CorpusRecord 10411

San Angelo ISD School Board Meeting - January 21, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / San Angelo ISD
Date
2025-01-22
Location
Tom Green County, TX
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,363 words · about 108 min
Collected
2026-06-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening and welcome H my name is Taylor Kingman and as president of the Board of Trustees of the S Angelo Independent School District I would like to welcome all of you who are present at tonight's regular board meeting I also welcome those of you who are watching the recording of this meeting online or on our Public Access Channel we appreciate your interest in the activities of our students and The Business of sasd all items that will be discussed at our meeting this evening have been posted as required by state law also as you may be aware our board meets a minimum of two times per month and most if not all of the items on the our agenda this evening have previously been discussed at the earlier pre agenda board Workshop as members of

002the saisd Board of Trustees we are here to set goals listen to reports from our superintendent approve budgets contracts and Personnel appointments and to make policy for the district please keep in mind that our mean is a mean of the Board of Trustees held in public and not a mean of the public however we have a public comment item on every one of our media agendas that allows anyone present who wishes to speak to our board team on an item not on our action agenda or an action item on the agenda an opportunity to do so please provide your name and contact information and the specific topic you wish to address on a public comment form located at the back of the room should you want to speak on issue this evening please listen carefully

003and comply with the following rules so we can move through this part of the meeting efficiently each speaker will be given a total of three minutes the district will provide an official timekeeper you will be notified when your time is up you to stop speaking and return to your seat please respect the privacy of others and refrain from identifying students employees or other community members by name disruption of the meeting will not be tolerated at any time and comments on any subject whether positive or negative must be courteous and respectful comments are limited to the specific topic you indicated on the form you filled out and any speaker with a complaint about District employee decision or operational issue should present that through the appropriate me mechanism which is the district's formal grievance process if you

004have a pending grievance being processed please please be reminded that you are not permitted to speak about the grievance during public comment also please understand if you speak to us on an item not on our action agenda that the board cannot reply to you except to thank you for your comments since the matter has not been posted for discussion in compliance with state law these proceedings are recorded and will become part of SD's permanent legal record in order that the recording will adequately reflect the proceedings I ask you please refrain from talking while others are speaking I also ask as I remind my fellow board members and myself to turn off your or silence your cell phones again thank you for being here and for the support of SAS D we do have a quorum

005this evening um Mrs misel Flint is on her way um but we can go ahead and start because we do have a quum six of us here I'm going to call up uh Harold Watkins he's pastor at Freedom Fellowship Church for the invocation thank you for being here e every student who is a part of the S Angelo Independent School District Lord that they would not get weary in the well-doing especially the teachers Lord that they would never get tired they would never stop being inspired to teach our children to grow up and to become mature adults to uh be a great part of this Society father I thank you for the wisdom that you impart to those on this board that are here that are not here Lord that you would give them uh

006the desires of their heart to see this school district Excel as I was reading their goals and the vision uh of the school district Lord it is about the student it is about bringing them out from from where they're at Lord to where you want them to be in their life to succeed and Lord I Thank you that that is the desire of the every person on this board every teacher in this school and every employee so father today we give you thanks and glory for who you are I thank you that we live in a country where we can still lift up the name of Jesus and exalt this the name above every name so bless this time bless this meeting that it would be orderly Lord that much would be accomplished and Lord

007that uh as we leave from this place that we can say it was good to be in your presence and it's in Jesus name I pray amen all right we now have some fifth graders from botom elementary they're Pros they've been doing this since prek they told me so they're going to get we're GNA be doing this well today um Sam Willcox Zoe Suther Kaden Miller and Harper Brandon if you all come up and help us do this unes God [Applause] all right we um now have some recognitions and so uh soon child is going to lead us first in a recognition for the SEL schools Foundation good evening Dr Kingman Dr Moran and members of the board tonight we recognize the S Angelo schools foundation for their continued support in joining sisd and uplifting

008our students and our staff these dedicated Foundation members some of which we have here with us tonight collaborate with our district and Educators to help our students reach their individual hopes and dreams by supporting and inspiring our Educators to create and pursue Innovation and excellence in the classroom since May of 2002 alone the S Angela schools Foundation has awarded more than $115,000 in scholarships funded primarily through payroll deductions of the S Angela IST staff to graduating seniors this year the schools Foundation awarded more than $94,000 in Grants to 75 differen makers and all campus grants supporting Innovative learning across 19 campuses we cannot wait to see the Innovative projects our Educators and teams put the grant funds toward to help our students collaborate create think critically and communicate we are so appreciative of the SEL

009schools foundation for their decades I think it's more than 35 years now of commitment to our students and our staff and our support in the support of our mission and of our educators at this time Dr Moran and board members please join me in recognizing our SEL schools Foundation after I call out each of the board members names uh and the board members who are here when I call out your name if you'll please come forward and afterwards we'll have a group picture president Mike Ford executive director Norine Carpenter Brian abery Jenna Barnes Carol Mar Jennifer Boyd Bridget Carr Amy Crispen Amy Dugen Marissa gek Crispen Graves Lauren Harper Ashley Hony Dion kouan Tara langerhans Rene or gianne Owens Cecil fluger Corey Stewart Terry thinon and Robin trainer thank you all so much [Applause] all

010right um let's wait on the next let's go to public comment I guess not do the recognition till Amy gets here okay um all right so we're going go public comments and some Miss best you'll come up regarding the taper report thank you um I'm nervous and I have three minutes so I'll be quick and please know that anything that I'm speaking with with regard to the taper report that will include the star scores um is not meant as a criticism but a starting point perhaps to be able to lift saisd out of the ditch we appear to be in with regard to at meets grade level or above scores now I know sa saisd in all scores in Texas will get a pass for getting to the point of being at approaching grade level

011or above this is a very long report and it was revised this week so reading through it twice is tough but you can see it doesn't move very much between the two reports and what we get at approaches grade level or above if you follow those numbers from third grade to the end of eth grade those kids don't catch up right so we end up in high school with those kids also having difficulty so when we look at the numbers under that report starting on page N9 of 33 working it's on uh way down for a couple of pages you can see that third grade to eighth grade it's very difficult to find kids who are at grade level at the end of their school year who are moving on above 40% and that's a

012that's I understand a difficulty but we're we're going to be talking about bonds to build new buildings and we're going to be talking about new curriculums that are going to come in and and help and really we have to have a plan on how it's going to help I don't know what lifts us up but we're an extraordinary Community we have extraordinary access to Resources with Angelo State and the city and county um all of us know people there who are we're just a tremendous community and I think we have the opportunity to do better lifting out of the star report I'm going towards the back of it now and forgive me cuz I you know I get to high school and I look at eighth grade and Ninth Grade passage rates on just um

013end of course Algebra 1 at meets grade level or above only 19% of our kids are at grade level in Algebra 1 so you get to high school and you start taking your act and your SAT scores and you've got difficulties so we get into that and we get the scores from tea that talk about the 87.4% of seniors in the class of 2023 who took the ACT I leave out the SAT for time nine only 99.1% of our kids were at a 24hour above and if you're putting a kid into college like I am you know scholarship money and acceptance is 24 is in the dump right so effectively what that means is restated 91% of our students could not get 70% of the ACT English questions correct 56.6 of math or 65% of

014the reading questions correct those are seniors taking this test when we go on and we move on from that we look at us news enrolled reports and AP talking about AP courses at Lake View this year only seven AP courses are authorized according to AP now and college board that may be wrong and please correct me if it is but it's the only source of information I have of that only 16% of kids at Lake View are participating and of those seniors who have taken at least one AP exam in their four years only 1% has passed it 1% we have to do better I didn't even get to Central thank you thank you Miss best thank you all right next up we have Viro petti regarding the Sano closure and the bond so you're

015going to vote on closing San sento today because of safety and age but you know what our third oldest Elementary is Santa Rita and apparently it's just fine so it's approaching 100 years old no problems there I wonder why but sento Reagan mysteriously safety issues you've known since 2002 that Foundation needed to be fixed according to your budgets you didn't fix it because I've dug through everywhere you did that so when you're voting to close it down you did that and every January 21st I'm going to remind everybody in this community you did that you might close it down but we're not going to forget the bond you want $400 million and I notice Parker Hills here they're all dressed up and ready to go cuz they're going to get 10% of it I don't

016want to give these guys $40 million we don't have a lot of money in this community so we're going to give them $40 million right off the top and then they're going to give us another Fannon $465 a square foot and it's running 6 months behind and they're already having issues with it meanwhile right up the street they built a Chick-fil-A in 3 months so you built eight classrooms and a bathroom no kitchen none of the high dollar stuff $465 a square foot and when you ask them about it oh that's commissary with normal things I don't trust them and I don't want to give them $40 million we can't trust you with $400 million you have the same team in place that couldn't get fan in a migil done and now you want to

017give them $400 million they couldn't even handle $20 million you need to have an engineer on staff you need to have a project manager on staff you need to have someone that actually knows something about construction on staff before you go begging the community to give you $400 million the tax assessor here told me that the whole Community Tong Green county is assessed at $7 billion and you want to give you half a billon do to build a couple of schools y'all are so far out of out of range y'all sit up here on your high horse and you sit there with your gavel and you think you're you know better than everybody $465 a square foot we could have built a house in Bentwood for every one of those classrooms you know what kids

018instead of this th000 square foot classroom that cost $465 a sare foot we got you a house in Bentwood cuz it was cheaper and now you want to give these guys $40 million no thank you no thank you and remember when you vote tonight to close that school you did that thank you Mr petti all right next up is Brent Woodworth topic is sanderso my name is Bryant Woodworth and I am the father of a student at our community Elementary Sano I am here once again fighting desperately for my daughter and my neighborhood I shouldn't have to my neighborhood turned out in Mass two years ago when Administration and this board pulled this stunt before at that time we had neighborhood meetings and numerous board meets to make the decision your strategy has greatly changed

019this time as this decision is making is being made with barely a whisper you obviously know that this decision stands in Star contrast with the wishes of the city and most importantly the sanano community superintendent Moran last week spoke of our school as an old sight seating attraction and only a montary number it is nothing of that sanino is the pride and pillar of our neighborhood and children it is not a numbered value but rather a monument that has stood the test of time for 118 years two years ago at the at these at these those meetings Administration said that San had selling issues that needed to be addressed in two years what has anything if anything has been done to rectify a known problem I spoke with Moran personally and he cannot answer that

020he even admitted that the earthquake was most likely not the primary cause of the structural issues so I ask you again what was done or was this the plan all along pretend like pretend like you represent our city but instead you buy your time time waiting for a scapegoat to get you out with what you really wanted all along since San Cento has been combined with Reagan has been an absolute nightmare I lose hours every week of quality time with my daughter and she has to be bust to a neighborhood that is not in our own we have lost so much of our contact with our teachers as they're not there when we pick her up and this is not alone my sentiment a quick search of social media would we'll find many many other

021parents not only in sento but also phanom expressing these same concerns your job as board members is not to represent the administration and simply relay that to the public your job is to represent your voters and ensure Administration knows what we want you unfortunately have lost the Public's trust representing Administration this is why we are pulling our children out in favor of charter schools and will continue to deny bonds two years ago our neighborhood board could not be bothered our neighborhood board member could not be bothered to attend our neighborhood meetings she refused to voice our neighbor neighborhood's concerns on the on the closure and when many of us tried to contact her we were instead put in contact with a silver tonged ambulance chasing lawyer we were not represented but we still fought if

022you want this City's trust you have to start listening to us against administration's wishes I heard that that woman from admin speak here a few months ago telling you that it is in the school's best interest to do whatever they say to do that made me absolutely sick to my stomach and if they didn't it yours it's your responsibility to ask yourself if you actually represent the voters and if you actually deserve to sit here tonight one more page no that's I'm here to speak you're here to listen to me I am still speaking to Georgetown Texas a city that same size that we will that be happy for you to email me all of your comments so you can get to me I'm sorry thank you if uh next up is Mrs cardinas hi

023guys I I I know most of you um remember me from two years ago along with a lot of the parents that are sitting here thanks everybody for showing up last minute I found out that this would be on the agenda two hours ago and I thought right away oh my God I have to prepare something I'm not ready but I am ready because I live there I live this I know how it's going to I know how it's already affected me and all the parents who messag me Carlo what are we going to do what's going to happen I I don't know all I can do is is speak to you all and I'm glad I'm glad that my mother's here in the audience today and she taught me one very important thing that

024I'm not noticing from our leader there is when somebody's speaking to you or you're speaking to someone you look at them in the eye let respect this is very near and dear to all of us Dr Moran I was lucky to be a part of The facil facilitators Advisory board that presented that the bond um topics to you all that was awesome I was proud to be a part of that you told me in confident I don't know if it was in confidence or not but I've never heard you say publicly what you told me you said I wanted to build a new elementary school but the board doesn't want to how come you haven't said that to the community out loud now sano's old yes but why don't we deserve something new why can't

025we get something new for Reagan and sanjino we're not asking for a name change change the colors of our school change the name this and that why can't we have something for our kids it's very important for our community to have a neighborhood school now the only thing I keep uh seeing is dollar signs we're going to save $700,000 if we combine schools and then what's going to happen next we don't know is Dr Moran going to be here I don't know I hope so but you know they come and go it is what it is but you guys stay here you you guys y'all's roots are here now I'm very lucky and blessed to be in the profession now that I always wanted to be I'm I'm a coach now and I know that

026the best coaches I've had many coaches the best coaches are the ones with experience you can open a textbook all day long be a good test taker pass get your degree the best coaches are the ones with experience I live the experience of what it has caused to to combine the schools together guys guys and I'm very blessed I you cannot imagine the other parents what they go through that are not in the same spot that I am in that God has put put me in now it is hard very hard now I don't know what you're going to vote tonight but I I I feel like you all know what's right and wrong we can do better we're with sisd eight plus hours a day how come my friends and my peers have the

027lowest Dropout rates all kinds of negative things in our life why has sasd not built our community up we have the opportunity now guys to not have people say h they failed us again let's do this together okay I'm everywhere right now I'm everywhere but I have so much to say thank you guys for listening to the principal my parents everybody thank you guys and thanks for looking at me in the all right we're going to go back and do recognition of the sandel school board and Shannon or no soon's help us with that I'll just make comments from the board desk here but uh the the month of January really is a time for us to pause and thank the board members for their service um I think it's pretty obvious that being on

028the school board takes time takes thoughtfulness and energy and uh and volunteerism you don't get paid for it and but I speak on behalf of the staff and the community when I say thank you for your service to the board thank you for your dedication to be here twice a month at least and to work through issues on behalf of all of the kids in saisd and so uh we have a couple of things for you uh Mr Meers do we have those on on the board desk there uh we'd like to present the board and Dr Brandon can you help we're just going to hand the board one each these were Handmade by our students uh in the wood shop but it's a shuder board that um we'd like to hand you hopeful hopefully

029you'll enjoy it as much as the kids did in making it I'm sure but uh in the shape of Texas thank you board members y yep we're going to take a picture okay where would you like us why don't we stand uh you want to stand down here or you stand up here yeah let's go down there two thank you all right we are going to go into executive session quickly under real property which is code 551.071 and we will be back all right we are back from executive session we took no actions we made no votes we're going to move forward with our agenda the next is a financial audit presentation and Dr Brandon I think's gonna start us off on that Dr kemman Dr Moran members of the board each year the district

030engages an independent certified public accountant to audit its Financial reports this audit then must be presented to the Texas Education Agency The Firm of I Bailey was engaged to perform the audit for fiscal year 2024 this evening Jeremy Stevens CPA and partner IID Bailey uh is with us to make that presentation good evening members of the board uh I'm Jeremy Stevens with I Bailey uh our firm has completed the audit uh of the financial statements of the district as of and for the year into August 31st 2024 uh I left a copy of those bound financial statements at at each of your seats additionally I have a brief presentation to go over some of the financial highlights uh before I get into it though I want to say the audit went well uh did not

031have any adjusting journal entries uh as a result of audit procedures additionally we're not reporting any material weaknesses or significant deficiencies in internal controls over financial reporting uh so like I said a a good good good clean audit so that being said get into the the bound packet and the the the the presentation as well uh our audit report starts on page number 11 uh goes on over through page number four uh really it makes kind of four main points uh which I've summarized up on the slide uh first of all is our opinion at the top of page number 11 uh states that in our opinion the financial statements present fairly in all mature respects the financial position of the district uh this is what's known as a unmodified or a clean opinion on

032the financial statements uh it then goes on to describe our basis for our opinion uh which uh is that we conducted our audit in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards and we believe that the uh audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion uh it then describes Management's responsibilities for the financial statements uh which is management is responsible for the preparation and the presentation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles uh and management is responsible for the design and implementation of internal controls and lastly on page number 12 uh it describes our responsibility as auditor which our responsibility is to express an opinion as to whether the financial statements are presented uh in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles uh and to obtain

033reasonable assurance that financial statements are free from Material misstatement uh there's some additional narrative regarding approach to internal controls which is that we gain an understanding of the district's internal controls uh to design or audit procedures however do not test them to an extent that allows us to express an opinion on the effectiveness of internal controls uh so we're not expressing an opinion uh on the effectiveness of internal controls uh now moving on to some of the basic financial statements themselves starting with the statement of net position uh starts on page number 23 goes on over through page number 24 uh this particular statement provides uh a snapshot of all assets and liabilities of the district uh as of August 3020 30 31st 2024 uh is presented on what's known as the full acral basis

034of accounting uh so it includes all assets liabilities of the district uh including those that are uh long-term uh in nature so it includes your Capital assets includes liabilities for bonds payable and includes a liability for the net pension uh net pension liability uh as well as as the net other post-employment benefit liability uh I've got a very very summarized uh slide uh up there with a a a comparative column for 2023 uh you'll see under this basis of accounting total assets at year end uh about 315.50 million previous fiscal years about 32.4 million toal assets did increase uh a little bit year-over-year about about $3 million but pretty pretty pretty comparable year-over-year as far as liabilities of the district about 1995 million this year previous fiscal year is about 206 million uh so liabilities

035did decrease about $15 million year-over-year uh a large part of that is just pay Downs of your bonds payable kind of regular debt payments of the St as those have been made those liabilities have drawn down uh if you add it up you get your net position at year end which is the amount that the assets exceeds liabilities about 120 million in the current fiscal year it's about 106 million in the previous fiscal year uh second statement I'll touch on is the balance sheet of governmental funds uh which is on page number 27 uh of the bound packet uh again this particular statement uh provides a snapshot of assets and liabilities of the district uh however it's presented on what's known as the modified AC cruel basis accounting uh so its focuses on current assets

036and current liabilities uh does not include Capital assets does not include liabilities uh for ponds bonds payable uh or for your net pension or net OPB liabilities and so forth uh this particular statement this focuses on uh current obligations and the district's uh resources to meet those obligations uh under this basis of accounting uh you'll see total assets at year in we're about $101 million uh previous fiscal year is about 108 million uh so assets did decrease about $7 million year-over-year uh primarily uh those Investments have decreased year-over-year uh down to about 11 million this year from about 23 million in the previous fiscal year uh total liabilities uh of the district pretty comparable about 26.7 million this year is about 25 million last fiscal year uh so if you add it up your fund

037balance is the amount that your assets exceeds liabilities uh about 74.6 million this fiscal year and then it was about 83.4 million uh in the previous fiscal year here uh on this particular slide i' I've summarized that fund balance uh across all funds uh based on the various categories can kind of see how those have changed year-over-year uh again you'll see the total uh fund balance did decrease about that $8.8 million year-over-year uh to about $ 74.6 million uh largely you'll see that the that reduction is in the committed fund balance uh and that is a fund balance that has been was previously committed for fun uh for construction activities uh was spent down so that committed balance did draw down a little bit uh fund balance of the general fund uh which is the

038fund balance kind of to fund regular operating activities uh about 64 A5 million this fiscal year is about 74.4 Million last fiscal year uh so did decrease about 9.9 million year-over-year again largely to th due to those uh reductions in those amounts that have been committed for construction activities uh uh reduced down to about that 11.7 million this fiscal year uh the unassigned fund Bal balance is the amount of the fund balance that's available to the district to fund uh kind of regular operating activities uh generally I I hear the recommendation to keep at least a a thre Monon uh Reserve in your unassigned fund balance uh based on the general fund expenditures uh if you compare the August 31st 2024 unassigned fund balance of that 51.5 million uh to the average monthly expenditures for

039the 2024 fiscal year uh it's about 4.3 times your average monthly general fund expenditures uh so you are a little bit ahead of what it here is that minimum reserve for your unassigned fund balance and the last statement that I'm going to touch on is the statement of revenues expenses and changes in fund balance on page number 29 uh basically the income statement of the district uh this first slide summarizes Revenue sources of the district uh pretty comparable year-over-year total revenue is about1 174 million this fiscal year is about 175 million in the previous fiscal year uh if you look at the individual categories uh you will see that Federal program revenues uh have decreased a little bit year-over-year down to about 31 million uh again all those Esra funds uh starting to run out

040a little bit uh kind of so that's Federal funding is kind of duv tailing a little bit uh uh as those dry up a little bit uh State revenues have increased and then that was offset by a reduction in the that local Revenue but total revenues like I said pretty pretty comparable year-over year it's just kind of the the different sources changed up a little bit uh as far as expend ad Ministers of the district about 184 million in the current fiscal year uh it's an increase of about 21 million year-over-year uh if you look at the individual expenditure categories biggest part of that increase is in your Capital outlay uh again as that committed fund balance was was spent down those Capital expenditures showed up about 16.7 million in the 2024 fiscal years about

0412.3 million in the 2023 fiscal year uh so that's where a big portion uh of the increase in expenditures that uh overall each Min category did increase a little bit year-over-year but we are in a a rising price environment and that was everything for the basic financial statements there's two other reports that we issue uh which are in the very back of that bound copy uh the first is on page number 122 uh and it is our report on internal control over financial reporting and on compliance uh again this report reiterates that we're not expressing uh an opinion on the effectiveness of internal controls uh however if we did report any material weaknesses or any significant deficiencies or any instances of non-compliance is the report that it would be in again happy to report that

042there are no such items and the last report is our uh report on compliance uh required by the uniform guidance uh this our single audit report uh each year as a part of our audits uh we look at the federal programs and uh determine which federal program is to be tested as a as what's known as a major major program uh and then we perform tests of that program so we can determine and express an opinion as to whether the district complied with the requirements of that program uh this year we tested the Child Nutrition cluster uh the opinion on that is found at the top of page number 124 uh basically states that in our opinion the district complied with the requirements of that major program uh so again it's an unmodified or a

043clean opinion on compliance as well and that is everything that I have so with that I will open it up does anybody have any questions for me Mr Stevens thank you for your work uh with our staff here and and I commend our staff Dr Brandon and his crew uh for uh assistance in helping you get there but in the in the end run we did get uh an unmodified or a clean report which is about which which is not about it is the best you can get as far as an OD is concerned for a school correct yes it wasn't unmodified opinion which is the highest level of assurance okay thank you Mr Stevens any other questions for Mr Stevens thank you for being here all right thank you very much appreciate it all

044right moving forward we're going to go with Alan wolf from Park Hill Architects with an update going take action he asked if we could skip down and take thank you Dr keeman could leave Dr R members of the board either way I'm sorry can do it either way oh yeah it' be an action item B if you wanted to take yeah we do that um all right we're gonna so Mr Stevens can get on the road with it being cold and stuff we're going to skip real quick sorry you're good wolf we're going to go to action item B um which is Page 58 that's question and um do I have a motion to approve the August 31st 2024 annual financial report and the auditor's opinion Dr K the move to approve the August 31

0452024 report annual financial report and the auditor's opinion so have a motion from Mr dendle do I have a second I'll second I have a second for Mr gagos uh any other board comments or questions all in favor say I all against say the same motion passes 70 all right thank you for being here now Mr Wolf update please thank you Dr kemman members of the board I'm going to go through just a a summary of what we've been doing for the last several months I wanted to start with just a a thank you um and I know a couple of our advisory committee members are here um an incredible effort uh put forth by your citizens committee you can see how many meetings and hours donated just as you uh you the board have

046done uh they also have donated uh several hours so this proposal that you're going to see this evening and I know that you've received their recommendation at your previous meeting is really a a proposal by the committee and and for your citizens and your students I was just going to go ahead and summarize the projects and this I'm not going to read every line uh or every uh line of text but it's broken down into five different categories so Safety and Security these are high priority things like the public address systems and and Communications your your comps in your building um uh targeted security fencing and things like that uh there's a new construction item that we're going to talk about a little bit later I know which is the Glenn Middle School replace there

047are uh additions and Renovations uh at both Central High School and at Lake View High School and you can see uh the categories of those work items um between the the two high schools and then there's also a line item for right sizing elementary school so this is continued work at at both Fannon and McGill to to finish out the master plan that we had uh discussed back in 2022 but it also addresses a a major need at crocodil Elementary School with the with the cafeteria moving on Capital renewal through the work of of AJ and Scott and Tony and their team and Jason uh going through the highest priority Capital renewal projects for HVAC fire alarm Replacements um and and electrical panels uh there's also quite a bit of Plumbing I've got a little

048Matrix in in a minute that that'll be in your packet that you can see the breakdown of each campus for that it's also important to recognize those physical needs that we experience within the buildings are also extended in some of the athletic uh facilities predominantly things like locker rooms and so you'll see uh a uh an amount for each to address those things both at Central and at Lake View but also at the middle schools so the middle schools have needs you can see there as well uh there was also some uh discussion in uh some of the facilities at Lake View for example at the baseball and softball field don't have a concession and restroom uh building that serve those facilities so you can see um you can see those uh listed as well

049so when we come come down to the total we've broken this down into uh by category so you have Safety and Security new construction the additions Renovations uh Capital renewal projects and then uh the athletic Renovations and Improvement projects are those repairs we talked about and listed earlier this again was uh all all totals up to four a little over $42 million I think it's really important important to point out that there were other lists of needs that the the citizens committee worked through these projects got a super majority of the vote from the citizens committee so it's not even just a 50% from them these got a super majority so five out of eight tables had to had to vote for that uh which I think is a really powerful process they were very

050diligent in how they were trying to prioritize funds as you all know the the costs of construction and repair have escalated since the last time a bond was approved in 2008 and so these are uh facility needs that they identified and they prioritize there uh I know that your uh uh Advantage is going to talk a little bit about this there's some choices that you have in how you uh go about packaging uh bonds you can do them in a single proposition or you can do them in separate propositions there is a little bit of overlap um in the in the projects that were identified by the committee specifically at Glenn for the locker room areas there and so there's a choice that you have it's about $6 Million worth of locker room Renovations that

051are needed there uh and if you have a a new Glenn Middle School as part of your bond package that would obviously be something that you wouldn't wouldn't have to do there's different options uh that you you can see there or you'll see on the next slide that you you have to do if you break it down as one proposition um and take that $6 million out it's 397 million if you split it into two propositions and leave that $6 million at at Glenn to address all the locker room issues and plumbing issues that you have you can see the breakdown would be a little under 281 million as a proposition a and if you included Glenn Middle School as a proposition B on a separate prop 122 million as I mentioned the the $6

052million that you have in Glen and again these are this is just some ideas for you to think about this isn't um a set in stone way to do it we would certainly need to allocate that in the in the bond communication for what those funds would be utilized for uh but there's different options that you could do there's certainly a a large amount of uh Capital renewal that we have that we're addressing so there's different options with how to do that uh one thing though is you could you could keep the bond amount under under 400 million if you if you took that $6 million out and uh we're addressing that with the new construction so those are some of the some of the choices there that you have I'll I'll let that again

053this is something just for discussion uh this evening I wanted to show a little bit more detail and and show you uh some of the things that were important to the uh facilities committee about the campuses and we've got a little bit more information that shows uh in more detail than what you've seen before on how the how the projects could lay out on the site some preliminary layouts um this is just that Matrix I was talking about this is the same information that was in the facility assessment uh presentation that and that the citizens got as well um at Central I'm going to go through I'm not going to go through every slide but this is basically your current configuration we talked about the one of the biggest things that that was discussed by

054the citizens committee was the amount of TR travel time across campus uh and trying to address and save instructional time I'm going to keep going through this and just kind of show what a first phase could look like this is the same information that the citizens committee received but in a more three-dimensional graphic the the project that you saw earlier was replacing the burnhard theater um there's many many issues that we discussed with the facility assessment about that I know that's been something that's been discussed by the board before and the citizens committee before also the construction of a of a gymnasium and a replacement cafeteria to deal with deal with the physical needs that you have there and the the the number of kids who have to eat outside uh especially during inclement weather

055there's a way to do this that you'll see in a minute where we can uh share all those facilities together so they work well when you're having an event after hours whether that be uh for a basketball game or whether that be a performance so one of the things we talked about as well is just security was a big a big topic and how can we make the campus go from being spread out to being uh contiguous and again this is not this is uh showing how it could how it faced replacement over time could be done the committee really wrestled with the uh replacement of Central and so we wanted to show how that could be done over time uh this again is not a set in this is just what could be done

056we wanted to prove out that it would work uh and that this construction that you're considering as part of phase one would would prove out over time under this uh master plan idea so this is not a final just like these Graphics are not a final we put them together enough so that we have we can verify the budget and make sure we've covered the spaces I I really appreciate the principles and the staff at all the campuses for their time to help us with the program and space programming that we have again this is just a a a general graphic it doesn't include all of the spaces that would be within those areas um I think what's great about Central is it can address a number of different programs whether it's choir theater band

057um and you can see the the the gymnasium as well currently you're the the size of the facilities that you have both are are much smaller uh in some cases half the size of some of your peer districts so that can create some challenges and and we know that there's a correlation between those extracurricular uh programs and Fine Arts that is beneficial to your uh academic achievement as well kids who are involved in U more than one extracurricular activity do way better in in schools so um these facilities are important and that's the message that we got from your citizens committee uh again taking over some of that older construction and renovating that to expand Health Sciences and culinary arts was another priority of the committee this is just what things could look like um

058you can see the the number of certifications the fine arts department also has things like technical theater certifications and things like that so there are also those opportunities available to use those spaces for career and technology these are just examples of what things might look like uh what a dining facility could look like uh what's very comparable in other other uh facilities uh gymnasium spaces as well uh and other support facilities um here you can see kind of what a Health Sciences renovation could look like so I'm going to go on to Lake View uh I know many of the the citizens committee had an opportunity to to tour San Angelo Central but also to tour Lake View uh we had a chance to look at the the really tight space for the Mariachi program

059which is which is growing and thriving uh we looked at the welding lab they can't weld on a flat surface because the floor slopes things like that and so the the facilities committee really wanted to address those things as well over at at Lake View you noticed a line item to to address uh the locker rooms the uh the 1977 locker room area there has not been addressed since the original construction so it was not part of the rebuild uh back in the early 2000s so there are physical needs there that need to be addressed again I'm just going to go through some of the some of the uh ways those facilities could could look and function you can see a a quick screen capture there um so there's more than $30 million there allocated

060to to uh Lake View moving on to Glenn this was one that was really a uh I think an eye opener for the the committee when they walked around uh those of you who attended uh attended Glenn kind of know the layout of the of the hallways and the the uh classrooms um this is the existing campus we looked at what would what could be done if you replaced it over time see if I can get that to go maybe up a little bit it's still thinking there we go um so it could be it could be replaced on site um and that allows us to to utilize uh the utilities and also keep the the building open on time excuse me open during construction pardon me and then there's ways that we could look

061at the site certainly there's a grade change there as you all know so uh but the idea would be able to provide a practice football field there's some construction there you might want to re reutilize uh certainly the the band hall building would be one with its proximity towards the the field that you could do that with and then these are just these are pictures of other middle schools of other other districts in the area many of whom you're familiar with with uh and then you can also see the I think one of the advantages and I know I know uh when we went through the the gymnasiums and we went through the choir rooms and we went through the other spaces at Glenn something like this in the hands of your your great teachers

062would be I think something that the the committee wanted to explore okay we've we've had a chance to to do the first phase at Fannon uh and you guys have done that but there as you recall from the original master plan there were other phases to build that out replace older construction uh and and more rightsize that facility here's the current the current stage you can see the eight classroom Edition that just completed looks great in there um this is the plan uh going for the next phase so very similar so McGill has a new kitchen in cafeteria Fanon does not so in in that many of you are familiar there off of Wilson Street there that's where the cafeteria is it's much smaller uh the also we want to create a instead of having

063the entry off of that street we would like to bring that over onto the east side and provide a longer drop off area the site's been prepared for those things and so this is a natural next phase that you can see this this is a little less than 17 right around 17 million on this particular option on this particular part this is what the entry could look like this is the same rendering you guys have seen before uh so I think we really got a lot of folks were excited about this and creating a new front door for Fannon this is what uh some of the spaces could look like inside uh really inviting for the school I think uh those who've been who've had a chance to be inside the uh The Hub space

064over at Fannon or have been and Mill have can see the difference and and the smiles on the kids' faces and the staff it's been it's been really great to see so let me talk real quick about McGill the purple area here that's what's been recently redone it's about half of an elementary which I know that that you guys have done in the past and uh this uh this is uh working working well but we have other phases that we need to be complete or that were recommended by uh the citizens committee as part of continuation of the 2022 master plan you can see at adding uh 17 additional classrooms uh that would allow some of that older construction where the first and second grade Wing is over there on the West Side to be

065replaced to provide additional drop off areas so that we can keep the traffic separate uh buses and cars so you can see kind of the build out there and then finally this is the same rendering you guys have seen before um I'm going to keep going lastly uh this is now Crockett back in the 2008 Bond the the exterior corridors were enclosed and it got a complete renovation it's it's really a nice very well done um what wasn't done was the kitchen and cafeteria and so the uh it's basically in this area in Red so the proposal is to replace that and then there's room that uh for new for four new classrooms on the end of the wing there and so that that would allow this campus to to function long term uh for

066the district so that's that in a nutshell is is a review of the just some more images um one of the things you have over at at Lamar and some of your other campuses as a maker space it's a very uh popular area for kids to to learn who are tactile Learners as well as the other different modalities they learn by so um really a great opportunity I think and I'm I'm so excited and appreciative of all the time that your citizens committee put in all the time that your staff put in uh to get this put together uh and this point I'll ask for any questions that you guys have so any board questions comments so just for the record Fannon is finished there's there's one uh area of dra on the drainage on

067the back side there uh on the myself oriented on the west side to to clean out that ditch on the back in other words the Indo all that stuff is complete yes okay thank you it's not six months behind thank you no sir no they're they're they're occupied and going so okay thank you Mr Wolf appreciate it um you'll see a theme tonight we're getting a lot of information so we can try and make good decisions with everything going forward so next Jeff Robert is up with an update as well thank you Dr Kingman Dr Mar and Jeff Robert our board members Jeff Robert with Hilltop Securities um Dr Brandon wanted me to go over um sorry had wanted me to go over some of the financing potential financing scenarios with you and then also

068um in in talking with with Dr Mar Dr Brandon maybe talk about uh separate propositions all on one proposition those type of discussions as well so I'll start with a scenarios um hopefully you can see this but what we've done is I've got a $398 million scenario here on this first page just a summary so at the top in column one you see the 398 and we've talked about doing uh 275 immediately and then coming back in column four with the remaining 123 in 2027 and that would meet uh The Architects and construction folks uh construction cash flow needs um for both of these I'd assume a 25 year amortization with a 4 and a half% interest rate if we were to to do it right now we'd be closer to 4% um maximum ins

069tax rate there 3725 in column 6 with your current 0874 in column 7 so it'd be about roughly a 28.5 Cent increase and to give you an idea back in 2008 the maximum minus tax rate went up to 3125 I believe however at that time your M rate was A14 whereas now as I believe it's about 72 and change orino so so the overall tax rate even though the ins would be a little higher for them back then the overall tax rate would be quite a bit lower uh than what it was back in in 09 the graph there below that black line at the bottom that you see there that is is the projected required ins tax rate for the district's existing bonds so what's outstanding right now uh which will be paid off

070I believe there in 2035 and you can see that's roughly at about just under 10 cents where you are right now uh the green line shows what the ins or projected ins tax rate would be after that first $275 million is issued and then the total ins tax rate after the remaining 123 is issued in 2027 and I've used you know again we try to be very conservative with our assumptions and those assumptions are interest rate feel comfortable with those 4 and a half% rates but but also the main assumption is the tax-based growth and it's going to be shown on this next page but it's going to be real small because it's a large spreadsheet I've only assumed 1% growth for the next 10 years and then half a percent thereafter and so what

071happens and what happened back in 09 is we use those same conservative tax-based assumptions and that's why you saw the ins tax rate come down year to year because ultimately the actual tax-based growth outpaced what our assumptions were which is what we want we don't want to want to take chances with taxpayer money so here's the detail of that scenario I know it's very difficult to see I apologize for that but wanted you have all the information um in column one that's the actual tax base for uh 2024 and fiscal 2025 which is the current one we're in right now and you can see after that in column two I've assumed 1% for 10 years and then half a percent thereafter your existing bonds there in column three four and five total principal interest in

072total p&i the what we call assah which is the additional state aid for the homestead exemption increase says there in column six what that is is since the state has raised the homestead exemption multiple times over the years they've held you harmless by giving you that money to offset those those increases in the homestead exemption the projected principal and interest total pni for the first 2025 issuance of 273 there in column 7 and then column 10 11 and 12 would be that subsequent issuance and we'll come over to the tax rate there in column 15 and you can see what the projected ins tax rate is and again that number would come down if you grow more than 1% per year uh next graph shows what if you decided to split out and do uh

073two propositions how much would each proposition cost if they were done on a standalone basis and so the 275 if we did that immediately you can see the Maxs tax rate would be about 28.5 cents there in column 4 if we did the 123 stand loan without that 275 it' be about 18 cents would be the ins tax rate and you can see the graphs Below in what that looks like and then I did the same thing just show the detail for both of those as well um are there any questions on the the numbers themselves can I can I ask a question before yes sir so if we split the bond if we we we call it if we split a bond could we still do a series in 2027 if it was split

074to keep the tax rate lower for people more would I think the Allan correct me if I'm wrong the the 2027 was for the Glenn project is that correct so if you split it and let's say the Glenn project did not pass assuming that was that proposition you would want to still do I believe in order to meet his con construction cash flow needs You' do the 273 immediately okay I get I get that question so if but for the 123 right part of the way with the series a and series B you were showing was it was well if they both passed you could certainly still do you could still move them you could still move it later yes you can still stage them legally yes whether they're combined or they're two separate propositions

075they both pass you can still have the same timeline of issuance yes sir that's what I was trying to ask thank you yes so with regard the question was kind of asked was was thoughts on you know splitting propositions and full disclosure um I went to Glenn jior High and I went to St Angelo Central um but I would I'd give you this opinion whether I went to lonar or whether I went to to to Lincoln and I will say I've probably been involved that's kind of racking my brain I've probably been involved close to 200 to 225 Bond elections over the 29 years have been doing this and I I really couldn't think of an instance where a district split propositions for non extracurricular or nonshared Services type facilities if we're talking talking about

076campuses within the district and we kind of call that allart uh propositions where you're separating everything and I was talking with Dr Brandon and I kind of said well if you had let's just say for hypothetical if you had a $10 million Lincoln project on one prop a $10 million Lone Star on another prop and a $10 million Glenn on the third prop you know I I would say back when I lived here went to Glenn I didn't think much of Lone Star in in Lincoln at that time and my parents would probably say well we're going to vote for The Glenn one we're not going to vote for those other ones and the Lincoln would probably say we're going to vote for Lincoln but not Glenn and lonar and same with the lonar folks

077and you've got people are going to vote against it no matter what so my experience is when you start to separate and go to that what I call allar propositions for non- extracurricular or non-shared Services type facilities I think you increase the likelihood that it's not going to pass and I also think when you have a proposition that has multiple campuses being touched I think it's rare that every voter says I want everything in there I think the normal thought is that you know what I may not be as high on these two projects but I'm real happy that these things are excuse me these things are happening here and maybe that gives him an inclination to you know to vote for uh for that proposition so I mean even before the state made changes

078uh which forced districts to now put stadiums Fine Arts facilities Standalone Fine Arts facilities natatoriums teacher housing those have to be on separate propositions even before they made that action or did that action in 2019 most districts would put stadiums on a separate proposition but I I can't think of any instance where just one campus was separated from the proposition and kind of put out there on a standalone basis um I couldn't I couldn't think of any so that's kind of my opinion on that and I and I yield there's certainly experts on on uh polling and that kind of thing that could could maybe give you more sign scientific information that's just my experience and haven't done it for quite some time any questions any other board questions or comments we're good all right

079thank you thank you all right so now we're going to zoom Miss John from Advantage Marketing all right why don't we have Dr Gomez present on the paper report and come back oh oh sorry sorry weing I don't have the messaging thank you we don't have audio yet you try speaking now and see make sure we can hear you we got to turn you up all the way up here just a let's try that hey good evening okay try that again okay good evening there we go go for it okay yay all right good evening uh Dr keeman trustees and Dr Moran thank you so much for the opportunity to join your meeting this evening and uh be able to visit with you guys about the upcoming uh proposed bond election I'm Travis cram our

080director of client experience and I are excited to be here but apologize that we couldn't be there in person Mother Nature has her own plans so uh we are appreciative that we were able to join virtually this evening um first of all I just want to start out by saying congrats on a successful election in November 20124 uh I'm going to share my screen so hopefully you can uh see some of these things but we have uh collected some data about the election and so just as a walkth through in prep preparation for the bond there's some things that we need to refresh on um so you've heard from the architect about the bond uh program the current list of projects and from the fa on kind of the financial scenarios so now we're going

081to go back into some different kinds of numbers and talk about uh voter uh analysis and what we can kind of expect to see and then I'm going to point out how that's going to change in May because it's not the same voters it's not the same scenario not the same conversation so first of all um you can see I'm not sure if all of you can see this so but this should be a refresher there are four columns really rep presented up here the first one on the left is the total number of registered voters Broken Out by age R we're we're just still seeing you we are not seeing your screen oh okay well let's see oh you have to share the screen reest sorry try that try that now okay sorry about

082that small details right small details okay let's try again here we go okay I apologize so there's really four columns here the first column on the left represents the total number of Voters broken down by age and once again you can see that the electorate in St Angelo ISD as a political subdivision is is Young 51% of the voters are under the age of 49 so we would correlate those to younger voters are 18 to 49 year olds uh or parents I'm sorry um but as you look at what happened so let's look at the presidential election um we saw 32,000 about voters turn out about 56% uh state state average was about 65% um you can see that your younger voters in this election even though they make up 51% of the total uh

083they they only made up 42% of the turnout in the presidential election which is obviously the highest election cycle we have every four years now as we slide over and we look at a midterm that group of Voters drops to 30% of the turnout and our voters over the age of 50 increase to 70% of the turnout now that's in the governor uh you know the midterm election now what happens in a low turnout it's not on this screen but what happens in a low turnout so we're going to talk about some previous elections um typically San Angelo or typically across the state in May in November odd Year and may even year we see about 5% of Texans V so 95% of people stay home in this upcoming cycle and so it really pushes

084uh the number of of Voters that are turning out in these low turnout Cycles um 80% of them are usually over the age of 50 and it is and that is that happens um in large districts urban districts rural districts medium small it's just the way that voters turn out in the state of Texas across the board it's a very standard uh outcome and one thing that can increase that is having something like a school bond election or maybe a a a um contentious marriage race or some kind of other proposition that helps to drive out the turnout um in that cycle and so in San Angelo the highest in a low turnout cycle so I'm looking at a November election right now was about 8,000 and even in that election 81% of the voters

085were over the age of 50 um lowest one I saw in the last couple of year was May of 22 uh 92% of the voters in that cycle were over the age of 50 so nine out of 10 people that came to the polls were what we would call mature voters um only 7% so remember I said 51% of your electorate qualifies as 18 to 49 year olds only 7% of those will show up so I get a lot lot of times well our teachers will you know if our teachers vote well if our parents vote well those are a lot of ifs because we know from voter behavior that even though people want to vote in these low turnout Cycles even if we we get a message out and we create a lot of

086demand um polling in May elections is very limited usually so that's something that we're we're looking at um with the district and the county but polling locations and times are very constrictive red in May elections there's only 7 Days of early voting in May um if you can get your county to give you Saturday and Sunday and potentially open up Monday through Friday from 7 to 7: you could help younger voters make their ways to the polls and turnout but currently a lot of those voting times are shorter um and days on the weekends which I I think we're moving toward that um those are critical in turning out those 18 to 49 year olds uh in versus in November even an odear election this coming November we would have 12 days of early voting

087plus election day so there's a big difference in turnout in every single cycle um one of the things we also know as we approach this selection cycle about the voters in your district from your survey is that um 45% of those voters knew and believe the tax freeze message so we have almost half so you would think it would be 100% of all senior citizens would know and believe but it's actually from the polling that we collected uh last for the uh the Vader election for proposition a uh told us that piece of information so that's just something that we take into consideration so uh I want to talk real quick about the research because I do think that it's important um for those of you who may remember and if you have it uh

088I'm not going to pull it up necessarily on the screen because it's going to be a lot of clicking around but on page 15 of that survey from uh last from July where we we did the polling for the proposition a um you might remember that the informed position on the uh once voters got information so the prediction was 59% and if you remember what you won your election in November was almost right at 59% so my point in saying that is this data was collected in July we went through the process of running um a rigorous voter education campaign a very robust um with a lot of competition right from the Republicans and the Democrats and every other message that was going on um out in the um in the cyber world uh and

089we were able to to keep up what we would consider uh to be an informed position that tells us that voters got the message they got the information and it came out so let's let's take a little walk down memory lane of some of the research that was collected for the bond so um I appreciate Mr Robert's opinions certainly from being a student in the district um and and growing up there but I want to remind you that um I I'll use a I I'll use kind of a a um uh I relayed this story my own experience from being on the board when I was in Georgetown and being uh on a bond committee and when I was in that Community I knew everyone whose opinion mattered in making directional generational decisions but I

090didn't know everyone I didn't know everyone who voted and so what this research does for us is it it gives us that um extra layer of insight and Assurance so that we can get a read on everyone in the community and then it's it's um skewed toward the turn out of the cycle that we're in so it takes that opinion and then it says okay well if only people of this age or people in this area or any of those Dimensions which we have a lot of which I'll show you in a moment if only those people voted what can we expect to happen and how much information does a voter need uh so that they can be confident when they enter The Ballot Box so this was one of the things that had come

091up um so that we could help the committee if you remember make these really tough choices because we're now at somewhere around $400 million and um when we were constructing this uh committee process and when we were building a a a bond proposal we were trying to determine okay well how do we know how how do they know you know where's the line where's the line of their comfort level and where's the line of of the rest of the voters and the rest of the community so this was one of the slides of many that was presented but the reason I'm showing this is this is why uh this conversation about splitting Glenn Middle School has come out because of the of the major project areas that were presented to all the voters in the

092community and then kind of skewed toward these older voters this is what they told us about their preferences so it doesn't mean that these things are um you know it's a lightning rod for a no but you can see when we say which project do they least prefer out of all all the sentiment out there over a third of the voters said I'm just not interested in this project so when they tell us that then it it makes us have to take like a timeout and say okay well what is that mean if we move that project into uh a bond what what could we expect to happen and this is the other piece of this is It's $122 million project um but it in of itself is not um it's not the only thing

093that should be considered because if you recall the the best um position when we tested the total cost was $170 million now remember I'm not the pollster I'm not Matt so I I can't interpret his research I'm interpreting it now but not the way he would but I didn't construct it but I do trust it and what this tells us at7 70 million is that we're at 5050 we're at 5050 at 170 million now if we do the work in the campaign and we're working with voters and remember 80% of these voters are over the age of 50 and only about 5% of Voters are going to naturally turn out if we have an active robust community group they could actually move that needle to the turnout could actually be somewhere between 10 to 15%

094but that wasn't present in the last election cycle so we can't really know for sure if we can trust that we have uh enough effort or resources to move the needle to work the turnout to get to a better position so at 170 million you can see right here I mean he says this indicates a close election we're now considering 370 million plus so the reason why Glenn Middle School and I I you know I like once again I really appreciate that the the experience that that Mr Roberts has but I also have some experience in this area and we have had success in districts where they are now uh since 2019 is way in the Ry mirror people are getting more creative and putting things in a second prop for instance in Pampa ISD

095they had had a lot of projects just like you and they their surveys show that their Community would only support up to a certain amount um they also couldn't Bond over a certain amount because they didn't have the tax base but they were expecting and hoping to get a factory a fertilizer Factory in the district if that fertilizer Factory uh went through and announced their plans to build it would add enough to their tax base to be able to do all of these projects so we actually did a proposition B that was a ghost proposition it would never be sold unless this Factory announced that it was coming to the community so I use that as kind of a that's the most maybe rare version of using that but we use it more and more

096especially when we have really great data like this to help shape the proposal and uh in honor the fact that you know this is what we know to be it the last survey came out when it was done you know almost six five months before election day to the percentage that it was predicted and so the reason why uh the reason why that we were kind of looking at moving Glenn Middle School to proposition B is it's not necessarily about voter Choice what voters are responding to in this this survey is not the 170 the 270 or 370 it's the cost per month and what we know is when we hit somewhere around the high 20s 27 28 we start to see a price resistance and especially since covid that level of price resistance for

097the monthly impact is what they're processing on the monthly impact has actually come down it used to be somewhere in the low3s now the high 20s low 30s is about about the the highest that they you know they want to have that conversation so what you're seeing here is them responding and if my math is correct and Jeff can correct me but at 398 million your monthly in proposition a is about $356 and if if I could read the screen because it was crooked for me but I believe uh what he put on the screen earlier if the two were broken out is Proposition a is now $24.10 a month proposition B which would be I once again I believe I was trying to read it on a screen crooked but I believe it was

098$11.54 cents so voters aren't going to come in and choose the cheapest option and they probably don't make as emotional decisions about these and you would think and I'm going to remind you why it's because the voters that were going to see in this election cycle have probably lived here and voted and rejected a series of bonds over their entire grown-up life and they are the most reliable voters these May voters and these upcoming November voters um that you have the most educated voters um so so I've never seen them and I've never seen them in all of propositions that I've done I've done almost 150 I've never seen voters make a choice based on cost they make it they make it when on cost when it's too expensive to consider or afford or they

099don't have enough information to where they understand the cost but usually when we do surveys when bonds fail it's not the first one is not the cost there are people that don't want to pay the tax but those are the no voters that are baked in to the 40% or you know in the old days 35% of no voters you know now that number is a little bit different so I just wanted to uh bring this up tonight in terms of how you start to think about constructing this because you do have options you can put everything in a and just all the chips in at $35 64 almost $36 a month you have that option and you can do that but if the escalation or the risk of pushing any or all of these

100projects into the future is too high for whatever reason then you do have the option and I'm happy to visit more in depth with you uh if you want to but you do have that option to break these out and take some of the financial the monthly perception of that off of the voter by putting these into U some smaller pieces so that they can consider it um and that's one of the other things I was going to point out is um from a messaging standpoint we really have some really great opportunities with the bond that are really different from the proposition a election so proposition a we're still talking about students and teachers and teaching and learning and um barriers and opportunities that you're having in the district with your mmino budget issues and

101how this that election you know could be a solution uh to some of those problems so we do the same thing in the bond but one of the that I think really cool thing about this process and especially with your committee is the development of a mass plan and so as you know Park Hill and Allan and RJ have built with your with you and your committee this long-term master plan you've now got these projects phased up and teed up to to roll out and their prioritized as to how they would roll out so this this is an opportunity for me and you guys to get to explain to the voter that we have this plan this long-term plan and This is Our intention so that as we start to explain where projects like the

102athletic projects or Glenn Middle School or um any of the other projects that might be in here um that they if they were to be pulled out and broken out uh they can still be packaged as a whole for consideration and I'll sum that up by saying we also in Joshua ISD uh they had failed two Bond elections and had a proposition a approach and uh they pulled out because if they were a growing district and uh the tax impact was fairly high so they went from one proposition to five we passed all five Long View ISD did the same thing they broke out the propositions a little bit passed all five at 60% after failing two times so um there are examples of this and like I said I just wanted to give you

103some options for consideration and match those options that the project plan the data that Jeff has shared with the data that you've the research that youve paid for so that you can kind of start to shape in your mind um how this can be presented to the community for their consideration if there's I'm happy to answer any questions although Jessica you may have to interpret the questions does anyone have any questions I so if we have a committee when obviously we didn't go to Every committee meeting R because ofs hang on a second I'm going to turn you towards the board Direction okay and I just pushed something on my screen give me one second I'm not exactly sure what I just did here but I made a boo boo okay I'm sorry okay so

104if if a committee comes and says hey we want these projects and then a board doesn't go after all those projects simultaneously do you still get that committee bought in to helping you get your bond passed is that were you to hear his question yes and it's a great question so I would say when I started doing elections uh almost 15 years ago the standard was a proposition a approach it was take the committee recomend recommendation you know a unanimous approval and as as the honestly in The Last 5 Years as the school Finance scenario has changed um and there there's decisions that boards have to make that about land purchases and um other things that impact that can't necessarily always be presented to a committee we do have the ability or we do have

105scenarios where boards take the proposal and they can adjust it so in this scenario uh you you've got options where you can take the full package that they came back with and keep it in one or like we talked about and break it up or you can uh push some of those projects to the Future into the master plan so let me make sure um what I'm saying clarify that so the master plan the great thing about having a master plan and really building the bond proposal as part of this long-term uh vision and and Community built plan is that if a project isn't placed in the bond today that project doesn't go away it just gets moved to a future date along unfortunately with its escalation and inflation so its cost naturally goes up

106and that's part of what's commun communicated to the voters um it should you decide to um to to do it as a proposition a or to split the projects one of the things they need to know is hey if you don't if you choose not to select all of these and and approve all of these and vote for all of these then just know that as you do that you're pushing these projects into the future and you're voting basically to say yes to the same thing it's just going to cost you more because these types of needs don't go away I mean you've you've been acre them for you know 16 years so um that's part of the communication to get a voter to see that if you just pick prop b or prop D

107prop A and C and you know B are still needed it's just they're going to cost you more in the future and they could have other um other um uh issues and implementing those projects that we don't even know about today uh so it gives the voter that choice because a lot of times when voters come to The Ballot Box they perceive that if they vote Yes uh and they're you know basically saying I'm in agreement with everything that the community and the board has developed and I'm you know I'm going to vote for this and if I vote no nothing happens and that's the biggest piece of what we have to explain is there's a lot of things that happen when projects aren't approved and so in this case the first explanation to answer

108your question is to go back you know explain to the committee that one the research is there um you know and you have these options if you choose to exercise them and that you are going to pursue the projects but you have to have G you have to know that there's a certain amount of success that's in that's um that you could expect a probability of success um otherwise all of the projects if the whole proposition a fails all of the projects along with all of the escalation inflation moves into a future election cycle and every election cycle is another 6 months which is somewhere probably Mr Wolf is there he'll correct me but probably somewhere between 4 and 6% um every six months that's now traveling along with all of those projects so um

109yes so is it appropriate to is it great to you know take the recommendation and push it forward but yes but there's nothing wrong also with having that U long-term View and saying we're going to have to do this a different way or we're going to perceive it pursue it a different way um I think they would honor that and and respect it I don't think I I know I see them do it all the time but boards more and more make changes to committee recommendations and honestly more and more they add things to the proposal that committees are afraid to add like stadiums or auditoriums or practice facilities so it's usually you know there is more of that now than there there ever has been since 2019 any other board questions or comments all

110right thank you Mr Johnson thank you we appreciate it let us know if you have any other questions all right now Dr Gomez we're going to do the public hearing on the taper report 23 24 I think they're going to switch over okay so Dr Moran Dr Kingman and members of the board this evening we will discuss our District's annual report using the pdf version of the paper which you all received uh released by the Texas Education Agency on December 12th according to statute a public hearing must be held within 90 calendar days of receiving that PDF taper within two weeks of the public meeting each district must widely publish its annual report we will do so by posting on our website and hard copies will be available to any stakeholders who may not have

111access to the internet the pdf version of the Texas Academic performance report includes only major data points and for it to only include major data points it's 33 pages long so I just want to point that out uh but it is designed to allow districts to fulfill their public hearing notification requirements it provides additional data um through or excuse me the state provides additional data through what is referred to as the Texas performance reporting system or tprs because we have a lot of acronyms in education the difference between the taper and tprs is the taper takes a snapshot date then testing information for students that tested on a campus or within the district whereas um the Texas performance reporting system is more compreh ensive and data is available on a rolling basis also the tprs

112integrates additional state and federal reporting requirements into a single reporting system so it's the most comprehensive system the state puts out both of these the tprs and the taper pull together a wide range of information on the performance of students in each school and District in Texas every year performance is shown disaggregated by student groups including ethnicity and socioeconomic status and the reports also provide extensive information on school and District staff programs and student demographics there's some updates for the 2324 taper there are uh currently no uh a through F ratings those remain pending and subject to change based on judicial rulings there is however the state's final accountability manual which was posted May 9th and that can be found online now because this report is so extensive the state releases a glossery which is

113available primarily for staff however it's also available to the public so I'll just show you briefly I said our district taper report is 33 Pages the glossery alone is 48 pages and I just point that out because there's some very specific academic language um for example taper will measure star performance by grade level subject student group and performance level it will measure School progress academic growth and accelerated learning and it breaks down what academic growth and accelerated learning means bilingual education ESL participation rates attendance rates annual Dropout rates graduation rates by cohorts including those graduating on a recommended high school program a distinguished achievement program and a foundation high school program it also reports college career military ready including College ready graduates career and Military ready graduates then college career military Readiness indicators in terms

114of student information it gives you enrollment there's a lot of discussions about facilities and right sizing so this report gives comparisons again not only in saisd but throughout the state you've heard a lot of conversations from the district about a right-sized Elementary being closer to that 600 Mark where many of the SD Elementary campuses are substantially smaller so just point out the information if at any time stakeholders are wondering about seisd they can pull any District across the state um ethnic distribution economically disadvantaged English Learners students with disciplinary placements at risk students with disabilities by type of primary disability 504 students students with dyslexia retention rates class size information and then it goes on to give you a whole wealth of information about staff information one of Dr Moran's superintendent goals um and as we

115heard earlier from Ra was the passing of the Vader to retain staff so not only can you see the district's staff experience and retention rate you can compare that with estate along with salary information those are just some highlights from the glossery itself we go back to the main report I think it's just important that stakeholders know where they canot only access our information but have comparable data so in summary we will review uh the key components of the statute and then we'll conclude with some highlights and some Focus areas that the district is uh working around first key indicator for the statute is the pe's financial standard report had a lot of conversation and the district continuously says they provide Financial transparency this is another way where you can see the district's finances this

116is reported in the pe's financial standard report from the 2223 Financial actual reports and that's linked in there this is provided by the state funding division so this isn't provided by just the district alone or our Auditors it's the actual State funding division it also can be accessed from the very last page of the taper report so I wanted to show you a couple of ways that you could access that information um we go back one I'm sorry Mr Maris is driving for me um okay scroll up so just in summary it's going to show you again this is from the 2223 Financial actual reports it's going to show you the district's total operating revenue from the general fund and then other funds so you can see that there from the total operating Revenue general

117fund colum and then the all funds column and the full report can be accessed there just want to give you a second because I know you have a lot of screens okay it's important that I tie back to when I said the a through F ratings were pending so a district tester report their accreditation status since the a through F ratings have been pending due to judicial situations the last two years a district has to use the rating from the 22 school year so as you see on our uh cover sheet of that taper report we are accredited it's just to clarify though where that data came from since there has not been the issuance of a3f ratings the last two years okay then we're going to take just a moment um you have the

118full district report because that's a requirement from the public hearing but I want to make sure that all board members and any stakeholder watching on TV knows where they can access any campus report so you can go to the Texas Education Agency website they're Linked In This which will also be on our website and you can type in any campus name or any District name in the state of Texas to get their full reports and then again within two weeks that will be sooner for us these will also be on our seic website after this evening then you can do the same on the Texas Education uh website for the Texas performance reporting system which is the more comprehensive system that we discussed earlier where the data is released on a rolling basis not just

119taking the snapshot and then the testing window and this is more comprehensive as we talk further in the calendar year about Federal report cards due to going back to that revenue and the fact that we get funds outside our general fund we do receive federal funds so a part of that Financial transparency is showing additional information so again Texas performance reporting system for campuses and districts across the state each School District in each campus is required to have a district Improvement plan and a campus Improvement plan a part of that entails campus performance objectives earlier the very beginning of this school year Dr Moran presented to all of you his new superintendent board goals specifically there were academic goals there were safety goals there was a goal of passing a Vader doing a comprehensive salary

120study that's just the executive summary of His goals once a district has new goals you have to have performance objectives written to support those goals so each campus and the district has done so with the new superintendent board goals and those were presented to our District's community- based accountability system that we refer to that council is cbas that was done in November because that Committee of over a hundred stakeholders also serves as our district site based committee so all of that has been done just highlighting those are reviewed the next review for those will be done in Fe February but because the majority of this report is around academics I'll specifically highlight the two academic goals that were a part of that including the robust summer program for reading and math and also the increased

121um goal of students meeting their expected growth measure and grades 3 through eight math and reading English 1 English 2 and Algebra as measured on nwaa or the map assessment we are currently in the middle of the Year Administration window we will be reporting to you all when that window closes it closes at the end of January so you will receive additional information but those um performance objectives tie to those board goals okay another component of statute is that each district reports on their special education intervention stage and determination status last year when the state released our taper reports our special education intervention stages were not released these are only for districts not for individual campuses we have known in St Angelo ISD for the last two years that special education is what we refer

122to as a major focal area or a big rock so we've emphasized a lot of resources from professional learning for our staff for differentiation and also in resources we have received the 2324 determination status we are in what's called needs assistance because we need to increase our performance passing rate for special education students on the star assessments um we just met with ta last last Friday we shared our plan while we actually had the highest performance level in the area of reading language arts for grades tested our plan which we began last year uh knowing that we needed to improve in that area we made the most gains and we explained to the Texas Education Agency that we did not want to abandon that plan and just move for a mark to improve in other

123content areas because we needed more time if you don't have strong readers it will impact all your other content areas the state agreed and said that there was a very well-written plan as the growth was seen from last school year we just have continued progress to make also in full transparency as Safety and Security is a top priority of the school district the other reason why we were needs assistance for special education was because of removals of special education students for disciplin um excuse me disciplinary reasons it is the district's first priority to make sure students are safe in a classroom so if it is a mandatory violation of the code of conduct special education or not the student will receive the appropriate discipline consequence um but please no for mandatory offenses and discretionary if

124you have students in those subpopulations and they're removed that can come back for a district for needs assistance so specifically on that report we had 2,135 students in special education with total removals for 1,114 now what that does for us is we look at every one of those disciplinary placements again if they were mandatory we 100% support the Safety and Security of the other students in the classroom and also the safety of that special education student involved in the discipline and Fracture if they were discretionary then we look at ways in which we could possibly assign discipline through another manner or if it needed to remain as it was that's how you break it down it's just very important because sometimes the public doesn't understand that there are special subpopulations resulting in further actions for

125districts and that's one such example which leads into the next portion on ADD District giving information on violent or criminal incidents that is something that each School District must report these are goes back to Safety and Security in last year's report the district had 13 terroristic threat incidents assault of District employees 15 and assault of non-district employees 54 so all of those being mandatory placements which the code of conduct was upheld because of the severity of the incident this is not um a requirement of that report we want the education for parents in the community vaping or ecigarettes has become a growing issue for a number of years and long-term research and consequence um for individuals Health it's not fully published but when we say we're looking at that we're looking at ways to educate

126students to educate families this is definitely an area where it takes everyone's help ecigarettes last year there were 280 incidents so often times those are hard conversations when an administrator has to call home it's not about the discipline as much as it is the long-term safety of their child and those are the conversations we want to promote with our families and also a ways in which we're so lucky within St Angelo in this community and having strong partnership Partnerships excuse me um adak is one of many that we work with on a regular basis about educating and understanding so we just really want to stress to families to have conversations with their children and maybe sometimes to go in their children's things when their children don't always know to make sure that they're making wise

127and safe choices another component of the statute is that a district reports on students performance in postsecondary institutions so there is a report released by the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board um by county and district and measured by grade point average so for every High School the following year there's a report for students um letting districts know how their students did in their first year after After High School so we will give you some information to meet this requirement specifically for Central High School from the graduates of 2022 there were 770 graduates reported with 399 of those not being found meaning they could not be tracked After High School uh and well not found and then 11 not trackable there were 16 of those reported to attend an independent college and university 84 of those

128reported to attend a 2-year public college and 260 of those graduates who were reported to attend a four-year Public University then further data is available by grade point average for each one of those with very quickly those in two-year public colleges less than 38 had a GPA lower than 2.0 12 had a a GPA between 2.0 and 2.49 four GPA of 2.5 to 2.99 11 of a 3.0 to a 3.49 and then 14 higher than a 3.5 for a four-year Public University 59 had a GPA of lower than a 2.0 22 of a 2 .0 to a 2.49 2.5 to 2.99 was 41 52 of a 3.0 to a 3.49 and then 81 of greater than a 3.5 so when looking when we talk about the mission of St Angelo ISD in producing Future Ready

129graduates whether that be college career or military there's just some snapshot data as they enter their first year for Lake View High School School graduating class of 2022 was 179 98 of those were not found two were not trackable two attended an independent college and university 30 a 2-year public college and 47 a four-year Public University of the 2-year public College 12 reported to have a GPA of 2.0 or lower 4 2.0 to a 2.49 three of a 2. 5 to a 2.99 five of a 3.0 to a 3.49 three of higher than a 3.5 of those attending the four-year Public University 14 had less than a 2.0 nine of a 2.0 to a 2.49 four of a 2.5 to a 2.99 10 of a 3.0 to a 3.49 and eight of higher than a

1303.5 so again just a snapshot if Future Ready graduates another component of the statute is that each district provides an update on its Early Childhood for literacy and math and also around college career military and Readiness so as you all know we have four sites that have prek we also had restructuring of our instructional coaches but throughout the restructuring we still have one instructional coach that supports our early childhood so our prek from the very earliest and then this year to really compliment and commend all of our instructional coaches working on all 15 of our elementary campuses and having content specific Support also we have a director of early childhood and she and our instructional coach both attended the Texas Association for the education of young children conferences to stay current the district is also

131work working to meet all the indicators of a highly qualified prek program so if you have not heard or seen yourself there is a prek Facebook page specific to seic prek and also monthly newsletters that are going out so we'll be getting ready to enroll if you have anyone in the community um that wishes to be a part of those programs please share in terms of a college career military ready CTE is a point of Pride within the District that's one way in which the district sets itself apart I know that there's individuals in the audience who um work directly with the chamber with the workforce we have students being hired right out of high school and it's uh changing the trajectory for their families today we had our CT ambassadors from our high schools

132down at our middle schools talking to them about the Transitions and it's not just having conversations hey go down this pathway because my friend is in there it's also using um a curriculum and program to really look at their aptitudes and long-term match their strengths the rest of the week they will be at lonar and at Glenn having those conversations so that's a lot of information I know very quickly and that very extensive report on performance let's talk about some highlights so the the state of Texas changed the star assessment in the 2223 school year at the same time there was change with an se's curriculum and instructional department and with many uh directors and campus leaders throughout the district as well that very first year the district knew that there had to be immediate

133training on the change of the state assessment itself when we talk about having areas that we still want to focus on for high school or why are kids not reading at grade level you don't just go address it at the high school level you have to start at the very foundational level so 22 23 a lot of training about the change in the state's expectation last year districtwide a major uh focus and instructional support in the primary grades where students learn how to read so districtwide a new curriculum was implemented in grades K through two in the 23 24 school year and then this year that has expanded all the way through fifth grade so while the Improvement in performance is not where we would like it to be by any means for all grade

134levels we are already seeing Improvement in the earliest testing grades in the area of reading and most importantly in the area of annual growth as I'll point out we know that our students in saisd we have a higher at risk rate than the state as a whole but when we have students in our system and we can keep them with high quality curriculum and support with our staff we're as able to close those gaps attendance is another area attendance is reported two years out coming out of the pandemic this is not specific just to St Angelo ISD it's across the state and Across the Nation if students aren't in school we can't give them what we need uh still coming out of that taking multiple years it will take all of our wonderful partners that

135we have to help really close those gaps so while it is two years out we've done a lot District why to really focus on attendance and we're seeing some initial gains and we'll continue to report for that I want to point out on this report attendance is reported for students in grades 1 through 12 and then the issue of chronic absenteeism that takes all students once they're first enrolled so prek K those primary grades when students enter your school buildings we need them in school and chronic absenteeism is students enrolled for 10 or more days missing 10% or more of a school year so we are seeing improvements but we have further gains that need to be made in the area of college career and mil military ready do you see from that report or

136if you've ever been on a high school campus the state requires us to test a lot to keep students motivated for every test they have maybe you have a high schooler yourself or have or soon will or have a friend it's really hard to motivate them for the multiple tests that come their way but when you look at St Angelo ISD and college ready going back to that mission of the district with the district being at 78.7% of college ready graduates versus the state at 61.9% on page 23 we will fully own the work that we need to do need to have done but we are producing students that are college ready and then dual credit and our um opportunities for our students and comparison to the state as a whole that just really complement

137the wonderful Partnerships we have with Angelo State and Howard but we have more that we can tap into um also if you look at page 28 and 29 of your report and I alluded to this earlier the district and the state are very comparable on economic um disadvantaged percentages but it's the atrisk percentages so the district at a whole is at 58.5% whereas the state is at 53.2% we know that means that we have some other barriers to work through and we fully believe we can do that by taking advantage of all the resources we have you're discussing right sizing of Elementary campuses that's why I really encourage some exploration of some other Elementary campuses across the state when we have extremely small Elementary campuses we can't utilize our resources as effectively when you have

138two per grade level to PLC when you have two per grade level and you need auxiliary support staff but they have to go to 14 other campuses in a time when we're short human capital that poses some challenges so the fact that we're having conversations about right sizing is a positive however sometimes there's a misconception of when you right size you won't be able to maintain small class size ratios as you'll see on page 30 of that report the district is very much in line with the state on the class size ratios so having a right siiz Elementary does not remove meeting your ratio requirements from the state for prek all the way through fourth grade of 22:1 and fifth grade those ratios change so you can see we're very much in line the differences

139fully running effective um campuses and all areas Focus areas we know without a doubt that mathematics is a focus area for the district I gave you um the recap of the timeline of what's been done with curriculum when we first addressed the area of rla at the youngest levels so this school year the 2425 school year the district rolled out support for grades 3 through five and high quality instructional materials in math and also Algebra 1 it wasn't that we oops sorry about that it wasn't that we skipped the other grades the high quality instructional materials were not available from the state at that time we just got ahead for Algebra 1 because we knew that our student performance was below where we needed it uh for or not needed it where we wanted it

140because we want all of our students to be at their very best also another Focus area as I've said throughout the discussion is the area of special education special education in the state of Texas means just that students receiving both accommodations and modifications to meet their learning styles but its differentiation as a whole which also addresses our gifted and talented Learners who have unique smartness and gifts that we need to make sure we're differentiating in our classrooms and also our EB students and then lastly a continued Focus area for the district is safety pointed out the violent um incidents we want students and staff safe in our schools it's a different time with behavior than any other time in education uh that's also one of the board goals and we will continue to remain focused

141around the Safety and Security lens so that is a whole lot of information that I tried to summarize for all of you but I do want to remind you that should you are any stakeholder watching we have a point of contact and we can schedule follow-up conversations and more detailed discussions because it is so much information and I would be happy to do that with anyone wishing to do so first off thank you Dr Gomez great presentation and um as Bo we know the work that is being done and that sometimes it it's just slow sled for a little while and um we but we do appreciate how much you and your whole team are diving in and working to get that work done and um the fact that we actually have curriculum that's approved

142by the state instead of having to wait for that high quality curriculum has obviously been helpful um any questions for Dr Gomez I was reading a lot of this stuff and um and I got on at home to to look look at it and there's a lot of positives in there and then there's a lot of room for work for improvement but like you were talking about the um the ccmr the college career military ready students you know we went from 74.9 last year to 81.3 and then the state average is 76.3 so we're doing good on that there's a lot of things I mean like you said the college ready students you know we're graduating kids that are ready and but there's a little things like you said mathematics reading you don't just teach

143kids how to read right off the bat they're not going to pick it up especially when they're not ready when they come in from kindergarten or whatever so but yeah there's room for improvement and when you start reading this it makes good reading for nighttime if you get really if you really get tired but um it'll uh it'll show you a lot of Stu a lot of positives in there so but thank you for that report I think what I'd like to with that Mr gagos is that while there's things to be celebrated there's definite grows as well and when anyone thinks we don't have room for improvement we don't need to be here we're fully committed to thinking inside a box outside a box with no box so that we can make improvements um

144but there is good to celebrate and we have a lot of work to do the good thing is we have amazing staff who aren't afraid to roll up their sleeves and get to work so I really can't um compliment the amazing teachers we have in our campuses that work with students on a regular basis I just I just want to highlight three things that I think it's important to know and that is um and Farah you're so right we never settle no one a teacher never an educator doesn't settle until I mean we're the best that there is and that we can be and um we you talked about you know growth and this report it'll show that but you don't truly see the growth until you have that conversation with a child and I

145know those conversations are happening this week and last week and next week we Maps testing and I know that teachers have met with their students in a face-to-face one-on-one conversation and said this is what you did last time what is your goal and this is where we're going to get and I've um heard children celebrating um that their growth and um the other thing is if anyone has never gone to the TA website and looked at a STAR test the amount of reading on any math science any test is just over the top so um the fact that we're focused on the reading is the foundation is the key to every test you take and lastly I want to say this Stars State mandated we take it we we go in there we are excited

146but it is one test on one day we're not perfect there are days that children aren't perfect so we take that with Grace and when um maybe a child isn't as successful as they thought they should be we always celebrate their smartness any other questions all right thank you Dr Gomez all right so next um is item seven our agenda it's cons sent items A and B it's our minutes from our December meetings and bid 24-24 um do we have any questions or comments regarding this we talked about it last week pre agenda move for approval Dr King have a motion from Mr dendle do I have a second I'll second so a motion from Mr dendle and a second from Dr Mills any further board comments or questions all in favor say I I

147all against say the same motion passes 70 all right so next we have considered campus attendance areas closure expansion of Reagan Elementary School attendance boundaries to include current attendance area of Sanders Elementary School effect of July 21 July 1st 2025 and I want to thank you all for bearing with us while we get through the business of this meeting so thank you all for staying here um who's presenting on that well there's not necessarily a formal presentation other than the comments that um you know that I made last last week about the building being old and uh the structural Foundation being compromised um I our staff doesn't feel that it would be in the district's best interest to recommend to you all to repair sanjino uh for a couple of reasons we're talking about um

148the declining enrollment and we're talking about the size of San jino and Reagan together now um is is still small and it just doesn't U make sense for us to to try to repair a building that's 118 years old now I will make a comment that uh at the beginning of the facility of advisory committee process it was my hope that we could consider a new constructed elementary school and I don't know that it was intended necessarily to replace sanjino or Reagan or both but uh just a new one for that uh Community the cost of a new Elementary is $45 million and when we talked about the cost of one Elementary School at $45 million that would benefit fit about 450 Kids versus trying to rightsize all of the elementary schools eventually in sisd

149uh the facility advisory committee looked at uh a phase one which is has been presented tonight and a phase two that actually contains more improvements for existing elementaries with facilities that are not quite as old and I think the reality is uh that as our district lines in enrollment we're going to have to get honest with ourselves about the Staffing and the ability for us to uh house the students we have in the facilities we have now with some upgrades and improvements I would love to build a new elementary school I I don't think when you think about the tax impact and the amount of students that that would uh benefit compared to the overall upgrades that that we would do across the district uh I think common sense is we need to use what

150we have and you know this sounds crude but if you have an older an older human being uh let's say a 98y old man or woman who fractures their hip there's a decision to make whether you go you know into surgery to try to to repair that hip or you live the life you can with what you've got and I I am new to this community and I have great respect for the people that have been here I will say respectfully um this is not going to be an easy thing for any Community if the board were to approve this but in the long run for the district as we decline an enrollment and as we try to staff better for our kids you know I think at the beginning of the year we had

15118 classrooms without a teacher and so we put substitutes in those classrooms we have the teachers in our district we have too many classrooms with very very small enrollment and if we if we fill those classrooms not to overflowing but fill those up we could take the teaching staff we have now and plug the holes and have higher quality teaching for our students across the board so we're talking about a financial impact to the district and it's not all about the almighty dollar yes we're going to save money if we do this but that's not the the end goal the end goal is to better provide for all of our students to put highquality teachers in front of those kids and uh we can do a better job if we move that direction and it's

152not just for uh the sanino community and um several of those parents I've talked to and several have spoken to tonight and and I respect their opinions I respect them for voicing their opinions but uh this is not going to be the final step we're going to have to do some more consolidating you heard me say that last week there needs to be at least two more and uh we can we can operate better as a district we can provide a better education by doing that is it hard yes um and I'm sorry for that but I would recommend that the board consider this tonight so you know obviously uh none of us got on the board to close any schools um I think every person on this board is here to to serve the

153students in San Angel ISD um and we talk about saving money but we're not saving money we're deploying money where it needs to go we're trying to deploy money to discipline to reading to math we're deploying money so that we can get the most impact for every kid in this District okay and we need to be able to give support to our students there was a report it sticks in my head but like there was a report of the kids who come into saisd as a kindergarten 133% of those kids are where the State thinks a kindergartener should be we start at 13% so we have some challenges as a community and as a community we have to pray that we have the wisdom and the strength to make tough decisions um our community just

154voted for prop a because they believe our teachers do make a difference like they believe in security for our kids and they believe that our people are impacting their kids um and now we have to continue to work with our community to make sure that we're put in everyone in the best situation possible and so I'm going to make a motion to approve the I want I say it correctly so one second to to approve the current attendance boundaries of Reagan Elementary to include the attendance area for San J Elementary per policy FC local and that Sano elementary school should be closed effective July 1 2025 do I have a second or any other board comments Dr K I've been sitting here all meeting writing down a million fiscal reasons why we close schools or

155do something different um you know we're responsible to our employees we're responsible to our students we're also responsible to our taxpayers but you know this this board cares about kids and it hurts my heart to even to even think about this but you know with with life comes challenges change disruption and I'm sorry that's happening at this moment but um long term I think we're going to put kids in a better place by moving these kids from from San Jack Sano to Reagan at this point and I would second that motion is there any further board comments or questions I mean I'd like to I'd like to make a comment I mean I both me and my wife we went to elementary school here we I understand the emotional attachment to these schools I really

156do when I told my wife last week about she went to Buie about buoy potentially being on the chopping block and she was it's it's sad there's there's there's no way to cut this there's no way to make this no way to sweeten the pot it's a sad thing um but San justo the building itself is clearly at a critical fail point I mean it is reached its end of life and that's just where we're at do I think Reagan moving the kids to Reagan is a forever is it without its own problems is it a perfect solution does it not have its own issues that we'll have to work through obviously it's it's not perfect I mean we we're dealing with what we have uh it doesn't make sense to invest a lot of

157financial resellers into a building that's clearly failing that especially when we have a district that has mountains of facility issues it just doesn't seem reasonable I mean I I agree with I agree with the superintendent's decision to not try and put more money into something that's just not going to help especially when we have room for the kidss in other building in other places um is this part of the do we think Reagan is the forever home is this part of the master plan we don't have to figure that out tonight tonight why the why did Sano fail that's an exercise and futility it it doesn't matter at this point the the building is no longer uh capable of housing children for school so um like Dr Kingman mentioned none of us got on the

158board to close schools but um unfortunately I I I think that's that's just where we are we're doing we're making the best decision what we have at the moment so okay okay now um I I just have a few comments to to the people there at s and like I said I've been doing this for 20 years okay and s s has been brought up several times s before several times before we did the work on it in 08 the 08 Bond okay it had problems then okay all we did was slap a bandaid on it and that's what I said back then I thought we're just putting a bandaid on this thing you know there were different ways we could have done it I think but we didn't okay I've been reading stuff there's

159a lot of things that could have led to this but the bottom line is that it's just like like I said it's it's at the end of its life I mean you've got peers down there at the bottom support peers that are just unbelievable I mean we went down there to see them they're we went down to that base it scared me being down there you know it's just and then you know and the one thing I noticed that you walk into that building on the inside and it's a beautiful well-kept building but the bottom holds a lot more more and it scares me that's what scared me was going okay what's going to happen one day yeah we got our kids in there that's great we wanted to do what you want and this

160is what I was thinking I go you know why do I want I know people I know the attachment but do you really want to leave them in there when it's we don't want to go to that building no well I mean and that's not my but that's not my point right now I'm not I'm not I'm trying to talk about I'm trying to talk about the point of why should we keep that building open guys are just no we're not trying to cover up no mistakes that building's 115 years old there's no mistakes about it I mean it's just old I mean there's a lot of things that are old about it I mean you know the the peers and the peers that hold it up the support peers those were ported in 1909

161they weren't even requiring reinforcement rebar in them you know there's things on there that that just scare me and then you're less than an eighth of a mile from a railroad track that's been used since 1888 that vibrates the ground there's a lot of things that work into it a lot of things and you look at that building you're going it is a on the inside it is beautiful now what we do later on you know what we do later on like resizing elementaries possibly doing another one you know you never know but we do have the 45 million dollar Choice there for resizing schools and getting the kids to where we need to get them to provide them better things other than wasting money I think on trying to keep something alive that has

162died that's that's how I see it and and not the not the spirit of the school that's not what's died that's that's gone with you it's gone with you to Reagan right now okay but I'm talking about the outside structure what keeps it just there and you know I have no problem anymore I've got no problem with this because we need to start fixing instead of just CPR in all the time we need to fix it and quit putting Band-Aids on it if it comes to the point where we knock it down and build another one so be it okay but that's just it that building has has come to its to the end of its life I mean it leans it sags even if you were to fix whatever is there it's going to

163do it again and then what you do fix there on the bottom the middle is going to be warped and messed up so there there's a lot of things there that just one's going to lead to another and we're going to be having this conversation again in two years or three I guarantee you we would so so that's that's my that's my thought on the whole matter any other board comment I just have a quick comment I just want to recognize that our two principles are here from San Jack and Reagan and um you have done a tremendous wonderful job this year and every student that's walked through those doors know that they are loved their teachers have taught them and for that happening so quick and for the job you do I want to

164thank you Pam you took the words that I was going to say to thank the principles that are here from San Jack and Reagan and um you know Taylor mentioned earlier um Dr Kingman mentioned earlier making the most impact for every student and you know I think back to when we when we voted to keep the school open a year and a half ago and at the time I thought we were making the right decision um and I I think you know if we could have had a Looking Glass and look ahead and see what was going to happen I think it's much harder this way the way it happened this year where having to with this kids having to leave just before school started and make an adjustment without being having the you know

165without being able to expect that um I think I think that made a diff an impact in a different way that we didn't want want to make and um looking back I wish we decided to close the school back then you know we didn't know that back then you know but um and I just think when we think about the the safety of our students that's one of our top priorities um I even if we were able to fix the supports and make the school better and make it safe for the kids to walk in the doors long term is that providing safety for our students and that's that's what's causing me to move the other way any other board comments or questions this is a hard decision very hard believe me but as you

166say we need new elementary schools we need new schools I have faith that this is only the beginning for a better future for our kids every kid deserve deserve the best and I think what we decide tonight is going to be the best for our kids any other board comments or questions so we have a motion for myself and a second from Mr dindle all in favor say I I I all against say the same motion passes 70 um we're now going to move to item C which Dr s's can help us with the consider our targeted Improvement plans we did that one good evening Dr Kingman Dr Moran and members of the board um this evening I am providing a school Improvement overview for St Angelo ISD and we are going to ground ourselves

167in our lovely Pac-Man charts um from what you can see uh provided to us by lead forward because I think that will ground ourselves um in how our campuses are identified for school Improvement so if you'll pay uh particular attention to domain three that's the closing the gaps column um this is what Texas Education Agency utilizes to align with the criteria area of uh schools for improvement under the every student succeeds act Essa at the federal level um to identify campuses that need comprehensive support and Improvement as well as targeted support and Improvement and just as a a brief refresher uh for campuses to be identified as targeted um they have to have a student group or student groups that misses uh their targets in at least uh the same three indicators for at least

168three consecutive years in a row um in order to be identified as comprehensive this is where uh te will take a look at our Title One campuses um based on those closing the Gap scores and um those campuses are ranked by tea and um tea determines which of those campuses fall um in the bottom 5% for each School type and that's how a campus um is determined as comprehensive support in St Angelo ISD we have um campuses that H have been identified for both for comprehensive um we are looking at buoy Elementary Fannon Elementary Lake View High School belir elementary and Goliad Elementary for targeted support we are looking at Lin Lincoln Middle School Crockett Elementary and lonar Middle School tea does require that every campus that is identified as comprehensive or targeted um they

169are required to submit a targeted Improvement plan to tea um every year just to um report on the strategies that each of those campuses are utilizing to address um the the closing the gaps needs for each of those specific campuses um it is a uh two-way feedback process and involves not only tea but but also our local education um service center as well um a tip plan includes uh again strategies for in enhancing student performance and closing those gaps there are strategic conversations um around data components and evidence that we look at to ensure that we are number one targeting the right areas for each of those campuses and we are measuring the impact of those strategies as well as the impact of the systems that we have in place that will get us the

170student outcomes that we desire a tip plan is extremely important um as it help really and truly drives the work and the conversations um over the course of the Year regarding the the student performance and our opportunity areas for um growth and we we also prioritize gaps um in our school systems and practices as well there are two predominant High leverage School Improvement strategies um that we are focusing on and um predominantly across the board not just on campuses that have been identified for school Improvement but the majority of our campuses have engaged in an effective schools framework diagnostic um we have campuses that have opted in it's not a requirement but they want to know where their areas um of strength are and where their opportunities for growth are um we also participate in

171an instructional ership development through uh Texas instructional leadership that is facilitated by our friends at Region 15 um the best way to describe the ESF Diagnostic and the Texas instructional leadership pathway is basically the ESF diagnostic is like a diagnosis for a campus and then when you're working with region 15 through the teal pathway that is the um the Cure that is the the focus where you're you're going to spend your time as a campus leader and they'll be provided the tools and the professional learning to address those areas um I think another big point of consideration is to bring um attention again to the implementation of the high quality instructional materials that our district has already um implemented we've taken a huge leap forward and are definitely ahead of the curve um in regards

172to that um at the elementary level we are um going to utilize we are utilizing amplify now but um in all things education names and acronyms can sometimes change on us but uh blue bonnet reading and math for elementary um hmh science for elementary and carnegi um for Algebra 1 at the secondary level so again we're already ahead of the curve um when it comes to that work just kind of providing an overview of what the effective schools framework is because it does Drive the school improvement process this is the core um the framework it's based on years of research and it is um essentially encompassed in five levers so lever one is strong School leadership and planning uh lever two is Strategic Staffing lever three is positive School culture lever four is highquality instructional

173materials and assessments and lever five is effective instruction so in order for a campus to engage in a diagnostic we actually have an outside entity um an unbiased outside entity actually perform that diagnostic so it's not any of us on the internally that is looking at these these areas on each of the campuses which I think is a bonus um the diagnostic findings um that we uh looked at after all of our campuses or the majority of our campuses engaged in those Diagnostics we found that the prioritized Focus areas um all fell under lever five in effective instruction and more specifically in the areas of professional development for effective classroom instruction as well as building teacher capacity through observation and feedback Cycles those capacity building strategies two of those Keystone strategies are offering targeted professional

174learning not only for our teachers but also building capacity in our instructional leaders on campuses the other um strategy key strategy is the implementation of a coaching INF infrastructure now this is something that has been in the works for well over um the past year and a half um but with a coaching infra infrastructure in place um the best way to describe it is that everyone has a coach because in saisd we have a growth mindset even our principal supervisors have a coach from region 15 each principal is coached by a principal supervisor and in turn those principles are coaching and building capacity not only in their assistant principles but also building capacity in their teachers as well in order for principles in our campus leadership teams to have that capacity um we have to

175provide targeted professional learning and put those tools in the administrator toolboxes to make that happen because the individuals closest to the teachers that will augment that Student Success are the teachers um they're the closest to the students so we realize the significant need um with the coaching infrastructure as well um we realized that scope of impact is a huge thing we would love to um clone all of our amazing instructional leaders but unfortunately we don't have that technology quite yet so we have to increase our scope of impact by building capacity in our other campus leadership team members as well so we can do do that with the the implementation of the coaching infrastructure um we are engaging in uh weekly bi-weekly and monthly coaching conversations with principles we are monitoring um numerous data points

176and looking at evidence to make sure that the systems that um we have in place on campuses are actually effective um because really and truly if if you remember those prioritized Focus areas for not only our our campuses that have been identified in school Improvement but across the board um are definitely targeted professional learning and observation and feedback Cycles um if you're ever curious I could talk to you all not long about the research behind this but I will spare you but just in case you are um curious um again our practices are grounded and rooted in research um one thing I I do want to to leave you with is um all of our actions and initiatives in saisd at the district and the campus level level they're not just driven by compliance I

177know a targeted Improvement plan is a requirement but at the end of the day the components in that targeted Improvement plan are going to be driven by things that really make a difference for students on campuses as well as teachers um so we are committed to engaging in best practices across the board at every campus any questions no I was oh go ahead Amy go ahead now I was just going to make a comment that we we we I guess the the what you were saying how we are working on this but the schools that weren't included the ones that met the criteria and all that so we'll still keep doing the same thing we're doing there yes sir absolutely because it's what's best for we got a lot more that that met it the

178ones that didn't so okay thank you yes sir I wanted to thank you for all your all your work on that and I know that these targeted imp Improvement plans take a lot of effort time and effort um my I guess my question is the change of our high quality instructional material from Amplified to Blue Bonnet um in reading and math and um I don't know how much others have researched but it's pretty controversial um and I I kind of thought that we would have some board discussion on that before we voted Ed for that so um I don't know if I don't know where the rest of the board is we haven't ever talked about it but um I would like for there to be some discussion on that um I'll jump in really

179quick there will be board discussion starting in February about the long-term planning uh for the district including some detailed information because I completely agree that there has been some controversy presented there's also been some information partial information released as I spent over an hour today just on uh House Bill 1605 and these instructional materials so sometimes information gets shared um with the public um before full details have even been shared with Educators so it is our responsibility and obligation to give you that information and we'll be coming forward starting in February so if I'm sorry so if we approve this target Improvement plan tonight does that does that approve using Blue Bonnet in reading and mouth what Dr self was saying because first of all we don't have blue bonnet in this school year so

180you're approving the plan with the strategies for the professional learning um that it we are undergoing which does include currently we are using amplify and Eureka blue bonnet learning is the equivalent with the Texas standards and the tees but those are not in our campuses or in our schools yet yet they're not even available until the 25 26 school year right I'm sorry I understand that I just want to I just want to and I appreciate that and I understand what you're saying the plan is specific to the strategy though we can't we can't approve materials that we aren't in possession of right and I guess my question was just because there it's listed in the strategy so I I just want to make sure that of course I want to improve approve your work

181there's no doubt there but I just I want to make sure that before I approve it that we are not approving BL on it currently before we've had a chance to really look at it and discuss it right it will be shifting if it's approved but currently it's Amplified so I think it's just important to realize that the strategy is high quality instructional materials for sure okay thank you very much yes ma'am sorry we can't take any comment right now thank you though um not a comment but I yeah I'm sorry so it's amplifi my apologies it's amplifi amplify and blue bonnet are the same comp the same thing yes but blue bondet is Texas specific yes Texas specific amplify yes sir is now blue bonnet yes sir and so if we had a plan

182with amplify if we continue to improve our plans with amplify which we have done for the last two years it will shift that would shift automatically to Blue Bonnet yes sir if we decide to go with a different high level that would also change if at the point in time we discussed that but for this discussion we're really just approving the same thing that we have currently we've been using previously it just the state changed the name on us yes sir and they haven't even released what that is yet that's the chran I know what it is yeah know I'm just saying not so anyway that's the summary of this yes sir I'm I'm just going to make a comment on um what you said that I love lots of things right but um you

183know we talk about plc's and um merging our schools so that our kids can collaborate and what I want our community to see is that we are collaborating from kindergarten all the way to the top and um the kids are collaborating teachers are TC and yall are providing um time for the our principles to collaborate everyone is collaborating for one goal and one purpose and that is to be the best that we can be for our children and I wanted to bring that to light I know you said that but that's truly what we're all about and thank you for knowing that that's important that you know we never stop growing we expect our kids to grow we expect them to set goals we as adults need to model that so thank you absolutely okay

184real quick Farah um you said that in February we're going to meet again to discuss keeping or it's keeping Amplified but becoming blue Bond yes sir to clarify we will be discussing the district selection of high quality instructional materials as there been a change last spring when we went through the process and you all approved we discussed how the prior Proclamation process is no longer so what we had been using was amplify and Eureka blue Bonet learning are from the same parent companies but they're Texas specific and they address the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills for clarity educators are getting full access to the culum but what Dr self was saying we've been on the path with amplifying Eureka and that's how we're ahead because we've had professional learning and a lot of work around

185internalizing the curriculum which the premise behind that is to save teachers time but that is a process when you start new materials but the district does not currently have blue bonnet learning instructional materials they are not even available for purchase at this time they were just approved okay and that was approved on House Bill 16005 you said okay thank you okay everyone good everyone other questions answered okay so we need a motion to uh approve the targeted Improvement plans as presented I'll make a motion to uh approve the targeted uh the tips as presented so a motion from Dr Mills and a second from Mrs Duncan um all any other board comment or questions all in favor say I I all against say the same motion passes 70 next is consider a midyear superintendent evaluation

186we did that under Personnel um in last meeting so I'll make the M motion to just approve the midyear evaluation of the superintendent as discussed in Clos session under chapter 551.074 of the Texas Mo open meetings act I'll second motion for myself and a second from Mr dendle any other board questions or comments okay all in favor say I I all again say the same motion passes 70 um all right and now announcements we have a finance and pre- agenda workshop on February 10th and a regular board meeting on February 18th and with that we are adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.