but they are good and um our Music Teacher Diana she does or Di does such a great job over there I mean it's just amazing and you're doing it over at the elementary school in the comments yeah 6:00 tomorrow I would recommend you get here a little early uh if you want a seat otherwise you can come stand with me or with Amy wherever we end up at uh no we

039don't it's Festival seating uh tomorrow's also the day of giving so I think early release tomorrow so they'll be in here setting up probably a little after 2:00 and I think it goes 4 S somewhere and 19 is the day oh oh tomorrow's tomorrow's Wednesday tomorrow's Wednesday yeah so they're be putting all the boxes together that's right and then Thursday all of that together and then Thursday is when they when they come in Thursday is when they come in so if we have perishable item donate should we wait and bring those in on Thursday then du to like think you can bring them in tomorrow that way they have an idea of what's here okay they'll have room to store it that was my only concern put them in the fridge okay okay okay cool

040and then uh the last thing is part of our rural small modernization Grant um one of the things that we were doing was in uh cameras at the elementary school increasing the capacity and replacing some so the company that won the bid will be doing that over winter break so Lloyd has scheduled them to come in um they're even scheduled to work on December 24th which Lloyd thought was a little odd but I'm sure they'll knock off early but they'll be there three days next week and three days after Christmas and should have all those cameras done and up and operating and then we met last week with um aoll on the rest of the projects and with the um with the state who oversees those projects so we're currently scheduling the lighting project um

041in the springtime and then the HVAC will take place late spring through the summer so yeah we're making progress once we get those projects done at the elementary school we will have hopefully consistent cooling and heating in all the rooms and we won't have issues of putting things back together we'll have a brand new hbac system that should last us a good 15 years and the LED lighting also will make a difference and any questions or comments about that okay up next we have discussion and action items we have one information um topic and then one action item so the first is the artificial intelligence um AI the new electricity is that the one that you sent out right the AI uh no that was that was good oh okay did you like it though

042I did yeah really cool yeah pretty informative so this one what's this one about Joel's oh St let me me share my screen it's gonna be pretty disappointing while Joel's doing that do you mind if I ask a question to Trish yeah up to you um Miss Coral yes I I said that I would get her in contact with one of the employees from the shipyard yes about women in employment and I forget exactly what the whole topic was but um did she ever get a hold of Miss kushy I don't know that um but I wouldn't hesitate to say that when the new year comes that I think that'll be something that she looks at I know that all of the teachers have been trying to just figure out how to make it through

043we had like I said all of our Benchmark testing and things like that that we've been focusing on so um I know that she wants to do that so I would expect in January that that would be something She'll follow up on I know she was pretty excited about helping because she's our napsi engineering rep so you know it's like goes right up to Washington oh yeah all set you ready okay so I'm gonna apologize in advance because there's a lot of information on this um presentation so uh yeah get comfortable the um reason why we're doing this is that uh after talking with Jeff and actually quite a few people about uh our current procedure for AI we realized that we needed to update it significantly and with the help of Edmund School District

044we um we're able to make some significant changes and this is kind of an outline of how we're thinking about artificial intelligence as it relates to students and teachers so um I go um a couple of quotes here first AI is the new electricity will have as much impact on our lives as the Advent of electricity uh lots of experts believe that lots of people believe that uh and I love this quote you're not going to be replaced by AI you're going to be replaced by someone who knows Ai and then what is AI um for those that's very small sorry about that uh there are several types of AI U but the two main ones are reactive Ai and limited memory Ai and um artificial intelligence in like its infancy used huge amounts of

045proc huge amounts of processing power to make really fast decisions for people uh that were doing things like statistics um the new generations of AI do go way beyond that uh the the the the model that is making the most impact right now is part of the Limited memory um generation and it is called generative Ai and that's all of you have obviously heard of GPT and Gemini and all these those are generative AI uh systems and what they do is they use gpus which are graphical processing units to interact with human design these are not designed by you know computers these are human design models uh a huge data sets to then um create new content and they it takes a lot of power it takes a lot of uh there's a lot of

046they actually are are modeling these things on the human brain so they're actually called neural networks so these networks of gpus do incredible amounts of processing and through that using models made by human beings they create new content um they the great thing about them or the you could say it's a scary thing also is that not only are they creating new content but every time they create new content based upon these large language models or other models that they're using they learn from it so they now they've created new content that's learning they're actually learning you an examp give me just a common example that we see a really common I mean the one that I guess is is the easiest for I think for us to digest is uh for instance a picture

047so um if you say if you go into one of the AI the Genera of AI um engines and you say I want a picture of a person riding a bicycle up Mount Everest now obviously that's going to be really hard because there's no roads up there but it can generate something new content based upon all the the cont content of the internet basically and give you something an existing photograph not a photograph that it makes it it will take it will take the models of what you you say a bicycle Rider it goes on and looks at all the bicycle Riders on the internet and it creates something from that and then it goes all the pictures of Mount Everest and all the possible ways that you could ride a bicycle up Mount ever

048and it will generate something for you okay an app on my phone and if I want to see a cross between an elephant and an alligator it'll do it so um just so that I understand kind of the examples that you were talking about um there's commercials everywhere right for the phone that you just have a conversation with and it's all AI which version of that would like what what type of AI would you refer to that that actually probably has a little bit of both but most of the time most of the like the the cool thing about generative AI is that it is it it really works well for creativity for things that are um you're creating something new and um it's not it's not the I mean it works for statistics but

049that's not it's really what it's intent is so probably if you have a phone that's using AI it's generative AI okay yeah thank you yeah so just just uh I mean for assistence generative II works for virtual assistance for Content creation for text summarization amazing um data analysis amazing product design software development and fraud detection fraud detection has become like AI has transformed fraud detection so oops I just skipped a whole bunch of slides okay so I got I got some of these u a couple of them are from these are all from Washington based organizations dealing with education um so AI is online and intore shopping robotic tractors Precision agriculture Warehouse fulfillment credit card fraud protection insurance rates NASA images from space text to speech foreign language translation mapping and navigation AI is not

050alive it's not smarter than us it isn't Killer Robots it isn't only for Geniuses it isn't only for people in techie cities and always physical it is inside software and phone apps and it's not going this is from ospi uh gener of AI is a means to augment teaching and learning already embedded or I'll do the born against uh it is not a replacement for student development it is already embedded into many Technologies as is uh AI more broadly speaking it is not something that can plausibly be avoided or turned off it is permeated with flaws such as algorithmic bias that must be considered when utilized it is not a source of unquestionable factual information it is a product of companies led by teams of humans with their own values agendas limitations biases and organizational

051needs has not producing a vacuum free of societal influence it is an algorithm that enables users to generate new content based on a pre-trained large language model it is not a sentient being with untethered superhuman capabilities yeah I'm going skip this one just because this is take a while anyway so a this is OPI I'm sorry I'm so small I maybe I can get change my uh Joel would you be willing to um share your uh PowerPoint with us as an email yeah for sure thank you um OPI would like is it's got their guidance for us is that AI is human- centered we use it as human centered Tool uh it prioritizes needs and abilities and the experiences of students and Educators and administrators an educ an educational leader can support a human- centered

052learning environment by considering the following development developing students AI Literacy By helping them understand the concepts applications and implications um of AI in various domains and empowering them to use AI as a tool for Learning and problem solving very important for when considering to use AI in the classroom um ensuring ethical Equitable and safe use of AI by protecting the privacy and security data addressing potential biases and harms and promoting digital citizenship and responsibility that one kind of speaks for providing best well actually let me go back on that um one thing that Lynn and I were talking about earlier and I talked about it with lots of people is that if we lag behind this kind of Revolution learning we're putting our students at a disadvantage and the longer we wait the more significant

053that disadvantage becomes so I think it's really important that we're having this conversation and that we start getting our stud students uh with handson with AI at an appropriate level and then and with guids so uh providing professional development and support for educators that's I know brainer applying human- centered design principles to the development imp of and implementation of AI Solutions involving stakeholders in the design process testing and iterating the solutions and evaluating the impact and outcomes and then aligning AI Solutions with the best practices and principles of learning and I can tell you that it does that almost on its own um Trisha has been using it I mean almost on a daily basis uh Jeff and I I've used it a lot recently especially with building the cyber security program um and then

054Jeff is you know messed around with it a lot uh just showing the potential of what it can do for a teacher that's another thing from um OPI that kind of gives you what we're looking for here uh and I'm not just to read through this is because uh you can I can just have a conversation with you the thing that that using Ai and teaching allows a level of specificity for a student that it you will never get with the textbook um you can input uh I want sixth grade students at a sixth grade level a fraction lesson on the Washington State Standards at this at a certain level of ability um and it will output something for you within seconds seconds and you can then take that output and make it even more

055specific for an individualized student student so you are differentiating a lesson on the fly in a matter in in less than five minutes you can come up with an absolutely beautiful lesson for an individual student on fraction at sixth grade level that meets the standards and for their like level of learning at that moment and you can and it's just amazing what you can do with that that's that's the power of this for a teacher so so totally dependent upon skills of the teacher who understands AI exactly yeah that is if they don't if they don't have they don't if we first aren't the ones to get the learning all of us uh you can't produce that lesson because it's your input that determines what the output is oh my gosh yes I have run

056into that a lot yes how well is it being received within the staff I mean are people really embracing it or are we like uh I'm still old school it's it's unknown so it was introduced to me last year Joel had brought it up I know that Jeff was bringing it up and and I hadn't messed with it quite at that point in time and then um Deputy Matt actually had been using it quite a bit and he came and showed me he's like guess what I did with chat GPT today I'm like what he goes oh I was running late for a doughnut party for kinderg and I said yeah and he goes and I forgot the book so on my way here I asked chat GPT to create a story and I told

057him all the stuff I wanted to have in there Deputy Matt and I told him the whole premise of the story could you write a story for me to be able to tell kindergarteners have this output and it wrote an entire story for him he could share with the kindergarteners and you know all that kind stuff so it got got me interested in kind of learning and then we started using this um program called magic school thank you magic school because we were trying to find lessons that would help our multilingual Learners and um because we don't have you know that translation piece and we are having more more multilingual Learners um and so we were working specifically last year with Ashcraft and like our science and our history teachers to create lessons based off

058of what we were learning and using it to translate and then create the lessons using magic school which is AI as well is that correct yeah I have not used magic school so I can't speak to that um I started using that when somebody came and asked me for a letter of reference that was the first time that I truly had used chat GPT and that's what I know and I put into chat GPT and I was kind of really formal how I talked and you know was very like I wanted to do this type of thing and then recognize very quickly that it didn't matter how I spoke to chat GPT it would format for me however I needed it so then I realized I'm just going to try and use this because we

059have to write narratives for our evaluations at the very end of the year right summon paragraph and I'm not joking when I say you could spend a couple hours on each one of those well when you're doing that for 2 staff members it's a significant amount of time but it was just as easy for me to phone which has jet GPT and go into a very talk a very lengthy narrative into chat GPT saying all of the things that I had seen and how it connected with all of these different Criterion for tep and then chat GPT wrote a beautiful summary for me and so I was able to share that with all of my staff and say look at what I did in chat GPT read The Narrative that I gave it as un

060pretty as it and look at how it wrote this and they were pretty astonished by how it did that so I wanted them to feel comfortable in the fact that I wasn't allowing chat GPT to make any decisions I was still writing down everything that I had seen I didn't ask CH you know AI to make up anything at all I was simply asking them to find tune asking it to find tune how I would actually write it so that really showed me oh my word look at how much time this can save me because I'm a great writer I already know that I taught English for multiple years I have that skill already so I'm not trying to usurp that skill with anything what I'm trying to do is work smarter and this allowed

061me to work much smarter in that capacity so I think this is great but can you use it to like say chat gbt uh develop a marketing plan so I can roll it out in my school and some way to measure it and then yes you know maybe in your professional development days have have that so each individual has a maybe a lesson plan that helps them yeah it definitely but it all it all depends on the prompting you know what you and as you do initial prompting you'll get a response and and you can Nar you can read the response and say well I need something more specific well you need then to go to the prompt and identify some more specificity and then go back and then go back and you can even

062you can even take that prompt and ask them to write it as if you were a business teacher or write it in the language of an administrator or write it in the language of a CEO of a uh Fortune 500 company and if you prompted you're going to see those different ways of writing in the with that prompt just for in again in a matter of seconds so that's what I'm I'm trying to say is like if if you want this and you want it to be ingrained in our you which I think is you're right you have to be on it so you need to empower the program to help you figure out what's the best way to move forward because we're talking about it each individual is dabbling in it I haven't even

063touched it but you know my mind's thinking about okay how can they develop new batteries you know and fusion reactors and all of these cool things completely different level gets us in good places and they found that the the one thing that there's the limitations of it are easy to find when you start think talking about things like Fusion right because the large that we have are based on our knowledge as human beings so when we don't quite know something yet it can't know more it doesn't know much more but it can give you incredibly cool ideas on maybe how to solve that right so so I think you guys are right at the tip of the spear as far as getting this ingrained in this well what I see in that is that it's

064going to have huge transformation and education and especially for old dogs who were who were taught you know I think back I was taught how to Parts a sentence you know that's longone that whole concept of putting because it's going to do it's like giants check so it's not you know we're not going to have those long division write it all out kinds of skills it's going to be short cuted and it's gonna be learning about prompts yeah it's all going to be about prompts I like hearing the um successful parts of it and I don't want to be a downer but is there any concern about students yeah get to write their reports and then would that be considered plagiarism which is something I went through when I was in school and how like

065how do you recognize that and and make sure students are being originally writing their reports or whatever they're doing versus taking the AI that we're teaching them and now having their work done for them yeah so the since the Advent of cheating right yes humans have been doing that for each other for ages now and with even with you know just the internet in general this this is this is just the next um Evolution on that scale right you now yeah it seems like it's a huge jump and it is the cool thing about AI is that it also recognizes it itself it's you know it it can recognize its own output right um and we also as I was talking to L earlier we also need to maybe shift a little bit on what

066we think cheating is yeah when it comes to writing creating that kind of stuff because the prompt the the input is really the source I mean that's that's the source of Truth for AI so it's really hard to cheat that yeah so if a kid has an idea and it's a good idea and they want it written and let's say that they are um fifth grader who maybe doesn't have the best hand eye coordination they can but they have they have this great idea they can input that in even using their voice to an AI generative AI system and it will type it for them then the cool thing is is see if it's talked correctly the kid will go oh okay yeah I generated this now I need to edit it I need to

067go through it I need to look at it to make sure it sounds like me because to be honest it is still fairly easy even with some of the most beautiful like some of the best generated promps you can still kind of tell it's no different than going to when I was younger an encyclopedia grabbing a paragraph and then writing it in my own words to answer a homework question when you say write this like a fifth grader n yeah yeah yeah what what a GI for a special ed student though so so I like I liked your comment about um retraining our mind to cize what cheating is so if if a kid is creative and he has the initial thought then is that cheating no it's using his brain critical thinking y to

068establish a connection with the computer that allows creativity to come up and there's there's a lot of really strong arguments that say that that that are pretty I mean they're very strong that this peer to AI peer um interaction is actually going to build critical thinking even better than um our current model of building critical thinking right because the the interaction is so instantaneous so you're you're immediately getting feedback and then that you know they're building those critical thinking skills just IM immediately uh and I mean we think about it think about I mean all of you have written papers right and how laborious the actual writing process is when really what you wanted to do is get your point across but you had to type it so if you took out that imagine the

069depth of a paper that a fifth grader could write if they didn't have to type it if they could just think about it you know think about the ideas not have to physically go through and type it it's really a it to me it would be a transformation a transformation for the field of Education because I was thinking about um comment about you know cheating in the paper where the focuses on has been on the originality of the person who wrote the sentence and the paragraph the five-part paragraph and all that will become way less important than the content and the creativity which is are the kinds of things that really a teacher wants to focus on and they they have to build the bones first and a lot of kids bu the bones so

070they never get to that point of being able to express themselves in in a higher level format can I respond to that too is an English teacher um so I agree with both of you in that aspect too because that is obviously my first thing is and and I was talking to one of our big tech people here Brenda Roth who spouses all forms of technology and she's like I don't want it to take away from my writing I don't want it to take away from my creativity and so we really had some good conversations about that one of the things that I think about is it forces an educator to again go back to what that power standard is what is it that I'm assessing a student for if I am asking a student

071to create a five paragraph essay or three paragraph essay what am I assessing them for is it the content is it the conventions what am I looking for and what is it that I'm going to be focusing on because you're right if it's just content then that's we're open for just about anything right if I'm looking for specific conventions there might be different ways that I can assess that rather than a five so it really is getting down to the heart of what is it that I'm looking to grade and get you know find knowledge to seek Mastery for from my students and how does AI fit or not fit into that if I'm really wanting to know what a student has memorized that's a different expectation then create a you know plan to do

072whatever because then AI is going to help a student only think bigger and better and more grandure than simply memorization and you know so is so and I just one more thing Jo I just want to expand upon with that is that for example I was creating today with AI um sort of some of the PBIS stuff that we're going to be doing when we come back in January I had to sit through and I would read through what it came up with and then I was constantly looking to refine it how do I go back and refine it this sounds great and I would talk this sounds great but this is actually what I need please refine it or please change it to meet this then they would do it actually I like this

073part so generate more of this so continuously using those critical thinking skills as I interacted with it to create a product that I wanted and needed because it didn't do that right at the very beginning it gave me a good start but the creativity piece and the critical thinking piece that I had to do to interact to master what it was that I wanted it to come out with required a a very deep level of thinking and interacting on my behalf um that I would not have been able to do had I created that product on my own so it gave me the base already I knew what I wanted I said that into it and it created a base model for me and then I built on top of that so what I didn't

074have to do was create the base model I was able to refine everything and and bring it to what I wanted and that's the lovely thing just like you're able to do let's just say you're going through the policies for board policies if you were to upload your board policy into AI along with the rcws along with any new literature that has come out from ospi and you put that all and you would say could you please update our current board policy and create a standard template that we can begin to work off of it would generate a board policy for you to start with and then you could look at that board policy that was based on all of the documentation that you uploaded to it and then you would have all of that

075instead of each one of you having to read I think it's good for you to do that anyways but to have to generate after you've read and read and done all of this timely study on it it actually would do some of that for you so that you could spend the time on actually discussing what that policy looked like how affects our community um and you know what needs to be refined and and changed or altered about that as well so just again it's not about creating it and leaving it as is it's about the creation of the base of it and then working with AI to refine it and make it into the something that you need it to be that fits whatever it is that you're looking for I'm so sorry no you're

076fine along along those lines okay um if if I'm going to write an email it's an anticipatory thing that suggests what my next word might be in an email right I mean we're talking simple things like a text message or an email and it's not telling me what to write it's suggesting okay but if you're if you ask for a book report on to Killa Mockingbird and I ask for a book report on to Killa Mocking Bird it's going to tell us the same thing no okay except it's going to be written differently differently now we we we're putting in inform about ourselves for we have been for years everything we buy goes into AI it knows it knows our habits it knows our likes and our dislikes my wife and I can talk about

077our trip to Cancun without not even around our cell phone and then all of a sudden we're getting enement for a trip to Cancun right well you stay at our hotel um but what I what I don't like about the the process it's great to make it easier uh or faster to write but not when you're asking it for an algorithm opinion right it somebody wrote in their opinion of a of that book report or many people did and it's piecing them all together but it you know if you're asking a kid to write a book report he's going to do it the easiest way he possibly can and it might read differently than the other kids but it's it's giving them it's not allowing them to pull out their in their their opinions or

078their artistic ability in writing it that's that's my concerns so what I would say with that is that as an English teacher I would ask to see the prompts that they gave it so if a student is only going to say I need a book report and I think that Scout was a really cool character and I think that she needed to um grow up you know or something like that I would I would have that be a piece of what I was saying if I was to say use AI to do this I would say I want top like but I would also be very specific in saying I would like you to use AI to create a paragraph based on character development so in order to do that you're going to need to

079input four specific characteristics of Scouts and you're also going to need to input how SC responded in these particular situations that's your prompt that you're going to put in Ai and I want you to see what it comes up with so as a teacher I'm gonna say I want you to do this but I'm going to direct you exactly on how I want you to do it um now obviously in high school that might look a little different but in middle school if I'm teaching kids how to use AI I'm going to direct them specifically how to use what that looks like and then we're going to go from there and then I might say also tell I AI not to put any punctuation in it because I'm going to have you that out and

080I want you to punctate theph itself so again what I see is it's you was a teacher it's about you no longer it's no longer the teacher the fresh the eighth grade teacher says we're going to write book reports on the book you read and everybody's going to write a book your it now it's it's tailoring as you said tailoring the assignment where they learn how to use a so out of it comes not only what you learn about the book but you also are teaching in the process of using AI as a tool yeah I think effective use of it can actually enhance teaching significantly make it a lot more interesting you're you're you're going from write a book report to what trissa said where you're you're literally making them they have to read

081the book right because right the level of specificity kind of circles back around to my point is um rolling this out and marketing it so that people have that teaching uh has that critical thinking part to say these are the parameters that I'm going to work within my students and that interaction and feedback is what I expect that so the and just thinking about you were what you all are thinking the bad of AI obviously is increasing and or creating inequitable learning environments and that's that's what we're trying to right now prevent um unauthorized access to protected user information and unauthorized data collection that's a big one but that is based upon the we can help to work with that based upon the model or the AI that we use especially for students because we

082know they're mischievous everybody is like Siri don't listen to what I say exactly um perpetuating institutional and systematic systemic bias that's a big one for the large language models and we have to recognize that when we're using an AI we have to have some thought about you know hey is this really the case or is just is this something that is a bias built into it um and then playism obviously I can big one um and then over relying on technology and undermining the importance of human Intelligence on education um I think there's going to be a shift in that part because um AI for Education if use correctly just improves um efficiency and efficiency in education is really hard to attain because of the model that we use so anything that improves that efficiency

083is going to help our students um yeah I mean we kind of already went through this Trisha kind of gave examples already um there is a long list of these things these uh guiding principles this is this is from from um Seattle school districts and OPI um I'm not going to read them all to you but basically what they say is that has to be student centers we have to think about the biases we have to be transparent in our use has to transparent for the students to be uh explicit in our use when you are saying that you want to you know that you're going to tell them to use use Ai and if you don't tell them then they're that's you're not going to use it um and uh yeah and all these

084things well I'll just make sure you get this so you can see and these are all from Seattle School District this is a cool thing from OPI and it kind of shows uh a gradual use kind of the the graduation of of using it to where you get to level five which is AI as a co-creator which would be more High School obviously there would be some of that also in Middle School and you know probably to a limited extent in elementary school but each one of these levels kind of shows how AI can assist a student or a teacher uh appropriately and then uh I think an interesting thing is that the teaching students to use artificial intelligence is crucial for preparing them we already know that um but what we need to also

085realize that most of them have already started using it so if we can give them some guidance uh and some tools that are appropriate for their for them to use at school then we might be able to you know make an impact on how they use it uh and then elementary students uh you know chat GPT is is creative is is for 13 years and older so we have to find something that has appropriate guard rails for students that are younger than that um and luckily there are things uh and then we as administrators and as teachers need to make sure that we adhere to those to to using those tools at an appropriate level for the students um and the middle school well you'll can read that on your own great thing is like

086we've already said students with unique needs students with multi that are elll or that have special needs AI can be uh transformational like you said I mean it can uh a kid who has limited dexterity can participate in writing an essay just like everybody else empowers and empowers kids um and the the the immediate translation uh is so much better than Google translate you can't even it's it's out of this world translation because Google translate doesn't take into account the gender of the kid does doesn't take into account their where they're at like they're um if they are if you say Spanish well that could be hundreds of different dialect langu so uh you can input specific languages into an AI model and it will translate it into that specific language even down to Regions

087so magic school AI is the one that I would like for us to consider uh uh rolling out two kids uh and it has it is what Seattle school district is using and what some of the kitap uh Peninsula school districts are using it has tools on top of tools on top of tools for not only for teachers but for uh administrators and for students uh and I'll give you a little preview of what it looks like this is the student side can't really see it with this the way that the screen is but it has things like chat with a doc which is what Trisha was talking about before where you take your document that you've written you upload it into the the chat bot and you ask it questions about your document and

088it will give you specific immediate responses about what you just wrote that's pretty powerful for kids um there's a summarizing AI there is uh all sorts of the one that I love is that based upon the writings of an author who could be completely dead maybe for hundreds of years you can have a conversation with that author so for instance if you wanted to talk to Mark Twain you can have a virtual conversation with Mark Twain based upon his writing and his biography and what other people have talked about so that's pretty powerful I mean that's a pretty cool thing for kids to be able to do um and then there's a SAT practice for for for English language you can things like that um and then KH Academy is also going to be putting

089out a a AI um bot basically and it's based it's uh focused on science focused on math uh so it's specifically tailored for those subjects and I think that um that even the free version for us would be great for kids to be able to use so you you've been great about asking questions and being patient uh but does anybody have any final questions I had to throw the Matrix on there just because are you okay questions y do you have any parents who are going to say not my kid I don't trust AI I mean we've had parents say no Chromebooks so we probably will yeah so is there something I guess you guys hav figured it out but are we educating them in some capacity so they know it's coming and uh SM

090that you just did here we will yeah we'll have to that would be it's our responsibility to make sure that our community knows what we're allowing their kids to be to to that's that's I said probably some form of a marketing plan to to roll it out so people understand it instead of are scared of it sue you know I mean I think the other thing I think the other thing too is that we're not we're this is not going to be curriculum only I mean we're not going to say get rid of math English science textbooks curriculum and we're going to focus on AI it's it's a tool just like technology became a tool 20 years ago U just like cell phones became a tool so I think we we look at it from

091the standpoint that this is one more iteration in the 22nd century that we will be now using to enhance students ability to learn be curious we all know what our what test scores look like right now and we know what it was 10 years ago we look 10 years in the future and has AI improved the test scores of our fifth grade students right I that's what we that's what we'll tell us if this works yeah and I say that'll have to be a question that we'll ask you know in the next couple of years because right now theid really don't use it right at all and so I don't think we know the impact of what that'll look like and what the correlation might be right yeah well you death has some kind of

092a a measurement you know in order to understand so building that Matrix so you do get some kind of feedback and know what direction you need to there's a lot of kids I'm speaking of of experience that are my daughter and my son's generation who absolutely refuse to use it oh who refused to use it to them it is um cheating in more sense of the word than cheating yeah where and it doesn't matter how how well I morally wrong morally wrong yeah I would say my my daughter is kind of moving towards it a little bit because she sees that the value of it but and my son on is going to be in computer science so he's going to have to do but there is there is still even in younger kids and

093that kind of there's a resistance to it because it's so it's it's a little scary yeah it's the the unknown like anything else it is I I have a question when you're talking about you're putting your your document in what are you using are you putting it into the phone I I can't picture the link between well when I'm looking at see I don't I don't know the program so yeah so when I'm looking at chat GPT there's a little message but but is it like is it on your phone I don't like it's like when you text you there's a box on your phone and you start typing the letters to text and then hit send on chat GPT there's the same thing there's a little box so is it an app that's on

094your phone I mean I don't yeah you can put it on your phone and then you just type in whatever you want chat chat GPT CPT g chat I have two I have my personal one and then I have a school right one's with my personal account and one is my school account and my brother actually is an events manager and he is currently his new job role is to teach people about um Amazon the Amazon assistant and so that's his whole he goes all over the country sets up conventions and that's his whole role is to teach people how to use the assistant the virtual assistant be and he talks about it so I would he this is the way easiest way he talks about picking a recipe pick a recipe and ask it

095to create a recipe for you for something and then he takes them down the line and then he's like okay now that you have the recipe for a Caesar salad now ask it to create a whole meal around that Caesar salad now for 35 people yeah for a certain amount of people now I want to create an entire menu for my week of five dinners and I want to have Caesar salad two times a week I want you to create a shopping list for me but actually I want all of that to be gluten and I also only want to have meat on three of the nights and I want the other two nights to be uh protein from vegetable sources tell it to do all of that and it will do that for you

096and it really just it's it's getting to know you and your preferences bu it will do all of that and you can walk away with a grocery list and your whole entire menu planned out for the entire week including you can have it break down all of the recipes for you if you wanted in about one minute all those promps so getting to know you the first week you do it it might be one way but and now you're asking for maybe some little different things it's it's going to adapt to you yeah and then as it learned you better it it'll get you down like a tea and you won have to say much no and then here's the scary part after you've used it for a couple of weeks or even a couple

097months tell it to say something about you that you might not know and it will be scarily accurate based off of all of the information that you've inputed but I will tell you what it knows about me on my work chat GPT is different than knows about me on my personal chat GPT my personal chat GPT is about you know things I'm doing for my family create a vacation create you know all kind stuff everything in my work one is about obviously work and so it is it's interesting that I can have two separate chat gpts and it has two different flavors of who I am two different people yeah well our students I mean like the elementary students are and I would imagine in the middle school too you they're using it already in

098a sense that like we have the math programs right that okay you're at this level I'm going to present you these other things based on where you're at now that's already AI it's just not on this level like so there's still it's just taking that opportunity to present the information that is necessary for that child and C it's customizing it already we're already doing it it's just not called chat GPT and AI exactly we've been affected our existence has been affected by Machine learning for many years and now machine learning has gone to generative AI creating content so I mean we're just progressing Jill you mentioned in the beginning there were two kinds yeah and we're talking about generative what was tell me a little bit about the other one the other kind is basically

099it uses it uses more of a mathematical process than I me they all use they all use M what is it its purpose is to do statistics okay to do prediction like weather predictions although the generative ones are becoming kind of taking over for weather now but that was the old use of AI was that it was predictive like way better than a human could do them um statistical way better than so this this would be somebody like somebody working on their PHD and they were trying to get their get their stats all together for their or storm like like the Storm Prediction modeling um those types of things they they use that for just for years for that um I know when I went to my military reunion uh they were showing things are

100doing this one kid was modeling shape charges breaching like heavy reinforce you come up with that those are the AI models that the generative one is better at because the the regular statistical kind of um mathematical AI doesn't think creatively it thinks black and white yeah it's like yes or no but it does it in a huge you know capacity whereas the generative ones are like well it could do this if you place it here yeah he took existing Plastics and then uh had a 3D printer and printed out the shape charge and then just taped the plastic explosive it yeah it really yeah pretty crazy so you mentioned that you were you were interested in magic school so is that a thing where we'll be hearing more about this in the next coming months

101as far as cost and use and the whole Pro like process Robert was talking about for like a marketing thing and all that kind of stuff think we're gonna I think we're going to start with the free version because it's it is free to all kids and teachers and then eventually uh hopefully at some point we'll have resources to get the paid version and the paid version of magic school is way cheaper than CH GPT or gemini or any of those you subscribe to it you can and it all it does is it it has the same kind of feature set where you can save long you can have it builds your you know build your database whereas the free one is more um episodic so um but yes I will uh build a thing

102for um the magic school and then definitely we'll start doing some community outreach for what we're gonna do awesome yeah sweet thank you yeah of course are there any other questions lots of thank you Joel okay so up next we have the second reading of policy 6802 for the cyber security practices has anything changed since the first reading no nothing's changed is there any questions or comments I move that we um accept the Pioneer School District cyber security action plan policy 6802 and 6000 do I have a second second thank you it's been moved and seconded all in favor say I I I any oppos that motion passes uh up next is board share do we have anything for the board share I want to make one comment on this so the risk cube in

103there that's pretty standard in like industrial and using that in in this the risk assessment yeah yeah I like the way it was set up too easy to follow okay so on question next um our next board meeting is in January and that's our the our uh set of officers organization organ trying to get oute we'll have a we'll have a study session study session first second Tuesday and then but the board meeting is the organizational part of it the organization elect the president vice president okay thank you for bring that up I apprciate um anything else board okay do I have a motion to adjourn toj do I have a second I second all in favor say I that is it thank you guys

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.