CorpusRecord 103285

SASD Board Meeting Tuesday February 11th 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Sheboygan Area School District
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Sheboygan County, WI
Material
Transcript
Extent
3,130 words · about 18 min
Collected
2026-06-11

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I remember they by Lake I remember we invited a couple years [Music] probably not good the worst that's great so jie pretty rude oh exactly ready I call to order the committee of the whole pledge of allegiance of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation another God indivisible with liy and justice for all I seek approval of the agenda so move second all in favor and chair votes I motion carries roll call finds us here except for Miss ree Harrison on to number five under Section 117.1 2 and 3 of the Wisconsin statutes render decision on petition to alter School District boundaries of the school district and this is Dr Hine and Mr Bel um so this agenda item was on the finance committee tonight um we

002also had it on the full board because we wanted the give the um land owner there that's petitioning to change District boundaries a chance to speak to the full board which is required but we felt he should probably speak to the finance committee first as they're going to make a recommendation so they did speak to the finance committee um and the finance committee did uh vote to deny that uh petition um the family afterwards decided not to speak to the full board so they're not to speak here so I don't know if you want to add anything it was very nice the father spoke um to us and explained to us what the reasons were that they were seeking that and um um upon discussion the committee uh recommended based also on the administration's recommendation

003to deny the petition and um so the committee's recommendation was to deny and that was moved and approved just for everyone's information I spoke with him afterwards for for quite a while as well um part of this is an issue of special ed and open enrollment so they're facing caps in Newberg the same way we're facing caps here um and that can relate to the the issues he's having with school choice so I understand that um the other piece is it it was uncertain at best if user would accept it themselves because user just became aware that if they take on that property they would likely have to provide transportation to uh Shan Lutheran which would obviously be a huge cost to that District so um I know it was hard for you guys to

004say no so don't feel like you are the only ones uh it probably wasn't going to go through it now and he understood that and that's why he chose not to to move forward with it did is he resending his court request or is it just I don't think he is I just think he he felt like it wasn't worth the time we don't need to take it out we we we would need to deny it okay thank you so the action is to deny the petition so is there a motion second any other discussion all in favor vot I motion carries pardon me second Friday please miss LMA yes um so second Friday we conducted our membership count on January the 10th um what you'll see in your board packet is you'll have some

005slides that are pulled over to the presentation from third Friday so that's just a repeat of the data from third Friday what I am going to do is just kind of talk you through two slides that are specific to Second Friday um so we'll go ahead and that's page three in your packet if you want to follow along um so basically what this graph is showing is is um our I want to make sure I have this right yep so it's showing our enrollment um on third Friday in September compared to Second Friday in January over the past 5 years so you can kind of see it starting in 2020 to 2021 and then ending in 2024 to 2025 um the trend line shows you that the decline is um minimal but it it is

006happening and it's a steady decline over time when we dig a little deeper and we actually compare second Friday over time so you're kind of looking at that second row of each section for second Friday we're comparing that um year over-year so when you're looking get that what you'll see is that in 2020 2021 we had 9,573 students if you compare that to this year's second Friday it was 9,3 19 students so over that period of four academic years a decrease of 254 students um and then when we compare just if we compare um second Friday sorry I got a little caught up in my notes here just make sure I explain this correctly yep so we're looking at second Friday to Second Friday so you're looking at again that second row um in each

007section the most noticeable decline was 98 students if we're looking at last year in comparison to this year so that 9,414 students in comparison to 9,319 students so just want to point out some highlights from the data you'll get the final um takeaway here which is that we're only down um for students from third Friday but I want to still talk through some of the data points so I'm going to move you ahead like I said these slides are a pullover from third Friday so you've seen this data before I've highlighted the key takeaways in this data previously at that third Friday report so we're going to go to the last um table and what you're seeing here is that we are comparing our membership count so you can see it by grades you can

008see it by schools over time and this is what our count was for second Friday there's a slight fluctuation across schools um if you're kind of looking at it across this year so third Friday in comparison to Second Friday so that last column kind of shows you what the difference is but when you dig into that data what you'll see is we only had um 11 actually seven schools that had a fluctuation of 10 students up or down okay so I think that just again shows that there is some fluctuation from third Friday to Second Friday but it is normal when we look back over previous years and it's not a lot happening from school to school and much of that can be attributed to students coming and leaving the district over the course of

009the year um so ultimately what I wanted to share is if you look at that very last roll where it says total I know the print is small on the side but you do have it in your packet you will see that our third Friday count was 9,323 students and then second Friday came in at 9,319 students so down by four from um third Friday of this year so again it's it remains um steady overall yes um you have second Friday 2025 and then you have third Friday 2024 was there a reason why you didn't compare second Friday and second Friday that's a great we could we did actually we're comparing that on that previous side I I sent I I um provided for you but I had to when I was going through the

010data my brain play plays a little bit of a trick on me right we're comparing this year so the change over this year so when we did third Friday in September to this year and this is what we've done in previous years but sue if you go back to that first slide I showed you if you wanted yeah I was just looking at that between the third Friday and the second Friday you know from last year to this year you know I get it you know from one Friday to the other Friday somebody's absent or whatever but I thought if you compare apples to apples right because you're right if you did third the third Friday 2024 and then the third Friday 2324 you know 20 students or whatever so if the board wants us

011to make a change to that next year we absolutely can't I use a template that we used for previous years but so if we take a look at this table you can actually see it right so if we compare second Friday from last school year so this time last year it was 9,414 students and this year is 9,319 students so that's that difference that I highlighted of 98 students if we go back if we look at the previous year and we're looking at um the third Friday if you go to that slide Rachel what's important from in my opinion on a board accountability standpoint is if you flash forward you mean the last one y is a clicker struggling um don't you here just need press a little bo accountability standpoint is that you're able

012to compare within the year right so if you see something there that is out of the normal you're going to ask questions about that school right so all of a sudden if you see that South High School goes down 300 kids uh from third Friday to Second Friday you're going to want to know why there was a mass Exodus out of the school um so that's the importance of of that slide really what it doesn't show you is that South High School was down six kids they probably had 150 kids come and go and it just netted out at six the the transiency in our district is is is very high in some of our schools and that doesn't necessarily get reflected in here um It's A Hard number to to calculate during the year

013um but that's an interesting number otherwise what's what's always good about this slide I think is you're seeing some growth at the ELC um and you can kind of see where where things are fluctuating so um it just allows you to look at that North High School's down 24 kids you might question that and then you start looking into it and okay they have some early grads that makes sense we can account for that Central's up 11 so I'm sure some of those kids from North and South transferred to Central for credit recovery purposes Etc so that's what we work through um with this type of thing the other piece I would just add to this is it's really hard to get uh second Friday comparisons across other districts until a little later in the

014year when DPI collects that data and puts it out there publicly but Jamesville is always a good comparable for us um they were down I think 32 kids something in that range um so we're feeling pretty good to be down four and that's what you saw with our Moody's rating um they're always looking at enrollment across districts and they were very pleased to see declining enrollment never feels good but they are very pleased to see the level of decline here compared to other urban districts I felt we were hanging pretty tight just to follow up I I don't know if I'm missing Rachel but why wouldn't we instead of doing the third Friday I'm sorry at 2024 do the second Friday of 2024 I mean what's the difference which ones do we send into DPI

015the second Friday or the third Friday we actually send both in so when we do the count in September we report that and then we also report it with this most recent count um so sue we're just kind of we just decided right that we're comparing across the year so that you can see the change over the course of the school year um but we do have that data that you're talking about right like if you want to compare I'm looking at it yeah because our numbers look actually better the second Fridays so in you know like second Friday 2024 if we use those numbers to compare this year right when does the State ask yeah just third Friday is everything for us second Friday we use a little bit for title um but third

016Friday is what you get funded on just because we haven't gotten to the third Friday yet for for the school year that we're not comping those students no we haven't so third Friday's in September yeah so we've already done it for this for this school year yeah so we're looking at this school year that's the only thing I would suggest I don't know Jake if there's a reason why we throw those numbers differently between second and third instead of just saying if we're going to do the second Friday stats then for each year we use the second Friday stats but we want to know what's happening within one year right like who's coming and going right because you're using different Fridays and the numbers are different quite a bit to compare apples and apples right

017am I missing something guys or I I think so I think like it's two different it's two different issues two different data points right so if what we need to know is what is happening in our district this year where are kids going mhm then we would need the September third Friday to recent second Friday to make that determination keep it the same yes Mary just to stir the pot Okay I uh briefly but briefly so it's my understanding that the mark of a student who one of the marks of a student who may really struggle to learn is transients um leaving one school and going to another school to another school do we keep track of that we do I guess it's a matter of how we're keeping track of it right like when

018I think about our system right when I think about our schools and who's in our schools and who leads our schools so like our administrators our social workers those folks if a student is moving from one school to another there's some coordination between those schools to be able to provide some continuity and then construction and support is that what you're getting at I'm I'm I'm just wondering um because a lot of our schools are really pretty high um in low socio economic status and I'm just wondering I mean it would be an interesting not to say that it needs to be created or whatever but it's just an interesting data point that um we had 50 students who transferred to three different schools and um because and I know the district is looking at those

019in terms of you know those are the kids that are going to probably have you know a lot of issues and I'm just wondering if we're a high transfer transient population or and no need to answer that now or to create the data if they don't exist but I just I would say we have the data right it's probably in many different places and many different groups are looking at it for sure we can get that to the I'd be interested too and it's probably something that we should be aware of and talk about on an annual basis across our schools it's not all that hard to to pull we've pulled it before for individual schools and we looking at Improvement plans and things um but I think it would be good for the board

020and good for the public to see evictions and depending you know on a broader definition of homelessness and kids just moving from house to house or sofa to sofa or from one apartment to the next apartment and and and that sort of thing is just such a key indicator um and I think that happens in sh and you know it's been kind of my experience and so yeah just just wondering there's definitely movement for sure I mean I think that's definitely worth sharing with the public on some level because it does affect student achievement and if you look at the wealthier communities in sh and County where there's a higher instance of our students living in homes that their parents own there's much less movement than otherwise if you look Beyond us anecdotally one of

021my good friends has a daughter who teaches in Milwaukee Public Schools third grade last year at the end of the school year she had only three children in her classroom would have been there the entire year and if you don't think that that that makes the hair on my arm stand up you know I would think you're not being I did have one number question now the only the only number that stood up to me was swagan leadership which is like down to 208 was a drop of 15 students percentage why is that's a big one are we looking into why that's happening or what are we doing about that I don't know that I can say I've looked into it but it's caught my eye as well so obviously for them it's a it's

022a problem from a funding side of things too they're non instrumentality for people um and probably raises some concerns there but it's something we should probably look I had it highlighted on my paper as well thank you for that it could be that a whole bunch of kids got sick you know that spread that it spread through the school you know that too you never know Peter just one of the slides that is in the packet uh is the census how much of of uh these ships are simply available customers and I see that the the place where the 2020 sensor was higher was in the overall population and in the under five but it was lower so is that a little bulge that we should see moving through the system yeah so I'm just

023looking back at my notes from third Friday so the point you're making is that the overall population in the county increase um but the under five population and the under 18 population decrease so that's could be an indication of what that looks like in the future right like if we have fewer um 5y olds and 18 year olds but what we're seeing is that there is that decline but it's a St it's a slow decline right like it's not a steep decline um so the last senses information we have is from 2020 and we know the next one doesn't come out until 2030 um there are other sources for us to be able to get data and kind of make those projections out into the future when do you take this this raw data and

024say all right we have under 18 here's the percentage from the Census how that matches up to the number of under 18 students we have yeah so the system the reason we put that on there a few years ago and I wanted it there was to help explain I can remember that presentation and it's getting at what you're getting at it was like a 5% drop or something and we weren't seen that large of a drop in our schools so we were feeling good uh essentially I think at that time we were educating about half the kids in the county um and we weren't seeing that drop and then that's why we put all the other districts on there too so we could kind of compare and see where it was happening um if we're

025interested in this I and time allows at a future meeting I think gubo put out a really really nice uh slideshow on declining enrollment in the effects um that we could certainly throw up and and walk you through um and essentially what we're seeing right now is if you look at our 4K at 559 that's a pretty scary number um when you look at all the other classes right so we had a 601 there in first grade but other than that our classes are typically you know mid 600s or larger uh to come in at a 559 this year was troubling and then when we didn't see anything out of the ordinary for open enrollment out or we didn't see anything out of the ordinary for voucher enrollment it became it felt like okay it's

026not us uh but what we found out from the WBO presentation was 2020 was the lowest birth rates on record in the in the US 21 it slightly came up and now 2022 they think it's going back down uh and they're they're collecting that data still it takes time but if 559 becomes more of the norm um that's a concern and you're watching districts like Appleton Green Bay lacrosse Wasa Etc go through a lot of pain as they try to decide how to right size and if they should be closing down some schools and they closing and their building at the same ashkash is in a in a difficult spot right now um that's probably something that we need to have on our radar and just be looking at a little bit do we have

027the capability of tracking folks that leave the district and whether it's by choice or you know circumstance beyond their control I don't know if there's a way to engage at that level or make educated guesses that could yeah I mean you can track if they go to a voucher school you can track if they um school choice out versus if they move right so understanding who's yeah who's who's going to a different School in the area versus who Moved States versus who fell off the grid right so and you'll see that if you I forget Ally when you came on board I'm sure it was after third Friday but if you look and we can get you that third Friday report that's only report out on voucher enrollment and uh open enrollment ins and outs

028so those would be the ones that are choosing to leave everyone else is essentially moving okay away it's hard to know if a family moves to Falls because of the school I don't I don't think that happens often that wouldn't be accounted for um and really the way the state has it now that if students move from public school to Public School uh their ID number state ID number stays with them so you can track that um but if they move out of state then it's called a to a transfer out of state and you can't track them any longer but that's why for like graduation rates um if we have a student move in in 12th grade and they come to school for one day and they never show up again they count against

029us for uh for grad rate so that's kind of how that tracking works across the state um so Rachel Dr hin um just pointed out that there is some discrepancy between two of the the slides um and it would be I wish they had numbers on them the enrollment count Trends number three out of eight three out of eight yeah three out of eight the 2324 second Friday lists 9414 and then the slide just below it this shaben for 2324 at 9427 all the other scores are right you have that consistency except for that one so and that makes a difference I'm not following stud in my packet so in my packet and on the side let's go to the side okay this one okay this second Friday and then the next slide down actually

030they're all they're all third Friday 9661 9592 9506 it should be 9438 and 2324 and you actually have 2320 you have 9427 which is like do you see that where are you seeing the 9427 I'm not seeing that I'm looking at um slide 4 yeah that's a different number and we don't have that one it should be 9438 so no no go up she's talking yeah we'll have to look at that we can get it's on uh number four go up up one more way keep going no one more that's it yeah this number right here 9427 okay that's um it should be uh 9 9438 according to the slide right above it okay yeah we'll look at that that definitely was a p stud differ in favor of better enrollment I can tell you

031that's not accurate the accurate numbers are the numbers that are right here um so I'm not sure what happened there I will look into that but that was a pullover from a previous side right because those are your stats from 2324 in the slide above it so whoever put the other numbers in um didn't follow the sequence 9438 should have been the correct number okay thank you thank you are there any questions thank you very much is there a motion to adjourn second all in favor we are adjourned [Music] that was

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.