CorpusRecord 10409

San Angelo ISD School Board Meeting - February 18, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / San Angelo ISD
Date
2025-02-21
Location
Tom Green County, TX
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,585 words · about 87 min
Collected
2026-06-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] good evening and welcome my name is Taylor Kingman and is president of the Board of Trustees of the St Angelo Independent School District I would like to welcome all of you who are present at tonight's regular board meeting I also welcome all those of you who are watching the recording of this meeting online or on our Public Access Channel we appreciate your interest in the AC ities of our students and The Business of saisd all items that will be discussed at our meeting this evening have been posted as required by state law also as you may be aware our board meets a minimum of two times per month and most if not all items on our agenda this evening have been previously discussed at our earlier pre- agenda board Workshop as members of the

002sisd Board of Trustees we are here to set goals listen to reports from our superintendent approve budgets contracts and Personnel appointments and to make policy for the district please keep in mind that our meeting is a meeting of the Board of Trustees held in public and not a meeting of the public however we have a public comment item on every one of our meeting agendas that allows anyone present who wishes to speak to our board team on an item not on our action agenda or an action item on the agenda an opportunity to do so please provide your name and contact information and the specific topic you wish to address on a public comment form located at the back of the room should you want to speak on an issue on our agenda or not

003on our agenda this evening please listen carefully and comply with the following rules so that we can move through this part of the meeting efficiently each speaker will be given a total of three minutes the district will provide an official timekeeper you will be notified when your time is up please respect the privacy of others and refrain from identifying students employees or other community members by name disruption of the meeting will not be tolerated at any time comments on any subject whether positive or negative must be courteous and respectful and comments are limited to the specific topic you indicated on the form you filled out any speaker with a specific complaint about a district employee decision or decision or operational issue should present that complaint through the appropriate mechanism which is the district's formal grievance

004process if you have a printing grievance please remember that you will not be permitted to discuss this during public comment also please understand if speak to us on an item not on our action agenda that the board cannot reply to you except to thank you for your comments since the matter has not been posted for discussion in compliance with state law these proceedings are recorded and will become part of ssd's permanent legal record in order that the recording will adequately reflect the proceedings I ask that you please refrain from talking while others are speaking I also ask as I remind my fellow board members to please turn off or silence your cell phones again thank you for being here and for your support of of sisd um we do have a quorum this evening um

005Mr dindle is unable to be here this evening um this is allthough elected board is a volunteer board and occasionally jobs get in the way and he's almost always here but today work got in the way of him being here this evening um but with that we're going to ask mon senior Larry drol from the Cathedral Church of the Sacred Heart to start us with our invocation good evening let us Begin by recalling the prayer of King Solomon for wisdom as he began his leadership this is taken from First Kings 3: 7-10 Solomon prays now Lord my God you have made me your servant King to succeed David my father but I am a mere youth not knowing at all how to act I your servant among the people you have chosen a people so

006vast that it cannot be numbered or counted give your servant therefore a listening heart to judge your people and to distinguish between good and evil for who is able to give judgment for this vast people of yours the Lord was pleased with Solomon's request we pray Lord God for that listening heart which leads to wisdom especially for our sisd school board we ask your blessing on our entire school system the teachers and administrators the students and parents and staff we seek Your Blessing of safety in all of our Gatherings and Facilities we pray for those who are in need this day we pray for peace in our world and Harmony in our city through Jesus Christ Our Lord amen all right now we have some students from buoy Elementary we have Rachel Vale Danny Young

007jce Garcia and Emma hair and they're going to come up here and help us with our pledges of allegiance to the United States in Texas if everyone could please stand flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all and yall stay up there than [Applause] all right next we're going to move forward with our agenda um first we have recognitions and the first recognition this evening is for National School counseling week and Miss Klein is already up there good evening board members executive directors Dr Gomez and Dr Moran I am Rebecca Klein I'm the director of counseling and mental health for St Angelo ISD and I'm here to share with you some seisd counselor recognitions for the month

008of February February 3rd through 7th is National School counseling week we were able to focus on invaluable contributions by our school counselors for our students and it's not just that one week it is all year long this year Three Rivers counseling Association a local chapter of the Texas counseling association called for nominations for counselor of the Year along with student tribute and scholarship Awards many of our own people received recognition this year the George pler counselor of the year awardees are Olivia Sarabia from Reagan Elementary elementary counselor of the Year Janet Castro Michael McCarthy Deborah Ramos and Britney Wagner Glenn Middle School counseling Team of the Year and Jennifer young Central High School St Angelo ISD counselor of the year for high schools if you all would please come up we would love to get

009a photo [Applause] opportunity thank you counselors I do also want to to recognize that the friend of counseling award goes to our very own Amy Melle Flint she is part of the St Angelo Clubhouse and National Alliance for mental health and our biggest advocate for saisd student mental health so thank you [Music] Amy Three Rivers counseling Association also Nom had nominations for student tribute Awards these students received Awards because in the face of adversity or challenges they continue to persevere and Thrive the student tribute awardees are Greta valde of Crockett Elementary Drake Reid of lonar middle school and Gabriel Gomez of Lake View High School if you are in the room please come up for a photo opportunity they may not have made it here she comes here comes graa I see you gr oh

010good job greata Three Rivers also award scholarships to two of our high school students based on an essay written about who inspired them to enter the career field or major that they have chosen the scholarship recipients this year are Christian laran of Lake View High School and pton caseres of Central High School if you would please come [Applause] up thank you and finally each year the Texas School counseling is Association award school counselors and campuses the distinguished Crest or counselors reinforcing Excellence for students in Texas award this award recognizes the cyclical and reflective work of the counselors and their comprehensive School counseling programs that they Implement on their campus this includes classroom guidance individual planning responsive services and system support this year we would like to recognize our recipients so as I call your name

011or your school please up Lake View High School Stacy riddle Rachel gondar Jennifer O'Donnell and Jenny rert along with Zach Ramirez principal I know we only have one representing tonight it's [Applause] okay Lincoln Middle School Beth m kada Erica Soo and Joe gondar thank you Lone Star Middle School Crest leadership award this means that they have earned crest for four years in a row based on their applications so come on up Amber Garza Justin McClure Michael o'briant and Amy L master was the principal when they were working on this Crest award so Austin Elementary School although they have closed they did earn crest for one more year before they did that and the counselor for that school at the time was Jessica riddle and the principal at the time was April Johnson Unfortunately they can't

012be here today but we do want to recognize that they did earn the crest for their final year so we are proud of that Glenmore Elementary School also received the crest Ashley McDonna and principal Terry Gould this is their first year to earn the crest so we're super proud of that and all the work that Ashley has done too many things and last but definitely not least Santa Rita Elementary School earned the crest award for the first year this year Kaye Fontano our counselor and K Scott the principal we are super excited for this one we could not be prouder of our counselors and the work they do to directly support our students and staff we appreciate the support we reive from all of saisd cabinet team board members and families thank [Applause] you Dr

013King Dr Moran before we move on to the recognition at this time I'd like to personally thank Mrs Rebecca Klein our director of counselors for all of her support she's about students first and does a tremendous job lifting up our counselors and all of our staff and seisd so thank you Mrs Klein for your [Applause] leadership next Dr Gomez is going to help us with recognition of the SSD Vex robotics Dr Kingman Dr Maran and members of the board we are thrilled with a full house and the audience this evening and are so excited to recognize the hard work of these students and staff we extend our deepest gratitude and admiration to the incredible stem and robotic staff and coaches for their unwavering dedication hard work and Showmanship during the recent first annual Robo Ram

014showdown at the Angela State University Ben Kelly Center for Human Performance this competition was held on February 1st their guidance Innovation and commitment to Excellence Have Been instrumental and shaping the next generation of problem solvers and leaders at this particular competition the following campuses received Awards during the event if present we invite coaches and students to come up for a picture when I call your name first up we have Santa Rita Elementary now listen to these team names they come up with these team names so Santa Rita Elementary 18493 a if you are present will you please come up right here to the center [Applause] and their sponsor Mr weaton and their principal Mrs Scott she's giving me a look you are their [Applause] principal this team before before y'all leave guys this team received

015the teamwork Champion award and the robot skills second place award [Applause] congratulations next up Crockett Elementary well this is a long one team 043a Crockett robotics if you're present would you please come up and there coach Mrs [Applause] Ratcliffe this team received the teamwork second place award and the robot skills Champion there are some missing team members but thank you both for being here we understand that they're very busy schedules from Lamar Elementary if we have anyone present from Lamar if y'all would start making your way up as I call out their team name of 847 37a the Titans come on [Applause] up yall have to smile these are proud parent moments too so please look ahead at the camera and their coach Miss Rivers and this team received the teamwork award [Applause] congratulations from

016Fort Concho Elementary 3105a the Sandman and their coaches and sponsors Miss Ferguson and Miss Sanchez and is Mrs Barton was she able to make it maybe not she's hiding Miss bartan are you looking at me like Mrs Scott they're pointing at you miss bartan we'll just wave I'm sure she will thank me for that congratulation this team received the teamwork third place award also from Fort Concho 31f [Applause] Supergirl sorry coaches and sponsors and Mrs Barton another photo this team received the judges award [Applause] congratulations now from Glenn Middle School we will start first with the teams from the robo Robotics and then um we may have some other teams um for from Glenn for their showings throughout the course of the year so first up from Glenn Middle School this is a long one

017411 00c info required and their sponsor Mr [Applause] ratliffe I have uh oh y had a smile Mr rackliffe why don't you stay up there congratulations to that team for the teamwork award next up from Glenn 411 00b info needed oh so for clarification they're saying Mr Ratliff picked the [Laughter] names notice some of our teams did bring their robots this team received the judges award congratulations next up go ahead and stay there Mr Ratcliffe next up 1400a standard deviation okay come on up well we've got some give them a second here we come and this team also received the judge's award congratulations [Applause] the students you saw in front of you this evening demonstrate creativity teamwork and perseverance values that extend far beyond the competition floor congratulations students on a job well done if

018we have any stem coaches um that were not called for the February 1st competition we would also like them to stand and be recognized for their contribution to stems and Robotics in the district it's very important that we thank Mrs FC Mr lagon Mrs Barton and all of our stem coaches and robotic sponsors for bringing to life the seisd learner profile thank you for your passion for making a lasting impact in the world of Robotics and stem your contribution are truly invaluable please join me in a final round of [Applause] applause and board members at your seat you have a small token of appreciation for your support of stem and Robotics education and saisd thank you Dr Gomez you're up again yes sir so we're gonna do the recognition of Career and Technical education month

019and the fact that we're a district of Distinction absolutely so we're going to display a slide for the first portion and Mrs Fentress I know that we don't enjoy these things but if you could please make your way to the front my daughter and then my son was on the GL perfect so Dr kemman Dr Maran and members of the board as we move to the next recognition as you all are aware February is CTE month last week for the pre- agenda meeting we had a workshop in advance where our CTE ambassadors were able to share with you firsthand their experiences through our CTE classrooms and seisd to begin this evening's recognition as you will see picture there before you we are here to honor Mrs roxan Fentress our director of CTE our High School

020principles and all of our CTE teachers and staff for their outstanding in leadership and dedication to our CTE programs they're unwavering commitment to providing students with high quality Hands-On learning experiences Have Been instrumental in preparing our students for future careers their hard work and vision were pivotal in our district receiving the prestigious District of Distinction award from the career in technical Association of Texas cat you know we like a lot of acronyms so that is this beautiful award here and this on your screen is M Mrs Ventress receiving this award on behalf of the district I won't make you come stand in the middle yet also as you will see behind us here the banner that was received under Mrs fess's guidance our CTE programs have achieved remarkable Milestones including Innovative programming industry-based certifications Community

021Partnerships and exceptional student outcomes thank you Mrs Fentress for your dedication to Student Success and for making a lasting impact on our district and Community if we have any CTE teachers present if you two would stand I know we had some we would like to honor you I see them hiding in the back just kind of wave and at this time we will switch over to our latest CTE video this video can be found on the St Angelo ISD web page under Career and Technical education and you also may have seen it on our social media platforms this video is a little longer than normal but we felt it was very important to take this 4 minutes and 24 seconds to highlight the outstanding work of these dedicated educators [Music] hello I'm Rox San Fentress

022and I'm proud to serve as a Career and Technical education director for S Angelo ISD the mission of saisd is to engage all students in a relevant and inspiring education that produces Future Ready graduates the CTE program aims to do just that with 18 programs of study and 12 different cre clusters there's something for every student in saisd our goal is to empower students with the knowledge skills and hands-on experience they need to succeed in their chosen careers at San Angelo ISD we're preparing students for the future through our Career and Technical education programs RCT courses offer students Real World skills Hands-On experiences and Pathways into high demand careers across Industries whether students are interested in healthcare engineering agriculture the Arts or business saisd CTE programs provide a foundation in diverse career clusters each designed

023to open doors to future success with state-of-the-art computer equipment virtual reality simulations and Industry standard tools we ensure our students are trained on the same resources they'll encounter in the workforce by using the latest in technology and Equipment our students are prepared to step into their careers with confidence working with tools and software that are current relevant and built for success in today's Industries our programs are Hands-On bringing learning to life from culinary arts where students learn food safety and culinary techniques to Automotive where they gain skills in repair and Diagnostics each course prepares students for success in Practical impactful careers the reason why I like this program so much is because it just shows you different ways of cooking and different ways of preparing food we took our test over food handlers every uh

024vendor in the state of Texas needs that and it would help us on our like resume my CNA and photomy certifications mean a lot because it's going to help me in my healthcare career through my time through this program I've learned how to do uh concrete Roofing uh Plumbing how to build walls electrical and this class is teaching me the basics of how to do it when I go into trade school certifications in areas like graphic design welding and business provide our students with credentials that set them apart through Partnerships with local businesses and community events they gain Real World Experience often leading to job offers and internships students also have the chance to compete in organizations like taffy for future Educators and BPA for business professionals these competitions build leadership teamwork and critical skills

025that will serve them well in any career our dedicated instructors each with industry experience guide students through learning and growth Partnerships with local businesses and organizations provide students with mentorship helping them develop both Technical and interpersonal skills all of our Career and Technical education courses incorporate employability skills where students learn those applicable soft skills of responsibility than employers are looking for we're able to offer students those skills when they're involved in our courses student leadership organizations and certification programs we want students to graduate from from our programs with the tools they need to succeed in high demand High wage occupations the saisd CTE program opens Pathways in Industries like engineering business the Arts and agriculture whether students plan to enter the workforce or pursue higher education the skills and experiences they gain here lay the

026foundation for their future quality CTE programs are poised to provide the very Solutions we need to address the talent and the skill shortage to come that means means we need to Foster Partnerships by getting businesses inside the schools and the schools inside the businesses and to do that we as a business Community must invest the money and the time in Education and Training at San Angelo ISD we're building tomorrow's professionals creators and innovators today join us and discover the endless opportunities that the CTE program has to offer Dr Maran at this time would you please come for a piter with Mrs Fess and any of the CTE teachers are welcomed I don't think they'll take me up on that but you're welcome to come join the picture oh they were brave souls thank you [Applause]

027again Dr Gomez before we move on how many how many districts in the state were able to get the distinction award 35 and how many districts are there in the state many more than 35 well over a thousand thank [Music] you great job Mrs fend [Applause] next up we're going to have Dr Brandon and he's going to help us with the month of the bus resolution Dr kemman Dr Moran members of the board many of our students spend a considerable amount of time each year on school buses Administration recognizes that school buses are the safest form of transportation in the US and this this level of safety is made possible by the men and women driving maintaining monitoring and overseeing our transportation system we very much appreciate the members of our transportation department and the

028symbol of safety our yellow buses have come to represent in today's culture so for February love the bus month we have the following resolution whereas the yellow bus is among the most recognized icons of American schools in society and whereas the school buses make up the largest mass transit system in the United States and whereas research demonstrates that the yellow school bus is the safest mode of transportation for some 26 million American school children each day and whereas yellow school buses are built to exact federal and state safety specifications and school bus drivers are provided rigorous training preparation and testing to ensure the safety of our children and whereas the yellow school bus provides access to education and learning for children who live in rural suburban and urban areas including children who present with special

029needs and whereas the yellow school bus enhances the educational experience by providing access to extracurricular activities such as field trips and sporting events and whereas the yellow school bus contributes to improving our environment by reducing the number of vehicles that must be on the road to get our children to to school each day and whereas the men and women who manage and operate local school transportation systems are dedicated to the safety of all children to ensuring efficiency and accountability in the delivery of school transportation services now therefore be it resolved that the S Angelo ISD recognizes the vital role that yellow school bus plays in our education Enterprise and the life of our district and be it further resolved that the S Angelo ISD declar is the month of February 2025 to be love the

030bus month in St Angelo ISD we call upon our students our families our faculty and staff and our community to recognize the work of our school transportation team and all they contribute to the well-being of our students and at this time we have to recognize our transportation department we have our Lee Livingston director of Transportation Jer paw administrative assistant to the director K Fuentes bus driver and Diana Alvarado Transportation router let's give them a hand [Applause] thank you Dr Brandon all right now we're going to move forward with public comment ments uh first up we're going to have Mrs Karen best uh regarding Blue Bonnet thank you all right I appreciate the opportunity to speak with you once again against the against the blue bonnet curriculum and I appreciate that several board members have visited

031with me about my concerns about blue bonnet I took the opportunity and I if I could ask how many of you have read the readers or that have been provided all of the readers that you're going to be reading if you have um then you're going to notice some of the things I'm going to speak about tonight um quickly if you haven't you should before you vote on it I'm going to pick one this is grade one foundational skills unit one snapshots and I'm going to read from it snapshots is list it is two words it's a one-word word um but okay and I'll make it quick because I got to be fast Beth I am Beth I am tin I am at camp Camp is fun once mom and dad went on a trip

032to the camp all of us were at the camp dad and I went up on top of a path at the pond mom got a snapshot of us misspell this is the snapshot misspell then Mom let us snap some shots dad got a snapshot misspelled of mom I got a snapshot misspelled of a dog with a hot dog cat and the trip to the UK this is cat cat is a kid I met at Camp I have a lot of snapshot misspell of cat this is a snapshot misspelled of cat with a fish cat and I had a lot of fun at camp but then cat's mom got a job in the UK cat left and I felt sad but then Mom set up a trip to the UK mom and I went on a

033jet ships are fun and jets are the best I got to sit next to the wing I had lunch then I had a nap mom got this snapshot Miss build of the nap cat met us at the end of the ramp I ran up to hug her then cat's mom doc got us a cab this is a snapshot of us with with the cab man it goes on like this it's pathetic in fact if you stay up until 2 am like I did which I can ill afford to do because I have to be at a surgery with my son this week and should be on the road out of town this is how important it is to me to stay here tonight and drive tonight after this to present about this this is not

034education this is not learning if somebody along this distinguished line of Educators think this is how you teach kids to read or you engage them in education this is not it this is not it who's accountable for this what I'm going to call for lack of a better word crap it's crap and parents like myself shouldn't be staying up until 2: a.m. when we have Educators who all of you care about our kids but you have all of this pressure from the state to take this crap I can't help that and you can't help that but at the end of the day the members of this board represent the rest of us and every child in here thank you thank you Mrs [Applause] best next up we're gonna have Mrs Ginger Moore good evening Ginger

035St Angelo I have a masters in early childhood and also have taught English and psychology and I'm I'm my issue I gave last time were all the items that I felt were important this time I'm focusing on three items for one thing uh blue bonnet curriculum I am for and I went to the uh State Board of Education to testify for it and I listen to 100 people testify by the way um I like the paper pencil materials um cursive from second to fifth grade is back on paper and pencil they have paper course books they have no AI screen time at all zip the parent can look at it online but the child is not online um and Screen Time causes and we can go back and debate this but poor achievement of Developmental

036milestones in communication motor skills problem solving and social skills higher likelihood of inadequate sleep lower scores on thinking and language test social skills connections with more distracted less emotional stability sometimes difficulty making friends in inability to finish task premature cortical thinning of the brain and we have a couple doctors that probably know more about that increased depression symptoms with suicidal outcomes and rates are higher with those that are stay on these iPads and they're saying this is even for like three and four year olds um the other second thing is classical literature and historical documents although all of the books are not good uh people have input into blue Bonet curriculum it belongs to the state so if they would need something changed they can have they can go online and be a part of

037that they're asking for people to do that but our nation's Founders had Jesus judeo-christian conservative values in God we trust is on everywhere I put out signs for all the schools with that uh biblical references are to sport classical and historical literature um and they used to be taught that used to be part of the curriculum the Bible is is part of the literature uh State Board of Education had a lawyer at the meeting to reference any issues and he answered multiple issues on all of this I assure you BL onet has been vetted it incorporates Texas values and histories it was written for Texas by Texas um the third thing is Blue Bonnet is free plus $60 per child for materials all paper products are are paid you can pay for with the $60

038and there won't you won't have to pay for the iPads except in third grade because the star test but the star test is being changed to meet Texas blue bondage oh thank you Mrs Moore um next we have Mrs Angela Bible regarding Blue Bonnet sorry I'm short hi uh I'm Angela Bible I am a teacher at St Angelo ISD and I just started this year I was drawn here for several reasons one of the reasons was what a wonderful and diverse uh people group that I was going to get to teach and another was the Excellence that the St Angelo ISD has shown time and time again towards having a an education that is worthwhile um one in which the teacher actually has a voice an opinion and gets to inject their passion one in

039which overall in Texas this this particular issue is being driven back as we saw in with SE sorry as we saw with ccope several years ago with that whole debacle we had a curriculum which was completely written we had had Exemplar lessons they came out they were wonderful some of them some of them weren't and so then we had to have to have all of that pulled back completely um and I still have some of those ccope curriculum um components I liked some of them some of them were fantastic some of them were not but I like having the capacity to say yes this component is amazing this component is not um um I also don't see the peer vetting uh and review that is necessary not all of the curriculum is even out yet

040not all of it is even printed yet not all of it is even a able to us to see yet I am afraid that St Angelo ISD is not an ISD that has the capacity to absorb all of the lawsuits and other issues that might come if this is not one of the things that are one that ends up being as good as we think it might be because we don't know yet um we we don't have to adopt this this year for it to be something that we adopt I think that even if we do want to adopt this this does turned out to be something that is amazing wonderful and good let's give it a year let's see how this goes for everybody else um finally this like I said before the ability

041for teachers to instill p passion in their lessons I come here because I could come and teach about the thing that I am super passionate about I get to teach about plants and soil and I know that sounds like super something crazy that you might be excited about but I love plants and I get to talk about that I get to bring people into my classroom that also love to talk about that and I would not have that room if I'm scripted every single sentence of every single lesson thank you Mrs Bible next we have Mrs Gretchen Smith regarding high quality instructional materials good evening I I come here not only as an educator but also in my second job I am the director of Christian education at St Paul Presbyterian Church I also do

042Supply preaching which is basically a substitute teacher for churches um substitute preacher so I started to dig into this curriculum as a person who is very theologically founded and theologically driven and as I started going through it I found some significant gaps in what exists in this material as a community we have and as a district we have developed this idea of the Future Ready learner we have developed this learner profile that is what we want to see in our students by the time they make it from kindergarten to graduation right we have this idea that we want them to think differently be able to problem solve connect globally with different things and I don't see how we col connect globally with different ideas with an americ Centric christocentric curriculum um we're supposed to to

043uh part of our goal is to uh raise Learners to exhibit flexibility adaptability curiosity and Innovation as I'm looking through I spent a lot of time particularly on the kindergarten reading for some reason and the teacher has a script and the teacher has a script and they're supposed to read this script and they're supposed to pause and ask this question and there's an idea of what the student supposed to answer which is hilarious if you've ever been in a kindergarten classroom um but and then and it's and you're supposed to show these color printed cards that show the picture to go with the stories and in the nine years I taught Elementary five of the five of them in this District I never had access to a color printer so I first want to ask

044where that's coming from because I'm looking at this idea of $60 per student and I'm looking at the massive number of worksheets that need to be printed out and I know that a rem of paper what $45 we have invested in iPads we have invested in technology we have invested in infrastructure we've invested in computers and technology and I understand the desire to go back to paper and pencil but worksheets don't build dendrites Stacks and stacks of poorly developed worksheets do not actually do what this ideal of pencil and paper is we want to engage students um as an educator I am evaluat on my ability to differentiate to Monitor and adjust and to engage with my students as I looked through the curriculum there were no suggestions for how to modify this curriculum for

045high achieving students for special education students for cross-curricular things the things that I am supposed to do as an educator aren't in this curriculum where I could find it the only thing I could find was for my emerging bilingual students which is an important population but not my only students with needs thank you thank you Mrs Smith next we have uh Mr Daniel counts regarding the bond good evening board I come here tonight to thank you for your hard work and your dedication I don't think youall hear that enough from the citizens but the reality is we have a trust issue right now now the citizens do not trust what you're doing with our money we don't trust the decisions you're making with our children's future I exhort you to think when you go home

046are you leading with humility if if you think you are you're not being humble enough do you think that you are leading with transparency you're not being transparent enough any that you think you may be exceeding at excelling at you're not doing enough for the citizens because we just we don't feel that in our hearts so as a parent you know with children in the school system we want to know that when we spend our tax money we are supporting our children when we spend our tax money we are directly linking that to our children and how they feel if they're supported yall are the business wing of s Angelo School District but your business is to further the education of our children you're not in the business of building buildings you're in the business

047of helping our children further their education and supporting the entire citizen population so um I my goal was not to get cut off by the Bell so I just want y'all to go home tonight and think we do appreciate you as Citizens you may have have some citizens it might be a thorn in your side that come up and you know tell you everything you're doing wrong you do some good things and some things are right and this bond is really needed but what's needed along with this bond is a trust being built back up with the citizens so thank you thank you Mr counts next and I apologize I don't know which page was next so I apologize but we're going to go with Miss Carla cardinas um regarding Community perspective every time something

048happens in a neighborhood like theirs they want to scream Injustice dude just because now you have to drive more than 5 minutes to get your kids to school it's a problem everything in St Angelo is 20 minutes or less get over it already I worry about the closing of schools because we are already so short staffed in our department and having more kids further away from school will put a lot of pressure on a department I'm just really worried for the future Carla if only you could see what happens on these buses it's getting shut down okay no matter what you say so get over it get used to the lies they run this country I read in an article that the best way for schools to have control is by eliminating the neighborhood schools

049that's all they want is the control neighborhood schools are the only home that so many students have 31 years experience as a teacher has taught me this no trust no bond you don't want to pass the bond then be ready to leave it to your kids as a big mess and that will be on you we have been lied to constantly why should I believe anything they say I'm voting no I'm voting yes I thought I knew who my real friends were I guess I know now stop bringing up the pass already just move on oh you really think she did something good all she did was make a mess for us at sanino we had to move all of our classrooms because of y'all fighting over a broke down school is it not obvious

050why would they disrespect the head of their school's PTO they just don't like her rep reports show lack of maintenance since the 2022 school year when it was advised to have immediate repairs done that would not be very costly in comparison they just lied to us man I'm transferring my kids out of saisd I'm sick of this this is a separation right now within our community within St Angelo so many other things being spewed at each other that I myself wouldn't even feel comfortable reading today the division is unreal I personally believe that the lack of transparency from the top has played its role in this entire situation where's your accountability I have spoken with many board members and told them that the only way to try to bridge this huge gap right now between

051our people is to be sincere in what has happened in the past and to be honest we know the truth and you know the truth but we need to hear it publicly now while it is true that you cannot change the past you can learn from it build on it Grow from it and start fresh you all are the leaders of our school system and it starts at the top if the people don't believe in you how can they trust you sincerity and empathy go a very long way stop hiding important details that we deserve to know the truth of the matter is we are in a hole right now how we got there well that's for another 3 minutes but we can start now and try to bring this city back together and it

052all starts with you thank you thank you Mrs cardinas next we have Miss shanana Payne regard the blue bar curriculum hi my name is shanana Payne I want to begin by telling you that I am a former saisd student from very long time ago the mother of two saisd students a middle schooler and a high schooler y'all pray for me and an saisd teacher of 19 years I want to tell you about just a couple of my concerns with the BL Bon curriculum the first I'll mention but will not dwell on because I know you've heard it is the infusion of biblical teachings into the reading curriculum just to give a few examples the reading curriculum includes kindergarten reading lessons on the creation story as told in Genesis and ask comprehension questions like what did

053God create on the third day it includes a first grade lesson on the story of The Prodigal Son now I am a Christian I've raised my children as Christians and I love every student that crosses my path in the way that my God leads me to do however I do not want to be responsible for the spiritual and religious growth of of children in a public school setting nor do I want other public school teachers directly teaching my children religion or spirituality that is not our place it goes beyond Towing the line between church and state and it puts teachers in a precarious position my other issue is my are my academic concerns for this year I've been teaching what is the current version of what will be blue bonnet curriculum it is called amplify

054my concerns are many so I'm going to list them in bullet points with as much time as I have there is a notable absence of a variety of quality High interest children's literature all of the reading both to and by students come from what is essentially a basil reader a book written specifically for this curriculum children don't have the opportunity to explore different genres authors illustrators or topics they only have time for what is force-fed to them there is no way to foster a love of books or reading within that structure the material and pacing is not adequate for what is needed to to pass the star test or show adequate growth in reading and academic Readiness students don't do enough reading in my third grade curriculum there have been days in which the read-aloud

055portion of my lesson is 75 minutes that's me reading two nine-year-olds for 75 minutes you couldn't even listen to me for 75 minutes I can't stand to listen to me for 75 minutes and I go home with no voice as a result I'm becoming a great reader I have some misgivings about my students while I do believe in the value of paper and pencil more than you know I believe more in the value of student created products this curriculum need leaves no room for that by packing every second of each lesson with teacher Le learning and approximately four five to six worksheets per day that's busy work the scripted nature of the curriculum negates my expertise my education my experience my professionalism and possibly most importantly my knowledge of and my relationship with my students

056by giving me a script to follow and I don't get enough time to hear individual students or small groups of students read and as a result I know less about what further support and instruction they need from [Music] me thank you Miss Payne um next we have Miss Alexander Looney hi my name is Alex lenning um I am not a teacher I am a mom of two saisd kids though and this curriculum is really important to me I spent every moment of the past two days reading through what my kindergarten son will see next year and my daughter that will be in third grade at bonom next year I was really moved by your words last week in support of upcoming bond election agree that our community needs to prioritize the safety and education of

057children not just my own but every child in this city to ensure the success and future of St Angelo I also understand we need a new curriculum and something's got to change and Texas blue bonnet has been presented as high quality um and it's got a great financial incentive that comes with it but I'm really concerned that Texas blue bonnet is not the path towards a well-rounded education for the children in St Angelo and their brighter future so I know supporters say we should teach about religion especially the Bible because it's important to for just a frame of reference for students I believe that the actual text of this curriculum goes far beyond that I went to private religious school and this curriculum is has more religion and Christian centered content with the idea that

058the United States is a Christian Nation protected by God than I ever saw in my private religious education which really really concerns me um I read through next year my kindergarten son will be given an extensive lecture um a lot of just talking at about uh and with follow-up sequencing activities and discussions about the Book of Genesis as just one of the examples um my our oldest elementary students which my daughter will be there in a like a blink of an eye um will get a version of Martin Luther King Jr's letter from a birming Birmingham Jail that sanitizes it so extensively that the true meaning of that letter feels very much Stripped Away um of course then that lesson on letter from a burn me in jail is also followed by a Bible Lesson

059related to what MLK Jr was referencing um I fear that high quality relevant lessons that encourage critical thinking have been sacrificed in order to promote a very narrow characterization of the history and origins of our country um my children have excellent teachers at Administration I know that there is no perfect curriculum that is absolutely the truth however um I know they'll do the best to remain neutral I just I don't think even the best efforts of the staff can make up for the thinly veiled bias within this curriculum we love saisd and San Angelo we enthusiastically support and recommend these Local Schools as to anyone literally that will listen and as local Property Owners we would support the proposed Bond and a heartbeat however if saisd adopts the Texas blue bonnet curriculum it would leave

060San Angelo without a school that offers secular curriculum and that's I think a shame for our community and not something I can personally support thank you thank you Miss Looney uh next we have u m uh Brie Berger hello um I am a local military spouse um and one thing that we don't really get to choose is where we live and St Angelo has a really special um relationship with the base um because we do you know A lot's happened there it's a symbiotic relationship okay that's for another time however I am not from Texas my children are not from Texas um my children are half Jewish um and I think that bringing biblical based um curriculum into the school is what a private school is for is not what a public school is for

061this is um you know the separation of church and state and you know we're not going to end here my kids will not graduate from school here but I know many military families um that don't support this this this area has a lot of options for um spiritually based education and that should remain outside of the public school system thank you thank you Mrs burer uh next we have Mr Jesse Ramone good evening uh ladies and gentlemen of the board um the first time I stood at this Podium I introduced myself um despite being called an outside as a resident of St Angelo for a very long time and I came to St Angelo to attend a private Catholic school that's how I ended up here in St Angelo at the ripe age of 10

062um and just to Echo those sentiments that's that's exactly what private christian-based schools are for that that choice of Education by my family was elected very specifically instead of the public school system um now as a longtime resident of s Angelo I am an adult educator I'm responsible for writing curriculum reviewing it and making revisions and I can't seem to get my hands on this blue bonnet curriculum to review it extensively and I can't imagine you are able to get the complete items as well so to ask to vote on something that you don't have tangibly in front of you to be able to look through um seems very very outrageous um and again as an adult educator um there's there's opportunities for me to expand in conversations that are introduced and elaborate and part

063of my annual performance review by my employer is seeing how well I go off script how well I do um introduce topics and provide my own person personalization and the ability to um help them understand it without just reading from a script and that is exactly what blue bonnet does over and over and over and you're essentially just asking these Educators to turn into self-checkouts that just kind of feed out a receipt and it's just not productive it's not comprehensive and to ask our Educators to introduce a topic but give them a point that they have to stop that they cannot expand on and expect them to go home and finish that conversation with their parents or their church that's exactly why those conversations and topics just need to stay at home and in their

064Church um it's the other uh the other thing that was mentioned was transparency and again this school district has longstanding prided itself on its transparency and I just again find it extremely ironic that you would be voting on materials that lack transparency and the items that have been transparent have included a number of revisions and they still continue to be problematic thank you thank you Mr Mr Ron all right that concludes our public comments section we're going to move forward with our agenda into our information items um which will be a facility update by Dr Brandon first good evening again just wanted to Circle back after after last month's discussion uh we've gone over the Park Hill facilities assessment and some detail uh well in-depth detail for all facilities and then the question uh of

065our support facilities um was also an offspring of that conversation uh as we look around the district and so this uh rather than hundreds of pages of a report uh this this chart uh gives you the major systems uh of any of our buildings and then whether that needs repair place replace now uh five years out uh within five years and then replace Beyond 5 years and so you see a lot of items that are repair or replace now um for multiple campuses uh facilities across the district um you see not only um elementary school campuses uh and campuses that were in District um and then those that are support facilities uh Transportation which we've talked about that the city actually owns that facility uh it's a shared uh Arrangement and then we have other

066campuses uh listed and then most of that being rep hair replace now is due to the age uh of the structure and as you look across uh Black Shear day and Rio Vista Sam Houston uh those elementaries all being built in similar time periods and 71 years old 7275 um you know we have buildings over a 100 years old uh there's just some things that are hard to remediate over that period of time major electrical systems major Foundation Systems uh the plumbing that was put in place 75 and 80 years ago so as we and honestly the only way to make those Replacements is a bond uh the state we've had several Finance discussions the state does not send school districts money to build buildings they only send the money to educate the students in

067the classroom provide for buses provide for meals uh and then you work through uh the rest of it to provide curriculum and uh other items uh but as far as building a structure uh that's just like we've talked about with a home morgage right you're going to add a major renovation to your home you're going to put in a pool Norm normally you just don't open up the checkbook sometimes that's would be great uh but we talk about a bond uh for that so as we talk about these facilities uh at the moment and the time that we're in it's what other facilities do we have in the district that we could be uh could be made available um that aren't 75 and 80 years old so we've kind of started that process uh there's

068other uh buildings in the District that may only be 30 or 40 years old which still may seem like a lot but even half of the half of that time you can imagine the improvements that were made over a 40-year period both in Electrical Plumbing foundation so that's the process that we're in right now is looking at all of the other buildings and there are there ways to move children from 80 90 100 year old buildings into those other buildings uh that may only be 40 years old and and require uh less uh remodel or upgrade uh to Major systems in the building um so we've started the process of assessing each one of those and then asking different directors of programs whether that be special education bilingual Child Nutrition Maintenance and Facilities uh walking

069each of those facilities and asking the questions what works for your program what do you not have or what's limitating to your program at the moment that we might be able to improve upon in some sort of move within the district so those conversations are being had with each one of them and then through those conversations um we also need to be cognizant of taxpayer money and what the thing the decisions that we're making that are savings uh to the district District uh to our families and then you see some of the financial efficiencies that arise from being able to move from 80 100y old structure uh to some of our what you would call newer buildings in the district uh reduce Staffing uh anytime that if you think about if you had two separate

070campuses two uh school resource officers to secretaries to cafeteria managers to custodians three four grounds workers if you're able to move into one that is a newer facility there's also efficiencies within electricity gas water the things that were done over time to improve those types of efficiencies um and then reduce facility and maintenance and then eventually uh if there if one of the oldest structures in the building uh is um vacated or or raised uh then the savings that comes uh from not paying out additional um Property and Casualty Insurance um we have some vacated uh properties that once uh the insurance company would tell you once that it's not used for its original purpose they'll no longer cover it within the insurance uh good example of that is the old Lincoln gym on the

071north side of town uh I mean it's just a very old structure that the plumbing infrastructure Foundation issues HVAC flooring so we've used that for the several years now as a warehouse type facility uh with uh Furniture items uh and so the insurance company informed us we're not going to cover it right as a gymnasium in your District because that's not the purpose that's being used for so trying to be efficient uh within the district and letting the board know exactly those conversations that we're having through all programs to try to Define what are the best facilities in the district for our students and staff to be in any questions any questions for Dr Brandon what we'd like to do is ultimately those conversations will leave to a recommendation in either March or April if

072we're able to do any other consolidation or consolidating uh programs into a facility thank you all right next we have Dr Gomez and she's going to give us a stem and Robotics academic update Dr Kingman Dr Moran and members of the board earlier we had our robotics recognition at this time we will have our academic update for both stem and Robotics I would like to recognize some key Educators that bring this to life every day in our school districts they don't always like it when I do this but um this recognition is very deserved so in the overall recognition I announc them by name now I'm going to ask them to come to the podium so miss F Mr lagon as our digital Innovation facilitators if you would please come up Mrs Barton I will

073not have you come up but I will just ask that you wave from the back so um this evening they have captured the overview of stem and Robotics in St Angelo ISD as you all know and can proudly see in this boardroom the mission of St angel ISD is there in front of you so as Educators we plan a design from what we call a backwards design we always start from the high school level and work down how do we produce these Future Ready graduates so stem and Robotics can't just start in high school we have to start exposing our students at a very early age and that's the great work that the educator mentions the Educators have mentioned plus the coaches that you saw this even and many more that weren't able to be

074here that they do on a daily basis in St Angelo ISD so at this time I'm going to call it over call the two of you I I don't know who's going first just and I'm gonna be real quick because I just want to just kind of elaborate a little bit of what Dr Gomez said um especially when we start in the elementary school when it comes to stem it's very easy to look in the window of the classroom and it looked like the kids are just playing you know they've got little toys out there and they're piecing the things together but if you take a step inside the building and you actually watch and you listen to the conversations that the students are having and the way that they're having to think critically through

075whatever challenge is being handed to them problem solve work together to create something to innovate something is a truly magical thing and having my own children in this District that are experiencing that um it's truly something that's amazing and to then visit with students in middle school that were in elementary school participating in the things that we were doing and saying wow look what I'm doing now it used to be I was just putting these Legos together and now I'm programming them to move around and throw a ball and then the next thing I know I might be inventing something we don't even know about yet so it's amazing to be a part of that and thank you Bor for supporting that and everything that we do because it's not just playing so with that

076said want to just take you on a little journey of what it looks like starting from the elementary and the journey that it goes stem and saisd is awesome and I look like we're just playing around but we're actually learning skills that will help us now and in the future in elementary school we dive into teamwork and collaboration explore cyber security and and use the engineering design process to create and build we test our ideas make changes and improve our designs just like real Engineers I think what I is probably pick up [Music] more we need to make any modifications I need I need to take these three off cuz I think it's getting heavy when I did this fall we've all been introduced to computational thinking and we really get to put it into

077practice during coding challenges build projects and especially with robotics so this is the brain and in here is the battery and this is like some of your programs and steps and everything these are all the codes so like to drive forward and then reverse tonomous Drive which is where our robot drives by itself we're also thinking of putting our distance sensor in the front instead of the optical sensor brain our main part that we put all of our codes and stuff it has a sensor on it but our distance sensor is only facing backwards so we need to put our distance sensor in the front so it knows what's in front of it so it knows it can drive in front and now that I know what I know I'm ready for stemon Middle School

078first thing they kept breaking down was this little thing right here just so we put a little we put a little washer a little washer at the end of it so would so kep falling out um our team we got third place on our last competition uh I also joined robotics last year as in like Elementary and I was like interested it cap captivated by its design program and overall it's just like a cool thing to learn about perseverance is definitely one of those things because we used to do or we had to do autonomous challenges in sad here and enough perseverance actually make it through so I think that's really a good skill cyber security is more than just coding it's about protecting information in solving real world problems they're learning how to think

079like it Professionals in Cy Patriots the entire goal is to uh secure networks cyber Patriots helped me learn how to like like actually stay on task and stay focused for long periods of time cuz I personally want to go into military and the Air Force has a really good cyber security program High School courses like computer science and engineering that would help a lot with those on to high school the CTE pathway is perfect for future Engineers like me um the only requirement the major requirement is that it has to be a circle on the inside it has to be a certain ultimately it's just problem solving um of course a little bit of math comes some around here you need to have a good understanding of math knowing how to do stuff by yourself

080and being independent a lot of us we have too many options and what we want to do when we get older it's a little bit hard to choose with all these classes that they've given us and all these opportunities it just opens a lot of doors for you know different opportunities that can benefit us uh throughout life I am set for S and sisd is setting me up for Success the skills I'm learning today will help me in the future let's get Future [Music] Ready oh thank you thank you um so that's just a just a little picture of what it looks like and just the progression of where it can grow and really where our future is and you know we've talked a lot about what our students need and what we need for

081them to be future ready and we've got to get them prepared for jobs that don't even exist yet and we've got to be ready we've got to make sure that our students have what they need to be successful and so I thank you guys for that support once again um as the kids move on from middle school and into high school we want to continue those uh those opportunities especially in the CTE program um my partner here would you like to add anything to that she said she said she is all good I'm so shy talking in a microphone so normally you know um but it's truly been a teamwork effort and we've all been really working well together with the classroom teachers stem teachers and everybody just really seeing the bigger picture of where

082things can grow so we just wanted to keep going and keep being freeer ready and let's get some really cool kids out here inventing and creating some really cool things to take care of us in the future amen man amen thank you are there any questions board team we have questions if I could just make a comment um I got to go to the robotics competition and um I just wanted to thank uh the coaches and the staff um and the parents for coming and spending the day on that entire Saturday it was a great day and to spend the time watching the kids um try to figure out problem solve and um to see the excitement and the disappointment but then like they come back and they're like oh wait I know how to

083fix this it was so exciting it was my first robotics competition that I'd been to I'd always wanted to go and was excited to have the opportunity but thank you for bringing that making that happen in St Angelo and I look forward to seeing it grow thank you thank you very much any other I just GNA say thank you Brandon um every time I see a video of the kids with their doing the robotics or with stem and all that you know their their creativity there it's on I'm loud enough aren't I can you hear we can hear you about that she's a teacher she was a teacher anyway um you know watching what they do and the creativity that they come I mean they just you know I have to talk about this with

084a lot of people they'll go well what about our kid what about our kids today said our kids are very very creative they are very creative and and far thinking you know I I've had people tell me they're always on these they're always on that and they're always on that but I mean this things got more data in it than what took a ship to the Moon and what did that creativity creativity things these kids are doing today you know every time I see the the robotics kids they got the little soccer ball thing it's got the little designs on it y'all seen those right well you know I was reading one day that uh when they built the first atomic bomb they couldn't figure out how to implode it to make it explode and

085I think a guy by name Alvarez and Johnston they developed the detonation system that they got the idea from a soccer ball you know and it's just that kind of thinking that creativity to solve a problem so that's just stuff like that and I know these kids are going to go far I mean I have a lot of faith in our kids I really do I'm not worried you know I even tell my kids I'm not worried y'all are going to do fine so but thank you thank you and thank y'all for everything y'all do and I was talking to those welders from CTE last week boy them kids can weld they really really can I was really impressed with them so well that was why we wanted to make it a point to not

086just show them doing the things you know it's really easy to just see a little video of them playing and things but actually to hear them Express what they're doing explain their processes talk about all that that's the Magic in that is that they're really able to explain their process think through their problem and use a lot of big words that I know when uh Mr Skinner was talking up there y'all didn't know what he was talking about when he was talking about that color sensor and stuff but we nod and we say yeah that sounds good right you know but they know and they're able to articulate that and that's huge to be able to do that and so every kid that was speaking on that video there was not a script that was

087handed to them that was just a conversation and that's what came out of that so I think that like you said Gerard I'm not worried either the these guys got it so thank you so much you don't get to leave yet sorry um also thank you and we've come a long way in robotics over the last and stem over the last several years just as far as an update how many of our campuses are how many have a robotics team now how many have a teacher for all those things and what are we doing for the programs that don't have it yet we are currently all of our Elementary staff uh campuses all have a stem teacher um where the students are all going regularly to see their uh see their teachers um we have

088I'm going to say seven correct me if I'm wrong six or seven of our elementary school campuses that are participating in the robotics competitions right now however all have all of the materials and have all of the things that are doing robotics within their classrooms some are not quite ready to compete but are working towards getting there um but we all have all the things and so we're just kind of working and building up the confidence within our teams and getting them ready there's a lot of there's a lot of bells and uh a lot of logistical things that come into getting ready for a competition and as we're getting our feet wet and as we're getting ready to go um and Miss Barton has been a really integral piece and getting that part together

089and helping and supporting all of our campuses to make sure that they have what they need to start um and then we come in and help them get it going and get moving with that so we are getting there to get all of our campuses ready to go but right now we have about seven that are actually competing and but they all are experiencing and building with the Vex robotics within their stem Labs one more one more one more question um we just have it for the elementary and the Middle School correct um no actually the robotics does it extend in like the robotics it keeps going keep going to high school where the kids can compete in robotics yes we have some high schools that are competing um and I believe Stanley is one

090of their coaches right over there okay great and great okay I do both do the IQ so that I go down and I help element they come to me me it's important for my kids to see okay okay thank you good Mr Walker was the high school educator pre in the video yeah all right any other board questions or comments all right now youall get to go all right thank y'all [Applause] verybody um next we have item seven which is consent items a through F so that's donations are minutes from our January 13th 2025 pre- agenda are minutes from our January 21st 2025 regular board meeting it's bid number 20-9 U maintenance transportation and miscellaneous supplies that was an ad uh RFQ 25.01.2013 which is playgrounds and shade structures and 23-18 new vehicles um those

091were all discussed at our pre- agenda meeting do I have a motion to approve items a through F I'll make a motion to approve consent items a through F and do I have a second he second so I have a motion from Mr gagos and a second from Mrs zyo any further board comments or questions all in favor say I I all against say the same motion passes 60 all right so now we have Financial uh action items action item a is our bills accounts and financial statements for December 2024 and January 2025 um as a reminder these were all discussed at our uh pre- agenda workshop and um our all our financial statements are available on our website at uh sd.org um does anyone have any comments or questions regarding our bills accounts and

092financial statements from December and January do I have a motion I'll make a motion to approve the Bill's accounts and financial statements for December 2024 and January 2025 I'll second so I have a motion from Dr Mills and a second from Mrs misel Flint um any other board comments or questions all in favor say I all against say the same motion passes 60 next we have a proposed amendment for District official budget General funds as of February 18th are hope here she's not is she we know we talked about this last week I don't want to give anyone not the credit ability to walk up to the mic if they don't want to um so this is a proposed amendment accounting for the um passage of proposition a back in November and it's increase in

093revenue and expenditures in the amount of 4 m842 290 um to our general fund budget any questions regarding that budget amendment any do I have a motion to approve that budget amendment try I am too it's on page 89 I can make a motion uh I'll make a motion that we approve the general fund budget amendment for February 18th 25 with uh which results in no mon with changes to function codes which results in no monetary differences and an increase in revenue and expenditures in the amount of $ 4,842 290 do I have a second second so a motion for myself and a second from Mr gagos any further board comments or questions all right all in favor say I I all against say the same motion passes six zero next we have item C

094which is consider House Bill 16005 and instructional materials Dr Gomez Dr kayman Dr Maran and members of the board we've been having discussions for an extended period of time now um as Educators we've been deeply involved in this process for over 6 months as the state has modified um it's and created a new process around instructional materials referred to as the instructional materials review and approval or emra process through house bill 16005 came many changes that we've previously shared this evening we will highlight those um but I do want to remind everyone we've had extensive conversations the emra process has created new criteria from the State Board of Education uh for approval criteria under this process includes teaks coverage so again in education we have a lot of acronyms at times it's its own language

095the teak are the actual curriculum they stand for the Texas Essential Knowledge in skills and any educator in the state of Texas that serves in a public school setting under the authority of the Texas Education Agency is required to teach the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills criteria also includes quality suitability for the grade and content area free from factual error this is according to their criteria no harmful content or other statutory compliance and the new addition of the parent portal compliance throughout our conversations we have discussed and we will recap this evening Financial impacts for schools you have heard and will continue to hear of additional additional funding on top of the state's regular instructional materials and Technology allotment provided to school districts that choose to use what is referred to as a state board

096of education approved material that additional funding is what you've heard to be the $40 per students fa m g now I guess for the audience sboe the State Board of Education yes and the tea are they the same entity no they're not the same the State Board of Education and the Texas Education Agency are not the same but the State Board of Education sets policies that the Texas Education Agency has to work under and public schools and public charter schools have to work under the parameters set forth by the agency okay thank you uhuh you will also and have heard and will continue to hear of an additional entitlement of up to $2 for districts printing the state-owned materials that's important because there's still some confusion about what is state-owned versus what is not state-owned

097as we've stated the parent transparency is a new key component um not to deflect and talk about me as a person outside my professional setting but I have had both of my children go through S Angelo ISD and many of our Educators serve in dual roles as Educators and parents and the district believes more than anything that parent um involvement and parent um education around what their students are being taught is more important than ever so this bill does require that school districts establish um a form for parents to see the curriculum and materials that are being used in our classrooms now as I've mentioned and we'll continue to highlight the state-owned textbook was the biggest change in this bill and in the revision of the process so this requires t to develop state-owned textbooks

098that are subject to approval from the State Board of Education so Mr gyos to go back to your question remember there's the State Board of Education sboe and the Texas Education Agency correct um the teaks again which mean the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills which are the actual curriculum that all educators are required to teach are to be reviewed and revised so as part of this process it does require a new vocabulary and B book list for those rla reading language arts standards it does create more flexibility and review and Revision in that schedule and this is super important because not everyone understands this it does prohibit the use of three queing in phonics materials and so you've heard us previously talk about the requirement for all primary education ERS to be trained in reading

099and that is the specific instruction that um teaches the science of reading and why we do not use the three queing system and then very important I wish more than anything as an educator of 29 years that the average 10e and experience of our Educators was at that 1920 mark it is not currently in St Angelo ISD this spring we have seven clinical teachers there are less and less teachers coming into the profession of those seven clinical teachers what some might know as student teachers only one of those candidates is seeking Elementary certification so as not only the state of Texas but the nation is going through a teacher crisis there is specific protection for Teacher time that states that teachers cannot be required to use their planning time time to create initial instructional materials

100unless there is a supplemental agreement as we've previously discussed and as you were accustomed to under the instructional material technology allotment that is the funding that comes with the state based on a school districts a student enrollment count so the IMT or if you're not accustomed to the te being in there for the technology piece because that funding does allow for devices because we are also required to teach technology skills so that funding is all bundled in one it's not textbooks and Technology separate your funding from the state is all combined and that's all a district gets to buy those resources for the entire grade span of a school district the district received leaves that General funding allotment and then the two new pieces are the additional funding that came forward with House Bill 1605

101is specific to the State Board of Education approved instructional materials so districts have their normal allotment and then the two additional entitlements which you're hearing referred to a $4 and $20 for an extra $60 what's important to not it through this is decisions are not ever made solely on money decisions are made on what's best for each student in the overall enrollment in a district so your state board approved entitlement and your open education resource entitlement is based on your overall enrollment not just limited to the number of students in the grade spans where there is a stateboard approved instructional material so specifically we could use the example if there's a material just on the approved list for K5 the entitlement is based on all students in that District not just your K5 enrollment you

102will also note there that the imta allotment is banial the state board approved instructional materials entitlement is annual and it does carry over so if there are any balances in the funding that were not used it will roll forward on the state developed open education resource entitlement it's annually but any unexpended balances do not carry over so specifically for our district if when we're discussing the state board approved instructional materials entitlement that's approximately an additional $1 million for the school district if a stateboard approved instructional material is adopted for the state developed open education resource that's an approximate $237,000 240 for the district so with both entitlements it's an additional $1.2 million of funding for the school district so how did we get here again um as for over 6 months the district has been

103working examining the evolution of what can be recommended this did not just happen overnight so you have the timeline and as you all are aware the district is currently using amplify and Elementary for reading language arts and Eureka for math in grades 3 through five those resources were available through the state's covid emergency response act all of that curriculum was free for Access digitally so the cost of print the cost of readers the cost of teacher manuals was all at a District's expense with house bill 16005 as the traditional Proclamation process ended and last spring we were able to make recommendations for our final Proclamation you'll see that after this school year is the evolution of blue bonnet learning so blue bonnet learning is the Texas version which is 100% aligned to the Texas Essential

104Knowledge and Skills whereas the amplify Eureka and Texas MTH solution or Carnegie that we are currently using were the national versions that's the different it's difference in the curriculum resources so we have shared this we've had extensive conversations on what the state is allowing school districts to present for adoption the next three slides I know it's very fine print but we've poured over this shows the materials that are considered State Board of Education approved so in order to receive the additional entitlement of a little over a million dollars for St Angelo ISD the district would have to adopt one of these resources just skimming through here you can see publisher names you can see publisher names such as salice Texas Education Agency I want to highlight that because as we talk state-owned textbook you will

105see the Texas Education Agency listed and then specifically you see blue bonnet learning now you will see partial sub objects when you see amplify and notice that's only the phonics component so when we talk about student readers for it to be a highquality instructional materials readers are a component of the program which provides students with less complex to more complex text as they learn to be readers that's teaching skill in materials that are appropriate for the grade level of the students the knowledge component which is not on the state board approved education list that provides experiences through literature is not on here from amplify alone which is what we currently have so the only option there would be the Texas Education Agency version so lastly what's important for the board to consider for local control

106districts have local discretion When selecting instructional materials the State Board of Education reviews the materials that any school district can bring forward for recommendation again in statute and what we firmly believe in St Angelo ISD is Parental involvement parents have a right to review all instructional materials parents have a right to temporarily remove a child from a class as both a former primary teacher and a former reading specialist I spent many years teaching young students how to read also outside of my professional duties through my own church I've taught religious education we do not believe that it is an Educator's responsibility to teach the religion it is an obligation from the State Board of Education and the Texas Education Agency that we teach about religion but there are lines and specific should be discussed in

107the home that is not our place as Educators so as we come forward to make a recommendation to the board I personally don't believe there is a perfect resource I do believe in great teachers from the options we have to offer we do believe Blue Bonnet learning is the best resource we can recommend for number one the standards alignment it is Our obligation to teach the teaks however the craft of teaching is what is most important the voice of good teachers must and should always be most prominent in our classrooms we currently have systems when there are lessons and there are and all of our resources that we have to make local decision so along with the local decisions on what to adopt it's a District's local decision on how they Implement I know this

108has not been an easy conversation we're very grateful for the involvement we welcome conversations and discussions but more than anything it is our responsibility to provide students with high quality instructional materials and the best teachers we can put in our classrooms with seven clinical teachers this spring that's a hardship that not only St Angelo ICD faces but school districts across the state of Texas and the nation as a whole I was you you said um that the State Board of Education approves um the curriculum that we're going to use okay so let me ask you so if we were not to get blue Bond okay and so would we go another Direction and finding a different curriculum and if we did find one locally controlled would it have to be approved by the State Board

109of Education so to receive the additional funding of approximately $1 million it would have to be on one of those three pages of resources presented to you for review okay and if we didn't want those then you would not have um the additional entitlements and you would have to ensure 100% of te's alignment to the resource so I'm going to propose something and obviously everyone can board to everyone can anyone can make a motion or not a second or regardless um I would propose we ask Dr Gomez questions make sure questions are asked and answered and but I would also propose that this is tabled till the full board is present um I know but that is any single board member is able to make a motion um but that would be my proposal just

110because of an even number of board members and what that could set up um I would like all board members to be present however also um I'd like more time to read because there's a lot of stuff that I found out today that I started reading on and yesterday and I was just like I don't got time to read all this right now and this is going to guarantee me another week two weeks to find out what I really need to find out um and I just thank all of you for coming and we got you a read on everything that you had to say about it I mean I I you know like I always say this is this is democracy at work you know you get to come voice your opinions and I'm

111very very thankful that y'all came out and and gave us your opinions and what you thought of so thank you very much but I'd like to did you make a motion well I'll make the motion to table it I mean well let's let everyone ask their questions because I do think it's important we make sure we get questions asked as well well but um then the other thing um I forgot we'll ask questions then we'll go from there I sorry I know what L I apologize okay um I do think though that whatever the board decides although as I'm going to say up front now we're going to make a vote at our pre- agenda meeting which is because we're discussing it tonight we had it on our pre- agenda meeting for last week and

112that gives the admin team the ability to use spring break to use whatever decision the bo makes and go from there so I do think we should post it on the next meeting although it is not a regular agenda meting just to kind of clarify so obviously our options are very limited to begin with frankly um I know you mentioned last week that there is like alternative material for all the educational or all the religious stuff is that is that true would it be and maybe I'm I'm just kind of thinking out the box could you could we adopt as a district and then just as a blanket just do the alternative stuff across the board so to answer your question that would be a no because we are obligated to have standards alignment and

113so while we've been discussing the specific references to Christianity there are other religious uh references and it is currently in the tees and the State Board of Education that we are required to teach about religion so you can't do a blanket and say any piece of literature for historical context is to be omitted we would not be aligned with the standards okay so that would have to come from the individual parent yes there also so as I've mentioned in previous um discussions and through Friday facts the national version was written for approximately 180 days the blue bonnet version is said to be written for approximately 160 days we have 17 school days on our calendar so with just the pacing of the curriculum that doesn't put in any other assessments and Angel D is committed

114to a multiple measures of data so while yes we're required to take the star assessment because it's the state assessment we don't just use that one data measure we as you are very well aware we also give map as example so when we talk about the pacing that's just if you rolled out with no other um special district in instances so we still will not be able to meet every single lesson but in the transparency the parental portal let's say a specific lesson is omitted we have to make that we have to have that notice for appearance and then I guess that goes with the district local control of on what you adopt and how you implement if you make if you have any revisions you have to be transparent in how you made the

115revisions and then individual parents Dr Mills to answer your questions if a parent let's say a parent of a kindergarten student says I don't want my student to have this lesson there's an alternative lesson just as if a second grade parent says I don't want my child exposed to this Jewish historical context we have to honor that as well right so I guess to kind of piggy back on that so let let's say as a district I know we can't get rid of all we can't answer that question but if there was something that was particularly polarizing could we absolutely could that part we've already that already happens that already happens in our classrooms today the difference is the parental portal requirement of the bill so there have already been instances and when we say

116instances it's not multiple lessons it's less than five but there's been Educators that have voiced concerned there is a process you do have to have standards alignment and going back to that teacher voice which is the craft of teaching it can't be teacher a just says Nah I don't like this so I'm not doing it and teacher B says oh I like this so I'm doing it there's a formal process because we have an obligation to ensure consistency and Alignment among all of our campuses and to I guess to to your point um I know there were several teachers that were I guess had some concerns about like having a strict script and is that is that true or they there is a script it is true with those resources that there is a script

117now what's goes back to the craft of teaching if I've been teaching 19 years do I have to stand there and read the script no if I'm this these are real stats from St Angelo ISD on average the district hires between 100 to 125 new to district teachers of those new hires around 6570 on average are new to the profession this year in St Angelo ISD and our new teacher Academy we had 66 teachers and by new to profession we mean a teacher coming in with zero years of experience meaning they could have gone straight through traditional univers or university based schooling where that's what they went to school for they were a clinical teacher traditional pathway it also means some someone that has a degree outside the field of Education that participates in alternative

118certification program it also means teachers that were employed in other school districts that did not require the educator to have a state board of educator certificate s Angelo i d believes in providing the highest quality teachers and it is a requirement for a teacher contract that you have a stateboard approved educator certificate so those a number of approximately 6570 annually our current stats those educators are not coming in with a background to have the craft to know whereas somebody that's been in the profession and has multiple years of experience that's completely different so like you're saying that a teacher that was new or didn't have as much experience they could rely on the script more absolutely but an experience they need to rely on the script an experienced teacher would not be they don't need

119to read and lose the craft of teaching word for word do they need to cover the standards in the lesson absolutely that's your standards alignment can I comment on that U thank you Dr Mills I think that is where our plc's that we've talked about teachers coming together collaborating is so vital because if and you know a script is good I after 30 years probably hopefully would not be reading a script Okay so if I if I'm teaching a lesson and I have a great idea I would hope in our plc's me a first year teacher I'm going to share that with her and I'm going to say this is the script I want you to read it dig into it learn but this is a great way to teach that and that's where our

120um collaboration our plc's all come together the other thing that you noticed was the teacher is not required to make okay that's create new material that is that and I'm I'm okay with that but you know if I have a great idea I'm going to create it whether I'm paid or not because that's the heart of a teacher so um I think I would hope we have an we have amazing teachers out there that do amazing things and we're not necessarily tying their hands a great teachers I'm going to go way back if any of you remember we adopted Saxon many years ago I was teaching sax it was very scripted I read it every night because I was like I'm going to hear what they say and then when I went into the classroom

121I taught the teak because that's that's a non-negotiable you have to teach the te if you teach in Texas but how I taught it and what I used sometimes was not the Saxon way okay um so it's very complex it's very hard to even explain unless you've really been in there but I think with our plc's and our ic's going into classrooms and helping I I don't want people to think that every single day I'm going to read a script because excuse me I I've spent the past four days reading from kindergarten all the way to fifth grade and sometimes when I was reading those social stud study scripts I was like going what but that helped me cuz I'm not a social stud teacher but it helped me understand what I was going to

122teach there might be days that I was like that I may be like you know what I need this today it's a resource I need this today to teach this unit because maybe I'm not really great at it but the next day I may read it and go you know what I've got this I'm going to teach it this phenomenal way that when I was a first year teacher my teacher beside me and I always use this analogy when I interviewed for my first job I said please don't make me teach science well my first job was science because I had that certificate the teacher beside me was Mr horn he had been teaching it for 32 years and he was phenomenal so every morning 21y old Pam would walk into her room and say

123his room and say why is why are clouds important teach me he taught me there are days maybe he wasn't there to help me so I needed something to help me so that's kind of how I look at this whole big picture it's so complex and so weaved it's not just this this or this so I hope maybe that helps everyone understand it's not it's not there's always things that aren't good in anything we do but we have to find what is the best and I love the part that um you know the parent can see it a parent can take it away and say and I had parents do that you know when I was there were word problems maybe in math I would send home they didn't like it so you know what

124I gave them a different word problem when you're a teacher you learn to Pivot you learn flexibility you learn a lot of things and that's what you're a teacher you have that skill to be able to do that and we have people in admin on our campuses our principls that have the skill to help everyone so I don't know if that that was beautiful thank you it's that's more or less the point is I hope that regardless of whether we adopt ultimately adopt blon or not that we don't ever strip away the art of teaching and that we're cracking down on teachers because they can't they don't want to read a script one day or they want to bring something else in but still cover the material I think that is important to keep that

125alive and that's the heart of teaching and I just think that's important so thank you P Dr Mills I would also like to commend misss Duncan on your account of being a teacher as a current serving administrator I wish we had the Mr horns next door that we could offer all of our teachers that had 32 years of experience we have guidelines for mentors and part of the guidelines are to have three years of service we have some campuses and some grade levels where they can't meet that requirement because there is no educator on the team that has the three years minimum service it goes back to the need to equip teachers with resources that provide supports that we're not depending on just the teachers next door I have a a few things I wanted

126to ask about um the first thing is and I know that you're reporting um what the state is telling you but I disagree that it's our job to teach about religion I think um I think that's the parents job I think that's the church's job um I was talking to M senior Joel here before the meeting started and he was asking what's this blue Bonet thing that everybody's talking about and I told him and he said well that's what that's what PE preachers do that's what pastors do and so I um while I completely understand the need for the high quality instructional materials um and I understand you know that we need to go with something that the State Board of Ed approved um I'm really struggling with blo on it and uh like Miss

127best uh I also was reading through some of the readers this past week and uh really struggle with some of the readers um and she read it quickly but even if you read it slowly it it's they're just not strong readers and I I she read the first grade one I think was that first grade um but even the third grade one and the fourth grade one they're they're just they're not something that would make kids want to that it wouldn't instill the love of reading in children and I think that that's the concern that I have with the readers um so I guess my question is or one of my questions is if we used one of the other state board approved instructional materials um on that list would we there there were two

128columns and there was one column where we'd get the million dollars and then if we use boob on it it was an additional 200,000 so if we use one of these would we would we receive a million dollars but not the extra $20 for printing is that what I'm what it saying so that's correct the state board approved instructional materials if uh there's an adoption of a resource on this list that's the addition sboe entitlement which for our district is approximately a million the only option to receive the additional entitlement um for the printing cost Associated is Blue Bonnet learning right okay so but theoretically would we have to print all the materials for these items too um there would be printing associated with any resource on the list okay um okay and and then

129so it would essentially cost us $200,000 to print um if we had a that would that would vary so I could I I cannot give you an exact amount I can tell you currently with the co emergency response versions of the resources we receive zero reimbursement for the printing cost Associated the greatest difference is the prior additional funding that came through the Esser emergency response funds which we no longer have access to I understand that um and then um when um Miss Duncan was saying and you were saying that they don't have to read the script but they have to be able to cover the materials but last week you had said that they still had to pace and make sure that they covered everything in the right time so it would just be especially

130the first couple of years when you're studying I I haven't I haven't taught in a classroom but I would assume that when you're learning a curriculum it's going to take a couple of years to learn how to it right so would have to read the script in the beginning right or um I'm I'm going to agree to disagree on that because to pace and cover the standards does not mean that an educator has to read the script word for word what it does mean is that you can't spend four additional days or longer on a portion or you will not be aligned for the embedded assessments that are a piece of the curriculum got it and then one more question then um so these others that are are approved for the State Board of Ed

131um or by the State Board of Ed um something that um I think Miss Moore said in her comments was that the te or that the star was Rewritten to align with blue bonnet is that correct so if that's the case then we went with another um another curriculum would our children be what our students be at a disadvantage if if it's is it is it being written to align with star and if so would they be at a disadvantage with another curriculum that would be a matter of opinion the Texas Education Agency is the governing Agency for the star assessment so it is the agency most closely connected to the star assessment okay I got you all right thank you very much this one's quick uh I don't understand this stuff as well what

132is the difference between the English language arts in reading and then just English phonics like so that's um it's the commissioner statute that districts must have um a specific phonic component so when we started and we highlighted the statue that prohibits the use of 3 queing and phonics instruction the state has prohibited um phonics materials that teach the 3 queing so the phonics that you see approved does not teach the 3 queing system that's getting real In The Weeds about teaching phonics we wouldn't have to get that and like we if we got the if we adopted blue buun that's included we don't have to have a fonex in addition correct so there's a skills component and a knowledge component in Blue Bonnet learning the approved State Board of Education phonics component is only the

133skills portion so that does not address the tees that are specific to comprehension and uh writing I I guess the the reason I ask is so if we had amplify we wouldn't that wouldn't be just sufficient by itself we'd have to have something else that's correct okay thank you all right sorry I got a couple just to make sure I either reiterate or heard things correctly so we've made a lot about parents being able to uh adopt in or adopt out more appropriately of uh lesson plans Etc we would have the same and we have the same policy in place for teachers like would a teacher if a group of fourth grade teachers at bonum didn't want to teach a certain te this way they've taught a teaks and I apologize to every teacher in

134the room that I'm saying it the way I am but they want um but they want to teach the teaks the way they have taught it traditionally it has been successful for them they have figured out a way to put that in the pacing for them and like say this this book and this lesson we have always loved this and we've been been able to teach te X on this would that group of fourth grade teachers still be able to do that so I wish we could get any group and I say this as a reading language arts person but even more so than mathematicians Mrs Duncan to get an entire group of reading language arts teachers to agree on the perfect piece of literature to teach a skill is one of the hardest things

135to do to answer your question would teachers still have a voice if they had a concern over the resource they would have a voice and they currently have a voice but what's so important is one group can't say no I'm not doing that we want to do it this way at school a and school B is like we're doing it this way that doesn't have standards alignment and consistency across the district so the students at group a their family has to move for specific family reasons and they now go to school B where the teachers wanted to do things a different way now we don't have consistency and alignment across the district that's why there must be an aligned resource but to voice a concern we've had that happen this year we've had that happen

136every year I've been an educator what's important to know is there's a system for that so that we ensure consistency across the district it is no secret and surprise the mobility rate of our students and families in the district and to be just as blunt as we possibly can that's part of our reasoning in some past gaps when students Bounce from school to school and we're not following a consistent pacing I have a couple more questions I apologize um as far as all of the things on the slide the State Board of approved materials including the amplify we're using now versus Amplified Texas edition Blue Bonnet the only high quality instru soci material that is aligned with tees on this whole list specifically aligned to te is Blue Bonnet that's correct the full component when

137when you're talking the difference between the current version of amplify phonics that's still on the list that's only the skills version okay so the Texas Education Agency Blue Bonnet learning according to the State Board of Education that is not my call to make is 100% aligned to the te yeah I mean I think it's important to remember that there's some there are a lot of components in this that are local control um and there are and there is local control but there is some of this that is coming from house bills that are exist where you're' been given option A or option b and you may not like either option but you have to pick one of them and so okay um that that is my questions for tonight um any other board questions or

138comments of course I have two um I want to go back to Kyle when he was talking about the pacing you know um the pacing many many years ago when we didn't have this we called it um what do we call that back there was some word we use so you start at the end of the year where you have to be and we would sketch out the whole year because you have to teach all your teach so we would go you know in May how are we going to get them all done and that's what Farah was referring to because me for instance I love me some order of operation but I can't do it for two weeks so I had to like cut me off because I couldn't do that anymore so they

139they kind of I think these curriculums kind help you do that so you don't have to and then Dr Kingman was um referring to the teacher and I agree you know belir can't be doing this and this and this but here it goes back to that teacher and and I'm sorry if I'm using examples for myself but back when um we were really teaching factoring um a teacher many years ago had showed me a a process called upside down division I love it and my kids loved it so I got you know I called all the other seventh grade teachers at at the time Lincoln and Lone Star Lee and I and I showed them and they all agreed let's teach it that way because my kids understood it I had proof that it had

140been successful on star that teak was high and that's again I can't stress where that collaboration comes in so as long I mean if I a brand new teacher and a teacher shows me this and she's got facts that it works I think I'm going to probably do it all right sorry I'm gonna do one more thing so I mean I think the other issue we have is that if you if you look at item D on our agenda tonight is that what we're doing isn't working when we have 13% of kids coming into kindergarten on pre on grade level for what a kindergarten is supposed to know and so I guess my question Dr Gomez is do you feel like this is the best opportunity we have of the options given to us to

141to fix what's not working right now this would be the most aligned resource we've ever had to recommend for adoption I I'll reiterate and I'll say this with anyone that I have a conversation with I don't believe in a perfect resource from the list we have to present I do believe this is the best resource all right I'm going to make a motion unless there's any other board questions or comments that we table um considering House Bill 16005 and instruction materials to be voted upon at our pre agenda meeting just so everyone in the audience and watching knows that is at March 10th at 5:45 it is listed as a finance pre- agenda meeting but that there will be an action item regarding U Blue Bonnet or house bill 16005 and instructional materials on that

142agenda item um do I have a second I'll second I have a race for second from Mr G go to Mrs Duncan ladies first Mrs Duncan gets the second um all in favor say I I all against say the same okay so we'll table that next Dr Gomez you can help us with consider our 2425 district and campus performance objectives yes sir so miss Taunton is out this evening so I'll be speaking on her behalf earlier in the fall of this year the board you all approved new superintendent board goals anytime there's approval process of new board board goals then uh the district Improvement plan and the campus Improvement plans are written to reflect those board goals so as part of that process in St Angelo ISD we have our community- based advisory Council so

143after the board approved those goals they were presented to the community- based accountability uh Team advisory team which makes up a little over a 100 stakeholders and so you have the board goals and then you write performance objectives those were presented to The Advisory Council in the fall and now they're being brought forward to the district to formally approve the performance objectives because we are required to have the district Improvement plan and the campus Improvement plan uh plans for each individual campus reflect those goals and performance objectives so it's just taking it through the entire process of development review and lastly approval you do have all of those as they are uh being written for the first time you will note that the alignment between the district and the campus is the same at this

144time as the campuses are working to create their individual strategies and activities that meet those board approved goals this is just a question for you Dr Gomez so Our intention as a board when we went when we started creating board goals was to give um touch points that were being measured annually because traditionally our board goals were more like a four-year correct thing um just as a logistics if we are change because we're going to get into board goals again this summer um if we're changing our board goals every year or maybe not all of them but some of them do we need to I guess this is more a semantic question do I need to do we as a board need to be labeling them something different so they're not or do we need

145them to I guess what I'm trying to say are we creating more work for people that is not actually impacting students and are we by trying when we were trying to actually help improve students does that Dr want to answer but I'm happy to add on just a thought for the board to consider as we develop our goals and we begin the year uh the formalization of the process rolls into the the uh dip and sip we call it the district Improvement plan and campus Improvement plans which are living documents that can be changed I don't think there's any harm in us uh feeling good about annually amending our goals and updating them and rolling them B out to the district so that they can fold those blow into the plans for the campus I

146don't think that should affect us at all I just don't want to be making problems at the campus level where we okay fantastic um anyone have any questions regarding the the approval of the district Improvement and campus Improvement plans to include our superintendent plan uh goals from this past year have a motion make a motion to approve Administration Improvement and cus Improvement so motion from Mr gyos so have a second I'll second second from Mrs misel Flint any other board questions or comments all in favor say I all again say the same motion passes 60 announcements we have our finance and pre agenda workshop on March 10th at 5:45 we have a regular board meeting on March 24th at 5:45 and with that we are adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.