CorpusRecord 105072

January 14th, 2025 - Governing Board Meeting of Crane Elementary School District No. 13, Yuma, AZ

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / Crane Schools
Date
2025-01-15
Location
Yuma County, AZ
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,719 words · about 49 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I am now proud to say that I'm an eighth grader at Centennial Middle School. Our goal was to get 100 pairs of socks to donate to the Crossroads Mission by the end of winter break. Luckily, we managed to reach our goal. But not only did we surpass it by like two times or three times, we managed to surpass it by a total of eight times our goal and get a total of 818 pairs of socks. Without our community, we don't think it would have been possible to just do this alone. So we're very happy for all the help that parents, students, and other community members gave. Hello, my name is Ines Quesada. I previously went to Pueblo Elementary and now I'm an eighth grader here at Centennial. So what exactly do our students think about

002this program? Well, some of them have said, Need for Change empowered student voice. It's given me the inspiration to try. And I am confident I am a leader. So as you heard earlier, we did surpass our goal, but there was still so much more that we could have done for our community. So that's why, in my opinion, it's okay to fail as long as you fail forward. Our original SMART goal was too low. We could have helped many more people by taking our project outside of CTMS. So going forward, we will challenge every school in the Crean District to fill a box of socks and contribute to help our community thrive. And there are additional slides to this presentation in case you want extra information. Thank you so much. No problem. I'm sure. A few

003last little comments. Once again, I'm so proud of my students. About three years ago in the classroom, we came up with the Iron Giraffe Project, where we raised $1,000 to build a well in Sudan when we were leading a long walk to water. And being the teacher that I am, we needed to submit that project to Lead for Change for what you see up here on the board that they have. and Lead for Change Challenge Winner Award. And I have been communicating with our state representative all through our process with our project the first time we did Lead for Change. And I failed to submit. Their selection committee reached out to me and said, you know what? Centennial Middle School was in the running. You just needed to submit. I felt this big that I

004let my students down. So I'm very proud to say that this year we will not be submitting one, but we will be submitting two Lead for Change Channelist projects, and I know they are going to be amazing. I'm so proud of you guys. Great. If you have any more questions, Ms. Pico and I are always available to answer your questions, as long as it's not during class. Thank you. That was a wonderful program. Thank you for sharing. Inclusivity is a great component of it. I'm confident that you already are leaders and will be. That's a great program. Thank you. Okay, now. Okay, I'll figure out who's got this band here in a minute. It'll be Valley Horizon will have the band for us. Thank you. It's set both schools back. It's our turn. Good evening,

005ladies and gentlemen of the board, executive team, and our guests. I'm Leslie Momert and proud to be the principal at Valley Horizon Elementary School. Tonight, we wanted to showcase the talents of our band students from several of our district schools since we do share a band teacher. This year, we were very fortunate to find an amazing band teacher, Mrs. Eloisa Arvizo over there. Mrs. Arvizo serves multiple schools in the district, including Valley Horizon, Salida del Sol, HL Supercruz, Gary Knox, and Gallant Science Academy, and works with 5th through 8th grade students from beginning band to advanced middle school band. I'm going to turn this over to Leslie from the band, and we hope that you enjoy their performance. My name is Leslie, and I am a student at Valley Horizon. My fellow bandmates... from different

006schools in our district, including Gary Knox and Selena Del Sol. In band, we learn discipline, teamwork, and perseverance. These experiences help us grow into leaders and responsible citizens. As young ambassadors, we represent our schools through performances that inspire and unite us. We would like to be more active in our community, and in order to do that, we need... access to quality instruments. We need your continued support in fostering our potential regardless of zip code. Thank you for your time. So as you heard, these are students from five different schools in a district. And these are particularly beginning band students. So these are students who are playing for you. We've only been playing together from the beginning of the year to now. We have two very short pieces for you. I think you will recognize both

007of them. So are you guys ready? Here we go. One, two. Thank you, Mr. Arbiccio, and thank you, kids, for doing that. I was kind of absent-minded here a little bit. I should have introduced our new board member, Kelly Osborne. I should have done this before we had the band. I don't want her to think we're going to put a band show on for every time she shows up. So you'll have to just remember this one. And anytime you have any questions, she'll be able to answer them, I'm sure. Okay, thank you. Now we will have... Can I make a comment? Yes, you can. I'd like to acknowledge these band kids because I know how hard it is. I didn't make it. I didn't. I started off with a tenor sax and believe me, it

008was... But I have a granddaughter. Hey, I have a granddaughter that played in the BYU Marching Band, played the piccolo. So you can do it. And it's very exciting when you can do it well. Thank you. Anyone else? Over the airwaves. Okay. Thank you very much. And at this time. We will have Mr. Ryan Tyree will introduce the staff who will present on the school's occupational development program, which was created to further engage students in learning about workplace. Thank you, Mr. Tyree. Good evening. Good evening, members of the board, and welcome, Ms. Osborne. Welcome to the district. I think you have a child here, but great place to be, so welcome. I really wanted us to present last year, but it was really early on in January, and I think it was the second Tuesday,

009right, that we came back. But Mr. Francis coaches a lot of our sports. He started this program, and then I think he got it going at the end of the year last year. But what he's done this year has been amazing as far as really getting these student leaders that are to present here. been able to sustain this program. They're actually the ones that run this program while Mr. Francis is coaching out on the field. But I'm really excited just for this program, these kids. This is all Mr. Francis's idea and really complements the learning that we do inside the classroom. But after school and our kids really get an opportunity to learn some valuable work skills. and really prepares them for their first job, right? And they prepare something to put on their resume,

010but I'm going to let Mr. Francis explain. Or maybe in the interim you can say next slide and then you can advance forward. Thank you for having us here. My name is Jeff Francis. I am the career exploration teacher at Crane Middle School. And I created this program originally because I worked for an organization called Arizona at Work. And I saw a great need in the community to improve our community members' ability to... build their soft skills and keep their employment or retain their employment. We have a big issue in the community with people who they think they want to do something and they try it out and it just doesn't work out because they decided they didn't either like it and they didn't get that opportunity to explore that career field or they decided

011that it was tough and they didn't have those necessary skills to push through that adversity and move on. Can you advance the slide, please? So what is ODP? ODP is our occupational development program for our students at Crane Middle School. It is a comprehensive program that was put together to help the students gain hands-on experience in the workplace. And it is volunteer experience. So they are working for simulated paychecks and they are getting real hours working in both our cafeteria as well as with our custodial staff. And then we have some different positions as well where the students gain real live work experience. It's important because, as I mentioned, working for Arizona at work, I worked with a lot of adults in the community who didn't have these basic skills that they needed to obtain

012and retain employment. And I thought, because I'm a teacher now, I get to help students learn those skills earlier on, and I get to prepare them for that future. So we don't have that issue with high turnover or attrition rates in the workplace. It's also important because it instills a strong work ethic in some of our students and it helps them prepare for the real world later on. There are some studies, if you read the slides, that explain how this experience early on can engage the students further in. their studies as well. It is proven that students who spend time in after-school programs, sports, or academic programs after school are more engaged in their studies and do better overall academically. On the side, Jeff, it may have to be turned on. We try to give

013you all the options. All right, so my program has two primary goals. There's long-term goals and short-term goals. The short-term goals, I apologize, is to provide hands-on experience in different fields for the students so they can gain those necessary soft skills earlier on, such as responsibility, communication, time management, problem solving, collaboration, and all of these additional little soft skills that they get that you would normally get in a regular job gaining regular work experience as an adult. but they're gaining it earlier on so they're a little bit more prepared. In this program we also ensure that they get certification that they can use in the future to carry on into a real career. The two certifications that we obtain currently are the KOSH Safe Use of Cleaning Chemicals certification. It's actually a certification that's based

014out of the UK. The certification here in the US would be known as OSHA certification. However, it is a 40 hour plus program. And I am working with 12 to 14 year old students. So it's a little bit. So they learn how to handle cleaning chemicals safely and then use them with the custodial team at the school. And then they also get their food handlers cards. And we do a quick little course on that. And we talk about food preparation, safety, foodborne illnesses and sanitation. Then they use that certification. in a practical hands-on experience position working in our cafeteria with our cafeteria staff supervised by the cafeteria manager and then they work with the chemical certification with our custodial team and under the supervision of the custodians and the custodial supervisor. The long-term goals of

015this program is to reduce workforce turnover in our community. Ultimately, the biggest thing is supporting our community and helping our students become future members of our community and this society and to promote their strong work ethic and professionalism. So when they get there, they're better off than we were. We have several positions within our program. As I mentioned, there's cafeteria and food service. We also have custodial team members. And then I have two administrative employees who are with us here today. We have a human resources employee who handles several different. excuse me, several different things in her position and I'll let her speak on that. And then we have a payroll representative as well because as these students work, she clocks all of their hours on a simulated time sheet and then she provides simulated

016pay stubs which include federal and state taxes being removed from their pay. And then we have the CEO of the program who's absent most of the time coaching soccer and that would be myself while the students run and operate their own program. The cool thing about this program is it gains them that real world experience. It helps them develop those necessary soft skills that they're going to need later on in life. And each person is different and each work environment that they're going to go into is going to be different. So they're going to learn the skills that work for them and the things that they're stronger at. They'll have the opportunity to build upon. It also helps them realize that there's different career fields out there. and it builds their opportunity to network with

017different industry professionals. When they leave the program at the end of the year, we will have resumes generated that help them find a job in the future. In the state of Arizona, you only have to be 14 years old to obtain employment, and some of my students are able to obtain employment when they leave our school. It also has a positive impact on the community. As I mentioned before, students or young professionals going into the workplace will better prepare them and decrease ultimately that turnover rate at the end of the day. The benefits for the school is it improves student engagement. Students that are happier at school are going to do better in school and it enhances that climate. improves their achievement. It also creates positive community partnerships because I bring in business professionals from

018the community to come and present in our school and share challenges that they have with their employees, with my program employees. It also addresses workforce needs as we do have that high attrition or turnover rate in the workforce. There are several next steps to the program. I hope to secure additional funding so eventually these students can gain potentially real paychecks, maybe not at the full wage, but learning the state laws and getting them a little bit of real money so they can have that benefit and continue recruiting and training additional students, developing partnerships with local businesses so I can get more businesses involved and potentially get some of my 14-year-old young professionals employed in a real position over the summer before they start high school. And then I hope to market the program to more

019students and parents coming into our school and within other schools to let them know that this program is available to improve their child's future. And then obviously I am evaluating and continuing to change the program as we see fit or as we see the need to improve upon different processes. I'm now going to let my employees take over and talk about a few of the positions that we have within the program and their experiences. Thank you. Hello, my name is Carmen Tudor. I am the finance manager at Crane Middle School's occupational program. I keep track of employee hours on timesheets, which I convert into simulator pay stubs. I also use an online simulator called SmartAsset to calculate stay and federal taxes. I have learned how to manage my time and how to interact better socially.

020Hello, my name is Reese Thompson and I am a student at Crane Middle School and I am part of the Occupational Development Program. And in it, I am able to run the snack bar and help out students by getting them snacks during lunch. And I also get to pass behind the window during the cafeteria with the cafeteria leaders and get to pass out food. And I also, after school, get to shadow the janitors and help them with their job. And while I'm doing this, I get to learn some really valuable skills, such as money handling, teamwork, and good time management. So I'm really grateful for this program because I think it helps prepare me for the real world and the workforce. Thank you. Hello, my name is Eliana. I am the HR or human resource

021person at ODP. As such, I do juggle a lot of tasks, some of which are, of course, I make the schedule so that people know when to come into work. I ensure that employer certifications are on date, are up to date. I'm sorry. I screen and train new employees. I also handle our PQIs, which are performance quality indicators, which I hand out to the supervisors to ensure that all employees are working efficiently. And yeah, thank you. I want to... I want to thank the board for your time and I want to thank the community for listening to our program and hearing about it. And if anyone's interested or has any questions, you can reach me at Crane Middle School, same as Centennial, preferably not during classes, but anytime before or after. Thank you so much.

022Any questions for the board or the community? I just have one if I could. How do you manage sick time? Do you have people calling in sick? Do you have leave hours? We do use a program called Talking Points. I don't have to share my direct phone number and I don't get 2 a.m. text messages from students. And my students do reach out to me and they let me know if they're going to be sick from school. Actually, this morning I had a parent because she took her son's cell phone away. She emailed me the doctor's note from her son saying he was going to miss work. That's great. And then our HR representative found a replacement. Thank you. Thank you. I can't forget to say that you guys are ready. You don't have to

023probably stay for the rest of the meeting if you don't want to. So feel free. Thank you very much. Thank you guys. Nice job. Okay. Okay. B1. The superintendent needs to provide members of the governing board and the residents of Crane schools with a monthly statement of current happenings and pending events, including information about student academic achievement. Ms. Loring. Thank you, Mr. Colby. I wanted to start off. There's a new face on the dais. As Mr. Colby had mentioned earlier, we want to welcome Kelly Osborne. It's her first time serving on a school board. Kelly is the Sunset Health Behavioral Health Director. She's also a mom of two children and her husband is a teacher. So she has a real passion for education. So I wanted to welcome her here. We also have three members

024that just started another term. Dan Farr just started a two-year term again. And Jim Colby started a four-year term again. Marcos, who's online, started a four-year term again. Each of them have signed their oath of office, typically in January after we have new board members. Tom Hurt from the Yuma County Superintendent's Office comes down and does a ceremonial recognition and swears them in. However, he had a conflict tonight, but they did sign their oath of office. So I want to welcome all of them. And Regina is continuing part of her four-year term. She's halfway through that, so she still has two years. So I'm going to segue into it's Board Member Appreciation Month. January is School Board Appreciation Month, which is a great time to focus on the critical role. Our elected school board officials

025play in our communities and our schools. We appreciate their dedication and hard work. They're extraordinary people who voluntarily tackle the enormous job of governing school districts. Their actions and decisions affect the present and future lives of our children. We'd like to formally thank all school board members for this commitment and sacrifice. Thank you all for your service. Gowen Science Academy. Gowan Science Academy's Future Farmers of America chapter competed in their first career development event, the CDE, last month at Arizona Western College. They had students participate in team and individual events. The ag business team of Blake Daniels, Manny Mendeville, Eric Ronhell, and Tony Alberigi placed second with Eric Ronhell taking third place for the individual score. They had two livestock evaluation teams compete. Team A, Ryland Patterson, Jacob Boggs, Lincoln Marks, and Lexi Gray took

026second place as a team. And the following individual awards based on individual scores, we have Rylan Patterson for fourth place, Lincoln Marks fifth, Jacob Boggs sixth, On Team B, we have Olivia Bowers, Tegan Van Horn, Aubrey Bosch, and Grace Escalante, who placed fourth as a team, with Olivia's individual score earning her the eighth place as an individual. They also had two students compete as individuals in employment skills. Reese Casey earned fifth place, and Macy Bostic took seventh. We are so proud of these Gators who represented very well against area high schools, even though they're another school. Their first LEGO League teams competed in December at the regional competition. The GatorBots 1 team received second place and the GatorBots 2 team received the Innovation Award and will advance to the state competition. The IT department accomplishes

027the ISCCC course completion. Professional development has always been a key component of Crane, and I'd like to commend the entire IT department. Each of them completed the cybersecurity coursework to become certified. Being cybersecurity certified is crucial for safeguarding sensitive data and maintaining the integrity of digital systems. With increasing cyber threats, certification ensures that professionals are equipped with the latest knowledge, skills, and best practices to identify vulnerabilities to prevent breaches and respond effectively to incidents. U.S. News and World Report. The U.S. News and World Report, which is the global authority in education rankings, released the 2025 Best Elementary and Middle School Rankings. The report includes more than 103,000 public elementary and middle schools that are ranked at the state and district level. The 2025 Best Elementary and Best Middle School Rankings are based on publicly available

028data from the U.S. Department of Education. The rankings methodology focused on state assessments of students who are proficient or above proficient in mathematics, reading language arts, while accounting for student background and achievement in core subjects. Student-teacher ratios are also applied to break ties in the overall score. The 2025 Best Elementary and Middle School Rankings offer parents a way to evaluate how schools are providing a high-quality education and preparing students for future success. Research continues to indicate that how students perform academically at these early grades is a big factor in their success in high school and beyond. I am absolutely thrilled to announce that each and every one of our 10 schools made this ranking. So congratulations to all 10 schools. Bond Projects. We would like to express our sincere gratitude for our community's support in

029passing the Crane District Bond Election in the November of 2023. Your approval enables us to secure vital funding for important projects that restore and enhance the learning environments for our students and strengthen the community as a whole. On the screen, you can see some of the improvements to our facilities because of these bond dollars. Unfortunately, we're unable to show all of these projects and the impact that the generous support has had on our students and staff. However, I did want to highlight a few to include landscaping projects at our middle schools down the left-hand side, new parking lots at a couple of our elementary schools, which is on the right-hand side of the screen, and the new secure lobbies for Knox, Mesquite, and Crane Middle School, which are pictured. Of the $10 million of bonds

030sold last fiscal year, we've already expended or obligated 72% of the proceeds to address the priorities identified at the Governing Board Appointed Facilities Advisory Committee on Capital Improvement Planning. The category of projects includes weatherization, roofing, flooring, safety and security, landscaping, HVAC, playgrounds, new buses, and general school renovations. Later in this meeting, the Governing Board will be considering the sale of the remaining authorization from the November 2023 election. If approved, we'll be seeking to continue through the prioritized listing, including adding secure lobbies at the remainder of our schools over the upcoming summer break. Once again, thank you to our community for your continued commitment to education and supporting the needs of the school and students. Martin Luther Jr. holiday is coming up. All schools and the district office will be closed this coming Monday, January 20th,

031in observance of Martin Luther King Jr.'s birthday. Members of the board, this is my report for this month. Thank you. Now we should be on. E2, legislature or other government actions. Sometimes issues that could impact crane schools are considered by various legislative and or administrative bodies in the state or the federal government. Members of the governing board need to be aware of those issues and provide appropriate direction to initiate or respond to them. This agenda item offers members of the governing board the opportunity to discuss, take positions, or propose legislation and rules, and or direct the administration to research such issues. That would be you, Mr. Ponder. Thank you, Mr. Colby, members of the board. Yes, yesterday started the legislative session. Governor Hobbs provided her state of the state address in that dealt with some

032areas related to education, primarily. addressing Proposition 123 that's set to expire in 2026. I'm already thinking of the following year, but for FY26 that's set to expire. The aggregate expenditure limit continues to be an annual issue that school districts have to wrestle with. And then in addition to that is putting some guardrails or more. parameters around reform to the empowerment scholarship accounts and how those are currently functioning. Those are the three areas that she highlighted within her state of the state address. We will have the details of her executive budget on Friday afternoon. Typically, it's released around 2.30, 3 o'clock. We'll have a little bit more of an idea of what funding she might include within public education. To begin, Senate President Warren Peterson made a few comments before Governor Hobbs took the podium, which

033he stated Republicans would raise teacher pay above the national average, protect school choice, fund the recently passed Border Act, and ensure Florida-type election results timing. So those are initiatives of the... Republican leadership, at least from the Senate, what their priorities will be. So we ultimately will find out that what happens within Arizona will be somewhere in the middle. That's kind of the extent the House. House Education Committee met today. They heard three bills and then also heard presentations from the Auditor General's office with regards to the emergency operations plan audit that concluded in December. That report was released, shared some of the findings of that, gave the Department of Education and Department of Emergency Military Affairs an opportunity to respond to those findings before the House Committee. In addition to that, a presentation was provided

034on the SFOB or the School Facilities Oversight Board. Following that action, the House Education Committee unanimously approved the continuation of the SFOB for another two-year period. So that would be through up to July of 2027 is what was included within that. And then some changes within the operations plan. None of this is final yet. Obviously, it needs to go through the other chamber, has to go through those processes and ultimately to the governor's desk. But those are some of the items that are currently we're looking at now. I will share with regards to extending Proposition 123, a big area of focus from the Republican leadership is really putting additional money to teacher salaries, specifically identifying a $4,000 increase to that so we could reach national averages on the statewide teacher. compensation structure. So those are

035things that we're also looking at moving forward. So with that, I'll pause for any questions, if any. Are there any questions? I have a few. So in terms of what was presented so far, are there any reasonable solutions to those issues that have been presented so far? I've not seen any yet, no. So to be determined? Correct. Yes. Okay. And then any other things that we need to be aware of in terms of advocacy needs? Have there been any other proposed legislation related to education that we need to be aware of? That's a great question, Ms. Osborne. So there's a lot of pieces that are still kind of happening on the outside. Nothing really been drafted. I'd say we share, we as part of EFRG or the Education Finance Reform Group. Forum group also agree

036that the extension of Prop 123 is important and also addressing the AEL. I'd say those are two of our biggest priorities. In addition to getting the funding that we have this year that's expected to be reduced next year within special education and poverty weights, we would like to have those things reinstated. So those are kind of our priorities. I've shared with others that We can have strong programs. We can have strong systems if we have the financial resources. So from my perspective, and this may be selfishly minded, but I think advocating for more money will allow us to buy curriculum, will allow us to pay staff better, will allow us to do all of those types of things. So I'm not sure that I answered the question, but there's a lot of information that's probably

037yet to come. Yeah. Anyone else? Marcos? Regina? No. Nothing for me. I have none. Okay. F1, all reports on conferences, workshops, and school visitations. Periodically, members of the governing board attend various conferences, seminars, workshops, districts, schools, and so forth, and have information to share with other members. Do we have any? Yes, Mr. Farr. I was privileged this past week or so to... Miss Baker, who was here. Thank you, Lauren. My granddaughter's teacher. And they did a historical survey on Jimmy Carter. And I got to participate in that. Well, I didn't see the outcome, but Miss Baker told me that it was a hit. Really, I thought I was really excited. I got to participate and then my granddaughter's... presented well, so I thought that was pretty good. The older days, I'm feeling better about school.

038Marcos or Regina? No, I don't have any updates. Mr. Moore? I have none. Okay. Well, last month, we attended, several of us attended the school board conference in Scottsdale. Some very interesting topics of and breakout sessions. It's, you know, you think you know a lot about school until you go to one of those. Then you go, wow. Things that come up, but certainly was worthwhile. Okay. Consideration of adoption of hearing officers to conduct discipline, student discipline, staff discipline hearings. Yay. The governing board needs to approve the use of hearing officers to conduct student and staff discipline hearings for the district. At a regular governing board meeting on December 13th, the governing board adopted the use of a hearing officer. I should have said December 13, 2016. Is that the wrong number? A hearing officer to

039conduct discipline hearings with the exception of expulsion hearings. It was directed at the time to adopt that this item be brought back before the board for approval each school year. The administration would like to recommend the governing board adopt the full hearing officer listing, including those in Yuma County, trained and approved through the Arizona School Risk Retention Trust, incorporated and hearing officers for our district. Would you like to say something about this? Just basically, as he said, the people that are listed on this document have had formal training. They've all been approved by the trust. So they've had that formal training. We have some that are in Yuma. However, we would like to approve the entire list just in case they weren't available at some time. We can go outside of Yuma for our officers.

040Is there any discussion on that? We need to have a motion to vote on this discussion. I just think it's a good idea because if we have a conflict of interest, we can pull someone in from a different area. I'm for that idea. It's a great idea. Anybody else? Anyone would like to make a motion? So moved. Second? Second. It's been moved and seconded. At this time, all in favor, please say aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. So carries. Okay. Next, consideration of adoption of proposed amended governing board policies. Based upon, okay, an amendment to governing board policies is needed. Based upon a rule change issued by the State Board of Education, the trust is proposing a substantive policy revision to policy 5-203 regarding the provision of transition services to schools with disabilities. The trust is

041also proposing... style revisions to policy 5-203 and to three other policies listed below. The trust is proposing changes to the following four policies in order to improve clarity and or conform style. Policy 1-301 regarding rules of order, policy 5-203 regarding students with disabilities, Policy 5-204 regarding students with disabilities procedure safeguards, individuals with Disability Education Act, and Policy 5-408 regarding aging prevention. The Executive Administration has recommended pertaining to these policies listed below are presenting. Move, Commander. Presenting those for adoption, correct. I just wanted to make one quick comment. It mentioned in the write-up that there was substantive changes. Those actually only apply to high school, and it's about transition services for students in high school so that when they start in ninth grade, they start looking at when they are going to graduate and making a

042goal for that and looking at it. That section, actually, we removed. So everything before you are just style changes on these. So would we have a motion? I move that we accept the changes as listed. So it's been moved and seconded. At this time, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Aye. So carried. Five-oh. Okay. Okay, now. Okay. Consideration and discussion of comments and concerns from the public. Those wishing to address the governing board on items not on the agenda may do so at this time. Speakers are requested to hold their comments to three minutes. Individuals addressing the governing board may not yield any portion of their allotted time to any other individual wishing to address the governing board. In accordance with the Arizona Open Meeting Law, board members may respond to criticism made by

043those who have addressed the board, may ask staff to review a matter, or may ask that the matter be put on a future agenda. However, board members shall not discuss or take legal action on matters raised during an open call to the public unless matters are properly noticed for discussion and legal action. Do we have anyone that's speaking? Okay. Let's go to the next part of this. This is longer. I had to get it to come up. Okay. Anyone wishing to address the board on items on tonight's agenda may do so at this time or at the chair's discretion at the time the item appears on the agenda. Comments should be restricted to three minutes, not including board questions and comments and responses by the speaker. Individuals addressing the governing board may not yield any

044portion of their allotted time to any other individual wishing to address the governing board. In accordance with the open meeting law, board members may respond to criticism made by those who have addressed the board, may ask staff to review a matter, or may ask that a matter be put on a future agenda. However, board members shall not discuss or take legal action on matters raised during an open call to the public unless the matters are properly noticed for discussion and legal action. Are there any people for that? Okay. Consent agenda. Okay. The consent agenda conserves time by limiting the items to those of a routine nature, which normally do not require deliberations on a part of the governing board. The time or the items will be accepted and approved in one action unless a board

045member wishes to have an item separated from the consent agenda and specifically discussed. The vote or action on any item removed from the consent agenda will be taken separately. I move we approve the consent agenda as listed. I'll second. Okay, so it's been moved and seconded. All in favor of the consent agenda, please signify by saying aye. Aye. Aye. Thank you. Me? Come on. I'm getting there. Hey, um, by the way, can I can I add something I should have said? About things that we do as board members. I want to say that I've been to every school that had their parking lots repaved and striped and they really look good. Agreed. So I should have said that I'm old. All right. Now we're going to be adoption from gifts of the public. Branch school

046board. I guess this is it. Okay. Crane School Board Procedure 3-106. Federal grants and other funds accepted of gifts and donations required of gifts made by the district, by individuals or organizations be reviewed and officially accepted by the Crane Governing Board. Is there a sheet or anything that should be on there that I'm not aware of? Attachment. Comment. Dan wants to comment. Dan. I should have been at the migrant parent meeting. I don't need to read it. Okay. Anyone have any comments on gifts from public? In terms of comments, I just think it's really impressive. A number of these are things that were led by teacher initiatives. And so, you know, they've done their own work to advocate for their classrooms. And, you know, I think it's really impressive that the work that they've been

047able to do. We appreciate their effort. I move we accept the gift listing as submitted. I'll second. Okay, moved and seconded. All in favor? Aye. Opposed, say no. Okay. This is J1. to consider and if deemed advisable to adopt a resolution authorizing insurance and sale of school improvement bonds of the district and adopting certain written continuing disclosure compliances or compliance procedures and an issuance of post insurance tax compliance procedure. Recommended adopt a resolution. ordering the issuance and sale of school improvement bonds of the district, adopt certain written, continuing disclosure compliance procedures and issuance and post-issuance tax compliance procedure. Grant authority to the superintendent and the chief of finance and operations to approve the final terms and conditions of the bonds. to take all steps necessary to complete the financing and direct Stifel, Nicholas and Company

048Incorporated as underwriters to complete the financing. We voted, this was from 2023, wasn't it? A special bond election was held on November 7th in 2023, in which the majority of the qualified electors voting authorized the issuance of $20 million in school improvement bonds for Crane Elementary School District. The bonds are classified Class B, bonds for all purposes of Arizona revised statutes, Title 15, Chapter 4, Article 5. The district is now proposing the issuance and sale not to exceed 10 million in Class B bonds from the school improvement bond authorization. The sale will exhaust the authorization from November 2, 2023. Election funds will be used pursuant to voter information pamphlet. Attached is a bond resolution that... authorizes the issue or issuance and sale not to exceed $10 million in school improvement bonds included in the authorization

049of the sale of bonds is authority to issue a notice inviting proposals and superintendent and the chief finance and operation to sell the bonds in a manner that best benefits the district. The sale of bonds will be overseen by, I don't even know where I am now. Do you feel better? I think this is it. Draft copies of continuing disclosure certificate, bond registrar and paying agent contact and a draft preliminary official statement have been included. Representatives from Stifel, Nicholas and company will provide the governing board with a brief presentation to review the historical property values and tax rates in the district as well as the project. projected property tax rate associated with the bond sale with comparison to the voter pamphlet. Additionally, information will be provided that gives the governing board information about the current

050bond market and overview of this bond sale timing. Thank you, Mr. Colby. We can thank our bond legal counsel for drafting that. Make sure we check all the boxes to make sure it's totally compliant with all applicable laws. So, yes, thank you. A lot of materials you have before you in your board packet. Many of those are still in draft form, primarily the preliminary official statement. It is preliminary. And so the official statement will be released following. or near the sale of the bonds. I'm going to invite Bob Casillas from Stiefel to come up to the front to provide this presentation as he makes his way to the top, makes his way to the front. As indicated, this will exhaust the authorization that was provided by the voters back in November 2023. All the projects

051will continue to be spent in accordance with the voter information pamphlet and from the the committee that we put together to help prioritize and evaluate the projects. Jim Geale, who is the district's bond counsel, had shoulder surgery on Friday, so he apologizes for not being able to be here. He was willing to send someone in his absence or be available by phone. I shared with him that aside from Ms. Osborne, the rest of the board has had experience in working through this before, and so I gave him the night off. However, if you do have questions that keep you from being able to move forward this evening, I'd be happy to reach out to Jim for that. He said that he would be available. So with that, I'm going to turn the time over to

052Bob Casillas with Stiefel to provide you with a lot more of the nuts and bolts of the presentation, including some of the questions with regards to the tax implications, as well as what the current rate of bonds might be. Oh, also, I'm sorry, Bob. I did want to share that Bob has provided handouts to the board as well as executive team members for the presentation. Again, the same presentation is included within your materials, so you have an electronic version in addition to what Bob has provided. Perfect. Good evening. Board President, fellow board members, executive staff as well. Appreciate the opportunity to be here tonight. Time does fly. A year ago, I think it was last March, I was here before the board to go through that sale. And here we are now. It's refreshing. I

053don't get to see often improvements that are from bonds that have been issued. So Superintendent Doreen, thank you for. and the rest of that together and to describe it. So I'm very excited. Obviously, there are additional capital projects that you're considering. We've been working very hard with Superintendent Doering, Mr. Ponder, and the rest of the financing team to bring this resolution before you. Again, as already mentioned, very similar procedures you went through last time. I just wanted to highlight before we went to the resolution. uh some of the pages in the presentation i don't want to go there's a lot of numbers and data i don't want to go through in a lot of detail but highlight some of them and then answer any questions and then move to the resolution i'm not very good

054sometimes right there okay and this particular slide i think one of the takeaways is that the district's values uh assessed values continue to grow um projected for next year you can see whether it's the the net cash or the limited assessed property as well uh growing at a pretty healthy rate we should get uh later in february the preliminary numbers from department of revenue and we can share that with the district staff to update some of this analysis but your values grow which helps with the tax rate and bonding capacity This is just the breakout of the different types of property within the district. And then here just shows over the last 10 years for the various tax rates on a combined basis, what the tax rate is. Also shows the history of your successful

055bond and overrides as well. And then this is a summary. Again, last year was your last sale, but this shows on an aggregate basis. One of the highlights on this page I wanted to mention last March, which is a reflection of the board, strong management and other positive attributes in the district. The bond rating for Moody's was upgraded to A2. And so. Kudos there. We will go through a process with Moody's as well as the bond insurance companies, assuming the board deems it appropriate to move forward and schedule those talks. But I wanted to mention that A2 bond rating. And here, as I mentioned, with your growth of assessed valuation, you have plenty of bonding capacity, about $26.5 million as you pay down bonds. And as your value grows, your bonding capacity will increase going

056forward. As it relates to this sale, we try to be conservative with our estimates. Obviously, there are some things the district nor ourselves can control, which is the property values that will fluctuate. But we're using a pretty conservative growth rate, approximately 4%, and then it tapers off to less than 1% in 20 years, which if I was a betting man, I'd bet you a dollar that it'd probably be higher than that. But I'm not going to go there. I wanted to highlight on this particular... uh estimated sale the 10 million again the remaining authorization uh we're estimating the high interest rate of five percent again it's going to be lower than that when you sold last year your average all-in true interest cost was 3.98 percent We again need to go through the rating process

057with Moody's and qualified for bond insurance, which helps bring down that interest rate as well. So we'd be going through that process. But as you can see, we're very close, if not right on top of what the voter pamphlet was when you went to the voters in 2023. estimated to be approximately 64 cents next year, and then 62 cents for several years, and then dropping even below that, which is well within the range that you suggested to the voters. And then here, as I mentioned, we've been very busy, assuming the board deems it appropriate and adopts the resolution tonight. We are scheduled for Friday to have a diligence call with the entire financing team and then a rating call and the bond insurance process will commence after that. We hope to be in a position,

058our firm, to underwrite the bonds in early February, either targeting the week of the 3rd or February 10th. Last year was a very successful sale. As I mentioned, you sold 10 million. We had about 14, a little over 14 million of orders from various investors, retail, banks, trust departments, insurance company, money managers. And so we anticipate having another successful sale this year as well. Even an individual local taxpayer, right? Yes, we did get an individual retail as well. It was a good mix of various investors and we pledge to continue with that this particular sale. And then we hope to be in a position to close the transaction the week of February 24th. Deposit monies with the county treasurer for you to continue with your capital plans. I'll pause. I tend to just keep on

059talking because I'd love to talk before we get to the resolution. But any questions regarding the presentation? Yes, that's Board Member. Right now you're looking at if this new sale would be a tax rate of 0.62, 62 cents? That's the estimate based on the values. What is the current rate of what we currently have? 62 for the... Debt service is 62 cents. Debt service. Yes. And on this new, if we were to sell the new ones, would it be the same? It's going to, we're estimating 64 cents the first year, and then it'll drop to 62 in the next several years. That's fine. Thanks. Subject to change depending on what your values do. I was just wondering where we were as total debt service. Yep. Thank you. Yes, sir. I'm trying to figure this out.

060I might do something. Okay, it'll be issued at 5%, but it won't be 5%. I don't really understand because a lot of bonds I have, I mean, I know what it's going to be when I buy it. It will be, we're estimating on this page, I just pointed out that we're trying to be conservative with the interest rate estimate, knowing that we still have to go through the process. The financial markets continue to be very volatile, as we all know. Reading and seeing it affect and impact our daily lives as well. And so we'll continue to go through the rating process after tonight and the insurance process. And again, last year, the rate was the effective rate was 3.98%. And so also estimated at five, right? Estimated at five last year as well. So we

061will probably be. four and a quarter to four and a half, depending on what the market gyrations are. Am I wrong in, sometimes I read this stuff and I'm going, I don't get it. That's why I got a guy that does for me. But isn't there a tax advantage in buying? School bonds also. Can you tell me, I mean, I hate to take up people's time, but I wouldn't mind to know what that is. Yes, if you're a resident of the state, not only is the interest from these bonds tax exempt from a federal, but also a state law perspective. Oh, so it could be four and a quarter with no tax. Correct. And so this estimated rate is just one estimated one number. But I love talking about this, as I mentioned. So an

062investor of a bond that's going to mature in 2027 may get a yield of one and a half percent. An investor of the bonds that are going to mature in 2044 will get a higher yield, maybe closer to. And are they sold in increments of what, 10,000, 100,000? 5,000. 5,000. Okay, thanks. Any other questions? All good questions. I welcome. I could talk all night. Mr. Ponder will attest to that, but you're not going to let me. The resolution you have before you, again, is the authorizing resolution delegating to the superintendent and the CFO to finalize the terms. There are not to exceed parameters to make sure the actual sale and we underwrite the bonds in February are within those parameters. So not to exceed five and a half percent interest rate, not to exceed 20

063years and not to exceed 10 million of authorization. So and there's a lot of. additional legalese within the document similar to the resolution last year. But are there any questions related to the authorizing resolution that I would be happy to answer? If not, then I will sit down. Thank you. Thank you, Bob. So yes, unless there are any other questions pertaining to the information that's been provided to you all, we would ask for the governing board to approve the recommended motion, which is to move forward. But fortunately, somebody will have to read that entire piece. Thank you, Mr. Farr, if you'd like to do that so we can make sure we capture all those parameters and it's fully compliant with all applicable laws. I've done this before. I move that we... Adopt a resolution authorizing

064the issuance and sale of school improvement bonds of the district and adopting certain written continuing disclosure compliance procedures and issuance and post-issuance tax compliance procedures. And I believe to direct the superintendent and the chief financial officer. I believe there's information that allows the superintendent and the chief financial officer to approve those two, right? Absolutely. Mr. Park, thank you. I didn't realize it was in there. Did I miss something? Maybe I didn't read it. I thought I read it. Do we have a second? Motion. Okay. We have a motion. Made and seconded. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? So that will happen. Okay. Thank you. Next. Consideration of approval of appointment of a governing board member to serve on the YABC Trust Board. The governing board needs to appoint a governing board member to succeed

065Ms. Audrey Garcia to represent school district on the Yuma Area Benefits Consortium Trust Board. Ms. Garcia, former governing board president and member, and Mr. Dale Ponder, chief of finance and operations, currently represent the district as members of YABC Health Insurance Trust Board. With Ms. Garcia no longer serving as a governing board member, the district now has only one represented on the trust board. According to paragraph 3.02 of the trust agreement, board of trustees composition each participating entity of the YABC trust, including Arizona Western College, the city of Yuma, and Crane Elementary School District is required to appoint two trustees. Consequently, the governing board must appoint a new district representative, specifically a governing board member, to comply with the trust agreement, paragraph 3.04. Successor trustees specifies that upon the resignation or removal of a trustee, the

066governing board of the participating entity that appointed such trustee shall appoint or select a successor trustee. It is important to note that YABC trust board members are not subject to term limits and may serve until they resign or are removed by vote of the appointing entity's governing board. The governing board's action to appoint a successor is necessary to ensure full representative and compliance with the terms of the trust agreement. I have any discussion on this? Anyone interested? I'm interested in doing. I propose that we select Jim Colby as representative. I second. So it's been moved and seconded. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay. Now, governing board conflict of interest. Arizona revised statutes 38-502, 38-503, 38-509 requires that the district annually provide governing board members with guidance on what constitutes a substantial interest and that

067the conflict of interest statutes apply to all district governing board members. Dale Ponder, Chief of Finance and Operations, will provide the Governing Board with the annual conflict of interest review and training and ask that all Governing Board members provide the completed mandatory disclosure to the Governing Board Secretary, Mr. Mennon Sinas. What do we do now? Mr. Ponder? Thank you, Mr. Colby. As far as I can go. That's fine. Members of the board. Yes. So historically, you've received a one page document which had every member signed to disclose whether or not they had a conflict. It was believed that a more formal training would be necessary to meet the true intent of the law. And so I have 12 slides that I've prepared here. It's not going to be super in depth. We're not going to

068do a huge deep dive, but I do want to hit on some critical components that are referenced within statute. to bring awareness to each of you all as board members on when you should disclose, what constitutes a disclosure, what type of parameters might be included within that disclosure. So I want to make sure that we're mindful for all of this, which does apply to Governing Board Policy 1-105. So on the surface, the purpose of the conflict of interest laws is to avoid any self-dealings, make sure that... As public representatives, you are doing the work of the public and not for your own personal gain and to avoid situations where that may arise. The scope of the conflict of interest law, as Mr. Colby stipulated, is in Arizona Revised Statute Sections 38501 to 511. And those

069really set the minimum expectations of public officers when faced with a conflict that may be either financial in nature or proprietary or through some type of ownership. And they're relative. And we're going to describe what a relative is because it's very in-depth within statute. It's not... just what you think it might be. So there are some key definitions that are included within that statute, such as what is a remote versus a substantial interest. I will share that substantial has a small definition where remote within statute is one full page full of many different parameters on what a remote interest might be. I'm not going to read all of these, but to give you an idea, a remote interest means that of a non-salaried officer of a nonprofit corporation, that of a landlord or tenant of

070the contracting party, that of an attorney or contractor. If you're interested in learning more about what the specific requirements are for remote interest, let me know. I'd be happy to send you the statute with regards to that. Also talks about a board member relative, and I included... dependent claimed on income taxes, but it really goes beyond that. So the definition is a spouse, a child, a child's child, a parent, a grandparent, a brother, a sister of whole or half blood and their spouses and the parent, brother, sister or child of a spouse. Literally everyone and their mother. And so that's a true component that's there. So if you're unsure, you can take a look at the statute to make that determination. Also defines what an employee is, part-time, full-time, contracted workers. Talks about what a

071transaction is, and that includes any contract, a sale, a purchase, any interaction between the district and a supplier. What a supplier is, it's an individual, a corporation. It's not just a company, but it could be any other party with that. And the district has a requirement to maintain those official records for its protection, as well as your protection as governing board members. There are some voting restrictions as governing board members. In general, board members can vote on most budgetary personnel or related questions. And so specifically, let's say we had this a few years ago where we had a board member whose daughter was employed by the school district. She was able to vote on the global compensation for all staff because it impacted all staff. But if it was specific to her. child, she would

072have to recuse herself from that and not be able to participate in that. So there's still some freedoms that governing board members can have when taking a look at, I'll say corporately or globally, making changes to all staff and all personnel. If I would probably caution them, and I tend to be a little bit more conservative in that way, that if it's for that particular employee group, and as that the size of the group of people start to shrink, may want to consider saying I need to disclose that I have a conflict and will not be voting on that. There's items where it's prohibited voting, you know, concerning their own relatives. So a specific person within the organization, their appointment or the compensation tied to that. There are some employment restrictions where the governing board

073members or spouses can't be employed by the district unless permitted by law. And we don't, those don't apply to us, but they're for small school districts and really rural environments where everyone is connected in some way. In those small communities, it would be. very challenging to separate a relative from also being able to work within that school district community. In Crane, we are not qualified as a small school district, and so that wouldn't apply to us. Employment of former board members, this is possible following a two-year separation. The idea behind that is it would keep a governing board from establishing a highly compensated position and then saying, I think I want that position. However, there are some opportunities where a board member could leave and say, I want to be a teacher, I want to

074be a substitute teacher, I want to be a bus driver. Those things are permitted without the two-year rule. This is a fairly new rule that came into effect last legislative session. Again, with this idea that some boards were creating or the perspective or the optics were that some boards were creating these highly compensated administrative positions that in turn that board member would be eligible to apply for. When this law came, we advocated that if we have board members that want to be teachers, they should be able to do that. We have a shortage. If we have a... a board member who wants to be a bus driver. There should be some flexibilities with that. Or with speech and language pathology, those types of things where we already have a shortage of these key positions, there

075should be opportunities where that two-year rule doesn't apply. So basically, employment can be provided before the two-year term expires, as long as they're providing direct services to students. So substantial interest and on purchases, board members cannot participate in transactions where they have a substantial interest. So either that's indirect or direct for them and their relative, as we defined before. There's some supply restrictions where we cannot. purchase items directly from a governing board member without going through a formal procurement process regardless of the dollar amount. Our current bid threshold is $100,000, but if we spend one cent with the board member, we have to go through the formal procurement process. Again, that's for the board member's protection as well as the district's. And then there are some conditions for purchasing under specific conditions, including monetary limits

076and board approval. So mandatory disclosure, as Mr. Colby read and each of you have before you, substantial interest must be disclosed. And this can be updated at any time. It's not every January. The idea is every January we do this, so it's on some sort of cadence. But let's say that you have a child who marries somebody as part of the district. Well, now I need to disclose that I have a conflict at that time. So anytime there's a... a life-changing event, so to speak, where you have to disclose that. Feel free to update. Let myself or Minnie know, hey, I need a new form. We're happy to do that. We collect those forms. They're managed by Minnie and her team of one. And then as well as the purchasing department, they manage those as

077well to make sure that any conflicts have been identified. We're aware. So we're restricting business or making sure that those disclosures are there. Record maintenance again. It's a separate file. It's open for public inspection. The idea behind this is full transparency and accountability both for both the board member and the district and ensuring that those conflicts are identified. There are penalties for failure to do this. If it's intentional, it's a class six felony, which is the least severe of all felonies, but still can have a little bit of a prison time, four months to two years, and does carry a fine. If the violation is considered reckless or negligent, it's a class one misdemeanor, which is the most severe of all misdemeanors. And that's six months in prison and $2,500 in fines. Upon conviction, you

078lose the office, maybe any contracts you're a part of become null and void, which could hinder the district's operation in some way. So recommendations. Analyze every matter coming before the governing board to determine if you have a conflict of interest. So make sure you're reviewing the agenda, maybe especially in some of those areas like the report of purchases between 15 and 50,000, 50 to 100, 100 plus. Those are areas where, hey, I did work with a vendor. For example, we had a governing board member who recused herself because she had a home that was being constructed by the same company that we were using for a service. She wanted to be fully transparent. To me, it wasn't necessary, but I appreciate her transparency in saying I have a challenge with this. Some may recall that

079Ms. Garcia would abstain from voting on matters regarding Arizona State University. That was her employer. And so she disclosed that as being a conflict. And so just be mindful of those things. If you're not sure. Don't do it. Disclose. If you want to bounce some of those ideas off of Superintendent Doering, myself, we're happy to help. Again, I'm probably going to be more conservative in nature and saying, yeah, you know, if it's iffy, I would go ahead and disclose that. I would much rather err on that side than coming to find out, yeah, it was truly a conflict. And then there's penalties assessed to you as board members, as well as hindering our district operations as well. So that was quick, admittedly. And if there are questions or comments from board members with regards to

080this or follow-up questions, I'm happy to take those at this time. Clarify, so like the disclosure, my understanding is it's primarily related to business interests or financial interests, right? So my kid attending a crane school would not warrant a disclosure, but that would be more of a remote interest and would be something that needs to be monitored for future potential. That is correct, yes. Thank you. Great question. Any others? Okay, there's no action on this one. This was purely for your own entertainment and enjoyment, purely as information. If you would fill out that form, get that to many so we have a record of that. And again, if you have changes as you go through, let us know. We'll be happy to help you get that revised. Mr. Colby, thank you. Thank you. At this,

081what? I move we adjourn. At this point, I'm supposed to read that it is now consideration to adjourn the meeting. What you want, but I move we adjourn. I would imagine that's seconded, isn't it? All in favor, say aye. Aye.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.