CorpusRecord 105071

January 30th, 2025 -Special Governing Board Meeting of Crane Elementary School District No. 13, Yuma, AZ

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / Crane Schools
Date
2025-01-31
Location
Yuma County, AZ
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,031 words · about 73 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001It's going to be interesting, Dale. Yeah, we're just going to call this order, this meeting to order. We're going to start with a Pledge of Allegiance and a moment of silence, please. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. We're going to start with the first order of business. which is the one presentation and discussion of district's financial outlook. Information will be provided to inform the governing board on the district's current financial status and to shape the possible fiscal landscape that will need to be considered in the subsequent years. I'm going to turn the floor over to Mr. Ponder. You have the floor. Thank you, Mr. President, members of the board, executive

002team members, and community. Thank you for the opportunity to present this information to you. I'll start by saying I am battling a little bit of a head cold and such. So if I am not clear, let me know. If there's something that I say that doesn't make sense, also let me know. And hopefully it's not the Dayquil talking. Yes, I want to be able to provide a little bit of a framework of where we've been from a financial perspective and what does that look like moving forward. I think many of us will agree that we can learn a lot from the history and apply that to what we could see in the future, whether that's predicting student accounts, whether that's predicting financial resources, whatever those factors are. We can learn from history and be able

003to identify what that means for the future. So there are a few items and don't be overwhelmed by the list. It is a lot, but we're not going to be spending a great deal of time in some of these areas. Some will be more focused than others. Others will just be a high level introduction to that. So these are the topics that will be. Going through looking at Proposition 206, the Classroom Site Fund, evaluating our health benefits, Proposition 123, and so forth. I believe all of you all have those in front of you, too. And so we'll be spending some time in each of these positions. We'll first start with Proposition 206. Excuse me. Proposition 206 was approved by the voters in November 8, 2016, by a margin of 58 percent and really is in

004two parts. One is the state minimum wage and the other is a mandatory earned paid sick time. The minimum wage is the one that continues to change every year. But the sick time is something that remains constant and something that to Lupe and her team's credit have developed a great program around how we're implementing the mandatory earned. paid sick time. So first piece, our minimum wage, I believe, was $8.15 at that time. The state was $8.05, but it increased to $10.17, $10.50 in 18, 11, and 19, and $12 in 2020. And then the piece that I want to draw your attention to is it grows by CPI for each year thereafter, not until it reaches a certain threshold. Not until it reaches a certain date, it grows indefinitely. So that is a factor that will

005continue to grow over time. And I think that's an important piece to take a look at. So from a revenue perspective, the district pursuant to ARS 15901.01 receives the lesser of 2% or the rate of inflation. And the rate of inflation in this particular example or in this statute refers to the GDP price deflator. And so whatever is less. And so if, let's say, inflation is 1%, we're only going to get 1%. If inflation is 7%, we're only going to get 2%. And so that's what we're getting for revenue. But the expense piece, which is what's tied to Proposition 206 and found in ARS 23363B, is that it's really whatever the cost of living is. So if we get 2% and cost of living is 8%, we have to provide 8%. There's no maximum. There's

006no limitation. There's no capacity. There's no threshold. And so that's just something that we have to be mindful of every year and being able to move that forward. I will say to the state's credit in... response to the pandemic when interest rates, when inflation rates were well above 5%, some were 6%, some were 8%. The state did give school districts additional money beyond that in order to meet that need. And so we're thankful for that and has been embedded into our annual adjustments. This is a little history of where the minimum wage was dating back to 2014. You can see where that took place after Proposition 206 passed in 2016, effective for January of 17, and where we're at today. The state's minimum wage is $14.70. Our district is at $15. Next year, I'm estimating

007$15.10. That is a very fluid number. The ballot measure shows that it will be calculated from August to August. So we really know that number around September and October. But just based on what trends are showing, I would speculate to be about $15.10 for January of 26. If Crane were to be able to provide a 2% adjustment to that, we would still be above that threshold by $0.20. We're currently above that threshold now by $0.30 per hour. And do want to remind that the federal minimum wage is still $7.25 as enacted by the Fair Labor Standards Act. So taking a look across the nation, what does that look like from Arizona comparatively? I think it's always interesting to kind of see where might we be similar, where might we be different. Aside from the District

008of Columbia, which is $17.50, that's the highest in the nation. But by state, I have that table down the left-hand side. You can see Washington is the highest at $16.66, and then California and so forth. Those that are... Those with red font are those that are adjusted annually by CPI. And so they have an inflator built into them as well. So you can see like all those tied for six at $15 an hour. You will see that Colorado, Arizona, Oregon will soon leap those if they continue to remain static. If California continues to remain static, you can see that over time we would be surpassed those as well. So this is kind of what it looks like across the. The nation, I believe there are 20 states that still adopt the federal minimum wage as

009their own minimum wage at $7.25. Again, not much to remark on here. This is where we are currently, $14.70 as a state. Ukraine is at $15, and then again, estimating $15.10 per hour moving forward. Again, the mandatory earned paid sick time, that's not something that we're we were having to really wrestle with. I think we have that system pretty well down pat. The staff member does receive one hour for every 30 hours work and is capped at 40 hours a year. So not much to remark on there. I'll pause before moving to the classroom site fund and see if there are any questions that that generated through that discussion. And please, if there are things that come up as I'm talking, let me know. want it to be very informal and it's more for your

010benefit as well. Any questions on that? So what percentage of our current district employees are at minimum wage? Do you know that answer, Lupe? Yeah. I don't. It's generally just your new hires. So anybody that, it's board policy that for when we hire them, we have to wait 180 days before we can give them an increase. And so if they miss the board action, which is usually July 1st of every year, if they miss that timeline, they won't get a raise until the following year. which would be July of that year. Or if the minimum wage goes up, then they would get that January. But what we've tried to do is get ahead of the increase so that we're not doing mid-year adjustments. We do July adjustments. So all of our new hires that are

011minimum wage employees would be at the 15. And does that create, like I know at my work we've run into this quite a bit where like certain competitive positions get a higher rate, but their education level is six months of training and somebody with a master's degree or a bachelor's degree might make one to two dollars more an hour, right? So like what does that look like? Yeah, we see a lot of compression within our schedules because sometimes the minimum, I'll say especially early on when it was being adopted, when 206 was being put into place, those adjustments were happening a lot quicker and more accelerated than what we were able to provide to other employees. So very much to your point, Kelly, we were seeing some of those changes too. And we still have

012compression within our schedules. What Lupe and her team have tried to do is try to. spread those out where we could. If we can stay out ahead of the state minimum wage and we can create some of that distance between, I'll use an example, a daytime or an evening custodian to lead custodian, the difference between those are very minimal. And so if we can try to keep that distance, that's something that we continue to look at. But yes, the salary compression is still an issue. Not really education-based. Right. We don't pay people based on education. We pay based on the approved salary schedule. And so every year we look at that April, we would approve it. But never say, OK, you have a master's. I'm going to pay you more unless you're a teacher. But

013everybody else is just based on the approved schedule. All right, the Classroom Sight Fund. This was approved as part of Proposition 301 in November by 53.5%. It did raise taxes from 5% to 5.6% with that increase being dedicated to public education. It was created to compensate teachers for additional base pay and performance pay. And then laws of 2018 extended that. That was set to expire in 2021. It was a 20-year sunset. And so laws of 18 did extend that from 2021 to 2041. However, we lose the voter protection. So in reality... The legislature could sweep those funds and use it someplace else and saying we will need to eliminate the classroom site fund because that's no longer voter protected. I won't go into the politics behind that and whether or not that could be detrimental

014to their position, but that is a possibility where that could happen, which is why we continue to have that as a separate component within our, excuse me, our compensation structure. And then laws of 21 removed the 40, 20, 20. So 40% of what we received was going to performance pay, 20% to base pay, and the remaining 20% was to menu items. And 2021, they eliminated that and everything went into one bucket. So now we're receiving everything in one bucket, and then we're able to expend that out. I will share that performance pay plan still has to be a part of the program, but it does not have to be that 40% anymore. It could be $1. It could be $1,000. It could be whatever the district wants that to be. We've kept ours the same

015as when the classroom site fund was originally enacted. And so we've maintained that same dollar amount, but we still know that 70% of the teachers have to approve that. And we typically do that in the fall with the incoming teachers coming in because As we read the statute, it's those that are eligible. So if we did that this year for next year, then this year's teachers may not be staying and next year's teachers would be the one coming in. So we read that as eligibility, which is why we typically do that in the fall time. And for this year, that was in September of 24 is when we brought that before the governing board. All classroom site fund dollars goes to teacher compensation within our district, and we continue to state that we define a

016teacher as being someone who is appropriately certified and spends 50% or more of their time providing direct instruction in the classroom. That is part of the Attorney General opinion of 2013, which was I-13-005, which is what we use to define what a teacher is. So for us, this past year, the governing board approved the increase in base pay for $5,000 to $6,500. That's effective for this year, and that's provided biweekly as part of the regular compensation. The government's pay plan is separated into two different buckets. One is for professional development, and there are two categories within that, or two thresholds within that particular category, depending on the number of hours that a teacher spends in professional development. And then the other is teacher effectiveness. And so when we combine all of those together, assuming that

017they achieve the maximum in each, that's earning potential of almost $11,400 in additional money outside of what maintenance and operations or their typical primary funding source is. And that's the classroom site fund. So this is a huge component. So if the legislature were to sweep these funds, you could see how detrimental that would be, not only to our district, but teachers across the entire state. And then when there are positive changes to the classroom site fund, we take a look at that and see, are there ways in which we can make those same types of improvements to our funding and the salary schedule? And we don't, I'll say we're somewhat delayed in implementing some of those. So, for example. Back in 21, there was a huge surge, huge. It went from like $407 to $733

018per pupil. And so we were somewhat delayed on implementing that because what we tried to do is make sure that we can model that out for the next three to five years. What I don't want to do is give everything and then the next year we have to take it away and then take it away some more. And so what I like to create a little bit of stability when we model that out, work closely with Lori and Mike. and saying, here's the funding that we have available. What can we do to make sure that we can create some stability with that? We don't have a whole lot of ebbs and flows within the system. So if we feel confident that we can at least sustain this for the next three to five years, then

019let's go ahead and signal an increase for that, much what we did this past, for the current fiscal year, I should say, in increasing that by $1,500. So you can see what the trend has been again in 21 was a surge from 425 to 733 in 22. You can kind of see what that number has been over time. So it's been as low as $120 and now it's almost $800. Excuse me. Statutorily, the Joint Legislative Budget Committee has to provide us what the per pupil amount will be for the coming year by March 30th. We await that number. Just taking a look at sales tax trends and some of those other trends, I would see this number going up. We're seeing a little bit more of that. In fact, the state budget is performing better

020than forecast. So those are usually indicators that we might see an improvement to this. And if nothing else, it doesn't go down. So it may stay at 792, which is okay as long as it doesn't go down over time. So really seeing those as factors. Does the state ever give you the report after March 30th? Are they always on time? The year of COVID, they were delayed. Every other time they've been on time. Yeah. Any questions on the classroom site fund? I'm going to ask you another percentage question. Do we know roughly what percentage of our teachers are in the highly effective, effective? 92%. 92% are in those. I think around 1% ineffective, and the balance is in developing. But a majority of our staff is in the highly effective or effective group. So as

021far as where the majority are getting, essentially the most that they can get. And that's why when we provide estimates to incoming employees. We quote at the effective, not highly effective. The percentage is pretty high that you'll make it into that category. And we always let people know it is possible that you'll fall in a lower category, but it takes some real effort to fall in that category. Or non-effort. Well, effort meaning you don't come to work, you don't do your professional responsibilities. Yeah, so we have it where to continue past year three, you have to be effective. So all the teachers that have been here a while are effectively involved. Any other questions? All right. Health benefits. This is an area. So I really wanted, I should have done the next slide first, but

022anyway, effective July 1, YUBC, which is the consortium that we're a part of, along with Arizona Western College in the city of Yuma, will be utilizing the services by Valley Schools Management Group. And the reason for that. is of our maintenance and operation funds, 65% is in salaries and 23% are in benefits. And so 88% of our expenditures in M&O are related to salaries and benefits. And within benefits, the two largest areas are in the retirement system and in health benefits. And so retirement system, we really don't have, we have no flexibility. I shouldn't say we have very little. We have zero flexibility that's set by that independent board. And statute requires that we participate in that program. It's funny when we get new hires, they will take a look at their check stub and

023ASRS. You can keep that. I'll take the 12%, please. And it's like, I'm sorry. We are statutorily required to help you plan for the future. But 37% of our benefits are in health benefits. And so if there are areas in which we can implement cost containment strategies, identify efficiencies and improve that overall, then that gives us more money to do other things. Maybe that's providing that in salaries. Maybe that's for... Additional support, maybe that's for a program or curricular need, whatever that is that we need to do. Obviously, if we can eliminate some of those ongoing expenditures and have a little bit more cost containment in the area of benefits, that gives us more flexibility to use those funds in other ways. Mr. Moore. Yes, on the ESAs and all of those, we're having lower

024number of students, obviously, right? Lower enrollment. Has there been a decrease in teachers paying into the retirement fund? Because I mean, if that trend continues, what does the retirement fund look like for teachers that we have now? Yeah, I think over time, we will see that as enrollment declines statewide, as more schools are closing statewide, then yes, you have. a smaller pool of individuals contributing into the retirement system, which in turn might mean an increase to those that still are. So within the retirement system, you have municipalities, we have some counties, we have community colleges. So not just K-12 is within that system, but that means that as the K-12 population or those that are contributing into the retirement system decreases, then that shifts the need for these others. So whether that's cities, counties, or

025community colleges, their rates could be negatively impacted due to school choice or other factors where we're seeing a decline in enrollment. Yeah. Thank you. Absolutely. So that's about, I think, all I had to remark on that other than this is an area that we continue to look at. Yes, Dan. What is Valley School Employee Benefit Group? So they started in Phoenix by Deer Valley, Paradise Valley, and Peoria. They were the first three. They call them the founding three, but the three school districts that founded this employment program. And so they do health benefits, workers' compensation, and property and liability. So they have all of theirs within this own type of consortium. With health insurance? We're using the health insurance piece, but they... They do all aspects of insurance, so property liability as well as workers'

026comp, but we're utilizing the health insurance. You're not involved in the local consortium anymore? We will. We'll still be autonomous. We'll just be able to use the resources that they have rather than what we're doing now, which is we're piecing everything together. Are they going to make it any better here? They, it shouldn't be serious. So it wouldn't change for the member. It's all that we're going to be able to do is really generate efficiencies and provide. They have a great investment policy, which will allow us to have non-operating revenue to help offset any potential increases. Right now, the cash basically goes in a mason jar and sits in the backyard. Negotiating with whatever the new name is. On Vita? Yeah. So our plan is Blue Cross. We would still utilize Blue Cross Blue Shield

027as our network. And if whatever negotiations or contracts that they have. Yeah. So a lot of those same provisions. What we hope to be able to do is really generate efficiencies. The consortium here going to be with. Yes. Which is the city of Yuma, Arizona. No, just the Arizona Western College, the city of Yuma and Crane. Yeah. So yeah, that board in December elected to move over to Valley Schools. So we still make our own decisions. We still do all of those types of things. It's just... You have your own... Let me ask you a little deep. Are you going to set... What will set your insurance coverage? Is that by the screen? We do that. You're your own. You're still self-funded per se. And you still set your own benefits and... Plan design, rate

028structure, all of that is still within YABC. YABC still has the autonomy to do that. We're just utilizing their service and their providers to help with that function. So we'll still use our own stop loss carrier. We'll still use our own wellness program, but we're going to utilize them for the... health and pharmaceutical, really pharmacy is a driving factor for that because we represent 1800 lives, but they represent 35,000. And so they can get, yeah, the rates are a lot better. So we can utilize their contract, but still develop the plan design the way that we want to. So to me, it's really the best of both worlds. We get a lower cost and doesn't sound bad. Still have the plan design. Yeah. curious about that because it's like from a different angle yeah yeah

029so unlike maybe an as bait or kairos or something like that where uh where you just pay money and the plan design is already there yeah we still have the full autonomy to to design that structure yeah great question dan any other questions on health benefits yes all right prop 123 all right so This came into effect of May of 16 at a narrow margin of nearly 51 percent, increased the land trust distribution by 4.4 percent, and that is set to expire in January. My gosh, I'm sorry, June 30, 2025. Even with the expiration of those types of things, there are other items that are still in play. For example, the JLBC baseline, as well as the governor's budget, but the JLBC baseline, which is the one that most people utilize because that's the Joint

030Legislative Budget Committee, they have the equivalent of the 4.5 or 4.4%, but now it's coming in the general fund. And so the issue is that that ends up creating a hardship for the general fund over time. And I'll get a little bit about why that's also important as one of the triggers goes into play, too. But the $286 million that school districts are receiving now will continue to receive, even though 123 is expiring. Our share of $75 million will continue to receive. I will say, assuming that what's in the baseline as well in the governor's proposal actually comes part of the budget, but both of those items are still in there, which are good indicators that the chances of us having those are pretty solid. But there are these triggers that are still looming, even

031though the funding of this expires or the additional funding that we receive from the state land trust is expiring. I'm going to talk a little bit about some of those. One is an economic trigger. So if both the sales tax growth rate or the transaction privilege tax and the total non-farm employment growth rate are at least 1%, but less than 2%, the legislature is permitted, but not required, to suspend K-12 formula inflation adjustments for the following year. But if both the... TPT and the non-farm employment rate are less than 1%, the legislature shall not make formula adjustments. And so this trigger still is in play. You can see that this criteria has not been met since the enactment of Prop 123. There's no signs that this would take place, but that trigger still does exist.

032And the idea behind that was this Prop 123 came as part of the Cave Creek B. Ducey inflation lawsuit. And the argument that schools had was you're required to provide us with these inflationary adjustments. Prop 301 that was voted on by the people in 2000 said that you were going to do these annual adjustments of 2% or the rate of inflation, whichever was less. And there was a period of time, about six years, where they did not do anything. And the state's argument was, we understand that, but we didn't have the money to give it to you. So this was one of those negotiated items. They say, well, in the time in which there's an economic downturn and we don't have the money to give it to you, we want some flexibility where because we

033don't have it to you, we can't give it to you, we don't have to give it to you. And so that's what that first trigger is about. There's also one about the lower trust fund balance. If that reduces back to a number that was before this went into effect, then they would have the option to not. provide us with an inflationary adjustment. That criteria has not been met since Prop 123. And in fact, the distribution has been far greater than what was anticipated. This one here is one of the ones that I want to spend a little bit of time on. The K-12 spending triggers do not take effect until FY26 based on FY25 spending levels. So this is the baseline year, the year that we're in now, and they will look at 26 or

034next year as an indicator whether or not to implement some of these triggers. So they do not expire. Unlike the funding that we get, these are forever until brought back before the voters. If the general fund appropriation to the Arizona Department of Education is between 49 and 50 percent of the total fund appropriation, the legislature is again permitted but not required to provide the annual inflationary adjustment. So they could suspend it or they could reduce. to a maximum of 2%. Again, if that is between 49 and 50. If it's above 50, the legislature is permitted and not required for the following year that they could reduce it by two times. So up to a maximum of 4%. So if it exceeds 50%, the legislature could say, we're going to withhold funding at 4% because you

035as a K-12 education community. You are over 50% of our entire statewide budget. And so we're going to reduce that down so that you are not 50% or more of the entire statewide budget. Again, that was the idea that the state wanted some flexibility. In some legislators' eyes, they felt like they continue to give money to K-12 education and not seeing the academic outputs that are there. So what is the return on that investment? We continue to give and give and give and nothing happens. We have all these other needs within states. We have Department of Corrections. We have public service. We have roads and all these other boards and commissions that are also needing money. And so we wanted to have some flexibilities to say, you have enough money. You have 50% of our

036entire state budget. There's really no need to give you any more funding. Yes. ESAs. Are they considered part of K-12 education or is that like general fund and not considered? They are part of the ADE, which is what this is. So they would be part of the K-12 spending, correct? Because they have been talking about it being separated. Yeah. Not saying that they couldn't do something in the future, but right now it is part of ADE. So as this says, FY26, the JOBC is approximating that will be almost 49% of the statewide budget. So reaching that threshold between 49 and 50, and then the subsequent years dropping to 48. And a lot of that drop is with the decline in students, all of those factors that are indicated in there as well. So any questions

037on the triggers? I've got a question. Where is this in the budget? Is it general and we can allocate it, et cetera? Do you put it someplace that in case there's a problem, we can get rid of it? I see what you're saying. Yeah, so I would have this as a contingency. Right now, I don't have that as a line item because we've not reached those thresholds. But in the event that we do reach those thresholds, they would be placed in a contingency. We have a substantial, significant fund balance to absorb some of these. I've mostly held that with the idea that if the aggregate expenditure limit isn't resolved, then I would have that money so that we could absorb whatever impact that is. But that's really a one time. That's not something I can

038sustain. So likewise, I would use those same resources to help offset any of any of these triggers. The good news, the positive. How do I say that? With these is that I will know in advance where the AEL is lingering. I don't really know until that deadline comes, but this would be in advance and saying, okay, your per pupil funding is being. being cut because you're exceeding that budget limit. So some state land, is it diminishing or are they increasing? That fund is growing and continues to grow. There was a lot of concern when Prop 123 was going before the voters in 2016 that it was going to end up wiping out that fund and harming future public education, but that's not been the case. They've actually seen growth in that fund. It has, I,

039as, what I understand that when they passed it, it was, they were forced to pass it, by the way, and because it was so many people said, look, you're going to fund it, and this is their way of using the state land that's allocated to education to do that. The argument, though, to Dan was that that money was already earmarked for K-12 education. And for us to say we're paying, it's like taking out of your left pocket and putting it in your right. It's already ours. And so it's just how advanced are we getting that? How accelerated are we getting those funds? So it was already a pool of funding that was already dedicated to public education. It was just the rate in which those were being provided. There is some talk in the legislature

040about. about, even though the 4.4% increase is going away, about Proposition 456, which wouldn't be a valid proposition number to be technical, but what's the next step of 123 and using that money for teacher pay and saying, okay, we want to use the state land trust has done so well, let's use those same resources and apply that to teacher compensation in some way. So a lot of those A lot of those that were advocating against Proposition 123 are now finding that it was more successful than they had anticipated. And the story and the trust group. Yeah. Any other questions on 123? Okay, moving right along. Capital funding. This is a slide I like to show more of a historical account. We share this when we talk with our facility advisory committee, really showing the landscape

041of where we were in capital funding, really until 2023. So not that long ago. You can see, so the blue bars are the reductions that's taken place or the changes in capital funding at the statewide level. And the black line is what happened at Crane. So, for example, in 2010, the state saw a reduction of $144 million, and we saw a $930,000 reduction. You can see what that ends up being over time. And so a $352 million loss in 16, 17, and 18, that's when we were cut by 85%. Almost 90% of our capital funding was pretty much wiped out. And so at that time, we had to take money from our maintenance and operations budget, move it over to capital just to maintain some of the obligations that we had that were funding from

042capital that we thought were going to be there. Then began the restoration of the district additional assistance and being able to move forward. The timing of this is interesting. May 1st, 2017, us along with some other plaintiffs within the state filed the lawsuit, the capital funding lawsuit against the state of Arizona. And you could see kind of where that growth has been restored or some of these areas have been restored since the filing of that. And you could see that even though there is no... inflator within district additional assistance, unlike charter additional assistance where that grows by the rate of inflation every year, ours is static and had been static for a long period of time. So after restoration, the legislature ended up providing a boost to that per pupil amount. And so for three

043straight years, we've seen a boost to that amount. Based on this last budget, we're likely not to see one. Within the governor's proposal, she's asked for us to revisit that, us as a state, to revisit that and have the legislature reenact that so that we can see another increase of that because a computer costs the same for us as it does for our charter peers and that they're receiving inflationary dollars in capital funding, but we're not. That can create a hardship for us. I'd really like to show that the path that we've gone on as a district and really fortunate for our community to be supportive of our bonds and overrides to help offset some of these cuts that have taken over a long period of time. Mr. Morgan? Yeah, I would argue that in

044many cases, it's still even cheaper for them or charters because they can go to Walmart, right? Sure. They don't have to do the bidding like we do where they pay, you know, we have to pay $3 a widget and they can pay 50 cents. They have more flexibilities within the procurement code. They can declare themselves exempt where we do not. We have to go through the procurement code. So yes, there are some efficiencies that they have. And that was the idea behind the charter movement. Hey, we're going to find these efficiencies. We're going to pass those on to school districts. And, you know, it's been a 30 year experiment. I think we can see whether or not it's been been valid and maybe pass some of those on onto the rest of us. We'll be

045talking about that on the next one. So some other areas of capital funding, we have the building renewal grants. On January 21st, we received an email from the SFOB or the school, I'm sorry, the SFD, the school facilities division, which is a division within the Arizona Department of Administration, citing that the number of requests have exceeded what their budget is available. And so they are unable to fulfill future requests. They will be driven mostly around life safety. So I think fire alarms and those types of things, but roofing needs aren't going to happen. HVAC needs probably not going to happen. Plumbing needs probably aren't going to happen. So we have a number of applications that we have submitted that have been hanging in a escalated state, but not in a review state, but they've just

046been escalated for some. outdoor basketball courts, some HVAC needs, some plumbing needs around the district, but they don't have any money. There seems to be very little appetite for them to seek a supplemental appropriation. The last time that was done was in 23. They requested another $93 million. And with the addition of that $93 million, that made that appropriation to about $200 million. Well, since that time, the legislature has appropriated $200 million a year. So I think in their mind, there's no sense in asking for a supplemental because... Last time we did that brought it up to 200. Last I heard, if you take a look at the needs around the state, we need about 600 million to satisfy all the needs that are on the books today, not to mention what might be happening

047long term. So, you know, students first happen, go through the deficiencies corrections program, and 20 years later, it should not be a surprise to the state that these facilities are needing repairs that, you know, nothing lasts forever. There should be some money set aside for doing that. And before the Building Renewal Grant Program, there was a formula where districts would receive the money based on the size, meaning square footage, its age, the demographics, primarily if it was a K-8 or a 9-12 school. And all of those things came together and said, OK, based on these factors, here's the formula and you should get X number of dollars. And then this idea was that the legislature was getting upset. The school districts weren't spending that. Well, they just went through $1.2 billion in correcting all these

048deficiencies. And so I think it would be strange if school districts were spending all the money after they just went through to revitalize all of these different campuses. Here we are 25 years later and needing to seek this resolution. We now have a grant program and the grant program isn't sufficient to even meet our needs. There's like $30 million that's left in that. Our bond is 20. So you can imagine that's 30 million statewide. We can easily spend 20 million on our own. We had 112 million that was identified within our needs assessment. So not a great programmer system there. Mr. Farr? I was going to mention that the schools were... They were in bad shape when they did that, when they developed the, whatever, that building group. And they actually, and they did a

049lot of good work. They built schools. In fact, they built San Luis High School back here. But we're going to be right back where we were if they keep it up. The only thing that's supporting schools now are bonds, if you can afford them. That's exactly right. So initially, the idea behind bonds and overrides was to go above and beyond the minimum. Crane and many of us are using them just for us to maintain. We're not building fine arts centers. We're not building state-of-the-art football fields in Arizona. We're doing it so we can have roofs and HVAC needs and to address the flooring and structural deficiencies. All of those things are outlined within the minimum standards that have been established. And we're having to use local taxpayer dollars in order to be able to meet

050that need. Now, the state can boast that they have an increased taxes. But essentially, they've deferred their requirement to the local taxpayers. So we have to then increase taxes because they aren't doing the things necessary in order to give us the resources so that we can maintain our facilities. But we sent the state a letter from our attorney recently. How did that turn out? They have acknowledged receipt of that letter. So, Pete, there is also federal and state grants we continue to pursue. We have, I feel, an excellent grant writer who spends a lot of time trying to find ways in which we can leverage these where we can. You know, to be fair, there's not a whole lot of grantors that are wanting to give money for facilities. They're wanting more program based. They

051want more outputs that are there. But in fact, our facilities director, Ozzy Hernandez, just found one that's going to be beginning with Rosie Pena, who is our grant writer, about one that addresses safety and security. And so continue to look in those areas where we can. She was successful in securing a state grant for a new school resource officer. And so utilizing those types of things have been very helpful for us, too. And then, as I mentioned before, local support. And the generosity of our community does not go unnoticed. Very much appreciate that. Our capital override is set to expire in 2026. That can be renewed by the voters should the district elect to call for an election to have that go out. Unlike an M&O override that phases out in years six and seven,

052a capital override has the same amount for all seven years. So we will continue to get the $1.5 million a year for... or 10% of the RCO, whichever is less. And we've seen our budget grow. So it's been the 1.5 since inception. Any questions on capital? All right. Other revenue sources. So this is obviously the one that provides us with the most. This is the base level support, which is really tied to students. This is what creates the ultimately the revenue control limit and how we allocate funds and maintenance and operations. So you can see a 19 percent increase in the base level since 2020. Again, to the state's credit. As the inflation was soaring within Arizona nationally, they provided those funds to school districts to account for that as well. I might recall a

053couple of years ago, we had an increase of 3% and came back and said, oh, we want to add another 5% because the state gave us another 5% to be able to do that. And so to their credit, they've been willing to monitor that. Both the JLBC baseline and the governor's budget shows a 2% increase, so anticipating that increase to $5,113.26 per student for the coming school year. Other areas that we continue to focus on, Medicaid and public schools, might recall that the governing board identified the or created approved i should say a position that allowed a dedicated person to review this this has been very fruitful for our district uh we've had uh natalie padilla she recently got married her new name i don't yeah what is it Yes. So thank you, Minnie. Anyway,

054she is our Medicaid program specialist. She gave a presentation to the board and kind of sharing with you all what has transpired over time. And we've been able to use that funding to primarily offset unanticipated losses in federal funding. So that has been a big, significant contributor for us. And she continues to pursue those efforts. indirect costs and federal programs. The district is able to capture a portion of the expenditures that aren't related to capital needs and be able to recover those through services that we provide as indirect costs, primarily with procurement. financing and payroll. We process all the federal employees through our systems and we're able to capture the funds for that as well as food service as well. So those are big factors. We continue to use the incentives being provided through our

055procurement card. This generates maybe $30,000 a year but can help to offset some smaller... capital projects that we've had to use from time to time, primarily when the SFD doesn't have the resources to meet our needs, we're able to use those funds to do that. And then the timely sale of district assets and property, Mercedes Villafana, who is our Director of Procurement and responsible for the district's property, she's very... timely and getting those done on somewhat of a cadence to make sure that if we have materials and supplies that are no longer needed and they've set for a period that she's determined to be adequate for other schools may have found a need for those that we can auction those off as quickly as we can so we can recover those funds and then reinvest

056those into other areas. I'll say most notably the area that We see the most from this is the sale and resale of devices. So iPads and MacBooks, we're able to resale those. Because that is a capital purchase, a capital sale, we can only use those for capital expenditures. So in turn, we take those and then a portion of the Wi-Fi. improvement that was made this past summer was funded out of their servers and switches that Eddie and his team need are funded from that program as well. So just try to find other areas where we can identify revenues and be able to address those moving forward. Those are typically reinvested as well. Those aren't as great as hundreds of thousands, but we reinvest those and mostly goes back into our utility budget and then can

057be offset for the following year. Great question, though. Any other questions on revenues? All right. Moving right along. The AEL. All right. So a lot of words here, I'm not going to read it to you. But basically, this is what the Constitution says with regards to the aggregate expenditure limit. And we are limited, unlike a community college, which also has an AEL, but their AEL is limited to their own individual aggregate limit. So like Arizona Western College, for example, that's their own. They're not lumped in with other community college, whereas school districts were all lumped together. And so if we have. Yeah, so all of us are lumped together there. The formula really goes back to 1980. There it is. adjusted for inflation and student counts. There was a 10% adjustment that was approved by

058voters in 1986. And so all of that is how that is calculated. And then if we're in excess of that, the only way that we can override that is through two thirds of a vote from both houses of the legislature by March 1st. If they don't do that by March 1st, then the AEL goes into effect in April. So what's ironic about that is the legislature will approve all of this funding, say you're welcome to spend it, and then come back later and say, well, I guess maybe we were wrong. And so they could have the option of not allowing us to do that. So this is what it would have been for 25. You could see that we were, all of us, all school districts, and again, this only applies to school districts, not

059charters or those utilizing the ESA program, but you could see that we were $7 million at risk. And we were 14.5% over our budget. And that wasn't just us, that was all school districts within the state of Arizona. All of us would have seen a reduction of 14.5%, and ours would have been $7 million. And that would have been... catastrophic for us. That would have depleted our reserves and then some, and then we've not been able to offset any unknown impacts in subsequent years. It's taking some time to even build this amount up, but it would take more time to be able to do just the same. When in reality, again, the legislature appropriated those funds to us, we should have the authority to be able to spend them how we want. A little sidebar,

060I've been trying to work on some legislation that would essentially have the statutory limit match the aggregate limit or the constitutional limit. There's no sense in my mind of us having two different limitations. If the legislature says you could spend this money, that should be fine. That should be what is in place. And so that has been met with some resistance. And so we're having to modify that somewhat. But the long term goal is to address the AEL so we don't have this insecurity and instability hanging over. our heads in school districts where these cuts are continuously looming on an annual basis. I'll talk a little bit about where that came from. So this is a historical account of the AEL since 2003, and this is the recession. The red is where we have exceeded

061the limit. And so at that time, we exceeded the limit by about 1.8% or $98.2 million statewide. And so at that time, the state elected to override the limit. And then, you know, recession happens. We go all the way up until really 2021, where we start to see those lines intersect again, but spend a long period of time where. where we were well below the AEL. And a lot of that was driven because they weren't providing inflationary dollars. So going back to Proposition 301 of the lesser of 2% of the rate of inflation, the legislature was not providing their statutory requirement. And so that kept us below those limits. At the same time, district additional assistance, or what is known as DAA now, was being cut by 85%. So there was just less money going

062through the K-12 system. Then you begin 20 by 2020. We begin the phased in restoration of DAA. And you can see where this growth has taken place. And now we really have the reauthorization of the classroom site fund, where before that was voter protected and therefore was excluded. I shouldn't say it was that way. It was voter protected. But really, in 2002, the legislature put forth a ballot measure to the constituency and saying we would like the classroom site fund to be excluded from the AEL calculation. that was approved by the voters and so that's why that was excluded well here we are in 2021 the classroom site fund has expired. It's now appropriated through the legislature, and we've lost that flexibility of that being excluded. So now that had a huge jump. $600 million

063went back into the formula that wasn't there before. So that's really why this has become a more prominent issue now is the investments in K-12, but really the classroom site fund expiration and then being added through legislative appropriation. So you can see now. We have all of this red space that has been applied over time. We are currently at, again, 14.5% over or $1.2 billion over the limit as an aggregate of all school districts and continues to look like it will move in that direction. So we really need to identify a long-term solution, whether that's eliminating it altogether, do we even need it, whether that's an alignment to the statutory limit. whether that's resetting the base level from 1979-80 to 23-24, whatever the appropriate date is, so we can capture some of those same numbers.

064But luckily they... The legislature approved that and allowed us to exceed that. So the past two budget cycles, to Governor Hobbs' credit, she has asked that this be included in there. So once the budget is approved, she also wants the concurrent resolution to also go into effect that gives us the spending authority. So we don't have this looming impact where... I can remember a couple of Januaries ago, we were like, well, we don't know. It could be cut. It could be cut. We may end up having to cut staff. We may end up having to have these huge class sizes, whatever we needed to do to be able to capture that loss of budget capacity. So luckily, as part of the budget negotiation process, resolutions like this have also been part of that. And you

065can see historically when those have been approved by both houses dated back to 2007 and 8 and then most recently in 22, 3, 4 and 5. So you can see this is a long term ongoing issue that. really does need to be resolved moving forward. So what does that mean for the future? We are, we, as I'll say, crane, but also part of the education finance reform group that we're a member of are actively working on addressing this challenge. Again, my vision was to have the constitutional limit align the statutory limit. That was met with some resistance by the members of the legislature. So we're needing to pull back and regroup. To me, that's a... That's a perfect solution. Yeah, for long term, the one that we've, I'll say, conceded to is something that may

066be an issue in another 10 years. So we haven't really resolved anything long term. We kicked the can down the road, so to speak. And then in another 10 years, I'll have to work on addressing it then too, unless I win the lottery. So, I mean, those are things that are... troublesome for me and that as a state we're not open to making things better it's just you know kicking it down the road but that's just my my own editorial comment on that so has that legislation that the legislation that i read that you sent over that met resistance have we done anything what was the counter to that would it be just give up on it or It was not going to be heard in committee unless we made some significant changes, and that's

067what we did. So essentially, it's resetting the baseline from 7980 to I think 2324 is the baseline number, which will allow us to capture that capacity, but it's a 10-year fix because I can speculate in 10 years or less we'll have that same issue. Anything else on the AEL? Outstanding. All right. Enrollment trends. This one is interesting. So the Common Sense Institute, let me actually put my notes here. On January 16th, Glenn Farley, he was the director of policy research for the Common Sense Institute, shared this slide with members of the legislature. And I found it to be incredibly fascinating and also very indicative of what we're seeing in Arizona, but also what we're seeing in Crane. So really. What this slide shows is the yellow bars are total Arizona population. You can see the

068red line are school age, which are ages 5 to 17, and then what the trend line should have been, which is that blue line in 2022. And for the first time in the state's history or any documented history, the red line went down when the yellow bar went up. So as the state population grew, the number of school-age kids in Arizona shrunk. which was the first time that's ever happened in our state's history. And so is that really indicative of what we're seeing here within Crane? Yes, we're seeing a decline in students too, but just the total number of students available in Arizona is also down. So not just within our district, but within the state. So that's the first fascinating thing. This next slide, I'm going to highlight this dot here. This is the

069highest number of kindergarten students that our state has ever seen at one time, and that was in 12-13, highest number of kinders. Well, you know, they're about to graduate, right? So they're moving through the system. Here we are 12 years later, 13 years later, they're about to graduate. And so we're seeing the largest cohort of students in K-12 exit here within the next year or two. And the number of overall kindergartners in the state has decreased every year since then. So we're seeing fewer school-age kids, fewer kindergartners, fewer... students ages 5 to 17 within Arizona. So again, not just within our school district, but throughout the state. I'll pause. Does that generate any questions? I mean, did they give you any reasoning, any theories on why people are moving here like crazy? Yeah, I have

070some theories, and some of them have been supported. They didn't offer that as part of this presentation. They were just, here's the data. They didn't speculate as to why. I would say that, you know, we're seeing lower birth rates is one. We're seeing a maturation of communities primarily driven by housing, where homes are expensive and people have those 2% and 3% interest rates, and they're not going to give that up for 6% or 7%. And so the families that... would leave and then vacate those homes for another new family to come in. That turnover isn't happening as much as what we're seeing. So I'd say those are the biggest factors. But yeah, I mean, I found that fascinating because it just seems like Arizona is booming, but where are all the kids at? So there's

071also some national trends that go along with this, primarily with school choice. And so speaking to this, charter school enrollment nearly doubled between 20 and 22. So we're seeing more of that movement. 55% of the surveyed private schools reported enrollment growth in school year 21. Homeschooling went from 2%. to 11%, and now it's about 6% today. So school choice is having a factor on that. So not only do we have fewer school-age students, there are fewer school-age students who are selecting a school district as their school of choice, just based off of this information here. The USAs are pushing them. Human health has like a double their weighting for freshman class than they've ever had. I was talking to Superintendent Curt. He said that... Yuma County has the equivalent of five schools that we've lost.

072Kids. Five schools. Big two homeschools. Wow. Yeah, so I think... Sorry, does homeschool include online schooling? Kids who are just doing it at home online? That would be different from a technical perspective. Yes, they're at home, but yeah, they would be considered like the crane eye learning as an online school would be similar to that. Do they have to do the standardized testing as well or not? If they're a true online, most of the onlines are charters, but if they're true online, then yes, they would have to do the testing. Where do micro schools fall in this? Yeah, micro schools are kind of a quasi homeschool. So that, but yeah, they would be part of that population as well, right? So I think this is a fascinating statistic here where in 2010, roughly 80% of

073the share of kindergartners were in public schools, public school districts, and now that number is down to 62%. So we've experienced that and have for a number of years, really, where you see the eighth grade cohort leaving as 800 students and the incoming kinder might be 500. We've started to see that shrink or that. I guess that gap grows, so to speak, where the number of incoming kinders are reducing every year. We do see where those cohorts grow over time. And so we don't have this, you know, they might have started out 450 students, but they don't leave at 450. It does grow over time, but not at the same rate it once did. And so we're experiencing similar things to what we're seeing here. And really just wanting to share with the board the

074challenges that we have, which is, you know, student enrollment, not only. He made the comment during this presentation, even if a school district captured 100% of the students within their district, they would still be declining because there's not the same amount of kids as there once were. So to only show that, you know. that a decline is something specific to that district, we're not experiencing that. It's more of a statewide phenomenon. It's not anything that we're doing or we're not doing. It's more of what we're seeing with maturation of communities, school choice, birth rates, all of those things combined. So this is a, I thought, an interesting graphic as well. So the dark bar shows 218 above that, and that's the total number of school districts. And then 152, which is the reddish pink, those

075are declining districts. So every district that has a decline from one year to the prior year, there's 152 of the 218 that are that way. Sixty-six districts have seen growth of any kind since 2019, and 33 have seen growth of at least 10% since 2019. And why that's a factor is when... When the formulas or the methodology was created, the idea is it would grow by 2% every year is what the student growth would be. So 2019, five years ago, two times five is 10. So that's why that 10% was used as a factor. And only 33 of the 218 met that benchmark of a 2% growth every year. So you can see a majority of Arizona school districts are in a decline. I thought of Queen Creek. A lot of it is there, yes.

076They're coming from Mesa. Right. This is specific to Crane. Here's our trends dating back to 2014. And this is enrollment. This is not ADM. These are actual bodies. I like to consider kindergarten to be a full body. So I have that in here. And you can see just what our enrollment trends have looked like over the last 10 or so years. And you can see that. we've had somewhat of a decline from 6,100, our high there in 2015 at 6,321, and then slowly decreasing over time. And we expect that to continue to happen here into the future. Just in K-3, so going back to where school districts in Arizona were capturing 80% of the kindergarten population, and now it's 62. You can see our K-3 ADM weight. So these aren't bodies. This is actually ADM.

077That's the best way I can measure it. We can see that the K-3 number is also declining over time. Since really 2017 to now, even from the pandemic to now, we are seeing that the number of K-3 ADM or the weights assigned to those are also in decline. So I think that further illustrates that the number of incoming students aren't as high and therefore once they're here we feel like we can keep them here but they're they're just not coming because maybe they're not here. So that's a decrease of 5.3% just since 22. Our special education population or exceptional student services has increased and has done so about 26% since FY22. We're seeing that within our schools. And I would consider Connie to be our second, Connie Jerpseth, who is our director of exceptional student

078services. I would consider her to be our second largest school with just the population of ESS students that she services within our school district. So we're seeing the population of students there grow as well. Our ELL or English language learners, you can see significant, so nearly doubled just since 2014. So the number of ELL students that we have coming into our school district is also growing. So the needs of our students are growing. The state's lack of funding for these areas. Now in Arizona, we can't have unfunded mandates, but there's nothing that says we can't have an underfunded mandate. And I would argue that both our special education and ELL populations are well underfunded. So a lot of high needs, a lot of additional resources needed for those students coming into our schools. And we

079lack those resources to provide them with the quality of service that. we believe to be true for all of our students. And so, which ends up siphoning away from other areas in order to meet the needs of these growing populations. There was actually a bill that was going to be dropped that said you have to accept any, so like, for instance, crane. Say we're actually we're at the limit, right? We can't we can't accept anymore only if they're within district. But there was supposedly a bill that was going to drop that said you have to take anyone from anywhere. So it'll be like open enrollment for even them. So like you can't it's like, well, you send them to a charter that that would not work. You basically say you have to stay at you

080can go anywhere, whereas. there's a group that wants it like we shouldn't have to take just anyone we should make sure that we take care of our district first and if we have room we can take them but if we don't have room we shouldn't have to take them they should go back to their neighborhood school or their other district and so i don't know if that's got legs under it still or not but I think there would still be a push for that. Honestly, I think it gets vetoed if it gets to the governor's desk. But I think there seems to be the appetite for some legislators to move in that direction where you have to accept regardless of your capacity. I think some school districts would argue that there are schools. Luckily, we

081don't have any that are significantly deficient and that they're underneath the minimum adequacy guidelines. But there are some that. have structural concerns. And so to say, well, you have the capacity seemingly, but yeah, but that school is not suitable. That doesn't necessarily mean that you have the adequate staffing or even the resources. Like you might have to have special rooms. You might have to have special this, that, or the other. I don't know. But that was a conversation that I was having at the Capitol and they were trying to see how I fell on that situation. I think that's kind of right. But anyways. As a matter of practice, we accept all students if we have the capacity to do so. And that's been our position. And if we do not have the capacity, then

082we let them know we don't have the capacity to do that. And those capacity numbers aren't arbitrary. They're based on program capacity that we set, that the governing board sets every May as well. And so they're not arbitrary numbers. we just make them up. And so we take a lot of pride in making sure that we communicate with our parents and our interested parents as well. Dan, did you have a question? No, I'm wishing to fly. Okay. So our ADM trends, this is Yuma County. Again, this is ADM, so not actual bodies, but how it's calculated based on average daily membership. And so we can kind of see what Crane has been. So in 23, we saw an increase of about 1%. In 24, a loss of 2.5%. In 25, a loss of 2.5%. So

083we've lost 5% over the last two years, and we're expecting that trend to continue. What does that mean for other schools? So here are the other schools within the Yuma area. I included Yuma Elementary School District, Somerton Elementary School District, Gadsden Elementary, and Desert View Academy. You can see that Desert View has seen a loss of 10% over the last two years, so twice as many as what we've experienced. Yuma Elementary, you know, the net is about one and a quarter increase for them. And you can see what it is for the other school districts as well. So South County, which is Somerton and Gadsden, they've seen a significant amount of growth down there for a number of years and starting to see that somewhat taper and speaking with some representatives for both of those

084districts. Just another way to show the same type of trends. So instead of in a table form, a graph form there as well. Any questions on enrollment trends? Like, what can we do about this? Yeah. Great question, Kelly. So internally, and I think hopefully you've all seen the push that we're making for showcasing our schools, we're really wanting the community to see what it is that we offer. We feel that we are the district of choice within the Yuma community. We feel that the services that we provide are above everyone else. And I know every other district probably feels the same way, but we feel that. The results that we provide speak volumes to that as well. So our reputation is that. And so the focus of Lupe and her team and working with the

085principals of really developing these showcases so members of the community can come and learn more about Salida del Sol or Gary Knox Elementary School or Mesquite or Crane Middle and determine what is the best suit for their child. having a dedicated night where those things can happen. So we've thought internally about more what we could do to help market our program. And to be fair, you know, up until 20 years ago, this is the boundary. You're coming to us. We don't have to do anything, right? School districts were here. And so. And when charters came into play, the legislature got upset that school districts were spending money on marketing and said, well, school district, you've placed this competition where they're needing to do that. They should be allowed to spend marketing dollars to share with

086the community why they're the district of choice versus some of these other charter programs that are being provided as well. So they've been less resistant to that. They've been more welcoming to that, creating that competitive type of environment. I don't know if, Laura, if you have anything to add beyond that or Lupin. The hard part is that people just want gallon. They want to go to Gatlin. That's a lottery and it's a whole thing. So if they can't get into gallon, then they're like, see you later. I'm going to Woodsharker. I'm going to use my ESA and go wherever. So I think that's a struggle. I think you're right on that. And then also a big problem is the ESA. Oh, for sure. it's the concept is probably aimed in the right direction, but the

087guardrails are off the charts. Right. And so, you know, when you're, when you're taking, you know, there's been cases where secretaries leave, right. They take their kids because it's tax-free money. And so there's, there's a lot of problems with it. And I think that's. Putting a big drain as well. I think we do what we can do. We're trying. Is there anything legislatively right now in terms of ESA guardrails that has problems? There's no appetite from the leadership of either house to address that. Before Governor Hobbs even took the podium for the state address, they were very open in saying there will be nothing for ESA reform. The state of all the public. kind of outraged about the things that's being spent on and the amount of articles. There does not seem to be any

088appetite for that. You know, I think you bring up an interesting point there, Kelly. I think, you know, we've had a school district in the Phoenix area enter into receivership, and that has generated a lot of turmoil within the education community and also the legislative level of saying there should be some sort of criminal investigation into this. And this is a school district. that is heavily regulated. We have more compliance and regulatory requirements than any other form of education in Arizona. And the state seems to be very concerned about the use or perceived misuse of the resources that we have and seem to be willing to accept whatever happens in the other forms of education, which have fewer regulations and fewer compliance requirements where just seems like there would be a greater opportunity for fraud,

089waste, and abuse within those than what we have, which is heavily regulated. I mean, we have auditors in our office every six months looking at something. And so it's, yeah, I think to your point, there seems to be, that's okay, but school districts, there can't be, you have to be perfect 100% of the time, is how I feel. Good times are had by all. All right. Enrollment projections. The bold at the table to the left, the bold is actual above, and then the red below is based on information provided by the demographic study that we had commissioned in 23. I will share that that was before ESAs or any reporting of the ESAs. So a loss of 11 students or 0.2%, that's not real. And so I won't be able to use this number as

090far as projections, but this graph is illustrative of that because that was something that the district commissioned. It is also a document that I'm seeking to have revised now that we have more data points. excuse me, for the ESA program where we have a better understanding of where those students are and what could really be our true capture rate moving forward and looking at over time. So, you know, we are not performing as well as this would indicate. This is the impact of the empowerment scholarships. A lot of colors, a lot of stuff happening here. I recognize that. So the far left is fiscal year 2021 quarter two. And so that would actually be October, November, December of that year. And then all the way until it's not labeled, but we have quarter one of

091FY25, which is July, August, and September. And then each of the color are the different grade levels. And so you can see where. Let's use first or I'm sorry kindergarten, which is the lime green at the bottom just a sliver and now it's more pronounced so we can see more kindergarten students utilizing that program. And again, this is all the way through 12th grade. And so the the top four obviously 9, 10 and 11 and 12. Just taking a look at K-8, you can see a similar trend. Again, this is statewide, the number of students who are utilizing the program and how that has grown since the universal expansion in Arizona. Specifically for some school districts here in Yuma, the numbers in bold are the highest within any particular reporting period. So you can see

092for Crane and Yuma Elementary School District, as well as Somerton, quarter one of 24 was the highest ESA participants we had seen. Yuma Union was a quarter prior to that, quarter four of 23. And you can see of recent, Gadsden and... Desert View are seeing the highest. So they're now becoming more impacted by the use of ESAs where they weren't before. It's going to be really interesting what happens to Yuma Union by them building a brand new high school when they can't even fill Yuma High. And now they got Somerton. So they're going to have two multimillion dollar operations and nobody there. Yeah, I can't comment on what they're going to be doing. I would just say that- It's interesting to see how- Universally, if we're seeing fewer students and other elementary school systems, whether

093that's charters or school districts, are seeing fewer elementary students, you would- It's going to be compounded when it gets to that. Yes, that they would also see fewer kids in the long term as well. Yep. Anything on that? So for our like retention rate of students, do we know that they're typically staying with us once we have them? Or like have we looked at that from K to 1 to 2 to like how, what percentage of our students are actually staying with us? You know, it's been a couple of years, maybe. four years, 21 was the last time I looked at it. And we had about an 83% retention rate. I haven't looked at it since then. That would be something that I could take a look at and provide that to you, Kelly. I

094think that's a great idea just to see the longevity of when, you know, and that was those that were in kinder and came through. So that wasn't somebody who came in fourth grade and stayed through the system as well. That's something we could put together. I think that would be fascinating to see. And I don't know what's standard for Yuma, right? We know that Yuma has a relatively transient population. So I think we have to look at that number with some caution. There's a certain amount of that that we should expect. It's not going to be 100%. Absolutely. That is not the nature of Yuma's population. But whatever, if you're identifying a target, right, whatever a competitive retention rate would be. Perfect. We can do that. Optimal district capacities. I wanted to bring this up

095because they're in the news of late. A lot of Phoenix schools that are in the midst of closing schools or have consideration in closing schools. Most notably or recently is Phoenix Elementary School District. They're going to be closing two schools, Glendale Elementary, Paradise Valley, Cartwright. A number of other school districts are closing or in the midst of closing. And so I think it. You know, it was a question of, okay, what does that look like for Crane moving forward? And I want to start by saying, I'm not making a recommendation to close any schools. I don't, you know, I don't want that getting out that we're closing any schools. I'm not doing that. I'm not suggesting that. And I think the data will show that we don't need to do that. But I do want

096to share the data with you. So each of you have that. idea or the concept of at what point might that be something that we would want to look at. So the Office of the Auditor General determines that the optimal rate of occupancy is at 75%. And when you take a look at the entire district, if the entire district is at 75% or more, then they won't look at each individual school because they feel that the district is operating efficiently and effectively. So there's no need to pursue that any further. So getting right to the data, if you take a look at what the SFD or the school facilities division has versus what, well, first we'll start with this. So the SFD is the metric that the Auditor General's office uses. And so taking a

097look, you can see that we were using their metric in 2014. We had 95% occupancy and now we're at 85% occupancy. we are still well above the 75% threshold. And this is the metric that is used, again, for when the Office of the Auditor General determines whether or not a building is being efficient. And so you can see, again, both in graph form as well as the table, with the occupancy line at 75%, that we're well above that. When you take a look at what I would consider our program capacities, which is how we set our capacities, it differs a little bit. So when they had 95%, Back in 14, I show 76%. And now they're at 85% in 25 and I show at 76% in 25. And the major difference between that is they

098show. The overall occupancy of the entire building of how it was constructed and I'm showing here's the programs that we have at this site. So Valley Horizon may have a larger ESS population. And so that program capacity is different than Gary Knox, which only has a preschool. classrooms for students with disabilities. So just how those vary from one side to the other. So in both cases, we're above the 75% threshold. And again, the one that matters most is the SFD one that shows we're at 85% occupancy. So, you know, again, no discussion about school closures, but that is the point in which. begin to have those conversations. And I think those school districts that are just now responding, and again, it's easy for me, I'm on the outside, I'm not internal with those discussions, but

099just looking from an outsider perspective in, they may not have been closely monitoring these, and they're having to make some changes rather swiftly. We, as a... It's probably not groundbreaking or earth-shattering, but when we have a resignation or some type of separation of service, we take time to evaluate, is that a position that is needed? Do we need to continue to function with that particular position? Obviously, with student counts fluctuate, we can capture a lot of those losses through natural attrition. We have not had to implement a RIF policy since the Great Recession. Hope we never have to be able to do that either. So I think we can manage some of that stuff just from a staffing perspective where 88% of our budget is tied up in salaries and benefits. So if you really

100want to move the needle, you have to do something that impacts people in order for that to happen. I think we can do that naturally, which we've been able to accomplish over time. And look to continue to do that. But the other school districts that, Glendale Elementary was one of the first that comes to mind, but they ended up closing five. And they lost 16% in a two-year period. And so it went from this to now it's down to 50%. It's like, oh my gosh, what are we doing? Or 60%, what are we doing? And so those things that happen overnight where you're not ready for those to happen, that's where things can sneak up on you as well. Anything on that one? All right. Structural position. This is going to get a little nerdy.

101So a budget deficit occurs when a government spends more than it receives in tax revenue. Our goal is to be what's called structurally balanced, where we are able to operate within the revenues that we receive. And so the idea is I don't want to use carryover dollars. I don't want to be reliant on something external for us to meet our obligations that we have now. So this is, I'm going to walk through this table here. So this bottom line is from 2019 and includes adjustments to DAA through legislative reduction. But the revenue control limit, district additional assistance, those combined, that really equals a majority of our revenue. What we can do is for maintenance and operations and capital. And that total, we'll call it $32.7 million. Our expenditures for that year were $32.6, and so

102we had a surplus of $118,000. So that is a structurally balanced. We operated within the revenues that we were receiving and did not have to use any of the prior year budget balance carry forward in order to meet those obligations. Moving forward into 2020, similar situation. We captured another $350,000 to add to our budget balance. Add a couple more years, you can see how that's grown. And now we're using estrofons. We have the... three waves of COVID relief dollars that are coming through. And so our budget balance is growing because we're using ESSER dollars to offset some of those unanticipated impacts, whether that's a loss of students or whether that's improved operational costs. We hired the academic specialists and put three of those at every elementary site and provided one at each middle school. So

103all of those types of things that are going into here. And now you start to see some red. And again, I'll remind you that this was intentional. When we brought this before the governing board, we said we want to use budget balance carry forward to help with retention stipends or training and safety stipends or some of these one-time purchases because we knew that it wasn't going to be sustainable. We wanted to use them specifically for that piece. And some of that is based on how we're funded or the methodology that's there. So in 2016, the legislature changed from a prior year funding methodology to current year. Prior year was very, very stable, right? I knew exactly how I was going to build the budget. It was based on last year's kids. Well, now I have

104to guess right now how many kids I'm going to have a year from now. And I have no idea. You can see how it fluctuates over time. It's hard to be precise on that. And so if we underestimate and we have more kids that showed up, well, that means that our revenue was higher and maybe we could have done more for... a compensation adjustment than we did before. So now we have this budget balance that's there, and let's use that to provide that as some sort of a stipend or incentive to staff members. So all three of these years were intentional in the deficit spending. But FY25 is the last year in which we're going to be able to do that. Very likely, the recommendation that I'm going to make before the governing board will

105be that we need to go back to a structurally balanced program. ESSER is done. We don't have that to lean on anymore. And so to me, it's very important that we maintain that. But I do just want to bring this to your all's attention as well. Now, by law, Arizona has to be structurally balanced. When they develop the budget, they cannot operate in a deficit. And like that, we don't receive money that allows us to operate outside of those same parameters. Any questions on that? Does the legislature look like, look at those funds and say, you guys have more money than you guys really don't have a problem. You have excess money. I think we should go in and get it. They just reduce the funding later. So do they look at it? Yes, they

106look at fund balance. In fact, part of the annual financial report, we have to identify what our fund balances are, what our specific policies might be for those fund balances. I think there's always the threat, because it's happened before, of the legislature sweeping those fund balances and redistributing them in other ways. There's also what's called dead cash. And so you have cash that's sitting there that's not tied to budget capacity. And I'll give you an example. Let's say that you have budget capacity of $3 million, but you have cash of $6 million. I can only spend the $3 million I have in budget capacity. So the other $3 million sitting in cash is dead. I can't use it for anything. And so, yeah, they could sweep that dead cash and reinvest that to other programs.

107I mean, those are things that they can do and have done before. I'm sorry, Dan? The state will take it from you. Yeah, exactly. Give it to somebody else. Yep. But that is something that they're looking at. They want to take a look at fund balance. And from my perspective, it's irresponsible, probably is a better term, to spend everything down to zero, especially when the AEL is lingering. I mean, I don't know what that impact is. And I want to absorb as much as I can because the livelihood of all of our staff members and the services we provide to our community rests on those estimates. If there are things that are being cut or decisions that are being made that are outside of our control, I feel like I need to have a contingency

108available so I can release that burden from the district. Even if it's a short term saying, okay, we were able to get through that year. Next year, we're going to have to do something different. But I feel strongly that having a contingency and some sort of a reserve policy is the best practice. That is the best. I can vouch for that. I want to, I'm going to plug because we could be in so much trouble if we are not physically responsible. And his job is to make us physically responsible and to go, and this happened in a district I worked with where I had been there and been real physically responsible. The fool that came behind me was not. And the district had to lay off countless people because they lost so much money on

109a downturn. Because you have to always look down the road. And that's what Dale does. I really appreciate what he does. Thank you, Dan. I appreciate that. All right, we're almost to the end here. District maturation. So again, I reached out to a local realtor because I felt like homes weren't being turned over as much. And I said, can you provide me with a report of that in Crane? They're like, ooh, that's going to be a lot. How about just one subdivision? And they said, ooh. I said, what are you wanting to know? I was like, are homes turning over? And they said, no. I said, can you tell me why? They said, yeah, that's easy. It's pricing. and interest rates. I mean, those are the major factors that are there. And so I did

110very limited research here and saw the same thing. Just 2.5% of U.S. homes changed hands this year, the lowest rate in decades. I think it was 30 years. And so I said, OK, that's what I'm seeing within our community is fewer for sale signs, fewer turnover, where you have these newer families coming in and taking homes that are being vacated by a family that's growing and needs a larger home or that's growing in size. And again, it's elevated mortgage rates, it's rising prices and low supply and the economic and political uncertainty. I think these are the three major factors that they shared with me as being the driving force behind that. And we're seeing that too. We're seeing that our older district communities, I'll say the boundaries of maybe Valley Horizon, the boundaries of even

111HL Supercruise or Ronald Reagan, we're seeing those mature a little bit more. The turnover within those residential communities aren't as high. Where we do see some growth, like in Livingston Ranch or Barkley Ranch, typically those aren't the starter homes. You know, those aren't the ones that typically have elementary school age. Maybe they're middle school, maybe they're high school, college there, or they don't have kids at all. And so where we are seeing some of that growth, there's aren't kids aren't attached to those homes or those individuals coming in. And so we're seeing that, you know, ask before Kelly, I think it was. You know what's happened or maybe it was Regina. Is there any speculation? And so this I think this validates some of the speculation that we had internally on that. So just wanted

112to share that information to that. We're seeing less and less of that. Federal funding, just as somewhat of a reminder, here's the things that are there. ESSER is gone. We spent that in June. We had until September of 24 to spend that, but we depleted it all last year. So we have no more ESSER. And then these are the major federal funding sources for the district. Title IA, IC, II, III, and IDEA. There's been a even during President Trump's campaign indicated a desire for increased school choice. We'll talk a little bit more about a an executive order that was released yesterday and then the potential dissolution of the U.S. Department of Education. So all of these uncertainties that are there. I don't think he has the votes to do what he needs to to dissolve

113the U.S. Department of Education personally, but there are a lot of uncertainties. And with that, you know, create some turmoil and really being able to have security in the funding, even in the federal funds that we received. So there was a two week pause on federal funding and Tom Horn issued a statement that it was going to have no impact. on any of the economically disadvantaged schools. Well, it became moot anyway because the federal government pulled it back and they said, we changed our mind. We're not doing that. So we're not doing that review. It created a lot of confusion. So we don't have to worry about that one anymore. But yesterday was the expanding educational freedom and opportunity for families executive order, which really is a piece of that is seeing what can be

114done to it's that top one guidance on supporting state based K-12 educational choice. So how can more federal funds be moved to students who are choosing an alternative besides a public school district, whether that's a charter or through the empowerment scholarship? So even at the federal level, looking at way to funnel more money. away from the school district and to these other programs there. You're free to read that at your leisure if you're interested. It's only, I think, a page and a half, the executive order, but these are the areas that that executive order hopes to capture through this, quote, educational freedom and opportunity for families EO. And one of the last things is the governor's address. During Governor Hobbs' State of the State address, she spoke on just a few things with regards to

115education. One is the impending expiration of Proposition 123, which it seems like won't harm us from a financial perspective, but I think there's opportunities for us to grow from a financial perspective if we can also alleviate the stress that that puts on the general fund. addressing the AEL and then bipartisan solutions to create sustainable world-class schools for our children and parents deserve and really gearing that towards ESA. Are there ways in which we can create some parameters or guardrails to ensure that the public's dollars are being used most appropriately? If it's good for us, and I appreciate former Senator Bennett's comments when we met with him in a... a group setting when we're going through the modernization of Title 15. He said, if it brings value, let's do it. And if it's good for one,

116it should be good for everyone. And so if regulation is too much here, then let's either bring everybody up or let's reduce everyone else down. So I guess in summary. We're seeing a decline in overall student enrollment. We're seeing a decrease in our K-3 students. We're seeing an increase in students with disabilities and English language learners. We're seeing a decrease in operating revenues with increased associated costs driven by all of those things. Even with declining enrollment, building utilization is currently considered efficient. We continue to increase focus on other revenue sources. We are seeing a potential redirection of federal funds that's looming out there. And our focus is returning back to a structurally balanced budget. So I think that's all that I had. If there are any other questions or if there's things that you would

117like to see that I didn't cover or beyond what we've already talked about. I just have a question about the ELL and ESF students. So obviously we know it's an underfunded mandate. What roughly is the discrepancy there, like in terms of what's our actual typical spend, average spend for an EL student and an ESF student compared to what we actually have? We're only getting about 40% of what we need. And IDEA, which is federally funded, they're supposed to fund at 40%, and we're only getting 17% of that funding. Anything that can be done about that? So I do know that there are, for the federal level, we have advocacy groups through our international association. So we're part of ASBO International. They have a legislative advocacy group. In fact, Mike Berrigan from Glendale Elementary School District

118served as Arizona's delegate. And he met with several representatives and senators from Arizona and elsewhere. bring light to that and that they claim that was something that they that they found that was important to them. I think locally or here at the state the legislature increased the group b weights for what we call OHI or other health impairments. They increased that by 300%, which was great. But that's, you know, autism is one that's underfunded and that should be looked at. Hearing impairment is one that's underfunded and should be looked at too. So every year there's a push to have a special education study completed to evaluate what that should look like on a statewide basis and usually is met with some resistance because I think the state feels if they do the study, and they

119have the number then they feel compelled that they need to do something with it so if we just don't do the study we ignore it then it's not a problem again that's my my feeling yeah not representative of the district or the administration any other questions concerns we're not inaccurate though the only question i because i don't fully understand how gowan operates and if that's something that can be that model can be done in other schools right because we talk about obviously gowan is a very high demand school, right? So, you know, are there opportunities to create another STEM school or to do, you know, arts and music school, right? Like, is there an interest in doing that? Is there a way to do that, right? But, don't forget. We've looked at that as possibilities

120because of the choice for parents. One of the things the schools have embedded is that 21st century after school so that you're bringing in arts, et cetera. Jamie Haynes, who was the principal since Gowan's inception, she basically built her baby to the school that is now real big. She was just... got the position of the curriculum director that works with all the schools. So part of her charge is to try to work with other people as far as they do more STEM and innovation and some of that stuff. She and Pueblo have worked on student agency with kids with more voice and choice. We've seen some really great growth with our middle school age students, which is a lot of times difficult to do. So they're going to work together with that. So hopefully that

121will help roll out. Pull a few more of those students that are otherwise going to charter. I would add that when we take a look at focus schools, so we looked at fine arts and we struggle finding one band teacher. And so getting a school full of band teachers can be equally challenging. The equipment cost isn't so overwhelming. It's finding the people to fill those. So we've looked at different. what areas of focus we could have at every campus and meeting with principals and fine arts was one of them. And it's like, we can't find one elementary band teacher, let alone a school with many of them. So some of it is just the supply too. It's interest, but staffing. Right. Anything else? Okay, we're going to go to consideration of adoption of resolution of

122application to receive advanced state aid. And Mr. Ponder, I'd like to... You can expand on that. Thank you, Mr. Moore. Yes, actually, my recommendation at this time for the governing board would be to table this item. And the reason behind that is the district has sufficient cash now to address this. And really, because it operates in a lag, whatever you all would enact now might be available for FY27, beginning in 27. And the idea behind that was it would give me some flexibilities in determining what registered warrant fees, if any, might be incurred in 27 and then apply that to recapture that budget capacity. After reviewing this a little bit more, I would recommend that the Governing Board table this item, allow us to continue to monitor this moving forward, and if there's a need

123for us to seek an advancement on our state aid moving forward so that we can recapture that budget capacity in a subsequent year, we could do it at that time. So table it until further notice? Indefinitely, yes. Table it indefinitely? We still need to... Yeah, I'll make a motion to table. I'll second. Okay, there's been a motion to table the action indefinitely. Any discussion? So probably move in second. Let's proceed to vote. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, same sign. All right, motion passes. I move we're adjourned. Second. Any discussion? Let's vote. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, same sign. Motion passes unanimously.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.