CorpusRecord 104000

Verona Area School District Board of Education Meeting January 6, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / VASD Board Meetings
Date
2025-01-07
Location
Dane County, WI
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,537 words · about 76 min
Collected
2026-06-11

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e all right greetings everyone happy January officially I'm going to call this meeting to order let's establish that we have a quum beginning with a roll call vote let's go the other direction Juan Carlos yes here Christopher here meridith here John so here Corby here Joe here and I'm here as well we have a quorum uh Corby has this meeting been properly noticed yes it has thank you to help ensure that we're centering our board work around our shared values in serving our students We Begin each of our board meetings by reading our District's equity framework and the Ho Chunk land acknowledgement which can be found at the top of the agenda John would you please read those aloud for us this evening I would be happy to in the Verona Area School District our

002mission is that each student will acquire the Knowledge and Skills necessary to achieve their personal goals thrive in a diverse Global society and lead a healthy self-fulfilling life to meet this Mission the Verona Area School District will ensure that every individual has access to the educational social and emotional support they need to feel valued and affirmed in their unique identities and experiences we acknowledge that inequities and power dynamics exist in our system such that some individuals on the basis of their identities face barriers to accessing the opportunities they need to experience success in acknowledgement of such the Verona Area School District is committed to disrupting these systems of inequity and then our land acknowledgement there are currently 12 tribal Nations who call Wisconsin home with the hotu nation being the primary group living around Madison

003no matter where you are in the state you are on the ancestral land of a tribal Nation as we begin our meeting we honor the land on which we stand thank you uh board if you could take a look at the remaining agenda for this evening pleas so free to surface any amendments any questions otherwise I'd accept a motion to approve the agenda as presented thank you Meredith is there a second second thanks ju Carlos all those in favor of approving tonight's agenda signify with i i i any opposed the agenda has been approved so our next agenda item is Schoolboard recognition month and even though this is a Schoolboard meeting I'm not really very comfortable taking the lead on that as I know many of us have shared we feel like we are definitely

004in service to our community and Learners and District so it feels a little odd to recognize ourselves so I might just s that over you Dr happy to take it and thank you uh so in honor of not just board recognition month but in the service of all of our board members uh we really like to honor and thank each of the board members for their service to our community as president Murphy stated and just the willingness to serve on behalf of public education which we know is no easy task so in thinking of that we want to take this opportunity to express our heartfelt gratitude to our board uh you leave by example grounding your work in equity and demonstrating a deep commitment to all students families and staff members we deeply appreciate your

005willingness to serve on the board knowing the significant time and energy this work requires your Forward Thinking approach to decision making ensures that our schools are not just meeting the needs of today but are also preparing for tomorrow and the months and years ahead this year we are particularly grateful for the way that you have work together to implement a strengthened coherent governance model providing a clear and well articulated framework that helps ensure the successful execution of the district strategic framework this model is a testament to your dedication and it continues to grow stronger with each passing year your commitment to efficient effective minor reports that provide valuable insights into our successors in our areas of growth has been a GameChanger the seven of you exemplify what it means to collaborate learn and lead your

006ability to work together through complex and challenging issues reflects your share commitment to our community and our students I have on behalf of all of us students teachers parents and staff we extend our sincer thanks for your vision perseverance and passion you inspire us to strive for excellence every day and we are grateful truly grateful for your service so in honor of our full community thank you so much and uh we like to uh I know it's a small token of our appreciation but each of you have a a personalized gift basket in in front of you uh on behalf of the brary school district so again thank you for your service and if you're hungry you can start eating now you can fill them up with water yes thank you picture good you got

007pictures we have we have a fairly updated one yeah if I can speak for just supp board for but thank you thanks to all of those that helped and contribute we appreciate it a lot and hey thanks to my fellow board members you are a great team to serve alongside well you know it's um I'm very proud for this but also you know you see a well done bow I mean the did not do it so I canot that is a well done vot I canot tell life all right so moving on we will shift then to the superintendent report and take some updates from our leadership team greetings to Chad and Nate making their way up Happy New Year happy New Year happy School Board month to all of you Echo what Dr C

008said we're both I don't want to speak her name [Laughter] yeah we're incredibly fortunate to get to work all right we have a I I have two updates for tonight and I have one that we'll do together um most of our board should be familiar with at least the process related to what uh Nate and I are going to share with you this evening uh we have another property that has come up uh with the pre-existing 199 n boundary agreement between the Madison School District and the Verona Area School District uh so we're here tonight to give you a little background in terms of what's on the way with the pending board vote uh and give you a little bit of detail in terms of the properties that will be impacted uh so as a

009reminder this is true Statewide uh that uh School boards of two adjoining school districts uh as long as both boards agree can move their District B uh and uh in both 1994 and 1999 uh the mmsd school boards and the Verona Area School District board uh came up with a number of parcels many of which were undeveloped Farmland that at the time agreed to essentially most of the time these boundary agreements come in a way that a school district can swap property value lots of times for either uh students or students who will be coming in terms of uh developed property and that's what happened back in 1999 94 and 99 Home Depot as an example used to be part of uh the madis metropolitan school district Home Depot doesn't send us any students but

010it's in our tax base and was part of that boundary swap uh that happened back then uh these uh um I think are reasonably rare but with this uh boundary agreement in place and our two adjoining districts uh they've been more common with us uh recently because Madison's developing West and the stuff starting to fillm uh so we've got six more Parcels that a school board 25 26 years ago uh did agree both boards that we would do this uh when the time came so as I mentioned we've got six impact impacted parcels uh for the most part uh these uh Parcels are uh directly east of essentially Hawks Landing Golf Course uh and if you uh make your way down that road to the right uh there are bulldozers and Earth movers taking shape

011right now and this will eventually be a Verity Home Development uh that will uh in the end undoubtedly produce property value and students for the Madison Metropolitan school district for the time being uh there are no students that live in any of the impacted Parcels which makes this boundary swap a little different than the one we did a year ago where there were a number of students that were impacted and families uh by this uh transfer agreement so this should be relatively straightforward so we outlined in the form of a map the parcels that uh will be uh will end up coming through and if you're familiar with the area it's kind of mid Town Raymond Road uh are the the big chunks of of what were Farmland uh and now will be developed property

012those are the really the five big parcels and then there's a six that we detailed on a separate map so uh the acreage by the time we're all in is a little over 100 acres that we will be handing over to Madison metropolitan school district uh and we detailed those all six partials for the board uh there will eventually be probably uh more boundary transfers as Madison continues to develop West we included a map uh for the board to see in terms of other Parcels that potentially could be flaged all of the time these are areas that get annexed into the city of ma Madison for development and that's actually the trigger uh the switch that is flipped for us to uh go through this rather legal process to have these uh have the boundaries

013shift uh for the Madison metropolitan school district so we did include that map uh just so the board has a heads up so the yellow um are the parcels we're talking about tonight the green are the parcels that eventually uh will go over to the Madison metropolitan school district when they are annexed into the city of Madison so uh this map starting to get cleaned up as we've gone through a couple C of these now but there are both Middleton and the baron area school district have a few Parcels kind of left that eventually will make the Madison School District boundary a little more complete and a little less Tex which I think in general is a good thing for kids um we we've got even we have some goofy boundaries that uh that not

014great planning took place there's all kinds of there are other uh boundaries that are really interesting to me I don't know if all of you knew this like uh half of the East Town parking lot uh and East is the S Prairie School District uh and that's because uh the cities and the municipalities moved at different places than the school district and the school districts uh kind of get left behind so in some regards we're fortunate we had this boundary agreement in place to have this kind of make sense uh so in the end a couple of things will happen here uh this will be the board vote that happens on the 27th uh we did this presentation tonight um almost as a courtesy to the school board and to the community um there will

015be um a special agenda item that will allow uh the public to come uh say their peace in the event that uh folks either were in favor of or against this boundary transfer Nate I don't know if you have anything else to add as far as the legal ease related to this no he pretty much covered it all other than we've been coordinating with mmsd to make sure we're kind of synced up on this process and they're planning on having the same vote on the same P they've got we have a little timeline the Madison School Board meets the same evening so on the 27th uh they will have a um an identical vote um and we'll also listen to any public comment that may inform the board's decision to carry out what was a

016pre-existing agreement between the the two school districts so we're here to answer questions if the board has any so if I remember this from last year when we did this s how long ago was this like we we do have to vote on this but we 25 years ago the district signed a contract that said we would so I'm just trying to game out like I'm not suggesting that we would but if we didn't vote to approve the Detachment what's the downside is it like get for reach so yeah okay I I think that that is essentially it I think there is actually language that in the 1999 agreement that knows uh the boards will eventually have to act on it but yeah the other impact at least in our world uh is that the

017last time we did this uh there was a existing like $60 million of existing property that we handed over to the Madison metol School District which meant our equalized property value took a little hit and that had to get spread back out around our s billion of tax base this property is worth really next to nothing it's farming uh so it'll be it'll have next to no impact um on our overall tax base other questions I just like and appreciate that it's going to clean up those those District Lines because Midtown has always been problematic to me on both sides where the parcels the six Parcels are and then the opposite direction headed towards the golf courses I never understood which part of it is Corona and which part is Madison oh you got a

018little Middleton Madison there absolutely y there all clean things up so can you say again on slide 16 that gives kind of the math what then would trigger so what looks to be like dark purple those are still remaining Parcels that are under the same 1999 contract but haven't had that kind of trigger that you said kind of puts this into action to make that Annex transfer happen and there are um some of those it's my understanding if they are um like preserved Conservancy space uh that actually never gets annexed into medicine for development those could sit in perpetuity um and never be trans over uh but those are ones that are highlighted for when the city of Madison would Annex them in and we are not perfect at this we we our team caught

019this uh in the news uh the last time it is a case study in uh kind of government bureaucracy that in theory uh when the city of Madison uh planning division annexed these Parcels into the city of Madison they should have picked up the phone and said hey mmsd hey Verona uh we just did this you guys need to do your thing to make sure the school district boundaries are right that didn't happen didn't happen the other time when we all already had in the Chavez Elementary neighborhood we already had development that it should have been done years ago we caught it uh so it's this isn't perfect uh it it it it takes kind of both teams having an eye on this we gave the city of Madison heads up again hey if you

020guys move any person into the city uh please notify both school districts so aware of this uh this one we did catch in time that there aren't any homes um so that's those are Parcels that in the event that the city moves them in for development we would hand them over so is this map kind of all that's out there is this 1990 1999 contract kind of the the this is it the other um the other edges of our school district are clean yeah and do not have any pre-existing pre-existing inre but uh that they always could exist uh if we wanted to approach M horb and say you guys interested in a land swap uh it does happen that's how it happened in 1999 but this will kind of our northeast corner of our

021school district will I think eventually be cleaned up that these things are finally disappeared okay so we'll see this again on the 27th then for a formal vote yeah which we're certainly hoping very straightforward for the school board these can get um far more contentious if this was a a fully developed neighborhood with families who were entrenched in our school district uh and you were Mak and we we had a an agreement like this we were proposing to you these can get these can get very heated we we actually don't foresee much public input on this because it's Farmland that's going to turn into a housing development of the city I assume some of these other Parcels that in the future could get annexed have looks like they might have people living in do those

022people know that they're part of this because that felt true the last time right 100% yeah some of those some of those green areas like I understand this is really not likely but the contract says if they're annexed to Madison what if they're annexed to the city of Veron then I would guess the contract would be null and void because we would not have met the criteria outlining in that 1999 yeah and and John you're right those things also happen between municipalities right all good questions all right we will be we will likely have a um shorter um or slightly more concise version of this on the 27th just in case uh folks are watching to make sure that uh everyone's informed of the vote when we do it drafted we'll try and get it

023in BO dos as soon as we cat if you guys are curious to look at it thanks and then the last piece says we once both both V boards vote on it we file it with Epi so um and then we also um update DCI maps and a few other things to make sure that um all of the essentially the software side of this is uh updated for folks who are poking around the internet to figure out what school District certain Parcels are in perfect thank you thank you all right I'm assuming you might be staying around for the sh yep moving on to board action so we'll be talking about oe5 for compliance this evening we received materials in advance as board members so I'm guessing Chad you'll continue to give us some of

024synthesis as some of those key points around o5 yeah so uh I we did send out that video ahead of time I think couple of things we'd like to call out um I I I do believe you know our finance team including myself uh takes pride in the fact that uh we do try to be as transparent as possible with our board and our community uh regarding all of our steps related to financial planning uh the board has already received um our uh financial planning documents related to the 25 26 uh um projected budget and have kind of lived by uh you know kind of um our foundational document of that fiveyear planning document that has a lot of detail on it that I know the board's now uh very familiar with the last time

025we presented this the board oe5 uh we we had a work in progress because our annual meeting book we felt did not do a great job calling out uh essentially where the money is being spent in terms of our academic goals uh related to results policies and we made sure that our annual meeting book this year did do that in terms of saying uh here's where the money we're spending is going in terms of our both academic goals and some of the achievements that we're proud of uh so we called that out in this monitoring report um other than that the things you'll see in this report are things that the board's very familiar with uh the audit is called out again our um fiveyear planning document with assumptions uh that I I think should

026now be part of our regular vocabulary when it comes to financial planning all got detailed in this this report so I'm certainly happy to answer any questions but this is uh this this policy in my mind is essentially making sure that the board has uh enough information to make informed long-term decisions uh relative to our budget and you have it early enough to know what's coming essentially um it's a no surprises document uh when it comes to how we interact with each other on an annual basis to set the budget certainly happy to answer any questions related to the monitoring report the board as any at all just a reminder to the community that there is access to the video as well for the community to view and see and all the materials that we

027have access to anyone does video is uploaded on board LS tonight we I I plan on doing a similar uh but more detailed uh video actually for our school community in the coming weeks uh we have uh this month we've got the start of the Staffing process the 25 26 school year uh and it was useful last year for school-based staff to understand where we think the budget's going for next year and how that relates to Staffing additions or anything we're doing so that will that will be coming up over the next great um questions from the board that would be helpful to be directed to Chad and the team regarding oe5 I think like you said we've covered this I appreciate the thoroughness year around that's right to get to this point we know

028where we're going we know where we went yeah okay if there's no formal questions about the report for at at this point I'll accept a motion to accept and approve the report as presented so we can just begin any further discussion around compliance is there a motion Mo thanks Joe is there a second thanks Christopher so board we can now discuss anything further in terms of compliance of oe5 any questions comments thoughts the vote toward compliance with this operating expectation my only Point again is I I'm surprised when you kind of see things in the news about finances getting away from boards because we get so thoroughly updated about financial matters in the district um and hopefully the community sees all of that transparency online with all the documentation um yeah it's just kind of

029hard to imagine missing it I mean I snooze sometimes but I haven't missed anything yet because it's all in there well quite honestly it's this policy that we want this to feel like it's been it's a repeat every year because it's just our way of doing business uh and this is not the way every school district and School Board interact on an annual basis so it's a um I take it as a vote of confidence that oe5 uh can we can hand this over to you with a whole lot of ffir because it's just a way we do business okay well board there is a motion from Joe and a second by Christopher uh all those in favor of approving oe5 as in compliance as presented signify with i i any oppos okay taken thanks

030so much time all right moving on to board updates anything specific around Communications board members we are voting on Detachment in the 27 so this was kind of the heads up Yi was yes there is tenative language that was written in the slide but we will take our vote on the 27 thank you for clarifying um Yes again any board updates that I'm missing General updates or otherwise I'm having an awesome time in general General today in 2025 thanks for sharing y all right um know if you want just just for public knowledge uh for the Wisconsin State education convention um and we are very proud that many board members will be in attendance so that would actually be a quum place but you know go into cor notice to giv that with our delegate

031being in place any members attending and co-presenting as well y uh that that will be noticed as a a site okay thank you Lori I see that note thank you all right well we'll come back to some other pieces on future agenda items as well um but we'll shift then if there's no other board updates to public comment which I do have one that was sent to us in writing uh so I will uh put some voice to this that was sent in from a parent from Sugar Creek Yasmin Yasmin Lopez uh regarding police presence in schools why police presence can disproportionately impact kids of color as a mom I want all kids to feel safe and supported but the reality is that police presence doesn't impact everyone equally especially kids of color instead of

032feeling protected many children of color feel targeted judged or even criminalized in places that should nurture them like schools it's heartbreaking to know that black and Latino kids are often seen as older or more threatening than they really are this bias leads to harsher treatment for minor mistakes things other kids might get a warning for I've seen stories of children being arrested at school for something as small as a disagreement these moments don't just disrupt their education they also send a painful message message you are not safe here overp policing affect affects kids confidence and mental health it teaches them to be wary of authority rather than trust it instead of focusing on learning or growing they're left feeling like they have to prove they're innocent just for being themselves as a mom I believe

033there's a better way we need more counselors and restorative programs in schools resources that help kids Thrive instead of labeling them as problems every child deserves to grow up feeling valued not judged our kids are watching it's up to us to create a world where all children no matter their race feel safe supported and free to just be kids thank you yasine for your letter appreciate your time and what you've shared for us as a board um we did uh take all of the thoughts around a possible SRO in our schools very seriously we've had some good discussions around such so thank you um any other public comment that I'm missing Lori tonight okay so we will be shifting then into board workshops so just a reminder board um we have a couple of topics

034as just kind of headers for discussion but there's no kind of formal presentation necessarily attached we'll get a couple of kind of notes and places to start dialogue around with the support of our Advent team so I think in order to really again highlight the fact that we're not in presentation mode we're not in board action mode truly in discussion we'll do a bit of the rearranging of our SP um and shift to that so we'll take just kind of a little pause here um we'll mute mute the meeting and we'll do a little rearranging e e e thanks for that pause rearranging um so the way it's listed on the agenda we have School Safety First Act 95 waiver 2 I think for the sake of where the conversation may go in terms of

035depth I think we'll reverse that I did not make a formal agenda motion to change that but if you all are okay we'll start with act 95 conversations and then Circle back to school safety so as pre ly mentioned we're not in presentation mode we are not in board action or vote mode but this is a couple of topics that I think the richness of this board and what we um can Surface in terms of insights can be supported by what our admin team is brainstorming around so I believe Amy you might be helping us ground in some of the ACT 95 Pieces Just to be clear so we are taking take no action at all on corre Strictly just rolling out our ideas that is correct that is very great you'll take lots of

036notes and I appreciate all your input yes for this one specifically though the action will need to be taken at a later date because of the nature of the leg of of of of act 95 but just really wanted to create a space to hear any any and every idea I really I think we've kind of all discussed our pleasure or displeasure with the law itself but we do have to take action on it in it forms of a waiver I'm not making I conting with you John for for a reason um um but there are many opinions on it I think both within the district and CommunityWide that just want to kind of understand everyone's perspective of where where to go next just add real quick not about act 95 I think these discussions

037are in response to the fact that historically we've had to make decisions about like things like act 95 or school safety and it hasn't always felt to people who are not in on the action with us that we put a lot of deliberation into it we just have to vote so this is kind of a you know for our communities we do deliberate about this stuff a lot we're going to deliberate right now a bit and then not done thanks so just a little context on act 95 we know it became legislation last year and guaranteed admission for students to ww system schools in the top 10 % um except for um two sites of plan lacrosse and in the top 5% to W Madison when it was originally conceived the only criteria with which

038we could create that ranking system was grade point average at the end of the 11th grade year um this summer then DPI developed a waiver process recognizing that some sites had more than um that 10 or 5% that were experiencing a 4.0 or the highest GPA that could be attained in addition District so they did create a waiver system for schools to incorporate other um criteria into their ranking system um we did end in a place in Verona last year where we did have just the right number of students we came in under that 5% Mark so we were able to use GPA but it was very close at this point last year we were over that Mark and we still had two grading periods left for our current Juniors to get there so we

039don't know what that will look like but in the event that we do have more than the 5% or the 10% of our students who all have 4.0 based on solely GPA we would need to provide some sort of tiebreaking criteria um and so this part of this waiver is helping us to determine and to communicate to our community and to our families what would those criteria be how would we approach this tiebreaking system all of that in mind we could come back and not actually need it right our numbers could come back to a place where we end up there's 477 students in our junior class ultimately you're looking at about 24 students in the top 5% 48 47 in the top 10% and if we came under that number this this waiver in

040this tiebreaking process wouldn't be wouldn't be needed correct and just to clarify if we were If This Were have if we had to make a decision today we would be over the number of students that have a four 4.0 so we the the only thing that would bring us to a place where the board would not have to utilize a waiver is if I believe 23 students fell below the current 4.0 that they're currently at so there's really a likelihood that we are going to be over 5% after the next two gring periods yeah then to the point you made prior we have to submit what our criteria is going to be corre to DPI in advance of having to use a tiebreaker so this discussion will then feed into what those extra criteria will

041be that will be submitted that's correct and what we've linked here in the slide for you is by no means what needs to happen but we always look to what um admin rules or what policy already exists we have an academic Excellence award that we provide and have four years for our students as admin rule 434 p and that does set some criteria for how we go about selecting those students um and what the tiebreaking process is there so it starts with GPA then it goes to ACT score composite ACT score specifically and then it goes to total number of of credits earned so again those are just some criteria that are already built into an admin rule that we have we certainly would not have to make those um the same criteria for ACT

04295 but that does already exist within our system we also named and we know that other area districts are also grappling with the same idea of a waiver and are exploring many other possibilities as well for figuring out how we would move forward with um breaking any ties That might exist as a result of being above the ti five or top 10% any questions or clarifications any board members have just on act 95 or kind of just the status of the frame of the discussion just to make sure that's all clear are we allowed to as one of the criteria to have students like withdraw themselves from consideration because I have to imagine there's at least a number of students with four 4.0 grade point averages that aren't interested in the W system is that

043possible or legal so like a a voluntary opt out from consideration kind of a criteria we like different parts of the statutory language so I see I think it's interesting about total number of credits earned being a potential criteria because I know we've had discussions as a board about and with admin right about just graduation requirements kind of depth and breadth to which a a student has experienced you know course offerings through their high school years um so I I think that's an interesting way to kind of see right did I get a 4.0 at 23 and a half credits did I maintain a 4.0 at 27 credits and just just perhaps giving some sort of elevation to just a depth of course experience and I don't see that being inherently challenging you know once

044students are here at the high school having that criteria kind of right to your point like this would then all of a sudden impact this junior class so how do you put a criteria in that doesn't all of a sudden make it like well if I had known that I would have done right to some degree that feels a little less like is and also we want to for both the bullet points and I think it's if you if you're using the one that was in board dos we is not refreshing it to indicate we for total number of credits we're talking about total number of credits earned at rone area high school or in in a credited similar uh High School uh and those also for the ACT score we're talking about the Bron

045Area School District delivered act not I'm just going to keep taking the ACT over and over again ah to try to address some parameters right it is Reed it is a state assessment so we do offer it here many students pay to take it multiple times but to try to make sure that everyone has Equitable access to their criteria that we're providing we're thinking of looking specifically at that assessment similarly with credits there are students um families who choose to opt for um paying for summer courses at other places online courses Etc and we wanted to be clear in terms of um again access for all students and that's we were thinking specifically around high school credits earned here at rary high school or transferred in from another High School experience they're try to make

046sure that again all students have access to that opportunity and weren't necessarily given an advantage one way or another and so that's something would be communicated in advance to family so if they wanted to prepare their student strategize around how do we earn maximum credits in the event of a tiebreaker or how do we focus on getting the highest confident score just to jud's point nothing's a shocking oh I wish I knew we that that's that is going to be the Shocker for this first group because this has to this has to happen now that okay so there's no transition time and there's nothing the Juniors can do about credit hours now that that sorry I yeah this has to happen Okay correct but going forward obviously and I think that's also some of the

047bigger considerations for for the board as we think about some of the other District options if you look start to look at Wy grades or looking at Advanced courses at what time do you do you start that with the freshman class so you would have had the opportunity to start considering those those type of classes if if we were to go in that direction but in terms of the media of having to do this W this this specific waiver we have to do it now got so like in theory we could have a list for this year and we could repr propose a new list if we wanted to have more grandio conversations around being less ah this is all of a sudden happening to you so for this year ahead you sure good okay

048so for this year I was wondering what is the fairest measure the fairest criteria given the options that we have that won't you know will be the closest to the most Equitable when we shock these students and say hey sorry we're GNA have to which one in your mind is it's gonna shock you the least it's gonna be like okay well this is something I should have been doing anyway can I jump pleas because this is something that like this is the first second year that we have students that are doing this so I mean all this is none of this could have been really put in place when they ref freshman um and you're thinking about students that would be potentially this is their goal was to go on to ew Schools they're already

049taking a classes so that would not be a shock they would be already pursuing College um coursework in that area um I think the total number of credits is also a valid point but I would I think the ad the AP courses is something that would not be an unfair measure um for students at this point I mean again nobody would have had knowledge of this the freshman year say the only thing that's up there that they they um that wouldn't have already passed would be if we did go to the vahs administration of the act that hasn't happened yet so we could make this decision if that was one of the criteria and let them know this administration of the ACT would be the tiebreaker and wouldn't have implications on anything that they had

050done previously like course selection like credits Etc because that's still coming but the other pieces definitely would may have factored in differently for a student perhaps um the ACT is the only one that's still yet coming in the spring that they would not have that feel a lot of pressure kid just don't well and plan on taking it multiple times in order to achieve their so having that like one and done is kind of um and it really doesn't actually speak anything other the ability to take a test off the cup so you're going to have the people that are able to afford the pre prep and I just feel like we're setting up in here effes that are just going to be so I would still go back to you know GPA uh total

051credits earned and AP courses can I just drill down that what's specifically about a courses like the number that you've taken yeah I wouldn't B it on um the test I don't think not everyone takes the you know AP exams just and that again there's additional cost to that just are they willing to if they have your GPA and AP courses you're kind of seeing a rigor you know you're getting a measure of rigor Marth is that your thought on what you would do because like for the immediacy of this or would that be your thought regardless that those are your you know what I'm saying because we kind of have this context of what do we do for this graduating class and what might be what might we visualize as being our criteria without

052these kind of constraints or ickiness of impacting a group right now I would do that now I guess I don't see that there'd be a reason not to put that into place again these are students that didn't know the suest of their ver year um so this is a group of students that would have been pursuing these credits anyway um that's what I mean so would you keep those as the criteria for the seventh grade who are eventually coming to us okay just to clarify right if we're kind of having a conversation about this year's group versus our criteria in general I mean unless there's a a reason not to um but again I have I have trouble with the ACT being a measure just for yeah I think there's a few of us that

053can I get a clarification from Joel's statement you said the the number of AP courses taken you mean the past with a certain score no that was that was the clarification I was asking about are we saying just the broad number of courses enrolled in or the AP the score on the AP I think the credits earn if they fail the class they're not earning credits but if they pass the class that's if they fail the class I doubt they'll be in the yeah not not e but would it just be the a because I mean we have other Advanced courses besides just Advanced like a courses um dual credit yeah right some students aren't on a track where they're necessarily interested in learning about AP English Literature something I they're looking Madison they're going

054taking courses as a matter of requirement you're not getting in otherwise so I have a overarching qu question about act 95 that a parent asked me two weeks ago that it kind of stunned me and I didn't know the answer to and uh what do he asked me was he said he has a problem with act 95 and I said what what's the problem he said so UW Madison is supposed to be the flagship institution of of the state of Wisconsin and I said okay whatever and he said um once you get admitted there you should be able to choose any of the wuw systems from there that there shouldn't be a difference between u m you once your guaranteed admission to W Madison that should Grant you admission guaranteed admission to any of the

055WW systems is that not how act 95 is working right now is there separate guaranteed admissions to the other UW systems like Madison versus Whitewater versus there's tears yes there's G GP tears and that's what he was saying he has an issue with that if you if you meet the tier to to get it get guaranteed admission into W Madison because of the institution it is that should guarantee you admission to the other UW schools so if you're in the top 10% you go to any wre if you're in the top 5% you go to W Madison direct at you can go to UD mson so technically if you're in the top 5% you would already be in the top 10 so you should should be able to go either way okay direct admit right

056which also happened at the exact same time does have really clear tear W Clair and W lacrosse are and Madison are not part of direct admin okay which was a separate families opt in we send their information and then they automatically universities reached out to our now 11 students um throughout the course of the summer to demonstrate or to you know share their Acceptance in those specific places but that's another piece that's a little confusing for our families came at the exact same time there's a lot of confusion between direct ad ad 95 yes yes there is I have a question go uh the criteria for the academic Excellence award is basically those bullet points it's based on a grade point average tax score and total total number of credits earned and then you earned

057the academic Exon Bo how many students out of curiosity are in are basically set to earn that award yeah so the awards the actual admin link is there it does say the number of scholarships is is determined based on the student enrollment on third Friday count so it varies based on the enrollment the current um 11th grade class is actually one of our largest at 477 um and the eligibility criteria go through um you know specifics about being being enrolled the last four semesters Etc these pieces are really just the tiebreaking procedure so they look at GPA first similar to Wisconsin guarantee but if they have to break that tie then that's when they would go to act and um total number of high school credits earned for the admin Ro right now it says

058seven semesters of high school study um Wisconsin guarantee is looking for us to come up with after eight or no after after the end of their 11th gr year so not seven to six and then in the academic Excellence that and these are for the academic Excellence Bo okay again this was just a starting place for our team when we started thinking through what what might already exist for tiebreaking procedures but we're not at all the board's not bound for these to become the specific criteria we could certainly go in a different direction then we would have to make a decision do we want to align the academic Excellence Award with how we're approaching at 95 or not but this was a starting 2015 so you mentioned that other districts are in a similar position

059of looking a tiebreaker criteria do you have any examples of what they're considering other districts might the uphold as well sure so um some districts are exploring weighted grades okay some already had them some are exploring weighted grades others are looking at Advanced course credits earned somewhat similar to what we're talking about here but there's differences in whether or not they're looking at advanced placement dual credit honors lots of different systems that different schools have for um making those notations other schools didn't need to apply for a waiver or were far under that number and so aren't as concerned with as we were given the numbers that we've seen I want to Echo an earlier concern about students who have a spot under any of these criteria that don't really want it because they're not

060interested in the University system um and uh and then Tate's comment about the nature of the waiver that you know you're exempting yourself from part of the statute so there's limitations how creative you can get right yeah not to say that's impossible you can try it the way with d just that would actually help us eliminate because I think a lot of people at the end of junior year saf you're not cutting that out I this the end of the junior year when theyd have to then commit and say I'm not going to take this yeah I would I thought what do I and to the criteria just that talking in general I am so hesitant to try to create shifts in philosophy and practice in our district to surround criteria for ACT 95 so

061like the conversation around rated rates we've kind of toyed with that on and off I mean that is a philosophical shift in how we do things as a district so making that shift you know if other districts want to do that great I am in no desire to satisfy act 95 criteria by doing such a Monumental thing that I don't know that I fundamentally agree with um so how to have this conversation around this criteria really recognizing that you know what we're doing in our district and making conversation points around things that we value regardless of at 95 I think is super important but at the same time the easy Poss the easiest solution Cuts against the grain of what philosophically using these ACT scores um and so you know I'm not I I don't

062think we should change any philosophy in response to one exigent thing but I don't think we should do the inv either so so I just wonder if there's another this thing outside the box if we have our our um our Equity framework we we're thinking about you know preparing our our students to be Global Citizens and part fobal Society are the ways we can evaluate that engagement with community and what students are doing Beyond just their academic life but outside of school in connection with Community uplifting like really seeing that framework in a living perspective and seeing our students do that uh I think it's just something to consider our service think service service hours yeah I mean so there's things that happen but I don't know that we can it's like a video game

063right like you accum accumulate like silver cord you get like points and you know all this stuff like I mean it can get real formulaic and messy really quick but you know are there intangibles you know like when I was teaching introductory classes at the University like there are a lot of intangibles that come out in that first semester where you've get a lot of students that had 4.0 all the way through their lives that are shocked at some of the self skills they need to the need to have had to survive in a big place like the University of Wisconsin Madison um and it was always kind of like how do we make those soft skills count like the organizational skills you know the self discipline skills to stick with it when you can

064party every night and you've never had that freedom before and um but it's a slippery slope right it's a very careful thing I think I I I think this is a dumb law and I hate it right but like setting that aside we do have an opportunity to use the criteria that we're being required to establish to incentivize what we want out of our students I'm just not really and we've kind of teased around these conversations before I'm not sure we really know exactly what we want our students to do and then there's the problem of how you take that in incentive and turn it into an objective ranking or a tiebreaker like how do you incentivize service without then ranking students in order of who serves the most you know like uh that's the

065reason I don't like the law but like also struggle though with this using this to incentivize is that this same thing as what will help somebody be a successful student at w and that's ultimately I don't want to send our kids to ww and have them not be you know in the place that should Beed how do we ensure that we um to Joe's point I think it's less a question of like do we need to have a discussion about what we want from our students we had a whole Community involved like process around what a you know like Verona lifelong learner what a graduate looks like and it it kind of was part of our strategic planning process the question is how do we take those you know five six Criterion and turn them

066into quantifiable things that are legally acceptable as per the DPI which is its own tricky thing um in a way that's true to our values then or you know our our our Frameworks um and the problem is like I don't know that we have well I mean it's maybe not a problem because like if we say we've already done all this leg work with our community we know what our community is said the tricky part is how do we apply it in these circumstances legally how many criteria do you have to submit I you can put whatever you need in the waiver I think we're recognizing that we keep saying 4.0 but if we ended up this could be a tiebreaker for students with 3.97 that are at the bottom of the 10th percentile and

067we need to cut that off um so I think we were trying to make sure if GPA was tied having at least two other criteria the economic Excellence award essentially says if they're tied on these other two criteria it will be a it will be a drawing so we would like a lottery basically if you can correct it doesn't it doesn't mandate a certain number of criteria that we would use right try hit the five or have as many as we want or as many as we need as many as we need get the number that's required by but we don't know what we need until we actually we know the number of students we know the number of students but not the number of criteria that will lerate enough students yeah and how to

068like so that spot it five four three that's what's we won't until right we don't have ACT scores get total number of credits earned would be at the end of the year say five I mean what's the number our our best guess was three three okay that's your three that's not g to get my approval but it doesn't matter that's just there um total number of credits and advanced courses into Joe's point I think it was about more than broading it a little bit beyond credit it could be a and I think we have to accept that no matter what we do unless we do the AC which I agree there's not a lot of appetite for it's all going to be kind of retrospective and people are going to be unhappy about that but

069we didn't put ourselves in this right all of them are but if the point is to assess rigor and how much they've challenged themselves I do like looking at the collection of advanced courses because that means they've challenged themselves thir ADV placement or credit or other additional courses that they takeen that they've taken that aren't those whatever they may be thetically suggest they successful well and then theoretically kind of disaggregates how you earned your 4.0 I think right if grade point average is a criteria I think disaggregating the establishment of that 4.0 seems to make sense by looking at rigor however that maybe gets measured I appreciate the broader scope though of rigor that we recognize it doesn't just have to mean there's an AP label on your course I think it has the advantage

070to and I'm not sure I'm that's I I want to think of a little bit more but when we were talking about this law when it first came up my biggest concern was it was going to start to disincentivize yeah your and this kind of somewhat counteracts that a little bit yeah right and I remember Dr clar I thought we discussed this when we were talk average and how we didn't like it it was because it was hard to distinguish we're really going to elevate a student that takes AP science but then a student that's maybe at the top of their game with woodwork or a specific trade how do we how do we say that that's just not it's that doesn't qualify so so I guess the advanced courses I don't I want to

071make sure that we don't leave out any of those students that are advanced in the trade so to speak and not the traditional you know AP type classes and dual credit classes and that remains a concern that remains a concern so it Still Remains a concern there's not really a way to cleanly do this corre I Dum law it's a dum law but is there a way that we can do the something just throwing it out there since we're just throwing ideas out internally to resolve that and say hey someone who's doing Advanced ww or Advanced whatever the advanced courses are that are not traditional speak they're not they don't carry the AP can we do our own distinction and say hey it's not AP or your credit but it's right you know whatever it

072is I'm struggling with this because if if I throw what I'm hearing if we throw out the 10 and 5% requirement this sounds a lot like direct admit to me when we're looking at the CR IIA like we're not throwing out the five or 10% we have more people our 10% there's a tithe that's bigger than like 133% of our graduate classes a 4.0 we can only send 10% so yeah W system is saying we don't want your 13% if they're all 4.0 you need to cut down and hit the 10% threshold the I guess I'm I'm struggling with the criteria that we're looking at it because to me 95 and correct me if I'm wrong focuses more on standardized testing doesn't really focuses on GPA it said that we must create a class Rank

073and it has to focus on GPA GPA first yeah GPA has to be first okay and the waiver is for us to consider things in addition to GPA but not to my understanding to eliminate GPA at all so the concern that I'm still having around using those that advance course label is a couple of things one is it still requires some like value judgment of what's Advanced and what's not um and two I if we were doing the most Equitable solution I think it would just be credits earned um uh but I'm not sure that's I mean this is the struggle that I'm having I'm not sure that that's incentivizing the same things that we want to be incentive because you easy credits yeah so that wouldn't really be a directly coordinated to rigor it

074would be maybe just strategic it would be a different type of rigor riger in a larger course load rather than riger in terms of yeah but if you AP courses that were very difficult and you took five very easy courses three AP courses is going to be much more RSE so I think that's still not gonna capture everything I'm for it because none of that's going to matter because my kids's getting dual credit so they're going to graduate with more credits than anybody can possibly accumulate so that's where cred would already benefit but that it's part of us that right I guess my point is if we're looking at like just for the next um Administration we have then total number of credits and then AP courses knowing that dual credits are already factored into

075the total number of credits they're not this would be total number of high school credits dual credit would be giving college credit as well we wouldn't keep for this first I mean I think if we there's a decision that needs to be you know reached before it gets too much later you know I guess I would think that we could do an advanced courses with kind of the easy the line for AP dual credit Capstone type of things and then take another look at the more expanded um each department what would be considered their highest level of course is there a way to do that as a secondary for our years moving forward I think that's more work than would be possible to do this time and there's also some ability to kind of prepare

076kids for what would be considered a advanced course I don't even know does high school do like course numbers I mean gr's you know course schedule so he's you know if he's in a 700 level we know that that's harder than a 100 level where it's more advanced is there something that we can look at different number levels you know course numbers I don't know how that would work but that's again for the next iteration for this first iteration keeping it simple but I like where it's going because if our we don't like this rule because we think it de can de incentivize students from really challenging themselves that have to like focus on such a narrow scope to stand out and earn automatic admission and our goal is to incentivize trying different things and

077excelling in areas that aren't recognized as per the current system as being rigorous or you know worthy of you know school credits or whatever you however you want to put it I kind of like if there's a solution you know that we kind of assign this is the highest rigor in these different areas and for scoring purposes we're going to incentivize reward students to continue challenging themselves even if it's an AP course or dual credit course isn't part of that path their Journey but they choose a different Journey we incentivize them challenging themselves in their respective path using woodworking as an example because that came up right so we wouldn't de incentivize the person that has a gift in that area in that technical area you know trade school call whatever just do you guys

078get where I'm going yeah we would incentivize it by introducing some kind of system where we say hey challenge yourself because this can be a a potential tiebreaker that earns you direct admission to the U even if you don't want to take the traditional IP courses or the do credit classes well in theory I what you're describing though is still waiting grades that would be waiting grades yes I me that's the concept right of way that's that's that's how you weight grad um and this is just me speaking I can't prove this but if you're asking me what my belief is my belief is the law was designed to push districts to weigh grants okay so that it's it's really so it's an easier it's the easy so whether it's waiting grades or not we

079still have to do it and what are we going to do we don't have to do it tonight no but something be done this year and yeah close the waiver application doesn't have a specific timeline we have to before we have to get the waiver approved before we have to make the selection this summer to be fair students impacted want to get correct happening at the end of this month so if students are selecting their courses for next year and we're choosing something like total number of credits it would be of them to know that at this point or we're choosing something like Advanced courses and we with our course guide is already out we have not necessarily in our course guide advance or defined Advanced courses I'm looking at intro or metal fabrication which

080is a dual credit course and it's labeled a 158 level right so the course number is not necessarily indicating for a student that that would be an advanced course and we haven't denoted that in the course guide that they already have so that's I think going back to then is it a two-step process where we have what criteria we use this year and that can then be already kindly understood um Advanced coursework with and tasking them with each department to kind of figure out I don't know I mean if it's ends up being weighted grades again none of this seems like fair so how do you create Fair criteria with a unfair premise and that's my my main take like the reason I don't like weighted grades is I don't like us making value judgments

081if this class is worth more than that class right and similarly yeah like in some areas like math it's easy you know Algebra 2 is more advanced than algebra one but like in especially like in the Arts or in music or band it's not so easy to say this is the more rigorous class and that is the easier class they're different and like how do you weight those how do you give more value to one than another and is that really what we want to be telling our students I know so then how do you square that with criteria for this and that's why I'm more leaning towards let's just Punt and say the total credits total credits and that's where I'm so curious like for this group how filtery does that get and I

082know like how how much of a tiebreaker would it be to be at that criteria that kind of may not be an indicator of at all I just think you can kind of gain that but I mean I me there's no perfect system I know no perfect system I think if you were taking an AP class as a freshman and you wanted an open hour because of the rigor of that course right you technically lost a partial credit but you had a harder course on the F side tell for me I a Spanish speaker that is how I wacked up AP credits additional credits it was hard for everyone else it was easy for me my GK and and knowing the system I was like I know what I have to do to help myself

083out right so um nothing wrong with that maybe I'm just using the knowledge that I have to you know give myself an advantage but it's it's with these I don't know just it's there's no win wi it's just this credit thing you can also play that game just you're looking at a course like was the easiest way for me to rack up credits and get that 4.0 boom and now I didn't necessarily get that education that we intended to provide you and the experience we intended to provide you but great you got into you know automatic admission to Wisconsin you know that's my concern but there's no this is what we're talking about it because there's no perfect solution right my hope is that you guys it's good to have the dialogue yes this is

084one we not can I just ask a more forward looking question not I need the conversation about right now can we use criteria that are like if they're weighted or whatever that are like extracurricular based or co-curricular based I'm looking at you D sorry but like it doesn't have like all everything that we're talking about right now is your GPA but then also like well we got test scores but also like your credits the things those are all like in the classroom you can you can so I think if we go into a larger discussion or even right now if we have a quick and dirty one but a larger discussion it's worth asking like you know when we went through this whole strategic planning process where we got community input which like again is

085really important in a decision like this we have criteria for a lifelong learner that came out of that process the question is how can we apply that fairly and equitably in this circumstance that you know meets the standards of the law but like this outlines what a lot of people like thought in our community would be s a successful student and um I mean it doesn't lend itself to act 95 so like I said it's more of a forward thinking question but like we have 9th to 12th grade criteria for collaboration and self-awareness written in paragraph form so maybe the question we ought to be asking is like how is that something that then can be reflected in how we then go through and rank students you know is that tied to credit hours I

086mean maybe you know personal growth somehow is I don't know you can make an argument there um resourcefulness I don't know like you could tie some of these metrics to those but I think that as a board if we're looking for a longer term solution that complies we have something of an obligation to reference the Strategic plan that came out of our community and doing this so I'm pointing at my computer because I have it up because I'm cheating in this conversation and of course all of that still lying under the umbrella of a 4.0 which is the fun thing about it right like a 4.0 contribut one of these is like community involvements in here a little bit like a 4 with a silver cord you know you know is one way of showing

087that Community involvement are there other ways sure you know depending on which group you participate in um so yeah that's what Chris was saying right yeah somewhat new I'll use the new new guy card um looking at thinking back to se schs one of the one of the inequities that we saw uh that was glaring was around Advan placement so students that got into advanced placements once you got in you were in there was never a way to really come out and and we had no no students in advanced placement for the entire city of Seattle which was like as Preposterous right so I I don't know like details like on how advanced placement works here but you know I I just think about racial in equity and all those other pieces and whatever we

088come up with what are the te consequences are we adding to that or we helping uplift those who have not had the opportunity to be considered for those important programs and I don't I don't know you can talk to me afterwards more information but perspective that I remember working on I feel like we've looked at statistics in our own District that show an inequity and advanced placement along similar lines so yeah it's not there have been ongoing conversations for a long time about access to AP and what does that look like and what barriers do we have structurally and trying all sorts of different things to kind of so it's yeah there have been a lot of iterations and conversations trying to address just that for a long time not not to many water but

089just something to think about it is it giving you the team something to kind of take consider any final thoughts from board members certainly if the discussion is feeling flourishing but I'm feeling like the energy is kind of to that point of it's so big we understand it's so big I appreciate the thoughts that everyone has surfaced a do you have something one final thought for me like it's my view that this weer has to be applied for each year so and what you're voting on whenever we actually decide on a plan is the actual waer application so each year if you decide that whatever you decided decide today work you have another yeah so we can literally be making a waiver for this year and come back to this see how it even plays

090out with the student body that we have I'm gonna ask a crazy question if we yeah you sit next to me I don't know why um if we create something like a wild cat score right the scores all these ambiguous things and we apply for a waiver to include that and then that the underlying like how that scores price changes year over year do we have to keep applying every time we change that underlying criteria for how we Define wild SC I think you have to keep applying regard correct oh you have to resubmit your waiver every year saying what your criteria is okay but the criteria could say we have a wild cat score and that's what we use and then I like the wild but to the point of like helping students understand

091that doesn't help students understand if we something me so yeah we need to also help it sounds like John's volunteering to be the one who assigns while I give myself 10 great uh any final thoughts anything else Amy that would be helpful for you just I mean I understand the premise of a wildcast score but and if we were thinking about how we actually practically use it right now there the three bullets that are already sitting up there so are we also going to change initiative rule because this is how we currently determine who gets fun scholarships towards where universities that we're talking about the academic Excellence Bo those three areas three and they are also part of our results policies and if it's just the order that they're applied so just have a question

092about ownership you said these are administrative roles it's not like that's not like a board thing great correct so you can keep your academic Excellence criteria and you can the philosoph the philosophy is completely different why we have one Philosophy for one thing and one Philosophy for another we want to be for the sake of the suits too I mean right if this is really the outcome is very similar getting a scholarship to an institution with which act 95 is in supportive I mean that feels like parallel for student input or student experience fa we just back around then to what you were saying at the beginning like it we should not be taking a philosophical leap just to match act n because there are these other implications yeah and it should all align philos

093philosophically with what we value and it's important to us as a community not just as a board um so close to it in the policy no because I mean that's a scholarship so that's an additional benefit AC into scho well I just think my opinion is for this W should we should keep in ad R for this for this waiver period keep in alignment this admin rule because it's will basically the proposed three bullet points because it's aligned and where currently things are and it's how our results policy are it would be shocking to our students they I think it'll be like oh okay that makes sense um and then maybe go forward we can talk about do we want to change that that's my opinion that's my only request would be to maybe change

094the order of the criteria that's what I was just suggesting right do can can it just be flipped yeah that credits would be first AC second I don't have a full grasp of the implications of doing that right I this is filtering yeah yeah is that easy to flip okay it's easy to flip and what that composite excore it's not like the writing portion it's the composite comp sorry the composite yeah I would like to earmark that consider the community engagement inside of of that later on as we move forward well I need to talk about graduation requirements I mean there's so many in weavings with so many topics that we've kind of had these grapplings around that again to have some sort of synergy around all of them rather than everything being side card

095also feels and for families and students to be able to plan and predict and to know what to expect yeah right we already know that our our current freshmen have act 60 which requires financial literacy so they'll already have 0.5 more credits for that class coming up and so to help them begin to plan and chart out their for your plan and their Journey To Know What To Expect will also be important for our students okay yeah transition transition yeah another quick another light board shop topic for a time so I'm going to turn to Dr Clarity to again give us just a frame for this discussion because there's been conversation in some of your advisory groups correct after Clarity especially given um recent happenings in Madison yeah so just in terms of timing um

096are the staff advisory parent advisory and student ADV advisory were all happen the Wednesday Thursday following the tra and uh on on Mond at Abundant Life um so obviously we switched all of the original genda points ironically we December is the time that we bring our our staff advisory and our parent advisory together in one large one large group is usually more celebratory obviously nothing to celebrate during during that during that time and our Focus was really about school safety uh and just uh wanting to get some perspective from our our caregivers in in those spaces as well as uh just being transparent about the amount of uh inquiries either through email or direct calls to central office or to different buildings about uh promotion of additional safety measures for our our schools uh some

097of those uh things did include uh things um that went to a level and I'm going use the term metal detector because that's the way they articulated uh if you as you don't do the research we know that metal detectors as we think about them are not what we're actually talking about we're talking about weapons detection systems that are more the AI generated ones not the beep and clear your pockets and do do the whole thing that we that older metal detectors used to used to think of um so in the slides that I have in front of you I did put together themes that allowed uh uh The Voice of all the groups to to to be here for our board as you considered your our discussion about uh what is the what is

098our overall FL Fe about our next steps if any in school for for school safety um I just want to be able to quickly present those to you before I turn it back for back for discussion so beginning with our students really uh they really talked about the need for transparent and inclusive communication and there were all already some adjustments at the high school really our high school V voice has really resonated that our messaging goes directly to families in the moment and at the same time we do know that students have immediate information on their hips all the time and they want to know how not not just what's happening but being able to navigate what's fact and what's not what's not real and how we're responding to a district uh Beyond just that

099reassertion of of are they safe and I and I tend I tend to agree with their stance on this that they are you know mature enough to be able to handle those type of communications directly to them and uh also knowing that not every family immediately or at all sometimes talks to them about the issues that we have communicated to them um and so they really felt that there was a gap in that direct contact in the moment just to know everything was going to be okay here in in in our in our district and I I respect and think we respond to that uh really thinking about uh enhanced expanded safety group drills I thought one of the most powerful analogies that many of the students brought up is like since kindergarten we've done

100fire drills once a month so in essence nine nine times a year for for 12 years for 12 years of of school and we've never seen anything close to a fire but we see we see school shootings on around our society all the time why is there not frequency of preparedness and why is there not uh additionally not always the one that are perfectly set during period four or period five like how do we practice for lunch I know we practice it we in the outside area all all those things so uh things that you know Chad and Nate continue some we did the drill first day of school coming back uh on January January January 2 for for active threat continue the training uh today for for roik as well but also make sure

101our students knew that but I think that's that's a great feedback we've we've talked a lot about continued access to mental health and emotional support and then a reassurance that um uh the the information that we put on our websites they also want quickly access to it how do they get resources when they're you know beginning to need that emotional support and they don't always have someone adult right there with them and how how how do they make contact if we scroll to the um staff and parent pieces of it um as we got deeper into things like uh entry point weapons detection systems I want to place your eyes back to Bullet number one which can we do that or balance safety without and using a direct quote have an imprison like atmosphere which

102I you know I completely honor honor and respect um again they brought up addressing the potential gaps in security such as unsecured entr this is a big beautiful high school it's got a lot of doors and so how are how are we thinking about that the budget implications are huge we we know that uh and then also just wondering what is the role of school Personnel in responding to threats knowing that uh currently um um if there were were Intruder armed versus unarmed did come didn't come up in terms of being able to have to have a responsiveness there and then finally the final three we're really about our long-term vision for safety knowing that we are in reactive mode right now but what is and I think what brings us together what is our

103district philosophy around total in totality what the safety protocols look like what um we do know that if you do go to weapons detection systems in buildings that is a huge philosophical shift in our way way way of programming uh but I just think the from the number of voices that we've heard from our community and uh seems to be becoming more and more of a trend in in school safety the conversation does need to happen so we turn it over to the board for either clarification on anything things that I presented from the advisories or just to start the conversation so maybe it's because it would be a shift but where I went to [Music] school we have weapons detection systems in Watts California but you could enter the school without going through it

104we didn't think anything of it because that's all we knew but maybe like you're saying this is a shift in philosophy or whatever that that it would change the culture so to speak but I mean for the for the most part it wored the SRO that's a different story we'll get to that later but I'd love to know more about what a modern weapons detection system looks like because honestly until you said it just a few minutes ago I was picturing same screening you go through at the airport like um uh and maybe that's not what we're talking about and so without kind of fully understanding what it is it's hard to form an opinion I guess yeah and that's what I think why this conversation is so important because if if it's something that

105the board desires that their Administration does deep research on or happen to do that but if it's not even a consideration is that the time that you want want want those uses but yeah but I understand for me personally even that's hard for me to I was just the same thing we have no concept of cost what types of resources we would be using and there are various different types there are so many different types of weapons a de di on that when we were building the school and just it was I mean things are evolved even since the planning for the school so the types of information that I had from 2017 is already significantly outdated you know what kind of I would have no concept of what whether this is a worthy exercise

106or not so that be inform and like Joe said there are some that do look like the airport there are some you don't even realize are even there you're walking through what appears to be a door frying and it's a weapons detection system and now what type of Staffing would be how would we need what type of space would we need if somebody alerts how do we secure that without compromising the you know the individual's own you know personal space um and all those questions are a catalyst by do we want to spend the time investigating answers to those questions I think there's also like what's what's the cost I mean even just some of these preliminary questions you know if this is like this is an million doll expense and we can't possibly afford

107it no don't investigated but we don't have any I have no concept of what this would cost and also there's the immediate cost and then the Wong cost right updating and upgrading Etc but I would you know I think you lay out a great point that this is somewhat reactive right so we're going something reactive and and the one bullet point that I think is most important around moving towards something that's proactive is that we we have a a community that none of our students ever get to the place where there is a shooting incident that's brought upon by them by our student body or our community externally coming into our our schools so the mental health and emotional support I want to really highlight that that is the key for me the most important

108piece here um you can build all the safety structures and everything else but if you don't have that at one piece it could be for not I mean I just want to really reiterate often we of Overlook that part as as being critical and and I think we just need to really put that Focus there as well there's something I to what does our open campus do as far as I mean a perable campus isn't here less safe and how how is that contributing to the safety of our school I mean that seems like an easy place to at least look and maybe it Le nothing but [Music] one of the things I've I've said a couple of times and it's an uncomfortable thing to talk about but when incidents happen at other schools uh

109there are always lessons to be learned from them and how to improve your security because it's I'm sitting here trying to think and be proactive and be like oh what are our vulnerabilities but it's never what you think it is um and I'd really like to build in and I can't get the information from the media reporting about these incidents that gives me I don't know if these schools had a weapon detection system I don't know how people gained entry into buildings did they have was a door left unlocked was you know what happened I I feel more comfortable having some kind of debrief that gave us Lessons Learned or or so that we as a board level can feel like we have information to know what's what the relative value is of various Security

110Options that are out there so basically the incidents that happened what areas tend to what were the gaps that were most common that would get us the greatest return or or alternatively what was what worked right what's the greatest return on our time and investment based on what's what's happening yeah I get that I feel like I can't get that from media report right I agre component yes that is something that we're doing now and we need to continue doing it and that's really what the long-term change's going to happen and we can't control unfortunately the the policies the gun policies in our country and the state of things um we can't change them overnight however I don't think that we shouldn't ignore this you know school shootings are all too common and for us

111not to do something to be a little bit more prepared as prepared as possible I think would would would be a missed opportunity to add layers to our mental health andal support Focus to make our whole Community safer the the point is how do we do it without it feeling invasive and feel like it's really meaning going to change our culture and our schools so I love Joe's ideas and then from that knowledge what can be the most least invasive or least disruptive social things that we can Implement maybe it's an AI system weapons detection system right where you walk through and you barely notice anything's happening right um I don't know what those things are but I mean I like that approach of Step One what is what are the common things that have

112gone wrong how can we focus on that sh goes up here and then step two is out of what we find out what's the least invasive and disruptive to a environment that feels safe and as least police state as possible I know we're not getting into sro's yet because I think that's another layer that honestly I'll just throw it out there could done in the right way way could actually help right but it has to be done right and you know has to be implemented in the right fashion it's my opinion right you know but I'm going to throw that out there you know me being Latino person of color as well I get that that feeling feeling unsafe and feeling like I might be you know especially in Wisconsin ton of about Latinos maybe

113Madison milwauke but outside of that not a lot of Latinos not a lot of people call it but I get that point but done correctly and I trust our Administration and I trust what I've heard the relationship that we've been developing with the police for Verona that that could be a a I don't know helpful part if done correctly right if we feel that that's the direction we want to go to sorry I took up a lot of time so one of the things because we're talking about laying down kind of a philosophy right about this sort of stuff or changing a philosophy or having to change philosophy and acknowledgement of some of the realities that are out there one of the things that I always struggle with is when we're talking about solutions that

114treat safety like a thing like you can defend it right and build a better Fortress or something like that um and it's a feeling right you have to acknowledge the the mental health components that go into it because that's its very nature you feel safe right you can feel safe because of things but safety itself is not a thing right an SRO can help make some people safe and some people not safe right and depending how that SRO is implemented and trained and interacts with the community that they're policing that's the whole difference in how that feeling is generated so the question of like we weapons detection systems well you got to balance like the efficacy of the system the need for the system with the feeling that it generates does it generate a feeling

115of safeness or is it generating a feeling of policeing that's creating more anxiety right the amount of drills that we do like the way that we do those drills like they can add to safety by drilling people in appropriate ways and safe ways but they can detract if they're constantly adding more anxiety right if they're opening up the potential in people's minds that this is a thing that happens all the time and we've just got to deal with it and who knows when somebody's going to have a problem that they feel like this is the solution you know like that where it starts to detract from that feeling of safety and so like these are all you know we're not just talking about buying a few new doorways that can detect things like we've got

116to talk about how do we um make investments in a way that engenders safety how do we create a safe feeling environment to people like those are what the students are saying ones who are most dialed in to what and dialed into one another I mean to your point and that's something that I know we talk about in our family of talking to my daughter about listen know people talk to people at school if you hear something say something we have ways in our district of speaking up and sharing about things that you're hearing that having students feel interconnected with one another and with the staff in the building I mean Everything feels so reactive always that feels like the one giant proactive thing that we can do is have students feel like individuals care

117about what you when you come into this building and I just I hate when that feels fluffy I think sometimes even the way I'm saying it just feels all squishy and unimportant that is the Crux of all of it is hurt people hurt people so if we have students that don't feel hurt and feel loved and cared for you know and we also and rightfully so we want to keep our baby safe that's why we're all here we also have to think about our staff our teachers our educators our our Administration our students because or our our faculty because I was always told back home that's why those detectors were mainly there and there shouldn't have been a mainly it should have been there for for all of us but our teachers back home were

118afraid of us and that's why they went through those safet Mees and I say that to say whatever we decide to do we need to think about our our educat our administrators as well when we look at abundant life is perfect example of all of it come into cation everybody equally needs to feel safe right thank you well with pretty much all of our Workshop topics it's not a nice tidy have a dialogue wrap it up and have a conclusion so the accepting non-closure and continuing dialogue I think is highly valuable um anything else that anyone wants to sh share based on the discussion tonight anything to offer Dr clar and the team specifically from this conversation just for clarification I get just more of a question and doesn't have to be V or anything

119is this exploration of what things could look like a reasonable mix up for for me I think so like a very preliminary investigation I would say if you think it is then bring it to us I don't know that we have enough information even decide if that's how you should spend your time that should be a if you feel like this is something that is a meaningful uh step then we would support that I think that or I would support that but I don't even know that I have enough information to I it could be I I think it's important because it's important to the community for us to have continued conversation with a little bit more context even if it's something that ultimately we don't think is the right direction um I I I

120think we should have more open conversation about it that's the piece I thought too is you and your team heard quite a bit from community members I know I didn't receive anything directly so I appreciate hearing from you other conversations that did come about that a reflection of what is being shared that didn't necessarily come through any and you have a huge Advantage because there were people part of your parents Advisory Group who actually on scene there yeah first first respond so those gaps that that Joe talked about they actually spoke to that yeah yeah that's great and again it's not I maybe I shouldn't have frame this just know what I'm trying to help us all understand is that our community needs to hear us talk about this that's why I put it as

121a topic it's it's crucial that that they that they they know that we're having these conversations and not kind of waiting like wait wait can see more so I mean so are we saying that the next episodes exp explore what we think are the top areas to to look in deeper into that will make us safer discuss if we agree on those areas and then then say yes let's go deeper in specific areas such as AI weapons detection such as an SRO such as anything else that comes out of that because I just want to be clear on what the next steps are because I I I would love to hear I think the first step would be to hear what those gaps are what the administration thinks the areas of focus and then us

122discuss those areas of focus and then try to narrow that scope because it's if we give them a long list of 10 items that might just be way to based on speculation based on speculation yeah so I think we just need to drill down a little more highlight things drill down further and then narrow out that make sense yeah mhm got it I just want to it feels like this conversation has gone toward um in some ways what I think is appropriate like looking at you know continuing to explore um SRO and continuing to explore weapons detection if that's like a thing it's necessary I just want to reiterate you know the items students brought up just brought up the mental health components um we already know that like you know getting the appropriate amount

123of mental health support to probably bu well more than $8 million you know and it's just lot so much more need um that funding um so kind of as we go forward yeah we're looking at these physical Investments but also like what sort of supports are we also I just want to make sure that's not lost I I would like to say one thing you know and I think Jo again coming back to what you said have talking about the each situation and maybe that's something done in close session because I know I have some information that is not public and I would like to bring that out but I'm not going to do it sitting here and um because it's not mine to share but it is something that's in the back of my

124mind and I'd like to talk about what were the situations that contributed to other tragedies how do we then look at all of the things that we have going on to ensure that because I do think here comes a lot of things can make us feel safe I think the ensuring that our kids are taking care of mental health the community with you know supports is really the only thing that will actually ensure that we're safe but I think talking about some of these situations you know maybe even close session so we can hear some of the behind the scenes that are not necessarily broadcast we would not broadcast our own safety plans publicly about every detail of it that would be unsafe that would make us inherently unsafe I think there's some more um

125discussion that you know obviously it should be had publicly but I think there can be some things that discussed maybe privately where we can talk I do want to highlight also this last incident that um most recent incident the communication that came out and the support for families to have conversations with their children at home I think um whatever support we can also think about not just the student body but but the families as well parents and caregivers um because I I think that's that's one of the hardest pieces here too as a parent you know having that conversation with my kids and answering their questions about what does this mean you know what is go away you know there's larger larger um I think just that conversation is so hard right and um and

126how do we prefer students to just be able to to communicate with their their their their friends and to know what's going on and to be the ones that are communicating as well be part of the whole system but yeah that's I think the more that we can provide support for our families as well is important to piggyback off that I was I would just like to throw some Kudos out to the district like I was very happy to when I went to our web page to look some stuff up the day after to have a popup come up like here's some resources for talking to your kid about it like that was really really nice it came up on every subsequent page that I click through so after a while I had all the

127resources I need but like like that's the type of thing that I felt really really like oh yes this is this is really great I agree actually did I do a good job of talking to my kids about it I did not I mean there's there's that part that are there other ways to build communi so other parents can talk to their parents there's a more Community approach that we talking there's multip John and what you were talking about was when we're evaluting these things to definitely bring up M's health emotional support and make sure we talk about what additional resources can we add right that where's the bang for the buck there right yeah absolutely thanks board ad not a fun easy but to Dr 30's point this is the point of I think

128having this time right to just be able to Voice have the dialogue so the community can hear us reflect and share with one another about how how we're thinking about the district okay well we'll wrap up Workshop time for this evening so traveling back to the agenda we are technically at superintendent consent agenda so please make sure you've taken a moment to look that over are there any questions hearing none superintendent consent agenda is approved as presented similarly board consent agenda please make sure you've looked that over are there any questions okay hearing none the board's consent agenda is approved as well so just a reminder again future agenda items tomorrow is the deadline for filing signature papers to run for a board of education seat so I'm seeing thumbs up from Christopher and Joe

129that have filed their papers so you need to be to central office by 4:59 p.m. tomorrow so Lori can accept your items by 5:00 pm um and then board January 15th the next greater Dan County Consortium Gathering I believe you all received a Google form invite from Mount horb District so if you do intend to go please fill out that form perhaps Lop Lori in directly if you do intend to go but have not voiced that explicitly so we can again acknowledge if there's possible Quorum and so M horb can have an accurate headcount for meals I missing anything about the 15th Dr Clarity no thank you okay and then again convention coming up at the end of January and our upcoming board meetings anything else on dates future items that are forgotten or worth

130mentioning okay so then we will adjourn to close session uh pursuant to Wisconsin statute 1985 sub one subg to confer with legal counsel for the government body who is rendering advice concerning a strategy to be adopted by the body in which litigation is likely to be involved specifically litigation regarding an alleged breach of contract as well as remaining in close session under Wisconsin statute 1985 sub1 subc to consider employment promotion compensation or performance evaluation data of any Public Employee over which the governmental body has jurisdiction or exercises responsibility specifically considering the employment contract of the superintendent uh is there a motion to adjourn to close session so move thanks Joe is there a second second thanks Christopher go roll call vote please to adjourn to close session Joe hi Corby hi John hi Meredith hi

131Christopher hi ju Carlos hi I am I as well we are adjourned to close session we'll take a short transition break thanks all

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.