CorpusRecord 10412

San Angelo ISD School Board Meeting - January 13, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / San Angelo ISD
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Tom Green County, TX
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,292 words · about 24 min
Collected
2026-06-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening and welcome my name is Taylor Kingman as president of the Board of Trustees of the San Angelo Independent School District I would like to welcome all of you who are present at tonight's pre- agenda board meeting we appreciate your interest in the activities of our students and The Business of sasd all items that will be discussed at our meeting this evening have been posted as required by state law also as you may be aware our board meets a minimum of two times per month and most of the items on our agenda this evening will be discussed tonight and voted upon at our regular board meeting as members of the sisd Board of Trustees we are here to set goals listen to reports from our superintendent approve budgets contracts and Personnel appointments and to

002make policy for the district please keep in mind that our meeting is a meeting of the Board of Trustees held in public and not a meeting of the public however we do have a public comment item on our agenda that allows anyone present who wishes to speak to our board team on an item that is not on our action agenda or an action item on the agenda an opportunity to do so please provide your name and contact information and the specific topic you wish to address on a public comment form located at the back of the room please listen carefully and comply with the following rules so we can move through this part of the meeting efficiently each speaker will be given a total of three minutes the district will provide an official timekeeper you'll

003be notified when your time is up please respect the privacy of others and refrain from identifying students employees or other community members by name disruption of the meeting will not be tolerated at any time and comments on any subject whether positive or negative must be courteous and respectful comments are limited to the specific topic you indicated on the form you filled out and any speaker with a specific complaint about District employee decision or operational issue should present that complaint through the approp appropriate mechanism which is the district's formal grievance process if you have a pending grievance please remember that you will not be permitted to speak on that grievance during public comment also please understand if you offer public comment that the board cannot reply to you except to thank you for your comments since

004the matter has not been posted for discussion I ask that you please refrain from talking while others are speaking I also ask as I remind my fellow board members to please turn off or silence your cell phones again thank you for being here and for your support of sasd we do have a quorum this evening our entire board team is present um and with that we're going to go ahead and I'm Alas and the pledge of allegiance to the United States in Texas would you please stand we have no public comment this evening um so we're actually going to move into executive session quickly and then we'll come back and do our um agenda we're going under Personnel matters 551.074 all right we are back from executive session we're going to slowly get into our

005reports Mr gagos is walking back still but we we took no actions we took no votes um and it is 6:41 all right so now we're going to move forward with our reports and I'm going to turn it over to Mr dindle to conduct our finance and AUD commit Workshop thanks you Dr Cayman we've got a couple of reports tonight first is the district facility strategic planning update I think Dr Brandon is going to help us with that and per chance Dr self at some point not for sure Dr BR Dr keeman board members uh we will um Mr colbach and uh Dr self will be helping as we take a look at our district facility strategic plan planning this evening uh we're going to start with um a conversation we've looked uh good several

006times at the age of the buildings across the district um you've seen this chart the saisd inventory and we talked about how there's not any of the facilities from 0 to 20 years so we really start when we think about the facilities in our district uh from 20 to 40 being some of the newest and then from there 40 to 60 and then 60 to 80 with some over 100 years old we then went from that conversation uh one thing that we haven't brought out uh was the support facilities so as I'll kind of give you a minute to look across the list um and you'll see not only facilities but programs uh Black Shear where our pay program and Tiny Texans are housed our Bridge uh where we have our uh special education students

007up through 21 working on job skills uh Carver we have day Elementary used by Cog um for head of course the District administration food service maintenance then again two elementaries Rio Vista and Sam Houston Sam Houston being the facility that our special education staff diagnos dis s uh are housed in and then of course transportation is there but it it's a city-owned facility uh that is shared and one of the things that you see are a lot of hammers right when you think about uh those facilities and one of the reasons that you that that's the case is when we look at the age of build a number of years old and in particular the elementaries that were built about the same time uh Black Shear day Rio Vista Sam Houston all of those 70

008plus years old uh then we have uh at Bridge or the Portables uh so even the Portables at 34 years old um Carver of course 66 uh the district admin at 34 years old being you know one of the newer buildings and then we have our food service uh that facility at 80 um and so as we look across the district it's like do we have 70 and 80y old facilities with a program that we might be able to move to a 40y old building right to make it better for not only staff and students uh but then buildings that are more efficient and you wouldn't think you'd move a move to a 40-year-old building for efficiency but but when you're operating out of one that's 880 years old it is more efficient so that's

009one of the things that we wanted to kind of um talk about is you know when we when we think about consolidation of campuses uh what are the what are the benefits uh that might could be realized uh for the district and one of those is the discussion about age of facilities we also talked about operational cost we know that two of the oldest buildings in the district are San jento and Reagan at 114 years old uh and then you see that the operational cost per student um at8 and $9,000 to teach the child for a school year uh versus when you go down the chart and look at some of the other uh elementaries that are newer uh or more students and you see that cost drop the 6160 is the line where that's

010how much we are paid by the state of Texas to teach a student 6160 for the year and so if half of those campuses are above that line it makes it very difficult to have a proper maintenance program things of that nature that you realize uh by being able to bring that cost per student under the line we couple that with uh shrinking enrollment um we've looked at this each year as we do the budget uh we budget that's how we uh receive funding from the state right taxes and the number of students uh so as that number has dropped uh we know at one point it was 15,000 uh but now we're looking at coming back from the Christmas break 12,900 so we've almost realized that 1% drop we felt like it was leveling

011uh but we almost see that 1% drop uh at the Christmas break and so we're looking at probably a 1.5 it's kind of going to be the estimation at the moment the 1.5% uh by the time we get to the end of the year and Mr Colin Bach's going to continue that conversation with enrollment thank you Dr Brandon just a couple of slides um from our the report from our demographer uh this first one is the um it's an overlay of the local birth rate uh with our kindergarten enrollment one thing to notice is that the to show the correlation the birth rate is is uh it's moved up so that's the five years prior so those two numbers are showing basically the same group of students so uh if you look at 2024 that

012birth rate is from 5 years earlier to show that that's the group of students that then enrolled this year so um you can kind of see the correlation there between that birth rate which when you look at that demographers report it's the one thing that sticks out that um is the primary reason for the grad ual decline in um enrollment we do have obviously the numbers uh the birth rate numbers projected out so there are two years ahead and that continues to to be the case we will still see when this decline uh really began we will still have about four years left of those students that are coming into high school now so that those smaller kindergarten classrooms we have another four years of that effect that's going to be happening because that original

013when you see that decline start happening however many years ago that was those students are about to go into the ninth grade so we'll have another four years where our we will be bringing in fewer students then we'll be graduating fewer will be coming into kindergarten then we'll be graduating waiting and then um this is the projection um and really three projections going forward uh based on that demographers report that shows what potentially the enrollment will do over the next I believe um nine or 10 years so you can see that obviously the if the birth rate continues the way it has been on the um trajectory that it's been on and then this also takes into account the next four years of what our of what our um enrollment will be and I believe

014Dr self is next good evening so as we dive into the academic benefits resulting from strategic planning and right sizing particularly at the elementary level we want to First Look at the impact of services to the students um one of the most prominent benefits that we're going to see is um augmented resources for our students um through two two Pathways predominantly funding and Personnel when we think of funding um we think of provided additional um access to technology um specialized equipment and potentially uh specialized support Support Services could also open Pathways for greater access to different and varied extracurricular activities um also when we think about um an ideal size for an elementary uh campus we are looking at uh 600 students and we can still uh effectively accommodate within our master schedule um PE

015and music rotations stem rotations lunch schedules all of the scheduling things with one gym one cafeteria and one area for our campus leadership team so that's a huge positive um and even if our uh elementary schools are sitting around 600 which is ideal and considered larger we're still able to offer those smaller student learning environments through small group instruction targeted intervention um and even Advanced academic Society so we still have the opportunity to offer off that specialized support when and if we need it and finally I think one of the uh biggest benefits is it strengthens professional learning opportunities um for our teachers so that's where you're looking at um in our smaller Elementary campuses where they PLC together and there's two teachers per grade level you would now see five teachers in that grade

016level um planning and networking together um which really and truly impact impacts their efficacy we know that efficacy is the biggest impact on student achievement um that's what research uh tells us and if we offer those opportunities for our teachers to network with more professionals it it only benefit students um the academic advantages of a larger Elementary School um we've kind of touched on this but more teachers per grade level for that collaboration and professional learning and then also Alo on the student side of things um there's more peer-to-peer collaboration and learning exchange opportunities for students I think one of the most prominent um academic advantages is the opportunity to provide um more support services um through full-time like have each Elementary having a full-time assistant principal because not all of our elementes are staffed

017with a full-time assistant principal currently and the other thing to think about too is we currently have vacancies at the elementary level and we know that Elementary is Keystone because at elementary you lay the foundation for students to build their lives on and it we as hard as we try vacancies kind of present a challenge so when we rightsize our elementary schools and decrease those vacancies students win um there's also more staff to facilitate those extracurricular and enrichment activities um and even thinking through taking on on uh Duty assignments as well because safety is our number one priority and then finally more parents and Guardians to volunteer and support organizations such as um PTA so what what does this look like from the budget perspective uh because we've had a half a year um of

018for the year to start you know with our consolidation uh and we talked about this as we were budget planning so right at the beginning uh the 5 FTE um for altaloma and for Austin so that was a $600,000 savings and those teachers weren't gone from the district they were in the district they simply moved to the other campus but just with the efficiencies of taking a larger number of students and dividing them across the Great level at still the state 23 24:1 still relatively small class sizes uh but able to act maximize that instruction and then we went through and then you know when you um take a principal uh and a head cafeteria a custodian librarian nurse you aren't duplicating those in the other campus right so those were able to come off

019uh and then on the new expenses you see where we went back in and then added an AP uh that was either a part-time or not at all at the smaller campus so the addition of uh instru full-time instructional coach full full day uh assistant principal and then our transportation services that we added back uh so that we could make sure that we uh were allocating those resources both expenditures and uh savings and then but so one .4 million in those two closures and that's year after year um and we've talked about what you know uh that saves the district overall when you think about uh expenses to the Future whether that's insurance for all employees or whether that's a possible raise um but um those are some of the numbers that we know and

020we'll be able to um present that at the end of the year so that you can see where that fell under the line of 6160 uh with the consolidation any questions for this group board definitely some challenges ahead as we move through this uh process but uh thanks for that information and uh uh some some good news so thank you anybody else all right going to move forward next to the uh a longterm planning report and that's going to be offered by Dr Moran thank you Mr dentle uh the board's heard an overview from a variety of departments with high level information that can help guide us in the future so I'd like to begin my comments by acknowledging the fact that we're all here for the same purpose and that's our students um and

021the mission of St Angelo ISD is to engage all of our students in a relevant inspiring education that produces Future Ready graduates our 1850 employees know this you can ask them and they should they should be able to recite that to you uh and I bet the board knows it too uh it's our goal to provide teachers and staff the support facilities and encouragement they need to be at their very best for every student every day well everyone in this room is keenly aware of the fact that our community has declined to approve six of the last seven Bond measures for one reason or another and that our district is in desperate need of addressing deferred maintenance and replacing aging facilities the law guiding School finance and bonds is the only mechanism available to public

022schools to engage in major construction and renovation projects that the board is now considering and as a district you heard this evening there are a number of very old support facilities we maintaining that should be considered to be vacated and raised for a variety of reasons such as safety and extraordinary costs associated with maintenance and upkeep at the same time we've have to acknowledge the impact of inflationary pressures on the district we're really thankful for our community stepping up to approve prop a the voter approval tax rate election in November which generates substantial funds for operations and staff moving forward and I'd like to emphasize to the community uh that prop a was not a bond election and I'd also like to stress to the community that uh to support to pass prop a did

023not increase the school tax rate rate but kept it the same it was a restructuring of our taxation to maximize State funding for St Angelo ISD so this evening you've heard for the second time a report of declining enrollment in our district this declining enrollment trend is a state and national phenomenon caused by fewer students entering kindergarten each year resulting in shrinking enrollment as a result our district elected to shutter two elementary schools this year Austin and altaloma this action reduced the number of elementary schools from 17 to 15 saving the district about 1.4 million per year and I'd like to commend the staff of U Migel Fannon Austin and alala for the work they did to pull this off this year and they've done a great job and we're really pleased with how they're

024handling that as of Tuesday January 7th enrollment and saisd fell below 13,000 at 12,936 students just 10 years years ago St Angelo ISD had an enrollment of 15,144 elementary students enrolled on campuses we have seven elementary schools with an enrollment below 400 students one of our elementaries is at 175 students that's Reagan Elementary School as a taxpayer in the district and the individual that the board is hired to ensure stewardship of public funds and resour s ources and to be accountable to you the Board of Trustees I report to you that the current number of Elementary campuses is not sustainable the board has heard concern of our district being overstaffed as enrollment declines will need to be responsive and strategically placed staff to maximize the instructional impact on each student and have the funds needed

025to provide meaningful pay raises and to maintain our current facilities so I'm recommending to the board to consider shuttering three elementary schools by the fall of 2027 that's 2 and a half years from now this is whether a bond passes or fails by reducing the number of elementary schools to 12 we can maintain an average of about 57 students per Elementary School this does not take into account the declining enrollment this is not a new conversation in the community and with the Board of Trustees in October of 2022 the board discussed the consolidation plan that included alala and Austin and a possible second round of closures that could include sanino Reagan and buoy I also recommend the board strongly consider the facility advisory committee recom recommendations for a possible bond election for May 3rd 2025

026as a community we're at a Crossroads the future of our city largely depends on the quality of facilities academic rigor and safety we can provide our Public Schools whether a Community member currently has kids in the public school system they choose to homeschool attend a private school or Charter or perhaps they're just retired and have no children or grandchildren in this public school system we all should be concerned about the future of St Angelo ISD and take pride in the success of our Public Schools a successful Public School System only benefits us all I believe it's time for our community to step up and support the public school system for the common good my wife and I have grandchildren in another school district in Texas and I'm thankful the citizens in that District are doing

027what is right by providing appropriate and safe facilities for their children and my grandchildren people may visit our city to see old buildings but parents with kids don't move here to put their kids in Old buildings they want updated facilities that are safe and appropriate for the education of our students it's all about the common good it's my goal and the goal of the district to provide the highest quality of instruction for every student regardless of the campus they attend according to the Texas Education Agency St Angelo ISD currently has five campuses identified as needing academic comprehensive support and Improvement those campuses are buoy Fannon Belair golad and Lake View High School there are three campuses identified as needing academic targeted support and Improvement they're Lincoln Middle School Crockett Elementary and lonar Middle School you're

028going to hear more about this next Tuesday in an academic report so I'm advocating for all of our students by making these recommendations to you I believe every student in our district is blessed with gifts and abilities it's our responsibility to give every student opportunities to be challenged and to grow every student deserves the best we have to offer regardless of the campus they attend so our staff is working on a long range plan to provide the board guidance and options if a bond measure were called and it passes the plan will provide direction to the board if the community fails to support a potential bond this plan will outline the very difficult decisions our community will have will be forced to make in the future this year as a result of the compromise structure

029at Sano we were forced to relocate San Jack students to Reagan Elementary just two weeks prior to the start of the school year as of January 7th s Angelo Elementary has an enrollment of 260 students and Reagan has an enrollment of 175 students together there are 435 students on the Reagan campus the saneso students have been on the Reagan campus all year as difficult as this may be it makes logical sense to begin considering combining those two campuses for the 25 26 school year for several reasons repairing the building a at Sano is not a recommendation this Administration is willing to make to the board due to that building being more than 117 years old through consolidation we can use existing Personnel to fill vacant positions in our district the students of Sano are already

030on the Reagan campus no additional rezoning would need to take place for this consolidation to occur the savings we realize through consolidation can be used to provide meaningful support for our instructional staff and students maintain the facilities we have and assist in continuing to provide meaningful pay increases to saisd staff in the future we can provide a better education to all of the students at Reagan and sanjac by consolidating I'm not asking the board to act on any of this information this evening but feel strongly that through transparency and stewardship the conversations need to be taking place so that's an overview and we want the board to have that information as you begin to consider uh possible bond election uh as the fac has recommended to the board and next Tuesday we're going to be

031bringing more information to help the board sort through what that might look like for a May 3rd election and then the board will have the opportunity to either accept those recommendations modify those recommendations or reject those all together thank you Dr BR as you can see this board has significant significant work moving forward uh and some definite challenges to uh that will truly cause disruption for a season but to make things better in the long run there sometimes there has to be some positive disruption so any other comments from the board uh I just want to say I I appreciate I know our admin team has been working diligently all of y'all to try and come up with a plan that puts San Angelo ISD in the position to provide support to our students to

032provide support to our teachers who um as you know when you hear about discipline or um you know I think we had a report a year ago that 133% of kids came into kindergarten on grade level um there are challenges that we are facing as a district and I appreciate the fact that we're being honest with where we're at as a district and where we need to be and the we also need to be honest about what that impact is on Stan Angelo over the next 20 years uh because this District needs to be a district that provides students with the ability to um succeed in St Angelo and succeed outside of St Angelo and come back to St Angelo and that we're going to have to make some hard decisions in order to support

033our staff and our students appropriately and so I just want to thank y'all for starting that work and it'll be on y'all but also the seven of us with the voting uh ability to look at things over the next several weeks and months because the reality is if we look to pass to call a bond um that date to make that decision will be February 10th and so as a board over the next several weeks we need to be on honest with each other and honest with our community about what we what the do what the district needs what our students need and um what our options are also this board has been uh prudent in providing a balanced budget for I'm not sure how many the last few years or the last 10 15

034years and has not stepped beyond their means whereas 60% of the districts in in the state of Texas are are using borrowed money to to balance their budgets this year and our taxpayers would not take County to us if we stepped out beyond our means to provide uh funds for these projects so our only option is to present bonds to move forwarding and building and building facilities for really it's for not for it's not for me today but it's for the future of the kids in St Angelo that that come three four five 10 10 15 years now because once these buildings are built they're going to go into service for quite a significant time so uh the challenges we Face are great but uh uh it's really it's for the better of San Angelo

035in the long run that we provide for our kids so that they get a great education uh and the best education that s Angelo can offer any other comments okay with that we'll we'll move forward with some report reports uh some only reports because we came back from uh Christmas Vacation early so we've got a couple of reports tonight first of all on uh is our on page six is our tax collections report for November of 24 versus November of 23 again November 24 shows were slightly behind uh November 23 with collections at overall at 4.12% in 24 for the 24 and collections for 23 at 8.86% and I'm not for sure if that's uh the reason if other folks are feeling the same kind of crunch that we feel as they move forward and

036chose not to pay their taxes in November we'll see a significant amount paid in December and then we'll round up to almost probably 95% in January as we move forward but that's our our outlook on our tax collection report so far on page six of a note Mr D just a reminder because we didn't pass because the proposition a was the November 5th election tax uh documents didn't get sent to people till later this year so that's part I think that's part of why we're seeing a decrease in the um accum or the money brought in good good very well man multiple reasons and the only other report we have this month are for uh po reports for December with purchases over $20,000 there are several items in there there's the cost of our audit

037which was approved we have some field maintenance uh some furniture purchasing some Consulting some fiber purchases kitchen equipment for a serving line at one of our elementaries uh map testing uh fire alarm repair occupational and physical therapy some software purchases and uh a tremendous amount of chicken sandwiches and that's in page uh page seven where that report uh is can be found and with that Dr kman that concludes our finance report tonight thank you Mr dendle all right so we're going to move through our proposed agenda for next week um we'll have our invocation our pledges and recognitions um we'll have some information items uh one of not is will be the Mr Roberts will be here with our audit report next week so we'll get that as a report next week um we'll have

038further facility updates similar to what we had tonight but with some specifics from Dr Brandon correct as yes and we probably will add an an an information item um that is not on here right now that may be discussion so that the the board can have discussion with our uh experts to help the board talk about possible proposition packages whether it be one two three and work through that as far as the uh tax structure goes you see that Jeff Rober will be here that's actually I think Robert there's no s on Roberts correct okay yeah so that's a correction but um so we may make that an additional information item for the board as well perfect um and then we will have the public hearing of our uh taper report there's some really good

039things in our taper report and there's some things that um where as Dr Moran mentioned earlier we're increasing our rigor um across the board is something that we need to look into and and um not just look into but make sure that we're getting the results that we um we desire so we'll go through that next week with Dr Gomez um and then um we have some action items uh the audit report will need to stay um Regular the targeted Improvement plans um really do you need to give us or do do we need to give anything to us on that tonight you going to do that next week okay we'll do that as regular as well and making one item consent doesn't really help us we'll just keep miscellaneous item 24-24 we have cons

040the minutes oh the minutes yeah so we'll make uh is is there he is let's hear come on and tell us about bid 24-24 so we can add one more thing to our consent all right bid 22- 24 24 or 24- 024 miscellaneous supplies this is a bid that we put out uh annually to gather all the different miscellaneous supplies that don't fit on our other other bids some of these would be grocery items clothing Electronics housewares small appliances Refreshments that sort of thing uh this year we had I think we had 30 7 responses and we uh recommend the approval of all of them in these different categories any questions any new vendors any new vendors yeah this one's kind of a fluid one where we bring some on and then other ones move

041on to other uh bids uh we did have a couple new ones uh GA Auto Glass was one of them that was a big one that we were concerned about getting on there Sams is probably our biggest one that we use off of this one Sams uh we buy a lot of TVs most of the TVs are bought off of this bid good thank you m chairman you're welcome all right yeah anyone have a problem with that being consent thank you um so announcements we'll have a finance and pre- agenda workshop on February 10th we also have a meeting next week and we'll have a regular board meeting on February 18th any other board comments or questions before we adjourn this evening all right that meeting is adjourn

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.