CorpusRecord 102524

TSD Board Work Session - January 9, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Tumwater School District
Date
2025-01-10
Location
Thurston County, WA
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,042 words · about 45 min
Collected
2026-06-14

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e session is reconvened at 55M we will now move on to the which are uh 2425 budget update and gu principles evening board members um it's a pleasure to be uh presenting to you on both the Curr year update as well as planning for the 202 budget cycle this presentation will be done mostly by myself and my colleer might situations around the table here told me we Haven so the one comment I would make before we get going here is that um there's quite a bit of data content at the beginning of the presentation um some of which you've seen um include and continue to include this data in presentation more and more people into where delber transparent and share that all the audiences most of the content that is specific to the

002board and gobling with toward the end of the presentation so I will be moving quickly to the first part we want to most okay I'm just gonna step out my daughter lives in Los Angeles and she said call me when she can when I can so I'm going to let you guys keep going um I'm not going to okay so this evening we're going to talk about primarily four things first of all provide a u Current financial status update we've got another months of data here that we can share also seriously dat on Statewide and District Trends and then in part three and four we're going to talk about a recovery plan and talk about options in next steps and seek some input from the board discuss what could be some guiding principles um to

003guve the work as we prepare for the reductions necessary in first we're talking about Current financial status so this is a slide you're familiar with and it just reiterate that last year the district spent $4.5 million more than ative Revenue which resulted in the fund balance dropping from over 11 million to 6.6 million and then we immediately get into the current year now this slide here was only updated for November but an hour ago I got the data for December so um the thck green line there represents our C balance in the general fund and the December number is 1.38 million doll about where we would expect that line to continue on the trajectory being that it was 26 in November for context uh it's the brownish line that represents the 23 24 school year

004so you'll see that last year at the same time month end December we at 6.5 million currently we're at 1.3 million for a difference of about five million that gap of four half million relatively consistent we expect to be consistent as a result we continue to expect that in the months that are Circle in red we could conceivably the is particularly in March and for that reason um put an in loan before December that atting this is simply a recap of some of the fact of what a fund loan is for some of the members of the audience briefed on this the last meeting but in essence um it doesn't doesn't the situation theor so now we're g to talk about any questions by the way about the I went quickly we talked about question

005of what's Happening Statewide um first of all um most of us here are aware because we live in this region which is close to the legislative deliberation state agencies um the state has agencies setting we're about to in the session session it is a cal cycle where it does look as if agencies by state to cut and anticipa that the best and the next two slides are actually not of my making we Bor these from the office super instruction conted them bottom but we've talked about the notion of an es CP several times as a body and this does a really good job of illustrating what that clip has me at a systemwide level you see in the orange line is you'll see starting in 2015 what the trajectory of enrollment in the entire State

006and then when it turns blue what the trend line was suggesting about where that enrollment would continue to be then you see the orang dip below and flat that is an representation of what enrollment has actually done see the Gap right the Gap essentially that is the gap between what all the forecast were saying about what en one would do both District by District as a state of and then what actually and in many respects that's what Esser fill in support in different ways in different districts because not all districts were water that was in perhap not as extremely as some districts but also other districts um and that Gap was filled in by best years those PL are now depleted for all ask a question about that um so es money was designed to

007support schools for their cost that included staff andot so what's the connection with so the purpose of as money as it was written up in the federal law was was more than just buying the the medical know masks and sanitizer whatever it was also designed um and I actually think this was a phrase in the falow um to main maintain continuity of operations so what was happening in was that March of 202 I was that okay school districts found themselves literally right in the middle of the school year Boom the pmic H kids coming to school and left to its own devices like school districts were going to EXP enrollment get radically funding as a result of the governor and the federal leaders we don't want to think this Mass Logistics start wholesale firing all

008their bus drivers and teachers and but they know that have to fire back after so they encourage dists to use the money not necessarily operations so most the districts continue to have bus drivers and F service workers even during the period um when some of those Services wer even being provided because the idea was remember at the time thought it be like a one or turn around Avid and so as far as I can see did a lot of that did a lot of basically how to how to to maintain uming and the services that had going into the P yeah right I mean among the districts that I've seen not nearly as signicant imp some of the but there was I think we also spent money like after the back we had defin um

009uh struggles you know to bring students back we had beh you know we had to deal with behaviors we had to deal with these things that we we hadn't had to deal with before been out for about a so I think I think in the late in the later years of the ex money we were using that money especially around speci around behavioral Texs to to help you know help that which might seem like an ad but I think sense to because those defin as a result I think there was also you know we talked about that relationship with en to this there was an expectation at some point around he this ends we open the doors full on and these people return to school I think that last graph kind of showed that that

010hasn't it didn't happen it hasn't happened and it continues not to happen it is like and that again this isn't the T water specific Washington Pacific it's a nationwide issue again and this is so I think part of why we this is the district really hasn't adjusted like Staffing with the rollment that has for us it's more flattened we didn't see the like we saw a drop and then it's kind of flattened out and we just haven't seen that Spike go back up to pre pandemic levels and increased like was projected at some point so I think one of it's just it's added to our the complex of the situation we facing now that we need to sort right siiz the district to the fundel next I've been studying the federal budget situation and there's

011a lot of talk now about going back to 2019 budgets so the question I have for us is how do we compare how does our budget currently compare with 2019 um and that might be again help us with a solution if we're way above that level and spending then it helps us to rationalize with our people that we work with like his school teachers Etc very valuable people that we work with why we may cannot maintain where we are because we're going to end up with this deficit perpetu for a while that was my curiosity of 2019 versus now um I don't there's a couple slides that come later that actually do give a little bit ofc context that um and so maybe we can pick that up at that time um this slide nearly

012shows and again this is not our slide we've attributed here but was from opi's presentation that uh this sort of illustrates the impact that inflation has had on school dist um because you know when you look at the state budget you look how much has gone to education you look how much you spent education me or something well the number keeps going up so what's the problem and this chart illustrates that that when you're looking at inflation adjusted dollars school districts have less purchasing power today than they did in 2019 that's a counterintuitive thought folks we fund increase but the number inflation is also very serious shared just Insurance million things really taken off cost and illustrates that even though funding may have gone up a nominal dollars not um these are the amounts of

013the um Esser claims so looks like um over a three-year period um the school just claimed about $8 million um that money obviously no longer available to the district to your point director Adam there's some historical numbers about um just gathered from the s75 both for certificated staff and classified show like what it would mean to go back to 2019 um sh you ly linky discussion that we had about these two um but perhaps we can move back to that and then like you see the you've also seen this slide um Tom water is a classic example of uh the importance of looking at the disaggregated enrollment data as opposed to the total data um because what what has happened is that even though total enrollment in in has been you know down but more

014or less flat um greater percentage of our students are availing themselves of the variety of educational opportunities available to them like the Mill Center like running which impacts the district so one of the things that we've undertaken here in the fall is scrubbing through fenes um and it is common at this time of year for people to speculate as to well if we just cut all of our non-salary costs um you know like start there first right um one of the things I like to do is just pull the top 25 and sort of illustrate for people the reality of what that is um our number one nonell expense and these areally a 24 I the current year but last year just our our liability insurance was by a 1.7 mil we negotiate that the

015extent you can the issue there is you have to like you want L Insurance in the school district a cane deductible you know but there's only so many things you can do with insurance um the services that we get to our Educational Service District the amount we pay PS UIL just uh the amount we pay to South Sound for running Start programs and our purch card program which ISO card you know that's a lot of school suppli material um gives you a flavor for like these are the largest monality cost in the district now the place where we've been really able to make some inro so far this year you go all the way down to our attorney Bill we're down 70% so far this year um in our expenses um we made a very

016conservative effort the limit as best we can now we need to call attorney we're calling an attorney but no standing meetings no like just the most AER approach possible for the of representation so now I'd like to kind of stage into the part of the presentation where we talk about um next year here after frame some options um maybe like the the board dialogue a little bit about um Next Step so there's a few things I'd like to do first address some timeline issues um talk a little bit about cost drivers and our hope what is our goal here and there are some decisions to make about the goal some nuances in terms of timing and specifically about board policy and also what we're trying to do to address B envir I think there are

017at least seven things is probably not an exhaustive list but um there are at least seven things I think would constit a FIS 256 include following the first is um given where we are on a c basis we will be recommending to fun to be clear pretty much regardless of what we do how aggressively we proceed we would anticipate that that loan would be necessary for the duration of this year and into next year because it would take if effect and so just for transparency it's not you just here a question of how quickly can um we have um undertaken reductions in non-al expenditures already I think the superintendent share memorandum of October 11 to schools and departments where all schools and departments were required to reduce a minimum of of 10% of the discretionary

018non um and S account so there are some of these things that are in the contract and we um did not seek to um create a burgain issue um third thing is that you know when we talk about this recovery part of the issue is um the amount of the desired the second is the speed at that um we will be recomending a multi-year approach to the board this evening but we will be couching options cont of that it is clear at this point that we will need to recomend reduction and staing for the 25 26 school year we can expect to see steps in place throughout the early winter um have to be bringing those recommendations to you I will also be um probably as a matter of timing I would say after that

019is done we're going to be rolling out a pretty ambitious uh revision of pretty much an entire overhaul of budgeting and spending procedures and practices in this District um ranging from policies of travel food purchase what does and does not want improve overtime um how we approve over time how we engage facility use who pays for facility use when we allow facility use we can do over time um it ranges pretty much every program will impact it's going to be a pretty significant U change and weend to engage partners and our departments in that before we roll it out um but that is in the we also have implemented with M Factor's assistance and Leadership um pretty ous program of um what we call cual quarterly business analytics dashboard which is tracking everything that essentially

020we can track about how we spend by program uh by expense um and we have at this point at the beta stage of that practice we illustrate Reas here and then finally we're going to take a look at the minimum fund balance policy make what it says um impact to this so to initiate this sort of plan I think there's essentially three steps the first here we're going to immediately ask for the loan authorization we will continue to implement those on reductions we at the point this we at the point now where unless there's a legal reason comp telling us to fill a vacancy what not we had one vac Capital that we did fill that the capital fund but other than that if it's required by an or there's some other ex circumstances uh

021we have been notor re separ closely and then 2526 would involve at this point a reduction not just of nonary expenses but also Staffing Guided by and then finally know 26 beond this is a pretty fluid situation just learn the state seates are up like considerably and that's also going to have an impact on it we these things you know we learn week to week so um it will um it will it's kind of unnecessarily leading Target we hope very sign ches bys also set us back a bit but we are in the of of consist reassessing our position and what we need to do um but we are looking very close for not just number of positions we have but where we charge these positions are we appropiately our categoricals are we using our

022lab dollar strategically our CP dollar strategically our title dollar strategically we have a clear vision of what we should targed Capital um these are all um at this point just to give you I'm ahead so this is what I want to something that I think is relevant to situation this I don't know if you're all familiar with's financial help so every year OPI publishes once districts close their they submit their s196 report gathers that data aggates it put on spreadsheet and flag certain District fin if you were to go to the website right now and pull up that fin Not only would not final but you see it has a total score well higher than other District it's because that model is it's a lag a year so here's a here's a district that has

023legitimate concerns of going past negative and yet you know the oi unless you sort of knew what it does you would be led to believe that uh things are okay so it sort of highlights the to track in the moment that's what we're trying to implement with business Antics dasboard so every month you know we're looking at overtime pass outs Su costs we're looking at what we're paying out legal it's really the idea is we're trying to get under the hood of the district and provide like Analytical sture in real time rather than waiting to see where we close in looking at it assemble and then realizing too late also given a considerable amount of attention thought to Communications part of this um the superintendent has been out to the community email twice with budget

024messages once in October and once in December about the evolving nature of this issue um superintendent and I have also the budget advisor committee now and has had some very robust discussions about Miss Bry and I spent the greater part of this week and some of last week meeting with our labor workers um trying to be transparent about the situation we find ourselves in cont language um and also we're trying to keep our gear to the ground in partner with our state reps you know when it comes to that we discussion whoever can be an objetive for us because there are things that so at this point i' like to talk about what I think our options are going in the next year um first before we get into options a little primer the first

025is that um we derive these from the best information we have available and once the legisl comes out is what they're going to do once the federal government the new president our is surprises for us um but we think regardless of how those things go um it seems um seems obvious will be necessary our goal is to ground the reductions in philosophy or a specific goal rather than just ring as without and the size of the budget problem is a fluid situation influenced by bargain now the goal is driven by the board of policy should say there really two things that are constitute the post here for what we're trying to do one is of PR of getting getting getting off the Sol right we need to getent before that that is the first before

026we even of get to the point talking about 6% exactly what um so that's one part of the go post the second part of the go post is um to really be clear about this policy and just so that we're all on the same page the policy that you have on the books right now does not show that the district have a total fund that is not what this I don't know if that what it was intended to say understanding but that's not that's not mean of the language I highlighted the portion that is that I'm referencing here but when when the board policy calls out fors of fund balance that are in spendable s but are not legally restricted as to their use and what that does is it takes 12 F exclude in

027there that is attributable to a program that is restricted that would include at least about three and half million of money for SK CER money state inv very signicant very sign last year the district ended um in AGG under the policy so option A again I'm not trying to be toal try to stop the stop digging phrase means right now we're spending more than we're so the longer we go bigger in the fund okay so optioning is what I probably describe as the the minimal amount that the district would have to do just establish this wouldn't even necessarily get rid of the which eliminates theer right now best information we we just finished a year SP that's stop option b not only stop so what would that this option says okay not only do youate

028the budget but you need to build a mod Opera get off the so if we expect to be negative and this year months what would it take EV so under this scenario again the information we think that if you did this and I do think this is a sensible option um that you would still in parts of 256 perhaps the enti 25 but you would be on your way off so at some point you would be a re we think that would require approximately $6 million reduction and then option C which is now we're talking abouty now we talking about now we're talking what exactly in that this would eliminating the budget up and then building a larger oper not just to TA to so you know we think that this is a difference to

029the board's role here important decisions they to the's policy and we're seeking to sort ofis focus of build I thought actually devel I guessed over time and they developed these six affirmative statement or principles toide thought they were pretty good we sort of went through the cabinet and of buiness feel like feel like appropriate princi at least from the sou perspective but those six are um commit to reducing or delaying employ cost First to consider sustainability offer consider the imps on to look at current imp consider ruction closer alignment the St model whenever possible use extion reping position consider the so I guess the openend question super these seem like sensible principles to guide the work um question that we ask yeah so really if I were to say what what is the desired outcome

030of this um we would like some input on AB everyone understand I but I could find it's just I have a I have a PDF super on but I know they're from Abend starting all right so first does anyone have any questions about what any of these no talking no we're talking about dating principles yeah what's on screen anyone have questions number pack that one a little bit have we been enhancing things too much in certain areas is that the kind it'sing with respect to St yes um I think I wasn't part of the development but tell you how and you know we definitely have program where our finan connect to that program is beond we receed for to be fair that's not entirely unusual in school districts but also it's a matter of Knowle

031special student take do particular robust job by funding those needs our our expenses for that cons consider you could you could go down the list of other programs from Food Service to language program to other um essentially basic ends up supporting or local some of which are relatively so one of the things that is interesting is that is number two kind of addresses that but it's speaking to the optional forams and I would think that having some kind of combination of those in fact I would prioritize the lawn optional programs say you know step one trying to consider reduction at closer line taking into consideration impact on students particular comfortable have that specifically so I was try to model that I would be taking two and four and ESS kind of com yeah just the

032the word optional optional programs like maybe that is what do that mean yeah this is this is from a public Fus I don't so that's what I'm saying kind to fund it more and help the kids more what Barby was really putting together for which is prototypical school model basically the second half I think an example of an optional program was TV a few years ago it was not sustainable we did not have the en to sustain until that yes right so I think that is what I was wondering is there something and I don't know what the words are considering our goals of try to close GS is there something that we can I don't know and it's likely what is meant we consider stud particular stents but I'm wondering if there's something can

033consider considering go I don't know was maybe part of the idea is is as resources become available so this that just C the situation gets better that we prioritize resources align and I think in many ways what we'll be talking about is alignment to the Strategic plan opening will be developed by April of this year we see that because I think we're g see strategic plan gos and outcomes and maybe those are the last Cuts like those are the last Cuts think it's more not necessarily when things are getting better but this is a budget priori that we've already identified the yeah I think one of the things we can do is come up with just kind of use this this conversation today and come back at another you know at a future meeting with

034sort of these see as we that concept talking principle or you can also so we don't we might want to address would be efforts to increase deficiencies from private something Lot F too much but instead of making cut cut cutcrease incre efficiencies and Mone so I don't know if there's some kind of brainstorming or something that do have like our staff come up with ideas of they think would help commit to increase efficiencies and what would make it how the teaching be more efficient help yeah I think May that sort of adding some additional words to number one which really is reducing non employe that's really around what you're talking about is efficiency of of non-employee increasing the efficiency of the employees you know like like for example we we figed out our participating to

035help our our transportation department be more efficiently look what happen now the year time we're on time so we did a lot of brainstorming as far as increasing the efficiency of our transportation situation I think we can do a thoughtful process of thinking about how to make certain things that we do more efficient um so that's something that you can draw from or priv they their stff more I mean I don't know I mean I'm not sure the wording of this I I guess in essence I feel like when we're talking about the significant the significance of the cuts we're talking about whether it's 4.5 million to 8.5 million in essence for us to accomplish any of those scenarios we will inevitably become more assist because the kids are going to be showing out like

036the same number of kids like this does not we're not expecting declining enrollment the same number of kids show up a year from now with again with that kind of reduction inevitably there's less staff to to support them teach them service them all of these factors and so the only way we will accomplish we will have to have efficiencies improved or people are going to have to take on additional duties I mean there's lots of factors that we'll have to consider um that are almost built into this process is that does that make kind of sort of but I still think you're better off to specifically come up with consistencies that you can do and let people know what they are okay and let them participate in their ideas nobody does better than the person

037who does the job what are things that can be done to help be more efficient that's why I'm thinking I don't think it could be I understand where you're coming from but I think if you're focused on stuff then you have more Chan if you have thoughts about what that looks like in terms of guiding principles we we have we have this conversation we'll take some notes and see if we can come up with something but if you have something more thoughtful on thiss not that's my think amaz helpful and smart people actually are a lot of so in our case we provide the same service if you can improve it of the district I'm sure that very deep value ask to come IDE this were your green job what are what are things that

038make aen job for you and you be surprised that people will come up with stuff you think it's just it's not point but I think it could improve by um I like what Jo was saiding about rep I think some of these are were passed already so not I think we're P that we're already doing that's you're not that's kind of strategy I like the ones that are associated dat we can quantify a little bit and see that I think four is a good one weate the data um again number one I think that's something we're already doing or at least that's what we said we to I have questions around six is six just about our balance policy nutshell yeah again this is a wasda training but I can tell you what how I

039respond to I think it's like just the the governing body in this case the board having a a good reason for their fund balance calls understanding what it is and supporting what it is and standing behind it basically in your view it constitutes appropriate reasonable and sustainable levels of res reserves so again I think that's what we already doing we have staing we kind toward that next lot of this so I think we're already doing some so um I like moving forward in three and four um and then I think need some work on that I more and so we need that clarified a little bit more I what do you mean the first part because we move the second part down into number four you talking about the first part of that one that

040so it's it's not typical so I think that helps that s along the part that seconds this one might be data d a little bit we some data points to this I although um I don't know if we're going to be forcing enough to be in that position get down deter don't know maybe that get more into the options concerned I think again I think if you go back to kind of the purpose of this is really for you to really give some clear guidance to myself and this team as we as we work to develop this ongoing budget is these these as a group have decided these are really important concept for us to really take um again I think the clarity of that will help us in developing a budget that meets your

041needs right that is in line that we're all in we're all in the same page that we develop a budget that said yeah that this ision we agreed that the decision because we're to make a lot of tough decisions and um we value we value these programs there's there's not a lot of excess in just ra syy but that that really doesn't exist so we're we are trying to make some really tough decisions so that's really getting around guiding principles that will help us in that process for the best of our daab and I think that those what you're talking about I agree I think as we keep some of those are helpful as we start to prioritize different decision making um rather than a blanket if just said we believe that the district should

042cut 10% across the board you right I could be a guid in principle that we'd be like uh not super comfortable with that we want the we want the leverage that kind of that aligns with what you're thinking we don't want you to cut everything equal that is not like we're not looking for blanket reduction that we see it is more nuanced in this and that's I think that way and for those that the details of this are helpful as we start to develop processes and my answer is very confusing I kind of jumped all around those if I were to give my summary of thoughts I would say I would look at these as priorities on which ones are we prioritized and for me I think you get a lot of clarity prioritizing for

043um is priority and then whatever the combination of two the three looks like so yes the prototypical school model but then where do we want to spend local from Jewel strally best flexibility there but then what top I think also in it enhanced programs not optional based upon District goals and plan um and based upon again this is what important to the board based upon District goals and our district Focus Kevin's to work on this that we're gonna if we cut stuff and it's based upon what our goals are we still want to achieve the goals of likeing the tests if we can helping specials I think by that gos we so hard on term president so it's so hard for that year to get our goals nice and concise and specified but if we

044reference that it helps okay um soby has to and so I just like your thoughts do you have any thoughts on a andc before you we can continue this after anything else when we say enhanced what we're talking about is like you discussed earlier the programs that we beyond what yes and then also I think I don't know if this would be a guiding principle or obviously if if we follow these principles them um the goal is to to have a product an outcome of a is there a way to have a shorter term accountability or tracking of those decisions that being made andion save us x amount of dollar or we cut this program that's going to save us$2,000 um so that when we are making these decisions we have don't know but we've

045made these decisions the project is that something that's been provided provided down consistently yeah so I mean what you're describing right now is a lot of what we're spending every hour doing right now you know is trying to sort of think about those um you know as I I hope this answers your question by the trying to give it a practical spin on it's not uncommon for districts to conf forward say we're going to do these six things and it's going to save X and then it turns out not to save X for a variety of of reasons some of which are you know not because somebody didn't do some right but because the landscape has changed special education is a very typical example of that where because Staffing is driven by I could be

046changing laws it could be Federal Court decisions um you think you might be saving something andu or not so we would have to do sort of like iterative reassessments of like where we're at relative to those decisions um and I would expect that there would kind of come in the form of uh for work it's not entirely disimilar from what we're doing now um but that level of detail I mean you know to be be clear about it like the whether you sort of empower the superintendent with a set of priorities and you tell the superintendent and super me um we want you to work with these principles given um versus some other model is for for you all to work out in the superintendent board realationship um but in terms of the followup of

047it and in terms of like we're all about that cut our finger on every po that that exists and um I we will we we will know I would say roughly you know quarterly whether the changes that were putting having the effect that we thought that they would um sometimes they do but sometimes they don't and for nobody's particular fault it's just Weir CH were you talking about up process or updates next year as as we overseeing the budget yeah I guess what I'm talking about is kind of checking your progress um we can give you theing principl makion I just just to talk next decision yeah so I think what we we want to kind of we'll have to figure this out a little bit because the guiding principles will guide us we will

048end up developing a plan that will meet The Guiding principles to the best of our ability and to like that option A B or C with what you already heard um then talk about the subject to change due to a long range of variety of reasons and so I think one you will start to see not only as early as January our beginning of this plan and I would say is probably at a at a bit higher level than individual positions you'll see some numbers you will see estimated cost savings um and broader again I haven't seen this with developers yet but I'm kind of anticipating like the bo role in this is not at a position school you know that kind of level it's a little bit broader but you will get an essence

049of this is the reduction percentage reduction Dollar Save estimated in this process and then as we go into next year will get updates around are we achieving the savings that we said we are and you should see that in real time in a variety of metrics so I think there that it won't be quite to that position because I think we really want to make sure I think it's the board superintendent relationship is really clear on that we don't you hire your jobs you hired me and all small and then we do that decision making so we kind of that just back and forth around what is our how do we support and create a program that matches with what you're asking you to create need to be that rle and so I I try

050again it's a little I know it's messy and it's going to be a bit messy I think so we did we did guiding principles few years we haven't haven't really guid principles you know for a couple of years so fig this out once we give them the guided principles that we will because of the legis they're going to be working and they're going to come up with scenarios that won't be real until until in the end what what I what I don't want is for them to bring a budget to us and we say no way we're not going to approve it because and and and it will be perfect we War but like you know you know sticking to the state's prototypical School model seems like an easy one but we could we could

051say actually we don't care about the prototypical school model we want to make sure that we have X of whatever staff regardless right we could or we could have a so that's what I just hard to think about which is you know why I really wanted you know as got the presentation think about it but um it's it's so when they bring the budget and it's they feel like all the work that they're going to do over the next few months they feel like they have done what they feel the board wants because otherwise they are sitting there I don't know it's been it's been hard to last couple of years without yeah and I think again there's these do can have they can have a really significant impact and I I'm you know my

052I have some Oregan experience and one of the things that was really common in Oregon districts was for school boards or across the state to cut days and and that you could unilaterally do that and basically get approval from the state kind of after the fact and so districts would often times hey this is the money that we get we can only afford to go 170 days so we are cutting 10 days from the school calendar away we go and that's the savings and so there and so times districts that I've been associated with which dat guing principal says we will have a full calendar school year and right so those kinds of even parameters um I don't know if that's if that's not necessary in I it's not quite as easy in Washington to

053do that kind of work so I again it's different different processes have occurred so if there's something of really of value to you at the broader level and I don't know what good examples of that are I you could you were let's just say Early Education Advocate you could be asking the board to prioritize Early Education or pay two kids or pay one students and again that we may want some clarity about that or you allow us the option like as we look at this are we going to prioritize K1 students in this process so that's those are like guiding principles that can shape the work that we do as a do you think of anything else based on this conversation and what Kevin going to be bringing that refined list to thee that we

054the timing I'm not sure exactly we'll talk about the timing of when that comes back but this is sort of a quick first conversation draft we'll have another opportunity to refine I think just gives us some good initial convers go to 63 we were plan to go to 6:30 obviously this Flor can go as long as you choose to all right option to option and to start that's kind of lower score and that op cost another million depending on the timing that we have to be careful and not be too drastic to cut too much too soon because change we don't want to people us stud however that iidm right and so that is still going to be really diff that dist we're not alone almost every entity is now facing the same the that

055even Amazon is cutting staff you know a superow company so we're in good company put it that way and I like how is is that the financial crisis that come exactly from following the lagging indicators not looking at the Le indicators so um that's really important that we have a wake we thought we not because lot of just okay so I'm supportive of in and I'm not thinking I don't know that we would in so that we devel time yeah um I'm G back up a little bit here um these budget options a b and c these are for this school year for 25 um and so with that option option b don't talk about policy so option C says we make the policy so my assumption option A and option b do not meet

056the minimum fund balance policy in August of 26 correct just just so option b does have the goal of meeting the policy it just doesn't do it immediately the sort of a speed is okay thanks um where did these options come from my brain we I mean yeah I'm sorry oh yeah as well that was a terrible misstep because one of them was Cur so I would like to I would like to quickly recant my response but just so just so we're clear option A I mean just like just to make it super clear if you don't do option A you just get further and further in cash insolvency we're clear about that right like the thing is it was actually one of the budget parameters that I found part of the law TR is

057like your revenues equal expenditures so that was one of the budget parameter ideas and pul they pulled it out because I I wonder if we could argue that that would be a guiding principle that so I think we're giving them a guiding princip there have been times of will be a great time complete that always beend an annual basis the budget we're talking about trading not talking I mean Ben said the same thing option just iron it's going to be you can't have and and if we don't we've done it with a plan in place how it's going to get go back to big brain and and um so is the budget advisory committee give input on this at all so usually when I present options to a grou con what is there's a recommendation

058what is the recommendation a consensus or what is their varying recommendations I mean I have a recommendation um so I think A and C both some danger right a poses a danger in the that se is a different danger which is sort of what director you don't want to because what are you what are you do creating larger operating just to get to the end point fast right then you're at the end point what are you do start adding sta back starts to create a bit of yo-yo and I think generally speaking that's not where you want to be now it's an option is the board policy and we don't want to assume too much about oh we can just not need board policy right but it seems sensible to me that you would not

059act too rashly but also not not and option b is like recognize youer eliminate and you're going to se to make games on the fund policy not assume end of and so I think option b is the probably I don't want my staff from my perspective probably often see agress um o would require you know continue into the next year umti or you know continue to to different costs the the cost from the bottom is that to be to meet the the goal of the auction trying to div there are there a lot of time on ways so instead of like something to be paid by August that we your cash flow tough I think what say so here's an example so we have two separate but related problems the first is a cash flow

060problem talking absolutely to we uh were sent our insurance bill in September our provider does not allow they send Bill dat it comes with was a contributing factor to not much they could do we want to explore not but would another provider allow us to pay half in the fall half in the spring whatever orderly um that's not going to eliminate our that's really to operating at all but it will help us get out of the loan so thank you that is absolutely guess my falcy created crey bu I don't like the bud polies more dict the bud so I would prefer option see but I understand agressive more open to other options that come closer to being confined with the policy there's a reason for that we have back tracking just for the sake

061of you still have to balance this budget one way or the other it's fast 12 um that's my concern then again this bud is kind of going to dictate we have to pay speaking of that comes up with the terms is that something that you guys come up correct and so then who decides how much require how long term so that's up to us the county dictates the we can come up withay back in two months or two years isn't that something that that been care come up with is that is that something you guys would come up with and change and look at and analyze over time yes so there are are we to have it off by the interest itself and how we pay that back isend on gu sorry got one be

062looking to do here later this month has to be paid back there potential or is an option for another to another closer to policy yes so we would have to foll back this year and then we would then issues Al in next year 2526 help the cash FL um and then at that point depending on the TS and how we um you know how the projections work you can decide at that point as when it be best to pay it back and of course you want to get back as soon as we could so that we don't agree additional interest so I'm gonna say that for us to do the additional loan to get up to the 8.5 million would be we're notna borrow yeah no so the the interfund loan is only helping us

063with the cash flow piece of it um so that we you know as as we make the looking at AB and options that's actually helping um fix the deficit um you know to get the deficit that we have at the end of the year so the cash flow and the the air loan are two separate issues um so we would you know will have to get that second loan for cash flow and probably beine um know 25 25 or 26 by mid year yeah by New Year um so does that answer your question just the cuts necess exactly exactly yeah and that's with option b I figured we halfway through the year with in 25 no I'm not making promise I'm just hoping I'm a little concerned know ignoring the policy you know so I

064just wonder so yeah we've been thinking about that too like we so the Kee thing here is getting above water on oper once we are spending less then we bring in even if it's ainal amount we're guaranteed progress towards our goal right um that's the now if if we literally go if we get to a spot are making we're not going to be able to predict as to the GU but if we get above water and we can see that that that we're making progress to the policy then the board can have much more latitude the coming see see that once you're above water and once you're making progress that's much more uh a little cush when it has to we want to make when we are making we're making the goal we're head in

065the right direction cut at that point only accelerate the rate at which you fun balance policy but at least you're eded in the right direction that it's a totally different Fring un cuts and if you're still so philosophically the idea not only get flat but get in a spot where you're making game you don't know exactly how much game but we're making we're spending less than we're bringing in and so at that point it becomes the you want to make more cuts that will accelerate the, but you know that you're on the right the budget on that isos to be and then you see how comfortable you are with it and how buiness you know going even deeper or that as as if for General again this process I guess move forward like here we're

066not really doing the vo it's like move forward with this some consensus board move forward with this and we'll do our best ability to kind do the the board in this process so if you say option b that's our work will begin developing this and we know again I'll just kind of reiterate lots of things can change in the next it will change over the next number of months and so we will this will be an ongoing conversation about our initial like our initial work and again we have all of our representatives from all of our employee groups and very very anxious to see and hear kind of how this process rolls out and what we hope is kind of a wor case scenario and then they sort of things as it and then as

067things change so um we they want that information somewhat soon for a variety of reasons so this gives us like an idea of begin this work in this Frame because again each of these options requires us to do different a couple of us really want us to be a policy um and so when I when I'm wondering I heard you sayc are you DC you kind DNC priority you can do option and I don't know if this helped but it may not at a couple of points in this conversation which has been very good and very helpful I appreciate um it's not that option be ignores the policy it's that it does not gu get compliance so if it if it helps to phrase it as compliance with the policy over a a period that's

068different than saying that it doesn't you know it ignores the policy and I feel like it's not intending to IGN policy a ignores the policy right B says we got to make progress because we have a policy that we have to me the question is not that that there is isn't a policy the question is the speed with which we need that policy so one other thing have to remember at the time we set the policy the financial situation before us was much different we we were at the 4% level had successfully leing that and thus we thought it wasent in order to help our bond uh chances having a higher rating that we thought it was to add the six to the six level so the six is not something that again time thaty

069can or we can view it as we're just on a timeline slightly long that or the economy can get worse and we can be in worse shape you know we just don't know but um it's I think it's more of the situation the timeline uh that I think we still agreement on tr% but budget 26 27 or 27 28 times re that we have that um kind of like to talk about showing progress policy there maybe we have a goal I don't know what number 60% of policy going to allow us toy clarification on Poli regards to talking about what reality I wasn't here question Taylor about point of that guiding princip you know about reserves and all that I think it was yeah yeah and I think this is it is like the board

070understands and owns its definition reasonable level it is and so the current policy basically says that you would have that actually speaks for budgeted sorry so I think right now a total number of things that we would consider to be restricted as to their use was like 3.5 million so we closed at 66 3.5 of that meets to the exclusionary language in the board of policy so like right away you're almost half of that so you you start thinking about okay is that is that what was intended I don't was in because I wasn't here when it was Rewritten but it's a very material change for the policy whereas you know most people didn't think it was it's actually very material so to be able to comply with this we'd have to be able kind

071of okay here's 6% of fund balance and here's fund balance above and beyond that 6% that is associated with these po of money that IL legally restricted by state or federal money um so 6% was 6 million just for real members You' add all of the restricted categorical way and you'd be up you know you'd be up the n10 million range for a uh you know maybe less but I'm just quot it's just SE here um that um is that what was intended right so if that was what what the board intended then then you need that that gu if you're unclear about what that meant you're like mean that I really meant for you to kind of separate out the skill center but I wasn't so meaning that you separate all L money you

072know whatever but the uh budget advisory committee spent was an hour on this and it Le a lot about like each one of these pots like well what really makes sense to separate what is like doesn't make sense to separate and they have a lot of robust discussion and ideas about that um I think of was that when the money was restricted you know we you know we went through a period where we had a large fund balance but it didn't all it it can't all be spent um because some of it is in the market some of it is or you know whatever it is that it doesn't all get spent and so I think the board at the time recognized that wanted to be clear that we don't want a company Market because

073if we did have an emergency we can't use remarket money you know um from what I understandably you see depend on remarket money to you know pay to six or whatever it is so I think we we wanted to be clear that we are we are looking at the unassigned that that we are looking at the unassigned f we looking at the fund balance Beyond market and whatever is dedicated to other but in my two years we've passed we approved a budget that didn't comply with that right and again I thought and again I think with an idea that I think again like in year or two I think I'm in a different place was at the beginning of last year there was sort of an understanding that we were in compliance when in fact

074we weren't but there was sort of a general idea that we were so there's been some confusion just even for me around what this meant because we kind of presented budget that was a $6 million which I know is barely it was 6.6 or 6.9 that that was the budget I was develop a year ago um with the idea that that wasn't compliance when in fact it wasn't we ended we ended up ending the year at like 11 million which ultimately did put us in compliance but we didn't budget that so in many ways like we didn't I don't know we need some work on this I think is to my point to really get clarity about what we want and then I'm kind of hearing of this is just based on your different comments

075here then you want to see maybe revision to this policy that meet your needs as well as a longer kind of articulated plan to build back up to what you want and that we would start to anticipate making some kind of educated guesses that will kind of alter over the course of the year but that we'll have a plan that will get revised that we'll keep bringing back to this body um showing our progress towards meeting a revised policy like is that is that kind of what you're saying is like I want to see what is your goal when are we going to get to the policy that we agree on and our at least our best guess our direction of where that's happening I'd be interested in conversation I don't if you want I

076don't I don't know that I want to change the policy so I'd be be interested in if what language would be helpful in you know this um but yeah the the policy is actually on the budget the final you know the final number but I am very interested in having a f that do notes not I that's it's just I've never like the way that it was operationally understood and the way that it actually read so different in the first few months here that right I was like everybody so in your case you understand and want you current policy we a goal not a reality it's not a goal it's a policy and I think it's pretty clear I still take yes remove the still I don't think we didn't have anything that we thought

077that was the big number that was throwing it off and it made sense to do it the word outside sources makes it pretty clear that tells me that's an outside sour mark talking about money that is restricted that we're spending it that's not outside that's inside to me so um if we need to make that Cent more clear we wanted to say Skill Center I believe but I believe L came back with language around this um I know we've had some turnover in the finance department and so this was a question I had many times last year around it but there were other higher priority so if you more clear language on it I think we give that but I'm with Melissa this is no this is what we intended take the skill C out

078and 6% of what like helps now we can say that a lot better than make that was the of the budget advisory committee as welled that just to give you an idea so the restrict dat comes right now um you know close at the end of the year is about 3.5 million well the skill center was at 1.7 so there was that quite a de um that increases the the fund balance um and if we if we don't really explain that in the policy um then that moves that that question as to which which general totals we add to the to the fundal that's our Target us is that so the chart we've been using because of the tax situation the that now is tax it is not fund there is a and it it

079doesn't exclude so it includes so that is all cash in our bank account basically at mon nothing exp I think we get this get settled and get aity that was a great discussion about budget um we see I with no further business coming for the board the work s ised

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.