CorpusRecord 1025

School Board Workshop: December 10, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Lee County School Board
Date
2024-12-10
Location
Lee County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
30,933 words · about 172 min
Collected
2026-04-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good afternoon everyone it is Tuesday December 10th 2024 this is a Schoolboard workshop and the time is 1 p.m. Sergeant arms has the lobby been attended to yes thank you Chief our student representative this afternoon is Jose Jose Videl Jose is a senior at South Fort Meers high school he has a unique educational background because he has moved numerous times since elementary school however this has allowed him to become adaptable to new environments Jose has been at South Fort Myers High School since freshman year and has been actively participating in the programs and extracurricular activities he is the Brigade Commander for JC senior class president and is a member of National Honor Society Jose intends to become a member of the Navy by completing his training at the United States Naval Academy please welcome Jose

002sorry just excited to introduce him we have nine items on the agenda today starting with food service construction change order report for October 2024 job descriptions Elementary and secondary school emergency relief or known as Esser investment returns and investment strategy insulin litigation presentation board advisory committees public comment and good of the order other business per board protocol I want to remind everyone that just stried for 4 minutes for initial comment 2 minutes for followup for a total of 10 minutes Madam superintendent are we ready to begin for the first item yes sir we are okay the first item on the agenda is Food Service if you want to do the introductions yes we're very proud today to have our team who I'm going to let them introduce themselves and talk with you a little bit

003about our food service please ladies good afternoon I'm candy messenger I am the director of food and nutrition services this is Sarah Cox the Executive Director of Business Services and Amy Carol who is one of my coordinators in nutrition services while I'm presenting we also have food samples that are will be handed out to you they're bringing they'll be bringing them forward so we would like you to enjoy them as we go through our presentation get you're going to have to y so what you're being served is Big Daddy's Pizza the orange chicken and fried rice Taco rollups and then we have the pull apart and the pancake sausage breakfast item along with a Brookie which is a dessert the governance of food and nutrition services department has federal guidelines that are that are required

004similar to Academia the federal oversight is the United States Department of Agriculture the State of Florida Department of Agriculture and consumer services fdax the Florida Health Department who governs both supper and snack programs and the Florida health code the local oversight is the school board of Lee County School nutrition departments are separate from the school district's general fund and education budget the school nutrition budget fund School meals salaries for school nutrition staff kitchen equipment staff uniforms and other items related to school nutrition the chart is representative of the reimbursement that we receive per meal served breakfast and lunch as you see has two different reimbursement rates the top number is what we received for as the free rate for our free meals and the bottom number is the full paid reimbursement that we receive in

005the next couple of slides I will explain to you why there are two reimbursement rates for breakfast and lunch the community eligibility provision CP is a non-pricing meal service option for schools and school districts in lowincome areas C allows the nation's highest property schools and districts to serve breakfast and lunch at no cost to all enrolled students without collecting household applications the identified student percentage ISP is multiplied by a factor of 1.6 to determine the local percent percentage of meals reimbursed at the federal free rate the remaining meals are reimbursed at the federal paid rate there is not a re reduced price meals that are claimed by C this chart represents the reimbursement rate percentage per C formula as stated there is not a re reduced reimbursement rate for C the goal in grouping schools

006is to get the most reimbursement for for the meals as a district we can regroup when we see the percentage of economically need shifts the data is gathered during our October data collection and our April data periods our department runs a direct certification process monthly so on this slide for instance in 2024 the bottom line 20242 we have 89% that is paid out at the free rate so for breakfast we would get $284 per meal and at lunch we would get $454 per meal the remaining 10.5% for breakfast we would receive 39 cents per meal served and we would receive 53 cents per meal served at that 10 10.5% of our full meals that we served that month food and nutrition services oversees 86 locations employing 766 dedicated School level staff and 21 district office

007Personnel this exceptional team is the back backbone of our success from the Frontline staff to the administrative team each individual play plays a vital role in ensuring our students receive nutritious meals my role as director would be impossible without their tiess efforts and commitment to Excellence having worked every level at the at in within food and nutrition services I deeply appreciate the hard work and dedication of our entire team they are the true heroes of our department a summary of this slide lunch participation has shown a steady increase over time with a temporary decline in school year 23 due to Hurricane Ian breakfast participation has remained relatively stable within these four years the summary of this slide is the food and nutrition services is focused on achieving Financial sustainability by balancing revenue and expenses this

008includes monitoring reimbursement from the community eligibility program and implementing cost saving measures this one I can do it okay offer versus serve is a provision in national school lunch program and School breakfast program this allows students to decline some of the food that is offered the goals of offer versus serves are to reduce food waste in the school meal programs while permitting students to decline Foods they do not intend to eat at breakfast School schools must offer students five required food items and at least the minimum required amounts under offer versus serve a student must be offered at least five of the food items it must select at least three of the food items one of which must be a half cup fruit or vegetable for offer versus serve at lunch schools must offer students

009all five required food components in at least the minimum required amounts the component at lunch are Meats meat Alternatives grains fruits vegetables and fluid milk under offer versus serve a student must take at least three components that in the required serving sizes one selection must be at least a half a cup either fruit or vegetable what this slide is talking about is that all School meals the school breakfast program and the national school lunch program must adhere to nutrition standards set forth by the USDA and a lot of people aren't aware of this Factor but there are limits on calories sodium fats and beginning next school year sugar that we have to keep within those constraints there's also weekly requirements that we have to meet including every single week we have to offer a red

010orange vegetable a dark green leafy vegetable and a legume these are all required by the USDA as part of a healthy diet and I just want to make a comparison between one of our school lunches and a popular lunch you might get at a fast food restaurant so here we have whole grain chicken nuggets tater tots which count as a starchy vegetable apple slices a whole grain roll and a 1% milk you have that equating to 520 calories and 16 grams of fat if you look at a popular fast food meal that a child might get you have your five chicken nuggets your French fries sliced apples and a milk here at 645 calories 26 G of fat so you just jumped up 10 G of fat and 125 calories none of it's whole grain

011and it's all deep fried there are a total of 59 locations serving supper snack a super snack or supper in the month of October the daily average of the super snack meals served was 1,358 with supper the daily average was 1,266 reimbursement rates are the same for both super snack and supper meals in the month of October food and nutrition services is looking at all costs associated with the meals that we serve to to the students in Lee County we meet with the vendor that supplies the super snack meals twice a year to ensure that we are keeping up with the students preferences on this slide you'll also see our after school snap we currently have six under the 21st century grant program and then we have eight Community sites that pick up from five

012different locations and then we have two schools that are still under the after school snack program the reimbursement for supper and super snack is significantly higher and the amount of food food that the student receives is also more student the super snack meals have five meal components as stated previously for lunch after school snacks contain two items either a fruit and a grain or a juice in a grain what is super snack these kits contain components of the Supper meal variety provides students with more substantial meals but also keeps it simple to serve as a snack why food and nutrition services moving to super snack versus after school snack the feed is because we have feedback from the schools that it was concerned that students was not receiving enough food with their school snack after

013school snack the meals can be served anywhere on campus not just in cafeteria and using this format will help with the labor expense that allows food and nutrition services to concentrate on breakfast and lunch meals and when we were searching for a vendor for our super snacks we decided to go with the same manufacturer that Services blessings in a backpack because because those are very well received by the students this slide is comparing K12 to commercial Foods K there's generally two lines of food when you think about food manufacturers there's a retail line and there's a K12 line a lot of food manufacturers want to get in the K12 world because they know that the students there's going to be brand recognition so when you think of companies like Kelloggs or General Mills they are

014they have two lines of food in their factories a k12 and a retail because their K12 line has to meet the standards put forth so the poptarts that your child may receive for breakfast in the schools you cannot buy in the stores so I'm sorry will you go back real quick if you look at the K12 foods like I said they're regulated by the USDA they have to be whole grain lean proteins lower fat and lower sodium starting in next school year 25 26 there will also be a restriction on sugar where commercial Foods you know the taste primarily comes from the fat and sugar so it is going to be not whole grain and generally higher in those items so back to the Pop-Tart example this is just a comparison of a K12 poptart

015to a retail Pop-Tart the biggest different is going to be that it's made from whole grain it has no high fructose corn syrup and I mean it's not there it's relatively close in calories and fats but the whole grain and the no high fruit toast corn syrup make a big difference these are the pull apart doughnut holes that you guys were served and again it's just a comparison k12's always going to be generally less calories sodium sugar and always whole grain a comparison of our applesauce again if you look at the ZZ blue raspberry applesauce is a super popular choice with the students and it has zero added sugar where the MS has I think it's 22 gram of added sugar so this slide is what we have set as our goals financial goals is

016to increase participation and both both meal programs and alicart sales collaborate monthly with Finance to optimize revenue and reduce cost transition to Direct Delivery for high schools to eliminate the $17 per case delivery fee our operational goals is to implement Edison which is an automated inventory program to streamline Inventory management and production recordkeeping and Foster Cross trainining of amongst our District staff to ensure understanding and efficiency our student engagement goals is to expand student feedback Beyond taste test testing and including broader surveys for increased inclusive representation engagement engage with student groups to gain insights and tailor offerings these are just some highlights in the f F and nutrition services department we were starting this year granted $450,000 from Sprouts supermarkets to help with our Healthy Living collaboration and our school Gardens which are growing exponentially

017so we can get fresh produce directly into the cafeteria it makes a world of difference we were the first school district in the country to ever be given this amount by Sprout so we're honored we were also given $90,000 by the laboratory downtown to help fund our school garden so that's basically over a half a million in one year and we're continuing to grow the other article is every year we do a crunch event in celebration of farm to school month this year we the students crunched you crunch the produce sweet potatoes grown in our school Gardens we did it at three elementary schools and we had students karaoke about sweet potatoes it was just such a fun event to hide highlight what they're being served in the cafeteria national school lunch week every year

018in the fall we have national school lunch week and in the spring is National School breakfast weeks and the this is just highlighting these National programs and a lot of times we use it as a time to offer new items and do like a districtwide taste test and get feed back and just different things because the students do get menu fatigue so we try to vary it up and then our Healthy Living collaboration which I mentioned earlier is basically collaboration within the school district our mission is to improve overall health and increase food security for our students and families and it's a collaboration between food nutrition services Comprehensive Health education Environmental Education and Career and Technical education so many of our high schools have an agricultural program and it's basically using your Gardens as a

019living classroom stem curriculum all throughout the garden bringing that produce into the cafeteria to Foster our smarter lunchroom movement so it's kind of a full circle initiative and it is going amazingly well these are some actual pictures from our cafeteras of different things we serve prior to co we were very big into fresh fruit and vegetable bars like you see in the center Co kind of messed things up for a little bit and that students couldn't serve themselves etc etc but we are getting back to our fresh fruit and vegetable bars and as you can see there's pasta there's chicken nuggets there's always salads and every student tray that comes through that line has to have a half cup fruit or vegetable so we would like to invite you to visit any of our schools

020for a meal breakfast or lunch and I welcome your feedback as you go out to the schools and see what's happening in our cafeterias are there any questions before I turn it over thank you before I turn over the board members Madam superintendent is there anything you want to add before we yes thank you just very briefly if I could so just want to to first of all thank our team for being here today and for sharing not only our delicious lunch but also some information about our food service program we really appreciate that and I just want to kind of underscore a couple of things that I think are important one is you know looking at the amount of money that you have received via grants and other opportunities generating income which is refreshing

021nice to see so thank you on that and just a big Kudo around our Kudos around our school Gardens so I know that our students get that opportunity and if you think about back in the day I had a wonderful grandmother who had me do gardening but I think it's a lost art I think so many of our children don't get that opportunity to participate in those types of activities so just U major kudos to you and your team and we'll now turn it over to the board members for their questions and comments thank you thank you madam superintendent board member comments questions concerns Mr psons first I don't know how you I'll do it the logistics of this must be absolutely amazing because you it's not like you call up the grocery store and

022say I need this tomorrow I mean how far out do yall have to order your food products make sure you have a supply and is your supply chain working out okay the supply chain is working good now we're able to get everything but we lost our door-to-door delivery service so because we had to hire a freezer company and a trucking company we're ordering probably 3 weeks out yes U the gardens are great if I can continue one more thing I even helped plant some but and I went to one of the Crunch and it is funny cuz some of the students look at them like I can eat that because it but they do and they say oh this tastes good so there's a lot of produce being sent do you have any idea how

023much from the garden tonnage wise or or pounds wise last year we did a little over 177,000 lbs excellent all right thank you and just with the Sprouts money this year we have set up four full Gardens at four schools now we have 14 and our goal right now is to get them consistently being able to furnish their cafeterias with that produce and then continuing to expand that it Mr person anybody else M Jordan I just want to say thank you production on how you do order and maybe that would be a great for the rest of the to come and see how to actually do that I was looking at the one page slide three what is that catering for for who like a lot of times we have one right now at Bonita

024high they want to do like a holiday spaghetti dinner for their school staff right so we will order the items prepare prepare the food and then it's just like a catering function that will be build to them we are just catering and preparing the food and then that money goes into the to that particular School because it's not like the culinary classes so that's why I was when I saw catering I was like where does that fit in where does that money go to the catering revenue is just documented as just that into the Food Service fund it doesn't necessarily go back to that school it just supports the overall food service operation okay thank you and thank you for what you do Miss lenford Fleming thank you for putting this together I appreciate it

025and thank you for cooking for us today I know that a lot of work goes into this and I get so many emails and conversations about food so I'm not trying to sound harsh I just know that we can always better our game the last slide you showed I've never received a picture like that and that would be my expectation actually sending my child to school especially with the Sprouts organization donating I know that they did last year at a couple of schools and I think that every one of our schools should have a garden K through 12 quite frankly I've been to a middle school elementary school and a high school garden and they you know obviously they're more advanced the older the age so the problem is as much as I appreciate you

026cooking not one thing on this tray is green orange red yellow from a garden so that might have been a helpful perhaps today to see you know what our Gardens are doing and the the basically Farm totable concept I love that concept and growing up in a farming Community I remember days where the lunch ladies would come over and say now did you eat your peas and I would scoop them under a napkin maybe but I still tried to smile and say Yes so I I mean I know we can't do that any longer but the fact it was there and somebody who tried I have an app that I use for work and it inputs and outputs exactly all of the macros of a meal so while I put that this meal into here

027and I know it's going to be really close because they're very specific but just in this meal alone are over 85 Cal carbohydrates and carbohydrates make children very re tired and adults while they're healthy as long as they're healthy carbohydrates I love to hear that we're going to have lels and and maybe some more brown rice on their kids table I think that's great you just have to remember some of these kids eat at 10:30 in the morning and then they're expected to continue to sustain High academic achievement throughout the day so carbohydrates equal sugar sugar is that high and then they crash and for one meal to be about 1,400 calories that's a very high caloric meal without a whole lot of nutritional output we know protein is I mean everybody knows you know

028you want to balance the protein and the carbs while both are important and the lesser the fat the better I have gotten an email and on social media messages and texts about the blue raspberry sauce and why it's blue I went and looked at the ingredients and I've tried to find out where the blue dye is it blue dye is it natural dye cuz I can't find it on the label like what number do you do you know it's blue dye it's not natural dye it is blue dye okay but more they're moving the K12 lines you can see them keeping up with Trends they're all moving towards the natural dies beats turmeric so we're seeing that even with the Kellogg cereals only for schools not yet out in the retail they are moving towards

029those natural dyes okay and I appreciate you giving us the balance between I think you compared it to a fast food place on slide 12 I would probably I'd love to see instead of comparing a fast food place because I know I can't afford to send my kids to fast food every day what an at home meal looks like so I would want to perhaps see those to lined up together not school food versus fast food but maybe School food versus what an atome meal would look like May that's just where my head went and then my other question through the chair to the superintendent we have a lot of vending machines in our schools and I think that's great we're we're creating an opportunity for kids especially kids who are really active they're really

030hungry about an hour or after they've left the house what kinds of items are in those vending machines are they packs of Snickers and Skittles or are they granola bars and nuts do you yeah I'll weigh in on that I love for Staff first of all do you have that information if not the vending machines are operated by the schools and this is a big source of contention because it is competitive Foods so generally they are stocked with Coke Takis all that kind of stuff they are not to be turned on until 3:30 I mean sorry until 30 minutes after the end of the school day yeah but we're finding that they're on all day but Food Service we don't run the vending vending machines and so that point is well taken because I'll just

031share as a as a mom what I've seen in various schools and just as a principal there are schools that have tried to focus on healthy choices water I've seen some of those at schools and then I've seen what you alluded to which is the sodas and all of that so it's an opportunity for us for sure well and like I said none of this is a knock against what your department is doing whatever at at all I just our goal at fsba was to be the best and number one in academics and nutrition what we're putting are the overall experience for our students so thank you for answering those questions and putting this and our salads are from the gardens our primarily our primary produce coming from the gardens now is lettuce tomatoes and

032peppers because it's a quick turnaround the lettuce can be har harvested every 6 weeks so when that garden lettuce is served e either in a salad or like on a sub the participation goes up exponentially because you can tell it's coming from the garden right outside the door so the salads in that picture are from our Gardens okay thank you Miss juvenile thank you I think I tried every thing yeah I did actually and it's good but thank you Miss Fleming because it's not fresh I mean that's the thing and I haven't ate like this in a while so I really just blew my diet thanks but it would and actually was all tasty so I would really be curious what the student rep thought of the food because the kids are the ones been

033telling us that they're not happy with the food and so that for me me is probably the most important I want to hear from you so the I haven't actually had ate this food I'm doing wrestling and so I have to watch what I eat but I have had all this in the past before and obviously it's up to personal preference what people like so like what you serve does I like some of the food more than the others but I wouldn't say any of it is bad like take singer at all and actually the presentation opened my eyes onto new information and how you guys really benefit the schools in the community and what Miss Fleming said about you know seeing Gardens in all the schools I think if I experienced that in like

034my middle school growing up I think that would have you know helped me a lot more in like the way I ate and like watch what what I took in so I think if you know more kids you know could realize how beneficial you guys are I think it open a lot of their eyes as well but yeah I mean it's I think the food is just up to personal preference but I think everyone should be grateful that you know it's free food that you're being served and part of our initiative with school Gardens is when we get that produce in the cafeteria there's a program out of Cornell called the smarter lunchroom movement and it's all about using the cafeteria as another place of learning so that kids do understand where their food is

035coming from how it benefits their bodies Etc because like you said a lot of a lot of people have no idea students and adults so not every school has the Fresh Garden so only a few schools are getting the salads so I think that's really key to the garden situation because I love the concept I'm very supportive of that and learned a lot about it when I was on that healthy living one liais zone or whatever you want to call it that was I was great and that's grown and but I and I like to see it grow more but it's not it's not just growing it you got to get it to the table and that's where y'all come in because that's hard that's a hard to have enough food to go out to

036you know get through all the students and everything so I look forward to seeing more fresh and I'm probably going to eat this I don't know the rest of this I've ate the top of that cupcake thing that's delicious so thank you okay I'm gonna ask some questions if the board is all right with that okay thank you everyone first off I don't need this answer right now for the community eligibility program are we seeing any trends of where we me way where we may be at excuse me next year I know we were watching with watchful eye I guess is the best way for this year so I don't know if we have any Trends or anything at the moment I am currently working on the groupings to see how we can us and

037I'm working with the state to make sure that we are getting the best possible reimbursement that we can and to add to that we use survey 3 data to calculate those groupings which is the February student survey so once we get that information that really helps us plan for the groupings for the subsequent year thank you okay now I'm going to kind of piggyback off Miss Langford Fleming as well as Miss juven Elli and I appreciate you all I have three kids in this District that eat these meals every day so I get lots of feedback especially on the chicken sandwiches by the way but looking at this again and I appreciate all the cafeteria staff they're amazing especially all the things they went through covid and you know it's important that we treat those

038people as you know as just amazing people that they are so but getting you know the thing that comes up for me is how can we do better as a district kind of going up with Miss lenford Fleming said you know one for example that we looked at for example is I mean still the snack it's still a Pop-Tart it's still lots of sugar it and stuff like that Donuts things like that I know it's a better version but I know a lot of it comes down to funding and choices and try trying to pick for everyone and I'm not asking you to necessarily answer this now cuz it's on both the administration the board as well but how can we do better for this because I know there's you know kids obviously a lot

039of these kids this is where their main meals come from out the day and some of these healthy choices aren't there I love the garden program my son went through it at one of the schools in fact I think that is fantastic but where are kind of our opportunities where we can you know help with that I mean we all get corresponden and emails and things and to the that effect so that's kind of my general question to all of us actually I guess is the best way to say and Co during Co it was hard because when we had to move all the meal services to the curb there was no prepackaged like hot breakfast high protein items for instance and we all in the school nutrition World went to the manufacturers and said

040these items we are serving are way too high in sugar I have parents call me and they would be like this breakfast has 80 grams of sugar and I could not disagree so over the past couple years our biggest request to the food manufacturers especially at breakfast was to give us more hot items with protein and we are getting more into that and we're looking to go more back to semis scratch cooking versus the Heat and surf that's going to be a lot of training a lot of our staff the younger folks don't know how to cook like we did back in the day so it is training for them and baby steps Le you know maybe next semester go with two semis scratch recipes and then expand from there so we do know in

041the past few years that the meals have been high in sugar it's been Nationwide thank you that was music to my ears and I'm sure many of the board members as well so that's all I have I appreciate you all anyone else want to give any comments or questions before we move on to the next topic Miss Jordan briefly and the pictures of course they're staged pictures and I think that people eat with their eyes first so when the kids are seeing you know looking at their food and that's what they snap pictures of because of course this is takes time to make sure that they all look like this yes and that was everything that was served that day and you might have a student just get the you know the chicken nuggets and

042an apple and a milk so every tray is not going to have every component but that was what was served in that kitchen that day yeah that would be your complete meals yes yes thank you thank you thank you for the meals I was able to try some of as well thank you all I appreciate your hard work we're going to move on to item number two now which be construction change order whenever you're ready to proceed Mr rickenbacher good afternoon board members I'm not seeing the presentation up in the folder here do you all have a handout yeah unless Jen can find it yeah we all have it on board do good afternoon board members superintendent Carlin and S Squire Deo Bruno this is your October of 2024 change order report acquired by Statute

043that we give every month and if you all have the handout while we're waiting for the presentation to come up on board it's a pretty small one this time and I know your time's valuable today on the first page we had direct material purchases that's where we bring the money back into the district and we provide the payment for the materials Direct ly we did $358,900 68 in tax savings that comes back to the district C coffers in regular change orders nonmaterial direct purchase change orders we did 7,358 487 and contingency adjustments contingencies are embedded within the capital projects it's a shared contingency between construction manager in the district to support any unforeseen issues and we had expended $1,511 42 and if you go to page two the second page is the breakdown of all

044the change orders associated with this report we had two DMP change orders for Gulf Point construction at the Veterans Park Academy of the Arts for roofing materials suff construction at Riverdale High School purchasing of kitchen equipment and both both of those returned $2,553 to the district we had four standard change orders and you'll see the large one there the biggest one that will pop out at you that is the lease expenditure for the temporary Hector caffara campus that covers Us for the duration of the construction build for the lease payment of the portable campus and we had one contingency adjustment down at Riverdale High School for some added on-site rooms fire pendants and Associated equipment are there any questions board members comments questions concerns Miss lenford Fleming Then followed by Mr Ribble my only comment

045is I really love when we have money returned to the district we try thank you yeah I just want to comment I spent half hour with Mr Rick aaker yesterday I enjoyed every minute of it and I was totally shocked as a as Miss Fleming was about getting money back I've never I've not seen that I was so pleased with the way you manage our money and or our for each and every statement on the on this sheet and it was it was time well spent I thank you well we can it's money that comes back that helps provide seats so Dr well and I wanted to Echo the sentiments of Miss Fleming and Mr ribel first of all thank you Scott and thank you for my very first Workshop bringing money back to the

046district that was perfect setup on that and we'll we'll checks in the mail right no all King aside that's what we're doing as a as a district right now Now is working very diligently to find ways to return revenue and any other operational dollars and capital dollars back to The District budget we know we have priorities I've been very loud and clear about those priorities keeping us very focused as a governance team as well as our leadership team and our entire District on what's most important and that includes student achievement teacher Recruitment and Retention safety you know being fiscally responsible and that's what goes to this particular return to the to the district so thank you Scott and thank you the board for recognizing his hard work thank you have a good day everybody thank

047you Mr rickenbacher moving on to item number three on the agenda would be job descriptions good afternoon board members superintendent Carin attorney depri Bruno before you today I'm bringing job descriptions for your review you have already been provided those those are including supervisor of Transportation stock room coordinator Transportation associate superintendent of of Adult Career Technical and alternative education chief of safety security and Fleet operations and director of internal compliance at this time I'll put it to any questions or comments that you may have Dr K board members we look forward you we have had conversations about this in our one-on-one briefings and so we look forward to any additional questions or comments we stand ready to answer those questions board members any comments or questions okay Miss Jordan thank you I actually have two the

048coordinator for transportation is that's a new item I mean a new position yes that is correct that is correct and then when I was trying to re I apologize I was running this morning I was looking at and there's a lot in this job description and I know that is our job is to make sure that we go over job descriptions and to put these into place but what exactly as far as is this in the budget is the money in the budget for this position have we budgeted for this all all positions that are coming forward we have discussed with budget and we are prepared to move forward with those so yes the answer is yes okay and then the location of this person it was it looks like they're going to be in

049all the all the different areas in the district it looks like are you referring just particular one right here we will we will get that answer for you thank you on and then my next I have some more but I'll ask those later of you and then the next one was the associate superintendent that was another one that I had some questions about in that particular one and I know we did have a brief conversation about that in our 101 but my concern is that's 100 the U the pay grade is u22 so that's like 142,000 beginning salary on that one and for us if we're really trying to we're concerned about Revenue we just got some money back which we thanked U Mr Scott for that and now this is a lot of money

050that's going out I know we already have a director of a director for the acce we already have one in place we have an executive director of adult and career so we have all these people in place and so that's why I was a little bit confused on why we actually need another associate superintendant because if you listen to what the people out in the communities have always spoke about how we were always so topad heavy and so I just want to make sure that we're having this conversation because we're the ones who are again responsible for these job descriptions and then once we approve these they will be put out and possibly what I've noticed lately it's the minimum requirement not the maximum requirement and it's a 5-day turnaround and it's done so I

051just want to make sure that I'm bringing that to light and I was just told that yes that money is there in the budget which I'm not sure where it's at I would love to see that as well if I may through the chair first of all Mrs Jordan thank you very much for your questions and I'd be happy to have a more extensive conversation with you offline what I will share with you is when I uhing tour and as a campaign and I will share with you that one of the very top priorities of this Community is to ensure that we have more support particularly around the trades I'm sure you've heard that in the community as well our community is very loud and proud about the extreme need for children to come out

052of school and to be ready to enter those jobs we have an extreme number of folks that have retired in those areas and I know that multiple people approached me about having resources available to give to our district in those areas particularly supporting the trades internships externships other resources if we were doing a great job in this area with all due respect we would have been meeting those needs and I would not have encountered so many groups on the campaign trail that would have said Dr Carlin you're the first person that's come to talk to us about this so we do have a need for leadership in this area we have a need for resources in this area I will share with you that is my understanding that the prior superintendent saved us about $3

053million in a reorganization and yes we are going to have to spend some money to be able to get the things that our children need but please rest assured that the next process that I have going on with our cabinet right now is to look line by line through each budget line and to discover those must do and those NE those nice todos the nice todos are going to be going by the wayside in this district and we are going to put resources behind the things that this community cares about and one of the things they care about are the future of our children and I know we all do as well we want our children well prepared and when we don't have enough resources behind this work that's why I'm bringing this forward today

054so thank you for the opportunity M Jordan and I thank you for your comments however I and I know that I'm out there and I'm sure when everybody else is out there we're speaking about the acmy and we're constantly talking about our high schools how great they are even our middle schools how they're starting to get the kids ready for when they go to high school with ourmes because we have great acms but I think also too we have a great resource in our communication Department which we they're obviously winning some awards this evening and with that we need to tell our stories better we need to be out there making sure that we're able to disseminate that information and speak on what we have in our district and then so I don't know if

055we need that another person to do that or if all the principles of these schools and our communication Department that we already have invested in making sure that our kids are great if if we don't encourage them to be our spokespersons for our emies yeah and so if I may just one additional piece of information and I wholeheartedly agree and you and I have had those conversations offline I think actually all of our board members have talked about the importance of telling our story better this position is not about telling our story better this position is about getting out into the Community garnering Resources M making contacts with business community members and making sure that when the community has resources for our children that we have somebody out there that's actively seeking those not to

056say you we don't have grms we have wonderful career acmy at our schools wonderful not enough people know about those and also there are resources that are untapped so my anticipation for this job is for this person to be out in the community 90% of their job will be being out in the community garnering resources from people that I personally encountered that want to give resources to us we have not come to them and so that's this person's job so thank you for that comment Mr persons I'd like the superintendent anticipate this person bringing in much more resources than the salary that we're paying them and to me that's definitely a win-win situation you know so it's got not just going to be cost neutral it's going to be cost positive for us so I'm

057all for that also would like to say that this is all sort of new to us having an elected superintendent but we have to give her room to organize the district as she sees fit because we're going to throw under the bus if if it doesn't work but but seriously it is her job to do the operations we have to look at the job descriptions and things but I think it's been explained pretty well that's all then we got to move on so Mr Ribble yeah I just want to comment with I have a lot of experience with my former business 35 years in business this is a key this is a key position which we talked about in our 101s I totally went over this job description and I think it's the really the

058key to making this happen with the business Community we have a big gap between the school district and the business community and many there's many folks out there would hire and actually pay these students interns and give them a monthly salary for helping them build their business while they build their skills before they graduate so I totally support this function I think I don't even think you could put a price tag on the return you're going to get on this so I'm all for it Miss Jordan then miss juven then we really got to move on I just wanted to make a real quick comment thank you Mr persons I understand that we have a an elected superintendent however it is our job as board members and I just want to make sure that I'm

059doing my job and asking the right questions to because we are responsible for the budget we are responsible for the job descriptions as board members that is our constitutional duties to do that and that's the only reason I bring up questions thank you thank you my question actually is regarding some the transportation jobs who will the supervisor stock room of supervisory supervisor report to and who will the coordinator report to the supervisor will report to the executive director of Transportation okay the coordinator will report also to the executive director director thank you I do support these positions as well I think that what we were doing has not been enough and I think this will help with making that the especially the what's the superintendent the associate superintendent I don't know that Dr Carlin can

060be out there enough to Garner the needs and we have so Lee County is has unique opportunity and business opportunities are not the same in every other district and therefore I think the need is there is needed for someone to Garner these Career Technical positions that are needed in for just our in our for our community not for the State of Florida just for our community and I think that's what the focus will be on so I'm kind of excited to see what this person will do and who that person will be because I think that it's going to take a certain kind of person yes and a person that can really get out there and hit the ground running to achieve the needs and meet our needs for the community that's really I think

061the end game is that to meet the needs and we're not doing that as a district so I'm excited to see how that goes thank you anyone else before we move on okay thank you Chief mon thank you moving on to item number four which will be Elementary and second secondary school emergency relief also known as Esser Madam superintendent if there's anything you want to add before we begin thank you for the opportunity to talk about Esser fun today and provide you with some updates and I'll turn it over to our team at this time allow them to introduce themselves I do have one piece of information that was just brought to me coordinator of Transportation will be at the South compound so that was a question that was asked thank you good afternoon School

062Board superintendent Dr Carlin and attorney depri Bruno I am Lita DEET Smith joined by Matthew aosta we are both assistant directors I work in the Grants Department and Matt works for us over in the budget Department our presentation today is focused on an overview of Esser how these Grant funds came about to our school district some ways in which the funds were expended the completion of the Grant and how Esser will impact our work moving forward this time timeline while may seem confusing what's important to know is that we started receiving Esser funds in March of 2020 20 and the orange arrow shows you that we are all the way over in December all of our Esser funds had to be incurred by September 30th 2024 and then we are given a little bit of

063flexibility in order to liquidate funds and request reimbursement through the dep Florida Department of Education so to provide you a little bit of history on Esser Esser stands for the elementary and secondary school emergency relief funds these are federal stimulus funds that were provided by the US Department of Education through three acts and to the Florida Department of Education the Florida Department of Education then provided our districts with the stimulus money given certain allocations to Target specific initiatives on this slide you see the names of the different allocations that fell under each Act totaling over $300 million so Esser is the largest most popular portion of this funding and on the next slide you see it broken into three three parts this slide represents the specific initiatives that were funded with use of Esser funds

064and it's important to remind you and the community that when we received Sr one this was during unprecedented times where we had to work swiftly in order to ensure that online learning could continue and student engagement was still occurring even when students were at home so as we had the opportunity to move through Esser 1 2 and 3 we were able to make more informed decisions about the needs of our district and how to better allocate These funds to impact student achievement through our collaborative e efforts Esser 1 ended in September 2022 Esser 2 ended in September 2023 and Esser 3 just concluded in September 2024 I can happily report that since the creation of the slide deck we can update the community that 100% of all of these funds have been expended and every

065single dollar was utilized with $0 being sent back to the Florida Department of Education all of these grants totaled like I said almost $300 million so why many of us are thankful to put Esther in the past and behind us we would be remiss not to thank those hardworking individuals that may or may not be in this room today Esser provided our district with the most significant amount of federal stimulus money that we have ever received and it was no small feat to make decisions regarding the allocation of this funding every Department and Division in this District was represented through the process of expending these funds our academic Services Department assisted in making decisions hot coco can we can we have that audio turned off please sorry about that please continue no my apologies our

066academic Sur Services Department assisted in making decisions regarding curriculum and tutoring programs that directly impacted student achievement our HR department assisted in the hiring retention and transition of Esser funded employees our business services department supported Esser through procurement processes related to Federal grant guidelines providing budgets to schools and departments that receive monitoring of spending and reimbursement to our local Charter Schools operations Department assisted in the initial distribution of PPE and assisted schools preparing for students to return face Toof face as well as compliance efforts related to the Davis bacon act our business intelligence Department assisted in monitoring and tracking student data providing data used to calculate return on investment and the assurance that all students had access to home internet on this slide you see a listing of our top 10 expenditures that were spent

067with use of Esser funds again these totaled over $300 million with the largest expense being focused on stabilization pay it is important to note that our Charter Schools also received a very large allocation of these funds and they receive funding based on their proportionate share and students that attend their schools after looking at our top 10 expenditures we would like to dive into some specific data related to the projects and impact you've all been provided a data sheet which I will briefly look at a couple of items with you which is important to celebrate 260 of 276 employees that were funded through Esser have been transferred into District funded positions last summer we were able to provide funding for our summer series which gave 883 teacher participants the opportunity to attend over 160 professional development

068sessions over 4 days of those teachers that participated 89% of them agreed or strongly agreed that provided them a meaningful opportunity to learn and grow as professionals Esser was also able to provide two years or an additional year to our new teachers a second year of mentoring of those that receiv received those mentoring 93% of them were retained in the school district 48 of our school scho in the district receed level one high reliability School certification which was funded out of Esser 20 of those 48 schools improved by three or more percentage points on their school grades six schools in our school district were able to achieve level two high reliability School certification moving into curriculum Esser was able to prepay for several online subscriptions for this school year in order to enhance student achievement

069we were also able to purchase instructional materials for approximately $14 million we're also going to continue to take a deeper dive into return on investment our back on track program which was tutoring provided to our high school students spent approximately $950,000 over two years with 1,700 students participating and almost 1,300 credits recovered it is important to note on the bottom of this data sheet that I wrote as of 930 that charter schools had expended all but $1 million again it's important to note that all funds have been expended related to Esser and 0ar were returned to the Florida Department of Education next I would like to talk to you a little bit about Glimpse Glimpse is a vendor that we have partnered with which you will continue to hear more about and their role is

070to calculate and provide specific data related to return on investment so we started this project with the use of Esser funds because it was important for us to make well-informed decisions about moving forward even after these dollars were gone so on this slide you see a sampling of one of our supplemental education products used to support reading in the 2324 school year for 3rd to eighth graders of the 177,000 students who use this program with Fidelity according to the vendor students showed an average growth of 5.82% on fast from pm1 to pm3 and while it looks like everyone users partial users and non-users grew when you look a little bit more deeply you see that those students who used the program to the recommended usage almost doubled the growth of non-users this data again is

071one small sampling of the work that we're doing with glimps and provides key insights to make us allow us to make decisions about our financial responsibility regarding the number of licenses we're purchasing the impact our professional development is making on student achievement and support for our Educators to improve Fidelity of our products again because we were able to prepay for many of these subscriptions this school year we will continue our study of return on investment and have we will we have continued to start looking into other programs with other Federal grant money so as mentioned Esser was given to school districts during unprecedented times where we had to make decisions very quickly with large sums of money while we did many things well we also had great learning opportunities and helped us improve systems and

072processes moving forward related to not only Grant dollars but dollars as a whole to begin some of the improvements we are making is in the human resources department solidifying processes related to Grant funded positions notification to those employees and ensuring that those employees feel valued when they're working in those Grant funded positions the Grants Department is developing specific criteria and procedures for departments that are requesting Grant funds these requests will be tied directly to the Strategic plan they will be vetted and approved based on specific criteria we will also continue to seek and secure alternative funding through local partners ships and competitive grant opportunities and future initiatives that are determined to be eligible for grant funding will be strategically planned with an evaluation of impact lastly we continue to be committed to deepening our analysis

073of return on investment for vendor products and how it directly relates to student achievement and because everyone wants to know there's lots of auditing and reporting that goes alongside Federal grant dollars so we have been audited and provided several reports related to this money we continue to ensure compliance of District state and federal processes we ensure Inventory management and tracking to date there have been no audit findings related to our Esser funds most of our reporting was completed at the end of the grant which was September 2024 and we do have some flexibility to liquidate those funds and request reimbursement we do anticipate and additional auditing for these funds and recently asked for documentation related to the Davis bacon act so in conclusion Matt and I will continue to work together to make sure that

074all the final reporting is given to the Florida Department of Education at Grant end we will continue our partnership with Glimpse to study the return on investment of the vendor products that we are purchasing with the district and we will continue to seek alternative funding methods for initiatives that have proven to have a strong impact on students achievement at this time we welcome comments and questions well thank you very much to the team for your presentation Esser is very complex we saw that there are multiple tiers certainly we are very appreciative of the support that we had financially relative to when the pandemic first commenced I remember being in the superintendent's office and listening to the governor announced that we were going to be closing schools and I went oh my goodness what's this going

075to look like for our elementary students so we're very fortunate in Florida to get back online get children back in school as soon as possible so that was really great and Esser funds have helped us do that as well so we look forward to the board's comments and questions thank you madam superintendent board member comments and questions okay Miss Jordan thank you for the presentation I really appreciate it and I noticed there was a brief description of Glimpse in there and I know for probably about a year and a half I've been asking for a presentation on that because the application when we purchased this was to look at all the work that we're doing and to see is it working or is it not working and if it was not working then we would

076discontinue that and use the funds elsewhere we've yet to see that come before us but I did I appreciate the fact that you threw it in there for like a half a second but that's something that I don't we're not sure if it is working or you know we've paid for that program and or the application and how is that how is that working for us and the programs to let us know if in fact they are worth paying for or not if I may yes so thank you if this has been a wish of the board and we haven't fulfilled that I just made a note on that so we'll we'll we'll make sure that happens anything else Miss Jordan no thank you okay any other comments and questions okay thank you both for

077your presentation we appreciate it moving on to item number five which will be District investment returns and investment strategies with Dr desamor Miss Jensen and Mr Grady for Mike Miss Jensen please thank you couldn't tell if I was echoing to myself good afternoon superintendent Carlin board members and colleagues I'm Danielle Jensen director of financial services today we have a presentation by public trust advisors who has been the district's financial adviser since 2015 they were founded in 2011 public trust advisor specializes in managing and servicing the investment needs of local governments Nationwide public trust has more than 80 9 billion in assets under management as of September 30 2024 and more than 12 billion in the State of Florida the district team is led by John Grady the managing director and partner of the investment advisory

078services division John has more than 25 years of government investment management and Public Finance experience servicing as an investment adviser for fixed income assets for numerous public entities across the United States we are very proud to have them present our fy4 for fiscal fiscal 24 investment report and provide a current economic update thank you Miss Jensen Mr chair board members superintendent thank you for the opportunity to be here today I'm joined here by my colleague Rod batini and it's good to be be here happy holidays and we've got some interesting things going on in our economy as you know but one of the things that I'll highlight today is that these higher interest rates that we've experienced over the last couple of years have resulted in some considerable increases in your interest earnings so when

079you're thinking of budgeting and so forth there's been a huge benefit of that of these higher rates versus what we saw just a couple of years ago so you're doing the economic up is okay we do that yeah thank you sorry Danel no worries thank you my bad and as I present the format of the presentation is just to spend a few minutes on the economic update and then follow up with a review of your overall investment program but please as I'm I'm talking through my points if you have thoughts questions during my presentation please jump in or we can wait until the end but what generally what we like to do is just highlight a few of those larger macroeconomic discussion points that you likely hear and read a lot about and the first

080one of course is gross domestic product or the growth of our economy and the most recent reading of course was for the third quarter of 20124 into September 30th GDP growth was 2.8% it's actually a pleasant surprise expectations for growth during the third quarter were much lower and that follows a 3% growth in the second quarter and if we look back over 2024 the good news is economic growth has actually been much better than what economists had projected at the beginning of this year and interestingly very similar story happened to 2023 so you likely remember reading a lot about an upcoming recession like strong likelihood of a recession going back to far 2023 and even into 2024 that doesn't mean that's off the table completely but the good news is as an economy we've continued

081to grow I would say that the consumer who makes up more than three4 of the economy of course us as we go out and spend we've been resilient is probably the best word to use now that said we've taken on a lot of debt as consumers over this time frame as well as the federal government as as we all know so debt continues to be something in the in the background so to speak that does cause some concern for future growth but that said through the third quarter and likely into the fourth quarter of 20124 we'll hopefully see another quarter of Positive Growth in the economy and again most of that growth in recent quarters has been led by the consumers which is very normal the other bigger component of GDP of course is business

082Investments that was a little low or light in that third quarter but in recent quarters businesses have continued to invest in our economy as as well and when you see that generally suggests that businesses expect consumers to go out and buy their products and services and so they invest heavily in that area another big topic of course is inflation right we know that we read about that all the time and if we rewind back to the summer of 2022 where inflation was up year-over-year over 9% was the highest inflation rate that we've experienced in four decades the good news is inflation has come down dramatically over the last two years so that's good news that said we still have inflation prices are still increasing they're not decreasing because inflation's coming down they're just increasing at

083a lesser amount and so when we think about GDP growth on that prior slide and the ability of us as consumers to spend inflation continues to be a very difficult discussion point and a lot of that in fact if we look at CPI and the components of CPI over the last several months and I would argue 18 plus months shelter costs have been the biggest part of inflation and if anyone can feel it's Florida and arguably Southwest Florida this is one of the hottest areas for Price home price growth as as you know and so that's been the challenge so is the Fed as we'll talk about with interest rates as the FED raised interest rates to try to slow down that inflation they can't really impact house prices as much as they can really

084other components of the economy so that's been a really Big Challenge of the Federal Reserve but again the good news is that we have seen that rate come down that the Blue Line is overall inflation as you can see at 2.6% in October overall inflation which includes food and energy at 3.3% but really trying to get the fed's hope is that rate will will Trend closer to that 2% Target that they've had and so we will see as we move forward I think again as as shelter continues to be the dominant that might be the challenge of getting that closer to that 2% but good news is we're in a much better spot than we were certainly in 2022 and 2023 and what drives our economy of course as consumers spend we need jobs we

085need to be employed to to spend and that is the other side of this so the fed's two primary goals are stable monetary policy and full employment and stable monetary policy of course governed by inflation and hoping keeping that low the other is helping the economy to have full employment if we look at the chart on the top right that's really just monthly job growth that you hear about each month when that's released on the first Friday of each month it's a little skewed when we look at this chart because this includes those those months right after the pandemic had set in in 20 and then the recovery of those 22 million jobs into 2021 so you can see on that left-and side of that chart job growth on a monthly basis somewhat volatile but

086some months reaching 7 800,000 jobs a month that was more of a recovery time rather than normal job growth I would argue that historically job growth is generally considered good job growth is anywhere from 150 to call it 250,000 jobs per month and so that is likely what we'll start to see from this as these sort of pandemic and covid periods roll off of these charts the last job report was 12,000 obviously that's not a great jobs report the one month prior to that was 223,000 which was good but we had three hurricanes and so that likely had a huge impact on job growth in that October figure so I think as we look at November and December and then as we get through the holiday season in 2025 of course we'll see how the

087economy is playing out from a jobs perspective most believe that the job sector is cooling down from what we've seen if you recall back 12 to 15 months ago it was certainly much more in favor of the employee rather than employer we work with all public entities and I can tell you the number of conversations we've had had with with our clients and that's been in the public sector in particular has been very challenging to fill jobs especially in finance accounting and so forth but arguably across the board so the job markets does seem to be cooling off that said unemployment Still Remains very low from a historical perspective the job the unemployment rate on the bottom chart 4.1% through October it's slightly higher than that 3.6% that we experienced a little over a year

088ago but if we think about relativity overall full employment has generally been considered 5% or less and so when we see unemployment going from 3.6 to 4.1 it was as high as 4.3 there was a bit of concern that inflation was pardon me that unemployment was moving up faster than anticipated or expected but it sort of settled in just over 4% and many believe that's again a still strong unemployment rate and that the job market is still moving along at a fairly decent pace so these next few slides we'll just talk about interest rates for a few minutes and then we'll tie that into your investment program but just to summarize this GDP growth stronger than expected inflation good news is coming down job market seems to be cooling off but with the exception of

089this last month we still seen some decent job growth on a month-to-month basis thank you Daniel just quickly on this is there's a lot of information this is the Federal Open Market committee's Dot Plot the FED meets every 12 weeks or so and then every three I'm pardon me every 6 weeks and every quarter they update their Dot Plot which is essentially their expectation of where the overnight rate is anticipated to be and just as a reminder the fomc or Federal Open Market Committee they set that rate with each meeting based on a vote that rate was as high as 55% through September and that was the highest level we had that rate for a little over a year it was the highest rate since 2002 so over 20 years the to reach that highest

090rate again that will as you'll see in a moment ties into the very significant interest income that you experience in 2023 which was a great thing now as we look to where we are they've reduced that rate now by 75% through two meetings they're expected to potentially reduce that rate here next week by another quarter of a percent which would ring that rate down to 4 and a half per. when we think about going from 5 1/2 to 42% of course that's going to have not a it will have negative impact on your interest earnings but if we think about the overnight rate even at 4 and a half% to give us some perspective between 2008 and 2015 that rate was 0 to 25 basis points and then it was also 0 to 25 basis

091points between 2020 and 2022 so for the last out of the last 16 years or so nine years that short-term overnight rate has been close to zero so experiencing that rate moving up to 5 a half% has been very beneficial and the hope is and this is what you hear a lot about Market economists talking about is that instead of going into a recession this soft Landing if that were to occur or even a light recession that hopefully the FED wouldn't have to bring that rate down to zero or close to that as they've done through the housing crisis and credit crisis and then in the pandemic more recently so hopefully the FED has been able to manage this we'll see how that plays out by the way just for some historical context the last

092over the last 50 years when the FED has gone into to their tightening cycle or raate increased the interest rates there have been three times that the Fed was able to avoid a recession and all three times that was the main result of that was due to a decent job market or strong strong job market and so we're hopeful that this recent job market that we've had even with a cooling off can hopefully help us Stave off a recation a re a recession at least for the near term so that's a little bit of the overnight rate but that's important because it does tie into your liquidity funds which make up a majority of your overall Investments a lot of data on this chart I'll just make one comment if we look down that column

093on the leftand side in those yellow numbers those are projections of the overnight rate moves and what what the market is anticipating is potentially 3/4s to maybe 1% rate cut between now and the end of calendar year 25 so that could potentially mean an overnight rate that would be between 3 and a half to 3.75% if that were to take place this is highly unreliable but it does give us an idea of what the Market's expecting at any particular time this is actually from November 18th if you looked at this chart this morning it's very similar so the expectations again of maybe one to three rate Cuts here in the near term and then seeing how the economy reacts to those lower interest rates we'll skip I'll skip number eight since we've talked a bit

094about that and just going to to size 9 and 10 and looking at our yield curve when we think about your investment program and public investment public entity investment programs in general very very high quality safety first so when we're looking at a yield curve we're showing you treasuries and the reason for that is you're invested only in fixed income securities this gives us a good idea of what those rates might be and so we're showing two lines The Gray Line is from April 15th which is generally thought of as as the most recent peak of this current interest rate cycle and you can see overnight rates on the leand side at months out to 5 years so anywhere from 4.6 to above 5% in in April we've seen rates come down we saw rates

095come down considerably through September but we've actually seen rates move back up since September so that's been a good thing for more recent Investments but the ideas that we want to illustrate today from this is that we're still seeing interest rates that are above 4% and that's a good thing we'll talk about your liquidity strategy and then your longer term strategy and the benefit when it comes to investing public funds the other thing I want to make to sure to mention is that it's never to try to time the market it is to make investment decisions based on your cash low needs your risk tolerances and so forth with a primary objective of safety of principle but with that we want to help design an investment program that protects you in a rising interest rate

096environment as well that is one that helps you to protect some of your Investments when interest rates come down and lastly on the interest rates just to highlight the amount of volatility we've seen really over the last almost two years going back to January of 2023 we've seen rates move up and down as these as these economic indicators have have come out and again a lot of those results or responses to economic indicators were jobs reports and CPI and that's why we wanted to talk about those a little bit with you when whenever there're stronger than expected jobs report stronger than expected CPI we tend to see rates move up as the markets believe that you need higher rates of turn to offset those inflationary factors and the reverse is true and we see rates

097coming back down that's an expectation that the economy is going to slow down so really just showing you the level of volatility really 100 basis point moves in these interest rates from quarter to quarter and again to reiterate the goal is not to try to capture rates at any particular time but to be disciplined with your investment program and to ensure you have safety first and then have the liquidity to meet your short medium and long-term obligations so that's a those are some talking points on the economy I didn't want to rush through that I want to be respectful of your time but let me pause and any thoughts or questions from the board that I might address from the economic side board members do you have any questions okay continue on sir thank you

098thank you D so just to spend a few moments on your investment program and can how that ties out to the economy you have a very diverse investment program we work very closely with Dr desor Miss Jensen Miss ingersol and that we believe is hugely important because in order for us to make investment recommendations to the district to ensure you have the liquidity you need but also to be able to invest out and lock in some interest rates for some of your longer-term assets that conversation that dialogue is important to help us make those recommendations and so as your investment adviser and in addition to providing advice just to give you a little more perspective of our role and in those strategy recommendations it's providing some reporting for month quarter and fiscal year end we

099have a portfolio management team of course that supports this relationship that makes those investment decisions as rod and I have these conversations and work with them anytime you're invested outside of a treasury note it's our belief that you should have individuals that are reviewing those issues so if you're buying a Amazon Bond or a Toyota Bond just because it has a rating that's approved or a maturity that's approved we believe it's important that those Securities be reviewed by an indep dependent credit research team so we bring that to the table as well for the district for those Investments outside of treasuries and then of course we have operations in accounting and probably most important is compliance so know that every transaction that's conducted on your behalf for the district and even for those Investments that

100we don't manage we help provide advice on we want to make sure that those investment strategies are compliant with both Florida State Statute as well as your investment policy statement so this first slide just to give you a good summary on the le- hand side just shows you that pie chart of how you're allocated there you can see all of these larger percentages are actually your liquidity funds these are local government investment pools they're AAA rated and you can think of those as a money market fund strategy where you have daily access to those funds you send a note in request those funds and they're sent back to your bank on a daily basis the benefit of this strategy the fact that you have over 90% in this particular investment program has been the increase

101rates as I mentioned in 22 from 0 to 55% and that has been a huge benefit and in fact for your fiscal year ended 24 those assets earned a little over 58 million in interest just to give us some perspective in 2022 that amount would have been 2.9 Million and so that just to gives you an idea of how much of an impact these interest rates have had so hopefully they don't come down too far and if they can level off that should still provide decent interest earnings well Diversified again Within These multiple pools again AAA rated but that's the reason why you see a majority of your investment income from that from the your liquidity investment program as well and then the balance of around 8% or so is in the longer term portfolios

102which we'll talk about here in a moment one more slide on your liquidity portfolio as a make up a majority of your assets you can see on the leand side where we're just showing you the balances and then in addition to the balance you see those percentages those are the yields on each of these local government investment pools the two smaller ones and much lower rates you can see truest in money market fund those are By Design just generally provide a much smaller yield to maturity in any interest rate environment you can see you don't keep very many Assets in there those are generally assets moved to those two components when you're getting ready to spend those and then the others are maintain in SBA Florida Class Florida fit and Florida palm and the average

103of those pool programs by the way for last fol year was close to 5% 4.89% the last two slides that we'll cover discuss a 1 to threeyear portfolio strategy and a 1 to fiveyear portfolio strategy so these are the two investment portfolios that public trust is your investment manager that we manage on your behalf we again provide advice on the entire program the idea of the 1:3 and the 1 to5 again is to help diversify your investment program as well as protect you through a declining interest rate environment so where your liquidity funds have benefited from a rising interest rate when rates start to come down those liquidity funds actually reset on a daily basis so if we see rates come down rather quickly those liquidity funds will feel that impact literally on a daily

104basis whereas your 1 to three and 1 to five portfolios have an average maturity of 1.8 years and two and a half years respectively and the idea is as we invest a small portion of your portfolio out anywhere from 1 to three and 1 to 5 years you're locking in the those current interest rates and providing some protection so if rates come down you're still going to earn those four four and a half 5% yields for you know anywhere from 1 to 5 years depending on the time to maturity for those Investments these two portfolios are equally balanced between again each each of these portfolios and then the majority of the assets again in the liquidity program so you can see if we look at the asset allocation on the top right you can see

105a majority of these funds and both of these programs are in US treas IES that's by design a small allocation to government sponsored Enterprises those are simply Fanny May Freddy Mac Home Loan Bank so they're not full faith in credit of the US government but they are government agencies and they generally trade right around the same yield as treasuries and so as the markets have changed we've generally favored treasuries over those GSS but there is a small allocation and then smaller allocation to municipal bonds and then as I mentioned corporate notes as an example as well you're invested in a or better corporate bonds again each issue in your portfolio and all of our public trust manag portfolios are reviewed prior to being approved and authorized for portfolio management to buy those Securities so we

106have pre-trade compliance means which means that before the portfolio manager can buy a security it has to meet your investment policy parameters that's then verified post trade and then we provide compliance of those transactions and your Holdings on a monthly basis as well and then finally working with the district providing information for your yearend financial report to show gasby related requirements we provide those as well just to verify that again everything is compliant with your investment program lastly 1: five so similar to the 1 to threee investment program similar and holding similar similar in asset allocation the primary difference of course being the maturity so this portfolio is designed to have Securities that mature between 1 and 5 years so this duration or average maturity is slightly longer than the 1:3 the idea that it

107will protect from a downturn in rates for a little bit longer than a 1 to5 U pardon me than a 1: three the other good news about the current rate scenario that we've seen even though we've seen that volatility we show we've shown on that chart the fact that rates have actually stayed higher than I think many would have expected certainly 18 months ago and stayed within that three and a half to almost 5% range that's allowed us to continue to reinvest as we have maturities Within These portfolios at these higher levels and protect by locking in some of those higher yields than we saw just a few years ago know that's a lot of information let me let me just you summarize some of those that it's important for us to work closely with

108the team here at the district to ensure that you have the program that meet your liquidity needs and invested in very high quality Securities that it's Diversified and as I mentioned but it's important to to summarize it compliant with your policy statement that we review annually with your team as well as with State Statute and that's State chap state statute 28415 that governs public funds entities so with that let me pause and ask the board superintendent if you have any questions on your investment program overall or our role with you all yeah I just again just thank you to Mr Grady Miss Jensen for providing us with this important update about our investments as we talk about being fiscally responsible this fits right in line with that priority and so turn it over to chair

109fiser and our team thank you board members comments questions I see Mr Ribble with his hand yeah I want to thank you for an excellent presentation I was overwhelmed with the $ 58.2 million return on that portfolio that number really jumps out at you so congratulations well done thank you and congratulations to the district it's exciting it's tougher to be in this role when it's 3 million a year and we can't take credit for all of it but we what we do enjoy is the relationship we have to help put this program in place to help you to hopefully enhance those earnings thank you Mr R and board member comments or questions Mr person just trying to figure out I mean I like all of us we're a little worried about the interest rates coming

110down right do we have the right allocation in your opinion as far as between the one and three and one and five or should we have even a little bit more in there that's a great question we are actually having that dialogue with your team as we speak so you're you're heavier in those liquidity funds A lot of that has to do though with capital project expenditures and those cash flow needs but in our recent dialogue there may be an opportunity we like the we like and recommend a balance between the 1: three and 1: five so what is the appropriate amount in those there may be an opportunity to move some of those assets into the 1: three and 1 to five and protect a little bit more but what we're doing right now

111is just making sure that we have your liquidity needs met first that is of course the primary goal and then looking to maybe allocate so to answer your question I think there is an opportunity we just want to make sure your cash flow needs are met first well I tell you what to do except that would be a big mistake but yeah thank you for looking into that thank you Mr person thank you Mr persons anyone else Mr Grady thank you for the enlightening presentation I'll actually bring up to the board real quick I was going to bring it up later on probably the perfect time one of our portfolio Investments is Florida palm and just so you're all aware I was appointed to the Board of Trustees to that recently so if you have

112any questions feel free to let me know so thank you Mr gr thank you Miss Jensen I appreciate you both congratulations on that appointment Mr fiser or chair fiser that'll be give you some great experience on the liquidity of for public funds thank you for the partnership with the district happy holidays Merry Christmas and great to be here today appreciate it thank you moving on to item number six which will be insulin let ation presentation with our attorneys thank you thank you Mr chairman good afternoon board members and Madam superintendent as legal counsel I recommend that the school board participate in a multi-district litigation and retain Ferraro Law Firm to pursue claims for damages associated with an overpayment of insulin products under the school district's self-funded health insurance plan due to price fixing between pharmaceutical

113manufacturers and Pharmacy benefits managers joining us today is attorney Natalia Salis who is a partner at the Ferrera Law Firm attorney Salis focuses her practice on Commercial Business disputes class actions and multi-district litigation attorney James Ferrara was planning on joining us but was called away and thus unable to attend Benny broy our legal services coordinator will assist Miss Salis in her presentation it is important for the board and superintendent to note that attorney Salis was appointed to the plaintiff's EX executive committee of the insulin pricing litigation mdl number 380 before The Honorable Brian martinotti seated in New Jersey retainer agreement is on the agenda for your consideration this evening and at this point I will hand it over to attorney Salis to explain the litigation in detail thank you very much good afternoon I'm happy

114to be here and most importantly I'm happy to help the district recover funds that it has overpaid for insulin products over the course of the last 20 or so years you know I've I've been hearing the meeting and I understand as a parent to to two children who are in the school system down in Miami dat County how important it is to have to have money in the door that goes back to servicing these students and so here this case is really about overp payments by self-funded payers so as you may know I'm I'm sure you likely know the district as you know the ninth largest in in Florida has a significant room to recover funds in this case because it provides health insurance for all of those employees as well as for members of

115their family and what this case is about really is the difference between what in our view should have been paid for insulin and these products and what was actually paid and so I'll start with that I'm going to I'm going to go through kind of a little bit of background about myself my firm the case but I will say just at the outset that this is this is an opportunity to join in the litigation that could potentially bring in significant dollars to the district we have causes of action that allow for what we call treble damages that means three times the amount of the damages and we've pulled data initially before presenting so we do know that there all the check marks of being a self-funded payer of Contracting with one of the relevant Pharmacy

116benefit managers that are at issue in this case CVS care Mark has that check mark has has been met and we have seen the spend on in and the analog products and it is significant here so I just I would like to start with that just as far as background I'm a partner at the Ferraro Law Firm it's a Florida based firm we're about to celebrate our 40th year and we are a contingency firm meaning that we do all the work and front all the costs and we are not paid a dollar and no one here is paying us a dollar unless there is a victory what we have been negotiating and what we've done with other districts and other government entities in this case is a 25% contingency fee we are we are fully

117committed to this case we as as was mentioned earlier I'm on the executive committee meaning that I'm on the leadership of the case so these are cases that are filed all over the country they're then Consolidated un sent over because there's common issues of fact and law to one judge and that judge is in sitting in New Jersey so it's important kind of at the outset to to say that you know hiring someone who's on the inside of the leadership is really important because you're going to have as the client an inside track and knowledge that others may or may not have because this is not a class action there's there was a consumer class so others consumers of products have brought a class action case in our case as self-funded payers representing self-funded payers

118government entities who provide health insurance private companies unions we are not a class action we don't believe it's appropriate for class treatment which really is beneficial to the district as a client why because each case is going to be treated separately so we're going to have Belle weathers which is a fancy way of saying there's a few that are selected to go first we've already started in that process we're now in disc in the discovery phase of the case and I will jump ahead just to kind of give you some background and I really I think what the best way to this slide I really think kind of speaks volumes because we were talking about inflation and this is not about inflation it's not an inflationary tale this is really about a lack of transparency

119and frankly greed I have seen the documents firsthand and there has been absolutely a lack of transparency between the payers of these products and the middlemen which are the pharmacy benefit managers who then negotiate with the manufacturers we see Shadow pricing where they're increasing the prices in loog step and it just defies logic because this is a product that's been around for 100 years and it makes no sense that it is now increased by a th% over the past 20 years now this has all been revealed recently by a senate bipartisan Senate finance committee report that was released in 2021 and most recently by the FTC which not only released a scathing staff report but then decided to bring a lawsuit as well so I am confident that there's a case here and I'm confident

120that we can be the ones to to represent the district in bringing that case time is really of the essence here because as I mentioned that staff report was released in January of 2021 there's a risk that the judge will rule that's the period in which people should have have known that they could have been damaged and the statute of limitations for certain claims potentially could run as soon as January of 2025 for certain claims so we are the reason why my partner James Ferraro is not here is because he is presenting to boka I'm next presenting to Highlands County where I presented to Port St lcy yesterday Broward on Friday so it is a kind of a mad rush right to to get get all these cases on file we do have I've been

121like intimately involved in the process of drafting the complaints they're voluminous but we have the groundwork now to gather the data which we've already started to do and get them on file to avoid any risk on the Statue limitations issue I'm going to jump through here's just if I think it's really interesting and helpful he the link relating to the different insulin investigations the shadow pricing scheme and the status of the mdl I do want to touch on kind of who's who's involved in this case so far so here we have approximately 50 government entities that have filed thus far in the mdl including 14 States this is a bipartisan issue in fact the majority of the states that have filed thus far what you would consider typically conservative states which not it's not it's

122a little bit unusual be but in this case it's it's really a of public interest to people to become involved as far as the Florida school boards you have Broward County and Miami day that have voted to retain Council so far and we are personally presenting to to Highlands County and to Palm Beach County as well the the landscape of who has filed thus far in Florida is not fully transparent yet because some people have retained Council but not yet filed in the mdl I want to say about 15 or so Florida government entities have now voted to retain Council but I think that there's going to be a huge wave just seeing what I'm doing in the between now and next week about 10 presentations I think you're going to see a big wave

123on that front and this I think is what is going to be kind of the most important thing I would I would think to the board which is what are what are we potentially going to get here right so we have an expert who has ained and given us a very conservative damages model it's an antitrust model and so like as I mentioned before it's the dividend between what what the product should have cost and what we paid for the product and that model on average is about $5,000 per user per year which is significant if you think about it so I think I mentioned Lee County may have approximately 12,000 employees and this is not even including their additional beneficiaries so if you take that number approximately 10% of those individuals just based on

124the averages that we see in in the country maybe diabetic so that's the national average average so if you're just looking at that number in one year you're looking at $600,000 in one year and this is dating back to 2001 so the judge has already ruled that we can gather documents from 2001 to date I think in our case you know in some cases you can't get documents that far back but it is a significant amount of of time to recover and as I mentioned we have recal claims and other claims that are outside of the contract involving conduct that should be penalized so we call punitive damages so there is a larger window for recovery than in other types of cases and I know that this is a lot of information to share I

125do I mean I'm here mostly just to answer to answer questions I feel very strongly about the case and so I'm I'm here to help and answer any questions that you may have have thank you attorney Solace attorney de Bruno is anything you want to add before I go to board questions board at this time we would love to entertain any questions that you may have thank you board member comments questions Mr persons followed by Miss lenford Fleming yeah you sold me on the one graph that showed it going up 1,000% versus inflation yeah I'm all for this being self-funded healthc care I mean that would really greatly help that fund so that's all thank you for the presentation thank you m l for Fleming my question is if you go back to that while

126we're on it slide 15 and it talks about the comparison between 4,000 and 1,000 that's significant what role is OIC playing in this when it comes to so many consumers using that for weight loss rather than what it was intended for is that playing a role at all into increase of price so it's not playing a role as far as the increase of price because when you look at the time frame for when it start for when it increased it actually predates the use of OIC for this off Lael usage that you're referring to but OIC actually does play a role in increasing the potential for damages in this case because because we're not only looking at insulin we're looking at all the analoges of insulin and OIC is there and there's been no ruling

127that says whether if you're not diabetic we can't recover for it because the price is the price so it actually is helpful because it could actually increase the potential recovery okay thank you're welcome any Miss Jordan I am definitely for this I am a diabe so I get it and I've seen that over the years so thank you I know I've heard from a lot of people that you know it's really it's it's become a huge issue recently and you know people are having to travel to other countries to get insulin product so I'm I'm I feel very passionately about about this case so I'm happy to help is that it m Jordan thank you yes anyone else I have some questions but does anyone else have any before I go thank you attorney Solace

128I ask this anytime that we have any case before us what is our legal exposure in any way if we sign up with this so you know it's a good question because sometimes there is fee shifting right you can be on the hook for attorney's fees in some causes of action so in Florida under the RICO statute there is a fee shifting exposure what we have I believe that risk is very low but what we have done with other government entities that do have a concern over that risk is what we did in in opioids which is that we have we have paid for and sought out insurance to cover the fee shifting so there is an insurance product out there that we've already done for at least one other government client that we can

129obtain where we pay a premium to cover the risk of any sort of fee shifting should that should that be an issue otherwise the risk is non-existent really because it's a it's a win-win but I do want to say in full disclosure that is a very small risk but it is a risk and we're happy to look into the we've already been in contact with one insurance company so we've placed it in the past and we can do it again agree I'd be comfortable with that risk last question just briefly because I know this could go very long can you give an idea to us of kind of the timeline on this I mean just looking at this obviously discover is going to be quite a lot so we've been we've been at this about

130a year and now we're P we're pass motions to dismiss so the pleadings like there initial pleading stages the judge has yet to rule on that I I believe that Discovery is going to take at least another year I would say the from beginning to end five years would be my estimate these cases tend to settle after the Bell weather stage we've been involved in past the water contamination cases and that's what we've seen in that case that we got a large settlement after about 3 years of being involved so I would say an average is five years thank you I just wanted to make sure everyone else understood that I appreciate that anything else before we move on from anyone okay thank you so much attorney Solace we appreciate it thank you very much

131moving on next on the agenda will be topic number seven board advisory committee discussion with our Deputy superintendent Ken Savage welcome back to the Dias Dr Savage thank you chairman the board members and our super intendent Dr Carlin and a pleasure to be here among you again today so this really is an opportunity for the board to have some additional discussion it's planned discussion that the board agreed to some time ago prior to our elections where we welcomed our new governance team and this opportunity was for the board to have some discussion around your board advisory committees so obviously the board advisory committee for those are aware there's a policy that governs your board advisories and specifically the decision was made by the prior board prior to the election to suspend current board committees so

132that the board could have a plan discussion about at what point to resume and at what point if you'd want to make any revisions to your current policy and that we were here to be able to have some discussion that said always we also gather on the staff side we work with our staff members to understand the staff Vantage Point as well and so the opportunity I've had to discuss some of this with the superintendent as well so here today to be able to have some board discussion but it's important to remind you that these are your board advisories so ultimately at the end of the day it is your discretion because you as board members you rely upon advisement for those bodies and so I think it is important that you know the final

133decision of course rest with the board we are here to serve certainly I serve as superintendent but the superintendent is still the secretary of the board and so we're we have certain recommendations that we're willing to share today to at least get the conversation started and so with chairman with that respect I'd love to offer up some of that and some context and then begin if that works for you go ahead thank you so the way one of the things that Dr Carlin mentioned when we first joined was a real commitment to trying to emulate we want to be the best in our state and really one of the best in the country in order to do that you have to be willing to study what do the highest performing systems what does the top

134level governance do in those High perform pering systems that are focused on student achievement and the highest organizational outcomes what do they do and so that's really where we come at this from is not necessarily historical precedent but a focus on results because we all want to achieve great things for our students and so that said the prior board had some contemplation even our prior superintendent prior to my interim service about what do other boards do and so one of the things that we uncovered when we did an analysis across the entire State for these many months one thing that we found was that our board in Lee County for a long period of time met six times a month which actually was the highest amount of meetings in the State of Florida obviously this

135board chose to amend that and decide as you adopted your board schedule decide to go to a number of board meetings that is consistent with some of the higher performing districts in our state because not only was the six meetings a month one of the highest was the highest in our state but is among the highest in the entire country and so the amount of meetings of course is not directly correlated to student achievement to high outcomes for students the other key factor back when Dr berer was here as well that we studied and the board the prior board was briefed on this information as well was we studied about the different board advisories and so many much of this information was shared with the prior board and what we found when we analyzed across

136our state was that among the the districts in our state there were only two districts in Florida that had the same or more amount of board advisory committees and those were Broward and Miami Dade and those are the only two districts that had an amount of that exceeded our amount of board advisories and of course you know those districts are significantly larger than us on the level of diversity and so forth and so one of the contemplations we had is how do we ensure that the district and the board is getting diverse levels of information and Broad input from a vast array of stakeholders that is truly data driven and not necessarily indicative of a small sampling of voices that are not in any way being derived from any type of larger sampling methodology that

137would ensure that what you're hearing is truly a diverse constituency but in some cases is predicated based on just those who choose to apply to to be considered for those as for those different roles and so that was something that we contemplated all that information that had been collected the second thing we contemplated was really from a staff standpoint the investment of time and energy that it takes to prepare for every single one of those board advisories the am of effort it takes on the staff side of it and then we tried to assess what were some of the outcomes of those committees that added value from a staff standpoint truly it's up to the board to contemplate the value that it created for you as board members only you would know that but from

138a staff standpoint we really tried to contemplate the amount of energy it took in delivering in some cases redundant presentations to multiple committees each with different focuses many of which had troubl making Quorum due to membership concerns some of which had all sorts of different potential issues and so forth and so as we moved forward to recommendation we again read went back to the data of what do some of the high performing districts do and what are what's what's the right balance of quantity and impact and so forth and so we came to a conclusion that the DAC committee which as you know is a district advisory committee which is very diverse and has a very unique structure afforded because it is comprised of our Sac committees each member of the DAC is a member

139of a sac and those sacks by Statute are diverse they represent a broad swath within our community and there are statutory guidelines on those sacks and how they are comprised both ethnic diversity based on the makeup as well as positional diversity you have teachers you have support staff you have parents you have business Community you have a number of folks who are already invested and and linked to one of our schools they have the opportunity to then support that school-based team with some of their critical decisions they have to make but they also have the vantage point of being able to serve in a district capacity and hence the D and the DC allows for that broad group covering our entire region so there's lots of different interests represented from the far reaches of our

140community and then that piece so the Dak represents one opportunity and Dak also has a scope of significant variance in what they can they can they can speak to they can speak to really any matter that comes before the district and they also have the precedent of being able to have form subcommittees or ad hoc committees so because of the membership of Dak and its inherent connection to Sac it affords us an opportunity that if we had specific one-off concerns that needed in-depth periods of review without we' have the ability within the Dak to to create some of those types of subcommittee types of reports and allow those current organizational needs to be fulfilled so that's daak in a nutshell that we have that and I think there's a lot of opportunity within the Dak

141structure to address some of what we currently address through other board advisories secondary to that we have by policy a audit committee this was something as we analyzed other districts that had a board auditor and as you all as a board are intending to hire a board auditor as well the audit committee can provide an excellent opportunity to have an independent group again I would was we as we researched audit committees in other districts what we found was there were significant credentialing that was expected of the membership of that committee so the people who serve in that capacity truly should be highly qualified to add significant value so they provide an expertise whether in operation audits whether in financial audits so that there's an opportunity for them to really dig into anything that would be

142naturally audited and it would it would include any of those things especially sensitive materials as well as just anything that would be of a business interest to the district so that audit committee has that function that is Broad enough within the current policy and is found consistently in other districts that have that board auditor function often there is either a charter or an audit committee as well that audit committee could look into things such as finances it could could look into things depending on financial audits that come through it could look at all the things that currently would be identified through an auditor a board auditor so that you'd have that additional set of eyes to support and provide expert consultation so between those two specific groups the thought for us is that would be

143a recommendation that we know we could support we know there's clear precedent around the state that those are pretty well established that we find audit committees as well as District advisories that do have some of the broad functions that I've outlined today and then many of the current committees that we have that have specific focuses whether it's curricular whether it's specific to strategic plan whether it's specific even to equity diversity related on our EAC and some of the site selection many of those things we could put within a larger structure and that would still allow you to have advisement as needed but it would still put it within that larger DAC structure so that was really something wanted to share with you as we analyzed U again all of this ultimately is the board it's

144just a humble recommendation as we assess those pieces but I stand ready for any questions you may have about those recommendations or to just help participate in any additional conversation that you as a board would like to have on this matter thank you thank you Dr Savage is there anything you want to add in Dr just U to piggyback on what Dr Savage spoke about you know one of the theories that I had as a school leader and a district leader was always looking closely at what we're doing every day and making sure that we're adding value and I seem to subscribe to the position of doing doing less better making sure that what we're doing is not just throwing a smattering of of activities across the board and making sure that we are actually

145very intentional with our work these lifts that I've been talking about that we've been talking about as a board you know wanting to be the best in the state and best in the nation requires strategic thinking it requires taking a look at the wide landscape of work that we have ahead of us with the resources that we have the team members we have and deciding what it is we can do I had that conversation at school levels as a teacher I felt it there were a lot of things we gave teachers to do and I would say administratively let's step back for a moment and let's see what is it that we're doing that's bringing value to Mrs Jordan's point before about return on investment and then what are we doing that is actually making

146a difference and so I just encourage you to use that lens today sometimes when you walk away from something it actually helps you do something better so I just want us to to use that lens as have our conversation or at least encourage that today so thank you thank you Dr Carlin and just to give some of our new board members a little bit of insight on this well actually both of you came from committees I know fairly recently but you know one of the issues that seems to permeate is also finding people to sign up I mean that's that's been very difficult this board the prior board for the last two years that was very difficult as well there were some operational issues with actual committees themselves that I've you know I know I

147had to deal with with Dr Dr Savage and attorney to Bri Bruno as well so there's a whole bunch of considerations as we go through and talk about this so why don't we go through and have some comments and discussions and I will start with Mr persons and it looks like Mr rib will be next I didn't hear mention of isok I think we have to have that if I may that's a great question so isok so this there's a number of things I omitted right so what I'm referring to are only the technical board ad advisory so ISAC was is technically certainly would would maintain and that's a that's part of the reference but that is not a board advisory that is an independent committee so that is often folks often refer to that

148as a board advisory and certainly they help our district they're instrumental to our success and to our entire Community but they are not a board advisory this also includes things such as student advisory that is not included in any of that discussion that is not technically a board advisory we would not be recom these would only be actual board advisories which in this particular case would include your construction advisory curriculum advisory District advisory which you mentioned is the DAC Equity diversity advisory Finance advisory then strategic planning accountability and so they're often used interchangeably but but the isok is actually not does not fall into that category certainly that would be included and would still exist as it is as it is required to do but thank you for that distinction sir right thank you I

149answer my question Mr yeah I just want to make a comment that CU I was on a committee for six years and attendance you're right attendance is a major problem and then about 3 years in we decided we're going to try the zoom Fiasco and I'll call it a fiasco because it was an absolute disaster we had people that saw they didn't have to come up so they'd be on Zoom the kids would be crying in the background the dog would be barking you'd be going to do a vote on a motion and you'd have to ask the person three or four times that wasn't paying attention and what are we voting on it and are we required to do Zoom if we have if we do run with these committees we I mean there's

150obviously our policy has been revised several times we actually have empowered the Committees to make a decision based on their individual piece it's one of the first things they get to do and they have that meeting is what's the format U so some have required a face Toof face only some have have done completely virtual depending on those individual committees well my vote would be not not allow the zoom because that to me it never worked out and I watched the other committees as well none of them run harmoniously when they have people on Zoom that's just my very strong personal opinion thank you I'll jump in if nobody's going to jump in so and we more want to focus I guess on the structure of what those committees are going to be are we

151can continue with some of those committees I mean for me as I said one thing we should all recognize and realize is we're not in any way inhibiting any kind of community contact any kind of community outreach I mean that is also incumbent on us as elect officials to go out there and solicit that and I know our DC committees have been very successful with that at least my kind of thought on this would be kind of for follow more of the model of moving some stuff under DAC or utilizing that better I think at least from me as an individual board member that would be my standpoint there's a lot of you know even in the two years that I've been on there's been a lot of difficulties and the participation has been extremely

152tough especially trying to recruit people and some of those committees went off track a bit to be honest so they got outside of what the scope of what they were and that was a bit of a difficulty so miss Langford Fleming I just wanted to jump in and just m State for the record I completely agree with the direction of the thought process with this I think Dak is a great umbrella to serve all of those committees that you listed that would fall under underneath that I've served on a several of these as well and attendance is a huge issue but even more important than that is giving back time to staff to do what's really important and when we're asking our staff to be here until all hours of the night after they've been

153here way before they were probably supposed to be anyway I just think that's a huge benefit for staff mainly thank you M Jordan for the last six years that I've been here we have I think the we have been trying to figure out what this committee what the Committees are supposed to do so in the beginning you know it was the Committees were supposed to be here for us the board was supposed to have conversation what is it that we would like for our committees to work on because they're our advisory boards but it never happened what has always happened is the very first meeting there's a chair there's a vote for a chair Vice chair and then the Committees decide what they wanted to discuss but that may not be what we're working on

154so that was kind of an issue at some point in time and I know audit committee that's not part of 9140 either so they're not part of the Committees I just wanted to clarify that as well so when you were speaking all all the other ones and yes sometimes it is hard I know Finance I was on that several times it was very hard to get people to to commit to that to be there people have because it is volunteer people do have obligations and I know you know personally I've gone out to my district to invite people to come and to be part of it but I think we never we kind of failed too as a board trying to figure out what is it that we would like these committees to help us

155and give them you know give us the you know tools you know for them to do like right now Dak is working on school start times we put that out there to them to to talk about that to you know have conversations to bring that back to us and that's a good thing because now they have a mission they know that they're working for you know something that we really are you know would like to have some input on and I think that this is what this is about it's about input you know to to us but we still have to give them a purpose or a why why do why do they exist and what do we need them to do I just wanted to put that out there followed by Mr psons also

156I think that the Committees were supposed to be kind of like telling our story our cheerleaders but I don't really I can't really say that has happened completely it part of it had became agendas bringing back to us their agendas different agendas that's really probably what I see that the committee's wound up doing yet it wasn't a board's committee at that point it became the community but we have how do we how do we have that conversation with our community to hear what they're saying we have to have that how you know what Avenue are we going to take to have that communication because some of the so like Dak that's really more parents and okay and more parents and not necessarily the community and we still have to hear our community regardless so I

157don't want to send that message that we're trying to close you know stop the community from coming being able to come besides you know our meeting because three minutes is not enough for someone to tell us how they feel sometimes and then in and we need to hear that we need to have that opportunity we don't want to close that door we have all these other things that we have on the list I had to get the list because yes we have advisory committees but there's other other liaison that the board belongs to that the new board members are not so far are not you know invited to that so we do need to talk about what happens with those and switching just for example just the calendar one I've never been in my eight

158years I've never been on the calendar committee and I feel like actually Jada you're the first time being on the calendar committee that you that the board had an input like we really never had an input the calendar committee kind of did their own thing and I mean you got the Veterans Day on there that wasn't ever on there I don't think or not for a very long time so you know I think that's an example of what we need to be doing and the Committees that we need to be doing and so I know you wanted to answer my question I don't know which one it was but go yeah so those are just great points M janelli so the first first one I just wanted to address what because it we'll go backwards

159in order was U this did no way preclude some of those other pieces so you mentioned there are in some cases board Liaisons or Liaisons for our school board the institutional or in other ways there maybe District advisory committees but they also have a board seat so a board member can hear it and participate in no way are we taking any of that away this really strictly has to do with the Committees that are then subject to Sunshine that exists for the sole purpose of providing you as a board advis so I wanted to really utilize that distinction because it really does go back to the first question you had which has to do with how do we get meaningful input from the broader community and so one thing I just I failed to really

160kind of give voice to we now have the ability with different types of technologies that we have to get thousands of voices in some cases of whichever particular group we want to do and the power of of getting thousands of voices is that maybe three or four voices may show up to speak at a Podium and sometimes they will say I am speaking on behalf of of the whole Community but there may not be data to substantiate that in fact that voice really does in fact carry the weight of the community so using more statistically significant sampling methodologies utilizing more advanced surveys as well as for us you know an example was thought exchange and other tools we now have the ability to aggregate large level responses and utilize artificial intelligence to theme analyze qualitative

161responses so people don't just answer a simple question they tell you why in their own words and they can can be aggregated so we preserve all those thousands of different answers that people speak from their own personal experience but you're able to see and analyze themes that then tell this board more accurately how does a larger swath of very it's both quantitative and qualitative data and so certainly we don't want to discourage people from exercising their own individual rights we're we're grateful for for folks who take the time to inform of the issues to help us send emails to our board members but you all are the ones that are duly elected you're the ones that the community selected we want to make sure that the things you're getting in terms of providing you data

162are truly aggregate level responses whether that's students themselves so it's not just one student voice but thousands of students because we serve over 100,000 of them whether it's a particular level whether it's parents whether it's business community so that's really a big body of work that we are attempting to really also pursue is more Avenues to get that type of feedback to you all so that you can have if you have critical questions to able to get you those insights from a larger Aggregate and share that data transparently with you and with our Comm our larger community so thank you for both of those questions Miss juven I hope that answered how we would attempt to address still really deeply engaging with our at large community not just one group in deak but to but

163to bring it to different utilized Technologies to do a broader level of Engagement as well one more thing too regarding the sack meetings a lot of times I find that sack meetings are on Tuesday nights of our board meeting and I always always thought that was kind of conflicting and maybe done purposeful wait I'm sorry but I that's how I felt because it didn't allow opportunity for a parent if they wanted to come or even a teacher or staff if they're having to attend that or whatever so I think that well with one meeting a month that that should be easier for them not to have it on that night so and if that actually is on y'all so if y'all could take care of that would be great thank you persons yeah the Committees

164it does get community input but it's just from a few just like the board meeting and it's not saying it's not good input or anything like that I think we need to engage the public a little bit more outside the Committees even if whichever way we go I think all of us should maybe think of doing a town hall in our districts at one of the schools you know at least one a semester or one a quarter and get input and if the district would help promote it obviously would be good but I think that kind of feedback I know when I go to a school and the few Town Halls we've had have been a lot better as far as talking to people but I you know I'm I'm fine either way I think

165the subcommittees probably to me makes a little bit more sense I think we should probably try that and see what happens and then if it doesn't work then we can always amend our policy without much effort to go back to the way it was but I would love to see if not all all maybe all the different committees but most of them be subcommittees of the deak I think would be the way to go because it's such a whyde and I think you'd get a lot of good people there except for like we talked about the audit because you need a very specific the only committee that I've been on that makes no sense to me committee members please forgive me is the construction committee because it's all made up of people who do business

166with the district either as a construction or as Architects there's only like two on there I think that are like retired and not involved and I just we really don't cover a whole lot to to me it makes a whole lot of sense to have that and so I don't know if that could be restructured a different way or something under DAC but that's the only one that I would say that I'm not looking forward to possibly seeing thank you Mr persons I'm actually G to jump in and take privilege in this I have a question for Dr Savage that may help with some of the thinking here there wouldn't be anything precluding us individually board members for attending a subcommittee would there no because so and just to answer the prior the one of

167the things site selection still has to occur as per a separate board policy and so that would function there so that is one function that would still kind of occur and it would would be within that DAC structure both it has that kind of construction bet as well as the equity diversity aspect that is essential it's a part of that requirement as well but to back to the question at hand U Mr Fischer yeah certainly board members are able to attend those are something that you know it's it's just you have the chance to hear the engagement live that's often been the case for our board that they do get to hear and they get to hear some of that input directly from folks who are and it's and it I know it was considered

168it was parents but it isn't always just parents it can be any of those roles on that sack to have that membership on there so it isn't just a parent voice it really is support staff teachers even administrators in fact students in some cases can be on the sack as well so students can be part of that it's intentionally diverse it's intentionally inclusive of those different groups as well so following up on that and I appreciate that Dr Savage because one thing we served in the committee for two years together so and one of the things for me and that's why we'd be good with it I saw and you know at least per policy our role was simply there to listen not to interject just to listen to feedback so I don't see how

169it would really be that different if we're still there listening and taking that feedback it was not my role to interject Ando anything so but Miss Jordan had a question yes so the only problem with sack is it is as Miss J said it is your teachers your students students teachers School administration but there's no outside business Community actually yeah they do business community members you're required to have two that can fit either Community or business as well so that's that's why I'm saying it really does include everyone that it's it truly is and here's another advantage of it encouraging some of the folks who who want to contribute here that our business and Community they can then get more directly connected to our schools we have a lot of folks who are hred who

170maybe haven't been in our schools in quite some time this helps them bring their Vantage Point schools are always looking to recruit community and business people for their school sacks as well it can be one of the more challenging roles to get because the rest of them are constituents that are right there in your school a lot of times they have to rely upon friends or relatives of friends who say oh I know someone who I would surely be able to do it then just connects people to to different partners so all of those are represented and if we were to go down this road we could make sure that diverse representation is expect Ed within the deck as well so you don't over represent one group so you really do have a whole swath

171of not just the engaged School Community but the out large community as well okay Jord finish turn to Bri Bruno I wanted to jump in real quick I just want to clarify something because saxs are a creature of Statute so Florida statute 1 1.45 2 specifically states that it will be balanced appropriately with teachers education support employees student parents and other business community and Community citizens so it has to be a balance and plus it should be a representative of the ethnic and racial and economic Community served by the school so that's required by Statute and thank you for that but how do how does the community how do one we would not be appointing anyone anymore so that would go away and then how would how does the community know to get involved in

172the school or a school in order to be part of that statute that you just read how do they even know that do we put that information out there to the world so that they understand if you now want to be a part of the school district advisory you need to connect with the school and get get engaged with our schools and I mean so I can speak to that so I served as a school-based administrator for 18 years here in the school district and our job as principles is to get out into the community that is your job number one certainly to meet the statutory requirement as principles we are we are in charge of making sure just like board members and superintendents to follow the law principles are charged with following the law

173we are so lucky because our community is fantastic there are so many community members that come to us at schools but part of our job as principles was also to get out into the community and so no matter what community I serve no what community most are our principal serve in and I feel very confident speaking for them because they want to follow the statute too they will get out and seek they will talk to parents they'll go visit with community members they'll go to Civic organizations our principles are numerous boards and Civic organizations throughout this community so it is incumbent upon them not just for sack but for other duties and other responsibilities that they are need needing to fulfill at the school level to get out into the community a lot of them

174do through newsletter websites interactions with boards teachers are also very involved in these processes I know I relied on my teachers you know that business you know this person you know that person get out there and so there were 108 of us out in the community looking for those very best people to be on our Sachs and a lot of our principles exceed that requirement too let me just speak to that for a moment that's a minimum requirement I've been to Sachs personally as a principal and also as a supervisor going to visit Sachs and numerous times I've run into into sacks where there are more than one Community member on there so our schools do a very nice job and even if they're not on a Sac they do a great job of engaging

175so do we have more to do on that absolutely that's why we're bringing that other position on board but our principles get out there they work very hard and our job will be to continue to support that work CH Mr F and also just to clarify in addition to what Dr Carlin said the school board does have a responsibility as well so the statute and I'm just going to read the statute so that it's it's on the record The District School Board shall establish established procedures used by schools in selecting business and community members that includes means of ensuring wide notice of vacancies and of taking input on possible members from local businesses Chamber of Commerce community and Civic organization and groups and the public at large the school board shall review the membership composition

176of each advisory Council if the district school board determines that the membership elected by the school is not representative of the ethnic rational economic Community served by the school the school board shall appoint additional members to achieve proper representation so there is a role there for the school board and one additional piece I'd like to add to that we do have team members that review our school advisory Council compositions so in academic Services we do have team members that go through those to make sure that they meet at least the minimum requirements and like I said many of our schools exceed that Miss Jordan then miss juvell thank you and thank you for that both of you for that information however I have been to SEC meetings where I've not seen anybody from the community

177there so that still is a concern to me and as far as the list and Mr PR Bruno I would love to have that if you can send me that statute again or so that way I can read that I would really appreciate it that information you just gave us because that is something I was not aware of but I definitely will look look at that as something that is our responsibility and I do appreciate that but I still a little bit concerned about Community being how do we pull them in and make sure that they're there before Miss juvell Dr Carl so two things I would say Miss Jordan one is School stum time struggle with the same thing we've struggled with as a board people will sign up but they don't always show

178up and that's something that you all have Str you know struggled with and we've talked about that on our one-on ones the other thing I will say and I'll go back to something Dr Savage said this is not the only way that we will secure Community input so as a new superintendent coming on board one of the things that I feel like is very important is getting out there and so not only like as an elected official I'll be out there you're out there a lot I know we run into each other at at events and I know our board is out there so we want to be asking those questions but also there'll be a series of ad hoc meetings the Committees that I will be setting up to ensure that we get appropriate

179feedback because that is another methodology used by high performing districts is bringing the community in for ad hoc U purposes so if we are working on the budget I wrote down before when we were looking at our investments to have some of our community members that are very good in the area of Finance to take a look at our financial investments and to see are there other avenues for us to explore when we look at you know other types of opportunities within our district I'm already thinking about I want external voices looking at those those pieces you know looking at results of our Audits and having them come back as a as a community group and say you our business community group these are some things Dr Carlin we think we can do better you

180know these are some other avenues so I don't want us to be myopic and look only at the Dack or bust there there are multitudes of opportunities and I think we can borrow some of the methodologies used at those High performing districts and we will do that juven thank you so interesting enough I attempted to attend when my daughter was still in it was her last year in high school I did I was able to go to a couple of Sac meetings but I found that not a lot of advertising is done being done and that the principal selects who he wants attending the meetings and at the time and also the principal also selected who was on Deck so I felt like it was you know it was somewhat controlled and instead of open

181and inviting and so I I think that we need to figure out a better communication aspect I have no idea as a Schoolboard member when my dad when need any sack meetings are for any of my schools and I would like to know that I'm going to I'm going to task you that I want them allall and because and I think I want to invite everyone needs to know at this table needs to know like especially the all county seats need to know when these meetings are not that they can attend everyone but they can probably focus on putting them on on their calendar to have attendance or to encourage someone else to go and I mean if you want that be the communication aspect that I think is needed because I don't know how

182else if you're going to take something away you're going to have to make something better to do that I mean I think that would be the endgame I my understanding so that's what I would like to know like I said when all the sack meetings are so I mean not that I can attend every one of them but I will certainly in attempt to do one one month and one another month obviously because I got a funny feeling they're going to be on the same Tuesday off of our Tuesday my guess so you just don't know but I'm just saying I got a funny feeling so that would be that would be most helpful thank you happy to do it little bit more than we got to close this out was that your yeah and

183Mrs chavano yeah thank you so coming from my most current experience I guess coming on to the board where I came from from my daughter's school I served on the PTO and they combined those meetings so they' have PTO and Sack and so every year we actually meet on Wednesdays so that was fortunate for us but in those for district advisories we work in the room to see who's going to participate and take hold so I guess in my experience over the last four years three and a half in our PTO environment I know it's very open you get a lot of good engagement in the beginning and it does fade off I think with every other committee and so even with PTO and sack it's the same situation that you're you're seeing now with

184committees where you have that engagement very excited in the beginning super happy to be here and then life gets in the way things happen and then that committee kind of falls to the sidelines so I think you know seeing the way you know my children's school was run and the engagement from that admin and staff I know the communication was done via newsletters via social media we would do text phone blast with voicemails so I was like Leverage everything to get everyone that you can possibly get and tell them we will feed them because if you feed them they will come so I think we have Avenues to properly communicate when things are happening I think it's on the schools to leverage those resources that they already have with their voicemail messages and those text

185blasts that they can do so we have it I think it's just that initiative of them using them but again in the same Essence I think it was an issue of just getting that commitment very exciting in the beginning but then it fades out but again still very good engagement on the school base and Mrs chaviano I would encourage you I'm sure the rest of our board members to give some input in your recent experience with Dr Savage and Dr Carlin since you've literally just been in those roles so I'm going to ask Dr Savage some questions as there anything else before we but I would ask oh Mr persons I just wonder would it sort of be end up having like standing committees under the deck I would think there there's certain ones we

186want to have every year or would it be totally a little bit different I mean so I think there are certain some requirements like and then just to clarify an earlier point I think one of the board members might have been board member Jordan about the audit committee just wanted to make sure I emphasize that the audit committee could serve so some of what we currently ask our finance advisory to do in theory you could fold under audit committee so it wasn't to say they're different it's just to say that's an opportunity that was it falls in the scope of something that could be looked at you could be looking at that financial review that said for some of these other ones that we have like strategic plan you know if you're in a season

187where the Strategic plan is being renewed like for example we have in the early spring the new governance team will be having an opportunity to dig in much greater detail and really allow a thorough review of kind of strategic plan outcomes and have that re revised so that could be something that in theory the Dak could be could play a role in collecting data and reacting to some of those data elements so that would be something that's there the equity and diversity aspect of it you know anytime we do site selection planning for new facilities that's that's a required element of a different policy so that would happen in there so that would be a standing group that I could foresee within that particular group just so that policy always be addressed and in fact

188in times where we haven't had it that is a role that DC had functioned to address some of the site selection when EAC was unavailable hadn't been compris committed that's when daak existed to support some of that as well curriculum it's not necessarily A standing item but if you had a curricular issue that needed some in Exploration you'd have a good sampling of teachers who who actually have to work curriculum on a daily basis in addition to parents who then have to engage and help support their student as they engage in the curriculum students themselves as they may in fact speak to what it's like to engage in that curriculum on a daily basis so it just has or community members what what have they heard what have they consumed through media so you really

189get that diversity for those issues but having as a standing issue I would say it's probably going to be the recommendation would be more on the ad hoc basis that they are it's fluid There's an opportunity to formulate it if there's a need and a request and it comes to the deck from the board in that way the other Advantage just to kind of reiterate for our board particularly for newer ones the way the Dack is structured is a it's a it's a unique arrange M DC is comprised of every single sack provides one member to the DC so you have this ability to bring information that bubbles up to the DAC and then the did the board has the be to interact with the dck and direct the DAC to bring issues back down

190to the school level as well so it can also be an opportunity to have issues at our level such as a School St times that many schools may not even be aware of for them to engage and then they bring that information back to the sack so there is a group of that ende's constituency at the school based level to then and then they sometimes have to bring information back so it becomes both a source of information and engagement in that kind of structure as well so just want to give you that as another food for thought but but realistically for us most of them would be done as on an ad hoc basis with the exception of the equity diversity advisory but the rest of them as you mentioned the C Construction advisory really

191would be folded into site selection you'd have your curriculum advisor which should be ad hoc your independent sales Tech which is totally separate not at all related to that a finance advisory which should essentially be dissolved but it would go into the audit committee would be able to look into any financial matters because it's within the scope of their ability and then the Strategic plan would be again as an ad hoc when it made sense to review strategic plan outcomes within that larger deck structure as well so I hope that helps answer the question okay board members and Dr Savage Dr Carlin unless there's objection why don't we go forward Dr Savage if you have enough of our input information to perhaps put some kind of preliminary plan of what this could look like and

192then come back to us if that's all right is my board good with that our board so the other thing just in regards to that we talk about input again I'm going to kind of springboard off Dr Carlin in this again as elected and officials input is input and we talk about this a lot whether it's out here whether it's up here whether it's phone calls whether it's text messages whether it's social media whether it's a student on the dis whether it's at the soccer field in fact it is our job and it's incumbent on us to go out and seek that input I treat all those whether you're speaking here at the Lector or whether you're speaking to me on the soccer field I treat that equally and as on coming upon us as

193represented of the people to make sure we're going out there and doing that so I know you're very good about that Miss Jordan so as we look at that I just want to make sure that we are still continuing to gather input from our communities so thank you Dr Savage I appreciate it moving on the next item on the agenda will be public input attorney Runo please address the item of public input thank you Mr chairman School Board policy provides the opportunity at this point in the meeting to address the board concerning any matter on this meeting's agenda if you completed a public comment card please provide it to staff public comment will be held at the podium in the central aisle in the front please be advise that the board will not respond during

194public comment to remarks made by speakers abusive language defined as swearing use of profanity or name calling is prohibited speakers who fail to follow proper decorum in the chambers will be ruled out of order any speaker continuing with such remarks will be required to relinquish the microphone per board policy 01691 and may be removed from the chambers there will be one warning for board policy 016 9.1 the time for speaker is 3 minutes you will find a countdown on the big screens in the front of the room once your time has elapsed the microphone will Auto automatically shut off please state your name when you approach the microphone and Mr chairman there are two individuals that would like to address the board thank you attorney de Bruno please make sure you've completed a public comment

195card if you intend to provide public comment the card is a public record identifying those who speak and providing contact information to staff for fault these cards are located with the staff is there anyone in the audience who is not failed a public comment card that wishes to give said public comment okay seeing none attorney Bri Bruno please begin public comment thank you with the following individuals please line up Marge Cox meline Stewart hello there I'm March Cox I'm a retired educator I live in Bonita Springs and I served on the curriculum committee last year and as I listened to your conversation this afternoon about the Committees one of the things that I really struck with me was something Miss Jordan said about being sure the committee knows what they're supposed to do our chair

196last year it was his second year and he thought we were going to write curriculum and I said to the school Personnel that was there are we not doing Florida's curriculum in Lee County and he said yes I said I assume but you need to let the chair know cuz he thinks we're going to write it I think being sure the committee really knows what it is they're supposed to be doing sounds really obvious but it wasn't and so I just I want to encourage you to be sure regardless of the format that the Committees are in that they know what their task is it was a very interesting year and the school Personnel did say after the break that you know we were not going to be writing curriculum but it was like somewhere

197along the line seems like being sure they know what the purpose of the committee is of whatever committee it is really key to it maybe before they sign up but I just I appreciate your conversation because we do all want what's best for Le County students and I think the Committees can make a difference and can be helpful to you if they know what their charge is so thank you for all your work your job is forever ongoing thank you have a good day and Merry Christmas or happy Hanukkah or k quansa whatever it is you celebrate good afternoon I'm Maddie Stewart I had something I was going to say but well first of all I wanted to congratulate all of you who are the newly elected board and some of the old board members

198I was struck by something that has been discussed and this is what I think we're missing in Lee County you can listen to what people say but for us to be able to hear you talk to each other is so I would say edifying because because we need to understand what you're thinking too that's really critical I think so the communication that Mr Savage is Dr Savage is talking about that's important but we need to the community needs to hear you all discuss these things as well and not everybody I love the idea of having these local districtwide what wherever they would be where people could actually see the whole board they could come out not everybody can come to a school board meeting you know that they could watch it on TV but it's

199over what are they going to do then so we make comments you don't have to comment on what we say okay that's understandable however we need to hear the discussion among all of you because that's what tells us what you're thinking and we need to know that as well thanks so much Mr chairman that please public comment thank you attorney de PR Bruno thank you everyone for your public comments they're truly appreciated at this point we're going to move on to good of the order and public comment I promised I would start at the opposite end with Jose so what was the question again sorry if you wanted to M we had talked about before if you wanted to go over anything in particular about your experience so this obviously is a new experience for

200me first time being up here although I have been on the opposite side before a few times but to actually be here and hear all the you know different areas of what you guys actually discuss and work on it's very opening to someone like me I like to take the opportunities and anything I can I like to know about but what I learned a lot about today is mostly you know health and how the food department really helps the schools and cares about the students but I think there's kind of a lack of students understanding like how they help the students themselves so I think you know like advertisement on the department side probably could be you know beneficial to students to understand like why the schools serve the food that they do cuz some

201students really don't really care or have the need to take care of themselves and then yeah that's what really struck out most to me today thank you for thank you for your comments and thank you for being up here we really appreciate you so we're going to move on to Mrs javian well we were all fsba last week so that was great to get to meet other Schoolboard members and other districts and kind of learn and see how they operate and it was nice to kind of connect outside of that and brainstorm and and talk about things and it was nice to be with everyone freezing our butts off in Tampa for a week but a lot of good information to kind of take back and really process here in our new roles at least

202myself and Bill on how we can be the best board members for the Le County School District so that was good thank you thank you Mr persons pick you back a little bit on the ssba but the superintendents were also there so it was nice talking to our superintendent also ran into to Dr berer Who was there and also Dr Atkins was there so I three superintendents I got to talk some to and it was very interesting I'm mentoring a school board member of brand new one from dval County and he's an interesting gentleman but I'm looking forward to that so there's mentorship and I'm sure Vanessa got a mentor and so did Mr Ribble even though they didn't think he existed there for a little while someone came up say who's this will Ribble

203but it really is the connections you make are probably more important than the actual seminars even though there was an excellent one put on by our attorney so thank you for that on First Amendment rights so it was a very great great time up there and well worth the effort that's all Mr persons Miss Jordan thank you Jose thank you for being here thank you for your comments really appreciate you being here and yes I was at FSB as well learned a lot and I will share my other comments because ever since I've been back we've had a lot of things happening in the community and I will share those later thank you thank you m Jordan you I also want to thank you sharing your afternoon here with us toight was enlightning but I'm

204going to say my comments for this evening that's all I have thank you Mr Miss juven Elli I don't have a lot either I know that armor and I attended the grants ceremony and Debbie you there right too the three of us before fsba trying to think I know I attended my granddaughter's and Debbie's grandson's National Honor Society Elementary School C celebration that was at Edison Park that was that was actually very nice they did a nice little event and I wanted to talk a little bit more about the food I was excited about the presentation but I still think we're we have to do better like I that's all that was all packaged food in fact it reminded me of like gas station food that's what I thought of and it actually wasn't bad

205but that's not what that's not what we need to be eating or that's not setting the tone for because that's all the children are going to like I like one of my daughter's friends granddaughter's friends only eats chicken nuggets I'm talking that is all she eats is chicken nuggets and her mother caters to that and I just like my granddaughter who likes to eat everything because she's presented everything I think that's what we need to do more of that in the schools is presenting food and it may not be their they may not like it now but they may like it later like I have memories of things that I like from high school that High School from school food that my grandmother was a Bonita Springs cafeteria worker and she made the best yeast

206roles in your life now that's not quite healthy but they were the best but I mean even another thing that's my favorite today as an adult which y'all might not like but they used to serve a bed of lettuce and a scoop of tuna salad and today I still eat that's the way if I could have tuna salad that's the way I eat it and I mean that's something that my mother never did really you're not mind I get that at home but I mean it's something I love today like I love a good tuna salad with that but I mean so my point is if you expose children to better food they're going to they're going to have that opportunity to try it and the exposure is huge otherwise you're going to eat a

207burrito out of a package and a piece of pizza or a you know a what was the other thing oh actually the rice and the chicken was pretty good actually I ate all mine just for the record but but my point is I think the exposure and we're not exposing them you can't expose them to have pizza every day because that's all they're going to eat like chicken nuggets so I mean I think that we really need to look into more fresh and we do not have enough of the farmtable schools to help with that so everh how we can we can explore that opportunity and look for grants that are going to give put put more money back at the school to put it back on the table is going to be really important

208and that's really what I wanted to talk about because I mean I know these ladies they're they're doing the best they can with what they have and heating it up but like I said my grandmother would go in there early in the morning and she made pans and pans of fresh yeast but rolls that were un like my mouth's watering just thinking about it but we'll have to skip that but anyways I just wanted just wanted to comment that the exposure is huge and we don't want kids in their adulthood only eating pizza and chicken nuggets and wrapped up burritos thank you and Miss Miss flim is not here I know she would have added to to that thank you thank you Miss Juvenile and 100% agree with you with that so I'm looking forward

209to seeing what we can do with that so I have two items of business I'm going to leave the rest of our exciting times for tonight so first order of business attorney Bri Runo had emailed you in regards to our board manual for protocols so one of the things I wanted to bring up at least for today and this is always an evolving ongoing process I would ask and for the new board members we used to have briefings and workshops and the briefings had comments in it we combined essentially workshops and briefings now into this model before the briefings were W run by the Vice chair and the regular meetings were run by the chair so I would ask for the support of this board to amend our protocol manual that the vice chair goes

210back to running these workshops so I support that thumbs up we good with that say I don't know if that's with you and Dr Carlin and Dr Savage I don't know absolutely okay so that order of business and feel free we can always bring forward more oh M Jordan sorry can we take a vote on that here with the protocols because so we you never vote on your protocols so Protocols are usually something that you work on during your workshop and then you take you kind of we get from the conversation which direction the board wants to move forward so what I just saw was that the board wanted to move forward with allowing the vice chair to lead the workshop shops okay I just want to make sure because we also have other protocols

211that we need to look at as well because of the change of the makeup of these meetings as well okay okay thank you sir okay so then at that place then for the January Workshop then the vice chair will be running this meeting if everyone's an agreement so next item of business just as a refresher I would ask for we were looking obviously at having our own board Mr chairman I just need some clarification though because I heard something else about the protocol man ual so that's what I what do you want to cuz I just heard Miss Jordan say something about additional changes so what direction do we have with regards to that how do you want to handle that go ahead okay well we because of the fact that we have changed this

212there are some items in our protocol that will take us now three months to take care of because there's only one meeting and I know we came across that the other day when I was speaking with the superintendent regarding someone bringing like a mentor of the year for the awards that we do but our protocol says that we have to have it in XYZ but now it will be far past that time frame because of the fact that there's one meeting to even have that conversation my suggestion on this would look at it yeah my suggestions why don't we as individual board members bring up any issues we have the protocol manual and Dr car if you and your staff would be able to review those with us yes that I was going to make

213that suggestion if I may Mr chairman that we have you bring any items that you see as glaring discrepancies or any decisions that you think we need to like look at as a board bring those if you would to your one-on-one with with with me and then we will gather those together and then we can put those out as like a proposal for for you know for future meeting discussion okay anything else okay go ahead talking about changes so what we didn't really talk talk about was when with the with the Committees and the liaison we still have I know that the new board members are taking over from where the old board members but we've we've surpassed that time we're almost going to be a going to be a year an extra year on

214top of having the and I think we need to be changing things up like and giving opportunity like I'm on Deck but I certainly think that other people should have that opportunity to be on deck and as well as there's the insurance task force now that's Mr rieles but I mean if that's what he wants to want maybe he would want to be on something else and there's the school health advisory that Miss Fleming's on but I know we just voted in the value adjustment board person so that's probably taken care of but you still have Learning for Life which I'm on that there's uncomon friends a governing board that has been Miss Jordan for a long time that I mean there's things that do need to change and we get stagnant and I don't

215think we give opportunity for other people I just think that should happen Miss juven Elli again U my suggestion on the prior board I'd asked actually for that to change during November and there wasn't support for that the time that would have changed for this so my suggest at the moment unless anyone disagrees why don't we talk about do we have a little bit of time maybe at our next Workshop to go through figure out you know some of the U committees as well as the exterior organizations we go to and then have a brief discussion on that and then we can see if anybody you know wants to change and go forward with that so wait and I'm sorry when did when did you say you asked about that prior board I did but

216that's prior board now we have two board new board members no I know I didn't have any support at that point so well I mean I don't think the change with obor I think it should have happened it should happen now because that was my concern is every time there's a reor or anything it always happens in November so I felt we should be making these changes November so that is that is true and that's when they were done and they were changed one year couple years ago during the summer and that was a that was what I mentioned at that time if I'm now I'm I'm thinking clearly and I believe it should go back to November because that's when change happens you know with and regarding board members you know what I mean

217and and so I mean I just don't think that and like I said I'm more than willing to share the wealth and the knowledge that's all and that's what I'm trying to do thank you 100% agree and I would be 100% on board with that so why don't we bring forward and obviously if anyone has any discussions with Dr K with that or turn to Bri Bruno and we could make some time in January if that's all right before I move on to my next item of business is there anything else in regards to that okay thank you next is a board auditor obviously we were in the process of trying to hire own a board auditor did not want to think we've forgotten this the last board agreed that it would be proper for

218us as a new board to make that decision since they would be one working with this board so what I would ask is to the continued ability last time from the board members to kind of continue to to head and pilot this project where we'd go again to making sure collecting current applicants and then figuring out the criteria working with Chief Mont Morano on that I would like to continue doing that you know going through rubrics and setting up a pattern of meetings that in order to figure that out so does anyone have an objection to that Mr juell I don't have objection to that I would actually ask now that since this process has been taking some time if we can get an updated list like who's still in and who's still out and

219that kind of thing as well because I think it you know who knows someone could have already taken a job so that they're not going to leave to come here for so or or they're still interested so I just think that updated information but I would love to get this quit kicking this can as you know I mentioned before 100% that would be my first order of business with that so unfortunately the two hurricanes really impacted that so but is everyone all right with that if I continue on that with that work and if I could work within your staff Dr Carlin to figure out some of those absolutely Mar down thank you Dr Carlin that is all I have the moment I'll move on to attorney de Bri Bruno well Jose right Jose I

220saw that you wanted to become I guess go to the Naval Academy and join the United States Navy yes that got my attention because my husband is retired Navy so we're big Navy people at the house and so I see you're doing a lot of things that are great leadership for that with the Brigade commander and being Senor senior class president and member of NHS so that's totally awesome you're definitely on the right path and I again am a fan of the Navy so I think it's a great great way to move forward congratulations thank you is that all ATT yes okay just while the double check Dr Carlin I have one quick order of business and it ties into the conversation today so each quarter we want to give the district advisory committee a

221some direction on where they need to or where we could benefit from their input and so for quarter three we will be asking for input around our student code of conduct student services will be working closely with Dak to get input onto potential changes and any other ideas that they have for our code of conduct so that'll be quarter three and that's all I have for today thank you Dr Carlin future meetings today we have a student performance at 5:40 so just one little process clarification so Dr Carlin has made a recommendation in terms of the student code of conduct now we just want to make sure excuse me that the board members are okay with that recommendation board members do you have any objection to that recommendation

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.