CorpusRecord 103435

Committee of the Whole Meeting 01.06.25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Solon Springs School District
Date
2025-01-07
Location
Douglas County, WI
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,450 words · about 59 min
Collected
2026-06-11

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001just don't escap all right we'll call the meeting in order at 6 pm on the 6th of January roll call got John here Ben here Britney here and myself and Keith won't be here tonight he is working as so can I get approval of the motion to approve the agenda so move second there is going to be just a switch in um switching up the yeah we're just we're just going to move uh we need approval to move the Project based learning right after the staff and student Community recognition I'll make the motion okay second all in favor all any opposed all right good that being said we will go to some res recognitions so Nathan alberg so just in in recognition of Nathan alberg selection as Wisconsin baseball coaches association a coach of the

002year uh this is a a great reflection of your efforts and dedication to the baseball program got repeat for sure thank you thank you Hannah Balor so this is recognition of Hannah Ballard's completion of her North American monory Center certification which I forgot to bring that ceric that to you and then masters of education degree her dedication to continuous learning and professional development is a great asset to the districts all [Applause] right and then last but not least Nathaniel Ballard in recognition Nathaniel's completion of his master's uh degree is his dedication to continuous learning and professional development is a great [Applause] asset was it the same degree no I didn't so so thank side ah thank you all right we're we're going to move to Project based learning so welcome hi I'm Paula zi and

003I am from the parkfalls area I formally led a Project based learning High School in the schwam school district for 15 years and I been involved with Charter School since the early 2000s I started working with uh Britney and her uh design team in 20 spring of 2022 before uh you opened your facility in 2022 and I came on board to coach uh practices Plus student centered learning cultures and some shared leadership collaboration things uh I we started that in August of 2023 so I'm very pleased to be here to share a little bit about how instruction occurs uh in a Project based learning school like eagles Academy keep in mind though that this is like a 30,000 foot view in about 10 to 15 minutes um but it should give you some idea of

004how that works and how credit and and things are assigned some learning objectives that we have for today are that Eagles Academy's mission and vision is a piece of the district puzzle EA teachers and Learners accomplish the school's mission and vision through the Project based learning model project-based learning design includes learning and instruction across five phases of a project Eagles Academy teachers and Learners align varied instructional practices and strategies to support students success Sim similar to other teachers in district schools and Eagles Academy High School advis earns credit grades and GPA consistent with their peers in the traditional High School this is ultimately one of the most exciting pieces I've ever seen a district present this puzzle piece which I don't know who designed this but it's amazing it it truly is and because Eagles

005Academy is one of five options in the district and one of three options for your middle school and your high school it is reason to celebrate that sort of excellence in accentuating difference and diversity to be offered in one district and then allowing your schools to have that autonomy to meet the needs of the students who enroll there is really a tremendous thing and to then work together as a whole right because you have one unifying objective and that is that you meet all Learners so they are successful confident College and Career ready citizens of our communities and that's truly so much and I hope that you do celebrate that is you learn and go through the Growing Pains of having multiple uh learning models so quick question so not every student is College Bound

006so how do you incorporate the people that are in college that's why we work with standards and we look at career and College Bound things so what do we need to do just like any of the other schools or the high schools doing too what do we need to do to prepare students to go out into the world and live in our communities and work and be productive citizens not everybody is going to college that is definitely the case and I don't know that everybody should go to college right we have other occupations have other ways and avenues like aish some work rated things as such and Eagles Academy is working with those skills uh that are necessary to build those pieces and of course with a lot of student choice and voice about how

007they do that and then getting them the resources that they need so let's ground ourselves a little bit in Eagles Academy's Mission it is a Project based learning community in your District where self-motivated students learn through challenging interdisciplin AR projects rooted in our community so as drivers of their learning students explore Pathways to success including skills to navigate real life now and in the future opened in 2022 serves 6th through 12th grades which is Middle School and High School in multi-age classroom experiences and has a maximum of 26 students I believe Britney did pass out a quick one pager on what Project based learning and monor uh schools look like and that is from the Wisconsin Resource Center of charter schools resources as far as the vision is concerned our vision for Eagles Academy is

008utilizing our community mentors partners and partners as a foundation for learning students are exposed to a wide variety of subjects and experiences so where does inst instruction actually occur instruction or to to accomplish that mission and vision learning and instruction occurs throughout the life cycle of projects in a student centered collaborative culture what that means is there are two key areas of or of format I guess or structure of of that instruction and it's called seminars which tend to be a with a focus topic um usually more Community Based and involve the whole school or the whole ad advisory meaning the high school might just do it or the middle school might do it or the whole group does that work there's also something called student Le projects we call them slps in the Project

009based learning world and those are students selected usually High interest topics or experiences that students want to take on they come from their own interests their own Curiosities their own questions their own need to know uh one example might be a student who interested in a career as a nurse she might have a student Le project that is not only researching all the different kinds of nurses but she's reading different material in fact I just recommended a book to her that's about women in Vietnam as combat nurses those kinds of things plus going out into the field to hopefully get to talk to someone uh who actually is working in the field that she wants to take up in both of those examples seminars which are more teach Le and the student Le projects in

010both cases the teacher serves as a guide and a facilitator and the student autonomy the level of Independence the students has is varied and that's varied out a lot of things it could be the learning targets themselves it could be the student skill level with both the process of project building or even just the skill level of working independently regardless there working the teachers are working to create more Independence in the student as they grow so that we have successful citizens who can also do the things they need to do independently as well both of those Avenues also Implement core subjects and the power standards sometimes called targets and all of the learning is assessed through rubrics or a form of a rubric some are more formal than others but there are a variety of

011those that are used always rounded in the standards themselves and what what you have determined as a district or the state of Wisconsin has determined that says this is when someone's met that standard and then the students work up to that point or past it in some cases regardless students learn and demonstrate their Proficiency in the same standards as students in the traditional classrooms albeit in different ways and probably in in a different order so instructions occurring across all five stages or five phases The Proposal research product presentation evaluation and perhaps in another presentation I could actually explain what those different parts are but think of it this way if I'm going to rebottle my bathroom I start with a proposal how can I remodel my ba bathroom with the least amount of money and

012time right and then I work on researching it I'm figuring it out I'm getting quotes I'm getting do all those things and then I'm either hiring somebody or I figured out my husband hopefully can do some of that work and so on and it's very similar to what you and I do every single day to probably get things done at home and at work Head Rush serves as a repository to manage all the produ projects for students and teachers it populates the standards uh that we've assigned to individual projects it tells us it it will populate the credit the grades the GPA and create a transcript when it's all done so every project gets entered and we're going to show you a little bit about that every project has these credits or standards when the

013project project is gets near the end the teacher and the student are going to evaluate it on a some characteristics credit gets assigned to it uh and that credit then is produced in this headrush and we can print a report so if a student had five projects over the course of a quarter each one gets closed out and that credit gets added and added and added until you have a cumulative for each of the course subject areas and electives as well and here's an example of what those standards look like uh this is just a snapshot you'll see on the left those are folders with all of the learning targets by content area and those learning targets are directly copied from the states the state list or your District ones depending on you know what

014the case is with those they're just copied into a spreadsheet uploaded to project Foundry or excuse me headrush it used to be project Foundry and then we can use those standards to put on people's projects the same is true on the right you'll see that there are what's called habit of mind habits of mind standards these are really interesting because they are the framework for developing the kinds of things that dispositions we think not we the charter school but in general people believe that leaders need to have these are the skills they need to have when they're confronted with problems and situations that might not have direct answers so basically they're the core things people need in order to solve problems and that's what we want in the world are people who can think about

015solving problems so the spreadsheets again created from a collaboration with the district in fact I believe you're working on English language arts standards right now we have standards selected and we updated all of that this summer we spent a lot of time working on that and getting those uh better aligned with your District or what's common practice and now as you evolve in that process it'll be very easy for Brad to go in and adjust if there's something that needs to be adjusted you know maybe there's a power standard that we didn't select that we can select and then deselect something else so now that we know sort of where it occurs throughout that whole process how does it actually happen here's where there's a lot of variety in the strategies and the structure that

016a teacher uses in Project based learning but in some ways they're they're still the foundation of core teacher strategies they just might be delivered in a different way so for example a lot of what Project based learning teachers do is to guide the learning by inquiry based questions sometimes students will say you didn't answer my question well it's not really the teacher's place to answer the question it's to get the student thinking about what the answer is so there might be more questions so that in itself the art of questioning and asking inquiry based questions is exactly what um Brad and Britney work on every single day we work with and through those conversations with students and we develop that critical and creative thinking well what if what if you did that where did you

017find that information what happens if you change that all of that kind of um diverse thinking rather than um a real structured thinking it's either yes or it's either no well what about this what happens if you change that again scope sequence of learning tasks meaning how do we get a student to this place we call that backwards design and education we know we need them to be over here on a certain skill or knowledge base and then we we back that up until we get to where the students at that's called the scope and sequence to get them where they need to go might be fast might be slow we know that that's what that works but it's always attached to standards grade level standards so that we know that kids have the ability

018then to achieve competency and proficiency at those things that that we've determined as a community are what they need to have it might look like getting at those learning tasks might look like manyi lessons that a teacher would conduct because there's either something they see a student or a group of students might need there's a skill they're missing excuse me a skill they're missing so they would teach a lesson could be student to student um I had a student yesterday teach me how to do slope again for some reason I struggle with slope and I was helping another student that student taught me because that student knew how to do it we collect artifacts as evidence of that learning so we can show progress all the entire way through the whole process so it's not

019it's not um it's not maybe just a you know a unit test at the end of something it's whole progress along the way much like a trai traditional environment might have homework or classwork that would demonstrate that or multiple drafts of something we're doing the same thing we collect those and they go into headrush so that we could demonstrate at any point in time where that students's growth along that Continuum of whatever standard or skill they were learning is at and then finally one of the most important parts of Project based learning is place-based field experiences most if not all Project based learning schools are grounded in their community and they leave the campus and go outside to do all kinds of things those could be direct contact with Community Partnerships so that they can

020fulfill projects in the community uh they could be field experiences to the school forest and something happens in the school Forest like they repair Trails they plant habitat it could be all those things it could be to go down to your local Museum like last year and work with the museum staff to then create um some work for that museum what's really important to understand about leaving the campus to go or having people come in would be that those off-campus learning experiences are part of the curriculum they're part of of what it is that either the student individually is doing or the group is doing so it is attached to learning opportunities and there's always standards and targets that are involved with it too and in that vision for Eagles Academy there's a statement that

021Community as our classroom and that's what that means that means that the community is coming in the community is going and we're going out into the community some schools are out a a day a week some are out every couple weeks it just depends on the model it depends on the opportunities that are available and the weather and and all of those things my school spent the last six years living in our school Forest we got off the bus kids got off the bus the school at 8:00 we were on campus till 9:30 to fulfill some other obligations we left at 9:30 went to the school forest or in the Lake Superior region and we didn't come back till 3:30 and all of our curriculum was attached to the work we were doing outside that's

022just one example of a pbl experiential school um I didn't time I skip this one okay this is uh I added some extra slides there that I did skip that will give you some other examples and photos of some other ways in which instruction occurs this is a great example of how rubrics are used in head brush as evidence of learning and I have two different versions for you to look at on this screen they do not go together meaning they're from totally different projects but when you have a chance to look at them they will tell they will give you an example of a in progress assessment of a character analysis from a fiction reading a fiction book that students were working on and and that is considered a task like an assignment that

023you might see they read a certain amount of chapters they're filling out a character analysis they submit this to Head Rush like they're turning it into a paper basket and then it is assessed based on the standard that is attached to that skill and the teacher and the student would sit down and talk about that work and and what needs to happen next the one on the bottom is a rubric for an end product that was the micro grid project that students did the difference between the two would the the scaling is the same the difference would be which is would be great for you to take a look at at some point to understand is that at the standard met that's what basically if you've completed these parts of that standard you have fully

024met that standard now it's nothing wrong if it's emerging or basic but you're not quite there so what is it that you need to learn next in order to get there and not every standard is always going to be met but you want the students to be on that Continuum and if you were looking at this whole rubric there's several rows of standards that are on there but the rubric is at the end the um maybe in the middle there wouldn't be a rubric as much as there would be a check against the standard itself these two examples are those ones I was saying about uh this is a Community Field experience uh for a rain Garden that's the rain Garden um and N this is part of a larger project put the wrong slide

025here sorry here we go n Ray Forest I forgot her last name I want to make sure I got that right this is a rain Garden visit where students had helped design and build the rain Garden so the final product the unit test is the rang garden and is the rang Garden successful that's what they're assessing themselves and with Nell's help serving as the expert as to whether or not it's met its goals they've met their goals or do they need to do something else is part of the rain Garden not working imagine if this rain Garden was connected to your school cafeteria and that is helping pollinate your school's little garden that it has so you can serve fresh vegetables to your kids that would be a phase that you could Implement with that

026too the one on the right is a visit to a local Community Partners residents to take a look at a micro grid so this occurred during the research phase where the kids are learning about the micro grids because they're going to build their own mini version of that and this was an example of getting to see that so for sake of time maybe this is our presentation phase that we invite all of you to be a part of next Thursday evening um that'll be the 16th from 4:30 to 6 30 um just an example of of one of the ways that presentations and evaluations happen with our students um is there anything else Paul or should we skip right in because I be mindful of time Yep this is right where we should be so

027now how do you boil it all down and put credit on this thing right every teacher asked that question I came from an English background so when I had a 150 essays sitting in front of me on a rubric and I went with my exemplars you know here my this ones and my husband used to tease me while me just throw them down the stairs and see which ones lay on the top and the bottom I said that's not how it works honey and we looked at what those were right and then we used a rubric very diligently used a rubric we ly to the standards to say these are the things that show this is proficient writing very similar thing is happening with every single project a student does whether it's a small project

028that gets done in two weeks or it takes a year the same process is occurring and uh Project based learning schools work with a yard stick that says 100 hours is one credit and that's pretty standard across the country with pbl schools yard stick remember it might be different and Vary but that tends to be um pretty close close in most cases then teachers and students work together collabora collaboratively to decide what have they accomplished at the end of this project and they consider things like the amount of time the student put in the effort that was put in for the amount of time what's the quality of the artifacts and the reflections of the learning those are critical to understanding our learning and what what we need to do next and the overall growth

029did the student make Monumental growth did he make small growth but was it really significant growth things like that are considered and then we use multiple assessments to arrive at this it's not like this is the only valuation remember they've been going on throughout the whole process and this is very similar to what a traditional teacher would do too is use these different kinds of Assessments and at the end of the product you come up with the final check to are these standards met are they emerging are they exceeding what are they and then from there following your graduation requirements State well I should say the state requirements and soul and springs graduation requirements students fulfill those just like they were in the traditional school and the difference would be if my student if if

030my students is is sitting in English 12 class he's getting English 12 credit period regardless of how many Social Studies books he read right because historical fiction is a lot of social studies right if I read Lord of the Flies I got a whole lot of ss going on in there but I'm only going to get English credit right the project is aligned by multiple subjects because it's an interdisciplinary model so multiple subjects if they are warranted we don't just put subjects here willy-nilly again they're aligned to those standards so in this case the pro this project which you can't even see what that is was worth 125 credit total and it happened to be divided between English 11 and civics B+ in English and a B minus in Civics you can interpret that to

031say the the English part of it was a little higher caliber effort than maybe the Civics meaning maybe all the standards were not at the standard met uh but close and then teachers track teachers and students track this through Head Rush they can easily see where they're at at any given time every time a Project's completed they can go go in and they look at their transcript and they can see yep I now added .125 credit to my Civics I still got 30 credit left to go to have a half a credit at the end of semester one not the quarters the end of semester 1 and the end of semester two Brad supplies the business office with a transcript from Head Rush and that will have courses on it not all the projects but

032courses that remember how I said that all accumulates into those core subjects or content subjects that's what gets handed to the business office and then they input that into Skyward so that it's all in one District transcript I know that was a ton it was a 30,000 view wasn't I right well done and if you haven't remember that we did three things we looked at PDL implementation and how it might be facilit is is facilitated we looked at instructional practices and some strategies and we looked at how credits and grades are assigned and how assessments are basically used throughout the proc the whole process regardless of the length of time any questions that you have for me or Britney Brad had to go to basketball that's here no that this was good and I I

033know that uh there have been a number of questions just around what what is Project based learning and that that's the sole purpose why you know Paula and and Britney are here is just to provide some more background as to how does this operate you know just trying to communicate that a little more um so we have an understanding what one of our schools does and and how how that integrates into the traditional minded learning and and Grading and whatnot so how many roughly across Wisconsin how many are using Head Rush how many the charter Project based schools well I would have to look it up more than three oh gosh yes okay um Head Rush is the Premier Project based management system what are some of the challeng so in in our setting if

034we bring this in and so we have with Traditional School we just have some what's the challenges when when head when when work with hedish when it's brought into a we're trying to go Apples to Apples here is what we're trying to create well it's really hard for Project based learning I would almost say out of all my years of 25 years of experience it's almost impossible to fit project Foundry into a Skyward or Infinite Campus box not the the process piece of it it's it's not we have pract we have some things in practice credit reporting to the state and I shared that um little cheat sheet we made with the Wisconsin Resource Center of charter schools in order to make that process a little easier when you report it out to the state

035of Wisconsin but because Project based learning works at such different paces and they don't have traditional assignments both Skyward and Infinite Campus are set up to put in you know page 10 110 to page 115 um you know unit one test it just doesn't work that way and projects don't finish all at the same time or all within a 9we period to assign a quarter credit you also would lose the ability to do multi- interdisciplinary coursework meaning you would have to go back to assigning all English all Civics even though they were the same thing so my experience has been because I helped write that cheat sheet some years ago when I was working because we were just like how do we get this done how do we make it easier for our district but

036also not um fail the students in the sense that we're not giving them credit for what they actually did and so we came up with ways to report that out in our case here because you guys are rural you have a small school schaman was small we had about 35 to 40 kids we could do the same thing you guys are doing which is to take those transcripts and have one person responsible for manually putting those grades in twice a year because we wouldn't a public a pbl school would probably not have grades in the traditional sunset first quarter they would have a lot of things in progress and they might have some grades done some projects might have finished by the end of nine weeks but a lot of things won't happen so then

037it would look odd to your parents right be like why are there no grades here this way um Eagles Academy could they send out a progress report that demonstrate hey they got these all these projects going and they can report on progress very easily the other thing that Head Rush allows us is to differentiate by student and projects good point and So within our student learning project process for first semester um we have some required Ela standards that every Stu student is needing because it makes sense for the research phase but for their content in science or social studies a student might be doing these social study standards and these students might be doing these science standards um that's another big pinch point for can we use Skyward for pbl that has not been no

038addressed so and I don't I don't know many schools I can't even think of one who would be y Yip hoay we're going to do Sky Infinite Campus except at this end part which we know is super valuable we have to have that process um because we it's just Unfortunately they have a market and they're selling to that market and they're not selling to anybody else who doesn't fit in that box and a pbl school doesn't really fit in that box you know so headrush is your is really your best way I I know of other schools who don't use rush and then they create these really extravagant Google documents and things to keep track of it I would not do it every penny you're spending for Head Rush has been worth it I personally

039know the people who have also worked on that software it was a former company called project Foundry and they are constantly looking at their people and serving them you know Brad and Britney can call them and heartbeat and say we need we need this report do you have this report or can we get this report and they actually create it for you um so do pbl students take the standardized test that Wisconsin was they are required because they're a public school to take all of the same tests that your District assign all of your schools um sometimes there could be some flexibility like um you know there's always a window for that standardized test sometimes schools districts will say well you have this window and you guys decide when you're going to do your forward

040test or when you're going to do it um it just depends on the test and what that is or if you have a district assessment like star or some of the others um that might be the case or or you just say everybody takes the test in these three days and you know then the the the Project based learning school just makes allowances for that and knows that they're going to be doing testing during those days so we do Head Rush we do fast fridge um just like all of the district schools beginning middle and end of the year as well as act forward exam all of those standardized tests and and E the EA staff use those same statistics to do the same similar things that the other teachers are doing in the other

041districts so when they get their data back they're looking at it and doing some of the same things so we know a student is on the lower end of the reading and we need to move them up we look at that reading we've analyzed where that is and then we steer those students toward activities or interventions depending on what it is uh to build that skill what what's the push back that you would get from traditional the traditional teachers push back are they is is there is there push back from my experience you mean or are they celebrating like I think I think what it is from my experience I Britney and not for not for Project based learning for the fact that we're now using GPA and grades so now we're going to be

042using the same currency if I can use that image yeah actually but we're yeah that so would there be push back I think not they probably would be happy that it's consistent because if there are some Project based learning schools charter schools in general that don't participate in any GPA they don't even give grades they strictly are either you know um standard based or some other form but the difficulty with that is is in a lot of districts mine included in this one if you don't give students a GPA then how do they participate in scholarships right um all the other kinds of things I mean there are ways to do it but honestly um from my experience we were better off when we did the the um GPA and gave grades on these assessments

043that we had and we were very clear about how we got at the assessments which is what Brad and Britney are doing by building good solid rubrics I'm trying to fish for was it the law of unintended consequences that's what I'm trying to tease out like what's some of the social cost if any to having two different schools no to well we have two different schools but now we're going to say you're going to share the same oh I see you're the sh you're going to end up with the same grade system but you're both coming at a very different coming at a different at least yeah maybe they're and for your presentation maybe they're not so different after all well they are in their presentation and the amount of um collaboration and student like

044factor that they would not have in the traditional environment so that part's different the pace is different there's probably more depth of learning versus breadth of learning but we're still covering a breadth of Standards but there's usually more depth in Project based learning um that's a district level decision you need to make if you decided that you wanted to go away from um GPA and things like that there's a lot of people who wouldn't argue with you because GPA sometimes um doesn't work for people you know it doesn't work for people and perhaps you know you could that's something your school could decide to do to say you know what Eagles Academy isn't going to do GPA and grades just going to do credit and be standards based but then think about what those consequences

045would be would it impact your enrollment because someone said well I want my student in there but now he can't participate because he has no grades to get into the scholarship stuff right and and that takes a person or a student out of the running for pretty significant funds you know if if they if they truly achieve top status in their class right so the one thing you could look at is if you decided to go that route you could check to see are there schools who've done it actually not had a GPA and still participated if it's even legally able to be done I don't know yeah but you could go that I know in our school in shanigan it worked better for the whole if we assigned credit and grades and the kids

046then that went into their transcript because some pbl schools do their own transcripts their own graduations everything we went in with ours because it made more sense for our community that's what would be the deciding factor and is it more understandable for the community if you went to a different school but you still at least have a currency that like you said sure that's the same and the fact that you have that autonomy as a PD school to present and and design that curricul differently because we have so many students who really struggle with that traditional pathway did our last year's seniors from Eagles Academy graduate with a GPA or were they doing GPA last year I think we had yeah we didn't have any seniors that F that because it's so new that we

047have't right this is this this is the first year right first year gradu third as a school I don't know if this answers your question it's you know you're talking about app and oranges the way that you get to the GPA the way that you um and an you might be able to speak to this but there are districts who you know are moving towards the lat system where it's not just the GPA that you're looking at you're looking at um lots of other things and so I don't know if that answers your question or gives you more information or even question but Shaman did that they went to the L but it wasn't because of the L system like a college does so um it wasn't because we had a PDL School than in

048Traditional High School it was because we had six or eight people at the top with all the same GPA but they hadn't done the same level of work or course study and so we went to the L to start to separate that out because we saw kids who really deserve that top honor but did not have a 4.6 average or whatever it was turning out to be and this way kids are kids earn latte coins for all kinds of things you could set that up how you want and I think I shared the website to shamans where you can see all of our stuff it's worked fabulously fabulously I've been on that committee before I retired in 2022 and it was wonderful Paul thank you for this very thorough presentation yeah yeah thank you for

049having me here I appreciate you moving me up um so I could get myself back to where it falls I hope it's not snowing I don't think they're still on the forecast for a long time really oh that's sad yeah oh I guess you were saying that weren't you you were Hing for the 1 that's right all right thank you Paul yes all right moving on to 30690 day I think your n 60-day PTO and committee as a whole wrong I think it's the third not the fourth according to my Che unless we're doing it on Tuesdays for that month for some reason the 60-day oh yeah you y the march on it is the four that's on a Tuesday in February oh in February it's the third yeah and in March is the third

050yeah okay no I was just putting in my phone that's why I noticed it March you are correct yeah yep all right fair enough just wanted to make sure we aren't doing a Tuesday for some reason no not today Monday and Tuesday all right I won't be here for the February committee as a whole for we all all I will not either which one the February 3rd okay I'll be somewhere in the cby what is your commitment all right that it anything else on the those okay technology security and purchases this is Dave so the one thing that was shared there is uh Dave put together the uh spending uh proposal for technology um and just he's going to highlight a few things that have changed I I know that uh life cycle for Chromebooks

051that was one thing that kind of surprised me with the changes here and then also just getting into the purchases as we further uh U take care of our one toone commitment so all right uh the original life cycle of Chrome books was like five or six years so that um worked out pretty good for us we started at fourth grade and the kids use them through 8th grade and then they got a new computer in ninth grade and they use that till they graduated and we usually sell the computer to the kids when they graduate because kids are pretty rough on computers and it so was a little car to get them to take care of it for those through graduation and and they don't they don't they don't hold valum very much after

052that many years and then Google changed how they do the end of life and they changed it to 10 years and so now what's happened is when the kids go from 8th to nth grade and they turn their computers to me instead of them going in a pile and then going to recycling they're good for another five years also added to that was we changed when we started one to one we originally started one to one in the sixth grade and then uh Beth was the fifth grade teacher she asked if you move it down to fifth grade we moved it down to fifth grade and Tim was here as the fourth grade teacher he asked went down to fourth grade went down to fourth grade and then when we decided to do a split

053three four split and it was kind of awkward to have half the kids have laptop there half kids own so we moved it back up to fifth grade why why was there a split at fourth grade well because because when we got the monor we split there one two spit thir so things have changed just I don't know if you don't it doesn't matter what why but it's happened yeah so we're now we're back to sixth grade going to start at sixth grade and we've over the years we've built up almost every classroom well not almost every classroom in the elementary has a classroom set we used to have a cart and then we started that one to one after that but now because of changes people asked for that we had money for that

054we did classroom set so every first through fifth grade class whether they're in Monas or regular traditional they have a classroom set so we're going to start in sixth grade so I have a pile of computers in my room that are still have some life left in them so if on the list what we're going to do is we're going to try to I'm going to go through them while I already did it and pick out the best ones and and any that's got any kind of problem I side the junk and then we are pushing those we're run them through a second cycle because they have to last and so the end of life is important I have to keep an eye on that and not so they'll they'll make it through one more

055cycle then they'll get disposed of and and since I wrote this I talked to the monori um E2 and they they had they have four five and six in that same classro and they had originally signed one to one in there end fourth grade but they did it differently between the fourth and fifth graders and the sixth graders in there the sixth graders have more autonomy with them and they take them home they can take them home stuff just like the sixth graders can over here so we're just going to do a classroom set for four and five so even though it says this many will start out in the fourth grade once we get where those people work our way up to new place so that they'll have classrooms set for four and five

056six will will give it well not a new one anymore a gently used one in sixth grade should use up till eighth grade and the same will happen with traditional so I know it's it's a confusing thing but it's it it's all can work out I can keep track of all I have lots of numbers up there that I can see where how long they're going to last for because what happens is then they just don't get updates anymore and then once they get updates then other problems so anyways so we have that set um and then we'll we do need to um purchase computers where we traditionally purchase them again in the nth grade so that's on here the nth grade um I try to buy something better than what the younger kids have

057because they take a little bit better care of them I tried a bunch of different things touch screens wasn't really expensive to replace so went to larger screens but one that Britney has is the same that was with the model I bought a couple years ago um for the nth graders and so I've been buying 14in screen ones for them just so they have a little bit screen to do their work so those are on here um with with a hard case I like to get hard cases for them um More Than This protected um got kind of rubber bumpers around them we we have cloth cases for a number of years those get really disgusting after a couple years and um so trying to pH those out and get the hard cases I got

058I found hard cases for the smaller ones which is good and then we then there's also on this list the teaching staff we have a four-year replacement cycle in the teaching staff and we have and so and the teacher t i just divided them in a half years ago and then whoever replaces whoever whatever whatever half of that um and those teachers will get a replacement computer next year and we move teachers of Chromebooks on the last and they're better Chromebooks than the than the students have so like mine is one of them um this one has a touchcreen and is a convertible but I but I prioritize larger screen so I Linda has one what we'll be eting next which is like 16in screen um so because teach are getting older and they can't

059see so the bigger screen get better touch is not as important although Dale will probably argue with that but um he he loses to my I um so that's that's on here and then it's only 10 it should be like 15 but we had an issue with these ones we bought that were post pandemic um supply chain issue computers where we had a bunch of them fail early so a bunch of have already been replaced had those there replaced early so we have 10 for next year so any that's all what what what's what we're looking for for for next year and it should be around 18 for next year's Replacements and then the next year would be again that kind of amount and then the next the next three years after that would be

060less because we don't have to do a teacher replacement so for three years any questions about that that process works are these Chromebooks basically just internet connectors I mean Super basic laptops or yes I mean they're just a browser okay but that being said there's a difference when you have a browser based one that has four gigs of RAM and you have one that has eight gigs of RAM and you have and you have a bigger screen all these things the teacher ones are way better I mean they work fast people have a prejudice against Chromebooks all they're just cheap junk but I would bet that 90% of you and the rest of the world I'll use of the browser so why have all that other computing power sitting we did we did MacBook uh

061airs for a while with the teachers the teachers really liked them and but they were they were $1,000 a piece and they use a browser so it was just kind of like and then and Apple at the time they've gotten better at this they didn't have very good management for large you know like that Enterprise type thing they've come way a long way in that it's like now too late we done that 8 10 years ago I things will turn out different but chromes are Chromebooks are super easy to manage they're super easy to roll out they're super easy to change from one person to another because all your stuff lives in the cloud so you don't have to worry about like I all this stuff on St on my laptop everybody does everybody's stuff

062is somewhere and it also makes it safer I take this Chromebook and throw it across the room I don't have any store on here just pick up another one and login is me and and there I am right where I left off so that's that's worked really good good for me the only the only bad side of of Chromebooks is it's Google and Google likes to have a really good thing and then decide to it go away so hopefully that won't happen in my the next five years before I retire for good and then somebody else could have that problem but um they don't have a very good track record on that well they they've had some interesting changes and and and just to highlight or to put in a PSA Dave is not advising

063people to throw their Chromebooks okay some people have done that but by accident yeah okay and and then be wanted me to address security too and and especially for you guys so there's there's two things that I I I'd like to do because you have access to important information of the schools and that is important information of student information and financial information to school that's like our two digital precious assets obviously our real Precious assets are our students and our staff but our our assets digitally are are our financial records and our student records and I know you don't have direct access to either of those things I was just going to say but but you get but you get reports I mean I'm I'm guessing from Pete that have that information in them that

064have personal idential I can say identifi personal identif information which is pii which is is like our is a big push in in this world right now is to make sure that that's safe so the the lowest form is having two- Factor authentication so we started two-factor a few years ago I did it first then I made all the office staff do it now I've made all the staff do it and the school board should do that too Brad's done it the rest of you haven't so I I'd like you to set up two Factor authentication because it just that little step of having to have that and it doesn't make you do it relog in every time and use your phone every time but that little step makes it so that somebody has to

065have those two factors in order to impersonate you and get your information that you have how would we do that set up two Factor authentication I sent you a that said how to do it that has a the directions okay so in your in your school Google account you click on your little picture whatever symbol you have probably just a b or something or a k I don't know want first name it's your first name so and then it say like your Google account then you go into like security it's all it's all spelled out in that email I sent when did you send that I sent it before the last board me and and I sent it to Pete actually I sent it to Pete Pete for to you I didn't to you guys

066to you guys because I've been on his case about it that you guys should do that but we can do that within our own device yes yeah we don't have to have a chrome no that was my that was our Chrome yeah as a browser yeah you have to use Chrome as the browser for it but other than that no you don't have to okay I can move with that so so that's a perfect lead in John to what I wanted to say next and and I know I know you guys have some resistance to this is that I think and and i i f with Frank the entire time Frank was here about this is that anybody who works for the school district should use a school own device because then that security has

067been set up by me the mistake is on me not on you because if your device gets hacked and they get school information but isn't that what to uh well I mean that helps that helps yes but but you also have your own stuff on your on whatever device you're using and if your own stuff gets hacked that the hacker doesn't care that that other stuff is the school's stuff yeah if they get into your stuff then and and then I haven't done everything I could do to prevent that and I can do within the restrictions that I that you have your own device yes I've done everything I could do but so so uh a school a school-owned Chromebook is impenetrable no no well okay I mean so what's the difference I mean I

068get it that you have more confidence in in the things you control right um what what it comes down to is is the the security settings and and the and the uh firewalls and whatnot that he's able to establish on these devices versus personal devices which he's unable to do I mean you you do have some protection through your devices but it's not necessarily the same level that he's able to provide through District devices so okay so the the financial or things that you send out are well you're not sending them through Google Docs you're typically you're putting them on board docs correct in in some sense yes okay and and but allten they're they're PDFs right yeah so you have to open them in a PDF reader yeah so that that's where and then

069in order to open that you're actually downloading that to your computer you have a copy of that even if it's just like in a cache not not something you can see and and then it's on your computer on a computer that the school doesn't control that that I just think that this is the school's information it should be on only school I mean there there are obviously exceptions to that but I'm I just want to say it and have it out in the open that I said it and if something happens well I said it but but but I'm I'm not meeting my duty of doing the best I can to make sure by by by but I can't tell you I can't I don't have the power over you guys you guys have the

070power over yourselves to do it my only thing with that is I travel a lot and I'm not going to take another laptop with me than I already have that's that's the problem I've already got three devices that I take with me I'm not taking a forth yeah you know just for checking EMA so if I don't want if you know if it's stuff like this I could you know log in at home I guess but um but if something urgent I'm like down in the cities or whatever else that sorts so where where where it comes down to is do doing our due jaillance and our duty to inform the board and provide as much information so you can make informed decisions what about I mean we could do something like that or or

071if there's a way to to make um board dos more lock down I don't know cuz like I whenever I do anything with work I have to log into a VPN before I can when I'm outside of their Network like when I'm at home I log into a VPN at home on my private Network that's secure but I still have to use their bpn right well and well I mean the thing about a VPN is just to go to it's just the travel from one network to another yeah you're going to you know when you're you're going to Google when you go to your Gmail how much your school email account so I mean there's a certain level of security there I mean I guess if you could agree to use stronger security within the

072account that you use for the school stuff we could do that I just activated a thing a couple weeks ago that requires any password change to now meet up standard than did before but I did not make it mandatory so I didn't I could push that out would make everybody have to change their password all I have it is that if you do make a password from now on it has to be a higher standard but there's things like that and like two Factor but there's more there's more than two Factor we could do security keys that you could use with your device that in order to get on our account you have to plug a USB key in touch it with your finger and then it unlock okay and I I'm not sure the

073expense I'm sure we can find it I know W Madison and their extension that's exactly what they use is that piece and I know VPN capabilities that's become far more um easier to to establish and set up and that so yeah and I mean I have to use a two Factor every time I log in right right well that's the other thing you know like I have those things but I have them on the on the loosest settings yeah because people already compl that they can't remember their passwords and they have to log in to many times and all these things and I mean we aren't logging in all the time so if you set I don't know can you set them different for everybody or do they have yeah I can set up my

074group so I mean I can the Schoolboard Group which you guys are all in and make that a stricter group like you have to we have to do two Factor every time we log in because we don't do it I mean I don't do it every day I mean I check my email notless you switch computers then you'll you'd have to do it but yeah if you're using the same computer it saves it on there most see mind I have to my work one I have to doesn't matter if I use the same computer or not I have to to f right well yeah that all those things can be turned out and and if if you guys feel that that is a better solution that you can still use your own device you have

075to use it under stricture security requirements that that's a good compromise between the two things see I'm okay with that because to me buying me another laptop or whatever or Chromebook or whatever it's kind of a waste because I'm going to use it maybe I don't even know how much other than like board meetings and checking out a couple things you're looking at maybe two hours a month 3 hours a month that seems like a lot of wasted resources for that yeah well I mean everything's a lot until until something happens then it's that's really yeah okay thank you Dave yep thanks Dave all right middle school high SCH school program Edition Jack uh so the information I shared with you just uh to review for tonight is uh the feedback that I've gotten from

076the survey sent out to families as well as students in the coursework that they would like to see added and um uh from both sides the things that are sticking out is food preparation cooking nutrition and then the personal finance and I I will say uh all three of those lead to uh lure or a person with lure in family and consumer head because that person can deliver instruction in all three of those areas and the nice thing with that that uh family and consumer Ed uh position is that that person could offer exploratory for our middle school so adding more for middle school and then also electives and required course work of high school so um much like the meeting we had before so there's 23 responses is that of good enough sampling you

077think to make a decision right so it's questionable yeah so typically um I'm trying to remember back uh in Old School perceptions talked about in my travels with them they talked about once you re get into a certain percent percentage I think it was right around that 30% if you've gotten response to 30% of the people that you've surveyed there's not going to be much change after that yeah so I think we're we're pretty close I I don't I don't see these results yeah I don't see that swinging much at all so I was hoping for more but yeah I know I'm not sitting at the table I received the survey but it did not have a button for me to select that I have a current sixth grader um it was only like eight

078up I so I was yeah it's weird because if you look it shows sixth grade on here but nobody right I I switched that out so yes getting feedback so anyway that's okay did you want to no well I didn't vote because I wasn't able to select what grade my child was in so looks like and this is an extra position this is that reallocation of that FTE that we had Su okay all right project no we did that open enrollment seats for 2526 go first yes please it's going to be overwhel it's so exciting and thrilling um so for specialed a um there's a document in there that kind of outlines we look at um the students that we currently have in special education and how many case manager service providers we have um

079and then we look at not her student because we know that a student that has a learning disability say in math has a different amount of support than a student with significant Behavior or medical needs so we weigh our students by more a workload versus a specific you know onetoone correspondence um so looking at our current staff and projections for next year we looked at um you know what we have in terms of speech and language staff OT staff Elementary early childhood and middle school high school um and looking at that our current enrollment what we project for next year and saving some space for um new referrals that come in um we do not currently have any space available to accept students that are open that want to open r with an IEP um

080without acre more cost to the district and hiring more staff but we're adequate for what we have now we are staff good right now we actually when I look at um speech language you might be understaffed and OT we make it work it's tight it's tough but yeah so I mean is the ask to the board to just cap or not accept any more enr for the next so so just to to bring everyone up to speed it is it's Wisconsin State Statute that a school board has to make a determination on open enrollment specifically towards special education but then also above and beyond that so and were required for IND District students to provide appropriate level of Staffing no matter what you are correct yeah okay so we have a whole bunch of stud

081that move into district with I we have those so yeah if on this report that I put together if you look at the very last page it kind of has projected Staffing and case loads and how many seats we would have available maintaining you know a couple assuming we get some referrals kids that thought absolutely this is great work very complicated so it's a process so any and that and that's yeah this is just kind of my plug here too uh as we're talking about our seats and an open our uh seats in special education that I would encourage you to reach out to our state legislators to really Hammer home the point that we need more uh Medicare reimbursement for services that we provide our students because right now school districts receive about 34%

082reimbursement of the services that we provide but for the the hope is that they will push it to a 60% reimbursement rate I think DP was going 90 but yeah W said 60 the state superintendent has proposed 75% for next year and 90% for the following so it's a biannual budget uh whereas the push in previous the previous two years has been 60% as well as now pushing forward the next biannual budget 60% so I think that that is prudent when you look at it's almost doubling so School Board convention they'll be addressing some of these proposals to I'm sure there's going to be some discussion on it in the General Session it's right this topic has been coming up uh regionally with our cisa group it's been coming up through uh wasda so with

083school our superintendent and then also there motion or uh uh no not not specifically to that no no that's what I thought like which is weird right you think they'd really want to push that but check but it but it's I I think it's been brought up previously so they're not reiterating that piece but they're really lobbying for that increase in reimbursement because I I think that's one thing that hits school districts pretty hard the fact that we we have to provide a lot of extra service here we're not getting much back on it so so is this a a topic that will require uh board approval or disapproval next uh school board meeting or is that f for the open yes this is a requirement that uh at our next meeting we would have

084to approve that that's correct all right academic career planning update thank you actually any that so that was a special a piece open enrollment yeah we have just oh yeah um so I just provided um a document just looking at our current um Charter School enrollment and so we just took our current students this year and rolled them over into next year so what you're seeing there is the 25 26 of what we currently have um how many are actually open enrolled with us right now and then what that cap is for those levels within the monory program in our Eagles Academy as well so that that's kind of where it sits right at this juncture uh what we're looking at is keeping things uh open on our traditional side knowing that there's caps per

085classroom uh on the monory side and there's a process for you know getting into that so so how about do we are we considering it looks like we're not a cap for virtual Charter um that is one thing that the um the charter board has to Define as far as a cap on it they haven't established it just yet but it's been in discussion as far as providing what what is the maximum number of students we should have in there based on our current Staffing so how much Staffing does it involve with the virtual Charter really I mean you have the one person that kind of oversees right right I I think it's it's more of the administrative stuff I mean it gets more cumbersome to more students you have I shouldn't say cumbersome but

086there's just more requirements when you get more students as far as tracking getting the the grades communication and whatnot so do we have eight graduating this or seven graduating yeah there's quite a few seniors this year and virtual yes are we able to project at all how many is mostly Juniors and seniors that are making up the the bulk of our typically that's what it's been is is Juniors and seniors okay when would a sophomore have to say I'm I'm going to I want to switch to Virtual so in all reality they could Swit since it's part of our Charter program they could switch at any point in time during their academic career we had uh uh we do have a few elementary students that are currently virtual so so any my daughter been B

087since sth grade we have a large number yes so but we get the same credit as we do somebody sitting in here for virtual so what do you mean that financially we get the same credit right but there's an additional expense as well correct a little bit Yeah well about three grand a year I think per student there's there's a chunk so okay all right now the cre um yeah so every year we're required by um DPI that we have this posted to our website and so this just kind of details what we offer our students um in terms of academic and career planning and um what's provided and just kind of some of the things that are offered overall through our district I know this uh was originally rolled out uh by Jena back

088March of 22 if I remember correctly I was visiting at that point in time and um this is truly just updating uh where we're at as far as uh what we're providing uh to make our students College and Career ready um you know it's looking at course offerings as well as uh career paths and how we're meeting that so this is just a little bit off topic um well kind of s or not I mean You' mentioned 4K um in this I know Min on does a 3K how do they do that and is it worth doing something like that um so that's a good question that you bring up so I I would say currently uh when we're talking about funding for students 4K students currently we do not get a full allotment of

089funds so uh for instance uh students in 5K and up uh we receive a set amount of funds for those students well with our 4K I think it's three4 of that 60% there you go thank you very much so it's 60% of that that we would actually get and 3K would be the same so I I don't know if it's really same or I thought 3K was nothing I'll double Che I'll double check on that but I yeah I just wondering I knowest they did my my granddaughter was in it for they moved that's why and they loved it so I was just wondering if it's even a I I I would say I would caution us to at that that I I I know the one thing that this could be something too that

090you talk to your legislators about is that full funding of 4K students I know that is a topic that has come up and I would strongly encourage it simply because our our 4K students are here Monday through Friday full days not partial days so anyway off topic thanks right High School e8th grade van culture Fe field spirit thank you I am Char Sor V teacher um and our eth grade in high school students are hoping to see um a Broadway called an Juliet at the Orum in Minneapolis on May 18th at 1M um I think you have the itenary in front of you but we would leave arrive in Minneapolis around 12:30 p.m. and then the show ends at 3:40 p.m. after which we would eat an early dinner and head back around 500 p.m.

091so this puts us back in so between 7:30 and 8:00 p.m. um I well would you like I'll read you aloud the synopsis if you like um I read okay uh it's rated AG above uh this hilarious new musical flips the script on the greatest love story ever told and Julia asks what would happen next if Juliet didn't end at all over Romeo get whisked away on a fabulous J as she ditches her famous ending for a fresh beginning and a second chance at life and love her way um the educational purpose of this trip would be to for the students to experience high quality live musical production and to see and hear the instruments playing in the pit Orchestra and learn how they contribute to the overall production of the musical and to learn

092about um well a lot of the music actually all of the music of this musical is composed by Max Martin who you may not know his name but you know his music he's written like practically every pop song in the last 30 40 years um and lastly but most importantly to me is that they will have an opportunity to practice Their audience etiquette which is something that we have and learning in when I taught them exploratory Arts the last few years um so This falls on a Sunday so um that was for a number of reasons there's that's the only day that group tickets were available um in the amount that we needed also it avoids an overnight stay because it's a one pan performance um the MAA is also the most cost effective auction

093and uh the first reason we look at it is because that's one of the very few days that uh most of the students are available they have commitments on weekends and evenings um so uh also if you want to learn more I I could show you a preview if you want but um yeah that's quite short and sweet what's roughly the cost per ticket oh um sorry should you first so group ticket this is a group ticket rate um like $37 per ticket but but the the fundraising that that uh you're that you've done previously is is covering yeah so last summer we raised some money um the we got a donation from the Lucas Woods Performing Art Center and then just recently um December 19th the students held their own fundraiser and really did

094all the leg work and heavy lifting um to do this the f was not uh to raise money for the activity account for with this specifically in mind for the 8th grade in high school students and for the younger students at pizza party I think it's good part part of why why it's here when we take a look at uh our handbooks and the approval process and I I know I talked with Keith at you know at length on this it talks about you know um if if we have trips that go out of state we need board approval well I can say that our state border is very close and it's this is going to bring on another topic as far as that approval but but Keith Keith felt that we should bring this

095uh to the board for approval because with what our current handbook States and and the distance I I would argue that uh that would fall within a radius that wouldn't necessarily have to get to this level but I mean that's that's a topic for for us to discuss at a later time but anyway taking a look at this I think it's a it's a great opportunity um and getting into the Orum it's it's a it's a wonderful venue and learning some of these uh etiquette pieces I think is a great thing and exposing more to the Arts is a great thing are they going to be able to see the pit or anything like that or beforeand we usually doing the performance you can't but uh beforehand I would probably take overing intermission or something

096because the Orum the pit is done you can actually just see it's it's down pretty if it was if it was in for not to see right right well no but I mean be cool if you I don't know if you can call ahead and say hey if we get their can we watch them like their warmup real quick and get back during usually you can like during adiss you can go take a look so the the choice of a Sunday is because the kids don't want to go on Saturday um no it's they weren't available so that that particular weekend so we we at a bunch of um different possibilities for the spring so that particular weekend um May 18th I think I think graduation might be on Saturday or something yeah following okay

097so there's some students they're out of town um it's not that they don't want to do Saturday it's that they're not available I'm really uncomfortable asking same with our Sports practices I just don't think government which is what we are should be putting any pressure on our students to make a choice between no I I get and that's that's where this would be a a a truly a voluntary deal so there's I know what you're saying so there is no truly volunteer when there's power when there's a power play a power power play I just well you're not making anybody go uh no but I understand what you're saying yeah I mean if it I had a field trip at the beginning of the year and more than half the class didn't go and I

098don't think they suffered any consequences no but but it's it's it's more of that putting putting yes putting pressure on a student to make a decision one way or the other so is this something we want to put on next month's agenda or uh I would say just with the with the timing I think we would want to make an approval sooner than next month oh this is May you mean this January January meeting or the February meeting January so next meeting not next month yeah yeah so no no don't don't drop us so we can do the pro the the approval tonight or on the 20th I will say that you know and this was Charlotte's concern as well and i' I've seen that too trying to get tickets long weight sure availability lessons

099so and that's part of also again that Sunday date is we these um we did a lot of research and looked at a lot of different performances and we were looking at those in November and and they we said well we'll see what we can do based on how much we raise and then we raised the money and said all right great let's pull the trigger let's see what we got and a lot of stuff is already sold out okay well so tonight Mr President I need a motion I'll make a motion to approve the proposal okay second I need to second can't second second okay second all in favor I I oppos opposed okay passes all right can I get a motion to convene in close session proceed Council statutes 19851 C to consider

100employment promotion compensation performance evaluation data of any Public Employee which over the governmental body has jurisdiction and responsibility motion second second all in favor we taking any handwashing break I didn't I want to check the score game actually I got to the bathroom have you you looked I haven't I think it's same as what it was okay so there was

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.