CorpusRecord 102585

January 9, 2025 VISD Board Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / VISD Public Meetings
Date
2025-01-10
Location
King County, WA
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,303 words · about 47 min
Collected
2026-06-14

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001talking about that absolutely um so I'm going to get us situated and oriented and um so we'll just kind of kick off I love doing introductions first and so it is the brand new year right we're pretty close to that I think we can still say Happy New Year to everybody so say Happy New Year to the folks at your table get some we be going on here and then uh we'll we'll go ahead and start introductions around the table here then over here then over here uh over and over here and then what I want you to do is your name and kind of your role you know you may have multiple roles you can say that as multiple roles um and then one word that you wouldd like to use to describe the

002upcoming year okay one word you would like to use to describe what's a year in front of us in front of us all right and then um we'll start with we'll start with uh we'll start with Oscar all right so introduce yourself your role and then one word to describe the upcoming year I I'm Oscar um my role I'm a student at ban high school and what I'm looking for or no just one word to describe in the upcoming year [Music] excited I'm junifer School Board member busy Karen James on princi cha um productive John Erikson principal at Bashon High School fun uh Tiffany Rice payroll um I wasy could be a thing uh Le M uh parent PTO president uh yeah I'm going to go busy busy here exciting I'm Anna walon I'm a

003parent and co-chair of CAC and I also this year I'm working at MC Murray as the school counselor and learning I have a lot learning that doing this year Jason Butler I'm a teacher at the high school and optimistic Julie Kangas principal here at chiaka and full had a meet well almost uh Ward I'm a school board U member and I also do a little bit of tutoring with student link um uh my name is John I'm the director of technology for the school districts and I would say my word is musical Stephanie director facilities and maintenance and I would say a word would be occupi Catherine Coleman student services is interesting uh my name is Lucia armenta I'm a school board member and my word will be create creativity and of and um I'm

004Amah I'm HR director for the district and I'm gonna say fast faster I am Jessica Adams I'm the new board member um and I would say prom my name is cor I'm student and my be Adventure Stephanie Spencer member and director of teaching and learning um opportunity and I'm just feeling envious of our young board reps looking at the snacks that they're able to place in front of them it's kind of unfair good Lisa Miller M teacher of the high school um vice president of the B Education Association and my I'm Marky fac Le and I guess I'll go with better better River we're introducing ourselves and we are using one word of uh how we would describe the year in front of us I'm River um I'm on the school board and and a

005parent of an elementary school kiddo um CH well a challenging mystery to word all right Greg M muray um one word is hopeful and my Slade my word it's going to be fun okay and so uh we'll see how much fun we can have tonight right uh but look at your people on your table these going to be your you know Patriots for the evening uh I've printed off pretty much all the documents that we're going to be using tonight and uh we're going to have some help in facilitation tonight from juniper our board chair the new elected board chair let's give her a round of [Applause] applause everybody and also let's round Applause for Jess Adams who's just come on the school [Applause] board yes thank you thank you thank you um and uh

006who's also going to be joining in tonight will probably C [Applause] fail that's right sorry Stephanie it's okay we were going to talk tomorrow train I'm also envious uh of all the snacks our uh younger folks can put down too so um we have a lot of work ahead of us tonight it's a g impact agenda and so I'm going to be your facilitator of the evening I'm going to keep us on track keep us on time and uh we and Amy is also going to be helping us out R you taking notes in our budget Advisory board agenda do so um so we have 10 minutes for the opening what should I do for the next two minutes no just kidding um we have uh essentially kind of big things we want to do

007tonight is um juder going to help us out kind of situate and Orient us around board priorities uh the board work on those uh last year it's weird to say last year but yes they did that last year and we're using their those as kind of a foundation so she's going to give us kind of a quick overview of those priorities and then during the evening we're going to be kind of reflecting back on those and kind of where we have connection between um you know the upcoming decisions around budget planning how those are connected to the board priorities and then we have some other kind of big you know not decisions to make tonight but the board's going to be on January 23rd they're going to be looking at a fund balance policy it's

008called 622 and uh we would love to the board and I would love to hear from this group um some of your feedback so we'll have some discussion around some of the totals around that fund balance policy that they're going to just second read on so taking notes around that and then also uh part of what we're going to be looking at tonight is the rings of data that that you that we've collected uh from the the survey we had some pretty good responses there was some definite concern around the kind of timing of that survey CU we just got off of the C that big CE survey um but I feel like I was really for me kind of pleased that the the responses that we got we resend it out to parents and

009staff on Monday and got some more responses and then I was able to quickly try to get those printed off for you um and then on Tuesday get the kind of the summary level feedback but we are going to have some time to look in that if you've been busy and haven't been you kind had a chance to to dig into that um there's nothing that's final tonight that's good news right we're just we're just kind of exploring having good conversations the board is is at pretty much each table um and so we'll be you know make just making sure that we um you know that we're tuned in uh and remembering those conversations and those notes for future decision making around how we're going to plan out the 2526 budget okay so um and

010specifically uh you we asked folks about just what do you need you know we asked teachers what do you need we asked families what do you need we asked students what he needs to make this experience better and in terms of mostly in terms of like targeting programs or targeting funding around kind of what would help you know our children our students have a have an amazing experience and the pr us to be able to make sure that we fulfill our our our Von promise with that being said I'm going to turn it over to to to Juniper and uh um the next document in your package it has a green bar at the top and it says board priorities so um so I had this really helpful conversation the other day with a um

011a consultant from wda the Washington State School director's Association this woman married who was really fantastic and she was saying that in her District which I think way she also serves on the Statewide um um the education uh Board of Education um that they have their board priorities really front and center on the district website and so when it comes to uh looking at budgets when it comes to making difficult decisions that um decisions may be uh unpopular difficult painful but the the board can always point to well this these decisions align with our priorities and it's not a mystery to anyone it's not news to anyone it's it's aligned with what they say they stand for um and so we looked at these back in October yes October is the answer um and I

012feel like we're not done um sharing our gratitude to Casey Alanis although we're super excited for Jess to be here Casey did a lot of heavy lifting on this with us um so it's always worth um sharing some gratitude per Direction um there's some things in here that are are nothing here is like revolutionary or um totally um out of scope of what you might expect from this particular board um but there were things in here that felt really important to us like things like in priority 2D identify mental and behavioral health issues facing our district and explore policies and practices poised to Foster healthy learning communities so that's the first time we've addressed youth effectively youth mental health and it's not just youth mental health it's also staff mental health and wellbeing those things

013feel really important to us as a group and we want to make sure that our priorities and decisions that we make on things like that um uh that we have a a document to point to collectively and so um while it's um maybe not great to be throwing this document at you and having most of you see it for the first time ever tonight we wanted to sort of offer this as um some framework that the board um spent a fair amount of time on and that we feel really strongly about the the um the decisions that we made including things like we we currently have this hasn't been made sort of in a big splashing but we do have a tentative agreement in place to um sort of uh open up some of our

014communication policies and protocols so that um for example if staff want to communicate directly to board members there's no nothing stopping them from doing so whereas previous existing policies um do prevent them from doing that so we really are looking to kind of open up uh and have as much robust and transparent um communication as we can in all directions and we feel like these Bo priorities reflect that um things like Center and Infuse anti-oppression in all facets of board workor so um or in priority 2A a shared Equity framework they're they're words that get thrown around a lot like anti-oppression and equity and things like that and maybe not everybody has the same language or the same framework around that how do we work together how do we grow in the same direction so

015that we we are are operating with the same values in the same framework um so I'm I'm not I don't necessarily think it's useful to go over these Point by Point um but I think if you can sort of have these in mind as a reference and also any board member probably with the exception of Jess can sort of talk a little bit about them I bet she could wing it and we never know she'll just seen these for the first time tonight also um uh we also use these to inform our new um uh superintendent evaluation model which um we feel really great about again use these as a um a reference and a framework for those for developing that again Casey um so we just wanted this to sort of be a piece

016we didn't want anything especially if you're seeing this at the 11th hour to sort of be either at odds with or super seed the feedback the feedback feels to me so vital from students and staff and parents and everybody in terms of what is important to them so it's not like we're saying no actually this is actually what's important not is how can this sort of set of guiding principles and these priorities um uh sort of be in conversation with or or um inform how we analyze the feedback that came through from the yes yes yeah thank you so much thank you so much um and because we're we're really I mean I think what junifer you know shared is like this values and beliefs that's going to run through the priorities and it should

017be running through you know our strategic plan and our school Improvement plan um tonight we really are going to be focused around budget planning and their first priority is fiscal solvency and sustainability because we just have a few minutes thanks student for leaving some space there look through that um a through D and I'd like you to prioritize AB C D um and give that a one two three four how would you rate those take a look at them how you rate those in terms of Priority One being your highest priority four being the the lowest priority doesn't mean that things are unimportant it just means of yourself you know take that page with the green thing on top and put a 1 two 3 4 next to the ABC D on priority yeah how

018would you in that Priority One how would you how would you just kind of if you were to do a a quick first choice what Happ you have one minute to do no just we're your neighbors [Music] serious housekeeping anytime that anyone needs to use the restroom there's a single use restroom here but then if you just go through the doors use one time only one time [Music] is I have more things to say about that but I won and then uh some uh other restrooms down the hallway towards uh towards my office okay um this where good see so how many uh chose a as their number one just take a look around take a look a little higher right so one two three four five six seven 8 9 10 11 12 okay

019so 12 wow that's a lot okay how many chose b as our number one two four five n okay how many chose c as their number one okay one feeling good about that feeling really good and then uh D who chose d as number one it was me it was just me was doing the math 25 people here okay so uh a was chosen as number one and uh can would would someone who chose a as number one just volunteer uh why they chose a as number one be bold be brave Cassie can you you want to share yes I would love to I chose it because of the sustainability all right well thank you very much okay moving we're we're early which is going to be great because I was really scared about um

020section three in our agenda so let me get to that reorient okay so section three of our agenda is really going to be us doing some diving into the data and we're going to provide some time so that you can familiarize yourself with you know the data in front of you um it may be a second read it may be a third read and no problem if it's a first read everybody so just let you know that um I'm going to just describe documents in front of you so you can kind of get an idea of what what it is that you're you know kind of going to be uh taking taking a look at and then when we're ready we're going to have some small group discussions specifically around this idea of gaps or

021areas of concern highlighted in the data um if you if you think about it the board when we're when we're together we're making decisions around budget um as capacity allows we want to make sure that we're making the right investments in the right area is and and how we're doing that is we want to make sure that staff are informing that decision that parents are informing those decisions students are informing those decisions and admin are informing those decisions and there's probably community members would be like the kind of the next level out there and that's a little that's a little harder for for district small and large to to you get community reps in here um but a lot of us because we're Islanders we're we're community members as well right so we do it's

022not like we have the PS um and so um so and then again that that what Juniper was inviting us to do is to have that board priority document kind of as a reference or side by side that if there are noticings or you're remarking like oh you know that makes sense like that's yes what we're talking about is represented you know in that board PRI doc we're grounded that way so that's kind of our our Target you know uh at the end of this 25 minutes we're going to be um we're going to have some IDE you're going to have some you know conversations in your group and you're going to hear from each other about what they saw in the data what are some of those gaps or those resource needs that that

023really aren't being met by any and all of those stakeholder groups what you have in front of you if I could uh yours and you're going to have budget needs assessment so this is the larger budget Dock and what it is it's a control print it doesn't always do everything you want when you want it to do it in terms of printing out the whole bar graph the whole chart and so um so we're going to be a little bit limited but it has what it does do is that it prints out all the comments okay it prints out all the comments and it prints out um it prints out the the pie charts really well just doesn't always do the great job with the with the bar chart this is for uh staff admin

024and parents I didn't send we we really didn't think about what it was going to be for it wasn't as intentional as I want to be with the survey with students so I I made a copy of that document and sent it out to students on Monday and Tuesday and so yeah you got that one exactly Oscar got that one and got that and so in Tuesday midafternoon or whatever I went in and I just did a data dump real quick there's more responses in there by the way and we can always that to the board um but it was nice to see kind of a a nice representation even us amongst the 30 or so kids that we got and that data is here in this document the next one is really you know

025an analysis of the open-ended respon so each constituency group was asked to give an open-ended response to a question and to two questions and so uh those responses were analyzed and then kind of you know summarized into five five top priorities and so um you'll see that staff is first then there's data around the students and then there's data around the families and then there's data around V vsi administrators and so it it basically says what the question is and then according to uh the data what the top five themes are kind that emerged from those multiple responses for those right so those are the those are the documents in front of you that you're going to be looking at there's no order so you can kind of go you know you can tiptoe through

026them as you would as you would like if you're if you like to read response by response by response you can do that you can skip to the to the summary document you know um kind of as as you please we're going to have a total of 10 minutes of just quiet contemplation you know and use your pen you know whatever you brought with you to underline take notes with notes in the margin step he's got a highlighter sorry I didn't provide highlighter I thought about that like 5 minutes before the meeting sticky notes I have downstairs raise your hand if you would like sticky notes and stuff like that I think we're going to be fine okay all right we're have an exra I just have the survey in I I think I'm some

027paper I'll come I'll come I'll come take a look at what you have yeah okay so we're going to have like 10 minutes of quiet time and then I'm going to start prompting groups for small group discussion but uh I know I know for most people they need quiet and so you may be tempted to have some discussion at your table to start talking so just hold off uh and let's respect that kind of think time hael you than for just this way very okay for for h [Applause] it's okay disappear about four minutes until we open up some discussion for yeah for more do you feel Valu now so this is going to take about a minute give you some direction your your team some directions uh so on each table I put a

028yellow piece of paper and so the first dire someone in your group is going to have to be a we're going to invite them to be the group recorder so uh you'll need to have a group of quarters and then over the next 15 minutes because we're going to break until over the next 15 minutes your group is going to have that discussion and again kind of focus gaps or areas of concern that you see highlighted in the data and the goal of your group is to have at least every person contribute to a list uh on that yellow paper and so you're going to have a reporter who's going to uh for example if Hazel points out something in the data that she sees and she like that recorded here's a gap that I

029see and a break recorder he's going to make sure that that gets written down and then we're going to make sure that everybody in team over here has their voice represented on that paper you have two three this list is not limited to just five because uh we're going to come back after the break and do some work with that so um right now you're going to have some discussion you can kind of go around the table and share out just make sure you have a recorder who's who's recording those things that are standing out to the members of your team um and uh you know this certainly not going to be exhausted these are starting points for contemplation these are not you know kind of in the in the final stages right now so

030think of these as kind of draft draft ideas so you're going to have you're going to have 15 minutes to do that and I'll give you kind of countdowns when we have 10 minutes left 5 minutes left so that we stay on kind of on track and your reporter knows that oh we haven't heard from River yet so we want to make sure that you we get you know that that no down okay and top five things from everything we've looked at but we think the top whatever standing out to you right now uh the recorder is going to say Hey you you're going to talk about it and the person make sure they write that down okay ready set go I know exactly don't be you know you want to take not know I

031knew you were G to ask that's why I did Gra langu we not top five it's not the top five one from every person so there should be at least [Music] five almost like you got you just got to have a different ml assistance we've been trying the same thing for years pretty obvious need can't have a point to high school expect them to do job oral whatever so you know it has to be [Music] Mel lot school they were just saying 33 but I know English is 36 grade you have timeis huge class that Gap is huge for my kid in seventh grade class but his is his meth is 33 your initial brain yeah so we have a and then we last year but has to go everywhere we were [Music] kind well

032kind get you get y we got it so how about we have six graders eventually graders will be [Music] Department know [Music] and I [Music] so I was think more on a on a level basis where you [Laughter] [Music] never about one minute [Music] liquid dollars liquid your Equity dollars you got anybody so trying to find that I apprciate all our great ideas but this is the first then you got to get yeah so like to me it's like this is all performance until know that's a thing we know then we got to figure out right now is 9 based on okay yeah just one quick 30 second Direction now I know some of you are still feeling at your five making sure that every member has some contribution on that paper if you have

033that already and you feel like you are ready you can start to consider prioritizing that list that you do have you can consider prioritizing the list that you do have and then you start doing ones twoos threes and fours down the list that you have in terms of what's going to be that top that top uh priority for you that top Gap that you see that your group has some consensus on so start priori that pretty challeng I was kind ofoen first one to go [Music] we have like three minutes left before we break three minutes left before we breaki [Music] anywh [Music] be M Staffing they [Music] so what you think is sort of number one but even if you have a car in the class I mean I do think that some of

034our class sizes are getting to a place where Washington St over yeah it impacts the teachers it impacts the students it impacts education I mean it's just across the board like I don't know I just think that okay everybody I get your attention back up here please your exit ticket your exit ticket to break we're going to have a 10-minute break is your team has to pick someone as your reporter okay who's going to report out in your team so that's going to be your exit ticket once you decide that then we'll come back at top of the dot 6 7:00 then we'll have 15 more minutes of activity where we're with the data so we have some more work to do so you've done a nice job right right now getting the getting the

035you know the meat out of this now we're going to start maybe thrilling down a little bit more okay once you have your reporter you can just the break come back have five and then eventually you will start to try prior to get we hav you don't need do anything right now but have a Rec repor out there is I me I don't see it I mean un I mean just class Manasses I've beening time this for me these two for me create [Music] exp I would rather have easier have class of 25 [Music] stud work work so we had better systems here to take that workload no idea my what are the best practices what are the best practic because you know you have so let's say you have some kids are on fourth

036grade level some kids that are on and then throw on top of that it's just I think that these things not necessarily whatever whatever the best practi I don't I'm just saying without a lack of a system of ml supports it real system that every time we're going to do x y and know we don't have now so if I got a skin I got a this certainly does but if we had these two things in place few more K that's [Music] just came from dve [Music] there we go done done yeah and then exactly analy what I'm but because of what's going onsu still iade Year big job have a bunch of first graders another that's why systems are easier turn into longterm as [Music] oppos I know we have some here share not

037minute everybody I know that makes sense I just think that like the thing is that school district TR to Pride themselves private schools is that teachers to right they know that it's a better Environ $24,000 it's like welcome back welcome back welcome back see can for I appreciate it thank you w for bringing your attention back to the center of the room appreciate it thank you m James thank you Mr ER thank you Miss Mr appreciate it appreciate your attention back up here uh we have 50 minutes so what we're going to do our next kind of round through this I saw most of you kind of start to thank you Mr ER for your attention to the front appreciate it uh so most of you extended that conversation that discussion and I hope you

038found that that that really helpful and so um and I hope you finding the Oreos helpful as well um I'm just listening and watching everybody here and I'm just thinking I'm still just kind of in full of gratitude that we have you know all the budget advisor board members with the board members this is kind of I think the first time we've done that and so that's that's pretty incredible so just much much appreciation about that and I can't remember which board member had the idea of doing this but um was it you junifer it was probably me I think it was you River um so you do have a list now uh that's kind of um in in rough form May some there may been some refinement to it um you're going to have

039just two minutes right now to to to boil it down and come up with your c a top three and then your reporter is going to have your reporter is then going to have you know we're going to have one two three four five we're going to have two minutes your repor is going to have two minutes to share what the top three are and I'm going to kind of have a timer on here like we do you know kind of public comment right going to go go off when it when 2 minutes is done and all you're doing is just sharing your top three you're just sharing your top three that that kind of came up that bubbled up for your group um I know that each one of you could could probably give

040a five minute you know kind of explanation around each one of those top three uh items we're going to kind of save that uh for some future uh deliberation so we want to end at 7:15 right now with hearing from every group your top three if you take less than that's um you that's fine too and we have 1 2 3 four five so we're we're going to wind it back around Miss [Music] Miller who's your reporter okay your top three can I ask uh just so that we can all here you please stand up for us thank sweet number one um we just said do support in general so tier two tier three supports so that's ml what Staffing or training that's that's kind of our number one number two adequate Staffing um so

041that we can stay on top of and maybe ahead of rather than trying to fill in adequate Staffing and that's for both teaching so all teaching facilities Paris district office you name it any program and then the third one is program offerings um both in terms of like courses offered in our system and programs and then tied into that is the class sizes and safety and actually taking a look and seeing where some programs might take more and some programs get by fewer students so that was it this still have to go in order either so uh but let's go let's just keep it predictable predict all right wow coming up you started a TR starting with threey language said all that encompassing in there number two being enhanced Core Curriculum specifically I think we

042we saw a lot about the science and language departments needing a little bit more CRI there and number three being enhanced teacher collaboration thanks Stephie let's appuse if we didn't do we do it for you that way or are you ready I know we we didn't get a chance to under one minute we can give our not I don't Haven talk uh supporting uh multilanguage Learners um and by that through the staff and um student support access to counseling increasing smaller class sizes the tier 2 reading math reading and math writing Behavior languages at the high school um and McMurray um in increasing um availability and more advanced classes there AP and advanced classes um ability to support mury in terms of behavior safety discipline after school programs professional development trainings um what did I

043miss uh and the individual ability to supplement classroom I'm sure there were themes running through those that's great all right so really as I'm hearing all of you go around we could consolidate ours first one multilingual tier 2 additional um support for students needing that support so that was one um and class size that that was another one and then talking about staff increases so that could affect class size if it's certificated staff uh in facilities in HR in all of the places that support and uplift um and those are our three and or nvp at the middle school too that was staff thank very much J and group one yeah instead of following the directions we ended up having a lively philosophical conversation that um uh ranged from discussing some of the um endemic

044issues in the in the public school system that we all inhabit and proudly so uh we talked about research base for um you know some of these competing um initiatives or ideas and um even talked about uh whether or not uh making decisions based on what's good for students or what's good for teachers or is that a false that cing there um in terms of something a little bit more concrete we did talk about um requests for additional support um for tier 2 and tier three including smaller class sizes uh more admin assistant uh at uh McMurray um and more challenging classes and um more time that was something we came up with we'd like to have more time okay slow rotation and everyone really came under 2 minutes that was really like that was

045that was amazing and um you know I I did raise your hand if you heard something that surprised you wow okay so right so I didn't hear any I didn't really hear any kind of like things that was like wow that's but I I did start to hear some concentrated scenes you know around uh Services class sizes Staffing um we you know kind of when you're in the system um you know that these inequities exist we know the Gap funding exist for the state by the way want to give you heads up um our students two out of three of them were able to uh make time and their busy schedule can handle uh we do have two students who are in competition this uh this weekend so Hazel's in a in a in a

046wrestling competition was is not able to join us for the legislative conference which uh Martha uh and cor and Oscar will be going with us to to really start to you know lobby with our legislators and organiz and try to address these these issues you kind of at the source but I heard some conversation earlier like wow you know is this just a an performative exercise you know like unless we uh yes it is sorry Jason so this this just Jason said you can quote me I know so yeah we get to mess around with bit so the um you know is this just a performative exercise because typically school districts don't have extra money to spend on things right and so we're really trying to be more proactive we're you kind of doing our

047budgeting cycle earlier um we have great support from the PSD you know we're in a in a you know unique position where we where we could you know trans you know transferred out a lot of that institutional knowledge but we're bringing it back in and we have some good recet here and so what will that mean when we start really getting further down into the budget planning process related to that is you know is going to be our next discussion around fund balance because you know you kind of have to know your fund balance where you're going to stand and then all your materials supplies and operation cost and your Staffing cost and then what's left over as capacity allows that's when we start to you know once we get the minimum funded or what

048we feel is one of our minimum benchmarks then we ask capacity allows the I would like the board to have some idea and myself in administration some idea about okay if we're going to we know all these gaps exist like nothing was new that we heard we know that there are gaps how do we start to prioritize you know uh capacity once if if we if we see that capacity materialized and so these are going to be intense conversations you know um the board is anticipating taking action I would be recommending that they take action on a fund balance policy um but that fund balance policy plays into some of the decisions around uh providing any set asides you pulling aside any any set aside dollars for additional funding for programm and so um everything

049is inter play with everything and and that means we have to be mindful have have to have the best information possible for us and have to hear when the opportunity presents itself from stakeholders to see kind of what you're thinking um so that the board can then come to some of those very difficult uh decisions um and admin with those very difficult recommendations so um that's where we're headed and so uh I'm going to kind of what I'd like you to do right now is take a look we're going to start moving into section five of our agenda unbalance policy Proposal review and feedback so once again know you have two documents they were the last two documents in your in your packet one of them uh John can you hold up your chart for

050everybody to see what they're looking for in their packet we looking for the chart one table yep the table yep so everyone's looking for a table Y show your people table table and then you're also looking for a draft policy great can you show that it says draft on no Stephanie make sure that make sure everybody at your table is looking at the right document a water on there you go and so um what uh what I'm going to do is I'm going to turn it over to to Cassie who's going to um do some orientation on these documents um I'll be kind of pitching in as needed or Amy will be pitching in as needed but I'm turn it over to you [Applause] [Laughter] yes boost she told me I was crapping too much

051for the whole meeting so exct so this document here if you um look towards the bottom um you can see what we would have needed to set aside if we had done 25 days 30 days and 35 days cash on hand um so that's just kind of a good visual to show you um what it would have been in previous years I also just want to highlight that we don't have really good historical cash flow data so it makes it a little bit harder for us to pinpoint what the days of cash on hand looks like um but we do know it's between 25 and 35 days um so we know you know the max is going to be 35 days is probably where we would want to max out at um and also just

052keeping in mind that when we're talking about cash flow that really is likeing about what the bank account for the district is so we need to make sure that we have enough um cash on hand to meet our obligations which is going to be payroll and then paying all of our bills and we want to be able to do that without having to borrow from any of our other funds um so in any given month we need to be able to make our payroll and we need to U make sure that we can keep the lights on in all of our buildings um and just kind of aligning with the the board priority document um the fund balance is going to have a focus onization and suain ability so those are just kind of some

053big points if you have questions let me know [Music] or so Cassy have a question um I'm trying to read this correctly so for instance and and take any of the 25 30 days um is this on the far right side what we would need per month or uh per year or per annual annual okay yep all right I just wanted to make sure and this is exactly the same document that we used at the December board meeting yeah yeah and I just want to make sure that this is this is for the entire this was 23 24 so for 2425 uh right we only so we only have a couple of months of data so so I mean I guess what I would say is is uh do we add 5% to that 1%

054to that what do you think in terms of uh just sort of a very conservative estimate on inflation but inflation is now at 3% if I'm correct so one would one add 3% to that and I'm just trying to be common sense here right and I think um Justin would say kind of in that situation and um we don't have the magic number like there's no formula that can really tell us exactly where we need to be so I don't know that looking at it from a percentage SC points going to give us all the information that we have um but because of the way a portion is coming to us each month in a different percentage we have to make sure that our cash flow is enough so that we can you know pay

055all of those obligations and then just I'm learning all this stuff but I I remember from last year what's the what's your minimum fund balance that you have that percentage wise or days wise right so that minimum fund balance was was initially set as a Target at 5% okay and with all and and a target of 6 and a half% okay so minimum of 5% and a target of 6 and a half% can you talk about the doing days versus percentages one way or the other you want to talk to that yeah so if you think about um 35 days 30 days 25 days just quickly what this number means right here is that we kind of given our current projections of revenues and expenditures uh you know ESD and Cassie are projecting that if

056we wanted the 35 day cash on hand we would have to under extend you know kind of decrease our expenditures by about $29,000 um and this 35 days is about a 99.6% fund balance more or less more or less um this right here 30 days if you take a look at it IT projects that if we went down to a 30-day cash on hand um this would come out to a 8.3% about 8.3% bance and then this the last one uh which is a lower amount of cash on hand would be around 6.9% um but as you can see the you know when we get down to 25 days and I think Martha you may you may have heard this but um our regular payroll is about 1.8 1.9 so this is this is kind

057of where we you know kind of the the minimum that's why we don't see any projections lower of cash on hand and what cash on hand does it's a again a way of looking at what savings do you have in the bank so it's unassigned it's it's money that you can just pull out and use um and Ty Al again those low portion months of like April December or something um we we you we you you probably know them better than I what months they are what April's a April's a good month October and April are good months February's terrible June is awful uh July August are awesome 25% of your annual revenue come in in summer months when nobody's here to spend money yeah and what the reason why the state does that they

058like to keep the money they they gain interest on it and then they kick it out to us you know but you're also getting your um local Levy abortion mins in October and April so they they feel less compelled to give you their full allotment because you just got a bunch of money from a different resource assuming everybody pays their property test and right now the ESD um and Cassie have a have a a cash on hand projection tool that we're going to be using to more accurately look at you know that cash that cash balance on a monthly basis feel like in meeting with Justin that he like what I understood him to say was that he was really going to analyze our finances and be able to give a recommendation for the number

059of days and has that recommendation come in or yeah yeah you know we we'll hear more from him but he's initially um targeted 30 okay he's initially put a kind of a you know a little bit you know uh I would say that you know when when given the uncertainties of ipd and interest inflation and the implicit price ofl or Cola as we you used to call it um yes our business office and the ESD are going to have a budgeted projection like that's going to be that's what a budget is it's just a projection so they are going to you know we're not going to wait until the end of the legislative session and then the month that it takes for the you know the whatever rule making or rules the legislators make to

060go to Opi and then they finally it to us uh you know one month later we won't be waiting for that because this legislative session goes it's a longer session um and especially with the you know the budget shortfall that if you just heard Ferguson talk about you know you're trying to cut you know programs in you know in the state each by 6 and a half% to to buffer the 12 billion funding Gap that they have so you know this is not going to be a year where where we probably expecting a lot of extra money for education um that being said um you know we want to position ourselves and as Justin Cassie talked about that kind of fiscal stabilization is going to be um Paramount to us and going to be part

061of that kind of foundation making those recommendations to the board so um you know and the n and a half% uh is what you see in the current uh document um the policy of 6022 um and when you when you take a look at that uh that document actually is a um is a an artifact from Sun Bon Lake um so we looked at like five different uh fun fund balance policies and what we really liked about the sun Bonnie Lake policy which we made a recommendation to the board at December 19th meeting for first read is that it really outlines the purpose of why you of why you have an unreserved or unassigned unbalance so again we're starting to see districts looking instead of a percentage um you know cash on hand seems to

062be a metric that that that we feel that I like um and that that gives me a much clearer way to go okay you know now I now I kind of know how much unassigned monies do I have if we have an unexpected expense or if we have uh you know in I'll just tell you in Sun Bon Lake you'll see what does it say fire what does it say um fire earth yeah and so fire earthquake in Su b l is said Bahar so so I thought tsunami would be the kind of the appropriate you do see some tsunami warning times on the island but really what it means is some type of you know kind of national you know natural disaster so so when we talk about a 99.5% multiplier what number are

063we using as the multiplier is it the uh the is it the budget for the for that upcoming school year no it's that 23 24 number that 26 no no no I'm saying you want so so what you're asking for is to have a 9.5% fund balance based on what number 9.5% 99.5% of what what are we it's not revenues it's revenues expenditures expenditures expenditures this from the previous year yeah that that's what we're working for right now okay no no we're going to we're going to estimate we're going to use a 99.5% fund balance minimum okay and all I'm asking is what number are we multiplying by 99.5% every year because we're going to do this every single year right right so so the expenditures from the previous from the previous years okay so

064we're going to take 23 24 expenditures and we're going to base our fund balance on the previous year's expenditures okay so we're always going to kind of be a year behind our fund balance is always going to kind of be based on numbers from the once we once we set it in place then we can then we can lock it no I understand that the current Cent so as the budgets being built okay um as you look forward to where you're putting in your anticipated ending fund balance in the year that anticipated ending funding balance would be 9.5% of the revenues right so so we're either going to okay no I get it but I'm just trying to go okay so if we agree that we're going to have 99.5% in an unassigned Reserve account

065every single year every single year the the unreserved fund balance is going to increase because every single year either the budget increases the expenditures increase uh the revenues increase some number increases I'm just trying to really figure out what number are we using to to figure out the un assigned fund balance if it's previous year's um expend it's not previous year's expenditures it's so it's budgeted expenditures for the next year okay so it's our it's our total budget so 99.5% so our total budget of 2425 is about 27.1 million okay that's what I'm saying so whenever we come out and we say we have an expected budget of 28 million I'm going to go back and go okay what's 9.5% of 28 million and then I'm going to look at what our current fund balance

066is and I'll see a gap and so that Gap so if we have this as a Schoolboard policy we're going to have to make sure that Gap is filled right yes so so we're locking I'm just saying we're locking ourselves into a minimum fund balance of 9.5% on a budgeted on a on a on the next year's budget which is fine fine the practice has changed no I understand that but the 9.5% has changed because before it was five as a minimum 6.5 a Target now we're locking it in 9.5 locking it in we can change it truly at any time it's in 6 months Boy so this isn't like we're locked in the 99.5% for the foreseeable future until we decide we're not locked in for 20 I hope not no really at any

067time the board can revisit this if we get new information if all of a sudden there's some Dr change in EN if we just look at um increases of I think Martha's question was good what's like what kind of part is our expected increase budget every year on year it's around 2 and half 3% right so I think that's what Martha was asking and so now we project out okay if if if I'm going to have to add 3% on a 2574 then that's my next year minimum fund bance at 9.5% right and then I go on another 3% and another 3% that number gets bigger and bigger and more actually more difficult to obtain I'm going to draw it back draw back so well we are what we're what we're contemplating uh the board

068is contemplating basically three models right here a 35 day 30-day and 25 day you know uh cash on hand balance and as you know this is around a 9.6 so close to that you kind of draft policy level um the 8.2 or three and then the 6.9 so as what what I'd like you to do at your table is as you increase your fund balance your ability to you know kind of provide fiscal stabilization okay there are you kind of pros and cons and so part of uh what we're going to be doing in the in your small group discussion we have about 10 minutes still to do it is kind of what are strengths of having a strong fund balance what are concerns you know what are the tradeoff um or potential impacts when

069you have you know a higher fund balance versus a lower fund balance so I want our I want kind of as because the board's in contemplation of this and as as a group of stakeholders you know when you think about where you see fund balance policy or cash on hand unassigned you know money in the bank what do you see as a potential pros and cons for these three different models 35 days 30 days and 20 days so you're going to have 5 minutes at your table and you don't necessarily need to write this down but we are going to we are going to share out in in a whole group so so right so that would be okay I mean the Delta is well actually it's 209 plus so the difference is you get

070so so if you go with 35 days you're short 209 630 so to achieve 39 days you have to find $29,000 if you if you well actually it's the difference because Years A Plus yeah I mean yeah you're top 10 I mean it's probably $125,000 with all the other stuff distri I always always think of a teacher like 125,000 the administrator 16000 but I guess my only concern is this this thing I love this number this percent Chang you can see let's just assume this revenues are are costed here 23 million 24 million 23 27 going up this number is going to be multipli so so that means less more money and then we minimum was saying this is a bad idea I just want I just I would just prefer like this is what

071I think is the best thing to have here here are some of theice you do Pro is like that sustainability or that security and the con is on other things over the moon and so it's it's great but it doesn't come when [Music] like what's more important right or do you find the middle ground 30 de [Music] not [Music] 9 it's like you know got and all like we don't do this now everybody quick second Fork interesting perfect thank you a 30 second Direction uh now that you've had some pretty you know strong conversation around pros and cons um I would like the recorder to write at least one pro one con and then we will be sharing that you're welcome to write more than one pro one con but we're going to have four

072minutes or so just to solidify your thinking at your table on that piece of paper which is going to go to the board um we're going to click one pro and at least one con for you know what you see in your discussion around 35 30 25 you know share your thinking please share your thinking show your all right we have minutes like this this PRI this is the board like these two things that are this is what which means you're saying these are great priorities but they [Music] are years after un states of Amica Canada can become the you guys you know stability ability to sure whatever here don't minut minut we're start with table three this time start this time [Music] no it was taken away put counsel MC I was I'm only

073years but I was told that when the vice princial went away that's [Music] thankar [Music] um did you guys hear the one about the superintendent that fell down the well he didn't see [Music] that're getting we're keeping going all right um let's go ahead and hear from table three and four and five and one and two and do kind of a short summary of pros and cons how have you approached it with any of those three numbers or all three uh there's a unanimous recommendation for the 30 days um and the pros being that the um given that funding streams are shifting that this uh positions us to adapt better so it's more stabilizing versus being in a reactive decisionmaking position uh and that bills will be paid um the con being that um it's

074it's a minimum for sustainability it's less of a cushion um um less less immediate access to money for IMX and other other aspects such such as that days and the we were bills and we don't have to borrow money from other programs and our was it does tie up a bit of money that we use but it's not as M as doing some compar thank you didn't the wer to recomend you to a recommendation but um I'm glad your your team is doing that so but it's not the expectations just want to to say that well we also focused on the 30-day because um we thought it was best choice for financial stability give us money for all expenses but also give us a little bit of money to build program like designate it to

075specific things but we also came up with our own option as to because it doesn't give you quite as much money to designate so we with a 29 Day [Music] Option One I'm veryy I just learned how this all works thanks to my table um and what I'm realizing is that I think uh 25 days sounds really nice because it seems like we have a lot of other things that we could use the 500,000 for in our district um and it's still an increase on what we've had before we're at 5% right um previous [Applause] so we were at 30 days with an 8.3% um but I like the 29 so the pro for the higher the percentage is fiscal stability the con is lack for of support for students um teachers Paras custodians and

076everybody so that's it in a nutshell we're we're at a good point right here where I just want to kind of offer a reflection I was at the middle school um sharing I think just doing the my listening session and one thing that I that I heard and that we spoke about was everybody's kind of experience with finances in this room personally you know is probably different than everybody at your table there's probably some things the same some things are different some of us grew up um in different you know different ways and different experiences different neighborhoods different countries right and when you think about uh you know a group of five coming to a consensus around one way to try to allocate resources to kids um and teachers and parents and and our community

077it's just really difficult because you know everybody in this room has different risk tolerance right and we heard you know kind of here and here and here and here you know there just lots of lots of difference but what I want us to really contemplate consider as we as we leave tonight is that um um I don't I didn't hear that there was anyone in this room who said we think our kids should get less or our teacher should get less or our family should get less and so um you know it's it's really a matter of making some very tough decisions and and making sure that they are aligned with our strategic plan with the board priorities with the work that we're doing and so um um I'm going to speak on behalf of

078me um but then I'm going to actually just maybe put either Martha or or Juniper or any of our board members on the spot to kind of close our our meeting tonight um we have a lot of great information from you around you kind of things that you're prioritizing things that stood out to you in the data there's going to be more data and that'll be you know shared further with you and the board um we're going to have a kind of a feedback session for tonight where I'm going to send just to how did tonight go um I again appreciate you being here for a couple hours to to share your experiences and your thoughts and your own contemplations around this budgeting process um My Hope Is that we just do a little bit

079better every year you know um practice doesn't make perfect practice just hopefully makes it better and so this is really good practice for us exercising the muscle I want to um you know end by some appreciation for a for taking notes and that by the advisor board document for us for our business department and for again our new board member for just jumping in you saw her standing up here and and privately just want to let you know I told jti this the other day um I had some rodent damage in my truck twice yeah it cost me $1900 to get this fixed the Titus will no joke two times and we're in the the board's awake and you know kind of deliberating on what you know what what which one of our amazing candidates

080you know are they going to be appointing and we're just having a conversation and I forget how it came up but just said no that's covered under comprehensive and uh I was like oh crap and so anyway um I just want to say thank you $1,800 I'm already saving money in the so so you know making a difference is making a difference is really our theme for the year and I and I and I promise you kind of my invitation tonight you know food and snacks but I also promis you that you'd be making a difference and I hope that you have uh felt that way uh by the feedback that you're providing board tonight so I'll let uh let one of you two send us out well I've been appointed by junifer first thank

081you so much I know what it's like after a long long day of work for all of you to put on in another two hours this is greatly appreciated I want to thank each and every one of you who did fill out the assessment um and the people who collated it all um I'm hoping next year we get even more people um doing this you've got a board that really wants to hear from each and every one of you and each and every department and the more um information we get the better we can try to do our jobs um we do not want to screw this up I mean that's just really honest we want to do the very best job we can um and I've been just totally grateful that you all came

082thank you so much all right make sure you think everybody your table and then we are dismissed [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.