001good evening and welcome my name is Taylor Kingman and as president of the Board of Trustees of the St Angelo Independent School District I would like to welcome all of you who are presentent tonight's regular board meeting I also welcome those of you who are watching the recording of this meeting online or on our Public Access Channel we appreciate your interest in the activities of our students and The Business of sisd all items that will be discussed at our meeting this evening have been posted as required by state law also as you may be aware our board meets a minimum of two times per month and most if not all items on the agenda this evening have previously been discussed at our pre- agenda board Workshop as members of the sasd Board of Trustees we
002are here to set goals listen to reports from our superintendent approve budgets contracts and Personnel appointments and to make policy for the district please keep in mind that our meeting is a meeting of the Board of Trustees held in public and not a mean of the public however we have a public comment item on every one of our meeting agendas that allows anyone present who wishes to speak to our board team on an item not on our action agenda or an action item on the agenda an opportunity to do so please provide your name and contact information and the specific topic you wish to address on the public comment form located in the back of the room should you want to speak on an issue not on our action agenda please listen carefully and comply
003with the following rules so that we can move through this part of the meeting efficiently each speaker will be given a total of three minutes the district will provide an official timekeeper you'll be notified when your time is up please respect the privacy of others and refrain from identifying students employees or other community members by name disruption of the meeting will not be tolerated at any time comments on any subject whether positive or negative must be courteous and respectful and comments are limited to the specific topic you indicated on the form you filled out any speaker with a specific complaint about a district employee decisional or Opera decision or operational issue should present that complaint through the appropriate mechanism which is the district's formal grievance process if you have a pending grievance being processed by
004the district please remember you're not permitted to speak about the grievance during public comment also please understand if you speak to us on an item not on action agenda that the board cannot reply to you except to thank you for your comments since the matter has not been posted for discussion in compliance with state law these proceedings are recorded and will become part of ssd's permanent legal record in order that the recording will adequately reflect the proceedings I ask that you please refrain from talking while others are speaking and I also ask as I remind my fellow board members to please turn off or so silence your cell phones again thank you for being here and for your support of saisd we do have a quorum this evening uh we have six out of seven
005of us present this evening um and we're going to move forward with our invocation and Kevin Hudson is going to help us with that this evening special guest for 38 years Shelley and I have been honored to be a part of this community and tonight is part of our uh our final time here we could not be more honored uh to have had 38 years uh of this incredible Community uh in this school district and we thank the Board of Trustees now and those who have come before you let's pray father we are gathered here tonight uh to take care of important business and that is the business of our children father a lot of times there are other things that get in the way and Cloud the important business of our children and I
006ask that you would forgive us when we let those things rise above the most important thing that we have and that is the care and the nurture and the education of the children that you place in our care father tonight as we gather as I look at these students that are here I pray that you would plant within them great dreams and Imagination of how you will work in their lives and of all the the good things that you will do through them in the years to come and father for the rest of us help us take the important responsibility that you have placed before us to be people of kindness of truth of goodness and help us to nurture them God I pray that you'll be with this community that this community the St
007Angelo Community we'll step up we'll rally around our children and we'll dream great dreams of the future father thank you for the gifts that you've given us I pray that we will use those gifts wisely in the name of Jesus we pray amen amen thank you now we have some students from belir Elementry we have ephan verella Carson Vasquez Carly Vasquez Magnolia Ramsey Gabrielle jannis zadrian jannis and Aya Eaton if y'all all come up we're going to line up and say our pledges everyone will stand with them and us as we say the pledges salute flag aliance to the flag of the unit States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all honor the Texas flag alance to the Texas one state
008indivisible [Applause] you [Applause] all right we're going to move forward with our agenda now first we have some recognitions and soon is up there to give us some recognitions for sandel Reeds good evening Dr Kingman Dr Moran and members of the board since its launch five years ago our s Angelo Reeds literacy initiative has received incredible support and this year's Reeds Day events again demonstrated its powerful impact s Angela Reeds continues to inspire and unite our community tonight we want to recognize the many Community Partners whose generosity made both St Angelo Reed's day on December 4th and the North Pole pop-up event on December 5th such a success this year we were thrilled to have more than 50 Community Partners join us in championing literacy during our two-day celebration of literacy if you'll direct your
009attention to the monitors you'll see um the names of our wonderful businesses and organizations that volunteered special thank you goes to HB our sangela Reed day partner for gifting every saisd third grade student a copy of the bad guys and spreading even more joy with h buddy at Bradford Elementary additionally 36 volunteers visited other elementaries across the district to host special read alouds making the day even more memorable then on the following day those same Community Partners along with 11 saisd departments pray the chilly weather to bring our North Pole pop-up event to life despite the wind and the cold it was wonderful to see everyone enjoying the festive activities and the Joy on the children's faces the success of s Angela Reed's day would not have been possible without the partners who share our
010dedication to public education and the future of our students we are deeply grateful and we would just like to take a moment and tell them thank you so please join me in thanking these incredible partners for their own way waver and commitment to literacy and their generous support of our s Angelo [Applause] Community our next recognition this evening is for Shelley HUD huddleson uh chief of school leadership and Dr Moran is going to start us off with that well and I'll keep my comments uh brief so the board can make their comments but um some of you were at our reception the afternoon for Shelly and uh Kevin we're glad you were able to join it just seemed like a fitting way to do this tonight it worked out well but uh Shelley Hueston has
011served our district for 29 years as a English teacher at Glenn in central an instructional coach uh a an assistant principal at Central a principal at Bonham and now at the administrative offices for quite some time and her uh Steady Hand her calm demeanor and wisdom have really helped our district so Shelly we've given you lots of comments and thanks tonight this is just another to add in front of the public and uh just to say on behalf of our school district to thank you for 29 years thank you for being so dependable and faithful and wise in your service to sisd thank [Applause] you any further board comments I would since I wasn't able to come to the to your reception um to Shelly and to Kevin um I just wanted to thank you
012both for all that you've done for our community um both of you have been a big part of the community in lots of different areas where I participate so I just wanted to let you know how much I appreciate everything that you both have done and um we you'll be missed in St Angelo and especially for St Angelo ISD um I'll speak to Shelly and Kevin my love for you runs deep and I believe with everything I had that God gave you both gifts and you have used them to your full ability and I know that when you leave here you'll continue that path so thank you both and thank you Kevin I mean Shelly for the years that we work together um I still remember you walking I was teaching and you came to
013Glenn as a student teacher because you decided that's what you were going to do and boy did you do it and you did it well so thank you you'll be missed um obviously we we did have a reception this afternoon and people who have worked with you a lot longer than I have um said a lot nicer things than I can ever say out loud but um what I will say is that uh in the eight years I've known you working here um on this board is that you have put this District above any personal or other desire you have you've made decisions you've made recommendations and you have put this District above anything else professionally and um I just wanted to thank you for your commitment um and like everyone else has said you're
014Steady Hand and um you're going to be missed here in s Angel all right any other so Gerard's going to cry so we're going to keep moving all right so thank you shy uh moving forward with public comments no one has signed up this evening so we're going to move forward with our information items and we're going to start with our uh an information I'm from our facility advisory committee and I think Debbie cross is going to start us off on that thank you very much for giving us the time this evening to uh share with you what we've been working on uh my name is Debbie cross and I am a member of the facility I mean I mean the facility advisory committee and I know a lot of you are probably wondering who
015and what is the facility advisory committee well let me just show you with all of our committee members please stand up the ones that are here we had a group of 60 plus very diverse group of people who are community volunteers who were nominated by their peers and were selected to be on this very important committee and I applaud all of them for all their work so thank you'all very much [Applause] there are doctors lawyers Educators business owners moms dads Granddad grandparents on this committee and we were all have a a commitment to this community and to our schools and to our children we all accepted this task and we took it very seriously and we worked hard we met together we ate together we gathered we toured campuses we col collaborated we made new
016friends and we strengthened old friendships we became educated and informed of the infrastructural and educational needs of our district I would like to thank Dr Moran and our facilitator Elma Mohler for presenting a committee with an opportunity to shape the future of St Angelo and saisd in the thousands of eager children who will benefit from our efforts we believe the committee has put together a f fiscally responsible Bond referendum for consider consideration by the board I was starting to look back and Counting the years that I've been a volunteer for the saisd and it's over 35 years I've been doing something with the school district be knows and um so and and I and I have enjoyed every bit of it and I highly respect our teachers our administrators and our board for all you
017do for our for our children and thank you very much I'm a product of saisd I can I uh attended Austin Elementary Migel Elementary Robert E Lee Junior High Central High School and I'm a graduate of 1975 we T Central was one of the schools that we toured and uh we we saw the Sarah Barnhart theater we saw the gym we saw the practice areas the locker rooms and just a general tour of the campus and it hit me as we were walking around except for the new administration building Central has not changed in over 50 years it is in dire need of up updating and let me tell you it is a security nightmare that school is so we need to do better for our children and this is one of the things that
018was top priority in our decision I have two grandchildren that attend Central High School one's a junior and one's a a senior and uh if any of you here attended Central High School you remember walking in ankle deep or higher water getting to classes when it rained well let me tell you our students are still walking in ankle deep or higher water to get to their classes our students deserve better our community deserves better and that's what we are here to do we believe we have put together a good plan and we need to band together and be the solution for our kiddos thank you for your time and would I now would like to introduce to you my friend and fellow Committee Member Trey Holmes who will inform you on how this committee worked
019thank you and Merry Christmas got to raise the mic just a little bit but don't worry Mary I'll put it back down for you so yeah so so the ladies will bring the seriousness and the facts and I'm here for the color as most of y'all who probably know me um but I have to say speaking of color thank thank you to those of you who read your emails and wore blue in support of this and I'm so happy that that my wife helped me pick out a blue tie to wear to this event but you know speaking of blue we saw these students here that were here earlier tonight to lead us in the pledges of Allegiance and they were you know they were the focus of our group and as a matter of
020fact if we were to turn and we were to read the mission and vision which now I can't read it without my glasses on oh good okay so uh I was going to try to impress y'all with how far sided I am but it says the mission of San Angelo Independent School District is to engage all students in a relevant and inspiring education that produces Future Ready graduates and I say those words with emphasis because that's what we focused on our students and the future of St Angelo and we want it to be as bright as possible and so Debbie um did did mention that that there was a diverse group people from all walks of life in St Angelo some of us who grew up here and went to you know Central High School
021and all the different schools before I was even born and then those of us who are newer pardon me my wife has to live with me by the way so so anyway um you know all the way to those of us who are newer arrivals to this community such as myself um but throughout our time together you know we we we learned about school Finance um we learned about um facilities we learned about a little bit about Educational Theory we saw how property taxes work to fund our schools and how the state and I'm going to use the word manipulates how that how they get dispersed so I'm super thankful that we passed prop a last November to free up more money for us but as we were were learning all these things and meeting
022you know every couple of weeks for the last few months um we did that we toured all the facilities of sais so we walked through the elementary schools we walked through the middle schools we walked through the high schools you know and and saw the area of central that becomes a river and um I'm not going to say all the all the things we saw we saw let's say this we saw Lots of good things and then we saw some things that need to be fixed and that's what we were there to talk about and so and to learn about and so as as we uh went through these past few few months and we jailed into uh somewhat cohesive units I think um priorities began to form some of those were already there and
023were already listed for us but really what it comes down to is we we um we saw three things that Rose to the service surface over the last few months by the way am I supposed to be addressing y'all or these so nobody answered so I'll just keep going but so so three things arose to arose to the top um number one and and Debbie mentioned this she said safe children we want our children to be safe and we want the the Educators and those who serve them also to be able to come to work and know that they're going to be safe um number two and I know there's some some of yall in this room that will appreciate this more than others we want lower taxes in the long run and that was
024one of the things that that we did discuss um you know when it comes to property taxes and and how do we lower those most of us here in San Angelo have learned that the the tax base consists of Residential Properties so which is why we all get mad about our property taxes so how do we expand that will we attract more businesses and we do that by investing in the future of our schools because Michael Looney's not here tonight but he'd be one of the first ones to tell you that when The Economic Development Corporation gets a phone call from a business that's already been looking at San Angelo for months and months one of the first things they talk about is our schools and he said you would be amazed at what they
025know about our schools and what they can tell us before more than than we even know and so so we want lower taxes in the long run but most importantly we want strong schools for a strong future and you guys know everybody who was on the committee and some of you others may have seen some of the list that we went over all the projects you know we weren't um we weren't handed packets to vote on and to discuss we were just given lists of projects that were prioritized and by people much smarter than I am but we were given these these pages and pages and we went through and we deliberated and and we voted on them but you know if we took everything that had been shown to us everything on the list
026and everything on those those pages and said hey we want to we want to do it all and we want yall to look at a bond that price would be $650 million approximately $650 million I think I heard some HS out there because we all recognize that $650 million is is not pocket change it is it is quite a substantial sum and you know the most fun part about getting to tell y'all the $650 or even stay that number is I don't live in saisd I don't as a matter of fact I uh I live in in Christoval Texas and and let me say this really I sleep and I sleep in Christoval Texas beside my wife and then I shower in Christoval Texas so my wife will allow me to continue to sleep beside
027her but San Angelo it's where I work where I play where I worship and really where my life is and you may you may ask when I say this and I've told you that I don't live in say ISD you may say well why does a man who who doesn't live in the school district and doesn't have children here I'm going to say yet why do I care because I recognize that as St Angelo goes so goes the rest of the koncho valley so goes the rest of the koncho valley and my roots in the koncho valley Run Deep not only but not only do I look back at my roots I Look To The Future just as the rest of us and you know I don't know if y'all remember this but I was
028was surprised to learn that the projects we looked at you know are not 10 20 year fixes but they're 75 years worth of worth of improvements that's how long they're designed to last that's five generations that's not just our children and grandchildren or future children and grandchildren in my case but it is our great great grandchildren think about that for just a moment it's our great great grandchildren and speaking of great great grandchildren you know my uh my great great-grandfather was born in 1872 um he and his family migrated shortly thereafter actually he was born in the back of a covered wagon on the way to the Concho Valley believe it or not and uh when he became an adult he ranched and farmed not too far from where we are and I've always Heard
029lots and lots of stories about Papa Hickman all right when I was growing up and I heard about how he had these two mules that he plowed with you know cuz technology was where it was when he began to farm and ranch and grow a family I also heard this will tell you a little bit about his financial condition that um he and my great great grandmother had more children than they had furniture that was the joke My grandmother used to say some of y'all some of y'all I could see got that but he plowed with these mules and then um and he also was very very frugal he was a man that didn't spend money didn't have a lot of money didn't spend money but one of the things that he invested invested in
030after World War I was a tractor he got rid of the mules and he invested in a tractor and to him I don't know what the cost was I've never heard I've never asked um I don't know what the cost was but I'm sure that it was a small fortune kind of like we hear $650 million and we think that's a small fortune but he was willing to pay that to invest in his future really to pay the price of progress now the best part about this and the good news about it is that investing in San Angelo's future through this bond isn't going to require $650 million I'm going to leave it up to miss Mary Casten wha I hope I pronounced her name correctly to tell you more about that and to deliver
031the good [Music] news I told you yes thank you Trey yeah there's a there's a big difference there as you can see on height wise but thank you Trey good evening every everyone um today I want to talk to you about the proposed projects and continue the discussion on why these are crucial for our schools our students and the overall growth and prosperity of our community the heart of these proposed projects is our students current and future students every child deserves a safe modern and well equipped learning environment that Fosters academic achievement and personal growth unfortunately many of our schools are aging with outdated infrastructure that no longer meets the demands of the 21st century education system here is a list of proposed projects that we as a facility advisory committee considered discussed and voted
032on as you can tell it is a lengthy list that was developed throughout our time together as mentioned by Debbie and Tre through a thorough and collaborative process we discussed the proposed projects extensively focusing on what was most urgent and impactful for our schools and Community after careful evaluation we arrived at this number a little over 400 million which is a lot better than what Trey mentioned earlier right a lot better but this amount reflects the scope of work needed to address critical infrastructure needs enhance educational spaces and prepare for future growth while being mindful of financial responsibility by acting now we can address these needs before they become more costly emergencies delaying repairs and upgrades will only result in higher expenses expenses down the road let's consider the alternative if we do not move
033forward with these proposed projects we're just maintaining the status quo but we're also falling further behind think back to Trey's story about his grandfather replacing the Mills with a tractor I think immediately about when I wanted to keep my previous car forever because I loved that car it had a CD player and a cassette player now mind you only us folks that were born in the 1900s know what those Contraptions are and we appreciate them just saying but this is the big butt I eventually had to accept that my car first of all was a gas guzzler the oil changes were getting more expensive because guess what even the automobile oil has evolved but on top of that it did not provide those safety features such as the rear view camera that I really needed
034did throughout all my travels it was time to invest in a newer car to save money in the long run but honestly it was to keep my family and myself safe there comes a time that we have to be mindful of what is best for our students our families and our community and ladies and gentlemen that time has arrived without these critical improvements our schools will continue to deteriorate jeopardizing the quality of Education we can provide our students deserve better they deserve schools that Inspire them to dream big and achieve their potential we evaluated each proposed Project based on its impact on safety educational quality and long-term benefits to our schools and community first and foremost we prioritize the safety of all of our students ensuring that our schools are secure and equipped to handle
035emergencies is at the core of this proposal but more importantly being proactive to deter those security issues and emergencies is the key so circling back to what Trey mentioned earlier with Glenn Middle School we observed multiple classrooms that are literally coming apart at the seams we saw where the wall has detached from the ceiling and there leaves huge gaps where rain doesn't just drip down it runs down the Walls we saw walls that were covered in mold and while we were visiting those classrooms we immediately noticed the dampness and we even had one of our committee members have a reaction to it where her asthma kicked in now imagine that was just us there being a few minutes in those classrooms I cannot even imagine our students and teachers being in those classrooms for hours
036day in and day out now we're going to turn our Focus to not only providing more secure learning environments but also making them more conducive for all of our students from the elementary all the way up to the high school so campus additions and Renovations projects by optimizing the use of space and resources we can warrant that every child has access to a comfortable and appropriately siiz learning environment and create a more efficient and equitable distribution of resources now these learning environments need to be appropriately maintained so this leads us to another big concern many of our schools require major repairs to their H uh HVAC systems Plumbing utility repairs and electrical infrastructure to meet current safety and operational standards these upgrades ensure that classrooms are safe clean and conducive to learning while also addressing
037potential hazards posed by aging facilities one of the most critical components is replacing HVAC systems that are over 20 years old that's a long time that was an eyeopener for us now these outdated systems not only struggle to maintain consistent temperatures but also fail to adequately filter air leading to discomfort and potential health risk for students and staff new energy efficient HVAC systems will provide clean temperature controlled environments that promotee Focus reduce distractions and create optimal conditions for learning proper climate control also ensures that classrooms remain operational during extreme weather reducing disruptions throughout the school day so just think August West Texas heat that's all I got to say period now again this reminds me when I made the decision to Trad in my previous car for a newer car along with those better safety
038features other optimal features such as seat warmers help me to be more focused as a driver versus fidgeting with the temperature controls and possibly causing an accident so this allowed me to drive further in my life in a safe manner so think about what are we providing to our students here so just as a reliable fuel efficient car ensures a smoother safer and more comfortable ride a modern HVAC system ensures a consistent comfortable and healthy key word healthy environment where students can focus and Thrive new systems will create the ideal conditions for concentration participation and overall well-being now moving on to athletic Renovations and Improvement projects renovating these spaces is critical not only for Hygiene but for safety as well updated facilities will ensure proper ventilation prevent accidents caused by aging fixtures and create a
039secure environment for our students for example the locker room for the cheerleaders at Central also serves as a public restroom for events which I had no clue until we toured that so these Renovations will not only protect our students but also provide a better facility for our parents families community members and out of town visitors now adding lights to practice fields and replacing aging Turf will significantly enhance safety for our student athletes proper lighting ensures that practices and events held during early morning or evening hours are well lit reducing the risk of accidents replacing wornout Turf is equally vital as it minimizes injuries caused by uneven or deteriorated plane surfaces these improvements prioritize the wellbeing of all of our students while also allowing the extended use of these facilities not by just our school but
040also by our community again safety was the driving force behind these proposed projects now here is the list of projects that were not approved so with everything on the table this is the list of projects that as a committee we considered and discussed extensively but we felt they would not be as impactful for our students and Educators and our community as the others so strong schools make strong communities which leads to a strong future when we invest in our schools we invest in the future Workforce leader and innovators of our community high quality schools increase the value of our community attract families and draw businesses to our area strengthening that local economy just like Trey mentioned these Investments aren't just about education they are for our future generations of families they are about Community Pride
041and most importantly Unity I now ask all present facility advisory committee members to please stand here stand before you retired teachers realter business owners medical personnel pastors longtime s Angelo residents Educators Aunts Uncles parents grandparents formally requesting and respectfully requesting the school board to accept these proposed projects we are s Angelo let's invest in our children in our community and ourselves in our future thank you [Applause] um any questions well first off I just want to thank you all for presenting this evening and the entirety of the committee those who can be here tonight and those who couldn't I know one of them's coaching my son's basketball team um but um I just want to thank youall for the time and the commitment because learning school Finance looking at facilities um trying to understand why
042the district hasn't done some of these things previously where the money has been and is um it takes time and it takes a lot of hours and those are hours that you all did not spend with your families um did not spend um doing things that were much more fun than looking at our facilities so first of all I just want to thank all of yall for that commitment um as a board obviously we will need to look at all these recommendations and um things that came to my mind is that we need then ask our administrative team to make sure that we have a picture for our community of what these projects really look like in reality for our children and our parents and our community members who are going to have to pay
043for it and then we also need to look at what will what our district will look like if we don't do it because this isn't just looking at what it could be it's also looking at what what it could be or would be if we don't do these things um because I do know that um anyone who's done anything over the last five years knows that prices have gone up and delaying things have only increased the cost of what we can do for for a dollar um so we need to look at um that and then we also need to look at our district we need to look ourselves in the mirror and we need to look our public in the mirror and say how are we going to maintain these facilities in such a
044way and what will our plan be through our budget over the next 10 years to make sure that we are keeping these facilities in um in a status that is exemplary for our students and we need to make sure that our public understands that we have a plan for that um and not that we not not that we haven't been doing that but we we don't always show the public what how we're doing that and I think if we're going to go ask for the trust of our citizens to vote Yes on this we have to go figure we have to show them um the steps that we're willing to take to make sure and they understand how we're doing that um but most of all I want to thank yall all for being here
045this evening and for the work you've done at this this far and understand that obviously we have some work to do now from the work that you all given us and we appreciate and we very much appreciate that any other board comments I just want to say thank you to all of y'all that that participated in this because like Dr Kingman said it takes a lot of time a lot of time and we appreciate the time that you gave to us and to the kids and to the future of this District so thank you again and I have the privilege of being a bystander in some of these meetings and I saw the uh the the actually the hard work that was taking place and the intention and the thought that went into this process
046that that you saw some things that you see that you needed to act on uh and you guys were making the plan not only uh uh for you to see through see it to the end but for us to help us in our quest to to make lives better for kids in this District so thank you very much thank you so much for your time and consideration thank you all thank you all right we are going to move forward with information items and next we'll have uh Jason Henry come up with a construction update thank you for having me here tonight I'd like to introduce RJ Lopez from Park Hill Architects and he's going to go over our major construction projects thanks Jason uh Dr Kingman Dr Moran and board of directors it's great to
047be here tonight uh I love following up the uh recommendation it's been a real privilege to work with your community members they were um really selfless and they were uh hardworking and the questions that they asked uh they really didn't hold anything back which I think is what you need because it's that's what's going to happen when it goes to the community so I really appreciate their hard work as well and I see this happen a lot in um this process process is doesn't always go as as positive as it did with this group and I think you owe a lot of that to your community and their willingness to work together to do hard things so all right now for the current projects um that is based on work we started uh a few
048years ago U Mill Elementary School um we have the certificate of occupancy uh everything has has past Building Inspections um we have a few more uh punch list items for Mill but uh it's it's it's well down the road um the last portion of that project will be the demolition of the the building d one of the oldest facilities uh on campus that's still being used for classrooms I believe is uh uh for for kindergarten students but now they're able to move into a new facility and you're able to remove that uh that classroom U from your campus so it'll be exciting to to see that happen um the landscaping and irrigation was completed uh this past Friday and uh we have a few more items uh that'll be generated on the punch list where
049we go through and Mark you know every sprinkler head that we see has a problem or any cracks in the sidewalk or any issues which right now we haven't F in a lot of those so that's good but we make sure that they provide top-notch quality as you would expect in a brand new facility so we're going to make sure that's done right you see the uh the photos of the newly completed McGill elementary school if you remember some of the renderings uh from about a year and a half ago year to a year and a half ago this is uh almost exactly like what we we talked about so the the floor plan is what we plan for the design is what we plann for and now it's now it's here to be used
050for students so it's an exciting time see uh last touches the Landscaping going in and then uh some of the the new hallways and there's uh some really nice special spaces that we'll be able to show next time uh of the the cafeteria and some of the commons areas that that really show well and I think will function exceptionally for the students and teachers all right and then the second project Fanon Elementary School um uh the building is complete it's being used uh but the the site uh playground they're still working on uh the drainage system between the New Edition and the gym they're still uh wrapping up some of the site fencing um if you've been out there obviously it's a quite a bit more complicated site than McGill Elementary School and so they're
051they're working through that um the play court and um the basketball court and the uh the dock for the gym is uh nearly complete and then just finishing up all the the handrails for the ramps and stairs is still underway and so we're going to continue to try to to push on them because they really can finish before students come back um they just have to uh to get out there and get it done so um we've got uh couple pictures there showing and there's even been some work done since uh this picture was taken there uh but you can kind of see that uh basketball court on the on the right there and then some of the tree uh and Landscape going in some of those Stone benches that surround the uh the basketball
052court so the the students can have a place to to sit and then uh just showing that that entryway with that that ramp there and some of those wood uh rails have already come out and they're installing U metal railing and hopefully finishing up within the next couple weeks out there and that's that's where we're at so hopefully the next time we do this construction update uh in January I'll be able to tell you you have two completed schools and now we can start looking towards the next phase and the next step for U St Angelo ISD any questions about current construction any questions and Migel we're using the classrooms already correct students move this week yes yes and the cafeteria will be up and running after did oh today they use the cafeteria yeah
053fantastic so so it's moving in the right direction that's sure okay um and on budget yes yes on budget okay on budget and as planned perfect one more one more comment uh RJ I know that uh I don't know if the public realize it but this these two projects were were a pretty good reach for the board because they were accomplished out of a fund balance uh out of the M budget that we normally have so uh these projects right here are few and far between when we can gather enough funds to do major projects like this so uh again the urgency for uh some uh potential Bond money to complete some other facilities that we really need to work on yeah projects of these sizes are almost impossible to do out of fund balance
054and it's pretty rare that we're we work with you know districts across the state and uh we don't have many projects of this size that they're able to do um out of fund balance so it's aug huge win to be able to to do what you've done but obviously that's really the the top level of what's able to be accomplished out of fund balance all right thank you very much yep thank you um next we're going to move on to an update on academic programs and Dr Farah Gomez is going to give us that update Dr Kingman Dr Manan and Dr Brandon I'm happy to go now but do we have some visitors for the next item that might like to go before hearing me talk about instructional materials and House Bill updates I mean
055I'm going to be here the whole time but you guys might be traveling thank you Dr GES good we're going to move forward with item D we'll come back to Dr Gomez and uh we're going to do a value study appeals services update Dr Kingman Dr Mor Board of Trustees um line Barger has been representing School District cities and other political entities in all ADV valorum taxation matters including collections since 1976 for over 48 years line bger has established reputation for unmatched experience quality of work that generates tangible results and you're going to hear about some of those tangible results uh this evening and we have the pleasure of having with us uh from lme Bogger Mr Bill messic thank you thank you very much it's good evening it's it's a pleasure to be here
056um to update you on the comproller property value study to give you a little historical background um starting back in 2021 uh St Angelo ISD did not pass the property value study but they were eligible for first year grce so no funds were at risk and and that's the way the systems designed uh when you do uh fail a property value study the controller immediately does a study the next year they normally skip every other year so St Angelo had another study in 2022 they failed in 2022 and they got two years of Grace and that's all uh the grace that a school district could get luckily in 2023 uh the chief appraiser um got a hold of some relevant sales information did a bunch of reappraisals and St Angelo was valid for 2023 um
057and even though a district is valid and you get full funding we're still able to file a self-report appeal and uh we didn't have to file a property valed study appeal but we filed a self-report appeal and that if you look at uh on page four of the charts uh for 2023 we show that we brought in an additional 2.6 uh million doar in in state aid um um for the school district and that's important because a lot of districts think if they pass the property value study then there's not any more money to be to be gained but there are uh by the time the role is certified there's a lot of Corrections to the role that happened there there could be continuing ARB uh hearings could be litigation uh late Homestead late uh
058a exemptions um and of course there could be adjustments to exemptions and over 65 freezes and so we were able to to follow the self-report appeal um in addition to self-report appeals we're able to file an audit every 3 years for school district and so we just recently filed a 2021 audit for St Angelo and that will end up bringing in another $210,000 appr Pro Pro imately in state aid uh that that the school district should get sometime around April or May of 2025 so we we do these uh we review them and sometimes many times we can't find any additional uh state aid for any of the school districts so we still review everything but in this situation we were able to find some corrections that will result in uh more funding now for
059since the district was valid in 2023 uh for the 2024 year they have what's called a methods and assistance program where they look at business practices and procedures and and look at the internal workings and it's critical that the district passed this map review because it's one of the requirements to be eligible for grace and in speaking with the chief appraiser uh there's not going to be any problem with the map review so everything's good there the 2024 results of the property value study will will be released uh January 31st of 2025 St Angela won't have a property value study but they still have to certify the tax roow so again we will look at the tax rooll Corrections and see if we need to file a self report appeal if we do we'll contact
060superintendent and get his authorization to do so uh and again sometimes we can find some money and sometimes we don't the critical uh juncture is going to be for the 2025 property value study because the district will not be eligible for grace in 2025 you have to have two years of Grace and they only have 2023 so the 2025 property value study which won't be released till January 31st of 26 this is way down the road uh and Tyler's got time to to to get to the market and analyze things and and look at that but if for some reason say the controller's office analyzes the same information that Tyler's looking at and comes up with a different conclusion we're prepared to F an appeal we only have 40 days to Fallen appeal we're we're
061the safety net we're your Safeguard we will seek for your authorization um but we don't since there's only 40 days we'll immediately start the appeal we'll have boots on the ground we have very senior appraisers that come out and inspect property they're all former com troller property tax assistance division appraisers so they're very familiar with the system and all that but I'm hoping that's not a situation that we have to put up with we're looking forward for the 2025 study to be a valid finding and if that comes out you guys will be eligible for two years of Grace you won't have another property value study till 2027 and at that point you would have two years of Grace so a lot of it is going to it's unknown but I feel very confident in
062saying that I think you guys are in good hands I think the appraisal district does a very good job uh with one arm tied behind their back because sales information is getting so hard to find all across the state of Texas um but uh I think you guys are one of the the lucky ones you got a A good Appraisal District you got a very uh active market and I I think you guys are in good shape is there any questions about anything about property value study it's kind of a unique animal any questions or comments I I just want to yeah thank y'all for y'all's work I mean over the years the through the appeals process um we've been able to save taxpayers dollars by by yall performing these appeals and finding dollars for
063us and so um you know it's an important thing to look at when we're uh going up against the values that the com controller provides so um thank you all for your work with the district I appreciate it we've got a real good history here with St Angelo we've been doing it for over 25 years and it's been a good uh combination good teamwork and uh we're we're very proud to help you guys out and do what we can all right thank you very much thanks and you can thank Dr Gomez for letting you get home a little [Laughter] earlier uh now we're going to do an update on academic programs and Dr Gomez is going to help us for an update on House Bill 1416 Dr Kingman Dr Maran and members of the board
064tonight's academic update will actually include two highlights um around for uh 1605 excuse me House Bill 1605 with instructional materials and um 1416 which replaced the prior House Bill 4545 and I really just want to spend a moment and begin with the updates to 16005 because it it integrates with 1416 so if you look at this first slide here um this process for continuous Improvement actually began during Co and it's been quite a process um but some of the things prior to house bill 16005 that you were accustomed to from the state was the Texas Education Agency or tea established the teaks as the standard framework for curriculum and instruction instructional materials had to align with these standards but school districts retained local control over material adoption and implementation you also fact y'all did this
065last spring um districts had Statewide textbook adoption processes um where there was a centralized process we'd go through our teques review and Publishers would submit to tea with a list coming out from the State Board of Education for districts to adopt from and what was key and still continues to be vital under the passing of the bill is local flexibility so districts could purchase approved materials using State funds or select non-approved materials using local resources so that's where the money side of the house comes in Dr Brandon while flexibility allowed for Innovation it sometimes led to inconsistencies in quality and Alignment across districts and even across schools in the same district so fast forward a little bit to the timeline there and the passing of House Bill 16005 last year you heard us begin to
066talk to you more and more about what is referred to is high quality instructional materials in fact last spring with a normal Proclamation we shared with you that' be the last time for us to go through that formal process and we did a lot from K8 science to um technology applications in several CTE courses just to highlight a few so under the passing of House Bill 1605 the bill emphasizes the provision of ta vetted high quality instructional materials and the reason behind this is to ease the burden on teachers and ensure Statewide consistency in curriculum delivery now if you look at this process here we knew from our local data we had some areas we needed to address uh to improve instruction and opportunities for our students we also wanted to be ahead of it
067so that we had a plan to ease into the transition so you heard us first start sharing with you a slow roll out that began K2 primary with amplify skills that was in the 23 24 school year then we added on this year for 2425 amplify through all of Elementary gets a little confusing if you're not in the classroom because after second grade skills which non-educators non-reading teachers that's phonics um is combined so third on up it's not separated and it just stands for knowledge there so we added that in and a slow roll out was really important because professional learning and ongoing support for our teachers was key unlike previous systems with the passing of 16005 um it introduces a more Dynamic review process which is super important to remain current with educational Trends
068and lastly there is an opt-in framework so this is where from boards and making decisions you all are super important districts can choose to adopt the new state provided resources or maintain their own systems however those opting in do benefit from a a streamlined process and state funded resources which will take you to this next slide and please note I'm pulling several of these straight from ta using their language for you to see what's being shared and I'm glad you have your screens because I I know that print is super small um but on the left is the traditional IMA funding that districts received and on the right is the transition to districts receiving those state funded resources if you opt in the difference in funding and so again local districts they can opt in
069and to choose to adopt or maintain their own systems however if you do adopt um you do benefit from state funded resources so with this you're going to hear more about what is referred to as Blue Bonnet learning now and I mentioned we've had a slow transition with amplify we expanded and we added on Eureka for upper elementary math this year and high school because again we wanted to be able to Pro to provide support to teach teachers and not take on too much at one time where teachers did not have support those were not the Texas specific versions on that timeline in the very first slide those were open uh educational resources available during Co when a lot weren't in a traditional system but it's important to Texas to be Texas specific so beginning
070with the 25 26 school year these Blue Bonnet learning resources are are from the same Publishers we've slowly been introducing to our teachers the change would be these have been revised to specific Texas standards so I've included a slide there for you in Reading language arts and then the next slide is around math but what you will see in both content areas for Blue Bonnet learning is curriculum delivery at scale meaning these resources provide pre-designed instructional materials and lesson plans for core subjects ensuring Statewide equity and more equity in individual districts with multiple campuses professional development integration which is again why our district chose to slowly roll this out because professional development and learning is vital as we transition teachers with us in those content areas have received training on how to internalize the materials
071um so that they are spending less time having to create lessons and then one of the things that due to this funding shift as we've gone along sorry I'm kind of going back to the original slide is when we first began because the way funding was we couldn't automatically provide print in all of those areas where we were First beginning and so we had to first begin with some digital only resources but with this transition to Blue Bonnet learning we will be providing print access in addition so that's just very important um to see is the transition and the change in the funding so for this final slide on this update um before a district can access funding you must adopt an instructional material transition plan however if you are participating in strong Foundation which
072is a grant from the state then that does qualify you our district has submitted a Grant application that was submitted last week um should we not be awarded funding we do have a plan to present for our instructional material transition plan we feel quite confident because of our pre-work with those resources and our slow implementation as we were to move forward K5 reading language arts K5 math and six through Algebra 1 mathematics for our teachers so that was just kind of real quick on Blue Bonnet learning definitely wanted you all because you're going to hear that but as I summarize let me go back to this last slide as board members um it's important that you are aware anytime time you change resources we have challenges which I like to replace with opportunities and considerations
073one of those being our District's responsibility to balance local control while House Bill House Bill 1605 and blue bonnet learning they do provide significant support we must ensure that we retain autonomy and adapting materials we currently have processes for this and we would continue to do so I want to provide some clarity by adapting materials that doesn't mean omitting materials completely or we lose the Fidelity of the resource however especially in the area of rla and I feel like it's only fair to close out with shelle's last board meeting that I bring up rla and what could potentially be a controversial passage because that happens all the time in Reading language arts and English classrooms those things may come up but we're committed currently and forward movement to have a process and that's where we
074look at Alternatives if we're like this is not the best we need to stop and reflect what were the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills we were to be covering and what other passage could we potentially use to meet that objective so I just really want to stress as board members that is a very important important consideration um that we do continue to balance that local control another very important consideration is teacher buyin anytime we're changing it is so important it's at the Forefront of our district that we do not want our teachers to lose the craft of teaching we don't want Master Teachers to feel like that that just gift of being an educator is removed so there is something very powerful in having a alignment but you can't replace the human element of masterful
075teaching and we will continue to uplift that and lastly for considerations is sustainability as Blue Bonnet learning evolves maintaining high quality updates and Equitable access will be key to our long-term success and now as we segue into 1416 I said I wanted to cover Blue Bonnet learning because because it supports 1416 you know those legislative updates Give us new numbers to memorize and learn so prior to what's now referred to as House Bill 1416 you heard a lot about House Bill 4545 as board members you may have had Parents teachers community members ask you about what's this extra help or support for students in need around State assessments so um with the passing this past June of 24 the state put out some updates and because 4545 had um very rigid time constraints and student
076constraints and Mrs Duncan I know that you understand this so well as a former secondary teacher to be required to have a 3:1 ratio when you have a roster of 120 to 150 students that's a tough demand so with this change in this bill it gave District some flexibility for secondary we were very eager to get started however there's no magic pill and getting information late in the summer provided some opportunities that we needed to work through again around training staff and really communicating around differentiation and scaff in in those secondary classrooms specifically we wanted to begin with reading and math so there's a couple of screenshots in there for you our district chose for middle school high school to use a program that was on ta's approved list which gave us even more flexibility
077waved those very tight ratios called EXL so you may have already had some parents maybe you rep parent yourself I don't know maybe just people have asked you what is this new program in secondary so we trained very late October like October 30th by the time you get the new materials purchased you get all the right people in those things unfortunately don't happen at the beginning of the school year when there's L notification from the state those screenshots just show you since that short amount of time skill proficiency already and then it was important as board members that you knew there is access to this program in school that would count for Universal instruction as part as just the regular course or for students needing acceleration in additional time to meet the hours depending on
078the state assessment area they needed to work to improve outside of the classroom um as well so both tier one and tier 2 instruction so in this very short amount of time you can see that yes the majority of these have been accessing the program in school with 91% but there has been some home usage as well and I just want to close with this and say you guys know what happens from November till winter break and so since basically November as of today about 1:30 when I logged in on the dashboard you can see the number of question questions our secondary students have already answered I just want to point out it says eight schools and some of you might be saying how do we have eight schools on there when you said this
079was secondary so to clarify it's all middle schools high schools Carver and pay but the eight comes from we had a demo en account because we were trying to learn ourselves before we trained our teachers and one of those fell under Austin Elementary which is not a campus it was a second we couldn't use same login for the second demo so truly it's not eight schools it's the six schools all three middle schools both high schools Carver and pays um with Elementary we elected to continue using the resource that we had prior been using previously because of the extension of amplify and Eureka we did not want teachers to learn an additional new program and we really were in need of a resource to meet the requirement for our secondary campuses so I know that's
080a whole lot of really in the weeds teaching and learning highlights for the academic update but it was important for us that you knew um the progression of blue bonnet learning and what our district was doing to provide striving students additional levels of support do you have any questions that I can help with any questions for Dr Gomez I don't really sorry have a question but this is a lot of work a whole lot of work from the ad admin team here and I appreciate that and I love um this EXL program I love if y'all don't know it's um if I'm right Farah tell me this like if a kid gets it it's like they get this number if they miss it goes back it goes up is that the program yes so Mrs
081Duncan what's key with this program and again as a former secondary math teacher I know that you um can understand the need for this it provides an explanation um so a lot of times that's what's missing yes that's what's missing as we go up the grades because we don't want students to just guess we don't want the program to just drop down and become easier it needs to be there needs to be a feedback loop so students know why they're not getting answers correct I I love that and and I'm hearing from some of the kids that um it's like a challenge because then they get into these debates with this I don't know why this just doing that but I want to reiterate what you said that with everything that we're doing it's the
082teacher that brings their skill to the table um in Texas across the state we're told what to teach but we're never told how you know so we're not putting teachers in a box teachers are still able to bring their strength or weaknesses and when I say weaknesses because sometimes teaching a topic for me might be a weakness where my co- teer isn't and it enables us to learn from each other so um all of this is great news and the fact that we're trying to align the district great news even if we look outside our district when children move from town to town city to City the state of Texas I feel like is trying to get where we're not losing ground we're always looking forward and always trying to reach that goal of um
083the knowledge that we need when we graduate so thank you Farah and your team for all the support that you're giving teachers and the hours of hard work that you are doing to implement all of this any further board comments or questions obviously Dr Gomez thank you for all your work and there'll be more to come on this as we move forward and so um we will look forward to hearing more riveting updates all right all right now we're going to move forward with our action agenda um we have consent items a through G which is consider donations are minutes from our November 11th and November 18th meeting uh bid RFP 25-9 uh bid 20-14 Cooperative uh then a consider a Cooperative purchasing organization F consider bid 24-15 for wireless radio and G consider bid
08424-23 on Dual Purpose paper um any board questions or comments or anything that needs to be pulled from the consent items a through G do I have a motion for consent items a through G make a motion to approve consent items a through G and do I have a second I'll second so I have a motion from Mr gagos and a second from Dr Mills any further board comments or questions all in favor say I I all against say the same uh consider HS a through G pass um next we have our action items we have consider bills accounts and financial statements from our November 20124 meeting any questions regarding our bills accounts and financial statements do I have a do I have a motion to approve our bill accounts and financial statements Dr kman
085move for approval our bills accounts and financial statements for November 24th in addition to that Dr Kingman all these reports were were reviewed in detail at our uh previously at our pre- agenda meeting last week uh in addition to that all this information can be found online and our website scd.org uh and look for the financial transparency tab I was flipping did you put a motion in there too I did okay so there was a motion from Mr dindle do I have a second I'll second and a second from Mrs Duncan um all in favor or any other board comments or questions all in favor say I I all against say the same motion passes 70 next we have action item B which is consider a quarterly investment report it's found on page 56 um
086our total interest earned for the first quarter was $847,000 $847 8920 um any questions or comments regarding our quarterly investment report do I have a motion to approve our quarterly investment report move for approval Dr Cayman motion from Mr dendle do I have a second a second a second from Mrs misel Flint um any further board comments or questions all in favor say I all against say the same motion passes 70 now the one everyone's just chomping the bit for their phone calls tomorrow about um it will do Dr Gomez in the district calendar Dr keeman Dr Moran and members of the board I know you've received much communication over the two proposed calendar options for the 2526 school year including some comprehensive feedback from SD's cbas committee which also has dual membership on our
087district site based decision-making committee and one of the many task of this stakeholder group is to gather input to be used by Administration to create calendars to present to the board for ultimate board approval so um Dr keeman I'm sure you appreciated one of the comments on there from the board members that said good luck because that's how we feel when it comes to creating a calendar we just must remember we do our very best with our number one stakeholder being our student and how we can maximize instructional time so on both calendars presented to the board for review there are um there's the feedback from that large stakeholder group but they also hold true and tight to SD's core beliefs including uh finishing the first semester before we leave for winter break having a
088common spring break holiday as our local University Angelo State and lastly finishing the school year by May one of the key differences on the two Cal or the key difference in the two options presented to you for consideration were around instructional planning days so because those are so vital I want to provide some clarity for those that don't work within the organization instructional planning days have been described by teachers as gold they are not days where nothing is happening it's time where as internally we say it's the gift of working on the work we've talked earlier this evening about the craft of teaching that takes time and so typically in a regular work week There's not time there's always all the things that fill up the time from meetings to required paperwork and the list
089just goes on and on so these aren't days where teachers are just working on that never- ending to-do list or tied up in additional meetings these are days where Educators get to come together and look at internalization lesson design and the creation and analys Analysis of Assessments so instructional planning days are super important to staff which I know you saw in several of the comments one thing that we work really hard to do is avoid Fridays for instructional planning days because many of our Educators also support all the ways our students are smart through extracurricular and many of those extracurricular events fall on Fridays and those educators are teachers first that's why you see on your calendar options instructional planning days not on Fridays with uh when possible so uh the key difference between your
090two options staff feedback repeatedly points out how beneficial it is for teachers to have a day after a break before receiving students that's your difference between option A and option b around that March instructional planning day so if I can answer any additional questions before we move forward and I know board everyone received this but just to clarify by the only difference in option A and option b is March 20 uh March 9th versus March 23rd so that's really just make sure everyone's on the same page on that this calendar fell beautifully um everything align Christmas was wonderful Easter was wonderful all those things that tend to throw wrenches when school districts are trying to adopt a calendar were beautiful so those weren't issues that's why there's not significant differences in your options does anyone
091have any questions for Dr Gomez just a quick question I I keep hearing that teachers prefer to have the day after after a break so the 23rd of March is the is one of option so what would be the benefit of having the 9th instead of the 23rd it's um going back to the why behind it instructional planning it's preparation before a new grading period begins so we with the way things fall they need one before the final grading period begins so that's why it needs to be somewhere in March no I understand that but I'm just saying that the 23rd would do that as well right right okay so is there a reason that that the n9th is an option because it still provides for that it provides for them to work in advance
092of the final order before it begins okay so there's always um to to meet that number one core belief of finishing the first semester by winter break your first semester is shorter when you follow that model so you have longer um grading periods in the second semester however you have some things that come into impact which people will provide guidance around February tends to be a time excuse me as my throat now itches um where we have some illnesses so some want that third grading period a little longer um where some argue the fourth with all the end of year events so really um Miss Melle Flint it goes back to the need to provide that time for teachers to work on the work right okay I just wanted to make sure that we weren't
093giving up something on the 9th by approving the 23rd thank you so much yes and I'll comment on that because I think if I'm right you're right both the way that I would look that as a teacher is the ninth if I wanted to work during spring break I would I would have that time with teachers before the spring break to plan to organize and then I as a teacher if I wanted to that would give me that week at home to do stuff versus I'm not using my spring break for that which which is perfectly great and I'm just going to do it and hit the ground running when I come back so it it provides exactly the same thing just it's it's really a preference am I right on that yes ma'am okay
094so thank you for your work on that Dr Gomez so I need a motion to approve either option A or option b unless anyone else has any further questions any questions do I have a motion to approve one of these calendars I'll move to approve option b with the March 23rd off so that they have the day after the break like they requested a second all right so I have a motion from Mrs misel Flint in a second from Mr gagos any further board questions or comments okay well then all in favor of option b which is the March just to clarify the March 23rd um day say I all again say the same motion passes 70 all right Dr Gomez you're busy tonight um we are going to now do the non- business days
095for Public Information Act for 2025 yes sir so last year was the first year for our school district um and others to adopt a PA non- business day calendar the difference here is it doesn't follow an academic calendar it follows a true calendar so you all had already adopted the P Pia Public Information Act non- business days for 2024 now as we finish up this December and we will return in January of 2025 we need to officially adopt for the 2025 calendar year um it's very in line with what we had done this year with what the calendar options that had been presented to you and most importantly those federal and state holidays pretty much um Drive the days that a district is going to put forward so it's pretty self-explanatory but it is a
096formal process that requires board approval then our Communications Department will post and make available to the public at their offices in our district website I like this calendar much more than the academic calendar yeah and and this like you said this follows mostly the weekends and the state and federal holidays and a few less than 10 or 10 um um designated days that coincide with our with our school calendar a little bit to make sure that we have um we make sure we get the information we have the people here on at the facility to get the information back to our public as they request this isn't about not giving them the information it's about making sure that we have the staff here to get the information to them in a timely and so that
097they know in advance when how if they need something before some of these dates that we that they give us that time beforehand you're exactly right many reest will require um information from multiple departments and when the business is not or when the district is not open for business or there's less staff um working within the district we always want to be responsive to the community however it does provide a burden and a hardship at time to meet those deadlines when the district is not open or staff for traditional business hours so does anyone have any further questions for Dr Gomez regarding the Public Information Act nonbusiness days all right do I have a motion to approve the public information act non business days as presented move for approval oh and a second from Dr
098Mills because he was trying um motion from Mr dendle and a second from Dr Mills any further board comments or questions all right then all in favor say I I all again say the same all right motion passes 70 all right we do have have some quick uh executive session we're going to go in under 551.071 under real property and 551.074 under Personnel matters all right it is 7:45 we have returned from executive session we have taken no actions and made no votes our announcements are that we have city council meeting uh School Board recognition on January 7th at 8:30 a.m. we have our finance and pre- agenda workshop on January 13th and our regular board meeting on January 21st and with that we are adjourned