CorpusRecord 1040

School Board Workshop: February 4, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Lee County School Board
Date
2025-02-04
Location
Lee County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
25,019 words · about 139 min
Collected
2026-04-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good afternoon everyone it's Tuesday February 4th 2025 this is a Schoolboard workshop and the time is 1:00 p.m. sergeant of arms has the lobby been cleared yes thank you there are 11 items on today's agenda safety update construction change order December 24 2526 code of conduct for students first briefing 2526 conduct of adult students first briefing Human Resources Division outcomes budget overview proposed school start times for the 2526 school year job descriptions policy review public comment and good of the order per board protocol each board member should strive for four me four minutes for initial comment and two minutes for followup totaling 10 minutes during our discussion today we are going to start off with we're going to begin with our safety update presented to us by Dave nulan good afternoon board members superintendent Dr

002Denise Carlin and our board attorney Robert dodic is here today as you know this is a safety update we do we're going to do monthly updates on certain topics when it comes to safety so today what I'm here to talk about is open gate as you all know during the Inception of opengate when we first started open gate and put them into our schools as you know it took us about a year for the whole project to make sure every School site was covered every entry point and getting that process down with staff and students and even the public coming to our main entry point the interesting part now is as you know or you may not know but I collect we get data from the our local Partners law enforcement Partners every month on

003number of arrest that occur our schools nose to and for those you don't know what nose to appear is it's actually a it's not a physical arrest but it's a court date you would appear on a later time for a some type of criminal violation then we have civil citations so those are given to us each month by all four of our local law enforcement partners and so the interesting concept was since we've had a good mid year of use this year of Open Gate compared to last year one of the questions was is there a correlation to the incidents that occur at schools based on law enforcement activity again mentioning arrest nose to appears and civil citations has those activities or instance reduced since open Gates been in our schools so is there a

004correlation the answer was looking into this initially the answer was I didn't know the answer to the question let's see what the data shows I know what the feedback was from our schools that they felt there was a difference they could see a change but again looking at feeling versus data what does that look like so what you'll see first of all this is again this is 2023 midyear comparison August to end of December to our midye of4 August to in December for this year so last year you'll see there's a total of 604 incidents that have occurred total in 2023 and again that's a combination of all your agencies law enforc agencies that includes just your arrests those two appears in civil citations in comparison to this year midy year we're at 366 so

005a pretty significant decrease compared to last year and as as you can see here I break down the data kind of shows each agency then we look into the overall so overall there's been an overall decrease of 39% compared from last year this year in activity as far as Arrest no to no two appears in civil citation if you look at it by agency so F County Sheriff's Office they went down 40% from 289 type of again incidence of arrests no to appears and civil citations down to 174 which is 40% decrease Fort Meers Police Department saw a decrease of 29% and C cor saw a decrease of 42% decrease again since we have had open gate in all of our school sites so again just another just another graph to kind of show the

006difference but I thought was pretty significant because again like I said not knowing the answer to that question is there a correlation from open gate to incidents that occurred our schools will it make a difference hasn't made a difference so I was happy to see the data that it show in comparison to midy Year from last year to mid year to this year and obviously we'll continue to monitor that progress we get we get a full year as it go as we go forward but I thought it was very interesting data to share with all of you when you hear about Open Gate and at our school sites and then this is another breakdown basically if you go individually for give you example so for Lee count sheriff's office in 2023 there was a total

007of 82 arrests down to 57 in 2024 another example look if you look at Cape gr police dep department for no to appears they went from 239 to 112 so those those are significant I pull out of the DAT to kind of show you the big decrease in change but so I thought it was very important to share that with all of you today and answer any questions questions you may have superintendent and board do you have any comments Dr car yes if I may just thank you to Mr nulan as you know Safety and Security is my top priority coming into this district and so I've asked Mr nulan to ensure that each and every Workshop we provide an update for you on where we stand relative to this very important issue he brought

008this data forward to us in cabinet we were thrilled obviously you see most areas experiencing a decline and so we wanted to make sure we share this with you so we look forward to your conversation today Mr persons excuse me two things one I really appreciate the last slide breaking it out the arrest the Civil you know notice to appear are we the only School District in Florida that has open gate every school or are some others caught up to I know some of the schools have or the districts have some of their school sites I'm not sure if any of them have 100% all of them covered at this point I know I've had a lot of them that have made contact with us they have come down here to see how we run

009the program with with open gate even out of state as well but I don't know if need to have every school cover as a yet I'm not sure about that well I really appreciate your guidance keeping us right on in the Forefront thank you Miss Jordan I just a question regarding like Slide Five where and I see that everything has decreased so but what does this equate to as far as how many schools I think that would be good too to see so is it 20 schools versus you know 20 schools in the unincorporated versus five schools in the city of Fort Meyers or 10 in Cape so how are we doing compared to the schools and is there something maybe we could do more of in those certain areas yeah good question sense I

010have and it's too much to show but I have a lot all the raw data that breaks down by School site by month type of violation everything and I can tell you I have seen a decline in all of them there's nothing that there's nothing I know that's jumped out that's in increased that's gone the opposite direction if anything every's gone everything's gone decreased or may a couple of stayed the same that have very minimal activity but overall it's been every school I've seen I've seen a decline especially on certain if I saw a major issue on a topic of last year like I mentioned for example Minor High School has a lot had a lot of civil citations or no no to appears for nicotine violations for example those have have significantly declined since

011op gate has been put in place because of the vaping so that shows that's that's working thank you Mr fiser thank you thank you for this presentation Chief and thank you I'm a big fan of Open Gate question out of this could it be said that besides you know deterring access from things going into school could it be argued that it's a deter to anyone going on a school campus yeah absolutely I think we have you know we put together a lot of call for anybody come on the campus at least the the process of coming into the building you have to go through the system first as well too so I think from what I've heard is it is deter as well plus knowing that you have to go through this to enter the

012building thank Miss ganelli thank you Chief Nan this is actually great and I'm glad we're able to talk about that this safety was a big deal I remember talking about this back in 2017 but before you know having metal detectors and I think this was a great compromise cuz it's not quite a metal detector but it is in the sense it really is beneficial and so I'm so glad that we have it now because especially a year after Parkland I remember at the time was Sheriff Mike Scott said he actually recommended metal detectors at that time saying that it's a determent and that is the key to make someone think twice about coming to this school with a weapon so thank you very much thank you thank you for the presentation I had one I

013guess request or maybe it's an additional breakout and I Mr fiser kind of hit on this but I'd be curious to see what it is for this student versus parent or guest breakout for citation so when we're talking about students coming on campus you know coming in in the morning checking in versus parents coming onto the campus to pick up students or what that looks like what that citation breakout would look like I can go through some of the raw dat after today and get that information to you it's very minimal but I can definitely show you that the ones we' have shown as far as adults versus students right to the main entryway thank you thank you Chief Nan the only the only question I had was while all these metal detectors are in

014play and it seems that or weapons detectors it seems that you have a decline I do still often out in the community get emails and then when I'm you know even at an activity on school campuses that there are still some like hot spots in certain schools of where students are congregating and whether it be inside the school or outside in like a parking lot there's always these little areas that they seem to be how do we manage that do we I mean how are we keeping an eye on those hot spots that are on some of our campuses well we asked that if we get that information gets to us somehow and when I some I do receive some information I'll relay that to that local law enforcement agency that is over that school

015to look at those areas whether it be outside or inside or even there are some things sometimes how students may attempt to bring sent men to the school a certain way and we are we here you know other students talking to us and share that information with others so we can be ahead of it but obviously never be complacent always looking for just moving forward and the continuous training and as we learn new things with the system we always try to make sure we put that out to everybody as well to you know keep keep training moving forward on new techniques and things you may catch okay Miss luming if I may also any constituents that would have any concerns we always encourage them to go to the principal and let them know about situations

016we have cameras at at schools and we have other things at schools but the best line of defense is always the people so anything you see that may look out of order as Mr nulan mentioned we want to make sure we bring that to the administration's attention so that they are looking for those types of things and can address them thank thank you see something say something right thank you that's all thank you thank you next is our construction change order for December 2024 our presenters this afternoon are Tina silcox and Melissa Rivera good afternoon board members Dr Carlin and board attorney DOI good afternoon it's nice to be here today Scott's out so I'm presenting in his place Melissa and I are presenting to you the December 2024 change order report if you look

017at the front page there are zero direct material change orders we have 93,471 for non-direct material purchases and zero contingency adjustments and if you look on the second page the change order report cons consist of eight there's two that are Z amount change orders extending the substantial completion date five reductions to the contracts returning approximately 175,000 of unused funds back to the district and one direct material P purchase reconciliation do you have any questions board members any questions Miss Jordan hi Tina thank you the one for Riverdale every time I see Riverdale like kid like in my stomach so this is something that money that we're seeing on here that is already it's in a pocket for us to be spending right it's not yes ma'am we did not increase their original contract amount that

018funding was pulled out of their contract for a direct material purchase to save taxes for kitchen equipment we reused kitchen equipment or did not need some so we canceled the whole DMP the direct material purchase order and that will go back into their contract and once and then we will move that into contingency to be used for other things or it will be returned to the district okay because I know even when the public sees the school it's like okay what are we doing now so thank you so much I appreciate it okay Mr ribel yeah I just want to I just want to congratulate you on another 93,471 so it's it's a nice Trend so keep it going thank you thank you all right thank you both thank you next is the 2025 26

019code of conduct for students this will be our first briefing follow follow by the 2526 code of conduct for adult students also first briefing thank you for presenting this afternoon Dr Jessica Duncan and Chuck Bradley good afternoon board members Dr Carlin and attorney dodic thank you for the opportunity to come back to you today with our first reading for the code of conduct so and if you can see in the presentation on the last slide talks about our timeline but I'm actually going to start with that today so when we met with you last time that was our pre-briefing so we got your feedback you had some questions and since that time we've done quite a few things we've had a survey that have gone out to all parents we've met with our principal leads

020we've met with Dak we've met with the behavior and discipline task force twice and we've met with the teacher task force twice so we have some things that will look familiar from our last discussion and then a couple of just new informational pieces and then today we will also get your through your discussion your thoughts and then we'll come back to you in march with the final code so basically whatever we come to today you'll see reflected in the final code that will come back to you in March all right so our agenda for today we're going to look at some review of our feedback groups for the 2025 2026 code and then also reviews our proposed updates for the 2025 2026 code so some of our feedback groups of course that we mentioned previously

021that we've been to we have met with our administrators and Deans we've met with our teacher task force and they we just finished up with them this last week we have met with students our student Advisory Group Success Academy students and we've also met with some students at Gateway High School and Mariner High School we met with our behavior and discipline task force in multiple meetings between November and January we have met with our district advisory Council just recently and We've held several student services com Community conversations one in each region as well as one here at lcpc we've met with superintendent's cabinet and we have engaged in survey collection with a substantial survey that was provided through horns Marsh Middle and we've also met with tal and spal so for the behavior discipline task

022force just to review this quickly because this again we presented at the last meeting we have members of the community task force a variety of members including La law enforcement tal and spal District leaders parents Advocates and we met with them to talk about our dis our current discipline we did review the code also to talk about some recommendations which at our last meeting actually last two meetings were focused on recommendations so our work right now in the spring will be to be reviewing those and seeing what we could Implement in the fall we also had our teacher task force which was open to each school and any schools provided the opportunity to provide input and we also met with all administrators so the changes that you will see that we are proposing some of

023these we went through last time and of course we'll be open to feedback but we didn't get too much feedback the first time so we won't spend too much time on those we're looking to separate disrespect and insubordination into separate infractions so that we can do some data collection because how we respond to those behaviors in the school looks also different so we will look to separate those infractions we're looking to amend the consequences for drug use and possession and this means that there will be some additional opportunities for principles for consequences we did have a strive Academy open at Success Academy this year and that's been very successful in supporting students so we've been able to provide more options for different consequences whether they be restorative or other consequences as part of the code

024so in here for the biggest change was that a student previously could have up to do a third infraction in a school without a recommendation for Success Academy next year it they could have a second infraction and then a principal could recommend Success Academy after the second infraction so some other updates that were proposing we've updated web links and QR codes we also have are proposing changes to the consequences for bullying the current level is level four we're propos proposing that be changed to level three with the option for a Success Academy review committee meeting and potential placement at Success Academy we also are recommending an changes to the consequences to sexual offenses our current code first and repeated our level three with the option of a sarc review for the repeated we're proposing that

025we delineate between minor sexual offenses and major sexual offenses with minor offenses being level three and repeated with a level three with a sarc review and major offenses being moved to a level two we then are proposing some changes to our electronic and Telecommunications devices policy this is our current policy which does say that students May possess cell phones and other personal Electronics while on school grounds but they must be turned off at all times unless utilized for an appropr approved activity and then possession of all personal electronics including cell phones is at the student's own risk and this is just our policy regarding theft or loss so at our first pre-briefing what we shared was some input from some of the schools particularly at the high school level that was requesting that the board

026consider some discretion potentially in passing or in cafeterias we did get the feedback from the board so we'll revisit that feedback today we also through this met with our leadership teams and regardless of of the direction we go with this whether it's Bell to Bell restriction or whether there is some opportunity for students to use that we made some additional considerations which next slide are some updates to the infractions so because of the current legislation where students cannot use cell phones in the classroom we did increase the school level response so that schools have an increased response to students who do who do break that who do commit that infraction in the school so you can see there we went from on the bottom where we have it is went from a level two with

027a sarc review or if it's repeated directly to a level two so our expectation at a minimum is to follow the law which is no cell phones in the classroom so our code is reflecting that we also made some updates where you could see where we added the bus so if we're looking particularly at a bell to Bell one of the questions was Transportation transportation is not necessarily included Bell to B but we do have an expectation that students follow this code on the bus as well so we wanted to delineate that our expectation is that these the code is followed here and for first and repeated where we had a level three we have a level three with sarc review and a level two so we did gather information regarding wireless communication devices through

028a survey which ran from January 13th to January 27th it was located on our website and information also went out to our schools messenger through school messenger to all families we had over 5,000 responses as of January 24th and 94% of the respondents were parents so to the question I agree with the Restriction of wireless communication device used during the instructional day as long as students can access it from their backpacking in case of an emergency 85.3 of % of respondents replied yes and to the question which of the following most likely is most would most likely improve with a restriction of wcds during the school day you can see that increase in academic performance was the number one and then we go to I do not believe any of these will improve was our

029number two however taken together increase in academic performance increase in positive social interactions reduction in bullying and reduction in peer conflicts were by far the in the majority and in the survey when asked when considering Wireless de communication devices 28.5 were concerned that they wouldn't be able to reach their student in case of emergency and so that's expected and that is something that we've addressed in in the code where we are saying that if students do not have them that they're put away and off in their bags so they are still accessible to our students 35% the largest group did feel that the disadvantages of wireless communication outweigh any advantages and the additional considerations so as we met with our lead and our principal groups and there are considerations that we'll have to make so

030as even if we're Bell to Bell these are things Inver Sation that will have to happen in each school and particularly the high school cuz our elementary and middle don't have cell phones right now so some things I talked about was we still need to make sure we're preparing students for phone use After High School in some ways phones can increase positive interactions maybe there's some things that students interact with them through games or something they're doing in the cafeteria the impact of phone collection in relation to new laws so our doors are closed in our schools so with key personnel at the doors schools will have to consider what that means for cell phone Collections and then monitoring collection where if you're collecting them or you're in the hallway or at those things what

031does that collection process look like so these were considerations that they brought up they did share that whichever way the board goes they are prepared and ready to follow the board Direction and The district policy and just wanted to ensure that we as a team and with our district with our stakeholder groups and with our board that we've looked at all of these considerations considered all of the pros and the cons and that whichever way we go that we feel strongly that is the best way for students and that then that is what we will adhere to move forward with so just to revisit our timeline of course we're at this board first reading here in February we do anticipate bringing the final version of the code of conduct for 2025 2026 to Bo the

032board Action meeting in March and then of course we'll finalize print and distribute in June at this time we turn it over to Dr Carlin and the board for comments and discussion so thank you very much and a special thank you to Dr Duncan and Mr Bradley for all of your hard work as well as as your team I know that you have been working diligently with staff with cabinet with principes with our parents via that survey input and of course our board so just thank you to you and your team for all of your hard work this does not go unnoticed by by the board and myself so basically at this point we turn over to the board and we look forward to your feedback and your conversation today Mr Ribble yeah I just

033like to make one comment here depending on which way the board goes I want them to consider the fact that we need to be consistent in what we do we can't have one school doing going to the left another school going to the right because when we have a grievance come up or we have litigation come up the first thing they're going to present is that we're not consistent in our policies so I think we have to really think long and hard about which way we want to go and make sure that we're not going to do a cookie cutter or ha P of enforcement that's all my comments Mr psons yeah I'm totally for the phones from first Bell to last bell remaining in the backpack there's been so many articles and data from

034other schools that is definitely helped you know they've had and not just from Florida these have been National articles from other places and that's the easiest way to be consistent you're not only consistent for Elementary Middle School and High School I've had emails saying well we want our child to have his cell phone at all times but no one has sent me an email that says why they need to have their cell phone on or to be able to use it so there's a want versus a need and other than the a couple Exceptions there for health you know they need a cell phone to be able to to monitor like you know sugar or something along those lines but that's just where I'm at Miss ganelli thank you so as I've been to schools

035and spoke to teachers and actually recently at the finalist for the Golden Apple I asked different teachers randomly what they thought of it they said that the students are if they have it in the hallways and if they have this the phones in the lunchroom they still manage to meet up and do the things that they shouldn't be doing with the phones and that was a big eyeopener however a school speaking of being consistent Gateway has no tolerance at all they do not have it in the hallway and they do not have it in the lunchroom and there was teachers that supported the princip Le in that so I asked for data because I believe that it would lower infractions that we have based without those without having the phones from other districts that have

036a no tolerance cell phone tolerance because I would love to see I believe the student achievement has gone up when they don't have the phones at all as well as children are engaged with each other because they're left with no other choice because they don't have to engage with the phone so I think I was told that the lunchroom atmospheres are better I mean it's just I love to see the data because I believe it's all positive without the cell phones I believe the cell phones is more negative so hearing what the teachers that are in the classroom every day deal with the phones and would rather not deal with the phones I'm leaning towards no phone tolerance not even in the hallways or at lunch it can be in the backpack but for the

037children to be able to access during emergency I guess I would agree with that but I am leaning after speaking to many teachers they say the positives outweigh the negatives by far and I think if that's I mean that is what our job is to make sure that children have the best education with no distractions the phone still continues to be a distraction and where they do the Meetup get have the fights they even they even take it one step further I was told where that they break up their own fight before the other teachers get there just to break it up because then they won't get an infraction so they are they outsmart us every step of the way could you should never underestimate a child so that is my concern the other concern

038that I had that you mentioned was the sexting minor and major offenses and I'm I'm anything with sexual content for me is a slippery slope so and then who determines what's minor and what's major to me it would be all anything sexting would be major for children to be be involved in because there's something going on more than just them being silly with their phone that they shouldn't be which is back to using your phone so I think that was another concern when when you mentioned when you mentioned that those the levels and minor and major because I was thinking okay what's minor you know and then who determines that what maybe me I might think everything's major maybe I am wrong but I think the parents are the ones that should have a say

039as well as what they think is odema appri appropriate for their child but still as a board we should have some kind of guidelines that's appropriate and not appropriate and sexting to be to me is not appropriate regardless of what the content is so I that was just a couple of things that I had I would love to see again the data for not having cell phone usage what that if that would lower infractions and the evidence and the and plus increase student achievement I know the evidence the data is out there but I would like to have seen that today thank you but thank you for this Mr fiser then we'll go to Miss Jordan thank you after looking at the pros and cons I support Bel toell for all grade levels I again

040our number one Focus needs to be academic achievement obviously disciplines with an issue I have not seen and I want to say I appreciate our administrators I've talked to a bunch of them and teachers and looked through the materials they've provided but I at this point in order to further what we need to do I support Bell to Bell on that I just I don't see where the cons outweigh the pros for this there's too much distraction there's concerns about fights as I said I mean you know obviously kids do have to understand how to use technology in this world and we do work with them whether it's in the Chromebooks and stuff like that but there's also plenty of time outside of school that can be dealt with by the parents as I said

041outside of that everything else the code of conduct I don't have any other issues with at the moment thank you Miss Jordan thank you I was at the deck and they were everybody was really concerned with the consistency so thank you for bringing that up that is a huge Factor also I was looking because we have earbuds we have all of that those devices but we don't have the lately when I'm at the schools I'm seeing them with the headphon not the is it headphones hoodies over the headphones yeah the headphones like over your over your ear so they're listening to something with the headphones walking in the hallways so and I see that's not on there but my concern was maybe I misunderstood on the bus I don't the drivers are trying to drive

042a bus how in the heck are we going to be asking them to now police these kids pulling out a phone I think that's a bit much to ask of them so I'm I'm just a little bit concerned with that because they really need to be focusing on the traffic and getting our kids home safe so I when they're in school and they walk off that bus and they're inside those classrooms they walk through that door I mean I'm all for that but when they get out of that school and on a bus I just think that's a lot to ask for a bus driver and everything else that they have to do that's my personal opinion safety first thank you do you have something Miss shavo go ahead thank you guys for for bringing

043this information again and second to curious to see what the referrals are specifically to cell phone use because I know specifically in some schools and i' and I've spoken to some parents where there's a point where parents have to go pick up the phones from the schools right and there's those pieces and I have a middle schooler who I've pulled their phone from and they still get information of fights that are happening when they don't have their phone and they still get the updates when peers share and in the last conversation I'd mentioned you know seeing no purpose and having a phone in the hallway and kind of understanding having it during lunchtime my concern is the lack of conversation with their peers right I fully support a BTO Bell schedule our kids are better

044at technology than we are at at this point I don't think they really need to they're more prepared for the real world and Technology I think than we are at this point I think they need to understand the impacts of social media and what that is in the real world at this point I would like to see an addition to the items with smart glasses because those are out there as well so adding that as a device because there are students that do have the smart glasses and you can take pictures and record and make phone calls with those so I would like to see that added but yeah other than that I think I'm in support with the Bell thank you m Jordan I understand what you're saying on the bus it doesn't say

045they can't be on while they're on the bus it just says they can't be used improperly they can't be sexing they can't be bullying they can't be filming fights I think that's what they're after because several parents actually asked they be on because they're actually better at tracking where the bus is by using find a phone you know tracking the phone where their child is so if that's how it I that's how I read it but I don't know correct so when you see the infractions so like here unauthorized taping photographing or posting of social media of disruption on campus it previously just said on campus and we've now included the bus on campus always included the bus to us but we wanted to put that out there directly so that there was no no

046misunderstanding that we expect the rules to be followed on the bus and while our driver's first priority is to be driving ensuring our kids are safe if they engage in one of these infractions that the code will still apply to them okay thank you yep thank you for clarifying that Mr Fisher one last thing sorry I forgot to talk about I know there's also some underlying concern that if we pass and go through that parents would come and petition us and they want to change our minds which again they're free to do but I mean part of our job as a board to make tough decisions and stick by them so I just wanted to make sure to reiterate that to everyone so we've had you know whether it's high schools rebuilding schools things like

047that a lot of tough decisions and people come petition us and that's their right but as I said I don't see any issue again with this board you know I said going back on that so I just wanted to reiterate that to the public thank you thank you I agree with Mr Ribble you nailed exactly what I had written down already is consistency is key across the district K through 12 because that's how I feel like that's how our administrators kind of get in trouble if you will so not to mention it's I if consistency is across the district then there is no of the this teacher allows it this teacher doesn't and it to me it just it takes a pressure off of the teacher and they can do their job it also takes

048the pressure off the administrator having to police those types of classrooms I'm really glad to see that there were I think 5,000 plus participants but we have 100,000 students and that's that's a great number but would love to see more participants and I understand that 20 94 of them were 94% were adults so maybe a suggestion on how we can get these surveys just more participation when we send any survey out we I know we sent another survey out right before we went up to Tallahassee about some questions and obviously we're seeking out our community's opinions so we welcome them I just would love to see more participation and I don't know if that's something we actually reach out to our news media if they're covering what's going on in Lee County School District perhaps

049they could you know say hey there's an opportunity for you all to take this survey you know and have the link up there I mean i' I'd love for our media to connect with us on on on that and then as far as the infractions this is something a little bit different I think I've been really vocal about my support with bell tobell and cell phone so I'll I guess for the record I'll say it again but when it comes to infractions and I'm not sure if this is Dr Carlin a question for you or or for you folks over here how are we getting our parents to really understand these levels of infraction I understand it because I was a teacher and I'm on the board so I'm I'm reading this but I think

050we have so many parents that truly when their child does get in trouble and they get that phone call from the office how are we explaining these levels of infraction to where they can really understand and grasp to me that could be real foreign language to some of our families so I'll take a stab at it so as a principal one of the things that I required our team to do was to make sure that the code of conduct got to the parents and so then there was the signature that was indicating that they had read it and then taking those opportunities in openhouse and other opportunities to share that information again that's only as good as parents coming in and then as an assistant principal I wore that hat for five years taking the

051time you know the root of the word discipline and Latin is to teach and so many times it wasn't just teaching the child about what happened and what will happen next but also conveying to the parent as the assistant principal here's what's next here's why this is a level three or why it's a level one to to that extent and so those are opportunities for us as we continue to work through the you know leadership development work that we are doing right now to redesign our leadership development program is to make sure that our aspiring leaders and our system principles and principles incorporate those types of practices so many of them do but we do have a fair number of new leaders in our district and so we'll want to make sure we convey those

052those best practices to to our leaders so thank you for that so just to follow up I know we print or or excuse me I know we have a link to our code of conduct and the fact that you all have shortened it and condensed it is I hear positive feedback about that all the time and I appreciate as a parent but is there somewhere within that code of conduct that are examples of infractions that a parent can just be like okay they keep talking about this level one or level is there a list or a list of examples Bill 10 so a couple of pieces we do have that for our administrators but we can certainly prepare something that would be appropriate for our parents that we have accessible to them on the website

053that would be something that we could do fairly easily so I think that's a great suggestion also wanted to speak quickly to the data so when we look at a school light Gateway and we pull their data and we look from semester 1 this year to semester we see great data and reductions how like sort of in line with with Mr Nan shared right before us we're seeing that though across the board so it's a little bit difficult for us to say what is specifically about cell phones or what behaviors are related to cell phones on our referrals right now we have if we have an infraction we can tell if there's a drug or alcohol if there's something related to that because we have an area that we would Mark and we had talked

054about having our referrals reflect something about Wireless communication because even if it's in subordination we can't tell if that's related to a cell phone or something like maybe a student got an insubordination infraction but it was started with a cell phone and it's not listed then under electronic communication devices so if we were to add something we would be able to pull some better data for you so we have data for each school which we can provide you can look at and certainly with a Gateway who's been doing this now for 3 years one of the things the principal shared was this year she really engaged the teachers and that made a substantial difference and one of their numbers right now last year they have about half of the electronic communication device in fractions that

055they had last year so you can really see that in her implementation so and of course because she has been implementing she's going to be a source of information for us and we're going to be going to her for for several things as we have up to this point but that is something with data that we're will give us better information because right now there's a lot of infractions that could have potentially started with a cell phone but end up with a different code then thank you for that information U the S the suggestion about the parent information I think that's something we can can easily do we also have our community conversations that we offer to parents so we go out into each region with our whole team so we will continue to do

056that and hope to engage more parents there and just before I don't know if there's any other information but Dr Carlin talked about the team and I would be remiss not to thank the people who were up not up here with us today Rob Cooper Roger Lloyd and Rachel G who are regional directors who were critical in the not only the development but the facilitation of many meetings evening meetings Community meetings so want to thank them as well and we hear your input and so when you see the code in March what you will see reflected is in the electronic commu communication device section will be a bell to Bell restriction so when you see that come that's what you will we'll see in March thank you Miss fling based on what you were just

057speaking about that has always been a concern where the parents and the signatures how many signatures and I know that we have requested and we have received you know it's been a while since we received that number of what parents or who I mean the DI the demographics of who did not actually sign that so of course when they did not sign do they understand no they don't understand because they haven't signed it and I know that's been an issue I brought that up I bring it up every year because I every year that this comes up it's like okay how do we ensure that our parents are reading this how because we all read you know make sure that we understand what's taking place with our children how do we make sure that all

058the other ones are doing it and I know that at one point in time they said the school was reaching out to parents who had not yet filled that out but putting those links like you said I think is an excellent idea because people do have to need the understanding of what that actually means for their children but but again how do we once once this is finished how do we make sure that everybody is signing this so again we're in that situation where these children are getting these in ctions and but I really appreciate everything you just said thank you Dr car yes and thank you m Jordan and we'll be happy to provide that data just so and maybe a fiveyear look at it so we can actually have some comparative data one

059thing that I will say as elected officials we also have an opportunity to engage with our families right so our schools work extraordinarily hard to get this information out and many of you are connected with your schools but I can tell you as elected officials we have such a wonderful opportunity to incorporate this conversation when we go out and speak with with our constituents so I would say we can be a value ad to what the schools are already doing to increase that number thank you if there are no more comments about this would you like to move on to the adult student okay so with the adult code in our pre-briefing we shared that I think the biggest change really is that we now have that in both Creole and Spanish which we have

060and we're excited to to have that available in those languages there were no recommendations at that time the changes were U fairly minimal to that adult code so at this time there are no additional changes than what were presented at the pre-briefing are there any comments questions okay thank you all right we will move on next is human resource division outcomes Angela Mont Morano will be presenting to us this afternoon good afternoon members of the board superintendent Carlin attorney dodic today I'm here to represent and human resources and present to you our strategic Plan update the outcomes that we have had for last year I'm going to be sharing some key developments and achievements as we move on with the HR transformation so our agenda today we're going to talk about the HR transformation the

061HR key performance indicators program highlights short-term priorities and long-term goals so as you can see here we did start out as a part of the HR transformation we set some initial initial priorities to build a strong foundation for our initiatives I'm pleased to announce that we've successfully completed the following the Evergreen compensation study phase one this was crucial in ensuring our compensation practices remain competitive and Equitable the integration of professional development into the main HR umbrella we have finalized this integration and bringing that back to HR we have created two new departments underneath human resources talent management this new department will focus on reviewing systems to evaluate performance identifying areas of improvement and recognizing High performers we've also added on the field operations Department in which we will be having the human resource business partners

062that are going to be the representatives out in the schools to provide the support that the schools need additionally we're currently currently progressing on several key projects still in the works so our people soft optimization this is you know we're actively working to optimize this people saw system to improve the efficiency and the user experience so that is still ongoing and the integration of employee relations and as I stated the HR business partners this integration aims to streamline processes approve collaboration and ensure that our HR services are responsive and aligned with the employee needs so looking at our key HR ke performance indicators we're going to specifically focus on strategic priority three which was the recruiting developing and retaining highly effective staff when we look at our key performance indicator 6.1 This was reducing employee

063turnover for each segment so we're we're looking to look and really retain our Workforce here and then we're also going to look at our kpi 7.2 which also aims to increase the percentage of employees who report having received meaningful feedback and the opportunity to learn and grow within the organization by us focusing on these areas we believe we can create a more Dynamic and engaged Workforce so on kpi 6.1 as you could see here in this chart this data displays the work of reducing employee turn turnover for each employee segment the official baseline as you could see here this was from October of 2023 our turnover for fiscal year 24 was 15.6% in the teacher sector 15% in the support staff sector and 8% in the admin the Strategic plan requires a current Target and

064a 4year performance targets where our goal is to reduce employee turnover by 1% each year the US Bureau of Labor Statistics states that the average turnover rate to be between 12 and 15% in all sectors and as you can see we are seeing a decline here so as we're looking at kpi 7.2 again this was to increase increase the percent of employees that report having received meaningful feedback and the opportunity to learn and grow so we looked at the new teacher training camp participation retention so when we look at this we see the retention rates over the past two years for these of our teaching staff teachers with less than three years in the classroom and our first year instructors steadily increasing and this program has been very successful the new teacher program training camp

065excuse me so now when we're talking about leading leading measures this graph displays our school-based instructional retirements in blue and separations in Orange separations are considered to be employees who left the district The Gray Line displays the number of hires that we've had for fiscal year 24 staff had hired 624 instructional staff but we did lose 81 instructional staff members this slide now is showing you the total instructional turnover by fiscal year and breaks down the two categories that make up turnover transfers and separations are the two categories that make this up transfers are employees that move job locations or positions within the district regardless each action represents a transaction that occurs in both HR and at the work site for the past year we in we experienced an increase in employee transfer which led

066to a higher turnover rate on this next slide I do want to let you know that the slide that you received there is incorrect you will be receiving slide nine after the meeting and updated to this what I'm showing you on the screen is the updated slide so I just want to let you know if you're looking at your screen there this slide is representing the hiring retirements and separation of non-instructional staff includes support staff in the spout unit and the salary schedule end unit as indicated we hired 1,1 support staff members in fiscal year 24 and 722 non-instructional staff members left the district this does not mean that we have full employment of support staff because this data does not include the vacancies that existed in these groups at the beginning of the fiscal

067year so taking that into consideration looking at the this slide represents the percentage of non-instructional turnover by fiscal year we had a significant decrease here in fiscal year 24 year over-year which is positive for the district transfer stayed identical year toe but separations are at 15.08% with our goal indicated earlier to be reduced to the 14% we've successfully aligned our inperson training with our administrative assistance enhancing our overall operational effectiveness this program has really seen great great things to improve the customer service experience we remove the TB test and the physical requirements for employment and now accept electronic transcripts streamlining the hiring process for our new hires we've completed phase one of the Evergreen compensation study which has a set a solid foundation for Equitable compensation practices and thanks to a strong partnership with Kelly

068Services we have increased our fill rates from 69.1% a year ago to an impressive 93.5% since February 26th of 2024 to current our talent acquisition team has enhanced marketing strategies and Outreach efforts to bolster recruitment our new teacher training camp has been instrumental in new teacher retention resulting in 88% retention rate amongst our first year teachers who attended this new teacher training camp we are excited to share these impactful highlights that showcase our commitment to continuous Improvement and effective HR practices so looking at some of our short-term priorities and our long-term priorities our number one here is recruitment realignment project which with Dr Carlin has been one of her main focuses is the recruitment our focus is on optimizing and restructuring the recruitment process to better align with our current organizational needs and goalss this

069will enhance our ability to attract top talent and streamline hiring processes our next is phase two of the Evergreen compensation project study in this phase we will build on our initial findings to further refine and expand our compensation structures ensuring they remain competitive Equitable and aligns with industry standards for our long-term goals we have the HR transformation we're committed to continuing the evolution of our HR strategies systems and processes ensuring they remain agile and aligned with the organization's future objectives the ongoing transformation will support greater efficiency Innovation and employee engagement in addition for a long-term goal is our people soft enhancement our long-term strategy includes the continuous enhancement of people soft to ensure it remains a Rob robust and effective tool for managing HR functions these improvements will support our evolving needs and optimize the

070user experience for both employees and HR professionals at this time superintendent comments and board discussion thank you very much Miss Mont Marino appreciate you and your team for all of the work that you continue to do in HR board members as you know one of our top priorities and addition to school safety and increasing student achievement has to do with teacher retention and recruitment and so HR I'm very proud of them they've been very laser-like focused on making sure that we hold on to the teachers that we have and the staff that we have in partnership with our schools and departments they can't do it by themselves this is really a team effort and then of course recruitment you've heard me speak many times about when I was sworn into office well over 200 teacher

071vacancies and I think that number is down to Miss Martin Marino 187 187 so we're going in the right direction from about 2:30 to 187 and we're working our way to zero and that's going to be within the next couple of months so that's our commitment I we're saying it out loud because we mean it so we look forward to your comments and your questions are relative to hr's presentation the Strategic plan outcomes thank you Mr persons I had a question what is the a turnaround for let's say a teacher or a par professional walks in today F you know with the application and everything they need or does whatever they're supposed to do online how long until they're actually vetted and put into a position it's a process I'm going to tell you that

072and I don't have an exact number to give you but I will get you some figures for that but I will tell you that one of the challenges is is from start to finish when that first comes over from the school with a what we call forward to hire and then we have to start the background check as well as do their credentials in terms I'm talking about a teacher where credentials have to be met in order for them to become a teacher so it sometimes takes two months it could be a little less it could be a little bit more I can get you some figures on that on averages though I would love there's some way to put one person in charge of another person and walk through it just stay on it

073every day until they I mean because we're in such dire need understood understood and there is something I will say Mr person that we are working on we have enhanced our onboarding process and that is really made a very big difference and has decreased our times in that regard we've also having as I mentioned earlier the administrative assistant training that we've been doing has really been very beneficial in order getting that information from the school to our HR department as soon as we receive it in Human Resources we're acting and we're moving on that as well as looking at the communication with each and every applicant or new hire as we would call them at that point making sure that there's a touch point that we are touching them we're talking to them and making

074sure that we're not losing them because they've had no contact so in the last year that I've been here that's been a priority of mine is making sure that as we identify these candidates and people that we wish to hire we are having full contact with them well thank you I would love to see that gotten down to one month I mean that's really where it needs to be lose their interest for sure yeah I want to work and then nothing happens for two months thank you for sure shv thank you for putting the presentation together I had a question on slide seven so 801 for the separation do we have exit interviews completed for them when they leave that highlight where they're going since they're not sure going I guess within the district cuz

075I'm I'm going to assume that on slide eight where it shows there's a transfer versus a separation for that 15.64% that's a separation do we know where they're going correct so one of the things that we're looking to enhance in our people soft optimization is the different when we go in and somebody leaves and separates from employment with us is to have a better I'm going to call it a category in terms of how we are putting them in a why they're leaving right once we are able to optimize and get that data we will be able to provide the board with much more specific data as to where people are going and for example just to use an example we have a category called personal so if personal if an administrative system when they

076go in and put in that paperwork if they put personal we don't know what the definition of that personal is so we're looking to enhance that so that I can provide you that data in the future thank you so then on slide eight where it shows that 15.64% is that based off of 801 that's separated completely I have to get back too on that because this includes transfers when it's talks about turnover when in Prior the separation talks about people that have left this now includes people that have transferred so transfer I'm Excuse me I take that back transfer outs are the blue and the separations are the 15.64% are can can you share those yes so we've engaged just recently with our current marketing vendor that we have and we are doing increased in

077regards to broadcasting which will include radio some TV we are doing more digital Outreach that's going out these are things that we have not done in the past that now we are looking to increase and do that now to get to our goal for May 1st are these in Market or out of Market broadcast do you know I don't know the answer to that question I'd have to get back to you I don't have the specifics of where I have where we're going right now we haven't finalized that particular plan yeah I'd be curious to see what that strategy is sure I appreciate it thank you Mr fiser thank you thank you chief monano for you and your team's hard work so one of the things and kind of pigging backing off of Mrs chavano

078one of the biggest things we've dealt with there transform the question is how is our culture and obviously we need some measurements on that I know that was one you know exit survey what about also getting some more metrics to measure that I know Deputy superintendent Savage when he was superintendent dealt with some feedback through thought exchange so I'd like to see us to see where we're at with our culture because one of the things obviously for example an exit interviews you know all of us I'm sure hear different things from different employees but is that actually getting across are they telling HR when they're leaving are they telling you know X Y and Z versus what we're hearing so cuz that's obviously some very constructive feedback we need on that Mr Fisher I and

079I didn't answer the question in regards to exit interview so I'm glad that you just brought that back up so we have also relooked at our exit interview process currently and we have created a new tool as well as with the HR business partners are going to be going out and ensuring that we're getting the exit interviews from those people that separate from the organization so that again we can provide additional data now when we have those either conversations they have the option ask to speak with us or they fill it out there is more specific and trying to drill down the reason why people are leaving and once I have data from that from a quarter then we can start to provide data to you in regards to that the past data we did

080not get the participation that we needed but now that we have the HR business partners which that is will be a part of their role as well cuz they'll be out in the schools they'll know when people are leaving they'll go to them personally and try as well as talk to the new staff that are in the schools agree thank you I'd also like to see more current metrics like I was talking about current Personnel I don't know if that's something we could thank you and we are doing stay interviews for the current Personnel so that is in a pilot program right now and as that pilot program we tweak that out and we get ready to roll RO with that we'll be able to provide you that data as well okay thank you and

081my second part of this PeopleSoft where are our long-term goals on that we had and again this is not on HR when I say this we had a consultation that I feel that we've gotten zero value out of so and that has really not translated so from your standpoint where do we see people s going so currently as you know we did engage with another you know consult that we are no longer engaged with moving forward we are looking at we're doing working with our internal staff and also brought on another company that can help us just taking what we have right now and trying to give us what the needs that we have and they've been working diligently on that in regards to the specifics it's it's really hard to say but I will

082say that h you know there is opportunity for improvement and the needs of what the district needs to come from people soft in order for us to be able to provide you the information and as well as us to recruit and retain our staff and to provide the data that is needed there so Mr Fisher what I hear is there's an opportunity for improvement there absolutely yes Madam superintendent outside of that last kind of question just going back to data General I said I'd love to see again just some more General feedback for us and members of the public of some of our HR data and stuff like that I know that's working Pro progress but I'd like to see more of that to kind of give all of us a big picture on that

083so you got it thank you're welcome Mr yanelli well you both hit on the exit interviews but I not no offense to you but we've been asking for that prior boards have asked for it in the past and I know you're really new to the to the job so there's lots of things to that has room for improvement so thank you for this work but we do need to and thank you Mr Fischer for asking for the data because that's really really important at this point in time because I'm I'm my thought is how do we keep them it's retention right so how do we keep them even when they we're losing them like can we go to them and say hey what can we do to keep you even if it's changing schools if

084it's at the school level and you know we should be going to Miles try to keep our keep our staff to for the retention and I don't think we act quickly enough in that situation also this is actually for the superintendent one of my things that I've brought up in the past is like the flexibility for do do we have options or the flexibility to for new employees or even old employees if they have health insurance through a spouse or another you know can they opt to not take like I don't take the health insurance I don't get credit for it but can they get credit for it and not even maybe not full credit but H maybe half to because I would believe that would lower not only lower our premiums but lower our

085risk because that would fall most health things would fall back on the on the spouse's insurance so that's a savings that's a possibility I mean and just having that flexibility as an employee I think you might get someone that is allowed that flexibility and or you might keep them for that so I mean I just think we have to think out of the box and that was one of my thoughts I've always kind of brought it up why do you have to take the insurance if you don't want like I choose not to because my husband has it I don't need to double dip because I'm never going to use it so you know and so it's that opportunity to be creative and giving that even if it's you know our insurance is quite expensive

086so and they some people pay in but what if they could get that 5,000 a year instead of we spending that saves us 5,000 basically and that gives them 5,000 back in their pocket so that's just some things that I think we should have you know you can have a conversations with your staff about and if and maybe it's not possible but if it is that flexibility would be awesome and that would help change culture and I think bring more you know more retention or or even bring in new employees for that option thank you that's it Miss J vanelli what else say is absolutely all of these ideas are in we are really being very aggressive in our retention and recruitment efforts as Miss mon Marino talked about everything's on the table right now

087because we have to make sure not only do we need to retain our employees in our schools but also in this district office there there are numerous people I will just say being being retired 17 months before I came into this job that are no longer here and and I say a fair amount of them were very talented people so and you spoke about culture a few minutes ago that is super important and that speaks to many reasons why people have left this building I will share that personally so we have to look at all facets of it including compensation benefits and culture so I want to applaud the board because you're you're hitting on all the areas that need to be carefully addressed thank you thank you Mr Jan Elli I will also just

088say just to add to Dr Carlin's comments the in regards to the if you do not elect our insurance we do have a very small payment that goes to employees that don't elect it but there's a you have to elect an a voluntary benefit in order to receive it and Dr Carlin and I are working on looking and revisiting that so yes everything is on the table and we are looking at it but yes there is a there is a small amount that they would receive now if they elect a voluntary benefit thank you're welcome anyone else Mr Ribble I just want to make a couple quick comments the first is X interview has always been a problem and it's a big problem corporately for many many corporations especially if somebody leaves that's dis grinded

089they hesitate to talk to someone because they're angry so it's a very difficult thing I just suggest that we try to do what other districts are doing with best practices just continue to try to come up with something clever the follow Mr person's comments and delay and employment I have had a lot of feedback about fingerprinting and I can't understand working with a large company that does fingerprinting why it would take so long to get fingerprints back and delay someone getting on the payroll because the longer we wait there's more of a chance are going to go and seek employment with someone else and last but not least I know our superintendent's been actively involved in the relationship with FGCU and we have a Dean over there Dr Diana chesar who's just outstanding I was

090over there with her Friday with a bunch of students that are studying to be teachers and I hopefully we're getting those students engaged and partnering with them and giving them some opportunities to do some teaching here maybe pro bono or I don't know how how you could reimburse them but that's a big part of gold there if we can get the relationship cuz ker County and charlott's going to snatch them from us if we don't don't execute that plan that's all I have yeah we do work with them and we're continuing to build on that relationship as well all right I just have a few things first of all I just want to touch on something that hasn't been brought up yet this is why it's so important that our state legislators start working with

091us to and thank you to our government relations ladies that are in the audience today thank you so much for working so hard and alasse a couple weeks ago I know that you're going to bounce back and forth between there but I think it's really important that the public knows that we are trying to have these conversations with even our local and state representatives about things such as teachers who want to come back maybe they took a couple of years off out of the classroom they're wanting to come back what but the links that they have to go through to get back into the system whether it's continuing ed or or what have you or their their certification has expired so just to let the public know that we have Two Fine ladies that are

092working really hard to help execute that I agree with you on the onboarding that was something I heard when I went out in August to see a couple principles that they were just they had people eager and ready to go but it couldn't go fast enough and then again they lose interest so I won't beat a dead horse you already talked about that Mr Ribble you bring up a good point about the exit Serv survey a couple of things when it comes to Corporate America versus here in Corporate America you're just a number no offense but it is the truth here I feel like our district provides an opportunity for our staff to become family and so when our staff is leaving whether it's disgruntled or not emotions are involved and I think that especially

093people who deal with children have so much empathy for lots of things so I when we when they're doing these exit surveys which most of the time they just don't they just they wash their hands they move along they think it's not going to do any good and some people just aren't honest they're so worried that it's going to come back and what if they wanted to come back to the district and I think I mean honesty is a virtue so continue with that we talk about retention we talk about exit interviews but what about interviews about why people stay so the stay interviews that we're we're conducting and are in a pilot program right now is exactly what we're looking at okay so again as I said it's in a pilot program we just

094want to make sure that the instrument that we're using the questions we're asking are getting the data that we really want so as soon as that's at a Pilot that will that will go out because we all know that you know you focus on the negative you continue to stay negative if we start focusing on the positive and we have our folks out there sort of campaigning on why it's so great to work at the Lee County School District that can't help but Reach people in a different way and I think it would change the mindset because we keep talking about culture I think it would start to shift the mindset so just a suggestion Miss Shavano talked about marketing earlier why not have these you know like highlight reels or you know these interviews

095not just with teachers but what about our students why we loved and what about our graduates oh grab them grab them and ask them will you do an interview why you graduated in this may or this past May grab and asked into an interview what was so great what did you love about the Le I guarantee you we can find hundreds of kids that would testify that this was a great place to receive their education and maybe start using using that as our own marketing strategy something just a little bit different but that's just my own two cents so anything else board superintendent all right thank you so much thank you next is budget overview with Dr Amy desmore and Kelly Lecter good afternoon Dr Carlin members of the board can you all hear me

096okay make sure that was okay well it's always budget season for us but we are in the middle of really focusing on on the FY 26 or the new fiscal Year's budget and so we wanted to take this opportunity to give just an overview of you know the entire budget process what that looks like what you can expect and then get some feedback from you as to what you would like to see or what you would like to hear throughout the process so that being said I will turn it over to Mrs Kelly lecher who will give some overview and then we'll go into some conversation good afternoon what I want to start with is just kind of going over the major parts of the budget or the funds so that we all have a

097clear understanding of what they are and what the purposes of them are for so there is six parts or funds to the budget each one of them has their own specific use of dollars the main one is the general fund that is the largest that one is the primary funding source for our classrooms the education of our students and the operating expenses of the district we have our debt service which is the payment of our debt this fund is made up mainly or 100% from a transfer from Capital so when you're looking at the budget and you have that total amount in debt service funds that is actually money that is already being accounted for in capital funds in the revenue and then being transferred over so it's kind of like a double count but

098we have to show it separately this these are the funds that we use to pay off the our certificates of participation or our mortgage payments both principal and interest then we have our Capital funds these are the funds of course as you know used to build our schools secure our buildings buy equipment and maintain our buildings as well the These funds the main funding source is the capital outlay millage piece of it we also have sales tax which is the second highest part of it and then we have things like impact fees and just some small things that come in and the building of the budget for this we have a capital committee that meets regularly that goes over all of the needs of the districts and then prioritizes them based on what needs to

099be done and the funding that we have available for us for these things the next fund is our food service fund the Food Service fund as you know supports the breakfast and lunch program for all of our students the Food Service team while building the budget will estimate the revenues they think they'll be bringing in and the expenditures needed in order to have the staff to feed the students and stuff and then this is a reimbursement from the federal government for the meals that we serve then we have our special Revenue which is our federal funds or our grants these are set these are used for specific purposes and there's actually two types that we get we have the entitlement grants which is like your idea your title one your title two they're given to

100us specifically for use for certain students or programs and things that have to be done and then we have the discretionary grants which are the grants that people go out and apply for that they may have a need or want to do something and they go get a discretionary Grant in order to you know fill that Gap the next and the last part is the internal service funds these are funds that cover all of our insurance is our health insurance and our property Casualty Insurance this is another fund that is a direct transfer from mainly the general fund but for our health insurance if we have someone who's paid from a grant the grant actually pays for the health insurance for the employees that are paid from those grants so these this though is a

101complete transfer from one funding source to another so it's kind of like a repeat in the budget as well so I kind of wanted to go over the timeline and building the budget so you have some idea of you know what we when when we start what we do and everything so the budget actually starts building in November so you know September is the final approval we have a couple of months to kind of keep get things settled up and then we start right up into the next year's budget in November we start planning for both the budget or both the department and the school processes at those times in January we open as you know the school choice applications we normally do our FTE our student projections with the state however this year I

102will tell you that they just informed us that they will not be ready to open that system until mid-February so we'll be a little bit behind on when our projections to the state will be and January we normally receive the governor's recommended budget we actually just received that information yesterday so we'll be digging in onto what the governor has recommended and we also start our department process as you know the superintendent has made it her priority to look at every piece of the budget and so that process is actually was started before January it was started before we left for the holiday break so and that is an ongoing process in February the school choice open enrollment ends we will start working more in depth on school allocations with the projections of the school by

103schools and really looking at where we think the students are going to show up and what type of students at what school in March the legislative session will convene the school choice batch will run in mid-march and then we'll release the school allocations to the schools at the end of March we do that right after the school batch to make sure that the projections that we've thought the schools were going to get align with what where the parents have enrolled the students at so that we there's no disconnect that they have more kids that show up than what we had thought they would in April if there's after we release those we work with schools in case there's any concerns that they have you know they may think they may get more kids than you

104know what we have they may think the student population is a little bit different than what we have and we work with them to address those we're also going to work with them beforehand to kind of give them an idea of what we're looking at so that they can provide feedback prior to as well and then we'll be reviewing legislative items as they're coming in and as we're seeing them to see what the budget impact on us may be and then in May the legisl session will end and we will receive our first ffp calculation or Umi Florida Finance education calculation in June we will be presenting a preliminary budget to you we will continue over the summer both June and July to reviewing school allocations just to make sure as kids are coming and

105going that our schools have the right resources to be ready when they start school in July we will receive our second calculation that comes in right after the final millage rates are determined by the state and basically that most of the time is just to switch in funding from state to local or local to State funding we have had some changes minor changes in the past but we really don't expect much change in that overall Revenue at that point we will be avering izing the tenative budget and following all of the trim requirements or the truth and millage requirements we will be presenting the tenative budget to you all at a public hearing and we will again be reviewing School enrollments and then in August our students are back in school after they come back

106about the 10th day of school we actually do another count just to make sure that the schools have the resources they need for the kids that have shown up at the school and then we start we really start finalizing the budget at that point to bring you the final budget in September and then we're getting all of our documents to the Department of Revenue and the Department of Education property appraiser and tax tax collector all of those things that are due after the final budget's approved so that was an overview of all year long really the types of things that we look for in the budget process the types of information information we need to incorporate into the budget process and when we do that so when we are thinking about building the budget or

107when you're thinking about building the budget really think of it as in three kind of distinct processes that we work on the school process the department process and then there's the districtwide or the overall District process for types of expenditures and planning for that really we do at the district level we're going to talk specifically about two of those today the school and the department process so with the school process the schools receive what you'll hear called a Dr or District resource allocation and that's their the school's budget for the year for personnel and in all things school in order to generate those we do work with our principls with the regional superintendent the different program areas such as ese esol technical education and the planning department and the things that you see listed here

108are some very important details that we need to know and plann for to appropriately resource a school so what types of programs will be placed at the school how large is the school and how many students or FTE can it hold versus how many we think will actually show up right are those things that we think about and also of course what are the projected overall revenues we're going to get through the ffp because those things that Revenue has to balance out between what we are giving our schools what we have at the department level and what we have to support everything else districtwide so those are the types of information that we analyze and goes into creating their Dr or their District resource allocation that will be provided to each School as Kelly just

109said around the March or end of March time frame and then the schools make their resource and their Staffing decisions based on that budget and their needs and the established requirements that come with that District resource allocation so with the Dr the schools do receive information about requirements what it is requ what it is that they're required to do with those dollars what it is that they're recommended to do based on the types of population types of programs that they have but then within those parameters they have the ability or the flexibility than to use their resource to staff as they believe is appropriate for their individual location so that's an overview of the school process and then after that after each school is allocated there Dr then we do meet weekly with regional representatives

110to or the regional associate superintendents to review those School budgets and any request that any individual school has made after they have received their budget so if there's something that they believe that they need that they cannot resource with their resources something that they believe that maybe we didn't think about or see they have additional information they certainly are free to go through and provide that information to us put it in request and then those requests are reviewed and then schools are communicated with as to the decisions of those requests based on all the information that we have in the department process which works just a little bit differently Department in the department process as Miss Mrs lecher alluded to earlier through this year Dr Carlin has U made it clear that we need to

111examine everything inside of the budget and take a critical look at everything that is there and kind of take a new look at it based on the priorities that we know that we have or that we've outlined for the upcoming year so in the proc every division is in the process of doing that now meeting with the chief strategy officer the deputy superintendant for a detailed budget review and within that then every department is tasked with reviewing possible areas of fund realignment based on the district priorities so how would funds be realigned in order to better meet those priorities and then the division Chiefs together with the deputy superintendent will prioritize those requests and then based on that review of those prioritized requests then the superintendent will give a final approval on any recommendation for

112Department budgets so the school process and the department process are very different and very distinct u in the building of a budget in each individual year so we are going to be providing information to you every month on budget overview as we're in the process of building the budget some of the things that we'll make sure that you have information on are the estimated FTE projections once they're done the governor's recommended budget where that what that makes you know looks like for us the school allocations what are those required things what are you know what is the recommendations kind of giving you that full picture so you understand what the schools are looking at and what they need to build their budgets on the revenue Outlook as the legislative session is going on we'll be

113providing some Revenue outlooks based on some estimates that are coming in and the information that we're hearing and then of course the recommended five-year Capital plan is another big piece of it that we'll be sharing with you as we're moving forward these are just some of the things that we'll be bringing back to you as the months go on and definitely if there anything that you want to have more information on or you want some in-depth information on please share that with us and we would be more than happy to add that to our presentations to make sure you have the information you need to make the decisions that you need to make I just want to remind you that the tenative public the public hearing on the tentative budget is scheduled for July 29th

114and then our final public hearing is scheduled on September 9th and from there we'll just turn it over to Dr Carlin and you for discussions thank you very much Dr dores and Mrs lecher really appreciate the overview and one of my goals coming in as superintendent is to make sure that our budget is readily available to you all but the public as well and to make sure that our budget and processes are as transparent as possible you know one of your most important responsibilities related to statute is to provide oversight for a budget and so it's very important to me that you are provided on an ongoing basis not just waiting till July or September when you are provided with preliminary or final budgets but all along each month of the year where we sit

115down at a workshop I've actually asked the team to make this a standing item so that we bring portions of the budget forward our thinking about the budget and our processes related to the budget so that you have a chance to look closely at it to ask all the questions you want to ask because is such an important role that you play as a board so just thank you to our team and to all of our team members in support of these presentations and we look forward to your questions and your comments board members I'm going to open this up for comments or questions Mr persons oh I love this discussion haven't had my own business the one thing that helped me the most would be to compare the previous year year to current year

116especially on expenses you know where are we at I mean has insurance I mean I'd like to be able to compare to two salaries and it could be broken up into T SP Administration all those different major areas that we actually have some control over there's some that we don't so it's not much we can do unlike my business revenue is very important our revenue is sort of set so we don't really have a lot of things we can do there so I'm not as concerned about that other than we don't go over budget obviously but I would love to see those figures where we're actually at on expenses and different things compared to previous year to this year okay thank thank you Mr fiser thank you I'd like to add on to that if

117we could get perhaps next time kind of an update we're at with our hp1 school choice dollars and how that's kind of been impacted throughout this year did you say school choice dollars yeah hp1 oh hb1 got it okay so and one last question just generally going back to the School process has there been any major changes to how the budgets are handled with schools this year any anticipation I know last year was kind of a big change and there was a little bit of feedback on that so I just wanted to see if there's any I know we now have the regional superintendents that we didn't at that point last year so I was just curious yeah yeah last year as you well last year coming so the budget for this fiscal year for

118schools was there was a completely different setup and process for what we use we have been communicating with principles throughout the way we've been taking their feedback and we're making some tweaks to the process we don't Envision that there'll be another major change like what you saw last year going into you know next year but there will be some tweaks to the process based on the feedback that we were getting from our regionals and from the principles as well thank you and we will I can't really detail those right now because we're still working on them but there will be a presentation to you sometime coming up very soon when once we nail them down we'll be able to say specifically what those were what those are thank you MH okay thank you so much

119for this Pres presentation and your hard work it sounds like June and July are not the months you two take off yeah just putting that out there if I don't if you don't mind I'm going to pause briefly we have a board member we have a public comment and I just wanted to ask the board we have a very lengthy item following up with this item and we only have one public comment listed right now would you all mind if we allowed public comment best at this point because the topic is for another for an item that's already passed would is everyone okay is that a thumbs up yes okay so attorney dodig will you please proceed with public sorry to throw that at you no it's all good okay School Board policy provides the

120opportunity at this point in the meeting to address the board concerning any matter on the meeting's agenda if you completed a public comment card please provide it to staff public comment will be held is held at the podium in the front please be advised that the board will not respond during public comment to remarks made by speakers however at the conclusion of public comment the chair superintendent or board attorney May respond if deemed necessary Abus of language is prohibited speakers who fail to follow proper deorum in the chambers will be ruled out of order any speaker continuing with such remarks will be required to relinquish the microphone per School Board policy 01691 and may be removed from the chambers there will be one warning board policy 0191 01 69.1 the time per speaker is 3

121minutes you will find a countdown on the big screen in the front of the room once your time has elapsed the microphone will automatically shut off please state your name when you approach the microphone there is one speaker and that is nette bird Smith thank you're welcome thank you Dr car and the board I'd like to after the lengthy period of retirement of involvement in public schools I had a personal in that reignited my passion and when I looked at the agenda for your meeting today part of it is our student code of conduct which includes our dress code I'd like for the opportunity I would like to see you look to see at the disproportionate targeting between male and female when our dress code descriptions are there they're very heavily weighted towards female that

122most of the infractions are female induced and the consequences are often inappropriate and they definitely are not consistent from school to school based on my information where I went and researched there is also when I looked for information and research situation there really is not any data driven suggestion that strict dress codes really influence student achievement there's a lot of opinionated data there's a lot of classroom or teacher but there they're basically a lot of opinionated things but the biggest one is that in enacting a dress code and deciding on an infraction or whatever the biggest thing that really got me in the particular incident Was the removal of a student from instructional time and being the second thing on the list for the superintendent when we want to be punitive which there's no other

123way to look at it other than that and we're removing a student whether and it's it's too inconsistent from school to school because one school would look at a minor infraction probably go on about the day maybe relook at the situation and the kid is not removed when we have classroom time that's only 47 minutes and you're pulling a kid out you've just lost a whole class period and I'd like to see that we look at it in that basis and look to see that those infractions are really female-based and they put the onus on a female student who's going to be responsible for someone else's Behavior because often times we site this violation as a distraction to someone else and I think we need to look at that in the situation that everyone's responsible

124for their own behavior and to hold a female child in middle school is the big emphasis because we have so many changes in a middle school child and to tell a female that what they look like or what they happened to accidentally done raise their arm thank you your time is up thank you and just so the public is aware I don't think we have anyone else but had should someone come before the meeting's over I'm welcome to open this back up sure all right thank you we're going to go ahead to and sorry to throw this team off a little bit proposed school start times for 2526 Dave nulan Dr Nathan Shaker and Jared McKinny will be presenting this afternoon good afternoon boy board members superintendent Dr Denise Carlin and board attorney Robert dodig

125we are back in front of you today for again the proposed this is a followup to the proposed safety start Initiative for transportation of the three-tier bus route system that we bring in front to you today again this proposal is for the beginning of the 2025 2026 school year and as we get started one of the things I want to start up with is why are we here again today again as a reminder you know we want to stay focused on on the issue while we're bringing this forward you know the idea is we want to resolve the busting issue which is very important we're responding to again as a safety concern to improve student achievement responding back to community about the concerns for busing to be more efficient and be fiscally responsible again we

126want to make sure that we are responding to the to the families we don't want students any later delayed at bus stop stops unattended and we are committed to improve the bus riding system to respond against Community conerns for the safety of our children I bring it in front of you again from last time just a reminder to talk about our am arrival and PM arrival which again this goes back to arrival at school students arriving at school on time right 83% and then picked up is at 60% when we look at that yeah again how many bus riders do we actually have so back in October we did a survey we have approximately 47,000 students that ride the bus to schools so you look at the arrival time we mentioned the am you're looking

127based on those that numbers that means that 7,990 students arrive late in the morning if you look at the a PM arrival time based on the percentage what that means is 18,800 students are picked up late in the PM time so when we look at these this is i l show you the numbers based beyond percentages of what students are actually arriving late in the morning and are picked up late in the afternoon my apologies can you hear me there we go with that only updated proposal we have tier one which is an arrange so you have all your high schools and we want want to make you make sure you keep in mind that the numbers that are next to the high schools in the middle in the elementary are the number of routes

128for those on tears so in the high schools we have the 7:00 to 2:00 p.m. we always have the buses drop off 20 minutes earlier for the breakfast so that mean buses will be dropping off at 6:40 in the morning for that 7:00 start for the elementary your K to 8s will be 7:10 along with your middle schools that be 9:25 yep since our last presentation we've gone through a pretty extensive feedback cycle and we anticipate going through another one after this presentation we have spoken with principles we've spoken with principal leads transportation staff Communications has been heavily involved Labor Relations talc was provided an opportunity to provide input student enrollment apc's Food Service had a lot of positive input to to put in and considerations as we look at these times there's cabinet discussion

129operations has been involved just making sure that it knows about changing the door locks or changing the times for for alarms there's there's been a a whole system kind of involvement and what are the implications of these changes we know that it was a topic at Town Hall and we anticipated it continuing to be a topic at the Town Halls so I'll say of that feedback the top concerns that were shared were really about amm Care at elementary schools teachers supported entry and dismissal what does it look like for buses and parent pickup will 2 minutes per period really make a difference High School contract time contract start times and end times as they relate to the bell times was brought up elementary schools currently with an additional 30 minutes we have nine elementary schools

130that currently have an additional 30 minutes as well as concerns with sb733 the legislation mandating later start times for high schools what I can I want to address each of these with you I'll start at the top and kind of go from there when it comes to AM and PM care at elementary schools all elementary schools will have a program either internal or from a partnership and many middle schools already have them teacher supported entry and dismissal at all three levels but especially with high school there will be a reduced time between the start of a teacher's contract and the time that students arrive to class at the high school level this could be 15 or 20 minutes in situations where interor dismissal requires classroom teachers Beyond contract hours School administrators can address the situation

131with supplements with staggered schedules or with leveraging support staff for non-instructional staff we are hearing that the concern is not Universal so our principles will do what they do they're going to get creative they're going to take care of their staffs and they're going to help Shore up time for our teachers to do what they do best which is to teach the question of will two minutes really make a difference the answer is yes in big and small ways in small ways 2 minutes per period is time for an exit ticket it's time for a little it's a little extra time for students to complete their homework and it's enough time to make up for a bathroom visit in a big way an extra 2 minutes per period is 14 minutes per day over 180

132school days it equals almost 42 hours of instruction High School contract times start and end as they relate to bell times Regional superintendents are committed to working with our principles to build systems that maximize the time our teachers have to plan and teach common planning is an example of an effective way to help teachers collaborate during the school day for IEP meetings mtss meetings Etc I think we can take advantage of the success we've had with the Kelly with the Kelly Services System to provide coverage during the day for these types of meetings elementary schools currently with the additional 30 minutes the 30 additional minutes came from a funded State directive more than 5 years ago that mandated the extra minutes but it ended after the first year we have continued this practice by funding

133the extra time through our general funds we offboard three of our middle schools last year and this year it will take effect with our elementary schools as far as it's tied to comp compensation the moment is right as we build compensation systems through phase two of the Evergreen study compensation revision instead of receiving salary for the extra 30 minutes the study seeks to compensate staff who are working at hard to staff locations or with that needs students and lastly SE sb733 the legislation we're diligently watching the path of sb733 the change is the natural next step after the improvements and efficiency that came about from our proximity shifts shifts a three- tier transportation system is safer and more efficient and will result in more achievable daily expectations for our drivers so those are some of

134the most common concerns that we're hearing they were also included in an FAQ that's available to to the board where are we going after initial feedback was provided high schools did move forward by 5 minutes they went from a 7:05 to a 7:00 start time this is to help build in that hour and I think we're given Transportation I think it's getting an hour and 10 minutes between tiers now just to provide a little bit of buffer middle schools did Express concern with going to the 49 10 minute period and that was a strong voice from the Middle School principles so middle school is going to stay at 47 minutes for for another year and we'll reassess next year ending at 4:15 instead of at 420 this accommodates added lunchtime so the move from 4:00

135to 4:15 at the middle schools is really part of the process of adding 5 minutes to each of their lunch shifts which was something we worked pretty closely with tal on special centers moved to tier three there's a particularly complicated nature of special centers Transportation these schools transport students from around the district not just within a proximity Zone schools like Royal Palm schools like Buckingham so we have committed that after the first batch runs in early March we'll get a better perspective on where all of our bus routes are going to run and we can kind of give it a second look but really in order to to make sure we can hit that three- tier system and be there on time our special centers did move to tier three and one of the biggest

136changes that is going to add time into that day is a 30-minute lunch across all levels very early on this was a conversation with the with t and it was something they were interested in and as we talked with them about adding some instructional time throughout the day the 30-minute lunch was a partnership that we wanted to commit to so that 30- minute lunch will account for an extra 15 minutes in the day because there's three lunch shifts and extra 5 minutes at each we'll build out some of that time the really the final feedback period follows this Pres presentation next month we will bring the board a final recommendation for start times at each school so our timelin pending board approval will be as of February 1st we have assigned every single eligible student

137this school year into our maps to be routed so that we can have the tangible routes in hand when they finish to see what everything's going to look like so on the 28th every route sheet will be printed and we will begin our tie up process have the staff worked together so that we can have the accurate data for the final phase of the process and by March 8th we will have everything done tied together all the zones we working together and we will have the tangible data of what everything will look like and what's needed for this initiative to work I'm sorry for school administration in in February really they're going to continue to build mock Bell schedules scenarios considering transition times our high schools currently have a 5 minute transition time which is

138going to bring a lot of non-instructional time into the middle of the day but they are big places as well meeting schedules how can we make sure that we can have teachers at meetings but also not require them to be there after contract times and how do we make sure we're protecting planning time in March when the first batch is assigned based on Final student enrollment due diligence will be given in considering Minor Adjustments to the special Center tiers and really in April Master scheduling workshops will be there to support common planning and flexible scheduling with our special education students will be an absolute top priority in supporting our schools Food Service they've reviewed the Bell schedules to manage the impact on Staffing and food service at breakfast and lunchtime I think they're going to

139have a strong ability to respond once we have final numbers or final times shorted up they're going to need to communicate Staffing or material needs to budget creating a cost analysis if we if we decide to have more opportunities for grab and go bre how can we make sure that we still have those high protein breakfast items in a grab and go scenario was a big conversation that we had and in April can we train kitchen managers and staff as needed would be the plan and for communications again pending a border approval you'll see any updates to this would be obviously affect our website any existing documents would be changed and then of course we would continue to communica with our families via messenger social media and media Outlets to let them know that any

140new changes that this was to be approved and we'll stand by for any questions the board or super sorry about that thank you very much to our team for stepping up and taking on this major Challenge and as we've talked about at prior workshops to my colleagues on the board we've talked about two major priorities in the school district one is to improve student safy this accomplishes that it does not allow students to be left alone at a bus stop only for a bus not to come or maybe a bus to be an hour or too late you know that may be okay if you're a high school student you're 17 or 18 years old you can turn around and go home if I am a an 8-year-old I shudder to think what that looks

141like I'm a parent myself and I would not want that to occur and I'm sure you would not either I heard some statistics today things like 8,000 students late to school every day I just want you to think about that number for a moment 8,000 so if there is a compelling why for us to make this change 8,000 speaks very loudly to me and I know it speaks loudly to you we are number nine out of the 10 largest school districts in the State of Florida when it comes to student achievement it is not a mystery to me any longer when I hear those types of Statistics why we are in the place we are and then I hear really good news I hear things like 2 minutes of instructional time we gain per period

14214 minutes a day 42 hours of instruction at the high school level that's six more days of instruction what could that do for our students especially our students that struggle so we're excited about this proposal we see it fixing a real problem in our district again you know I'm about solving problems not living in problems and we're here to U hear your conversation today and we look forward to your discussion thank you Dr Carlin Mr persons for the public if you would just give a definition of the two minutes gives you time for an exit ticket what that is because I think the public may not be aware I apologize for the jargon absolutely exitic is a great way to do a check for understanding at the end of the at the end of a

143day so if I teach a lesson say on on Main Idea just asking the kids on the way out the door write down one word on a piece of paper about what you think the main character did that influenced the main idea of the story they write one word and they collect it at the end of the day and the teacher can really get a good sense of of what they what they captured that day that really regular formative assessment is what we call check for understanding is very powerful right thank you for that M ganelli thank you I know this has been a conversation it's been a Hot Topic even for the community actually so my real concern is or I understand that student achievement that's important so that is a concern however I

144am concerned over how this will impact the teachers planning time I know that they in the morning in the afternoons they would take advantage of that additional time and now I think that time is shortened if I'm not if I'm understanding that correctly and then I know another concern that a teacher shared with me was that they lost the teacher Duty days due to Hurricane and they lost that this year and those those teacher Duty days are vital for for teachers and so for the for their own success and I know that they're looking at changing their curriculum or how many tests they give and how much work they give them based on what they are able to you know do themselves as far as you know checking and their own you know it's the

145the work it's there's not a time enough time in the day to get the work done so how are we how are we going to help the teachers be successful and to allow success in the classroom thank you I can give a partial answer Mr youen at this point I would say anything we can do to have our teachers when they are on our campuses teaching our students is going to be the most effective piece we can do I know a lot of their time can be taken up with meetings as I mentioned Kelly Services having a strong fill rate really provides us an opportunity to call in Subs temporary Duty Subs to help cover classrooms so that teachers can attend IEP meetings mtss meetings during the day it's a practice we've done in the

146past and veered a little bit from during the sub crisis contractually teachers get 300 minutes of planning a week and so we average that out there's an additional 30 minutes that's built into the contract that happens one day a week so we're committed to that 49 minutes during the planning period and then really making sure we protect I would say ideally 10 minutes at the start of the day to to just kind of get in and get ready for the day our high school principls are telling us that when it comes to monitoring the students outside of the instructional time they do have systems and resources that can can help take that burden off of the teachers Dr Shaker if I can add to that as well one of the pieces of advice that I've

147given to our associate Regional superintendant is to make sure that they're sitting with School principles as we are planning through this so here we are in early February this isn't in place until August potentially so to sit with their principles and go through check for before school programs at the elementary check for after school how is that going to work at dismissal what's planning time going to look like how can we share best practices around our lunch times and you know we have some more senior principles that you know like us have been around for a while you mentioned substitute teachers or guest teachers being available those are some practices we used for many many years at schools so it's kind of going back to the future right going back to benefiting from some of

148those great practices we had in place that freed up time for teachers so that they could be engaged in that planning they didn't necessarily have to worry about you know those other duties because we had substitute teachers that were available to step in for a period of time so we'll be asking our associate Regional superintendents to sit with each school and make sure that those processes are tight and that we're adhering to the contract thank you I know that leadership is different at different at every school so I appreciate you giving that guidance to the principles for those that may not be you know quite there yet in those decisions so I just know I am concerned and you know the teachers sometimes they feel forgotten and so we just want to make sure that

149we're bringing them along but I mean I know that what is it cheeks in the seats is very important and that was a conversation that we had many you know when this came out about 5 years ago they need more time seat time and instructional time and we weren't able to do it then but I I commend you for taking that taking this bull by the horns and doing it now and it's a baby step because I think you know with the time with the time changing possibly again in 26 if we if our girls are not successful in in getting that changed which they're working on it everyone's working on it but I mean then this is a step towards that as well and I and know that and that's something that a conversation

150that people need to be aware of we may not have a choice so this is a small step towards a bigger step that could happen that you know we don't really have a choice so thank you Miss Jordan thank you I have a couple questions please One is I'm trying to understand the comment planning and then Kelly Services because you just mentioned that so and I'm not a teacher never been a teacher so you have the comeon planning time do we just call these the Kelly Services and they're going to pop in and take over so the teacher can leave the classroom to go do their planning I mean what does that look like no I apologize they're two separate two separate Avenues and so common planning really gives our teachers an opportunity to meet

151with their plc's to meet with their grade levels if we build into the schedule if we build into the master schedule that teachers who teach like subjects or like courses or like grade levels can meet at the same time can have their students away at the same time so when we refer to Common planning it's really just increasing the efficiency of when they would have Team Planning time PLC time when we talk about using Kelly Services that's really in service to not having meetings before school not having meetings during planning times but really having a substitute come in and kind of they juggle between classrooms all day long they go to this classroom the teacher is able to leave and come in and be part of an IEP meeting or an mtss meeting and then

152the sub moves to another room and that teacher is able to come out for that period and be part of an mtss meeting or an IEP meeting it is a it is a an effective practice when we use it that makes more sense to me so thank you for that yeah and then my other one was the amm care we know that our schools a lot of the schools already have that however we also know that there is not adequate space for this so every child is not able to even get into these because there's just not enough space so what do we do how do we how do we take care of those kids because I know that for a fact that there's many of my schools that the parents at the day one

153they're full so these kids are going home they're you know the latchy kids are back again and they're you know some of them are going home some of them get home because if you look at your number almost 19,000 are home late versus the almost 8,000 that are late in the morning so that's a lot of children that are just somewhere so I just that's really concerning to me it's like what and I know that we people say that you know once they're finished school they're not our problem but they are to me so I just want to make sure that we look at we do look at that and then the other one was the high the schools with the 30 extra minutes so those schools that have the 30 extra minutes already they

154will continue to have those 30 minutes they will lose that 30 minutes so in essence they lose that 30 minutes and then they lose the money that they have been receiving so we are now taking the money from the teachers who have been receiving this so now they're going to be a decreasing their wage and that and I'm hearing that because they're very concern about the loss of that revenue and as I mentioned that it was a system that was put in place years ago we've kind of maintained it we've kept it afloat we did off-ramp our middle schools last year I think with the expectation of off ramping elementaries this year and my hope is being in a shift right now with our compensation study that those schools typically having the additional 30 minutes

155had represented an instructional need had represented a need need to to to provide the students because they're they're at R students or they're in they're in schools that need additional support I believe in this in this next round of compensation the next round of negotiations which comes up I think addressing compensation as it relates to the schools that you serve or the schools that you work in instead of relying upon that extra half an hour for the additional compensation is going to be key to the to the to that study to negotiations right well because it's very hard to tell that the teachers that have been receiving now you're going to lose I don't know what3 $4,000 I believe it's somewhere around there and so if they're counting and they're used to that and I

156understand it was a pilot we've only been doing it x amount of years but now I've been accustomed to that's part of my B my budget for my home and my family and now you're going to take that from me so I just so if I could just caution the conversation Crossing into bargaining oh okay it's not bargaining okay well I understand you're talking about compensation so I just sorry wanted to caution you all I just wanted to share that thank you thank you Mr do Mr fiser thank you first off kudos to superintendent Carlin and her team she officially started talking about this in November and it's beginning of February and look at how far we've come so I want to give as I said kudos to you and your team this is amazing

157this has been a needed step and I know we have some consternation from some of my fellow Elementary School parents but we need to do this we all you know especially of us been here for a while have seen you know the calls the emails the things about having those kids not showing up in time and the impact it has I mean I know we've gone out to schools and they'll point out you know this bus isn't here this bus isn't here now this holds back for you know our Ela and for math so kudos to that so I just wanted to request to things I just want to make sure and I know the superintendent is always on top of this making sure communication to our families and staff is very clear on this

158and very precise I know that's a standard you hold so and the second thing I know it's been out there in the community a little bit and I can always have Mr dodig follow up on this but there's been some talk about compliance with the law and for next year for 25 26 this does comply with the law so as it currently stands that's correct the statute that was impacted by HB 733 doesn't go into effect till the following year okay thank you thank you everyone okay I have a couple of comments thank you for all three being here I hesitate to even have this conversation because we like Miss ganell pointed out before it may not even be a conversation we needed to have but nonetheless we've we're going to we're going to fight

159it all the way but so I'm GNA ask Miss Jordan you bring up a good point and I appreciate you asking on behalf of this part of our this part of our staff how does this affect we're adding the 30 minutes how does this affect our Title One schools that already have additional time don't does it affect them at all Dr Shaker that are required additional time to be there they're a little bit longer or they come early in the summer can you talk about that so our Title One schools having Title One status doesn't attach to having an additional 30 minutes the additional 30 minute piece was a was a different piece of legislation that dealt with the bottom 300 schools in the state so Title One is we have Title One schools that

160don't have an additional 30 minutes okay I just want to reassure our teachers that are at those schools because we'll get an email about that I don't want to put you on the spot but I'm going to Mr McKenna how are how is your staff like have you gotten feedback from your staff about I our bus drivers and our transportation is so important have you just can you talk about that for a minute yeah so we had meetings in every Transportation site it was voluntary all the drivers and attendants came and we un we explained to them the why to know the what they were very receptive a lot of them didn't understand at first but we did break it down to bring the comprehension and they were very excited I think they are happy

161to see the change come okay thank you're welcome we're in sync I wrote down what's the why behind the what look at that it's it's amazing and but but it wasn't about Transportation but that's that's to the same point I have gotten a lot of emails and a lot of conversations and sidebar conversations about teachers with their own children in daycare MH and they are just very concerned so I spoke with an ele I sat down with one Elementary School principal who graciously gave me their 30 minutes and one Middle School principal who graciously gave me their 30 minutes just to get an idea about the impact that it would make on their students or excuse me their staff with children or you know even whether they're students that go there or or young young

162babies like at preschool daycare before care after care I'm a huge believer in communication is key and whether you like what you hear or don't like what you hear is one thing but if we can at least tell them the why behind the what they're more apt to understand why we are doing what we're doing and when you have numbers like 8,000 students are showing up to school late and what did you say 13 or almost 19 are in the evenings unsupervised who knows I think if we can just in the future should this be put into play if we can just be very transparent about why we are doing what we're doing I think you're going to get a lot of people that hop on the train it change is hard mhm and teachers

163like living in a planning period you know 7 to 3 and all day long so I completely appreciate that and change is hard but I think if we are transparent about why we're doing this I think it will be accepted so that's just my recommendation that we make sure we're real clear and I completely agree one of the things we continue to talk about as we walk down this path is making sure that we are being clear in our Communications but also attaching faces to the to the situation that's why when we were talking the other day perhaps in in I believe it was in cabinet a percentage is one number when you start to put it in terms of numbers 8,000 18,000 13,000 that starts to resonate with people so that feedback is excellent

164and thank you and we will be communicating very clearly we've really wanted to have the conversation with you first like really making this going along certainly checking in with t checking in with principles checking with others as we now start to ratchet up and move forward and start to think about how are we going to bring a final product forward to you we will blast it in all media Outlets so everybody's going to be hearing about it we just wanted to make sure we took the training wheels off and just were able to dissect what some of the issues were working on in FAQ going back and getting some additional feedback surveys things like that so that we can really understand what people's perspectives are so we think we're getting even clearer on what those

165concerns are and making sure that we're addressing those not just giving lip service to it but actually having real solutions to the issue so we thank you for your conversation last month and this month it's really helping us to refine this plan thank you and to your point earlier about the fact that we are elected officials and we have the opportunity to engage our own communities and neighborhoods I you know I would charge this board with getting out there and making sure we're communicating with our YMCAs and our boys and girls club and our stars and our and all of the in the wonderful organizations that partner with our the before care and after care and have some true empathy of you know while we may adjust while we have to adjust maybe they will

166adjust as well their times to help accommodate our amazing educators any other comments Mr I just want to add one more W to your what and why and that's when and I think it's important that we communicate the targeted date over and over and over again even if we do a countdown the nice thing was I visited yesterday with a high school principal really wanted to talk about code of conduct we wound up and she brought up the changes in in the bus schedules and how they'd be effective and they're already talking about it in this school with the teachers and they're very positive about it so I think we're getting the message out there good job thank you thank you all have a great afternoon we're going to go ahead and move on to

167job descriptions and we're going to welcome back Miss Mont Morano back to the podium thank you good afternoon again today presented to you we do have one job description that you were given previously to review that is a coordinator of community support and volunteer programs and at this time I will open up for any superintendent comments or board questions I have no comments just look forward to your conversation any board member comments I have one okay so when I was reading the major function and then I knew that we were just before this we were going to have this conversation about then the conversations I had with the principal and then other teachers would this particular person be that brand between our C the district and those organizations I just named YMCA Boys and Girls

168Club helping with teachers that need assistance with daycare where you know if those time changes go in effect we're really going to need to start to have these conversations with our fellow philanthropists and you know our awesome charity organizations so would this particular person help be a vessel between the district and those foundations so I think it's going to be incumbent upon all of us to be part of that we certainly can engage this person you know be working closely with constituents the primary role of this person is to address constituent Services constituent concerns as they come forward and to be able to Route those and also work with our schools to coordinating volunteer programs so yes tangentially this position could be perhaps I have a few other ideas on who might be a better

169Point person for that work okay all right thank you thank you thank you thank you next is policy review Kathy dupe Bruno will be presenting this afternoon on policy review good afternoon board members we have four policy that are before you are there any questions or concerns about the policies board members do you have any questions or comments for Miss depe Bruno Mr persons are these taken from niola yes okay that's what it looked like in I thought so that was all I just want to make sure it was conforming to everything else thank you okay may we move this forward to public hearing second reading thank you mam chair Mr doic I just want to make sure no one has some shown up for public comment additionally not the I have no information that

170there's anybody else okay all right thank you're welcome so then we're going to go ahead and move on to good of the order another business board members do you have any comments I will start with Mr fiser okay most I'm going to reserve for tonight the only thing I want to give you an update is the on the board of auditor the job has remained open I'm going to be sending out memos shortly I just need to get one more piece of feedback from Administration but that'll outline kind of the process and where we're going to go with that so and if you have any questions I encourage you to follow up with staff and legal on it they've been very helpful so I appreciate HR and legal especially for all their help on this

171that's all I have thank you miss you relli okay I'll be brief I do have a little bit of a list of place of things I've attended but just reminder that this Saturday is stastics and everyone here is invited including anyone out there it's a wonderful event it's Saturday Downtown at the harbor side from 10:00 to 2: and then Sunday is the junior parade for the Edison Festival light and I encourage everybody and the junior Fun Run and I encourage everyone to participate or attend it would be awesome and I know it's Super Bowl Sunday so that's a conflict but just depends on what your favorite thing is to do but I mean so I this past weekend I judged the science and inventors Fair Saturday at FGCU and that was awesome I encourage y'all

172to attend that if you can next year because it's really these kids are like very intelligent just saying so and then Debbie and I attended Pippen I don't know if anybody else did on I Sunday it was Sunday yes and that was awesome at no Myers High School and then on Friday night was it yeah Friday night was Aladdin and at Edison Park that was great and then I did get down Debbie let me reminded me that they had was the artfest with the CH the chalk walk yes but I was down there for the parade stuff and I got to walk around and take some pictures and see some of it because it's it'll be there all week it'll be there on Sunday actually if anybody's down there that and that was that art

173is amazing that they do I don't know when they start drawing but and when they finish because I can only imagine it takes some time but that is all I have so thank you Mr Ribble I'm going to defer till tonight okay Miss Jordan I'm going to do most mine this evening but I just wanted to say I attended my first DC meeting there was 88 in attendance Mr B Bruno had come in and spoke with everyone of course on Zoom came in on Zoom and spoke about the new structure of in Dr Amy was there who was here with us I forget who was there with us I'm sorry CU McCoy thank you I was like CU McCoy she was the other person that was there with us but they spoke to everybody regarding

174the structure and the breakout rooms there really wasn't any comments about that everybody understood it and then of course they did a presentation on the code of conduct there was a lot of good conversation that took place and a lot of it was about U cell phones and the consistency we heard over and over again so I just wanted to share that with you and then of course they broke down what will happen if we have other needs for them if you have to do breakouts then that would be done at a different time never at the same time so other people will be able to participate and that is it for now thank you I will defer until tonight okay all right well I'm probably not going to be very popular at the dinners

175oh I got to have Miss chavano I'm so sorry go ahead you're next I'm reading off my script Sor I'm defer till tonight so you're good thank you I'm probably not going to be very popular at Dental table tonight because I said cell phone Bell to Bell and I also want to thank Miss Smith for coming and speaking this afternoon and thank you for in indulging getting out of the order but I do think we need to address dress code of code of conduct across the board especially K through middle it's it is a constant I feel like I hear about this all the time just little spurts here and there and you know while it's important that we let children express ourselves as one thing but I do think uniformity somewhat does help whether

176it's distraction or not distraction I am a firm believer in dressing for Success makes one feel successful and that's even in when you leave high school and go get your first job job or even in in high school when you go to get your job you know and we teach our children to you know look their best they feel their best and but I think that's something maybe we should have some discussions about is you were right about inconsistency from school to school and maybe those are some chats we have offline for sure I so I'll be in trouble tonight because I talk about cell phone and uniforms so but anyway I did get to walk the Dare the what's Mr fer help me thank you I took fifth graders to that and when I

177was a teacher and it's it's very realistic at times especially when you're a 10 10-year-old watching what could happen because of a bad choice so as I was walking through that we have just talked about this afternoon about open gate and the just this vas vaping epidemic and I don't know maybe that's something that it's not necessarily falling on our shoulders because I know a different organization puts the drug house Odyssey on but perhaps it is something that they talk about with high schoolers about the consequences of vaping you know cuz most of our students probably went through the drug house ody tosey whatever elementary school but it was just it just something that triggered while I was walking around there and then I'll save again my apologies Miss shvan I didn't turn to you

178sometimes I need to go to my left first but I'll save all of your athletic updates for this evening so Mr doic do you have anything just great joining you today I don't have anything else thank you and Dr Carlin and I will be very very brief I want to give a shout out to Mr rib he threw out a name of a book at our last Workshop called the anxious generation and I will tell you have inspired our student services team to kick off a book study and they even brought me a book so we will absolutely share if the board would like to read that book it's very interesting about mental health and the impact of cell phones and other things that are happening with this generation of students so if you're interested

179please let me know we'll make sure we get you a copy I have finished chapter 1 and I as I just received the book and I'm looking forward to reading it thoroughly just to get a little better handle on that and I'll reserve the rest of my comments for this evening thank you thank you tonight we will have a student performance at 5:45 followed by our Action meeting at 6 p.m. at this point having no other business to come before this body and seeing no objection this meeting is adjourned the time is 3:35 p.m.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.